διπλωματικη κοιν εκπ

2006
ii
15
28
43
2.1
51
4 ,
52
68
91
120
137
158
iii
2.2
187
10
188
11
211
11.1
213
11.2
215
11.3
219
11.4
222
11.5
227
11.6 ,
234
11.7
239
2.3
254
12
255
12.1
255
12.2
264
12.3 . 278
12.4
292
12.5
307
2.4
313
13

314
14

328
iv
14.1
336
14.2 ,
15
341
354
15.1
354
15.2
372
386
16
388
403

1.
, ., 1988, ;, ,
2.
, ., 1999, , ,
3.
, ., 2001, , ,
4.
, ., 2003, , , ,
5.
, ., xx, , ,
6.
, ., 1978, , ,
7.
, ., 1981, , ,
8.
, ., 1984, , ,
9.
, ., 1994, , ,
10.
, ., 2005, -, , 92, 87-95
11.
, ., 1987,
, ,
12.
, ., 1990, ,
,
13.
, ., 1991, :
, , 14, 38-42 .
14.
, ., 1992, :
,
, 15, 38-42 .
15.
, ., 1997, :
: , 1997, 119-134
16.
, ., 2003, , ,
17.
, .,1998, , , 88, 31-46
18.
Apple, M., , , ,
19.
Apple, M., 1993, , ,
20.
Apple, M., 2001, ,
21.
, ., 2004, , ,
22.
, ., 1990, , ,
23.
, ., 1994, , ,
24.
, ., 1990, , ,
404
25.
, .,1986, , ,
26.
, . Benton, T. Grundman, R., 1995, :

, , ,
27.
, ., 1996, , ,
28.
Bachelard, G., 2000, , ,
29.
Banks, O., , , ,
30.
Barrington-Moore, M., 1978,

, ,
31.
Bell, D., 1991, : , 1991, 621-697
32.
Bell, D., 1999, , ,
33.
Bernstein, B., 1991, , ,
34.
Bertrand, Y., 1994, , ,
35.
Blackledge, D. -Hunt, B., 1995, , ,
36.
Bottomore, T., 1992, , ,

, 62, 29-32.
37.
Bourdieu, P., 2002, : ,

,
38.
Bourdieu, P., 2002, , ,
39.
Bourdieu, P., 2004, , ,
40.
Bourdieu, P.-Passeron,J.-Cl., 1996, , ,
41.
, ., 1993, ,
, 69, 76-80.
42.
, ., 1985, :
, ,
43.
, ., 1985, :
, , 22, 36-49
44.
, ., 1990, , Gutenberg,
45.
, ., 1996, , Gutenberg,
46.
, ., 1996, : ,
Gutenberg,
47.
, ., 2001, , , 4,
36-62
405
48.
, ., 2004, - - :
,
, 39, 23-46
49.
, .-, .-,., 1986,

, ,
50.
, ., 1972, , ,
51.
, ., 1981, , ,
52.
, ., 2005, Paulo Freire , ,
53.
, . , ., 2000, :
Madan Sarup, , 41, 103-119
54.
-, ., 1994, -
, ,
55.
-, ., 2000,
, , 93, 27-48
56.
Carnoy, M., 1988, - , ,

40, 8-42
57.
Carnoy, M. Castells, M., 2001, H ,

: . . . ., 2001
58.
Carr, W.-Kemmis, S., 2000, , ,
59.
Charlot, B., 1999, , ,
60.
Charlot, B., 2002, , , 125, 37-50
61.
Chatelet, Fr., 1985, , ,
62.
Collins, R., 2002, Max Weber, ,
63.
Craib, J., 1998, , ,
64.
Craib, J., 1998, : , 1998, 225-267
65.
, ., 2003,
, , 129, 91-106
66.
, .-, .(), 1993, , ,
67.
, .-, .(), 1997, , ,
68.
, ., 1990, Habermas
, , 2, 149-174
406
69.
, ., 1998,
: , 1998, 67-85
70.
. , 2003,
50 , ,
71.
, ., 1992, : ,
,
72.
, ., 2001, --, ,
73.
, ., 1997, , , 1997
74.
, ., 1998, , , 98, 37-44,

99, 49-56
75.
Davidson, D., 1981, , , 27/28, 183-205
76.
De Queiroz, J.-M., 2000, , Gutenberg,
77.
Devereux, E., Jr, 1996, Parsons : ,

1996, 97-159
78.
Downs, 2002, , ,
79.
Dreeben, R., 1997, :

, , : , 1997, 195-230
80.
, 2001, :
, ,
81.
- , 1996, ,
,
82.
Encyclopdie de la Pliade, 1991, , ....,
83.
Engel, P., 2000, , Scripta,
84.
Feyerabend, P., 1986, , ,
85.
Geissler, E., 1997, , ,
86.
Giddens, A., 1989, , ,
87.
Giddens, A., 1997, , : ,

1997, 509-533
88.
Giddens, A., 1998, ;

Habermas : , 1998, 317-334
89.
Glucksmann, M., 1998, Louis Althusser : , 1998, 79-133
407
90.
Goffman, E., 2001, , ,
91.
Grundy, S., 2003, : ; , ,
92.
, ., 1989, , ,
93.
, ., 1984, , ,
94.
, ., 1997,
: , ., (.), 1997, 135-143
95.
Habermas, J., 1987, , ,
96.
Habermas, J., 1990, , ,
97.
Habermas, J., 1993, , ,
98.
Habermas, J., 1997, , ,
99.
Hacking, I., 2002, ,

..,
100. Hansen, A., 1976, , ,

101. Honneth, A., 1998, : , 1998, 280-298
102. , ., 2003, . , ,
128, 55-59
103. , ., 2004, ,
, 70, 16-25
104. , 1991, ,
105. , 1998, ,
106. , 2000, ,
107. , ., 2000, , ;, ,
108. Jessop, B., 2001, :

, 2001, 87-123
109. Jones, D. Ball, St., 1994, O Michel Foucault :
-, 1994, 169-178
110. Joyce, P., 1997, , , 10, 23-33
408
111. , ., 1996, :
, ,
112. , ., 1996, :
, 1996, 32-54
113. , .-, ., 1995, :
, ,
114. , ., 1998, : , Virtual School, The
Sciences of Education Online, 2/1
115. , ., 1997, . , ,
116. , ., 1983, , ,
117. , . , . , ., 1999,
, , 13
118. , ., 2003, P. Bourdieu: ,
, 73, 75-83
119. , ., 1999, , :
,
120. , .-, ., 1994, :

, Gutenberg,
121. , .-, ., 1996,
2000, Gutenberg,
122. , .-, ., 1998,
, Gutenberg,
123. , .-, .(.), 2002, ,
,
124. , .-, ., 2004, :
2004, , 2004
125. , .-, ., 2005, , Gutenberg,
126. , ., 1991, , ,
127. , ., 1996, : ; :
, 1996, 357-363
128. , ., 2002, , ,
129. , ., 1999,
: , 1999
130. , ., 1991, - ,
409
, 61, 65-71.
131. -, ., 1995,
, Gutenberg,
132. -, ., 1995, :
, ,
133. , . (.), 1996, -5
, ,
134. , ., 1991, :
, ,
135. (.), 1993, , ,
136. , ., 1994, :
: -, 1994, 259-282
137. , ., 1995, ,
, ., 1995, 155-181
138. , ., 1998, :
: -, 1998, 106-142
139. , ., 2005, :
, ,
140. , .-, . (.), 1995,
, ,
141. , ., 1994, ,
, 75, 22-29.
142. , . , ., 1990,
:
, , 53, 151-169
143. , , ., 1989,
, ,
144. , ., 1996,
, , 90, 55-60
145. , ., 2003, ;, . ,
14 . 2003
146. , ., 2004, , ,
147. , ., 1996, , ,
148. , ., 2001, , Gutenberg,
149. , ., 1993, ,
, 72-73-74, 42-49, 27-38, 38-46
410
150. , ., 1994, , ,
78, 34-37.
151. , ., 1994,
, , 79, 24-31.
152. , ., 1997, ,
, 41-42, 116-126.
153. , . - , . , ., 1994,
, , 75, 29-37.
154. , . , ., 2001,
, , 118, 68-79
155. Kuhn, T., 1981, , ,
.
156. , ., 1983, ,
,
157. , ., 1996, :
, ,
158. , ., 1996, ,
, 24, 38-68.
159. , ., 2001, , ,
160. , , 2004, : , , ,,
, 39, 103-139
161. , .-, ., 1998,
, , 103, 73-80, 104, 70-77
162. - , ., 1974, ,
,
163. , ., 1983, ,
, .
164. , ., 1991, : , 1991, 609-619
165. , ., 1995, Pierre Bourdieu :
, 1995, 63-71
166. , ., 2004,
, , 39, 69-102
167. , .-, ., 1995, P. Bourdieu:
, -,
168. , ., 2002, -
411
, ,
169. , ., 1972, , ,
170. , ., 1976, , ,
171. , ., 2003, ,
,
172. Laclau, E., 1997, , ,
173. , ., 1994, ,
, .-, ., 1994, 145-168
174. , ., 1997,
: , 1997, 202-216
175. , ., 1999, :
, Virtual School, The Sciences of Education Online, 1/2
176. , . , ., 1991,
, , 56, 62-69.
177. , . , ., 1991,
, 1991, 399-413.
178. , . , ., 1998,
, , 101, 58-64,
102, 66-72
179. , ., 1990, ,
, 8, 33-35.
180. , ., 2000, , , ,
181. , ., 1977, 18 , ,
182. , ., 1978, , , , ,
183. , ., 1978 , , ,
184. , ., 1981, , ,
185. , ., 1982, , ,
186. , ., 1992, , ,
187. , . , ., 1976, ,,
,
188. , ., 1997, , ,
43, 80-87
189. , ., 1981, ,, ,
412
190. , .(), 1995, :
, Gutenberg,
191. , ., 2001, :
, . , 18, 33-70
192. , ., 1983, ,
, 13, 36-46.
193. , ., 1993, , ,
194. M-, ., 1999, ,

106, 69-77
195. , ., 1981, , ,
196. , ., 1988, :
, ,
197. , ., 1988, , ,
40, 43-48.
198. , ., 1990, , , , 55,
71-77
199. , ., 1993,
, , 71, 31-33
200. , ., 1994, , ,
44
201. , . , . , ., 2005,
, ,
202. , .-., 2002, , ,
203. , ., 1996, , ,
204. , ., 1997, , ,
205. , ., 1998, , ,
206. , ., 1992, , ,
207. , ., 1995, HABITUS: Bourdieu
: - , 1995, 54-62
208. , ., 1997, , ,
209. , ., 2000, , ,
210. , .-, .-, ., 1998,
: , . (.), 1998, 666670
211. , ., 1990, : , ,
413
212. , ., 2004, , ,
213. , ., 1999, , ,
214. , . , ., 2004, , , :
, , 89, 75-109
215. , ., 1998,
, , 27, 71-96.
216. , ., 2004, ,
,
217. , ., 1986, , Gutenberg,
218. , ., 2000, , ,
219. , .-, ., 1994, , , 9, 117-130
220. , ., 1998,
, ,
221. , ., 1983, 1986,
, , 26, 71-85 37, 92-107
222. , ., 1991, , ,
223. , ., 1998, , Gutenberg,
224. , .(.), 1997,
( ), ,
225. , ., 2001, , ,
226. -, ., 1998, :
, Gutenberg,
227. -, ., 2000, ,
, 111, 39-45
228. , ., 1979, ,
1931-1973, ,
229. , ., 1985, :
, 119, 43-48
230. , ., 1986, , ,
231. , ., 1989,
, , 2, 28-30
232. , ., 1990, , ,
233. , ., 1990, , ,
234. , ., 1995, Pierre Bourdieu :
414
- , 1995, 49-52
235. , ., 2003, , ,
236. , ., 2004, , ,
237. , ., 2005, ,
, 74, 34-37
238. , . (.), 1998, , , ,
239. , ., 1998, , ,
240. Nield, K., 1997, ;, , 10, 5-22
241. , ., 1984, , ,
242. , ., 1977, , ,
243. , 1996, ,
,
244. , 1999,
, , ,
245. , ., 1992, , , ,
246. , . ., 1983, , ,
247. , ., 2003, , ,
248. , ., 1990, Habermas ,
, 3, 117-133
249. , ., 1994, , ,
74, 47-55.
250. , ., 1992, , ,
62, 33-45
251. , ., 2002, ,
,
252. , ., 1981,
, , 44, 46-51
253. , ., 1985, : , 1985,
251-279
254. , ., 2000, ,
, 113-114, 47-56, 41-52
255. , ., 2001, - , , 45, 10-13
415
256. , ., 1991, , ,
257. , ., 2002, , , ,
, 123-124, 65-80, 83-93
258. , ., 2004, ,
, 41, 65-88
259. , ., 1987, 1948-1985:
, ,
260. , .(.), 1996, 1998, , .
,
261. , ., 2002, , Scripta,
262. , 1976, , ,
263. , 1980, , ,
264. , ., 1981, , ,
265. , 1982, , , , ,
266. , . , 1977,
, ,
267. , ., 2002
1960, , 124, 41-45
268. , ., 1995,
-, 1995, 84-120
269. , ., 2000, , ,
270. , .,2001, , ,
271. Perrenoud, P., 1996, ; , ,

87, 27-38
272. Perrenoud, P., 2002, ;,
, 63, 27-35
273. , ., 1982,
, , 42, 51-61
274. , ., 1987, , , 8,
69-80
275. , ., 1988, , ,
416
276. , ., 1988, ,
, 40, 52-63
277. , ., 1976, , ,
278. , ., 2002, , , , ,
279. , ., 1997, , ,
280. Ritzer, G., 1996,
: , 1996, 41-95
281. Ritzer, G., 1996a, : , 1996,
235-279
282. Ritzer, G., 1996b,
: , 1996, 281-331
283. , . , ., 2004, :
90,
,
284. , ., 1995,
,
, 30, 35-39.
285. , ., 1998, : ,
1998, 623-638
286. , ., 2006, , , 94,
81-104
287. , ., 1994, :
, : -, 1994, 113-144
288. , ., 1997,
: , 1997, 188-199
289. , .-, ., 1994, , - ,
290. , . , . , ., 1996,
, , 90, 43-54.
291. , ., 1981, , , ,
292. , ., 1984, , ,
, , 6, 31-47
293. , ., 1986, , ,
417
294. , ., 1986,
: , 1986, 249-303
295. , ., 1995, , ,
,
296. , ., 1999, , ,
297. , ., 2005, , ,
298. , ., 1999, , ,
299. , ., 2002, , , :
,
300. , ., 2004, , ,
301. Sharp, R., 1990, , ,
, 7, 36-42.
302. Sharp, R. Green, T., 1997, :
: , 1997, 442-457
303. Stenwood, L., 2003,
, ,
304. Sweezy, P., xx, , Gutenberg,
305. Sweezy, P. Baran, P., xx, , Gutenberg,
306. , ., 1986, , Gutenberg, .
307. , ., 1993,
, , 71, 34-38
308. , ., 1983, : ,
,
309. , ., 1986, , ,
310. , ., 1999,
, ,
311. , 1999,
, ,
312. , ., 1984, , ,
313. , ., 2000, , ,
314. , ., 2002, , ,
315. , ., 2001, , :
: , 2001, 152-172
316. , ., 1977, :
418
(1830-1922), ,
317. , ., 1986, , , ,
,
318. Tippelt, R., 2001, ,
, 32, 189-205.
319. , ., 1999, 9 ,
, 108, 37-52
320. , ., 1986, , ,
321. , ., 1987, --, ,
322. , ., 1998, ,
, 100, 31-40
323. , ., 1977,
, ,
324. , ., 1978,
1911, . ,
325. , ., 1978, , ,
326. , ., 1985, :
, ,
327. , ., 1987, , ,
328. , ., 2001, : 1880-1980,
, ,
329. , ., 2004, ,
, 39, 47-68
330. , ., 1997, :
: , . (.), 1997, 237-254
331. , .-, .(), 1998, ; , ,
332. , ., 1995, :
. ,
,
333. , . , ., 1991, :
, ,
334. , . , ., 1995, ,
, 31, 22.
335. , . , ., 2004, , . ,
419
336. , ., 1987, , ,
337. , ., 1996, ,
, 39, 26-30.
338. , ., 1999, , ,
339. , ., 2003, , . ,
340. , .-, . (.), 1985, :
, ,
341. Varian, H., 1992, , ,
342. Walkerdine, V., 1994, : , 1994, 105-111
343. Walsh, W., 1985, , ....,
344. Windelband, W. Heimsoeth, H., 1991, , ....,
345. Wood, G., 1992, ,

, 19, 36-38.

1. Abercrombie, N. Hill, S. Turner, B.S., 1980, The Dominant Ideology
Thesis, Allen and Unwin, London
2. Abercrombie, N. Hill, S. Turner, B.S., 1983, Determinacy and Indeterminacy in the
Theory of Ideology, New Left Review, 142, 31-47
3. Althusser, L. at al., 1970, Reading Capital, New Left Books, London
4. Althusser, L., 1971, Lenin and Philosophy, New left Books, London
5. Althusser, L., 1994, Ideology and Ideological State Apparatusses in: Zizek, S., 1994, 100140
6. Altonji, J., 1995, The Effects of High School Curriculum on Education and Labour
Market Outcomes, Journal of Human Resources, Summer, 410-438
7. Anderson, P., 1998, The Origins of Postmodernity, Verso, London
8. Antonitis, M. Tsakloglou, P., 1999, Who benefits by Public Expenditure in Greece?
Athens University of Business and Economics, Discussion Paper 99-02,
420
9. Apple, M., 1995, Education, Culture and Class Power: Basil Bernstein and the neoMarxist sociology of education in: Sadovnik (ed.), 1995, 106-131
10. Apple, M., 1997, What Postmodernists Forget: Cultural Capital and Official Knowledge
in: Halsey, 1997, 595-604
11. Apple, M., 1998, Teaching and Technology: The Hidden Effects of Computers on
Teachers and Students in: Beyer-Apple, 1998, 314-336
12. Apple, M., 2000, Official Knowledge, Routledge, London
13. Apple, M., 2000, The Politics of Common Sense: Why the Right is Winning in: Apple,
2000, 15-41
14. Apple, M. Kenway, J. Singh, M., 2005, Globalizing Education: Policies, Pedagogies
and Politics, Peter Lang, New York
15. Archer, M. Bhaskar, R. Collier, A. Lawson, T. Norrie, A. (ed.), 1998, Critical
Realism /Essential Readings, Routledge, London
16. Aronowitz, S. Giroux, H., 1991, Postmodern Education, University of Minnesota Press,
Minneapolis
17. Aronowitz, S. De Fazio, W., 1997, The New Knowledge Work in: Halsey, 1997, 193-206
18. Arrow, K. Bowles, S. Durlauf, 2000, Meritocracy and Economic Inequality, Princeton
University Press, New Jersey
19. Balibar, E., Masses, Classes, Ideas, Routledge, 1994
20. Ball, St. Vincent, C., 2001, New Class Relations in Education: The Strategies of the
Fearful Middle Classes in: Demaine, 2001, 180-195
21. Ballantine, J., 1997, The Sociology of Education: A Systemic Analysis, Upper Saddle
River, Prentice Hall, New Jersey
22. Baudelot, Ch. Establet, R., 1972, LEcole Calitaliste en France, Maspero, Paris
23. Becker, G. S., 1964, Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical analysis with special
reference in Education, University of Chicago Press, Chicago
24. Becker, H., 1952, Social-class variations in the teacher-pupil relationship, Journal of
Educational Sociology, 25, 451-465
25. Benabou, M., 2000, Meritocracy, Redistribution and the Size of Pie in: Arrow, K., 2000,
317-339
26. Berger, P. Luckmann, T., 1967, The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the
Sociology of Knowledge, Allen Lane, Penguin, London
27. Bernstein, B., 1996, Pedagogy, Symbolic Control and Identity, Taylor and Francis, Exeter
28. Bernstein, R., 1978, The Restructuring of Social and Political Theory, University of
Pennsylvania Press, Pittsburgh
421
29. Bernstein, R., 1992, The New Constellation: The Ethical-Political Horizons of
Modernity/Postmodernity, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
30. Berube, R., 2004, Radical reformers: The Influence of the Left in the
American Education, Information Age Publishing Inc., Greenwich, Connecticut
31. Berube, R., 2004, Teachers as Reds in: Berube, 2004, 13-26
32. Beyer, L. Apple, M., 1998, The Curriculum: Problems, politics and Possibilities,
S.U.N.Y Press, New York
33. Bhaskar, R., 1975, A Realist Theory of Science, Leeds Books, Leeds
34. Bhaskar, R., 1989, The Possibility of Naturalism, Harvester, Herfordshire
35. Blaug, M., 1970, Economics of Education, Penguin, London
36. Blumer, H., 1969, Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method, Prentice Hall, New
Jersey
37. Bottomore, T., 1991, Social Classes in Modern Society, Routledge, New York
38. Boudon, R., 1986, Education, Social Mobility and Sociological Theory in: Richardson,
1986, 260-274
39. Bourdieu, P., 1977, Reproduction, Sage, London
40. Bourdieu, P., 1977, Outline of a Theory of Practice, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge
41. Bourdieu, P. Wacquant, L., 1992, An Invitation of Reflexive Sociology, Polity Press,
Cambridge
42. Bowen, W.G., 1977, Assessing the Economic Contribution of Education in: Cosin, 1977,
27-42
43. Bowles, S., 1971, Growth Effects of Changes in Labour Quality, Greece: 1951-1961 in:
Chenery, 1971, 371-385
44. Bowles, S. -Gintis, H., 1998, Recasting Egalitarianism, Verso, London
45. Bowles, S. Gintis, H., 1999, Reciprocity, Self Interest and the Welfare State, Nordic
Journal of Political Economy, Arrow at al., 2000, viii -xv
46. Bowles, S. -Gintis, H., 2000, Does Schooling Raise Earnings by Making People Smarter?
in: Arrow at al., 2000, 118-136
47. Brown, P. Lauder, H., Education, Globalization and Economic Development in: Halsey
at al., 1997, 172-192
48. Callinicos, A., 1989, Against Postmodernism, St. Martins Press, New York
49. Callinicos, A., 1995, Theories and Narratives, Duke University Press, Durham
50. Callinicos, A., 1999, Social Theory, New York U.P., New York
51. Callinicos, A., 2000, Equality, Polity Press, Oxford
422
52. Carchedi, G., 1977, The Economic Identification of Social Classes, Routledge and Kegan
Paul, London
53. Carnoy, M. Levin, H, 1985, Schooling and Work in the Democratic State, Stanford
University Press, Stanford
54. Castell, R., 1967, Education, Development, et Democratie, Mouton, Paris
55. Castells, M., 1996, 1997, 1998, The Information Age: Economy, Society and Culture, B.
Blackwell, Cambridge
56. Castells, M. -Freire, P. -Willis, P. (ed), 1999, Critical Education in the New Information
Age, Rowman and Littlefield, Boston
57. Castells, M., 1999, Flows, Networks and Identities in: Castells at al., 1999, 37-64
58. Castree, M., 2000, Review of Castells s The Information Age, Historical Materialism,
7, 241-256
59. Chenery, H. (ed.), 1971, Studies in Development Planning, Harvard University Press,
Cambridge, Mass.
60. Cicourel, A., 1974, Cognitive Sociology, Free Press, New York
61. Clarke, S. 1991, The State Debate, McMillan, London
62. Clarke, S., 1991, Marxism, Sociology and Poulantzas s Theory of the State in:
Clarke, S., 1991, 70-108
63. Clarke, S., 1994, Marxs Theory of Crisis, St Martins Press, New York
64. Close, F., 1988, The quark structure of the matter in: Davies, P., 1988, 396-424
65. Cockburn, C., 1977, The Local State, Pluto Press, London
66. Connell, R., 1979, A Critique of the Althusserian Approach to Class, Theory and Society,
8/3, 328-341
67. Cosin, B.R., 1977, Education: Structure and Society, Penguin, London
68. Cosin, B Hales, M., 1983, Education, Policy and Society, Routledge and Kegan Paul,
London
69. Crook, S. Pakulski, J. Waters, M., 1992, Postmodernization: Change in Advanced
Societies, Sage, London
70. Davidson, D., 1990, The structure and content of Truth, Journal of Philosophy, 87, 22-36
71. Davies, P., 1988, The New Physics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
72. Demaine, J., 1981, Contemporary Theories in the Sociology of Education, McMillan
Press, London
73. Demaine, J., 2001, Sociology of Education Today, Palgrave, New York
74. Descombes, V., 1980, Modern French Philosophy, Cambridge U.P., Cambridge
75. Dreyfous, D. Rabinow, P., 1982, Foucault, Basil Blackwell, Oxford
76. Dworkin, R., 1981, What is Equality?, Philosophy and Public Affairs, 10, 284-402
423
77. Eagleton, T., 1992, Ideology, Verso, London

