Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NIAS
to a presentation on
Namma Metro
Externalities Mono Corridors
Bangalore - Population
( in Lakhs)
105 85 67 56.2 41.3 29.2 16.7
1971
1981
1991
2001
2005
2011
2021
1971- 2001 : Census 2005 extrapolated & 2011-2021 as per draft CDP
Bangalore - Vehicles
3% Au tos
others 6%
TRAFFIC PROBLEMS
Air Pollution
Daily average annually micro gms / m3
205 165 120 79 16 59 59 16 19 15 2005-06* Limit 60 60 158 166 140
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
SO2
Source : KSPCB Web Extract
NOX
SPM
*Avg 9 months
Noise Pollution
Permitted Noise level Present Average Noise level Peak Noise level recorded
100 m
Health Problems
Respiratory Problems Bronchitis Asthma Wheezing Ophthalmic Problems Irritation Redness Burning
Source: Indian Journal of Pediatrics Jan 2006
1 in 3 school going children suffers from respiratory problems DRIVING BANGALORE AHEAD
Traffic Survey
Land use pattern and development Socio-economic characteristics Nature, extent and capabilities of the transportation system
2002
Distribution Of trips by Mode and Purpose without Walk Work Car 2W Auto Bus Cycle Others Total 90607 704629 133060 586870 26476 4774 1546416 Education 7789 84535 17084 281700 21151 3190 415449 Others 36468 122507 51835 318628 2105 2236 533779 NHB 2514 7028 15008 39462 700 863 65575 Return 133484 887952 126166 1207253 49285 10872 2415012 Total 270862 1806651 343153 2433913 99717 21935 4976231
36% 50%
7%
2002
Hourly v ariation of v e hicle at M ysore Road
Number of vehicles 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
-7 00
-9 00
70 0
-1 90 0
-1
-1
60 0
80 0
-1
16 00
18 00
12 00
14 00
Time Interval
20 00
10 00
-2
-1
10 0
10 0
30 0
50 0
2002
Hourly variation of vehicle at Chord Road
Number of vehicles 8000 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0
-7 00
-9 00
30 0
50 0
10 0
70 0
-1 90 0 20 0
-1
-1
60 0
80 0
-1
-1
18 00
14 0
12 0
10 0
Time Interval
16 0
-2
10 0
2002
H o u r ly v a r ia t io n o f v e h ic a le s a t K u v e m p u R o a d
Number of vehicales 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 D ir1 D ir2 B o th
00
00
70
30
10
50
-7
-9
-1
90
-1
-1
-1
60
80
00
00
00
00
00
10
16
12
14
18
Tim e Inte r va l
20
00
-2
-1
10
(phpdt)
phpdt
<20,000 Upto 15000 <10000 15,000 25,000 > 25,000
TYPE OF MRTS
High Capacity Bus System Monorail
Place of Use
Bogota, Curitiba Tokyo, Seattle , Kualalumpur, Chongqing Lubin, Gdansk( Poland) Kualalumpur, Manila Singapore
About 105 Cities
Metro Rail
MRTS
MONORAIL
Transit Systems
SKY BUS
Transit Systems
TRAMWAY
Transit Systems
Electric Trolley Buses
Distance Up to 250Mts. 250 to 500 Mts. 500 to 750 Mts. Up to 1 Km. Total
Sl No 1 2 3. 4. 5
Section Toll Gate Magadi Rd Vidhana Soudha M.G.Road Malleswaram- Swastik Magadi Rd- City Rly Stn Majestic - Chickpet
City
Passenger/km
(Million passengers per km)
Car Two Wheeler Auto rickshaw LCV Bus Truck Cycle Cycle Rickshaw
Energy Cost Per Passenger Km( in Rs) 0.66 0.19 3.66 0.21 0.16
Axle load/ tare weight Axles 4 Metro (Bangal ore) 4 LRT Mono Axle Load 14.50 Tare Weight 34.00
9.00
