Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LWI 04-2009 English
LWI 04-2009 English
I n f o r m a t i o n
Highlights
FEATURE: Ecumenical Solidarity
on a Journey to Liberation
LWI
Churches Called to Recognize
Image of God in Dalit Women....3
Participants in a workshop at the
Global Ecumenical Conference on
Justice for Dalits in Bangkok, Thailand,
highlighted the close connection
between caste and patriarchy...
Global Church Organizations Pachnali, Far Western Province, Nepal, November 2007: Gore Sunar, 55, a bonded Dalit laborer, has worked for 25 years with no
Welcome Durban II Outcome, salary, just to keep his four landlords happy so that they won’t ask for repayment. A March 2009 LWF/WCC conference in Bangkok,
With Some Regrets................ 10 Thailand, sought to generate churches’ solidarity with the plight of Dalits worldwide. © Jakob Carlsen
Two global church organizations have
congratulated the United Nations When Elske van Gorkum took up her first are some 260 million Dalits worldwide, 200
Durban Review Conference against
job in a Dalit community in India, her hosts million of them in India.
racism on the adoption of its outcome
document, but regret that the latter could hardly believe what they heard when As part of the International Dalit Soli-
makes no mention of the plight of she said there were no castes in her native darity Network, van Gorkum lobbies her
hundreds of millions of people affected Netherlands. “For them, a society without government and the European Union to put
by caste-based discrimination...
castes is unthinkable,” says van Gorkum, caste-based discrimination at the center of
“but coming from an egalitarian society, I the political, economic and development
FEATURE: Just When I also had difficulty at first understanding relations with the countries where these
Needed It Most..................... 11 ‘untouchability’.” human rights’ violations occur.
Mai can smile now, though most of
her life has been no smiling matter... Van Gorkum, a development worker with “Learning about the suffering and
the Interchurch Organization for Develop- atrocities Dalits have endured gives me
ment Cooperation, a Dutch aid organization, dedication and commitment to stand beside
shared her experience at an international them in solidarity,” says van Gorkum, who
ecumenical conference on justice for Dalits has been working with Dalits since 2005.
held in Bangkok, Thailand, in late March.
Jointly organized by the Lutheran World
Federation (LWF) and World Council of Accompaniment
Churches (WCC) the conference sought Generating such commitment to stand
to generate solidarity and support within beside the Dalits in their struggles is the
churches and ecumenical organizations essence of global ecumenical solidarity
worldwide by bringing into focus the plight
04
of Dalits, who have suffered from caste- Continues on page
based discrimination for 3,500 years. There
2009
Lutheran World Information Contents
Communio
9.........Call for Lutheran Communion Solidarity with Communities Affected by Climate Change
LWF Secretariat
10.......Global Church Organizations Welcome Durban II Outcome, With Some Regrets
News in Brief
2.........Namibian Premier Welcomes Anti-Racism Conference Outcome
8.........Anniversary Celebrations Mark Lutheran Church Witness in Holy Land
12.......Budget Reductions Impact ELCA Engagement Overseas
The Lutheran World Federation English Editor Lutheran World Information (LWI)
– A Communion of Churches Pauline Mumia is the information service
150, route de Ferney pmu@lutheranworld.org of the Lutheran World
P.O. Box 2100 Federation (LWF).
CH-1211 Geneva 2, German Editor
Switzerland Dirk-Michael Grötzsch Unless specifically noted,
dmg@lutheranworld.org material presented does not
Telephone +41/22-791 61 11 represent positions or opinions
Fax +41/22-791 66 30 Layout of the LWF or of its various units.
E-mail: info@lutheranworld.org Stéphane Gallay
www.lutheranworld.org sga@lutheranworld.org Where the dateline of an article
contains the notation (LWI),
Editor-in-Chief Circulation/subscription the material may be freely reproduced
Karin Achtelstetter Colette Muanda with acknowledgment.
ka@lutheranworld.org cmu@lutheranworld.org
No. 04/2009
Global Ecumenical Conference
Church-Based Initiatives
Church-based initiatives are taking
steps to offer Dalit women alterna-
tives to such debasing and impover-
ishing employment.
