You are on page 1of 94

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS

OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

TAMIL NADU STATE JUDICIAL ACADEMY, Chennai.

Compiled by #$%$

Page1

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

Page2

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

Contents

Sl.No. 1 2

Page No. 05 52

Particulars Subject Index Nominal Index

Page3

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

Page4

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

INDE&
SL.NO. CAUSE TITLE AR'ITRATION ACT ALTERNATIVE REMEDY 1 Sanjana M Wig vs Hindustan Petro Corporation Ltd ARBITRATION ACT 1996 Section 7 2 Jagdish Chander Vs Section 8 ' 4 5 $ %gri (o)d &*i!s Ltd vs Sri La+sh!i ,nits and Wovens and "rs -harat Se.a Sansthan vs /P &)e0troni0s Corporation Ltd Hindustan Petro)eu! Corpn Ltd V Pin+0it1 Mid.a1 Petro)eu!s P Manohar Section 9 # 8 4 10 %dhuni+ Stee)s Ltd v "rissa Manganese and Minera)s Pvt Ltd Hi!adri Che!i0a)s 3ndustries Ltd vs Coa) 5ar e6ining Co Mahat!a (andhi Saha+ra Sa++are ,ar+hane vs 7ationa) Heav1 &ngg Coop Ltd 8 %nr 7 Srinivasa v ,uttu+aran Ma0hine 5oo)s Ltd Section 11 11 12 1' 14 15 %0e Pipe)ine Contra0ts Pvt Ltd v -PCL 2atar S.it0hgears Ltd v 5ata 9inan0e Ltd 8 %nr 3ron 8 Stee) Co Ltd v 5i.ari oad Lines 200# 5 SCC '04 2000 8 SCC 151 200# 5 SCC #0' 200# 5 SCC 245 M%7/ SC 1#'$ 2004 200# # SCC 125 200# 8 SCC 110 200# $ SCC 4#0 %3 2004 SC 221# edd1 and -ros V Maharashtra ,rishna Va))e1 2ev Corp and "rs 200# ' SCC $8$ 200# # SCC #'# 200' $ SCC 50' %3 2004 SC 1##$ a!esh Chander and "rs 200# $ SC%L& '25 2005 8 SCC 242 CITATION

Maharshi 2a1anand /niversit1 8 %nr v %nand Coop LC So0 Ltd 8 %nr S-P 8 Co vs Pate) &ngineering Ltd 8 %nr ARBITRATION ACT-1940 Section 30

1$

a!a0handra edd1 8 Co Vs /o3

%3 2004 SC 2$24

DOCTRINE OF SUBSTITUTE 1# -PCL vs 5he (reat &astern Shipping Co Ltd 200# 12 SC%L& 24#

Page5

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. NON SPEAKING AWARD 18 14 20

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

&ngineer S1ndi0ate vs State o6 -ihar 8 "rs Mar+6ed Vanaspati and %))ied 3ndustries vs /"3 aipur 2eve)op!ent %uthorit1 vs Cho+ha!a) Contra0tors CI(IL LA) ADVERSE POSSESSION

200# ' SCC 44 200# 11 SC%L& 1'8 1484 ' SC 144

21 22

-ondar Singh and "rs Vs 7iha) singh -onder and %nr vs He! Singh dead :1 L s and "rs CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE Amended CPC

2004 1 LW #0$ 2004 ' LW 1#4

2' 24

Sa)e! %dvo0ate -ar %ssn Vs /"3 Sa)e! %dvo0ate -ar %ssn VS /"3 Fraud

%3 %3

200' SC 184 2005 SC ''5'

25 2$ 2#

a! Chandra Singh V Savitri 2evi and "rs Santosh V Jagat a! and %nr

200' 8 SCC '14 M%7/ SC 004# 2010 %3 1444 SC 85'

SP Chenga)vara1a naidu vs Jagannath Section 9 of CPC

28 24

2hu)a:ai vs state o6 MP ai;ada 5opandas 8 %nr v (ora+hra! (o+a)0hand Section 10 of CPC

2005 ' SCC 42# %3 14$4 SC 1'48

'0 '1 '2 '' '4

Chitiva)asa Jute Mi))s Vs< Ja1pee

e.a Ce!ent

%3 2004 SC 1$8# %3 2004 SC 2''4 %3 1448 SC 1452 %3 2005 SC 242 %3 2004 SC '504

(upte Cardia0 Care 0enter and Hospita) Vs ")1!pi0 Phar!a Care Pvt Ltd 3ndian -an+ Vs Maharashtra State Co=operative Mar+eting 9ederation Ltd 7ationa) 3nstitute o6 Menta) Hea)th and 7euro S0ien0es Vs C<Para!esh.ara Pu+hraj 2< Jain and "rs< Vs (opa)a+rishna Section 11 of CPC

'5 '$ '#

P V Jose V ,ani0+a!!a) 2ead :1 L s Pandit 3sh.ardas V St o6 MP 8 "rs Saroja v Chinnusa!1 2ead :1 L s 8 %nr

2000 4 SCC '50 14#4 4 SCC 1$' %3 200# SC '0$#

Page6

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. '8 '4 Singhai La) Chand Jain 2ead Vs

CAUSE TITLE ashtri1a S.a1a! Se.a+ Sangh Patna

CITATION 144$ ' SCC 144 %3 200# SC 1828

Su:hash Mahadevasa Ha:i: vs 7e!asa %!:asa 2har!adas 8 "rs Section 20 of CPC

40

"! Pra+ash Srivastava Vs< /"3 8 %nr Section 24 of CPC

200$ $ SCC 20#

41 42

7ahar 3ndustria) &nterprises Ltd 8 "rs Vs Hong ,ong 8 Shanghai -an+ Shri adhe1 Sh1a! Vs Sh1a! -ehari Singh

2004 4 C5C #4 %3 14#1 SC 2''#

Section 47 of CPC 4' 44 45 4$ Janaparedd1 Lat0han 7aidu V Janaparedd1 San1asa!!a Moti La) -an+er V Mahraj ,u!ar Mah!ood Hasan ,han Prati:ha Singh and %nr V Shanti 2evi Prasad and %nr Seth Hira)a) Patni v Sri ,a)i 7ath Section 48 of CPC 4# Pentapati Chinna Ven+anna and "rs V Pentapati -engararaju and "rs Section 80 of CPC 48 44 50 51 52 5' 54 %!ar 7ath 2ogra Vs /nion o6 3ndia /"3 (hansh1a! 2ass and "rs Vs 2o!inion o6 3ndia (hu)a! asoo) and %nr Vs State o6 Ja!!u and ,ash!ir and %nr aghunath 2as Vs /"3 Sa.ai Singhai 7ir!a) Chand Vs /"3 State o6 Punja: Vs (eeta 3ron 8 -rass Wor+s Ltd State o6 Serai+e))a Vs< /"3 Section 89 - ADR and Lok Ada at 55 5$ 5# 58 State o6 Punja: and %nr V Ja)our Singh and "rs State o6 Punja: and "rs V Phu)an ani and %nr aj %3 %3 %3 %3 2008 SC 1204 2004 SC 4105 200$ SC '084 200# SC 15$1 %3 14$' SC 424 %3 14$4 SC 1454 %3 14$' SC 155$ %3 14$8 SC 108# %3 200' SC $4' %3 14$2 SC 144

%3 1484 SC 1004 %3 148' SC 1188 %3 14$4 SC $#4 %3 14$$ SC 10$8 %3 14#8 SC 1$08 %3 1451 SC 25'

State o6 Punja: and "rs V Shri (anpat /"3 V %nanto 2ead and %nr Section 92 of CPC

54 $0
Page7

Sri Je1ara! &du0ationa) 5rust and "rs Vs % ( S1ed Mohideen and "rs Sri Vedagiri La+sh!i 7arasi!ha S.a!i 5e!p)e v 3nduru Patta:hira!i edd1

