2(62), 2009

2(62)
2009

CA&CC Press

 2(62), 2009

: 620720-0459

: M-770

CA&CC Press.
: 556699-5964
: 22 339

/: (994 - 12) 497 12 22 E-mail: elis@tdb.baku.az

/: (46) 920 62016 E-mail: m.esenov@gmail.com

(, )
/: (994 - 12) 499 11 73 E-mail: jeyvazov@gmail.com
()
/: (+7 - 701) 531 61 46 E-mail: timur-cac@mail.ru
()
.: (+996 - 312) 65-48-33 E-mail: lbondarets@mail.ru
()
.: (992 - 917) 72 81 79 E-mail: madzamila@mail.ru
()
.: (998 - 71) 125 43 22 E-mail: farkhad_tolipov@yahoo.com
()
: (+994 50) 3006694 E-mail: ziken12@yahoo.co.uk
()
: (374 - 1) 56 65 59 E-mail: haroutiun@gmail.com
()
.: (995 - 32) 96 85 87 E-mail: sakresp@gol.ge
()
.: (972) 2 5882332 E-mail: mssamed@olive.mscc.huji.ac.il
()
.: (49 - 89) 3003132 E-mail: GA-infoservice@s.m.isar.de
()
.: (86) 10-64039088 E-mail: sunzhzh@isc.cass.net.cn
()
. (7 - 495) 3163146 E-mail: egorova@mosinfo.ru
()
.: (380-44) 524 79 13 E-mail: zhangozha@yahoo.co.uk

2(62), 2009

, ,
()
, ()
,
( )
, ,
()
, , -
()
()
,
()
, ,
,
()
, ,
. .. ,

( )
, ,
()
, ()
, ()
()

()
,
()
,
- ( )
,
()
, ,
()
, ,
( )
, ,
()
, , - ,
()
,
. c ()
, ()
, ,

()

, ,

:
CA&CC Press AB
Hubertusstigen 9. 97455 Lule
SWEDEN
: www.ca-c.org

, 2009
CA&CC Press, 2009

 2(62), 2009

-
2(62) 2009 .

. .

-
:
, , ......................... 7

. .

............................................... 19
. .

-
......................................................... 29

. .


............................................................... 36
4

2(62), 2009

. . FRICTION



............................................................ 51
. , :
. .
...................................................... 61
. .
:
.................................................. 76
. .

..................................................... 84
. . VS.



................................................................................. 95

. . :


............................................................. 103
. . ,
............................................................. 118
. .




.................................................................................... 130
. ,
. .
.................................................................... 138
5

 2(62), 2009

. . -

-
.............................. 151

,
, , ,

2(62), 2009

-
:
, ,

, ,


()

(1827
1897 .),

,
, , - . ,
, - . , . ,

, , , , -

- 100 1.

? ,
, - ? - ?
1
- (., , !
- (). 18
2007 [www.osdp.kz], - . ).

 2(62), 2009

? , (. , . , .
.)?
,

,
, - . - ( . , 310 .), -
() (. ,
140 .), -
() (. , 90 .), - (. ,
61 .), -
() (. , 5 .),
- () (. , 5 .) 2.


-
: 1990, 1993, 1998 .
(, , -

,

.)
, ,
- , . , . , . , . -, . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . .
, , - (-, -,
-, -). ,
- - , . ,
, , ,
: ,
,
,
, , -,
, .

2
, ,
,
.

, ( , , -), , ( ) : . ,
8

2(62), 2009

. , . , . , . , . . . 3, . 4. , ,
5. ,
, ,
, ,
6.
,
. , ,
- ,
. ,
adolat, , -
, - . , , , .
- . . , XX .
, . , . - : , , . , ,
, , , 7. (-, , ), , .
, ?8
, , -,
; -, ; -,
.
, .
O Estado de So Paulo, 4 April 2007.
. // , 25 2005.
5
The Guardian, 27 tober 2004.
6
The Guardian, 17 February 2006.
7
.: . - ,
6 2003 [www.varorud.rg] (. : . , , 10 2008 [www.ozodi.org], . ).
8
, (), (. 14)
. ,
, , .
3
4

 2(62), 2009

, , ,
,
. , 1990- 9, - .
, . , , , . - ,
. , , , . - , - , , .
-10. -
: , ,
. , ,
, ,
.
- , , ,
.
- ( ),
, , . , . , , , 11. , , , , 12. ,
- . : .
.
.: .. , 1995 [www.press-service.uz].
.: . - ,
6 2003.
11
.: ! [www.osdp.kz].
12
.: . : , 6 2007 [www.kisi.kz].
9

10

10

2(62), 2009

, - 13.
, , ,
. , -,
, .

,

?


. , . , .
( . , 55 . ),
(. , 90 .), . , , ( ) - . .
: .
, ,
14.
.
, - , , 1994 , , , . - ()
( ).
, ,
15.
13
2007 () .
(21 ).

. , ; , , (.: 20 2009
[www.un.org]).
14
.. . : , 2003. . 88.
15
.: - . 2 24
1994 [www.kenesh.org].

11

 2(62), 2009

-.
, , , . , . , -
: , ; ,
. . , ,
. , - , , .
,
1990-
16. , , , - -
, . ,
, , -
17, 18, ,
19, . ? , . . ,
, 20, . . , 21.
.
-
?
, , , . , , , , . , , , ,
, . , ,
- . ,
- 22 ,
16
.: .. 48- . 28 1993
[www.press-service.uz].
17
.: .. XXI : , , 1997 [www.press-service.uz].
18
.: .
19
.: .. , , .
(1998, 2) [www.press-service.uz].
20
.. , 1995 [www.press-service.uz].
21
.: .. , 1995 [www.
press-service.uz].
22
Socialist International Leaders Address Global Financial Crisis in Meeting at United Nations 26 September 2008. Statement on the Global Financial Crisis. 26 September 2008 [www.socialistinternational.org].

12

2(62), 2009

.
.

-




- : , -
, ,
, , . , , , , ,
.

, .
( ) , . -
, , -
, .

-,
. ,
, ,
.

. , - : , , , ,
.
-
. -, , , . .
13

 2(62), 2009

-?
-
, , , - . , (,
)23.
.
. , (,
).
- , . - ,
,
, , , ,
. .
, 35 24.
, , ,
. , , ,
. , ,
( , , ). , ,
, . , - - ,
.
- ? ,
. , , , , , .
, ,

.
23
-
(.: - .
24 1994 [www.kenesh.org]).
24
.: . - ,
6 2003.

14

2(62), 2009

2009-:


-
, , - .
25.
- 26.

: , (19912000 .).
2001 ,
, 2002-
: ,
, 2003- , , , , . 1 2002 , ,
. , ,
,
,
27. -

, .
, -
,
. , ,
, - . . : , , . . .
, 28. , , , , ,
. - 29.
.: - , 20 2009 [www.akorda.kz].
- . 24 1994 .
27
.: ..
. , 16- [www.press-service.uz].
28
. - , 6 2003.
29
.: . , - 2008 2009 (, 16 2009 .) [www.president.tj].
25
26

15

 2(62), 2009

- . ! -30. -
2009
.
-
, , , , , , ,
- : , . -,
:

31.

:
-

?
, 15 32.
2008
20092012 33. , ,
2008 - . (
. ,
).
, ,
-
, - 34: - ; , ; ; ; .: ! .
.
32
.: .. , 1995.
33
, , , ,
- , ,
, , ,
.
34
- .: . I // , 1997, 5 (11). . 7.
30
31

16

2(62), 2009

35. , . , ,
, 36.
15 - . : , ,
, , .
-
, , , , . , . ,
,
. . ,
. , 37.
, , -
, ,
38,
. , .
- .
, , . , , 39 (, )
, , , , 40.

,
-


,
35
.: ..
[www.akorda.kz]. ,
, 10-
[www.akorda.kz].
36
.: .. . . 14.
37
.: . - ,
6 2003.
38
.: .-. . , 21 2009 [www.politobraz]; . 4 , - , 25 2009 [www.politobraz].
39
.: . . , 9
2009 [www.politoboz.ru].
40
.: .

17

 2(62), 2009

-. , ,
, , ,
-.
, , . ,
- .
, ( , , 41). - , . , -
42.
, - . , .
, , ,
.
-
. ,
- , , . , , , - .
, , ,
-. , ,
- ,
43.
- .

* * *
, , . -, ,
. , -, ,
, 41
.: Socialist International Leaders Address Global Financial Crisis in Meeting at United Nations 26 September 2008. Statement on the Global Financial Crisis. 26 September 2008.
42
.: .-. . .
43
.: . - ,
6 2003. . , , 31 2007 [www.press-uz.info].

18

2(62), 2009

44.
- .
44
.: Socialist International Leaders Address Global Financial Crisis in Meeting at United Nations 26 September 2008. Statement on the Global Financial Crisis. 26 September 2008.

,
,


(, )

.

,
.

,
, .
,
,
, . ,
.

,
.

, , . , , ,
,
.
,
, , , .
- , 19

 2(62), 2009

. , , , -
1.

,
.
, ,
,
, , .

,

1
.: .. . . 2-..
.: , 2001. . 40.

, ,
, , (.. ).
, . , - . , .

3.
, .
4, , .
( , ) , . , , , , ( ) . . , , . ,
, , ,
5.
2

( ,
, ) (622661 .).
3
, .
4
.: .. . . . 46.
5
.: -, -. / . ., .. . .: (), 1984. . 220221.

20

2(62), 2009

, . , .
, 6.
,
, , - 7.

:
(, , ) (, , , , .),
.
, , -, , , , , , , 8. , , , ,

.
, . .
.
, . , , ,
.
6
.: .. -. .: : . .: , 1991. C. 260;
Barrett D., Kurian G., Johnson T. World Christian Encyclopedia. 2nd edition. A Comparative Survey of Churches
and Religions in the Modern World. New York: Oxford University Press, 2001. 2 vols. 719 p.
7
.: . : // , 2004, 1 (16)
[http://www.religare.ru/ article8821.htm]
8
.: ..
. , 2001 [http://www.sociology.kharkov.ua/docs/chten_01/ gerasina.
doc].

21

 2(62), 2009

, .
. , - - ( ) , , . , . 9. ,
, ().
, - (18051849 .) , (18631883 .).

. :
, , ,
.
, , ( )
. , , .
, , -,
, , - . , 10 , ,
, . , , ()
, - .

10
.
,
9
.: Pye L.W. Asian Power and Politics: The Cultural Dimensions of Authority. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1985. 414 pp.
10
(.: Rustow D.A. Middle
Eastern Political Systems. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: The City University of New York, Prentice-Hall, Inc.,
1971. P. 7273).

22

2(62), 2009

.
.
,

,
( ), , .
- , . , ,
, , .
.
( . ,
. , . ) .
, . 2005 -, 77 , 24 . , -2005: . , , , .

, . 1952
-, 1805
1806 11.
, .
.
.
12.
, 19701980- ,
. , , .
,
, 2003
. ,
.: Rustow D.A. Op. cit. P. 4749.
, 19521986 30 . (19511991 .) 14 ( , .) (.: ..
: . . .: . 16 2005 [http://www.iimes.ru/rus/frame_stat.html]).
11
12

23

 2(62), 2009

, ,
. . ,
,
13.
. .
, , . .
( 2000 .),
. . . , . . .
, .
, ,
, .

: , , .
. ( . ) ,
. .
. .
,
, .
. ,
, - . ,
43- ,
. - . ,
-
,
-.

,
, .
13

.: .. . .

24

2(62), 2009

, , . ,
, , ,
, , , ,
14. , -
, . ,
; , ,
, .
,
, , 15. -16 , , , ,
. , ,
, , .
, , , 17.
. , XX
. , , :
1) ;
2) ,
, , .;
3) , ,
, .
1970
1980- . (), , ()
, , . ,
20 . 1970 46 . 1981-,
1991- 91 . , 45 . 10 . .
1992 60 . , , . , 14
.: The State of Religion in Egypt Report / Ed. by Abdel-Fattah Nabil, Rashwan Diaa. Cairo: Centre for
Political and Strategic Studies, 19951997. P. 56.
15
.: Wickham C.R. From the Periphery to the Center. The Islamic Trend in Egypts Professional Associations. .: Mobilizing Islam. Religion, Activism, and Political Change in Egypt. N.Y.: Columbia University
Press, 2002. P. 176183.
16
1928 - . ().
17
.: Sullivan D.J., Sana A.-K. Islam in Contemporary Egypt. Civil Society vs. the State. London: Boulder,
Lynne Rienner Publishers, 1999. P. 22.

