, ,

.' '
" ,1755
"" :
: , ,
1
".
" " -

.Ceci est moi : -
. , ,
. ,
" " ,
. : "",
,
.
;
.
" 2010 /

23

 .
. ,
. .
-
.

.
, -
" " -
,
.
2
.
" " , -
-
; ,
, .
") beati possidentes "(
.
,
.

-
,
-
. ""
.
"" ,

. "" ,
"" ,
.
.

24

 .

"" .
. .
"" , ,
. -
-
.
:
,
.
,
.

,
.1990-1917 ,

, , .
- -
,
.
" : " . ' , ,
3, ,1840
-
. ,

- .
, ,"
" ,
. ,
,
. , ""

" 2010 /

25

 :
.

. -
- ."
" ,
,
. ,
" ",
.

. , ,
; .

"" .

.
.
""
. , ,
:
.
.
- ,
.
,
;
.
,
.
, ""
, :
26

 ? :
,
" .
" , ,
" " .

, .

,
.
, , ,
.
,
.
,
.
.
,
,
.

-
,
, ,
, .

.
-
, .

.
, .
, :
" 2010 /

27

 -
.
,
,
.
:
,

. ,
.

.
, ,
"" ,
, . "
" . ,
.
" " -
.
, ,
, .
. ,
, , ,
-
.
, .

,

.

28

 ,
, .
, ;
, ; ,
-
.

.
,

; , - -
.
,
,
.
. ,
.

, ,
.
, .

.
-
,
.
. , ,
- .
" : " .
.
,
, "" . .

" 2010 /

29

 -
.
.

.
, . Frankfurter
Allgemeine Zeitung 13 .2009

.1' ' " , " , ,

) : ,(1993 ,' .161
.2 , : , ) : ,(1947 ,
' .606-592
Pierre Joseph Proudhon, What IIss Property? eds. and trans. Donald Kelley and Bonnie .3
).Smith (Cambridge: Cambridge, 1993

30