Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • The Embodied Mind Review

    Uploaded by

    Dimitra Billia
    15 views33 pages
    The Embodied Mind Review

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The Embodied Mind Review

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    15 views33 pages

    The Embodied Mind Review

    Uploaded by

    Dimitra Billia
    The Embodied Mind Review

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 33

      

    
    
            #
    ! "$&% %'   ("*)+,
    -.0/ 132 46587:9;/<7 = 9?> 7A@ BCE5 DF>G9 HI9?J+/ KMLN9;/N> L</ O+> 7
    P QR2 O:> T
    1 SVU/NW<9I/N>XL</:Y
    Z\[^]_[0` ab]_[c]8de]$fg]_[
    h8ikjIlnmponqrsoutvjxwylzi|{~}xi i iR i{lk<$iui|u8rVu u}
    h8ikjIlnmonqeh* o|le<uuoo i8 i{lk*i|ANuiyErVuuzuuu}

    ]83 ^  ] p

    Ii+t8oui^ (zI8En& uF+?0FFz


    ?ze+?8(I|us ?n +;G |+ (E
    z?IRIG8 RR F*eE u
    NnInu ?F n+ unnF<e |n6*FV
    k _In8u zIV<+ FIz n$pVk u
    ?p ?V $I_0:; |IV+zI?
    u0?F RNe 0+I|Au | zA*F;
    8 nIs$ F IEIzFz zI+?? +? *I
    svsI$zg: Env z?vn Ev:gu?I
    zuN +I F+:;:8 n :k+u
    ?* <I  :upI8*e vIu< F
    ?(  ?IzunuFI n  F_I(FI| ?I
    znC~? IV<*z nkN IIEIANI~I N ?I

       !#"%$&')(+*,,.-/ 0 1,10324557698,:;=<>!#*,?3A@B,CD ::E
    >!#F(GIH#J,I2>@&038DK1,CE
    L<A!#<>F2?D
    M

    e;s<~Ek 8+ ev N I ?VI NsI<E;u


    ~V FzusFNIFNIR8 F++N$?n
    nnk|$z:  vn n z|?z N? I vNF N I
    |Ek <N|IsI NNVzI$ II8
     || *x|~I g z<u u?
    3 ? _ uvI*;:nIA0|u8u*e InR<
    nue8z I+E V??I+ I|u< ue Vu u
    V nR$++ *EIzeR _ +6E zn3I( ? z
    n zn u$? nI| < AIz0 F|u+z z
    G E ;  uINF$u sN Fu
    
    e EzI$Fz :* ;u8 I xEn  V?I euN
    pvFn  I+?|| zFV?I|Iz0 uI
    $ ?;I I;nII ?II  e eE uIs8;n+
    FF ?|z III?IA ?IINv|x;
    ? xeIu u |I|E z ?E? :Eu
    II?I+ ?IIee|| zNs??I~zx: sE?
    vF ?z *uE0I8 $  ??I $
    nI ?EzF?$I $ *n $ +  n< u <I
    |Ize Nn? 8?EF Vz N?e88z?z8g? *?E
    InxF N~zR8+IuuuzI nN? E Fz N+ A+n
    n F u<NI+:n?zEI+e s uV
    $_ ^n < 8ve II|u  V :IN+ n,Ize
    uINI II|Ve u N N uA8 uN
    I|$?$zx su+zIzuuN E$
    eI ns? kn

    InI  :???IF* eI ze s kn ze N+I


    zI eI z+usA*G?+ueFEI$ 0e
    ?0e +EE e n u~( ? :n8\ n
    ? nE?|Iz Iu E<nnFIv 8zknz?EIu+,
    I+?x n88 I?n Ee+EA?  uNIE
    E I E: e nE
    R:+?e 8 |z ?nCIA+V u M e
    Iu8 V nA u A^:+?  Vz ^Fu
    $ eI n*nE+IuFeI_+Iuz 8^n +p$E *
    zInF ;uMI( 0 AkI(F?IVz?8I uEe z?_
    Fz$I eI n?nIN Fn 0E+nI~   ?
     e? 8 N+~ NIuN uF_ I x?E E u
    |I|N~z+v x?e eE$~IuA u ?
    vu++?
    u 8EA  NN

    

     

    [F]8d

    !"!#$&%

    '(*) *+-,."$&%

    e * E;EA8|n#s  +<s n?e <+F


    nFn+ n0 /veu F NIE es ?eV uz
    I? ue 
    < +I?+8 F z n(n(

    Fz+
    I|n:E|n+ z + :svkz + Iuz
    z uEe?Iv uu NvI<z<_|+   ?x
    

    6 <I|u+I8$ u 8VIzI InI


    II?E? + se?IE+?znu< + u$zI
    +u ^nIIp zI? $\ /v+ F
    E*Iz+8IN ?Izv Ie N? +?< ?
    FN V u ?vIIe?nuzI$
    zII8IA|se NIn$s8e+EF u_ eFI|  I
     