25

 2(62), 2009

, 1993 170 . ,
30 . 18.

, , . , , , . , (),
.
, .

() . 19. , .
32 1964 64 2002 ,
. ,
. ,
; , , ,

. , ,
.
, () () 1990-
14 15 ., , , 30 .20 . - , 11 360, 27,6% . , 1990 3 . 21.
1994 - 22 , 8 .

.
, , , .
18
.: The Middle East Watch. Third World Traveler [http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/ Middle_East/
Middle EastWatch.html].
19
.: Al Sayyid M.K. A Civil Society in Egypt. .: Civil Society in the Middle East? / Ed. by A.R. Norton. Vol. 1. Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1995. 300 pp.
20
.: Wickham C.R. The Parallel Islamic Sector. .: Mobilizing Islam. Religion, Activism, and Political
Change in Egypt. P. 99.
21
.: Ben-Nfissa S. NGOs, Governance and Development in the Arab World // Management of Social TransformationsMOST. Discussion Paper, 2000, No. 46 [http://www.unesco.org/most /nefissae.htm]; Revel M., Roca P.J. Les
ONG et la question du changement. .: Deler J.P., Faur Y.A., Roca P.J. ONG et dveloppement. Paris: Karthala,
1998. 221 pp.
22
.: Egyptian-American Human Rights Activist Saad Eddin Ibrahim Receiving Second Trial for Receiving Unauthorized Foreign Donations and Embezzling // High Beam Research, 20 May 2002 [http://www.highbeam.
com/doc/1P1-53105022.html].

26

2(62), 2009

, , , . . .
- -, 26 ,
123.
, . , (), , .
32, . , ,
.

. , , , ,
. ,
, . . -, 4
500 1991 .
21 ,
23. . , ,
, .
, .
, , , . . ,
1980- 16 .
,
- -, :
, .
, .
. ,
19801990- .
- - -- --, -, -
- ,
, , , ,
.
23

.: Ben-Nfissa S.P. Op. cit.

27

 2(62), 2009

, ,
.
. , ,
, ,
,
.
19801990-
, . -, , (), - . -,
,
.

,
, .

, , ,
,
, .
, , . .
, , .
,
, ,
.
,
.. . . . , , .
, , , . , .
, , , , - :
28

2(62), 2009

, . , ,
, .

,
,



(, )

-
(). () , , ,
, .
,
- . ,
, , - .
- -
. -
, ,
, ,
1.
1

.: , 20 2005.

29

 2(62), 2009

,

,
2.
,
.
,
- .
, , () ,
, - .
. , ,
, , ,
3. , ,
1990- . :
, , , ,
.
, ,
, - 4.
,
, - , - .

.

.
, , , , . , (
) .
2
.: . : // , 2007, 9.
3
.: .. . , . , 2006.
4
.: .

30

2(62), 2009

, , , ( ) .
,
. , . , , ,
5.
,
,
(), , . , ,

.
,
. , - , , -
.
, - ,
, ,
.
. , , . , , 6. ,
( , ). , ( )
. (, , ). 7.
. 8.
, . , .: .. . .
.: .. // , 2007, 137.
7
.
8
. // , 2 2005.
5
6

31

 2(62), 2009

. -
,
.
. ,
, . 9.
, , , , , .
. -
. ,
,
, . ,
, . , , , , . .
. , .
,
! ,
, , . . - :
, . , , .
,
. .
,
. 10.
, , -
:
, - , - ;

, ,
;
-
- , , , ;

- .
9

.: . . .
.: , 2006, 37 (1792).

10

32

2(62), 2009

,
.
, . , -
,
11.
.
. , -
. - ,
, 12.
- ,
, , ,
13. , , , ,
, , , ., .
, , ,
. , ,
,
, .
, , , , , .
,

, ,
.
-
- .
, ,
.
11

net].

.: .. [www.edu-zone.

12
.: .. // , 2002, 12.
13
.: .

33

 2(62), 2009

1. ,
, , , , .
2. , .
3.

. ,
,
.
4.
-
, , - . ,
, , , , , , , . , ,
.
,

.
5. - ()
. , ,
,
, , .
6. ,
( ) - .
7. , , , -
.
8. ,
, , ,
.
34

2(62), 2009

9.
.
10.
, - , , .

.
, .
, , -
, , ,
-
.
, - , ,

, .

35

 2(62), 2009

,
,


(, )

(2008 .)
. ,
,

.
. ,
() .
-

,
.
: ;
, ,

..
.
36

2(62), 2009

. .

, ,
, , , 1.

, . , ? ,

.


-
2
.

XXI , .

* * *
,
XXI , . ,
.
.

.
.
.

,
,
.


.
. , XX
(
19171920 .,
1991 .) ( . , . )

, (
. )
.
,
, , , .
,

. -

1
Caracciolo L. La Lezione di Putin alla Casa Bianca // La Repubblica, 18 August 2008.
2
, ,

.
, ,
, .

- - , . ,
() . , , .
, - .
,
.

37

 2(62), 2009

,

.

, , .
, , , , . , - .

,
.

, - .

(XIX .)


. . ,

, 1888 .
,
3.

.
(
) 1941
1946-.
,


4. -
.
-
.
,
.

-
.
- ,


,
.
, XXXXI


. , . -

.
4
-
- (.: .. 1941:
. // , 2004, 3. . 24, 2627).

3
.: .
: //
, 2000, 3. . 73.

38

2(62), 2009

, ( )
, .
,
.
-

5.
5
. . .: ,
2001. . 282.

I.
:



. .
, .

. ( - 1991 .)
, .
,
. ,
-, . ,
,
. , ( ) , . 2/3 40% 6.
, , .
7.
6
.: Energy Superbowl. Strategic Politics and the Persian Gulf and Caspian Basin. Nixon Center for Peace
and Freedom. Washington, DC, 1997. P. 14.
7
.: . . . . 70.

39

 2(62), 2009

, , - - 8.
, . ,
(
.. ). -
, . ,
() , . ,
. .
, .

. 1994 ,
. ,
( , ,
).


. , .
.
, , .

.
. , . :
.
1990-
.
8

Energy Superbowl. P. 14.

40

2(62), 2009

() (
). (
).
(
), 1999 .
1990- , 1999 2001-.

. , , .
, 1990-
. - .
.

II.
:
-


XXI . .
1.
. . . , . , . 2000
- , .
2. , , , 11 2001

. , . .
, .
3. , , . ,
41

 2(62), 2009

1994 . 2002- .
2003 , 2005-. 50 1 760
, . ,
. , ,
. , , - .
,
.
, . ,
, ,
.
(
25 2005 .) .

, .
- 9.
, . :
.
. , XXI ,
(
-). . , , .
. , . , ,
. .

I
- ,
9
., . . // -, 31 2006, 161. . 9; .. // -, 10 2007.

42

2(62), 2009

.
. .
.

:
, . (. , . ), , , 10.
:

,
. . , : , ,
.
, ,
..11 .
. -
: .
. , , 12.
13, , . . , .
10
.: . // , 22
2001. . 5; . // , 26 2003. . 10; .
? // , 27 2004.
11
.: . [www.utro.ru/articles/2003/02/07/126422.shtml];
: ., . : ? // , 4
2002. . 10; . // , 1 2005.
12
.: Washington Profile [www.washprofile.org/arch0403/interviews/Kazhegeldin].
13
, .
, . , . ,
,
. , . ,
(.: .
// Pro et Contra, 2003, . 8. 2. . 184, 185).
, ,

.

43

 2(62), 2009

. , : - . , ,
. ( )
.
, , 14.
,
.
, , .
.
, 1990- . , ,
.
,
, .
. , , ,
, .
. ( ) , . , , , ,
15.
, . : , ,
; .
, ,
- . 16. , , -
.

. .
14
. ? // , 10 2003. . 11;
. // , 2228 2004. . 8; . // , 25 2004. . 8.
15
. . . . 244.
16
. . . . 7071.

44

2(62), 2009

,

.
.
, . , 17.
.
2005
135 ., . ,
, , , . 2005
() 200300 . - , .
,
XXI . , , , . .
. 2002
- .
. ,
.
, , .

, - .
,
.
, , -
.
. .
. .
, - .
. ,
.
17

.: . // , 11 2003. . 5.

45

 2(62), 2009

2006 . 2006.

() . - .
, .
, - .
, .

III.
:

, . . -. , 2001
. .
11 2001 :
. , , .
. .

.
.


. - . ( )18. , ,
.
.
,
.

, 2006 .
18
.: . . // -, 22 2007.

46

2(62), 2009

,
.
2006 -
, ,
.
(2728 2006 ., ).
-
. , , , ,
.
, , , ,
.
. 4 2006 , . . 2007
. , 2001 .
2007 , :
.

.
, .
2007 .
( 2007 .) , .
. . ,
19.

.
. (
, , )
, . , , .
20.
19

. 13.

.: . : // -, 2 2007.

20
( ,
, )
,
, , , .

47

 2(62), 2009

, 16 2007 . : , , , , .
. ,
(1,7 .)
:
( ). .
2007 ,
. :
. , - . Dallas Morning News ,
21.
, ,
: .
-, ( -
) - 22.
. 2008 ,
( 402 .),
23.
2008 .
225295 . 1 . . .
(2008 .) . . .
2009-. , , ,
.

, . 21
.: . . ,
// , 12 2007, 241 (4202).
22
.: . - // -, 24 2005. . 14.
23
.: , 20 2007, 235 (3811).

48

2(62), 2009

- . , .
,
, XXI . , .
,
. 24
, . ,
, .

- .
. .
, .
. , . , , .
,
. ,
, ,
.

, .

, . , .

* * *
XXI (
11 2001 )
, ,
24

(FOI) . 23 2008
.

49

 2(62), 2009

, -.

, .
, , , . ,
.
,
25, ,
.
- . 11 2001 , , .
25
. : Dmitri V. Trenin. Getting Russia Right. Washington: Carnegie Endowment for
International Peace, 2007 // Pro et Contra, 2008, 1 (40). . 101.

50

2(62), 2009

FRICTION





,


(, )

Friction

.
. : ,
. , (), 1. friction. ,
. , , , (, , ..).
Friction , , ,
, .
1
. : Luttwak E.N. Strategy. The Logic of War and Peace. Cambridge, Massachusetts and London: The
Belknap Press of Harvard Univ. Press, 1987. . 12.

51

 2(62), 2009

,
.
. -, , ,
: (ISAF),
. ()
, - , , .
11 2001 (.. 7 ), . , , . , , friction .
, , . , 2006
4 . , .
.
, -, 2002 , 21 118.
2007 ,
: 566 , 2006- 425.
2007 8 . 1,5 .
. ,
(237 .) , , ( 2006 . 191 .)2.

, , . - , 3.
, friction,
, :
, , ;
, ;
, , 4;
2
.: . //
urasianet, 7/04/2008 [www.eurasianet.org].
3
.: The Guardian, 17 October 2008.
4
, , ( .: . // . . . : . , , 2004. . 88101).

52

2(62), 2009

,
-
;
, , , , , , ,
, , ;
. ,
,

5.
, , . , , .
, , friction.
. . , .
, 2001 , ,
, ,
. , , ,
. , : . , : , , 6.
, 2008 .
: , , , - .
. ,
. , ,


, .
,
. .
n

, , .

, ,

5
Mihalka M. Pashtunistan, NATO and the Global War on Terror: If you dont fight, you cannot have
peace in Afghanistan // China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, 2008, Vol. 6, No. 1.
6
.: Ibidem.

53

 2(62), 2009

.
, ,
.
n

, , , , .

, .

19972001 6+2,
, .

