Professional Documents
Culture Documents
For nearly 90 years our business has grown by exceeding our customers expectations. From quote to install, Amada exceeded ours.
Greg De Caster, CEO Badger Sheet Metal Works
Established in 1923 on the foundation of providing customers with the utmost in quality and service, Badger Sheet Metal Works has steadly grown to become one of the Midwests premier sheet metal fabricators. However, Greg De Caster, the companys CEO and a third generation owner of the family run business, was facing difficult challenges. De Caster put it in these terms, Our aging equipment couldnt keep up with the pull we were experiencing from our fabrication floor. We were no longer making state-of-the-art technology available to our customers and they deserved better. We needed to increase capacity and partner with a technology leader in order to automate both production and setup. De Caster turned to Amada to custom-engineer an integrated solution consisting of an FO 4020NT laser equipped with an automated load/unload system and two networked, Hybrid Drive System (HDS) press brakes. According to De Caster, his decision to partner with Amada is paying off. Weve increased the thickness capacity of what we can cut by 50%. And, were no longer starving our fabrication floor because Amada has resolved bottlenecks in our laser and bending areas. Amadas automated networked solution enabled Badger Sheet Metal Works to: Increase capacity (Equipped to process full 6.5x 13 sheets, the FO 4020NT is engineered to reliably and economically cut a wide variety of materials in a full range of thicknesses). Reduce lead time (The lasers user-friendly network control, cartridge style lens, and one-touch nozzle reduce setup. By incorporating an AMNC-PC control on the laser and two press brakes, Amada provided continuity which facilitates employee cross-training and greatly simplifies setup. The intelligent, network control also enables extremely efficient offline programming). Manage workflow and reduce costs (The networked laser and two NT press brakes, combined with an advanced automation system, enable automated setup while streamlining overall workflow. These efficiencies provide for quick turnaround and lower part costs regardless of lot size).
74 COVER STORY
Today lean thinking has led many to consider not just manufacturing costs, but also the costs that occur over the entire product life cycle. is is where hybrid laser-arc welding has really stepped up to the plateliterally. e technology can be used to weld high-strength steel parts e ectively, which is great news for the transportation industry as they look to reduce the weight of components.
Cover photo courtesy of ESAB Welding & Cutting Products, Florence, S.C.
contents
Features
Interest in incorporating more aluminum parts into nal product designs is causing fabricating operations to reconsider how they approach sawing this material. Traditionally, the conversation focused on circular saw technology to cut aluminum, but now new band saw developments have helped to expand the discussion. Why calculate values such as bend allowance, outside setback, and bend deductions? Because sometimes you will need to work your way around a bend on a print, and you may not have all the information you need to complete a at pattern. e issue for Laser Access employees wasnt getting the equipment running, it was the time they spent away from the machine, hunting for the right tools and material. ats why the Michigan shop took steps to keep the necessary tools nearby and neatly organized. Tejas Precision Metal Fabrication Services, San Antonio, needed to breathe new life into two of its older press brakes. Instead of ditching them for new models, company ownership invested in new controls. Estes Design and Manufacturing, Indianapolis, nds that laser welding produces a joint that is cosmetically appealing to customers. Were looking for an appearance that matches almost exactly the outside of a formed corner, said Jay Reddick, the companys laser welding development manager. Managing a shop full of a great number of incredibly diverse, short-run, nonrepeat orders can be a complicated undertaking. Fedtech, a St. Paul, Minn., fabricator, stays on top of all the activity by giving customers a single point of contact. Upon receipt of an order, one person shepherds the job through productionfrom cradle to grave.
80
78
According to the 2013 Capital Spending Forecast, to be published this month by the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association, projected spending for U.S. metal fabricators climbed 4 percent over last year. e total amount is just shy of readers projected spending before the recession.
Management Strategy
48 Biz Talk | Growth opportunities worth trumpeting
88
e Fabricators & Manufacturers Associations 2012 Salary/Wage & Benet Survey is out, and it proves a lucrative career awaits those fabricators willing to put in the work to hone their skills. Metal manufacturers that work with toxic chemicals should note that the EPA is issuing and considering other rulemakings that could a ect their manufacturing operations.
54 Around Washington | EPA adds to toxic chemical reporting requirement 60 Improvement Insights | Uptime
Many high-product-mix fabricators simply dont know the actual throughput rate of their machines, so they base their operations on guesses. is notion of it is what it is shouldnt be acceptable. Its waste and it should be eliminated. developments. As this Q&A with Plante Morans Je Mengel reveals, an innovative approach to a customer relationship can lead to a very successful supply chain partnership.
68 Chief Concerns | Beyond mere convenience Innovation doesnt have to be limited to technological 70 Chief Concerns | Show and tell time
e best metal fabricating partner in a supply chain is the one that not only provides on-time delivery of quality products, but also provides complete and open communication.
70
e perils of oversimplication Chris Kuehl, economic analyst for the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association and managing director of Armada Corporate Intelligence, Lawrence, Kan., o ers a reasonable look at taxes and what they mean to business planners.
contents
52
Departments
12 Editors Corner A metal fabricating road show
A group of about 50 fabricators got the chance to learn from their peers as they hit the road visiting six fabricating operations, two manufacturers of laser equipment, and one systems integrator of custom laser machines as part of e FABRICATORs Technology Summit in early October.
13 Readers Forum 16 Calendar of Events 24 Industry News TRUMPF Photonics celebrates 10 years | IMTS 2012: Unusual times in manufacturing
62
50 Product Highlights Safety light curtain protected from damage | Fiber laser system increases
thin-sheet processing speeds | Laser cutting system integrated in robot custom manufacturer streamline material handling
52 Applications Grill manufacturer saves time with improved welding control | Andon system helps 56 Precision Matters 3-D CAD: Productivity, reliability, and responsiveness
Columnist Gerald Davis discusses when formality should enter a CAD operators workow and o ers up an example of how a simple CAD task might go. Todays press brake operators need only download a bending program from the network directly to the machine control and bending can beginbut only after the right tooling has been put in place. Technology developments, however, may make that manual intervention a thing of the past. With behavioral-based robotics, which ditches the traditional teach pendant associated with robotic programming, the operator actually shows the robot how to accomplish a task. is could prove to be a good t in high-mix, low-volume manufacturing operations. Fabricators that worked with di cult-to-cut materials in the past often relied on traditional M42 bimetal band saw blades. However, a new band saw blade has been introduced that should give those fabricators longer blade life without the expense of carbide-tipped blades.
62 Technology Spotlight Automatic tool changer, meet the manual CNC press brake
64
66 Technology Spotlight Band saw blade lls the gap between M42 and carbide
e Know
e Back Page
66
Whats on thefabricator.com?
company production and design information. He has seen some companies su er as a result of inadvertently providing information about their fabrications to others. 60 percent of respondents to a survey on thefabricator.com chose the economy.
November web exclusive For CEOs: Industrial espionage or not? Regular contributor to thefabricator.com Carl Smith addresses protecting Participate in a survey. What issue matters most to fabricators in the November election? Not surprisingly, Look for manufacturing assistance. Research and compare metal fabricating equipment and service
Get the latest fabricating news. Like e FABRICATORs page on Facebook, and follow Dan Davis (@ fabricating) and Vicki Bell (@fabcomlady) on Twitter.
118
Learn how a ber laser not only changes the laser cutting process for a job shop, but also how it a ects other Find out the status of the current helium shortage and what that might mean for welders. Read about the proper way to maintain a setup on your ironworker to avoid edge distortion and bowing.
the fabricator
Editorial Advisory Board
Dan Berdass, Bermo Inc. Greg Cornett, Tennessee Stampings LLC Matthew Gehman, Metal Locking Service Matt Kalina, LAI International Subramaniam Manivannan, Accuride International Inc. Jim Poe, Iowa State University Roger Schulz, Monroe Truck Equipment
f you werent a part of e FABRICATORs Technology Summit in early October, you missed a great learning experience. About 50 attendees visited six fabricating operations, two manufacturers of laser equipment, and one systems integrator of custom laser machines. If the event didnt ignite innovationas its tag line suggestedit certainly got some people thinking about how they might change their own operations. What exactly did attendees see as they traveled around Minnesotas Twin Cities? ey got to see everything, from the automated manufacturing processes used to fabricate Ho man boxesone of the most recognizable brands in the metal manufacturing industryat Pentair Technical Products, Minneapolis, to the manufacturing might needed to construct giant grain handlers at Schlagel Inc. in Cambridge, Minn. At those stops and others they saw the latest in automated storage and retrieval systems that feed material to laser cutting machines with no human intervention; specialty laser cutting devices tailored for industries such as medical device and aerospace parts manufacturing; and even a ber laser that ripped through tubes, cutting shapes in a matter of seconds. But the biggest takeaways for attendees dont always involve the cutting-edge fabricating equipment. Instead, they might be a new, simple approach to a fabricating dilemma that frankly hadnt crossed their minds. Here are some examples: At Pentair Technical Products, the maintenance team implemented an alert system intended to minimize equipment downtime. When metal fabricating equipment initially goes down, the maintenance technician on duty and assigned to the area is notied. If enough time passes without a response, the maintenance supervisor is then contacted. Finally, someone involved with plant supervision is notied if no maintenance response occurs. is change and associated lean manufacturing principles have helped the company improve its production timefrom taking a blank from the turret punch to pulling it o of the nishing linefrom two days to four hours. Herold Precision Metals, White Bear Township, Minn., ensures that some of its hardware-insertion equipment can be moved easily with a lift truck so that cells can be created as needed. When a company goes through 10 million pieces of hardware a year, it needs the exibility to move hardware-insertion capability close to one of its 26 press brakes to eliminate extra handling of work-in-process. Bermo Inc., Circle Pines, Minn., laser-cuts stainless steel Not so surprisingly, even though parts using oxygen as an assist gas and has to contend with the roundtable discussion each oxide edges, which are not friendly to paint or powder coating adhesion. Instead of switching to the more expensive nitromorning of the two-day event gen assist gas, company management decided to invest in a chamber. When enough laser parts are collected, began with talk about fabricating shotblasting they are stacked on a perforated platform and loaded into technology, the topic worked the shotblaster with a lift truck. Once the shotblaster is up and running, the entire oxide-removal process takes about its way back to a di erent issue: two minutes, which is much more e cient than the previous . tumble method of agitation the company used to prep the metal edges for nishing.
Directors
Teresa Beach-Shelow, Superior Joining Technologies Inc. Robert Clark, Clark Metal Products Vivek Gupta, Texas ProFab Corp. Rick Hargrove, American Strip Steel/Marinoware William Je Je ery, IRMCO Dan McLeod, Brenco Industries Ltd. Carlos Mendizbal Prez, Industrias Selbor S.A. de C.V. Lyle Menke, Peddinghaus Corp. Ed Severson, SB Specialty Metals Gregg Simpson, Ohio Laser LLC Jerry Ward, METCAM Inc.
people
Not so surprisingly, even though the roundtable discussion each morning of the two-day event began with talk about fabricating technology, the topic worked its way back to a di erent issue: people. How can technology help to get inexperienced workers more productive more quickly? What are the best ways to extract the fabricating experiences of veteran employees so that knowledge doesnt leave the shop when they retire? What are the best ways to let inexperienced workers gain valuable shop oor experience without threatening product quality or on-time deliveries? In the end, the metal fabricating business is still a people business. And what better way is there to learn than from other people in the business? ats why these and other Fabricators & Manufacturers Association educational events are so valuable. Fabricators are learning from each other as much as they are learning from discussion and seminar leaders. Fabricators looking for a similar learning experience might want to make plans to attend e FABRICATORs Leadership Summit, Feb. 27-March 1, 2013, at the Innisbrook Golf & Spa Resort, Palm Harbor, Fla. is event focuses more on best practices related to shop operations and business decisions. Check www.fmanet.org for more details as the event gets closer. Of course, events such as e FABRICATORs Technology Summit wouldnt be possible without the courtesy o ered by those companies that welcomed us into their facilities: Pentair Technical Products, Prima Power Laserdyne, Schlagel Inc., Cambridge Metals & Plastics, Herold Precision Metals, Bermo Inc., Innovative Laser Technologies Inc., Fedtech, and AltaMar. ey recognize the need to support the metal fabricating industry in the face of global competition. ats an easy lesson to learn.
For more information on FMAs Certied Education Centers, visit our hotlink at www.fmanet.org/cecs
the fabricator
Published by FMA Communications Inc.
833 Featherstone Road Rockford, IL 61107-6302 815-399-8700 | Fax 815-484-7700
Sta
President & CEO, FMA Communications Inc.: Edward Youdell Group Publisher: Dave Brambert Editor-in-Chief: Dan Davis, dand@thefabricator.com Senior Editor: Tim Heston, timh@thefabricator.com TPJ e Tube & Pipe Journal Editor: Eric Lundin, ericl@thefabricator.com Green Manufacturer Editor: Kate Bachman, kateb@thefabricator.com Practical Welding Today Associate Editor: Amanda Carlson, amandac@thefabricator.com Contributing Editor: Amy Nickel Senior Copy Editor: Teresa Chartos Graphic Designers: Mary Mincemoyer, Janell Drolsum, Margaret Clark, Jennifer Paulson Publication Coordinator: Kelly Palmer Director of Circulation: Kim Clothier Circulation Manager: Brenda Wilson Data Verication Specialist: Rhonda Fletcher Senior Fulllment Specialist: Anna Peacock Web Content Manager: Vicki Bell Multimedia Specialist: Sherry Young Senior Web Developer: Jason Bartholme Web Developer: Johanna Albee
Advertising Sales
Associate Publisher: Jim Gorzek, jimg@thefabricator.com 815-227-8269 Senior Account Representatives: Michigan/Northeast: Sean Smith, seans@thefabricator.com 815-227-8265 Ohio/Southeast/International: Mike Lacny, mikel@thefabricator.com 815-227-8264 West/Arkansas/Louisiana/Mississippi: Tony Arnone, tony@thefabricator.com 815-227-8263 Indiana/Iowa/Minnesota/Missouri/ Wisconsin/Canada: Amy Hudson, amyh@thefabricator.com 815-227-8237 Alabama/Florida/Illinois/Tennessee: Michael Scott, michaels@thefabricator.com 815-227-8271 Classied Advertising: Patty DAmico, patriciad@thefabricator.com 815-227-8278 France Representative: Arnaud Vacherand Pressedition SA www.metal-industries.com German Representative: Lutz Krampitz Im Schlenk 34 47055 Duisburg, Germany Phone 49-203-4568-266 Fax 49-203-4568-538 krampitz@krampitzVv.de
Statement of Policy
13
As the o cial publication of the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association, International, e FABRICATOR recognizes the need and importance of disseminating information about modern metal forming and fabricating techniques, machinery, tooling and management concepts for the metal fabricator. e policy of the publisher and this journal is to be nonpartisan, favoring no one product or company. e representations of fact and opinions expressed in the articles are those of the author and are not necessarily endorsed by the publisher and this journal. By including information on new products, new literature, news of the industry, articles, etc., this impartiality is strived for and extends to the mention of trade names. Unless product identication makes the reference unavoidable, the generic name is used. We acknowledge that on occasion there may be oversights and errors; the editors regret such oversights and re-emphasize their policy to be impartial at all times. e publisher reserves the right to refuse advertising deemed inappropriate for publication in e FABRICATOR, including ads for classes of products and services not considered of signicant interest to the readership. e FABRICATOR is a service mark and a trademark of the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association, International, and is used, under license, by FMA Communications Inc. Standard Rate & Data Service lists our advertising rates in Section 88. Consult SRDS or our current rate card for full rates and data. Publications of FMA Communications Inc. maintain a policy of keeping editorial and advertising separate to ensure editorial integrity that most benets our readership. Editorial content, including feature articles and press releases, is determined solely by the publisher. Editorial content cannot be purchased, nor can it be used as a benet of advertising dollars spent. Editorial is free-of-charge, subject to space availability, and open to all interested parties that submit items meeting our editorial style and format as determined by the publisher. Note: Some photographs printed in this publication may be taken with safety equipment removed for photographic purposes. However, in actual operation, it is recommended that correct safety procedures and equipment be utilized.
Readers Forum
(continued from page 13) software with original settings. If the problem goes away, you likely have a corrupted registry. 4. Use SolidWorks to edit the templates you are using. e part template should have its units set to three decimals, same with the drawing template. is is a long shot and probably wont have any impact on your problem, but it is a good thing to standardize anyway.
e Sliver Lining
I was wondering if your publication has ever published any articles on dealing with slivers on stamped products. Also, is there a way to locate and search through back issues of your publication? Robert Fishel Tyco Electronics Corp. Greensboro, N.C. Editors Note: Most of the articles that have appeared in e FABRICATOR, STAMPING Journal, Practical Welding Today, and TPJ- e Tube & Pipe Journal for the last 10 years now can be found on thefabricator.com. On this particular subject, we recommend Piercing, cutting aluminum sans slivers, by STAMPING Journals Die Science columnist Art Hedrick. e article can be found at http://www.thefabricator.com/article/toolanddie/piercing-cutting-aluminumsans-slivers or by typing the article title in the search box in the upper righthand corner of the home page.
Calendar of Events
NOV. 7 9 TOLEDO, OHIO Spray Finishing Technology Workshop DeVilbiss, Binks and Owens Community College 800-466-9367 www.owens.edu/workforce_cs/ spray2012-brochure.pdf NOV. 11 LAS VEGAS RUN4MFG 5K Charity Run Fabricators & Manufacturers Assn. 888-394-4362 www.fmanet.org NOV. 12 14 LAS VEGAS FABTECH FMA, SME, AWS, PMA, CCAI 888-394-4362 www.fabtechexpo.com NOV. 13 15 HARTFORD, CONN. Fundamentals of Brazing Kay & Associates 860-651-5595 www.kaybrazing.com DEC. 11 13 ORLANDO, FLA. Power-Gen Intl. PennWell Corp. 888-299-8016 www.power-gen.com DEC. 13 NOON 1:00 P.M. Webinar: How to Specify Robot Systems Robotic Industries Assn. 734-994-6088 www.robotics.org JAN. 20 22, 2013 CORONADO, CALIF. Aluminum Symposium Platts 800-752-8878 www.platts.com JAN. 21 24 CHICAGO Automate 2013 (co-located with ProMat) Association for Advancing Automation 734-994-6088 http://automate2013.com FEB. 26 28 HOUSTON Houstex Society of Manufacturing Engineers 800-733-4763 www.houstexonline.com FEB. 27 MARCH 1 PALM HARBOR, FLA. e FABRICATORs Leadership Summit Fabricators & Manufacturers Assn. 888-394-4362 www.fmanet.org
Plasma, lasers, and waterjets can be used successfully to cut plate to size. This 90-minute webinar will explore the bene ts and limitations of each of the available cutting methods, providing you with the facts that you need to select the best method for your unique operation. Fee: $129 (FMA/TPA Members save $30)
NOV. 14 15 RALEIGH, N.C. Design2Part e Job Shop Co. 800-225-4535 www.d2p.com NOV. 14 15 MONTREAL AeroCon UBM Canon 310-445-4200 www.canontradeshows.com/expo/ aerocon12/ NOV. 26 29 ORLANDO, FLA. Defense Manufacturing Conference Universal Technology Corp. www.dmc2012.com
is pump-source module, produced at TRUMPF Photonics in New Jersey, will be integrated into the companys disk laser system.
At the heart of a laser diode is a semiconductor, which has a very useful property: It converts electrical power into light power. Using processes like metal-organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD) and photolithography, the Cranbury factory works on the microscopic scale. To grow the gallium-arsenide (GaAs)-based semiconductor material, specialized processes deposit more than a dozen layers of di erent thicknesses, from 1 micron down to about 7 nanometers13 atoms stacked on top of one another. Each layer is tailored so that the semiconductor material produces the desired light for the application. ese grown wafers are processed into chips, which are then mounted onto an electrically conductive submount or heat spreader. ese devices become part of an integrated laser system, such as a pump source delivering more than 10 kW of power for solid-state disk lasers. As Leibinger explained, TRUMPF managers knew of the laser diodes potential in the 1990s, but at the time most of the laser diode work tended to be focused on what was the hottest industry of the day: telecommunications, a sector that was laying the ber-optic cable that
I think we need to return to that traditional American respect and even glorication of research. It is really an American characteristic.
Rep. Rush D. Holt, D-N.J.
What drew TRUMPF to Princeton Lightwave was not only its technology, Leibinger said, but also its people and location. A short drive away is Princeton University where Albert Einsteinwho predicted the possibility of a laser decades before it was invented in the 1960sheld o ce hours. e surrounding area is a hotbed of photonics and for technical companies in general, so much so that it has become known as Einsteins Alley. Guest speaker Rep. Rush D. Holt, D-N.J., was quick to point this out.
The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
29
Technicians at Local Motors build one of the companys Rally Fighter vehicles at the 2012 International Manufacturing Technology Show in Chicago, Sept. 10-15.
e company itself is not just a custom car manufacturer. Jay Rogers, Local Motors president, CEO, and founder, said his companys car designs result from crowd sourcing, taking design ideas from a virtual community of would-be Henry Fords. In fact, the Rally Fighter design, which is built upon steel-tube frames and with composite body panels, came from an art school student. Its an open-sourced car, but it comes from DIY roots, the Harvardeducated Rogers told an IMTS crowd on the opening day of the show. Such is manufacturing today. Rogers called his companys approach to manufacturingand eventually sales and servicing of its carsdisruptive when compared to the current way automobiles are designed, built, sold, and serviced. Manufacturers are similarly facing challenging times, particularly as they struggle to maintain high levels of productivity without adding labor cost. In a way, these metal manufacturers are being challenged to embrace disruptive technologies of their own. IMTS featured several examples:
hours and has room for two batteries. At the very least, these types of technologies and others on display at IMTS have the potential to keep metal manufacturers ahead of the competitors down the street and around the world. As Dr. Rebecca Blank, acting secretary of the U.S. Department of Commerce, told attendees during opening day remarks, U.S. manufacturers are on a roll in recent years, pushing manufacturing output
up 20 percent since 2009 and increasing manufacturing exports 36 percent between 2009 and 2011. Investment in new technology is one true way to ensure that manufacturers continue on the path to increased productivityand hopefully protability. ats the plan for many companies, no matter what bad news may be found in the morning headlines.