    M 

    e  8A|s<<u e$zIE
    e^ VuRI uxsIII?V  unn
    /vuu +z8INI ?I; z?n,ke Iun uIVE
    *p <?I z?n /<u  $+8 8z+<0FV
    ?II zn$gz;InNF8u nIvIz_lou(u nI
      z?n#eu_ EIIz~~k V Eu nIeg+ $
    <N$8E <|u<nnFI?+ I+zI 8E
    e R xIuV+V+:E nVn
    e <n +p8s|nE <
     w i|lkou
     IEE

    ysi| {  FF ?nFVzIV+  Izp


    F n?_I
     w i|lkou
     /vu6ee

    ysi| { se??IE+z I<IF e I|I


    +? zI|e nn? NEN I n?_I
    E n E E:
     w i|lkouR
     /vsE _|uNnn I| uI

    ysi|{  _ <n?; 8 n?sz+nI|e EI


    +F0 ?z ~0nI Ez V +
    u+_ *nn  I  
     _?I$$nR:IFk nA NFnu
    z?_FIse  IE z s :
    n?_Ip IF xV0IuN?M v+?z_
    zx  F F | | z3IN A^0I 8z
    I:nuIn \IE n?8| ~F
     z I_ Rz I?zR ?NE FuEV F?
    ? +? n
    e?IuVE $ u< n?*INFN ?|z
    In u 6 FF *nF | ze n |In u
    IA+?eIz+N *zVz + FI|E0
    ?n^ nVNzV ? I0I +* u
    uuEAI+ez+8IF Iu z  M  
     ^n In+ E+ u $ n+eIzIF I *8IIA z
    z?+ NI: NII| E EIn $ NI EnpF
    n uI vF ilm  M e _IN I +?s v s+?
    8zI vI+ *?v n?AvI <  M I ? ?<
    IzA N:I n In+ 
    e n:I<_gE Inu?FvEI*e8E
    x N  I|8+:
    e <zIE <+:eekssnF$8I +
    Iuz$ze|+I? E^e EuE6I|e+?
    

    (GM < +?I^n x_ Iu eI


    +??luwu { vF:  :INnVn
    uu~+ nIzVEV + sVu _8 u
    IzpIe e N x IuIF_Iny I<s V
    ? ;EI+III $? IEA:?~Iu I
    I8zFge8 AEFp? $I80|+  
    I< Fs$nV+??Iz_zF /<uuI+ s V
    kN *+:+?In+I<e e s IE+?e*I
    +_V n$::  IA?zIN F|II
    +??IzA+Nvu_+I8I|EV 8n^VIIV
    z
    e *IE | z z+ vz vgz y e
    $_I$ ?n I+ ze 8Ivn xI8z~k 8z
    A+ ?+??vu$++Iv * uIu
    

    e 0+IA?< euE;+ In8zI z


    u z zFsI_:s n?E | z^y ;8I+In
    8vn uNFI  FIzuVv:L ?:?*npu
    uI sn+ z u  z gIz_v?& 0
    ?nTI *+V?NIE 8n?;E+vCI
    n  ?zgNA|I8In zuz;  vE0V +
    I?( E pA?#e F++uI?u+E
     ?n Fn I(+?8I: ?+I?_
    Fue|+V uNu  I M 
    

    e Vz n ? <II8I$ ?$p?$| n   eEF$+


      E * xuN_ I+Iez gn?_I< nI< xuV
    ?
    e * Vn+FE * n< u < 
    w i|lkou  IEE

    ysi|{ e N+I<sgn6 n_n+ +I ?|


     w i|lkou
     /vu6ee

    ysi| { e A? EIIxIp <I e+


    ?z: 8 N:
     w i|lkouR
     /vsE _|uNnn I| uI

    ysi| {   R 8+E I$In Fz <I+z


    nIIA+:nI xN u*?z M$zI gn +8u
    nx   
    

    vIuu+ z
    n^ 8 8n z+Ize

    n ;?nA n InF ^n InA I  F


    Ize$z z I$?+? $In InN u E gnI
    e:nI u In+ 8v+V+:EFxn n
    I g nFpsEFn se :8I?e EEz
    u F+:8 nCu_ VIu u: E8|nI
    IzeV  x? eI?peVIusnuE e? IVF
    E nI ;nN z?n InV I*n
    vu$Iu< u<IE+?Iu<;_ +  sz  $
      

    e +n N$? uu$u|I n#EFzu


    i|t_i{i|?l|l<nnF| I*s n<z zpeNe ?+8
    n?I_$N n u+ n+:?80z
    u NN8  nnnF6n:z
    I ?n x VI<E :~ FvI :n u  s 
    z zF :n N n?I|zu nn
    FV FvIu$I ?NzIIzeR+?VIRIu
    z zFE< F_IAF 8 +$I :gnI
    e$+zuv8y +?snnFE nv$E NIFn
    | nnnFsnEVIuV se E $ekz
    u
    u u n InN Eg*+I +* n z
    u s+?? zI $Ize_ n,I_? +?
    n VnII|u  Iz u^ n;+ $ Iz gu
    uIu
    

     

     *+
    *' , !#+ '   
    ' ,

    eN N?I|As EIuN ; 8 I<E?zA


    s<nI F uI xVFFVeInu s $uN <   
    zeV < Iue n?$ nE8?I_8 EIuse Iuz
     I:nEe< 

    v x?s? I |e?z8kuxs n IIunI|6s+


    I?z:e+ + <E+ zn, NE F V z|
    Iz nVIR n0Ez z?nb +|NV0  ;
    

    s +IuVnz nvIVA? IA<_neI*;?I


    ?n u< znA uNz z?n
    e8?;zV EN e+Vs?N  <uI?sInI
    ?n*n FI~uF_++I<v:, N?: _En
    ?z nn I(? +  nA EnRu+
    ?E$uVE+FE FFEnI$ ?+?
    nyv  + z
    g ?I z?n I z
    ngz z?n^e F+ I<_|+ $ zu ?
    INu8<se eEV:;? $ EIv V I ?EI ~s|:
     IFu  * E_IVIAz nkN I|

    u zk:II*In I AE 8 RIN+


    EeFNn I+uI  V EuVIE$zI u
     N;:zINnI F I ?$IvFV, II
    v n< ;g u | ?I II8IE I8
    z 8<? N z8nI 8 IV*nI AEI8N
    z+ 8IuV   I?k ? z ?I
    

    e 0AI* *I8N$n^I|u < +zF I


    F e~ ++nN:;?$ +?VN 8k|$8|$?z0*nAnR
    n+?
    Iu? NE_

    <IpIE EF * z|?ze?