29.00 13.00
Civil structures
Mono Concrete Piers Track Beams Elevated Stations Central concrete Piers Prestressed concrete girder (deck/U type) for double line Ballastless slab track(welded) with elastic fastenings Circular Tunnels with concrete lining Elevated & underground stations. Compact earth formation Concrete bridges Tunnels Ballast & Track (welded) with elastic fastenings Stations DRIVING BANGALORE AHEAD
Metro
Heavy Rail
LRT
Max.speed KM Op:speed KM Vehicles/ transport Station Spacing (Metro)
Metro History
London Sub Way in 1863 Budapest, Sub way in 1896. Paris Tube rail in 1900. New York sub way on Oct 27, 1904. Berlin Urban railway in 1906. Tokyo Sub way in 1927. Washington D.C. in 1969. Kolkata Metro Nov 12, 1984. Singapore Metro Nov 7, 1987. Delhi Metro Dec. 2003. Bangalore Metro by Dec 2009/Sept 2011
DRIVING BANGALORE AHEAD
Metro Gauge
City
New York London Paris Tokyo Shanghai Bangkok Berlin Tehran Sau Paulo Beijing
Source : Janes Urban Transport
Gauge
SG SG SG SG SG SG SG SG BG SG
Gauge of Cities
Type
Metro Metro Metro Metro Metro Metro Metro Metro Metro Metro
Standard Gauge ( SG) - 1435 mm Russian Gauge (RG) - 1524 mm Broad Gauge (BG)- 1676 mm Other Gauge (1000,1067,2060mm) Total
City
New York YEREVAN SAU PAULO TASHKENT LOS ANGELES BILBAO GLASGOW DURBAN MOSCOW TOKYO
73 14 10 8 105
Gauge
1435 mm (SG) 1524 mm (RG) 1676 mm (BG) 1524 mm (RG) 1435 mm (SG) 1000 mm 1200 mm 1067 mm 1524 mm (RG) 1067 mm
Namma Metro
EAST WEST CORRIDOR NORTH-SOUTH CORRIDOR TOTAL ELEVATED AT GRADE (At Ground Level) UNDERGROUND GAUGE TRACTION SPEED NO. OF STATIONS TRAVEL TIME HEAD WAY
18.10 KMS 14.90 KMS 33.00 KMS 25.65 KMS 00.65 KMS 6.70 KMS Standard Gauge 750V dc Third Rail Max 80Kmph ; Avg. 32Kmph 32 (25 elevated, 7 UG) 33 / 28 Mins. (end to end) 4 Mins at start ;later 3 Mins
Contd.
ORR
MAHALAKSHMI LAYOUT
RAJAJINAGAR
KUVEMPU ROAD OLD MADRAS ROAD SWASTIK CMH ROAD CRICKET STADIUM TRINITY CIRCLE ULSOOR M G ROAD INDIRANAGAR B HALLI TERMINAL
MALLESWARAM
MAGADI ROAD
CENTRAL COLLEGE
HOSAHALLI
TOLL GATE
MAJESTIC CHICKPET
VIJAYANAGAR K R ROAD DEEPANJALI NAGAR LALBAGH MYSORE ROAD TERMINAL SOUTH END CIRCLE
JAYNAGAR
CORRIDOR
% OF LENGTH IN CURVES
EAST-WEST
18.10KMS
14.70KMS
3.40KMS
44.30%
NORTH-SOUTH
14.90KMS
11.60KMS
3.30KMS
39.70%
Geometries of track
Gauge (standard gauge) Distance between two tracks Minimum radius of horizontal curves Elevated section Underground section At stations Max. gradient 1435 mm (4 ft 8.5 inches) 4.20 m
Coaches
Max permissible speed Commercial speed Coach body 80 kmph 32 kmph Stainless steel Length 20.80 m Width 2.88 m Height 3.80 m About 50 sitting and 306 standing (at 8 persons per sq.m area) 14.5 tonnes. One 4 of 180 KW each in Motor max 1.0 m /sec/sec max 1.1 m/sec/sec (normal) 1.3 m/sec/sec(emergency) Air-conditioned Automatic door closing Vestibuling PA system
Carrying capacity
Axle load Class of accommodation Traction motors coache. Acceleration Deceleration Additional features
Train Operation
2011 31000 4 Min 6 CARS E-W 3 CARS N-S 180
10.20 LAKHS/DAY 16.10 LAKHS/DAY 15% of traffic
Funding
Rs. Crs.