%3 2010 SC $#1 %3 14$# SC #81

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

$1 $2

Order 21 Rule 29 Shau+at Hussain a)ias %)i %+ra! and "rs V -hunesh.ari 2evi 2ead :1 Lrs and "rs
Sri ,rishna Singh V Mathura %hir and "rs Section 9! of CPC

%3 14#' SC 528 %3 1482 SC $8$

$'

"rissa H1dro Po.er Corporation Ltd Vs Sant.ant Singh (i)) Section 100 of CPC

200$ 4 SCC $$'

$4 $5 $$

C % Su)ai!an and "rs Vs State -an+ o6 5ravan0ore %).a1ee and "rs Cha0+o and %nr Vs Mahadevan a!avi)aso! (randhasa)a Versus 7SS ,ara1oga! Section 14! of CPC

%3 %3

200$ SC 2848 200# SC 24$#

2000 5 SCC $4

$#

>i)a Singh and "rs V Ha;ari and "rs Section 148 A of CPC

%3 14#4 SC 10$$

$8

3)a Vipin Pand1a Vs S!ita %!:a)a) Pate) Section 1"1 of CPC

%3 200#SC2404

$4 #0 #1 #2 #' #4

%rjun Singh Vs Mohindra ,u!ar and "rs Pra+ash H<Jain Vs Ms< Marie 9ernandes Sneh (upta Vs 2evi Sarup and "rs State o6 Punja: vs 2arshan Singh State o6 /P and "rs Vs oshan Singh ?2ead@ :1 L s< and "rs<

%3 14$4 SC 44' %3 200' SC 4541 2004 $ SCC 144 %3 200' SC 41#4 %3 2008 SC 1140 %3 2002 SC 154'

State o6 West -enga) and "rs Vs ,aran Singh -ina1a+ and "rs #rder 1 Ru e 8 of CPC

#5

7ara1an -hag.antrao (osavi -a)aji.a)e Vs (opa) Vina1a+ (osavi and "rs #rder 1 Ru e 10 of CPC

%3 14$0SC100

#$ ## #8 #4 80

a! Prasad 2agdura! Vs Vija1 ,u!ar Moti)a) Mira+han.a)a and "rs a!esh Hiranand ,undan!a) Versus Muni0ipa) Corporation (reater -o!:a1 a;ia -egu! Vs Sahe:;adi %n.ar -egu! and "thers Savitri 2evi Versus 2istri0t Judge (ora+hpur Su!ti:ai 8 "rs vs Paras 9inan0e Co 8 "rs

%3 14$#SC2#8 1442 2 SCC 524 %3 1458 SC 88$ 1444 2 SCC 5## %3 200# SC '1$$

Page

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. #rder ! Ru e 17 of CPC 81 82 8' 84 85 8$ 8# 88 84

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

%jendraprasadji 7 Pande 8 %nr Vs S.a!i ,eshavpra+eshdasji 7 8 "rs %ndhra -an+ vs %-7 %!ro -an+ 7V 8 "rs -, 7ara1ana Pi))ai vs Para!es.aran Pi))ai 8 %nr Heera)a) vs ,a)1an Ma) 8 "rs a!0handra Vs 2a!odar 5ri!:a+ 5an+sa)e 2 and "rs evajeetu -ui)ders and 2eve)opers V 7ara1anas.a!1 and Sons and "rs Shiv (opa) Sah vs Sita a! Saraugi 8 "rs /"3 vs Pra!od (upta 8 "rs /sha -a)ashahe: S.a!i 8 "rs vs ,iran %ppaso S.a!i 8 "rs #rder 7 Ru e 11 of CPC

%3 200# SC 80$ %3 200# SC 2511 %3 2000 SC $14 %3 1448 SC $18

200# $ SCC #'# 2004 10 SCC 84 %3 200# SC 14#8 %3 2005 SC '#08 %3 200# SC 1$$'

40 41 42 4' 44 45 4$

Ma1ar H, Ltd 8 "rs vs ".ners 8 Parties vesse) MV 9ortune &*press 8 "rs P, Pa)anisa!1 Vs 7 %ru!ugha! 8 %nr Pre! La)a 7ahata 8 %nr vs Chandi Prasad Si+aria Sa)ee! -hai 8 "rs v St o6 Maharashtra 8 "rs Sopan Su+hdeo Sa:)e and "rs Vs %sst Charit1 Co! and "rs Sudhir ( %ngur 8 "rs v M Sanjeev 8 "rs 5 %rivandanda! vs 5V Sat1apa) 8 %nr #rder 8 Ru e 1

200$ ' SCC 100 2004 4 LW #5 %3 200# SC 124# 200' 1 SCC 55# %3 2004 SC 1801

%3 200$ SC '51 %3 14## SC 2421

4# 48

%dit1a Hote)s P Ltd vs -o!:a1 S.adeshi Stores Ltd 8 "rs 7 Jadi and -rothers 8 "rs vs Su:hash0handra #rder 8 Ru e !

%3

200# SC 15#4

%3 200# SC 25#1

44 100

Jag Mohan Cha.)a 8 anr vs 2era

adha S.a!i Satsang 8 ors

%3 %3

144$ 2222 200# SC 10

ohit Singh 8 "rs v St o6 -ihar 7o. St o6 Jhar+hand 8 "rs #rder 8 Ru e 9

101

")1!pi0 3ndustries Vs Mu))a Hussain1 -hai Mu))a %+:era)) #rder 9 Ru e ! of CPC

2004 4 SC%L& ''8

102 10'

(auhati /niversit1 Versus 7ihar)a) -hatta0harjee La) 2evi and %ns Vs Vaneeta Jain and "rs

1445 $ SCC #'1 %3 200# SC 25##

Page!

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. #rder 9 Ru e 13 of CPC 104 105 10$

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

-a)dev Singh V Surinder Mohan Shar!a and "rs 7aresh Chandra %gar.a) Versus -an+ o6 -aroda Sahara 3ndia 8 "rs vs M C %ggar.a) H/9 #rder 13 Ru e 10 of CPC

200' 1 SCC '4 2001 ' SCC 1$' %3 200# SC 12$1

10#

La+sh!i and %nr V Chinna!!a) A #rder 20 Ru e 2

a11a!!a) and "rs

%3 2004 SC 2'52

108

S Madanappa and "thers Vs Chandra!!a and %nr #rder 20 Ru e 3

%3 14$5 SC 1812

104

Vinod ,u!ar Singh V -anaras Hindu /niversit1 and "rs #rder 20 Ru e 9 to 19

%3

1488 SC '#1

110

La+sh!i a! -hu1an V Hari Prasad -hu1an and "rs #rder 20 Ru e 12

200' 1 SCC 14#

111

(opa)a+rishna Pi))ai and "rs V Meena+shi %1a) and "rs #rder 20 Ru e 14

%3 14$# SC 155

112 11' 114

2attara1a V Shai+h Mah:oo: Shai+h %)i and %nr Jodha1an V -a:u a! and "rs

%3 %3 %3

14#0 SC #50 148' SC 5# 1484 SC 20#'

Johri Singh V Su+h Pa) Singh and "rs #rder 20 Ru e 18 of CPC

115 11$

Hasha! %::as Sa11ad vs /s!an %::as Sa11ad 8 "rs Muthangi %11anna V Muthangi Jaggarao and "rs #rder 21 Ru e 10

200# 2 SCC '55 %3 14## SC 242

11#

9C3 Vs S 7 7agar+ar #rder 21 Ru e 11

%3

2002 SC 808

118

-has+aran V Sreedharan #rder 21 Ru e 1" and 1!

2002 $ Supre!e '84

114 120

2hani a! (upta and "rs V La)a Sri a! and %nr (anga:ai (opa)das Mohata v< 9u)0hand and others

%3 1480 SC 15# %3 144# SC 1812

Page1"

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. #rder 21 Ru e 22 121

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

Sat1anarain -ajoria and anr V a!narain 5i:re.a) and anr #rder 21 Ru e 32

144' 4 SCC 414

122

Bashpa) Singh Vs V333 %dd) 2ist Judge and "rs #rder 21 Ru e 3"

1442 2 SCC 504

12' 124 125 12$

Moha!ed Masthan V So0iet1 Congregation -ros S Heart and %nr Prithvi0hand a!0hand Sa:)o+ V S B Shinde

%3 %3 %3

200$ SC 1#0$ 144' SC 1424 2002 SC 804

atan La) Jain and "rs V /!a Shan+ar V1as and "rs avinder ,aur V %sho+ ,u!ar and %nr #rder 21 Ru e 4!