Through the Slum Women’s
Advancement Program, the Women
in Church and Societ y desk of
the United Evangelical Lutheran
Church (UELCI) in India provides
microloans to women in the slums of
Chennai to help them establish new
Bishop Dr Vedanayagam Devasahayam, Church of South India. © LWF/P. Prove livelihoods.
No. 04/2009
Lutheran World Information Ms Indira Ghale, treasurer of the in the face of widespread, deep-rooted and dehumanizing. They urged the
Nepali Feminist Dalit Organization, prejudice present even in the churches. worldwide ecumenical community to
spoke about efforts by the LWF De- affirm that women are also created in
partment for World Service program the image of God and that any form
in Nepal to empower Dalit women Family Level of abuse of women distorts the divine
through advocacy, income generation “I have no issues sharing the Eucharist image in each human being.
and capacity building. with a Dalit but I will never get her Some 95 leaders and representa-
Workshop participants—drawn married to a boy who is a Dalit,” as- tives of churches and human rights
from churches, church-related and hu- serted a caste Christian from India, and development organizations
man rights organizations from all over speaking about his daughter under worldwide attended the Bangkok
the world—agreed that such initiatives condition of anonymity. ecumenical conference.
towards Dalit women’s emancipation are The participants called for the (By UELCI communication officer,
a welcome sign but raised the question churches to recognize the current Timothy Melvyn)
whether they could bear the desired result treatment of Dalit women as sinful 27 March 2009
No. 04/2009
tion in Baguio City. However, “the
Ms Indira Ghale, treasurer of the Nepali Feminist Dalit Organization advocated for Dalits’ right to education,
employment and political engagement. © Lance Woodruff Churches Called to
Not a Uniquely Indian Dalits reveal that they are mostly Solidarity
Problem bonded laborers, and Dalit Chris- The church representatives at the
Participants heard about similar tians are doubly marginalized. workshop called on the global ecu-
dynamics in other countries. While Manoharan pointed out that menical community to be more proac-
Nepal also has anti-discriminatory Dalits’ primary form of employment tive in ensuring that their respective
laws in place, Dalits there, compris- in Bangladesh is as “sweepers” clean- governments enact and implement
ing 20 percent of the population, ing streets and collecting garbage. policies targeting discrimination.
share the same predicament as Dalits In Sri Lanka, despite ethnic Bishop Dr Zephania Kameeta of
in India, according to Ms Indira struggle having a stronger impact, the Evangelical Lutheran Church
Ghale of the Nepali Feminist Dalit caste-based thinking is prevalent in the Republic of Namibia, and
Organization. “Though reservation even among Buddhists. Though LWF vice president for the African
policies [are in place] in Nepal, Dalits not given the name region, pointed out
are deprived of their right to educa- “Dalit,” people of In- that a universal hu-
tion, employment and politics. They, dian origin who are man rights issue was
without other options, are pushed Sri Lankan citizens at stake and, as such,
[into] menial jobs.” do not have the right advocacy was not op-
Other South Asian countries to vote. tional for the church.
where caste is a defining reality, such The workshop re- “Discrimination and
as Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangla- vealed the need for oppression is a scan-
desh, have yet to enact affirmative anti-discriminatory da l on hu ma n it y.
action legislature. According to Rev. policies outside the Our solidarity with
Vincent Manoharan, international region as well, even if Dalits is not a favor;
advocacy secretary of the National the concept of “caste” it is our Christian
Campaign for Dalit Human Rights is not expressed as calling and respon-
A human rights issue is at stake, said LWF
in Pakistan, all Pakistani Dalits, such. vice president, Bishop Dr Zephania Kameeta.
sibility to be involved
whether Muslim, Hindu or Chris- I n t he P h i l ip - © UELCI/Timothy Melvin in the global Dalit
tian, face discrimination from the pines, for example, solidarity process.”
government. “The Islamic state does there is no caste system, according (By UELCI communication officer,
not recognize the Dalit issue,” he to Rev. David Tabo-oy, dean of the Timothy Melvyn)
commented. Studies among Hindu Episcopal Cathedral of the Resurrec- 27 March 2009
No. 04/2009
Lutheran World Information racy in the world, these discriminated Dalit communities” at the Durban
people, once labeled and treated as Review Conference, and urged “all
“untouchable” due to Brahmanic ritual participating governments to accept
traditions viewing them as “polluted” the inclusion of caste-based discrimi-
or “polluting,” now call themselves nation in those discussions.”
