( )

Email: javadsaberian@yahoo.com

.

.

. .
..

.
.

.
.
-
.
.

35/71 29/43
. .

: .

53

/ / / 1389


[Huang, 2007][ ,Ahuja, et.al., 2002] and [Djidjev

.1

.]et.al, 2000

Cook ( )1996

[Cook and

.]Halsley, 1966 [ ]Chabini, 1998

...

[ .]Wu, 2006

... .

( )TDSP

[ .]Dean, 2004

[:]Dean, 2004

- :

[,]Alivand, Alsheikh and Malek, 2008

[.]Chabini, 1991] and [Huan, awu and Zhan, 2007

[ ]Wu, 2006 and Dean, 2004 .

1959

Klunder and Post, 2006[.]and [Pallotino and

Scutella, 1998] .

/ / / 1389

54

[ Hung, 2007,

]Djidjev, 2000 and Dean, 2004

- :

. 1

[]Alivand, 2008

.
.



.



 ")

 




&!

")
+  /
/,
0

-*$
%
0
 '#

.1

 @./
]3)f'[
#*U @2
1*RJ
 @**S2
1\Q
c/
BC
1C
>F
c, 
@/.$
c/
>3/

c$
1C
@*D^

@*D^ Z%
[]Alivand, 2008



>3/


(afb$
#*U @2
.d
c$ ]*b$
@U
.: >)(^
1C
c/


@&>F
 ?&
1^hQ
@&


@*D^

>F

.

@&
.2

@*D^
@VC
.^
f_8^

fC
@*D^
fH
`)

]*F./
c3F
1

@'a.*/
 ><
L) @F

1C

^
@3e/

@*D

1C .
)
@Oa
f^
@&

@*D^
.



   
1C
c3U@&
.8a 
LCf2
(_e^
.Y*Y;2
@*D^
 @./
.eF
cb

( )A


^
.eF
.C
`)
@/
1C
c3F
c*%2
]3)f'[
(a.^
(&>*!*
c0C.;^
@/
1C
c3U@&
.8a
c$
(2.Y*Y;2
@5$
@*D

[ ]Alivand, 2008 .

@ 

 

1C
>F
.8a
#*U @2
E) AU

Ed.$
1*RJ


@*D^
c0C.;^
 @7
.^
Ed.$





.^
c/
10Da
(b*/
E*
Z/.X
>^
#)
./
W/.N^
c%0F
.e*&")
c$
1C
`)
@/
@U

`)
  )

.
."
")
+

A .

.^
c/
c3D/ 

P/.2
`)
 fF(^
T)@R2
.^
c/
10Da
@VC
.^
(b*/
E*
P/.2
#)
.)
@d
 @/
>^
`)

`) @/.b/
>b

1C .

.


E*
P/ f2
`*b!_d

W*X
.*D/
(%*U @2
.d

)
`3F
.*3<


`)
.^A\^

(%
;@

.)
 >3/
@&
c/

1C



c%0F

.X.V2

./

#)
@d

@*D^

.=3a
 cY*X

.d./
c/
.^
.C
 
c3U@&
.8a
W*Y
.]Murchland,

.d

c3DD&

B[1970


Murchland

&
c$ () (C>bd
.d@3^ .
(KR/
.C
@/
@&
@d
#D)
>b$
f0Q
@2
`*).
#D)
./
.d @&

c$
1C
c3U@&
.8a
 caf

c3D/ 
(/.)@*D^
@/ (b30^
.eF
cRCf2
1e7

(305^
>X @&
@d
#D)
Z^.Q
 @$
 
 f/
>F
 
`*_=2
>a@4+^
#

(RX 
 >d.G^

.d
.C
@/
@3G*/
(/.)

(C@/
c/
.*a
(C>bd
.d@3^ .
.C
@/
#D)
c0C.;^

.^
 f

55

/ / / 1389

fOb^
c/
 cO;[
@VC
.^

Z0X
.d

@VC
.^
(3Q.C
.^

.^A_d
fM
c/


c$
1C
>F
c, 
(F
W*Y


`**R2
 @/
c$
1C
>F
 .V3C


A*a
.)
@d
#D)
Z^.Q

`*b!_d
1C
>F
 .V3C
.)f
.d c%0F

@*D^
`)@3

- .

.2

. .

[ ]Wu, et.al., 2007

[Preygel,

[ .]Thompson, 2003

.]1999

[ ]Coreman, et.al., 2001 [ Detcher and

[.]Azizi, 2003

]Pearl, 1985

- .

[.]Guhneman, et al., 2004

/ / / 1389

56

b5Vc

+I/=
!/c

!/c 

@4
_-*aC
%-U@4
b5Vc

+I/=
!/c


b'a,
/,

3C
@4
%2C
/,
@4
_-*aC
%-U@4


+4/Q/C
bG-^c
/6]
eaQ
b1

3C
@4
%2C
/,
@4
_-*aC
%-U@4


+4/Q/C
bG-^c
/6]
eaQ
b1



b'a,
/,
.

.
=@ Z +8

/V5C
+1/,@-D]
!/d^5,e*Z

e2d1
3d8

Y2W
!/c

@VC
/]
b1
e1@]
!/c
+8
=@

e2d1
3d8


e4

Y2W
!/c
+]
_,@1/a1

@VC
/]
b1
e1@]
!/c

3C
b5Vc
@*,


e4

3C
b5Vc
@*,
[Hail and
+]
_,@1/a1



]E-#
+*`e*$
ba-

]
b'2F
!/dZ/,
@VC
/]
+a-1
E-#
+*`e*$
ba-
&
+V[5>]
/X-X<4
ea&/4
eF
/V5C
/d`

b`e*$
b

+V[5>]
/X-X<4
ea&/4
]@&
H>G]
?,/1
/
&
eF
/V5C
/d`

b`e*$
b
&@
&@ ]@&
H>G]
?,/1
/


@4
_-*aC
%-U@4
b5Vc

+I/=
!/c


b'a,
/,
3C
@4
%2C
/,
@4
_-*aC
%-U@4


+4/Q/C
bG-^c
/6]
eaQ
b1

!/c

.]Walnut, 1980
.





 
!


b1
e4+]
b[^8


3C
?F
/9`
Y2W
!/c
 

  
b1
e4+]
b[^8


3C
?F
/9`
Y2W
!/c

!/]
!/c
/C
@1

!/]
!/c
/C
@1

/V5C
+1/,@-D]
!/d^5,e*Z

@VC
/]
b1
e1@]
!/c

3C
b5Vc
@*,+]
_,@1/a1


e4



+8
=@

e2d1
3d8
 Y2W
!/c

]!/
@

/V5C
/,


b2C/<]
!@1
c
%D,
!
]@VC
/] !/

]
!/

/c

E>1
_,
]
b2C/<]
!@1 @VC
/
@&
/F
!
]!/

 /c

E>1
_,
 "    "  @&
/F
&@ ]
b'2F
!/dZ/,
@VC
/]
+a-1
E-#
+*`e*$
ba-]

+V[5>]
/X-X<4
ea&/4
eF
/V5C
/d`

b`e*$
b& @&
H>G]
?,/1
/

]+


?`eF
+]

:-Je4
b]

b&
eF
]+
?`eF+]

:-Je4
b]

b&
eF
 
! 

  
b1
e4+]
b[^8


3C
?F
/9`
Y2W
!/c 
!/]
!/c
/C
@1
]Thompson,

[2003
!


 
"


!


 
"
 

 "    
/V5C
/,
@
c
%D,

!/]

b2C/<]
!@1 @VC
/] !/]
!/c

E>1
_,
 @&
/F

+1
/a4
!/c@5]/#
?,/1
?51

.


!@1
?`eF
@>5C
+'-U@4
!/c
+]
eOa]
_,
!@1
?`eF
@>5C
+'-U@4
!/c
Y,?24

e4
/,
@c
+1
]!/

/a4
!/c@5]/#
?,/1
?51
/,
@c
b2C/<]
eOa]
b1
]!/

b2C/<]
eOa]
b1
]?`eF+]

:-Je4
b]

b&
eF+
"#

( )
]
@&
/V5C
%8e.


+]
Y,?24
B`/&@U
!/KU
b1
/]e)
!/K

 



?a&.

+]
Y,?24
B`/&@U
!/KU
b1
/]e)
!/K
U


%-U@4
/a*-C
%8e]
Y,?24
]
@&
/V5C
%8e
U


%-U@4
/a*-C
%8e]
Y,?24

 !


 
"


W
Y<]
%8e]
Y,?24

b&
3C
_,

b,eU
Y6]
/dF


/=
B`/&@U
%,
eW

Y<]
%8e]
Y,?24

b&
3C
_,

b,eU
Y6]
/dF
]
@*,
b1
32D`
%8e]
Y,?24
3,A
 
 

.