200' 8 SCC 284

12# 128

Manna)a) ,hetan and "rs V ,edar 7ath ,hetan and "rs S1ndi0ate -an+ Vs Vija1 ,u!ar and "rs #rder 21 Ru e 48 and "0

14## 2 SCC 424 %3 1442 SC 10$$

124

Mohit -hargava vs -harat -hushan -hargava 8 "rs #rder 21 Ru e "4

%3

200# SC 1#1#

1'0

-arnes 3nvest!ents Ltd and "rs V #rder 21 Ru e "7

aj , (upta and "rs

%3 2001 SC 2818

1'1

7an01 John L1ndon V Pra:hati La) Cho.dhur1 and "rs #rder 21 Ru e "8

%3 148# SC 20$1

1'2

(hansh1a!das and anr V "! Par+ash and anr #rder 21 Ru e !4

%3 1444 SC 1242

1'' 1'4

La) Chand Vs V333th %dd) 2ist Judge and ors S S 2a1ananda V , S 7agesh #rder 21 Ru e !! ao and "rs

%3

144# SC 210$

144# 4 SCC 451

1'5

2esh -andhu (upta V 7 L %nand 8 ajinder Singh #rder 21 Ru e 84 to 8!

1444 1 SCC 1'1

1'$

-a)ra! son o6 -hasa #rder 21 Ru e 89 to 92

a! V 3)a! Singh and ors

%3 144$ SC 2#81

1'# 1'8
Page11

Cha))a!ane Hu0hha (o.da V M

5iru!a)a and %nr

2004 1 SCC 45' %3 1440 SC 1828

Chinna!a) and ors V P %ru!ugha! and anr

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 1'4 140 141 142 14' 144 145 14$ 14# 148 144 150 151 2adi Jagannadha! Vs Ja!!u)u

CAUSE TITLE a!u)u and "rs %3 %3 %3 %3 %3 %3 %3 %3 %3 %3 %3 %3 %3

CITATION 2001 SC 2$44 148# SC 144' 14#8 SC 418 14$# SC $08 1441 SC ##0 14#4 SC 1''1 1442 SC '85 1441 SC 1825 200$ SC 18#1 1482 SC 484 1444 SC 158' 14#1 SC 2''# 1454 SC 1'$2

(anpat Singh 2ead :1 Lrs V ,ai)ash Shan+ar and "rs Hi!!at:hai V Jana+ i+hi)a) and "rs

aj V (urdia) Singh and %nr

Jas.ant)a) 7atvar)a) 5ha++ar Vs Sushi)a:en Mani)a) 2angar.a)a and ors ,a1ja1 3ndustries P Ltd Vs %sne. 2ru!s P Ltd and "rs ,u!ar Sudhendu 7arain 2e: Vs enu+a -is.as and ors ao Harshe and "rs

Sagar Mahi)a Vid1a)a1a Sagar Vs Pandit Sadashiv Sahe: ,han Vs Mohd Busu6uddin and "rs

Sardar (ovindrao Mahadi+ and %nr Vs 2evi Sahai and "rs Sat1anarain -ajoria and anr Vs Shri a!narain 5i:re.a) and anr

adhe1 Sh1a! Vs Sh1a! -ehari Singh

/"3 V ,ishori)a) (upta and -ros #rder 21 Ru e 97

152 15' 154 155 15$ 15#

%shan 2evi and %nr Vs Phu).asi 2evi and "rs -a:u)a) Vs aj ,u!ar and "rs

200' 12 SCC 214 %3 %3 %3 144$ SC 2050 1445 SC '58 1448 SC 24#$

-han.ar La) Vs Sat1anarain and anr (hasi a! and "rs Vs Chait a! Saini and "rs

P Janardhana ao Vs ,annan and "rs Shreenath and %nr Vs #rder 22 Ru e 3 and 4 ajesh and "rs

2004 11 SCC 511 %3 1448 SC 182#

158 154 1$0 1$1 1$2

Piara Singh and "rs Vs 7atha Singh and "rs S %!arjit Singh ,a)ra dead :1 Lrs and "rs Vs Pra!od (upta dead :1 Lrs and "rs 5 (nanave) V 5 S ,anagaraj and %nr 5he %ndhra -an+ Ltd V Srinivasan and "rs

%3 %3 %3 %3 %3

1441 SC 1524 200' SC 2588 2004 SC 2'$# 14$2 SC 2'2 14$2 SC 84

5he State o6 Punja: Vs 7athu a! #rder 22 Ru e 10 of CPC

1$'

%!it ,u!ar Sha. and %nr Vs 9arida ,hatoon and %nr #rder 23 Ru e 1 of CPC

2005 11 SCC 40'

1$4
Page12

2.ari+a Prasad V 7ir!a)a and "rs

2004 14 SC%L& $82

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. #rder 2! Ru e 1 of CPC 1$5

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

Pada! Sen and %nr V 5he State o6 /P #rder 32 A Ru e 3

%3 14$1 SC 218

1$$

Jagraj Singh V -irpa) ,aur #rder 33 Ru e 1

%3 200# SC 208'

1$#

Vija1 Pratap Singh vs 2u+h Haran 7ath Singh 8 %nr= #rder 39 Ru e 1

%3 14$2 SC 441

1$8 1$4 1#0 1#1 1#2 1#' 1#4 1#5 1#$ 1## 1#8 1#4 180

% Ven+atasu::iah 7aidu v S Che))appan 8 "rs 2a)pat ,u!ar 8 anr v Prah)ad Singh 8 ors 2ora: Ca.asji Warden v Coo!i Sora: Warden 8 ors (angu:ai -a:)1a Chaudhar1 8 "rs v Sitara! -ha)0handra Su+htan+ar 8 "rs (ujarat -ott)ing Co Ltd 8 ors v Co0a Co)a Co 8 ors (ujarat -ott)ing Co Ltd and "rs V Co0a Co)a Co and "rs HPCL Vs Sri Sri!an 7ara1an and %nr J M -is.as Vs 7 , -hatta0harjee and "rs ,u)dip Singh v Su:hash Chander Jain 8 "rs Mahadeo Sav)ara! She)+e 8 "rs v Pune Muni0ipa) Corp 8 %nr Manohar La) Chopra v ai -ahadur ao aja Seth Hira)a)

%3 2000 SC '0'2 %3 144' SC 2#$ %3 1440 SC 8$# %3 148' SC #42 %3 1445 SC 2'#2 %3 %3 %3 1445 SC 2'#2 2002 SC 2548 2002 SC 1$44

%3 2000 SC 1410 1445 ' SCC '' 14$2 Supp 1 SC 450 1444 SCW 2801 %3 144$ SC 144$

Morgan Stan)e1 Mutua) 9und v ,arti0+ 2as ajni:ai a)ias Mannu:ai v ,a!)a 2evi 8 "rs #rder 39 Ru e 2A

181 182

Sa!ee ,han Vs -indu ,han 5a1a::hai M -agasar.a))a and anr V Hind u::er 3nd Pvt Ltd #rder 39 Ru e 3A

%3 %3

1448 SC 2#$5 144# SC 1240

18'

% Ven+atasu::iah 7aidu Vs S Cha))appan and "rs #rder 40 Ru e 1

%3 2000 SC '0'2

184 185 18$

-rig Sa.ai -ha.ani Singh V 3ndian Hote)s Co Ltd and ors &verest Coa) Co!pan1 P Ltd V St o6 -ihar Hira)a) Patni V Loon+ara! Sethi1a and "rs