Dalits (“oppressed, crushed”).
Caste-based discrimination is so
deeply entrenched that churches and Moral Statement and
human rights groups in India and Mission
other caste-affected countries admit But some Indian activists were not
they can hardly solve the problem on pinning too much hope on the Durban
their own. “We need your solidarity,” Review Conference. “The Indian gov-
they appealed to participants at the ernment has ensured that caste-based
four-day global ecumenical confer- discrimination would not be taken
ence on justice for Dalits held in up in Geneva,” said Mr Vijaykumar
Bangkok, Thailand. Parmar of the National Campaign for
Mr Vijaykumar Parmar represented the National
Delegates to the Bangkok confer- Dalit Human Rights in India. Campaign for Dalit Human Rights in India. © Private
ence recognized progress in address- Parmar appealed to the ecumeni-
ing caste-based discrimination by UN cal family to make a “moral statement” liberation a central mission objective.
bodies such as the Committee on the and help churches around the world The declaration calls upon churches in
Elimination of All Forms of Racial become aware of caste-based dis- caste-affected countries to be “in full
Discrimination, the Committee on crimination. Among the participants solidarity with the Dalit movements
the Elimination of Discrimination committing themselves to further ad- and to speak with a united voice in
against Women, and the Interna- vocacy within the churches globally working toward Dalit liberation.”
tional Labour Organization. was Rev. Dr Lesley Anderson, chair-
They recalled the failure of the person of the Caribbean Conference
2001 UN World Conference against of Churches (CCC), who pledged to Monitor Caste Atrocities
racism held in Durban, South Africa, take up the concern with his Roman According to the declaration, church-
to address caste-based discrimina- Catholic counterpart in the CCC. es are expected to implement aware-
tion, but saw the 20-24 April Durban Noting that Guatemala sup- ness-raising programs, empower
Review Conference in Geneva as a ported the cause of the Dalits at the Dalits, monitor and respond to caste
new opportunity to internationalize 2001 Durban UN conference, Par- atrocities. They would also encour-
the issue. mar suggested that enlisting the help age Dalits to express their culture in
In a statement titled the “Bang- of even small countries could advance worship, liturgy and theology, and
kok Declaration and Call,” confer- the Dalit struggle for liberation. support Dalit women’s initiatives.
ence participants called upon the Through the Bangkok Declaration, In addition the text appeals to
international community “to offer participants at the conference com- the international community to
a platform to those representing mitted themselves to making Dalit campaign for an end to manual
scavenging by the end of 2010. This
degrading, caste-based task forced
upon Dalits, entails removing hu-
man excrement barehanded from dry
toilets and transporting it in baskets
to dumping sites.
The declaration also calls upon
churches in less or differently af-
fected countries to provide resources
for solidarity work in both their own
and caste-affected countries, and
to facilitate mutual exchange and
exposure visits.