    E|v?z e$ zn<n+ +n+EINn zk*I<$+I
    I+n+< u:e_IEeI?II?e EI| IF u
    I| e V #e8AzIEI* ?NNFn zk
    /v#8e

    z ;<I I I? Nz+


    Iu vE n*nIIE~
     I M  M   
    gN8 z?n^ N$ nM< ? z z z?z
    N+IV|ENF~  |? 88 * xn zn
    *F +zI  e?? +?0  E  + yFIn _I*En 
    

    e 8uu : v _ 0I_I8n8zIzu_R
    ?VIIz+NN?~NI~ IeI*Iu_
    II| En*I IIu< , IIInV s
    IVN I+z?;e?IV u EI:Nn0
    Nn+ 8 ?* *;$E8 g? EN6?? +?uVn
    _ Nu+?+sI<? +?
    e * vF;?E <$z xIN Eunu+ 
    0V_M u yM|s ?~I?$ uE
    F8I u n s I?II_
    e u8+Is8 VIzInEIIzNe e u+?u6e:
    IVNu< V  < u6VIV V?+INI zv?
    NIE I e Iu  I M  M 
    

    I Rg 0R + 8+V $?nI+? ?
    I ne E;nFeeu _
    

    e+z$|~ * u:p  | k+IGz0I8 :p


    ?eI:+Iz FzI|n:Ay F(z:InI$
    * ? FI n:_y F; ~y
    

    F FIgIII8uRIu^I? F;9 V nx


    ?V?Iv6NzI<I|A~? FnI x~ n
    z g
    < Vg E+u+eI sIeI+8nM Mn+ u < z
    E| pI Inu?^ 8?;?Vu NF vI
    ~uN F_|u Vs n<su v8 ?|v
    +Enu$I gI_u| Iu$?

    u + I ? 0N^ ?Ien< y < n


    E I|++In _? $:nun  I 
    Fx IE? x + NsInx+z +I
     ? +E~nE  ?E zeI  I M 
    e Iun+IEI$~zI ~IznI|I_??
    +?*e ^CI~  z?zv V?IkNI0I~ :n z|?z
    yk| Iu *IznI Eu8 s?znnFg
    Iv  ~ p? +NIze~zII8? :e6I
    I|n+s?Vxz|FV Iv xvu?Fnn+
    eIuz   
    e <EI; xFo ou{
    vun < 6+ < A: <I
    e Iun 
    su e V Eu Nz + IV ?8
    zkn ?I M y_e_Iv 8VINe ~u
    + IIg zuI 0 83   zu
    |I (u . /vI M   N0 83 0uI zu8I
    nx|I VE;INzI8EIn  u E

    ? &'  AGI%GIH,<AHA(


    H K;
    M>M

    NuI?se v < V I|uE?GIes? E?8


    n*zv zuN <eF:u+$?+ n z|?z
    Vg M  e+ n<gI|+<In8?8 nIe
    I? 8+?xE$| ? +  VN? +s 
    Nz ; nF uI<FIuk+: N AzI
    s  +Iu | ? u?+ ? ? z|u8IF?;u
    u? vIs  ? I <6ks *:I I
    |I s|EEIuz EF 8|u+8_nu
    

    e EF8II<n :Fxss sNz<n8 uE|I|eE


     znVn znN?I0$ $Iun u sN$:I0|? x$
    uz  z IVz <6IVN_Ize~ F;I 6_zI
    e?+?ezI|~ $ $ x?< nnF< Fu F
    * vI$  _?+I nIn ? *z g 8Ize
    nI|EIe? +?e+ In
    s < +e$_I8 Fk *?6e 8z z, AIu$
    I+<Es I- < 88IN u uu VI|
    A|Ae *nn,_Iz<n+ 8k|V 8? _z_s
    z zIgI  sgV??;geIgI<ueeuV
    I u< sI+ u g?: Iu_?8Nnn
    I+V V *u~ ~? In?~<I +AF?
    N?z8s *z z,I  <e  I  
    

    
    

    
      H &
    I5 ! ' !#<<A3! '  &=$>HH D  ' &  '  &
    $>H H %3!( D D D !  H &*%!# ' 
    ' (H &H J' H !  D D D  &H<A  A! J,
    &H J' H ! 3( &=GIH  I!#'  H  A! J' & * H
    " ! '  I!#'  &='  ?*,' %H   =$AHH ! A
     ( H, & <&J' H  H,  $ /! &H,3D
     &'

     

       AGI%GIH,<AH A( H K1


    
      A! J F!
    &  ' $>
    E
    H " ! , ! " ' &H GIH,3G ' H

    

    

    

    

    

    

     

    

    

    

    e NIuN u^ In +p 
    w i|lkou  IEE

    ysi|{ /I|   n+ nI g _IEue


     w i|lkou
     /vu6ee

    ysi| { se~ nIzz$g eug? unIn


    +n ze |
     w i|lkouR
     /vsE _|uNnn I| uI

    ysi| {   8I:I _ N ?zv_k u ~xu


    nI|<NzIIN_  Fkv IIVAu F nI  I
    

    

     M I M  M>M N AIn8F n(e


    In ;n n?I($uR+I?$ Fu: u
    vIzF $Iu u?nI|IvIze nCIInC
    nE * u  v NInA 8u zn  In znE+
    NIuV uI *nII n+F~ *n +I8z ? I
    e AIFG  z <_  |en;Nn $ u
    |I|u  pz xGN ;u$ n: < *zx$xNz
    eIu<z|ee8  +   /vI+I u <uzI < sI
    v+N0 /vI88vIsFu *Inex  ?u /vI
    uI
    /<Ixv Fs* In8FIz I
    ? u u+  M NeVE$ ?z <I~II*6u? n?
     ?_ <nI E u:I|u<
    Fe u nIz+ vunI
    <?n+0 u8I ^I ~ u8II?V 8
    M

    World features

    level 1
    specification,
    enaction

    representation

    Neural nets,
    cognitive modules

     M E n?FIF

    e_ EI uV:?

    g M   , nE EIn
     
    E 
    n?knI x
    u
    ,z?