78. Edgell, S., 1993, Class, Routledge, London
79. Elliot, G., 1994, Althusser: A Critical Reader, B. Blackwell, Cambridge
80. Flynn, J.R., 1996, Group Differences: Is the Good Society Impossible?, Journal of
Biosocial Science, 28, 573-585
81. Foucault, M., 1976, Power/Knowledge, Harvester Press, Brighton
82. Foucault, M., 1977, Discipline and Punish, Penguin, London
83. Fraser, St., 1997, Introduction to the Bell Curve Wars in: Halsey, 1997, 779-783
84. Fung, A. -Wright, E. -O., 2003, Deepening Democracy, Verso, London
85. Gans, H., 1972, The Positive Functions of Poverty, American Journal of Sociology, 78,
275-289.
86. Garfinkel, H., 1967, Studies in Ethnomethodology, Prentice Hall, New Jersey
87. Giddens, A., 1984, The Constitution of Society, Polity Press, Oxford
88. Gilborn, D. Youdell, D., 2000, Ratioting Education, Open University Press, Philadelphia
89. Gilborn, D. Youdell, D., 2001, The New IQism: Intelligence, Ability and the Ratioting
of Education in: Demaine, 2001, 65-99
90. Giroux, H., 1997, Pedagogy and the Politics of Hope, Westview, Colorado
91. Giroux, H. Shannon, P., 1997, Education and Cultural Studies, Routledge, London
92. Goldthorpe, G., 1983, Social Mobility in Britain in: Cosin Hales, 1983, 60-82
93. Goldthorpe, G., 1987, Social Mobility and Class Structure in Modern Britain, Clarendon
Press, Oxford
94. Goldthorpe, J., 1997, Problems of Meritocracy in: Halsey, A., 1997, 663-682
95. Habermas, J., 1984, The Theory of Communicative Action, I, Heinemann, London
96. Habermas, J., 1986, Autonomy and Solidarity, Blackwell, Oxford
97. Habermas, J., 1987, The Theory of Communicative Action, II, Polity Press, Cambridge
98. Hallinan, M., 2000, Handbook of the Sociology of Education, Kluwer Academic, New
York
99. Halsey, A. Lauder, H. Brown, Ph. Wells, A. (ed.), 1997, Education: Culture,
Economy and Society, Oxford University Press, Oxford
100. Hammersley, M. Woods, P. (ed.), 1976, The Process of Schooling, Routledge and Kegan
Paul, London
101. Hargreaves, A., 2003, Teaching in the Knowledge Society, Columbia University Press,
New York
424
102. Harvey, D., 1989, The Condition of Postmodernity, B. Blackwell, Cambridge
103. Herrnstein, R. J. Murray, C., 1994, The Bell Curve: Intelligence and Class Structure in
American Life, Free Press, New York
104. Hill, D., 1998, Postmodernism and Education: A Structural Neo-Marxist Critique,
Birmingham University Social Justice Research Seminar, 24 March
105. Hurn, Cr., 1993, The Limits and Possibilities of Schooling: An Introduction to the
Sociology of Education, Alyn and Bacon, Boston
106. Hurn, Cr., 1993, What school teach in: Hurn, 1993, 186-224
107. Itoh, M., 1988, The Basic Theory of Capitalism, McMillan, London
108. Jameson, F., 1981, The Political Unconscious, Cornell U. P., New York
109. Jameson, F., 1989, The Ideologies of Theory, New York U. P., New York
110. Jameson, F. -Miyoshi, M., 1998, The Cultures of Globalization, Duke U. P., Duke
111. Kaplan, A., 1993, The Althusserian Legacy, Verso, London
112. Karabel, J. -Halsey, A. (ed), 1977, Power and Ideology in Education, Oxford University
Press, Oxford
113. Kelly, J., 1998, Rethinking Industrial Relations, Routledge, London
114. Knorr Cettina, K. Mulkay, M. (eds.), 1983, Science Observed: Perspectives of the
Social Study of Science, Sage, London
115. Korenman, S. Winship, C., 2000, A Reanalysis of The Bell Curve: Intelligence,
Family Background and Schooling in: Arrow, K. at al., 2000, 137-178
116. Laclau, E. Mouffe, Ch., 1985, Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical
Democratic Politics, Verso, London
117. Lambiri-Dimaki, I., Les Chances d Accs a l Enseignement en Grce en : Castell, R.,
1967, 107-116
118. Lamnias, C., 2003, A Sociological Analysis of the Internal Differentiation of
Pedagogic Knowledge, Pedagogy, Culture and Society, 11/2, 243-261
119. Lauder, H., 1997, Education, Democracy and the Economy in: Halsey at al., 1997, 382392
120. Leibenstein, H., 1967, Rates of Return to Education in Greece, Center for International
Affairs, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
121. Lemert, C., 1995, Sociology After the Crisis, Westview, Colorado
122. Levin, H Kelley, C., 1997, Can Education Do It Alone? in: Halsey at al, 1997, 240-251
425
123. Levine, A., 1998, Efficiency Politics in: Wright, E.O.(ed.), 1998, 121-138
124. Levine, A., 2003, A Future for Marxism, Pluto Press, London
125. Levitas, M., 1974, Marxist Perspectives in the Sociology of Education, Routledge and
Kegan Paul, London
126. Lundberg, S. Startz, R., 2000, Inequality and Race: Models and Policy in: Arrow at al.,
2000, 269-295
127. Luttwak, E., 1999, Turbo-Capitalism, London
128. Lynch, K., 2000, Research and Theory on Equality and Education in: Hallinan, 2000, 85105
129. Marx, 1981, Capital, Harmondsworth, London
130. Matthews, M., 1980, The Marxist Theory of Schooling, Harvester, Sussex
131. McClosky, H. Zaller, J., 1984, The American Ethos: Public Attitudes towards
Capitalism and Democracy, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
132. McKenzie, J., 2001, Changing Education: A Sociology of Education since 1944, Prentice
Hall, New Jersey
133. McLaren, P., 2003, Life in Schools, Alyn and Bacon, Boston
134. McLaren, P. Farahmandpur, R., 2005, Teaching against Global Capitalism and the New
Imperialism: A Critical Pedagogy, Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham.
135. McLellan, D., 1996, Ideology, Open U.P., London
136. McRobbie, A., 1978, Working Class Girls and the Culture of Femininity in: Womens
Studies Group, 1978
137. Meyer, J., 1986, Types of Explanation in the Sociology of Education in: Richardson,
1986, 341-359.
138. Mignolo, W., 1998, Globalization, Civilization Processes and the Relocation of
Languages and Cultures in: Jameson -Miyoshi, 1998, 32-51
139. Mincer, J., 1974, Schooling, Experience and Earnings, Columbia University Press, New
York
140. Molnar, A., 2000, Vouchers, Class Size Reduction and Student Achievement, Phi Delta
Kappa Education Foundation, Bloomington
141. Morrow, R. Torres, C., 1995, Social Theory and Education: A Critique of Theories of
Social and Cultural Reproduction, S.U.N.Y Press, Albany
142. Morrow, R. Torres, C., 1998, Education and the Reproduction of Class, Gender and
Race: Responding on the Postmodern Challenge in: Torres-Mitchell, 1998, 19-45
143. Morrow, R. Torres, C., 2002, Reading Freire and Habermas: Critical Pedagogy and
Transformative Social Change, Teachers College Press, New York
426
144. Murnane, R. Levy, F., 1996, Teaching the New Basic Skills: Principles of Educating
Children and Thriving in a Changing Economy, The Free Press, New York
145. Norris, C., 1995, Truth, Science and the Growth of Knowledge, New Left Review, 210,
105-123
146. Norris, C., 1997, Against Relativism, B. Blackwell, Oxford
147. Nozick, R., 1974, Anarchy, State and Utopia, Oxford University Press, Oxford
148. Offe, Cl., 1985, Disorganised Capitalism, Polity Press, Oxford
149. Parelius, R., J. -Parelius, A., P., 1987, The Sociology of Education, Prentice Hall, New
Jersey.
150. Parelius, R., J. -Parelius, A., P., Sociology and the Field of Education in: PareliusParelius, 1987, 1-19.
151. Pecheux, M., 1982, Language, Semantics and Ideology, Macmillan, London
152. Pecheux, M., 1982a, On the Ideological Conditions of the Reproduction / Transformation
of the Relations of Production in: Pecheux, M., 1982, 22-27
153. Piore, M. Sabel, C., 1984, The Second Industrial Divide, Basic Books, New York
154. Popkewitz, Th., 1998, The Sociology of Knowledge and the Sociology of Education:
Michel Foucault and Critical Traditions in: Torres-Mitchell, 1998, 47-89
155. Power, S., 2001, Missing: A Sociology of Educating the Middle Class in: Demaine, 2001,
196-205
156. Psacharopoulos, G., 1982, Earnings and Education in Greece: 1960-1977, European
Education Review, 17, 333-347
157. Psathas, G. (ed.), 1973, Phenomenological Sociology: Issues and Applications, Wiley,
New York
158. Rawls, J., 1972, A Theory of Justice, Oxford University Press, Oxford
159. Richardson, J., 1986, Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education,
Greenwood, New York.
160. Roemer, J., 1982, A General Theory of Exploitation and Class, Harvard University Press,
Cambridge, Mass.
161. Roemer, J., 2000, Equality of Opportunity in: Arrow at al., 2000, 17-32
162. Rorty, R., 1979, Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature, Basil Blackwell, Oxford
163. Rorty, R., 1982, Consequences of Pragmatism, University of Minnesota Press,
Minneapolis
164. Rorty, R., 1992, Objectivity, Realism and Truth, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
427
165. Ryan, A., 1982, Marxism and Deconstruction, Johns Hopkins U.P., New Jersey
166. Sadovnik, A., (ed.), 1995, Knowledge and Pedagogy: The Sociology of B. Bernstein,
Ablex Publishing Corporation, Norwood, New Jersey, 1995
167. Salvadori, M., 1990, Karl Kautsky and the Socialist Revolution, Verso, London
168. Sarup, M., 1978, Marxism and Education, RKP, New York
169. Sarup, M., 1993, An Introductory Guide to Poststructuralism and Postmodernism,
Georgia U.P., Athens Georgia
170. Saunders, P., 1990, Social Class and Stratification, Routledge, London
171. Schultz, T.W., 1961, Investment in Human Capital, American Economic Review, 51, 117
172. Schutz, A., 1964, Collected Papers, II, La Hague, Nijhoff
173. Sen, A., 1995, Inequality Reexamined, Clarendon Press, Oxford
174. Sharp, R. Green, T, 1975, Education and Social Control: A Study of Progressive
Primary Education, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London
175. Simons, B. -Billig, M (eds), 1994, After Postmodernism, Sage, London
176. Sorensen, A. Morgan, St., 2000, School Effects: Theoretical and Methodological Issues
in: Hallinan, 2000, 137-160
177. Spanos, W., 1993, The End of Education, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
178. Stryker, S., 1976, Symbolic Interactionism: a Social Structural Version, Benjamin
/Cummings, Menlo Park
179. Thompson, J-B. , 1983, Studies in the Theory of Ideology, Polity Press, Oxford
180. Thompson, J-B., 1983, Action, Ideology and the Text: A Reformulation of Paul
Ricoeurs Theory of Interpretation in: Thompson, 1983, 173-203
181. Thompson, J-B. , 1983, The Theory of Structuration: An Assessment of the Contribution
of Anthony Giddens in: Thompson, 1983, 148-172
182. Thompson, J-B. , 1983, Symbolic Violence: Language and Power in the Writings of
Pierre Bourdieu in: Thompson, 1983, 46-73
183. Tomlinson, S., 1994, Educational Reform and Its Consequences, Rivers Oram Press,
London
184. Torres, C., 1998, Education, Power and Personal Biography: Dialogues with Critical
Educators, Routledge, London
185. Torres, C. Mitchell, Th., 1998, Sociology of Education: Emerging Perspectives,
S.U.N.Y Press, New York
186. Trifonas, P., 2000, Revolutionary Pedagogies, Routledge, London
428
187. Tudor, H. Tudor, J., 1988, Marxism and Social democracy: The Revisionist Debate
1896-1898, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
188. Turner, R., 1961, Modes of Social Ascent through Education: Sponsored and Contest
Mobility in: Halsey, A. Floud, J. Anderson, C., 1961, 121-138
189. Usher, R. -Edwards, R., 1994, Postmodernism and Education, Routledge, London
190. Waslander, S. Thrupp, M., 1997, Choice, Competition and Segregation: An Empirical
Analysis of a New Zealand Secondary School Market, 1990-1993 in: Halsey at al., 1997,
439-459
191. Waugh, P., 1992, Postmodernism: A Reader, Ed. Arnold, New York
192. Wexler, P., 1987, Social Analysis of Education, Routledge, London
193. Whitty, G., 1997, Social Theory and Education Policy: The Legacy of K. Mannheim,
British Journal of the Sociology of Education, 18, 121-135
194. Whitty, G., 2001, Vultures and Third Ways: Recovering Mannheims Legacy for Today
in: Demaine, 2001, 206-222
195. Willis, P., 1977, Learning to Labour, Fairnborough, Saxon House
196. Womens Studies Group, 1978, Women Take Issue, Hutchinson, London
197. Wood, D., Democracy and the Curriculum in: Beyer Apple, 1998, 177-198
198. Woodhall, M., 1997, Human Capital Concepts in: Halsey at al., 1997, 218-223
199. Wright, E.O., 1994, Interrogating Inequality, Verso, London
200. Wright, E.O., 1997, Classes, Verso, London
201. Wright, E.O., 1997, Class Counts: Comparative studies in Class Analysis, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge
202. Wright, E.O.(ed), 1989, The Debate on Classes, Verso, London
203. Wright, E.O.(ed.), 1998, Recasting Egalitarianism: New Rules for Communities, States
and Markets, Verso, London
204. Wright, El. Wright, Ed., 1999, The Zizek Reader, Basil Blackwell, Oxford
205. Young, M., 1958, The Rise of Meritocracy, 1870-2033, Thames and Hudson, London
206. Young, M. F. D. (ed.), 1971, Knowledge and Control, McMillan, London
207. Zizek, S. (ed), 1994, Mapping Ideology, Verso, London
208. Zizek, S., 1994, Kafka, Critic of Althusser in: Zizek (ed.), 1994, 321-327
209. Zizek, S., 2001, Interview, Historical Materialism, 7, 181-197
429

, ,
,
. , ,
: 1)

, 2)
(, , ,
) 1.

(fait)

. , ,
. ,

. sui generis

.
. , [ ]

[] :
)
, )
)
2. ,
Blackledge, D.-Hunt, B., 1995 , , ,

28
, ., 1987, , , 8, 70
4
, . ,
60-
Educational Sociology
.
,
,

.
3.
60.

(, 1987, 73).
The Journal of Educational
Sociology Sociology of Education
. 60, ,
Basil Bernstein4 ,
, , de Queroz, []
,
60 [ ]
, .
5.
3
Banks, O., xx, , , , 11-15.

: Bottomore, T., 1992, ,
, , 29-32
, ., 1985, , , , 138-148.
B. Bernstein
1958.
De Queroz, J-M., 2000, , Gutenberg, , 37.

.
:
Ballantine, J., 1997, The Sociology of Education: A Systematic Analysis, Prentice Hall, New Jersey.

: Sociology of Education: A Unique Perspective on Schools, 1-22; Conflicting Functions
and Processes in Education: What Makes the System Works, 23-55; Education and the Process of
5

, ,
,
.

. , ,
.
Stratification, 56-85. : Hurn, Cr., What School Teach in: Hurn, Cr., 1993, The Limits and
Possibilities of Schooling, Alyn and Bacon, Boston, 186-224. :
McKenzie, J., 2001, Changing Education: A Sociology of Education since 1944, Prentice Hall, New
Jersey,
. : Changing
Perspectives, 42-68,
New Labour .
: Parelius, R., J. Parelius, A., P., Sociology and the Field of Education in:
Parelius, R., J. Parelius, A., P., 1987, The Sociology of Education, Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 1-19.
, -
: Meyer, J., Types of Explanation
in the Sociology of Education in: Richardson, J., 1986, Handbook of Theory and Research for the
Sociology of Education, Greenwood, New York, 341-359.

, ,
.

.

.
,

, , , .
,

, .
. Edward
Devereux Jr1 Parsons
,
,
. , Parsons,
,
,
. Parsons
,
. Alvin Gouldner
The Coming Crisis of Western Sociology
1
Devereux, E., Jr, Parsons , . (), 1996,

, , , 130
7
,
,
30

,
2.

.
.

.

(Devereux, 1996, 117-121).

. ,
. ,
, ,
, .

.
, (act unit)
, , ,
,
, .

,

2
Craib, I., 1998, , , , 69-70.

, Mills Gouldner, . Lemert, Ch., 1995, Sociology after the Crisis,
Westview Press, Colorado
8

, .

. Craib (Craib, 1998, 7778) .
,

. ,
, .

.
,
. [.]
, ,
,

.
,
,
. ,
,
.

,
,
,
.
, , ,
,
. , ,
,
,
9
Spencer ,
. ,

,

(Devereux, 1996, 130).

.

. ,
, ,

.

. (
)
(), (), ()
().
,

, ,
.

.
ad infinitum

,
...3
3
. Devereux, 1996, 149-159 Craib, 1998,
10
, ,
. ()

.
,
, ,
. (),
,
-

. ()

,
. , ()

,

. , ,

.

. G. Ritzer, []
,
,
, ,
4.

5.
79-83. , ., 1997,
, , , 31-39.
4
Ritzer, G.,
, 1996, 51
H. Gans
11

,
.

,
6. , ,

.
,
, ,
.
, ,
.

,
,
.
.
, ,

.
, ,

. , Dreeben
The Positive Functions of Poverty, American Journal of Sociology, 78 / 1972, 275-289,

.
. , ., 1986, ,
Gutenberg, , 178-186 Ritzer, 1996, 59-63
6
, ., 1985, :
a , 1985, 252.
: Demaine, J., 1981, Contemporary Theories in the
Sociology of Education, McMillan Press, London, 19-29.
12
7
, ,
. , []

,

,

,

(,
1997, 90). , ,
, ,

.

. ,
:
) ,

)
(,
1985, 251).

.
Dreeben, R., : ,
, , , ., 1997, :
, , , 195-230
13
,

8.
Turner
, []

,
(Blackledge-Hunt, 1995,
113).
, ,
,

.
, -
,
,
,

,
,
/ ( need
dispositions) . ,
, ,
,
. ,

, [ ] [] []
,
(, 1997, 30). ,
Ralph
Turner Earl Hopper Blackledge-Hunt, 1995, 110-122.
14

.
, ,
, ,
,
() .