Dan Davis, Editor-in-Chief
31
866-872-4868 www.pivatic.com
Pivatic_Turret_vs_Pivatic_final.indd 1
7/13/11 11:28 AM
35
Web news
Caml Farr Air Pollution Control (APC) has partnered through its ltration system, which ultimately delivers with Arkansas State Universitys Center for Digital Initia- clean air back to the factory. tives (CDI) to create a 3-D animated video titled Clean FANUC FA America, Ho man Estates, Ill., has launched Air Rocks at www.camlfarrapc.com/videos/77. e a new website at www.fanucfa.com with enhanced re3.5-min. video takes viewers on a virtual tour through sources and functionality and expanded content. e the inside of the companys Gold Series dust collector. website features detailed information on the companys 7569 Koike_Liebherr_Fabricator_Nov_2012 10/2/12 5:25 PM Page 1 e video places viewers alongside dust particles as they CNCs, drive systems, laser systems, service, and support. (continued on page 42) travel from the workplace into the dust collector and
To be the preferred supplier of welding positioning equipment to Liebherr USA, you have to do a lot of things right. And Koike Aronson does. The Virginia facility of Liebherr, one of the worlds leading manufacturers of mining equipment, has been buying welding positioners from Koike for years. Some of the original machines are still in operation, reports Jim Farley, project manager. And the service support is terrific. When it comes to responsiveness we can get directly to a person who can help. The guys on the floor are sold on Koike, too. I love the Head and Tailstock, says Fabrication Lead Man Charles Moler. Koike worked with us so it was designed to fit our needs and reduce set-up time for each rotation.
Koike Aronson Ransome Head and Tailstock positioning a Liebherr mining truck frame.
Fabrication Supervisor
Fabrication Manager
Follow us on
www.koike.com
41
Supplier news
(continued)
e GSI Group Laser Division, a manufacturer of CO2, Nd:YAG, and ber lasers for industrial applications, has rebranded as JK Lasers. Established in 1972, the company began as a manufacturer of pulsed lasers, followed by Nd:YAG systems for welding, cutting, and drilling. In 1982 the company was acquired by Lumonics of Canada and developed and installed the worlds rst ber-optic delivery system on a
solid-state laser. Lumonics merged with GSI in 1999 and, following the sale of the Lumonics brand, the laser segment of the business changed its name to the GSI Group Laser Division. OMAX Corp., manufacturer of abrasive waterjet machines and accessories, has announced plans to expand its Kent, Wash., facility with a new, 22,000-sq.-ft. building. (continued on page 44)
Supplier news
Aicon 3D Systems GmbH, Braunschweig, Germany, has acquired more than 80 percent of Breuckmann GmbH, Meersburg, Germany, from Austria-based voestalpine Group. Dr. Bernd Breuckmann, founder and former owner-manager, holds 20 percent shares in the company. e brand Breuckmann GmbH remains unchanged. Breuckmann GmbH is a manufacturer of optical systems for contactfree, 3-D measurement, digitization, and inspection. Aicon is a provider of optical camera-based, 3-D measurement systems. Genesis Systems Group has received the new certied robot integrator designation from the Robotic Industries Association (RIA), Ann Arbor, Mich. To become certied, integrators go through a rigorous process which includes an on-site audit, safety training, and hands-on testing of key personnel, among other important criteria, said Je Burnstein, president of RIA. e program allows integrators to benchmark their own processes against best industry practices, allowing them to identify areas in which they can improve. Eight companies have received the designation since the program began in January 2012.
43
Swagelok Co., Solon, Ohio, has acquired the assets of Innovative Pressure Technologies (IPT), Erie, Pa. IPT is a manufacturer of highand medium-pressure and subsea valves, ttings, and uid control devices used mostly in oil and gas, chemical/petrochemical, waterjet cutting, automotive, and water blasting applications. Swagelok is a provider of uid systems, including products, assemblies, and services for the research, instrumentation, pharmaceutical, oil and gas, power, petrochemical, alternative fuels, and semiconductor industries.
Steel news
Aurora Capital Group, a Los Angeles-based private equity rm, has announced that its a liate Aurora Resurgence has sold New Star Metals Inc. and its Premier Resource Group and Electric Coatings Technologies subsidiaries to an a liate of Insight Equity Holdings LLC. In conjunction with this transaction, Aurora Resurgence also sold the U.S. Metals and Supply division of New Star to Custom Steel Processing Inc., Madison, Ill., and retained its ownership of Miami Valley Steel Service, Piqua, Ohio. Under Aurora Resurgences ownership, Miami Valley will continue to provide valueadded processing and distribution of sheet steel products to a diverse array of end markets. Bushwick Metals LLC, Bridgeport, Conn., has announced the acquisition of Tarco Steel Inc. and Metal Fab
Aaron Walker
MC MACHINERY
A SUBSIDIARY OF
SYSTEMS, INC.
MITSUBISHI CORPORATION
EDM | LASER | WATERJET | MILLING | HIGH-SPEED VMC | PRESS BRAKE AUTOMATION | CONSUMABLES | PRE-OWNED | SERVICE | FINANCING
BOOTH C3040
People news
Provider of product cost management software for discrete manufacturers in Concord, Mass., aPriori has announced the appointment of Eric Sockol as CFO. He is responsible for the companys nancial and adminThe FABRICATOR | NOVEMBER 2012
45
www.Mitsubishi-World.com/eX 630-616-5920
47
Biz Talk
e all know wage growth in this country is next to nothing. Its one reason that the presidential election season has been so contentious. Employees continue to work harder than ever, while employers hesitate to hire more people. But metal fabricators and other manufacturers have another problem: Some would like to hire more, but they cant nd the skilled talent they need. Its been this way for years, of course. If skills are in high demand, many assume that higher pay would follow such demand, and to some extent it has, as reported by the Fabricators & Manufacturers Associations 2012 Salary/Wage & Benet Survey. As just one example, a code welders average salary has risen more than 3 percent since 2010not very impressive, but the pay increase isnt nonexistent, as so many people have experienced since the recession. During the election season, as politicians trumpeted the benets of a manufacturing renaissance, manufacturing salaries at or below average made a few headlines. In early October a Chicago Tribune reporter talked with several workers at an East Peoria, Ill., Caterpillar plant. One worker left a job as an assistant manager at a fast-food restaurant to work at Cat, only to nd himself making $15.57 an hour installing fenders. At the fast-food restaurant he was making more than $17 an hour. [Working at the fast-food restaurant] was one of the easiest jobs Ive ever had, and it was also the best-paying. is doesnt make manufacturing sound like a promising career at all. Even worse, whenever you hear of union negotiations in manufacturing, you always hear of wage concessions. e message: Workers today arent making as much as they once did. But we dont hear as much about people like Steve Ross. He started as a general laborer at Arin Inc., a Detroit-based low-volume stamping and laser cutting operation. He worked his way up, becoming a press operator, laser cutting machine operator, and nally plant supervisor. He literally starting sweeping the oors, and now hes running the shop. Small businesses dominate manufacturing, though they dont necessarily dominate the headlines. While workers at large factories ght for better pay, the best workers at small shops are rising through the ranks, either at one company or by moving from one small fabricator to the next. ey may start as a non-code welder making less than the $36,695 average salary as reported by FMAs survey, but eventually they may become certied in a specic code. As their skills grow, they make
If a welder starts at a belowaverage wage, chances are he eventually will be making well above averagefar above that of many who may have mounting student loan debt from a four-year college.
more and more. ey may stay where they are or move to other organizations. And if they get good enough, these code welders have a good chance of pulling in between $60,000 and $80,000 a year, or even more. For any given job in metal fabrication, the salary ranges are extremely broad. Most people dont work for wages at or near the average. Instead, standard deviations are high; the pay level is dispersed along a signicant range. Yes, the average code-welder pay is $45,238. But when you look at the minimum ($21,900), maximum ($83,000), and standard deviation ($14,137), you can see that the reality is more complicated. e standard deviation is almost a third of the average salary. What does this variation tell us? For one thing, one shop may dene a code welder di erently from the next, and a welder who becomes certied in one code may be paid more than one certied to another code. Most important, a code welder getting into the businessthough its certainly not guaranteedmay enjoy steady wage growth over the years. If most salaries were clustered near the average, it would be a di erent story. But as it is, wages are distributed. If a welder starts at a below-average wage, chances are he eventually will
be making well above averagefar above that of many who may have mounting student loan debt from a four-year college. Standard deviations are even larger when you get to front-o ce jobs as well as supervisory and management positions. An operations managers average salary in this business is $83,201, but the range of salaries reveals more about whats really happening. e minimum reported is $45,000, and the maximum is more than triple that number, at $150,000. Like Arins Steve Ross, a person may start sweeping the oor, then move up to hardware insertion, laser cutting, press brake operation and programming, department supervision, and then land a job as an operations manager starting at more than $50,000 a year. He may move to another fabricator, then another, then another before capping out at a six-gure annual salary. ats not a bad career. You might think that if a talented operations manager were to grow his salary signicantly, he would move on to a larger organization. But this may not necessarily be the case. Companies with more than 250 employees reported an average operations manager salary at more than $84,000, while the same position at shops with between 100 and 250 employees made an average of $99,000. Some rms with fewer than 50 employees reported similar salary ranges as their larger counterparts. is may be because so many metal fabrication managers wear many hats. A small companys president or vice president may also be the operations manager. Technical personnel may not make more money at larger plants either. For instance, the code-welder and press brake operator survey respondents making the most money werent at the largest operations. In fact, thats where on average they made the least money. Instead, the best-paying fabricators for these positions had between 100 and 249 employees. Regardless, the wide wage ranges for many jobs show a steady career path in metal fabrication. Workers wont get rich starting out. Like in any business, some companies are better to work for than others. Some fabricators pay well, and others do not, but the surveys pay ranges do reveal that opportunities for growth aboundnot just for top management, but also for various skilled personnel throughout the organization. Few elds these days o er that. During a time of anemic wage growth and a big squeeze on the middle class, such opportunities are worth trumpeting. To purchase a copy of FMAs 2012 Salary/Wage & Benet Survey, call 888-394-4362 or visit www. fmanet.org/store.
PRODUCTIVITY = PROFITABILITY
cole-tuve, inc.
51
Resolution
e company hired Contour-Arc Inc. to manufacture a custom-built, CNC spot welding system. It consists of several major components built around the Siemens Sinumerik 802D CNC, using three axes of coordinated motion, and the Miyachi Unitek IS-120B inverter spot welding power supply. e system has four independent welding stations attached to two oscillating rotary index tables placed side by side. is conguration allows the operator to load the xtures on one side of the index tables while the machine is welding on the other side. In addition to the three motion axes and two rotary index tables, the control monitors and controls all functions of the machine, including the spot welding process. To accommodate the di erent material thicknesses of the rebox assemblies, the CNC interfaces with the power supply so the programmer can call up any number of prepro-
Situation
Robert H. Peterson Co. is a producer of gas grills and gas logs in City of Industry, Calif. Its nearly 230,000-sq.-ft. facility comprises all facets of the manufacturing process, including sheet metal fabrication, laser cutting, robotic welding, die and press brake forming, grinding, polishing, assembly, testing, packaging, and distribution. Recently, as part of the continuous ow manufacturing line for its new Echelon and Aurora gas grills, the company decided to automate the welding of large, cumbersome stainless steel grill rebox assemblies with a CNC spot welding system that would integrate into the line of fabrication, assem-
Resolution
e company installed a color-coded visual alert system from Industrial Andons. e andon system allows operators to communicate their needs in advance to
For a quick quote contact us online, or at 763-784-4600 ext. 105 Visit our website at www.LaserGrating.com
52 The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
Around Washington
Stephen Barlas, a freelance writer based in Arlington, Va., can be reached at sbarlas@verizon.net.
etal manufacturers should beware. e Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is in full-blown prosecution mode. e EPA ned two Washington state metalworking companies in September for failing to disclose their use of certain chemicals such as chromium and lead as theyand all metalworking companiesare required to do under the Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) reporting program. Under TRI rules, companies that use certain toxic chemicals are required to report annually about releases, transfers, and waste management of those chemicals at their facilities. e TRI program falls under the auspices of the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (EPCRA), which aims to inform communities and citizens of chemical hazards in their neighborhoods. North Star Casteel Products is a foundry that manufactures metal castings for various industries, including transportation, mining, and power generation. It coughed up a penalty of $87,000. Jorgensen Forge Corp. is a metal forging facility that primarily serves aircraft, aerospace, oil, gas, marine, and defense markets. It paid the EPA $73,600. ose nes remind the metal manufacturers that work with toxic chemicals that the EPA is issuing and considering other rulemakings that could a ect them. For instance, a new rule issued in July expands the data companies have to supply on Tier II forms required under the EPCRA. e
e nal rule amending the chemical and hazardous material reporting requirements addressed some of ACAs comments, but failed to address all of our concerns.
Timothy Serie, American Coatings Association
Some of the new data required on Tier II forms will help local emergency-response o cials speed up their reaction to a dangerous chemical release or spill. Here, companies will have to add such information to their Tier II reports as the name of the facilitys parent company and of the facility emergency coordinator. Some of these additions may seem unnecessary, such as latitude and longitude of the facility, but when you have some reporting companies using a post o ce box number as an address, the information is necessary. e latitude and longitude re-
engaged
definition: involved in activity
adj \in-'gjd, en-\
Weld Fume & Metal Cutting Dust Collection Systems Fire Prevention & Suppression Systems for Dust Collectors Dust Collection Systems Full-Plant / Ambient Air Cleaning Systems Oil Mist Collection Systems Aftermarket Replacement Filters & Maintenance
CALL: 888.ROBOVENT
W W W. R O B O V E N T. C O M
Scan this code with your smartphones QR Code Reader App.
Precision Matters
Gerald Davis is a job shop consultant and chairman of the board of DSM Manufacturing Co., gerald@glddesigns.com.
very operator of a 3-D CAD workstation is involved in a workowprobably several workows, truthfully. Also, depending on the deliverable, the workow of a 3-D part model differs from that involving the production of a 2-D manufacturing drawing. So heres a prediction: A persons rst experience using 3-D CAD immediately will result in a workow. at process probably will be focused on scanning through menus, looking for things that seem like they might do something desirable. is workow is the result of mental vision of the desired result but lack of knowledge of the needed terminology and technique. With each modeling session, the CAD jockeys workow will become less dependent on searching for methods and techniques. Instead, it becomes more a repetition of what worked last time. To some extent, the productivity of the CAD jockey automatically increases with experience. Once the CAD menu is memorized, the mouse clicks and keystrokes just happen faster. Heres another prediction: is emerging skill set of CAD techniques will stagnate until something goes wrong. Everything goes wrong initially, and as techniques are being mastered, very little productive work is being performed. Sometimes the same model is remodeled repeatedly from scratch simply to take advantage of some new CAD ability.
FIGURE 3a We need to change the wall from 2 in. to 2.5 in. A simple change, right?
FIGURE 3b e simple edit caused the complex part to fail. e modeling techniques used did not anticipate the need to change the wall thickness. Typically, however, the pressure to change the workow comes externally in the form of product design revision. Obsolescence, market demand, and product performance have their perpetual impact on CAD workow. e task to change an established model in a specic way forces the CAD jockey to evaluate the consequences of the modeling techniques that were used. ose techniques that prove to be easy to edit within the constraints of the overall manufacturing process will be incorporated to improve the future CAD workow. However, some CAD modeling techniques are very di cult to edit. Figures 3a and 3b show a slightly complex model before and after a simple edit. In Figure 3a we see a through-window cut in a wall and are looking at a trough inside the box. I changed the shelled wall thickness from 2 in. to 2.5 in. e result is shown in Figure 3b. Numerous features have failed. It is going to take some serious CAD labor to change this model successfully because of the CAD techniques that were used originally. With this in mind, our plan is to purge the rookie mistakes and improve the CAD workow.
FIGURE 1 Two modeling techniques are compared. Which model would you rather build?
Left 4 in. 3 setups/6 cycles Depends on grinding and welding 55.671 sq. in. 4.992 x 11.785
Right 12 in. 3 setups/6 cycles Depends on sheet metal and welding 54 sq. in. 15.168 x 11.812
FIGURE 2 A comparison of the left-hand model and right-hand model shown in Figure 1 reveals that the left-hand model is a much more complete design.
em?
at kind of insight into the various kinds of CAD deliverables and related workows may change the way the CAD jockey approaches a task. It is a rookie mistake to enter a brainstorming session with fabrication as the only priority. Exploration and discovery are higher priorities at the early stage of the products CAD evolution. Once the design evolves from concept to planning, design for manufacturing enters into the selection of modeling techniques. Quick blobs give way to realism and detail. e persistence of CAD techniques like parametric links that may be used in this middle stage of product design remain responsive to changes, but not to the same extent as can be accommodated during the rst stage of modeling. Detail and specication bring inertia that impedes design revision.
e blessing and curse of 3-D CAD is that many paths lead to the same result.
Invention requires speedy modeling. In this particular mode, a CAD operator isnt worrying about rebuild times, drafting standards, or manufacturability. Parametric links are necessary and useful; le names are arbitrary. e only real standard is speeda need to visualize the products design quickly. My recommendation is that if you can extrude faster than you can revolve, then extrude. But in your training time, develop the speed skill to revolve, so you can select a technique when it makes optimal sense. Fond readers of this column may recall that revolves are kinder to the CPU than extrudes. Final release of a product to manufacturing may not tolerate the CAD techniques that were required for invention and initial product visualization. Consider a parametric link between a screw and a chassis. e chassis has a hole that follows the screws position in the assembly. It is wonderful to be able to keep the hole and the screw together while stretching and pulling the design during the product development modeling sessions. Once the design is committed to manufacturing, the hole should no longer be linked to the location of the screw. In the production CAD model, the location of the screw should be driven by the holes location. Now lets put the apparent workow conict in a di erent light: e designer cares about where the screw is, while the fabricator cares about where the hole is. Sometimes the designer and the fabricator are the same CAD jockey, just at di erent moments of the day.
The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
57
FIGURE 5a Drawing templates can be set up to display information that is stored in the 3-D model. is gure shows the raw links that make the magic happen.
Cosen_TV_MAY12FAB.qxd:Layout 1 4/11/12
e CAD department has standards for preparation of nal documentation and models. Such standards apply later in the products design life. Perhaps one element of that standard for nal models species that all modeled features be renamed with meaningful titles and descriptions. For example, Cut-Extrude19 gets renamed as Trigger Axle Pocket. at plain language policy is rational for models of parts that are in production. In future years, the CAD jockeys that revise the 10:52 AM Page 1 model will benet from the clarity in the documentation that is built into the models history. Such diligence about feature names is a complete waste of time for models that are as likely as not to be deleted in the next few minutes. Brainstorming sessions do not benet from detailed policy and procedure. Manufacturing does not benet from a fragile and poorly administered CAD database. us, we see the need for optimized workows that anticipate hand-o as the product moves from concept to prototype to production and maintenance.
FIGURE 5b Custom Property tab forms speed the data-entry process. Drop-down lists are surprisingly fun to use. Just type the rst letter and the rest of the eld lls in magically.
FIGURE 5c BOM templates standardize the tables appearance. Details like BOM tables make purchasing and production planning personnel happy.
C-650MNC
SH-1000DM
C-760FNC
FIGURE 5d Gauge tables help the CAD jockey to select the correct material, thickness, inside bend, and k-factor. Dont you wish all of your customers used your gauge tables so their parts at layouts were always correct? Hey! Send them your templates.
SH-500M
COSEN SAWS, USA 11626 Wilmar Blvd., Suite B Charlotte, NC 28273 877-SAWING1 704-943-1030 704-943-1031 (fax)
www.cosen.com
info@cosen.com
FIGURE 5e e prize goes to the swift. By using the combination of templates and data-entry forms, the CAD jockey can complete a drawing like this in minutes.
in packages that have increasing levels of capability and cost. We also have looked at a few of the accessory tools that are not part of the basic licensesheet metal costing and mechanical load/strain simulation in particular. e goal of that shallow exploration of software tools is to alert you to the wide scope of solutions for sale that address specic CAD workow issues.
ronment. Be a frequent saver. It gives you time to think about what youre modeling. 7. Create a 2-D drawing using our drawing template. is automatically gives us a drawing that looks like it is ours. Title block and notes are all perfect and complete. 8. Import model dimensions and annotation views and add dimensions to the views. Figure 5e is an example of a 10-minute drawing. Now that Ive published it for the entire world to see, I realize I didnt dimension the slots. Ill leave that for you to nish up. 9. Save the parts drawing.
Excluding Step 8, such a 9-step workow could be routinely completed in less than ve minutes. Adding dimensions and special notes to a drawing is an artistic endeavor and might take another 15 minutes for a typical sheet metal part. It will be fun to read this article 10 years from now to see what ination has done to time, but 20 minutes to make a fabricators drawing isnt too bad.
Gerald Davis uses CAD software to design and develop products for his clients at www.glddesigns.com. Send your questions and comments to dand@thefabricator.com.
In future years, the CAD jockeys that revise the model will benet from the clarity in the documentation that is built into the models history.
A CAD Workow Example
With all of that said and in place, we now set up an example CAD task scenario. Our mission, should we decide to accept it, is to produce a manufacturing drawing for a sheet metal part. Our nal drawing is to detail both the at and folded conditions of the part. e model for the part is given to us as a STEP le. Heres our step-by-step CAD workow: 1. Open the STEP le using our part template to set up default custom properties, material, unit of measure, drafting standard, and color scheme automatically. 2. Diagnose and correct any imported feature errors. If import diagnostics fail, then this workow ends. We might request the same model in a di erent CAD format, but if we cant get a good model to start, we dont start. 3. Save the parts model le in a meaningful location with a useful name. 4. Use our Custom Property form to enter the title block and BOM information so it will be saved in the parts model. 5. Add features to the part so it will unfold. For example, use the Convert-To-Sheet Metal tool. 6. Save the parts model again and do it often. is isnt a knock against the CAD so much as it is awareness of networked le locations and complex software in a collaborative enviThe FABRICATOR | NOVEMBER 2012
MC MACHINERY
A SUBSIDIARY OF
SYSTEMS, INC.