] 
@*,
b1
32D`
%8e]
Y,?24
3,A


Y,?24

e4
+]
eOa]
_,
!@1
?`eF
@>5C
+'-U@4
!/c

+1 /a4
!/c@5]/#
?,/1
?51 /,
@c !/] 
b2C/<]
eOa]
b1
1
+,f/1
3-^c

bZ/D]
_,
%-U@4
+1

P1e4
+]/^4

3C
e=@1

+,f/1
3-^c

bZ/D]
_,
%-U@4
+1
/a4
!/c@5]/#
@>5C
!@1
b&
eF
/a4
!/c@5]/#
@>5C
!@1
b&
eF
+]
H>G]
/]e)
!/KU
1



" #

+]
H>G]
/]e)
!/KU

.3




?a&
+
]
Y,?24
B`/&@U
!/KU
b1
/]e)
!/K
U


%-U@4
/a*-C
%8e]
Y,?24
]
@&
/V5C
%8e
[5>]
/]
%8e]
P1e4
?a,

/V5C

T,@R4
ea&
/4
+V[5>]
/]
%8e]
P1e4
?a,

]+]
3C
b1
/]
%8e]
P1/4
%,
/-X
+]
3C

/X5`

%8e]
Y,?24

b,/#

b1
/]
%8e]
P1/4
%,
/-X]

/X5`

%8e]
Y,?24

b,/#


/=
B`/&@U
%,
eW

Y<]
%8e]
Y,?24

b&
3C
_,

b,eU
Y6]
/dF
]
@*,
b1
32D`
%8e]
Y,?24
3,A
 
:

b1
/]
%8e]
! 
 ?a,


bN1
+]
3C

]
eI
bb1
/-X
!
]1
/]
%8e


/X5`
@5]/#

 
bN1
`?

@&
bU/J
/1
%8e]
P1e4


eIb1
/-X]

/X5`
@5]/#
?F 
@&
bU/J
/1
%8e]
P1e4
?`?F

P1e4
+]/^4
3C
e=@1
+,f/1
3-^c

bZ/D]
_,
%-U@4
+1
/a4
!/c@5]/#
@>5C
!@1
b&
eF

+]
H>G]
/]e)
!/KU


 










/V5C

T,@R4
ea&
/4
+V[5>]
/]
%8e]
P1e4
?a,
+]
3C

b

]1
/]
%8e]
P1/4
%,
/-X

/X5`

%8e]
Y,?24

b,/#


    
 .

 
  






?a, +]
3C
b1
/]
%8e]
! 
 
bN1
eIb1
/-X]

/X5`
@5]/#

@&
bU/J
/1
%8e]
P1e4
?`?F



Z/]@`
eOa]
b1

T[5>]
!/dC/-X]
@&
A-Z/]@`
eOa]
b1

0,@J

3C
/X5`
@5]/#
]
/]
%8e



/-X]
@5]/# 
/]
%8e]
bN1
_,


0,@J

3C
/X5`
@5]/# 

/-X]
@5]/#



 bN1
_,
b


 a 
  
 

 

3C
?F
bU/J
 
@U
eF+]
@4

B'Q@1
%$e&
/-X]
b$
@c
+aR,
3C
B`/&@U
B'Q
/1
0C/a5]
/-X]
@5]/#

 +]
@4f/1
B`/&@U
eF+]
@4 %$e&
/-X]
b$
@c
+aR,
3C
B`/&@U
B'Q
/1
0C/a5]
/-X]
@5]/#
3C
?F
bU/J




b'a,
/,
3C
@4
%2C
/,
@4
_-*aC
%-U@4 a-1/2


+4/Q/C
bG-^c
/6]
eaQ
b1


!/c 

@4
_-*aC
%-U@4
b5Vc

+I/=
!/c
@&
bIg=
@,
b[;@]
7a#

e4
`+]

%8e]
Y,?24
/9
@&
bIg=
@,
b[;@]
7a#

e4
`+]

%8e]
Y,?24
/9



T[5>]
!/dC/-X]
@&
A-Z/]@`
eOa]
b1


0,@J

3C
/X5`
@5]/#




/-X]
@5]/#


/]
%8e]
bN1
_,


/V5C
+1/,@-D]
!/d^5,e*Z +8 @= e2d1
3d8
 Y2W
!/c 
@VC
/]
b1
e1@]
!/c

e4+]
_,@1/a1
3C
b5Vc
@*,

. 






@F

E>1
%,
/1.


\-a&+]
bD,/X]
/a*-C



@F

E>1
%,
/1

]\-a&
b'2F
!/dZ/,
@VC
/]
+a-1
E-#
+*`e*$
ba-

+]
bD,/X]
/a*-C
]
/>5`

@O`
e]
/]
%8e


]
/>5`

@O`
e]
/]
%8e
&@ ]
+V[5>]
/X-X<4
ea&/4
eF
/V5C
/d`

b`e*$
b& @&
H>G]
?,/1
/
B'Q@1

 +]
@4f/1
B`/&@U
eF+]
@4 %$e&
/-X]
b$
@c
+aR,
3C
B`/&@U
B'Q
/1
0C/a5]
/-X]
@5]/#
3C
?F
bU/J
!




  
b1
e4+]
b[^8


3C
?F
/9`
Y2W
!/c

!/]
!/c

/C
@1
.



]+]
b2C/<]
/a*-C

E>1
_,
/1

%8e]
3c/2F
A-

 






4 "A1
?Q
?X$
@c

3C
@5G-1
b1/G4
?F/1
@4
&\-a
]+]
b2C/<]
/a*-C

E>1
_,
/1

%8e]
3c/2F
A-

"A1
?Q
?X$
@c
&\-a







@&
bIg=
@,
b[;@]
7a#

e4


/V5C
/,
@
c
%D,

!/]

b2C/<]
!@1 @VC
/] !/]
!/c

E>1
_,
`@&
/F    "  +]

%8e]
Y,?24
/9


.
 Y'FTZ
TZ
Y'F
?`eF.
+]

:-Je4
b]

b&
eF
]+



\-a&+]
bD,/X]
/a*-C
 @F

E>1
%,
/1
]
/>5`

@O`
e]
/]
%8e

 !


 
"

&
EFe#
/a*-C
Y&
/4
\-a
&
PW
  Y'FeF

EFe#
/a*-C
Y&
/4
\-a
]+]
@'4
  
Y;@]

\-c+]
3&@;
3C
3^C
b1

%8e

+]
@'4



]@;
Y

\-c
]+]
3&@;
3C
3^C
b1

%8e






&
  \-a :

3C
@5G-1
b1/G4
?F/1
@4

"A1
?Q
?X$
@c
]+]
b2C/<]
/a*-C

E>1
_,
/1

%8e]
3c/2F
A-

Y,?24

e4 +]
eOa]
_,
!@1
?`eF
@>5C
+'-U@4
!/c

+1
/,
@c !/] 
b2C/<]
eOa]
b1

/a4
!/c@5]/#
?,/1
?51
/^c
@,
3C


/a*-C

+,/c/8
b$

/=
B`/&@U
%,
b&
\,
&
! 

?F
/-1
b


eM
/^c
@,
3C


/a*-C

+,/c/8
b$

/=
B`/&@U
%,
b&
\,
@&
H>G]
/9a,
/4
@&
H>G]
/9a,
/4





"#
?


&a
+


]
Y,?24
B`/&@U
!/KU
b1
/]e)
!/K
U


%-U@4
/a*-C
%8e]
Y,?24
]
@&
/V5C
%8e

1 -
TZ Y'F
  ]

/=
B`/&@U
%,
eW
Y<]
%8e]
Y,?24

b&
3C
_,

b,eU
Y6]
/dF 
@*,
b1
32D`
%8e]
Y,?24
3,A
3c/2F
A-]
b&
/a*-C

E>1
@c
B#
@&
b2C/<]

/a*-C
B`/&@U
e4

_,

%8e]
/1
!@5G-1
3c/2F
A-]
b&
/a*-C

E>1
@c
B#
@&
b2C/<]

/a*-C
B`/&@U
e4
]+]
%8e]
/-X
]+]
%8e]
/-X
&
PW
  Y'FeF

EFe#
/a*-C
Y&
/4
\-a
 

Y;@]

\-c
]+]
3&@;
3C
3^C
b1

%8e

 .

3C
e=@1.


+]
@'4

P1e4
+]/^4

+,f/1
3-^c

bZ/D]
_,
%-U@4
+1
/a4
!/c@5]/#
@>5C
!@1
b&
eF
+]
H>G]
/]e)
!/KU
]
3C
E>1


/-X]

/1
L24@]
B`/&@U
b1
@5',A`
+D`/&@U
!
?F/1
b5F
/-X
]
3C
E>1


/-X]

/1
L24@]
B`/&@U
b1
@5',A`
+D`/&@U
!
?F/1
b5F
/-X

/V5C

T,@R4
ea&
/4
+V[5>]
/]
%8e]
P1e4
?a, +]
3C
b1
/]
%8e]
P1/4
%,
/-X]

/X5`

%8e]
Y,?24

b,/#
&
! 

