Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HRM Notes (On Almost Every Topics)
HRM Notes (On Almost Every Topics)
PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL
MEANING OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL performance appraisal may be understood as t e assessment of indi!idual"s performance in a systematic #ay$ t e performance bein% measured a%ainst factors suc as &ob 'no#led%e$ (uality and (uantity output$ initiati!e$ leaders ip abilities$ super!ision$ dependability$ co)operation$ &ud%ment$ !ersatility$ ealt and t e li'e* Assessment s ould be confined to past performance alone* Potentials of t e employee for future performance must also be assessed* Performance appraisal is a met od of e!aluatin% t e be a!ior of employees in t e #or' spot$ normally includin% bot t e (uantitati!e and (ualitati!e aspect of &ob performance* Performances ere refer to t e de%ree of accomplis ment of t e tas's t at ma'e up an indi!idual"s &ob* It indicates o# #ell an indi!idual is fulfillin% t e &ob demands* Often t e term is confused #it effort$ but performance is al#ays measured in terms of result and not efforts* A formal definition of performance appraisal is +it is t e systematic e!aluation of t e indi!idual #it respect to is or er performance on t e &ob and is or er potential for de!elopment*,
FEA-.RES OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL Performance appraisal is t e systematic description of an employee"s &ob rele!ant stren%t s and #ea'nesses* - e basic purpose is to find out o# #ell t e employee is performin% t e &ob and establis a plan of impro!ement* Appraisals are arran%ed periodically accordin% to a definite plan* Performance appraisal is not &ob e!aluation* It refers to o# #ell someone is doin% t e assi%ned &ob* /ob e!aluation determines o# muc a &ob is #ort to t e or%ani0ation and t ere for$ # at ran%e of pay s ould be assi%ned to t e &ob*
PROCESS OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL Performance appraisal is planned$ de!eloped and implemented t rou% a series of steps1 ES-A4LIS5ING PERFORMANCE S-AN6AR6
FOLLO7 .P AC-IONS 23 Establis Performance Standards* Appraisal systems re(uire performance standards$ # ic ser!e as benc mar's a%ainst # ic performance is measured* In order to be useful$ standards s ould relate to t e desired results of eac &ob* Appraisals must a!e a clear) cut criteria* Performance standards must be bot to t e appraiser and t e appraise* - e performance standards of %oals must be de!eloped after a t orou% analysis of t e &ob* Goals must be #ritten do#n* - ey must be measurable #it in certain time and cost considerations*
83 Communicate t e Standards* Performance appraisal in!ol!es attract t#o parties9 t e appraiser # o does t e appraisal and t e appraise # ose performance is bein% e!aluated* 4ot are e:pected to do certain t in%s* - e appraiser s ould prepare &ob descriptions clearly$ elp appraise set is %oals and tar%ets9 analysis results ob&ecti!ely9 offer coac in% and %uidance to appraise # ene!er re(uired and re#ard %ood results* - e appraiser s ould be !ery clear about # at e is doin% and # y e is doin%* For t is purpose$ t e performance standards must be communicated to appraise and t eir reactions are noted initially* - ese standards must be re!ised or modified as and # en re(uired* ;3 Measure Actual Performance* After t e performance standards are set and accepted$ t e ne:t step is to measure actual performance* - is re(uires t e use of dependable performance measures$ t e ratin%s used to e!aluate performance* Performance measures in order to be elpful must be easy to use$ reliable and report on t e critical be a!iors t at determine performance* Generally$ mana%ers re%ardin% o# to measure actual performance use four common sources of information1 personal obser!ation$ statistical reports$ oral reports and #ritten reports* <3 Compare Actual Performance #it Standards and 6iscuss t e Appraisal* Actual performance may be better t an e:pected and sometimes it may e!en %o off t e trac'* - e assessment of anot er person=s contribution and ability is not an easy tas'* It as serious emotional o!ertones as it affects t e self)esteem of t e appraise* Any appraisal as'ed on sub&ecti!e criteria is li'ely to be (uestioned by t e appraisers and lea!e im (uite de&ected and un appy # en t e appraisal turns out to be ne%ati!e*
>3 -a'in% Correcti!e Action$ if Necessary* Correcti!e action is of t#o types1 - e one$ # ic puts out t e fires immediately and t e ot er one$ # ic stri'es at e root of t e problems permanently* Immediate action sets t in%s ri% t and %et t in%s bac' or trac'$ # ereas t e basic correcti!e action %ets to t e source of de!iations and seems to ad&ust t e difference permanently* 4asic correcti!e step see' to find out o# and # y performance de!iate*
A3 -raditional Met ods Confidential report Ran'in% Grap ical ratin% scale C ec'lists Forced distribution Critical incidents Essay e!aluation Group appraisals
43 Modern Met ods 2* 5uman resource accountin% 8* mana%ement by ob&ecti!e ;* Assessment centre <* 4ARS? 4e a!iorally anc ored ratin% scale 3
-raditional met ods1 Confidential report met od It is mostly used in %o!ernment or%ani0ations* It is a descripti!e report %enerally prepared at t e end of t e year$ by t e employee"s immediate superior* - e report i% li% ts t e stren%t s$ #ea'nesses$ ma&or mista'es$ merits$ %ood #or' done etc* of t e subordinate* - e impression of t e superior about t e superior is merely recorded ere* It does not offer any feedbac' to appraise* It is a narrati!e met od of performance appraisal since t e report is not made public and ence no freedom is a!ailable$ t e sub&ecti!e analysis of t e superior is li'ely to be otly contested* Ran'in% met od - is is relati!ely easy met od of performance e!aluation* In it$ t e ran'in% of an employee in a #or' %roup is a%ainst t at of anot er employee* - e relati!e position of eac employee is tested in terms of is or er numerical ran'$ for e:ample$ # en t ere are fi!e employees ?A$4$C$6$E3 to be compared$ t en A"s performance is compared #it t at of 4"s and decision is arri!ed at as to # ose is t e better or #orst* Ne:t$ 4 is
also compares #it all ot ers* Since A is already compared #it 4$ t is time 4 is to be compared #it only C$ 6$ and E In t is e!aluation is as'ed to rate t e employees from i% est to lo#est on some o!erall criterion* It is easier to ran' t e best and t e #orst employee$ it is !ery difficult to ran' t e a!era%e employees* Grap ical ratin% scale It is t e oldest and t e most commonly used met od of performance in t is$ a printed form is used to e!aluate t e performance of an employee* Four to t#el!e factors are selected$ dependin% upon t e cate%ory to # ic t e employee belon%s* Some of t ese factors are (uantity of out put$ (uality of out put$ initiati!e$ inte%rity$ dependability etc* t ese factors and t eir de%rees are mar'ed on a %rap paper pro!ided in t e form* - e rater as merely to c ec' on t e scale # ere e t in's t e employee belon%s* C ec'lists and #ei% ted c ec'lists - e c ec'list is a simple ratin% tec ni(ue in # ic t e super!isor is %i!en a list of statement or #orld and as' to c ec' statement representin% t e c aracteristic and performance of eac employee a c ec'list represents a set of ob&ecti!e statement about t e employee and is be a!ior* A more recent !ariation of t e c ec'list is #ei% ted list* .nder t is t e !alue of eac (uestion may be #ei% ted more ea!ily t an ot ers* - e follo#in% are sample (uestions in t e c ec'list1 ) Is t e employee is really interested in t e tas' assi%ned@ ) Is e respected of is collea%ues@ ) 6oes e follo# instructions properly@ ) 6oes e %i!e respect to is superiors@ ) 6oes e ma'e mista'es fre(uently@ AesB No AesB No AesB No AesB No AesB No
A ratin% score from t e c ec'list elps t e mana%er in e!aluation of t e performance of t e employee* Forced distribution met od It #as de!eloped to eliminate t e bias and t e preponderance of i% ratin%s t at mi% t occur in some or%ani0ations* Its primary purpose is t e correct tendency of t e
rates to %i!e consistently i% and lo# ratin%s to all employees* - is met od ma'es t ose of se!eral sets of pair p ases$ t#o of # ic are positi!e and t#o of t em are ne%ati!e and t e rates is as'ed to indicate # ic of t e four p rase is t e most or least descripti!e of a particular employee* Actually t e statement items are %rounded in suc a #ay t at t e rater cannot # ic statement applies to t e most effecti!e employee* - e fa!orable (ualities earn a plus credit and t e unfa!orable ones earn t e se!erest* In t is t e o!erall ob&ecti!ity is increased in t e employee"s performance because t e rater does not 'no# o# i% or lo# e is e!aluatin% t e indi!idual$ as e as no access to t e storin% 'ey* Critical incident met od - e mana%er prepares test of statements of e!ery effecti!e and ineffecti!e be a!ior of an employee* - ese critical incidents or e!ents represent t e outstandin% poor be a!ior of t e employees* - e mana%er prepares records of t e critical incidents of t e #or'er"s be a!ior* At t e end of t e ratin% period$ t e recorded critical incidents are used in t e e!aluation of t e #or'ers" performance* Essay Appraisal .nder t is met od t e rater is as'ed to e:press t e stron% as #ell as t e #ea' points of t e employee"s be a!ior* - is tec ni(ue is normally used #it a combination of t e %rap ical ratin% scale because t e rater an elaborately present t e scale by sustainin% an e:planation for is ratin%* In it$ t e rater considers t e follo#in% factors1 /ob 'no#led%e and potential of t e employee* Employees understandin% about t e company"s pro%rammes$ policies$ ob&ecti!e$ etc* - e employees %eneral plannin%$ or%ani0in% and controllin% ability* - e employee"s relation #it t e co)#or'ers and superiors* - e attitude and perceptions of t e #or'er$ in %eneral* Group appraisal In t is met od an employee is appraised by a %roup of appraisers* - is %roup consists of t e immediate super!isor of t e employee$ ot er super!isors # o a!e close contact #it employee"s #or'$ mana%er or ead of department or consultant* - e ead of department or mana%er may be t e c airman of t e %roup and t e super!isor may act as t e coordinate for t e %roup acti!ities* - e immediate super!isor enli% ten
ot er members about t e &ob c aracteristics$ demand$ standards or performance etc* t en t e %roup appraise t e performance of t e employee$ compares t e performance #it t e standards$ finds out t e de!iation$ discusses t e reasons$ t erefore su%%ests #ays for impro!ement of performance$ prepares an action plan$ studies t e need for c an%e in t e &ob analysis and standards and recommends c an%es$ if necessary* - is met od eliminates +personal bias, to a lar%e e:tent$ as performance is e!aluated by multiple rates* 5o#e!er$ it is !ery time consumin% process*
43 Modern Met ods1 5uman resource accountin% 5RA is a sop isticated #ay to measure in financial terms t e effecti!eness of t e personal mana%er acti!ities and t e use of people in an or%ani0ation* It is process of accountin% people as an or%ani0ation resource* It tries to place a !alue on t e or%ani0ational uman resources as assets and not as e:penses* - is met od s o#s t e in!estment t e or%ani0ation ma'es in t e people and o# t e !alue of t ese people c an%e o!er a time* - e ac(uisition of employee is compared #it t e replacement cost from time to time* In brief$ in t is met od t e employees" performance is e!aluated in terms of costs and contributions of employees* Mana%ement by ob&ecti!es It is t e modern met od of e!aluatin% t e performance of personnel* Mana%ers a!e become increasin%ly a#are t at t e traditional performance e!aluation systems are c aracteri0ed by facin% %oals* - e concept of M4O is actually t e outcome t e pioneerin% #or' of 6ruc'er$ Mc%re%er and Odioine in mana%ement science* M4O can be described as t e process # ereby t e superior and subordinate mana%er of an or%ani0ation &ointly identify its common %oals$ eac indi!idual"s areas of operations$ responsibility in terms of results e:pected of im and use t ese measures as a %uide for operatin% t e unit and assessin% t e contributions of eac of its members* M4O t us represents more t an an e!aluation process* - e M4O can be described in four steps1 - e first step is to establis t e %oals eac subordinate is to attain* - e %oals typically refer to t e desired outcome to be ac ie!ed* - e %oals can be t en used to e!aluate t e employee performance
- e second step in!ol!es settin% of t e performance standard fro t e subordinates in a pre!iously arran%ed time period* In t e t ird step$ t e actual le!el of %oal attainment is compared #it t e %oals a%reed upon* - e e!aluator e:plores t e reasons or t e %oals t at #ere not met and t e %oals t at #ere e:ceeded* - is step elps to determine t e trainin% needs* It also alerts t e superior of t e conditions t at may affect but o!er # ic t e subordinate as no control* - e final step in!ol!es establis in% ne# %oals and$ possibly$ ne# strate%ies for %oals t at pre!iously not attained* At t is point$ subordinate and superior in!ol!ement in t e %oal settin% may c an%e* Subordinates # o successi!ely reac t e establis ed %oals may be allo#ed to participate more in t e %oal settin% process t e ne:t time* - e process is repeated* Assessment center In t is approac indi!iduals from !arious departments are brou% t to%et er to spend t#o or t ree days #or'in% on an indi!idual or a %roup assi%nment similar to t e ones t ey #ould be andlin% # en promoted* Obser!ers ran' t e performance of eac and e!ery participant in order to merit since assessment centers are basically meant for e!aluatin% t e potential of candidates to be considered for promotion$ trainin% on de!elopment$ t ey offer an e:cellent means for conductin% e!aluation process in an ob&ecti!e #ay* All assesses %et an e(ual opportunity to s o# t eir talents and capabilities based on merit* 4e a!iorally anc ored ratin% scale - is met od is also 'no#n as be a!ioral e:pectation scale* - is met od represent e latest inno!ation in t e performance appraisal* It is t e combination of t e ratin% scale and critical incident tec ni(ues of employee performance e!aluation* - e critical incidents ser!e as t e anc or statement on a scale and t e ratin% form usually contains si: to ei% t specifically defined performance dimensions*
;CDE PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL - e appraisal may be any person # o as t orou% 'no#led%e about t e &ob contents$ contents to be appraised$ standards of contents and # o obser!es t e employee=s by performin% a &ob* - e appraisal s ould be capable of determinin% # at is more important and # at is relati!ely less important* 5e s ould prepare reports and made &ud%ments #it out bias* -ypical appraisals are super!isors$ peers* Subordinates$ employees t emsel!es$ user of ser!ice and consultants* Performance Appraisal by all t ese parties is called ;CDE Performance Appraisal* Super!isors Super!isors include superiors of t e employee$ ot er superiors a!in% 'no#led%e about t e #or' of t e employee and department ead or mana%er* General practice is t at immediate superior appraises t e performance$ # ic in turn is re!ie#ed by t e departmental eadB mana%ers* - is is because superiors are responsible free mana%in% t eir subordinates and t ey a!e t e opportunity to obser!e$ direct and control t e subordinate continuously* Moreo!er$ t ey are accountable for t e successful performance of t eir subordinates* Sometimes ot er super!isors$ # o contact #it information* Peers Peer appraisal may be reliable of t e #or'%roup is stable o!er a reasonably lon% period of time and performs tas's t at re(uire interaction* Subordinates employee #or' also appraise #it a!e close a !ie# to pro!ide additional
In de!eloped countries$ t e concept of c an%e superiors rated by subordinates in bein% used in most or%ani0ations* Suc a met od can be useful pro!ided t e relations ips bet#een superiors and subordinates art cordial* Subordinate=s ratin%s in suc cases can be (uite useful in identifyin% competent superiors* Self)Appraisal If indi!iduals understand t e ob&ecti!es t ey are e:pected to ac ie!e and t e standards by # ic t ey are to be e!aluated$ t ey are to a %reat e:tent in t e best position to appraise t eir o#n performance* Also$ since employee de!elopment means self) de!elopment$ employees # o appraise t eir o#n performance may become i% ly moti!ated* .sers of Ser!icesBCustomers - e customers on users of ser!ices can$ better &ud%e employee performance in ser!ice or%ani0ations relatin% to be a!iors$ promptness$ speed in doin% t e &ob and accuracy* E:ample$ students better &ud%e a teac er"s performance* Consultants Sometimes consultants may be en%a%ed for appraisal # en employees or employers do not trust t e super!isory appraisal and mana%ement does not trust t e self)appraisal and t e appraisal done by subordinates* In suc situation$ t e consultants are trained and t ey obser!e t e employee at #or' for sufficiently lon% periods for t e purpose of appraisal* 7 en to appraise@ Informal appraisals are conducted # ene!er t e super!isor or personnel mana%er feel it necessary* 5o#e!er$ systematic appraisals are conducted on a re%ular basis9 say for e:ample$ e!ery si: mont or annually*
P.RPOSES OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL -o create and maintain a satisfactory le!el of performance* -o contribute to t e employee %ro#t and de!elopment t ou% t trainin%$ self and mana%ement de!elopment pro%rammes* -o elp t e superior to a!e a proper understandin% about t eir subordinates* -o %uide t e &ob c an%es #it elp to continuous ran'in%* -o facilitate fair and e(uitable compensation based on performance* -o pro!ide information for ma'in% decision re%ardin% lay off$ retrenc ment etc*
REF.IREMEN-S OF A GOO6 APPRAISAL SAS-EM1 It must be easily understandable1 If t e system is too muc comple: or to time consumin%$ it may be anc ored to t e %round by its o#n dead #ei% t of complicated forms # ic nobody but t e e:perts understand* It musty as support of all line people # o administer it1 If t e line people t in' t at t ere role is not !ery important t en t ey #ill not consider t e system seriously* Similarly$ if t e people find t at t e system is too t eoretical$ too ambitious$ or t at as been foisted on t em by t e i!ory)to#er staff consultants # o a!e no compre ension of t e demand t en t ey #ill recent it* - e system s ould be sufficiently %rounded in t e re(uirement of t e or%ani0ation1 It s ould reflect t e !alue system of t e or%ani0ation* In fact functionin% as a definition of performance$ it s ould tell e employee # at set of acti!ities or # at (ualities are considered desirable by t e or%ani0ation* As suc it s ould a!e lin'a%e #it t e &ob description* - e system s ould be bot !alid and reliable1 - e !alidity of t e ratin%s is t e de%ree to # ic t ey are truly indicati!e of t e intrinsic merit of t e employees* - e reliability of t e ratin%s is t e consistency #it # ic t e ratin%s are made$ eit er by different sectors$ one by one rater at different times* 4ot !alidity and reliability result from ob&ecti!ity* - e appraisal system of many or%ani0ations lac's t is ob&ecti!ity and bunc es all employees into one or t#o
top ran's #it out ta'in% into account t eir merits* - is raises outstandin% performances but also raises doubts about t e !alidity of t e system* - e system s ould a!e built)in incenti!e1 - is means t at t e re#ard s ould follo# satisfactory performance* Many aut ors o#e!er$ ad!ocate a%ainst t e direct lin'a%e bet#een t e appraisal and re#ards* In t eir opinion$ suc a connection t rottles do#n#ard communication of performance appraisal because superiors do not li'e bein% (uestioned by dis%runtled subordinates* - e system s ould be open and participati!e1 It s ould in!ol!e employees in %oal)settin% process* - is performance better* - e systems s ould focus more on t e de!elopment and %ro#t 1 Of t e employee t an on %eneratin% data for administrati!e decision ma'in% related to promotions$ increments$ etc* t e system must elp in identifyin% employee"s stren%t s and #ea'nesses and indicate correcti!e actions* For e:ample it may re!eal t at %oals need to be modified on9 t ere is need for classification of duties or for additional trainin% or &ob rotation or &ob enric ment* elps in plannin%
GREIVANCE