.

.

.
(, 1997,
25-36) -
1
,
.
,

, ,
,

2.

-
. , ,

3,
, ., 2001, : , ,
, 41-174. , ,
- . .
, .- , ., 1998 , Gutenberg,
, 19
,

, ,
16

, ,
,
-
4
. ,
-
,
.

,
.

.
,
,
.
, .
,
5. ,

,
.
6,
: 1981, :
, ,
4

: ) ,

)
. . , 1985, 251.
, ., 1977, 18 , , , 15
. ,
17
.

. []
,

.

7.
.

, .

. ,
, 8,
9,

10.
, ,

.
. , ,
, , ,
,1997, . , , , 75-94
7
Marx, K., 1981, Capital, Harmondsworth, London, II, 120
, ., 1981, , , , 16

, ,
.
The Nature of Social Class : Bottomore, T., 1991, Classes in Modern Society,
Routledge, New York, 5-31
10
. Wright, E. -O., 1997,Class Counts,

Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 492-499,
Wright, E.-O. (ed.), 1989, The Debate on Classes, Verso, London -
Guglielmo Carchedi Uwe Becker. : , .,
2002, , Scripta, , 453-555
18
,
, , ,
,
,
,
. , ,
11.
, ,

, ,
. , ,
,
, ,

. , ,
,

.
,

.
.
, ,
.
, ,

-
. , ,
,
, , .

11
, .- , ., 1976, , , , 41-42
19
. ,
,
12,

,
13. -

,
.

.

,
14.
,
,
,
15.
, . ,

,

, (, 1978, 75).
-
,
12
Craib .. . . Craib, 1998, 295-354.
13
1972
. , ., 1984, , , .
: , ., 2005,
-, , 92, 85-97. 1966.
14
, ., 1978, , , , 200-217
15
. Jameson, F., 1981, The Political

Unconscious, Methuen, London, 94
20
,
, , -
,
.
(structure a dominance),

,
, .. .

. , ,
, ,

. ,
, , -
(peculiar) , , , ,
,
,..,
,
,
16. , ,

.

,

.
(, 1978, 214),

.
16
Althusser at al., 1970, Reading Capital, New Left Books, London, 104 ( :
, , , 2003)
21
17
,

,
. ,, ,
.
, ,

.
.
,
18
,

,

.

.
19.

.

, ,
17

- : Miriam Glucksmann, Louis Althusser
, 1998, 79-133
18
Eagleton, T., 1992, Ideology, Verso, London, 70-91.
19
, ,
: Callinicos, A., 1999, Social Theory,
New York University Press, 112-124 , . - , . - , ., 2005,
, , , 123-174.
. Eagleton, 1992, 93-123.
22

.

.
,
- ,
.
:

, ,
,
, , ,
.
,
,

,
.
, , ,
,

.
,
,

.
.

, ,
,
20. ,
20
Althusser, L., Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses in: Zizek, S. (ed), 1994, Mapping
Ideology, Verso, London, 127 ( : , , , 1981, 69-121)
23
,
.
. ,
, .
. ,
. ,
. ,
. , Slavoj
Zizek 21.

22. , , ,
23.
21
Zizek, S. (ed), 1994, 30
22
Althusser, L, Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses Zizek, 1994, 123
23

.
. , ,
:
( ) , ,
( )
. , ,
,
, ,
. , ,
Lebenswelt ( ) ,
.

Lebenswelt;
. : ) ()
, , , )
,
( : ,
) ,
,
. ,
, ,
24
.
.
,
.
,
: , , !. ,
.
( )
24.
, .

, ,
. ,
, : , . ,
(Althusser, 1994, 127).
, , ,
, , , .
; , ,

.
,
, ,
,
. , ,
, :
,
,
(cogito),
,
, * (
. (, ., 1994, , , , 107-108).
* (..)
24
( ), ( )
. , , , ,
.
25
: , ,
, ,
... (Althusser, 1994, 127).
, , .
.
, , , ...,-
. , ,

,

.
, .
, ,
,
,
.
,
, , -

(Zizek, 1994, 4)25.

.

Sur la reproduction 26-

.
25

(.. )
(..
)
26
. , ., 2004, ,
, ,
: Sur la reproduction.
26
, ,

.
.

.
, , .

.
,
,
.
Michel Pecheux,

, .
,
. [ ]

, [] inertia,
27. ,
,
, ,

,
,
.
.
27
Pecheux, M., 1982a, On the Ideological Conditions of the Reproduction / Transformation of the
Relations of Production Pecheux, M., 1982, Language, Semantics and Ideology, Macmillan,
London, 22-27. Pecheux . Thompson,
J., 1984, Studies in the Theory of Ideology, Polity Press, Cambridge, 232-255
27
,

,
: , ,
... (Althusser, 1994, 137-138).
, ,

,
-

.
,
28.
28
. :
Carnoy, M., 1988, , , , 40, 8-42,
Sharp, R., 1990, , , , 7,
36-42
Apple, M., 1993, , , ,
Apple, M., xx, , ,

: Levitas, M., 1974, Marxist Perspectives in the Sociology of Education,
Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
Demaine, J., 1981, Contemporary Theories in the Sociology of Education, McMillan
Press, London, 65-91 123-152.
- : McLaren, P., 2003, Critical Pedagogy:
A Look at the Major Concepts in: McLaren, P., Life in Schools, Alyn and Bacon, Boston, 193-223.
, ,
, : Torres, C., 1998, Education,
Power and Personal Biography: Dialogues with Critical Educators, Routledge, London.
3

,
,
,
, .
,
, -
: , ,
, ,
.
19 Dilthay1

.

.

, Dilthay
, .
,
Dilthay 2.

. , ,
. , ,
-
1
. Encyclopedie de la Pliade, 1991, , ,

...., , 222-229 Windelband, W.- Heimsoeth, H., 1991,
, , ...., , 195-261
, ., 1972, , , , 11
29
, , .
Collingwood,
.
,
, ,
3.
Max Weber,

4. , ,
, .

Husserl,
, 5. ,
,
.
,
. ,
, .
, , , .
, ,

. :
.
,
3
Collingwood, R., 1946, The Idea of History, 14, Walsh, W., 1985,
, ...., , 76
Randal Collins, Weber

Dilthay, , , ,

, (56). . Collins, R., 2002,
Max Weber, , , 49-73
Husserl . Chatelet, Fr. (ed.), 1985, , , , ,

313-349. ,
, Thompson, J-B., Action, Ideology and the Text: A Reformulation of
Ricoeurs Theory of Interpretation : Thompson, 1983, 173-203
30
. , , ,
.
,
. .
Husserl, ,
.
,
,
.
, ,
-

, , , ,
. , ,
6,
.
Alfred Schutz,
.
:
,
7.
,
.

.

,
- . Craib,
, ,
, , ..,
, . . Craib, 1998, 188
Schutz, 1964, Collected Papers, 2, The Hague, Nijhoff, 11,

, 1997, 44.
31
,
, .
, ,
,

. , ,
.
, , :
, ,
8.

. ,
,

.
,

(, 1997, 52-53).

- .
,
-,
.
Husserl (Ritzer,
1996, 286-288),
.
.

,
8
Ritzer, G., , 1996, 296
32
. Alexander Blumenstiel,
,
, , [] ,
,
,
.
,
9.

(cultural dope) , Garfinkel.
Garfinkel,
, , -
, .
, ,
,

.

-
. , ,
,
.
, , ,

(social order).

.
9
Blumenstiel, A., The Sociology of Good Times Psathas, G (ed.), 1973, Phenomenological
Sociology: Issues and Applications, Wiley, New York. Ritzer, 1996, 292.
33

,
. Schutz,
, .
,
.

. Garfinkel,
, . ,
. ,
.
Craib, [] . ,

.
.
,
,
. Schutz, ,
.
, , .
, ,
,
. ,
,
. ,
, ,
(Craib,
1998, 197-198).
, .
,
,
,
. ,
.. ,
34
, ,
. ,

,
,
,
,
.
, ,
,
, , 10.
,

.
.
, ,
,

.
, ,

10
Garfinkel
,
, (breaching experiments).
,
.

, .

. . Garfinkel, H., 1967, Studies in Ethnomethodology,
Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 47-49.
35
. ,
, .

. 11,

.
, .
, ,
. ,
.
,
.
- . ,
, .
, ,
. , ,
.

.
, ,
Watson
12, , ,

.
,
11

C. S. Peirce- : , ., 2002, , , :
, . :
, ., 2002, , , , , .
12
Mead,
,

.
, ,
.
36
,

.
, ,

. , ,
,
, Mead,
13.
,
- .
,
,
.
, , .
, ,
.

. 14
,
.
.
, ,

.

-
.
13
Ritzer, G., , , 1996, 243.
14

E. Goffman The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. .
, ., Goffman, E., 2001, , , , 9-58.
37

, H. Blumer,
:
.

,
, .

.
.
,
.
, ,
.
,
15.
Blumer -
, ,
,

. (Blumer, 1969, 18)16
15
Blumer, H., 1969, Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method, Prentice Hall, . Jersey, 9.
, 1997, 50.
16
, Blumer
,
. ,
, ,
, . ,
- , .
.

,
(87-89).
38
,
G. Ritzer (1996, 276-277) , :
1. , ,
.
2. .
3.

.
4.
.
5.

.
6.
,
,

.
7.
.

. ,

. ,
39

-.
, , ,

. ,
,
,
. ,
,

.
,
. , ,

.

, ,

, , .
, ,
. ..
,
,
,
,
.
.
,

.

40
.
-
, 17,

. ,
.

,
,

.
,
,
. ,
, ..
Howard Becker -
-18.

,

, Becker
. ,

.

. , ,

17
, .
18
Becker, H., 1952, Social-class variations in the teacher-pupil relationship, Journal of Educational
Sociology, 25, 451-465. : , 1997, 424-439.
41
- .
.
.
, , ,

-
. -

,
.
-.

19.
, ;

, ;

-
-.
, , ,
,
, 20.
19
P. Rock, ,
.

,
...

, , , ,
. . Craib, 1998, 172
20

,
. Sheldon Stryker
42
Aaron Cicourel . .
Stryker, S., 1980 Cicourel, A., 1974.
44

. , ,
.
. ,
,
80,
, .
, ,

1974, (discipline)
, ,
,
. , ,
,
.
1,
, 30,
70. [] ,
.
:

. ,
,
, , .

. 2
, ., : ,
.(.), 1997, , , , 137
, ., :
45

, .

,
, .
, 60
. 3,

. , , ,
,

,

4. ,
,
.

-
- ,
.
.
*****
: , 1997, 238
3
. -, ., 2004,
, 1959-2000,
, 39, 69-102. ,
. Bottomore, T., 1992, ,
, , 62, 29-32.
80
, ,

, :
.
46

- ,
1964-1967
1974, 19675.
6 - 1962-1963
- ,
: )
, ) ,
, ,
, )
(lites) (

) (

) ) , ,
,
,
(-, 1974, 15).
-

.

- Coleman,
Bourdieu-Passeron Basil Bernstein (-, 1974, 64-117)7.
Bourdieu-Passeron, ,
5
Lambiri-Dimaki, J., Les Chances d Accs a l Enseignement en Grce : Castell, R. et al. (ed.),
1967, Education, Development, et Democratie, Mouton, Paris, 107-116.
-, ., 1974, , ,
:
: .
47
, ,

8. Bourdieu, ,
9. , ,
,
.

.
, , Bourdieu

, ,
.
Bourdieu: []
,
(, , )
, ,
, , , , ,
[savoir-vivre]
. , ,
. , (Bourdieu-Passeron,
1996)10. , -
,
status
quo, (-,
1974, 76).
, ,
.
8
Bourdieu, P. Passeron, J.-Cl., 1996, , ,
. -, ., 1995, Pierre Bourdieu :

Pierre Bourdieu: , -, , 63-71
10
Bourdieu : Bourdieu, P., 2002,

: , , Bourdieu, P., 1999,
, , , 49-234.
(1974, 71) Les Hritiers, 41-42.
48

. , ,
,

.
.
,
,
.

.

11.
, ,

,
(-, 1983, 76).

.

.
:
.
, ,
11
-, ., : -
: -, ., 1983,
, , , 61-84.
49

-.
*****
-
.
,
,
.

60 70 .
,
,
, ,
. :
, , , ,

,
.
, ,
,
,
. ,
.
. ,
12.

,
12
, ., : , .,
1984, , , , 57
50

.
,

.
.

13 (, 1984, 59).

.

(, 1984, 43-45)14.

(, 1984, 87-110, 189-251) (
1976,
,
).
,
-
.

.
.
13
. . , .- ,
.- , ., 1999, , ,
, 13, 96-98
14
, ., .
2.1

52
4
,
, ,
.

, ,
,
.

,
1.
, ,
.
, ,

,
1922.
,
, ,
.
,
,
.
,
.
. , ,

,
2 , 1
, ., 1979, :
(1830-1922), , , .
, ,
53
-
. ,

.

.
,
,
. -
,
,
(, 1979, 269-371). , ,

(, 1979, 375),
19 . 20
.
,

,
,
, -
,
.

. , ,

1922.

.
54
-
- ,

, , 3.
,
,

[] ,
,

(, 1979, 381).

.
, ,

4.
,
,

3
.

,
[]
(,
1997, 145).

,
,
, ,
.
55
, .
, ,
,
[.]

(, 1979, 382).

,
, . , ,
,

.

[]
(,
1979, 385)5.

5

. ,
-

,

. , ,

,
.
56

. ,

(, 1979, 391-495)6.
,
, ,

-

.

,

,
7. :
,

8 (, 1979, 520-521),
6
Baudelot Establet
L Ecole Capitaliste en France, Maspero, Paris, 1972.
,
-
,
. 1910

,
. , 1926,

[] .
57
,

(, 1979, 518). , ,
,
,
, ,
[] , ,

,

9 (, 1979, 526). ,

,
. , ,
,

,
,
10 (, 1979, 516)
, ,
.

(509).
10
. , ,
[] ,
,
.

- ,
.
, ,
.
58
,
19 .
,
. -

,
-
,
. ,
,
,

.
,
: 11
,
.
,

.
,
,
, ,

[
]

11
,
; ; . 531,

,
.
59
,
(, 1979, 530). ,
,
.. ,
,
,

[],
, ( )
, [],
,
(,
1979, 540-541). ,
,

,

(, 1979, 542-543)12. , ,
Bourdieu-Passeron,

,

, ,
,

, ,
,
(, ) (Bourdieu-Passeron, 1970, 21-22).
12

,
.
60

19 .
,
, .

,
. , ,
, .
, , ,
(, 1979, 543).

,
(, 1979,
552-567).

13.

- ,

14. ,
13
,
, ,
[]
,
(553).
14

, ,
, ,

. , ,
,
,
,
61

,

.

, .

.
,

. ,

(, , )

.
,
.
,
,
(, 1979, 567).

.
*****

; .
.
. . Gramsci, A., 1965, In Search of the Educational Principle,
New Left Review, 32, 53-62
62
. ,
, ,

, .

, .

15,

16.

, ,
17. ,

,
. , ,

. ,

.
, . ,

,
. , ,
. ,
,
15
, ., , : , ., , 1981,
, , , 69-121
16
, ., 1980, , , , 74-166
17

, ,
(385),
(530).
63
, ,
.
, 1972,

, , , , 18.

,
,
19.
, , .
, ,
. ,
Trger (),
:
,
, ,
, (
), ,
.
, , ,
, , , ,
Trger, , ,
. ,
.
18
, ., 1983, , , , 43-49.
1966- :
, ., 2005, -, , 92, 85-97
19
- . , ., 1978, ,
, , 219-241,
,
, []
. ;
, ,
, , ,
: .
64
, , , , , ,-
(, 1983, 48).
, -

(, 2005, 90).
, ,

- . ,
,
.
.
,
. ..
.

20.
P. Sorokin, J. Goldthorpe R.
Turner (, 1979, 382-283). Ralph Turner,

,
,
,
. , Turner
,
,
.
, ,
19 .,
20
, . Edgell, S., 1993,

Class, Routledge, New York, 16-37 Saunders, P., 1990, Social Class and Stratification,
Routledge, New York, 68-85
65
Turner21. , ,
,
. . ,

:
. [
] ,

22.

, :
,

23. , ,
,
-
-, -,
24.
,

. ,

21
Turner, R., Modes of Social Ascent through Education: Sponsored and

Contest Mobility, in Halsey, A. Floud, J. Anderson, C. (ed.), 1961, Education, Economy and
Society: A Reader in the Sociology of Education, The Free Press, New York, 121-138
22
, ., :
, , , 1977, 15.
23
, ., , , , , , 1986,
147-169
24
, , ,

contradictory class locations, Erik Olin Wright
. (, 1986, 156).
66
,
. , , ,

(, 1979, 529).
, ,
. , ,
- -

.
, , , ,
.
.
,
,
. , , ,
,
.
.
. ,

. . ,
,
.
,
. , ,

.

.
-
67

25. ,
.
25
Bourdieu, P. Passeron, J., Cl.,

La Reproduction Les Hritiers, Castel, R. Passeron, J., Cl.,
Education, Development et Democratie, Baudelot, C., - Establet, R., LEcole Capitaliste
en France. : Coleman, J., The Concept of Equality of Educational Opportunity,
Boudon, R., L Ingalit des Chances Floud, J. Halsey, A Anderson, A., Education, Economy
and Society
.

.

.
-
. ,
801
.

- . ,
. ,

2.
: ,
, ,

(, 1977, 153)3.
1
, ., 1985, :
, ,
, ., 1977, , ,
, 155

-
.
1917, 1922,
,
(137).

69
,

20 . -
,
, . ,
, , ,
,
. ,
.
,

,
.

. , ,
.
(, 1979, 132)4. , ,
, ,
: , , 1922
-
, , 5.
,
1922 , ,
-
,
: , ., 1996, (1821-1985),
Gutenberg
4
, 1926,
.
,
, , ,
(122).
70
.
, [] ,
.

, .
,
(, 1977, 155).

,

,
.
,
.
[ ]
,
. .
: , ,
, ,
,
.
, ,
(,
1977, 101-103).
,
.
, ,
, ,

6. , ,
. :
, ., 1972, , ,
71
7 -
, ,
, ,
,
.
,
,
. ,
(1977, 107), , []
.
,
,
, , . ,
,
(, 1977, 94-95)8.
,
,
,
(, 1979, 95). ,
, ,
.

9, 1954
.

,
.
7
Bourdieu. . Bourdieu, P., 1972, Le Marche des Biens Symboliques,

L Anne Sociologique, P.U.F., Paris
, ,
Bourdieu Passeron, Bourdieu-Passeron, 1970,

, ., 1979, , ,
72

.
, ,
. ,
, , .
, ,
. : ,
, . , ,
,
, . ,
,
,
(, 1979, 109).

.
*****
.

. 10

, -
Basil Bernstein ,
Labov Halliday.

.
,
10
, ., 1987, :
, ,
73
, .
, ,
Emile Benveniste (, 1987, 17). , ,
,
. ,
,
.
,
. Benveniste ,

, !.
.

, ,
11,
. ,
,
. , ,

, ,
.
12

11
,
,
1973 , . , .
. .
12
, , 2001, : 1880-1980,
, , .
, , ,
, , .
.
, , 1981, 33-41 , 216-234
74
[]
.

-

.
, ,
.

.
-
, .
,
,
. ,

, ,
(,
1987, 189).

(, 2001, 154).
, ,

. , []
[]
,
, ,
, ,

(, 2001, 155),

75
. , , .
, ,

, , []
(
.). ,
,
,
,

(, 1987, 229).
, , ,
, .
*****
,
.
,
;13.
,

. ,

,
. ,

13
, .- , . (.), 1997, ; -
, ,
76
,
[]

,
(-, 1997, 152).

,
. ,

,

,
,
(-, 1997, 152). ,

,
.
, ,
,
(-, 1997, 160)
,
,
14. , ,
14
- ,
, ,
,
(197). ,
, , ,
: ,
,
- ,
77

, ,
.
*****

,
.
,

,
.
,
. []
,
, .
,
, . ,

,
. ,

(, 1985, 13). ,

15, .

. . , ., 1981, , , , 305.
: Apple, M., The Politics of Common Sense:
Why the Right is Winning in: Apple, M., 2000, Official Knowledge, Routledge, London, 15-41.
15

(14)
78

.
,

. , ,
, . ,
,
, ,
, - .

.
.
,
, [] ,
,

[] ,
, , ,
(,
1985, 28), , , []
,
, (30). ,
,
.

. , . ,
Merton,

16 ,

16
Connell, R., 1979, A Critique of the Althusserian Approach to Class, Theory and Society, 8/3, 337
79
, ,
,
.

. , ,

,
,
.

(, 1979, 156), []

[]

(, 1985, 157).
, ,

.
, ,
.
,
,
.
,
,

(gradational), ,

17. ,
17

Goldthorpe, J., 1987, Social Mobility and Class Structure in Modern Britain, Clarendon
80
(relational)
18. , , ,
, 19.

, ,
. , , ,
,

.

.

,
[, , ]

(, 1985, 91). , ,
Basil Bernstein,

,
. ,
,
. , ,
Press, Oxford, 40-43. ,
Goldthorpe, J., Class Mobility in Britain: Three theses examined in: Cosin, B. Hales, M., 1983,
Education, Policy and Society, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 60-82.
Boudon, R., Education, Social Mobility and Sociological Theory in:
Richardson, J., 1986, Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education,
Greenwood, New York, 260-274,
.
18
.
Wright, E., O., 1997, Class Counts, Cambridge Un. Press, Cambridge, 1-42,
Goldthorpe.
19
E. O. Wright
: .
(Wright, 1997, 8)
81

-

. ,

. , ,
, ..
; ,
.
, ..-
20.
.
, , .
,
,
.
*****
,
,

. ,

,
19 . , ,
.