?F
/-1
b
/^c
@,
3C


/a*-C

+,/c/8
b$

/=
B`/&@U
%,
b&
\,
`?

@&
bU/J
/1
%8e]
P1e4
@&
H>G]
/9a,
/4


eM


 -

]2
bN1
eIb1
/-X
!
]
b1
/]
%8e
_--R4
eOa]
b1
@]
_,

eI
@*,
!/dD`/&@U
Y<]
_--R4
eOa]
b1
@]
_,

]@; 
Y'F
\-a&+]
@'4
 
/4 
Y
?a,
+]
3C
&
Y'F
\-a
]

@--S4

%8e]
/-X

+]
@'4

]@;
/4 
Y


/X5`
@5]/#


@--S4

%8e]
/-X] ?F



_,

%8e]
/1
!@5G-1
3c/2F
A-]
b&
/a*-C

E>1
@c
B#
@&
b2C/<]

/a*-C
B`/&@U
e4
]+]
%8e]
/-X
 





) @- 

]+
) @- .   
 C=W

] +

 
]
E>1


/-X]

/1
L24@]
B`/&@U
b1
@5',A`
+D`/&@U
!
?F/1
b5F
/-X

3C
I
/-X]
@5]/#]
and
de, 2008
(2 -).
],
%8e[
Clark,]
[Ahmed, 1979] ,[2003

T[5>]
!/dC/-X]
@&
A-Z/]@`
eOa]
b1
]
/


0,@J

3C
/X5`
@5]/#


bN1
_,

eI
@*,
!/dD`/&@U
Y<]
_--R4
eOa]
b1
@]
_,
 ] 
Y'F
\-a&+]
@'4
 
/4 
Y;@]


@--S4

%8e]
/-X
B'Q@1

 +]
@4f/1
B`/&@U
eF+]
@4 %$e&
/-X]
b$
@c
+aR,
3C
B`/&@U
B'Q
/1
0C/a5]
/-X]
@5]/# 3C
?F
bU/J
3 - 12
[ ]Nakata, 2004 .
`@&
bIg=
@,
b[;@]
7a#

e4+]

%8e]
Y,?24
/9
]@-)+
&\-a

+]
bD,/X]
/a*-C



@F

E>1
%,
/1

(2 -).
]
/>5`

@O`
e]
/]
%8e



]
3C
@5G-1
b1/G4
?F/1
@4 "A1
?Q
?X$
@c

 
\-a&+]
b2C/<]
/a*-C

E>1
_,
/1

%8e]
3c/2F
A-



]
PW
  Y'FeF

EFe#
/a*-C
Y&
/4
\-a&+]
@'4
  
Y;@]

\-c+]
3&@;
3C
3^C
b1

%8e

.

TZ
Y'F


eM /^c
@,
3C


/a*-C

+,/c/8
b$

/=
B`/&@U
%,
b&
\,
@&
H>G]
/9a,
/4

  

 

 #


&
!


?F
/-1
b




 #


 

]
_,

%8e]
/1
!@5G-1
3c/2F
A-]
b&
/a*-C

E>1
@c
B#
@&
b2C/<]

/a*-C
B`/&@U
e4 +]
%8e]
/-X
&\-a .

3 1-

+]
@'4
/dC/-X]
/^4
!@1
&
/4\-a
]@;
Y

+]
@'4
/dC/-X]
/^4
!@1


]@;
/4 
Y


]
3C
E>1


/-X]

/1
L24@]
B`/&@U
b1
@5',A`
+D`/&@U
!
?F/1
b5F
/-X

 ]
eI
@*,
!/dD`/&@U
Y<]
_--R4
eOa]
b1
@]
_,  
Y'F
\-a&+]
@'4
 
/4 
Y;@]


@--S4

%8e]
/-X

-C
T[5>]
!/dG>1
/1
T[5>]
!/dC/-X]

b&
3F
\-ce=

+2,@J
b5Ce-#
%8e]
Y,?24
/9`
/1

0,@J
?`eF+]
?-Ze4
/a*-C
T[5>]
!/dG>1
/1
T[5>]
!/dC/-X]

b&
3F
\-ce=

+2,@J
b5Ce-#
%8e]
Y,?24
/9`
/1
]@-)+



  

 

 #

&XU
e<]
b&
\-a
&
eM

3-RWe]
@*`/-1
+XU
e<]
b&
\-a
+]
\C
!e^`
0,@J
_,

!@1
?a5Dc
%8e]
/1
b-Z
+]
\C
!e^`
0,@J
_,

!@1
?a5Dc
%8e]
/1
b-Z
`
/a*-C
e-C@)
b9-5

`
/a*-C
e-C@)
b9-5



\-a&+]
@'4
/dC/-X]
/^4
!@1
]@;
/4 
Y
`(
/G`

0,@J
+)A1 $%
bNX`
@c
?c+]
/G`

0,@J
+)A1

]<
b8

?c+]
/G`

/-X]
\./W
e
$%
bNX`
@c
(`
b8

/]e) 
/a*-C

?c+]
/G`

/-X]
\./W
e<]

/]e) 
/a*-C

0,@J
?`eF+]
?-Ze4
/a*-C
T[5>]
!/dG>1
/1
T[5>]
!/dC/-X]

b&
3F
\-ce=

+2,@J
b5Ce-#
%8e]
Y,?24
/9`
/1
57
/ / / 1389
`
eM

3-RWe]
@*`/-1
+XU
e<]
b&
\-a& +]
\C
!e^`
0,@J
_,

!@1
?a5Dc
%8e]
/1
b-Z 
/a*-C
e-C@)
b9-5


  

 

 #
?c+]
/G`

0,@J
+)A1
$%
bNX`
@c
(`
b8

?c+]
/G`

/-X]
\./W
e<]

/]e) 
/a*-C

]@;\-a&+]
@'4
/dC/-X]
/^4
!@1

/4 
Y

&

0,@J
?`eF+]
?-Ze4
/a*-C
T[5>]
!/dG>1
/1
T[5>]
!/dC/-X]

b&
3F
\-ce=

+2,@J
b5Ce-#
%8e]
Y,?24
/9`
/1

&


! 

?F
/-1
b&
eM /^c
@,
3C


/a*-C

+,/c/8
b$

/=
B`/&@U
%,
b&
\,@&
H>G]
/9a,
/4

_,

%8e]
/1
!@5G-1
3c/2F
A-]
b&
/a*-C

E>1
@c
B#
@&
b2C/<]

/a*-C
B`/&@U
e4 +]
%8e]
/-X]

3C
E>1


/-X]

/1
L24@]
B`/&@U
b1
@5',A`
+D`/&@U
!
?F/1
b5F
/-X]

eI
@*,
!/dD`/&@U
Y<]
_--R4
eOa]
b1
@]
_,


Y'F
\-a&
+]
@'4

 
/4 
Y;@]


@--S4

%8e]
/-X] 

@-)+]

c
h`


DL
DfhB
$
?1Ph9
5gc
h`


KC6

e+
!5J,0
e6
h6F`
/,1WF9
echac
&5f

KC6

e+
!5J,0
e6
h6F`
/,1WF9
echac
&5f
$
&%
F6
*=h`
\0D79 !5aU

DV6
$
&%
F6
*=h`
\0D79 !5aU

DV6

 8I
&%
ec57L
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5(

8LE-

DV6
/dV0    8I
&%
ec57L
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5(
 
Dc
57U
*1WF9
/6%5d9
&5f
 
Dc
57U
*1WF9
/6%5d9
&5f
F:`5( e+
DL
NCM`
F:`5( e+
DL
NCM`

*0
8LE-

DV6
/dV0

%
hL
/`
F,9
e:Xf
*0
8LE-

DV6
/dV0
 
 8I
/.:Xf
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5(
 
 8I
/.:Xf
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5(

hL/`
F,9
8U5I 

hL/`
F,9
8U5I 

:`5(
e+
!5@

/d16
K1(

F;3`
&5fF:`5(
e+
!5@
hL/`
F,9
!5J,0
8LE-

DV6
/dV0
hL/`
F,9
!5J,0
8LE-

DV6
/dV0
   8I
eci5I
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5(
   8I
eci5I
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5(





#

 


]Matlab
7.6.0[
`
5fF:`5(
b0

*0
Ff
/f
#%
e6
86hc


hSd`
b0
&F6 DI/`
5fF:`5(
b0

*0
Ff
/f
#%
e6
86hc
DcDL
NCM`
5gc
e:LE-
*1WF9
5I
F6
5g]50
$Dd0
DcDL
NCM`
5gc
e:LE-
*1WF9
5I
F6
5g]50
$Dd0

*1WF9 .2

*1WF9

\-a&+]
@'4
/dC/-X]
/^4
!@1

/4 
Y;@] 

.
.

