Decision dated 21st January, 2009 of Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in O.A. No.

2708 of 2008 filed by Shri Braijesh Kumar Jha. We have examined the issues involved in this OA already in OAs No.1389/2007 Dr. Bikram Singh Gill Vs. Chairman, U.P.S.C. and another, OA No.1747/2007 Neeraj Kansal and others Vs. U.P.S.C. (both decided by common order dated 18th July 2008), OA No.2570/2008 Sandeep Kumar Vs. U.P.S.C. and another dated 27.11.2008 and OA 133/2007, Ravi Jindal Vs. U.P.S.C. and another dated 21.02.2007. After considering the relevant judgements of the Honble Supreme Court and Honble Delhi High Court, this Tribunal had come to the conclusion that there were no rules which permitted re-examination and reevaluation of answer book and that no purpose will be served by the Tribunal to peruse the answer sheets because it is the work for the experts. The aforesaid OAs were found to be without merit and dismissed. 2. The same order has to be passed in this OA also. O.A. is dismissed in limine.