Professional Documents
Culture Documents
पालकनीती जुलॆ १३
पालकनीती जुलॆ १३
4
4
4
4
gnmXH$
gOrdZr Hw$cH$Uu
gnmXH$ _S>i
Zr{b_m gha~wXo
dXZm Hw$bH$Uu
{`dXm ~ma^mB
ew^Xm Omoer
_wIn>-_mS>Ur
a_mH$mV YZmoH$a
AjaOwiUr
A^` T>_T>oao
dm{fH$ AmOrd
dJUr dJUr
.200 .2500
dJUrMm MoH$ / S>mQ>
"nmbH$ZrVr n[adma'
`m ZmdmZo H$mT>mdm.
gnH$ :
nmcH$ZrVr n[adma,
A_Vm pb{ZH$,
g^mOr nyb H$monam,
H$d} aVm, nwUo - 411004.
) -020-25441230,
25673596
palakneeti@gmail.com
www.palakneeti.org
`m AH$mV
~mbH$mMr b{JH$ gwajm : EH$ Cno{jV Z
- gOrdZr Hw$cH$Uu
`oH$ ~mcH$mcm gwa{jV Am{U `m` dmVmdaUmV
dmT>m`cm {_iU hm {VMm/`mMm h$M Amho. nU
`jmV _m {H$VrVar ~mcH$mZm hm h$ S>mdccm
OmVmo. `m`m dmQ>mcm Agwa{jVVoMo, c{JH$
A`mMmamMo AZw^d `oVmV. H$moU`mM ~mcH$m`m
dmQ>mcm Ago AZw^d `oVm H$m_m Z`oV, Am{U hr
O~m~Xmar _moR>mMrM Amho.
nwVH$ n[aM`
_w$ {ejUmMm g_ AZw^d
- AYVr Vwinwio, g`m qhJUo
_w$ dmVmdaUmV, H$moU`mhr H$ma`m ~YZm{edm`
_wc Amn`mcm hd Vo, hd Vg - hd Vohm {eH$VmhoV
ho H$nZoVc dmQ>md Ag {M `jmV ~Km`cm {_iV,
Vo gS>~ar hcr Hy$c `m A_o[aHo$V`m emioV.
`m emioda AmYm[aV "\$s AQ> cmQ>'
`m nwVH$mMm n[aM`.
Ag {eH$U gwaoI ~mB... - coImH$ - 14
J{UVm`m Jmdmcm OmD$ `m... - gw{MVm nS>iH$a
H$mohmnya`m gOZ AmZX {dmc`mVco H$n
_wcmgmR>r Zoh_rM AmZXmMm, {eH$`mMm R>odm KoD$Z
`oVmV. AemM EH$m "J{UVm'`m H$nmV _wcmZm
{H$Vr Y_mc Amcr, `mMm AZw^d `m coImVyZ
`$ Ho$cm Amho.
ImH$s dXuV XS>cocm _mPm ~mn... - S>m. {ZVrZ OmYd
"\$mXg S>o'`m {Z{_mmZ Amn`m d{S>cm{df`r`m,
chmZnUr`m AmR>dUr _mS>Uma _ZmoJV...
AmB-~mn hm`M`? coImH$ - 9
_yc hmoD$ XoVmZm - S>m. {V^m Hw$cH$Uu
`m coI_mcoVrc hm g_mamonmMm coI. AmB~mn
hmo`m`m {ZU`mer OmoS>`m Joco`m {d{dY H$mQw>{~H$,
gm_m{OH$ ncyMr MMm `m coImV Ho$cocr Amho
Am{U {ddoH$mZ, VmaV`mZ {ZU` Ko`mM _hdhr
AYmoao{IV Ho$coc Amho.
eXq~~
Zoh_r dmnamV Agco`m H$mhr eXm`m AdVr^dVr
{\$$Z `oVmZm dmMH$mZm eXmMo ZdrZ AW JdgVrc.
gnmXH$, _wH$, H$meH$ d _mcH$ - S>m. gOrdZr Hw$bH$Uu `mZr nmcH$ZrVr n[adma H$[aVm
JrZ Jm\$sg, gr-102, gw{ZVm AnmQ>_|Q>, 1417 H$g~m noR>, nwUo-411011 `oWo N>mnyZ KoD$Z
A_Vm pb{ZH$, g^mOr nyb H$monam, H$d} aVm, nwUo-411004, `oWo H$m{eV Ho$co.