%3 %3 %3

144# SC 218' 14## SC 2'04 14$2 SC 21

Page13

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 18# 188

CAUSE TITLE 3C3C3 V ,arnata+a -a)) -earings Corp Ltd and "rs S Sa)ee!a -i V S P1ari -egu! and %nr #rder 41 Ru e 11 %3

CITATION 1444 SC '4'8

2000 4 SCC 5$0

184

M(M5 o6 2evi 5heatre V Vish.anath aju #rder 41 Ru e 22 and 33

2004 # SCC ''#

140 141

-anarsi and "rs V a! Pha) Chandra!ohan a!0handra Pati) and "rs V -apu ,o1appa Pati) 2ead thro Lrs and "rs #rder 47 Ru e 1

200' 4 SCC $0$ 200' ' SCC 552

142

e+ha Mu+herjee Vs %shis ,u!ar 2as and "rs Summar$ Suit%

2005 ' SCC 42#

14' 144 145 14$ 14#

2e6ian0e ,nitting 3ndustries Pvt Ltd Vs Ja1 %rts "7(C Vs S-3 "verseas -ran0h -o!:a1 aj 2ugga) Vs a!esh ,u!ar -ansa)

200$ 4 MLJ 4'4 SC %3 %3 %3 %3 2000 SC 2548 1440 SC 2218 200' SC 1'22 1448 SC 2'1#

ajni ,u!ar Vs Suresh ,u!ar Ma)hotra and %nr Suni) &nterprises and %nr Vs S-3 Co!!er0ia) and 3nternationa) -an+ Ltd COURT FEES ACT

148 144 200 201

Co!!er0ia) %viation and 5rave) Co and "rs v Vi!)a Panna)a) Sathappa Chettiar v Sha!sher Singh v a!anathan Chettiar ajinder Prashad and "rs

%3 1488 SC 1$'$ %3 1458 SC 245 %3 14#' SC 2'84 %3 148# SC 2085

5ara 2evi v Sri 5ha+ur adha ,rishna Maharaj EASEMENT ACT

202

Hero Vinoth !inor Vs Sesha!!a) INSOLVENCY ACT

%3 200$ SC 22'4

20'

Ven+ata

eddi and "rs V Pothi eddi

%3 14$' SC 442

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY Co&$ Ri'(t 204 205 20$ &astern -oo+ Co 8 "rs Vs 2- Moda+ 8 %nr &ntertain!ent 7et.or+ ?3@ Ltd Vs Super Cassette 3ndust (ra!ophone Co!pan1 o6 3ndia Ltd V -irendra -ahadur Pande1 and "rs %3 2008 SC 804 2008 4 SC%L& $4 %3 1484 SC $$#

Page14

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. Patent% 20#

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

J Mitra and Co Pvt Ltd V %sst Contro))er o6 Patents and 2esig and "rs )rade *ark

2008 10 SCC '$8

208

2hari.a) 3ndustries Ltd 8 %nr Vs MSS 9ood Produ0ts INTEREST ACT

%3 2005 SC 1444

204

5aha;hathe Pura1i) Sara:i and "rs V /"3 and %nr LAW OF CONTRACT +ank ,uarantee

2004 # SCC '#2

210 211 212 21' 214

Hi!adri Che!i0a)s 3ndustries Ltd V Coa) 5ar e6ining Co Hindustan Constru0tion Co Ltd V St o6 -ihar 8 "rs St -an+ o6 3ndia 8 %nr V Mu)a Saha+ari Sa+har ,ar+hana Ltd S5C o6 3ndia Ltd Vs Jainsons C)othing Corp and %nr /P State Sugar Co V Ms< Su!a0 3nternationa) Ltd Contract of ,uarantee

%3 %3 %3 %3

200# SC 2#48 1444 SC '#10 200# SC 2'$1 1444 SC 2##8

144# 1SCC 5$8

215 21$ 21# 218 214 220 221 222 22' 224 225 22$ 22# 228

%!rit La) (overdhan La)an v St -an+ o6 5ravan0ore 8 "rs -an+ o6 -ihar Ltd v 2r 2a!odar Prasad 8 %nr 3nds) 9in Corp o6 3ndia Ltd v Cannanore Spinning 8 Weaving Mi))s Ltd 8 "rs Maharashtra State &- v "L High Court &rna+u)a! Margaret La)ita Sa!ue) v 3ndo Co!!er0ia) -an+ Ltd MS %nirudhan v 5he 5ho!0oCs -an+ Ltd Pa.an ,u!ar Jain V 5he Pradeshi1a 3nd and 3nv Corp o6 /P Ltd and "rs Punja: 7ationa) -an+ 8 ors v Surendra Prasad Sinha Punja: 7ationa) -an+ Ltd v Shri Vi+ra! Cotton Mi))s 8 %nr aja -ahadur 2hanraj (irji v S-3 V Mrs 3nde*port aja P Parthasarath1 a1ani!varu 8 "rs

%3 14$8 SC 14'2 %3 14$4 SC 24# 2002 5 SCC 54 %3 1482 SC 144# %3 14#4 SC 102 %3 14$' SC #4$ 2004 $ SCC #58 %3 1442 SC 1815 %3 14#0 SC 14#' 14$' ' SC 421 %3 1442 SC 1#40

egistered and ors egistered 8 ors

St -an+ o6 3ndia v 3nde*port State o6 MP v ,a)ura!

%3 1442 SC 1#40 %3 14$# SC 1105 %3 148# SC 10#8

/nion -an+ o6 3ndia v Man+u 7ara1ana Fru%tration of Contract

224
Page15

o;an Mian V 5ahera -egu! 8 "rs

%3 200# SC 288'

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. -n.u%t /nric(ment 2'0

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

,era)a State &)e0 -oard V Hindustan Constru0tion Co Ltd 8 "rs 0icariou% Lia1i it$

%3 200# SC 425

2'1

-an+ o6 -ihar Ltd V Maha:ir La) and "rs MEDICIAL NEGLIGENCE

%3 14$4 SC '##

2'2 2'' 2'4 2'5

Martin 9 2Sou;a Vs Mohd 3sh6aD Post (raduate 3nst o6 Medi0a) &du and St o6 Har1ana 8 "rs V State o6 Punja: V Shiv NOMINATION aj ani a! and "rs es Chandigarh V Jaspa) Singh and "rs

%3 2004 SC 2044 2004 # SCC ''0 %3 %3 2005 SC '2#4 2005 SC '280

2'$

Shipra Sengupta V Mridu) Sengupta and "rs PERSONAL LAW ,uardian and 2ard% Act

%3 14$4 SC '##

2'#

os1 Ja0o: Vs Ja0o: % Cha+ra!a++a) 3indu La2

%3 14#' SC 2040

Adoption and Maintenance


2'8 2'4 2har!a Sha!rao %ga)a.e V Pandurang Miragu %ga)a.e 8 "rs SS Munna La) V SS aj+u!ar 8 "rs %3 %3 1488 SC 845 14$2 SC 144'

Marriage and Divorce


240 241 242 24' 2urga Prasanna 5ripath1 Vs %rundhati 5ripath1 Ma1adevi V Jagdish Prasad Saroj ani V Sudarshan ,u!ar Chadha S!ruti Pahari1a V Sanja1 Pahari1a %3 2005SC'24# %3 200# SC 142$ %3 1484 SC 15$2 %3 2004 SC 2840

Sucession
244 245 24$ 24# 248 244
Page16

Chintha!ani %!!a) Vs 7andagopa) (ounder and %nr Co!! o6 Wea)th 5a* ,anpur 8 "rs V Chander Sen 8 "rs ( Se+ar v (eetha 8 "rs (opa) Singh 8 "rs V /jagar Singh 8 "rs (urdev ,aur and "rs Vs ,a+i and ors Mahant Sa)ig a! V Musa!!at Ma1a 2evi

200# 4 SCC 1$' %3 148$ SC 1#5' 2004 ' LW 80# %3 1454 SC 5#4

200# 1 SCC 54$ %3 1455 SC 2$$

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 250 251 252 25' 254 255

CAUSE TITLE Ma+han Singh 2 :1 Lrs V ,u).ant Singh "!pra+ash 8 "rs v adha0haran 8 "rs