1! MEANING" DEFINITION # - e concept GGrie!ance" as been defined in se!eral #ays by different aut orities some of t e definition are follo#s1 4eac defines a %rie!ance as +any dissatisfaction or feelin% of in&ustice in connection #it one"s employment situation t at is brou% t to t e notice of t e mana%ement,$ # ere as Flippo indicate t e %rie!ance as +a type of discontent # ic must al#ays be e:pressed A %rie!ance is usually more formal in c aracter t an a complaint* It can be !alid or ridiculous$ and must %ro# out of somet in% connected #it company operations or policy* It must in!ol!e interpretation or application of t e pro!ision of t e labour contract*, /ucius defines a %rie!ance as +any discontent or dissatisfaction$ # et er e:posed or not$ # et er !alid or not$ arisin% out of anyt in% connected #it company # ic an employee t in's$ belie!es or e!en feels to be unfair$ un&ust or ine(uitable*, A %rie!ance is more t an li'ely a !iolation of an employee=s ri% ts on t e &ob$ a ri% t t at is usually$ but not al#ays defined by t e contract* In seein% a %rie!ance in t is #ay$ #e can understand better t at t e best place to loo' for a #ay to defend t e member is in t e lan%ua%e of t e contract* So for all practical purposes$ e!ery union officer must %o bac' to t e contract first # en a member comes in #it a complaint or a problem* - e contract pro!ides us #it t e stron%est ammunition in resol!in% t e issue for our member* Is t e contract t e only means to resol!e member=s %rie!ances@ Of course not* 4ut it is probably t e stron%est le% you a!e to stand on* Lastly$ t ere are many %rie!ances t at fall into a lar%e cate%ory # ic #e say are discipline)related* - e union can c allen%e certain rules or t eir application* 7e may ar%ue t at a member is bein% disciplined #it out H&ust causeH or e or s e is sufferin% from disparate treatment* - e t#o e:pressions are simply an arbitrator=s or la#yer=s #ay of sayin% t e member is bein% disciplined unfairly* So t e best ad!ice t at can be offered in andlin% a member=s problem is to c ec' t e contract first* If t ere is any reasonable #ay of dealin% #it t e issue as a
contract !iolation$ you ou% t to use it* Aou and your local union are only limited by t e contract$ t e s'ills of t e %rie!ance representati!es$ and t e po#er of t e local union* NEED FOR A GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE Grie!ance procedure is necessary for any or%ani0ation due to t e follo#in% reason1 Most %rie!ances seriously disturb t e employees* - is may affect t eir moral$ producti!ity and t eir #illin%ness to cooperate #it t e or%ani0ation* If an e:plosi!e situation de!elops$ t is can be promptly attended to if %rie!ance andlin% procedure is already in e:istence* It is not possible t at all t e complaints of t e employees #ould be settled by first) time super!isors$ for t ese super!isor may not a!e ad a proper trainin% for t e purpose$ and t ey may lac' aut ority* Moreo!er$ t ere may be personality conflicts and ot er cause as #ell* It ser!es as a c ec' on t e arbitrary action of t e mana%ement because super!isors 'no# t at employees are li'ely to see to it t at t eir protest dose reac t e i% er mana%ement* It ser!es as an outlet for employees %ripes$ discontent and frustrations* It acts li'e a pressure !alue on a steam boiler* - e employees are entitled to le%islati!e$ e:ecuti!e and &udicial protection and t ey %et t is protection from t e %rie!ance redressal procedure$ # ic also acts as a means of up#ard communication*
2!CONSIDERS GOOD PRACTICE IN $ANDLING DISCIPLINARY AND GRIEVANCE ISSUES # endorses t e ACAS Code of Practice2 for andlin% disciplinary and %rie!ance issues summari0es t e statutory procedures # ic came into force in October 8DD< includes t e CIP6 !ie#point* S%&&'()
A summary of issues # ic can be addressed t rou% t e 4asic Grie!ance Procedure include$ but are not limited to$ t e follo#in%1 All alle%ations of discrimination9 alle%ations of non)compliance #it t e Personnel Rules9 impro!ement of systems$ practices or procedures9 safety9 ealt 9 #or'in% conditions9 materials or e(uipment9 super!isory practices or procedures considered improper or unfair9 disciplinary actions suc as suspensions of <D ours or less$ reprimands or memos of concern9 or any ot er matters sub&ect to t e aut ority of t e A6OA 6irector and for # ic no ot er met od of redress is pro!ided or pro ibited in t e Personnel Rules* R*+,(-.,-/0+ An employee may not submit a %rie!ance c allen%in% t e follo#in% mana%ement ri% ts$ but may submit a %rie!ance concernin% t e manner of t eir administration$ insofar as t ese personally affect t e employee1 - e a%ency=s ri% t to direct its employees9 to ire$ promote$ transfer$ assi%n$ and retain employees9 and$ to maintain efficiency of %o!ernment operations$ and to determine t e met ods$ means$ and personnel by # ic t ese operations are to be conducted* An employee may submit a %rie!ance concernin% a specific performance factor ratin% by utili0in% t e EPAS Grie!ance Procedure* An employee may not submit a %rie!ance concernin% t e receipt of a performance decrease$ t e non)receipt of a performance increase or special performance a#ard$ t e amount of any increase or decrease$ or t e use of any &ob)related supplemental ratin% factors to determine t e receipt or amount of an increase$ decrease$ or special performance a#ard* An employee may submit a %rie!ance usin% t e 4asic Grie!ance Procedure #it in 2D days of receipt of a plannin% EPAS or #it in 2D days of failin% to recei!e$ after #ritten re(uest$ a plannin% document* N/01A223-.'43* M',,*(+ A summary of issues # ic cannot be addressed t rou% eit er t e 4asic or t e EPAS Grie!ance Procedure$ include$ but are not limited to$ t e follo#in%1 Retirement issues9 life insurance or ealt insurance issues9 suspension for more t an <D #or'in% ours$ demotion$ or dismissal resultin% from disciplinary action9 any e:amination$ certification or appointment9 any classification action9 and any reduction in force
action and matters not sub&ect to t e 6epartment of Administration control* Ot er a!enues e:ist to see' redress or remedy in!ol!in% t ese actions* A&*05&*0,+ Once a %rie!ance is referred to any step beyond t e immediate super!isor$ it may not be amended* If additional documentation is submitted by t e %rie!ant after t e initiation of t e %rie!ance$ t e re!ie#in% official may remand t e %rie!ance to t e appropriate pre!ious le!el for reconsideration* It is t e employee=s responsibility to pro!ide documentation to support t e alle%ations raised in t e %rie!ance* C/06-5*0,-'3-,) '05 U+* /6 O66-.-'3 A%,7/(-,) - e preparation$ submittal$ re!ie# and response to a %rie!ance are confidential* Correspondence re%ardin% a %rie!ance s ould be andled in a confidential manner$ and en!elopes containin% %rie!ance material s ould be clearly labeled Hconfidential*H No reference to t e complaint s all be included in t e employee=s official personnel file* Copies of #ritten responses sent at eac step of t e procedure are limited to respondents at t e precedin% steps$ t e a%ency ead or t e a%ency ead=s desi%nee unless it is necessary to notify additional personnel because t e response re(uires anot er indi!idual to ta'e some action* No person s all directly or indirectly use any official aut ority or influence in any manner to discoura%e t e use of t is procedure* Any person found %uilty may be sub&ect to penalty under A6OA Personnel Rule R8)>)>D2* R*2(*+*0,',-/0 At any step of t e %rie!ance procedure after t e mandatory pre)%rie!ance oral discussion ?see belo#3$ %rie!ant may select one representati!e to pro!ide ad!ice andBor spea' for t e %rie!ant at any meetin%s determined necessary by mana%ement in t e course of t e %rie!ance process* An A6OA employee # o ser!es as a representati!e is re(uired to re(uest and obtain prior appro!al for annual or compensatory lea!e for any time de!oted as a representati!e durin% re%ular #or'in%
ours* If a representati!e is c osen$ t e representati!e s all be identified on t e %rie!ance form G(/%2 G(-*8'0.* S ould a %roup of employees file a %rie!ance$ all employees of t e %roup are re(uired to si%n t e %rie!ance and to clearly desi%nate$ on t e %rie!ance form$ one member # o #ill act as t e %roup=s contact person* - e contact person #ill act as a spea'er for t e %roup in any meetin%s determined necessary by mana%ement* P(*2'(',-/0 T-&* 6urin% t e entire formal %rie!ance process ?after t e oral discussion at Step I3$ employees are allo#ed up to four ours #it pay to prepare t e %rie!ance andBor confer #it t eir official representati!e on t e %rie!ance* Employees cannot use state e(uipment for t is process* Employees must re(uest and obtain prior super!isory appro!al for time off$ # ic #ill be sub&ect to t e operational needs of t e unit* - e time an employee de!otes to attendin% any meetin%s sc eduled by mana%ement to discuss t e %rie!ance is considered #or' time and is not included in t e four) our limitation specified abo!e* E9,*0+-/0+ - e A6OA Personnel Rules re(uire t at t e a%ency ead respond to a %rie!ant not later t an <D #or'in% days after receipt of t e %rie!ance at t e first step* 7it in t e <D #or'in% days re(uirement$ t e time at any step may be e:tended by t e a%ency ead #it concurrence of t e %rie!ant* If at any step t e response is not made #it in t e prescribed time and no e:tension as been a%reed upon$ t e employee may submit to t e ne:t step* M'05',/() O('3 D-+.%++-/0 In accordance #it Personnel Rule R8)>)ID8*A*2$ t e employee is REF.IRE6 to a!e an oral discussion #it t e immediate super!isor prior to initiatin% a formal
%rie!ance* - e employee must clearly state to t e super!isor t e employee=s intentions of filin% a formal %rie!ance$ t e issues in!ol!ed$ and t e re(uested resolution* - e purpose of t e meetin% is for bot parties to e:plore t e issues and t e re(uested resolution* If t e employee fails to ta'e t is step$ t e %rie!ance 7ILL NObe accepted t rou% t e formal %rie!ance procedure* It is t e employee=s responsibility to remember t at t e Step I %rie!ance must be submitted #it in 2D #or'in% days after t e occurrence of t e action bein% %rie!ed$ and t at t ese 2D days are not e:tended by t e date on # ic t e oral discussion ta'es place* - e employee may select a representati!e at any step after t e oral discussion #it t e super!isor* P(/.*5%(*+ 7 en an employee #ants to submit a basic %rie!ance$ t e employee must1 .se t e appropriate form9 state t e problem and outline all of t e specific facts$ circumstances and issues in!ol!ed9 pro!ide all t e appropriate documentation to support t e alle%ations9 state t e specific resolution # ic is sou% t9 of a Personnel Rule !iolation is alle%ed$ t e specific rule alle%ed to a!e been !iolated must be stated as #ell as an e:planation of o# t e rule #as !iolated9 and$ t e employee must si%n t e %rie!ance at eac step and state # y t e response at t e pre!ious le!el #as not satisfactory* - e employee must also meet t e mandatory oral discussion re(uirement prior to submittin% t e complaint and ad ere to t e re(uired time limitation for submittin% a %rie!ance* S,*2 I - e Step I respondin% aut ority is t e employee=s immediate super!isor* - e time limit for submittin% t e %rie!ance is 2D #or'in% days from t e date of t e action bein% %rie!ed* If a suspension is bein% %rie!ed$ t e date of t e action is considered to be t e first day of t e suspension* - e date t e action occurred is not counted # en determinin%
3!:$Y
ARE
DISCIPLINARY
AND
GRIEVANCE
PROCEDURES
NECESSARY;
6isciplinary and %rie!ance procedures pro!ide a clear and transparent frame#or' to deal #it difficulties # ic may arise as part of t eir #or'in% relations ip from eit er t e employer=s or employee=s perspecti!e* - ey are necessary to ensure t at e!erybody is treated in t e same #ay in similar circumstances$ to ensure issues are dealt #it fairly and reasonably and t at t ey are compliant #it current le%islation* 6isciplinary procedures are needed1 So employees 'no# # at is e:pected of t em in terms of standards of performance or conduct ?and t e li'ely conse(uences of continued failure to meet t ese standards3* -o identify obstacles to indi!iduals ac ie!in% t e re(uired standards ?e*%* trainin% needs$ lac' of clarity of &ob re(uirements$ additional support needed3 and ta'e appropriate action* As an opportunity to a%ree suitable %oals and timescales for impro!ement in an indi!idual=s performance or conduct* As a point of reference for an employment tribunal s ould someone ma'e a complaint about t e #ay t ey a!e been dismissed G(-*8'0.* 2(/.*5%(*+ '(* 0**5*5# -o pro!ide indi!iduals #it a course of action s ould t ey a!e a complaint ?# ic t ey are unable to resol!e t rou% re%ular communication #it t eir line mana%er3* -o pro!ide points of contact and timescales to resol!e issues of concern* T7* 3*<'3 2/+-,-/0 Most of t e pro!isions %o!ernin% discipline and %rie!ances at #or' are to be found in t e Employment Act 8DD8 and t e detailed re%ulations made to implement t e pro!isions of t at Act namely t e Employment Act 8DD8 ?6ispute Resolution3 Re%ulations Some important e:amples include t e1 Employment Ri% ts Act 2JJC as amended Employment Ri% ts 6ispute Resolution Act 2JJK 8DD< ?SI8DD<BI>83* Numerous ot er pieces of le%islation cross refer to discipline and %rie!ance issues*
Employment Relations Act 2JJJ* - e statutory disciplinary$ dismissal and %rie!ance procedures From 2 October 8DD<$ t e Employment Act 8DD8 made it a le%al re(uirement for all or%ani0ations to follo# minimum disciplinary$ dismissal and %rie!ance procedures in certain circumstances* - ese statutory procedures amount to a minimum standard t at must be follo#ed by all employers and employees*
T7* M'-0 F*',%(*+ O6 T7* P(/.*5%(*+ A(*# - ree step statutory disciplinary$ dismissal and %rie!ance procedures # ic must be follo#ed in most cases failure to follo# t e statutory procedures by t e employer prior to dismissal #ill render t at dismissal automatically unfair employers #ill pay a potential increase in compensation of bet#een 2D)>DL if t e procedures are not follo#ed by t e employer an employee may be pre!ented from presentin% some types of claim in t e employment tribunal if t ey a!e not follo#ed t e %rie!ance procedure first t e procedures are non)contractual until furt er notification by t e 6epartment of -rade and Industry unless an or%ani0ation c ooses to incorporate t e statutory minimum into t eir o#n contractual procedures* T7*(* '(* ,=/ +*,+ /6 2(/.*5%(*+# standard$ and modified* It is en!isa%ed t at t e standard procedure #ill be used in all but t e most e:ceptional circumstances* - ese procedures apply in a #ide ran%e of circumstances # ic are not limited to issues relatin% to t e capability or conduct of t e employee but$ for e:ample$ to dismissals # ic occur on t e e:piry of a fi:ed)term contract and in a smaller scale redundancies* - ere are some e:emptions to t e statutory procedures$ for e:ample if one party reasonably belie!es t ere is a si%nificant t reat$ arassment or it is not practical to %o t rou% t e procedures for reasons beyond t eir control$ or if t ere are issues of national detailed %uidance for employers* security* CIP6 endorses t is Code* - e ACAS Code of Practice Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures2 pro!ides CIP6 members can find out more on t e le%al aspects of t is topic from our FAF on in t e Employment La# at 7or' area of our #ebsite*
-op of Form G(-*8'0.* 2/3-.) '05 2('.,-.* It is essential t at %rie!ances from employees are treated in t e same fair manner* Failure to address %rie!ances lea!es employees #it Gresidual an%er" and can lead to %eneral unrest and disputes in t e #or'place* Employees must 'no# to # om t ey can turn in t e e!ent of a %rie!ance and t e support$ suc as counselin% or sources of ad!ice$ t at is a!ailable to t em* All line and senior mana%ers must be familiar #it t eir or%ani0ation"s %rie!ance procedure* - ere are a number of additional factors to bear in mind # en dealin% #it %rie!ances concernin% arassment* For furt er details see our fact s eet on $'053-0< <(-*8'0.*+ -06/(&'33) Indi!iduals s ould be encoura%ed to discuss ordinary$ day)to)day issues informally #it t eir line mana%er* - is elps concerns to be eard and responded to as soon as possible* 7 ere t is as been unsuccessful$ or circumstances ma'e t is route inappropriate for t e indi!idual$ t en matters s ould raised formally t rou% t e %rie!ance procedure* $'053-0< <(-*8'0.*+ 6/(&'33) Employees s ould also be a#are of t e formal route open to t em$ includin%1 t e t ree sta%es of t e statutory procedure and any furt er elements of t e or%ani0ation"s additional procedures #it # om to raise t e complaint and appropriate sources of support timescales #it in # ic t e or%ani0ation #ill see' to deal #it t e complaint details of t e sta%es of t e %rie!ance procedure e*%* o# a complaint may be raised #it t e ne:t le!el of mana%ement if a satisfactory resolution is not reac ed* An employee s ould be %i!en t e ri% t to be accompanied to %rie!ance earin%s by a collea%ue or trade union representati!e as e:plained abo!e* As in disciplinary matters$ record 'eepin% is important
4!GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE
PROCEDURES#
T$E
STANDARD
T$REE1STEP
Aour employer"s %rie!ance procedure may a!e more t an t ree steps$ but it must include t e follo#in%* 1. :(-,,*0 +,',*&*0, Aou must set out your %rie!ance in #ritin% ?often called a Gstep one letter"3* Aour employer"s %rie!ance procedure s ould say # o to send your letter to* If t at"s t e person causin% t e problem$ or if t ey"!e i%nored pre!ious complaints$ send it to t e 5R department or to t e person"s boss* 2. M**,-0<# Aour %rie!ance s ould be loo'ed into in a fair and unbiased #ay* Aour employer s ould in!ite you to a meetin% ?sometimes called a earin%3 to discuss t e problem$ and you s ould attend if you can* If t ere is someone else in!ol!ed$ t ey mi% t also be t ere ?but you s ould tell your employer if you are uncomfortable #it t is3*- e meetin% s ould be at a con!enient time for you and anyone else in!ol!ed* If you t in' you"!e not ad enou% time to prepare$ as' for more time* If your employer doesn"t a%ree ?and t ey don"t a!e to3$ you s ould %o to t e earin%$ but ma'e sure t at your lac' of preparation time is noted* Gat er your t ou% ts before t e meetin%* 6on"t be afraid to #rite do#n # at it is you #ant to say* - ere is not in% #ron% #it readin% t is out at t e meetin%* It is up to your employer # at format t e meetin% ta'es but t ey #ill normally %o t rou% t e issues t at a!e been raised and %i!e you t e opportunity to comment* - e main purpose of t e meetin% s ould be to try to establis t e facts and find a #ay to resol!e t e problem* - e Ad!isory$ Conciliation and Arbitration Ser!ice ?Aces3 a!e a code of practice # ic sets out o# your employer s ould carry out a %rie!ance procedure* If you as' your employer before and$ you a!e a le%al ri% t to ta'e a Gcompanion" ?# o is a collea%ue or trade union representati!e3 to t e meetin% #it you* If no collea%ue is #illin% to accompany you$ and you"re not a union member$ as' if you can brin% a family member or a Citi0en"s Ad!ice 4ureau #or'er ?but your employer does not a!e to a%ree to t is3* - e companion can present andBor sum up your case$ tal' on your be alf and confer #it you durin% t e earin%* - ey"re protected from unfair dismissal or ot er mistreatment for supportin% you* - e meetin% must be at a con!enient time for your companion* Aou can as' for a postponement of up to fi!e days if necessary to %et
your c osen companion t ere* Aou s ould be %i!en notes of t e meetin%$ and copies of any information %i!en by ot er people* .nless t ey need to in!esti%ate furt er$ your employer s ould tell you reasonably (uic'ly # at"s been decided$ and about your ri% t to appeal if you"re not satisfied* Aou mi% t be told of t e outcome !erbally at first but it #ill usually be confirmed in #ritin%* 3. A22*'3 &**,-0<# If you"re not satisfied #it t e decision$ or you t in' t e procedure follo#ed #as seriously fla#ed$ you a!e t e ri% t to an appeal* - is is usually eard by a i% er le!el of mana%ement* If t at isn"t possible$ your employer could as' an Aces mediator or ot er independent person to ear it* - e appeal earin% is similar to t e ori%inal meetin%$ and you a!e a ri% t to a companion$ as before* Aour employer s ould %i!e you enou% time to appeal* If t ey don"t$ ma'e your appeal any#ay$ and say t at you"ll pro!ide more information later* If you are considerin% ta'in% your issue to an Employment -ribunal you may #ant to appeal e!en if it seems pointless$ because a tribunal a#ard could be reduced if you don"t* If you can"t sort out t e dispute$ you can %et employer a%rees to it* elp t rou% mediation$ conciliation or arbitration$ if your
DISCIPLINE
1!INTRODUCTION# 6iscipline is re(uired for bot t e or%ani0ation and t e indi!idual* In t e
or%ani0ation it is needed to re%ulate t e be a!ior of people$ maintain peace and c annel t eir efforts to#ards or%ani0ational %oal* Sad to sate$ most people do not e:ercise self discipline and t is fact ma'es e:ternal control necessary for brinin% order #it in an or%ani0ation* CONCEPT
6iscipline is not a %lamorous term* It is !ie#ed #it fear and suspicion in or%ani0ation* - e multiple e:planation ad!anced by different e:pert in t e filed a!e only added to t e pre!ailin% confusion*
NEGAIVE DISCIPLINE -raditionally$ discipline is interpreted as a sort of c ec' or restraint on t e freedom of person* 6iscipline is used to t e act of imposin% penalties for #ron% be a!ior* If employees fail to obser!e rules$ t ey are punis ed* +6iscipline is t e force t at prompts an indi!idual or a %roup to obser!e t e rules$ re%ulations and procedures # ic are deemed to be necessary to t e attainment of an ob&ecti!e$, POSITIVE DISCIPLINE Employees comply #it rules not out fear of punis ment but out of an in erent desire to cooperate and ac ie!e %oals* 7 ere t e or%ani0ational climate is mar'et by t#o)#ay communication$ clear %oals$ effecti!e leaders ip$ ade(uate compensation employees need not be discipline in t e traditional #ay* Positi!e discipline$ accordin% to Sprie%el enables an employee$ +to a!e a %reater freedom in t at e en&oys a %reater de%ree of self)e:pression in stri!in% to ac ie!e t e ob&ecti!e$ # ic identifies as is o#n*, e