,
( 1999 .) , ,
.
, 2001 ,
6+2 6+3,
7.
, 2008
, ,
,
. , friction
, ,
, , , .
,
, .
, , -, -
, . . , , ,
, , ,
.
,
. , 7
.: / //
, 4 2008.

54

2(62), 2009

. , ,

.
,
friction. , , .
A) ISAF:
(, - ) ISAF , , . , ,
, , ,
.
, , ISAF, , , .
, , .
B) ?
?
.
, . - , . , , ,
.
2007 , . . , .
, .
, , a-la Taliban .
, 8.
.
, : ?,
? , .
, ,
-
. , ,
,
.
8
.: . ? // , 2003, 5 (29).

55

 2(62), 2009

,
, , , . , 10 2008 : , , , . ,
, 9.
, ,

, . , .
, ,
? , , ? ,
( ).

(,
, ).
( 2009 .) .
,
.
,
. , (2005 .), ,
, , . , ,
, ,
. ,
, , , ,
.

, , . , , . , ,
.
9

Quoted from: Mihalka M. Op. cit.

56

2(62), 2009

. , ,
, , - . , : , ,
. ,
, .
? , ,
-2. ,
, .
, ,
(
. ..).
10.
, , .

, . ,
-, , , , , .
-,

. , ,
. -, ,
. . -,
. ,
.
, - ,
, . , ,
, ( )
.
, , ,
, , ,
.
,
,
10
. : . // Eurasianet, 5 2009.

57

 2(62), 2009

, . , ,
/ - . , , , , . , , : .
, , , , .

11.
ISAF OEF 2008 , ,
.
,
,
, ..12
, ,
, ,
- .
. , : - 13. , , ,
, , .

,
, , . , , , ,
-.
. 2008 . , -
. , ,
, . ,
14.
, . ,
.
(2009 .) .
11
.: . :
// , 2008, 2 (56).
12
.: , , . .
. / . . . , 2008.
13
. - 2004 .
.: / . . . : , 2004. . 18.
14
, 12 2008 (. [www.centrasia.org], 12 2008).

58

2(62), 2009

, 17 2009 .
. , 2005 .

friction . .
, , . , , , : , ( ) adhoc - .
, ,
. , . , , , . ,
, ,
.

.
, . , ,
, .
, () , ()
15. , , , . .
.
1)

, .
friction. , ,
, , . , .
? ?
15
.: . XXI //
, 2008, 2 (56).

59

 2(62), 2009

, .
, .
2) , , : ,
.
, ,
, . ,
, .
,
( ).
3) ,
, ,
. friction
, . ,

.
,
.
.
4) , , ,
,
. . ,
84%
,

, - .
, , , , , , , , . , , 16.
16

.: Foreign Affairs, November/December 2008.

60

2(62), 2009

, , ISAF
: , , . ISAF . ,
( ISAF OEF),
, .

:



,
(, )


(, )

,

, . ,
,
,

, 1.

().

, (
) -
.
,
,
, , , -

1
(), () ().

61

 2(62), 2009

,
.
.
, ,
, .
.
, , .
20092011
.
2008- , . , ( ) -2008, 2 .
, 40 , 240
.
27 - -2008, ,
.
. .
, - .
2,5 . .
, .
. , . . :
( ) - ;
929- - . . - ;
20- ( , ) - , ;
10- ( -) , , -62

2(62), 2009

, - 2;
5580- ( 11-
) , - , - ;
- ( -9)
, .
,
- , , .
- .
.
- (), . 1990- -

. .
2000
,
-
, 2001- .
, . 1 2004

.
. , ( 2015 .)3, , , ,
,
4.
- - .
; ,
, :
, ;
. ( ) ;
2
- , 10- (-)
.
3
2007 .
4
.

63

 2(62), 2009

( , , ) ;
( . , ) ;
. (
) .
, . , ,
, .
, .

* * *
-
. , , . , ,
, ,
. -
, 2008
.

. ,
,
.
. . 1990- , . , -

.

() 1999 ,
. .
, 64

2(62), 2009

. ,
2001 () () () .
- 2003 ( 20 ) ,
.
.
- . , -
. , 2006
. -2006,
,
( ) .
. 800
. 2000
40 . , 2006
- .
.
:
999- ;
954- -
. - ( -);
338- - () ,

, ;
17- - - - - ,
.
,
; ,
-27, -29, - -39, -8
-24.
- . -
, , . 1990- ,
I .
20012005
, 2005- 4,5 .
. 2006- 20062008 - , 27 .
65

 2(62), 2009

- 5.
- - . - , 1994 ,
. :
,
, -111 ;
- ( 95%
) ( -), ;
, ;
, , 2002 .
, . , - , .
.
, . 5 1992
() 5 . .
1999 ,
. -
.

.
, , .

* * *
. , ,

5
, -125
- -300 2 .

66

2(62), 2009

. , ( ), .

.
, .
. .
1990- , (19921996 .).
.
1993 (), 201- (). ,
, -
.
201- .
, , , . 2000 , 2001- (
).
20012004 .

. 201- . , , - - .
2004
, .
.
, 201- .
- . 11 2008 ()
67

 2(62), 2009

. ,
- .
.
(20 ) 201- .
.
500 . 50 .
.
,
10 :
201- ( 201- ) 201- , 92- , 998- - , 1098- - ;
191- - 149- 201- ;
670- 303- , ;
1109- -
( 7680 ) ,
6.
- . , . ,
, (, , ) (, ),
. ,
201- .

- . 201- ,
, ,
. .
.
2004 - 6
2006 -
.

68

2(62), 2009

. 20052006 , 26 . , 2007- 201- . 2008 . , 1 .

- - .
,
. , , - ( ) ,
, , .
. ,
,
(), .
.
2000
, 2004 .
16 2004
,
.

* * *
-
, .
,
. , , , ,
. - .
, , , (, , 20012004 .),
- .

,
69

 2(62), 2009

, , . ( )
,
.
. .

1992 () , .

. 201- .
- .
1990- , . , - ,
, . 1999
.
11 2001 -
. , .
,
. 16 2004 , 2005- , . :
,
, , .
.

. 2005
( )
, 200 . 2006 2006 ( ). , 2007- ( 2008 .)
( ).
.
250 .
, , - , (
70

2(62), 2009

),
.
. ,
. .
, 8- , , , .
- . - .
. , 2 1994 , 1990-
7.

. , - .
, , , , .
- - . - 26 1994 ,
.
:
- . (),
-76 ,
8;
- ( ), 2007 -8 -24.
7
, . - ( )
1998 ( - ), .
8
1990- 2001
, -76 ( , ). 2003
, . ,
. -76 .
2007- -114
-. 2015 28 .

71

 2(62), 2009

* * *

. , , , - - . , , ,
. , , .
, , ,
,
.

.
,
, ,
.
, , - - .
31 1992
, .
.
, , ,
. ( , ) 10 .
- , ,
.
1992 . 19921994 .
, 1993 .
1994- (
) 3 . .
72

2(62), 2009

.

, . 1990-
. 1994-
,

. , ,
.

, .
1999 , .
1990-
.
. .
, 2000
,
, . 2003
. , : ( 25 ) .
, , , , , , . ,
- . , , , . , - . - . . 2006
- .
2007 .
, . 2007 . . , . , - .
73

 2(62), 2009

2008 , . , .
. . .

, .
- 2008
. - 10 (
70 .).
,
-2008,
, , .
2008 .
,
2025 , .
, , .

* * *
: . , .
,
, .
, , , , . , ,
, , ,
.

, , .
74

2(62), 2009

, , (, ) .
,
, ,
, .
n

-, , .
. ,
- , , , .

-, - , -, , , .

-, , , ,
.

. , . , ,
,
.
,
, - , , . , - .

75

 2(62), 2009

:


( )

(, )

, , , ,
.
,
()
, , .
,
, . ()
3,
. ,


, ( )4. -

: , ,
.
,
, . ,

1. : ,
. , 2. ,
, ,
1
.: Libaridian G.J. The Challenge of Statehood. Armenian Political Thinking since Independence.
Cambridge, MA.: Blue Crane Books, 1999; Suny R.G.
Looking Toward Ararat. Armenia in Modern History.
Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University
Press, 1999; Payaslian S. The History of Armenia.
From the Origins to the Present. New York: Palgrave
Macmillan, 2007; Tololyan K. The Armenian Diaspora
and the Karabakh Conflict since 1988. .: Smith H.,
Stares P. Diasporas in Conflict. Peace-Makers or
Peace-Wreckers. Tokyo: United Nations University,
2007. P. 106128; Zurcher C. The Post-Soviet Wars.
Rebellion, Ethnic Conflict and Nationhood in the Caucasus. New York: New York University Press, 2007.
2
.: Manzoni A. I Promessi Sposi. Firenze:
Sansoni, 1827 (. . 1981 .). P. 20.

3
.: Caucasus Region. Geopolitical Nexus? /
Ed. by A.I. Kapidze. New York: Nova Science Publishers, Inc., 2007.
4
() (, , ..),
, -

76

2(62), 2009

, ,
, . ,

, .
, .

, , , .


:
.

.
,
. ,
,
, , , ( .: Understanding and
Supporting Security Sector Reform. London: Department for International Development (DfID), 2002
[http: // www.dfid.gov.uk/Pubs/files/supportingsecurity.
pdf], 2 April 2008; Global Facilitation Network for
Security Sector Reform (GNF-SSR). A Beginner Guide
to Security Sector Reform (SSR), 2007 [http://www.
ssrnetwork.net/documents/GFNSSR_A_Beginners_
Guide_to_SSR_v2.pdf], 1 April 2008; Organization for
Economic Development and Cooperation (OECD).
Handbook on Security Sector Reform. Supporting
Security and Justice, 2007 [http://www.oecd.org/
dataoecd/43/25/38406485.pdf], 1 April 2008).

:

1991 ,
: . , , -
5.
6,
, .
- : 1994
, ,
, 7.
5
.: Giragosian R. Toward a New Concept of Armenian National Security. Armenian International Policy
Research Group, 2005 [http://www.aiprg.org/UserFiles/File/wp/jan2005/WP0507.pdf], 5 July 2008; . Repositioning Armenian Security and Foreign Policy within a Region at Risk. Armenian International Policy Research
Group, 2006 [http://www.aiprg.net/UserFiles/File/wp/jan2006/wp07-06.pdf], 3 July 2008.
6
.: National Security Strategy of the Republic of Armenia. Ministry of Defense of Armenia, 2007 [http://
www.mil.am/eng/index.php?page=49], 1 July 2008.
7
.: Libaridian G.J. Op. cit.; . . .
.: , 2005; The Caucasus: Armed and Divided. Small Arms and Light Weapons Proliferation and Humani-

77

 2(62), 2009

, , , , . , .
, , . , .

, , , , .
, ,
.
() 1991
, 1992
( ), 2002- ,
().
, ,
.
1996 ,
(PCA),
2001 .
(2006 .)8.
9 , 10. :
tarian Consequences in the Caucasus / Ed. by D. Hiscock, A. Matveeva. London: Saferworld, 2003; Mehtiyev E.
Armenia-Azerbaijan Prague Process: Road Map to Peace or Stalemate for Uncertainty? Camberley: Conflict Studies Research Centre, 2005; Nagorno-Karabakh: Risking War. International Crisis Group, 2007 [http://www.
crisisgroup.org/library/documents/europe/caucasus/187_nagorno_karabakh___risking_war.pdf], 5 July 2008; Armenia: Picking up the Pieces. International Crisis Group, 2008 [http://www.crisisgroup.org/library/documents/europe/
caucasus/b48_armenia_picking_up_the_pieces.pdf], 5 July 2008.
8
.: Partnership and Cooperation Agreement. European Union and the Republic of Armenia, 1996
[http://www.delarm.ec.europa.eu/en/newsletter/pdf/pca_armenia.pdf], 1 July 2008; Working Together. The European Neighboring Policy. European Commission, 2007 [http://ec.europa.eu/world/enp/pdf/information/
enp_brochure_en.pdf], 1 July 2008; Armenia Public Sector Reform Program. Government of the Republic of Armenia, 2007 [http://www.gov.am/pwc-apsrep/html/index.html], 3 July 2008; Hovsepyan A., Khudaverdyan A. Public
Sector Reforms in Armenia 19992005: Achievements and Challenges. Armenia International Policy Research
Group, 2006 [http://www.aiprg.net/UserFiles/File/wp/jan2006/wp03-06.pdf], 3 July 2008.
9
.: European Neighbourhood Policy. Country Report. Armenia. Commission of the European Community, 2005 [http://ec.europa.eu/world/enp/pdf/country/armenia_country_report_2005_en.pdf], 2 July 2008.
10
.: EU/Armenia Action Plan. European Commission and the Republic of Armenia, 2006 [http://www.
delarm.ec.europa.eu/en/press/16_11_2006.pdf], 1 July 2008; European Neighborhood and Partnership Instrument.
Armenia. European Commission, 2006. Country Strategy Paper 20072013 [http://ec.europa.eu/world/enp/pdf/
country/enpi_csp_armenia_en.pdf], 1 July 2008; Implementation of the European Neighborhood Policy in 2007
Progress Report. European Commissions Delegation to Armenia, 2008 [http://www.delarm.ec.europa.eu/en/press/
10_04_2008.htm], 1 July 2008.