`m {Z`VH$m{cH$mg _hmam> am` gm{h` Am{U gH$Vr _S>imH$Sy>Z AZwXmZ m Pmco Amho naVw `m
{Z`VH$m{cH$mV {g Pmcocr _Vo _hmam> am` gm{h` Am{U gH$Vr _S>img _m` AgVrcM Ago Zmhr.
Am
gdmXH$s`
_mo S > b . ~mB b m nmo Q > J rgmR> r
`m`mgZmg_mo a nXa ngamdm
bmJbm. Zd`mZ `m ~mBer g~Y
AgVrb nU _mP {V`mer b
Pmbob Zmhr, Agm gya H$mT>bm.
`mda `m`_y V vZr Ho $ bo `m
{dYmZm_Y`m wQ>t~b _mZdr
h$mgmR>r bT>Um`m H$m`H$`mZr
bJoM AmdmOhr CR>dbm. `m wQ>r
I`mM AgVrb qH$dm H$Xm{MV
_m`_m Z r H$iV - ZH$iV
{Z{_`m AgVrb. H$Xm{MV Amnbo
_wo nwT>o aoQ>`mgmR>r {_imbo`m `m
gYrMm \$m`Xm H$m`H$`mZm hdm
Ago b . Zm`mgmR>r b hr
nm b H$ Zr Vr
go _ Z_H$ma,
_bm Amn`m gdmer H$mhr ~mobm`M Amho. Jobo H$mhr {Xdg
_r EH$m {df`mda A`mg H$aVo Amho. `m A`mgmV _bm H$m`
{Xgb, `mVyZ H$m` gwMb, Vo _bm Vwhm gdmZm gmJm`M Amho.
nmbH$ZrVr_YyZ Jobr gdrg df gmV`mZ Amnbr JmR> nS>Vo
Amho, `m_wio `mM dmQ>oZ Amn`mn`V nmoMm`Mm `Z _r
H$aVo Amho.
_mUgm`m {nmbm O_mnmgyZ I`m AWmZ nm`mda C^
amh bmJon`V, A, d, {Zdmam Am{U {ejU Aem {H$_mZ
Mma Jmo>r {_im`mV hm `mMm h$M Amho. `mVbr n{hbr
{VgmX
_r nmcH$ZrVr`m IoiKamV Jocr nmM df H$m_ H$aVo Amho. _cm doJdoJ`m H$cm_`o ag Amho. _wcm~amo~a _r H$cogX^mVco
{d{dY CnH$_ KoV AgVo. ZwH$VoM _m`m hmVmV Am^m ^mJdVmMo "AmH$Vr' ho nwVH$ nS>co Am{U Vm~S>Vmo~ _r Vo n{hcr`m
_wcm~amo~a dmn$Zhr nm{hco. hmVmMm, nm`mMm R>gm KoD$Z `m`mnmgyZ mUr V`ma H$aUo, hr Iyn ^mar H$nZm Amho. n{h`mXm _wcmZr
Oohm ho nwVH$ nm{hco Vohm `mZm Am` dmQ>V hmoVo H$s hmV Am{U nm` `m`mnmgyZ mUr V`ma H$aVm `oVmV. hr H$nZmM
`m`mgmR>r Iyn ZdrZ hmoVr. AmnU KoVco`m R>em_`o Amn`mcm hdr Ver ^a KmcyZ mUr V`ma H$a`mMm AmZX H$mhr _wcmZr
KoVcm, Va H$mhr _wcmZr R>emcm Y$m Z cmdVm `m`m AmOy~mOycm aJ cmdyZ {Mo V`ma Ho$cr.
