After an explosion at the Imperial Sugar plant, lawyers and some people posing to be with the Mexican government, descended on the city looking for Mexican workers who were injured.
After an explosion at the Imperial Sugar plant, lawyers and some people posing to be with the Mexican government, descended on the city looking for Mexican workers who were injured.
After an explosion at the Imperial Sugar plant, lawyers and some people posing to be with the Mexican government, descended on the city looking for Mexican workers who were injured.
Sugar plant ‘Samaritans’ shaky
Two men who claimed to want to help injured Hispanic workers had no credentials
BY ALDO NAHED
912-652-0449 + sdo.nahed@savonnahnow.om
A couple of days after the Feb, 7 explo
sion that killed 12 workers atthe Imperial
‘Sugar Refinery, Maria Bowden reached ont
to injured Hispanie workers in the Port
Wentworth community,
“These people needed help, and I didnt
knowhow to got them help,” Bowlen said.
Soon afte, she was approached by two
—who identified themselves asinternational
elegates with the Council of Humen Rights,
‘Which they said was based in Mexico City
‘They met at a Waffle House where they
asked Bowden to introduce them to injuree
“Hispanie workers
Bowden, who works in insurance, said she
‘didnt get a good feeling from the men.
"They didnt want to show me their IDs at
first” Bowden said. “The guy was wearing
ey finaly showed me
Hinojosa and Gonzalez also appronched
Pastor Samuel Rodriguez of Fist Hispanic
Baptist Church. Rodriguez said he spent
about 15 minutes with the two casually
‘dressed mien.
“They told me they were human rights
‘workers on behalf of the Mexiean people,”
Rodriguez said. “They told me they were
going to help through an attorney in
"Texas.
‘SEE SHAKY, BACK PAGE
ON THE WEB
Ox.
previous
overage,
View photos and hear
audio related tothe
Imperial Sugar Co.
help the victims of
the explosion oF sign
st book of
men — Jose Hinojosa and Javier Gonzalez
Shaky
FROM PAGE 1A
Rodriguez said he didn’t get a
good feeling: “I thought that the
things they showed me weren't
very professional.”
John Newton, editor of Span-
ish language newspaper La Voz
Latina, encountered Hinojosa
and Gonzalez when they came
tohis office totalk about injured
Hispanic workers.
Newton said the men left
their business card — a hastily
printed card on a legal-sized
sheet of paper.
He, too, said he doubted the
men’s authenticity after he saw
their plain-paper business cards
and was told their organization
didn't have a Web site.
Hinojosa said in a telephone
interview from Dallas that he's
a secretary of international
relations for human rights out
_ of Mexico.
“When I hear of an accident,
I notify Mexico, especially if
I know there were Hispanics
involved,” Hinojosa said.
When calls were made to the
number Gonzalez had on his
business card, a woman's voice
was on the number's voice mail
and Gonzalez didn'treturn mes-
sages left there.
The men’s credentials cannot
be verified.
Ricardo Alday, spokesman for
the Mexican Embassy in Wash-
ington, D.C. said Wednesday
that Hinojosa is “not a repre-
sentative of the government as
he claims to be.”
“Hes impersonating himself,
He doesn't work for any human
rights organizations linked to the
government. Absolutely not.”
Alday said he also checked
with the Mexican Consulate in
Atlanta, where officials said they
don't know Hinojosa.
Hinojosa provided the
Savannah Morning News with
his Yahoo! e-mail account as a
contact.
“If you are working for the
government, you usually have
a government agency e-mail,”
Alday said. “It sounds fishy.”
Hinojosa also could not pro-
vide a Web site address for his
organization.
Alday said this is highly
unlikely for a government offi-
cial.
Efforts by the Savannah
Morning News tolocate a Coun-
cil of Human Rights in Mexico
City were unsuccessful.
Looking for injured
workers
Once in Port Wentworth,
Hinojosa said, he and Gonzalez
searched for Hispanic workers
injured in the blast.
‘They were able to reach seven
different families in Savannah
and 12 different families in
Claxton, he said.
“They have rights here, and
we are here to help in any way
we could,” Hinojosa said. “Ih
don’t need to be afraid. They
can seek legal help without fear
ofimmigration”
Hinojosa said his background
isin law and he’s worked with law
firms for the past 16 years as a
certified translator and as an
ey
investigator throughout Texas
and Florida.
He emphasized that he was
in the Savannah area as a
representative of the Mexican
government.
“Tnever identified myself'as an
investigator, he said,
Buthe said he did refer work-
ersto Savannah attorney James
Carter.
Carter said he was consulted
by Hispanic workers referred by
Hinojosa, but they had minor
injuries. Carter said he's not rep-
resenting any workers injured in
the sugar refinery blast.
“My position is that as long as
the company is paying workers’
compensation, they don’t need
legal representation,” Carter
said.
Carter said he believed Hino-
josa was legitimate.
“He had credentials,” Carter
said. “As far as his exact con-
nection with a human rights
group, I'm not sure.”
Texas attorneys sign
up injured workers
through ministers
In an unrelated instance,
Pastor Rodriguez said he’s
referred about seven injured
Hispanic workers to Texas-
based attorney Anthony Con-
stant on the advice of the Rev.
Bennie Mitchell.
Rodriguez has been helping
the Red Cross with translations
for more than 20 families.
Constant represented the
Earl T. Shinhoster family of
Savannah in a case against
Ford Motor Co. and Bridge-
stone-Firestone tires after
Shinhoster died in an acci-
dent in Macon County in June
2000. The terms of a 2003
settlement are confidential.
Rodriguez said Mitchell told
him Constant was “helping the
African-Americans injured in
the blast.”
“They asked us to join with
them to gain more power,”
Rodriguez said. “I thought
this was a good idea.”
Rodriguez said he’s not
involved anymore.
Mitchell said he does not
recall how many injured work-
ers he referred.
In a faxed flier, Constant
says he’s representing Law-
rence Manker Jr., “who
received a devastating blow
from the explosion at the
Imperial Sugar Refinery.”
Manker is'listed in critical
condition at the Joseph M.
Still Burn Center at Doctors
Hospital in Augusta.
Mitchell said he recom-
mended workers “to the lawyer
we know and trust.”
When asked if he was get-
ting referral fees, Mitchell said
hewas not and was insulted by
the question,
“You know better than to
ask me that,” Mitchell said.
“No one is getting anything.
That is downright ugly.”
Ken Chastain, a representa-
tive of Constant, refused to be
interviewed.
“Rev. Mitchell told me how
you insulted him, and I don’t
want to speak to you, either.”
Investigation into
misrepresentation
continues
The Georgia Bar Association
is investigating if any lawyers
have improperly solicited vie-
tims of the explosion or their
families.
“{can tell you that generally
we are looking at lawyers’ con-
duct regarding the explosion,”
said William P. Smith III,
president of the bar associa~
tion. “As far as the identity of
the lawyers, Ican’t confirm nor
deny any.”
Smith said if lawyers are
found to have violated the
state bar rules, they may face
charges of public reprimands
to disbarment.
“A lawyer in Texas can talk
to a Georgia resident,” Smith
said. “But they can’t come to
Georgia and represent them
or give them advice, not unless
they are authorized by the
Supreme Court of Georgia.”