,
20
,
, (188).
82

(, 1985, 36).
,
, ,

(, 1985, 160, 177).

.

,
,
. ,
.

.

. S. Bowles,

, [],

,
,
(, 1985, 161). ,
V. Isambert-Jamati,

,
(, 1985, 177).
Jencks,

,
,
83
,
(, 1985, 56)21.

, 22. ,
,
,
. . ,
, Jamati .

- []
:
.

. ,
,
. ,

(, 1985, 502,
). , , Jamati
,
.
Jamati

-
. , ,
21
J. Karabel A. Halsey
Power and Ideology in Education, Oxford Un. Press, Oxford, 1977
22
[] .
.

.

(101).
84
. , ,

,

.
, ,
, .
,
.

.
, ,

.
, .
.

. ,

. ,
,
(, 1985, 215),

, ,
(, 1985, 210)
.
; ;
.
, ,

(210). , ,

85
,

.

(215)! , ,
,
.
23
. ,
, ,
,

,

. , ,

. :
,
,
.
Bourdieu,
,
(, 2004, 54). ,
,
, .

.
B. Bernstein.

23
, ., 2004, ,
, 39, , 47-68
86
, ,

.
, ,
,
, ,

. ,
Bourdieu.
,
, , -
,
.
,
.
.
, , .
, ,
,
24.
Bernstein
.
,
, ,
(, 2004, 64).
, , . ,
.
,

24
,
. Perrenoud, Ph., 2002,
; , 63, 27-35
87
.
.
. ,

,

, ,
(, 2004, 64);

.
- -

25.
.
*****

.

,
, .

.
. ,
,
25
: [] ,

.
;
88
, ,
. , , , , ,

,
, ,
(, 1985, 171). , ,

, -
,
.
.
, ,
, ,

.
, .
, , . ,
. , ..,
, .
, .
, , ,
, ,
. Ernesto Laclau:

-

.
; - []

89
,
;26

.

.
, .

.
,
.
, .
, ,
.27 , ,

, , ,
.

,
,
26
Laclau, E., 1983, , , ,

115-116. Laclau
. , ., 2001, :
, , 18, 42-48.
27
, ,

, ,
. , .
-
Rachel Sharp, []
, , ,
,
,
(Sharp, R., 1990,
, , , 7, 38).
90

.28

.
.
. ,

, -
,

.
28

Cynthia Cockburn, 1997,
The Local State, Pluto Press, London
6

. ,
, , , .

, ,

,

,
70 ,

1. , ,

.
,
, ,
,
.
, ,

. ,

.
.
, ,
1
, ., 1985, :
, , 119, 45
92
,
- (, 1985, 46).

.
, ,
.
, , .
, 60 2,
. ,
.
,
,
.

.

,

3.

,
,

.
, ,
. . Levine, A., 2003, A Future for Marxism,
Pluto Press, London
, ., 1990 , , , , 132-133.
. ,
1989
93
1.

.
2.
.
3.

.
4.
- .
5. -
, .
6.
.
7. ,

,
,

.
(, 1990, 131-132)4
.

.
,

5 (, 1990, 132).
4
,
, , , 1981, 21-44
321-349
, , 1989
, 1985
.
94
, ,

.

,
.
*****

,
(1931-1973)6.

, ,
,

. ,

, ,

, ,

(, 1979, 41).
M.F.D. Young
. ,

,
- Young
, ., 1979, (1931-1973),
,
95

(, 1979, 34)7 .
, ,
,
, ,

(, 1979, 19). .
, Baudelot
Establet,
( )
8 ,
La Reproduction Bourdieu Passeron,

,
(, 1979, 18 BourdieuPasseron, 1977).
,

,
,
[ ],
,
,
,
(, 1979, 18)9.
Young, M.F.D. (ed) , 1971, Knowledge and Control,

Collier Macmillan, London, 33
8
9
BaudelotEstablet, 1972, 15, 21.

, . , -

.
(41). ,

96

.
.
, ,

.

.
*****

,
, .. Bourdieu
. ,

Bourdieu (, 1990, 124)10,
, (, 1990, 132).

,
,
, . , ,
(. )
.
(41).
10
Bourdieu .
: Carnoy, M., 1988, , ,
, 40, 25-27 [] [ Bourdieu-Passeron]
( )
() ()
.
, (25).
97
. ,
,

-
,
, ,
.
, ,
, . ,
, . ,
.
- ,
. , , ,
, Raymond Williams
, (, 1979,
27-28). , ,
. ,
- ,
,
(!) - .
,
,
,
,
(, 1979, 28-29).

. , , ,
,
.

- -
, ,
,
.
98
(
) . ,
, ,
,

. , ,
,

.
,
, 11.
*****
, ,

Basil Bernstein, M.F.D. Young. ,
,

(Blackledge-Hunt,
1995, 385)12. ,
, -
, , .
, - ,
.

,
11
: Abercrombie, N.Hill, S. -Turner, B.S., 1980, The Dominant Ideology Thesis, Allen and Unwin, London.
. Eagleton, 1992, 35-36
12
,
.
.
99
(Blackledge-Hunt, 1995, 386).
M.F.D. Young ,
,

(Young,
1971, 32).
, ,

, .

. , ,
. ,
-

. :

,
,
,
(, 1987, 76-77).
,
,
Karl Mannheim13 (Young, 1971, 3).
, ,
-
.
Mannheim
.
,
,
13
Young,
.
100
14.

.
Mannheim,
15.
, ,

,
.
Mannheim ,
, . , ,
,

:
. , ,
.

, ,
.
, ,

.

, , ,
, [ ]
14
Mannheim . McLellan, D., 1995, Ideology, Open

Un. Press, 35-43. Mannheim
. Whitty, G., Vultures and Third Ways: Recovering Mannheim s Legacy for Today in:
Demaine, J., 2001, Sociology of Education Today, Palgrave, New York, 206-222.
15
Mannheim, K., Ideology and Utopia, Eagleton, T., 1992, 108 (

: , ,
101
16. , Mannheim
,
, .

. , ,
.
, , Eagleton
,
,
(Eagleton, 1992, 109).
, ,

.
,

,
.
*****

. ,

,

,

.
.
,
16
Abercrombie, N. at al, 1983, Determinacy and Indeterminacy in the Theory of Ideology, New Left
Review, 142, 43
102
,
. ,

.

. , ,
.

.
[]
(,
1979, 300).

, ,
.

(),

(, 1979, 301).

. . ,
, ,

. , ..
103

.
.

.
, 1929,
. ,

,

. , ,
,
,
:

(, 1979, 233)17. ,

,

. ,
,
1929.
, 1964,
.
,
...,
,

17
. : , ., 1990, , , ,
108-284
104
,[]

(, 1979, 273).

,
, 1963 . ,
,

.

. , 1965,

, ,

[]

,

(, 1979, 283),
.

18.
,
.

. ..
18
, ., 1976, , ,
105
20 .,

,
19
.

60 ,
.
, ,
(, 1979, 272).

.
, ,
,
,

.

.
*****

,
,
.

. , ,

19
. , ., 1988, :
, , , 61-83, 315-324
106
,

.
(, 1979, 215-297) ,

,
. , , ,
,
.

. ,
,
, 20.
,

.
*****

.

-

20
,
60 : , ., 1981,
, , , 19-44
107
, , ,
:
.
, ,
.

(, 1979, 190-213). ,
(190),
(192).
, ,

(197),
(198, 199),
. ,

,

(201)
. ,

[]
(202).

(204). ,
,

(205).
[]
(ordre) []

108
[ ]
(206).
[]
, ,

(ordre).
.

.
,
,

(207).

(209).

(210).

,

.

.

(, 1979, 42)21.
, ,

21
,
, , .
109

.
. ,
, .
, ,
, ,
.
.
.

- ,

.

. , ,

(, 1979, 201) , ,

, .

22. ,

.
, -
. , ,
,
,
.
: ,
.
, ,
22
Althusser, L., Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses, in Zizek, 1994, 123
110
23.

.

, ,
, obsession,
.
.
, ,

.

. []
,
,

(
( )
(
) ,
[]

24. ,
.
23
Sarup, M., 1993, An Introductory Guide in Poststructuralism and Postmodernism, Georgia

University Press, Athens Georgia, 5-31
24
, ., 2005, , ,
111
*****

.

,

.
, , ,

.
,
-

, 25,
, ,
26.

,
74, 34-35
25
, , ,
.
26
.
. , ., 1990, , , , ,
, 2003.
112
,
.
, ,

.

80
,
, 27:

.

.
,
,
,
.

(, 1986, 61).

.
. . ,
[]
, ,
.

, ,
,

(, 1990, 71).
27

: , ., 1986, , ,
.
113
.

(, 1990, 70)28.

. ,
,

- ,
,
(, 1990, 134-142)29, , ,
.
, 30,
19 . ,

. ,

[ ]
, ...
28
, -
: ,
,
. (59)
29
,
, , 2/1989, 28-30, .
, , : Wood, G., 1992,
, , 19, 36-38.
: Wood, G., Democracy and the Curriculum in: Beyer, L. Apple, M., 1998, The
Curriculum: Problems, Politics and Possibilities, State Un. of New York Press, New York, 177198. O , ,
Dave Hill : Hill, D., 1998, Postmodernism and Education: A Structuralist NeoMarxist Critique in: Birmingham University Social Justice Research Seminar, 24 March,
29-33.
30
, ., 2004, , , , 162-167
114
(,
2004, 162-163).

.

(, 2005, 36).
*****
, ,

.
1566/85

- ,
:
: )
:
, )
:
, )
: , ,

31 (, 1986, 79-80).

,
31

, .
115
,

. , ,
.
.

-
. ,
,
Baudelot-Establet
,
- , .
(, 1981, 321-335), ,
,

.
,
, -
, , -
.
, ,
.
,
, ,
- ,
,
,
, ,

(, 1981, 327).
,

,
116
[] -
, ,
( ),
32
(, 1981, 328).
, , ,
,
.
, . ,
,
, ,
(
)[ ]
, -
( ),
(, 1981, 329).

.
, . , ,
,
, .
, ,
, .
-
. ,
. , ,
,
32
-

,

(Power, S., Missing: A Sociology of Educating the
Middle Class in: Demaine, J., 2001, 196-205, 205). ., : Ball, St. Vincent, C.,
New Class Relations in Education: The Strategies of the Fearful Middle Classes, 180-195.
117
33.
,

, ,
, ,

(, 1981, 332).
- -

. , ,

,
,

, /
(, 1981, 332). , ..

-
.
:

.
, []
[]
, []
, ,

(, 1981, 333).

,
. , ,
33
, ,
.
118
,
,
.
, ,
34. ,

. , ,
.

. , -
, -
.
,

-,
. , ,
,

,
,
. ,

. ,
.
,

()
[sic]-

34
,
.
119
, ,
35.
35
, ., 2004, 165-166. . Berube,

M., 2004, Teachers as Reds in: Berube, M., 2004 Radical Reformers: The Influence of the Left in
American Education, Information Age Publishing Inc., Greenwich, Connecticut, 13-26.
7

.
.
,
. , ,

.
.

, ,
. , ,
1

.
, , .

.
,
,
(,
1981, 9). ,
,
1
, ., 1981, : , , ,
. , ., 1988 , , 40,
43-48, , ., 1993,
, , 71, 31-33
121
, ,
.
.
,
, , .
,
, .

.
, , (, 1981,
178-180).
2 ,

[]
.
,
. ,
.

.
,
,
.
.
:
.
,
-. ,
, .

, ,
.
122

2.
,

.

.
Schultz
Coleman. , ,
.
.
*****

,
. 3:
1. .
-
2
,

. ..
: .

:
.
, , ,
. . , 1990, 105-107
, 1981, 19-27.
123

, , ,
.
2.
.
-
. .

.
3. .
, ,
. , ,
, .
- .

.
4. .

.
.
4. , ,

,
.
, ,
. , , ,
.
124
,
. , ,
,
.
, ,

(, 1981, 27).
,

. ,
,
,
,
, .

,
5.
, ,
. ,

.
,
,
,

,
.
,
5
, ,

. . , ., 2002,
, , 124, 41-45
125

, :
- ,

, ,

, (, 1981, 3031).
, , , ,
,

. , , ,
-
.
, ,
,
, .

. ,
, ,
.

. , ,
,
6.
,
, .
6
, ,
. , []
, ,
(36).
126

.
, ,
(, 1981, 37).
, ,
.

. , ,
. ,
,
, , ,
,

. , ,
, , , ,
.
,
,

(, 1981, 55).
,
7

.
, ,
, -
,

. ,
127

, ,

.
,
.

,

.
, ,
,
.

() (, 1981, 77).

, ,
. ,

13-14 (
),

- ,
,

[]
.
. , ., 1994, , , 44, 43
128

()
() (, 1981, 72).
,

, , ,
-
, ,
,
.

.
, ,
.

, ,

,
.

,
8.

9. ,
8
. , ., 1990, , , : ,
, 55, 71-77.
:

. ,
, .
, , , ,
129
,

. ,
:
,

,

,
.

,

.
. ,
],
[
] []
,
,
(, 1981, 89)10. ,
,

, ,
.
. -

.
, , ,
. (, 1981, 93)
10
.
, .- , .- , ., 2005, ,
, , 133-140.
130

(, 1981, 96)11.
, ,
.
,
, ,
, ,
.

.
-
. , ,

,
12 .

,
11

: , .,
: , ., 1994,
, , , 87-130.

, (110-112)

(104-107)
.
. , ., 1990,
, , , 13-78. : , ., 1990,
, Gutenberg, , 93-104.
12
., , .,
2003, Ivan Illich , , 128, 55-59.
, ., 1993, , , 69,
76-80 , ., 1994, , , 74,
47-55
131
. ,
[]
, ,
,[]

[ ]

,
,
(, 1981, 146-147). , ,

,

(, 1981, 164-172). ,

,

, -

,
,
,

(, 1981, 131).

.

, ,
. , ,
,
132
,
.
,
,

.
-,

(, 1981, 186).
*****

.
- ,

.

.
,
. ,
,
. ,
.
, ,
.
, , ( )

(, 1981, 56),
.
, ,
133
,
, ,
, .

.
,
. , ,

(, 1981, 9) ,

.
, , ,
, . ,

.
, ,

,
. , ,

.

.
.
, , .
,

,
.
, ,

134
- .
. , ,
.

.
, , ,
,

.
- , ,

:
-
, . ,
, , .

-

. ,

.

. ,
, ,

.

-
,
.

. ,
135
, ,
,
, ; ,

,

13. ,

,
.

.
14,
,
, .
Simon Clarke, []
, (. ., 101).
Clarke, ,

13
. Laclau, ., 1983, , ,
, 105-127 .
: Apple, M., 2002, ,
,
14
,

. ,
,
(, , 1978),
, :
Laclau, 1983, 59-91
Jessop, B., : ,
2001, : , , ,
87-123
Clarke, S., Marxism, Sociology and Poulantzas s Theory of the State in: Clarke, S.(ed.), 1991,
The State Debate, McMillan, London, 70-108
136
.

,
. ,
,
15, ,
, , .
, , ,
, .
,
, ,

(, 1981, 23),
. ,
, , ,

,
,
.
15
(1968)
, , (1978) .

.
8

.

.
,
,
.

(1960-1994)1. ,

,

.
, , ,

,
(-, 1994, 13). ,
, .

. , ,
, :
,
1
, ., - , . ., 1994,
,(1960-1994), Gutenberg,
138
.
, ,

,

. , ,

- 2. .
, , -
. , ,

, ,

,
, ,

(-, 1994, 22).

.

.
2
, ,
,
. Philip Wexler
-, , ,
,
.[ ]
discursive blockage[ ]
, , ,
. , [ ]
...
. [ ]. . Wexler, 1987,
x-xi, 10
139
. ,
.
,

.
.

, .

. ,
(-, 1994, 62)
, ,
3.

. ,
.

. , ,
,
- .

,
. , ,
, ,

3

-.
. .
, , ., 1981, ,
,
140
. ..

, (-,
1994, 57): ,
.
4. , ,
,
,
, .
:
( )

(, 1994, 58).

, ,
, ,
, .

5
. ,
.
, ,
4

.
: , ., .,
2004, - 2004,
. , (. 178-247)
, ., 1981, ,
, ,
141
,

.
,
,
.
.
..

. ,
langue Saussure,

, . , ,
, ,
.
, .
, 6.

.
, ,
.
, ,
[]
. ,
. ,

:
,
. ,
, []

6
. : ,
1978, 161-218
142
( ),
7.
,
.

,

8.

, ,
(-, 1996, 14).

(150-163).
- -

.

-

(-, 1996, 151, 152, 155). ,

,
.

( --)
,
, ., 2004, , , , 44-45
, . , . ., 1996, 2000, Gutenberg,
143
[]
, ,
, .

(-, 1996, 160).

-

.

,
.
,
, .

,
9.
9
1996, 163. , ,

. , :

,
, --
.
, ,
,
,
( ).
(, , ) , , ,
(, . , . . (.),
: , ; , , 2002, 166).
. ,
,
, .
144
;
.
, ,
.
.
,
.
-
.
, , -:

. , ,
. , ,
,
, ,
. ,
.

.
, ,

10. ,
,
, ,

,

.
.
10
, . , . ., 1998, , Gutenberg,
, 19
145
. ,
,
. ,
.
.
*****
, -
.

,

(-, 1998, 72).
- ,
,

.

. ,

.
(-, 1998, 72-74)11

( ,
) (
).
11
[ ]
[ ]
, . , ,

146
,
12. , . ,
- -
(-, 1998, 72).
- ,
.

, .

[]
( ),

(-, 1998, 72).
,

, .

-

. , ,

.
,
. ,
. ,
12

,
.
147

(-, 1998, 72)
.
,
,
,

[] ,
,
,
(-,
1998, 73)
. ,
, . ,

-
,
, ,
.
, , .
..
,

.

. , , ,

.
, ,

, .
148
,

, , , .
:
,

( ), .
.

.

(-,
1998, 54). , , , ;
, , ,
, ;

. ,

13. ,
,
:

. ,
, ,
. .
13

-
- -
, .

.
149
*****

14. - -

. . ., ,

,
, 50 60.
,

,
, ,
(, 1999, 11-12).
-,

. ,

15 (, 1999, 12).
14
, ., 1999, , :
, ,
15

.
, , , ,
.

: Wright, El. Wright, Ed., 1999, The Zizek
Reader, Basil Blackwell, Oxford, 1999, 53-101, : Zizek, S., Kafka, Critic of Althusser
In: Zizek, S. (ed.), 1994, 321-327.
.
: , . ., 1983, , , , 17-54
150
,
,
-

(;
..) (, 1999,
15). , , : .
. , ,
, ,
, :
, , :
. , :
,
, , ,
, , ,
:
16 (, 1999, 11).
,

.
, , , .

,
,

, ., , , ., 1998,
, , , 121-128
16
, , :
, .
,
, ,
(16).
151
(, 1999, 41).
,
. ,
,

17.

..,
[],
-
(, 1999, 152). , ,
. , ,
, ,
, 18. , ,

. ,
, ,
,
, ,
, ,
,
, 19 (, 1999, 156). ,
17
, ,
, , ,
. :
.

(68).
.
18

[]
(156).
19
, ,
152
4 .,
.
,
,
. ,
, ,
. ,

, . , ,
.
.
, , . ,
,
- , ,
. ,
20.

. , ..,
-
[], ,

[]
,
,
(, 1999, 160). , ,
, []
,
,
,
, ,
.
20
Zizek, S., Marx, Freud: The Analysis of Form in Zizek, S. (ed.), 1994, 296, 300,
the true secret [is] not the secret behind the form but the secret of this form itself.
153
,
[] ,
[ ]
(, 1999, 160-161).

, , .

-

.

, ,
.

,
.
.
-
. ,
,
.

,
- -
.

, ,
.
154

. ,
,
, , ,
, -
, ,
(, 1999, 167). ,
, , ,
.

. , , , ,
, .
,
. ,
(, 1999, 173).

.
.
.
, ,
21.
22. . ,
21
, ,
,
, (!)
.
, ,
.
22
:
, ,
, [ ] , .
, ,
(179). .
, , ,
155

. ,
, .
:
, ,

. ,
,

.

,
, 23.
.
,
.

.
,

. , ,
, ,
,
(171), , ,
, ,
. , ,
. .
.

.
.
23
, . , ., 2005, , Gutenberg,
156
.
,

, .
, ,
(, 2005, 18-26).

,
,
[]
,
,
. ,

: ,
,

, ,
(-, 2005, 32).
,
.
-
.
, ,
,
. ,
.
.

.
, ,

.
157
, , ,
,
.
24, .

.
24
, , . ,
,
[] (
)
(137).

.
9

.
,
.
, , ,
, .
,
, . .
, , 1.
, ,

.
,
.
2.

()
( )
. , ,
, , ,
sine qua non
. ,

1
, ., 2004, , ,
, ., :
: , , . ., 2002, 54. :
, ., 2000, , ,
113, 47-56 114, 41-52
159
-
,
,

, .

,
, , 3 (, 2002, 55-56).

, ,

, ,
.

,
4.
,

(, 2002, 56). .
[]
[]
,
[]
. ,
, ,
,
.

-
. , ., 2001, - , , 45, 10-13
( , ).

. ..,
.
160
.

, .
,
. ,
, :
( )
( , )
(
)

[ ]

,
: (, 2002, 60).
,
, 5
(-), , ,
.
6
, .
,
7,
, ,

()
(62)

-, Verstand Vernunft,
-, , ,
. . 2002, 61-67
, ., 2002, , , :
, , 123, 65-80
161
.
, ,
,
. ,
, ,

-
, . ,

, 8
.

,
, . [
] ,
, ,

(, 2002, 86).
,
.