MITSUBISHI CORPORATION
EDM | LASER | WATERJET | MILLING | HIGH-SPEED VMC | PRESS BRAKE AUTOMATION | CONSUMABLES | PRE-OWNED | SERVICE | FINANCING
VISIT US AT FABTECH
BOOTH C3040
Waterjet technology can open the door to big opportunities, new revenue streams and more cost-effective production. Explore your options with Mitsubishia partner with decades of diverse manufacturing experience and the best support network in the business. Well get you up to speed with the new MW3 waterjet a fast, durable and cost-effective way to get your feet wet then keep you going strong long after installation.
59
Improvement Insights
Uptime
f the iPhone represents electronics magic, then the latest versions of cutting, punching, stamping, bending, and robotic welding machines represent electromechanical magic. e two words that describe these machines are faster and betterevery year. As an engineer, I love this stu .
Bu ers
We have all heard the old sawcapacity solves everything. ats true if the process is under control and everything means predictable cycle and lead-times. And for what were talking about, it is true. We all see the e ects: Cycle and lead-times are much shorter when we operate at 50 to 60 percent capacity utilization than at 80 to 90 percent capacity utilization. And they are more predictable. So if you want short, predictable cycle times, increase your realizable capacity. Ergo, we want faster, better equipment. But do we have to do this? Shouldnt we examine what our capacity should be with our existing equipment? is comes with the concurrent need to improve cycle times, which means reducing and controlling WIP within a single-point scheduling control. is implies that building far ahead to reduce changeovers, cherry-picking jobs within a multipoint shop oor control, and other production maladies have to goforever. e reason that this approach holds so much improvement potential is that, in general, current uptime (capacity) often is not what we think it isor if it is, were paying for it with high WIP levels and sluggish, unpredictable cycle times due to the maladies described above. In other words, we have high uptime but clogged ow, which means we sometimes have no choice but to create a capacity bu er with overtime. But if we increase our realizable capacity, we have the cycle-time benets of operating at reduced capacity utilization. We have our needed capacity bu er and dont need inventory or time bu ers.
Analyzing Downtime
In the last column, I wrote about ow and why focusing on ow improvement must inevitably involve the systematic reduction of waste times (and associated costs). Part of the waste time that a ects all multiproduct operations, and especially high-product-mix ones, is changeover times and, more generally, machine or equipment downtimeuptimes opposite. If the machine is down because of a changeover, its unavailable. If its down because of a breakage, its unavailable. If the material is not at the machine when it is t for use and ready to produce, then its e ectively unavailable. e e ect is the same: e green light is o . Variability in a process (in this case, high product mix, but in general, any variability) relates to the necessity for bu ers for a given service level. ese bu ers can be inventory, capacity, time, or any combination. ats really all of the variables you have at your disposal. e size and cost of the bu ers are directly proportional to the variability of the process. e inventory I refer to is either nished goods or, in some cases, almost-nished goods that are rapidly congured (sometimes called JIT customization) in one or two nal operations that are highly uid (not constraint) activities. is inventory is not usual work-in-process (WIP) or raw materials. (Raw inventory bu ers uncertainty and variability in your suppliers lead-times.) e capacity bu er is the excess real capacity over what you would need to produce one product at a xed lead-time on machines that are expertly sta ed and never break. e time bu er is the excess time you must guard band to ensure you meet the service level. In other words, you actually can do the job in two weeks but you quote three weeks to account for proc-ess variability.
What if we can improve the uptime by just 1 hour per shift, to 5.1 hours? What is the e ect? at gives an uptime of 66 percent. e capacity improvement is 24 percent, a very signicant amount. is means that the machine and its operator will produce 24 percent more product during the shift than they currently do. And the labor reporting system will say the operator is 24 percent more productive. To improve uptime, we need to look at what causes downtime, and this is usually a target-rich environment. ese are the common areas to measure: Operator verifying what job to run next. Operator translating job-build documents to tools, power levels, and other parameters for the machine. e physical changeover: installing tools. Called setup, this usually is not a major component in overall downtime even though it is usually what causes the most concern. Lack of standard/best changeover methods. Quality-check to verify setup. Operator nding material. Operator moving material. Implied break between jobs. No changeover metrics or standard times. Minor stoppages of machine due to overload, poor material, tool problems, etc. Machine breakage requiring maintenance work. Tool or lens breakages. Once these and possibly other areas are measured and assessed, its relatively straightforward to conduct a Pareto analysis to determine the time e ects on downtime, and to reduce or eliminate them. e effect on ow and protability can be enormous. Unfortunately, nowhere in our cost accounting systems and the performance measures we pull from them is a line item called uptime, by machine or aggregated into costcenter performance. But few metrics are more important or more revealing as a basis for performance improvement. Ill address the full metrics issues in a later column.
and observed have uptime/downtime metrics, and its mainly because people think it is di cult to measure. It is di cult, if performed continually. Some modern machine controls and third-party packages deliver uptime and OEE (overall equipment e ectiveness) metrics on a continuous basis. ey are very useful, but the actual detailed causes of downtime normally still require human observation and measurement. But almost all of the improvement information can be gained from an audit approach after a one-time data gathering, a Pareto exercise, and initial improvement efforts. is, I believe, is the best way for almost everyone to improve. In essence, you must ensure youre realizing
the capacity you already have. If you havent eliminated the wastes a ecting uptime in your existing machines, a faster and better machine may prove to be an expensive disappointment. Waste trumps magic. Dick Kallage is principal of KDC & Associates Ltd., 522 S. Northwest Highway, Suite UL-8, Barrington, IL 60010, 847-525-6109, www.kdcconsultants.com. Kallage serves on the Management Council of the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association and helps lead FMAs LeanFab, metal fabrication seminars dedicated to continuous improvement. For more information, visit www.fmanet.org or call 888-394-4362.
61
The RIGHT CNC Cutting Solution for Your Application and Budget
Plasma
Choose an innovative and versatile MultiCam CNC cutting platform to automate your productivity. An easy-to-use Plasma, WaterJet, Router or Laser machine enables anyone to master steel and nonferrous metal part cutting.
WaterJet
e machine has a six-axis backgauge with independent L1 and L2 to handle complex part geometries, so it can gauge o of two separate points.
Router
Laser
Heavy-duty, commercial-grade reliability Cut material waste, decrease job times and increase prots Over 9000 machines installed worldwide Local service, training and support from over 70 Technology Centers with 20 across North America
Still, operators must manually perform the tool change. Modern brakes certainly make the process simpler. Hydraulic clamping seats tools quickly and accurately, and advanced controls walk operators through the tool-change process step by step. is has shortened setup time, but nowadays fabricators may need to reduce that setup time further or make it more consistent through automation. Automatic tool change on a press brake traditionally has involved a robotic cell. But many shops use robotic press brakes only for high-volume work. Its certainly possible to set up these cells with numerous small-lot orders; o ine programming and robot simulation can make this effective. But even so, disparate parts
1025 West Royal Lane sales@multicam.com DFW Airport, TX 75261 www.multicam.com 972-929-4070 store.multicam.com
can require numerous grippers and various programming nuances, and the robot may not be able to handle every part geometry or bend requirement out there. Inserting and removing brake tooling, though, is a straightforward a air, at least relative to the e machine uses external, in-process sensors practically innite number of mothat measure one or both sides of the bend. tions a robot might perform to bend parts in a high-product-mix environment. So why not have a manually operated, CNC brake, but with an automatic tool changer? According to Scott Ottens, Schaumburg, Ill.-based bending product manager for Amada America, this was the thinking behind the companys HD 1003 ATC press brake. Available in models with 55- to 600-ton capacities and bend lengths from 79 to 276 inches, the press brake builds o tool-changing technology introduced some years ago in Amadas Astro robot bending cell. e new system has grippers above to handle the punches and below to handle the dies. Moving on horizontal tracks above and below the work area, the manipulators remove, retrieve, and insert tooling. A high-body, extended-open-height machine, the press brake can accommodate tooling heights of either 170 or 220 mm. e unit uses the companys modular robotic tooling with a push-button release and a slot machined into the tools for the manipulators to grab (though Ottens said that, if necessary for the occasional manual setup, the unit can accept Amada-style tooling without the slot). e modular tooling comes in various punch proles, and all the tools have a xed height, so you can load a gooseneck, a straight, a sash, and others all in the machine at the same time if need be, Ottens said. e storage unit has 15 stocking areas (dubbed stockers) for punches and 18 stockers for dies. Altogether the machine can store 86 feet of tooling. ese stockers handle several types of tools: longs, to be placed together for long bend lengths, and sectionalized tools for shorter bends. One stock area also can hold specials, such as hinge tools. To move longs, manipulators slide the sections in from the side; to insert narrower, sectionalized tools, the manipulators move down the track and click the tool into place. e system also remem-
bers tool placements. is means the manipulator can move tools used in the previous setup to new positions while retrieving new tools as necessary. e actual tool-change time depends on the application; complex setups take longer than simpler ones. But in one recent application for a fabricator in Wisconsin, we had about three tool stations to set up, and the tool changes took one to two minutes, Ottens said. e machine has a six-axis backgauge with an independent L1 and L2 to handle complex part geometries. If, say, a part has two edges in the back, and one extends farther out than the other, the L1 and L2 allow the system to gauge o those two separate points. e machine also uses external sensors (called BI, or bend indicators) that contact one or both sides of the bend to measure the angle. e sensors can be used for the rst part of the batch, selected parts throughout a batch, for every part in the run, or turned o temporarily. It all depends on user preference and the job requirements. Fabricators that use this machine will do a large number of setups throughout the day, Ottens said. One current application involves a company that needs to set up the brake about 25 to 30 times a day. ey use a bar code scanner to scan the job, call up the program, and let the thing go. It will load tooling, and the operator gets his blanks. By the time he returns to the machine, the tools are already in place. He then performs the bends, and within a few minutes he has his rst part.
Amada America Inc., 7025 Firestone Blvd., Buena Park, CA 90621, 714-7392111, www.amada.com
patmooneysaws.com 800-323-7503
64 The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
geting shops that have short runs. You can train the robot to a certain task, then move it over somewhere else to perform another task, then move back to the original task. e robot performs a pick-andplace task at a table that has an adjustable height. Once nished, its taken over to another workstation, taught a new routine in 15 minutes or so, then spends an hour performing the new job. Later in the afternoon, its taken back to the original table, which has since had its height adjusted for another worker. When Baxter returns, it knows to look for the current table height, wherever it might be, and adapts its motion to accommodate. Traditionally, robots have needed to be positioned down to the millimeter in order to function, Rosenberg said. Baxter is of an adaptive nature, so its possible for him to reposition himself and readapt, even if the job hes returning to is a table that is o by a few inches from the path he originally took. Its no coincidence that Rosenberg uses he and him to describe the system. As robots go, Baxter comes closer to a movie-style anthropomorphic creation than most other technologies in the industrial sphere. It comes complete with a head-like screen and two eyes that, like a human, gaze at the job at hand. In reality, ve cameras and a specialized sonar sensor are doing the looking. Also like a human, the robot stops if it touches an unexpected obstruction. e operation halts temporarily, but the person is unharmed. e robot can do this not only because of its sensors, but also because of its mechanical design. e joints give a little bit. ey have a springiness, Rosenberg said. In addition, it will detect whether a human is nearby, and it will slow its operation, so the person has time to get out of the way. In recent months the company has had several beta-level robots in operation at customer sites. And at this writing, the company planned to start shipping its rst products by the end of October. At this stage, the robot has been mainly performing simple assembly, packaging, and pick-and-place material handling. e current model has arms with a payload capacity of
The FABRICATOR | NOVEMBER 2012
5 pounds. By next year, though, the company hopes to integrate the system for simple machine operation. Rethink Robotics has no short-term plans to integrate Baxter into a welding scenario, a harsh and complicated environment. Press brake operations arent on the immediate horizon, either. e current focus remains on lowskill tasks, like pick-and-place operations, in low-volume, high-product-mix environments. Long-term, the company roadmap includes some inspection and quality tasks as well.
But as Rosenberg explained, the future direction of Baxter may depend largely on its early adopters. We have something so di erent from what exists that its very di cult to forecast what were going to do next with it. It will depend largely on what our customers decide to do with it. I expect there to be a substantial amount of experimentation by some innovative customers, and I expect they may be teaching us a thing or two. Rethink Robotics, 27 Wormwood St., Boston, MA 02210, 617-500-2487, www.rethinkrobotics.com
65
e nature of a metal fabricating shop is one of unpredictability. e shop oor just doesnt really know what the days schedule holds. When it comes The to sawing, fabricators traditionally 732 The Fabricator_MET-F-9732 Fabricator 10/8/12 11:39 AM Pagehave 1 relied on bimetal band saw blades with high-speed-steel teeth tips for most jobs. e blades were cost-e ective,
Carbide-tipped blades are generally three times the cost of bimetal blades.
Gene Ramsdell, e L.S. Starrett Co.
Until recently metal fabricators had to rely on carbide-tipped blades for these heavy-duty sawing applications. e shops that cut large volumes of specialty steels didnt mind the added expense of carbidetipped blades because the blades lasted longer and kept the band saws going. However, shops that didnt cut as much of the specialty material more than likely stuck with the traditional bimetal blades, even if they had to replace the blades much more frequently than if they were cutting plain carbon steel. For these shops, L.S. Starrett Co. introduced its Primalloy band saw blades for heavy-duty cutting applications. What this does is act as a bridge between M42 and carbide, Ramsdell said. is Primalloy has inherently better wear resistance than M42. And it also has 10 percent cobalt versus 8 percent on an M42 blade. at imparts better heat resistance. So those two will aid in giving the traditional user maybe a little bit more of a nancial advantage by not having to go into the carbide arena. Carbide-tipped blades are generally three times the cost of bimetal blades.
e wear resistance is provided by a vanadium content in the blade that is three times that found in M42 blades. e resulting carbide hardness is HRC 84. at heat and wear resistance are important traits when sawing metals with abrasive characteristics, such as tool steels, mold steels, and heat-treated alloy steels such as 4340 and 4150 (see Figure 1). ese di cult-to-cut steels tend to eat up M42 edge blades quite quickly. e new heavy-duty blades are also more adaptable to the band saws that most fabricators have on their shop oors, according to Ramsdell. Generally, carbide-tipped blades require a band saw with a very sturdy build because the blades tend to fracture when subjected to shocks or vibrations. e Primalloy blade is more forgiving, according to Ramsdell, and can run on machines designed for traditional bimetal band saw blades. e blade also has a new tooth design. e teeth have a 12-degree positive rake form that penetrates the workpiece easier than previous tooth designs. e company said the tooth tip chemistry contributes to longer blade life and increased cutting accuracy. e typical tooth hardness is HRC 69, compared to HRC 67/68 for M42. is is a di erent high-speed edge for us, Ramsdell said. Due to the high alloy content of this edge, we precision-grind all of the teeth. Also, it requires a much tighter heat-treating tolerance as far as temperatures and soak times go. Starrett puts the alloy steel backing material for the blades through a proprietary treatment to help extend its working life. e process occurs as the material is exposed to controlled blast peening. e combination of activities is said to add more residual stress into the surface of the blade, which helps to reduce fatigue cracks that originate along microscopic grain boundaries. Company o cials said the benets of this treatment have been proven with X-ray di raction and extensive mechanical fatigue tests. ere is a constant evolution of materials in the marketplace for different applications. When it comes
down to separating those new materials, the question for some people is, Can we do the job economically with bimetal, or do we have to look
at perhaps buying a more expensive band saw machine to utilize carbidetipped blades? Ramsdell said. With this new product, we can have them
try these blades before they have to look at the carbide product. e Primalloy blades have been in serious development for about a year and now are available in most markets. ey come in blades widths from 1 to 2.625 in. e L.S. Starrett Co., 121 Crescent St., Athol, MA 01331-1915, 978249-3551, www.starrett.com
FIGURE 1 e Primalloy band saw blades are also suitable for cutting metals that show adhesive characteristics, such as PH series stainless steels and INCONEL. For these types of sawing applications, a rich coolant or straight oil is necessary to prevent a builtup edgechips adhering to the bladewhen cutting.
67
Chief Concerns > > ideas for running a more effective fabricating operation
e FABRICATOR: First, what is innovation, and how does it manifest itself in manufacturing? Mengel: In our report we dene several levels of innovation. First, theres the product innovation, which everyone can identify. Second, theres service innovation, which involves unique services a company can provide. ird, theres process innovation, which allows manufacturers to make a component better, faster, and to a higher quality than the competition can. Process innovation can occur if you have a unique process capability, or it can be about reducing the cost of manufacturing. Note that this is not a price adjustment; its a cost adjustment. eres a di erence. Anyone can have a lower price, but not everyone can have a lower cost. Manufacturers need to di erentiate themselves. But in a lot of places, manufacturing is fairly commoditized, and its really di cult to di erentiate. I call these convenient business relationships, and we saw a lot of these convenient relationships blow up during the recession a few years ago. e FABRICATOR: So, convenient business relationships usually hinge on price alone? Mengel: Not necessarily. Say a purchaser for a large OEM buys several million dollars worth of goods annually from 500 suppliers, and you are a fabricator that supplies $50,000 of that. at small amount of work may not be incredibly price-sensitive. e purchaser isnt going to spend a lot of time looking for an alternative unless there is a reason to look for an alternative. Its convenient for the purchasing agent to maintain the relationship with you, just because hes got other things to do. But as soon as something happens that makes the relationship inconvenientbe it poor quality, poor delivery, or bad nancial results in an economic downturnthe OEM purchaser wakes up and scrutinizes everything. If you and the OEM have an intimate business relationship, it would be disruptive for the OEM to nd an alternative resource, not just from a workload standpoint, but also from a strategic standpoint. e FABRICATOR: So how does a metal fabricated products supplier go about developing this kind of relationship? Mengel: We have a client in the automotive space. I cant mention the names, but I can describe the situation. Its a Tier 2 contract fabricator that supplies parts to a Tier 1 customer. e customer was concerned about the fabricators capacity, so they asked the fabricator if it could build a new plant to handle the work. Were talking about a $10 million investment. e customer also wasnt interested in a long-term, multiyear agreement, and for good reasons. ere are pros and cons for everybody for such agreements. From the fabricators perspective, there was obvious risk, which is why they analyzed the customer relationship. Years ago the fabricators prior owners had developed a good friendship and close connection with the customer. But when the fabricator was passed on to new leadership, the close relationship wasnt maintained. In fact, the relationship had evolved to the point where the customer viewed the fabricator as a low-cost supplier. It was a relationship of convenience. Managers determined that before they would invest in a new plant, they wanted to transform that convenient business relationship into an intimate business relationship. At the time the customer represented about 70 percent of the fabricators sales, so the fabricator did not have much leverage. ey couldnt tell the customer what to do, and if the customer were to leave, it would have seriously hurt the business. So to build this new relationship, the fabricator promoted openness of communication and transparency. As you may know, in the automotive world the schedule often gets broadcast to suppliers via EDI [electronic data interchange]. e suppliers get a notice that instructs their plant to produce a certain number of parts by a certain date, but it doesnt provide the full story behind the schedule. But what if someone from the fabricator were at the customer location to identify true levels of inventory and demand? More than that, what if the fabricator hired other people to work at the customer facility? By the way, the customer wasnt next door; it was 120 miles away.
nnovation has been said to be at the heart of business success, but in a contract fabrication company that often doesnt work with product development or design, where is that innovation? According to the Innovation Quotient (IQ) survey from CPA and business advisory rm Plante Moran (www. plantemoran.com) in Cincinnati, and executive education and training institute NewNorth Center, innovation doesnt necessarily apply to just products. It also can be about process innovation, like innovative manufacturing methods or technologies. And then there are innovations within supply chain relationships. Je Mengel, partner and a leader in Plante Morans manufacturing group, described how such innovation can change a customer relationship from one thats simply a matter of convenience into one that is intimatenot in the romantic sense, of course. Instead, Mengel uses the word intimate to describe a business relationship that would be very inconvenient and disruptive to break. So how does a company develop such a relationship? e FABRICATOR talked with Mengel about one contract fabricator that did just this. e company accomplished it not just by applying continuous improvement methods and changing part ow on Je Mengel, partner and a leader in the shop oor, but also by changing the very Plante Morans manufacturing group foundation of its business model.
It all really comes down to risk abatement, and it applies to everyone in the supply chain.
e FABRICATOR: Still, can such a close relationship backre, especially if a lot of business is tied to one customer? Mengel: It all really comes down to risk abatement, and it applies to everyone in the supply chain. A Tier 1 should be concerned with giving too much business to a Tier 2. What if that Tier 2 goes out of business, or is purchased and changes direction? Supply chain transparency can mitigate this risk. Customers and suppliers need to be willing to open the kimono. In recent years supplier alliances have helped mitigate these risks too. Alliance member companies may compete with each other on, say, only 20 percent of the goods they sell. But for the remaining 80 percent, they dont compete directly, so they can work together. ey can have a contractual agreement to help another company for a period of time. And if they use a technology that is proprietary, they can arrange a license agreement. e other company can continue to use the technology for its own benet, but it has to pay a fee for the privilege. e FABRICATOR: Does being physically close to customers help spur close collaboration to develop those customer-intimate relationships? Mengel: Geography really is a convenience factor. In a convenient business relationship, a customer may be 30 miles away from a supplier. at customer may have poor scheduling, but it doesnt worry, because it knows its supplier is close by and will be responsive. When that customer gets its act together and becomes better at predicting schedules and other requirements, it can turn to the world, really. It can be truly global. But if a company is innovative, it can develop intimate customer relationships that arent governed by mere convenience. is occurs not just by being physically close to a customer, but through the sharing of knowledge and supply chain transparency. Like the automotive supplier I described, fabricators can help quote, develop programs, and get in on the ground oor of product development. Again, it would be truly disruptive to break that kind of supplier relationship. Senior Editor Tim Heston can be reached at timh@thefabricator.com.