CITATION %3 200# SC 1808 2004 5 MLJ #$1 SC 200$ 10 SC%L& #5 %3 200# SC 2'$4 148' ' SCC '#$ %3 1454 SC 1041

Shee)a 2evi 8 "rs V La) Chand 8 %nr S!t %ss ,aur ?2@ :1 L s Vs ,artar Singh ?2@ :1 L s 8 "rs S!t 2ipo Vs Wassan Singh and "rs /jagar Singh V Jeo

Avyavaharika Debt
25$ Sita a! V adha:ai and "rs %3 14$8 SC 5'4

*u% im 4omen 5Protection of Ri'(t% on Di6orce7 Act 198! 25# 258 254 2$0 2$1 2$2 2ania) Lati6i 8 %nr V /"3 3D:a) -ano V State o6 /P 8 %nr ,hatoon 7isa V State o6 /P 8 "rs Mohd %h!ed ,han V Shah -ano -egu! and "rs Sha:ana -ano Vs 3!ran ,han Sha!i! %ra V State o6 /P 8 %nr REGISTRATION ACT Section 17 and 49 2$' 2$4 2$5 2$$ La0hh!an 2ass V a! La) and %nr %3 %3 1484 SC 142' 14#2 SC 1121 %3 2001 SC '458 %3 200# SC 2215

2002 $ SC%L& 1$5 %3 1485SC445 %3 2010 SC '05

2002 # SCC 518

Mattapa))i Che)a!a11a and %nr V Mattapa))i Ven+ataratna! and %nr Mst ,irpa) ,aur Vs -a0han Singh and "rs Satish ,u!ar V >ari6 %h!ed and "rs REPRESENTATION OF PEOPLES ACT

%3 1458SC144 144# ' SCC $#4

2$# 2$8

%ni) Vasudev Sa)gaon+ar V 7aresh ,usha)i Shigaon+ar Ma+han La) -anga) v Manas -hunia 8 "rs SPECIFIC RELIEF ACT Dec aration

2004 4 SCC '10 %3 2001 SC 440

2$4

a!esh Chand %rda.ati1a v %ni) Panj.ani Permanent 8n.unction

200' # SCC '50

2#0

Chair!an 5a!i) 7adu Housing -oard Madras Vs 5 7 (anapath1

1440 1 SCC $08

Page17

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. S&ecific &erformance 2#1 2#2 2#' 2#4 2#5 %nig)ase Bohannan Vs

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

a!)atha 8 "rs

%3 2005 SC '50' %3 200' SC 1'41 %3 %3 200# SC 125$ 14#1 SC 12'8

Manjunath %nandappa /r6 Shivappa Hanasi V 5a!!anasa 8 "rs PS ana+rishna edd1 V M , -hag1a)a+sh!i 8 %nr

C Chandio+ and %nr V Chuni La) Sa:har.a) and "rs Shiv ,u!ar Shar!a Vs Santosh ,u!ari TRANSFER OF PROPERTY Feedin' t(e ,rant 1$ /%to&&e

200# 8 SCC $00

2#$

enu 2evi V Mahendra Singh and "rs Lea%e

%3 200' SC 1$08

2## 2#8 2#4 280

-ur!ah She)) "i) 2istri:uting no. +no.n as -PCL V ,haja Midhat 7oor 8 "rs Jagdish 2utt 8 %nr V 2hara! Pa) 8 "rs 7arain Prasad %ggar.a) ?2@ :1 L s V St o6 MP 5ara Chand V Sagar:ai A Chai1a)i:ai Li% Pendent

%3 %3

1488 SC 14#0 1444 SC 1$44

%3 200# SC 2'44 %3 200# SC 2054

281

7agu:ai %!!a) 8 "rs Vs - Sa!a ao *ort'a'e

%3 145$ SC 54'

282 28'

-e)i a! 8 anr Vs Sa)ig a! Sardar %utar Singh Vs aja Sir Moha!!ad &ja; "rs #%ten%i1 e #2ner

%3 144$ SC #5# asoo) ,han sin0e de0eased 8 %3 1450 PC 88

284

Hardev Singh V (ur!ai) Singh ?2@ :1 L s Part Performance

%3 200# SC 1058

285

9(P Ltd V Sa)eh Hooseini 2o0tor 8 %nr Redem&tion of *ort'a'e

%3 200# SC 1058

28$ 28#

S 7a;eer %h!ed v St -an+ o6 M1sore 8 "rs 5ara Chand V Sagar:ai A Chai1a)i:ai )enanc$ 1$ 3o din' #6er

%3 200# SC 484 %3 200# SC 2054

288

apta+os -rett 8 Co Ltd v (anesh Propert1

%3 1448 SC '085

Page1

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE CONSTITUTION BASIC STRUCTURE

CITATION

284 240 241

His Ho)iness ,esavananda -harati Sripadaga)varu 8 "rs Vs St o6 ,era)a 8 %nr 3ndira 7ehru (andhi v aj 7arain

%3 14#' SC 14$1 %3 14#5 SC 2244 %3 144# SC 1125

L Chandra+u!ar Vs /nion o6 3ndia CIVIL SERVICE

242 24' 244 245 24$ 24# 248 244 '00

%ja1 Hasis and "rs< Vs< ,ha)id Muji: Sehravardi and "rs< %, ,raipa+ and "rs Vs /"3 %sho+ ,u!ar Badav and "rs< Vs< State o 6 Har1ana 2eva+i 7andan Prasad V St o6 -ihar 8 "rs Jasvinder Singh and "rs< et0 Vs< State o6 J and , ,< Manjusree Vs< State o6 %P Li)a 2har Vs< State o6 ajasthan and "rs a! Chander Vs /"3 Vija1 S1a) and %nr< Vs State o6 Punja: COMPLETE JUSTICE

%3 1481 SC 48# %3 14#0 SC 150

1485 ?4@ SCC 41# %3 148' SC 11'4 200' 2 SCC 1'2 2008?'@ SCC 512 2008?'@ SCC 512 %3 148$ SC 11#' %3 200' SC 402'

'01

2e)hi 2ev %uthorit1 V S+iper Cons Co P Ltd and anr COMPULSORY TESTIMONY

%3 144$ SC 2005

'02 '0' '04

2e)hi Jud Serv %sso 5is Ha;ari Court 2e)hi V State o6 (ujarat and ors 7andini Satpath1 Vs P L 2ani 8 %nr 5he State o6 -o!:a1 Vs ,athi ,a)u "ghad and "rs CONSTITUTIONAL VALIDITY

1441 4 SCC 4'1 %3 14#8 SC 1025 %3 14$1SC1808

'05 '0$ '0# '08 '04 '10 '11 '12


Page1!

%nuj (arg 8 "rs V Hote) %sso0iation o6 3ndia 8 "rs Charan La) Sahu v /nion o6 3ndia 8 "rs Mane+a (andhi Vs /"3 8 %nr Mithu Vs State o6 Punja: 7 7air 8 "rs Vs /nion o6 3ndia Peop)es /nion 6or Civi) Li:erties 8 %nr v /"3 Pooran Ma) V 5he 2ire0tor o6 3nspe0tion ?3nv@ 7e. 2e)hi 8 "rs Shanti Prasad Jain V 5he 2ire0tor o6 &n6or0e!ent

%3

2008 SC $$'

1440 1 SCC $1' 14#8 1 SCC 248 %3 148' SC 4#' %3 2001 SC 2''# %3 2004 SC 45$ 14#4 1 SCC '45 %3 14$2 SC 1#$4

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. '1'

CAUSE TITLE Vajrave)u Muda)iar Vs Sp) 21 Co))e0tor Madras ENVIRONMENT AND POLLUTION %3

CITATION 14$5 SC 101#

'14 '15

Muni0ipa) Coun0i) at)a! Vs Vardivha! 8 "rs Ve))ore Citi;en We)6are 9oru! Vs /nion o6 3ndia FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION

%3 1480 SC 1$22 %3 144$ SC 2#15

'1$ '1#

-ennett Co)e!an 8 Co Vs /"3 Virendra Vs St o6 Punja: FREEDOM OF TRADE

%3 14#' SC 10$ %3 145# SC 84$

'18 '14 '20

-S7L Vs /"3 ajagopa) A (opa) 8 %nr V St o6 57 8 "rs

%3 200$ SC 1'8' 1444 $ SCC $'2 1455 2 SC 225

ai Sahi: a! Ja.a1a ,apur and "rs V 5he State o6 Punja: HABEAS CORPUS

'21

5he State o6 Punja: V %jai: Singh and %nr HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATION AND COMPENSATION

%3 145' SC 10

'22 '2'

udu) Sah V State o6 -ihar and %nr S!t 7i)a:ati -ehera a)ieas La)ita -ehera V State o6 "rissa and "rs INTER COUNTRY ADOPTION

148' 4 SCC 141 %3 144' SC 14$0

'24

La+sh!i ,ant Pande1 v /"3 JUDICIARY

1484 2 SCC 244

'25 '2$

%)) 3ndian Judges %sso0iation Vs /"3 He!ani Ma)hotra Vs< High Court o6 2e)hi LEGAL AID

2002 4 SCC 24# 2008?#@ SCC 11

'2#

Su+ 2as v /5 o6 %runa0ha) Pradesh PREVENTIVE DETENTION

148$ 2 SCC 401

'28 '24 ''0

%2M Ja:a)pur Vs Siv+anth Shu+)a %, (opa)an Vs 5he State o6 Madras /"3 Vs Bu!na! %nand M PROTECTION OF WEAKER SECTION

%3 14#$ SC 120# %3 1450 SC 2#

200# 5 SC%L& $0$

''1 ''2
Page2"

Jo))1 (eorge Varghese and %nr V 5he -an+ o6 Co0hin Visha+a and "thers V ajasthan and "thers

%3 %3

1480 SC 4#0 144# SC '011

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. PUBLIC INTEREST ''' ''4 ''5

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

SP (upta Vs President o6 3ndia 8 "rs State o6 /ttaran0ha) V -a).ant Singh Chau6a) and "rs Vineet 7arain and "rs V /nion o6 3ndia and %nr RESERVATION

%3 1482 SC 144 2010 1 SC%L& 442 1448 1 SCC 110

''$

3ndira Sa.hne1 vs /"3 CONTEMPT OF COURT

%3 2000 SC 448

''#

, %nand Vs

egistrar 2e)hi High Court CRIMINAL LA)

2004 8 SCC 10$

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE A1%condin' Accu%ed ''8 Ja1endra Vishnu 5ha+ur Vs St o6 Maharahstra and %nr Antici&ator$ +ai ''4 '40 '41 '42 '4' '44 %dri 2haran 2as vs St o6 West -enga) MP Lohia et0 V St o6 West -enga) and %nr , ,rishna ,u!ar and %nr vs St o6 %ssa! Sa)auddin %:du)sa!ad Shai+h vs St o6 Maharashtra Shri (ur:a+sh Singh Si::ia and "rs vs St o6 Punja: State :1 the C-3 v %ni) Shar!a A&&reciation of /6idence in A&&ea '45 '4$ '4# '48 '44 '50 '51 '52 '5' '54
Page21

2004 # SCC 104 1

2005 4 SCC '0' %3 2005SC#40 %3 1448 SC 5'0 %3 144$ SC 1042 %3 1480 SC 1$'2 J5 144# # SC $51

- Vish.anath V State o6 ,arnata+a Chure1 La) V State o6 /P Jai Singh and "rs V 5he State o6 ,arnata+a Main Pa) and %nr V State o6 Har1ana and "rs a! Pat and "rs V State o6 Har1ana athnaiah V State o6 ,arnata+a Sa!:haji Hindurao 2esh!u+h and "rs V State o6 Maharashtra Shingara Singh V State o6 Har1ana and %nr Shivappa and "rs V State o6 ,arnata+a State o6 MP V -a00hudas a)ias -a)ra! and "rs

J5 2008 2 SC '05 2008 10 SCC 450 200# 10 SCC #88 2004 10 SCC $42 2004 # SCC $14 J5 2008 ' SC 5$4 2008 11 SCC 18$ 200' 12 SCC #58 2008 11 SCC ''# 200# 4 SCC 1'5

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. '55 '5$ '5# '58 '54

CAUSE TITLE State o6 /P V -anne a)ias -aijnath and "rs State o6 /P V (ovind 2as a)ias (udda and %nr State o6 /P V Punni and "rs S.a!i Prasad V State o6 MP Va)son and %nr V State o6 ,era)a Arre%t and Cu%tod$

CITATION 2004 4 SCC 2#1 200# 10 SCC #45 2008 11 SCC 15' J5 200# 4 SC ''# 2008 10 SC%L& #15

'$0 '$1 '$2

2ire0torate o6 &n6or0e!ent vs 2eepa+ Mahajan and another Joginder ,u!ar vs State o6 /P Su:e Singh vs St o6 Har1ana 8 "rs +ai

%3 1444 SC 1##5 1444 4 SCC 2$0 200$ ' SCC 1#8

'$' '$4 '$5 '$$ '$# '$8 '$4 '#0 '#1 '#2 '#'

Chenna -o1anna ,rishna Badav vs St o6 Maharashtra and %nr 9ree Lega) %id Co!!ittee Ja!shedpur vs St o6 -ihar ,ashi 7ath o1 vs State o6 -ihar

200# CrLJ #82 SC %3 1482 SC 14$' %3 144$ SC '240 200' 1 SCC $'2 J52004 8 SC '48 2004 # SCC 558 J5 2001 4 SC 11$ %3 200# SC 451 200' 1 SCC 15 2001 5 SCC 45' 1445 4 SCC 140

Mansa: %)i vs 3rsan and %nr Masroor v St o6 /P and %nr 7ir!a) Jeet ,aur vs State o6 MP Prah)ad Singh -hati vs 7C5 2e)hi and %nr ajesh anjan Badav at Pappu Badav vs C-3

a! Pratap Badav vs Mitra Sen Badav and %nr /da1 Mohan)a) %0har1a v State o6 Maharashtra /"3 vs 5ha!isharasi and "rs +ai in )ADA #ffence

'#4 '#5 '#$

Hitendra Vishnu 5ha+ur and "rs et0 vs St o6 Maharashtra and "rs Sanja1 2utt vs C-3 -o!:a1 State o6 Maharashtra v %nand Chinta!an 2ighe Cance ation of +ai

%3 1444 SC 2$2' 1444 5 SCC 410 J5 1440 1 SC 28

'## '#8 '#4

%s)a! -a:a)a) 2esai vs St o6 Maharashtra -hupinder Singh 8 "rs vs Jarnai) Singh and %nr Chaganti Sat1anara1ana and "rs vs St o6 %P

1442 CrLJ '#12 200$ CrLJ '$21 %3 148$ SC 21'0

Page22

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. '80 '81 '82 '8'

CAUSE TITLE (ur0haran Singh and "rs vs 2e)hi %d!inistration 7iranjan Singh and %nr vs Pra:ha+ar ajara! ,harote and "rs a! (ovind /padh1a1 vs Sudarshan Singh and "rs Si!ranjit Singh Mann and "rs vs St o6 -ihar Co'ni9ance %3

CITATION 14#8 SC 1#4a

%3 1480 SC #85 %3 2002 SC 14#5 %3 148# SC 144

'84 '85 '8$

Ja!una Singh vs -hadai Shah State o6 Har1ana vs -ahajan)a) 5u)a a! vs ,ishore Singh Com&en%ation under Section 3"7

%3 14$4SC1541 %3 1442SC$04 %3 14## SC 2401

'8# '88

Hari Singh v Su+h:ir Singh and "rs Vija1an Vs Sadanandan , 8 %nr Di%c(ar'e

%3 1488 SC 212# C2J 2004 SC 418

'84 '40

%run V1as 8 %nr v %nita V1as State o6 "rissa vs 2e:endranath Padhi Framin' of C(ar'e