2!DIFFEREANCE BET:EEN POSITIVE > NEGATIVE DISCIPLINE # P/-0, C/0.*2, N*<',-8* D-+.-23-0* P/+-,-8* D-+.-23-0* is t e creation climate confirm of in to a an t e
C/063-.,
Employees do not percepti!e - ere is no conflict bet#een t e corporate %oals as t ere indi!idual and or%ani0ational
o#n* %oals* S%2*(8-+-/0 Re(uire intense super!isory Employees from %oin% off t e trac'* ob&ect i!ies*
e:ercise
self)
3!SELF DISCIPLINE AND CONTROL# 4e a!ioral scientist !ie# discipline as a self) control to meet or%ani0ational ob&ecti!es* Me%%inson clarified t e term t us* +4y self) discipline e mans t e trainin% t at correct$ moulds and stren%t ens* It refers to one"s efforts at self control to certain needs and demands* - is form of discipline is raised on to psyc olo%ical principles* First$ punis ment seldom produce t e desired result* Often$ it produce undesirable result* Second$ a self) respectin% person tends to be a better #or'er t an one # o is not*,
4!PROGRESSIVE DISCIPLINE# - e concept o pro%ressi!e discipline states t at penalties must be appropriate to t e !iolation* If inappropriate be a!iour is minor in nature and as not pre!iously occurred an oral may be sufficient* If t e !iolation re(uires a #ritten #arnin%$ it must be done accordin% to a procedure* After #ritten #arnin%s$ if t e conduct of t e employees is still not alon% desired lines$ serious puniti!e steps could be initiated* In case of ma&or !iolations suc as ittin% a super!isor may &ustify t e termination of an employee immdiately* In order to assist a mana%er to reco%ni0e t e proper le!el of disciplinary action$ some firms a!e formali0ed t e procedure* 5!T$E RED $OT STOVE RULE#
7it out t e continual support of t e subordinate$ no mana%er can %et t in%s done* 4ut disciplinary action a%ainst a delin(uent employee is painful and %enerates resentment on is part* Accordin% to t e Red 5ot Sto!e rule disciplinary action s ould a!e follo#in% conse(uences1 A? B%(0+ -&&*5-',*3)# If disciplinary action is to be ta'en$ it must occur immediately so t e indi!idual #ill understand t e reason for it* 7it t e passa%e of time$ people a!e tendency to con!ince t emsel!es t at t ey are not fault* B? 2(/8-5*+ ='(0-0<# It is !ery important to pro!ide ad!ance #arnin% t at punis ment #ill follo# unacceptable be a!iour* As you mo!e closer to ot sto!e you are #arned by its eat t at #ill be burned* C? B%(0+ -&2*(+/0'33)# 6isciplinary action s ould be impersonal* - ere are no fa!orites # en t is approac is follo#ed* 6!@USTICAL APPROC$ TO DISCIPLINE# - e Industrial Employment Act #as passed in 2J<C #it a !ie# to impro!e t e industrial relation climate* - e Act re(uires t at all establis ment must define t e ser!ice rules and prepare standin% order* - e term Standin% order refers to t e rules and re%ulation # ic %o!erns t e condition of employment of #or'ers* - ey indicate duties and responsibility on t e part of bot t e employer and t e employees* - e standin% order contains rules relatin% to classification of employees$ #or'in% ours$ olidays$ s ift #or'in%$ attendance$ lea!e$ suspension$ stoppa%e of #or'$ redreassal of t ese terms and condition may lead to misconduct or indciplpine* 7!DISCIPLINARY ACTION# - ou% t ere is no ri%id and specific procedure for ta'in% disciplinary action$ t e disciplinary procedure follo#ed in Indian industries usually consist of t e follo#in% steps1 a* I++%-0< ,7* 3*,,*( /6 .7'(<*: 7 en a employee commits an act of misconduct t at re(uired disciplinary action$ t e employee concerned s ould be issue a c ar%e
s eet* C ar%es of misconduct or indiscipline s ould be clearly and precisely stated in t e c ar%e s eet* b* C/0+-5*(',-/0 /6 *923'0',-/01 On %ettin% t e ans#er for t e letter of c ar%e ser!ed$ t e e:planation furnis ed be consider and if it is a satisfactory$ no disciplinary action need be ta'en* On t e contrary # en t e mana%ement is not satisfied #it t e employees e:planation t ere is a need for ser!in% a s o#)cause notice* c* S7/=1.'%+* 0/,-.*1 S o#)cause notice is issued by t e mana%er # en e belie!es t at t ere is a sufficient prima facie e!idence of employees misconduct* En(uiry s ould also initiated by first ser!in% im a notice of en(uiry indicatin% clearly t e name of en(uirin% officer$ time$ date and place of en(uiry etc* d* $/35-0< /6 ' 6%33 63*5<* *0A%-() 1 - ese must be in conformity #it t e principle of natural &ustice$ t at is t e employee concerned must be %i!en an opportunity$ of bein% eard* 7 en t e process of en(uiry is o!er an findin%s of t e same are record$ t e en(uiry officer s ould su%%est t e nature of disciplinary action*
8!DISCIPLINARY POLICY AND PRACTICE#1 U+-0< ,7* 5-+.-23-0'() 2(/.*++ - ere are t#o main areas # ere t e disciplinary system is used1 capabilityBperformance and conduct* C'2'4-3-,)"2*(6/(&'0.* It is ine!itable t at at some sta%e all employers #ill encounter difficulties #it t e performance of t eir employees in t e #or'place ?t ese can stem from difficulties on t e part of t e or%ani0ation suc as insufficient trainin% and support$ or a lac' of leaders ip or inappropriate systems of #or'$ as #ell as t e indi!idual # o is stru%%lin% to fulfill t eir responsibilities3* It is %ood practice and also more efficient
t at suc issues are addressed informally$ as and # en t ey arise$ by mana%ers !ia discussions # ic clarify =# at %ood performance loo's li'e=$ %oal settin%$ support and timely positi!e feedbac' # ere appropriate* Only # en t ese options a!e been e: austed and # ere t ere is no alternati!e s ould mana%ers s ould enter a more formal disciplinary procedure* Situations # ere an indi!idual is unable to do t eir &ob because of ill) ealt also fall into t is cate%ory* In t ese instances an employee s ould be dealt #it sympat etically and offered support* 5o#e!er$ unacceptable le!els of absence could still result in t e employer ma'in% use of #arnin%s* C/05%., Employee misconduct could ran%e from continued lateness$ failure to follo# a reasonable mana%ement instruction$ abuse of t e or%ani0ation"s computer system or Internet access$ bullyin% be a!iour or creatin% a ostile #or' en!ironment$ t rou% to t eft$ fi% tin% and committin% criminal offences* - e more %ra!e offences may constitute %ross misconduct* In all cases$ e!en %ross misconduct$ an employer s ould attempt to follo# t e statutory procedures* Sta%es of t e process If disciplinary action is to be ta'en$ it s ould al#ays a!e t ree main sta%es1 1B L*,,*( 2B M**,-0< 3B A22*'3. - ere must al#ays be a full and fair in!esti%ation to determine t e facts and to decide if furt er action is necessary* R*./(51C**2-0< All records s ould be 'ept meticulously$ as t is #ill be !ital s ould a case be perused at an employment tribunal* Since t e burden of proof is on t e employer to s o# t at t e dismissal is not unfair or unreasonable$ 'eepin% records is !ital* -ype of records t at s ould be 'ept by employers is minutes of meetin%s$ attendance$ notes of telep one calls$ copies of correspondence etc*
$'05-0< 5-+.-23-0'() -0,*(8-*=+ All line mana%ers s ould be trained and supported so t at t ey are able to carry out disciplinary meetin%s #it t eir team* - e 5R department s ould be able to assist t em by pro!idin% a source of independent ad!ice on preparin% for and conductin% t e inter!ie#$ as #ell as s arin% 'no#led%e about similar cases in t e or%ani0ation and rele!ant le%islation* - e 'ey points to consider are1 Ensure you t e meetin%* Ma'e sure t e employee 'no#s from t e letter in!itin% t em to t e meetin% # y t ey a!e been as'ed to attend and t at t ey a!e a ri% t to a!e a companion present* Ma'e sure t e indi!idual as reasonable notice$ ideally more t an <K ours9 so t at t ey elp. C/05%., ,7* -0,*(8-*=. Ne!er pre)&ud%e t e outcome of t e inter!ie# before earin% t e employee=s perspecti!e* Start t e inter!ie# by statin% t e complaint to t e employee and %i!in% appropriate statements from people in!ol!ed* Gi!e t e employee ample opportunity to put for#ard t eir side of t e story and call any supportin% #itnesses* Aou can also call #itnesses$ but t ey can only be in t e room for t e rele!ant part of t e inter!ie# ) not t e duration* Ma'e use of ad&ournments1 al#ays ta'e a brea' to consider and obtain any e:tra information you need before reac in% your decision* Aou can also use if t in%s become eated or people are upset durin% t e inter!ie#* a!e a c ance to arran%e an appropriate representati!e if t ey #is * Ma'e sure anot er member of mana%ement can be t ere to ta'e detailed notes and a!e in!esti%ated all t e facts in ad!ance ?includin% consultin% t e
indi!idual=s personal file for rele!ant information3 and plan o# you #ill approac
6eli!er t e decision ?and %i!e reasons$ ta'in% into account any miti%atin% circumstances3$ confirm re!ie# periods and ensure you %i!e details of o# to appeal* Confirm t e decision in #ritin%* It is important t at e!eryone in!ol!ed in disciplinary action understand t e importance of follo#in% t e correct procedure$ as e!en if t e case a%ainst an employee seems pro!en$ t ey can still be deemed to a!e been treated unfairly if t e correct procedures are not follo#ed* An indi!idual is entitled to be accompanied by a #or' collea%ue or trade union official at formal disciplinary and %rie!ance inter!ie#s$ and to select a companion of t eir c oice* It #ould be %ood practice for an employer also to offer t is at any purely in!esti%atory meetin%* N/ '.,-/0 After t e meetin%$ t e employer may decide t at no action is necessary* For e:ample$ if an employee #as unclear about # at #as e:pected from t em and t ey a%ree to try to resol!e t e issue !ia additional support or counselin%* :'(0-0<+ Alternati!ely$ t e employer may decide to %i!e t e employee a #arnin%* An or%ani0ation"s policy s ould outline e:actly # at #arnin%s #ill be %i!en$ but t e follo#in% are li'ely1 R*./(5*5 /('3 ='(0-0< F-(+, =(-,,*0 ='(0-0< F-0'3 =(-,,*0 ='(0-0<. Clearly t ese sta%es represent an increase in seriousness* 7it process* .ltimately$ failure to reac dismissal* Any #arnin% s ould also specify a re!ie# period durin% # ic t e indi!idual recei!es appropriate support and t eir performance can be monitored* t e e:ception of e:treme e:amples of misconduct$ it #ould be inappropriate to =s'ip sta%es= in t e t e or%ani0ation"s standards may result in
6isciplinary #arnin%s s ould normally a!e a specified =life= after # ic t ey are disre%arded # en considerin% any subse(uent #arnin%s* -ypical timescales for t e types of #arnin% are1 (*./(5*5 /('3 ='(0-0< 1 6 &/0,7+ 6-(+, =(-,,*0 ='(0-0< 1 1 )*'( 6-0'3 =(-,,*0 ='(0-0< 1 2 )*'(+* 7 ere misconduct as been !ery serious$ it may be appropriate for t e #arnin% to continue to be re%arded indefinitely*
RECURITMENT
Recruitment means to estimate t e a!ailable !acancies and to ma'e suitable arran%ements for t eir selection and appointment* Recruitment refers to +6isco!erin% potential applicants for actual or anticipated or%ani0ational !acancies* Recruitment is a process +-o disco!er t e source of manpo#er to meet t e re(uirements of staffin%$ to employ effecti!e measures for attractin% potential manpo#er in ade(uate number,* Recruitment is t e process of identifyin% t e sources for prospecti!e candidates and to stimulate t em to apply for t e &ob* It"s lin'in% acti!ity brin%in% to%et er t ose #it &obs and t ose see'in% &obs* It locates t e source of manpo#er to meet t e re(uirements and &ob specifications* In recruitment process a!ailable !acancies are %i!en #ide publicity and suitable candidates are encoura%ed to submit application so as to a!e a pool of eli%ible candidates for scientific selection*
In recruitment$ information is collected from interested candidates* For t ese different sources of recruitment suc as ne#spaper ad!ertisement$ employment e:c an%e$ internal promotions$ etc* are used* In t e recruitment$ a pool of eli%ible and interested candidates is created for t e selection of most suitable candidate* Recruitment represents t e first contact t at a company ma'es #it potential employees* Recruitment is a positi!e function in # ic publicity is %i!en to t e &obs a!ailable in t e or%ani0ation and interested candidates ?(ualified &ob applicants3 are encoura%ed to submit applications for t e purpose of selection*
DEFINITION OF RECREUITMENT
Accordin% to Ed#in Flippo$ +Recruitment is t e process of searc in% for prospecti!e employees and stimulatin% t em to apply for &obs in t e or%ani0ation*
OBJECTIVES OF RECRUITMENT
- e ob&ecti!es of recruitment are as follo#s1 ?i3 ?ii3 ?iii3 ?i!3 ?!3 ?!i3 -o attract people #it multi)dimensional s'ills and e:periences t at suit t e present and future or%ani0ational strate%ies$ -o induct outsider #it a ne# perspecti!e to lead t e company$ -o infuse fres blood at all le!els of t e or%ani0ation$ -o de!elop an or%ani0ational culture t at attracts competent people to t e company$ -o searc or ead untB ead pouc people # ose s'ills fit t e company"s !alues$ -o searc for talents %lobally and not &ust #it in t e company*
PURPOSE OF RECRUITMENT
Recruitment as t ree ma&or purposes1 23 to increase t e pool of &ob applicants #it minimum cost* 83 -o meet t e or%ani0ation"s le%al and social obli%ations re%ardin% t e demo%rap ic composition of its #or'force*
;3 -o elp increase t e success rte of t e selection process by reducin% t e percenta%e of applicants # o are eit er poorly (ualified or a!e t e #ron% s'ills*
SOURCES OF RECRUITMENT
- e sources of recruitment may be %rouped into1
I0,*(0'3 +/%(.*+
E9,*(0'3 +/%(.*+ INTERNAL SOURCES# As t e term implies internal source of recruitment is for t ose # o are currently members or t e or%ani0ation* 7 ene!er any !acancy arises$ somebody from #it in t e or%ani0ation may be loo'ed into$ follo#in% are t e internal sources of recruitment* 1! P(/&/,-/0+# 1 In order to moti!ate t e e:istin% employees$ mana%ement follo#s t e policy of internal promotions* Promotion means s iftin% of an employee to a i% er position carryin% i% er responsibilities$ facilities$ status and salaries* Marious positions in t e or%ani0ation are usually filled up by promotions of e:istin% employees on t e basis of merit or seniority or a combination of bot * 2! T('0+6*(+# ) -ransfer refers to a c an%e in &ob assi%nment* It may in!ol!e a promotion or demotion$ or no c an%e in terms of responsibility or status* A transfer may be eit er temporary or permanent$ dependin% t e necessity of fillin% &obs* E*%* transfer from ead office to branc office*
3! R*,-(*&*0,+# 1 At times$ mana%ement may not find suitable candidate in place of t e one # o ad retired$ after meritorious ser!ice* .nder t is circumstances mana%ement may decide to call retired mana%er #it ne# e:tension* 4! R*.'33+# 1 7 en mana%ement faces a problem$ # ic can be sol!ed only by a mana%er # o as proceeded on lon% lea!e$ it may be decided to recall t at person* After t e problem is sol!ed$ is lea!e may be e:tended* 5! F/(&*( *&23/)**+# 1 Indi!iduals # o left for some ot er &ob$ mi% t be #illin% to come bac' for i% er #a%es incenti!es* An ad!anta%e #it t ese sources is t at t e performance of t e personBemployee is already 'no#n*
EDTERNAL SOURCES
As t e term implies t e e:ternal source of recruitment is of potential #or'ers # o are not currently member of t e or%ani0ation* It usually includes ne# entrants to t e labour force t e unemployed and people employed in t e ot er or%ani0ation see'in% t e c an%e* Company mana%ements a!e to use eternal sources for t e recruitment of super!isory staff and mana%ers as and # en necessary* - is may be #it a !ie# to introducin% t e Gne# blood" in t e or%ani0ation* E:ternal recruitment is one #ay of brin%in% into t e or%ani0ation t at as ne# s'ills or abilities and different #ay of approac in% &ob tas'* Follo#in% are t e most common e:ternal source of mana%erial recruitment* 1! N*=+2'2*( A58*(,-+*&*0,#1Ne#spaper ad!ertisements are o!er# elmin%ly popular source of recruitment* A messa%e containin% %eneral information about t e &ob and t e or%ani0ation is placed in !arious ne#spapers* Ne#spaper ad!ertisin% typically %enerates a lar%e applicant flo#* - ou% costly$ it pro!ides #ide c oice as it attracts a lar%e number of suitable candidates from all o!er t e country* - e best e:ample for ne#spaper ad!ertisement is t e -imes of India"s Asscent supplement # ic comes on e!ery 7ednesday and contains bot domestic as #ell as international &obs* 2! C'&2%+ R*.(%-,&*0,# 1 Colle%e Campuses are anot er !ery popular recruitment source* - e %ro#t of Mana%ement institutes$ IIts and Re%ional En%ineerin% Colle%es as pro!ided a popular source of recruitment* Pri!ate sector is able to attract many aspirants* It is an e:cellent source of recruitin%
mana%ement trainees* - e promisin% students %et &ob security immediately after securin% de%rees due to suc campus inter!ie#sBrecruitment* 3) R*.(%-,&*0, ,7(/%<7 -0,*(0*,# 1 - e Internet as (uic'ly become a !ery popular source of employment ad!ertisin%* - is source is (uic'ly %ro#in% in popularity* Currently employers can post t eir openin%s to any of se!eral ne#s%roups for free* Most employment ad!ertisement firms can also post t e &obs on t e Internet9 o#e!er$ t ey c ar%e a fee* A lar%e and fast %ro#in% proportion of employers use t e internet as a recruitment tool* More and more or%ani0ations are placin% information about open positions on t e 7orld 7ide #eb* - ere are many #eb sites t rou% # ic recruitment ta'es place* Some of t e e:amples are ###*nau'ri*com$ ###*monster*com$ etc* 4! @/4 F'-(+# 1 /ob fairs are !ery effecti!e* A &ob fair is an e!ent sponsored by a H&ob fairH company # o c ar%es a fee to participatin% employers* - e H&ob fairH company #ill typically ad!ertise in local media to attract (ualified applicants* 5irin% mana%ers can meet multiple candidates and conduct on)t e) spot inter!ie#s* 4ecause t e applicants may be inter!ie#in% #it multiple employers$ it is imperati!e to respond (uic'ly #it in!itations for in)plant inter!ie#s of (ualified candidates* If a &ob fair results in &ust one ire it is usually cost effecti!e* 5! E&23/)&*0, A<*0.-*+# 1 - e firm contacts an or%ani0ation # ose main purpose is locate &ob see'ers* - e company pro!ides t e a%ency #it information about t e &ob$ # ic t e a%ency t en passes alon% to its clients* Clients may be eit er employed or unemployed* A%encies can eit er be public or pri!ate* Fees may be c ar%ed to eit er or bot t e client see'in% a &ob and t e company see'in% applicants* 6! :'3C1-0+ :(-,*1-0+ '05 T'3C -0+#1 - e most economical approac for recruitment of candidates is direct applications* - e &ob see'ers submit applications or resumes directly to t e employer* - e ad!ertisement mentions date$ day and timin% durin% # ic t e applicant can G#al' in" for an inter!ie#* 7rite)ins are t ose # o send #ritten in(uiries* - ese applicants a ra'ed to complete application forms for furt er processin%* -al')ins is no# becomin% popular and t e applicants are re(uired to meet t e employer for detailed tal's* - e applicant is not re(uired to submit any applications*
23 Entry of youn% blood in t e or%ani0ation is possible* 83 7ide scope is a!ailable for selection* - is facilitates selection of people #it ric and !aried e:perience* ;3 Selection can be made in an impartial manner as lar%e number of (ualified and interested candidates are a!ailable* <3 Scope for eartburn and &ealousy can be a!oided by recruitin% from outside* >3 - e mana%ement can fulfill reser!ation re(uirements in fa!our of t e disad!anta%ed section of e society*
DISADVANTAGES RECRUITMENT
OF
EDTERNAL
SOURCE
OF
23 E:ternal recruitment leads to labour turno!er particularly of s'illed$ e:perienced and ambitious employees* 83 - e relations bet#een employer and employee deteriorate leadin% to industrial disputes and stri'es* ;3 - e present employees may lose t eir sense of security* - eir loyalty to t e or%ani0ation may be ad!ersely affected* <3 Employees feel frustrated due to e:ternal recruitment and t eir morale is ad!ersely affected*
SELECTION