The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
Platinum Sponsor:
www.mitsubishi-world.com
Presented by:
69
Chief Concerns > > ideas for running a more effective fabricating operation
e best way for you to maintain or earn preferred status with your customers is to show them that they can have visibility into the your operations and tell them that they are always welcome to check on things, such as a job status or shipment delivery date.
our customers have always demanded the best quality, lower prices, and streamlined delivery. But today your customers want something a little more revealing. ey want access to information about their parts, orders, shipments, product documentation, account status, and even deeper access to your business data, such as quality or job status. Is your business prepared to address these new demands for information transparency? If your answer is not unequivocally yes, you are not alone. While you might view this new and emerging requirement as another hoop to jump through, there is another perspective: Providing this visibility can give your organization a competitive advantagethe ability to maintain your preferred supplier status with your customers.
duction systems, streamlining production planning further. Bypass Manual Processing. Finally, if you have ever been approached by a customer to electronically communicate through electronic data interchange (EDI), you understand the complexity and cost of accepting an 860 document (a purchase order change request) or an 856 document (advance shipping notice) into your system. Many businesses give up unless forced to and instead log in to their customers web portal to get their orders and order changes and then turn around and manually rekey the changes into their own enterprise resource planning (ERP) system. ese businesses lose out on the benet of EDI with their customers. Reducing the unnecessary manual task of updating order changes is one benet, but the real benet is the speed at which your
Reducing the unnecessary task of manually updating order changes is one benefit of electronic data interchange, but the real benefit is the speed at which your company can then respond to the latest changes in demand on the plant floor.
is same query can be used to search the system. If a user enters a part number, every reference of the part in the system is displayed, including quotes, orders, jobs, quality events, and purchases. e same functionality can be used to generate a customer or supplier portal for sharing and collaborating on information. Whether your business is looking to share electronic documents, quality events, supplier blanket releases, sales orders, or shipment status updates, these portals can drive new e ciencies and give your business partners more access to what they need to ensure a smooth and streamlined supply chain. e Saving Grace of Web Services. You should consider adopting technology built on a completely service-oriented architecture (SOA), where web services enable access to every function, from the rst sales order to the nal invoice. Systems built from the ground up on an SOA enable connectivity and access to business processes either through traditional interfaces for computing, such as a sales order form, through a mobile device, or through a string of data that is validated as it is connected and brought into the system. is means that receiving and sending electronic information and mapping to customers and suppliers systems are enabled at a fraction of what it cost in the past. In part this is due to the fact that tools already exist that can map data coming and going through the web services, making the e ort to o er access a complex development task instead of a data-processing task. You can use these same tools to integrate nesting software into your procompany can then respond to the latest changes in demand on the plant oor. Dont be too shortsighted to recognize the opportunity to build in more operational responsiveness and agility.
Chief Concerns > > ideas for running a more effective fabricating operation
at much is obvious, no matter ones political stripe. e question, of course, is what exactly should change? We have a tremendously oversimplied debate going on in this country. So said Chris Kuehl, economic analyst for FMA. Oversimplication, he said, pervades any election season, and the current one is no exception. One side of the political spectrum says that the government should tax the wellChris Kuehl, o ; the other side scorns the idea of taxing wealthy job economic analyst, creators. Fabricators & e Mayan calendar will not end but reset at the end Manufacturers Association of the year; so, too, will the election cycle and, unfortunately, the postulating. While the arguments continue unabated, e FABRICATOR talked with Kuehl about the following three points that o er ration-al perspectivetoo boring for any stumping politician trying to grab headlines, but good for business owners planning ahead while trying to tune out the cacophony of hyperbolic sound bites. 1. e wealthy may give billions more, but the country needs trillions. If you dene wealthy as those who earn $250,000 a year or more, the biggest revenue boost from this kind of tax increase Ive seen is $49 billion, Kuehl said. ats not an insignicant amount of money, but we have a $15 trillion debt. Its a bit like trying to pay o a $100,000 loan a little faster by paying an extra $5. And yes, we may be in a time with relatively low tax rates. Some may cite that certain times of high growth also happened to be accompanied by higher tax rates. e wealthiest bracket of the 1950s was taxed to the hilt, at a rate of more than 90 percent. e top bracket of the 1990s was taxed a little higher than today, at more than 39 percent. Some argue that growth during these times didnt have anything to do with taxes. As always, Kuehl pointed to the subtleties. First, people avoided taxes then just as they do now. e rich in the 1950s shu ed their income to investments, which were not taxed at such a high rate. Second, the correlation between tax rates and economic growth has been a continuing debate. During this tenuous economic climate, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget O ce said a tax hike will cause an economic slowdown for several years, but after that growth would resume. On the other hand, a recent International Monetary Fund report about the lackadaisical global growth attributes it in part to drastic austerity measures in Europe and elsewhere.
Stump speeches are never strong on details, but its the details we so desperately need
his has been a year of trumpeting doom, of postulating, of worryat least thats how anyone would feel if they watched, listened to, or read the news. Workers in the media have serious column-inches to ll, and if you work in Washington, the election is the only game in town, one that has lasted far too long. Hence, we have worrying and postulating. Meanwhile, business leaders in metal fabrication press on. Consider the 2013 Capital Equipment Forecast from the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association (FMA). As detailed in this issue, capital spending projections inched up 4 percent from last year. ats certainly a less dramatic jump than forecast last year, but its a signicant increase all the same. Most important, projected spending levels are nearly where they were before the recession. All this is happening in the face of a pending scal cli and slowing global growth. Business leaders know of the uncertainty ahead, but they also know its riskier to fall behind by standing still. ere are issues that matter in the stump speeches, and none hit home quite like taxes, especially for business owners. Another element makes the issue of taxes especially poignant during this election cycle: math. Most politicians believe the government decit just isnt sustainable over the long term. When it comes to taxes, something will need to change in the coming years.
e argument is moot anyway, Kuehl said, because a tax hike alone wont solve the problem. A plethora of pundits spout ideas, from cost-sharing programs in Medicare to raising the retirement age to closing corporate tax loopholes. Solutions that make the most di erence usually involve cuts to the Defense Department, Social Security, and Medicare, which (especially the last two) represent the third rail in politics. 2. When taxes help. Germany remains a manufacturing power amid an economically haywire Europe. And unlike other euro-based countries, Germanys economy has been relatively resilient. Like most countries in Europe, Germany also taxes individuals higher than the U.S. does (though Germany does have a low e ective corporate tax rate). In 2010 the average individual tax rate in Germany was about 40 percent. eres a catch here, though. e taxes pay for a lot, including (most signicant for manufacturers) an education system that churns out technical talent. Why do U.S. citizens scorn higher taxes? As Kuehl explained, they see money taken out of their paychecks and wonder where its being spent. Meanwhile, every year health care premiums rise and more money is taken out of the paycheck. Yes, taxes pay for roads, bridges, and public safety. But beyond these basics, government spending doesnt seem to make anyones life dramatically easier. e worst possible way to tax is tax the way were doing it now, Kuehl said. e rates are sort of high, but not incredibly high, and it doesnt seem to pay for anything. Im paying a 30 percent tax rate, but Im also paying for health care and Im paying for education. e U.S. household also is seeing greater earning di erentials, with one spouse (now often the woman) making signicantly more than the other. And with so many expenses for necessities, there really isnt that much left for discretionary spending. You go to Europe, and the health care is nationalized, housing is subsidized, food is subsidized, and education is free, Kuehl said. ere isnt anything left to spend money on except to go to a movie. Kuehl recalled one Swedish client. In Sweden, theres lots of welfare for the people, but theres also welfare for the company. A Swedish client of mine made brake adjusters for heavy trucks, and they wanted to get into a new product line. e government paid for all of it, including a $30 million new plant. e company didnt even have to get a banker involved. Stateside, such support would give new meaning to those your taxes at work signs.
3. Free choice, careers, college loans, and paying up. In some countriesespecially those with a strong technical workforcestudents are tracked at a somewhat young age. Switzerland is a good example, where many youth go into apprenticeship programs before they graduate high school. Not everyone goes to a four-year college, either. Gaining strong communication skills as well as a mathematical and technical background in primary and secondary school is enough for a healthy career. is kind of tracking, though, may not sit well in America. Many feel students shouldnt be guided but instead be free to choose their lifes pursuit. Its not about what you can do for your country; its about, well, what you can do for yourself. And for many, this has entailed getting a student loan backed by the government (that is, the taxpayer), and majoring in anything. e countrys colleges are full of students who are ill-prepared for collegiate-level work, so they drop out. But Kuehl, ever rational, pointed to the larger problem: Too many students graduating from any schoolbe it high school, a two-year community college, for-prot college, or a four-year universityarent entering the workforce with skills employers need. is should be the focus of education policy, and it has been to some extent, with programs like the Right Skills Now initiative (www.rightskillsnow.org) and national technical certication programs. But another message that public school teachers hear, Kuehl said, is that every kid needs to go to college because a college degreeany degreeis a ticket to a good job. As a former college professor, he admits that he would have agreed with this notion a decade ago. Students who went to college could get a job because a degree in nearly any major was a badge showing that they could be taught. I told students that they could major in anything, because they undoubtedly would nd a job that didnt relate to their major anyway. I wouldnt dream of telling students that today. Problems with education perhaps are why business leaders in metal fabrication and elsewhere look at taxes warily. In business, nothing is more important than nding talent. If a fabricator cant nd talent, he hires and trains people so that they become talented. e fabricator does it because he has to, but its understandably frustrating. He pays taxes. He knows society needs roads and bridges, public safety, and national defense. He also knows the country needs public education, and this is a sticking point. His tax dollars for schools do not make his life any easier; to the contrary, the poor educational system actually makes his life harder. e frustration doesnt automatically push the fabricator toward a certain political camp. He knows the system needs to change. One side wants to pour more money into government so it can provide more and better See us at FABTECH services; the other side wants to Booth #C1717 leave more to the private sector. As Kuehl explained, both approaches have their pros and cons. e subtleties and messiness of the real world usually dont fall neatly onto one political platform. But few politicians cover these complex, messy realities. ey oversimplify, which in the long run doesnt help anyone. Senior Editor Tim Heston can be reached at timh@thefabricator.com. Chris Kuehl, economic analyst for the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association, is also managing director of Armada Corporate Intelligence, Lawrence, Kan., and author of Fabrinomics, a biweekly e-newsletter from FMA. For more information, visit www.fmanet.org/fabrinomics or call 888-394-4362.
The FABRICATOR | NOVEMBER 2012
73
ybrid laser-arc welding has been around for years, with some early developments going as far back as the 1970s. But only recently has the process truly started to take hold. It takes advantage of the lasers deep penetration and high speed, while the arc helps to bridge gaps, slow weld cooling, and, thanks to a ller wire, adjust metallurgical characteristics. Considering this, one might wonder why hybrid laser-arc welding (HLAW) took so long to nd a place in industry. But like any new manufacturing technology, the hybrid laser-arc welding process required several elements for widespread acceptance and adoption. First, it needed the right manufacturing environment, including gap tolerances produced by accurate cutting and bending processes upstream, as well as increased throughput downstream. Second, it needed industry to shift focus toward not only total manufacturing cost, but also overall product life cycle cost.
trates deep into the joint, produces a narrow heata ected zone, and enables a high welding speed. All this helps dramatically lower heat input. GMAW helps slow the weld cooling, reducing excessive hardness and cracking. It also broadens the fusion zone surface. GMAWs ller wire gives the engineer some metallurgical control; changing the wire content changes the weld characteristics. e ller also allows the process to remove or dilute weld contaminants. And it gives designers some exibility when it comes to weld joint geometry, such as creating reinforcing beads and llets. Most signicant, HLAW is fast. Processing speeds can be anywhere from 3 to 30 times those of a conventional fusion process, be it GMAW or submerged arc welding (SAW). is statistic
is made possible not by a lightning-fast welding head, but because HLAW can complete a joint in fewer passes. And because it reduces heat input by 80 to 95 percent, an engineer may be able to reduce the weld joint volume. For instance, a 15-mm-deep, single-sided SAW butt joint might require a 60-degree bevel with a 3-mm-tall land and 2-mm-wide open root. at same butt-joint application for HLAW could call for a closed root with a 10-mm-tall land and only a 28-degree bevel. is e ectively reduces joint volume by up to 90 percent (see Figure 2). is allows engineers to take new approaches to joint and part design. A joint that used to be welded in multiple passes now can be welded in one pass. A particularly deep joint fusing two thick plates may have called for a double-V groove requiring double-sided access; using HLAW, engineers can change this to a full-penetration joint requiring access from only one side.
Less Distortion
Less residual stress and distortion occur because HLAW has low heat input as well as a small fusion zone and heat-a ected zone (HAZ). Consider a partial-penetration llet that joins a vertical plate to a horizontal one, with a weld leg length of 0.375 in. (see Figure 3). In this weld geometry, the area known as the centroid of the stress eld resides outside the base metal entirely, far away from the structures neutral axis (that is, at the center of the vertical plate). is causes the weld joint to pull and distort, which is why welders go to great lengths to control how the weld cools, minimizing this e ect.
HLAW Basics
e process uses a combination of laser light and a traditional electric welding arc, usually from a gas metal arc welding (GMAW) power source in the spray-transfer mode (see Figure 1). e lasers small spot size creates a very high energy density and actually helps stabilize the arc. e laser pene-
FIGURE 1 Hybrid laser-arc welding (HLAW) uses a wire arc welding process with a laser beam. e laser provides concentrated energy for high penetration, while the arc helps overcome t-up challenges. Process elements include: (1) newly formed weld bead; (2) inert shielding gas; (3) focused laser beam; (4) GMAW gun; (5) wire electrode; (6) electric arc; (7) molten pool; and (8) the keyhole.
60
3 mm
2 mm
FIGURE 3 HLAW allows the use of the 0.125-in. full-penetration fillet joint, which shifts the centroid of stress inward toward the structures neutral axis. date the hybrid laser-arc process if manufacturing throughput doesnt change? Downstream joining, assembling, and finishing processesnot to mention external customer demandmust be able to handle the HLAW systems increased throughput. Yes, HLAW does decrease welding costs in respect to both material and labor, but if more products dont ship out the door in less time, a manufacturing operations profitability doesnt change dramatically. Those reduced welding costs really wont change the bottom line as significantly as an increase in overall throughput will. Of course, plenty of operations have successfully adopted HLAW by changing internal processes. Their dramatic throughput improvements have allowed them to lower costs and gain significant market share. But this involves only manufacturing. Today lean thinking has led many to consider not just manufacturing costs, but also the costs that occur over the entire product life cycle, and this is where HLAW has really stepped up to the plate (so to speak). tailored structures, which incorporate higherstrength and thicker materials only where needed for a particular design. For years the plates used for ship decks have looked even more complicated, in terms of varying material grades and thicknesses, than some of the tailor welded blanks in the automotive sector. Over the life of a ship, a little weight reduction can lead to incredible savings in reduced fuel and other operating costs. Thats why the U.S. Navy and other shipbuilders have been making the transition from AH36 to high-strength, low-alloy materials such as HSLA-65, -80, and -100. Some shipbuilders now are shifting away from hot-rolled mild steel structural beams, toward tailored highstrength, plate-fabricated steel beams. Several manufacturers are using hybrid laser-arc welding to produce such tailored beams for shipbuilding. Engineers have similar operating cost reductions in mind when specifying high-strength steels for construction equipment. The so-called light structures on heavy vehiclesincluding fuel tanks, oil reservoirs, cabs, and engine structuresrepresent a significant portion of overall vehicle mass, and reducing that mass can lead to significant savings in material and power requirements. The booms and arms of mobile equipment are extremely weight-sensitive. The vehicles performance (that is, how productive it is at digging or material handling) is determined by the arms weight. For products like truck trailers, railcars, and intermodal containers, payload plays a role. Think of a railcar, which can have a life cycle spanning decades. Every pound of vehicle weight represents
V-Joint
0 mm
FIGURE 4 Railcar weight may be reduced up to 40 percent through the use of high-strength steel and laserwelded designs. This weight reduction in turn increases payload carrying capacity.
75
1st Operations
Fabrication
Subassembly
Final Assembly
FIGURE 5 According to the traditional rule of thumb, shifting value-adding work back one step in the manufacturing process cuts the cost of that work by about 50 percent. But because of variation caused by distortion, many welding applications havent followed this ruleuntil recently. a pound that cant be carried for the life of that vehicle. In the design phases now, though, are some railcars and intermodal containers that use highstrength steels and advanced laser-welded designs to reduce weight between 30 and 40 percent, increasing payload carrying capacity by up to 20 percent (see Figure 4). Consider the implications for an intermodal shipping container. Reducing the weight by 20 percent represents an extra payload capacity of 50,000 lbs. per year per container. Thats a lot of additional revenueand the average user has many containers, each of which can last decades. Additionally, a lighter container consumes less fuel on the back-haul leg of a trip. For each user, this can save millions over the containers life. Designs for ships and heavy vehicles now make use of more stainless steel and especially the new, relatively affordable high-strength duplex and lean duplex stainless steels. Previously engineers had to call for increased plate thickness to provide a buffer for corrosion over a vehicles lifespan. Now using stainless grades, designers need not include such a large material buffer for corrosion. The result, again, is thinner plate, reduced vehicle weight, and greater payload capacity. The hybrid laser-arc process, with its low heat and high speed, can help enable the transition to these high-strength, thinner structures. The shift toward lean manufacturing and thinking about total life cycle cost moves the emphasis away from the specific cost per pound of metal and toward total production and long-term support costs. High-strength alloys and stainless steels obviously are more expensive than conventional steels, and these heavy products use a lot of metal. But that higher material cost still is miniscule compared to the savings and increased productivity over a products life. With high-yield-strength materials comes higher residual stresses and reduced material thickness, which exacerbates distortion problems. The use of high-strength steels has made the control of distortion more important than ever. It is here where HLAW plays a critical role.
more precise for that hole to be cut by a mechanized plasma cutting table at an upstream process. Conventional high-heat welding and straightening often prevent this. The rule of thumb goes like this: Shifting valueadding work back one step in the manufacturing process can cut the cost of that work in half (see Figure 5). This applies as long as the upstream process is accurate enough to allow for smooth downstream processing. Welding hasnt always followed this rule for many products. Shifting an imprecise welding operation several steps upstream has actually increased costs because of thermal effects like distortion. The distortion increased variation downstream, which in turn required numerous craftspeople at the assembly stages. They spent their days deftly assembling imprecise components into a functional whole. For years upstream fabrication processes like high-density plasma cutting, laser cutting, bending, and forming have met the need for accuracy, which is why this work has become more prevalent early in the value chain. But until recently, welding has put up a thermal barrier to this ideal. Weld distortion added variability, which meant sending the process upstream just didnt make sense. Low-heat-input processes like HLAW change the equation. The reduced thermal effect dramatically minimizes distortion, making the joining process nearly as precise as its cutting and bending cousins. This in turn minimizes the need for highly skilled work at the end of the manufacturing value chainwhere such work happens to be the most costly. As manufacturers begin to understand how to use the attributes of hybrid laser-arc welding to achieve total production savings and improved product quality, the industry can expect to see its adoption accelerate.
FIGURE 1 When it came to cutting aluminum, circular saws used to be the only saw choice for metal fabricators. Advances in band saw technology have expanded their options. is taking place as export markets in Europe and Asia struggle to regain their economic footing. Because great opportunities await those fabricators able to process aluminum e ciently, they need to be aware of cutting technologies that can help them do the job. If the focus is on sawing (see Figure 1), the question is, Do band saws or circular cold saws cut aluminum better? Technological advancements have been made in aluminum sawing with both types of saws, and the answer is often a very rm It depends.
By Richard Klipp
ith the continued focus on using lighter materials wherever possible, particularly in the transportation industry, metal fabricators are interested in learning about the best ways to process aluminum materials. Of course, this a ects every shop oor activity, including sawing. is interest in lighter-weight material appears to be a long-term trend. In omasNet.coms annual Industry Market Barometer, a survey of more than 4,000 manufacturing professionals in North America, 20 percent of respondents listed aerospace and defense as the top growth markets in 2012, which trailed only fabricated metal products (21 percent). is comes even as manufacturers stare at dramatically reduced defense budgets all around the globe, particularly in the U.S. In the same survey, 18 percent considered the automotive market to be the top growth market. What do the aerospace and automotive markets have in common? Companies are interested in reducing the weight of their products because less fuel is needed to power these lighter-weight aircraft and vehicles. A recent report from the Aluminum Association provides an excellent look at how hot this
the job.