%3 1444 SC 20#1 %3 2005 SC '54

'41 '42 '4' '44 '45

Po))ution Contro) -oard v Mohan Mea+ins S 7a1a+ v % %ntu)a1 8 %nr ao 8 %nr

%3 2000 SC 145$ %3 148$ SC 2045 %3 14$' SC 1850 2004 $ SCC 522 2005 1 SCC 5$8

St o6 %P v Chee!a)apati (anes.ara

St o6 %P v (o)0onda Linga S.a!1 8 %nr St o6 "rissa v 2e:endra 7ath Padhi Furt(er 8n6e%ti'ation and Re-8n6e%ti'ation

'4$

a!a Chaudhar1 Vs< State o6 -ihar ,rant of Pardon 1$ Se%%ion% :ud'e

2004 ?$@ SCC '4$

'4#

Santosh ,u!ar Satish:hushan -ari1ar Vs< State o6 Maharastra 8n;ue%t Re&ort

2004 ?$@ SCC '4$

'48

State o6 /P Vs Sho:hanath 8 "rs :uri%diction

%3 2004 SC 2'45

'44

Hiten P 2a)a) Vs -ratindranath -anerjee #rder of Remand

%3 2001 SC '84#

400
Page23

State ep :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e and "rs V 7M5 Jo1 3!!a0u)ate

2004 5 SC%L& ''0

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. Per%on 401

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

Standard Chartered -an+ vs 2ire0tor o6 &n6or0e!ent Po ice Cu%tod$

%3 2005SC2$22

402 40'

C-3 S35 7e. 2e)hi v %nupa! J ,u)+arni Mitha:hai Pasha:hai Pate) 8 "rs Vs St o6 (ujarat Pu1 ic Pro%ecutor

%3 1442 SC 1#$8 C2J 2004 SC 1014

404

Mu+u) 2a)a) 8 "rs v /"3 Rein6e%ti'ation 1$ A&&e ate Court

1448 1 SC 8$8

405

Popu)ar Muthiah Vs State rep :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e Re ati6e of 3u%1and

200$ $ SC%L& 41#

40$

/ Suvetha vs State :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e Ri'(t of Com& ainant

2004 # SC%L& 144

40#

,ishan La) V 2har!endra -a6na and %nr Searc( and Sei9ure

2004 # SCC $85

408 404 410 411 412 41'

MP Shar!a 8 "rs v Satish Chandra 2M 2e)hi 8 "rs adha+ishan v St o6 /P St o6 Punja: v -a):ir Singh St o6 Punja: v Jas:ir Singh and "rs State o6 MP thro C-3 et0 v Pa)tan Ma))ah 8 "rs Sunder Singh v St o6 /P Section 12" CrPC

%3 1454 SC '00 %3 14$' SC 822 %3 1444 SC 18#2 1445 4 C 3M&S #$5 SC 2005 ' SCC 1$4 %3 145$ SC 411

414 415

9u;)un:i V , ,hader Va)i 8 %nr Su!itra 2evi Vs -hi+ar Choudar1 Section 1"4 517 CrPC

%3

1480 SC 1#'0

%3 1485 SC #$5 2004 1' SC%L& '#$ 2008 14 SC%L& '$4

41$ 41#

%)agarsa!1 and "rs V State o6 2SP State o6 Punja: V (urdip ,aur Section 1"4 of CrPC

418 414

%ghnoo 7agesia v St o6 -ihar %!ar Singh v -a).inder Singh 8 "rs

14$$ 1 SC 1'4 200' 2 SCC 518

Page24

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 420 421 422 42' 424 425 42$ 42# 428 424 4'0 4'1 4'2 4'' 4'4 4'5 4'$ 4'# 4'8 4'4 440 441 442 44' 444 445

CAUSE TITLE %pren Joseph a)ias Current ,unju+unju 8 "rs v St o6 ,era)a -a)dev Singh 8 anr v State o6 Punja: -and)a!uddi %t0huta a!aiah 8 ors v St o6 %P

CITATION %3 14#' SC 1 %3 144$ SC '#2 144$ CrLJ 44$' %3 14#' SC 44$ 2001 ' SCC ''' %3 200# SC 2522

-hopat Singh ,ishan Singh v St o6 Maharashtra C-3 V State o6 ajasthan

C-3 Vs State o6 (ujarat 9addi v St o6 MP (eorge 8 "rs v St o6 ,era)a 8 %nr Ha))u 8 "rs v St o6 MP Harpa) Singh 8 %nr v St o6 Hi!a0ha) Pradesh He!ant 2has!ane V C-3 8 "rs La)ai A 2indoo 8 %nr v St o6 /P MC Mehta Vs /"3 Mu))a and %nr V St o6 /P 7isar %)i v St o6 /P Par+ash Singh -ada) 8 %nr V St o6 Punja: 8 "rs attan Singh v State o6 Hi!a0ha) Pradesh Sa+iri Vasu V State o6 /P 8 "rs Shan+er v State o6 /P Shei+h Hasi: a)ias 5a:ara+ v St o6 -ihar Sheonandan Pas.an V St o6 -ihar 8 "rs S7 Shar!a V -ipen ,u!ar 5i.ari 8 "rs SP C-3 8 "rs v 5apan ,r Singh 5apinder Singh v St o6 Punja: 8 %nr 5ara Singh 8 others v St o6 Punja: Wi)a1at ,han 8 "rs v State o6 /P Section 1"!537 of CrPC

14$4 $ SC '12 %3 1448 SC 1'#$ %3 14#4 SC 14'$ %3 1481 SC '$1 2001 # SCC 5'$ %3 14#4 SC 2118 2008 1 SCC 40# M%7/ SC 0041 2010 %3 145# SC '$$ %3 200# SC 12#4 %3 144# SC #$8 2008 2 SCC 404 %3 14#5 SC #5# %3 14#2 SC 28' 148# 1 SCC 288 14#0 1 SCC $5' 200' $ SCC 1#5 %3 14#0 SC 15$$ 1441 Supp 1 SCC 5'$ %3 145' SC 122

44$ 44#

H S -ains vs State asi+)a) 2a)patra! 5ha++ar V St o6 (ujarat and "rs

%3 1480 SC 188' 2004 1' SC%L& $28

Page25

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. Section 1!1 of CrPC 448 444 450 451 452 45' -anti A (uddu v St o6 MP

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

2004 1 SCC 414 %3 1481 SC $'1 %3 14#' SC 441 %3 14## SC 10$$ %3 14#' SC 1404 %3 1485 SC 48

(urna! ,aur v -a+shish Singh 8 "rs 7anh+u Singh 8 %nr v St o6 -ihar 7irpa) Singh 8 "rs v St o6 Har1ana an:ir 8 "rs v St o6 Punja: St o6 /P v M, %nthon1 Section 1!4 of CrPC

454 455

Maha:ir Singh Vs State o6 Har1ana State o6 /P V Singhara Singh and "rs Section 1!4517 CrPC

2001 # SCC 148 %3 14$4 SC '58

45$

Jogendra 7aha+ 8 ors vs State o6 "rissa Section 1!4527 of CrPC

%3 1444SC25$5

45#

M% %nton1 A %ntappan Vs St o6 ,era)a Section 1!7527 of CrPC

2004 $ SC%L& '$

458 454

Moti

a! 8 "rs v State o6 MP

%3 14#8 SC 1544 %3 2001 SC 2'$4

ajeev Chaudhar1 vs St 7C5 o6 2e)hi Section 190 of CrPC

4$0

Hira La) and "rs V State o6 /P and "rs Section 197 of CrPC Protection to Pu1 ic Ser6ant% A'ain%t Pro%ecution

