Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(e)
ey facts
&hat are the facts found by the court that truly make a difference" &hat are the facts that the parties advanced as key facts" 'ow did the court deal with the facts that the parties characteri)ed as key facts"
(f) Issues
&hat did the court take to be the issues" &hat did the parties advance as issues" 'ow did the court deal with this proffer of issues" &hich were the issues of fact" &hich were the issues of law"
&hat conclusions of law *'12$+,- . did the court arrive at" Conclusions of law 3 when these resolve matters in issue 3 are doctrinal. &hat comments on the interpretation and application of law did the court make that were not really in the issue" *1biter dicta.
(i) $isposition
'ow did the court dispose of the case" &hat are contained in the decretal portion *fallo. of the (udgement" &hat logical connection is there between the ratio and the disposition" 1ther possible case analysis 4uestions !o% do provisions of la% and state&ents of fact figure in the reasoning of the Court' !o% does the Court arrive at its conclusions' !o% does the Court refute positions it does not accept'