FIGURE 2 For high-volume cutting of aluminum tube, the circular saw still stands out as the most suitable saw for
FIGURE 3 If a band saw blade is going to be used to cut thick-diameter aluminum billet, it has to be exible enough to survive the speed generated by the saw. ish of the nal cut, the circular saw stands out as a suitable choice. By generating a very good nish, the fabricator may be in a position to eliminate a secondary nishing operation, which can result in dramatic labor savings. is is especially evident in fast cutting of single-piece, small-diameter material (see Figure 2). For example, in aluminum extrusion cutting, production volumes can be as high as 5,000 parts per shift, and the end nish is expected to be very clean. e fact is that circular saws cut aluminum so fast and e ectively that a fabricator really needs to develop a productive means for moving material in and out of the saw. A material handling method is either an incline or at-loading magazine on the input side, coupled with a high-speed output conveyor for sorting of the nished parts. is maximizes the aluminum cutting power of a circular saw. However, it should be pointed out that while a circular saw delivers a much cleaner cut, the blade will remove a nice chunk of the aluminum because of the blade size. For instance, a 40-in.diameter blade is about 0.33 in. wide. ramp feed and speed, which means the blade enters the cut slowly, ramps up, and then exits the cut slowly. Entry and exit are two areas where the possibility of blade damage is greatest, but this controlled process eliminates that. In addition, blades have advanced so that they can revolve that fast around the wheels and be exible enough not to break (see Figure 3). Further, these newer band saws provide good control of the blade. e equipments ball-screw, servo-drive downfeed (see Figure 4) helps to ensure that the beam is pushed rmly through the material at a feed rate up to 22 inches per minute. To generate the high blade speed (up to 4,000 SFM) requires the appropriate combination of horsepower and torque within the gearbox and motor, so that even at high speeds the equipment is not overworked. Current band saw technology hits all of these very important benchmarks. If a fabricator is cutting aluminum parts and other materials at lower volumes, say, 1,000 parts or fewer per shift, then a band saw can be a solid
performer. If the aluminum material is greater than 7 in. diameter, todays band saws are probably a good choice for the job. Also, if the squareness of the cut has a high tolerance, the band saw will be able to deliver. Fabricators also should be aware that a band saw blade is thinner than a circular saw blade, typically about 0.042 in. thick. is results in a signicantly smaller kerf removal when compared to the circular saw blade, generating material cost savings over time. How far has band saw cutting of aluminum come? Band saws are now cutting 11-in.-diameter 6061 aluminum bar in 14 seconds. at is 94 sq. in. of material, which is equivalent to a removal rate of 400 sq. IPM. is means that band saws are now able to cut at 3,500 SFM, which compares favorably to previous generations of band saws that could cut only up to 500 SFM.
FIGURE 4 e ball-screw mechanism on newer band saws ensures steady downfeed pressure during the cutting process.
The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
79
angle. For overbent (acute bend) angles, either the included or complementary angles may be used. e choice is yours, but it does a ect how you apply the data to the at pattern.
A bend deduction (BD) is the value subtracted from the at blank for each bend in the part, and there may be more than one. Bend deductions di er depending on the part itself, di erent bend angles, and/or inside radii. Note that when overbending and making the OSSB calculation using the included bend angle, you may calculate a negative value for the bend deduction. You will need to take the negative value into account when calculating the at blank, as discussed in the next section.
By Steve Benson
hen a sheet metal part is bent, it physically gets bigger. e nal formed dimensions will be greater than the sum total of the outside dimensions of the part as shown on the printunless some allowance for the bend is taken into account. Many will say material grows or stretches as it is bent in a press brake. Technically, the metal does neither, but instead elongates. It does this because the neutral axis shifts closer to the inside surface of the material. e neutral axis is an area within the bend where the material goes through no physical change during forming. On the outside of the neutral axis the material is expanding; on the inside of the neutral axis the material is compressing. Along the neutral axis, nothing is changingno expansion, no compression. As the neutral axis shifts toward the inside surface of the material, more material is being expanded on the outside than is being compressed on the inside. is is the root cause of springback.
Bend Allowance (BA) BA = [(0.017453 Inside radius) + (0.0078 Material thickness)] Bend angle, which is always complementary
calculations. ere are other values for stainless and aluminum, but in most cases, 0.446 in. works across most material types. If you multiply the material thickness by the K-factor (0.446), you get the location of the relocated neutral axis: for example, 0.062 0.446 = 0.027 in. is means that the neutral axis moves from the center of the material to a location 0.027 in. from the inside bend radiuss surface. Again, the neutral axis goes through no physical change structurally or dimensionally. It simply moves toward the inside surface, causing the elongation. Note the two factors shown in the bend allowance formula: 0.017453 and 0.0078. e rst factor is used to work your way around a circle or parts of a circle, and the second value applies the K-factor average to the rst factor. e 0.017453 is the quotient of /180. e 0.0078 value comes from (/180) 0.446. Note that for the bend allowance, the bend angle is always measured as complementary (see Figure 1).
Outside Setback (OSSB) OSSB = [Tangent (Degree of bend angle / 2)] (Inside bend radius + Material thickness)
Complementary Angle
Included Angle
OSSB
BA
e length of the neutral axis is calculated as a bend allowance, taken at 50 percent of the material thickness. In Machinerys Handbook, the Kfactor for mild cold-rolled steel with 60,000-PSI tensile strength is 0.446 inch. is K-factor is applied as an average value for most bend allowance
e outside setback is a dimensional value that begins at the tangent of the radius and the at of the leg, measuring to the apex of the bend (see Figure 2). At 90 degrees, it does not matter if you use the included or complementary angle; you still end up with 45 degrees, and you get the same OSSB answer. For underbent angles (see Figure 3), it is common practice to use the complementary
BD = 2 x OSSB BA
FIGURE 2 e outside setback (OSSB) is a dimensional value that begins at the tangent of the radius and the at of the leg, measuring to the apex of the bend.
Underbent
Right
Overbent
160
90
20
160
FIGURE 3 Terminology may be different depending on how a protractor is read. This article defines underbends as those with included angles of more than 90 degrees. Overbends (also called acute bends) are those with included angles that are less than 90 degrees. There is another way to look at the second option. As mentioned earlier, if you use the included angle for the OSSB, the bend deduction may be a negative value. As you may know, subtracting a negative value requires you to add: for example, 10 (-5) = 15. If you are working the formula on your calculator, it will automatically make the proper calculations. If you are working the formula through line by line, you will need to keep track of the answers sign and whether it is positive or negative. The following examples walk you through the flat-blank development methods. They apply bend functions to a simple, single-bend part, bent past 90 degrees complementary, to show how the complementary or included angles are applied in the OSSB and ultimately to a layout. The part in Figure 4 is bent to 160 degrees complementary. It has a material thickness of 0.250 in. and an inside bend radius of 0.250 in. The legs are each 1.000 in., and the dimension to the apex (between the part edge and bend apex) is 3.836 in. Note that in the formulas below, Ir represents the inside bend radius and Mt represents the material thickness. For all methods, we calculate the bend allowance the same way:
Bend Allowance (BA) BA = [(0.017453 Ir) + (0.0078 Mt)] Degree of bend angle complementary BA = [(0.017453 0.25) + (0.0078 0.25)] 160 BA = [0.00436325 + 0.00195] 160 BA = 0.00631325 160 BA = 1.010
The second flat-blank-development example adds the two dimensions (from edge to the apex), and subtracts a bend deduction. In this case, the calculations use a complementary angle for the OSSB, and the dimensions are called from the edge to the apexagain, as specified in Figure 4.
Outside Setback (OSSB) OSSB = [Tangent (Degree of bend angle complementary/2)] (Mt + Ir) OSSB = [Tangent (160/2)] (0.25 + 0 .25) OSSB = [Tangent 80] 0.5 OSSB = 5.671 0.5 OSSB = 2.836
3.83
6 Fla
nge
eg 00 L
0.25 0
1.0
From here, we perform different calculations, depending on the flat-blank development used. Using the first method, we develop the flat blank by adding the two legs of the bend and the bend allowance.
Flat-blank Calculation Calculated flat-blank length = Leg + Leg + BA Calculated flat-blank length = 1.000 + 1.000 + 1.010 Calculated flat-blank length = 3.010
20
FIGURE 4 This 0.250-in.-thick part is bent to 160 degrees complementary with an inside bend radius of 0.250 in. The drawing specifies that the dimension from the edge to the apex is 3.836 in.
ance (BA) of 0.187 in., you get a negative bend deduction. That means you subtract the negative BD (again, the same as adding) when doing the flat-blank calculation. As you can see, the same calculated flat-blank dimension results:
Outside Setback (using included angle) OSSB = [Tangent ($i /2)] (Material thickness + Inside radius) OSSB = [Tangent (60/2)] (0.062 + 0.062) OSSB = [Tangent (30)] 0.124 OSSB = 0.577 0.124 OSSB = 0.071 Bend Deduction (BD) BD = (OSSB 2) BA BD = (0.071 2) 0.187 BD = 0.142 0.187 BD = -0.045 Flat-Blank Calculation Calculated flat-blank length = Dimension to apex + Dimension to apex Bend deduction Calculated flat-blank length = (Leg + OSSB) + (Leg + OSSB) BD Calculated flat-blank length = (1.000 + 0.071) + (1.000 + 0.071) (-0.045) Calculated flat-blank length = 1.071 + 1.071 (-0.045) Calculated flat-blank length = 2.187 in. Editors note: An extended mathematical discussion of alternative equations is available online. Visit www. thefabricator.com and type The basics of applying bend functions in the search box.
For overbent angles (see Figure 3), the original formulaOSSB = [Tangent ($c/2)] (Material thickness + Inside radius)also may be written using the included degree of bend angle. But again, when you get a negative bend deduction value, you need to take that into account when calculating the flat blank. Working with an included bend angle ($i) of 60 degrees, a material thickness of 0.062 in., an inside bend radius of 0.062 in., and a bend allow-
81
Bend Deduction BD = (OSSB 2) BA BD = (2.836 2) 1.010 BD = 5.672 1.010 BD = 4.662 Flat-blank Calculation Calculated flat blank = Dimension to apex + Dimension to apex Bend deduction Calculated flat blank = 3.836 + 3.836 4.662 Calculated Flat-blank Length = 3.010
a negative number). In this case, we are using the included angle for the OSSB, and the dimensions are still called from the edge to the apex.
Outside Setback (OSSB) OSSB = [Tangent (Degree of bend angle included/2)] (Mt + Ir) OSSB = [Tangent (20/2)] (0.25 + 0.25) OSSB = [Tangent 10] 0.5 OSSB = 0.176 0.5 OSSB = 0.088 Bend Deduction (BD) BD = (OSSB 2) BA BD = (0.088 2) 1.010 BD = 0.176 1.010 BD = -0.834 Flat-blank Calculation Calculated flat blank = Dimension to apex + Dimension to apex Bend deduction Calculated flat blank = 1.088 + 1.088 (-0.834) Calculated flat-blank length = 3.010
In this final example, the flat-blank calculation adds the dimensions and then subtracts the negative bend deduction (again, you add when subtracting
You can see that regardless of method, the same answer is achieved. Be sure you are calculating these values based on the actual radius you are attaining in the physical part. There are many extenuating circumstances you may need to consider. Just a few are the forming method (air forming, bottoming, or coining), the type of bend (sharp, radius, or profound radius bends), the tooling you are using, and the multibreakage of the workpiece during large-radius bending. Also, the farther past 90 degrees you go, the smaller the inside radius will physically become. You can calculate for most of these, and this is something well be sure to tackle in future articles.
We can easily calculate the values using these formulas, but it is the application of the results that counts.
Getting the Part Right the First Time
There are lots of different paths to find your way around a bend, by using either the included or complementary angles. We can easily calculate these values; it is the application of the results that counts. However, once you know how and where the information is applied in a given situation, the flatpattern layout is easy. So why calculate all these values? Because sometimes you will need to work your way around a bend on a print, and you may not have all the information you need to complete a flat pattern. At least now you can calculate all the different parts of the bend, apply them correctly, and get it right the first time. Steve Benson is a member and former chair of FMAs Precision Sheet Metal Technology Council. He is the president of ASMA LLC, 2952 Doaks Ferry Road N.W., Salem, OR 97301, steve@asmachronicle.com. Benson also conducts FMAs Precision Press Brake Certificate Program, which is held at locations across the country. For more information, visit www.fmanet.org/ training, or call 888-394-4362. ASMA LLC produces training materials and bend calculation software, available at www.asmachronicle.com.
In the September issue, the previous article in this series, Dissecting bend deductions and die openings, stated an incorrect K-factor value from Machinerys Handbook (the value is 0.446), and erroneous verbiage regarding the bend allowance calculation, which could have been construed to mean that an included angle can be used in bend allowance calculations. The bend allowance always uses the complementary bend angle; it is the outside setback (OSSB) calculation that may or may not use the included bend angle. The OSSB equation also had a typographical error. The FABRICATOR team regrets these errors and has corrected them in the online version of the article, available at www.thefabricator.com.
Corrections
OMAX is a total solutions waterjet provider with the broadest range of machines, accessories, pumps, software and support in the market. Whether your shop processes aluminium, stainless steel, titanium, composites, stone, plastic, or rubber, weve got you covered with our innovative cutting technologies that bring the utmost accuracy, speed, simplicity and versatility to even the most challenging applications. But this is just an ad. Dont just take our word for it, ASK US FOR A TEST CUT TO EXPERIENCE THE REAL OMAX DIFFERENCE FOR YOURSELF.
Connect and follow OMAX for the latest news in waterjet technology.
WWW.OMAX.COM 1.800.838.0343 WWW.MAXIEMWATERJETS.COM 1.877.629.4365
once the previous job was complete. So said Jason Cunningham, shop foreman, who described how, because of such disorganization, the shop struggled to reduce process cycle time. The root causes of such disorganization involved seemingly mundane elements, including the placement of hand tools. The little things matter, he said.
This was the very question Laser Access managers asked about six years ago, when the company began informal continuous improvement efforts. We do a lot of challenging stainless steel and aluminum jobs, Cunningham said. There are a lot of places that wont cut this material. The material does require deburring, though, and thats why many parts coming off its 2-D laser cutting system flowed to the companys grinding work centers. Unfortunately, abrasive discs and similar consumables lay everywhere. Such disorganization increased work-in-process and lengthened overall manufacturing time. Thats because workers spent so much time hunting for the right abrasive media. A lot of these are intricate jobs, Cunningham said. You just cant put a 36-grit disc on and hog the material off. Sometimes the job would grind to a halt (pun intended) if a certain disc couldnt be found. The purchaser placed a rush order for abrasive discs, and workers would move on to other jobs. In this instance, centralized (not point-of-use) storage was the best option. The grinding and deburring area now has a centralized storage cabinet, where personnel can monitor consumable usage continually, and then request a replenishment order as the inventory of abrasive media reaches a certain point. By analyzing purchasing patterns over time, both the abrasive supplier and Laser Access could better predict when new abrasive media would be needed.
he people at Laser Access, a Grand Rapids, Mich., fabricator, know a thing or two about quick changeover. Launched in 1999, the high-mix, low-volume fabricator has spent the past decade perfecting the science of quick setup, with clear documentation and, at the shops fiveaxis laser cutting center, some quick-change tooling. The company started with just one five-axis laser; now it has two, plus one flat cutting laser with automated loading. Today the 22-person shop has expanded into arc and laser welding, as well as press brake work. Its customers range from those in the architectural industry to aerospace. On the two TRUMPF five-axis cutting systems, the operator need only loosen and tighten four bolts to change out fixtures between jobs. The flat cutting laser, with its automated loading table, doesnt take long to change over either. In fact, those setups are designed to occur in minutes, at least in theory. But until recently, setups rarely took just minutes. It wasnt because of poorly designed fixturing or machine problems, either. We just werent effective at making sure the parts, the tools, and the paperwork were all staged and ready to go
We just werent effective at making sure the parts, the tools, and the paperwork were all staged and ready to go once the previous job was complete.
Jason Cunningham, Laser Access
We work with our local supplier on this, Cunningham said. They always have 500 pieces on hand, in case anything goes awry. The shop monitors abrasive inventory both at post-laser-cutting deburring and at postweld grinding. In the latter area, grinders hang on dedicated hooks; its a shadow board, just without the outlines. Each tool has a quick-release tool changeout system. Until recently the blowgun also had a quickrelease connection to the shop air line, which reflected the shops focus on flexibility. Sometimes workers in other areas needed the tool, so they borrowed it and often forgot to return it. This
meant that postweld grinding operators had to go on a blowgun hunt, which certainly wasnt valueadded time. Thats why a dedicated blowgun made sense for the postweld grinding area. Other machine workstations have their own air guns, and they still have quick-disconnect fittings. But in the postwelding grinding area, the air line now is permanently threaded onto the blowgun; someone would need to go through great effort to remove it. Now theres always a blowgun there, Cunningham said. It cant walk away. This is about where Laser Access continuous improvement efforts stood when Cunningham and Quality Manager David Boland attended LeanFab, an event organized by the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association, held near Minneapolis earlier this year. At the time managers knew shop operations could improve, especially in upstream processes. The conference, headed by consultant Dick Kallage, principal at Barrington, Ill.-based KDC & Associates, focused on the importance of flow and machine uptime. In high-mix, low-volume environments, setup matters. As Kallage put it during the event, Youre not in the manufacturing business. Youre in the setup business.
Now remnant sheets are grouped by dimension and thickness. Most important, they are stored vertically, like a card file, so workers need only flip through to find the one they need before removing it with a lift crane (see Figure 3).
When it comes to getting worker buy-in for continuous improvement, making jobs easier is a good starting point.
FIGURE 1 A holder with tin snips, a tape measure, markers, and other basic tools is attached permanently to the fork truck. Wherever the fork truck goes, the tools the driver needs go with it.
FIGURE 2 These horizontal drawers previously stored remnant material. Unfortunately, material was grouped by type, but not by thickness or size. This meant workers needed to remove numerous sheets to get to the one they needed.
The operators also have a different process for removing remnants. After cutting, they place the remaining sheet on a wheeled rack, at which point they fill out the remnant information (grade, thickness, dimension, etc.) on the attached paperwork. This in turn is entered into an electronic file, which shows up immediately at the purchasers workstation in the front office. When ordering material, the purchaser now has an accurate record of available remnants. That means when he needs material, he orders only what is necessary, no more and no less. All these efforts have improved the shops raw stock situation dramatically. And they have reduced on-hand raw stock inventory and increased machine uptime at those all-important laser cutting centers. Cunningham was quick to point out that the improvement cycle isnt finished. It never is, really. For instance, even with an organized, efficient deburring department, a manual operation can deburr only so much. Thats why the company plans to bring in a flat-part deburring machine to speed operations.
Tracking Consumables
The fabricator recently had a problem with some laser consumable usagespecifically, a ceramic ring used on the five-axis systems cutting head. As long as the laser is operated properly, the ceramic ring should last for a long time; it isnt a high-wear component. But we found a lot of our ceramics were disappearing, Cunningham said. Thats why managers recently installed a vending machine that holds ceramic rings along with other consumables, like lenses, nozzles, and safety glasses. Operators are given special coins with their initials on them. They drop these coins into the vending machine slot to receive a new ceramic ring or another consumable if they need it. We can track whos using those ceramics, so I have a source, and we can communicate with the operator. It just gives us better inventory control on our consumables.
FIGURE 3 Today Laser Access stores its remnants vertically, so workers can find them quickly. it into a 5- by 10-foot container that stored remnants flat in horizontal drawers (see Figure 2). These were designed for a low-product-mix situation, where machines repeatedly ran the same material over and over, and this caused problems for Laser Access. The drawers separated remnants by material grade, but not thickness or size, and the sheets were all stacked flat. So if the next job called for a certain remnant, the operator needed to remove sheets stacked on top to get to it. We sometimes needed to remove 15 drops of material, or even more, just to get to the material we needed, Cunningham said.
85
writes the idea on a card and submits it for review. Cunningham added that this will be complemented by an employee recognition program. Most important, workers are given the resources to improve, and here Cunningham pointed to an important new position on the shop floor: the spider. The name comes from water strider or water spider, which is lean manufacturing jargon for material handler. But at Laser Access, a spider is so much more. At the end of each day, the spider, who was promoted from within, stages
On the US market Jammes is distributed by European Technology Center NA, Ferndale (MI) USA
248-217-1945
work for the second shift and for several hours into the first shift the next day. In general, he stays several hours ahead, so that operators have everything they needhand tools, fixtures, and materialexactly when they need it. As Cunningham explained, the variability of a job shop brings with it various cycle times; its impossible to level-load such an operation. Many jobs are nonrepeat orders too. For those unique, never-run-before jobs, a process cycle time could be plus or minus so many minutes. Staging material several hours prior to the next operation provides a buffer to absorb that variability. The buffer doesnt have days or weeks worth of material, just hours, and those few short hours keep machines running and jobs flowing downstream. The spider looks upstream as well. For instance, after the laser cutting operator loads remnant material onto the wheeled rack, the spider wheels the rack back to the storage area, enters remnant inventory information into the computer, and places the remnants back in storage. This eliminated the waste of the operator putting the drop material into the rack, Cunningham said. That just adds to downtime on the machine. Organizational improvements like 5S and its clean workstations and shadow boards are essential. But by themselves, changeovers can occur only so fast, simply because the operator must retrieve material and the tools necessary to conduct the changeover. This, sources said, is why the spiders role is so important. The spiders day focuses on part flow, so he can see inefficiencies that others, especially those tied to specific departments, cant. But the spider also makes everyone elses job much easier. And when it comes to getting worker buy-in for continuous improvement, making jobs easier is a good starting point. Senior Editor Tim Heston can be reached at timh@thefabricator. com. Photos courtesy of Laser Access, 1645 Broadway N.W., Grand Rapids, MI 49504, 616-459-5496, www. laseraccess.com. For more information about the Fabricators & Manufacturers Associations LeanFab events, visit www.fmanet.org, or call 888-394-4362.