78

2(62), 2009

, ,
, , . 20072013 ,
20072010 , 11.
1992 (). 2000-
. : , ,
,
.., , 12.

,
.
1994 ,

(IPAP) 2005 . : (PARP), (PAP-DIB)13.
: , ,
, ..
,
,
, .
, ,
, .
, , 14.
11
.: European Neighborhood and Partnership Instrument; European Neighborhood and Partnership Instrument. Armenia. National Indicative Program 20072010. European Commission, 2006a [http://ec.europa.eu/
world/enp/pdf/country/enpi_csp_nip_armenia_en.pdf], 3 July 2008; Working Together. The European Neighboring
Policy.
12
.: Action Plan on the Reform of the Prison System in Armenia. Council of Europe, 2003 [http://www.
coe.int/T/E/Legal_affairs/Legal_cooperation/Prisons_and_alternatives/Technical_co-operation/Armenia/
Armenia_4thSG_meeting%20report.pdf], 3 July 2008; Overview of the Office Activities in 2006. Organization for
Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). Office in Yerevan, 2007 [http://www.osce.org/documents/oy/2007/02/
23315_en.pdf], 2 July 2008; Overview. Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). Office in Yerevan, 2008 [http://www.osce.org/yerevan/13204.html], 2 July 2008.
13
.: Armenias Commitments Under Individual Partnership Action Plan with NATO. Mission of the Republic of Armenia to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, 2005 [http://www.armenianatomission.com/
index.php?cnt=3&sub=10&PHPSESSID= 26fde350a06c1dd42443a3372b18da78], 5 July 2008; NATO and Armenia General Information. Mission of the Republic of Armenia to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, 2007
[http://www.armenianatomission.com/index.php?cnt=3&PHPSESSID=26fde350a06c1dd42443a3372b18da78],
1 July 2008.
14
.: Parliamentarians and the Process of Defense Transformation in the Framework of Cooperation with
NATO. NATO, 2006 [http://www.marshallcenter.org/site-graphic/lang-en/page-mc-index-1/xdocs/conf/conferencescurrent/static/xdocs/conf/2006-conferences/0602/RazuksPresentation-en.pdf], 5 July 2008; National Security Strate-

79

 2(62), 2009

. ,
(PRSP) 20082012 15, , , . ,
. , , ,
. :
,
.

:

?
, . , : , ?

2007 . , ( ) , , , , . ,
, ,
16. , , , ;
gy of the Republic of Armenia. Ministry of Defense of Armenia, 2007 [http://www.mil.am/eng/index.php?page=49],
1 July 2008; The Military Doctrine of the Republic of Armenia. Ministry of Defense of Armenia, 2007a [http://
www.mil.am/eng/index.php?page=104], 1 July 2008; The Public Informing Conception of Ministry of Defense of
the Republic of Armenia. Ministry of Defense of Armenia, 2007b [http://www.mil.am/eng/index.php?page=111],
1 July 2008.
15
.: Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper. Republic of Armenia, 2003 [http://povlibrary.worldbank.org/files/
Armenia_PRSP.pdf], 5 July 2008; Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper Progress Report. International Monetary
Fund (IMF), 2006 2 July 2008 [http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/cr06239.pdf], 2 July 2008; Republic of
Armenia: Sixth Review Under the Three-Year Arrangement Under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility
Staff Report. International Monetary Fund (IMF), 2008 [http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/
cr08176.pdf], 2 July 2008; Government Program 2008-2012. Republic of Armenia, 2008 [http://www.gov.am/
enversion/programms_9/pdf/cragir_eng2008.pdf], 20 June 2008.
16
.: National Security Strategy of the Republic of Armenia. Ministry of Defense of Armenia, 2007.

80

2(62), 2009

; ; .
,
, , , , .

17. , ,
, . , ,
, . , , , .
, , 18.
,
. ,
19. , ,
IPAP, , PAP-DIB20.
IPAP , 2005 21.
, , , , .. , perestroika , , ,

.: The Military Doctrine of the Republic of Armenia. Ministry of Defense of Armenia, 2007a.
.: The Public Informing Conception of Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Armenia. Ministry of Defense of Armenia, 2007b.
19
.: Katsirdakis G. Defense Reform and NATO. .: Post-Cold War Defense Reform. Lessons Learned
in Europe and the United States / Ed. by I. Gyarmati, T. Winkler. Washington D.C.: Brasseys Inc., 2002. P. 89
203; NATO and Armenia General Information. Mission of the Republic of Armenia to the North Atlantic Treaty
Organization, 2007.
20
.: Lunn S. Defense and Security Policy: The Role of Parliaments and the Evolution of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly. .: Defense and Security for the 21st Century. London: Atalink, 2000. P. 1213; NATO,
EU and the Challenge of Defense and Security Sector Reform / Ed. by P. Fluri, S. Lunn, 2007 [http://www.dcaf.ch/
about/dcaf-brussels/_index.cfm?nav1=1&nav2=4], 2 July 2008; Fluri P., Bucur-Marcu H. Partnership Action Plan
for Defense Institution Building: Country Profiles and Needs Assessments for Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and
Moldova,
2007
[http://www.dcaf.ch/publications/kms/details.cfm?ord279=title&q279=armenia&lng=en&id=
31092&nav1=5], 5 July 2008
21
.: Mher S. Armenia Perspective. .: Fluri P.H., Cole E. Defense Institution Building: 2005 Partnership Action Plan on Defense Institution Building Regional Conference. Paper presented at the Conference held in
Tbilisi, 25 April 2005. P. 6265 [http://www.dcaf.ch/publications/kms/details.cfm?id=19825&nav1=4], 5 July 2008;
Joint Visit to Armenia and Georgia by the Sub-Committee on Future Security and Defense Capabilities and the
Sub-Committee on Democratic Governance. NATO Parliamentary Assembly, 1216 June 2006 [http://www.natopa.int/default.asp?SHORTCUT=971], 2 July 2008; Viewing NATO from the South Caucasus: Armenia, Azerbaijan
and Georgia. NATO Parliamentary Assembly 167 DSCFC 07 E bis, 2007 [http://www.nato-pa.int/Default.
asp?SHORTCUT=1283], 2 July 2008; NATO and Armenia General Information. Mission of the Republic of Armenia to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, 2007.
17
18

81

 2(62), 2009

,
22.
, ,
, , , . ,
, , , , . ,
, , ,
, .
, ,
, .

:
, ,
, : , ?23 :
, , , ,
.
, , .
, , -.
!24
,
,
. . IPAP ,
22
.: Parliamentarians and the Process of Defense Transformation in the Framework of Cooperation with
NATO. NATO, 2006; Marshall G.C. Armenia Defense Reforms I. Seminar on the Civilianization of the Ministry of
Defense and Amending the Law of Defense. European Center for Security Studies, 2007 [http://www.
marshallcenter.org/site-graphic/lang-en/page-mc-index-1/xdocs/conf/conferences-current/static/xdocs/conf/static/
2007-conferences/0710/0710_Overview_eng.pdf], 1 July 2008; On Introducing the Civilian Element in the Ministry
of Defense and Reforms of Law of Defense. Ministry of Defense of Armenia, 2007c [http://www.marshallcenter.
org/site-graphic/lang-de/page-mc-index-1/xdocs/conf/conferences-current/static/xdocs/conf/static/2007-conferences/
0710/Aghabekyan_Keynotes_eng.pdf], 5 July 2008; The Starlink Program: Training for Security Sector Reform in
Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Moldova, and Ukraine. PfP Consortium of Defense Academies and Security Studies //
Quarterly Journal, 2008, No. 7 (2). P. 8191 [https://consortium.pims.org/filestore2/download/4005/The%20
Starlink%20Program-Faltas-Hartog.pdf], 2 July 2008.
23
.: Inventory of Security Sector Reform (SSR) Efforts in Developing and Transition Countries. Bonn International Center for Conversion (BICC), 2005 [http://www.bicc.de/ssr_gtz/pdf/ssr_complete_list.pdf], 3 July 2008;
Security Sector Transformation in Armenia. Bonn International Center for Conversion (BICC), 2005a [http://www.
bicc.de/ssr_gtz/pdf/armenia.pdf], 2 July 2008; Avagyan G., Hiscock D. Security Sector Reform in Armenia, 2005
[http://www.saferworld.org.uk/images/pubdocs/Armenia_English.pdf], 3 July 2008.
24
. [http://lib.ru/CARROLL/alisa2.txt].

82

2(62), 2009

,
, , . .
, . , , , , . , ,
, . 2006 , ,
.
:
?
, . - , ,
, .
, . , ,
, , , . , ,
, :
. ,
, , .
, , , ,
-:
, . , ,
, ..,
. .
, , , . ,
, - ,
. 1990-
,
83

 2(62), 2009

. . , , , .
, .
,
. ,
, , . ,
, :
. , , ,
, , , . - . , -, ,
, , , .
, . , , ,
, , .

,
..


(, )

.

84

2(62), 2009

. , .

.
.

.
, ,
.
.
,
, .

.
, , , . , ,
. ,
, - .
, , - , . ,
.
, , , , 1. ,
, . ,
, . , , .
- ,
, , .
. , 2.
1
.: . //
, 2006, 1 (22).
2
.: . : // , 2006, 1 (43).

85

 2(62), 2009

.
, , .
.
, : , , , , ..
, 30% 3.

. , . , -
80% ,
.
. ,

, . , , , .

. , 86,4% , , . ,
50% , . . .
, , .
, .
, 2008 , ,

.
,
3

.: . . .

86

2(62), 2009

- . , - ,
,
.
,
.
, , . (, , , ) , .

. 5%,
.
90% , , . 97%
, . - , 2025
,
4.
.
. . , .
.
, . , , ,
.

-

4
.: . // .
[www.easttime.ru].

87

 2(62), 2009

. , , , , , , .. , .
, . , ,
, , .
, . -, 23 1 374 . . 18
845,6 . . ; . - - 150 . . , 1,5
-; . -, .
100 /
1 800 /5 .
. , .
.
, , , . .
- . , - .
. , , .
.
,
,
.

, .
, .
,
.
5
.: .
// , 2000, 3.

88

2(62), 2009

,
11% . (19902005 .) 490,6 . ., 293,3 . .
(59,8% )6. , .
, ,
, . , , ,

.
,
,
, ,
. - . ,
. - .

. , , , .
, , , .

,
,
, , , , .
, , , 7.
.: . 2006 [www.freedomhouse.hu/nit.html].
.: . // , -
.
6
7

89

 2(62), 2009

- ,
, , .
2000 . , , , , 1 375 . 993 ,
( 58), 400 .
,
.
. , 80 , 2025% ,
, . 15 . ,
.
-
. 1999 , () .
, .
.

.
,
: , ; 8.

.
.

. -
,
.
, 8
.: . - //
, 2006, 6 (48).

90

2(62), 2009

,

.

.

,
, .
, (), . , , ( )
-9.