Sl. No. 1 2 3 4 5
Particulars EQUITY SUBORDINATE DEBT Sub Total (1+2) Senior term Debt Grand Total (3+4)
TOTAL 1918.50 (30%) 1598.75 (25%) 3527.25 (55%) 2877.75 (45%) 6395.00 (100%)
YEAR
PASSENGER- MEAN TRIP LENGTH KM in PASSENGERS (IN KMS) Lakhs/Km (LAKHS/DAY) OF CORRIDOR
NO. OF
2011 2021
10.20 16.10
2.18 3.47
7.07 7.12
Rs.
16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0 to 2 2 to 6 6 to 12 12 to 15 15 to 18 6 3 7 5 8.5 7 Delhi (2006) Bangalore ( 2011) BMTC 2005 10 8 15 13 11.5 12 9 14 15
Km
Fixed Cost ppkm & Fare / km (in INR)- Guided Mass Rapid Transport
20.00
18.00
16.00
14.00
12.00
Fixed Cost Fare/ km
10.00
8.00
6.00
4.00
2.00
0.00 Elevated Bangkok UG Mono KL Mixed Shanghai Mono Chongqing Mixed Bangalore( Proj)
PPKM
PPKM
700.00
600.00
500.00
OCPPKM
400.00
FCPPKM in ps
300.00
200.00
100.00
3,000.00
2,500.00
2,000.00 Tot al revenue Op Cost s in Cr 1,500.00 Fixed cost s in Cr PBDT in cr PAT in Cr 1,000.00
500.00
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 (500.00)
Financial Indicators 5th year Cost per Pass KM Rs a. Operational b. Fixed c. Total Profitability Rs Crores a. PBDIT b. PAT 0.88 1.50 2.38 10th year 1.47 1.35 2.82
157 (26)
463 241
Sensitivity Analysis
Base Increase in project cost 10% Ridership reduction by 10% 5% on both
DSCR Minimu m
1.14
1.06
0.93
1.00
3.14 7.54
2.76 7.00
2.95 7.29
Reach
10 8 9 6
17 14 13 9
18 18 15 15
31 31 22 22
Voltage Tapping Station 66KV A Station 66KV Hoody 66KV 66KV REMCO Peenya
North South
66 KV
ELECTRICAL NETWORK
Sl No. 1 2 3 4
TYPE OF SUB -STATION RECEIVING SUB-STATIONS TRACTION SUB-STATIONS AUXILLARY SUBSTATIONS DG Sets ( for standby at all
stations)
DRIVING BANGALORE AHEAD
Nos. 5 18 34 34
Schedule of Constructions
Reach Via duct Stations Other Components( Rolling Stock, Elec, S&T) April 08March 10 July 09Nov 10 Mar 10 Aug 11 Sept 10 Oct 11 Dec 10 Dec 11
1 2 3
Byppanahalli-Cricket Stadium Yeshwanthpur -Swastik U/G Section Cricket Stadium-City Market Swastik City Market City market Mysore Rd City market R.V Road
Jan 07 -June 09 Feb 08 Feb 10 Apr 08 Oct 10 (Tunnel) Mar 08 Mar 10 May 08 - Apr 10
April 07June 09 Feb 08 Feb 10 Apr 08 Oct 10 Mar 08 Mar 10 May 08Apr 10
4 5
NAMMA METRO
Metro Gains
Safe and Comfortable travel Lesser fossil fuel burnt in signal points Reduction in greenhouse gases Reduction in Travel Time Reduction in cost of road maintenance CBD could grow more efficiently Reduction in Road Rage!