Retrofit to be tried
Old iron finds new life with updated control, backgauge
Figure 1 A press brake retrofit helped Tejas Precision Metal Fabrication Services avoid some of the complications associated with installing a new press brake, such as prolonged shop floor interruptions, the rigging in and out of equipment, and the need for extensive electrical renovations. Photos courtesy of Metamation Inc.
ryce Baker doesnt have to tell you his age because when he starts talking about his role at Tejas Precision Metal Fabrication Services in San Antonio, you know hes a graduate of the old school, where pen and paper were the main tools of all students. On my business card, I never put a title, he said. I think as long as I have lived, I saw only one business card that really had a good title. It was a gentleman that owned a company, and the card had worker on it. We all work. Thats what we are all here for. Theres no doubt that Baker is a worker at Tejas Precision. In a pinch, he can go out to the shop floor and run a press brake if necessary. But hes also the general manager/co-owner, overseeing the forming, punching, laser cutting, powder coating, and welding operations on a day-to-day basis. The other co-owners are Sharon Baker, Bryces wife, and Sharon Buchta, the wife of Louis Buchta, Bakers partner who passed away five years ago. Tejas Precision is enjoying success spurred on by a simple mission statement: Build whatever the customer desires. As a result, the company works with various materials, from shim stock to 0.5-in. plate, and fabricates products for customers in industries as diverse as food production and high-tonnage air-conditioning manufacturing. The 35-man shop, which is running three shifts, typically has between $4 million and $5 million in annual sales. While the description of an owner who actually understands the principles of fabricating metal and is willing to help out on the shop floor sounds quaint, dont for a minute think that Baker has
turned his back on modern fabricating tools. He understands what is needed to compete in todays market. Do younger workers miss some of [the metal fabricating basics using modern machines]? Yes, they miss some of it because they dont have a thorough understanding of everything from start to finish, Baker said. But its not economical for them to learn everything from start to finish. You need people that are good at that operation with technology at hand to be productive. Thats especially true for press brake operators, who are a dying breed. The matter is only further complicated when a shop tries to bring in new hires with little bending experience and expects them to hit the ground running on older press brakes. Tejas Precision was not immune to this trend, so it decided to do something about it. It breathed new life into its old press brakes.
Figure 2 With the new four-axis, automatic backgauge, press brake operators no longer have to manually set the position of the backgauge fingers.
R e or m 101 d e e a pa g on
This is how Tejas Precision runs its bending operations now: 1. It receives a 3-D file from a customer and feeds it into its MetaBEND press brake software, which unfolds it and automatically prepares bending instructions for the press brake operator. We like getting IGES models because we can blow it apart and, when we unfold it and set everything based on our bend deductions, it automatically picks up all of that. 2. When the job is ready for forming, the press brake operator simply pulls the file off of the server. 3. Using the new control software, the press brake operator runs a full 3-D bending simulation to see how the job is programmed and to check for any potential interference. They can look at it and see if they need to change their sequence. They can see exactly what it is going to do with the tooling they have, Baker said. 4. The operator places the part against the backgauge, and the job commences. Manual backgauge placementand the fear of having an operator adjust the backgauge by extending his arms through the forming windowis now a thing of the past because of the new backgauge upgrades with independent, four-axis movement (see Figure 2). The backgauges fingers automatically position where the bending needs to take place, as directed by software. Its very accurate. I would tell you that probably six times out of 10, youll probably have a good part on the first bend, Baker said. Tejas Precision is not only saving time on the front end of bending jobs Metamations Scott said offline brake programming can yield up to a 90 percent throughput improvement when compared to those shops that still rely on older controlsthe company is reducing the time needed to make changes on-the-fly. If you have to do an angle adjustment on a spot, its very easy to do. Its all done on the touchscreen, Baker said. The operator can rapidly generate parts using the profile feature on the control. He touches the corner of a blank and drags a new flange up. The control software, already knowing the given thickness and where the bend is to start, adjusts the angle at 5-degree intervals. Its clearly a marked improvement over the older-style controls, according to Scott. On the original controls, you had a limited number of steps and programs that you could make with the press brake, Scott said. And for each of those steps, you had to input the flange, the length, width, tooling, and all of the information for the backgauge finger settings. You had to do all of that as a manual entry on each one. It was great technology in the 1980s, but today it is simply a very antiquated process. This is completely overriding that. Now when a press brake operator needs to bend just one part or set up a special process, he doesnt have to worry about creating a CAD file.The new control has a manual entry screen that basically emulates the old input process.
Chris Kuehl
Don McNeeley
Early Bird Discount Sign up before Jan. 7, 2013 and save $200!
fmanet.org/metalmatters
Platinum Sponsors:
Presented by:
89
Looki n g good
Laser welding simplies fabrication of cosmetically important joints
By Tim Heston, Senior Editor
FIGURE 1 Estes Design and Manufacturing spent several years developing its laser welding process. Early on, technicians were impressed with how clean the welds looked. Most did not require postweld grinding or graining.
several years before we brought in a machine, but we at least validated the concept. Five years ago the company invested in a Prima Power CO2 laser machine. It can act as a at-sheet cutter, a 3-D cutting system, as well as a 3-D welding machine. Switching between laser cutting and laser welding doesnt take long. It allowed us to generate revenue through traditional laser cutting, which basically supported our laser welding R&D, Estes said.
Ramping Up
As laser welding development manager, Jay Reddick has an unusual title in the contract fabrication world. He spearheaded the companys R&D e ort, which took almost two years. e president of the company insisted that the new technology be developed to make legacy processes better and less costly. To that end, Reddick and his team took existing products that were welded with traditional processes and experimented with laser welding. A laser beam emerging from a focusing head looks like two cones, one on top of the other. Where those cones meet at the point in the middle is the focal point. e weld spot diameter changes depending on where that focal point is located in relation to the metal surface being welded. By moving the focal point away from the metal, the more out of focus the beam is and, subsequently, the wider the area a ected at the point where the beam contacts the material. e more out of focus the beam is at the point of weld, the more energy it takes to maintain the weld. e focal point is adjusted based on the type of weld needed. A higher focal point produces a more defocused beam for slower, more cosmetic welds; a lower focal point produces a small spot size for faster welds that arent appearance-critical. Speed makes the process attractive not only for processing e ciency but also for reducing stresses on the material. As Reddick explained, Youre moving so fast that the residual stresses imparted into the metal, especially in stainless steel, almost go away. When Reddick took on his new position, he found he was tackling a process that had been developed primarily for the automotive industrya low-mix, high-volume environment very unlike Estes Design and Manufacturing. We were starting out in a new territory. Conventional laser welding doesnt use a ller wire, so many of the rules of traditional wire welding dont apply. Reddicks years of welding cosmetically important joints did come in handy, though, especially when analyzing assist gas requirements. Getting coverage with an inert atmosphere, without blowing impurities into the inert atmosphere, is an art unto itself, he said.
ive years ago Estes Design and Manufacturing adopted laser welding not just because of its eye-popping speed. e Indianapolis fabricator is a high-mix, low-volume operation. Fast welding may be a bonus, but the contract fabricator isnt producing long runs of any one product. For many jobs, t-up tolerance is about 0.005 in. Precise cutting and panel bending upstream certainly helps meet these tolerances, but the team still must use special xtures to ensure the joint is exactly where it should be. e company didnt use the process initially to perform work that couldnt be joined with any other method, nor did customers demand that the fabricator bring in laser welding. Managers werent planning to use the process to move into new markets, either, at least not initially. So why exactly bring in this precise, fast, though challenging welding method? Ron Estes, vice president of operations, pointed to the postweld grinding cells. Were in a corner of the market where were dealing with highly cosmetic products made with light-gauge sheet metal, he said. Our fabricating processes are highly automated and very accurate. We were dealing with a lot of products for several industries that required welding, and we saw that whether it was MIG or TIG welding, it typically required a lot of secondary operations to make that welded area blend with the surrounding material. As a constraint process, grinding not only increased labor costs, but it also slowed overall part ow. e shop uses highly automated cutting and bending centers, but such speed doesnt mean so much with a big bottleneck in grinding. e laser welding system has allowed the fabricator to reduce the grinding and graining time greatly and, for some jobs, eliminate it entirely. is, sources
said, has made the entire laser welding endeavor well worth it. Our thought was that if we could create a surgically precise weld and eliminate the need for secondary operations, including grinding and graining, we could give the customer a superior product for a lot less money, Estes said.
Seeing Potential
About 15 years ago personnel witnessed e ciency and accuracy in upstream processes like cutting and bending, but they also saw that grinding bottleneck. So managers began considering options and experimenting. Refocusing the head of a 1980s-vintage, at-bed laser cutting machine, technicians laser welded a few test workpieces. e machine had no modern level of control, so they had to do a lot of nessing to make it work, but they eventually welded 20-gauge cold-rolled steel. ey liked what they saw. We did some simple butt welds and were encouraged by what we were seeinggood penetration and very at, nice-looking welds, Estes said. In some instances, the welds almost looked like an ornamental feature. It gave us the encouragement that there might be some merit to pursuing this process. About a dozen years ago the fabricator began welding some initial samples for customers, demonstrating the processs potential. One of the rst samples was for a stainless steel oven door that required a lot of welding and a massive amount of nishing. At the time workers ground the corner weld joints and then grained the surface of the door, so that the entire component looked uniform. As Estes explained, We didnt have a laser welding machine at the time, but in cooperation with one of the laser OEMs, we were able to run the parts and achieve very good results. It would be
He pointed out one recent application that required a full-penetration weld on a stainless steel corner joint with a clean root below and a cosmetically important surface on top. This required argon shielding below to cover the root, and nitrogen above to provide an inert atmosphere to shield the surface from impurities and help cool the metal. The heavy argon underneath supported the molten metal at the root. These are the kind of things you dont learn in school, Reddick said. We just had to determine what each gas did and how each gas affected the laser weld.
Our thought was that if we could create a surgically precise weld and eliminate the need for secondary operations, including grinding and graining, we could give the customer a superior product for a lot less money.
Ron Estes, Estes Design and Manufacturing
good candidates for laser welding. Technicians then ran samples, showed them to customers, and generated price comparisons. Sources conceded that acceptance of laser welding has occurred gradually, but at this point the level of acceptance has ramped up significantly, to the point where the fabricator soon may be installing a new laser welding system to handle the demand. The cost-reduction benefits speak louder than anything, Estes said.
Clever Fixturing
Consider a rectangular panel with 90-degree flanges, welded on all four corners. On our very best day with our very best equipment, we can
create a tight corner on all four sides, but the position in space of those four corners really has to be within half the width of a laser beam diameter, Estes said. Thats very challenging. Advanced equipment can bend flanges so that they mate perfectly to adjacent flanges, but the absolute positions of all four corners of the panel may not be exactly the same (again, less than the width of a laser beam) from part to part. This, sources said, comes from the unavoidable variability of sheet metal forming. We can form the corner precisely enough with our panel benders so that it will be extremely tight, and [laser welding] can fuse both edges of the material, Estes said. But to position all four corners in a point in space thats accurate enough for a precise CNC positioning system to bring a laser beam there, to weld at a specific point in space, thats where the clever fixturing design come into play. We term this, Bringing the corner to the laser, Reddick said. How exactly does the fabricator accomplish this? That, sources said, is proprietary, but generally speaking, the shops fixturing technology can hold joints accurately enough for the 4-kW, gantry-style laser system, which can position the processing head to within 0.003 in. in the X, Y, and Z dimensions. For each job, the fixture requires every bit as much thought as the parameters for the laser welding process itself. During the past few years the company has determined which of its existing products represent
FIGURE 2 For these samples, Estes technicians wanted them to look more like a formed section, and less like a welded corner joint.
Prima Power North America, 555 W. Algonquin Road, Arlington Heights, IL 60005, 847-9526500, www.primapower.com
91
Job Shepherds
Bobrowski was the shops second salesperson hired after Dave Fox launched Fedtech as a waterjet job shop in 1996. Today seven people, including Fox and Bobrowski, lead Fedtechs sales e orts. With 73 employees total, the companys salespeople make up a tenth of the overall workforce. e salespeople do more than just sell, though. ey estimate, work with engineering and programming personnel, and communicate with production to t the job into the schedule (see Figures 1 and 2). In a sense, theyre job shepherds. ey ensure no work order goes astray. As Bobrowski explained, several critical elements make this strategy work well. First, salespeople dont cover geographic territories. Instead, they focus on industries. is is roughly analogous to giving a specic beat to a newspaper reporter. Like most fabricators, Fedtech serves a horizontal market, one that feeds various vertical supply chains, from aerospace to power generation. Each salesperson becomes an expert in specic industries, which in turn helps him better relate to customers. If salespeople had geographic territories, they wouldnt become such industry experts, and they would have a tough time shepherding various types of jobs through the front o ce to the shop oor. One job may be for an aerospace company that demands extremely tight-tolerance work; the next customer might be a metal artist with a napkin sketch. ese market divisions arent etched in stone. Becoming an expert in certain industries is great, but a salesperson may have trouble providing adequate service if he has too many customers. ats why managers are careful not to overload any one salesperson. At this writing, for instance, many new customers that come onboard are being handled by Fedtechs newest salesperson, who was brought on earlier this year. e number of accounts a salesperson has isnt as important as the value and work that go into those accounts. For instance, one salesperson dedicated to the defense industry works with just
www.thefabricator.com/fab40
#30
Fedtech
ost fabricators recall 2009 with a sigh. ey talk of sales plummeting by 30, 40, sometimes more than 50 percent; the ensuing layo s; the hard choices; the hard times. But not Fedtech. In 2009 we had a record year. So said John Bobrowski. e sales manager at the St. Paul, Minn., fabricator said that the company may set another sales record this year. Revenue hit $13 million in 2011, and managers expect 2012 earnings to reach $15 million. He attributed the fabricators success to several factors. e company has an unusual technology
FIGURE 1 Kris Cabak conrms an order with a customer. Fedtechs salespeople shepherd orders through multiple front-o ce operations. ey act as the single point of contact for customers.
FIGURE 2 Sales personnel work closely with various front-office personnel, including Programmer Chris George (pictured), to shepherd jobs from order entry through production. three large customers. Another salesperson we have works with about 150 customers, and many of them may not do more than $100,000 worth of work with us a year, Bobrowski said. Theyre all small but very important customers to us. Another critical element is the salespersons technical expertise. Almost every salesperson at Fedtech started in technical positions on the shop floor, so they know the capabilities of turning versus milling versus waterjet cutting versus laser cutting. The one salesperson hired on from another company spent six months on the shop floor learning the intricacies of metal fabrication. and current capabilities were built up because of customer demand. It came about because they were satisfied with the services they were getting. What are these services exactly? It starts with the initial order and verification. There are so many details that arent necessarily on prints, Bobrowski said. When you get into some of the defense and medical applications, yes, those details are on the prints. Those orders are very detailed, very black and white. But when you get into the [ornamental] architectural sector, like artwork for airports and jobs of that nature, a lot of verification is done over the phone, working with people to develop what they want. And we have the same person there to answer all the questions and then work with production, to make sure the customers get what theyre looking for. This effectively eliminates any miscommunication between multiple people in the front office, because one person carries the job through multiple steps.
each machine. Some work centers are dedicated to certain part geometries; for instance, one waterjet has a rotary axis, so it receives a lot of 3-D cutting work. Another waterjet with no abrasive is dedicated to cutting plastics, urethanes, wood, and similar materials. This means we can run many jobs of a similar nature without having to completely re-set up the process, Bobrowski said, adding that integral to the setup is the substrate supporting the material being cut. Substrates can vary from foam to plastic to extremely heavy, thick cross members. Certain substrates are planed off level, to ensure the work material is perfectly perpendicular to the waterjetideal for extremely tight-tolerance work. Ultimately, the substrate type depends on whats being cut. There are quite a few cutting substrates that can be used on the watjerjet, Bobrowski said. If youre cutting small, delicate parts, youre putting them on foam. If were cutting 6-in.-thick steel, we use cross members that are 12 in. thick to hold it up. If you switch between foam and these heavy cross members from job to job, the setups would be prohibitively time-consuming.
About Service
Our competitive edge is customer service, Bobrowski said. He added that, yes, its a marketing clich, because every company on the planet says they have great customer service. But how do you define it? At Fedtech, its about having one point of contact, a technical expert who knows the customers market and communicates continually to ensure every party in the transaction is on the same page. Its nothing fancy, really. We just take a step back and try to provide whats often hard to get these days, with automated phone answering systems and outsourced customer service, Bobrowski said. Were just the opposite. Most important, when salespeople talk with customers, they provide immediate, truthful answers. Please hold, Ill transfer you isnt in their vocabulary. Senior Editor Tim Heston can be reached at timh@thefabricator.com. Images courtesy of Fedtech, 4763 Mustang Circle, St. Paul, MN 55112, 763-784-4600, www.fedtech.com.
Almost every salesperson at Fedtech started in technical positions on the shop floor.
Salespeople may not be absolute technical gurus, but they know enough to ask the gurus on the floor about manufacturing alternatives. Bobrowski recalled one job that kept increasing in price with every drawing revision. During the customer service process, though, the salesperson asked the CNC turning center operator about fixturing alternatives. It turned out that a slight design change made fixturing much easier and eliminated two turning operations. The change brought the quote back down nearly to the original price.
FIGURE 3 Fedtech has 11 waterjet machines, and each is dedicated to specific kinds of jobs, depending on the material type and thickness, part geometry, and tolerances required.
The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
93
y the time you read this, youll either be getting ready to elect a president, or youve recently cast your ballot. Once that happens, we still wont know for certain where business will be going during the next few years, but at least one unknown, the next president, will become known. e year has been full of unknowns. Where is Europe headed? How about China? How about that scal cli were supposed to be on the edge of? How about our future workforce? Where will the next press brake guru come from, the next welder, or the next machine programmer? Despite the uncertainties, fabricators are opening their wallets for capital equipment. According to the soon-to-be released 2013 Capital Spending Forecast, published by the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association, projected spending for U.S. metal fabricators climbed by 4 percent over last year. e total amountmore than $2.2 billion, a number extrapolated from a statistical sample of U.S. fabricatorsis just shy of where readers projected spending to be before the recession. Business owners continue to worry, but they know if they sit still, theyll be left behind. is years total spending projection may be even more signicant because nancing has changed since the heady days before the nancial crash, yet growth continues unabated. FMAs 2012 Financial Ratios & Operational Benchmarking Survey shows how nancially strong some companies are today. e weaker companies have been sold or shut their doors, and the strong rms continue to get stronger. ey know they need to invest in the business to ensure they maintain their strong position before the next dip in the business cycle. ese players are in positions to buy.
e Geography of Spending
Not only has spending increased substantially at these larger (but not the largest) plants, but the dollars spent has also become more concentrated. e Midwest always has been a metal fabrication center, and its becoming even more so.
Trend Data 2008-2013 Average Planned Spending Dollars Reported by Plant Size
1-19
$294,963 $186,085 $125,177 $91,587 $111,364 $414,531 $447,775 $243,534 $138,221 $232,843 $709,494 $633,860
20-49
1-49
100-249
$2,650,000
250-499
$500,980
$1,969,928 $2,011,364
500-999
$867,577
1000+
$1,093,666
$500,000
$1,000,000
$1,500,000
$2,000,000
$2,500,000
$3,000,000
$3,500,000
n 2013
n 2012
n 2011
n 2010
n 2009
n 2008
FIGURE 1 e average per-plant spending forecasts at companies with 500-999 employees more than tripled since the recession. Average spending projections at companies with 250-499 employees grew signicantly as well.
sourcing trend, with large OEMs outsourcing more metal fabrication work to reliable, top-performing contract fabricators. Larger top performers may have the scale and capacity to satisfy demand, while the smallest top performers can quickly turn around low volumes of specialized work.
Michigan - 14.9% Kentucky - 3.2% Florida - 3.3% California - 3.5% Ohio - 9.5% Minnesota - 4.3% Pennsylvania - 4.6% Wisconsin - 8.8% Illinois - 8.0% Texas - 7.1%
Michigan - 7.8%
Ohio - 7.4%
California - 6.7%
FIGURE 2 Spending trends are becoming geographically concentrated. is year in the top ve states, more dollars are predicted to be spent (48.4 percent of total spending). But those top ve states have slightly fewer plants (34.8 percent). Rounding out the top ve states are Michigan, Ohio, Wisconsin, Illinois, and Texasno surprises there. What is somewhat surprising is just how much equipment spending is expected to occur in these states. Metal fabrication plants in these top ve states make up 48.4 percent of total projected spending for the entire country. ats a higher geographic concentration of spending than projected in any FMA capital spending survey in the past 0 50000000 100000000 spending 150000000in pure 200000000 250000000 seven years. Still, while equipment dollar terms has become more geographically concentrated, actual metal fabrication plants have become less concentrated. In 2007 a little less than 40 percent of all metal fabrication plants in the survey were in just ve states. Today that number has decreased to 34.8 percent (see Figure 2).
Saws- Band Saws $133,568,455 Thermal Cutting MachinesPlasma $132,422,392 Waterjet Cutting Machines $91,320,398
(induction, roll, rotary draw, other)
(bevelers/notchers, flangers, folders, embossers, piercers, roll benders, seamers, scroll benders, spinning machines, stretch formers)
Other Sheet/Plate bending & forming equipment $79,521,157 Punch Press- Turret $78,739,750
After falling by almost 50 percent during the recession, total projected spending has bounced back almost to its pre-recession high.
All this may imply several signicant shifts in the industry landscape. First, when it comes to capital spendingboth in terms of dollars spent and number of metal fabrication plantsMichigan is ruling the roost, perhaps a testament to the automotive industrys resurgence. Second, operations that are spending the most are concentrated in fewer states. After the recession, stronger players have grown in these markets while the weaker players have fallen away. Today a local market may have fewer metal fabrication plants, but collectively theyre spending more. Consider Michigan again. e state has only 7.8 percent of all metal fabrication plants in the study, but they account for almost 15 percent of all dollars spent on capital equipment nationwide. ird, capital spending growth is concentrated at small companies and at larger operationsbut not at the largest operations. is may hint at an out-
Roll Forming Lines $52,901,235 Shears $52,757,977 Press Brake- Mechanical $49,801,655
(fineblanking, hydroforming, transfer, deep drawing, multislide)
Stamping Press- Hydraulic $40,763,384 Ironworkers $31,438,597 Coil Processing Equipment- Slitters $28,208,782 Stamping Press- Servo $27,609,704 Tube/Pipe Production Equipment- Welded Mills $27,153,883
(ERW mills, high-frequency, induction, laser, GTAW, plasma)
Punch Press- Single Station $23,728,717 Coil Processing Equipment- Cut-to-Length $22,947,311 Thermal Cutting Machines-Oxyfuel $21,931,482 Wire Bending Equipment $16,318,377 Coil Processing Equipment- Levelers $11,122,022 Coil Processing Equipment- Accumulators $5,287,519
$50,000,000
$100,000,000
$150,000,000
$200,000,000
$250,000,000
FIGURE 3 Like last year, welding power supplies topped the spending list. But laser cutting, turret presses, plasma cutting, and waterjet cutting all made signicant gains.