. , , .
2005 , .
: , , , .
, .
. , , .
, , . , 2002 .
.
, . . . ,
,
. , , ,
9
.: ( 10 1995 .
345, 17 1997 . 20, 19 1998 . 83, 7 1998 . 442, 28 2000 .
107, 22 2000 . 510, 5 2001 . 155).

91

 2(62), 2009

. (). . , .
.
. . . : .
,
. ,
, , ( ) , ,
.
, - .

1. 2008 . , , 2007 8%.
,
,
10 .
, ,
. .
,
.

. ,
.
.
, .
2. - .
, .
, , 10

.: [www.tazar.kg], 25 2008.

92

2(62), 2009

,
, , . .
3. - .
4.

, .
,
-
.
5.
,
. , 1996 1997-
, .
6. ,
. , ,
.
7. , .
8. , ,
, .
.

, 11.
9. ,
, , . .
, 11

.: . . .

93

 2(62), 2009

. .
.
, , .
. ,
. , ,
.
: , , . 12 , .
, , , , .
.
, , ,
, .
,
. ,
,
. .
13.
, ,
. ,
, . , . , .
, , ,
, , , . . .

12
.: . //
, 1999, 3 (4).
13
.: Duverger M. Political Parties. Their Organization and Activity in Modern State. N.Y., 1964; Dahl R.
Political Opposition in Western Democracies. Yale University Press, 1966.

94

2(62), 2009

VS.

,

-
(, )

11 2001 . , ,
. , ,
1.
2002 -
, , 8 12 .

. : , -, - -22. -2, .
, . , -2 ,
. :
.
-2, , ,

1
.: Davis J.K., Sweeney M.J. Central Asia in U.S. Strategy and Operational Planning: Where Do We Go
From Here? Washington DC: IFPA, 2004. p. 53 [http://www.ifpa.org/pdf/S-R-Central-Asia-72dpi.pdf].
2
.: . , 13 2005 [[http://www.
centrasia.ru/newsA.php4?st=1126591680].

95

 2(62), 2009

7 2005 ,
3.
, ,
, , 4.
2005 ,
, .
.
-2 , . , 20062008 , 1,4 1,7 . 5. , , . , ,
.

, ,
. , , . , , ,
, . , .

2008 286 . .6
2003 ,
,


(EXBS)7.
3
.: // . , 8 2005 [http://www.
gundogar.org/].
4
.: Davis J.K., Sweeney M.J. Op. cit.
5
.: [http://www.state.gov/p/sca/rls/index.htm].
6
: ,
(. [http://www.state.gov/p/sca/rls/index.htm]).
7
, , ,
, , (GPS), ,
, , - , . 2006 ,
450 . . , , (.:
[http://russian.ashgabat.usembassy.gov/archive.html]).

96

2(62), 2009

- , 2,5 .,
, , 1,8 650 . .8 , ,
,
.
, , , 9
23% .

,
. ,
, .
, ,
, 2002 ,
2003 . 22
, 10,
- 11.
, ,
, ,
. 10 2003 ( ),
, 2028 12.
,
.
, 2000
. ,
8
.:
- // , No. 190, 10.08.2007 // [http://russian.
ashgabat.usembassy.gov/].
9
2008 7,1 .
10

, , -
, - .
.
11
.: ..
- , 10 2003 // [www.mid.ru].
12
.: , , , 10 2003.

97

 2(62), 2009

. ,
. , 4 13.
, , , . , , . ,

. , 2007 , ,
, .
15 2007 ( ,
)
.

,
, . ,
, 2007
38% 2006- 4,8 .14 2007-
- .

1994 , , . .
. , ( ) , -, -
, , , . , 340-
43 , -24 -8. (400 .) 15.
- . 20032004
, 280 .
,
: 200 ., ,
13
.: , , , 10 2003.
14
.: [http://www.turkmenistan.mid.ru/rustm.html].
15
.: . -25 // , 27 2007.

98

2(62), 2009

. , 600 .16
. 2003
.
, .
, , , , .
, -
, - . . , - 17.
, - ,
.
.
.

,
,
18.

( 2008 .).

; , , . , .
.
, , 19. , , . ,

.
.: . : // , 2007, 3 (83).
18
. 2008 (.: // - , 2127
2008, 20 (236)).
19
.: // , 13 2008.
16
17

99

 2(62), 2009

20
.
. , 2001 , . , 2008
. , 21.
, , ,
22, . . 2008
- . , - , - , , , ,
. , , -
.
2008 ,
,
, . ,
23. , 2007
- ,
. .
2007 24.
. ,
. . ,
, 25.
, 2008
, 70 .26
. .
.: Der Spiegel: - ? // .,
20 2008.
22
. 2007- 2008 .
.
2004- 2005 . . 2004 .
23
// - , 1622 2008, 28 (244).
24
150 1,5 . (.:
., . //
, [http://www.easttime.ru/analitic/
1/2/541.html]).
25
.: // - , 1622 2008, 28 (244).
26
.: .
20
21

100

2(62), 2009

,
. -2008, , . ,
,
27, ( ) -
.
2008 ,
. , 28. , , ,
, - , - , , -,
, 19601980- 29 . , , .
, , ,

30. .
, . .
- , , , ,
.
, . .
, .
, .
12 31. , : . ,
.: .
.: . // , 2008, 16 (84).
29
.: .
30
RusEnergy.com : , ,
. , .
,
( ) . , ( ) .
26 , ,
(.: . //
(), 19 2008).
31
.: . : // ., 24 2008.
27
28

101

 2(62), 2009

. ,
, ; ,
32 ,
, . , 2007
.
, , , ,
, ,
,
. ,
, . 2008
,
3 . ,
, , .
, , 1995 , - (). , , .
, . .
, .
, (
, , ).
, ,
, .
32

.: // , 19 2008.

102

2(62), 2009

:



-
-
-
(, )

11 2001 ,


. ,
11 1.
, , 1
.: Manes Ch. America Discovers Central
Asia // Foreign Affairs, March/April 2003, Vol. 82, No. 2.
P. 120132.

. ,



- - (
K-2).
,
.
,
, .

103

 2(62), 2009

,
.
,
2.


. ,


2005
.

,



,
3.
.
,

-, 2
.: De Kytspotter V., Maj. The Very Great
Game? The U.S. New Frontier in Central Asia. A Research Paper Presented to the Geneva Centre for Security Policy 18th International Training Course, February 2004. P. 6.
3
.: Nichol J. Central Asia: Regional Developments and Implications for U.S. Interests. Washington,
D.C.: CRS Report Order Code RL30294, Library of
Congress, Updated 26 April 2007. P. 34, 35.

21 2005 .

, 4 .
,
2005
.
, , 2005
, .
,
; ,
.



,
, . , ,
.
4
.: Blank St.J. Strategic Surprise? Central
Asia in 2006 // The China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, May 2006, Vol. 4, No. 2. P. 109130.

, . 104

2(62), 2009

,

, . ,

. , .
, , : ,
. , ,
,
. , . , .
,
:
; ; .

,
. . ,
5. , , . , .
,
, . , , .
, , ,
, . , , 6. .: Clancy T. et al. Battle Ready. N.Y.: G.P. Putnams & Sons, 2004. P. 323324.
.: Blank St.J. U.S. Interests in Central Asia and the Challenges to Them. Strategic Studies Institute,
March 2007. P. 19 [http://www.strategicstudiesinstitute.army.mil/pubs/display.cfm?pubID=758].
5
6

105

 2(62), 2009

, ,

. ,
,
.

. 13 2004 . (
,
) , - , , , 18 .
. 2004
(
) , ,
7.

, . ,
,

, .
-, ,
, 8.

. ,
,
, .

.
,
7
.: Nichol J. Central Asia: Regional Developments and Implications for U.S. Interests. Washington, D.C.:
CRS Report Order Code IB93108, Library of Congress, 10 December 2004, CRS-20.
8
.: Blank St.J. U.S. Interests in Central Asia and the Challenges to Them. P. 1822. , ( ), .

106

2(62), 2009

,
, .
.
13 2005 , ,
, . ,
. . , , .
.
.
. , .
, ,
, :

, , , .
, , , , 9.
,
, ,
,
. ,
, .

.
,
, . 10. ,
,
11.
:
, , . ,
,
9
Starr S.F. A Greater Central Asia Partnership for Afghanistan and Its Neighbors. Washington, D.C.:
Central Asia Caucasus Institute and Silk Road Studies Program, 2005. P. 21.
10
.: Polat A. Reassessing Andijan: The Road to Restoring U.S.-Uzbek Relations. Washington, D.C:
Jamestown Foundation, June 2007.
11
.: Naumkin V. Uzbekistans State-Building Fatigue // The Washington Quarterly, Summer 2006, Vol. 29,
No. 3. P. 138139.

107

 2(62), 2009

.
, .
. , ,
. , . , 2004 ,
, , . , , ,
12.

, . , : , ,
, , ,
, , . , .
,
, , ,
, 13. , ( ) ,
14. ,

2001 15.
. , . , .
, . , , 12
.: Hill F., Jones K. Fear of Democracy or Revolution: The Reaction to Andijan // The Washington
Quarterly, Summer 2006, Vol. 29, No. 3. P. 119.
13
.: Macfarlane S.N. The United States and Regionalism in Central Asia // International Affairs, 2004,
Vol. 80, No. 3. P. 450461; Weitz R. Averting a New Great Game in Central Asia // The Washington Quarterly,
Summer 2006, Vol. 29, No. 3. P. 155167.
14
Starr S.F. Op. cit. P. 11.
15
.: Macfarlane S.N. Op. cit. P. 457.

108

2(62), 2009

, , ,
, , XIX 16. ,
,

, . ,

:
.
, , , .
.
, , , . , , . ,
. , . , . ,
, . , 2002 , . ,
,
, .
, . ? , ,

17. , ,
,
.

. 18 .
.
16
.: The New Great Game: Blood and Oil in Central Asia / Ed. by L. Kleveman. London: Atlantic Books,
2004; Swanstrm N. China and Central Asia: A New Great Game or Traditional Vassal Relations? // Journal of
Contemporary China, November 2005, Vol. 45, No. 12. P. 569584; Bhadrakumar M.K. The Great Game on a
Razors Edge // Asian Times Online, 23 December 2006.
17
.: Weitz R. Op. cit. P. 164. , , .
18
.: De Kytspotter V., Maj. Op. cit.

109

 2(62), 2009

, .

. ,
. ,
, ,
, . , .

. 20012003
. . 2003 ,
(NSCT),

. NSCT,
.
, , ,
, . NSCT
, : ; , ; ;
, 19. , , - , ,
20.
19
.: President Bush Releases National Strategy for Combating Terrorism. Office of the Press Secretary,
The White House [http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/02/20030214-7.html].
20
, , ,
, ,
, (Fuller G. The Future of Political Islam. N.Y.:
Palgrave Macmillan 2003. P. 76).

110

2(62), 2009

.
, . , , , , , , , , .
, , 21. ,
, . -,
. 2003 , , , ,
22. 2003
. 2003 ,
( 2004 .) (
2005 .) . , , .
. -, ,
- , ,
23. -, .
24. ,
,
, . , ,
.
. 21
.: Nichol J. Central Asia: Regional Developments and Implications for U.S. Interests. Washington,
D.C.: CRS Report Order Code RL33458, Library of Congress, Update 12 May 2006.
22
.: Olcott M.B. Taking Stock of Central Asia // Journal of International Affairs, Spring 2003, Vol. 56,
No. 2. P. 317; Hill F. Central Asia and the Caucasus: The Impact of the War on Terrorism. .: Nations in
Transit 2003: Democratization in East-Central Europe and Eurasia / Ed. by A. Schnetzer et al. N.Y.: Liberty
House, 2003; Tabyshalieva A. Human Rights and Democratization in Central Asia After September 11 // Nordic
Institute of Asian Studies Insights, December 2002.
23
.: Rumer E. The U.S. Interests and Role in Central Asia After K2 // Washington Quarterly, Summer
2006, Vol. XXIX, No. 3. P. 148.
24
.: Naumkin V. Op. cit. P. 138139; Hill F., Jones K. Op. cit. P. 122.