Externalities
Sl No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 SAVINGS IN PUBLIC/PRIVATE- CAP/OP COSTS REDN IN VEHICLE OPERATING COSTS LESS STRAIN ON ROADS SAVINGS IN TRAVELLING TIME REDUCTION IN NUMBER OF ACCIDENTS REDUCTION IN POLLUTION Total Rs.Crs* per annum 347 253 128 289 78 60 1155
IRR 8.20%, ERR 22.3%, NOISE LEVELS WILL COME DOWN BY 30% DRIVING BANGALORE AHEAD
Present Status
Task
Land & Rehabilitation Survey & Geo-Tech Investigation Utility Shifting Afforestation
% of work completed
25% 100% in 7Km & 30% in balance 40% in 7 kms 100%
General Consultant
Seamless Travel
Integration with KSRTC,BMTC,IPTs, Railways,Airport. Public parking to be provided at major Metro stations. Bus bays at other stations. Feeder bus services to be provided to all the Metro stations. Common ticketing for Metro & feeder buses.
1. Byappanahalli Airport links, Railway, KSRTC, BMRC, IPTs 2. Peenya 3.Yeshwanthpur 4.Swastik 5.RV Road 6.Mysore Road KSRTC,BMTC,IPTs Railway,KSRTC,BMRC, IPTs KSRTC,BMTC, IPTs BMTC, Mono at Banashankari KSRTC,BMTC,Mono
Construction Cost
Sl No 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Particulars Completed Construction Cost*Rs Crores 600 2593 603 478 186 1054 5514 398 5912 483 6395
Land Civil Engineering Works Electrical Works & VAC Signalling,Telecommunication & AFC works Depots Rolling Stock Construction Cost General Charges & Contingency Total Construction Cost IDC, etc TOTAL
Basic Cost April 2005 *Annual escalation @ 5% per annum considered at DPR prices.
Project to be commissioned in phases. Full commissioning in 5 years from starting construction (in Jan Jan 2007)
Safety
For Operations :
Automatic Train Protection (ATP) Automatic Train Operation (ATO) Continuous Automatic Train Control (CATC)& Cab Signaling
For Commuters :
Automatic Door Closures Plug swing type. Coaches with fire retarding materials, low smoke & toxicity Side walk way in tunnels and elevated structures for emergency evacuation Emergency doors at both ends of drivers cab.
Land required- 228.61Acres Private lands notified for acquisition - 26.13 Acres GOI lands - 32.23 Acres GOK lands- 106.30 Acres PSUs - 63.96 Acres
RESIDENTIAL
1 2 3 4 5 6 Shifting Allowance*Avg. Inconvenience Allowance* Avg. Transitional Allowance Rental Income lost Right to salvage material TDR Rs 15000/- one time payment Rs 30000/- one time payment Rs 75000/- one time payment Rs 10/- per sq. ft. lost Full As applicable
COMMERCIAL
1 2 3 4 5 6 Shifting Allowance*Avg. Loss Of Business*Avg. Business Re-establishment*Avg. Rental Income lost Right to salvage material TDR Rs 15000/- one time payment Rs 75000/- one time payment Rs240/- per Sq.Ft. for area lost Rs 20/- per sq. ft. lost Full As applicable
* Shifting Allowance, Inconvenience Allowance are provided both to owner and the tenant. * For persons continuing to stay in the balance of the property, 80% of inconvenience allowance is paid AND OTHER RELAVANT ALLOWANCES ARE PAID
Transport Hubs
Feeder services
Commuters
Price, comfort, Safety, speed
Namma Metro
Substitute modes
CTTS Study
To elicit traffic & transport characteristics of the city Modal split & parking characteristics Short term plan including traffic & parking management Medium term plan including grade separator, widening of roads & public transport improvements. Long term plan developing track route network integrating flyovers roads & peripheral ring roads etc. Integrated multi modal transport system including extension of metro, bus rapid transit system & integrating them with other routes like mono rail, bus etc.
Monorail
Four Corridors identified Mono rail to act as feeder to Metro To operate below 15000 PHPDT Concessionaire by 2007 To be integrated with Metro Stations
Monorail Corridors
Mono Corridors
Corridor I
Kanakapura Road to Mysore Road Junction with a Connection (T) from Kathriguppe to National College.
Corridor II
Bannerghatta National Park to Adugodi,
Corridor III
Jnanabhararthi to Mysore Rd. (Outer Ring Road) with a T connection to the Toll gate on Magadi Road.
Corridor IV
Tumkur Road on Outer Ring Road to Bellary Road.
U L A G A R A K S A M NA