Churches in less affected coun-
tries are expected to lobby their gov-
ernments and to urge private sector
Mr Ashraf Tannous (left), Evangelical Lutheran Church in Jordan and the Holy Land, chats with Bishop
companies and banks investing in
Devamani Bachu, Church of South India.© WCC/ Maurice Malanes India to ensure that their investments
No. 04/2009
encourage equal job opportunities Dalits, particularly by initiating a “With Jesus’ love in my heart, I’ll
No. 04/2009
Lutheran World Information who related the Dalits’ plight with “We, too, are children of global More information about the Bangkok
experiences of discrimination and ecumenical solidarity. Without the Dalit conference is available on the
exclusion under the apartheid white many peoples who accompanied us LWF Web site at:
minority rule in her country. in our journey toward freedom, we www.lutheranworld.org/
For Bishop Dr Zephania Kameeta might have been obliterated,” says What_We_Do/OIahr/
of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Kameeta, who is LWF vice president OIAHR-Dalit_Justice.html
the Republic of Namibia, accompanying for the African region. “So we are ac-
the Dalits and other victims of oppres- companying the Dalits not as a favor, Learn more about WCC work in soli-
sion in their journey toward liberation but as a Christian duty,” he adds. darity with Dalits:
is his church’s way of saying “thank you” Freelance journalist Maurice www.oikoumene.org/?id=3249
to other people of the world who helped Malanes from the Philippines wrote 15 April 2009
his country’s liberation struggle. this feature article.
No. 04/2009
Call for Lutheran Communion Solidarity
No. 04/2009
Lutheran World Information Global Church Organizations Welcome
Durban II Outcome, With Some Regrets
No Mention of “Hundreds of Millions” Affected
by Caste-Based Discrimination
GENEVA (LWI) – Two global church ence had “failed to acknowledge of humanity—the image of God
organizations have congratulated the suffering of the more than 200 in humankind. Racism desecrates
the United Nations Durban Review million people discriminated against God’s likeness in every person.”
Conference against racism on the on the basis of work and descent.” Both organizations said they were
adoption of its outcome document, Formerly known as untouchables, the satisfied that anti-Semitism and the
but regret that the latter makes no Dalits are “invisible” in the 21 April Holocaust, along with a number of
mention of the plight of hundreds of outcome document, despite their other groups and situations, had been
millions of people affected by caste- situation falling squarely under the explicitly addressed in the outcome
based discrimination. definition of racial discrimination by document. But they expressed regret
In a 24 April joint oral interven- UN standards. that “controversies over one single
tion at the conference in Geneva, In March, both organizations situation have so consumed the at-
the Lutheran World Federation convened a conference in Bangkok, tention and energy of the Durban
(LW F ) and World Counci l of Thailand, at which representatives process, from 2001 until now.”
Churches (WCC) welcomed the of churches and church-related or- They welcomed the proposal
made by the UN High Commis-
sioner for Human Rights to create
an “observatory on discrimination,”
which may help throw further light
on the situation of the millions of
victims of untouchability practices.
There are some 260 million Dalits
worldwide, 200 million of them in
India alone.
Another welcome development
was the exclusion of the concept of
“defamation of religions” from the
conference outcome document. By
not allowing the concept to “inappro-
priately intrude into [the document’s]
human rights framework,” the docu-
ment instead “properly addresses
The outcome document of the Geneva Durban Review conference did not mention the plight of hundreds of
millions of Dalits such as these village leaders in Thullanmedu, Cuddalore district, of India’s Tamilnadu state.
itself to the ‘stigmatization of persons
© The Lutheran/Linda Macqueen based on their religion or belief ’,”
stated the LWF and WCC.
reaffirmation of the 2001 Durban ganizations from around the world
Declaration and Programme of expressed their solidarity with the The full text of the LWF/WCC
Action, as well as the international Dalit struggle for justice. intervention at the Durban Review
community’s commitment to over- Conference is available at:
come all forms of racism “in all www.lutheranworld.org/
parts of the world, including those Controversies LWF_Documents/WCC-LWF_
‘under foreign occupation.’” The LWF/WCC intervention at the Statement_Durban_Review_
However, the LWF and WCC UN conference affirmed, “Racism is a Conference.pdf
stated their regret that the confer- sin because it destroys the very source 24 April 2009
Thanks to scholarship support from the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Thailand, Ms Sirirat Rueangsri is confident about realizing her dream career.
© UELCI/Timothy Melvin
BANGKOK, Thailand (LWI) – Mai can Mai’s mother had to take some drastic where to go and whom to ask (for
smile now, though most of her life steps. Unfortunately, it was Mai who help),” she told this writer.
has been no smiling matter. had to face the brunt of her decisions.