111

 2(62), 2009

.
, , ,
,

.
. , , ,
,
.

,
. .

. 11 2001
. ,
,
, . , , ,
25. 1990- , , ,
.
. , ,
, .
, . , ,
,
. , , , ,
. , ,
.
.
. , 2001 , (QRF) 25
.: Nichol J. Central Asia: Regional Developments and Implications for U.S. Interests. Washington,
D.C.: CRS Report Order Code RL30294, CRS-44, 46.

112

2(62), 2009

; 2002
, , ,
26. 23 2003

,
. 2004
16 1999 , 201- .
22 2003 . , , ,
. 2005 -
.
. , ,
,
.
27. 2002 , , , . 28 2003- 28
. 2004 ,
, , 29, ,
. . 2005 -
,
. ,
. 25 2006 , , , , 26
.: Weitz R. Op. cit. P. 157158; Blank St.J. U.S. Interests in Central Asia and the Challenges to Them.
P. 515.
27
.: Paramonov V., Strokov A. Structural Interdependence of Russia and Central Asia in the Oil and Gas
Sectors // Conflict Studies Research Centre Central Asia Series 07/16E, Defense Academy of the United Kingdom,
June 2007. P. 1.
28
2000 ,
, , . 28 2003 , - , ,
.
29
1994 , . , -.
1998 . ,
,
. 2001 . ().

113

 2(62), 2009

. ? , , ,

1,2 . (, ) , .
, ,
30. ( 2008 .) . ( ), , .
. , ( 2004 .) . . ( 2005 .)
,
. ( 2005 .)
, . . , , 31,
( ),
,
, 32.
, , , ,

.
, ,
. ,
, , , . ,
. ,
, , 2001 , .
- , :
.: Naumkin V. Op. cit. P. 135136.
.: Liu Fenghua: Russia in the Central Asia: Evolution of Policies // International Politics Quarterly,
2007, No. 2. P. 161166.
32
.: Sarsembaev I. Russia: No Strategic Partnership with China in View // China Perspectives, May-June
2006, No. 64. P. 33.
30
31

114

2(62), 2009

. , , , ,
, . ,
, , , .
,
,
. , , - , . .

. , . ,
, . ,
.
.
, ,
.
6,2 1,5 .
() . ,

. , , .
2001
, ,
,
, ,
, , .
-,
. ,
,
, . 115

 2(62), 2009

, .
, 7 2001 , ,
, .
,
. , 22 2007 579 5 885 33.
-
. ,
, , 34. (2003 .)
, . 21 2006
35. : 36. 5
2007 ( ) , 37. -
,
.
, . , , ,

. ,
,
.
.
,
,
. , . , , ,
.
( ), 21% , , . , , 2006 38,
22 2007 (. [http://www.icasualties.org/oef/]).
.: Johnson Th.H. On the Edge of the Big Muddy: The Taliban Resurgence in Afghanistan // The China
and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, May 2007, Vol. 5, No. 2. P. 93129.
35
.: Ibid. P. 93.
36
Senior State Department Official: South and Central Asia Regional Update // Foreign Press Center
Background Briefing Washington, DC, 22 March 2007.
37
. - [http://www.defenselink.mil/transcripts/transcript.aspx?transcriptid=3979].
38
.: 2005 The U.N. Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), 2006 World Drug Report, Vol. 1, June 2006.
33
34

116

2(62), 2009

. , ,
, , - .
-
, 2001 . . .. ,
:
, , .
, , ,
39. . . ,

.
1) .
2) ,
, .
3)
40.
,
, , , ,
, 41.
, ,
, ,
. - .
. ,
.
,
. ,

42. , ,
, , 39
.: Cornell S.E., Swanstrm N.L.P. The Eurasian Drug Trade: A Challenge to Regional Security // Problems of Post-Communism, July-August 2006, Vol. 53, No. 4. P. 10-18.
40
,
2002 0,3650,432 . (.: Drugs Situation in the Regions Neighboring Afghanistan and the
Response of the ODCC. The U.N. Office on Drugs and Crime, October 2002. P. 25).
41
.: Cornell S.E., Swanstrm N.L.P. Op. cit. P. 20.
42
.: Boyer A.L. Recreating the Silk Road; The Challenges of Overcoming Transaction Costs // The China
and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, November 2006, Vol. 4, No. 4. P. 7487.

117

 2(62), 2009

. , ,
. , , .
, , 43. , . , .
-.


, . ,
,

, .
,
44.
.: Rumer E. Op. cit. P. 147.
.: Weinbaum M.G. Afghanistan and Its Neighbors: An Ever Dangerous Neighborhood. .: Special
Report 162. Washington D.C.: United Sates Institute of Peace, June 2006. P. 8.
43
44

,



,


(, )

/ . , : (),
118

2(62), 2009

() (, ). , , (
960- , , ).

,

-.
10801090- ,
(1103, 1109, 1111, 1116 .)1.
,
,
,
. ,
,
, XVIII ,
XI XII , 2.

, ,
. , ,
(1223 .).
-
. , : , , ,
3.
, ( ),
. , ,
,
, XII
4.
( ) :
5 . , XIV (Codex umanicus)
: izba, kukel, samala (), (), yrs ()6.
.: .. . . 2. .: , 1991. . 533.
.: . . 83.
.: .. . . . 537.
4
. . 549.
5
. . 550.
6
.: .. - //
[www.litopys.org.ua/ukrmova].
1
2
3

119

 2(62), 2009

, , . ( , , - , ) 1 500 7.
() ,
( , - ,
, XV ). ( . , . , . -, . ) , Codex umanicus8.
, , , . , . , , : , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ..9 ,
, (16271698 .),
.
, , 4 000 . , , (), , , ()10. , , , , . ,
,
.
, .
, ,
. , , - .
- , , , .
, . ,
-, - 1826
1828 , - 18281829 .
.: .. . .
.: . . .: , 2005. . 177.
9
.: .. . . 1. .: , 1990. 592 .
10
.: .. // [www.litopys.org.ua/ukrmova].
7
8

120

2(62), 2009

() , . , . , , , .
, ,
, ,
, . : .
.
.
. , 1914 2 11. , (
12), -
( ).
, . 1926
1415%.
, .
.
(1991 .) , - - .

,
, ( ). ( ) 2004 .
,

- ,
. 19962002 (
675 , 500 .), ().
.: // / . . . 2. , 1996. . 631.
, 1930- , , 60% , -.
, 11 . ., , , ,
. , (.: .. 30-
[www.vybory.org/articles/54.html]).
11
12

121

 2(62), 2009

- , . ,
, , ,
, , , , , , , , , . , , , ,
, 13.
1996 , , 1997 ,
, .
(1997 .) (
),
( 19992005 . ),
-
. , 2002 , , ,

14. , ,
- .
, - () , (67 2001 .) .
.

. , 2000 ,
, .
20032004 , ,
,
.
( ), .

,
( .),
. .: - ( ) [www.ln.mid.ru].
.: . [www.inion.ru/
product/eurosec/st3vp16.htm].
13
14

122

2(62), 2009

15.
, , , (
),
. ,
, ,
16.
, . 25% , 75%
(
76 . )17. , , , . - , ,
. , , ,
, , .
, ,
18.
: 2000
19921993 26 . , 1994
,
. ... . , 1995
700 . , 20 . ( ).
2000 . 35 .
44 . 1 . . . 20042005 44% , 30
33%. , 2004 , : 2005 32%, , .
, 36 .
58 . 1 . . , 15
16

org].

.: . // , 2008, 48.
., ., . [www.eurasianhome.

.: . [www.centrasia.ru].
.: . -
[www.politdumka.kiev.ua].
17
18

123

 2(62), 2009

19
.
,
. ,
, .
.
, ,
20.
- (28 1998 .),
(4
2000 .), (29
2002 .).
- ,
19992009 , 19992009 .

(19 1998 .), 19992008 (7 1999 .),

(25 2004 .), .
,
. , .
, , , . , , , , ,
21. ,
- ,
.
. 2 .

- 22.
. 1940
. . .
.: ., ., . . .
21
.: : [www.abercade.ru].
22
.: ., ., . . .
19
20

124

2(62), 2009

() - 23.
, , 1996
320 -80 ,
-200024. , , , 25. 1997 10
26. .
- , ( 1996 . ). ,
,
-29 ( 3 .
), , (-) ,
27. , ,
,
, -,
, .
, ( 1994, 1997 2000 .)
- . 1997 40 28. , ( EXBS). - ,
,
.
, - 29. , . , 2002 22 .
30. (), ,
23
.: . . .. -
. .: . . .: . , 2007. . 27.
24
.: . - [www.niss.
gov.ua].
25
.: .. - . : . , 2006. . 424.
26
.: . . .
27
.: . [www.vpk-news.ru].
28
.: . - .
29
, . : (. ), (. ), (. ), (. ), (. ), (. ), (. ),
(. ) (.: . // -, 2004, 1).
30
.: 22 . [www.atlanta.com.ua].

125

 2(62), 2009

, .
2004 - .
, ( ),
,
. , , , , . 2000
.

,
. .
, - .
,
, , : ,
, , , ,
, , , , .
, , , , .31
,
, , - - : , , , .

: .
.
. .
,
, , ,
.
2004
, .
31
.. , . .: . . . 28.

126

2(62), 2009

. , ,
, , - . .

, ,
(, , ). (
) (
) ( )
--
. , , , . , - .
, ,
. ( 2006 .) ,
, , , , , .
, 2005-, .
. , (), , , , .
, , , ,
, , . , , , .
( 2006 .) - . ,
.
,
: - , , , , , . , , , 32.
, - , ,
, --
. : 2007 , 2008-
32
,
[www.bdg.by/news/news.htm?85933,3].

127

 2(62), 2009

. .
, 2011 . , , , , , , , , , ,
, , , 33.

, 2005 . . , 2005
, . 2006- , 2008-
,
, , , .
, ,
, ( 2007 , , 42 . , 8,5 . 7 . )34.
,
-- , , - . ,
( ,
),
, . . , 2008 ,
, , .

. , , , ,
, , , 30% 50% 35. ; , , .
33
.: -- [http://www.newsukraine.kiev.ua/news/110814]; [http://
mirtv.ru/content/view/46758/15].
34
.: ., ., . . .
35
.: . // Internationale Politic, 2008, 1. . 55.

128

2(62), 2009

. 2007 , ,
, , . , .
, , 36.
2008- , . .
,
.
.
.
.
. , . 37.
. , ,
,
. ,
, 2005 , , .

. : ... , , ,
,
. ,
...
,
38.

, . , 2009
.
, 39.

, , , . , , 2008 ,
- - - .: . . .
.: . [www.ng.ru/gazeta/2008-07-14].
38
., ., . . .
39
.: [www.pravda.com.ua/news/2009/1/
17/87975.htm].
36
37

129

 2(62), 2009

. , 2007
2006- 64,4% ( 3 .). , , , ,
, , 40. 2007 1,7 , 1 . , , , ,
, , , , 41.
2007 1,7 , 10 2008- 80 .42 - .
, ,
, .
.: ., ., . . .
.: . . . 11.
42
.: . - [www.
mfa.gov.ua/kirgizia].
40
41

(, )

, ,
/ . - 130

2(62), 2009

, 1990-
( ) . ,

.
, , 1990- . .
, 1. - ,
. , , ,
.
, , . ,

, , ,
, , 2.
,
. ,
.

. , :
, ,
. , 3.
4.
,
, -
, 5.
1

No. 2.