0,@J
?`eF
+]
?-Ze4
/a*-C

T[5>]
!/dG>1
/1
T[5>]
!/dC/-X]

b&
3F
\-ce=

+2,@J
b5Ce-#
%8e]
Y,?24
/9`
/1
1^A9

F:M16
%
b0


%
/`
5
,6
#h1IF-
\1^A9

F:M16
%
b0

  
8I
K05f 
!hg>`
DV9

K16
K0
 8I
K05f
5fe]5V`
DV9
e
!hg>`
DV9

K16
K0
+
%/`
5fe]5V`
DV9
e+
%/`
:
2
_ 1f
/`
\1,M9 
eR6
\
,L
e6

i5V`
$5.:I
3 1 
 /a*-C
e-C@)
b9-5`
-4

eM

3-RWe]
@*`/-1
+XU
e<]
b&
\-a&
+]
\C
!e^`
0,@J
_,

!@1
?a5Dc
%8e]
/1
b-Z
_1f/`
\1,M9 
eR6

\,L
e6

i5V`
$5.:I

@
&F6
e

5
+
e6
/9i5V`
$5.:I
\@
&F6
e
+
8I
5`

/L%
5V6F`
b0F:a
+
8I
5`

/L%
5V6F`
b0F:a
+
%
8I
$DL
$5X:I
5V6F`
b0F:a+
%

e]5[`
b0
+
%
8I
$DL
$5X:I
5V6F`
b0F:a+
%

e]5[`
b0

DL
DfhB
$
?1Ph9
5gc
h`
 
KC6

e+
!5J,0
e6
h6F`
/,1WF9
echac
&5f $
&%
F6
*=h`
\0D79 !5aU

DV6

?

c


/]e) 
/a*-C

.) -2 (
?c+]
/G`

0,@J
+)A1 $%
bNX`
@c
(`
b8
+]
/G`

/-X]
\./W
e<]

  
 




  
 

   

8LE-

DV6
/dV0    8I
&%
ec57L
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5(  
Dc
57U
*1WF9
/6%5d9
&5fF:`5( e+
DL
NCM`
.
  

 
 

   











%
hL
/`
F,9
e:Xf
*0
8LE-

DV6
/dV0  
 8I
/.:Xf
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5( 
hL/`
F,9
8U5I 

. 4 1 -5





/d16
K1(

F;3`
&5fF:`5(
e+
!5@
hL
/`
F,9
!5J,0
8LE-

DV6
/dV0

  8I
eci5I
#
%5d9
$%
e+
&F:`5(
 
 
   




 
 

  
& DcDL
NCM`
5gc
e:LE-
*1WF9
5I
F6
5g]50
$Dd0
*1WF9


hSd`
b0
&F6 DI/`
5fF:`5(
b0

*0
Ff
/f
#%
e6
86hc

    
    

65;
%


b1.c51`
FA:`
&5f
%
(8eI865;
%


!50

FXI
#5`
&

!50

FXI
#5`
&
 

$Dd>dI

$5X:I
56

i5V`
b0


i5V`
b0

.


FA:`
&5f

$Dd>dI

$5X:I
56
eSA]
$Df5M`
TTOi 
eSA]
$Df5M`
i

5



+


e6
/9i5V`
$5.:I
\@
&F6
e
+

8I
5`

/L%
5V6F`
b0F:a
+

%
8I
$DL
$5X:I
5V6F`
b0F:a+
%

e]5[`
b0
8U5I

FXI
#5`
b1.c51`

!5J,0
!hQ
 
59 
'j8U5I

FXI
#5`
b1.c51`
<` 8I
e:LE-
!5J,0
!hQ

&
'j<` 8I
eSA]
$Df5M`
8U5I

!50
FXI
#5`

e:LE-
!5J,0
!hQ

&eSA]
$Df5M`
8U5I

!50
FXI
#5`

TTh )

%

/`
5

,6
#h1IF-
\1^A9

F:M16
%
b0


 
8I
K05f!hg>`
DV9

K16
K0
E-
!5J,0
!hQ

e7dL%
j<`
e:Xf

&

#5`
b1.c51`
j<`
8I

e:LE-
!5J,0
!hQ

e7dL%
j<`
e:Xf

&
eSA]
$Df5M`
%

!50
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`
eSA]
$Df5M`

%

!50
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`

%
e:LE



%
e:LE- 5fe]5V`
DV9
e+
%/`

I

&

!5I

$5`F19
"hI
j<`
!5I

&
eSA]
$Df5M`
%

!50
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`
eSA]
$Df5M`
%

!50
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`
_1f/`
\1,M9 
eR6
\,L
e6

i5V`
$5.:I

%
e:LE-
!5J,0
!hQ

e7dL%
&5f%
FXI

%
e:LE-
!5J,0
!hQ

e7dL%
&5f%
FXI

(8I

()
10
 % 

Dd:Jf

5fF:`5(

*0
Ff
#%
e+

5`
ihg>`
Dd:Jf
%
5`
ihg>`

e:LE-
!5I

$5`F19
"h
 %

e:LE-
!5I

$5`F19
"h

e:LE8I
e:LE 
%

11

I
%
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`
j<`
    
 

I
%
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`
j<`


 






       
 

   
 DchL
/`
%F6

eR6
Y7Q
ihg>`
805gc

5V6F`
b0F:a+
%F6

 (
(DchL

/`


eR6
Y7Q
ihg>`
805gc

5V6F`
b0F:a+








  
) 
 




  













 













6
    















*0
FfF+
/d16
K1(

5g]50

*0
Ff
&5` FXI
#5`
$Dd0
&5g:U5I
&F6
#h9
&5` FXI
#5`
$Dd0
&5g:U5I
&F6
#h9
/`
*1WF9
&5fF:`5(

*0
Ff/`
*1WF9
&5fF:`5(

*0
Ff
#%
%F6

H(
#%
%F6

H(


DL
$Df5M`
#
&

%

$5X:I
56
8I
eSA]
FXI
#5`
e+
8I
e,7L

/05g]50
DV9
F6F6
i5V`
b0
DV9
Ddf
eSA]
FXI
#5`
e+
8I
e,7L

/05g]50
DV9
F6F6
i5V`
b0
DV9
Ddf
. /`
#5Mc

x-y

 $DL
$Df5M`
#
&

TTw ) /`
#5Mc



:
TTy

b1.c51`  %
8I 865;
%
FA:`
&5f$Dd>dI

$5X:I
56 
!50

FXI
#5`
&eSA]
$Df5M`   
i5V`
b0

) (
(
) TTh( ) 1


!5J,0
!hQ
 
59 
8U5I

FXI
#5`
b1.c51`
'j<` 8I
e:LE-
!5J,0
!hQ

&
eSA]
$Df5M`
8U5I

!50
FXI
#5`
 
 


  
 




24
%
e:LE

2
1
e:LE-
!5J,0
!hQ

e7dL%
j<`
e:Xf

&
0

#5`
b1.c51`
j<`
8I
eSA]
$Df5M`

%

!50
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`



\7Z
KC6
FXI
#5`
e7I5A`



%
5gf
/6FB
5f%hB
5W5O9
\17Z



%
5gf
/6FB
5f%hB
5W5O9
\17Z

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
hZ%
!5a:@
!50
Ff
*J0
$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
hZ%
!5a:@
!50
Ff
*J0

/`
#5Mc
) 2
.
eSA]
$Df5M`
%

!50
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`


 Df/`
#5Mc

!5I

$5`F19
"hI
j<`
!5I

&

%
e:LE-
!5J,0
!hQ

e7dL%
&5f%
FXI
)TTw(
\45J`
56
eg=h`

F1J`
*J0
e6

&50
e=h9
/d16
K1(
\45J`
56
eg=h`

F1J`
*J0
e6
\[c
%
\a@
&50h(
e,7L

F1J`
b0F:g6
&5ga:0h.]
\[c
%
\a@
&50h(
e,7L

F1J`
b0F:g6
&5ga:0h.]

Df

8I

e:LE







&5f

$DL
&%
Ta=
&5`
&5f
$

$5X:I 56
5fF:`5(

*0
Ff
#%
e+

e+
8I
$h6
$

$5X:I

56Dd:Jf

e+
8I
$h6
%DV`
h`
e^a=



8I
$DMc
 
8I
$DMc

5`
ihg>`

%

 
%
e:LE-
!5I

$5`F19
"h
I
%
FXI
#5`
b1.c51`
j<`
 %DV`
h`
e^a=




9
5+
b0


e,d0
e6
e=h9

Dc
e:WF-
FSc

i56
D@
*0
%
b105(
D@
*0
!50
Ff
FXI
#5`
&F6
/cihQ
/c5`
$%
*0

Dc
e:WF-
FSc

i56
D@
*0
%
b105(
D@
*0
!50
Ff
FXI
#5`
&F6
/cihQ
/c5`
$%
*0
) TTy( /`
#5Mc

) 3

56
/[1[A9
5+
b0


. eSA]
FXI
#5`
e+
8I
e,7L

/05g]50
DV9
F6F6
i5V`
b0
DV9
Ddf


%

$5X:I
56
8I

$DL
$Df5M`
#
&

-
FSc

_f
5d+

F:`5(
%
!50
Ff
*J0
e7I5A`
&F6
8I

!5a:@ 
Dc
$D
L
e:WF-
FSc

_f
5d+

F:`5(
%
!50
Ff
*J0
e7I5A`
&F6
8I
/c5`
5A]

F1J`
b0F:g6
b:W50
Df
/c5`
5A]

F1J`
b0F:g6
b:W50
Df

: 3

DchL/` %F6
eR6
Y7Q
ihg>`
805gc

5V6F`
b0F:a+

.