The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
95
Model Number
Enter reader service code 856636 at www.ffid.net AccuStream A-6015 AccuStream A-6030 AccuStream AS-6050 AccuStream AS-6075 AccuStream AS-60100 AccuStream AS-60150 15 30 50 75 100 150 60 60 60 60 60 60 .24 60 1.1 1.6 2.2 3.2
Enter reader service code 101902 at www.ffid.net HD 18 HD 37 APC 50 APC 50 APC 50 APC 50 APC 50 APC 50 24.8 49.5 60 60 60 60 60 60 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 .66 1.32 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3
Enter reader service code 1136854 at www.ffid.net 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 Enter reader service code 127381 at www.ffid.net AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD drive, Flow Intl. Direct Intensifier
D D
100
60
Mach 2 2031b
191
171
79
124
.004
.002
100
60
Mach 2 4020b
178
212
157
79
.004
.002
100
60
Mach 2 2020c
138
126
79
79
.003
.002
100
60
Mach 2 2030c
171
126
79
122
.003
.002
100
60
Mach 2 2040c
212
126
79
157
.003
.002
100
60
Mach 3 1313b
109
129
51
51
.002
.001
200
94
Mach 3 2513b
155
148
98
51
.002
.001
200
94
Mach 3 3020b
178
170
122
79
.002
.001
200
94
Mach 3 4020b
178
212
157
79
.002
.001
200
94
Mach 3 7320b
178
381
287
79
.002
.001
200
94
Mach 4 2020c
155
199
79
79
12
.001
.0005
200
94
*Accuracy per 24 in. of travel **File formats: AI=Adobe Illustrator, D=.dxf, I=IGES This information is provided by the manufacturers. For more information, use the corresponding advertising code at www.ffid.net or the links in the online buyers guide at www.thefabricator.com. Copyright 2012 by FMACommunications Inc. Reproduction in full or in part without written permission of the publisher is prohibited. Buyers guides are a part of the Forming & Fabricating Industry Directory.
Repeatability ( in.)
Accuracy ( in.)*
Manufacturer
Length (in.)
X Axis (in.)
Y Axis (in.)
Z Axis (in.)
Width (in.)
Model
Control and Software Machine Size Importable File Formats** Work Area Travel, Accuracy, and Repeatability Repeatability ( in.) Accuracy ( in.)* CAD/CAM Software Available From Machine Vendor
Pump
Model Number
Mach 4 2080c
413
199
79
315
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 3020c
155
238
122
79
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 3030c
196
238
122
122
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 3080c
413
238
122
315
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 30100c
498
238
122
394
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 30130c
628
238
122
512
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 4020c
155
278
157
79
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 4030c
196
278
157
122
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 4050c
284
278
157
197
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 4070c
369
278
157
276
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 40100c
498
278
157
394
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 40110c
543
278
157
433
12
.001
.0005
Mach 4 40140c
672
278
157
551
12
.001
.0005
AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD AI, D, I, DWG, SLDPRT, Step, Catia, ORD
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
200
94
Enter reader service code 1088012 at www.ffid.net 200 200 200 125 125 125 125 125 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 4.0 4.0 4.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0
Enter reader service code 473289 at www.ffid.net iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 .65-4 .65-4 .65-4 .65-4 .65-4 .65-4 .65-4 .65-4 .65-4 .65-4
Manufacturer
Length (in.)
X Axis (in.)
Y Axis (in.)
Z Axis (in.)
Width (in.)
Model
97
Model Number
HR412 HR68 HR610 HR612 HR614 HR84 HR812 HR814 HR1012 HR1014 HR128 HR1212 HR1214 HR148 HR1414 HR168 HR1610 HR1812 HR2410
48 72 72 72 72 96 96 96 120 120 144 144 144 168 168 192 192 216 240
144 96 120 144 168 48 144 168 144 168 96 144 168 96 168 96 120 144 120
144 96 120 144 168 48 144 168 144 168 96 144 168 96 168 96 120 144 120
48 72 72 72 72 96 96 96 120 120 144 144 144 168 168 192 192 216 240
12 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18 12, 18
.001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001
.001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001 .001
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A
AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI,D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I Ai, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I AI, D, I
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge Jet Edge
iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP or xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP or xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series iP and xP Series Streamline PRO2 125 Streamline PRO2 60 Streamline SL-V 50 Streamline SL-V 100 Streamline SL-V 200 SL-V 15Plus Streamline S30 Streamline S50 Streamline E30 Streamline E50 NEOLine
30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200 30-200
36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90 36, 60, 90
Enter reader service code 153725 at www.ffid.net 125 60 50 100 200 15 30 50 30 50 40 90 90 60 60 60 60 60 60 55 55 55 1.43 .73 1.0 2.0 4.0 .30 .52 .88 .6 1.0 .72
Enter reader service code 928367 at www.ffid.net 10 67 67 67 40 40 Streamline V50 Streamline V50 Streamline Streamline Streamline Streamline Streamline Pro S50 50 50 40 58 58 58 55 55 60 60 .72 .72 .95 .95
Enter reader service code 199945 at www.ffid.net 60 125 125 125 60 60 90 90 90 90 100 60 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2
OMAX, Kent, WA
OMAX 80X OMAX 80X OMAX 80X 120X/S 120X 265 265 265 260 340 152 152 152 207 207 80 80 80 182 240 165 165 165 137 120 .003 .003 .003 .002 .002 .002 .0005 .002 2 2 2 5 5 4 4 4 4 4 A A A A A Vector, Raster Vector, Raster All 4 4 4 4 4 OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX
Enter reader service code 232349 at www.ffid.net Direct drive Direct drive Direct drive EnduroMAX EnduroMAX 40 40 40 50 50 55 55 55 60 60 2.4 2.4
Repeatability ( in.)
Accuracy ( in.)*
Manufacturer
Length (in.)
X Axis (in.)
Y Axis (in.)
Z Axis (in.)
Width (in.)
Model
Control and Software Machine Size Importable File Formats** Work Area Travel, Accuracy, and Repeatability Repeatability ( in.) Accuracy ( in.)* CAD/CAM Software Available From Machine Vendor
Pump
Model Number
OMAX 80160 OMAX 60120 120X-1 120X-2 OMAX 55100 120X-3 120X-4 OMAX 2652 OMAX 2626 80X 80X-1 80X-2 80160 2626xp 60120 55100 MAXIEM 2040 5555 2652 MAXIEM 1530
243 225 420 500 155 585 665 139 116 265 338 440 243 116 225 155 202 131 139 164
134 110 230 230 94 230 230 67 72 152 152 175 134 72 110 94 112 95 67 98
80 126 320 400 100 480 560 52 26 165 240 320 168 29 126 100 160 55 52 122
.003 .003
2 2 5 5 2 5 5 2 2 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
A A A
All All Vector, Raster Vector, Raster All Vector, Raster Vector, Raster All All Vector, Raster Vector, Raster Most vector, raster formats Vector, Raster Vector, Raster Vector, Raster Vector, Raster DWG, DXF, OMX, ORD, AI, PDF, SVG, Raster Vector, Raster Vector, Raster DWG, DXF, OMX, ORD, AI, PDF, SVG, RASTER DWG, DXF, OMX, ORD, AI, PDF, SVG, RASTER DWG, DXF, OMX, ORD, AI, PDF, SVG, Raster Vector, Raster To spec.
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX OMAX MAXIEM OMAX OMAX MAXIEM
Direct drive Direct drive EnduroMAX EnduroMAX Direct drive EnduroMAX EnduroMAX Direct drive Direct drive EnduroMAX EnduroMAX EnduroMAX EnduroMAX EnduroMAX EnduroMAX EnduroMAX Direct drive EnduroMAX EnduroMAX Direct drive
40 40 50 50 40 50 50 40 40 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 40 50 50 40
55 55 60 60 55 60 60 55 55 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 50 60 60 50 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 1.9 2.4 2.4 1.9 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4
.003
A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A
.003 .003
.002
105
98
62
62
.001
MAXIEM
Direct drive
40
50
72 116
66 72
30 29
30 26
.001 .0005
5 5
4 4
A A
4 4
MAXIEM OMAX
40 50
50 60
Enter reader service code 316456 at www.ffid.net 100,000 Enter reader service code 930039 at www.ffid.net Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Quantum 66 66 .8 ESP 66 Enter reader service code 1021417 at www.ffid.net 122 7.8 .0019 .0019 3 4 A D 4 SL-V 50 50 60 .90
Enter reader service code 547653 at www.ffid.net WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 WJ-150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 150 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 90 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3
Manufacturer
Length (in.)
X Axis (in.)
Y Axis (in.)
Z Axis (in.)
Width (in.)
Model
99
News News and and information information from from the the Fabricators Fabricators && Manufacturers Manufacturers Association, Association, International International
IN THE KNOW
Day is that companies collaborated, said Ed Youdell, president and CEO of FMA. Perhaps one company in an industrial park got a notice and decided that this was a good reason to contact their industrial park neighbors even if they didnt know them. They also reached out to regional economic development offices or other regional manufacturing groups, believing that the more companies that got involved, the more newsworthy the message would be, and the greater the reach they would have into their community. Manufacturing has been suffering from a skilled-labor shortage for years. Even in the depths of the recession, manufacturers have found it difficult to hire people with the skills they need. With the average age of manufacturing personnel in the U.S. standing at 56 and the potential for almost two-thirds of the manufacturing workforce to retire over the next decade, companies know that they must focus on who will replace those retiring workers. Its not enough to look at interested high school seniors or community college students although they are important for shortterm hiring needs, said Edwin Stanley, vice president of GH Metal Solutions in Fort Payne, Ala. We need to be focused on how to entice students who are currently in middle school and junior high to consider
manufacturing careers. They must understand that math, science, computer, and other technology coursework is important for the kind of career training they will need once
they graduate from high school. We want them to have the time to take the right coursework and to realize it is their key to a well-paid, exciting career in our industry. Thats why I was so pleased that our Manufacturing Day open
house welcomed 110 students ranging from fifth grade up through the community college level. We need them all to want to work in our industry. Manufacturing Day will occur every year on the first Friday in October. For more information, visit mfgday.com or view the photos and stories from this years program on facebook.com/mfgday. n
Continuing Education
Networking Events
TRAINING
ALERT
FABTECH Conference
Nov. 12-14, 2012 Las Vegas, Nev.
the manufacturing segment performancearming you with the comprehensive analysis you need to make sound business decisions. Conference alumni and attendees new to the Toll Processing Conference will gain steel market insight from industry experts and worldclass speakers. As the conference kicks off at the height of basketball season, the theme of this years event is Business on the ReboundOr Is It a Double Dribble? Participants will hear how the political landscape in 2013 will affect the North American steel industry and learn whats in store for metal processors. In addition to hearing a broad global economy view from Kuehl, steel market analyst and conference favorite Glenn Kidd, Steel Market Analyst Glenn Kidd will present an outlook specific to the metals industry. Valuable networking time during peer-to-peer roundtable discussions, golf tournaments, and fun evening receptions round out the events, making them must attend for
those working to move ahead in todays competitive market. Dont miss out on this exciting opportunity to expand your network of professional contacts and strengthen existing business relationships. Make plans now to participate in order to receive the special FMA room rate ($199/ night) at the Innisbrook Resort and take advantage of airfare deals. Plus, save $200 on conference fees when you sign up by Jan. 7, 2013!* (Conference fees: $745 FMA Members, $995 General.) Additional details on the programs, registration, as well as sponsorships and exhibit opportunities can be found at: fmanet. org/metalmatters, fmanet.org/ tollprocessing or by calling 888394-4362. n
*Not applicable with any other registration discounts or promotional offers.
Manufacturing Day
Oct. 4, 2013
FabCasts:
Plate Cutting Comparative Methods
Dec. 6, 2012 | 10-11:30 a.m. CT
or call 888-394-4362
The FABRICATOR | www.thefabricator.com | NOVEMBER 2012
101
Rust-removing gel
Daubert Cromwell has introduced NoxRust Premium rust-removing gel, a waterbased, brushon rust remover. e gel takes o surface rust from steel, iron, and most metal surfaces without scrubbing or sanding. Acid-free, nontoxic, and ready to use, the gel can be applied by brush or roller. e thick, nonhazardous gel clings to vertical surfaces, making it suitable for derusting large or heavy metal components that are di cult to move. Light rust begins to break up within 15 to 20 minutes of application.
Daubert Cromwell | 800-535-3535 | www.daubertcromwell.com
RoboVent has introduced its mobile dust collection system, incorporating the companys PowerFlex pulsing system to keep lters cleaner for a consistent airow through the collector. e system collects dirty air, lters it, and releases it clean. Applications include metalworking, abrasive blasting, woodworking, and chemical production. e heavy-duty, 7-ga. construction is 100 percent welded. e unit can be truck-mounted.
RoboVent | 888-762-6836 | www.robovent.com
e GOM Atos ScanBox from Capture 3D Inc. is constructed and engineered to industrial standards to help ensure safety and mobility. Setup is plug-and-play. e unit includes an Atos Triple Scan digitizer, robot, rotary stage, software, and safety house. All elements are contained in one box.
Capture 3D Inc. | 714-546-7278 | www.capture3d.com
Laser Mechs Reflecting Parabola Focusing Heads are available in a variety of styles and configurations to satisfy even the most demanding industrial welding applications. Our most popular heads feature: Fixed input with preset index swivel, adjustable beam separation and fixed focus housing Fixed input with 360 swivel, air knife, interlocks, and parabola positioning and referencing using 1 incremental markings Contact a Laser Mech Sales Engineer today for more information on our complete line of Reflecting Parabola Focusing Heads.
(248) 474-9480
www.lasermech.com Fax: (248) 474-9277
Fiber laser
Amada o ers the FOL3015AJ ber laser, which the company says is the rst 4,000-W production ber laser designed specically for cutting. A 2,000-W model also is available. According to the manufacturer, the machine cuts thin material two to four times faster than a comparable 4,000-W CO2 laser. e ber laser cuts material thicknesses up to 0.875 in., and process range expansion (PRE) allows laser cutting of copper, brass, titanium, and other di cultto-process materials. e resonator generates a laser beam with a wavelength that is about one-tenth of that emitted by a conventional gas laser, allowing the system to cut materials that a CO2 laser cannot process. e machine also cuts thin-gauge materials at high speeds, with no optics or space inside the cavity of the laser source. With solid-state technology, no laser gas is required to generate the laser beam. Maximum cutting speed is 9,449 IPM. With all three axes driven by linear drives, the machine features a traverse speed of 13,380 IPM and a 5G acceleration speed for the work envelope.
Amada America Inc. | 877-262-3287 | www.amada.com
www.5Ssupply.com
888 4 LEAN 5S
Burr Oak Tool Inc. has introduced the small-diameter vertical-bend hairpin bender (SD VBHD) with throughput capacities up to 4,000 hairpins per hour and eight parts per cycle. e compact bending machine helps reduce scrap, labor, and oor space. It handles tubes up to 0.375 in.
Burr Oak Tool Inc. | 269-651-9393 | www.burroak.com
103
TRUMPF o ers the TruTool PN 200 prole nibbler for cutting mild steel sheet thicknesses up to 0.08 in. It is suitable for making diagonal cuts in trapezoidal sheets and for cutting CL-U proles. e tool features a 72-position rotation for changing cutting direction, which can be adjusted 360 degrees. e punch achieves quality cuts at a working speed of more than 6.5 FPM with cutting radii as small as 2 in. e unit is available for electric, cordless, or pneumatic operation, allowing users to choose the version most suited to their needs. e toolchange feature permits the tool to be replaced in seconds with no netuning needed.
TRUMPF Inc. | 860-255-6104 | www.us.trumpf.com
Abrasive waterjet
Vac-U-Max has introduced the model 1050 continuous-duty industrial vacuum. e unit features 100 percent more lter area than the previous model 1020. e increased capacity allows it to lter ne powders, reducing the load on the vacuum producer to put more power at the end of the hose. is gives the operator more power for an extended period of time, the company states. e atmospheric blowback system allows users to clean lters without compressed air, without having to turn o the vacuum. e motor can continue running while users change out lled drums or hoppers. According to the manufacturer, the unit is the quietest continuousduty industrial vacuum in the industry. e diameter of the front wheels has been increased from 10 to 14 in., and the 8-in. caster on the rear has been replaced with a dual 8-in. swivel caster for maneuverability.
Vac-U-Max | 800-822-8629 | www.vac-u-max.com
ABB Robotics o ers the IRB 120T multipurpose six-axis robot. In a 2.2-lb. picking cycle of 0.98 by 11.81 by 0.98 in., the robot completes a cycle in 0.52 sec., a 10 percent improvement over the 0.58 sec. of the standard IRB 120 model. With the addition of a 180-degree axis 6 reorientation to the movement, the speed improvement grows to 25 percent, 0.69 sec. per cycle compared to 0.92 sec. e robot is suitable for assembly and pick-and-place applications requiring extensive reorientation of the product. It features path repeatability of 0.0004 in., a standard payload of 6.6 lbs., a vertical wrist payload of 8.8 lbs., a reach of 22.83 in., a 16.18-in. stroke, and the ability to reach 4.41 in. below its base.
ABB Robotics | 248-391-9000 | www.abb.com/robotics
Peddinghaus Corp. has developed material handling systems to suit the needs of large and small fabrication shops. e systems are tailored to the specic needs of each facility in terms of footprint, modular design, and throughput. Indoor shop footprint can be minimized by placing material handling conveyors outside. e systems can withstand the elements outdoors alongside steel proles, allowing fabricators to place all material handling in-feeds and unprocessed steel outside to help minimize the systems total footprint within the main shop. Using a modular design, the systems are congurable to large and small shops. Conveyors and machines can be congured in many di erent patterns, arranged for each fabricators needs. e modular design also reduces the need to handle material with a crane or fork truck.
Peddinghaus Corp. | 815-937-3800 | www.peddinghaus.com
Valve-free respirator
e AirWave valve-free respirator from Moldex-Metric features a patent-pending wave design to allow increased airow in and out of the respirator. e waves double the lter surface area of the companys comparable respirator. e Dura-Mesh shell provides bidirectional protection from dirt on the outside and moisture on the inside. With its FlexFit design, the respirator expands and contracts as the wearer moves and speaks to help increase comfort. A pinchfree molded nose bridge eliminates metal nose-band readjustment and discomfort. For inhaling and exhaling, the respirator provides decreased resistance for easier breathing and decreased heat and moisture buildup.
Moldex-Metric Inc. | 800-421-0668 | www.moldex.com
105
Downdraft table
Airow Systems Inc. o ers the DT-3000V2 downdraft table, designed to provide sourcepoint collection and ltration of powder, dust, fumes, smoke, and other contaminants produced during industrial processing and production operations. e unit generates 195 FPM of downdraft air velocity across the 19.25-sq.-ft., grate-style work surface to draw contaminants down and away from the workers breathing zone. Contaminants then are collected and ltered from the airow path using a MERV 17 after-lter. e tables Vibra-Pulse lter cleaning system combines high-pressure compressed air and a random-motion impacter to remove dirt from within the lter pleats, returning the lter to its original dust-holding capacity. e direct-drive blower design eliminates belt and pulley repair, the manufacturer states.
Airow Systems Inc. | 214-503-8008 | www.airowsystems.com
Tank cleaner
TankJet 55 tank cleaner is available from Spraying Systems Co. e unit operates at low ows and fast cycle times to clean multiple tanks, barrels, and drums in minutes, says the company. Constructed of 316L stainless steel with carbon-lled PTFE seals, the compact cleaner ts in openings as small as 1.75 in. e standard model is suitable for fast rotation and short cycle times, while the slow rotational model has the dwell time to clean tougher residues. e uid-driven, turbine-driven cleaner uses narrow-angle, full-cone sprays rotating in multiple axes for 360-degree coverage. It is suitable for cleaning 59-gal. barrels; 55-gal. drums; and small tanks, containers, and totes.
Spraying Systems Co. | 630-665-5000 | www.tankjet.com
Pat Mooney Inc. e Saw Company o ers the Danobat iDS 5A automatic band saw. It features twin prismatic guide columns to help ensure torsion-free travel throughout the sawing range. e main prismatic guide column travels on linear rails and linear bearings, while the support prismatic guide column travels on free rollers. A hydraulic gripper vise positions material to the proper cut length. Two hydraulic cylinders control the saw head. e saw head columns and saw head are lled with polymer concrete to remove any vibration from the sawing cycle. e Intellicut software stores material speed and feed information in a library and allows the saw to be run as a machine tool. Once set, the exact blade speed and feed rate for either a bimetal or carbide blade is selected. e saw operator selects the material grade and type of saw blade, and the unit sets the proper blade speed, feed rate, and production parameters. Based on the selection, the saw blade ramps into the cut and proceeds at an optimum feed rate at all times, the company states.
Pat Mooney Inc. e Saw Co. | 800-323-7503 | www.patmooneysaws.com
107
Adhesives guide
The Loctite Adhesive Sourcebook, Vol. 12, from Henkel Corp. is a 202-page print and online guide to the companys Loctite adhesives, sealants, lubricants, coatings, and dispensing/ curing equipment for industrial manufacturing and maintenance. e book features technical information on more than 1,200 products and includes decision trees to guide the adhesive selection process. e guide is divided into industrial application categories: bonding; coatings; ooring and concrete repair; gasketing and sealing; lubricating; machining compounds; potting and encapsulating; repairing, rebuilding, and restoring; retaining; surface cleaning; threadlocking; thread sealing; toolboxes and specialty kits; medical devices; and equipment. Each category features product selector guides; typical applications; and information on primers, accelerators, and dispensing and curing equipment options. Selector guides provide product descriptions and technical information in an at-aglance format. e sourcebook also features a quick-reference list of products that meet agency and regulatory approvals from ABS, CFIA, CSA, FDA, ISO, Mil-Spec, NSF, UL, ULC, NEHC, and NAVSEA.