.: Erguvenc S. Turkeys Security Perceptions // Journal of International Affairs, June-August 1998, Vol. 3,

.: Torbakov I. The Turkish Factor in the Geopolitics of the Post-Soviet Space [http://www.eurasianet.
org/departments/insight/articles/2002].
3
Lainer S. Orta Asya ve Trkiye [http://www.usakgundem.com/yazarlar.php?id=43&type=3].
4
.: Trkiye Trk Cumhuriyetleri Ilikileri Raporu zeti, Dnyada Kreselleme ve Blgesel Entegrasyonlar (AT, NAFTA, PASFK) Ve Trkiye (AT, EFTA, KE, Trk. Cumhuriyetleri), Yedinci Be Yllk Kalknma Plan,
T.C. Babakanlk Devlet Planlama Tekilat Mutesarlg, Yayn No: DPT: 2410-IK:471, Kitab 5, Austos 1995,
. 110116 [http://www.ekutup.dpt.gov.tr/kuresell/oik471.pdf].
5
.: Onis Z. Turkey and Post-Soviet States: Potentials and Limits of Regional Power Influence // Middle
East Review of International Affairs, June 2001, Vol. 5, No. 2.
2

131

 2(62), 2009

.
. , , . 6.
, ,
. - (19891993 .). , . - 7. . , ,
()8.
()
. ,
,
9. ,
10. - (19911993 .),

( ).
11.
, , ,
,
12. 1990- ,
, . 1992 , - . ,
, 13. ,
.: Huntington S. The Clash of Civilizations // Foreign Affairs, Summer 1993, Vol. 72, No. 3. P. 42.
.: . . ., 2004. . 84.
8
.: Hunter Sh. Bridge or Frontier? Turkeys Post-Cold War Geopolitical Posture // The International Spectator,
January-March 1999, Vol. XXXIV, No. 1.
9
.: Demira Y. Souk Sava Sonras Trkiyenin Orta Asya Siyasetinde Gelinen Nokta ve Gelecekte Blgeye
likin zlenmesi Gereken D politika Stratejisi [http://www.jeopolitik.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=
22&Itemid=28].
10
.: Cem I. Turkey: Setting Sail to the 21st Century // Perceptions, Journal of International Affairs, September-November 1997, Vol. II.
11
.: Demirel S. Newly-emerging Centre // Turkish Review, Winter 1992, Vol. 6, No. 30. P. 9.
12
.: . //
, 2003, 2 (26). . 83.
13
.: : XX / . . .. . .: - , - , 2001. . 429.
6
7

132

2(62), 2009

, - 14.

, - . , , , .

,

,
. ,
: , , . ,
-
.
-, ,
,
. , 15. - . ,
, .
, - ,
. , 1980- , . . . -
16,
.
1992 . . , , .
( 1992 .)
,
17.
.: . - . , 2004. . 76.
Bal . The Turkish Model and the Turkic Republics // Perceptions, Journal of International Affairs, September-November, 1998, Vol. III, No. 3.
16
.: Ibidem.
17
.: Ibidem.
14
15

133

 2(62), 2009

18. -
, -
-, : , , () . ,
.
19.
, , 20. 1992 , , .

.
21, , ,
.
; , . ,
,
.
, ,
.
22.
. , , ,
. . ,
23. ,
,
,
.

. , 18
.: Kramer H. Will Central Asia Become Turkeys Sphere of Influence // Perceptions, Journal of International Affairs, March-May 1996, Vol. I, No. 1.
19
The Full Text of Foreign Minister Hikmet etins Speech at the Assembly of Turko-American Business Council,
Istanbul // Turkish Review, Winter 1992, Vol. 6, No. 30.
20
.: Kramer H. Op. cit.
21
, , , .
. ,
, , , (.: . - . .: :
/ . . . . 2. ., 1998. . 373).
22
.: Bal . Op. cit.
23
.: Uslu N. The Russian, Caucasian and Central Asian Aspects of Turkish Foreign Policy in the Post
Cold War Period // Alternatives.Turkish Journal of International Relations, Fall&Winter 2003, Vol. 2, No. 3&4.
P. 182.

134

2(62), 2009

- . . -,
.
.
1996 , ,
() . , ,
, . ,
. , :
, , 24.
.
. ,
25. . - : ,
? .
, , . , ,
. , ,
26. , , 2000 , : , 27.
, . , .
-
, , 24
.: Winrow G. Turkey and Central Asia. .: Central Asian Security. The New International Context /
Ed. by R. Allison, L. Jonson. London Washington: Brookings Institution Press, 2001. P. 202.
25
, , . , 1990-
, , . ( .: . :
// , 2002, 1 (19)).
26
.: Uslu N. Op. cit.
27
Trkiye ile Trk Cumhuriyetleri Ilikileri ve Blge lkeleri Ilikileri zel Ihtisas Komisyonu Raporu, Sekizinci
Be Yllk Kalknma Plan, T.C. Babakanlk Devlet Planlama Tekilat Mutesarl, Yayn No: DPT: 2511-IK:528,
Ankara, 2000. S. 3257 [http://www.ekutup.dpt.gov.tr/disekono/oik528.pdf].

135

 2(62), 2009

( ),
.

. .
: ,
. 1990-
-
,
28.
, 2002 ,
().
,
. ,
. , : , ,
29.

- .

, .
.
, ,
, 30.

- ,
, . , , .
. -
28
Aras B. Turkish Policy toward Central Asia // Foundation for Political, Economic and Social Research.
Policy Brief, April 2008, No. 12.
29
Lainer S. Turkey-Middle East Relations in a New Era // Journal of Turkish Weekly, 18 February 2009.
30
.: Davutoglu A. Turkeys Foreign Policy Vision: An Assessment of 2007 // Insight Turkey, 2008, Vol. 10,
No. 1. P. 7796.

136

2(62), 2009

,
.
- ,
.
, , . ,
. ,
,
.
.
, , ,
, - . , , .
,
, ,
. , .
, ,
,
, .
, .
n

. , . , ,
, 3
2005 .
. , , , .
, , . , .

, , ,
, , , , , , .
31.

31

.: Synopsis of the Turkish Foreign Policy [http://www.mfa.gov.tr].

137

 2(62), 2009

,





(, )






(, )

,
. ,
,
,

.


, , , . ,
-
.
4 1992
,
-

.


, XX .
, ,
.
1993
. .
, .
:


.

138

2(62), 2009

, .
12-
,
. - .

.

.
.

1996
, . .
, ,

, , ,
,
.
, -

.


. ,
.
n

1989
1991 ,
, - 1.

1
.: .

1991
1997
,
, : , , 2.

1997


: ,
, ,
.

, , ,
, , ,
3.

- 1997 ,
,
-
.

.
1998 , , .


. .: / .
. . .: , 2001. . 337.
2
.: . . 338.
3
.: . . 340.

139

 2(62), 2009

. ,
.
1999
,
.
.. , ()
, .
, -
6+2, . ,
.
1999
,
.
2000
. .
.
, 10- ,
,

, . ,
,
.
,

,

.
.
,
,
.
2000

.
. ,
,
,
, , , , 4.

.
, , :
-
,


5.
2001

. ,
. , , .
4
.: .. . :
, 2005. . 201.
5
. . 281.

140

2(62), 2009

2002 . 10 ,

, . , .

, . . . ,
,
-
.
,
,
6.
2003
2002 ,
.
2003
. , . ,
6
.: . (XIX XXI .).
: , 2004. . 457.

.
, .
.
,
2003 ,

.
.

, , ,
.
: , ,
, , , , .
2004

, 2005
, ,

- .
-
,
-7.

2006 2004-.
. 2007- ,
7

. 2.

141

.: -, 28 2005, 30 (288).

 2(62), 2009

,
.
,
, . ,
,

, .
, , ,
, , , -
,
XXI
, 8.

: ,
,

.
27 2008

,
,
. 8
.: . // , 24 2007, 4 (19558). . 1.

,
.
-
,
,
.
- 1992 , . 2000 2003
, , 2007-. ,
.
,
,
.

, ,
, .
,
,
.
.
.

.

.
- () .

142

2(62), 2009

: ,
,
,
- .
.
,
.

, 11 , 1992 2002
,
141,7 .,
74,355 ., 67,345 . 2002

12,39 . 15,2%
,
6,5 .
22,6%, 5,89 . 8%. 2003
( ) 5,72 .
143,6% 2002 ,

3,72 . 245,8%,
2 .
57%. 2004
63,1 ., 2005-
98,2 . 2006
158,9 .9 2008- , 351,95 .,
162%
2007-10.

, : , , , , , .
, :
, , , . -
.
, 11.
- .
-

-
, 15 18
2005 . 150 , 350 .
2005 , 1 . - . -
,
-

-
.

.

9
.:
, 2007. . 323.
10
.: -
, 2008. . 92.

11
.: . :
- // , 20 2003, 20 (529).
. 1.

1. - -

143

 2(62), 2009

10 .
2.

100 .
( 800 )
20
30%, , , , ,
.
3.
.
4.

,
( ) - ,

.

5. ,
12.
.
: , , , ..

296 .
( )
410 . 12
.:
1
// , 2005, 6.
. 19.

296 . 281,2 .
China Road.
,

.

-, 80
- . 2,3 , 7 , 38 .
40 .

.


.
. : ,
,

.
.


. 70% 30%
218%.
,
, .


. , -

144

2(62), 2009

. ,
. ,
, .
, ,
, .

. ,
1 . ;
65,1 . 4,1
1 . , 299,9 .
2,1 1 .
13.

, , .
2001
( 2003 .)
,
.
,
, ,


, 14.
13
.: .
// , 18 2006, 4. . 8.
14
.: ., .
/ . .. . :
,
2006. . 122.

.
, .
2007 , , ,

-,
20 . - . ,
2005 .


,
.

.
, - 23 , (
)

-,

.
-
,
.

15.
,

,
. -

145

15

.: . .

 2(62), 2009

,
,
. ,
,
, .
: -, ,
; -,
70 .


. . ,
1998
, .


, - . 1970-
. 1999- 65 . , , 5,364 , 1,193 , 16,059
(.. ),
,
() .. 1998
2,4

33,6%16 . 1991

148 . , 1995 520 .,
1999- 681 . .
,
, ,

.
-
.
,
. ,
.

.
,

,
.

:
10
10 .
2006
NUCTECH -

.
,
, : , , , .
16
.: // . , 2000. . 1.

146

2(62), 2009

()
, .
,
, ,
. . ,
. , , .
. - , , , . , -,
17.
, ,
, , .
, , . , ,
, . ( ), , 18.
. ,
- ,
.
, .

1999 , , 2000- .
, ,
. , ,
, , .
17
.., .. //
: . , 2005. . 16.
18
.: . . .: , 1998. . 151.

147

 2(62), 2009

- ,
, . ,
- .
, ,
. , . ,
.
.
2002 - ,
. , 1990 2001
, , 200
, 162 ,
, 440
.
. 1998 , , ,
, 15
150 .
- , 19.
..
: , 2001- 2002 , ,
. 2002
10 , 1992 .
.
2002 390 ,
, 2001 . 2002 1992, 1994, 1996
1997 20.
. , , . .
XXI , . , , ,
, . , .
19
20

.: .. . 464.
.. . : , 2003. . 37.

148

2(62), 2009

. : ,
, .
, , ,
.
2003
- ( )
-2003,
. , ,
. ,
,
.
2007 , ,
, , , , .
.

() -2007.
, , 6 000 .
.
- . ,
.
. , . , ,
, ,
. -
.
,
,
. ,
.
21.
21
.: . .
. , 2005. . 42.

149

 2(62), 2009

, , ,
,
.
. ,
. , ,
. -
, . -
, .
, , .

2009 17- . . , ,
, , . ,
, .
, ,
, .
5- 15- .
, , ,
, , ,
.
, . ,
, , ,
, .
, ,
, :
.
-
,
. -
, .
:
1) ;
150

2(62), 2009

2) - ;
3) ;
4) ;
5) , , , , .

-

-

. ..

(, )

, , (
, ) . ,
: - ,
, , , . , , , 1990- ,
,
.
, 1.
1

- 20 2006 .

151

 2(62), 2009

-
.

2,
( , , , , , .),

-
- . ,
, - 3. ; (22002000 . ..)4.
, , .
( , -)
, -
5.