nmcH$ZrVr`m "_o'`m AH$mVcm Am^mVmBMm coIhr _cm Iyn AmdS>cm. coI dmMVmZm cjmV Amco H$s `m`m_`o EH$
H$cmH$ma hUyZ Or c` Amho Vr Oa Amn`mV Amcr Va H$m` ^mar hmoBc ! `m`m coIZm_`o _wcmMo ~maH$mdo, {ZarjUo N>mZ {Q>ncr
AmhoV. _wcm~amo~a H$m_ H$aUm`m `oH$mcm hm coI ~`mM Jmo>r XoD$Z OmBc. CXmhaUmW, {MH$coMm dJ KoVmZm _yc _hdmMo
AgVo, {M ZVa ! H$coV {OdVnUm H$gm AmUm`Mm, H$coMm AmdmX H$gm `m`Mm, H$moUVrhr H$Vr H$aVmZm, CnH$_ KoVmZm {H$`m
_hdmMr Amho, [aPQ> ZmhrV. _wcmMr gOZercVm, _wcmMo _ycnU H$go \w$cdm`Mo B`mXr Jmo>r `m coImV Iyn ghOnUo gm{JV`m
AmhoV.
_r _wcmMr H$nZme$s dmT>mdr `mgmR>r Iyn doJdoJio CnH$_ KoVco AmhoV. nU H$mhr doim hdm Vgm n[aUm_ {XgV Zmhr Am{U
_J {Zame hm`cm hmoVo. nU Am^mVmBMm coI dmM`mda _mPo _Z Oam emV Pmco. H$maU H$moU`mhr Jmo>rVyZ H$Vr KS>Uo _hdmMo
AgVo, `mMo Cma `oUo Zmhr, ho _cm g_Oco. `m_wio _mPr JmS>r nwhm imda Amcr, hm _m`mgmR>r gdmV _moR>m \$m`Xm hmoVm.
Y`dmX.
aoe_m qcJm`V, nwUo
_w$ {ejUmMm
g_ AZw^d
AYVr Vwinwi,o g`m qhJUo
nwVH$ n[aM`
14
coImH$ -
~mB. ..
o
I
w
a
g
U
$
Ag {eH
11
_wcmMr no dmMy`m.
{` am_mZwOZXmXm,
H$mc Vw_Mr O`Vr Pmcr Am{U Amhr Vr gmOar Ho$cr.
Vohm _cm
H$m` dmQ>co Vo _r {c{hUma Amho. _cm Ago dmQ>co H$s
Vwhr AgVm Va
Vwhr Am_`m gOZ AmZX emioV Amcm AgVm.
Am{U Amhmcm
J{UVmVrc EH$ J_V gm{JVcm AgVm. Vwhr ZmhrV
hUyZ _cm dmBQ>
dmQ>co. _r Oohm Vw_Mm \$moQ>mo R>odV hmoVo Vohm _cm dmQ>
co Vwhr _m`m_mJo
AmhmV. _cm J{UV {df` Iyn AmdS>Vmo. _cm J{UVmc
m `mdfu MmJco
_mH$ {_imco. J{UVmV ^y{_Vr d Amhr Ho$coco JmU
o ho Iyn AmdS>co.
Vw_Mr {dmWu,
Am`m
{` am_mZwOZXmXm `mZm,
Amhr e{Zdma {X. 21-12-12 amoOr Vw_Mr O`Vr gmOar Ho$cr. Vr H$er
Ho$cr, Vo `m nmVyZ _r Vwhmcm H$idVo. n{h`mXm Amhr H$m` H$am`Mo Vo
R>adco. R>a`m_mUo H$m_ Ho$co. _r Vwhmcm EH$ {dMmaVo, "Vwhmcm J{UVmMr
AmdS> H$YrnmgyZ cmJcr? J{UV H$moUr {eH$dco?'