Selection is one of t e most important of all functions in t e mana%ement of personnel* Selection is more closely related to recruitment because bot are concerned #it processin% indi!iduals to place t em in a &ob* Selection is ne:t to recruitment* After identifyin% t e sources of uman resources$ searc in% for prospecti!e employees and stimulatin% t em to apply for &obs in an or%ani0ation$ t e mana%ement as to perform t e function of selectin% t e ri% t employees at t e ri% t time* +Ri% t man at t e ri% t &ob, is t e basic principle in selection* Selection is t e process of collectin% and e!aluatin% information about an indi!idual in order to e:tend an offer of employment* It is t e process of lo%ically c oosin% indi!iduals # o posses t e necessary s'ills$ abilities and personality to successfully fill specific &obs in t e or%ani0ation* Selection means a process by # ic t e (ualified personnel can be c oosen from t e applicants # o a!e offered t eir ser!ices to t e or%ani0ation for employment* - us selection process is ne%ati!e function because it attempt to eliminate applicants$ lea!in% t e best to be selected* In t e #ords of 6ale Aode!$ +Selection is t e process in # ic candidates for employment are di!ided into t#o classes N t ose # o are to be offered employment and t ose # o are not,* In s ort$ selection is t e process of c oosin% a person suitable for t e &ob out of se!eral persons* - e ob&ecti!e of t e selection decision is to c ose t e indi!idual # o can most successfully perform t e &ob from t e pool of (ualified candidates* - e selection procedures are t e system of functions and de!ices adopted in a %i!en company to ascertain # et er t e candidate"s specification is matc ed #it effecti!e until and unless1 23 Re(uirements of t e &ob to be filled$ a!e been clearly specified ?&ob analysis$ etc3 83 Employee specifications ?p ysical$ mental$ social$ and be a!ioral$ etc3 a!e been clearly specified* ;3 Candidates for screenin% a!e been attracted* - us$ t e de!elopment of &ob analyses$ uman resource plannin% and recruitment are necessary prere(uisites to t e selection process* - e brea'do#n in any of t ese processes can ma'e e!en t e best selection system ineffecti!e* t e &ob specification and re(uirements or not* - e selection procedures cannot be
IMPORTANCE OF SELECTION
- e importance of selection may be &ud%ed from t e follo#in% facts1) 1! P(/.%(*&*0, /6 E%'3-6-*5 '05 SC-33*5 :/(C*(+# 1 Scientific selection facilitates t e procurement of #ell (ualified and s'illed #or'ers in t e or%ani0ation* It is in t e interest of t e or%ani0ation in order to maintain t e supremacy o!er t e ot er competiti!e firms* Selection of s'illed personnel reduces t e labour cost and increases t e production* Selection of s'illed personnel also facilitates t e e:pansion in t e si0e of t e business* 2! R*5%.* C/+, /6 T('-0-0< '05 D*8*3/2&*0,# ) Proper selection of candidates reduces t e cost of trainin% because (ualified personnel a!e better %raspin% po#er* - ey can understand t e tec ni(ue of #or' better and in less time* Furt er$ t e or%ani0ation can de!elop different trainin% pro%rammes for different persons on t e basis of t eir indi!idual differences$ t us reducin% t e time and cost of trainin% considerably* 3! A4+*0.* /6 P*(+/00*3 P(/43*&+# ) Proper selection of personnel reduces personnel problems in t e or%ani0ation* Many problems li'e labour turno!er$ absenteeism and monotony s all not be e:perienced in t eir se!erity in t e or%ani0ation* Labour relation #ill be better because #or'ers #ill be fully satisfied by t e #or'* S'illed #or'ers elp t e mana%ement to e:pand t e business and to earn more profits and in turn mana%ement compensates$ t e #or'ers #it i% #a%es$ benefits etc*
SELECTION PROCEDURE
Selection procedure employs se!eral met ods of collectin% information about t e candidate"s (ualification$ e:perience$ p ysical and mental ability$ nature and be a!iour$ 'no#led%e$ aptitude and t e li'e for &ud%in% # et er a %i!en applicant is or is not suitable for t e &ob* - erefore$ t e selection procedure is not a sin%le act but
is essentially a series of met ods or sta%es by # ic different types of information can be secured t rou% !arious selection tec ni(ues* At eac step$ facts may come to li% t # ic are useful for comparison #it t e &ob re(uirement and employee specifications* Selection procedure is len%t y and time consumin% particularly in t e case of super!isory post* Follo#in% are t e stepsB procedures of selection1 1! @/4 A0'3)+-+# 1 /ob analysis is t e basis for selectin% t e ri% t candidate* E!ery or%ani0ation s ould finali0e t e &ob analysis$ &ob description$ &ob specification and employee specification before proceedin% to t e ne:t step of selection* 2! A223-.',-/0 F/(&# 1 Application Form is also 'no#n as application blan'* - e tec ni(ue of application blan' is traditional and #idely accepted for securin% information from t e prospecti!e candidates* 7 ere application forms are use$ t e data become a part of t e employee"s record* - e information is %enerally re(uired on t e follo#in% items in t e application forms1 Personal bac'%round information$ Educational information$ 7or' e:periences$ salary$ personal details$ e:pected salary and allo#ances etc* 3! P(*3-&-0'() I0,*(8-*=# ) Preliminary or initial inter!ie# is often eld in case of +at t e %ate, candidate* - is inter!ie# usually of s ort duration and is aimed at obtainin% certain basic information #it a !ie# to identifyin% t e ob!ious misfits or un(ualified* - us preliminary inter!ie# is useful as a process of eliminatin% t e undesirable and unsuitable candidate* If t e candidate seems to possess t e basic minimum re(uirements for efficient &ob performance$ e is %i!en an application form for bein% filled out by im* 4! S.(**0-0< A223-.',-/0 F/(&# 1 Information %i!en in t e application form is used for selection purposes* - e applicant # o seems to be not fit for t e &ob on t e basis of information %i!en in t e application blan' is re&ected out ri% tly at t is sta%e* - e applicants # o a!e not furnis ed t e re(uired information may also be re&ected* Applications #ill not be accepted after t e
close date* After t e close date of t e recruitment$ t e /ob E:pert for t e irin% department and 5uman Resources #ill screen t e application forms for minimum education and (ualification re(uirements* A recruitment date may be e:tended if t ere are no (ualified candidates* Recruitments can also be open until t e position is filled9 in t is situation$ applicants are re!ie#ed and inter!ie#ed on a re%ular basis until an eli%ible candidate can be selected and appointed to t e a!ailable position* 5! :(-,,*0 ,*+,#1 - e or%ani0ation a!e to conduct #ritten e:amination for t e (ualified candidates after t ey are screened on t e basis of t e application blan's so as to measure t e candidate"s ability in arit metical calculations$ to 'no# t e candidate"s attitude to#ards &ob$ to measure t e candidates aptitude$ reasonin%$ 'no#led%e in !arious disciplines$ %eneral 'no#led%e and En%lis lan%ua%e* Intelli%ence test measures t e indi!iduals capacity or reasonin%$ !erbal compre ension$ numbers$ !ocabulary$ #ord fluency etc* aptitude test measures indi!iduals capacity or talent ability to learn a &ob if e is %i!en ade(uate trainin%* 6! F-0'3 -0,*(8-*=-0<# 1 F-0'3 inter!ie# is usually follo#ed by testin%* - is is t e most essential step in t e process of selection* In t is step t e inter!ie#er matc es t e information obtained about t e candidate t rou% !arious means to t e &ob re(uirements and to t e information obtained t rou% is o#n obser!ation durin% t e inter!ie#* - e basic ob&ecti!e of t e inter!ie# is to measure t e applicant a%ainst t e specific re(uirements of t e &ob* Inter!ie# must be conducted in a friendly atmosp ere and t e candidate must be made to feel at ease* - e inter!ie#er s ould not as' un#arranted (uestions # ic ma'e t e candidate ner!ous* It bein% t e t#o #ay communication$ t e inter!ie#ee s ould also be %i!en a c ance to as' (uestions if e so li'es$ about t e &ob and t e or%ani0ation* 7! R*6*(*0.* C7*.C+# 1 After completion of t e final inter!ie#$ t e personnel department #ill en%a%e in c ec'in% references* Candidates are re(uired to %i!e t e name of reference in t eir application forms* - ese references may be from t e indi!iduals # o are familiar #it t e candidate"s academic
ac ie!ement or from t e applicant"s pre!ious employer$ # o is #ell !ersed #it t e applicant"s &ob performance$ and sometime from co)#or'ers* If reference is c ec'ed in t e correct manner$ a %reat deal can be learned about a person t at an inter!ie# or tests cannot elicit* A %ood reference c ec' used sincerely fetc es useful and reliable information to t e or%ani0ation* 8! P7)+-.'3 E9'&-0',-/0# 1 - e candidates # o a!e crossed t e abo!e urdles are re(uired to %o for t e medical e:amination* - is is !ery important because of a person of poor ealt cannot #or' competently and t e in!estment in im may %o #aste* - us$ a t orou% medical e:amination is essential* 9! S*3*.,-/0# 1 If a candidate successfully o!ercomes all t e obstacles or tests %i!en e #ould be declared selected* A appointment letter #ill be %i!en to im mentionin% t e terms of employment$ pay scales$ post on # ic selected etc*
Placement means offerin% of t e &ob to t e finally selected candidate* One t e employee is selected e s ould be placed on a suitable &ob* Accordin% to Pi%ors and Myres$ placement may be defined as +t e determination of t e &ob to # ic an accepted candidate is to be assi%ned$ and is assi%nment to t at &ob* It is matc in% of # at t e super!isor as reason to t in' e can dos #it t e &ob demands?&ob re(uirements39 it is matc in% of # at e imposes?in strain$ #or'in% condition3 and # at offers is t e form of pay roll$ companions ip #it ot er promotional possibilities etc*, A proper placement reduced t e employee turno!er$ absenteeism and accident rate and impro!es t e morale* Placement is not an easy process* It is !ery difficult for a ne# employee # o is (uite un'no#n to t e &ob and en!ironment* For t is reason$ t e employee is %enerally put on a probation period ran%in% from one year to t#o years* At t e end of t e probation period$ if t e employee s o# a %ood performance$ e is confirmed as a re%ular employee of t e or%ani0ation* - us$ t e probation period or trial period is a transition period at t e end of # ic mana%ement as to ta'e decision # et er t e employee s ould be made re%ular or disc ar%ed from t e &ob*
PRINCIPLE OF PLACEMENT
Follo#in% principles are follo#ed at t e time of placement of an employee1 23 - e man s ould be placed on t e &ob accordin% to re(uirements of t e &ob* - e &ob s ould not be ad&usted accordin% to t e (ualifications or re(uirements of t e man* +/ob first$ man ne:t, s ould be t e principle of placement* 83 - e &ob s ould be offered to t e man accordin% to is (ualifications* Neit er i% er$ nor lo#er &ob s ould be offered to t e ne# employee* ;3 - e employee s ould be made con!ersant #it t e conditions pre!ailin% in t e industry and all t in%s relatin% to t e &ob* 5e s ould also be made a#are of t e penalties if e commits a #ron%* <3 7 ile introducin% t e &ob to t e ne# employee$ an effort s ould be mad to de!elop a sense of loyalty and cooperation in im so t at e may reali0e is responsibilities better to#ards t e &ob and t e or%ani0ation*
.ns'illed #or'er N Semi)s'illed #or'er N S'illed #or'er N 5i% ly s'illed #or'er N Assistant foreman N Foreman*
Employees ?of all cate%ories3 #ant to %ro# in t eir careers as t is pro!ides more salary$ i% er status and opportunity to use 'no#led%e$ education and s'ills effecti!ely* An indi!idual #it potentials &oins a firm not for &ob but for career de!elopment* An or%ani0ation as to pro!ide better opportunities to its employees in t eir career de!elopment and also use t eir efficient ser!ices for t e benefit of t e or%ani0ation*
3! -o utili0e a!ailable mana%erial talent #it in t e or%ani0ation fully* 4! -o ac ie!e i% er producti!ity and or%ani0ational de!elopment* 5! -o pro!ide %uidance and assistance to employees to de!elop t eir potentials to t e i% est le!el* 6! -o impro!e employee morale and moti!ation by pro!idin% trainin% and opportunities for promotion*
-rainin% is essential for career plannin% and also for manpo#er de!elopment* Alon% #it &ob analysis$ or%ani0ational and &ob manpo#er re(uirement analysis s ould be underta'en by t e mana%ement* - is prepares proper bac'%round for t e introduction of career plannin% pro%rammes for employees*
business and industry* - erefore$ career plans for a period e:ceedin% a decade may not be effecti!e* ---. -8. Career plannin% is not an effecti!e tec ni(ue for a lar%e number of employees # o #or' on t e s op floor$ particularly for illiterate and uns'illed #or'ers* In family business ouses in India$ members of t e family e:pect to pro%ress faster in t eir career t an t eir professional collea%ues* - is upset t e career plannin% process* 8. Systematically career plannin% becomes difficult due to fa!ouritism and nepotism in promotions$ political inter!ention in appointments and reser!ations of seats for sc eduled castesBtribes and bac'#ard classes*
8. 8-.
Field staff at ead office #it necessary details$ and Facilitates a!ailable for trainin% and de!elopment #it in and outside t e or%ani0ation*
- e information collected on t ese aspects ser!es as t e base for t e preparation of career de!elopment plan for t e future period* 1. ANALYSIS OF PESONNEL SITUATION
2. PRO@ECTION OF PERSONNEL SITUATION 3. 4. 5. IDENTIFYING CAREER NEEDS SELECTION OF PRIORITIES DEVELOPMENT OF CAREER PLANS
6. :RITE UP OF FORMULATED CAREER PLANS 7. 8. 9. 10. MANAGERIAL PLANNING IMPLEMENTATION REVIE: AND EVALUATION FUTURE NEEDS
2! PRO@ECTION OF PERSONNEL SITUATION#) In t is second step$ an attempt is bein% made to find out t e situation li'ely to de!elop after t e completion of career de!elopment plan* - is can be done on t e basis of assumption # ic can predict # at is li'ely to appen at t e close of t e career de!elopment plan* 3! IDENTIFYING OF CAREER NEEDS#) In t is t ird step of career de!elopment plan$ efforts are made to find out precisely t e career de!elopment needs of t e future period* It is possible to
identify t e scope and limitations of career de!elopment needs on t e basis of t e data collected ?t rou% personnel in!entory of t e or%ani0ation$ employee potentials$ and appraisal of employees3* 4! SELECTION OF PRIORITIES#) It is rat er difficult to meet all t e needs of t e employees and t e or%ani0ation for career de!elopment immediately i*e* t rou% one career de!elopment plan* Naturally$ t ere is a need to select t e pressin% and ur%ent problems of employees and or%ani0ation* In addition$ ot er factors suc t e priorities* 5! DEVELOPMENT OF CAREER PLAN#) - is is t e most important step in t e # ole process of career de!elopin% plan* Suc plan must describe t e follo#in% in concrete formBforms# '. 7 at is to be attainedBac ie!ed@ 4. - e e:tent to # ic it is to be attained$ .. - e employees in!ol!ed$ 5. - e department in # ic t e proposed plan #ill operateH *. - e len%t of time re(uired t e ac ie!in% t e %oals* In order to e:ecute t e career de!elopment plan$ t e or%ani0ation s ould# '! Introduce systematic policies and pro%rammes of staff trainin% and career de!elopment for all cate%ories of employees so as to enable t em to# I. Impro!e t eir le!el of s'ill and 'no#led%eH II. Gain #ider e:periencesH and III. Assume i% er responsibilities* 4! Establis and effecti!ely implement a system of study lea!eH .! 6e!elop t e e:perience of t e employees by encoura%in% t eir rotation from one re%ion to anot erH 5! -a'e positi!e steps to encoura%e career de!elopment$ suc as# I. Pro!idin% #it in t e or%ani0ationH II. Gi!in% priorities in t e fillin% of !acancies in t e follo#in% order for# 1. promotion #it in t e or%ani0ationH 2. -ransfer #it in t e or%ani0ationH 3. Outside recruitment* as tec nical$ financial and administrati!e must be ta'en into consideration # ile finali0in%
III. IV.
Remo!in% artificial barriers to promotionH Establis in% a re%ister of employees for promotion on merit)cum) seniority basisH
6) :RITE1UP OF FORMULATED PLAN#) After decidin% t e priorities of career de!elopment plan$ t e ne:t ma&or step is to prepare a #rite up ?brief report3 of t e career plan* - is #rit)up s ould contain all necessary details suc meanin%ful* 7) MONITORING PLANNING -.*. MONITORING OF CAREER DEVELOPMENT PLAN#) Monitorin% of t e plan is essential for its effecti!e e:ecution* E:pected resultsBbenefits #ill be a!ailable only # en t e plan is implemented properly* Planned ?e:pected3 tar%ets and tar%ets actually ac ie!ed can be compared t rou% suitable monitorin% of t e plan* - e %ap bet#een t e t#o ?i*e* s ort falls3 can be located (uic'ly* In addition$ suitable remedial measures can be ta'en to rectify t e s ortfalls* 8) IMPLEMENTATION FOF CAREER DEVELOPMENT PLAN!#) ImplementationBe:ecution of t e plan is an inte%ral aspect of plannin% process itself* For effecti!e implementation$ co)operation and co)ordination at all le!els is necessary* - e implementation needs proper monitorin% so as to a!oid possible s ortfalls* 9) REVIE: AND EVALUATION OF CAREER PLANS#) A plan needs periodical re!ie#* Suc e!aluation a!oids mista'es$ deficiencies$ etc durin% t e implementation sta%e* It is built)in de!ice to measure t e effecti!eness of t e plan* Actual benefits a!ailable #ill be 'no#n only t rou% suc re!ie# and e!aluation* Suc e!aluation s ould be done by e:perts* It s ould be conducted systematically and also impartially* 10) FUTURE NEEDS#) - is is t e last stepBsta%e of t e current career de!elopment plan and t e first stepBsta%e of t e ne:t plan* 5ere$ on t e basis of t e ac ie!ements of t e current plan$ t e career needs of t e future period ?of employees and also of t e or%ani0ation3 are estimated* - e ne# priorities are decided and t e details of t e ne# career de!elopment plan are prepared* Plannin% is a continuous as sc edule ?time se(uence of plan3$ procedures and ot er details so t at t e e!aluation of t e plan #ill be easy and
CAREER STAGES#)
Education is t ou% t of in terms of employment* People %o for sc ool and colle%e education and prepare for t eir occupation* Mery fe# people stic' to t e same &ob t rou% out t eir life* Most of t em s#itc &ob eit er #it in t e or%ani0ation or in some ot er or%ani0ation* C ances are t ey c an%e &obs$ dependin% on a!ailable opportunity$ se!eral times before retirement* 7 ere opportunity is restricted t ey continue #it t e same &ob* - ey %o t rou% t e follo#in% sta%es# 1! EDPLORATION#) Almost all candidates # o start #or'in% after colle%e education start around mid)t#enties* Many a time t ey are not sure about future prospects but ta'e up a &ob in anticipation of risin% i% er up in t e career %rap later* From t e point of !ie# of or%ani0ation$ t is sta%e is of no rele!ance because it appens prior to t e employment* Some candidates # o come from better economic bac'%round can #ait and select a career of t eir c oice under e:pert %uidance from parents and #ell)#is ers* 2! ESTABLIS$MENT#) - is career sta%e be%ins #it t e candidate %ettin% t e first &ob %ettin% old of t e ri% t &ob is not an easy tas'* Candidates are li'ely to commit mista'es and learn from t eir mista'es* Slo#ly and %radually t ey become responsible to#ards t e &ob* Ambitious candidates #ill 'eep loo'in% for more lucrati!e and c allen%in% &obs else# ere* - is may eit er result in mi%ration to anot er &ob or e #ill remain #it t e Same &ob because of lac' of opportunity* 3! MID1CAREER STAGE#) - is career sta%e represents fastest and %ainful leap for competent employees # o are commonly called +climbers,* - ere is continuous impro!ement in performance* On t e ot er and$ employees # o are un appy and frustrated #it t e &ob$ t ere is mar'ed deterioration in t eir performance* In ot er to s o# t eir utility to t e or%ani0ation$ employees must remain producti!e at t is sta%e* +climbers, must %o on impro!in% t eir o#n performance* Aut ority$ responsibility$ re#ards and incenti!es are i% est at t is sta%e*
Employees tend to settle do#n inn t eir &obs and +&ob common* 4! LATE CAREER#)
oppin%, is not
- is career sta%e is pleasant for t e senior employees # o li'e to sur!i!e on t e past %lory* - ere is no desire to impro!e performance and impro!e past records* Suc employees en&oy playin% t e role of elder statesperson* - ey are e:pected to train youn%er employees and earn respect from t em* 5! DECLINE STAGE#) - is career sta%e represents t e completion of one"s career usually culminatin% into retirement* After decades of ard #or'$ suc employees a!e to retire* Employees # o #ere climbers and ac ie!ers #ill find it ard to compromise #it t e reality* Ot ers may t in' of +life after retirement,*
LO7
8>
;> AGE
<>
>>
CD
Career de!elopment consists of t e personal actions one underta'es to ac ie!e a career plan* - e terms Gcareer de!elopment" and Gemployee de!elopment" need to be differentiated at t is sta%e* Career de!elopment loo's at t e lon%)term career effecti!eness of employees # ere as employee de!elopment focuses of effecti!eness of an employee in t e immediate future* - e actions for career de!elopment may be initiated by t e indi!idual imself or by t e or%ani0ation*
Professionals and recent colle%e %raduates %enerally &ump &obs fre(uently # en t ey start t eir career* - ey do not t in' t at career)lon% dedication to t e same or%ani0ation may not elp t em furt er t eir career ambitions* -o o!ercome t is problem$ companies suc as Infosys$ NII-$ 7IPRO ?all information tec nolo%y companies # ere t e turno!er ratios are %enerally i% 3 a!e come out #it lucrati!e$ inno!ati!e compensation pac'a%es in addition to employee stoc' option plans for t ose # o remain #it company for a specified period* VI. MENTORS AND SPONSORS#) A mentor is$ %enerally spea'in%$ an older person in a mana%erial role offerin% informal career ad!ice to a &unior employee* Mentors ta'e &unior employees under t eir protP%P and offer ad!ice and %uidance on o# to sur!i!e and %et a ead in t e or%ani0ation* - ey act as role models* A sponsor$ on t e ot er and$ is someone in t e or%ani0ation # o can create career de!elopment opportunities* t e