,

. -
8

, . , []

, -
, ,
, , (2002,
72-73). , []

, ,
,
, 124 / 2002, 86.
162
, . , ,
. ,

(
)

.
, ,
(
) ,
.
( ) ,
,
. (

)
( )

.
,
. ,
() () ,
,
( )
,

(, 2002, 86-87).

. ,
, ,

,
163

.
,
,

.

,

. , ,

.

.
.
,

.
,
, .
,
,

.

. . .
,
,
. , ,
,
. , ,
.
,
. ,
164

.
,
, .

.

.
, , []

. , , ,

.
.

.

,

, ,
.
.

.

, , , -

. , ,
- ,

165
. , ,

9. , ,

: .

.
.
,

[] , ,
( )
(, 2002, 87).
.
,
..

, ...
9
.
,
.
- -
. , ,
,
[] ,
,
, ,
, . (, 1990, 125).
.
.
(, 1990
1994).
166
,
(, 1981, 30-31). , ,

.

.
.

.

- ,
,

, ,
.
.

- -

,

10.

.
, ,
,
.
10

. : , ., 1978, 18
, , , , 1992
167
. , ,
. ,

,
.
, , .

, ,
11. , ,
.
,

-
-.
,
. ,
,

,
. ,

, ,

,
.
.
, ,
, ,
, ,
-
.
11
- ,
: .
168

, , .
,
.

.
, , ,
, , , .
, ,

.
,

12.
*****

.
,
13.
,

-
12
, ,
. , ,
.
, , ,
.
13
, ., 2003,
, , 129, 91-106
169
(, 93).
.
-
(agents)
(acteurs),
(102). , Willis
Apple,
,
, ,
[]

(97). , ,
-

. ,
[] -

(, 2003, 98).

. ,
,
,
, .
,
,
.

, .
170
,

, .
, []
, ,
:
,
,
, .
,
. ,
,
. , ,

. , ,

.

,
.

.

.
. ,

- -
,
, .

171
14.

.
, ,

.

,
- .
- -
.

. , ,
.
(, 2003, 95)
, .

.
.
, ,
,
, , ...,

, , ... (, 2003, 95).
, ,
. ,

14
, ,
.
172
, ,

,
.
. , , ,
,

.
, , ,
- ,
.
*****
, , ,
15.

, , ,
- -
(65).
. , ,
,
, 16. , -
,
[] .
, , ,
[]
,
, (66).
15
, ., 2004, ,
, 41, 65-88.
16
, ., 1981, 98.
173
, ,
, .

.
. ,

. ,
-
. ,
. ,
,
. ,
(, 2004, 86),
.
.
[]
,

[][]
, , , ,

,
(, 2004, 86).

:
, ,
.
,
.
.
.
,
.
174
,
. ,
,

, .
- -
. , ,
,
. , ,

. , ,
. , ,

;
, , ,

, ,
. , ,
. , ,

.

.
, ,
-
,

.
- .
, 17
17
2004, 72.
. 67-72 ,
, , , -,
175
(
).

, , ,
( )
, ,

18. ,
. ,
.
. .

.
,
.
,
, . ,

.
.

,
,
, .
18
, , M. Apple
(, , 1986, 20),
R. Williams: ,
,
,

.
176
,

-
(, 2004, 81).

,
:
,
.
, ,
. , , :

. , ,
, (, 2004, 81).

. , ,
.
, , ;
,

. ,
-
.

,
: , , ,
19.

19
2004, 73. : [ ]

.
177
,
. , []
( - )
,

(, 2004, 73).

.

.

. ,

. , ,
(lived experience) .
, , , (naive)
.
( ,
, ,
) , ,
(, 2004, 75). ,
,

, , ,
.

. ,

,
; ;
; 20
20
178
, , ,
, ;
. , ,
.

.

.
Paul Willis,

Birmingham21.
, , , ,
.

.
.
,
.
,
, , ,
.
, ,
, .
, ,
,
, , ,
.
21
Willis, P., 1977, Learning to Labour, Farnborough, Saxon House. ,

, .
, A. Giddens The
Constitution of Society, Polity Press, Oxford, 1984, 289-309.
Giddens : , 1997,
509-533. Willis :
Blackledge -Hunt, 1995, 245-250 , ., 2001, 267-270.
179
-, ,
,
.
-
, .
,

-
.
,

.
Willis
.
,
,
. , ,
.
,
, ,
. , [] ,
,
,
. , ,
, (
)
(,
2004, 77). , , Willis
,
- ,
.
180
.
,
Willis. , ,
Willis. .
,

: []
,
, .
,
.
,

.
-
. [
]
[]
[], ,

22. Willis
,
,
.
, -
Willis. ,
, ,

.
22
Willis, P., The Class Significance of School Counter-Culture in Hammersley, M. -Woods, P. (ed.),
1976, The Process of Schooling, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 189, :
Blackledge, D. - Hunt, B., 1995, 248
181

,
, . , ,
-,
, ;
23. ,

. , ,
,
,

.

.
Willis , , Giddens
, ,
, -

. Giddens, ,
[]
(Giddens, 1997, 513). , ,

. (1997, 6465),

23
Giddens ,

-
. , Willis
[ ] []
,
(Giddens, 1997, 512-513).
182

, ,
- ,

,
. [] ,
, .

, ,
,

,
.

. , , ,

, ,
. ,
, .
-

,
24. , ,
:

. Willis ,
, .

24

, .
-
. ;
183
.
. ,
.

, ,
, .
,

25.

.
.

26,
-
. ,

. , []
,
,

(- - , 2005, 139). ,
,

,
.
,

.
25
, ., 1978, , , , 86
26
, ., 1976, , , , 187
184

,

. ,
,
,
. , ,
- , ,

,
.., , .

,
.
,

( .., 2005, 143). ,
,
,
.

- 27; , ,

- ; , ,
,
,
:
, 28,
27
: ;
; .
28
, ,
. an- sich fr-sich , , an und fr sich.
-, , . .,
, Eagleton, 2002, 98-104.
185

. , , .
. , []

[ ]

, (, 2004, 79). , ,

,
. []
-
,

(,
2004, 80). , ,
. , ,
.
,
.
.
, ,
, , .
, , ,

.
( )
(, 2004, 81).
.
, ,
(
, ,
) (, 2004, 82).

186
.

, . ..

;
;
.. ;
,
;
2.2

188
10

. , ,
1
. ,

-
,
-

(, 2002, 117).
, ,

.

,
,
. ,
,
.

.
,
,

,
(, 2002, 122).
,
.
,
1
, ., 2002, , ,
189
, ,
. ,

,
,
(, 2002, 124).

. ,
,
,
,
(, 2002, 188).
.
,

. - .

, . , ,

, []
, ,
,
, (, 2002, 236)
, ,
, ,
,
,

,
190
. ,

,
,
.
, []
,
, ,

.

.
.
,
(, 2002, 196).
,
.
.
, ,
. , []

, - .

,
, ,
, , , . ,

,
(,
2002, 288).
191

-
. , Parsons,

20 (, 2002, 573),
, 60 ,
, .
.
,
.
,
.
.
Parsons

1964

(, 2002, 574),
.
, Parsons
, ,
.
, , . [] ,
,
. Parsons

, .
Parsons
(, 2002, 575). , ,

.

.
192

.

Talcott Parsons (, 2002, 573-634) ,

Habermas. ,
,
.
, , ,
. ,

- -. , ,
,
.

.
, , ,
, .

- .

.
,

(, 2002, 597).
,
.
,
- -
- .

Parsons .
193
(integrated). , ,
,
. , Parsons2,

,
.
,
.
, ,
(, 2002, 624-625).
,
.
, ,

,
, Hegel
(Schlachtbank der Vlker),
, ,

(, 2002, 626).

, evolutionary universals, .
[] Parsons
,
(enhancement of adaptive capacity)
, ,
. ,

.

2
: Parsons, T. Shils, E. (ed.), Toward a General Theory of Action,

New York, 1951
194
(structural differentiation)
(, 2002, 631).

,
, ,
-
, ,

- .
,

(, 2002, 644).
*****

- ,
.
- ,
,
.
, ,
,
.

, ,
,

. , , ,
,
195
3. -
- ,
,
, ,
1960 1970.
, ,
,
. , ,
,

, Bhm Bawerk,
von Bortkiewicz, Paul Samuelson 4.

,
.
.
Arbeitswerttheorie
(, 2002, 492)
3
, [] [
]
.
, ,
, , ,
. , , ,

,

.
,
(18).
: Sweezy, P., xx,

, Gutenberg, , 119-154. : Itoh, M.,
1988, The Basic Theory of Capitalism, McMillan, London, 149-198.
. , ., 1986, ,
, , 7-110.
196

.
,

. Weber
, , .

. , ,
-
,
. , , ,
(, 2002, 496).

,
, ,
.
, ,
. , . -
-

, ,
! Mehrarbeit
(, 2002, 497)
Mehrwertrate
(, 2002, 498)

. ,
,
,
.
, ,
.
197

(Gesetz des tendenziellen Falls der Profitrate) [
, . .] , ,
(, 2002, 502).

, ,
,
.
,

5 . , ,
,
,
. , ,
.

Bernstein,
.
Bernstein
. , ,
. ,
. , ,
, 6 (, 2002, 507-518) .

,
, . Bernstein

- -
5
. , ., 1976, , , , , 620-663.
: Clarke, S., 1994, Marxs Theory of Crisis, St Martins Press, New York,
208-286
: Tudor, H Tudor,
J., 1988, Marxism and Social Democracy: The Revisionist Debate 1896-1898, Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge
198
1929, .
, , ,

,
de facto

. ,

.

, , ,

. ,

7.

, , ,

.

,
.
, ,
. ,
. :

, ,
.
. , ., 1978, , , , , .
.
199
, ...

(, 2002, 493). , , . ,
, - ,
8. , ,
.
,
,
9.

.
, ,
:
.
. , ,
.
.
.

, quarks10.
(, ., 1982, ,
, ) 1300 .
, , , .
,
,
.
, ,
; ,
- ; , ,
,
,
. . , Varian, H., 1992, , , , 54-158
10
. , ., 1991, , , , 3-34
Close, F., The quark structure of matter in: Davies, P., 1988, The New Physics, Cambridge U. P.,
Cambridge, 396-424
200

, ,
quarks. quarks, , ,
, standard
model ,
- .
ad
hoc .
.
, ,
. ,

- -

(, 2002, 28),

, , theory
laden. ,
:

, .
,

, ,
,
(, 2002, 28-29). , ,
.
, ,

,
[] ,
201
,
(, 2002, 560).
, , Parsons

1964. Parsons
Evolutionary Universals in Society:
:

.

(, 2002, 630).
,
. ,

.

.
.

- ,
11, Karl Kautsky
192012. , ,

Parsons.
,
. ,

11
, ., 1984, , , , 191-243
12
. Salvadori, M., 1990, Karl Kautsky and the Socialist Revolution: 1880-1938, Verso, London,
251-318
202
. ,
13. , ,
,
, ,

.

.
: , ,
, , ,
,
,

-
,

,

,
.

, , ,
. ,
1928

14.
, , ,
-
13
, 2002,250.
,
324-326.
14
, 2002, 76, 238-241, 271-272, 364, 370, 372, 538
203
, , ,
,
,
,
,
, ,
, , ,
, , (, 2002, 370).
, , , etc,

(, 2002, 364).

, ,

.
, ,
.
15.
,
!
,
19 . :
, (
, ..),
,
.

15
2002, 552, :
,

, .
204
16. , ,
.
*****
,
,
.

,

-.

17. : -

, ,
,
.
,

(, 2002,
33).
- , -18

.
, ,
. ,
16
2002, 403. : Downs, A., An Economic Theory

of Democracy ( , , , 2002)
17
,
-
! (291).
18
- P. Bourdieu,
M. Apple, A. , X. , . , . .
205

,
. ,

,
19. ,

- .
,
.
,
.
: []

,

. ,

.
. ,
, .

.
(,
2002, 456) . , ,

. ,
,
.
19
. : , , 1986, , ,
, ., 1988, , , .
206
, , . , ,

.
, (= )
(=
). (
) (
), (=
)
(= ). , []
,
,
,
20.
. ,
. , ,

-
,
. ,
. .
,
. , , , ,
, ,
.
,
,

.
20
2002, 34. , , ,
.
207

21.
, ,
.

. , ,
.
( )
, .

. .

.
- ,
, . , ,
,
, . ,
,
, , [] ,
,
(, 2002, 517).
21
,
, ,
. ,
.
. ,

. (80).
, ,
!
208

;
*****

.
22
-
,
.
,
, :

. , .

,
. ,
. ,
,

23.
,
, ,
.
[]
, ,
:
22
. , 8 , ,
, 2000.
23
, ., 2001, : :
, , , 116-117
209
(, 2001, 125).
, ,
,
.

.

,

. ,
,

(, 2001, 145-146).

.
, ,
.

,
, .
[ :]

, , ,

(,
2001, 21-22).
210
,
, , ,

,
.

Bourdieu, Bernstein, .
, , .
,
, ,
.

24.
, ,
, .
.
24
, ., , :
, . , ., 1995, :
, , , 84-120. : , 81-113
11

, ,
1, []

,

.

(, 19872)
3 (1987),
, ,
.

, ,
, ..
.
.

, , ,
.

. , ,
. 19714,
1
, ., :
, : , .,1997, ,
,
, ., 1987,
, ,
, .,1987, : , ,
Bowles, S., Growth Effects of Changes in Labor Quality and Quantity, Greece: 1951-1961, in: H. B.
Chenery (ed.), 1971, Studies in Development Planning, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
212
Samuel Bowles,

,
3%. ,
, Harvey Leibenstein5, -
7,2% 14% , ,
, 6.3% 13.7%.
. ,
, .
, ,
,
90,
. .
6,
, corpus
. , ,
. Human Capital Theory7,
,

, .

.

Leibenstein, H., 1967, Rates of Return to Education in Greece, Center for International Affairs,
Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass.
, ., 1999, , ,
Schultz, T.W., 1961, Investment in Human Capital, American Economic Review, 51, May, 1-17,
Becker, G. S., 1964, Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis with special Reference in
Education, University of Chicago Press, Chicago,
Blaug, M., 1970, Economics of Education, Penguin, London.
Human Capital Theory . Woodhall, M., Human Capital Concepts in: Halsey, A. Lauder, H.
Brown, Ph. Wells, A., 1997, Education: Culture, Economy, Society, Oxford U. P., Oxford, 218-223.
213
,
.

8. ,
,

,
.
, ,
-
.
, ,
, ,
,
.
(, 1999, 19-72), .
,
Schultz, Becker Mincer9,

. -
, -
,
.
.
, 1999 : , , , 2003
Mincer, J, 1974, Schooling, Experience and Earnings, Columbia University Press, New York
-
w- p
214
, : )
,
, )
)

( (dw/dt) > (dw/dt) ).

,
. (1999, 22-40).
- ,
-
earnings function Mincer (, 1999, 37-40)
()
(S), (),

. Mincer
LnYi = a + bSi + 1i + 2i2 + i
b
( b = lnY/ S ).
215
10
5.8% 9%, (1999)
8.3%
8.1% ,
. 11 6%
,
.
Mincer ,
, . .
(, 1999, 46-51). , ,
= ,
.
-

, . , ,

:
, .
, ,
. ,
,
. ,
,
10
Psacharopoulos, G., 1982,Earnings and Education in Greece, 1960-1977, European Education

Review 17, 333-347,
, . , ., 1985, :
, , , 1985
Magoula, Th. and Psacharopoulos, G., Schooling and Monetary Rewards in Greece: Contribution to
a Debate, Applied Economics, December 1999
11
, .-, .-, ., , , ,
, 1998, 666-670
216
(, 1999,
47-48).

.
,

, ,
,
,
. , , ,

,
,
,

, ,

.
. ,
,
. , ,

12.
,
13.
12

: , ., 2002,
, , . . , ., 1992, ,
, 62, 33-45
13
Sweezy, P. and Baran, P., xx, , Gutenberg,

, ., 1992, , , ,
217

,
14,

15. ,

,
16,
,
.

,
,
, , .
,

,

17 . ,
.

- ,
14
Hansen, A., 1976, , ,
15
, ., 2000, , ;,
16
. Carchedi, G., 1977, The Economic

Identification of Social Classes, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London,
,
, . Roemer, J., 1982, A General Theory of Exploitation
and Class, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
17
. Bowles, S.-Gintis, H., 1975, The Problem with Human Capital Theory: A
Marxian Critique, American Economic Review, 2
218
- 18.

,
,
. ,

19. 20
.
,

.
,
, , ,

.
, S. Bowles H. Gintis21,
(skills), (attitudes).
Huang (Arrow-BowlesDurlauf, 2000, 121-124)

22:
18
:
, 1981
19
Murnane, R. Levy, F., 1996, Teaching the New Basic Skills: Principles for Educating Children and
Thriving in a Changing Economy, The Free Press, New York. Sorensen, A.
Morgan, St., School Effects: Theoretical and Methodological Issues in: Hallinan, 2000,
Handbook of the Sociology of Education, Kluwer Ac., New York, 137-160.
20
Altonji, J., 1995, The Effects of High School Curriculum on Education and Labor Market Outcomes,
Journal of Human Resources, Summer, 410-438. , Levin, H. Kelley, C., Can
Education Do It Alone? in: Halsey, A. at al., 1997, 240-251.
21
Bowles, S. -Gintis, H., Does Schooling Raise Earnings by Making People Smarter?, in: Arrow, K.Bowles, S. -Durlauf, S., 2000, Meritocracy and Economic Inequality, Princeton University Press,
N. Jersey, 118-136
22
219
., (0.85
1974-1982, 0.90 1984-1989 0.95 1990-1994).
,
,
. , ,
Bowles-Gintis23

. ,

,
,
. ,

, , (merit). , ,

-
;
, . (2002),

,
.

(, 2002, 63-118)
- - .

. , ,
: ..
, ,
0, 1 .
23
, ,
(model of incentive-enhancing preferences).
220
Le Thanh Khoi,
(, 2002, 75)24. , ..

,
, ,

. ,
[] [ ]

- ,
.
,
,
,
. ,
,
, -
(, 2002, 48).
.
,
,

. ,
.

,
,
.
24
: Le Thanh Khoi, 1979, LIndustrie de lEnseignement,

Les Editions de Minuit, Paris
221

.25 , ,
26
Schultz Denison,
(residual),

(, , ) , .
,
, , 3%.
,
,

(, 1999, 65).
,27 1982-1991,

.
(1),
(2)
(3)
()
. R2Y.X1 X2
X3
=97.56%,
. , ,
Bowles, . , ,
.
,

25
. S. Bowles, Denison.
26
, ., 1999, 53-72 , ., 2002, 10-18.
27
, ., 2000, , , , , 206-211
222
,

. ,

,
(, 1999, 6667). , ,

,
.
( ),
, (
),
, ,
(
!),
,
(;), .
,
,
,

. ,
-
,

,
. ,
, .
, ,
, (, 1999, 91).

.
, ,
223

.

. , ,
..
28
,
. ,
2150 2881 (
5125 7012), 16

.

, 1987, .
1948-1985
(, 1987),
.

, ,
.
- (, 1987,
25-26). , ,
,
(, 1987, 31-51),
. . ,
, , ,
, , ..
-
28
Antonitis, M. -Tsakloglou, P., 1999, Who Benefits from Public Expenditure in Greece? Athens
University of Business and Economics, Discussion Paper 99-02
224
29,
..
Cl. Offe30,
. , []

,

.
, ,
(, 1987, 388-389).
,
,
. , ,
,
: , ,
(,
1987, 381).

,

.

(, 1987, 507-530).
- ,
.
29
Bowen, W.G., Assessing the Economic Contribution of Education, in Cosin, B.R., 1977, Education:
Structure and Society, Penguin, London, 30
30
Offe, Cl., 1985, Disorganized Capitalism, Polity Press, Oxford
225
Leibenstein (1967) .. ,
1980
31.
,
32,
,
, ,
. , ,

(, 1987, 529). , , ,

,
. , ,

.
, ,
, ,
- -
.
,
,
.
, ,

33, ,
31
. . , .,
2003, : , . , , 51-55
32
. , 1999, 45
33
, ., 1981, , ,
, ., 1977, , ,
. , ., 1984,
, , , , 6
226

- ,
(Leibenstein, 1967, 57-65).

, .
(
)
.

(Leibenstein, 1967, 62). , ,
Ph. Robinson
.
,
.

34.
31-47 , ., 1986,
: , ,
34
, , ,
( , ,
1987), ,
. , ,

, ,
, . ,
[]
[] []
, -
,
. , ,
,
,
, , ,
/ -
227
,
, -
-

,
.
, ,
. ,
,
.35

. ..
(, 1987, 522, 530)
-
70 80. , ,

36,

.
-
,
,
. []
,

, ,
,
, -
, .
35
, ., 1975, , ,
36
, ., 1988, , ,
, . , ., :
90, , , 2004.
228
- -
:

(, 1987, 236-245).

.
, ,
[]

. .

,
,
.
,
.
, , , ( ;) ,
. , ,
-

,
.

.
.. ,
,
, , ,
.
229

.
, ,
. ,
,
.
,
.
37
. ,
,

.

. , .
[]
,
[, ]
(, 2003, 12)

,
, . .
.. , ,

,
[]
37
, ., 1998, , :
, 623-638
230
,
,
(, 2003, 232)
.
,

,
(vouchers) ,

( ),
(charter
schools).

, (245), , ,
[] ,
,
(246).

- .
,
. , ,
.
,
..,
(237).
,
. ,
,
:
150%
, . , , ..,
,
.
, ,
. ,
231
, ,
. ,
, ,
, .
,
,
. , , .
,
(
,

), ,
.
,
(, 2003, 225),

(. 86) - (
)

. , ,

. , ,
,

(87)
.