!50
#

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`

!50
#

$DM
F1;29
#G1`
c
!50
*0

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J

/d16
K1(
\45J` F1;29
#G1`

!50
*0

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J
`
hZ%
`
hZ%



)3(

 
 
 

/`

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
hZ%
!5a:@














 /`

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
hZ%
!5a:@

hS

FXI
#5`
e+
/95VW
DV9
hS
d`
b0
&F6
F+
FC:I
\7Z
&5f%
5`
&%

#h9
d`
b0
&F6
F+
FC:I
\7Z
&5f%
5`
&%

#h9


/`
*1WF9
&5fF:`5(

*0
Ff


F+
/d16
K1(

5g]50

*0
Ff


FXI
#5`
$Dd0
&5g:U5I
&F6
#h9


&5`
#%
%F6

H(

/d16
K1(
\45J`
hZ%
!5a:@
#hdU
e6
Dch9

e6 hL
e:WF-
FSc

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
hZ%
!5a:@
#hdU
e6
Dch9
/`
8I
e:W
F9i56
!h7Z
\65Z
D@
*0

\7Z
&5f%

!50
/`
8I
e:W
F9i56
!h7Z
\65Z
D@
*0

\7Z
&5f%

!50

5`
b1.c51`
F6F6

$DL
F:M16
!50

FX
.

j<`
!h7Z
\65Z
D@

#
FXI
#5`
e:LE-
!5I

56
I
#5`
b1.c51`
F6F6


j<`
!h7Z
\65Z
D@

#
FXI
#5`
e:LE-
!5I

56

e+
/]50

e+
/]50

* J0
! 5<`
#hdU
.

*J0 !5<`
#hdU
8I
$F+
h7U
!h7Z
\65Z
D@

56
8I
$F+
h7U
!h7Z
\65Z
D@

56

#
FXI
#5`
e+
8I
/]50

F:M16

#
FXI
#5`
e+
8I
/]50

F:M16
8I
8I.

Df

&5fF:`5(
e6
/.:J6
e+
Df

/`
#5Mc

!5`Fc
8]5@
e6
8M-56
#5`
D`
#5af
TZ%


/`
#5Mc

!5`Fc
8]5@
e6
8M-56
#5`
D`
#5af
TZ%

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
F1;29
#G1`$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
F1;29
#G1`

 
 

 

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
hZ%
!5a:@
!50
Ff
*J0

2-3

\7Z
KC6
FXI
#5`
e7I5A`
 

%
5gf
/6FB
5f%hB
5W5O9
\17Z


h9/`
!50
FXI
#5`
%

b0
#G1` &50
D@
59
Ddch9
!50
FU
!50
!hQ
F:`5(
/`
!50
FXI
#5`
%

eI
e+
DL
NCM`
/IF6
%
Y1[A9

H(

/X^:C`
!50
FU
!50
!hQ
F:`5(
eI
e+
DL
NCM`
/IF6
%
Y1[A9

H(

/X^:C`
.]Vaniek, 1972[
 Df

/`
eS@j`
e+
hQ
/`
#5Mc

&50
e=h9


/d16
K1(
\45J`
56
eg=h`

F1J`
*J0
e6
\[c
%
\a@
&50h(
e,7L

F1J`
b0F:g6
&5ga:0h.]
9
D
!50
FU
%
!hQ
c
!50
/IDdf
&5fF:`5(
G=
!50
FU
%
!hQ
hL

F1;29 Dc
!50
/IDdf
&5fF:`5(
G=
!50
FU
%
!hQ
hL
/`
eS@j`
e+
hQ #5af
Ddd+
NCM`

F1;29 #5af
Ddd+
NCM`
 F1;29


$DL
&%
Ta=
&5`
&5f
$

$5X:I
56
e+
8I
$h6



 8I
$DMc
/dV`
b0
e6
D650

!hQ
&F:a+
#5`
D`
e+
/dV`
b0
e6
D650
/`
Kf5+
F1;29
#G1`
DL56
F:M16
!50
FU
e)
Ff
/dV0
/`
Kf5+
F1;29
#G1`
DL56
F:M16
!50
FU
e)
Ff
/dV0
8I
H,UF6 F1;29

#G1`
e7I5A`
8I%DV`
h`
e^a=



H,UF6 F1;29
#G1`
e7I5A`
58
1389 / / /

e,d0
e6
e=h9
56
/[1[A9
5+
b0

Dc
e:WF-
FSc

i56
D@
*0
%
b105(
D@
*0
!50
Ff
FXI
#5`
&F6
/cihQ
/c5`
$%
*0

!5a:@ 
Dc
$D
L
e:WF-
FSc

_f
5d+

F:`5(
%
!50
Ff
*J0
e7I5A`
&F6
8I /c5`
5A]

F1J`
b0F:g6
b:W50
Df



!50
#

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J` F1;29
#G1`

!50
*0

$DMc
/d16
K1(
\45J`
hZ%


...

[ .]Alivand, 2008

[]Chen, 2007

.4

:
)1

)2 .

. [Chabini,

]1998

. 20

(
1/5

Miller 3

5 .

[.]Miller, 1999

1 -

) .

( 3 -).
59

/ / / 1389


iP

&-YB6
i$ A31,+a
G,CY
 B-8.6
C-a
AH13
B7I-3
1,
iP
f$
Bg
1a
B)B3
1aBd
5^1=
f3
1,
BZE
1a
16
AI' +a

Ae'+a
i4T
"B*,
B-Fa 
+_4[

fE
1,
1h$

&-YB6
AH13
&$i'
1,
iP
B)
1a
A31,+a
B7F)
1,


"1g!
"1a
1TkP

i6+a
`g
13 iH
J@Ia
1,
Bg
+,1hd
&F,

1gB7a1#
c,

&,
Bg
B-8.6
C-a
f' c,
"B3
[
c,

AdiH
+EB3
5E


1hd

+e-3
G-#
]31[
B-V
]01Fa
f'
+,1h^1,

A,13
1gB7a1#
c,
f'
2-6B6
c,
f3 B'
1Z7E
]4
2 - 5
.5
'
c-LL@7a
+E1eH1'
Gd
1E
B3
! +3B<6
iK
f3
&F,
f4E1>a iaBY
+Y1'

c7HAd
1-7?

]-^
f3 +Ig!%#
1

Twin
AH c--U6
fPi3Ba
1/2

( )

( )TMC UMD

 *&
(
!#
+
(




 (




$

(
),

5
. 2000

13
i6+a
]-^
c-bg
f3
5F-d
B-*bI$
+d1(a
"1gC-^1d

"fR>^
f7Ei-#
B--W6 B-8.6
+^! Ae'+a
B--W6
f7Ei-#
iP
f3
&-YB6

.

"1g1'

f-MBY
c,
5YB)
BRd

5318
f\-[
:e#
c,


1,
BZE
1a
f\-[

Bg

1h^1,
BZE
1a
1TkP
5Y1,
BY
( )
UMD

`-F\6

1,i#
"1gf(4H

fe-h3
B-Fa
B'
A-#
!
&, 

  19a
ieT
f3
5E
Ag1Ia
C-d
B*,
+\-\>6
k-shortest path



C-a
f3
f;i6
13
"Ae3
`-F\6
13 Ad f7Fd
5318
"1g .


!1Z7a
AH
"!
Sb;
"1g
fe,Cg
13
C<a
+d1a
"1gf_K1Y
f3
f7Ei-#
1a
.


19a
ieT
f3
5E


  ArcGIS9.2


5E
f7YB)
BRd

f\Qea
+(-YB6
O,
[BH
f3
f;i6
13

f\-
13

 

!
BP


f

i>d
B'
J@Ia
f3
53id
1a


5E
;
3
1TkP
f3
f;i6
13
B-Fa
c,B7h3
`7,i*^
"B
1NY
"Ae3
`-F\6


AU3

f
Aa .
B'
1-3
B,
f_=Ba
Ae$

i6
+a

1'
!
+_'
iP


+a
]4[
"1hI@33
AE
. 5

" .