    In|In?;
    zuI?I I
    u
    ? ?EzIzu

    z
    zyu I
    + u
    e+ E
    n?
    xuV
    + _u?Fz + u_?+u I+z
    In|
    _I?
    M

    level 2

    Artificial Intelligence

    Holland

    Brooks

    Winograd
    Flores

    Grossberg

    Neuroscience

    Smolensky
    Arbib

    Lakoff

    Hinton

    Ballard

    Marr
    Poggio

    Freeman

    Feldman
    McCarthy

    Abeles

    Llinas

    John

    Linguistics

    Johnson

    Simon
    Newell

    Hubel
    Wiesel

    Chomsky

    Barlow
    Fodor

    Globus

    Neisser

    Pylyshyn

    Cognitivism

    Rumelhart
    Piaget

    Cognitive
    Psychology

    Hofstadter

    Dennett

    McClelland

    Bruner

    Emergence

    Maturana

    Dreyfus
    Rorty

    Goodman

    Philosophy

    Enactive

      

    | I IIeg N|uVIs? + v$IEpuE


    8 F e *+InIEIx?V v *
    ?|  I  

    M

    n  AIn?(p:z #e A3 AIzx_ z;


    EIIz <
    An?F EI$ R? NIVps
    ~+n+<Aun?
    8I| E ngI 6?? eu |  M ? $|+I sE
    VII <Iu< u eueI EnI nuI|++$ +|
    e Nu:z;E eu pe< 
    

    se~eeEIn<+?ke *$ Ne+
    I<u+8EzIzE EIAA? ++?k
        e F I 8 EN0 FIun zR
    zkIn+E Ve $I$ Ne  F;??8;
    een e Nex VeEIN n Iz
      !!"#$
    % s?I|V<+ _?F ?I+eFEA
    ?I| NEInII8+eNNE
    n?I+6? +e~ +< N$#  IE v+
     & #  %  ?v6F *uNs $Inu ?v+
    N?:s *+I ? s$z z^e Ve_ _I I( '
     
    
     

    e + +$u^( AuF  uI|AAIu u


    e Au8 8|u8z zFE __A?+z s| I:
    FpV eu ^8e  _kI
    F *A?n z
    IzeG ? x8+F8Nu (I u+?I(_eFIu^n
    |u<I8$zIee? +E+I :u
    <?I6C gzxn vIVA* IE8
    + uuVF+ ?z  E +u?VI E+  M 
    

    )+* - ,  A>! J,

    " H H%I!


    ! $AH

    &'  H,<&' G'   I5  G  ' H 


    M 

    /vu

    IFe0 u t8lziou FI?z _+


    < Inu?$NExI snIuIII nnu
    ?I+e zVII F$Ey EI$I nI
    ke
    I 6I E n

     M  

    /vI F

     u uIn ;zA N
    zs $* <*u n8 ? E8EII8 ?
    zNs * FI Nuv Nn+s N ?
    Ez$zz|u? Vn V zg * 
    IF8N? E+Ee? N: Izse+u+?n+E|u
    uuuI|IA?Iz +I n:*Ve Iu8I0?n   NI
    + *e6s n$n eE eu |;nI+zI|~ ~+<Nz
    n AF<?zIsI| I <zIn* FI  +
    AI8 Feg FI8I$IF E zu~ F F
    n IV8?v s p:+ u eF Nzz + 8+ IIze
    n u? FI<z ~+E #z?$?
     n Is _?+ e+s   +In?xI+? 

    s n?s8+  u:In?I+?V u +In?xI?


    n n?_IV|+ ep+ <EA *I|Ies
    u< se VF N;?E  xI Inne u+Izx
    I 8+?$I+ ?uN? +s
    nR e *IuV Ae Fu V<e$ ?_
    FI 6?F?_ EI u*nn?:+zE *
    M

    IEI+I eV I8?I _uN + n


    I<u s F$ *  I M 
    e ue NI Isz+*n u 8 E+
    IVI I0?I v0_ z;IANz nku7sz x uN
    :I<
    F v<+I8 E 8 <uA 8z+z
    I+  eFF uN FVn+ #  I
    nIn_E FIIeE vuz 8 NzIVsI+ se ee;Iz
    E N eFVF Eu<V: _ s  V I z
     M <Ize F I n z N + ?M G ?;*IG
    In< 6 Is |s_ vn zkV+uxEI nIn

    Az uNNze8 I|I FE * np,| n


    :I|?z n; F ;^z n;n^n InIA Iz I?z
    I nIxv_u(zInI(Ize( n IX?
    e AIzF _  +&V+?n + 
    IE?nI|_ _Iu<e #NII_++ | z#IEz I
    _u8IzIuu  :  II  xI8Izezu
    Iz I?z IzuVI|V$IF+I
    0nIn8R( Ee&k I( I 8:**z
    u NI|INnI g u E8 V?I8 <I$ <nI
    : IV|Iz ?gII|Fs v Iu<I 8$Iu
    nI|Iu usIE n < sI8ENpuz I
    ~?zV e ge +zuuV:sIE$ sIInN vunI
    F N;vFI?+EF xIuV eeuF?In
    M

    