%enerally t ro#s li% t on or%ani0ation"s structure$ career pat s$ (ualifications for &obs and career ladders* 4! INDIVIDUAL COUNSELLING#) Employee counsellin% is a process # ereby employees are %uided in o!ercomin% performance problems* It is usually done t rou% face)to)face meetin%s bet#een t e employee and t e counselor or coac * 5ere discussions of employees" interests %oals$ current &ob acti!ities and performance and career ob&ecti!es ta'e place* Counsellin% is %enerally offered by t e 5R department* Sometimes outside e:perts are also be called in* if super!isors act as coac es t ey s ould be %i!en clearly defined roles and trainin%* - is is$ o#e!er$ a costly and time)consumin% process* .! EMPLOYEE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMMES#) - ese consist of s'ill assessment and trainin% efforts t at or%ani0ations use to %room t eir employees for future !acancies* Seminars$ #or's ops$ &ob rotations and mentorin% pro%rammes are used to de!elop a broad base of s'ills as a part of suc de!elopmental acti!ities* 5! CAREER PROGRAMMES FOR SPECIAL GROUPS#) In recent years$ t ere is %ro#in% e!idence re%ardin% dual career families de!elopin% tensions and frictions o#in% to t eir inability to reconcile t e differences bet#een t e family roles and #or' demands* 7 en #e tal' of dual career couples ?a situation # ere bot usband and #ife a!e distinct careers outside t e ome3 certain pu00lin% (uestions arise naturally # # ose career is importantH # o ta'es care of c ildren H # at if t e #ife %ets a temptin% promotion in anot er location H # o buys %roceries and cleans t e ouse if bot are busy$ etc* reali0in% t ese problems$ or%ani0ations are pro!idin% a place and a procedure for discussin% suc role conflicts and copin% strate%ies* - ey are comin% out #it sc emes suc as part)time #or'$ lon% parental lea!e$ c ild care centers$ fle:ible #or'in% ours and promotions and transfers in tune #it t e demands of dual career conflicts*
standards establis ed$ if e #ants career pro%ress* Employee"s desire for career pro%ress s ould e:pose t eir s'ills$ 'no#led%e$ (ualifications$ ac ie!ements$ performance etc*$ to t ose # o ta'e t e decision about career pro%ress*
.! RESIGNATIONS#) Employees may resi%n t e present &ob in t e or%ani0ation$ if t ey find t at career opportunities else# ere are better t an t ose of t e present or%ani0ation* 5! C$ANGE T$E @OB#) Employees # o put or%ani0ational loyalty abo!e career loyalty may c an%e t e &ob in t e same or%ani0ation are better t an t ose in t e present &ob* *! CAREER GUIDANCE#) And counsellin% pro!ides information$ ad!ice and encoura%ements to s#itc o!er to ot er career or or%ani0ation$ # ere career opportunities are better*
EMPLOYEE TRAINING
INTRODUCTION#)
-rainin% plays an important role in uman resource de!elopment* It comes ne:t to recruitment and selection* In fact$ t e main purpose of trainin% is to de!elop t e uman resources present #it in t e employees* In brief$ trainin% is t e #atc #ord of present dynamic business #orld* -rainin% is necessary due to tec nolo%ical c an%es rapidly ta'in% place in t e industrial field* Ne# mac ines$ ne# met ods and ne# tec ni(ues are introduced in t e production$ mar'etin% and ot er aspect of business* -rainin% is for de!elopin% o!erall personality of an employee* It also creates positi!e attitude to#ards fello# employees$ &ob and t e or%ani0ation # ere e is #or'in%* -rainin% is t e responsibility of t e mana%ement as it is basically for raisin% t e efficiency and producti!ity of employees* - e purpose of trainin% is to ac ie!e a c an%e in t e be a!iour of t ose trained and to enable t em to do t eir &obs in a better #ay* - e trainees #ill ac(uire ne# manipulati!e s'ills$ tec nical 'no#led%e$ problem sol!in% ability or attitudes etc* trainin% is not a one step process but is a continuous or ne!er)endin% process* -rainin% ma'es ne#ly recruited #or'ers fully producti!e in t e minimum of time* E!en for old #or'ers$ trainin% is necessary to refres t em and enable t em to 'eep
up #it ne# met ods and tec ni(ues* In s ort trainin% is t e act of impro!in% or updatin% t e 'no#led%e and s'ill of an employee for performin% a particular &ob*
DEFINITION OF TRAINING#)
Accordin% to E5=-0 F3-22/$ trainin% is +t e act of increasin% t e 'no#led%e and s'ill of an employee for doin% a particular &ob,*
to#ards t e re(uirements of t e &ob and or%ani0ation* -rainin% refers to t e teac in% and learnin% acti!ities carried on for t e primary purpose of elpin% members of an or%ani0ation$ to ac(uire and apply t e 'no#led%e$ s'ills$ abilities and attitudes needed by a particular &ob and or%ani0ation* -rainin% is t e most important tec ni(ue of uman resource de!elopment* As stated earlier$ no or%ani0ation can %et a candidate # o e:actly matc es #it t e &ob and t e or%ani0ational re(uirements* 5ence$ trainin% is important to de!elop t e employee and ma'e im suitable to t e &ob* -rained employees #ould be a !aluable asset to an or%anisation* Or%ani0ational efficiency$ producti!ity$ pro%ress and de!elopment to a %reater e:tent depend on trainin%* Or%ani0ational ob&ecti!es li'e !iability$ stability and %ro#t can also be ac ie!ed t rou% trainin%*
computeri0ation and automation* Adoption of latest tec nolo%ical means and met ods$ #ill not be complete until t ey are manned by employees possessin% s'ill to operate t em* So$ or%ani0ation s ould train t e employees to enric t em in t e areas of c an%in% tec nical s'ills and 'no#led%e from time to time* IM* O(<'0-J',-/0'3 ./&23*9-,)# 7it t e emer%ence of increased mec ani0ation and automation$ manufacturin% of multiple products and by)products or dealin% in ser!ices of di!ersified lines$ e:tension of operations to !arious re%ions of t e country or in o!erseas countries$ or%anisation of most of t e companies as become comple:* - is creates t e comple: problems of co) ordination and inte%ration of acti!ities adaptable for and adaptable to t e e:pandin% and di!ersifyin% situations* - is situation calls for trainin% in t e s'ills of co)ordination$ inte%ration and adaptability to t e re(uirements of %ro#t $ di!ersification and e:pansion* M* $%&'0 (*3',-/0+# -rends in approac to#ards personnel mana%ement as c an%ed form t e commodity approac to partners ip approac $ crossin% t e uman relations approac * So today$ mana%ements of most of t e or%ani0ations as to maintain uman relations besides maintainin% sound industrial relations alt ou% deal #it it erto t e mana%ers are not accustomed to deal
#it t e #or'ers accordin%ly* So trainin% in uman relations is necessary to uman problems ?includin% alienation$ inter)personal and inter) %roup conflicts etc*3 and to maintain uman relations* MI* C7'0<* -0 ,7* I/4 '++-<0&*0,# -rainin% is also necessary # en t e e:istin% employee is promoted to t e i% er le!el in t e or%anisation and # en t ere is some ne# &ob or occupation due to transfer* -rainin% is also necessary to e(uip t e old employees #it tec nolo%y* t e ad!anced disciplines$ tec ni(ues or
2) -o create a pool of #ell trained$ capable and loyal employees at all le!els and t ereby to ma'e pro!ision to meet t e future needs of an or%ani0ation* 3) -o pro!ide opportunities of %ro#t and self)de!elopment ?career plannin%3 to employees and t ereby to moti!ate t em for promotion and ot er monetary benefits* In addition$ to %i!e safety and security to t e life and ealt of employees* 4) -o a!oid accidents and #asta%es of all 'inds* In addition$ to de!elop balanced$ ealt y and safety attitudes amon% t e employees* 5) -o meet t e c allen%es posed by ne# de!elopments in t e field of science and tec nolo%y* 6) -o impro!e t e (uality of production and t ereby to create mar'et demand and reputation in t e business #orld* 7) -o de!elop positi!e attitude and be a!iour pattern re(uired by an employee in order to perform a %i!en &ob efficiently* In ot er #ords$ t e purpose of trainin% is to impro!e t e culture of t e or%anisation* 8) -o de!elop certain personal (ualities amon% employees # ic can ser!e as personal assets on lon% term basis*
t e &ob* - is trainin% de!elops s'ills and confidence amon% t e #or'ers and enables t em to perform t e &ob efficiently* 3! TRAINING FOR PROMOTION#) Promotion means %i!in% i% er position* -rainin% must be %i!en for performin% duties at a i% er le!el efficiently* - is facilitates easy and (uic' ad&ustment #it t e ne# &ob and also de!elops ne# insi% t into t e duties and responsibilities assi%ned* For t is$ trainin% is %i!en after promotion and before actually &oinin% t e ne# assi%nment* - is trainin% is specific$ precise and of s ort duration* 4! REFRES$ER TRAINING#) - e purpose of refres er trainin% is to refres t e professional s'ills$ information and e:perience of persons occupyin% important e:ecuti!e positions* It %i!es information about ne# de!elopments and tec ni(ues to trainees and enables t em to use ne# met ods$ tec ni(ues and procedures for raisin% efficiency* 5! CORRECTIVE TRAINING#) Correcti!e trainin% is necessary # en employees !iolate company rules and procedures* For e:ample$ absence #it out prior sanction or smo'in% in a +No smo'in%, area or not usin% safety de!ices # ile operatin% dan%erous mac ines* 5ere$ t e be a!iour of employee cannot be c an%es simply by disciplinary action* - e mana%er s ould andle t e problem #it treatment t at corrects t e outloo' rat er t an %i!in% punis ment* - e mana%er s ould critici0e t e act and not t e indi!idual* 5e s ould moti!ate concerned indi!idual to correct is be a!iour*
SELECTION
OF
TRAINEES#1
Once you a!e decided # at trainin% is necessary and # ere it is needed$ t e ne:t decision is # o s ould be trained@ For a small business$ t is (uestion is crucial* -rainin% an employee is e:pensi!e$ especially # en e or s e lea!es your firm for a better &ob* - erefore$ it is important to carefully select # o #ill be trained* -rainin% pro%rams s ould be desi%ned to consider t e ability of t e employee to learn t e material and to use it effecti!ely$ and to ma'e t e most efficient use of
resources possible* It is also important t at employees be moti!ated by t e trainin% e:perience* Employee failure in t e pro%ram is not only dama%in% to t e employee but a #aste of money as #ell* Selectin% t e ri% t trainees is important to t e success of t e pro%ram*
TRAINING
GOALS#)
- e %oals of t e trainin% pro%ram s ould relate directly to t e needs outlined abo!e* Course ob&ecti!es s ould clearly state # at be a!ior or s'ill #ill be c an%ed as a result of t e trainin% and s ould relate to t e mission and strate%ic plan of t e company* Goals s ould include milestones to elp ta'e t e employee from # ere e or s e is today to # ere t e firm #ants im or er in t e future* Settin% %oals elps to e!aluate t e trainin% pro%ram and also to moti!ate employees* Allo#in% employees to participate in settin% %oals increases t e probability of success*
positions$ trainees can also be rotated from &ob to &ob in #or's op &ob* - is met od %i!es an opportunity to t e trainee to understand t e problems of employees on ot er &obs and respect t em* 4! COAC$ING#) - e trainee is placed under a particular super!isor # o functions as a coac in trainin% t e indi!idual* - e super!isor pro!ides feedbac' to t e trainee on is performance and offer im for su%%estions for impro!ement* Often t e trainee s are some of t e duties an responsibilities of t e coac and relie!es im of is burden* A limitation of t is met od of trainin% is t at t e trainee may not a!e t e freedom or opportunity to e:press is o#n ideas* .! @OB INSTRUCTION#) - is met od is also 'no#n as trainin% t rou% step by step* .nder t is met od$ t e trainer e:plains to t e trainee t e #ay of doin% t e &ob$ &ob 'no#led%e and s'ills and allo# im to do t e &ob* - e trainer appraises t e performance of t e trainee$ pro!ides feedbac' information and corrects t e trainee* 5! COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENTS#) .nder t e committee assi%nments$ a %roup of trainees are %i!en and as'ed to sol!e an actual or%ani0ational problem* - e trainees sol!e t e problem &ointly* It de!elops team #or'* OFF1T$E1@OB MET$ODS .nder t is met od of trainin%$ t e trainee is separated form t e &ob situation and is attention is focused upon learnin% t e material related to is future &ob performance* Since t e trainee is not distracted by &ob re(uirements$ e can place is entire concentration on learnin% t e &ob rat er t an spendin% is time in performin% it* - ere is an opportunity for freedom of e:pression for t e trainees* Off)t e)&ob trainin% met ods are as follo#s# '! VESTIBUTE TRAINING#) In t is met od$ actual #or' conditions are simulated in a class room* Material$ files and e(uipments t ose are used in actual &ob performance are also used in trainin%* - is type of trainin% is commonly used for trainin% personnel for clerical and semi)s'illed &obs* - e duration of t is trainin% ran%es from days to a fe# #ee's* - eory can be related to practice in t is met od* 4! ROLE PLAYING#)
It is defined as a met od of uman interaction t at in!ol!es realistic be a!iour in ima%inary situations* - is met od of trainin% in!ol!es action$ doin% and practice* - e participants play t e role of certain c aracters$ suc as t e production mana%er$ mec anical en%ineer$ superintendents$ maintenance en%ineers$ (uality control inspectors$ foreman$ #or'ers and t e li'e* - is met od is mostly used for de!elopin% interpersonal interactions and relations* .! LECTURE MET$OD#) - e lecture is a traditional and direct met od of instruction* - e instructor or%ani0es t e material and %i!es it to a %roup of trainees in t e form of a tal'* -o be effecti!e$ t e lecture must moti!ate and create interest amon% t e trainees* An ad!anta%e of lecture met od is t at it is direct and can be used for a lar%e %roup of trainees* - us$ costs and time in!ol!ed are reduced* 5! CONFERENCE OR DISCUSSION#) It is a met od in trainin% t e clerical$ professional and super!isory personnel* - is met od in!ol!es a %roup of people # o pose ideas$ e:amine and s are facts$ ideas and data$ test assumptions$ and dra# conclusions$ all of # ic contribute to t e impro!ement of t e &ob performance* 6iscussion as t e distinct ad!anta%e o!er t e lecture met od$ in t at t e discussion in!ol!es t#o) #ay communication and ence feedbac' is pro!ided* - e participants feel free to spea' in small %roups* - e success of t is met od depends on t e leaders ip (ualities of t e person # o leads t e %roup*
e(uipment and ad&ustin% to ma&or c an%es in &ob contents and #or' relations ip*
3. C$ANCES FOR PROMOTION#) -rainin% also (ualifies t e employees for promotion to more responsible &obs* 4. FOLLO: UP OF SELECTION PROCEDURE#) -rainin% is a follo# up of selection procedure* It elps in c oosin% t e most appropriate indi!iduals for different &obs* -rainin% can be used in spottin% out promisin% men and in remo!in% defects in selection process* 5. BETTER PERFORMANCE#) -rainin% brin%s about an impro!ement of t e (uality and (uantity of output by increasin% t e s'ill of t e employees* -rainin% ma'es t e fres employees more s'illed and accurate in performance of t eir #or'* and old
6. REDUCTION IN COST OF PRODUCTION#) If t e employees are %i!en proper trainin% t e need for super!ision is lessened* -rainin% does not eliminate t e need for super!ision but it reduces t e need for detailed and constant super!ision* A #ell trained employee is self)reliant in is #or' because e 'no#s # at to do and o# to do it*
iii. @OB BE$AVIOUR#) - is e!aluation includes t e manner and e:tent to # ic t e trainee as applied is learnin% to is &ob* iv. ORGANISATION#) - is e!aluation measures t e use of trainin%$ learnin% and c an%e in t e &ob be a!iour of t e departmentBor%ani0ation in t e form of increased producti!ity$ (uality$ morale$ sales turno!er and t e li'e* v. ULTIMATE VALUE#) It is t e measurement of ultimate result of t e contributions of t e trainin% pro%ramme to t e company %oals li'e sur!i!al$ %ro#t $ profitability etc*$ and to t e indi!idual %oals li'e de!elopment of personality and social %oals li'e ma:imi0in% social benefit*
Opinions s ould be obtained from t e mana%ement and t e #or'in% people t rou% inter!ie#s or t rou% (uestionnaire re%ardin% necessary and desirable trainin% pro%rammes*
83 GETTING READY FOR T$E @OB#) Follo#in% are t e steps ta'en in t is re%ard# a) IDENTIFYING T$E TRAINEE#) .nder t is step it is to be decided # o is to be trained* # o is to be trained N t e ne# comer or t e older employee or t e super!isory staff or all of t em selected from different departments* - e proper selection of trainees is !ery important to obtain permanent and %ainful results of trainin%* A trainee s ould be trained for t e 'ind of &ob e li'es and is suitable to perform* Careful screenin% of candidates for trainin% raises t e effecti!eness of t e trainin% #or'* -rainee s ould be %i!en t e proper bac'%round information before e starts learnin% ne# &ob s'ills and 'no#led%e* -rainer s ould e:plain t e trainee t e importance of t e &ob$ its relations ip #it t e #or' flo# and t e importance of trainin%* 4! SELECTION OF TRAINING MET$OD#) No# it is ad!isable to lay do#n # ic met od is to be adopted fro t e trainin%* 6ifferent met ods of trainin% may be su%%ested for t e different le!els of personnel* .ns'illed #or'ers may be trained on t e &ob* On)t e)&ob and apprentices ip trainin% may be a#arded$ to s'illed and semi)s'illed #or'ers* For super!isory and e:ecuti!e personnel On) t e)&ob and Off)t e)&ob met ods suc seminars etc* may be recommended* c) PREPARATION OF TRAINER OR INSTRUCTOR#) - e success of t e trainin% pro%ramme muc depends upon t e instructor* Instructor must be #ell)(ualified and may be obtained from #it in or outside t e or%ani0ation* It s ould be decided before and # at is to be tau% t and o#* 5e s ould be able to di!ide t e &ob into as role)playin%$ lectures and
lo%ical parts so t at e may teac one part at a time #it out losin% is perspecti!e of t e # ole* As because trainin% must be based upon t e needs of t e or%ani0ation t erefore$ t e trainer must a!e a clear)cut picture of t e ob&ecti!es of trainin% in mind* It s ould not be in a !acuum* -rainer needs professional e:pertise in order to fulfill is responsibility* 5e s ould also encoura%e t e (uestion from t e trainees* d) TRAINING MATERIAL#) - ere s ould al#ays be t e trainin% material #it t e instructor* -rainin% materials may include some te:t or #ritten materials as a basis for instruction$ re!ie# and reference* - is may be prepared in t e trainin% section #it t e elp of super!isors* - e #ritten material s ould be distributed amon% t e trainees so t at t ey may come prepared in t e lecture class and may be able to understand t e operation (uic'ly and remo!e t eir doubts$ if any* e) TRAINING MATERIAL#) - e len%t of trainin% period depends upon t e s'ill of t e trainees$ purpose of t e trainin%$ trainee"s learnin% capacity and t e trainin% media used* Generally no sin%le session s ould last lon%er t an t#o ours* - e time of trainin% # et er before or after or durin% #or'in% ours s ould be decided by t e personnel mana%er ta'in% in !ie# t e loss of production and benefits to be ac ie!ed by trainin%* 2! PREPARATION OF T$E LEARNER#) - is step consists# -. - e puttin% t e learner at case so t at e does not feel ner!ous because of t e fact t at e is on a ne# &ob$ --. In statin% t e importance of in%redients of t e &ob and its relations ip to#ards flo#$ ---. In e:plainin% e is bein% tau% t$ -8. In creatin% interest and encoura%in% (uestions$ findin% out # at t e learner already 'no#s about is &ob or ot er &obs$ 8. In e:plainin% # y of t e # ole &ob and relatin% it to some &ob t e #or'er already 'no#s$
8-. In plannin% t e learner as close to is normal #or'in% position as possible$ and 8--. In familiari0in% terms* 3! GNO:LEDGE#) - is is t e most important step in a trainin% pro%ramme* - e trainer s ould clearly tell$ s o#$ illustrate and (uestion I order to put o!er t e ne# 'no#led%e and operations* - e learner s ould be told of t e se(uence of t e entire &ob and # y eac step in its performance is necessary instructions s ould be %i!en clearly$ completely and patiently* -rainer s ould demonstrate or ma'e use of audio)!isual aids and s ould as' t e trainee to repeat t e operations 4! e:plainin% im eac PERFORMANCE TRY1OUT#) .nder t is$ t e trainee is as'ed to %o t rou% t e &ob se!eral times slo#ly$ step* Mista'es are corrected and if necessary some complicated steps are ta'en for t e trainee for t e first time* - en t e trainee is as'ed to do t e &ob$ %radually buildin% up s'ill and speed* - e trainee is t en tested and t e effecti!eness of a trainin% pro%ramme e!aluated* 5! FOLLO:1UP#) On t e completion of trainin% pro%ramme trainees s ould be placed to t e &ob* - e super!isor s ould a!e a constant !i%il on t e person still facin% any difficulty on t e &ob$ e must be %i!en full %uidance by t e immediate super!isor and s ould be initiated to as' (uestions to remo!e t e doubts* PRESENTATION OF OPERATIONS AND im #it t e e(uipment$ materials tools and trade
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
INTRODUCTION