.
, , . ,
..,
Pisa (, 2003, 117) -

232
. charter schools vouchers, ,
, . ,
,

(, 2003, 201),

, ,
. .
,
. 38

,
.
,

.
,

( )
,

.

,
Michael Apple.39 , ..,
,

.
- ,
38
Murnane, R. Levy, F., 1996, Teaching the New Basic Skills: Principles for Educating Children and
Thriving in a Changing Economy, The Free Press, New York
39
Apple, M., 2002, , , , 100
233
.40
, -
- Youdell Gilborn,41
, ,

, ,
.42 (Apple,
2002, 130)43
,
, ,

,
- . ,
, Apple (2002, 79),

(
, ,
)
, . ,
Hewitt, 19 .,
[
40
Ball, St. Bowe, R. Gewirtz, Sh., Market Forces and Parental Choice, Tomlinson, S. (ed.),
1994, Educational Reform and Its Consequences, Rivers Oram Press, London
41
Gilborn, D. Youdell, D., Ratioting Education, Open University Press, Philadelphia, 2000
42

,

. ,
- ,
, -
.
, , ,
.
43
234
] ,
.
44
,

, ,

.45 , Jo Boaler,
,
, (Apple, 2002, 290-293).

, , ;
-
, .
:

.

Murnane Levy. , ,
,
..
,
, , , , ,
. , ,
,
,
,
. -
44
Lauder, H. Hughes, D., 1999, Trading in Futures: Why Markets in Education Dont Work, Open
University Press, Philadelphia, Apple (2002, 110). ,
, Waslander, S. Thrupp, M., Choice, Competition and Segregation: An Empirical
Analysis of a New Zealand Secondary School Market, 1990-1993 in: Halsey at al, 1997, 439-459.
45
Molnar, A., 2000, Vouchers, Class Size Reduction and Student Achievement, Phi Delta Kappa
Education Foundation, Bloomington
235
.
H. Lauder, [] ,

,
(low skilled low trust) .
, ,

.

. .

(sophisticated), .
-, - 46
,

, ,

. , ,
, , ,
, ,
. ,
,
,
,
. ,
,
,

.
46
Lauder, H., Education, Democracy and the Economy in: Halsey at al., 1997, 382-392.
236
,
,

,
47
.

,
(, , ,
...)[]

48. ,

, .

.

. , ,
, , .

,
49.

, ,
47
, .,
, : , 1999,
, , , 85
48
, ., , :
, 2000, , , 667, 683.
49
, ., :
, : ,
, , 2003, 193-251
237
, , ,
, .

,
.. ,
,

(, 2003, 217218), , ,
, -
. , ,
,

(learning relationship)
(new basic skills),
,

50.

.
,
.
, , ,
.

-
- , , .

51.
50
, ., , : , ., 2001, ,
, , 29-30. . ,
227-229
51
. , ., 2005, , ,
238
[]
,
.
, ,
.
,
52
,
.

. :
,

.
,
, ,
- ,
, ,
, ,
- (multi-skilled)
.
(knowledge-producing
industries).
Manuel Castells, opus magnum

53, []
.
52
Carnoy, M. Castells, M., , :

, . , ., 2001, , , , 407, 413
53
Castells, M., The Information Age: Economy, Society and Culture (3 vols), 1996, 1997, 1998,
Blackwell, Oxford, p.17 (1996).
Castells: Flows, Networks and Identities: A Critical Theory of the Informational Society in:
Castells at al., 1999, Critical education in the New Information Age, Rowman & Littlefield,
Oxford, 37-64. , , Aronowitz De Fazio,
60-
:
Aronowitz, S. De Fazio, W., 1997, The New Knowledge Work in: Halsey, 1997, 193-206, 203.
239

,
.
,
, ,
, ,
.
,
Castells- networkers, networked
switched-off
(Castells, 1996, 174).
, , ,
.

,
,
54.
.

:
,

;
..
54
:
Crook, S. Pakulski, J. Waters, M., 1992, Postmodernization: Change in Advanced Societies,
Sage, London, Piore, M. Sabel, C., 1984, The Second Industrial Divide, Basic Books, N. York.
, ,
. 50 60 Galbraith Bell
Toffler- . , ,
, ,
. . , ., 1976, , ,
240
-

55.

(. ). , ,

56.
, ,
57,

, , , ,
.

.
55
Kelly, J., 1998, Postmodernism and the End of the Labour Movement, in Rethinking Industrial
Relations, Routledge, London and New York, Castree, N., 2000, Review of M. Castells The
Information Age, Historical Materialism, 7, 241-256
56

. Edward Luttwak
-
(The Old Titans) ,

- . , , .
. Luttwak, E., 1999, Turbo-Capitalism, London, 80-83.
., , Equality and Capitalism Callinicos, A., 2000, Equality, Polity Press,
Cambridge, 88-129
57
,
, ,
. Harvey, D., 1989, The Condition of Postmodernity, B. Blackwell, Oxford.
241
,
, .

,
, . , ,
, , ,
.

,

. 70 ,
McClosky Zaller58, 90%

. ,
, , ,
59 .

,
,
-
, , .

,
. , ,
.
,
58
McClosky, H. Zaller, J., 1984, The American Ethos: Public Attitudes toward Capitalism and
Democracy, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
59
Bowles, S. Gintis, H., 1999, Reciprocity, Self Interest and the Welfare State, Nordic Journal of
Political Economy, 2
242
,
.
, 60
, M. Young61

,
,
.
Meritocracy and Economic Inequality
(Arrow-Bowles-Durlauf, 2000),
:

(merit); (rewards)
;

, , .. ,
;

;

;

,
, ,
;
60
Herrnstein, R. J. Murray, C., 1994, The Bell Curve: Intelligence and Class Structure in American
Life, Free Press, New York
61
Young, M., 1958, The Rise of Meritocracy, 1870-2033, Thames and Hudson, London.
Young . Goldthorpe, J., Problems of
Meritocracy in: Halsey, A., 1997, 663-682.
243
-
-
, , ,

.

,
, .
,
.
,
, , .
.
. , [] (equity, equality)
(equality of opportunity) ,

, ,
, .. , ,

, ,
, ,
,
,
,
, , .
, .
(, 1999, 90-91).

.
,

.

-
244
.
, -

,
.
,
. .. 10% ,
10% .
,
.. ,
,
62.
,
, :
;
; ;
;63.
[]
62
, ., : ; :
, 1996, , , , 360-361.
Geissler, E.,
: , : Geissler,
E., 1997, , , , 115-147,
.

, , ,
(120).
-
,
.
: , ., 1999, , ,
, ., 2001, , ,
63
, ., 2002, , , , 265-266
196-197
245
.
,
..
.
[]
.
. []
[] 64 (, 2000,
106-107).

65. , ,

,
Daniel
Bell66 ,

64

:
, . , . , . -, .,
: , : ,1997,
,48-60. ,
,
(48), []
.
(49). , []
, [
] : ,
(50).
65
, ., : , 44.
66
Bell, D., 1999, , , , 295-304

: , . (.), 1991, ,
, , 621-697.
246
67.

. -
,

,
,
.
. , ,

.

- -
,

.
,

, , .
, ,
-
, ,
. ,
,
,
: ,
68.
67
-, ., : , 1991, 609-619.
68
., , Lundberg, S. Startz, R., Inequality and Race: Models and Policy in:
Meritocracy and Social Inequality, 2000, 269-295 , , Benabou, R., Meritocracy,
Redistribution and the Size of Pie , 317-339, .
,
247
, , Herrnstein
Murray69,
. Herrnstein Murray

- Arthur Jensen

,
, .
,
- .
Jensen70

, ,
Herrnstein Murray,
, Jensen
.
Herrnstein Murray
.
20 . ,
1920
, 1950,
,
. 1960,
,
.
: Levine, A., Efficiency Politics in: Wright, E.O.(ed.), 1998, Recasting Egalitarianism:
New Rules for Communities, States and Markets, Verso, London, 121-138
69
Herrnstein, R. J. Murray, C., 1994. . Gilborn, P

Youdell, D., The New IQism: Intelligence, Ability and the Ratioting of Education in:
Demaine, 2001, 65-99, Fraser, St., Introduction to the Bell Curve Wars in: Halsey, 1997,
779-783.
70
Jensen , .
, 1985, 113-127
248

,
.

,

.
.
, ,
. ,

,
. ,
(Herrnstein-Murray, 1994, 101).

40% 80%
60%[ ]
60% .. (Herrnstein-Murray, 1994, 105)
,

,
.
,
- ,
. , ,
,
. ,
, underclass,
.

. ,
[ ]
(Herrnstein-Murray, 1994, 414). ,

249
, ,
.
Herrnstein Murray

.
, ,
71,
,
72.
, ,
, , ,

(Lundberg-Startz, 2000, 269-295).
,

. . ,
,
, , ,
1970-
- .

, , .
,

,
.
71
Flynn, J.R., 1996, Group Differences: Is the Good Society Impossible?, Journal of Biosocial Science,
28, 573-585
72
Korenman, S. Winship, C., A Reanalysis of The Bell Curve: Intelligence, Family Background
and Schooling, in: Meritocracy and Economic Inequality, 2000, 137-178
250
, ,
.
,
Theory of Justice73 John Rawls,
,

, , .
, Rawls (utilitarian)
,
, .
, -

.

,
(Rawls, 1971, 26-27).

,

.
,

, ,
Robert Nozick Anarchy, State and Utopia,74
,
. , ,
73
Rawls, J., 1971, A Theory of Justice, Oxford University Press, Oxford
74
Nozick, R., 1974, Anarchy, State and Utopia, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 31-32
251

,
, (Nozick, 1974, 183-184). Rawls
,

. , , .
, justice as fairness (Rawls, 1971,
302),

75. , ,
Pareto,

, Rawls
. Alex Callinicos
(2000, 46)76, Rawls inequalities require justification by the benefits
they bring the least advantaged. , , Nozick,

,
Rawls

(Rawls,
1971, 311).
,

(Rawls, 1971, 75).

. Rawls
. ,
,
75
Difference Principle,
.
76
.
Lynch, K., Research and Theory on Equality and Education in: Hallinan, 2000, 85-105.
252
. ,
, , ,
, ,
77.
Rawls
(primary social goods)
,
, ,
.
,
.
, Amartya Sen
. Sen78
:
1. ;
2. ; (; ; ; ;
; ;)

( ),
( Ronald Dworkin79 brute luck),
(
Gerry Cohen John Roemer80
) ( Sen freedom
to achieve).

.
77
. Balibar, egalibert,
,

. B. Callinicos, 2000, 22
78
Sen, A., 1995, Inequality Reexamined, Clarendon Press, Oxford
79
Dworkin, R., 1981, What is Equality? II: Equality of Resources, Philosophy and Public Affairs, 10,
284-302.
80
Roemer, J., Equality of Opportunity in: Meritocracy and Economic Inequality, 2000, 17-32
253
81
, .
, ,
,
. , ,
.
. ,

. , ,
. ,
,
. ,

,
Kymlicka (Kymlicka,
2005, 198-271) .
, , Nozick Rawls.

[] [ ]

(Rawls, 1971, 102). , ,
,
81

. . , ., 1995, , ,
, , 1999, , , ,
261-292. ,

: Kymlicka, W., 2005, , , .
2.3

255
12

80
,
.
,
.

1983 1.

.

.
,
-
, ,

, , [
, ., 1983, , , 28, 25-45.

: , ., 1997, :
, , , 311-350.
256
]
,
(, 1997, 319-320).
- Schutz, Cicourel BergerLuckmann
,
,
. , ,

Piaget: ,
,
, .
,

. , ,
. , ,
.
,
,
.
,
, , ,
, ,

2 (, 1997, 328).
,

2
: , . , ., 1989,
, , , 203-215.
257
.
, . ,

- ,
,
, ,

(, 1996, 57).
,
.

,
,
,
.
,

Anthony Giddens
, The
Constitution of Society3.
, ,
Habermas, Jeffrey Alexander Coleman,
(, 1997, 64),
Giddens.
Giddens

.
3
Giddens, A., 1984. Giddens : Thompson, J., The

Theory of Structuration: An Assessment of the Contribution of Anthony Giddens in: Thompson,
1983, 148-172, : Craib, I., : , 1998,
225-267.
258
(knowledgeability),

.

(, 1997, 67):
.
.

. , ,
, , Giddens
. John Thompson,
,
.
, Giddens,
. , ,
,
. [
Giddens], , ,
, [] (Giddens, 1979,
70):
(Thompson, 1983, 167). 4, ,
,

. ,
4
Giddens
, - :
: + , , , a la langue.
, , ,

. , .
: ,
, , a la parole.
,
.
259

, , ,
. , ,
,
, . ,
:
, .
, . , ,
.
, , []

.

.
(Giddens, 1984, 15).
,
(, 1997,
71). ,
.
Giddens, (dualism)
, , (duality),

, .
,

Willis Gambetta 5 (Giddens, 1984, 288310). 6 -
5
, . 1997,
509-533.
McRobbie, A., 1978, Working Class Girls and the Culture of

Femininity Women Take Issue, Womens Studies Group, Hutchinson, London. . Apple, M.,
1993, , , , 163-171.
Aronowitz Willis
: Aronowitz, S., A Different Perspective on Educational Inequality in:
260

. Giddens ,
,

.

.
,
,
, , .
, , .

,
- .

. -
.
, , ,
,
. Giddens
,
,
,
(, 1997,
140). ,

-
, .
7.
Giroux, H. Shannon, P., 1997, Education and Cultural Studies, Routledge, London, 179-196.
7
[ ]
(142).
261
Giddens, Learning to Labour

. Gambetta

, , ,
. ,

. , ,

.

.
,
.
,
.
, ,
.
Anthony Giddens
, ,
, .
.
,

. ,
, .

Giddens
.

. John Thompson, []
Giddens

.
262

-

.
.
Giddens
: , ,
. , ,

.
[ ] ,
, ,
.
,
,
, (Thompson, 1983, 168-169).
. , ,
Giddens
, ,
.

, ,
- , ,
,
.
. , []
, ,

,

[]
, - - [ ,
263
],

, , , ,
8 (, 1997, 54-55).
, Giddens Willis

. ,

.
.
,
,
,
.
, Giddens
, ,
- ,
,
. , .
.

,
.
, , Giddens

8
: .
,
,
, ,
(117).
264

, , .

.

,
80, .
. 9,
, ,
, . ,

,
,
, ,
10.

.
, ,
,
,
, , .
- -
9
, ., 1985, : ,
, .
, ., 1990, , Gutenberg, .

- . , ., 2004,
, , 15-78.
10
, ., 1985, :
, , 22, 36-49.
, ., 1996, , Gutenberg,
, ., 1996, K: , Gutenberg,
265
,

, ,
,
. , ,
,

,
,
(, 1990, 198)
.
, - [] -
-
11
(, 1985, 52).

. ,
,
.
11
, , . ,
.
:

- ,
.
,
,
.
, (
, ,
) ,
,
(12).
266
-
(, 1990, 30).

,
-
, .
,

,
.

.
Weber, Schutz, Berger-Luckmann, Mead, Blumer,
Garfinkel12 (, 1990, 39-40).
, , :
.
, ,
(, , , )
(, 1990, 39)
, .
, ,
. , Schutz ,
, , ,
,
.
, ,

13. ,
12

, , , ,
, Goffman (33-34).
13
. 3 ( : , 49-103)
4 ( : , -
267
,
, :

, ,
() .
,
, , .
,
. [ ]

,
,
.
, ,

,
-
,
,
, ,
14 (, 1990, 109-110).
,
, 104-147)
14
, , , .
(, ., 1984,
, , ) []
(
)
,

()
.
,
(115).
268
:
.
, ,
.

,
(, 1997, 154-156).

,
.

- ,
(,
, ) (, 1990, 163)
[ ]
,

(, 1997, 154).
, , ,
,
: , , , . ,

,
,
,
. (1997, 155156), , [] ,

.

,
269

.

, . , :
[] ( )
per definitionem .
, ,
( )
. ,
, ,

,
(, 1990, 22). ,
,
. ,
, ,

15 (, 1990, 76).
,

.
15
:

.

.
.
,
, .
:
- ; ;
;
270

. ,
, ,
,
, ,
de facto .
( )
,
16 (, 1990, 180).

, , , .
, ,
: ( ),
( ),
( )
( ).
,

( , ,
,
) (;, ..)
(, , , ),
,
17 (, 1990, 178).
16
, ,
. ,
(180),
, , ,
de facto -
(195).
17
, Nemitz. ,
,
.
271

,
.
, -, - (
-)-
-
. (,
1990, 198-199)

.
.

,
(, 1990, 153-155).

-

, ,
. ,
,
,
, , -
.

,
,
.

(201).
272
. :
- -,
, .
[]
.
.
,
, 18.
,
.
: (1)
(2) (, 1990, 154).
, ,

.

(
) .

, -
, . ,
-
-

. , []
18
-
.
; , ; ,
,
/ ; ,
, , , ;
;, ,
; .
273
,
, ,
.
a priori
.

,

.
.
( )
(
) (, 1990, 155).

.
-
.
, sub speciae societatis
.

.
,
19 (, 1996),
, ,
.
.

19
. , ., , , .
, 80,
:
(105).
274
(, 1996, 199)
, []
,

,
,
(, 1990, 211).

; , ,

, (1996, 75-76) - , ,
,
;

; , ,
, -
,

,

(, 1996, 16). ,

, .
.

(, 1990, 207-208). , ,

,
(208).

,
,
275
. , ,
(209);

,
.
: -
, , . ,
, [] ,
,

( )
. , ,
,

- 20.
, ,
, , ,

. , , ,
,
. 21 (,
2004, 41) -
. .
20
, ., 2004, - - :
, ,
39, 37. : , .,
: , , , 2002.
. , ., 2001,
, , 4, 36-62.
21
,
, , .
276

.
, ,
.

,

22.

.
, .
/
: []

70 80 ,
, ,
23.
22

. : ,

, ,
,

.

,

,
(212).
.
23
, ., - - , 28.
: ,
,

.
.
277
, ,
.
,
,

.
, ,
,
, , ,

,
.
.
- . ,

- .
:
,

.
,
.

.

.
,
, . :

.
, .
Wexler, 1987, x, 3-32.
278
,
.
-,
,
.

,

, , ,
24
(, 2004, 42).
, , ,

, .
, ,
,
,
.

-
.

,
24
,
, , ,
, ,

- .
. , ,
(99).
. Jameson, F. Miyoshi, M., 1998, The Cultures of Globalization, Duke Un. Press,
Durham, : Culture and the Nation, 191-271 -: Mignolo, W.,
Globalization, Civilization Processes and the Relocation of Languages and Cultures, 32-51.
279

. , ,
,

, ,
-
25. , ,
- 26.

27.

Berger-Luckmann
.

, ,
. ,

, .
, ,
.
(, 1997, 202), []
,
,
. ,
25
Erving Goffman, 2001,:

, , ,
, , 9-58.
26
, . , ., 1998,
, , 101, 58-64 102, 66-72.
, ., 1999, : , Virtual
School, 2/1.
27
, ., :
, 1997, 202-216.
280
, ,

28.
, ,
-.

Durkheim, Bowles-Gintis, Althusser, Bourdieu-

. /

,

29
(, 1997, 204).
, ,
, / ,
,
. , ,

(, 1997, 205).
,

Knowledge and Control,
.

28
() : , .
, ., 145-168 :

(146).
29
, , ,
, .
.
281

.

,

[ ] ,
, ,
, , [] []
: []
,
(, 1997,
207).
. , ,
,
, ,
, ,
, ,
,

, , . , ,
,
. ,
,

,
(, 1997, 207-208).
, ,

, , ,
.
-
, , ,
,
282
30. ,

, ,
, ,
[]

(, 1997, 209).

.

.
,
. , ,
. , , ,

, . , ,
,
.
,
. ,

,

, ,
,
30
, , ,
(208).
283
31 (, 1997,
211).
, , , ,
, , .
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
, , -
-
.
,

- (, 1994, 151).
, ,
/ .
, , ,
,
.

(, 1994, 152).
,
:

, ,
.

[]

31
,
Berger-Luckmann, : () , 149 151.
:
, ,
.
284
. ,
,

, (, 1994,
153).
()
32

-

(, 1994, 153-159).
, ,
, , ,
, ,

,
.
,
,
.

(, 1994, 157)33. , , ()
32
,
.
33

,
: / (159-162)
(162-164).
:

.

.
285
,
Berger-Luckmann-
. , ,

.
,

, , ,
. ,
-
,
, ,
:
. , ,
-
(, 1994, 165).

/
.
,
, , .

.
: ,
-,

-,
,
,
, (162).
286
,
,

34.
, ,

,
Education and Social Control Sharp-Green35
Learning to Labour Willis,
.
. ,
-
,
,
. ,

:
, ,
(, 1997, 455-456).

Sharp-Green ,

,
,
.
34
.

- , , -
.
35
Sharp, R. Green, T., 1975, Education and Social Control: A Study of Progressive Primary
Education, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London. 6
1983 :
: , 1997, 442-457.
Rachel Sharp, , :
Morrow, R. Torres, C., 1995, Social Theory and Education: A Critique of Theories of Social and
Cultural Reproduction, State Un. of New York Press, Albany, 294-302.
287
36 , ,
-
. M. Apple,
-

.

[ , Rachel Sharp and Anthony Green, Education and Social Control,
]. , ,

.37
.
, ,

. ,
Berger-Luckmann

(Choses)38.

(Berger-Luckmann, 1967, 49, 106).

36
Blackledge-Hunt. . Blackledge, D. Hunt, B., 1995, 333.
37
Apple, M., 1993, , , , 66. Apple

, P. Woods, M. Hammersley D. Hargreaves.
, : Hammersley, M. Woods, P. (eds), 1976,
: , 1997
38
Berger, P. Luckmann, T., 1967, The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of
Knowledge, Allen Lane, Penguin, London, 30, : , ., 1997, 106 ..
288

- .