     *+ *'-  + 

    *+ $ +

    _ n|u nIFz :E <Iu V<gVz s+ 


    +? ~  M ek e Fn +Nz $?8 EIu u
    N InRR :n eIVNI e +Eu? pI euNuz N
    z _p0IAIun  RI y 8 + (+?|
    sz + nue8IzvInnVFnnIIz06zI;Vp
    :NF8?R + 8 ++< :n Ae+ n?RV :
    Iuzp^n n:EI* $0 |+e ~IIzFV NFuA
    nIIze_ +p$E+   Ie<s :eN n?
    eIuzE E ::+?u
    e Iu N s  +EFnI eI zs<n e Vz+
    IzeA_ze:;nIVI*8*e 8 ?V F| E n
    v?<$+ $? x <I:I< e+z8 s
    n 8 eI zVn < Iu n? :_ ee E;n<_

    8 In s8 E Ine<(s < seeInn


    v8: zu<IA ? zIgz zuE :E sIny u
    I|u uF _|| E :se * Eu Enu
    nIv I0,* I+?|| z+ n<;n ?;~zI?
    IA E0|u*nI u<e v|| zFzen EeNI
    n?$II?<I II|VEnI u

    e sIn z + Eue II?gIV?IIs


    IFnI|x8 zI euV I  I?uz ~
    nI EF nFnuI8II?II8 I??I*
    M

    STRUCTURE OF
    SCIENTISTS COGNITION

    COGNITION &
    EXPERIENCES

    STRUCTURE

     s ?IINx :I_ eE: u<z u

    I
    s;(IeF +u8FNNInnI F
    + ~Is?$ s+E?x|
    +I +u_nsn g;*$ ?IE *nI EE u
    z z  I M>M 
    

    IIsI8IE<n?E z u e+EnI
    n8 : ?I*uE e sEz*g+ |I8Ie
    u?N???Iv +? zu?vvn?EI
    II*R ?;I8~+Fuu8eNE * $I :
    zueFe ? FF ?nRuN : E(EI8
    AIRu +z+~Iz sx  0 8 I+? n;
    u$II?* ? x8+_  zAIFzAIz ;e ~
    eNIE? * : < E V < eI z#E sInn
    + n8e :nIN?I0 I$Nn R?
    NE|? xeIu?* I?I_ II|u  z u8
    8|? xvI?u<? V+ V+I nE I<
    II?eI|+ 8A??Vu;NIe_ _
     VIzzR N Iz Iz_ : IR+
    

    u|eNVF$Iuz+8+ E eI n( :Ie vE 8u
    ?+ *V F  M  Ine~? I eI zeIuNF :I 
    ueN?8 +IE :I~ ne?+ vN IgnI
    zIzvIIz~**I+_ I| gzI n: 8uV NE
    < E R8u*+ + IN : uI0_II
    ~unuVE Ee ?z eEzu?Iv III?8sI
    vIFzI+I zu6II *nI_z$ ?z#EFnu
    u_unuEVIuu?un<snI;s? |+IuI
    u8uE8 z<I?u +Esn+ I vuN;
    nuz < E+?<I z| e sI? :v$NIz
    I eg VI n xVIeI 8u z+ N* e VI
     Ru A IIRE:n+ N;nF6 INI8
    I,uvIIVu  F : FINI,VII<u
    z+ +I$E  V  ?z? e v u08+uII u 
    :Es  nu< :V+vuFIuV?un_IF e I
    8 n uF yn0I+ /v#?uVV ?z
    &V ?nv?A
    E|I IIzI s gg ssu8us EVzN_I
    I<uFIuV :Iuu
    e  I +? zE+?I|XuMFI&GFz8M
    +I+?p0 ?|z uk+e :+uz~+I?NI?Nu+I
    E  : eI z8<$$I eI ? z\u _uG?+ue+
    0 0  _ : uG A?I8y *8 FI
    zIz<$u<Iz+E NV F?- /vN?un EIzzeEusn: $n
    8u~z+ +II~I  s +?$0N?  :;(_
    n

    M

    e <nInE8E $En ue <V F?II eg NI;I?


    ?z+I < E?zI|$N?V;I?8eVV+ n$I?$Iv
    In<u n$I<< 08+?E;8E +V <;?V <IIn8
    nFez I?  I|
    /<uy N+uzE?n z;v e ne N ?I
    Vz* ?II?V ?z8 8E V v ?I0II z
    +I$IpI+$z
    <I|N ; *V p  M   
    e *NF zNI e +INIVN+?xIzI|;I
    u  ns+*nI v nNk?Ns+<
    I v+ 8?IF 8Ez I~uAIuuI $?nIA
    NIzEI| EIze < EA NIzE *? |A
    e NzNEFE F *Vp8nE ?I +IN8 *n +?
    nz? *Iz /vu <?II6sn?nE R Vnu~I
    ?? FI8 ?ns?n vI?? F u+ zuR
    II:? *IEnI eV _I+I;I?$ ?z$z  IVz#$I
    <  ?NI    N eI n zVIz0In+;u
    ? zF< ?III0;I /veux~ IuzA? x~I|RE
    n8NF u<s 8+ FENII+Fn u?#E+zI
    +I_0;Az _ 8e  V8 eI zVIuzR
    n 
    0e +zIunI|yuI+ n uzV IsFu
     InIzI8+IInnEn 0Vz I+ E F
    (E e(I0E XE n I( <z+ n
    I eu E 8* :E ?+ ?|z u0 G e
    I~ 8 n Nz e e <Iee<?I ?II
    

    IIe$F *uFuNe n?IIeVznNz+ +|


    F V :nR  I  
    u VnI x8nn0 8 uN+I I  +F
    uE*zu N ?n npx ?Is
    <?|:? 8nII? * zug_ Nz?zu8Iu
    n I;I?_ ?z 8z FI~ I
    vN+nV<IVE  IzNe I 0+IN +z6uN * n
    II0 $z++?R<: Eugv  M  eI8uI0nI
    +? *n A vE+? E *n E InI| 
    

    <gII E k EFuue 8uzEu N+N *n


    zu |zuI+Iu snIA V6+I?e n |
    E_AE+ne *v A IRE
    I nI *glIi8uE + u+? *z:<_z
    +I?Ee$px? _sz$IFFx *|?zx~
    +EI +I|Iv I uA +ku*pAI
    ? *p e EE +Nz V8I< V:IeVIns
    8zFI+?s nVI e ?? ? 8 Nn +I?8
    E?+?NI+|u?8E z eeen
    I*F?< juju{i|lV +I+ IIN ?;I++I
    ?+~? +
    

    

    ? &%!# ')!