"B3
iH
+a
J@Ia
AL\a
!
A4a
c-3
B-Fa
c,B6
!
AH
+e-3
G-#
"1a
BZE
1a
^>fR
;
BZE
1a
f3
f
i6
13
A73

'16i .

"

B7F<,
]9a
+31,B-Fa
"1gC-^1d

f'
5E
j
`-7YB)
BRd

5318
[f\-
"



13

 fR>^
BZE
1a
i$
iRea
c,

16 2009
[
i4T
f\-
"


f'
+d1a
!
`,B-*3
BRd

1hd

fR>^
BZE
1a
B3B3
5E
B(d
i4T
f\-[


f'
+d1a
16

1h^1,
BZE
1a
(3 -).

28
8

'
B8/a
"fR>^
BZE
1a
1,
Bg
"1a
BZE
1a
f4E1>a

f'
5H
f;i6
A,13
f74^
`-e
'+a
51Z7E
1,
"1a
BZE
1a

B

3 -
.
X^ 
](H 5E
2 .

 

C-a
B)
iH+a
f4E1>a
1h^1,
&F,
ib<a
Ad
B[
f\-[

!A>a

1?
f'
B-Fa
"1h^1,
+a1b6
"B3
!
f_=Ba
(3 -).
16

AeH13
+a
De;
&,

!
Bg
&F,
!
BZE
1a
i$
i3
B7b'
B-Fa
]' "1a BZE
1a
B3B3 

1h^1,
&F,
ib<a
4
.

iId

J-@I6
2E1ea
B-Fa
B)
1a
Ae'+a
5'B=
f-^!
"f\-[

13
16
B31'
!
AH

J-@I6
2E1ea
f-^!
B-Fa
.






!
B-Fa

AU3
!
B-Fa
c,B6

!

f4E1>a


 



!"1hH
1Z7E
13
16i'
+eU, !
B-Fa
c,B7h3


"B3
1-_bT
!

f4E1>a
iE
B-Fa
i4d
2E1ea
!
B-Fa
B)
`g
13 iH+a
B(6
C-d

"B3
!
B-Fa
f3
i3Ba
1-_bT

4 .

iH
B7I-3
!
B-Fa
BZE
1a
!
&F,
ib<a

B-Fa
BZE
1a
f'
A3
1,+a
fa
+,1;
16
A,A;
B-Fa
f4E1>a
iH
+a
B(6
.

iH

f\-[
:e#

 
 ](H

+a
"

J-@I6

13
16
fe-h,
B-Fa
ieT
f3
!
B-Fa
1bg
iK
c,

.


B(6
A,A;
AL\a
!
A4a
"B3
"

f_=Ba
1-_bT

B[
!
A4a
f\-[

f_K1Y

f'
A,A;
A4a
16
B31'
5'B=

AU3




3 1-

  ](H AEB3
AL\a
f3
B31'
f'
A31,+a
fa
+,1;
16
1-_bT
c,
iH+a

(

!#
+
((

,&


 (




$

(
),
&*
%
"'(
%

%


.3

/ / / 1389

60


TMO
N"

2R
!L
$9O
$R

Q&8

3%
$"T
!%$"3#7L
$,O
3%

$SP9#

CJ)1L
H.3L 
H8 TMO

$R


3%
Q
2P)7R
!"$R2P"
3D
2PR
$9O
$R
!<#%

2PR
!L
$9O

$SP9#


$AV>

$R

$SJ#?)7L

28

-#;T(
HL$
T:%
$R2P"
3D
!L$M(
QI$GL
N"
$S

T6
$S91%

K#63%
!"$SO
!+30
Q%
$(
2OT8
$,O
2"$
%


2O
$
/-
9 "
-

84 + $
/-

*:
5
8-
/6
4 4) 

 1

;-
0: 57(
4 -

8#
;-
0: 57(
4 -



&-
6
 -
0;
91-

-
6 $
/-
-

8-
/6
6
84 +
/6

4) 
925

/6


&-
6
 -
0;
8-
/6
6
84 +

8;-
4 -
6
/-
82
,;&
79-
9
4&;%
3

4(

*:
5
':
4 4) 

2-1
':

#
;-
':
!7.-
4 -

4&;%
3

(
(

2-
':

4&;%
3


:
 -


 -
)
6
;-

"



!


"
#
!

!

 


 


#

.4 


#
!#


#D3(
'"3"2L
43L
=6T(
28


@M+ $"3L
2/)L
U$" 
3S8
3)L
!#D3(
$R

TL QOTMO
N"


QG#F
2B%
Q% 
$6

!#D3(
$R
!L$M(
36
N"

'6
28
$E)6 2O
3F  
$ 9O
36

Q
 




!G#G/(
$
N"

Q
28
!.3>
4D
3O
"  
=6T(
4#O
3E6
$L
Q%
!#D3(

H"2&(
3%
2O28
'&*
QG#F
Q%

Q+T(
$%
56

28  


4D
3O

3)L $R$ )7"
3#
3F
H/L
2)%
$R
N"

$E)6
3%
'6
28
$E)6
2R!L
$9O

28
31)6
HGO

HM.
Q&8 
H8
28
K#63(
$SR$ )7"
N#% HGO

HM.
Q&8

!)M7F
$SR$ )7"
3#7L
Q%

&
*


&

$#(

$'
)

.5 $

AN^


#2\G
#A,
$ 
#2\G
#A,
]04
.42/A0E[
`N=X
"c_O
`4

2D
`/c^&
Z;_'
`5_G$
$
6O2D
@P4
`Y<A[

1389 / / /

61

@P4
`4
6O2D

.+0RA7
#
]8G@^
208>

AR
24
.42/A0E[
c4
A8D

e[2*
$
]/
.+0RA7
%2a#
`+_/
24
@G
`8RA

@84
`X2E[
W<
%A4
cG
6E7
%2b_H0'
$
.PU$
#

#2S8D
24
"2/2'

27
@G
!2;^
`X2V[
]/
 %2b_H0'
$

#2S8D

 .


 




6 . 


  
 


 
 


 
 
  Matlab
 
 

)Ave
 (TTUnNormal






    :


 

.

1/34= a0

$3_
CWF
!3_ 
7F
"BI
76:
$3eCWF
!3_
[)
BS8
d5
$3R
C0T
CWF
!3_
BS8
76Gb
!3`e 
dO5
a/

0/707= a1
=94%R2

[23G_
g_CV
a/

QY#

7F
$3R
C0T
$3eCWF
!3_
C/3Z_
a0-b30_

  
#

3/
Ce
$C5
"BI


a2=-1/033
6/CZ8
#3c8
"#
C,
#
C)
CPb
CK
3fb

!g8._
# Bc/._
3G>
d5
.\g`S_
BcI35
d9I
db3e3_ 36/CZ8 #3c8
"#
C,
.
( )R2
gI._
$3R
C0T
$3eCWF
!3_
[)
a0-b30_
C5C5
3/
(G/
# BbgI
._
gG?_
C0T
i_3)
BcI35
d9I


&9b 
[*I
BI
3=b 
# 
dOZb
#
a05
.53/C0G_ 
HA5

"BI
!305
4\3O_
d5 d<g8
35
3/
Ce
(G/
d6F3?_

E
5 8 28 . 7
%94
_53:
CWF
!3_
a9VC,
CPb

35
#
C9G=/
^9/g-\

"3W9F
35
.53/C0G_
d=09b 
[*I
U\
7`GY Be._
!3Jb

.53/C0G
 7
dP?\

CWF
!3_
!3`e
7`GY
a/

3f\3/
$
C5
"BI
d9VC,
CPb

CWF
!3_
Be .

.

gK
d5
d) 7F
._
!3Jb

3f\3/

*
&
)
'

&

$#(

$



$3e"
3F
C5
#
a/

"B_
7F

_=`
d5
C0G_
.SY#
CWF
!3_
g
gI._
dP>i_
d)
gN
!3`e
7F
"BI
7V3/
$



.

#2\G
#A,
]04
.42/A0E[
`N=X
"c_O
`4



C5C5


2



dP?\

C0G_
a/
CWF
!3_
g`=_
d
)
7F
.\3>

a/
7F
"BI
dZ0Y
_
#
g<g

^
AN

#2\G
#A,
$


3F
d/gb%
2D
`/c^&
Z;_'
`5_G$
$

[
6O2D
@P4
`Y<A

d)
gN !3`e
3_
Be
._
!3Jb

.53/C0G_
$3eD0\3b
;/39b

(0VC8
#
`+_/
24
@G
`8RA,


T0
.
16 18
C0:18

.-bg-'
^Y
#3W8
a/
#
7F
"g5
dZ0Y

@P4
`4

6O2D

.+0RA7
#
]8G@^
208>

AR
24
.42/A0E[
c4
A8D

e[2*
$
]/
.+0RA7
%2a

"3W9F
35
d)
7F
_
$C0G
0F
C0G_

g<#
+b
@C9G)3
F
#3W9_
C0G_
#
# "30

[*I

7`GY

gI

_.