Amhr AmOMm {Xdg J{UV {XZ hUyZ gmOam Ho$cm. Am_Mo JQ>H$m_,
XeZH$m_ Pmco. `oH$mH$S>o EH$ EH$ Z~a XoD$Z nmT>m V`ma H$am`cm gm{JVcm.
Amhr Vw_Mm dmT>{Xdg Agm gmOam Ho$cm. _cm Vmo Iyn AmdS>cm.
Vw_Mr {dmWuZr
amOHw$da
{` am_mZwOZXmXm,
`m
am_mZwOZXmXm, Amhr Vw_Mm AmdS>Vm {df` J{UV
o J{UVmMo
{df`mda JmUo ~Zdco Amho. Amhrhr Vw_`mgmaI
m J{UV
Vk hmoUma. Vwhmcm J{UVM H$m AmdS>Vo? Vwhmc
o hUyZ
gmoS>dVmZm Iyn _Om `oVo H$m? J{UV gmonm {df` Amh
S>m`Mo H$s
Vwhr {ZdS>cm Amho H$m? Vwhmcm ~mH$sMo {df` Amd
Vwhr
Zmhr? Vwhr ~mH$s`m {df`mda cj H$m XoV ZhVm?
ho _cm
J{UVM ^anya H$m {eH$cm, Xgao {df` H$m Zmhr?
Imcrc d$nmV {chZ m.
Vw_Mm {_,
Xodme
12
13
Mwcr noQ>m``m. AmVm Aer ZmVr nU Iyn H$_r am{hcr AmhoV Am{U
Iyn H$_r nmocrg Aer ZmVr OnVmZm {XgVmV. nU _m`m d{S>cmMm
Aem Zm`mda Iyn {dmg hmoVm Am{U Ver `mZr Vr Oncr nU.
_mP XhmdrM df hmoV. nmoamMr narjm Odi Amcr, hUyZ dS>rc
_cm XH$mZmV KoD$Z Joco. Iyn ^mar - ^mar noZ, H$nmg, {chm`M nS>
_r {ZdS>c. gJio {_iyZ XrS>eo n`o Pmco. _r ZmamO hmoD$ Z`o,
hUyZ `mZr gJi KoVc XoIrc. nU Vohm `m`mH$S>o \$$ nmg
n`o hmoVo. hUyZ VodT>oM XH$mZXmamcm {Xco. XH$mZXmamH$mH$mZrhr
EH$m eXmZ {dMmac Zmhr. _r Xhmdr nmg Pm`mZVa _cm noT>o
AmUm`MoV Ag hQ>c Vohm Vo hUmco, ""noT>o nwT>`m nJmamcm.
Ammm`m nJmamVyZ _cm XH$mZXmamMr CYmar naV H$am`Mr Amho.''
AmOhr _cm hm gJ AmR>dcm Var W$ hm`cm hmoV. Am{U _cm
{nVm hUyZ nS>Vmo H$s, AmnU XoD$ eHy$ H$m ho gH$ma Amn`m
_wcrcm, Oo ZH$iVnUo Imocda Odco AmhoV Amn`m ~mnmZ.