    3! =  H " H&(   H

     GIH&FG ' H &  A!


    

    <AH

    )!  
     

    ! <A! ' ! 

    H&G! 3(
    < &
     " ! $

     &=$&I!#' A2 3! H  &=H D


     & '     ' H A! A F! AGI=   H%! <>3GI' G=! ' A( !(H,< 3( $ !/G H,* ' ' J,FG '  '  34>! .! ' A( &?
    &
     $I3G H  '  J,?  ' *!  ' H.
    
    &  &=!
    H,"%$&' H != &".! A2'  H 3! 3(7!  !=I! ' HA! ! *,  &HEA! $>H, $A '  L
    ! >
     ( (+' ?3D
    '

     

    

    

    

    

    

    vNe_I  A n:xI:;n eI nIGFz


    |IzFe *nIzNFE F NuIeu<n  <Iuxv 
    8z+su |u NNI_<~? I|II?IIIE
    FIVu?8 E nVll Il l uouou_  +
    n6: 
    Rp |Fu I|_IzeApnNI eI ? z
     n <e 8Fn Av 8z vv ?In
    + MI(?I_+ RF ?|z |?8  e
    eI ? zv 8 IIzN+|Iz n F VI
    $z8+v +uk
     II II$E uFz+ Au A :v8+?ezIz
    e
    E8++?:v v+s  M  N$u?F  + En+Vg N?++
    nu  _E ?u? NE 
    

    e N? $g n eI $V 8 z| E+
    +nI|k IIe Izu I I? * E +*ne
    IVuA sE$en z VV<I Vz+&FI
    s8I V _nN NexIE NI  8 n 0k
    zzIz<_|Iz FE :eE E<EI <n 

    N* N | Vgu 8?$Fng?Ig
    nsIv: VIz_+IC x6I+_?IIu EIn$
    I I8A<EA$uynIn Ee <nVIE V
    

       
    
    ' $A H  !,((' &
     *  & H,I( ! 


       H
     & ! A( ' $>H & &,D
    ? &%H' *,' A!    ! "$#%!&'("*),+"$+-

    GIH," "  F! 
     &

    G&3G 
     ' &*'  /! &H, D

    HF( F G! 


    

     &

    '  " ' ' &*>D= , ,J  F! ,

    + zV$ <?IIue y* eI En < ?n


    I+n I 8< 
    8IuV+ $zIF$zgI 8; z ue g;z 8u8++
    +e 8IFn0I I 8EI8E$  I$ + ?
    ++??V A VI8 unF?+u  VIvFIn uV
    IG nIA?n0E?n ( AI+EII I (R u
    n :?A+$I 8eI *u 8zu
    <I+I8I?II?
    v *e F;8+zIn*^ 0<+EIu~Ik8IA
    III?s ?zE V _IV ~8# NII+ ?II
    6EE g Rg v $In zIuxIFI;I?<nu
    IN<< *In?~?| IR+ |NIAuz e 8:
    uv nI $I N8n /v*uv Iu~ v; NE <
    u$u$8 ?zIz +$ FzAE ee#$+I
    $ F*n *
    : IGCE _z x u+n+
    +?  I    
    e N e?II_: Iz +Iz: u<|I|<I+? F8 II|u
    e 0 FI$ V FuA< F?n EunInu_ RI
    I  *nus??+  ?zI|$6Az uI8E
    :: V ?IIu ve< + s IEE~+ ? eu *?
    ?  *ze vu8: u  8 * I8u8s
    FEFzs u8|I|$ xV+In|v 8+ eI ? zv?ekn
    e 0IN8I$_u| k+zE eI n* I n
    ? eE 8 VnIen N~zIV8? eI ? zE
    0nveIE eI ? zv+Iy  e::

    

    <<<EI6_ I?ue $+ Fze Izvu$6


    +E<+Iu  E e 
    M _z$?AFE IInv ?Iz + * z|
    zA*  I_n (+I ;$ y
    z?z8E I8 +I? I ?<_ zgn
    E+ E vIe z$ ?IIxA
    eI ? z :Iy  EI$N;zInsv IunV
    nN v Iun<+I+$:Iy : I$EIVuv:IFV
    6<uE?I~zEEFue+I  I 
     v zE *x+Iy  Euge e:Iy + ?~
    IIzVnIV V zuEE+ E?xE+ _I  |
    * A++?*nI+ A8 _$ II|u e  E R:
     z
    0 nqwy IiEnNE N+; V n?E$EIug*e
    N?  8 IeE $| z $? ++ 8
    + eE+ IA+nIu e??
    E _I?u< ?FIIFzIF 8 Gu
    zkIz |V ( E z ++I#F+ EIe
    F  n: i| EI8e:F I F0
    zFz+nn ;?gkg e  ?
    e
    ?nI z+? R I$
    < E u?6qou{Ez+
    N EI _n N?eEI<neIz E
    zI y V * n sIze_+??sI_? E * nN?
    EII + *IVz <E?unI|FIe