+b
"3

$ .

@84
`X2E[
W<
%A4
cG
6E7
%2b_H0'
$
.PU$
#

#2S8D
24
"2/2'

27
@G


!2;^
`X2V[
]/
'%2b_H0

$


#2S8D
24
_
g`=_
gI._
dP>i_
d)
gN

d5
$3_
$3fb#
3F
C5
#
C9G=/

T42M[
C(D
BR
!A^

#2S8D
24



]/A8b4

W+G
^\
c
!3`e
7F
"BI
d6F3?_
3/
Ce
$C5
"B_
7F


[@G
#A0>
$
`5D2=[
`N=X
`4
`N=X
cI
`4
`+5G
%2bX2/
.[2\7
ASD
"2

C8
"38g)
dZ0Y
2009
)
36/CZ8
d


C5C5


3F
d/gb%
"
3F
C5
C0G_
a/
.SY#
[@G
A?8D
@JV[
$
@5[
]04
A0E

 7F

dZ0Y
5

#
g<g_
$3_
$3e


_$3_
!#
C5
"#iR
!

d)
7F
$C0G
>
[*I
+b $C9G)3@
C0G_
3_
7F
(0839F
CWF
!3_
35
C9G=/

[K3


"$
A/2V[
.42/
A0E[
%A4
#@G
2?8^
`N=X
`4
`:c7
24


F?4

#@G
"204
3X2M[
T5L
2bX2/
%2[
"$
`5D2=[
cN_[
`4 35/71 .

C5C5
C0G_
a/
.SY#
CWF
!3_
g`=_
gI
._
dP>i_
d)
gN !3`e
7F
"BI
"3W9F
D0b 2P4A[
]/A8\*
$

#2S8D
24
)0RA7
%2[
%2aA
!3_
3MV
d/D=8
#
3/
(G/

W+G
@_^2[
2bX2/

)/
Aa
.-8Sa
$
`^$
.8O2D
ASD
"2[
%2ac\^
$
'8[2

T0 25/36
e
C5

[*I

C0G_
#
;/39b
g_
$30G5

d)
Bb3`b
d9W,3b
d96\
7F
C8
)"38g)
d0\#
C0G_
#
Ce

d
7F
"B_
7F
@G
A/
A/2V[
A4A4
"
`;08^
$

 ^;@G
!2
[=
BR
!A^ 
25D2=[
]/
@G
`5D2
4 :

>/B5
$C_
d\3G_
a/
d)

g<#
3fb
./B<
3`9
Bc)._
g6R
h35
(G/
35
$3f\3/

C0G_
d)
$g_

3fc8
#
BbgI
_.
`^$ $2_7
#$
24
A8[2'
"$




H/3`b
.5gA5
!

X0Z?8
;/39b
d)
BI 3=b
$dbg,
d5
CWF
!3_
#
#
#
BLZ_
#
B6_
3Zb
3A9b
$

g_
dbg`b
a/





 .-8Sa
$2_7
#$
24
A8[2'
"$

.ZOc_
"B_
7F
d5
;/39b
7VC,

   
\ 3=b
!g,3bg,
$3eBLZ_
#
B6_
#
U]9A_
h3>
$C5
d)
^e
$C-/
BS9_
$3f9G8

d96

`^d2D
$2_7
#$
24
A8[2'
"$
 
 

 
   

   


    7I
.bgA`e
d*6I
70SY#
         
 

$

#@[
6D

`
4
ASD
"2[
$
#@G
#@a2H[ %`N=X
ASD
"2[
]04 
  .-8E5\a 3/AK
cG.[
`N<e[
`*
cL "2\a

  


   


*\6D
#@G
`8RA,
AN^

%2aA8[2'
`4
ASD
"2[
%d24 .-8E5\a
#@_a
"2H^
`* 6D  2P4A[
]/A8



d6F3?_
$3_
CWF
!3_ 
7F
"BI
76:
$3eCWF
!3_
[)
BS8
d5
$3R
C0T
CWF
!3_
BS8
76Gb
!3`e 
dO5
a/

$3R
C0T
[23G_
g_CV
a/

QY#

7F
$3R
C0T
$3eCWF
!3_
C/3Z_
a0-b30_

  
#

3/
Ce
$C5
"BI

db#
36/CZ8
#3c8
"#
C,
#
C)
CPb
CK
3fb

!g8._
# Bc/._
3G>
d5
.\g`S_
BcI35
d9I
db3e3_ 36/CZ8 #3c8
"#
C,
gI._
$3R
C0T
$3eCWF
!3_
[)
a0-b30_
C5C5
3/
(G/
# BbgI
._
gG?_
C0T
i_3)
BcI35
d9I
&
a/
;/39b 
[*I
BI
3=b 
# 
dOZb
#
a05
.53/C0G_ 
HA5

"BI
!305
4\3O_
d5 d<g8
35
3/
Ce
(G/
d6F3?_

E
_
$C5
753:
CWF
!3_
a9VC,
CPb

35
#
C9G=/
^9/g-\

"3W9F
35
.53/C0G_
d=09b 
[*I
U\
7`GY Be._
!3Jb

.53/C0G

)
+%
('
 


"*

)(
!%
"
&
*
,

 $

$
dP?\
gK
d5
d) 7F
 
dP?\

CWF
!3_
!3`e
7`GY
a/

3f\3/
$
C5
"BI
d9VC,
CPb

CWF
!3_
Be
._
!3Jb

3f\3/
.6 ) ) )



6O2D

[
6O2D

cL

2/
Aa
%2[
ASD
"2
@2/
Aa
.+0RA7
%2aA8[2'
$
#
G
`5D2=[
%2b^$
A/2V[

#2S8D
24
C(D

$3_
$3e
"
3F
C5
#
a/

"B_
7F

_=`
d5
C0G_
.SY#
CWF
!3_
g
gI._
dP>i_
d)
gN
!3`e
7F
"BI
7V3/

"2[
cU$

2/ 2PR
@P7
2b_7
%`V0U
ASD
"2[
2OeL
]8G
208>

W0X
`4
%c[
`^c\^
]/
[=
@G
`5D2

6O2D
27

C5C5

dP?\

C0G_
a/
CWF
!3_
g`=_
d
)
7F
.\3>

a/
7F
"BI
dZ0Y


C5C5 
3F
d/gb%
_
#
g<g
62
/ / / 1389

@[
"c7.[
%!3`e
3_
Be
`V0U
ASD
"2[
#
]8G
208>

24
A/


^@^@G
`8RA,
AN
2/
Aa
)E/ `5D2=[
 @_8Ea
%2O
A0Q
`*
2aASD

dP>i_
d)
gN
._
!3Jb

.53/C0G_
$3eD0\3b
;/39b

(0VC8
C0:18
.-bg-'
^Y
#3W8
a/
#
7F
"g5
dZ0Y



'".
%
1
#&.


2-
 #

 
/+#
#)0


#&  
#&.
*- 
 
#
/
#&  
#&.
0
,

`5D2=[
%A4 
`M4

@G24
ASD
"2[
C_:

@/24
[2/
)E/
`+_/
W0X
`4
2
^$
6D
`4
B0
[
%2O
A0Q
`X2E[ A0917
"2

D0\3b

"3W9F
35
d)
7F

$C0G_ +b
"30F
C0G_

g<#
+b
$C9G)3@
# "30F
#3W9_
C0G_
#

[*I

7`GY

gI
_.

#&!
.
(+
1$ 

&

.
 

".
%
1
#&.

%
2-
.




   


  

   
 


 
 
 
 
     



  

  


   


.

d .

7

d6F3?_
$3_
CWF
!3_ 
7F
"BI
76:
$3eCWF
!3_
[)
BS8
d5
$3R
C0T
CWF
!3_
BS8
76Gb
!3`e

O5
a/


 


#

3/
Ce
$C5
"BI

_
$3R
C0T
[23G_
g_CV
a/

QY#

7F
$3R
C0T
$3eCWF
!3_
C/3Z_
a0-b30

db#
36/CZ8
#3c8
"#
C,
#
C)
CPb
CK
3fb

!g8
36/CZ8
#3c8
"#
C,

_ .6 ._
# Bc/._
3G>
d5
.\g`S_
BcI35
d9I
db3e3


C0T
i_3)
BcI35
d9I
_?BbgI
._
gG

.
gI
._
$3R
C0T
$3eCWF
!3_
[)
a0-b30_
C5C5
3/
(G/
#

a/
;/39b

[*I
BI

#
_
dOZb
#
a05
.53/C0G
&d<g8
35
3/
Ce
(G/
d6F3?_

E
5 2009


3=b


HA5

"BI
!305
4\3O_
d5


$C5
753:
CWF
!3_
a9VC,
CPb

35
#
C9G=/
^9/g-\

"3W9F
35
.53/C0G_
d=09b


[*I
U\
7`GY
Be
3
_._
!3Jb

.53/C0G
32/57
.