,
.
, , 6. , , 1947 , - - 7.
2
-
(., : Firdous T. India and Central Asia. A Case Study of Indo-Tajik Relations. .: Central Asia: Introspection / Ed. by M.A. Kaw, A.A. Banday. Srinagar: University of Kashmir, 2006. P. 321). ,
(.: Juraev A. Socio-Cultural Challenges of
Tajikistan in the 20th Century // Thesis for the Conference on Central Asia in Retrospect and Prospect. Srinagar:
Centre for Central Asian Studies, August 2006. P. 5; Nazarov U.A. The Present State of Tajikistan-India Relations //
Thesis for the Conference on Central Asia in Retrospect and Prospect. P. 1).
3
.: - .., .. . .: , 1985. . 595.
4
.: .. ( VIIVIII . ..). .:
/ . .. , .. . .: , 1986. . 11; .., .. . . .: .
. 1. / . .. , .. , .. . .: , 1989. .
165, 172173.
5
., : Haidar M. Indo-Central Asian Relations. From Early Times to Medieval Period. New
Delhi: Manohar Publishers & Distributors, 2004. P. 260261, 265; Kaushik D. India and Central Asia in Modern
Times. A Study in Historical-Cultural Contacts from the Early Nineteenth Century. Delhi: Satvahan Publications,
1985. P. 24, 2630, 3536.
6
. , . .: . /
. . . : , 2006. . 157.
7
.: Nehru J. Invitation to Inter-Asian Relations Conference. Selected Works. Second Series / Ed. by Gen.
S. Gopal. In 35 volumes. Vol. 1. New Delhi: Jawaharlal Nehru Memorial Fund, 1989. P. 483.

152

2(62), 2009

.
, .
n

-, ,
, - , .
1990- , , , .
- . , ,
. ,
.
, ,

, ,
8.

-,
: 9.
, .
,
.
l

- - - . , ,
,
, .
, , , 10.
- , -
.
, 1990- ,
-

8
.: Stobdan P. Strategic Emergence of Central Asia Implications for Indian Ocean States // Journal of
Indian Ocean Studies, April 2004, Vol. 12, No. 1. P. 39.
9
Stobdan P. Central Asia and Indias Security // Strategic Analysis, January-March 2004, Vol. 28, No. 1.
P. 71.
10
.: Nuri M.H. India and Central Asia: Past, Present and Future // Regional Studies, Winter 19921993,
Vol. 11, No. 1. P. 81; Palat M.K. India and Central Asia // World Focus, March April 1993, Vol. 14, No. 34.
P. 40.

153

 2(62), 2009

,
11.
l

(). , - .
, , ,
, .
,
.


, , 12 . ,
- , 1993
.

, , ,

13.

, . ,
, - , , , . , ,
-

, ,

14.
,

.

, , . -, -

11
Stobdan P. Regional Issues in Central Asia: Implications for South Asia // South Asian Survey, 1998, Vol. 5,
No. 2. P. 253.
12
Dixit J.N. Indias Security Concerns and Their Impacts on Foreign Policy. .: Indian Foreign Policy:
Agenda for the 21st Century / Ed. by L. Mansingh et al. Vol. 1. New Delhi: Konark Publishers Pvt Ltd, 1997.
P. 157.
13
.: Muni S.D. India and Central Asia: Towards a Co-operative Future. .: Central Asia: The Great
Game Replayed / Ed. by N. Joshi. New Delhi: New Century Publications, 2003. P. 118119.
14
Akbarzadeh Sh. India and Pakistans Geostrategic Rivalry in Central Asia // Contemporary South Asia,
June 2003, Vol. 12, No. 2. P. 227.

154

2(62), 2009

, ,
, . ,

15; - 16 . , -
, . , , 17. , ,

, 18.
. ,
, 60% 25 ,
(!) ; ,
19.
, ,
.
, .
, [ ] 20.
n

-, -
.
(, ) . , , ,

15
Sidhu K.S. Islamic World and Central Asia: Turkey, Afghanistan and Pakistan. .: Central Asia:
Present Challenges and Future Prospects / Ed. by V.N. Rao, M.M. Alam. New Delhi: Knowledge World, 2005.
P. 175.
16
Bal S.N. Central Asia: A Strategy for Indias Look-North Policy. New Delhi: Lancer Publishers and
Distributors, 2004. P. 332.
17
Muni S.D. Op. cit. P. 98 (see also P. 103 for the same considerations).
18
Dwivedi R. Security Scenario in Central Asia: An Indian Perspective. .: : , . IV (7 2006 .). : , 2006.
. 147, 157158.
19
Bal S.N. Op. cit. P. 359.
20
Nazarov U.A. Op. cit. P. 6.

155

 2(62), 2009

. : , 21.
, , . , , ,
. -
,
.
... - , ,
, , . , , 22.
, 23, - .
, -
,
24; ,
,
25.
, ,
,
26. , ,
,
: - ; ; . ,
1995 21

P. 102.

22

P. 88.

.: Stobdan P. Central Asia in Geo-Political Transition // Strategic Analysis, 1998, Vol. 22, No. 1.
Patnaik A. India-China Cooperation in Central Asia // Security and Society, Summer 2005, Vol. 1, No. 2.

23
,
, , (Kaushik D.
India and Central Asia: Renewing a Traditional Relationship // South Asian Survey, 1998, Vol. 5, No. 2. P. 241).
,
, ,
(Roy M.S. Indias Interests in Central Asia // Strategic Analysis,
March 2001, Vol. 24, No. 12. P. 2279).
24
., : . : // ,
2007, No. 6.
25
Patnaik A. Central Asia and Indo-Pak Relations // World Focus, 2001, Vol. 22, No. 1012. P. 56.
26
Firdous T. Op. cit. P. 323.

156

2(62), 2009

27.
- 2003 ,
28.
, -
, . ,
, - 29. ,
, -
30.
, , ,
,
. , , , . ,
, 1991
, 31. , , ,

, ,
.
( ) , , , . , ,
32 () .: Sengupta A. India and Central Asia // World Focus, August 2000, Vol. 21, No. 8. P. 23.
.: Patnaik A. India-Central Asia Relations: The Growing Prospects // World Focus, 2003, Vol. 24,
No. 1012. P. 50.
29
.: Sachdeva G. Indias Attitude towards Chinas Growing Influence in Central Asia // China and Eurasia
Forum Quarterly, 2006, Vol. 4, No. 3. P. 24 ff.
30
.: Patnaik A. India-China Cooperation in Central Asia P. 87 ( .: Bedi R. India Dabbles in
the New Great Game // Janes Intelligence Review, June 2002, Vol. 13, No. 6. P. 19; . India and Central
Asia // Frontline, 1427 September, 2002, Vol. 19, No. 19. P. 60).
31
.: Dhaka A. South Asia and Central Asia: Geopolitical Dynamics. Jaipur: Mangal Deep, 2005. P. 152.
32
.: Ibid. P. 150 (. : Mann P. Indias Foreign Policy in the Post Cold War Era. New Delhi:
Harman Publishing House, 2000. . 49; Khan R. Emergence of Central Asia and Its Relevance to India //
Mainstream, April 1992, Vol. 30, No. 24. P. 21). , (Ghufran N. The Islam Factor in Pakistans
Relations with the Central Asian Republics. .: Pakistan. Fifty Years of Independence. Vol. 2. Independence
27
28

157

 2(62), 2009

, .
, , ,
33.
, , , , ,
. , , ; 34.
, .
, ,
, 35.
n

-, - , . 1992 (, , ).
, ,
, .
- 2001 (,
1995 .). . ,
-, .
15 ( ,
, -, ..)
(
)36. , , ( -), .

and Beyond: The Fifty Years 19471997 / Ed. by V. Grover, R. Arora. New Delhi: Deep&Deep Publications,
1997. P. 378).
33
Stobdan P. Regional Issues in Central Asia: Implications for South Asia P. 257.
34
.: Khan R. Op. cit. P. 21.
35
.: Patnaik A. India-China Cooperation in Central Asia P. 81.
36
., : Nuri M.H. Op. cit. P. 81; Yadav P.S. India and the Central Asian Republics // World
Focus, October-December 1999, Vol. 20, No. 10. P. 63; Roy M.S. Op. cit. P. 2275, 2280; Patnaik A. India-Central
Asia Relations: The Growing Prospects P. 51; Firdous T. Op. cit. P. 322.

158

2(62), 2009

.., ( , ). , , , , , , ( ), , , .37
, , . .

. ,
(, ) , , .
, . , ;
, 500
38. -
.
( ),
39. , .
( 1990- .

- .
, 40.)
.
, , - - ,
37
.: Roy M.S. Redefining India-Central Asia Relations // World Focus, June 2002, Vol. 23, No. 6. P. 22
23; Nazarov U.A. Op. cit. P. 7.
38
.: . . // , 2007,
No. 8. . 2830.
39
.: .. : . : , 2002. . 266268; .. // , 2006, No. 5. . 7475; Mohapatra N.K.
Caspian Cauldron: Role of State and Non-State Actors // Contemporary Central Asia, 1999, Vol. 3, No. 3. P. 50;
Middle East and Central Asia. Data-book / Ed. by Edwards Economic Research Inc. L.: Europa Publications,
2004. P. 158159 .
40
.: Firdous T. Op. cit. P. 324.

159

 2(62), 2009

, . ,
(ICCR), . ,
ITEC, , . , (
- ), - 41.
.
n

-, -
. - ,
, ,
,
. , ( ) - , . , ,
, , ,
.

:

[ ] 42.
, ,
, ,
43. - , - .
25 . 12 -29 - , 44.
, 1990-
, , ,
45.

.: Patnaik A. India-China Cooperation in Central Asia P. 87.

Kaushik D. India and Central Asia: Renewing a Traditional Relationship P. 241.
43
Roy M.S. Indias Interests in Central Asia P. 2276.
44
. . . . 26.
45
.: Bakshi J. Russia, India and the Central Asian Republics: Geo-political Convergence // Strategic
Analysis, August 1996, Vol. 19, No. 5. P. 735736.
41
42

160

2(62), 2009

, , ,
46, .
, , , ,
47.
n

-,
- , .
, , , . , ,
(, ) ( ). ,
.
, ( ), , . .
,
,
:
, : , , . ,
, , -

46
,
, .
, . , . ,
- ,
( ) , , . , , ; , ,
, , , , , , ( . , 15- , 28 2007 .). ,
, , . ,
- . , . ,
.
,
( - 20 2006 .). , -,
.
47
Patnaik A. India-China Cooperation in Central Asia P. 93.

161

 2(62), 2009

48.
,
49. ,
, ,

( - ), , , . , , 50.
, 11 2001 , ,
51.
- ,
( ) ,
, .
, , , 52.
. - ,
53.
54.
55. , , 56. , 57.
. , 1990-
Rao V.N. Introduction. .: Central Asia: Present Challenges and Future Prospects P. 17.
Chenoy A.M. Central Asian Republics: Geo-Strategy and Human Security. .: Central Asia:
Introspection P. 169.
50
Kak K. Indias Strategic and Security Interests in Central Asia. .: Central Asia: Present Challenges and
Future Prospects P. 208.
51
Stobdan P. Central Asia and Indias Security P. 60.
52
Warikoo K. Security Challenges in South and Central Asia // Himalayan and Central Asian Studies,
January-March 2006, Vol. 10, No. 1. P. 7.
53
Sidhu K.S. Op. cit. P. 177.
54
Chenoy A.M. Op. cit. P. 185.
55
Dhaka A. Op. cit. P. 110.
56
Jha S. Russias Policy Towards Central Asia After Soviet Disintegration. .: Central Asia:
Introspection P. 199.
57
Stobdan P. Regional Issues in Central Asia: Implications for South Asia P. 249.
48
49

162

2(62), 2009

58.
,
( ) .
,
,
- 59 (, , , ).
,

60.
, .
, ,
. , .
( ), , .
, , , , . , 61.
, 62.
n

, , . ,
, .
l

-, ,
,
.

-,
. , ,
.

-, ,
.

.: Mohapatra N.K. Op. cit. P. 49.

.: Nazarov U.A. Op. cit. P. 3.
60
.: Ibid. P. 8.
61
- ( ), 19
2006 .
62
., : Shams ud Din Ahmad. Geo-Politics, Violence and Regime Change in Central Asia. .:
Central Asia: Introspection P. 143153.
58
59

163

 2(62), 2009

,
. , -
, , .

164