- e p rase GCollecti!e bar%ainin%" is coined by Sydney Q 4eatrice 7ebb* Accordin% to t em collecti!e bar%ainin% is a met od by # ic trade unions protect Q impro!e t e conditions of t eir members" #or'in% li!es* 4efore t e Industrial Re!olution$ t e employer$ more or less$ en&oyed un(uestioned po#ers on matters relatin% to #a%e$ #or'in% conditions Q ot er matters affectin% employees* - e #ee' bar%ainin% stren%t of employees tempted t em$ on occasions$ to e:ploit t e !ulnerable situation to t eir ad!anta%e* 7or'ers as a result became restless Q #idespread protests follo#ed* Go!ernmental inter!ention #as of little elp* 7or'ers reali0ed t e importance of fi% tin% &ointly on all #or')related matters* - is collecti!e fi% tin% spirit is be ind t e bac' of collecti!e bar%ainin%* 7it t e %ro#t of union mo!ement all o!er t e %lobe Q t e emer%ence of employers" associations$ t e collecti!e bar%ainin% process as under%one si%nificant c an%es* 4ot parties a!e$ more or less$ reali0ed t e importance of peaceful co)e:istence for t eir mutual benefit Q continued pro%ress*
OB@ECTIVES
- e main ob&ecti!es of Collecti!e bar%ainin% are %i!en belo#1 -o settle disputes B conflicts relatin% to #a%es Q #or'in% conditions* -o protect t e interests of #or'ers t rou% collecti!e plan* -o resol!e t e differences bet#een #or'ers Q mana%ement t ou% !oluntary ne%otiations Q arri!e at a customer* -o a!oid t ird party inter!ention in matters relatin% to employment*
Collecti!e bar%ainin% plays an important role in pre!entin% industrial disputes$ settin% t ese disputes Q maintainin% industrial peace by performin% t e follo#in% functions1 Increase t e economic stren%t of employees Q mana%ement* Establis uniform conditions of employment* Secure a prompt Q fair redressal of %rie!ances* Lay do#n fair rates of #a%es Q ot er norms of #or'in% conditions* Ac ie!e an efficient functionin% of t e or%ani0ation* Promote t e stability Q prosperity of t e company* It pro!ides a met od of t e re%ulation of t e conditions of employment of t ose # o are directly concerned about t em* It pro!ides a solution to t e problem of sic'ness in t e industry Q ensures old a%e pension benefits Q ot er frin%e benefits*
It builds up a system of industrial &urisprudence by introducin% ci!il ri% ts I
- ere are t#o sta%es in collecti!e bar%ainin%$ !i0*$ ?i3 t e ne%otiation sta%e Q ?ii3 t e sta%e of contract administration*
1. N*</,-',-/0 F'! I5*0,-6-.',-/0 /6 P(/43*&+
- e nature of t e problem influences t e # ole process)# et er t e problem is !ery important t at is to be discussed immediately or it can be postponed for some ot er con!enient time$ # et er t e problem is minor t at it can be sol!ed #it t e ot er party"s acceptance on its presentation Q does not need to in!ol!e t e lon% process of collecti!e bar%ainin% process etc*
F4! P(*2'(-0< 6/( N*</,-',-/0+
7 en it becomes necessary to sol!e t e problem t rou% collecti!e bar%ainin% process$ bot t e parties prepare t emsel!es for ne%otiations*
F.! N*</,-',-/0+ /6 A<(**&*0,
.sually t ere #ill be a c ief ne%otiator # o is form t e mana%ement side* 5e directs Q presides o!er t e process* - e c ief ne%otiator presents t e problem$ its intensity Q nature Q t e !ie#s of bot parties* 7 en a solution is reac ed at$ it is put on t e paper$ ta'in% concerned le%islations into consideration* 4ot parties concerned si%n t e a%reement # ic $ in tern$ become a bindin% contract for bot t e parties*
2. C/0,('., A5&-0-+,(',-/0
Implementation of t e contract is as important as ma'in% a contract* Mana%ement usually distributes t e printed contract$ its terms Q conditions t rou% out t e or%ani0ation* - e union ta'es steps to see t at all t e #or'ers understand t e contract Q implement it* From time to time dependin% upon c an%in% circumstances$ bot amendments* t e parties can ma'e mutually acceptable
.nions s ould be made stron% by creatin% a#areness amon% #or'ers* Interference of political leaders s ould be a!oided* - e unions s ould separate t emsel!es from politics* Go!t* s ould ma'e efforts for t e %ro#t of collecti!e bar%ainin%* Ad&udication s ould be used only as a last resort* Go!t* can ma'e le%islation for compulsory collecti!e bar%ainin% before resortin% to ad&udication* Mana%ement s ould de!elop a positi!e attitude to#ard unions* Muc ead#ay as already been made in t is direction* Presently$ mana%ers are mostly a#are of t e ri% ts of #or'ers* - ey are also reali0in% o# important cooperation bet#een mana%ement Q #or'ers for t e effecti!e functionin% of an or%ani0ation* As suc $ t ey are no# encoura%in% ne%otiations Q amicable solutions*
INDUSTRIAL CONFLICTS
All t e issues refer to collecti!e bar%ainin% may not be settled to t e satisfactions of bot t e parties* Suc issues result in Industrial Conflicts*
DEFINITION OF DISPUTE " CONFLICT
Accordin% to t e Industrial 6isputes Act$ 2J<I$ Section 8?'3$ +Industrial dispute means any dispute or difference bet#een employers Q employers$ or bet#een employers Q #or'men or bet#een #or'men Q #or'men$ # ic is connected #it t e employment or non employment or term of employment or #it t e conditions of labour of any person*,
CAUSES OF INDUSTRIAL CONFLICTS
It is not easy to identify a sin%le factor as a cause of industrial conflicts as multifarious causes blended to%et er result in industrial disputes* 6eep seated Q more basic causes of disputes can be identified t rou% in dept probe$ t ou% surface manifestations appear to be responsible for conflicts* - e relati!e importance of t ese causes$ # en more t an presents$ is often !ery difficult to %au%e* Accordin% to Mu' er&ee$ +- e de!elopment of capitalistic enterprise$ # ic means t e control of t e tools of production by t e small entrepreneur class as brou% t to t e fore t e acute problem of friction bet#een mana%ement Q labour t rou% out t e #orld*, Causes of industrial conflicts may be %rouped into four cate%ories$ Industrial factors$ Mana%ement"s attitude to#ards #or'ers$ Go!ernment mac inery Q Ot er causes*
A stri'e is a spontaneous and concerted #it dra#al of t e labour from production temporarily* It is a collecti!e stoppa%e of #or' by %roup of #or'ers for pressurin% t eir employer to accept certain demands* - e industrial disputes act 2J<I as define a stri'e as +an assertion of #or' by a body of persons*, employed in an industry actin% in combination$ or a concerted refusal or a refusal under a common understandin% of any no of persons # o are or a!e been so employed to continue to #or' or to accept employment* Stri'es are of se!eral types$ Sympat etic stri'e 7 en a stri'e is underta'en to s o# sympat y #it #or'ers in ot er industries$ it is called as sympat etic stri'e* General stri'e It is a stri'e by all or most of t e unions in a industry or a re%ion .nofficial stri'e It is a stri'e underta'en #it out t e consent of t e unions* Sectional stri'e It is refusal of a section of a %i!en class of #or'ers to perform t eir normal duties* 4umper stri'e It is a stri'e # en t e unions plan to paralyse t e industry$ firm by firm$ t e order bein% c osen by t e union* Suc contributions of t ose # o are still in #or'* Sit do#n stri'e ?also called stay)in$ tool do#n$ pen do#n stri'e3 It is a stri'e in # ic #or'ers cease to perform t is duties but do not lea!e t e place of #or'* Slo#)do#n stri'e stri'es are supported by t e
Rno#n as a G%o)slo#" tactic t e #or'ers do not stop #or'in% but put bra'es to t e normal #ay of doin% t in%s* Li% tnin% stri'e Out of pro!ocation$ #or'ers may %o on stri'e #it out notice or at !ery s ort notice* - ere is an element of surprise in suc cat)call stri'es* 5un%er stri'e -o %ain sympat y from t e public Q %et noticed by t e employer$ #or'ers may decide to fore%o food for a specified period* Small batc es of #or'ers may also %o on a relay un%er stri'e in a se(uential order* Suc non)!iolence protests %enerally brin% moral pressure on employers to iron out t e differences #it (uic'ly*
L/.C1/%,+
Loc')out is t e counterpart of stri'e* It is a #eapon a!ailable to t e employer to close do#n t e factory till t e #or'ers a%ree to resume #or' on t e conditions lead do#n by t e employer* - e industrial 6ispute Act of 2J<I defined it as +t e closin% of a place of an employment$ or t e suspension of #or' or t e refusal of an employer to continue to employ any number of persons employed by im,* If it is impossible to meet t e demand of #or'ers$ employers may decide to %o for loc')out* 5e may also dra# t e s utter do#n so as to brin% psyc olo%ical pressure on t e #or'ers to a%ree to is condition or face closure of t e unit*
G7*('/
G erao means to surround* In t is met od a %roup of #or'ers initiate collecti!e action aimed at pre!entin% members of t e mana%ement from lea!in% t e office* - is can appen outside t e factory premises too* - e persons # o are gheraoed are not allo#ed to mo!e for a lon% time$ sometimes #it out food or #ater* - e National Commission on Labour$ # ile refusin% to accept it as a form of industrial protest$ opined t at % eraos tend to inflict p ysical duress ?as a%ainst economic pressure3 on t e persons affected Q endan%er not only industrial armony but also create problems of la# Q order*
In pic'etin% #or'ers carry B display si%ns$ banners Q play card ?in connection #it t e dispute3 Q pre!ent ot ers from enterin% t e place of #or' Q persuade ot ers to &oin t e stri'e* 4oycott aims at disruptin% t e normal functionin% of an enterprise* - rou% forceful appeals Q ne%ati!e be a!ioral acts$ stri'in% #or'ers pre!ent ot ers from enterin% t e place of #or' Q persuade t em not to cooperate #it t e employer*
Pre!ention of industrial disputes may a!e different met ods* - ese met ods +co!er t e entire field of relations bet#een industry Q labour Q include enactment Q enforcement of pro%ressi!e le%islation$ #or's committees Q councils$ #a%e boards$ Q trade boards$ profit s arin% Q co)partners ip$ education$ ousin%$ #elfare #or' Q all suc measures # ic can brid%e t e %ap bet#een t e employers Q t e employed*, - e si%nificant pre!enti!e measures may be broadly outlined as belo#1
Standin% Orders
Grie!ances Procedure
/oint Consultation
/oint Consultations
Collecti!e 4ar%ainin%
Sec* <J ?23 Q ?83 of t e factories act$ 2J<K$ specifies t at e!ery factory # erein >DD or more #or'ers are ordinarily employed$ at least 2 officer must be appointed$ # ere t e number of #or'ers are in e:cess of 8$>DD$ t e assistance Q or additional #elfare officers are re(uired to be appointed to assist t e #elfare officer*
S,'05-0< /(5*(+
Ma&ority of t e industrial disputes are related to conditions of employment* -o pre!ent t e industrial conflict relatin% to employment conditions$ standin% orders are formulated* It #as made obli%atory t at standin% orders s ould %o!ern t e conditions of employment under t e industrial employment ?standin% orders3 act of 2J<C* - e standin% orders re%ulate t e conditions of employment from t e sta%e of entry to t e sta%e of e:it or retirement* Standin% orders act as a code of conduct for t e employees durin% t e #or'in% life of employees as t ey pro!ide do"s Q do nots*
G(-*8'0.* 2(/.*5%(*
Grie!ances %enerally arise from day N to N day #or'in% relations* Grie!ances of t e employees are redressed by t e mana%ement* Mana%ement can pre!ent t e occurrence of industrial disputes by sol!in% t e indi!idual problems*
C/33*.,-8* 4'(<'-0-0<
As discussed earlier$ collecti!e bar%ainin% elps for settlement of issues Q pre!ention of industrial disputes* Go!ernment also elps trade unions Q %o!t* to come closer to eac ot er Q come to an a%reement*
S,(/0< ,('5* %0-/0+
Stron% trade unions a!e t e stability of members ip$ sound financial position Q ealt y polices* Suc unions t in' Q act constructi!ely for t e mutual benefit of t e employees Q t e mana%ement* - ese practices naturally pre!ent t e industrial conflicts*
L'4/%( ./ K 2'(,0*(+7-2 > 2(/6-, +7'(-0<
Labour co N partners ip Q profit s arin% create a sense of belon%ness amon% t e employees Q t ey fill t at t ey are t e partners in t e company* As suc $ t ey t in' Q act for t e benefit of t e company*
@/-0, ./0+%3,',-/0+
A /oint consultation bet#een t e employees Q employer are t e differences bet#een t em Q pre!ents industrial conflicts*
SETTLEMENT OF CONFLICTS
- is is conducted by a board or court appointed by t e %o!ernment* It may be !oluntary or compulsory* If t e in!esti%ation is conducted on an application by eit er or bot t e parties to t e dispute$ it is !oluntary* If t e Go!ernment appoints a Court of In(uiry to in!esti%ate into a dispute #it out t e consent of t e parties$ it is compulsory* In!esti%ations do not aim at brin%in% about t e settlement of disputes directly$ but by analy0in% t e facts$ t ey aim at brin%in% about an amicable solution* 7 en t e in!esti%ation is compulsory$ t e stri'es Q loc')outs are re(uired to be stopped Q employers s ould not ma'e any c an%e in t e conditions of employment* - e result of in!esti%ation as no serious effect on t e dispute because t e %eneral public is least bot ered to ma'e note of t e dispute*
2. M*5-,',-/0
Anot er attempt to settle disputes is Meditation* In t is met od$ an outsider assists t e parties in t eir ne%otiation* It ta'es place #it t e consent of bot t e parties* - e mediator performs t e messen%er"s &ob for bot t e parties Q e neit er imposes is #ill nor is &ud%ment upon t em* - e main aim of meditation is t e settlement of disputes by brinin% about a !oluntary a%reement* - ere may be t ree 'inds of meditation1 a* - e Eminent Outsider9 b* Non)Go!ernment 4oard9 Q c* Semi)Go!ernment 4oard* If meditation is conducted s'illful Q sympat etically alon% proper lines$ it can brin% about t e ad&ustment of differences t at mi% t ot er#ise contribute to stoppa%e of #or'*
3. C/0.-3-',-/0
- e main ob&ecti!e of a condition Q arbitration is to reunite t e t#o conflictin% %roups in t e industry in order to a!oid interruption of production$ distrust etc* Conciliation is a process by # ic representati!es of bot #or'ers Q employers are brou% t to%et er before a t ird party #it a !ie# to persuadin% t em to arri!e at some sort of settlement* It is an e:tension of collecti!e bar%ainin% #it t ird party assistance* It is t e practice by # ic t e ser!ices of t e neutral t ird party as used in a dispute as a means of elpin% t e disputin% parties to reduce t e e:tent of t eir differences Q to arri!e at an amicable settlement or a%reed solution* It is a process of rational Q orderly discussions of differences bet#een t e parties to a dispute under t e %uidance of a conciliator* Conciliation mac inery consists of a conciliation officer Q board of conciliations* - e conciliator induces t e parties to a course of action* 5e plays t e role of an inno!ator$ protector$ discussion leader$ stimulator$ ad!isor$ face sa!er* 5e acts as a safety !alue Q a communication lin'* - e tas' of conciliation is to offer ad!ice Q ma'e su%%estions to t e dispute on contro!ersial issues* 4. V/3%0,'() A(4-,(',-/0 If t e t#o parties to t e dispute fail to come to an a%reement$ eit er by t emsel!es or #it t e elp of a mediator or conciliator$ # o a%rees to submit t e dispute to an impartial aut ority$ # ose decision$ t ey are ready to accept* - e essential elements in !oluntary arbitration are1 - e !oluntary submission of dispute to an arbitration9 - e subse(uent attendance of #itness Q in!esti%ations Q - e enforcement of an a#ard may not be necessary*
7 ere trade unions are #ee'$ t e met od of Compulsory Arbitration is used* Compulsory Arbitration is utili0ed %enerally # en t e parties fail to arri!e at a settlement t ou% t e !oluntary met ods* In India$ Compulsory Arbitration is enforced because collecti!e bar%ainin% #as not used for re%ulatin% #a%es Q ot er conditions of employment* It may be said t at Compulsory Arbitration may be at times Q under certain circumstances$ necessary Q desirable* - e nature$ scale Q timin% of state inter!ention s ould be suited to t e needs of different occasions* - e ob&ecti!e of state inter!ention in t e field of industrial relations s ould be to do social &ustice Q ma'e t e #ea'er party e(ually stron% to enable it ultimately to stand Q sur!i!e on its o#n Q settle its differences t rou% ne%ations Q collecti!e bar%ainin%* Compulsory Arbitration is one # ere t e parties are re(uired to arbitrate #it out any #illin%ness on t eir part* Any one of t e parties may apply to t e appropriate %o!ernments to refer t e dispute to ad&udication mac inery*
2(/&/,-/0
7 en t ere are !acancies in an or%ani0ation$ t ey can be filled up by t e internal or e:ternal candidates* - ou% t e or%ani0ation prefers to fill up t e !acancies by t e e:ternal candidates t rou% t e selection procedure$ t e internal candidates may also apply for post and may be tested and selected for i% er le!el &ob in t e or%ani0ational ierarc y at par #it e:ternal candidates* Is suc up#ard mo!ement of an employee a promotion@ Or it is purely selection@ It is purely a selection* If t e or%ani0ation prefers to fill a !acancy only by t e internal candidates$ it assi%ns t at i% er le!el &ob to t e selected employee from #it in t rou% mo!ement can be said as promotion* L D*6-0-,-/0#1 +Promotion is ad!ancement of an employee to a better &ob) better in terms of %rater responsibility$ more presti%e or status$ %reater s'ills and especially increased rate of pay or salary*, ) Paul Pi%ors and C arles A* Myers* ierarc y$ promotion tests* Suc up#ard
accompanied by increased responsibilities$ en anced status and usually #it increased ) Arun Monappa and Mir0a S* Saiyadain* Promotion is t e reassi%nment of a i% er le!el &ob to an internal employee #it dele%ation of responsibilities and aut ority re(uired to perform t at i% er &ob and normally #it performin%* 83 - e employee #ill naturally be dele%ated #it %reater responsibility and aut ority t an # at e as ad earlier* ;3 Promotion normally accompanies i% er pay* Promotion may be temporary or permanent dependin% upon t e or%ani0ational needs and employee performance* i% er pay* - us$ t e main conditions of promotion are1) i% er le!el &ob to an employee t an # at e is presently 23 Reassi%nment of
S P%(2/+* /6 2(/&/,-/0#1 Or%ani0ations promote t e employee #it a !ie# to ac ie!e t e follo#in% purposes1) 23 -o utili0e t e employee"s s'ills$ 'no#led%e at t e appropriate le!el in t e or%ani0ational ierarc y resultin% in or%ani0ational effecti!eness and employee satisfaction* 83 -o de!elop competent spirit and inculcate t e 0eal in t e employees to ac(uired t e s'ills$ 'no#led%e etc* re(uired by i% er le!el &obs* ;3 -o de!elop competent internal source of employees ready to ta'e up &obs at i% er le!el in t e c an%in% en!ironment* <3 -o promote employee"s self de!elopment and ma'e t em a#ait t eir turn of promotions* It reduces labour turno!er* >3 -o promote a feelin% of content #it t e e:istin% conditions of t e company and a sense of belon%in%ness* C3 -o promote interest in trainin%$ de!elopment pro%rammers and in team de!elopment areas* I3 -o build loyalty and to boost morale* K3 -o re#ard committed and loyal employees* J3 -o %et rid of t e problems created by t e leader of #or'ers" unions by promotin% t em to t e officer" le!els # ere t ey are less effecti!e in creatin% problems* M*(-, '+ ' 4'+-+ /6 2(/&/,-/0#1 Merit is ta'en to denote an indi!idual employee"s s'ills$ 'no#led%e$ ability$ efficiency and aptitude as measured from educational$ trainin% and past employment record* - e merits of merit system of promotion are1 23 - e resources of i% er order of an employee can be better utili0ed at a i% er le!el* It result in ma:imum utili0ation of uman resources in an or%ani0ation 83 Competent employees are moti!ated to e:ert all t eir resources and contribute t em to t e or%ani0ational efficiency and effecti!eness ;3 It #or's as %olden and)cuffs re%ardin% employee turno!er$ <3 Furt er it continuously encoura%es t e employees to ac(uire ne# s'ill$ 'no#led%e etc* for all)round de!elopment* 6espite t ese ad!anta%es t e merit systems suffer from some 5*&*(-,* - ey are1 23 Measurement or &ud%in% of merit is i% ly difficult*
83 Many people$ particularly trade union leaders$ distrust t e mana%ement"s inte%rity in &ud%in% merit* ;3 - e tec ni(ues of merit measurement are sub&ecti!e* <3 Merit denotes mostly t e past ac ie!ement$ efficiency but not t e future success* 5ence$ t e purpose of promotion may not be ser!ed if merit is ta'en as sole criteria for promotion* S*0-/( '+ ' 4'+-+ /6 2(/&/,-/0 Seniority refers to relati!e len%t of ser!ice in t e same &ob and in t e same or%ani0ation* - e lo%ic be ind considerin% t e seniority as a basis of promotion is t at t ere is a positi!e correlation bet#een t e len%t of ser!ice in t e same &ob and t e amount of 'no#led%e and t e le!el of s'ill ac(uired by an employee in an or%ani0ation* - is system is also based on t e custom t at t e first in s ould be %i!en first c ance in all benefit and pri!ile%es* S Advantages of seniority as a asis of !ro"otion are: 23 It is relati!ely easy to measure t e len%t of ser!ice and &ud%e t e seniority* 83 - ere #ould be full support of t e trade unions to t is system* ;3 E!ery party trust t e mana%ement"s action as t ere is no scope for fa!oritism and discrimination and &ud%ment* <3 It %i!es a sense of certainty of %ettin% promotion to e!ery employee and of t eir turn of promotion* >3 Senior employees #ill a!e a sense of satisfaction to t is system as t e older employees are respected and t eir inefficiency cannot be pointed out* C3 It minimi0es t e scope for %rie!ances and conflicts re%ardin% promotion* I3 - is system seems to reser!e t e purpose in t e sense t at employees may learn more #it increase in t e len%t of ser!ice*