, , .

(Berger-Luckmann, 49, 109).

- . , -
, , .
, , , .
-

. ,
Rachel Sharp, Anthony Green, Paul Willis-,
,
.
,
, :
39, ,
.

,

. :
,
, , ,

39

,
Miliband .
289
(, 1997, 211).

.
:

.
, , /
,
(, 1997, 210). , , , ,
,
40.
.
, ,
/

. , ,
, ,
BergerLuckmann,
,
, .
, , ,,
,
,
-

, ,
40

. , , ,
, / /
. , ,
.
290
,
41 (, 1997, 110).

. , , .

.
.
.
, ,

. ,
, ,
.
, ,
. ,
.
, .

, - -
-. -
-, - - ,
,
-, ,
42 (, 2000, 117).
41
:

. ,

- ,
. /
- - (111).
42
, []
. (discourse
practices) ,
291

, ,
. , , -

. , ,

,
.

,
, ,
.
.
-
, .

43.
,
, (gender)
. , ,
( ) ,
.
, .
,
,
. - LaclauMouffe : Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics, Verso,
London, 1985, .
Laclau . Laclau, E., 1997, ,
, .
43
., , , . , ., 1991, :
, , , ., 1995, :
,
, .
292
,
- .
44

.

, ,
. ,
.
,
,
,
. ,
,
.
,
. , ,
[ ]

(-, 2004, 270)

- .

, -
, ,

44
, . , ., 2004, :
, , .
293

,
, , 45

.
,

,
.

Basil Bernstein
, , .
46
-
Bernstein47. ,

.
,
48.
, ,
, Durkheim49
45
, ., :
, ., 1997, 188-199.
46
Bernstein, B., 1989, , , .
47
Basil Bernstein, . ., 15-39.
48
, . , .,
: , 1991, :
, , 399-413.
, . , ., , . .
, . , . , ., 1996,
( ) , , 90-91, 43-54.
49
, /
, :
,
294

,
, ,
/ ( ),
, , ,
, , /
, , ,
,
, ,
( , ) (, 1997, 190),

- , . ,
, Durkheim,
, , , ,
,
.

Althusser,
Bourdieu Bernstein. Althusser,

, , ,

.

, ,

. ,
,
,
, []
, , .
, 1997, 189.
295
Althusser (, 1997, 193).

. ,
[]

-

. , Althusser

, ,
. Althusser
.
, ,
, :
, , .
, , /
, ,

. , /
- , ,
-.
,
(
), Althusser,
,

, ,
(, 1997, 193). , ,
. , ,
(, 1997, 193) ,
Althusser, Baudelot Establet
(
296
, , )
. , Baudelot Establet

Durkheim , , ,

, ,
- 50 (, 1997, 194).
,

, , ,

.

. ,
Bourdieu-Passeron [ La Reproduction],
, , ,
, , habitus

,

,
(, 1997, 195-196).

.

Bourdieu-Passeron , ,
.

50
Baudelot-Establet, ,
(

.
297
habitus.
- /
51. habitus
,
.

.
Bourdieu, [] habitus, ,

, ,
, ,

,
52. habitus, , ,

, ,
,
, .
, ,

, .

, ,
. , ,
(intentionality) . , ,

, ,
53. O Bourdieu, ,
51
. , ., HABITUS: Bourdieu
: , 1995, 54-62.
52
Bourdieu, P., 1990, The Logic of Practice, Polity Press, Cambridge, 54, :
, ., , 177.
53
Bourdieu, habitus
(dispositions),
298
habitus . J. B.
Thompson,
, habitus ,
, ,
. , Bourdieu,
(dupes)
. ,

. ,

(style of life)54.
, Bourdieu ,
habitus
55. ,
(structured structures predisposed as structuring structures), ,

(regulated) (regular)
,
, ,
(Bourdieu, P., 1977, Outline
of a Theory of Practice, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 72).
54
Thompson, J. Symbolic Violence: Language and Power in the Writings of Pierre Bourdieu in
Thompson, J., 1983, 53. Thompson
Bourdieu, P., 1999, , , , 55-125, 237-295.
55
,
. ,
:

.
, , ,
. ,
.
, ,
[-], , Ausgeburt des Feldes: , ,
, (Bourdieu, P. Wacquant, L., An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology,
Polity Press, Cambridge, 1992, 107).
.
299
, -
.

, ,
Basil Bernstein.
.
, ,
,
,
, (, 1997, 197).

56.
, , ,
, ,
, ,
. ,
57.
, Bernstein
Michel Foucault58
, ., P. Bourdieu :
-, 1995, 49-52.
56
, ., : ,
: , 1994, 114.
57
Bernstein,
,
[privileging text] -
, . ,

. ,
, , ; (139).
58
, Foucault
: Jones, D. Ball, S., O Michel Foucault
Walkerdine, V., : , 1994,
300
. Foucault
, .
,
. ,
Foucault /
. , ,
. 59,
,
,
,
. , ,
, ,
, , 60. Foucault, ,

,
,
( )

.
,

. , , ,
,

, , 169-178 105-111. , ,
: , ., 1998, : ,
Virtual School, The Sciences of Education Online, 2/1. , ,
: Popkewitz, Th., 1998, The Sociology of Knowledge and the Sociology of Education:
Michel Foucault and Critical Traditions in: Torres, C. A. Mitchell, Th., Sociology of Education:
Emerging Perspectives, State Un. of New York Press, New York, 47-89.
: Spanos, W., 1993, The End of Education, Un. of Minnesota Press,
Minneapolis, 25-64,
Foucault Heidegger.
59
Foucault, M., 1977, Discipline and Punish, Penguin, London, 27.
60
Foucault, M., 1976, Power / Knowledge, Harvester Press, Brighton, 73-74.
301
.
(norms). ,
/ . ,
. , .
Foucault
61 :
. ,
.
.
, ,
,
,

,
. , ,
-62
. :
, , .

Bernstein63.
(discourse) (code).
61
, ., 1985, , , , 528.
62
- Foucault .
, ., Foucault : , ., , , , ,
2001, 13-42. Ian Hacking,
Foucault (a fraud),
( : Popkewitz, 1998, 62).
63
, (
)
, ,
()
, .
[ ] , , ,
(, , , , ) []
( , 1997, 120).
302
, Bernstein,
.

.

.
, , ,
.
Foucault

, , ,
(, 1997, 121). , ,

, ,

. ,
,
, ,

.
, ,
(, 1997, 123).
Bernstein, ,
.
,
, Bernstein, /
.
, , ,
, ,
,
,
() , ,
, ().
303

,
, ,
(, 1997, 125).
,
. , , (, 1997, 126134)
: , ,

. , ,
Foucault

. ,
- -
:
Foucault .
Basil Bernstein . , , Bernstein: Apple64,
,
, ,
.
, , , ,
, ,
. .
(discourse)
Foucault and other Parisians
the new definers of the social (
). , .
,
64
Apple, M., Education, Culture and Class Power: Basil Bernstein and the neo-Marxist sociology of
education in: Sadovnik, A. (ed.), Pedagogy and Knowledge: The Sociology of Basil Bernstein,
Ablex, Norwood, 1995.
304

(discourse)
.
[
]65. , Bernstein
Foucault,
.
,
Foucault. ,
,
, , - -
,
Bernstein.
.
. . ,
, , , ,
(major regulator), ,
, 66 (Bernstein, 1996, 11)

.
, ,

, . (discourse)
(code) , ,
Foucault, ,
[]
Bernstein(, 1997, 120).
, Bernstein
, ,
65
Bernstein, B., 1996, Pedagogy, Symbolic Control and Identity, Taylor and Francis, Exeter, 13.
66
Bernstein, ,
,
.
305
Foucault , .
67. ,
. , , Foucault
-

.. 68.
, Foucault .

69. Foucault,
, , .
, Foucault, ,
.

(Foucault,
1976, 85) . ,

67
Foucault - , -
, ,
.
68
, Bernstein
: Althusser. : ,
[]
Althusser: (128).
69
: [] , ,
, -
(, , , )
-

, ,
(115).
Foucault . , . , ., 2004, , ,
: , , 89, 75-109, 96-106 ,
., 2006, , , 94, 81-104,
: ;, 99-102.
306
,
.
. .
.
. , 70;
, , ,

.
Bernstein,

, . ,
,
, ,

- . , ,
Foucault .
. ,

/ . ,

, ,
, .
, .
.. . .
,
/ 71. Foucault
70
, Foucault
. . , ., 2001,
, , , 215-252. : []
.
,
, (Dreyfous, D. Rabinow, P., 1982,
Foucault, Basil Blackwell, Oxford, 221).
71
. . . Apple, M., ,
307
. , [] , ,
,
, . ,
,
/
. /
,

72 (, 1997, 116).

, ,
. .

Foucault,
,
73. , ,

, , . -, ., 1999
-, , 106, 69-77. Bernard Charlot
Charlot, B., 1999,
, , , 1999. , Michael Apple
: Apple, M., Teaching and
Technology: The Hidden Effects of Computers on Teachers and Students in: Beyer, L. Apple, M.,
1998, The Curriculum: Problems, Politics and Possibilities, State Un. of New York Press,
New York, 314-336.
72
-
. Wexler, 1987, 123-192.
73
, ., 1993, , , , 46-48, 121.

.

.
308
.
Foucault , ,
.
.
, ,

.
(, 1987)

Knowledge and Control. , ,
- -
. ,
74

.
, [] ,

(, 1987, 80).
, . , ,

.
. ,

75 (, 1987, 80).
74
Madan Sarup Marxism and Education (Routledge and Kegan

Paul, London, 1978) . Madan Sarup
. , . , ., 2000, :
Madan Sarup, , 41, 103-119.
, Jack Demaine Contemporary Theories in
the Sociology of Education (McMillan, London, 1981, 47-63).
75
309

Michael Apple
, ..

.
. ,
,
.
, ,
,
.
, ,

, ,
,
(, 1988, 55),
.
,
,
, ,
-
,
.
Learning to Labour Willis (,
1988, 56-60).
. , ,

Henry Giroux
Willis ,
. . , ., 1988, ,
, , 99-149,
(139).
310
, ,
(, 1988, 57).
,

(, 1988, 58).

, .
, , ,
,

.

(, 1988, 59), ,
76. , ,
,
. []

, .

(sophisticate) ,

- .

-
, , (,
1988, 61). , ,
.
, ,
76
Giroux
Giroux, H., 1997, Pedagogy and the Politics of Hope: Theory, Culture and Schooling,
Westview, Boulder, Colorado, 71-94.
311
. , Paulo Freire
77 (, 1988, 63).

. ,

- .

,
,
90 78. -
,
(contingent)
79 (Giroux, 1997, 218)
.

77

Paulo Freire (, , 2005). ,

Freire (9).
78
Henry Giroux Stanley Aronowitz ,

,
(Aronowitz-Giroux, 1991, 57-86)
79
, Giroux ,
, . , Giroux,
, . , , ,
Nancy Frazer-
-
, ,
(pastiche)
(Giroux, 1997, 207).
312

.
2.4

314
13

1.

2.

: (- )
.
(,
1982, 76).
, ,
, ,
(, 1982, 183). ,
,
.
, ., 1982, :
, , .
70.
, , : -, ., 2000,
, , 93, 27-48 , ., 2000,
, , .
, ., ,
, 26, 1983, 71-85 37, 1986, 92-107. : , ., 1998,
- , Gutenberg, , 87-131.
315

.
, ,
,
.

:
, ,
,
, .

,
, ,
- , ,
(, 1998, 9). ,
,
. ,
,

(, 1998, 11-27). ,

,
- M. Young P. Bourdieu B. Bernstein,
. [] , , ,
,
70

,

, ( )
316
.
, ,
(, 1998, 21).

.
, ,

, - ,
, ,
.
3.
,
, Merton, Mills,
Boudon .., -
:
,
. .

(, 1998, 243).
, .
,
:
;
:
3
.

,
, ,
. :
(, , , ..)
[ ]
. ,
,
. . .
. (138)
317
,
( )
.
(: ()
, ,
() ) ,
,
,
. de facto
, de jure
- 4.
, ,
,

.
:
.
,
- -,
, 5.
,
.
*****

.
4
, ,
, 1991, ,319.
1998, 24. , , -
( , . , 24 1997)
, structuration theory,
,
Anthony Giddens, Pierre Bourdieu Jrgen Habermas (24).
318
: 6,

(, 1983, 15)
.
7.
.
,
, . ,

: ,

.
( . , , )
.
, ,
,
8.
.

, ., 1983, : , ,
, ., 1986, , ,
1986, 20-21. :
-,
(mobilit social)
(reproduction). - ,
,

( ).
.
-
,
. ,
,
. (28-29)
319
.
, ,

. , ,
,
[]

[Durkheim] (, 1986, 31). ,

,

9. ,

.
.
.
, ,
;
;

;
.
,
.
9
, ,
. :
,
. Marx:

. , ,
. , ,
. (30). . ,
, .
, ,
, ,
.
320

,
,
,
(, 1986, 55).
, . ,
: )
( ) )

[] []
, [ ]

. -
, ,
. , , ,
.
;
*****

-.

,
.

,
:
, , ,
, ,
,
321
10 . -

. ,

(-,
1995, 18). , ,
,
,
,
. , ,
Samuel Bowles Herbert Gintis,

,

.

. 11,
10
-, ., 1995, :
, Gutenberg, , 13, 15.
11
1995, 85-123. , , []
(24-25).
,
- :
,
,
. , ,
Bowles Gintis

:
, .
Bourdieu Passeron

: .
Bernstein
(82-83).
322

, Schooling in
Capitalist America- ,
,
-

12.
, , ,

. , ,
,
.

60 .

,
, - .

. , -

. :
,
, ,

(-,
1995, 82).
.
12
: -, .,
1995, : , ,
, 25-48 ( ), 69-94 (
).
323
13 Schooling and Work in the Democratic State
Carnoy Levin-
: []
,
,
.

:

; (-, 1995, 83).
.

.
. []
, (-)
() ,

.
(, 1995, 366).

.
Laclau
Miliband14 , ,

,
.
:
13
Carnoy, M. Levin, H., 1985, Schooling and Work in the Democratic State, Stanford U. P., Stanford.
14
1995, 383. . Giddens, A., 1989,

, , , 98-104.
324
,
( ),
,
.
Laclau (1983,
68-72) (-, 1995, 18). ,
Laclau
-.
Laclau, .
,
,
. , ,

-
,
, Miliband

,
. , ,

. , ,
.
Althusser,
- ,
: , ,
.
, ,
(Laclau, 1983, 68-69).
, Laclau.

,
. ,
.
,
325
. ,
,
.
,
(Laclau, 1983, 69-70).

,
,
-. Laclau
:
, , .
,
, .
-
Laclau.
*****
,
15,

.
16. ,
15
, . , . , ., 1994,
, , 76, 29-37,
, ., 1994, , , 78, 34-37,
, . -, ., 2001, ,
, 118, 68-79.
16
, ., 1994, : ,
, 72 73 74, 42-49, 27-38, 38-46.
, ., 1994, ,
, 79, 24-31.
, :
, ., , , 41-42, 116-126.
326
,
.
.
,
,

,
, ,
.
. , , ,
,
,
,
(, 1996, 86).
,
. ,

.

. , ,

.

. , ,

.
,
, , .

, ., 2001, , Gutenberg, .
, , : , ., 1996,
, , -.
327
.

. .
,
, ,
.

(, 1996, 104-107).
, , .

- ,

(, 1994, 73, 30)
, , ,
Althusser
,

,
(, 1994, 74, 46).

. , ,

-

.

,
-.
14
JRGEN HABERMAS

Jrgen Habermas
-
. , ,

.
(Institut fr Sozialforschung)
,

.
- Horkheimer Adorno

,
, , -
1, Habermas
. , ,

20 . ,
, , Habermas , ,
- 2,
1
Honneth, A., : , ., , 280-298.

. Bernstein, R., 1992, The New Constellation: The EthicalPolitical Horizons of Modernity / Postmodernity, MIT Press, Cambridge MA, 33-45
Horkheimer Adorno .
Habermas, J., 1993, , , , 138-168.
Habermas
Adorno.
. (Habermas, J., 1986,
329
.

. ,
,

.
Habermas.

Theorie des Kommunikativen Handelns,
[] []
[]
3. , ,

.

,
.

,
,

, Horkheimer Adorno
4.
Autonomy and Solidarity, Blackwell, Oxford, 158)
3
Habermas, J., 1984, The Theory of Communicative Action, I, Heinemann, London, 398.
. , ., 1990,
Habermas , ,
2, 149-174. :
, ., 1996, :
, ,
. : , ., Habermas ,
330

Wittgenstein .
Habermas

.
.

. []
,
,
. ,
,
(Honneth, 1998, 301).

, , .

[] (Honneth, 1998,
301).

.
Horkheimer Adorno
Habermas 5,

,
.
, 3, 117-133
5
. Giddens, A.,
; Habermas, : , .,
, 317-334.
Habermas . : ,
., 1987, , , , 43-83
331

.
, ,
.
(Universalpragmatik)
,
, Austin Searle,
,
,
,
6. , ,

,
.

(validity
claims).
,
(verstndlich),
(wahr), (richtig)
[] (wahrhaftig).
,
,
(Thompson, 1983, 262)7.

,
.
,
, ( Thompson pragmatic
universals)
6
7
Thompson, J., Universal Pragmatics in: Thompson, 1983, 255-278

. ,
,
Habermas 1976 . : Habermas, J., 1997,
, , , . 32, 21
332
.
,

(Thompson, 1983, 264). Habermas, []
,
, ,
. []
.
,

(Habermas, 1997, 24). ,
, - .

- . Habermas, ,
(possible)
( )
(contrafactually)
, ,
(Thompson, 1983, 266).
Habermas , ,

.

Horkheimer Adorno, Max Weber,

.
,

: ,
, .
Habermas: Callinicos, A., The Limits of Communicative Reason in:

Callinicos, A., 1989, Against Postmodernism, St. Martin s Press, New York, 92-120
333
,
.

Habermas .
,
.

,
,
(Habermas, 1984, 285-286).

, ,
. ,
Habermas Parsons
- ,

, , . Habermas

.
.
*****
Habermas
.
, ,
9.
9
. Grundy, S., 2003, : , , ,

17-33, Habermas
334
Carr Kemmis10,
, Lawrence Stenhouse11,

(Carr-Kemmis,
2000, 18-19).
(CarrKemmis, 2000, 174-176).

.
-

-
,
. , ,
.
,

(Carr-Kemmis, 2000, 174) , ,

,
.

curriculum. Habermas
: Morrow, R. Torres, C., In Defense of Critical Theory as Educational
Theory in: Morrow, R. Torres, C., 2002, Reading Freire and Habermas: Critical Pedagogy and
Transformative Social Change, Teachers College Press, New York.
10
Carr, W. Kemmis, S., 2000, : ,

, ,
11
Stenhouse, L., 2003, ,

,
335
. ,

.
Carr Kemmis Habermas
.

[ ]

(Carr-Kemmis, 2000, 188-189). ,
Habermas

.

Carr Kemmis. ,

, ,

. ,

. ,
:

. ,

. ,

.
336

. ,

12 (Carr-Kemmis, 2000,
200).
Habermas,

-
13,

.

Habermas
14.
,
, Habermas
. ,

, ,
(, 1996, 13).
,
. , ,

12
Carr Kemmis
, Michael Matthews. .
Matthews, M., 1980, The Marxist Theory of Schooling, Harvester, Sussex, 78-115,
Marxist Epistemology.
13
Bernstein, R., 1978, The Restructuring of Social and Political Theory, Un. of Pennsylvania Press,
Pittsburgh, 222
14
, ., 1996, , ,
337

, , . Habermas
-

(, 1996, 14).

, , ,
: ,

. ,
,
, , ,
Habermas (, 1996,
15).

Berger Luckmann
,
. , ,
Habermas .

, ,
.
,
,
,
.
, , , ,
. ,

, ,
(, 1996, 100).
338

, Habermas.
, ,
Habermas,

(, 1996, 27)15.
,
, ,
. .

,
,
, , 16.

.
, , Habermas
. , ,
.
,

(,
15
, , , Habermas
. Habermas
Horkheimer-Adorno. : [ Horkheimer-Adorno]
[ ]

,
(Callinicos, 1989, 96).
16
Habermas
(-, - ).
, ,
. , Habermas
( , , , 1990)
Habermas.
339
1996, 32). ,

.
Habermas
. ,
Berger Luckmann

. ,
.

(, 1996, 90)17.
Foucault
, .

:
.

,
[]
(, 1996, 110).
,
;
; ;- .
17

, Bourdieu-Passeron, , , ,

,
. , appareil ,
, - ,
-
.
340
Foucault
. , , :
Foucault

18-
Habermas.

. , Foucault 19 (Foucault,
1986, 306-308) (discipline)
,

. , , ,
.
Foucault

. , ,
Foucault
,
(, 1996, 33).

Foucault
.

,

20 (,
18
, ., 1986, , ,
19
17 19 .
.
,
.
20

. .
341
1996, 54-66). . , ,
Habermas ,

Habermas 21.
,

Habermas .

.

.
22,
,
Habermas
Basil Bernstein-

,

23
(, 2004, 122).

21
: Habermas
,
The Theory of Communicative Action .
22
, ., 2004, : ,
, 39, 103-139. . , ., 1996,
, , 24, 38-68
23

, , , /
.
, .

, (132)
342

.
,
, .

,
. ,

. ,

, Bernstein,
.
, ,
, ,
, /
, ,
, , ,
,
. - ,
, ,
, ,
(,
2004, 123). ,
/
,
,

.. , ,

,
(, 2004, 124)
.
, , ,
, .
343
70
,
, 24. ,

.
/
,

. , ,
(, 2004, 125).
, ,

/ .