Henkel Corp. | 800-562-8483 | www.henkelna.com/asb
Diehl Steel Co. o ers tool steel, alloy steel, high-speed steel, carbon steel, powder metal products, stainless steel, and aluminum to tool-, mold, and diemakers. e products are squared to toolmaker tolerance with the manufacturers Accu-Square process. e company reports that each processed piece is delivered at, square, and parallel to help reduce or eliminate the need for customers to square the metal block further. According to the company, the process allows it to machine orders to exact tolerances while maintaining quick turnaround time.
Diehl Steel Co. | 513-242-8900 | www.diehlsteel.com
Lubrication handbook
e Practical Handbook of Machinery Lubrication now is available from Noria Corp. in a completely rewritten fourth edition. Originally written 20 years ago by Lloyd Tex Leugner, president of Maintenance Technology Intl. Inc., the book gives a blueprint for lubrication fundamentals. Robert Scott, a Noria course instructor and 30-year veteran of the lubrication industry, authored much of the most recent edition of the book, which addresses specic new topics such as oil properties and testing, oil analysis, grease applications, journal bearings, compressors, contamination control, storage and handling, wear and failure mechanisms, and troubleshooting. Available for a fee, the new, 220-page edition also contains updated graphics and illustrations.
Noria Corp. | 800-597-5460 | www.noria.com
Huntingdon Fusion Techniques Ltd. o ers the PurgEye family of Weld Purge Monitors for welding stainless steel and titanium tubes and pipes. e entry-level 100 model is a general-purpose, everyday monitor capable of measuring oxygen levels down to 100 PPM. It is suitable for most stainless steels. e 300, which measures to 10 PPM oxygen, has integral software to record oxygen levels throughout the weld purging cycle and to produce a postweld quality control document. It also o ers relays to switch welding machines or alarms on and o if oxygen levels rise above operator-preset limits. e 300 nano is designed for operators wanting a simpler, low-cost unit, the company reports. e small, hand-held instrument uses zirconia cell technology. e 500 has all the features of the 300, plus an integral pump that continuously extracts samples of the gas from the volume being purged for analysis. e 600 is the highest-specication device, measuring from atmosphere to 10 PPM in one instrument. e unit integrates the measuring system with a large touchscreen and records data using PurgLog software. e results can be loaded onto a ash drive for subsequent processing elsewhere.
Huntingdon Fusion Techniques Ltd. | 44-1554-836836 | www.huntingdonfusion.com
109
FAB
Fischer Technologys MMS NICKELSCOPE is a multimeasurement system that uses the Hall E ect test method for nondestructive coating thickness measurement of electroplated nickel coatings on electrically nonconductive or nonferrous substrates, as well as nonferrous metal coatings (copper, aluminum, lead) on steel. It also is suitable for measuring thick, nonferrous coatings. e system provides up to 50 application memories and handles 20,000 measurements in up to 2,000 groups. e unit, which features a large, atscreen LCD, provides full statistic and graphic evaluation capabilities. e companys DataCenter software expands the units functionality for transfer, evaluation, and printing of measurement data to personalized inspection reports. e system conforms to DIN EN ISO 2178.
Fischer Technology Inc. | 800-243-8417 | www.scher-technology.com
FCAW-G wire
Lincoln Electric o ers the new UltraCore HD-M ux-cored wire. e 75 percent argon/25 percent CO2 gasshielded FCAW-G wire is designed to provide deposition rates of more than 10 lbs./hr. out of position. e fast-freezing slag helps produce a at bead face in all positions. e wire conforms to AWS A5.20/ A5.20M: E71T-1M / 9M-H8 classication and is ABS-approved to 3YSA H10. Available in 15-, 33-, and 50-lb. packages, the wire comes in standard diameters of 0.045, 0.052, and 0.0625 in.
Lincoln Electric | 888-355-3213 | www.lincolnelectric.com
Forrest Mfg. o ers in-factory sharpening and repairs of all makes of carbide-tipped circular saw blades. e sharpening process takes about 20 min. per blade and uses automated, high-speed, diamond-grit machines with ood cooling. e front of the tip is sharpened by face grinding, after which the top cutting edge is nenished. e process removes about 0.010 to 0.020 in., allowing a blade to be sharpened eight to 10 times over its life under normal operation. Repair services include straightening bent teeth, replacing tips, regrinding both sides of all teeth, providing extra top grind for extremely dull blades, opening gullets, tightening or enlarging the bore, and welding or replacing steel shoulders.
Forrest Mfg. | 800-733-7111 | www.forrestblades.com
111
Jet Edge Inc. has introduced the EcoJet waterjet pump. e 55-KSI, 30-HP unit features a direct-drive pump design that consumes up to 40 percent less electricity than a 50-HP pump while producing the same output, the manufacturer reports. e pump produces up to 1 GPM of ultrahigh-pressure water for precision cutting, cleaning, and surface preparation applications. It runs a 0.015-in. waterjet orice and can power most manufacturers waterjet cutting systems and waterjet tools.
Jet Edge | 800-538-3343 | www.jetedge.com
Kinetic Technologies Inc. has developed a low-prole cart that spins on its own length to simplify the unloading of bulk containers lled with large items. e six-wheeled cart measures 6.5 in. high from oor to deck and has a 50- by 50-in. usable deck area. Additional features include a self-stowing, spring-loaded towbar; clevis/pin hitch; corner load stops; and a powder paint nish. e cart is available in 500- or 1,000-lb. load ratings.
Kinetic Technologies Inc. | 440-943-4111 | www.ktecinc.com
e M. K. Morse Co. has introduced Metal Devil New Xtreme Technology (NXT) aluminum-cutting circular saw blades. Ten blades are available from 5.375 to 14 in. dia. According to the manufacturer, the blades provide smooth, fast cuts in a variety of aluminum shapes and solids.
M. K. Morse Co. | 330-453-8187 | www.mkmorse.com
Tempil, an ITW Company, has updated its Temp-Stik test kit to include 5-in. Tempilstiks in place of the 2.5-in. sticks in the previous test kits. e sticks measure 125, 150, 175, 200, 225, 250, 275, 300, 325, 350, 375, 400, 425, 450, 475, 500, 550, 600, 700, and 800 degrees F. e temperature-indicating sticks can be stroked on a workpiece from time to time during a heating operation. When the rating is reached, the stick leaves a liquid smear. e new package includes a basic guide to ferrous metallurgy, as well as preheat charts.
Tempil | 800-757-8300 | www.tempil.com
Filler metals
Wall Colmonoy o ers Nicrobraz 31, 33, and 152 Ni-CrSi-P ller metals. e alloys were developed for use in the fabrication of modern heat exchanger systems. According to the manufacturer, the metals use optimal proportions of phosphorus and silicon, minimizing alloying interactions between the ller metal and base materials to provide corrosion resistance, increased joint strength, and improved substrate structural integrity. Brazing ller metal Nicrobraz 31 is formulated to provide a lower brazing temperature compared to Nicrobraz 30, BNi-5. e alloy is recommended for applications in which boron-containing ller metals cannot be used. e ller metal also is used to braze assemblies made of thin sheet metal as the di usion with the base metal is minimized.
Wall Colmonoy | 248-585-6400 | www.wallcolmonoy.com
113
Portable CMM
Hexagon Metrology has introduced the She eld 4.5.4 SF, a new line of CMMs built for the shop oor and designed to withstand harsh manufacturing environments. e portable unit has a footprint of 52.2 by 32.8 by 79.5 in., which ts through a standard door. e computer, controller, and interface boxes are integrated into one self-contained unit with locking wheels for mobility throughout the shop oor. e CMM also uses standard 110-/220-V outlets with no need for shop air. Hardened linear drives and recirculating bearings add to overall durability. Standard elastomeric dampers isolate the measuring platform from most vibrations. Inverted, high-resolution Heidenhain scales; covered ways; and internal cable management protect machine components from ambient dust and debris while minimizing friction. An optional active vibration dampening system is available for extreme environments. Advanced thermal isolation and temperature compensation elements help ensure accuracy in unstable shop oor environments.
Hexagon Metrology | 800-274-9433 | www.hexagonmetrology.us
Biodegradable lubricants
Metalloid Corp. o ers Addvance 6110 and Addvance 6370 biodegradable metal forming lubricants that can replace heavy chlorinated soluble oils. ese lubricants can handle heavy-duty metal stamping or be diluted with water for lighterduty operations on all metals. ese products are worker-friendly and environmentally clean, says the company, and have received biopreferred approvals by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Both products o er corrosion protection, long die life, and antiwear properties. ey are weldable without cleaning and clean o easily in ambient water.
Metalloid Corp. | 800-686-3201 | www.metalloidcorp.com
Hydraulic winch
Bloom Mfg. Inc. has introduced the new LS80K Lift-Safe planetary winch with a 65,000-lb. lifting capacity. e modularly constructed unit can be adapted to specic drum sizes and cable holding requirements. In addition, it can be ordered with grooved drums, as well as special drum lengths and diameters. e patented Duet-Safe doubleaction braking system combines a hydraulic brake with a hydraulic braking valve to hold loads automatically when hydraulic pressure is released and to control speeds during lowering operations. e winchs 5.125-in.-dia., heattreated alloy steel drum shaft is supported on both ends with heavy-duty, lubricated bearings.
Bloom Mfg. Inc. | 319-827-1139 | www.bloommfg.com
Anver Corp. o ers the E-series millduty vacuum lifter, a single-operator, heavy-duty, high-capacity lifter designed for handling heavy ferrous and nonferrous plate and sheet from the top for loading cutting tables. Featuring an all-welded steel frame and fully adjustable cross beams, the rigid lifter can be integrated with an overhead crane, incorporate redundant power stations, and be set up for radio control. Custom built with capacities up to 60,000 lbs. and multiple rectangular or round suction cups and doublespring suspensions, the lifter can handle steel plate up to 80 by 8 ft. e pendant control requires twohand operation. In case of power loss, the unit has a self-contained vacuum reservoir, check valves, and a leakage sensor with audiovisual alarms.
Anver Corp. | 800-654-3500 | www.anver.com
Finished-part rack
Royal Products has introduced the EconoRack, a device that collects nished parts as they come o of any bar-fed CNC lathe. It prevents damage to nished parts by feeding products onto a turntable covered by a low-friction UHMW material instead of into an oil-lled collection bucket. e rack enables manufacturers to let machine tools run unattended for extended periods. Free standing with adjustable height, it can be moved from machine to machine. With its compact, 28-in. diameter and 100-lb. load capacity, the rack is suitable for Swiss-type applications.
Royal Products | 800-645-4174 | www.royalprod.com
115
Classied Advertising > > preowned machinery, business opportunities, services, and more
USED MACHINERY FOR SALE
SERVICES
AMADA
Pega 255, 50" x 50" ball, 31 Sta. 3 A/I, 18P control, 2003 Vipros 255, 50" x 50" brush, 31 Sta. 3 A/I, 18P control, 2001 EM2510NT, 50" x 100" brush, 45 Sta. 4 A/I, NT control with MP1225NJ load, 2007 Octo 334, 30" x 40", 8 Sta. 1 A/I, 1984 Pega 357, 50" x 72", 58 Sta. 2 A/I, 04PC, 1994 Vipros 358 King II, 50" x 80", Brush table, 58 Sta. 4 A/I, Fanuc 18P, 1999 Apelio III 357, 50" x 72", 58 Sta. 2 A/I, 16L control, 2000 watt Fanuc Osc, 1998 Vipros 367 Queen, 60" x 72", 45 Sta. 4 A/I, 18P control, 2001 Vipros 368 King II, 60" x 80", 58 Sta. 4 A/I, 18P control, 2000
STRIPPIT
33 Ton FC-1000S, 40" x 50, GE Fanuc 0P, 1994 33 Ton FC-1250S, 50" x 80" ball table, 33 Sta. 3 A/I, GE Fanuc 0P, 2003 33 Ton Global 30 1225, 50" x 100" table, 33 Sta. 3 A/I, GE Fanuc 180i control, 2002
TRUMPF
TC1000R Rotation, 50" x 80" table, Bosch control, 15 tool cap, 2006
WIEDEMANN
33 Ton Vectrum 3000, 50" x 80" table, 52 Sta. 2 A/I, Fanuc 0P control, 114 style tooling, 1995
VIPROS 368 King, 18P, 2002 VIPROS 367Q, 18P, 1999 APELIO III 357V, 2kW, 1998 PEGA 367, 04PC, 1993 VIPROS 358 King II, 18P, 2000 VIPROS 358 King, 04PC, 1996 VIPROS 357Q, 04PC, 18P, 2001 PEGA 357, 04PC, 1994 PEGA 345Q, 04PC, 2000 PEGA 345K, 04PC, 1990 OCTO 334, 6M, Thick A/I EM2510NT, MP1225NJ, 2007 PEGA 255, 18P, 2003 VIPROS 255, 18P, 2000 AMADA MP1225NJ, 1999
STRIPPIT PUNCHES
PRESS BRAKES
Amada RG-3512-LD, LD control & BG, 2001 Amada RG-50, NC9EXII, 1998 Amada RG80, 8' O.A., NC9EXII, 1997 Amada FBDIII 1030NT, 10', 7-Axis BG, 2000 Amada HDS 1303, 10', 7-Axis BG, 2004 Amada HFB1704, 187 ton x 14', 5-Axis Operateur control and BG, TFT upgrade, 1993 Amada HFB1704, 187 ton x 14', 5-Axis Operateur control and BG, 1995 Amada HFE2204, 240 ton x 14', 7-Axis Operateur control, 5-Axis BG, 2006
Global 1225, 33 Ton, 2002, Thick Global 1525, 33 Ton, 2004, Thick FC1250H20, 50" x 100", Thin
TRUMPF PUNCHES
LASERS
LASERS
Amada Pulsar LC2415AII, 2kW, 5' x 12', 1998 Amada Altair LCV-3015, 2kW, 5'x 10' Dual, Fanuc 16L, 1998, 14K total hours Amada Gemini FO3015 NT, 5' x 10' Dual, 4kW, 2006 Amada Gemini FO4020NT, 6' x 12' Dual, 4kW, NT control, 2005 Mazak NTX 510 Champion, 1500 watt, 1999 Mazak 510 Flexible manufacturing system, 1999 Trumpf L3030, 4000 Watt, 5' x 10' Dual, Siemens control, 2002 Trumpf L3030, 4000 Watt, 5' x 10' Dual, Siemens control, equipped with rotary, 2003
TRUMPF L3050, 5kW, 2003 TRUMPF L3030, 4kW, 2002 (2) MITSUBISHI ML3015LXP, 3kW, 1997 AMADA F04020NT, 4kW, 2005 AMADA PULSAR 2415NT, 4kW, 2006 AMADA FOL3015NT, 4.5kW, 2006 AMADA GEMINI F03015NT, 2007 CINCINNATI CL707, 3300 Watt, 2004 AMADA PULSAR 1212A2, 2kW, 1998 MAZAK NTX510, 1.5kW, 1999
CNC PRESS BRAKES
MISC.
Amada MP1225 NJ load/unload, 1999 Trumpf Liftmaster 5 x 10 laser load/unload
See Web site Call / E-mail for Current Listings Wanted - Used / Surplus Machines
AMADA HFE2204, 2006 AMADA HFB2204, 1992 AMADA HFB1704, 1993, 1995 (2) AMADA FBD1253NT, 2006 TRUMPF C120, 2006 AMADA HFE1304, 2001 AMADA RG100, NC9EXII, 2000 AMADA FBDIII 1030NT, 2000 AMADA FBDIII 8025NT, 2000 AMADA RG80, NC9EXII, 2000 AMADA RG50, NC9EXII, 1997 AMADA RG3512LD, 2001 Check our website for a complete listing of equipment. Ph: 845-398-0073 Fax: 845-398-0074 jc@jordancraigmachinery.com www.jordancraigmachinery.com
tell these advertisers you saw their ad in The FABRICATOR < < Index
of Advertisers
Please visit our advertisers showrooms by entering their reader service codes at www. d.net
RS Code RS Code
866-322-8665 Toll Free
Page
Page
RS Code
716-542-4511 / 1-800-828-1527
Page
102149 LVD Strippit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 505334 Magnetic Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .114 115588 Mate Precision Tooling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
www.mate.com
FABTECH . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .116
www.fabtechexpo.com www.faccin.com
131641 American Torch Tip. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 77 547082 American Weldquip . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .103 316550 Arbor Image . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .114
734-741-8700
857706 Multicam . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62 100154 Multicyl . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .109 232349 OMAX Corporation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83 259602 OTC Daihen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
www.daihen-usa.com
100420 Automec . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57
www.automec.com
575001 BandSawBlades . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
www.bandsawblades.com www.behringersaws.com www.betenbender.com www.bigassfans.com www.blmgroup.com www.bluco.com
152919 Behringer Saws . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50 134310 Betenbender Manufacturing. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .108 578316 Big Ass Fans. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 841889 BLM Group USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72,73 200844 Bluco . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 118334 Boschert Precision Machinery . . . . . . . . . . . . . .105
www.boschertusa.com
856664 HGG Proling Equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 564906 Hodgson Custom Rolling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . INSERT 461901 Hougen Mfg. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .107
www.hougen.com
2047239 Innovative Product Ideas LLC / Scrape-N-Burr . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .107 473289 Jet Edge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .106
www.jetedge.com
916079 TaurinGroup USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57 108754 Taylor - Wineld . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .113 115951 Timesavers. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .111
www.timesaversinc.com www.trajansaw.com
599029 Kalamazoo Machine Tool . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .115 112084 Kalamazoo Metal Muncher . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .109
www.kalamazoometalmuncher.com www.kett-tool.com 269-944-1552
109426 Kett Tool. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .114 188963 K.I.W.O.T.O., Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .110 153725 KMT Waterjet Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54
www.kmtwaterjet.com www.knuth-usa.com 585-492-2400
100798 TRUMPF . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .120 155951 United Performance Metals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .113 900017 Ursviken . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34
www.ursvikengroup.com victortechnologies.com www.weilercorp.com www.wilausa.com
928367 KNUTH Machine Tools USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63 137224 Koike Aronson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 1182300 Lantek Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
www.lanteksms.com
141269 Victor Technologies. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24,65 103673 Weiler . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .102 856173 Wila USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 462891 Wilson Tool International. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
www.wilsontool.com
463043 Donaldson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 122865 Durma USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 548629 ERMAK USA Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 128605 ESAB Welding & Cutting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60
117
Back Page
Joanie Drizins Girly Steel versions of the Lombardi Trophy appeared in 20 ower planters in downtown Indianapolis during Super Bowl XLVI.
uper Bowl XLVI at the Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis pitted the New York Giants against the New England Patriots and featured a display of athletic prowess and classic gridiron toughness with a little speed and nesse. But also on display outside the stadium and throughout the heart of downtown Indianapolis was a combination of strength and artistic air that only a metal art sculpture can provide. Metal art, like football or any other form of athletic expression, can be a contradiction of sorts. On one hand is strength, on the other is grace. Both have a hard-nosed quality, yet when rened, they possess a certain beauty. Joanie Drizin of Noblesville, Ind., knows this contradiction all too well. In the past viewers of her metal art assumed that the arduous task of manipulating such a tough material was obviously a guys handiwork. I used to do art fairs with my ex-husband and everyone assumed that he did the work. I dont know why. It doesnt look like a guy does the work! So I had to do something to make people aware that it was a woman doing the work. I thought it was kind of girly, Drizin said. Hence the reason she came up with the name Girly Steel. With heavy inuences from nature, many of Drizins sculpDrizin draws artistic inspiration through mimicking and accenting nature.
tures are in fact, well, girly. She loves creating sculptures that not only enhance a landscapes appearance, but also provide a marked contrast to its surroundings. Coincidentally, though, her pieces at times, because of her use of color, blend into their surroundings and Color plays a meaningful almost appear as if they role in her art because of how it contrasts with the belong. I try to mimic nature rusty metal. and change it up a little. But theres nothing girly about how she constructs her Girly sculptures. A commercial artist by trade, Drizin was immersed in pottery when she was rst introduced to metal art at the Indianapolis Art Center. Once I started with metal, that was it for me. I started selling o all of my pottery equipment and buying metalworking equipment. I worked out of my garage for ve years before I got a studio. It took o pretty quickly. Never one to shy away from hard work, Drizin attributes that and her love of playing with re to the success shes had in metal art. Two gas metal arc welding machines, two plasma cutting units, and an oxyacetylene setupfor heating and bending form the barebones of a pretty basic workshop, but one that a ords her everything she needs.
e Lombardi Trophy sculptures were constructed from recycled rebar, sheet metal, and brake rotors.
e FABRICATOR (ISSN 0888-0301) is published 12 times yearly by FMA Communications Inc., 833 Featherstone Rd., Rockford, Illinois 61107-6302. e FABRICATOR is circulated free upon request to those who qualify and who are involved in metal fabricating; subscription to all others is $75.00 per year. International subscription is $140.00 per year. Periodical postage paid at Rockford, Illinois, and additional mailing o ces. POSTMASTER: Send address change to e FABRICATOR, 833 Featherstone Road, Rockford, Illinois 61107-6302. Printed in the U.S.A. Copyright 2012 by FMA Communications Inc. Reproduction in whole or in part without written permission of the publisher is prohibited. PUBLICATIONS MAIL AGREEMENT NO. 12345678 (41467014) RETURN UNDELIVERABLE CANADIAN ADDRESSES TO: Pitney Bowes Intl Mail Svcs, Station A, 11PO Box 54, Windsor ON N9A 6J5, Email: returnsIL@imex.pb.com
thelaserspecialists
> >
OPTIPLEX was designed to deliver performance features that specifically meet the needs of high variation job shops. Material thicknesses from thin gage to 1 standard. New PreView 2 control with touch screen and integrated tech tables simplifies operation.
>
AIO5 with automated setup assures optimized operation with less operator dependency.
>