    

    u{i|;iE? E v EuIz< n 8; I|+$E


    N n?eE8zI +In8zI ;nFn EIE
    InIuu 0N uE v+ue e?$uI
    + x|_ eIz+*+6 ;uIR 8I|
    ?$ I Is z *yIn<I $ ~E8AzIz
    $Iu zu $n8 A? +*E(E(FI_I
    uV -  # +nuE  ?II 8zv Nn?|I
    I+Ig I$uNnFn ?eI I_$ u
    Iux *IIg ?|z6 ?VII Fn
    R: # |_ 8<uI$Iz8Fn I eI ? z
    ?<N n eGu+ F z I8N;n?+uz$I~
     :+FF+n<IV NI IIIvI 0I| /veu
    F xIFIze nR?<I eI n : I0u_ +M
    I+?uVIE :e E AFVuIEu ~n
    Ip e ne V+nen *z;E eI ns z88IznE
    n EE 8?8 z
    e +Iu3 8 I+?s zAA n $I:n +p
    e  I +? nF~??IR*;p _nF?;$|?z^
    II?I II|usev u n? 8|? xenNI n
    :$+I zInI|_I?u ?II<I+ n e v I+ ?
    N z8~I? vE * Euun*8 ? n InnsI
    E * u x I?n x EzI8 ueIeN g $s
      &" ".!#' ?3( !   H H 
    L')2 H* &' ' J IGI'  AGI%!# 
    A! !  5+<>' AGI
    ! >( $>A! J' H,%!#  G ' H ! A
     ( A!  &7'   H".! ' H <&H&GI' &* J ' %3! D
    ' ' 2E H,* ' ' J, IGI'  AGI '  ! H !
     H" H  $A?A! J' H ! A( I5&<>'  > GI,D &H,"
    ' 2! A(
    L' ' 2 '  H H  A! & J,I!,GI' .H  GIH* &' ' J IGI'  AGIE' H,<>  H
     $>
     H A ( D
    ' 2!#I!,(H 5   H* &' ' J IGI'  AGIE' 3! D A! J' H, ! >(  5+<>' AGI

    & ' H  D
    '   ?H  ' H &  G! .
    I &/G ' IG

    

    !#'
    G!

    $>= A
     GGI' AG

      

     

      

     

    N uu;  E~NV$I<
     ?Iue N8z
    0vuE V uz~ vz k g?8 N~?<;n
    u8|I|$IA+Iy  E<N+z;xN $I _I?
    I I(  ?II  +unFe +I?
    InsN?;e eE sII NIezx I
    uI V VIuee + V s6gz
    F u I<u+ Vu< eee un Fzu
    +IzFI:++z?VI+ +IIF++nF
    ++8? zn#<z z?z  I 
    

    uxEI0FFE8+II$|++0 Iun
    EF|n:uIe+?s vIAI| <n+8I$8
    nV8g ; < *InI<N+E ??IuV|IIn+ _I
    zu+ EEIVFnI ? xe + Ie_ eI ? z
    nF NIuxE_ eII  IFzuF~MIun8Iu
    n~:nFI$u+ R0|uIVn

    ' " !    G ' H  D= H* &' ' J=FG ' AGI '  $A>! J ' H! A(.I5&<>'  >GI,D.
    L' ' 2  *! ' H   H* &' ' J FGI'  AG ,$A?' *
    $>A! J' H, ! A
     ( I5&<>'  >GI'   G ' H  D &  H,,GIH,*&' J, FGI'  AG A!# &H H  H H*,' G! # F! & ! A( A!  H  <&I!#*" ! ' G
    ! >(  ' ' F ! ' !  (' " &' H 3D
    ' ' ' 2   ' &.
    &3!(  &  '  ' &*7! $AH &'  G ' IG !#' D &' /'   &
    <&&' H,H,<&')G?! &" &"%$>H  &"E$AH>D
    ' J&2   GIH&
     '    A G   H,*&' ' J, FGI'  >GI=!#  A! $>A! J' H, ! A(EI5&<>'  >GI/!#
     G  ' H  D  H* & '  ' J FG ' A
     GI=$>' & *%$>A! J' H,! A ( I5&<A'  A GIE'   G  ' H D- '   G  ' H    A((A! A! &/! H  '  3! D
     !#" <&H,$A! $ %' 7
     (&! & *,?H  " ' <&  ' & *  &E!  &H, ,&<>H,'  ' H  ' . (IGI' $&' & *.!E<A!    H,"  &=GI' FG !#'
     H    A(&(+&'   F!('  ' H  D  H J3 (3G ')(+3( &'   & '    
    H  G !#'   H/<H&GI3(.! A (%'  $AH ( ! 
     3 D !
    !#

     

    

    

    

    

    

    

     

     

    

    

    

    

    

    

    

    !,(+J ' 3D


    I  ' &' F! '  ?'  ' '  ! !#<A! &=<&&'  H,H,<&&?3 F! ' 3( '
    !

    
    
    H/H& H 
     ' (?*,*,? ,  A(   D

     

     & >  F!(' ' H  H  " ' A ( &? !


    

     

     

    !   ! A(
    

    ! 