,
, ,

.

,
.
,
, ,
,
.
,
, ,
, (
),
24
, Bernstein (Class, codes and

control: The structuring of pedagogic discourse, vol. 4, Routledge, London, 1990, 153-154).

.
344
, , ,

25 (, 2004, 128).
, Bernstein,
.
, ,

.
,
.

,
. ,
,

(, 2004, 128-129). ,
,
,

,

,
25

, , ,
/ ,

. ,
, , ,
.
,
. ,
. Brown, P. Lauder, H.,
Education, Globalization and Economic Development in: Halsey, 1997, 172-192.
345
. ,

,

(, 2004, 130).

, ,
Jrgen Habermas.
26,

Habermas
Bernstein-

.

Habermas
()27 (, 2002, 11-25, 82-90).
,
:
, .
, ,
, .
, ,
, ,
,
26
, ., 2002, : , ,
27

( : ,
, , 1996).
346
,
28 (, 2002, 92).

Habermas,

.

- . ,
,

.
- .

.
, ,
,
,
(Callinicos, 1989, 101-102).

, ,
.
,
28
, ,

Habermas
. , ,
,

.

,
(322).
347
Max Weber - ,
,

.
, ,
, , ,
.
.
Habermas
. . , 29,

[]
,
.
Callinicos, [] Habermas
,

, ,

, , ,

, ,
,

, , ,
- (Callinicos, 1989,
102).
, ,
.
29
Habermas, J., The Theory of Communicative Action, II, Polity Press, Cambridge, 1987, 339
348

, .

.
,
, ,

.
, ,
. Habermas ,
,
-

:
30.
, ,
. ,
,
,
30
Habermas ,
, []
,
:
,

, (
) .

*,
(, 1997, :
- -, , , 244-245).
*
.
349

.
31 .
()
. , ,
Habermas

.
.

:
, ,
,

,

.
. (;),

, ,
,
.
. , ,

32. ,
31
, .
(268)
.
32
[Habermas]
,

, ,
, ,
(, 1997, 261) .
350
-.
,
,
. ,

. ,
33.
.
.
,
.

,
.
, [] ,
( :
,
, , ;),
Habermas, Parsons,
.[]
, ,

.
,
, ,

33
, , . ,
, ,
,
.
351
, ,
, ,
,
Habermas (, 1997, 257-259).
.
- .
,
,
,

,
(, 2002, 35)
, 34

. ,
,
.

.

,
(,
2002, 42).
-

.
,
35. (1997, 91),
34
. , ., 2002, , ,
16-30
35
352
-

status quo.
,
.

-,
, . , ,
,
- -
,
, Habermas.
, - .
.
,
-,
- -
(147).
36.
, , : Jameson, F., 1999,
, , , 33-52.
: Barrington-Moore, ., 1978,
, ,
36
.

. , , ,
(124),

(125, 153). ,
, ( ) :
, , . , .
353
.

. , ,
. ;
;
, ,

.
.
- :

, (131).
[ ]
(148)
. ,
, .
, , . , ,
,

,
(149).
,
. , ,
, .
Marx Engels,
Durkheim ,

,
(137), , - .
( ) 1883,
1883!
15

. ,
.
, , []

[]
,
1. ,
, ,
,
.

,

.
,
.
( )
, ., 1991 :
, , , 14.
: , ., 1995,
: , ., :
, Gutenberg, , 155-181. :
, . , ., 1990,
: , , 53, 151-169 , .,
1994, , , 75, 22-29
355
,
(, 1991, 15).

,
: ,

.
: ,
, ;.

.
,
, .
,

.

,

.
, ,
, (,
1991, 17-18).

, 2.

. , ,
.
2
, ,
. :
, . (.), -, , , 1993, 9-38
, . , . (.), , , ,
1996, 9-32.
356
Kuhn

,
, , Bachelard,

.
,
, ,
Althusser Foucault . ,

.
:

,
( / ).
Habermas
,
/ :

,
, ,
,
(, 1991, 24-25). , ,
,
.
, ,
.
*****
357
,
3 ,
. ,
- - , ,
,
.

,
. , ,

.

.

, ,
,
(

;),
(
,
;), (

;) , ,
(, 1991, 29).

,
.
- .
4 (, 1991, 40) -
Kuhn, T., 1981, , ,
,
, .
358

,
.

,
, ,
,

. Bourdieu-

5 .

,

,

(, 1991, 41).
, ,

. :
1. , ,

2. ,
,
3.
.

Feyerabend6 Kuhn7
5
,
.
.
. Feyerabend, P., 1986, , ,
Piaget
359
,
.

,
, .

,
, - ,
(
) -
(, 1991, 53-54).
, ,
.

( -)
- .
. []

.

self-fulfilling prophecy Bourdieu-Passeron (, 1991, 61).
, ,
.
, , ,

.

,
Wittgenstein , , .
360
8 (, 1991,
65).
.

.
, ,

. ,
, .

.
Popper, Lakatos, Kuhn Bachelard,
.

,
. , ,

.

(, 1991, 72).
, ,
,
.
,
-
,
-
(, 1991, 78).

[]

(67).
361

.
,

,
.

. , ,
, ,
- , ,
9.

- ,
.

.
:
, -

, .

() ,
-() -
Althusser. ,

,
( Berger-Luckmann, .).
,
9
, , , Bachelard
,

, ,
.
362
,
, (,
1991, 81-82). , .

, ,
. , , ,
,
:
- ,
.
*****

, .

, Carnap,
Popper
60 (, 1991, 93119, : ).

, ,
.
,

10. Kuhn, Bachelard
10
, ,
. ,
, (111).
, ,
363
Marx Althusser,

.
Bachelard,
,
.
,
,

( , ).

, .
,

,
,
.
Bachelard, ,

11,
12.
,
,

.
11
1991, 130, . . Bachelard, G., 2000,

, , . Canguilhem
[] ,
, , (142).
12

, ( Bachelard
), ,
, , ,
, .
(126-140).
364
,
.
, .

, , Bachelard - Kuhn
.
, Bachelard, Kuhn, ,
, ,
(,
1991, 155). Kuhn
,
,
:
,
(, 1991, 157).

, ,

. ,

.
, ,
, Bachelard
.

, , , ,
-
, ,
. Bachelard , , .
: []
365
.
, ,
(, 1991, 168).
,
, ,
. ,
,

(, 1991, 168).
.

. ,

.
Bachelard .
*****
, ,
.
,
, .

,
, 13.

.
,

13

:
K. Marx (1991, 177-182).
366
14.

,
. ,
: []
(
),
,
,
( ) ,
,
(, 1991, 186).
-
,
. ,

,

.

(, 1991, 193). ,

. , ,

.
14
367
15, ,
Bachelard,
.

,

.
, ,
( ).
(, , ). , ,
( ) ( )
( ). ,
, ,
,
(, 1991, 205).

.
, ,
Bachelard, ,
-

, ,

(, 1991, 212). []
,
. (
)
15
, 1991, 197-206. . :
, ., 1978, , , , 183-200
, ., , , , ,
, 69-76.
:
, ., 1990, : , , , (
. 44-61).
368
,
.

, ,
.

, ,
() ,
(, 1991, 214). , ,
. , ,
- .

(,
1991, 216-224).
,
, , []
(
)

. , , ,
,
.

.
, , ,

, .[]
( -)
. : ,
,
.

369
(, 1991, 230). ,

: ,
.
*****

.
. ,

, /

(, 1991, 234),
16.

.
,
,
,
. .

.

(, 1994, 240247)17.
16

: , . , ., 1994, , , , ,
259-282.
17
, ,
: ) []

370

.
, , -

,
,
- , .

,

.

.
,

, (, 1994, 249).

.
.
, ,
(244)
) []
-
.
-
. ,
,
,
.
. ,
, [] ,
(247).
371
.

.

.
,
- . ,

,
,
.

(, 1994, 252254).
:
.

.

.

.
. :
.
,
,

.
.
Foucault: , .
372
18
( )
.

.
19. , ,
.

.

. 20,

:
1. ;
18
, ., : , :
, . , . (.), 1998, ;-
, , , 106-142.
19
:
, ., 1991, : , , 61,
65-71,
, . , ., 1998,
, , 103, 73-80 104, 70-77,
, ., 1998, , , 100,
31-40 , , 1997, , , 43,
69-79. ,
: :
, , , 2005.
20
, ., : :
, ., 1997, , , , 120.
: , ., 2003,
, , .
373
2. ;
3. -
;
,
,
. ,

.

.
, :
, , ,
, ,
,
.
, ,
-
, ,
,

21
(, 1997, 123).
, , -
,
, (,
).
. ,
,
21

,
,
374
. ,
, .
,
, .

22.

,

.
, ,
,
, ,
,
,
,
,

(,
1997, 128-129).

- :
, ,
.
, ,
, .
, ,
(124)
22
1997, 125. []
,
, ( , 159).
,
: Hacking, I., 2002,
, ..., , 203 ..
375
-
,
.
,
.

(, 1997, 130).

.

. , ,
(
, , ).
, , ,

.
,
.
. ,

,
.

23.

,

23
376
,
. 24,

. , , .

(, 2003, 561-702)25.

, ,
, ,

.
[]
,
(, 2003, 607). , ,
,
(623).

.
,

,
(633).
,
, .
. . 1997, 132.
24

. . , ., 1991,
, , 14, 38-42.
25
:
.
377
, ,

- -

.
, [] [ ]
,
. ,
, ,

. ,
,
. ,
, .
, (
, ..)
.
, ,
(,
2003, 176).
- (Kripke-Putnam).

26.

26
2003, 182. : , ., 1983,

, , , 79-108.
: Engel, P., 2000, , Scripta, ,
, ., 1991, , , , 61-96, , ., 1997,
, , , 147-208.
378

.
.

(Tarski)
. : ,
. , ,
, .
,
( -),
, () (, [.,
, , 17], 1997, 46).

, , ,
, .
(, 2003, 183-184).
27, .

(): p p,
.
:
-

, , ,
().
(Engel, 2000, 68),
, ,
()
.

. (D. Davidson)
27
. , 1997, 173-187 , ., 1990, , , ,

158-160
379
28.
,
u t. (T, u, t): p ()
(u) (t) p.
,
29. -

. , ,
- ( alien)
,
30.

. -
31.

.
.
.
32.
28
. Callinicos, A., 1995, Theories and Narratives, Duke U. P., Durham 76-94,
.
29
Davidson, D., 1990, The structure and content of Truth, Journal of Philosophy, 87, Davidson, D.,
1981, , , 27/28, 183-205.
30
Callinicos, 1995, 82.

[] , ,
,
(183).
31
. , . (2003, 176), .
32
, ,
. , []
( 1974) ,
,
, , (548).

380
.

60
33 ,
(, 1983)
80.
34
. ,
, ,
, ,
,
. ,
, :

(, ., [ , Praxis],
1984, 65) (498).
. :
Levine, A., 2003, A future for Marxism? Althusser, the analytical turn and the revival of Socialist
theory, Pluto Press, London, 65-121.
- :
, ., 1990, , , ,
11-18, 59-71, 105-110.
33
, ,
: , ., 2001, , :
, : , , ,
.
2000.
34

- aleatoire,
1980 .
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
, , .
,
. . , ., 1994, , , , 249.
381
, , , .
.
,
. , ,
, ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
,
, (, 1994, 54-55).
,

,
,
.
, () , ,
... (, 1994, 71-72). ,
,
- -
35.
,
(, 1994, 80),
-
- .
*****
35
,
(contemplation) Rorty, R., 1982,
Consequences of Pragmatism, University of Minnesota Press, 162.
382
36,

.
,
,
- ,

.
,
, Roy Bhaskar37
38.

, ,
.
, ,
( ).
36
/
-
- Roy Bhaskar.
Bhaskar, R., 1975, A Realist Theory of Science, Leeds Books, Leeds,
.
: Archer, M. - Bhaskar, R.
Collier, A. - Lawson, T. - Norrie, A. (ed.), 1998, Critical Realism / Essential Readings, Routledge,
London, Norris, C., 1995, Truth, Science
and the Growth of Knowledge, New Left Review, 210, March - April.
: , . - Benton, T.
Grundman, R., 1995, : ,
, , .
37
Bhaskar, R., 1989, The Possibility of Naturalism, Harvester, Herfordshire, ch. 1 2.

Norris, 1995, 110-113.
38
, ,
: , .,
, : , . (.), 1998, ,
, , .
383
, ,
, , .
, ,
:
,
,
.
,
.
..
, , (usability)
.
,

.
. Knorr-Cettina Mulkay,
[]

,
(puzzling) , ,
.

39.
,

, ,

(intransitive) ,
,

39
Knorr-Cettina, K. - Mulkay, M. (eds.), 1983, Science Observed: Perspectives of the Social Study of
Science, Sage, London, 6.
384
(transitive)
-
40.
, (Bhaskar,
1989), - .
.
,
( )

,
, , ...41 , ,
- Bhaskar-
( ;,
, ,...;) (
;, ;). , ,
,
,
Bhaskar (1989, ch.
2), ,
.
40
/ , Bhaskar,
, , .
-
(object-domain)
(, , ) .
41
,

.
.

[with all the other stories we want to tell...]. .Rorty, R., 1992, Objectivity,
Relativism and Truth, Cambridge U.P., Cambridge, 82.
385

, ,
,
-
42 ,

, , -
(causal dispositions),
. , (

- )

.

, ,
, ,
, .
,

.

(absolutism).

-

.
.
, .
, ,

42
Rorty, R., 1979, Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature, B. Blackwell, Oxford, 175.
386
. ,
,
, ,
.
387
16
-
60 -
, ,
. , ,
. ,

.

.
, ,
,
, .

, ,
.
,

. - -,
, .
, , ,

. ,
. ,
,
,
. , ; ,
, ,
.

388
,
,
. , ,
, ,
. ,
,
.

.

.
-
, , -
, .
, , -
,
, , ,
,
20 ,
.
.

-
1. ,
1
, , ,
,
o Talcott Parsons.
, . ,
Jeffrey Alexander,
: Neofunctionalism and Education in: Morrow, R. Torres, C., 1995, Social Theory and
Education: A Critique of Theories of Social and Cultural Reproduction, S.U.N.Y Press, New York,
79-113.
389
, ,

. , ,

. . Lynch, []
,
.
,
.

,
.

,

[ ]
,

.

[ ]

2. Lynch
. ,
, ,
,
, ,
, ,
. , , : ,
,
.
2
Lynch, K., Research and Theory on Equality and Education in: Hallinan, M. (ed.), 2000, 100-101.
390
, , ,
,
. , ,
. , ,
. . , ,

.
,
, ,
,

. , ,
, , ,
. , ,
, .
, ,

.
60

.

,
.
, ,
.
,
,
,
. , ,
Morrow-Torres, []
(correspondence
principle)
,
-
391
,
[
] (causal nexus)
.
, -
()
(fallibilistic),
3. ,

,

. ,

,

, 4. , ,
,
.
, ,
. Halsey at al. []

70. ,

Morrow, R. Torres, C., A., Education and the Reproduction of Class, Gender and Race:
Responding to the Postmodern Challenge in: Torres, C., A. Michell, Th., 1998, 19-45.

, Henry Giroux, ,

, ,
, (function) , ,
, (Giroux, 1997,
89).
392
. []
(Halsey at al.,1997, vi). ,
,
,
.
Halsey at al.: , ,
- - .
Bernstein
Bourdieu. .
, , , ,
A. McPherson D. Raffe
, , J. Coleman
- ,
W. Mller
. ,
.[ ]
70.
.

, 70

. .
,
. ,
, -:
, ,
(vii).

, ,
5.

5
. Globalizing
Education: Perspectives from Above and Below in: Apple, M. Kenway, J. Singh, M., 2005, 1-30
393
6.
, Halsey at al.,
. ,
, , ,
, .
80. H

Gramsci (Morrow-Torres, 1995, 249-281),
Habermas (Carr-Kemmis, 2000),
(Aronowitz-Giroux, 1991).
Wexler, , ,

.
.
, , /

,
(Wexler, 1987, xi). , Derrida, Foucault,
Baudrillard
, , .
, ,
,
,
6
, ,
, ,

. , ,

.
394
. ,
,
,
. ,

,
7 (Wexler, 1987, 81). ,

. ,
,
8.
,

. ,
, ,
. , ,
,
, ; (Wexler, 1987, 101).

Wexler, , Giroux
[ ] ,
. , ,
, .
.
:
10 / 1997 K. Nield P. Joyce (Nield, K., ;
, 5-22 Joyce, P., ,
23-33).
, .
Nield
:
, Paul Feyerabend,
(22). Apple: . Apple, M., What
Postmodernists Forget: Cultural Capital and Official Knowledge in: Halsey, 1997, 595-604.
395
; , ,

.
, ,
,
.
,
, ,

.
,

.
*****

, .

, ,
, .
, , .
, , .
.
, , ,
,
.
, ,
, .
,
9,
9
396

.
,

. , ,
,
.
,
.

, .
, ,
,

.

, ,
, ,
, .

:
.
,
,
.
, ,
, , . , ,
.
-
-
.
,
,
.
397
. , ,

,
- ,
(, 2002, 464-477).
, ,

.
, ,

. , ,
.

, ,
. ,
, ,
.
. ,
,
. ,

,
.
, ,
.

.
.
. ,

.
.
398
.

.

, ,
, ,
.

.
,
,
. ,

-
,

.
, ,

,

, ,
. ,
,

.

,
, ,
. ,

. ..
399
-
-

.

.
. , ,

. ,

, ,

.

-
, Habermas, , , .

-

.
, ,
, ,
, , ,
10. ,

(,
1992 , 2003)
10
(2005,
, ),
(, 1991)
.
400
. , ,

. , :

,
, , ,
. , ,

, . ,
,
- -.
, ,

.
,

.
, / ,

.
,
,
. , , , ,

.

.

401
, ,
.
, , .
,
. ,

. , ,

,
,
. , ,

. , ,
. ,

.
. -
-
.

.

.

.
,
, .

.
*****
402
-,
, , ,
. ,
,

, . -
, ,
-
: , ,

, ,
,
(, 2002, 58).

, , .
, , ,
,
-

T. Kuhn. ,
,
.
: , .
.
G. Walford,
.
[]

1.
,
.
,

. , , .
, ,
.
. , ,
. ;
;
;
, , , :

; ;
1
Walford, G.(ed.), 1987, Doing Sociology of Education, Falmer Press, East Sussex, 4.

.
vi
;
; ; ;

, ,
.
, ,

.
, ,
. ,

, ,

,
, . ,
,
,
,
,

.
, ,
, ,
- .
, , .
, ,

,
, ,
, . ,
vii
,
, .

,
/ ,
, , ,
. ,

,
.

.

.

-.. ,
, -
,
.
, ,
,

.
.
, 1-3,

.
, 4-15,
, , ,
,
.
, , 16,
.
viii

,
- , , ,

, .

διπλωματικη κοιν εκπ

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

διπλωματικη κοιν εκπ

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

2006

, ., 2005, -, , 92, 87-95

, .,1998, , , 88, 31-46

Apple, M., 1993, , ,

Apple, M., 2001, ,

, . Benton, T. Grundman, R., 1995, :

Bachelard, G., 2000, , ,

Barrington-Moore, M., 1978,

Bell, D., 1991, : , 1991, 621-697

Bell, D., 1999, , ,

Bernstein, B., 1991, , ,

Bertrand, Y., 1994, , ,

Blackledge, D. -Hunt, B., 1995, , ,

Bottomore, T., 1992, , ,

Bourdieu, P., 2002, : ,

Bourdieu, P., 2002, , ,

Bourdieu, P., 2004, , ,

Bourdieu, P.-Passeron,J.-Cl., 1996, , ,

, .-, .-,., 1986,

, ., 2005, Paulo Freire , ,

Carnoy, M., 1988, - , ,

Carnoy, M. Castells, M., 2001, H ,

Carr, W.-Kemmis, S., 2000, , ,

Charlot, B., 1999, , ,

Charlot, B., 2002, , , 125, 37-50

Chatelet, Fr., 1985, , ,

Collins, R., 2002, Max Weber, ,

Craib, J., 1998, , ,

Craib, J., 1998, : , 1998, 225-267

, .-, .(), 1993, , ,

, .-, .(), 1997, , ,

, ., 1998, , , 98, 37-44,

Davidson, D., 1981, , , 27/28, 183-205

De Queiroz, J.-M., 2000, , Gutenberg,

Devereux, E., Jr, 1996, Parsons : ,

Dreeben, R., 1997, :

Encyclopdie de la Pliade, 1991, , ....,

Engel, P., 2000, , Scripta,

Feyerabend, P., 1986, , ,

Geissler, E., 1997, , ,

Giddens, A., 1989, , ,

Giddens, A., 1997, , : ,

Giddens, A., 1998, ;

Glucksmann, M., 1998, Louis Althusser : , 1998, 79-133

Goffman, E., 2001, , ,

Grundy, S., 2003, : ; , ,

Habermas, J., 1987, , ,

Habermas, J., 1990, , ,

Habermas, J., 1993, , ,

Habermas, J., 1997, , ,

Hacking, I., 2002, ,

100. Hansen, A., 1976, , ,

108. Jessop, B., 2001, :

120. , .-, ., 1994, :

194. M-, ., 1999, ,

271. Perrenoud, P., 1996, ; , ,

345. Wood, G., 1992, ,

77. Eagleton, T., 1992, Ideology, Verso, London

Blackledge, D.-Hunt, B., 1995 , , ,

Banks, O., xx, , , , 11-15.

De Queroz, J-M., 2000, , Gutenberg, , 37.

Devereux, E., Jr, Parsons , . (), 1996,

Craib, I., 1998, , , , 69-70.

. Devereux, 1996, 149-159 Craib, 1998,