Twenty year-old Sirirat Rueang- “My life came to a standstill when I
sri, known affectionately as Mai by was told that I [would] not be able to Helping Families
her relatives and friends, lives in a continue studies further,” she recalls. It was at this juncture that the Lu-
small, congested two-room wooden She says she was despondent that she theran Diakonia Department (LDD)
house with her mother in Lad Prao, needed to sacrifice her passion for of the Evangelical Lutheran Church
one of the areas in Bangkok that education. “Pursuing studies in the in Thailand (ELCT) offered her sup-
epitomizes the city’s economic divide. field of communication arts is my pas- port through its Family Development
Her mother is the sole bread winner sion.” Besides the studies, Mai found Ministry program that helps families
in the family. With the meager wage that just going to school exposed her improve their living standards. The
earned as a domestic worker in other to an open, friendly, accommodating LDD staff had known the family
people’s homes, she could barely pay milieu, a stark contrast to the situation through its ministry among elders,
Mai’s tuition fees. “(Life) was indeed at home. At school she was able to live which assisted Mai’s grandmother
terrible and every moment of it is still her dream. But that dream seemed when she was ill. Mai, a Buddhist,
etched in my memory which can never about to suddenly vanish into thin was enlisted in their scholarship
be erased,” says Mai. After school she air—a not unusual scenario for people program. “Our goal is to share God’s
would help her mother with laundry living in the lowest strata of society the love with people in need,” says dea-
work to supplement their income. The world over. coness Leena Helle, LDD director.
death of Mai’s ailing grandmother Mai knew the importance of The department helps people who are
left a huge debt which made life even education and desperately wanted to in dire need, irrespective of religion,
more difficult for the two women. study so that she could have a career social status or gender.
As a single parent facing an increas- and break away from the fetters of The LDD was established in 1987
ingly difficult time making a living, poverty. “I did not know what to do, as an ELCT department responsible
No. 04/2009 11
for the church’s diaconal work. The di- support because the college fee s exceed respectable job and I need not worry
Lutheran World Information
aconal ministries include work among the scholarship amount she receives. about my daily bread,” she says. Her
children, youth, unmarried pregnant Through the LDD diaconal work, aim is to become an editor in a lead-
women, elderly people, families and Mai came in acquaintance with the ing newspaper and, more importantly,
people living with HIV. local Lad Prao Lutheran congregation, she wants her mother to quit her job
Mai has been a beneficiary of the an encounter that has turned her life and stay home. “She (her mother)
scholarship program since she was in around. She is now a baptized Christian. has toiled her entire life for my sake
Grade 9 (around 14 years old). She The conversion process took almost and it is my duty to take care of her
is now a third-year bachelor’s degree three years. She is an active member of when I earn. I am fortunate that I am
student in communication arts at the the congregation and is a member of the able to continue my studies,” adds the
Suan Sunandha Rajabhat University ELCT youth committee. Her mother communication arts student.
in Bangkok. When asked how she feels, was also recently baptized. Still, according to Helle, the ELCT
she exclaims with a beaming smile, “My is aware that there are many young
life has taken a total transformation.” people in that same area of Thailand
The scholarship came to her as a boon Fortunate and Optimistic who are deprived of an education.
“just when I needed it most.” However, Mai is optimistic about her future. She affirms the LDD’s commitment
she still needs to depend on her mother’s “After my studies I will surely get a to continue to seek support for them,
drawing inspiration from Jesus’ words,
“as you did it to the least of these who
are members of my family, you did it
to me” (Matthew 25:40).
Timothy Melvyn, communica-
tion officer for the United Evangelical
Lutheran Church in India, wrote this
feature during a recent visit to Bangkok,
Thailand.
www.lutheranworld.org
E-mail info@lutheranworld.org
Fax +41/22-791 66 30
Tel. +41/22-791 61 11
CH-1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland
P.O. Box 2100
150, route de Ferney
The Lutheran World Federation
Published and distributed by: