Zc Kak @b^Z ^UKe

WKe aa] eR^

ea GK g iek ie S@ aue @`ie @Q abMd _el \A[f i[e @

KZK~ jf bw _Wf Kjf - ie, c @C _el \A _ea ^j c bf Ke[f `f
jf KcZ? c^e jZg _Pg ah adie _u ^cK ^ej aajZ S@Ue ZeY c GK
iWK \NUYe GA ciK Zk _Y jeAf _u GK K@e a]a Kke ahKe S@UG
\^@ Z _A @e Ra^ @[j^ Bgeu C_e _P @bc^

ce Kjae K[ jf - cYh Ra^e ~j ~Zak Pj[G Z KY iG _A[G?
^ @c c^ue Pja ^ Pja ij _e KYi i_K ^[G G_eK A_iZ Kc^e _ _A
@cc^ ~j gc Ke[C iaak KY gce CPZ `k ck[G? Z c ^j cYh ~j
Pj Z jGZ _G ^j Ga ~j Kaa Pj ^[G Z jGZ ck~A[G icd icd G_e
jA[G ~j _Aa af i Kaa i_e ba _e ^[f K ~j Z Ra^e @ia af
i ]e ^A[f - jVZ a^ Pe i bk NUY NU~G - i bk `k c ck[G K
K_e ? G[e MUG K[ _cYZ jA[G ~ - G ]e_e cYh aW @ijd Ze KYi K
Z ^j @C KYi @\g gqe AQe GVe iaKQ jA[G iL \L, R^ cZ Gia c
@cK ck[G Zc UK ]eie c^e PKf - ZcZ ^Re R^ ja K[ Kaa P Ke
^[f R^ ^aK Zc c KQ Ke ^[f Zc R^ ^a GK[ c ZcK Kj _Pe ^j
Zc AQ @^Qe c _gj ^[f K jVZ Zc \^ ^RK Ra^e _Af R^ Zc _A GK
NUY G[e Zce KQ K Z ^[f VK iAcZ \^ cZ c NU~a iZak ZcK Kj
c _Pea ^j Ga Zce ceaK AQ @Q ^ ^j ? Zc Gj aee @b~M c Ke _ea
^j ~ - Ga GZ gN G iie QWaK ce AQ ^j af KYi C_d ^j cZ \
ee @i @IR c \G ^j jVZ @i ZcK CVA ^G R^ MUG \^ @P^K @i[G
cZ c @P^K NU[G @C R^ cZe G \A @P^K NUY cSe ~jK Zc Ra^ af
ba[@ i[e ^RK K af baae _Mkc Zc KjK Ke[@ ? ~a Ra^e @if
NUY C_e Zce KYi K Z ^j - R^ C_e ^j, cZ C_e ^j Za UK ba \L G
\A NUYe cSe ~j ia NUY NU~G i[e Zce K Z @ia K_e? @e C_e ^dY
^j - @ C_e a ^dY ^j Za c C_e ^dY @ia KC@W ???

@c i]eYZ Kj[C - ~jKQ jCQ iaKQ bMe [f \a i~M ia bMa^
KeCQ Giae MUG @[ ajeQ ~ @c Ke KeQ @^ GK @\g i e, @\g gqe
~\ aae KYi NUY C_e @ce KYi K Z ^j Za @~[e Ra^e @c j
jf KjK Kea? ~\ Ra^e @eK - ghK a^ KYi _ge @c Ke Ke^aK a
jCQ Za Ra^ ~Ze cS _aK Ke Ke ^ae j _ecg ~G ^d _aK RY^G
~ - G ~Ze i K ^j, Z _A KQ KeaK ^j ae _ecc ~j KeCQ i Zj
KeQ iZak Ra^e P af KQ ej ^j a`kZ c KQ ej ^j _ecc ~\
RZCQ Za Zc RZQ i ~\ jeCQ Za Zc jeQ aRd Ze _eRd c Ze
Zc Kak ^UKe RY _Z @b^Z i ~cZ ^g \CQ Zc @b^d KeQ ^UKe
Zc \L[a @b^Z c C_e @b^d Kfak _e\ _Q_U ^UKe _Uw Ke [@

i ~_e Kj [@ @c i_e Ke[C c _Qe ^g^ @^ie @b^Ze @b^d iG

~cZ agbh KeA \G @c ij ag bhe aje[C ^gK ec Ke\f @c
ec jA aje - ^A eaY Ke\f eaY jA aje[C ^UKe ^gKK @b^Z
Wc Ke_e ^j ~ - cZ eaY KjK KeQ? c ec ja ^ ~j ^gKe AQ G
Ra^ ^UKe ^gK jf _ecc G Ra^ jf GK ^UK GK fk @c ia jf @
b^Z ZY G Ra^K @Z MeZe ij @\ ^@ ^j GjK Lk af ]e^@ i ~j
KeCQ Ke^@ ~j \LCQ \L~@ K Zc _ZK lZe @Q@ ej~@ _\ _Ze
_Y _e Ra^e Kc Ke~@ K ^RK K bae \L ^j ^R K e @i^e aiMf
P @i~G \L @i~G K jf _ecc ZY i`kZ a`kZ ia Ze ZcZ Kak
cZ GK C_KeY, ^c cZ ai, ic P ckA ~a

G iiee Pej \L @i[G @^[ ^j G C_f ~je @iMf i iL Ga g
jA~G P i jA[G K bae ~cZ Zc Ke Ke~@ ~ c K ^j, Z_e P
^[G K jA[G IfU ZcZ P QW \aK Pj[@ K K ZK ^j Zc iaak
\^@K \LAaK Pj[@ c Ra^e Gd KeQ, id KeQ AZjie ^c QW ~aK
Qj[@ ~Z\^ ~G K ZK RaW ]e[a - iZ\^ ~G P ej[a ZY @jue g^
jaK P Ke _eccu Zc Ra^e ic^ UK i^ \@ ZK iaKQ KeaK QW\@
Z jf Zce @ai ij QU _fU _e jA~a ~G Z a_e jZ]e PfQ Rwf bZe
aN, ije MR^ ji Rue bd a_ PZ K _@ c @Q Rwf \gK C_bM Ke
PfQ ice ij @i QW jAMf a _@e bd ^j i LZe Ke^ KeY i Z a_e
jZ ]e PfQ

MUG R_^ KjY i\ aajZ RY ~aK ^R _^ ij ^@e ai ^\ @eKke
[a Z MK ~C[f jVZ Z`^ SW cW @if ^@ _Y C_e Ukck jf aW~a
C_e _^ WeMf ~aK K ie ^e au bk g c\e ai[G _^ Kjf Zc
GcZ P_P_ ge aiQ K_e cZ Ga @aga ~aK jVZ @ e Ze ZfIeK KX
^R _^ aKe fMA \f _^ Kjf - Zc cZ WeAaK PjQ ? ~aK _Pef ZZ
We cW ^j? _^ Kjf - Zc jZe ~Zak ZfIe @Q c bd Kea KjK? _^e C e
gY ~aK ZfIeK aK C_e `eA @Yf ~aK Kjf - G [f ce C e ~Zak
SW, Z`^, aZ a^ ia Z jZe c @~[e KjK P Kea? G WwK i ~\ aWA
\a Za aWa a Aae [f a a c jZe ZfIe \L Z ~cZ bd _C^j KeY
c _Z Ze _c @Q @R ~\ Z cZ aaj Ke ^[ Za G ZfIe aKe fMf lY
bde P}e Ke [@ @R Z bd _C^j KeY Z c bZe _ce GK iZ i_Z jA
iefY @aKk iAcZ GK iZ _ecc @C c bZe jA iefY ZY ^\e ^@
Ukck jf a cZ bd fM^j Z`^ @if VK _Ye Waf a VK KeY ia Z
jZe @cc^ Kj Z jZ aje ^j Zjf _Y P KjK??