In s!ite of t#ese "erits$ t#is syste" a%so s&ffers fro" 'ertain %i"itations( - ey are1
23 - e assumption t at t e employees learn more relati!ely #it len%t of ser!ice is not !alid as t is assumption as re!erse effect* In ot er #ords employees learn up to a certain a%e and beyond t at sta%e t e learnin% ability of t e co%niti!e process diminis es* 83 It denominates t e youn% and more competent employees and results in employee turno!er particularly amon% t e dynamic force* ;3 It 'ills t e 0eal and interest to de!elop as e!erybody #ill be promoted #it or #it out impro!ement* <3 Or%ani0ational effecti!eness may be diminis es t rou% t e deceleration of t e uman resource effecti!eness as t e undynamic and old blood* >3 /ud%in% t e seniority t ou% it seems to be in t e t eoretical sense* it is i% ly difficult in practice as t e problems li'e &ob seniority$ company seniority$ 0onalBre%ional seniority$ ser!ice in different or%ani0ations$ e:perience as apprentice trainee$ trainee$ researc er$ len%t of ser!ice not only by days but ours and minutes #ill crop up* - us t e t#o main basic of promotion en&oy certain ad!anta%es and at t e same time suffer from certain limitations* 5ence$ a combination of bot re%arded as an effecti!e basis of promotion* S*0-/(-,)1.%&1&*(-, Mana%ement mostly prefers merit as t e basis of promotion as t ey are interested in enric in% its uman resources* 4ut trade union fa!our seniority as t e sole basis for promotion #it a !ie# to satisfy t e interests of ma&ority of t eir members* 5ence a combination of bot seniority and merit can be considered as t e basis for promotion satisfyin% t e mana%ement for or%ani0ational effecti!eness and employees and trade union for respectin% t e len%t of ser!ice* A balance bet#een seniority and merit s ould be struc' and a ne# basis is to be de!eloped* - ere are se!eral #ays in stri'in% t e balance bet#een t ese t#o basis*!i01) 23 Minimum length of service and merit:.nder t is met od all t ose employees # o complete t e minimum ser!ice$ say fi!e years$ are made eli%ible for promotion and t en merit is ta'en as t e sole criteria for selectin% t e employee for promotion from t e eli%ible candidates* Most of t e of t em may be uman resource consists of mostly
employees from cler'"s position to officer"s position* 83 Measurements of seniority and merit through a common factor. ;3 Minimum merit and seniority:In contrast to t e earlier met ods$ minimum score of merit # ic is necessary for t e acceptable performance on t e future &ob is determined and all t e candidates # o secure minimum score are declared as eli%ible candidates* Candidates are selected for promotion based on t eir seniority only from t e eli%ible candidates*
S B*0*6-, /6 2(/&/,-/0#1 23 Promotion places t e employees in a position # ere an employee"s s'ills and 'no#led%e can be better utili0ed* 83 It creates and increases t e interest of t e ot er employees in t e company as t ey belie!e t at t ey #ill also %et t eir turn* ;3 It creates amon% employees a feelin% of content #it t e e:istin% conditions of #or' and employment* <3 It increases interest in ac(uirin% i% er (ualifications$ in trainin% and in self de!elopment #it a !ie# to meet t e re(uirement of promotion >3 Promotion impro!es employee morale and &ob satisfaction* C3 .ltimately it impro!es or%ani0ational ealt *
S P(/43*&+ =-,7 2(/&/,-/0#1 - ou% promotions benefit t e employee and t e or%ani0ation$ it creates certain problems* - ey are disappointment of t e candidates$ refusal of promotions etc* Promotion disappointment some employees:-
Some employees # o are not promoted #ill be disappointed # en t eir collea%ues #it similar (ualifications and e:perience are promoted eit er due to fa!oritisms or due to lac' of systematic promotion policy* Employee may de!elop ne%ati!e attitude and reduce t eir contributions to t e or%ani0ation and pre!ent or%ani0ational and indi!idual ad!ancement* Some employee refuse promotion:- ere is a %eneral tendency t at employee accept promotion* 4ut t eir are se!eral incidents # ere employees refuse promotions* - ese include promotion to%et er #it transfer to an up#ard place$ promotion t at le!el # ere t e employee feels t at e #ill be (uite incompetent to carry out t e &ob$ dele%ation of un#anted responsibilities$ and # en trade union leader feel t at promotion causes dama%e to t eir position in trade union* - e ot er problems associated #it t e promotion are1 some superiors #ill not relie!e t eir subordinates # o are promoted because of t eir indispensability in t e present &ob and ine(uality in promotional in different departments$ re%ions and cate%ories of &obs* Promotion problems can be minimi0ed t ou% a career counselin% by t e superiors and by formulatin% a systematic promotion policy*
S P(/&/,-/0 2/3-.) E!ery or%ani0ational as to specify clearly its policy re%ardin% promotion based on its corporate policy* - e c aracteristics of a systematic promotion policy are1
23 It s ould be considered t e sense t at policy s ould be applied uniformly to all employees irrespecti!e of t e bac'%round of t e persons$ 83 It s ould be fair and impartial* In ot er #ords it s ould not %i!e room for nepotism$ fa!oritism etc*$ ;3 Systematic line of promotion c annel s ould be incorporated <3 It s ould pro!ide e(ual opportunities fro promotion in all cate%ories of &obs$ departments$ and re%ions of an or%ani0ation >3 It s ould insure open policy in t e sense t at e!ery eli%ible employee s ould be considered for promotion rat er t an a closed system # ic consider only a class of employees C3 It s ould contain clear cut norms and criteria for &ud%in% merit$ len%t or ser!ice$ potentiality etc* I3 Appropriate aut ority s ould be entrusted #it t e tas' of ma'in% final decision K3 Fa!oritism s ould not be ta'en as a basis for promotion J3 It s ould contain promotional counselin%$ encoura%ement$ %uidance and follo#)up re%ardin% promotional opportunity$ &ob re(uirement and ac(uirin% t e re(uired s'ills$ 'no#led%e etc* it s ould also contain reinforcin% t e future c ances in t e mind of re&ected candidates and a pro!ision for c allen%in% t e mana%ements decision and action by employee or union #it in t e limits of promotion policy*
S T)2*+ /6 P(/&/,-/0
As already noted$ a promotion in!ol!es an increase in status$ responsibilities and pay* 4ut$ in certain cases$ only t e pay increases$ and t e ot er elements remain sta%nant* In ot er cases$
t e status only increases #it out a correspondin% increase in pay or responsibilities* 6ependin% on # ic elements increase and # ic remain sta%nant$ promotions may be classified into t e follo#in% types1 ! "ori#ontal Promotion:- is type of promotion in!ol!es an increase in responsibilities and pay$ and a c an%e in desi%nation* 4ut t e employee concerned does not trans%ress t e &ob classification* For e:ample$ a lo#er di!ision cler' is promoted as an upper di!ision cler'* - is type of promotion is referred to as up%radin%= t e position of an employee* $! %ertical Promotion:- is type of promotion results in %reater responsibility$ presti%e and pay$ to%et er #it a c an%e in t e nature of t e &ob* A promotion is !ertical # en a canteen employee is promoted to an uns'illed &ob* - e concerned employee naturally trans%resses t e &ob classification* ;3 Dry Promotions:6ry promotions are sometimes %i!en in lieu of increases in remuneration* 6esi%nations are different but no c an%e in responsibilities* - e promotee may be %i!en one or t#o annual increments*
T('0+6*(
S M*'0-0<#1 -ransfer is defined as + a lateral s ift causin% mo!ement of indi!iduals from one position to anot er usually #it out in!ol!in% any mar'ed c an%e in duties$ responsibility$ s'ills needed or compensation,
-ransfer is also defines as +t e mo!in% of an employee from one &ob to anot er* It may in!ol!e a promotion$ demotion or no c an%e in &ob status ot er t an mo!in% from one &ob to anot er*, 5o#e!er transfer is !ie#ed as c an%e in assi%nment in # ic t e employee mo!es from one &ob to anot er in t e same le!el of ierarc y re(uirin% similar s'ill in!ol!in% appro:imately same le!el of responsibility$ same status and same le!el of pay* - us promotion is up#ard reassi%nment of &ob9 demotion is a do#n#ard &ob reassi%nment # ereas transfer is a latter or ori0ontal &ob reassi%nment* S P%(2/+*+ /6 ,('0+6*(#1 - e transfer in an or%ani0ation may be due to any one of t e follo#in% reasons1 ?23 %ariation in the volume of &or': -ransfers are necessary due to !ariation in t e !olume of #or' in *different departmentsBsections* S orta%e of employees or increase in t e #or' in one department due to different reasons leads to transfer of employees from ot er departments to t at department* 7or'ers are transferred from surplus department to anot er department # ere t ere is s orta%e of staff* ?83 Providing training to employees: -ransfers are made for pro!idin% opportunities to employees for trainin% and de!elopment*
?;3 (ectification of poor placement: -ransfers are necessary for t e rectification of poor placement made in t e initial period* Similarly$ transfers are necessary in order to utili0e t e ser!ices of an employee in t e best possible manner*
?<3 Satisfying personal needs of employees: -ransfers are necessary in order to satisfy t e personal needs ?personal difficulties3 of t e employees* - ey include family problems$ sic'ness$ and education of c ildren and so on* Suc transfers ta'e place especially amon% female employees* Female employees #ant transfer to &oin t eir usbands* - is leads to transfers* 7or'ers demand transfers # en t e climate of t e place of #or' is not suitable to t em* 5ere$ transfers are basically for t e con!enience of employees*
?>3 Meeting mutual needs of employees: -ransfers are$ sometimes$ made in order to meet t e mutual needs of t#o employees* It is a type of mutual e:c an%e and is usually accepted by t e mana%ement*
?C3 Meeting organi#ational needs: -ransfers are necessary in order to meet t e or%ani0ational needs de!eloped out of e:pansion pro%rammers or fluctuations in #or' re(uirements or c an%es in t e or%ani0ational structure or droppin% of e:istin% product lines* For e:ample$ senior and e:perienced #or'ers and super!isors are transferred to ne# plantsBfactories in order to mana%e t e #or' smoot ly*
?I3 Solution to poor performance: -ransfers are$ sometimes$ made # en t e #or'er fails to perform is &ob efficiently* 5e is transferred to a ne# place or post and is %i!en an opportunity to impro!e is performance at a ne# place* 5ere$ transfer is treated as a better alternati!e to outri% t dismissal*
?K3 )voiding fatigue and monotony: -ransfers are made for a!oidin% fati%ue and monotony of #or' in t e case of employees* - e producti!ity of an employee may decline due to monotony of is or er &ob* -o brea' t is monotony$ t e employee is transferred*
?J3 Giving punishment for negligence: -ransfers are sometimes made as a punis ment for ne%li%ence and indiscipline on t e part of an employee*
?2D3 (ectification of poor personal relations: - e relations bet#een t e #or'er and is superior may not be smoot and cordial* - is may affect t e #or' of t e department* One met od to sol!e t is problem is to transfer t e #or'er from t at department to some ot er suitable department* - is transfer may be necessary for remo!al of t e incompatibilities bet#een t e #or'er and isB er boss or bet#een one #or'er and t e ot er*
?223 Providing convenience to employees: -ransfers are made to elp employees to #or' accordin% to t eir con!enience* Suc transfers are also called s ift transfers*
?283 *o provide relief and to punish employees: -ransfers may be made in order to %i!e relief to t e employees # o are o!erburdened or are #or'in% under ea!y ris's or tension o!er a lon% period* Similarly$ on certain occasions transfers are made for indul%in% in undesirable acti!ities* - ey may be made as a disciplinary action for serious mista'es on t e part of employees* - is practice is #idespread mainly in %o!ernment offices and police department* Problem employees are transferred to some ot er &obs or to remote places*
Ty!es of Transfers 4roadly spea'in%$ transfers may be classified into t ree types1 2* - ose desi%ned to en ance trainin% and de!elopment* 8* - ose ma'in% possible ad&ustment to !aryin% !olumes of #or' #it in t e firm* ;* - ose desi%ned to remedy t e problem of poor placement* Specifically$ transfers may be production$ replacement$ !ersatility$ s ift and remedial* )* +rod&'tion Transfers:, As mentioned earlier$ a s orta%e or surplus of t e labour force is common in different departments in a plant or se!eral plants in an or%ani0ation* Surplus employees in a department a!e to be laid off$ unless t ey are transferred to anot er department* -ransfers affected to a!oid suc imminent lay)offs are called production transfers* -* Re!%a'e"ent Transfers:, Replacement transfers$ too$ are intended to a!oid imminent lay)offs$ particularly$ of senior employees* A &unior employee may be replaced by a senior employee to a!oid layin% off t e latter* A replacement transfer pro%rammed is used # en all t e operations are declinin%$ and is desi%ned to retain lon%)ser!ice employees as lon% as possible*
.* Versati%ity Transfers:,
Mersatility transfers are effected to ma'e employees !ersatile and competent i more t an one s'ill* Clerical employees in ban's$ for e:ample$ are transferred from one section to anot er o!er a period of time so t at t ey may ac(uire t e necessary s'ills to attend to t e !arious acti!ities$ at t e ban'* Mersatile operations are !aluable assets durin% rus periods and periods # en #or' is dull* Mersatile transfers may be used as a preparation for production or replacement transfers
/* S#ift Transfers:, Generally spea'in%$ industrial establis ments operate more t an one s ift* -ransfers bet#een s ifts are common$ suc transfers bein% made mostly on a rotation basis* -ransfers may also be affected on special re(uests from employees* Some re(uest a transfer to t e second s ift or t e ni% t s ift in order to a!ail t e free time durin% t e day to ta'e up part time &obs$ alt ou% t is is not permitted by la#*
0* Re"edia% Transfers:, Remedial transfers are affected at t e re(uest of employees and are$ t erefore$ called personal transfers* Remedial transfers ta'e place because t e initial placement of an employee may a!e been faulty or t e #or'er may not %et alon% #it is or er super!isor or #it ot er #or'ers in t e department* 5e or s e may be %ettin% too old to continue in is or er re%ular &ob$ or t e type of &ob or #or'in% conditions may not be #ell)adapted to is or er present ealt or accident record* If t e &ob is repetiti!e$ t e #or'er may sta%nate and #ould benefit by transfer to a different 'ind of #or'* S R*'+/0+ 6/( ,('0+6*(# -ransfers are of basically of t ree cate%ories$ !i0$ employee initiated transfer$ and company initiated transfer and public initiated transfers* )* E"!%oyee initiated transfer:, - ese transfers are also 'no#n as personal transfers* - ese transfers are primarily in t e interest of t e employee and accordin% to is con!enience and desire* Furt er$ t is transfer can be classified into temporary and permanent transfers* a! *emporary transfers: )
- e reasons for employee initiated temporary transfers are1 23 6ue to ill ealt or in!ol!ement of employee in accidents$ 83 6ue to family problem li'e ta'in% care of old parents$ ;3 6ue to ot er ad oc problem li'e pursuin% i% er education$ +! Permanent transfers:- ere are se!eral reasons for employee initiated permanent transfers* Employee prefers transfers1 23 6ue to c ronic ill ealt or permanent disablement caused by accident$ 83 6ue to family problems li'e ta'in% care of domestic affairs in is nati!e place$ ;3 7it a !ie# to correct is #ron% placement* Employee may not be interested #it t e #or' or #or'in% condition or en!ironment of is present &ob and ence may re(uire a transfer$ <3 In order to reli!e im from t e monotony or boredom caused due to doin% t e same &ob for year to%et er$ >3 -o a!oid conflict #it is superior* If most of t e employees #or'in% under t e same superior re(uest for a transfer$ t e situation s ould be corrected by ot er means li'e de!elopin% t at superior in interpersonal s'ills etc* rat er t an transferrin% t e subordinates$ C3 7it a !ie# to searc for c allen%in% and creati!e &ob$ I3 7it a !ie# to searc for &ob #it opportunities for ad!ancement to a i% er le!el &ob$ opportunities for ad!ancement to a i% er le!el &ob$ opportunities for financial %ains etc*
-* Co"!any initiated transfer:, -ransfer is also at t e initiati!e of t e company* - ey can be classified into temporary and permanent* a3 *emporary transfers: reasons for t e company initiated temporary transfers are1 23 6ue to temporary absenteeism of employees$ 83 6ue to fluctuation in (uality of production and t ereby in #or' load$ ;3 6ue to s ort !acations* b3 Permanent transfer: - reasons for t e company initiated permanent transfer are1 23 C an%es in t e (uality of production$ lines of acti!ity$ tec nolo%y$ or%ani0ational structure as discussed earlier$
83 -o impro!e t e !ersatity of employees$ ;3 -o impro!e t e employee &ob satisfaction$ <3 -o minimi0e bribe order)processin% corruption* .* +& %i' initiated transfers:, Public also initiate t e transfers %enerally t rou% t e politiciansB %o!ernment for t e follo#in% reasons1 23 If an employee"s be a!ior in t e society is a%ainst t e social norms order) processin% if e indul%es in any social e!ils* 83 If t e function of an employee is a%ainst t e public interest* - e ma&our dra#bac' of public initiated transfer is t e politicalisation of t e issue* Some employees may be transferred fre(uently because of political !ictimi0ation and company initiated transfer of some employees may be stopped due to political fa!oritism* - is dra#bac' is more se!ere in %o!ernment departments and public sector unit*
Benefit of transfer: -ransfers benefit bot t e employees and t e or%ani0ation* -ransfer reduce employee"s monotony$ boredom etc* and increase employees &ob satisfaction* Furt er t ey impro!es employee"s s'ills$ 'no#led%e etc* t ey correct erroneous placement and interpersonal conflicts* - us$ t ey impro!e employee"s morale* Furt er t ey prepare t e employee to meet t e or%ani0ational e:i%encies and meet t e fluctuation in business and or%ani0ational re(uirements* - us$ t ey en ance uman resource contribution to or%ani0ational effecti!eness* +ro %e"s of transfer: 6espite t ese benefit some problems are associated #it transfers* - ey are1
23 Ad&ustment problem to t e employee to t e ne# &ob$ place$ en!ironment$ superior and collea%eoues$ 83 -ransfer from one place to anot er cause # ic incon!enience and cost to t e employees and is family members relatin% to ousin%$ education to c ildren etc* ;3 transfer from one place to anot er result in loss of Mondays$ <3 Company initiated transfer result in reduction in employee contribution >3 6iscriminatory transfer affects employees" morale$ &ob satisfaction$ commitment and contribution* 5o#e!er$ t ese problems can be minimi0ed t rou% formulatin% a systematic transfer policy* -ransfer policy1 or%ani0ation s ould specify t eir policy re%ardin% transfers* Ot er#ise superiors may transfer t eir subordinates arbitrarily if t ey do not li'e t em* It causes frustration amon% employees* Similarly$ subordinates may also re(uest fro transfer e!en for t e petty issues* Most of t e people may as' for transfer to ris' less and easy &ob and places* As suc or%ani0ation may find it difficult to mana%e t e transfer policy* Systematic transfer policy s ould contain t e follo#in% items1 23 Specification of circumstances under # ic an employee #ill be transferred in t e case of company initiated transfer* 83 Specification of superior # o is aut ori0ed and responsible to initiate a transfer ;3 /obs from and to # ic transfers #ill be made based on t e &ob specification$ description and classification etc* <3 - e re%ion order)processin% unit of t e or%ani0ation #it in # ic transfer #ill be administrated* >3 Reasons # ic #ill be considered for personal transfers t eir order of priority etc* C3 Reasons for mutual transfer of employees* I3 Norms to decide priority # en t#o order)processin% more employees re(uest for transfer li'e priority of reasons$ seniority* K3 Specification of basis for transfer li'e &ob analysis* Merit$ len%t of ser!ice* J3 Specification of pay$ Allo#ances$ benefit etc* t at are to be allo#ed to t e employee in t e ne# &ob* 2D3 Ot er facility to be e:tended to t e transferee li'e special lea!e durin% t e period of transfer* Special allo#ance for pac'a%in% lu%%a%e$ transportation etc*
Generally$ line mana%ers administer t e transfers and personnel mana%ers assist t e line mana%ers in t is respect*
D*&/,-/0