$
dP?\
gK
d5
d) 7F 
dP?\

CWF
!3_
!3`e
7`GY
a/

3f\3/
$C5
"BI
d9VC,
CPb

CWF
!3_
Be._
!3Jb

3f\3/
.


$3_
$3e"
3F
C5
#
a/

"B_
7F
d5
C0G_
.SY#
CWF
!3_
g`=_
gI._
dP>i_
d)
gN !3`e
7F
"BI
7V3/
7-

_
C5C5 
dP?\

C0G_
a/
CWF
!3_
g`=_
d )
7F
.\3>

a/
7F
"BI
dZ0Y

C5C5 
3F
d/gb% 
#
g<g
.
.

 
dP>i_
d)
gN !3`e
3_
Be._
!3Jb

.53/C0G_
$3eD0\3b
;/39b

(0VC8 C0:18
.-bg-'
^Y
#3W8
a/
#
7F
"g5
dZ0Y


_
D0\3b

"3W9F
35
d)
7F
$C0G_ +b
"30F
C0G_

g<#
+b $C9G)3@
# "30F
#3W9_
C0G_
# 
[*I

7`GY

gI.
43/29 .


CWF
!3_
g`=_
gI._
dP>i_
d)
gN !3`e
7F
"BI
d6F3?_
3/
Ce
$C5
"B_
7F
d5
$3_
$3fb#
3F
C5
#
C9G=/

"
3F
C5
C0G_
a/
.SY#

C5C5

3F
d/gb%

C0G_


C8

"38g)
dZ0Y
7F)
36/CZ8
d

dZ0Y


#
g<g_
$3_
$3e

_
C0G_
3
 7F

7-



_

3f\3/
$3_
!#
C5
"#iR
!

d)
7F
$C0G
@
[*I
+b $C9G)3
>
(0839F
CWF
!3_
35
C9G=/

[K3

.

d
5



C5C5
C0G_
a/
.SY#
CWF
!3_
g`=_
gI
!3`e
7F
"BI
"3W9F
D0b._
dP>i_
d)
gN
!3_
3MV
d/D=8
#
3/
(G/



X6Oc_
^e
C5

[*I

C0G_
#
;/39b
g_
$30G5

d)
Bb3`b
d9W,3b
d96\
7F
C8
)"38g)
d0\#
C0G_
#
Ce

d
7F
"B_
7F

.

>
7F
.f/B5
$C_
d\3G_
a/
d)

g<#
3fb
./B<
3`9
_.

Bc)._
g6R
h35
(G/
35
$3f\3/

C0G_
d)
$g_

3fc8
#
BbgI

gI
"
H/3`b
.5gA5
!

X0Z?8
;/39b
d)
BI
dbg,
d5
CWF
!3_
#
#
#
BLZ_
#
B6_
3Zb
3A9b
$3=b
$

 g_
dbg`b
a/ .


35
#
"g5
.ZOc_
"B_
7F


d5
;/39b
7VC,
\3=b
!g,3bg,
$3eBLZ_
#
B6_
#
U]9A_
h3>
$C5
d)
^e
$C-/
BS9_
$3f9G8

d96

.

7I
.bgA`e
d*6I
70SY#

'
 

".
%
1
#&.


2-
 #

 
/+#
#)0


#&  
#&.
*- 
 
#
/
#&  
#&.
0
,

.7 8 28) )

()!&#

.
(+
1$


&

.
 

".
%



1
#&.

2-
.


()%

63

/ / / 1389

- Chabini, I. (1998) Discrete dynamic shortest path

problems in transportation application, Complexity
and Algorithms with Optimal Run Time, Transportation Research Record, 1645, pp. 170-175.

-
.

- Chen, X., Hu, J. and Hu, X. (2007) On the minimum risk-sum path problem, Lecture Notes in Computer Sciences, Springer, 4614, pp. 175-185

30
. 6

- Clark, S. (2003) Traffic prediction using multivariate nonparametric regression, Journal of transportation engineering, Vol. 129, No. 2, pp. 161-168.

- Cooke, K. L. and Halsley, E. (1966) The shortest

route through a network with time-dependent intermodal transit times, Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Application, Vol. 14, pp. 275-323.

- Cormen, T.H., Leiserson, C. E., Rivest, R.L.and

Stein, C. (2001) Introduction to algorithms, MIT
Press and McGraw-Hill, pp. 588-601

.

.

- Dean, B.R. (2004) Shortest paths in FIFO timedependent networks: Theory and algorithms, Technical Report, Massachusetts Institute of Technology,
U.S.A

.7
- Ahmed, M.S., and Cook (1979) Analysis of freeway traffic time-series data by using Box-Jenkins
techniques, Transportation Research Record, Vol.
722, pp. 19.

- Dechter, R. and Pearl, J. (1985) Generalized bestfirst search strategies and the optimality of A*, Journal of the ACM; Vol. 32, No. 3, pp. 505-536.

- Ahuja, R.K., Orlin, J. B., Pallottino, S. and Scutella, M.G. (2003) Dynamic shortest path minimizing
travel times and costs Networks, Vol. 41, No. 4, pp.
197-205.

- Djidjev, H., Pantziou, G. and Zaroliagis, C. (2000)

Improved algorithms for dynamic shortest paths,
Algorithmica, Vol. 28, No. 4, pp. 367-389.
- Frigioni, D., Matchetti-Spaccamela, A. and Nanni,
U. (2000) Fully dynamic algorithms for maintaining
shortest path trees, Journal of Algorithma, Vol. 34,
No. 2, pp. 251-281.

- Alivand, M. (2008) Navigation services in dynamic traffic by mobile geospatial information systems,
M.Sc thesis, K.N. Toosi University of Technology,
Iran

- Guhnemann, A., Schafer, R.P., Theissnhusen, K. and

Wagner, P. (2004) Monitoring traffic and emissions
by floating car data, Institute of Transport Studies,
The University of Sydney and Monash University.

- Alivand, M., Alesheikh, A. A. and Malek, M. R.

(2008) New method for finding optimal path in dynamic networks, World Applied Sciences Journal,
Vol. 3, No.1, pp. 25-33.

- Heil and Walnut. (1989) Continuous and discrete

wavelet transforms, Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics Review, Vol. 31, No.4, pp. 628-666.

- Azizi, A. (2003) Network analysis for urban traffic in a GIS, M.Sc Thesis, Kn. Toosi University of
Technology, 2003.

64

1389 / / /


- Vanicek and Wells. (1972) The least squares approximation and related topics, Department of Surveying Engineering, University of New Brunswick.

- Huang, B., Wu, Q. and Zhan, F.B. (2007) A shortest

path algorithm with novel heuristics for dynamic transportation network, International Journal of Geographical Information Science, Vol. 21, No. 6, pp. 625-644.

- Wu, J. J., Sun, H. J., Gao, Z.Y, and Li, S.B. (2007)
Effects of route guidance systems on small-world
network, International Journal of Modern Physics,
C, Vol. 18, No. 8, pp. 1243-1250.

- Ide, T. and Kato, S. (2008) Travel-time prediction

using Gaussian Process Regression: A trajectorybased approach, IBM Research, Tokyo Research
Laboratory

- Wu, Q. (2006) Incremental routing algorithms for

dynamic transportation networks, M.Sc thesis, Calgary University, Canada.

- Klunder, G.A. and Post, H.N. (2006) The shortest

path problem on large scale real road networks, Networks, Vol. 48, No. 4, pp. 182-194.
- Matlab7.6.0 Help, (1984-2007) The MathWorks. Inc.
- Miller, H.J. (1999) Measuring space-time accessibility benefits within transportation networks: basic
theory and computational methods, Geographical
Analysis, Vol. 31, pp.187-212.
- Miller-Hooks, E, and Yang, B.Y. (2005) Updating paths in time-varying networks given arc weight
changes, Transportation Science, Vol. 39, No. 4, pp.
451-464.
- Murchland, J. D. (1970) A fixed matrix method
for all shortest distances in a directed graph and
for the inverse problem, PhD thesis, University of
Karlsruhe, Germany
- Nakata, T. and Takeuchi, J. I. (2004) Mining traffic
data from Probe-Car system for travel time prediction, Internet System Research Laboratories, NEC
Corporation, Japan.
- Pallottino, S. and Scutella, M.G. (1998) Shortest
path algorithms in transportation models: Classical and innovative aspects, In: Marcotta, P. and S.
Nguyen (eds.). Equilibrium and advanced transportation modeling, Kluwer, pp. 245-281.
- Preygel, A. (1999) Path finding: A comparison of
algorithms, Management Science, Matthews.
- Thompson, E. (2003) Integrating PDA, GPS and
GIS technologies for mobile traffic data acquisition
and traffic data analysis, M.Sc Thesis, IT University
of Goteborg.

1389 / / /

65