`oH$OU Amn`m AmB~c dmQ>Um`m ^mdZm _moH$ionUmZ `$
H$aVmo. nU dS>cm~cM dmQ>U AmnU Iyn H$_r `$ H$aVmo. H$maU
AmnU `mH$S>o Vg ~KV ZgVmo. AmamontZm nH$S>Umao nmocrg Kar H$g
dmJV AgVmV _wcmer? Mmodrg Mmodrg Vmg nhmam XoUm`m nmo{cgmcm
dmQ>V Zgoc H$m H$s nmoamMm A`mg `mdm, nmoam`m emioV H$m`
H$m` Pmc ho EoH$md? narjo`m {R>H$mUr ~Xmo~Vmcm Agco`m
~mnmcm Zgoc H$m dmQ>V, AmnU nU AgM gmoS>m`cm Omd _wcmcm
hUyZ?
coH$sZ hQ>co`m "hnr \$mXg S>o ~m~m'Z Aem {H$VrVar ^mdZm,
_ZmV C_Q>co Am{U `mMo VaJ {H$VrVar doi _ZmV CR>V am{hco.
coImH$ - 9
_y
AmB ~mn
hm`M`?
14
15
PcH$ XmIdVmo.
`dpWV H$mao dmnacr Va Cm_ gmW
XoUmar J^{ZamoYZmMr gmYZ Am{U gmonr, H$_r
YmoH$mXm`H$ Agcocr J^nmVmMr {H$`m
AmVm Ambobr Amho, `m_wio nm{hOo VohmM
Am{U nm{hOo VgM _yc "H$aVm' `oBb Agm
AZoH$mMm g_O {XgVmo Am{U {ZgJmZ `mV
H$mhr AS>MU AmUbr Va Vo drH$maU `mZm
\$ma AdKS> hmoD$Z OmV.
VkmZmZ Va dH$s` jom_`o M_H$ma
KS>dcm Amho. gmoZmoJm\$sM VkmZ nmoQ>mVrc
J^m_Yrc Xmof XmId`mgmR>r \$maM Cn`w$
Amho - m~c H$mhrM eH$m Zmhr. nU
`mMm Cn`moJ H$$Z WmoS>mgmM Xmof Agco`m
J^mcm ZmH$mac OmV qH$dm {ZgJmMm g_Vmoc
{~KS>dUma qcJmYm[aV J^{ZXmZ H$$Z r
- J^mMm J^nmV H$adyZ KoVcm OmVmo. Vohm
VkmZmM ho XYmar e AmnU `mo` {XeoZ
dmnaV AmhmoV H$m, `m~c eH$m {Z_mU
hmoVo. OodT> kmZ A{YH$, _m{hVr A{YH$,
VodT>rM Vr `mo` H$mamZo dmna`mMr O~m~Xmar
A{YH$, ho cjmV `m`cm hd.
VkmZmZ AmO AZoH$ n`m` CncY H$$Z
R>do co AmhoV Am{U AZoH$ OmoS>nr `mMm Cn`moJ
H$$Z KoVmV - `mV `edrhr hmoVmV. nU
AmOhr H$mht`m ~m~VrV hr VkmZmMr _XV
Anwar nS>Vo. VkmZ EH$m_mJmo_mJ EH$ n`m`
XoV OmV Am{U "H$mhrhr H$$Z _yc hm`cmM
hd' Aem A>hmgmZo Oo `Z Ho$co OmVmV,
Vo nmhZ hV~w hm`cm hmoV. Hw$R> Wm~m`M
hm {ddoH$hr Aem doir _hdmMm R>aVmo. _yc
hmoU hUOoM "H$ico gmWH$ O_mVco' Ag
{ZXmZ AmO`m OmoS>`mZr Var _mZm`bm ZH$mo.
H$mhr _moOH$sM OmoS>nr OmUrdnydH$ _yc
hmoD$ Z Xo`mMm {ZU` KoVmZm {XgVmV. _yc
hmo U - hmo D $ Xo U hmM Amn`m Z g {J H $
gOZercVoMm Am{dH$ma Amho Ag Zho.
{d{dYmJr OrdZm_`o Aem BVa AZoH$ Jmo>r
AmhoV `m_wio gOZmMm, Zmdr`mMm AmZX
{_iy eH$Vmo, `m dahr OmoS>nr _ZmnmgyZ
{ddmg R>odVmV.
16