- e remainin% type of internal mobility is demotion* It is t e opposite of promotion* 6emotion is t e reassi%nment of a lo#er le!el &ob to an employee #it dele%ation of responsibility and aut ority re(uired to perform t at lo#er le!el &ob and normally #it lo#er le!el pay* Or%ani0ations use demotion less fre(uently as it affects employee career prospects and morale* S N**5 6/( 5*&/,-/0+# 6emotions are necessary for follo#in% reasons1
)* Uns&ita i%ity of t#e e"!%oyee to #ig#er %eve% 1o s: Employees are promoted based on t e seniority and past performance* 4ut$ some of t e employees promoted on t ose bases may not meet t e &ob re(uirements of t e i% er le!el &ob* In most cases employees are promoted to t e le!el of t e incompetence* Some employees selected for i% er le!el &obs may pro!e to be incompetent I doin% t at &ob* Suc employees may be demoted to t e lo#er le!el &obs # ere t eir s'ill$ 'no#led%e and aptitude suit to t e &ob re(uirements* -* Adverse &siness 'onditions: Generally ad!erse business conditions force t e or%ani0ation to reduce (uality of production$ #it dra#al of some lines of products$ closure of certain department order) processin% plants* In addition$ or%ani0ations resort to economy dri!es* Conse(uently or%ani0ations minimi0e t e number of employees* /unior employees #ill be retrenc ed and senior employees #ill be demoted under suc conditions* .* Ne2 te'#no%ogy and ne# met ods of operation demand ne2 and #ig#er %eve% s3i%%s( If t e e:istin% employees do not de!elop t emsel!es to meet t ose ne# re(uirements$ or%ani0ations demote t em to t e lo#er le!el &obs # ere t ey are suitable* For e:ample$ teac er andlin% 2D-5 class #ere demoted to t e le!el of K -5 class teac ers # en t e syllabus #ere re!ised and t e teac ers #ere found misfit e!en after trainin% in one sc ool in And ra Prades * /* E"!%oyees are de"oted on dis'i!%inary gro&nds( - is is one of t e e:treme steps and as suc or%ani0ations rarely use t is measure* - ou% t e demotion seems to be simple it ad!ersely affects t e employee morale* /ob satisfaction etc* as it reduces employee status not only in t e or%ani0ation but also in t e society in addition to reduction in responsibility aut ority and pay* 5ence$ t ere s ould be a systematic demotion policy* S D*&/,-/0 2/3-.)# Or%ani0ation s ould clearly specify t e demotion policy* Ot er#ise t e superiors demote t e employees accordin% to t eir # ims and fancies* Systematic demotion policy s ould contain follo#in% items1
23 Specification of circumstances under # ic an employee #ill be demoted$ li'e reduction in operations$ indisciplinary cases* 83 Specification of a superior # o is aut ori0ed and responsible to initiated a demotion ;3 /obs from and to # ic $ demotions #ill be made and specification of lines order) processin% ladders of demotion* <3 Specification of basis for demotion li'e len%t of ser!ice$ merit order)processin% bot * >3 It s ould pro!ide for open policy rat er t an a closed policy* C3 It s ould contain clear cut norms for &ud%in% merit and len%t of ser!ice* I3 Specification of nature of demotion i*e*$ # et er it is permanent order)processin% temporary if it as a disciplinary action it s ould also specify t e %uidelines for determinin% t e seniority of suc demoted employee*
PARTICIPATIVE MANAGEMENT
<3 R'-+-0< -05%+,(-'3 2(/5%.,-/0# As #or'ers %enerally ta'e interest in t eir #or' # en t ey are %i!en due importance$ respect Q opportunity of self) e:pression* >3 C(*',-0< 23',6/(& 6/( 5-(*., 0*</,-',-/0+# It is needed in order to create a platform for direct ne%otiations Q collecti!e decisions* C3 C(*',-0< (*+2/0+-43* '22(/'.7 '&/0< =/(C*(+# -o ma'e #or'ers more responsible$ disciplined Q constructi!e in t eir approac in relation to t e acti!ities of t e company* I3 E0./%('<-0< ./&&%0-.',-/0 4*,=**0 *&23/)*( > =/(C*(+# It enables mana%ement to understand t e #or'ers point of !ie# at t e time of decision) ma'in%* It remo!es suspicion amon% #or'ers* K3 R'-+-0< *&23/)**M+ &/('3*# For raisin% t e morale of employees Q in order to use t eir 'no#led%e$ s'ills Q talents for t e benefit of t e company* J3 I0,(/5%.-0< -05%+,(-'3 5*&/.('.)# 7or'ers participation acts as a means for ac ie!in% t e dream of industrial democracy* - ey are consulted as e(ual partners in t e production process* - is leads to industrial democracy$ # ic is one useful supplement of political democracy*
le!el* - is &oint consultati!e committee meets fre(uently for discussion on common problem before #or'ers and t e company* After discussion$ &oint decisions are ta'en and suc decisions are bindin% on bot t e parties* Matters li'e #a%e payment$ bonus$ trainin%$ discipline$ #elfare facility$ #or'in% conditions etc* are discussed in suc meetin%s* 7or'ers committees are e:tremely popular and effecti!e in France and En%land* In India$ t ere is statutory pro!ision for t e establis ment of #or'er committees under t e industrial disputes act$ 2J<I* Suc committees are constituted in lar%e number of industrial unit* Meetin% of suc committees are also arran%ed* 5o#e!er$ t ey are neit er effecti!e nor popular in India* As a result$ participati!e mana%ement t rou% t is mec anism is not effecti!e or purposeful in India* Many mana%ers feel t at suc committees a!e only a nuisance !alue* In addition to #or's committee$ many ot er committees are formed* 5o#e!er$ t ey are not effecti!e as a%encies of participati!e mana%ement* 2. @/-0, &'0'<*&*0, ./%0.-3+ F@MC+!# - ese council are similar to #or's committees #it e(ual representation to employer and employees* 7or'ers e:press t eir !ie#s$ problems suc discipline$ trainin%$ remo!al of #or'ers$ common as #elfare facility9 olidays$ %rie!ances$
rationali0ation$ e:pansion pro%rammes$ etc* are discussed in t e meetin%s of /MCs* Suc &oint consultati!e committees e:ist in .R and S#eden* In India$ participati!e mana%ement is mainly t rou% &oint mana%ement councils* /MCs are in addition to #or's committees # ic are statutory in nature*
.nfortunately$ t e /MCs are not operation effecti!ely in India due to limited interest and initiati!e in t eir functionin% by mana%ements and #or'ers* - ey are not used for e:c an%e of information$ !ie#s$ su%%estions$ etc* but for (uarrels and eated e:c an%es bet#een t e representati!es of mana%ement and #or'ers* Absence of cordial industrial relations in spite of /MCs indicates t eir o!erall failure* /MCs are mostly consultati!e bodies and t is type of #or'ers participation is of loose type* - e su%%estions put for#ard by representati!es are not bindin% on t e mana%ement* Suc councils ser!e no useful purpose* - ey only pro!ide platform for discussions*
3. C/12'(,0*(+7-2 F P'(,-.-2',-/0 ,7(/%<7 /=0*(+7-2! # In co)partners ip$ #or'ers are con!erted into s are olders of t e company ?by offerin% e(uity s ares to t em3 and are allo#ed to participate in t e mana%ement li'e ot er s are olders* - e company may %i!e financial assistance to #or'ers to purc ase e(uity s ares* - ey can elect t eir representati!es on t e 4oard of 6irectors* 7or'ers are also allo#ed to attend meetin%s of t e company and participate in t e discussions* Motin% ri% ts are also %i!en to employees* In t is met od$ employees participate in t e mana%ement as co)o#ners i*e* s are olders* - is %i!es t em an opportunity to participate in t e decision ma'in% and policy framin% of t eir company at t e i% est le!el* Co)partners ip is also a met od for introducin% industrial democracy* 5ere$ #or'ers are %i!en i% er status* - ey #or' in t#o different capacities as #or'ers and as co)o#ners* In India$ t e e:periment of co)partners ip is not popular* 7or'ers s o# limited interest in purc asin% s ares of t eir company as and # en offered* Mery fe# #or'ers purc ase t e s ares and &oin t e company as members* Naturally$ t e participation of #or'ers in t e mana%ement is #ea' and ineffecti!e* Many companies in India offer t eir s ares to employees but t e response of t e employees is not encoura%in%* - is su%%ests t at co)partners ip as a met od of participati!e mana%ement is not effecti!e B popular in India* 4. E&23/)** D-(*.,/(+# 5ere$ t#o or t ree representati!es of #or'ers are ta'en on t e 4oard of 6irectors of t e company* - e employee directors B #or'ers directors are elected by #or'ers and t ey e:press t e !ie#s of #or'ers in t e meetin%s of t e 4oard* 5ere$ employee directors act as connectin% lin' bet#een #or'ers and top le!el mana%ement* Suc participation ensures cordial industrial relations* - e representati!e of #or'ers can put t e !ie#s of #or'ers before t e directors and can also safe%uard t e interests of #or'ers* As a result$ t e personnel policies #ill be fair and fa!ourable to #or'ers* .nfa!ourable decisions to #or'ers #ill be a!oided and better treatment #ill be ensured to t em*
- is mec anism of #or'ers participation is no# used e:tensi!ely in t e public sector underta'in% in India as per t e initiati!e ta'en by t e %o!ernment* 7or'ers directors are no# appointed in companies li'e 5industan Antibiotics Ltd*$ and 5M- Ltd* - is sc eme also e:ists in t e case of nationali0ed ban's$ co)operati!e ban's* 6CM$ -atas and some more companies from t e pri!ate sector* - is met od of participati!e mana%ement as many limitations* Representation on t e 4oard does not substantially en ance t e participation of #or'ers in t e mana%ement of t e company* In addition$ t e #or'er director may not be able to play a constructi!e role due to limited 'no#led%e and e:perience* - e #or'er director may en&oy t e status on par #it ot er directors but #ill feel inferior to ot ers due to is s ortcomin%s* 5is contribution may not be satisfactory for t e #or'ers and also for t e mana%ement* Finally$ 7or'ers representati!es on t e 4oard are minority* - ey may not be able to protect t e interests of #or'ers as decisions are ta'en on t e basis of ma&ority !ote* 5. S%<<*+,-/0 P(/<('&&* " S.7*&*# .nder su%%estion pro%ramme$ #or'ers are as'ed to %i!e t eir su%%estion to t e mana%ement on !arious administrati!e and ot er matters suc as mac ine utili0ation$ #aste mana%ement$ ener%y conser!ation and safety measures* - eir su%%estions are considered by a &oint committee representin% #or'ers$ eads of departments and tec nical e:perts* - e su%%estions # ic are suitable are accepted* Suc su%%estions are for impro!ement in t e e:istin% or%ani0ational setup* Suitable su%%estions relatin% to production acti!ities$ cost control$ (uality impro!ement$ #or'in% conditions$ etc* are promptly accepted and e:ecuted* In addition$ re#ards are also %i!en to t ose # o ma'e constructi!e su%%estions* For collectin% su%%estions$ su%%estion bo:es are 'ept in all departments* Su%%estion sc eme of participati!e mana%ement encoura%es #or'ers to t in' ?indi!idually or collecti!ely3 and participate in raisin% t e efficiency of t e or%ani0ation* In India$ -atas$ 6CM and ot er industrial %roups a!e introduced su%%estion sc eme* On May occasions$ #or'ers directly connected #it #or' %i!e creati!e and practical su%%estions # ic are useful to t e mana%ement in different #ays* - ey may raise producti!ity or reduce t e cost of production* Su%%estion
sc eme #ill %i!e %ood results if #or'ers are encoura%ed to t in' and ma'e concrete su%%estions* - is idea of participati!e mana%ement is no# put into operation t rou% (uality circles # ic Companies* are popular in /apan and no# function in may Indian
6. :/(C*(+ ./12'(,0*(+7-2 " A%,/ M'0'<*&*0,# In t is e:treme form of labour participation$ #or'ers ta'e o!er t e industrial unit and mana%e it completely on co operati!e basis* Naturally$ t e entire mana%ement is by t e #or'ers t emsel!es* - is met od is called +Auto)mana%ement,* One e:ample in India under t is cate%ory is t at of Ramani -ubes Limited* - is leadin% unit #as closed do#n in 2JK> due to sic'ness* 7or'ers suffered ea!y loss* No#$ #or'ers a!e contributed to its capital and a!e become its o#ners* - e Ramani Employees" .nion too' initiati!e in startin% t is unit #it t e co)operation of financial institution form Ct April$ 2JKJ* - e Supreme Court also allo#ed t e #or'ers to run t e unit* - is is t e first e:ample of participati!e mana%ement in t e manufacturin% sector in India* It is one si%nificant constructi!e de!elopment in t e field of trade unionism in India* - e Go!ernment of Ma aras tra as ta'en a decision to and o!er sic' industrial units to #or'ers for re%ular functionin% on co)operati!e basis* 7. E%'3-,) C-(.3*# Fuality circle consist of a small number of employees # o comes to%et er on !oluntary basis #it one item on t e a%enda i*e* to impro!e (uality or to raise producti!ity or to a!oid #asta%es$ etc* t is form of participation is !oluntary* As a practice$ meetin%s are eld once in t e #ee' lastin% for about as our* Member of (uality circle is %i!en free and to sol!e problem related to t e (uality$ if t ey fail t ey can re(uest to mana%ement to depute an e:pert to sort out t e problem* - is circle i% ly pro!ed to be i% ly successful because t e problem is sol!ed by member t emsel!es t rou% t#o #ay communication and brainstormin% seriously and studies t em effecti!ely and promptly* - e su%%estion s ould be implemented$ if found suitable* 8. C/33*.,-8* B'(<'-0-0<#
Collecti!e bar%ainin% is t e process in # ic t e representati!e of t e employer and employer and employees meet to%et er to ne%otiate a contract %o!ernment bot t e parties* It results into si%nin% an a%reement t ereby restrictin% eac party t at it cannot ta'e unilateral decision armin% t e interest of t e ot er party* - is sort of &oint meetin% can brin% fruits pro!ed barra%in% is done in t e ri% t spirit #it positi!e attitude* Participation brin%s bot t e parties to%et er and impro!es t e understandin% t us ma'in% t e #ay for t e t#o #ay dialo%ue to sort out t e problems* Collecti!e bar%ainin% is a better alternati!e to stri'e and industrial disputes* It is peaceful and democratic met od for sol!in% t e problem and demands for #or'ers t rou% direct ne%otiation bet#een t e representati!e of #or'ers and mana%ement* A stron% trade union can protect t e interest of #or'er can more effecti!ely t rou% direct ne%otiation and consultation rat er t an t rou% disputes and stri'e # ic are normally armful to #or'ers$ employer and society at lar%e* 9. E&2/=*(*5 T*'&# 7 en t e aut ority is dele%ated to t e employees its called empo#erin%* In t is sense$ employment ta'es place # en employees en&oy po#er and t ey e:perience a sense of o#ners ip and control o!er t e &obs* Employees # en empo#ered$ understandin% t at t e &ob belon% to t em* As t ey are competent to spea' on t e &ob$ t ey feel responsible* - is appens to moti!ate t em and t ey %o out of t e #ay to #or'* Employees become (uality conscious and contribute to (uality impro!ement in product and ser!ices* Information is s ared at e!ery le!el leadin% to impro!ed performance* 10. @/4 *03'(<*&*0, '05 I/4 *8'3%',-/0# /ob enlar%ement is t e process of increasin% t e scope of t e &ob by addin% more tas's to it* As tas's are related$ employees to %et t e opportunity to ma'e %rater use of t eir mental and p ysical s'ills* /ob enric ment is desi%nin% a &ob in suc a #ay t at it pro!ide t e employee %rater autonomy for plannin% and control is o#n performance* /ob enric ment ma'es t e &obs more interestin% and c allen%in%*
- e main ob&ecti!e of &ob enric ment and &ob enlar%ement is to force t e #or'er from boredom # ic occurs because of e:cessi!e speciali0ation* 4ot t e &ob enric ment and &ob enlar%ement are considerin% met od of participati!e mana%ement as t ey pro!ide freedom to eac limited and restricted* - e basis purpose of abo!e noted sc eme of participati!e mana%ement is to associate t e #or'er #it t e decision)ma'in% process* 6ifference met ods are use in t e different countries as per t e situation a!ailable* - e met od used for #or'ers participation is not impotent* 7or'ers participation in mana%ement may be !oluntary or statutory* Moluntary participation is al#ays better and more effecti!e* Statutory labour participation is not effecti!e as it is mec anical and also imposed on bot t e parties by force* employee to use is &ud%ment* - is freedom is course
E:istence of atmosp ere of mutual trust and confidence is t e sine (uo non of participati!e mana%ement* Fair participation is not possible # en t e mutual confidence is absent* 4ot parties are a%ree to stay to%et er in an atmosp ere of understandin%* - is facilitates participati!e mana%ement in practice*
<* G*0%-0* %(<* 6/( ./1/2*(',-/0# Genuine desire on t e part of employer and #or'er to discuss$ understand t e !ie#s and come to certain acceptable decision is necessary for success of participati!e mana%ement* - is must be supplemented by desire to %enuine desire to s are aut ority and responsibility in mutually a%reed to sp ere* - e outloo' of employer and #or'er must c an%e and become fa!ourable for mutual trust and understandin%* >* P*'.*6%3 ',&/+27*(*# Labour mana%ement relation s ould be a cardinal or at least t ere s ould be a no tension in t e relation* Acti!e participation of #or'ers in mana%ement is possible under suc peaceful atmosp ere* It is &ust not possible # en t ere are disputes and stri'e in t e industrial unit* C* C3*'( %05*(+,'05-0< /6 /4I*.,-8*# Employers and #or'ers must understand clear t e ob&ecti!e of suc participation* - e ob&ecti!e must be clearly define and complementary in c aracters* Employer s ould not ta'e suc participation as an imposed liability and #or'er s ould not use it merely for e:pressin% t ere %rie!ances and demands* Participation s ould be for ac ie!e t e ob&ecti!e # ic are accepted by bot t e parties and also beneficial for bot t e parties* I* M*'0-0<6%3 +7'(-0< /6 -06/(&',-/0# 7or'er representati!e s ould a!e ade(uate tec nical$ financial and mana%erial 'no#led%e and information* - is #ill ma'e labour participation effecti!ely* For t is$ a suitable trainin% needs to be %i!en to t e #or'ers representati!es* Mana%ement s ould also pro!ide all rele!ant information to employees for t eir consideration* - ere must be a free flo# of information and communication bet#een mana%ement
and #or'er* - is a!oids suspicion and distrust and ensures purposeful participati!e mana%ement* K* P'(,-.-2',-/0 /6 +%2*(8-+/() +,'66# Super!isory staff s ould be %i!en a place on t e &oin mana%ement council* Similarly$ sub&ect earmar'ed for collecti!e bar%ainin% must be 'ept outside for t e &oint consultation* Participati!e mana%ement #ill be effecti!e if t e entire labour force co!ered by suc participation* In addition$ t e representati!e of t e #or'er must be dra#n from t emsel!es* - e participation of trade union leaders s ould be discoura%e as t e approac of suc leaders may not be positi!e or fair* Real representati!e of #or'ers can put for#ard t e !ie#s of all #or'ers #it confidence* J* E5%.',-/0 '05 ,('-0-0< /6 =/(C*(+# 7or'ers education and trainin% s ould be ma'e si%nificant contribution to meanin%ful participati!e mana%ement* -rade union and %o!ernment s ould pro!ide suc education and trainin% to t e #or'ers* - is #ill ma'e t e concept of participati!e mana%ement amon% popular amon% t e #or'ers and #ill ensure its success* 2D* V/3%0,'() .7'('.,*( 5*+-('43*# Participati!e mana%ement s ould not be made compulsory but s ould be 'ept !oluntary in c aracter* It s ould not be %o!ernment sponsored* It #ill not #or' fruitfully if it is imposed on t e bot t e parties* - us !oluntary condition c aracter is one pre)condition for t e success of participati!e mana%ement* - e need of suc participation must be felt by bot t e parties and t ey s ould introduce t e sc eme of participation on !oluntary basis*
I&2/(,'0.* /6 2'(,-.-2',-8* &'0'<*&*0,# - e importance of participati!e mana%ement is uni!ersally accepted and efforts are bein% made for introducin% suc participation t rou% suitable a%encies and met ods* Participati!e mana%ement as #ider socio)economic importance as it %i!en !arious ad!anta%es to #or'ers$ employers and society at lar%e* Suc participation %i!es i% er status to #or'ers and enable t em to t in' and e:press t eir !ie# on t e #or'in% of t eir company* Industrial peace and cordial industrial relation are also establis ed t rou% participati!e mana%ement* In addition$ #or'ers" participation brin%s industrial democracy in reality* Participati!e mana%ement is important it satisfies t e psyc olo%ical needs of self e:pression of #or'ers* E!en t e process of decision ma'in% is made democratic t rou% uman element in industrial mana%ement* Participati!e mana%ement introduces a ne# set of !olume for t e #or'ers and employers in # ic po#er is to be replaced by persuasion and compulsion by co) operation* Employee participation is useful for raisin% industrial production and producti!ity* It elps consumer in an indirect manner* - e national economy also %ets certain benefits # en industrial peace and armony e:its o!er a lon% period* In brief$ t e concept of participati!e mana%ement is important because of economics$ social and uman !alues connected #it it* - e ILO as %i!en morale support to employee"s participation and as ad!ocated its adoption in all countries* Efforts are bein% made in all countries in t is re%ards* In t e countries of #est$ t is e:periment is reasonable successful # ile in de!elopin% countries includin% India$ t e pro%ress is not satisfactory e!en # en consultati!e mac inery e:ists in many countries* t e #or'ers participation* It brin%