    F 0z6IsI$ V?Vu z+ ; II N


    E F e n<nFs NIuFEI$uI? I
    < $IIs<uu: Fz<AI+NI+?n+??N
    Nn I: euu+EIIN+uze?$ InI v?gup e
    I V$In zIzeF u |I|VI+ IV? V8 E z88u
    +IzIe nnInu;  Ev 8IuAVu*++N uz
    u u uF;Izz(EG FI& ?_NIE I I nIus ?
    AzIu? e;uAE+8Iu Ez| Iuuu N+
    ?z$+Nu?Fn :F~ eI zIzIgE: u<Iu
    E E*; zI|E < <In8nI$8*Vu?++?gI+
    Zb[  ]

      
     

    ]8C ^ GF ] p

    F +V $+Iy  u *+I:INAI


    n?0A E? _Iu F ?z+NIIuuFEI8~
    Nu VIuzIeu<IF e ?ns(enI?ge
    IuvV z|V _AEA ?VI ;EI$I
    zu|Ixse *n: ne E:z+ ue: u I
    \8nI?;?e F+?N? 8 A F;u8G z
    E FI6n _,8 z ?| uEn~?Vkz_ Nz E8
    ?e6?E $ $IuEIu ~|Ee *I|u ? 6 M
    ~IuA <8? s NIuF N ?|Es_I? I|
    

    $#$    "  

    IiEt8oui _|n I n8 uE|I|e? EFzs


    ?ze+?8(I|us ?n +;G |+ (E

    z?INI_s|V N$v?~eE u$sI


    *n Izu ? z?_?F uNnnF
     & #$   

    EE n ^Fn II pEA | In
    | z RI?z zs R ; z n(Izz I?zI
    Iz I?z I0n|Ig 8Vun ?nI|RIz 3z?
    ?N R
      %   

    e n8 N NzC+ zII* 8IV< uI*+


    \z +I8 FR?n uVE +e:0|I|uzA?
    I?z  s eIu uII8_  II
    #I<_ VE6 8 I+? 8Ee 0 e E ne
    I * ENuE nEII uszIz
    uFus eI zsn + 8:I
    uz p+? sAIu$+V8FnEI|+IzNIF ;
    eI z3FE &_ FVI0zAAz $?unI|
    <eVI N0
    v8IV8I|u*?V+ 8 ?VE$eE 8?V
    E <E;ue < nsI+??<gVu u$# u M
    +|++u+ u| z;uu /<u; 8Iu$ _ * 
    RIu8 ? 8 F I8zeA?zG$u?#
    IuF N 6VEEE +? xesIzyu? Nu
    Mue v+ ?M?EF$IzE;nAE +Iz /vIu?eeIuz
     ?A z?n<z z?n?( NIuV E v?|u?
    

    

    [  Rs [

    IIn *$z_Iuv ue ~n<IuuEn;VuAv $e


    uIIVI s y n $ z+?|++uI
    $F V :e+ n#~EV8: Iz
     $$ up? u*?vn F_AI n,v
    I u V eEx nIg~ Nzu
    E?* u?nI g e~Iu uF n?+E~+8I
    <g |nV gng n ~*~ I?nI x$Ize*n
    n+< zevI?? +?senIIu<__ s zvu
    ~pnInI|F *ng uVNAF  ?E
    eI ? z<InIIe *ze e e_?F$ 8 : n
    IzeA|uN|I|$IIF IN * < zu~ zIu
    8|+n |nn z 8e;+ 8Fze eIuu
    ?uz; neAuI
    a u d [  $
    I vF E e n?xI Nv X v vze~IR e  eI
    v+p*i|w?{rsoutvjxwulklou M   M 
     8<u n I 6 e Iz? zE|? ^Iz \zI
    nz   +++? E n ( I?# 6 e In?x
    e  F  uI $ 0z I h*ou{i|{i$}x|lni|t~u 
    <o ou E{u
     lkou u e M  ?
    M 

    
    M

    *0/v?;^rsou ;ilkou |lv}xt8o{oi8e z  | u  


    M 
      E _zn N EuzI
    n <+F ? v veI < +
    EI
        N   E   vs: ?Iv+?  M M
      8s n  ?R | gs n s u y  I
    *I N< u?E i|{|luu E{|uy *rsoulzi|tvjou{u{| gi|ou
    lIi E{onq  qi +u _}xoil   +  n euz   M 
      EEe +In  u<I  ,  +8| s:Iu
    ?nnnIR+ u+II*+:z?  iuou{u
    <{up}xi| i| M  M M 
      *$<gv /v + _s 8 ?  iuou{su <{u}xi i| M M
      M  +:us EIe +n  uEI e
      *$ ~ /vI$s$I<I|   nIF^? I??NzF M  u
    s?eE uIF IAF u v unzu
     *V Vs  esueN; VI
    g v e?x Viuu6+l Iisj ooj
    onq<j oou : M /V v unz  | M   M 
     M  $< FI
     ?v vInI vI   F?I?
     eRI 0v 6|F i{|lku u {uu  rsou
    lzi|tvjou{u{| i|8ouAlIi E{|uon q  qi +u _}xoilk V  :  n
    euz   M 
     MAM  e ?v  I
    g I A
     Fs ?Ez? 
    I :v u*i|{|lku u E{|uy 0rsoulzi|tvjou{u{|
      

    gi|^oul Ii E{(onq s qi 0 u^}xoil V?e  +  z | euz


      M
     M  I  u+s eu E?ge 6+8I n?   ee 8ss
    |n e <   ?FI {l  lni i i  u   M  <I
    M  M
     M  N eu |A?INE EzI?p {lk  
    lni i i- u M y M  M 
    u?I M  M
     M *$ /$ Exv  F
    nI?e {lk   lzi ?i| i.     ? M  M
     M   N Env  u
     {om ssuk    I  M   Iz M  
     M  I V Ix
    |qou{|t8lkou
    Iiou{|u }Ilkl|lk| <u   v x 8
    M  
     M   _  /VGI  I |
    Vi|li 6{?i rsoui|{louy
    ll IiVh*u gut8+ouFl IiV};i| i:onql IiV uI_I? euz   M  ?
     M  *V g< v VrsouuouwIiN

    jI u;i u eEF^s+Iu en  
    M  M
     M *$ v+< ~: Viuou{gu 6{u}xi| i| M  I M   M  <+
    +?e$<Iv <I  VnI u
       .
    /V?E} q|l ou{ *ruuA0   pIi|{i8l Ii*}xi| iu <w?ut
    iil v ?|I| u uI_I? euz M  
    

    

    You might also like