%3 2004 SC 2'80

4$1 4$2 4$' 4$4 4$5 4$$ 4$# 4$8 4$4 4#0
Page26

% %ntu)a1 vs

S 7a1a+ 8 "rs

1488 2 SCC $02 14#4 4 SCC 1## %3 14#0 SC 1$$1 %3 14$0 SC #45 %3 1448 PC 128 14$# CriLJ 1200 SC 200# 1 SCC 44 %3 145$ SC 44 200# 1 SCC 1 %3 14$4 SC $8$

- Saha 8 "rs v MS ,o0har -hag.an Prasad Srivastava v 7P Mishra 2hannja1 a! Shar!a v MS /ppada1a 8 "rs

HH- (i)) 8 %nr v 5he ,ing ,7 Shu+)a v 7avnit La) Mani)a) -hat 8 %nr La)u Prasad Badav V State o6 -ihar Matajog 2o:e1 v H C -hari Par+ash Singh -ada) 8 %nr v St o6 Punja: 8 "rs Pra:ha+ar V Sinari v Shan+er %nant Ver)e+ar

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 4#1 4#2

CAUSE TITLE San+aran Moitra v Sadhna 2as 8 %nr St o6 "rissa 8 "rs v (anesh Chandra Je. Section 203 of CrPC

CITATION 200$ 4 SCC 584 2004 8 SCC 40

4#'

%da)at Prasad Vs Section 207 of CrPC

oop)a) Jinda) 8 "rs

2004 # SCC '88

4#4

7oor ,han v St o6

ajasthan

%3 14$4 SC 28$

Section 209 of CrPC - Committa Procedure 4#5 4#$ La))an Chaudhar1 and "rs v St o6 -ihar Sudhir 8 ors et0 V State o6 MP et0 Section 30! of CrPC - A&&ro6er 4## State 2e)hi %d!n Vs Jagit Singh Section 309 CrPC 4#8 4#4 St o6 /P Vs Sha!:hu 7ath Singh and "rs Lt Co) SJ Chaudhar1 v St 2e)hi %d!in Section 311 CrPC 480 Shai)endra ,u!ar v State o6 -ihar 8 "rs Section 313 of CrPC 481 482 48' 484 -asavaraj Pati) 8 "rs v St o6 ,arnata+a 8 "rs %3 2000 SC '214 C2J 2004 SC 1'48 200' 2 SCC 401 2004 # SCC 502 %3 2002 SC 2#0 %3 2001SC140' %3 1484 SC $18 %3 1484 SC 548 %3 200$SC''#$ 2001 2 SCC $88

(anesh (ogoi Versus State o6 %ssa! La))u Manjhi 8 %nr v St o6 Jhar+hand 7ava) ,ishore Singh v St o6 -ihar Section 319 of CrPC

485 48$ 48# 488 484

2i)a.ar Singh Vs Parvinder Singh (anesh La) Vs State o6 ajasthan

C2J 2004 SC 1'48 2002 SCC Cr) 24# %3 2001 SC 2521

a+esh Vs State o6 Har1ana anjit Singh v St o6 Punja: Shashi+ant Singh Vs 5ar+esh.ar Singh Section 320 of CrPC

%3 1448 SC '148 %3 2002 SC 20'1

440

u!i 2har vs State o6 West -enga) 8 %nr

C2J 2004 SC 1'48

Page27

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. Section 327 of CrPC 441

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

State o6 Punja: Vs< (ur!it Singh 8 "rs Section 340 CrPC

%3 144$ SC 1'4'

442 44'

7 7atarajan vs - , Su::arao St o6 %P vs V Sar!a Section 389 CrPC ao 8 "rs &t0

%3 200' SC 541 %3 200# SC 1'#

444 445 44$

La)sai ,hunte V 7ir!a) Sinha and "rs 7avjot Singh Sidhu V State o6 Punja: and %nr Sanja1 2utt V St o6 Maharashtra 5r C-3 -o!:a1 Section 40! of CrPC

200# 4 SCC ''0 %3 200# SC 100'

2004 5 SCC #8#

44# 448

, %n:a;hagan Vs 5he Superintendent o6 Po)i0e >ahira Ha:i:u))ah Shei+h 8 %nr v St o6 (ujarat Section 433 A

%3 2004 SC 524 %3 2004 SC '4$#

444

a!raj A 7anhoo A -ihnu Vs State o6 Chhattisgarh Section 4"2 of CrPC

%3 2010 SC 420

500

Sunder:hai %!:a)a) 2esai Vs State o6 (ujarat Section 4!8 Limitation

%3 200' SC $'8

501

Japani Sahoo Vs Chandra Se+har Mohant1 Section 482 of CrPC

%3 200# SC 2#$2

502 50' 504 505 50$

Mohan La) 8 %nr V %jit Singh 8 %nr 7ee)u Chopra 8 %nr V -harti a! Singh V Sonia 8 "rs St o6 Maharashtra Vs Sa)!an Sa)i! ,han 8 %nr St o6 ajasthan Vs ,ashi a! Sentencin'

14#8 ' SCC 2#4 2004 1' SC%L& '1' %3 200# SC 1218 200' 10 SC%L& 1041 %3 200# SC 144

50# 508 504 510

Haru (hosh Vs State o6 West -enga) ,a!a)anantha 8 "rs V State o6 5a!i) 7adu Muniappan v St o6 57 Phu) Singh V State "6 Har1ana

J5 2004 ?11@SC 240 %3 2005 SC 21'2

%3 1481 SC 1220 14#4 4 SCC 41'

Page2

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 511 512 51' 514 515 51$ 51# 518 514 520 521 522 52' 524 525 52$ 52# 528 524 5'0 a! 2eo Chauhan 8 a! 2eo Chauhan A

CAUSE TITLE aj 7ath Chauhan v St o6 %ssa! aj 7ath V St o6 %ssa! %3

CITATION 2000 SC 2$#4

2001 5 SCC #14 2004 14 SC%L& 5'' %3 2000 SC 1204 14#4 4 SCC #14 200$ 2 SCC '54 %3 200$ SC '2$5 %3 2005 SC $82

a!raj A 7anhoo A -ihnu v State o6 Chhattisgarh ang -ahadur Singh 8 "rs vs St o6 /P attan Singh Vs St o6 Punja: Shai)esh Jasvanth:hai 8 %nr vs St o6 (ujarat 8 "rs Siddara!a 8 "rs Vs State o6 ,arnata+a St o6 MP vs Munna Chou:e1 8 %nr St o6 /P vs a! Veer Singh 8 "rs aju

State o6 ,arnata+a V

%3 200#SC'0#5 200# 11 SC%L& 114 2000 2 SC%L& $10 %3 2005SC'5$# %3 2005SC222 %3 200'SC'141 J5 2004 8 SC 2## 2008CriLJ'5'' %3 144#SC18 1444 5 SCC 25' 2004 $ SCC 51' %3 2008 SC '040

5he State o6 ,arnata+a Vs ,rishnappa State o6 M<P< Vs -a)a A -a)ara! State o6 Madh1a Pradesh Vs -a)u State o6 Madh1a Pradesh Vs (hansh1a! Singh State o6 MP V Shei+h Shahid State o6 Punja: Vs Pre! Sagar and "rs Surja a! Vs State o6 ajasthan

State SP through C-3 vs 7a)ini 8 anr Surjit Singh v 7ahara a! 8 %nr S.a!1 Shraddananda A Mura)i Manohar Mishra V State o6 ,arnata+a )ender of Pardon

5'1 5'2 5'' 5'4 5'5 5'$ 5'# 5'8

-ipin -ehari Sar+ar 8 %nr V St o6 West -enga) ,onajeti aja:a:u V St o6 %P 8 %nr Lt Co!!ander Pas0a) 9ernandes V St o6 Maharashtra 8 "rs a!esh.ar V 5he State o6 ajasthan

%3 1454 SC 1' 2002 CriLJ 2440 %3 14$8 SC 544 %3 1452 SC 54 14## 4 SCC 5'$ %3 2008 SC '41 %3 14$' SC 1850 %3 1458 SC $$

Sardar 3D:a) Singh Vs State 2e)hi %d!n 8 "rs Sitara! Sao A Mungeri Vs St o6 Jhar+hand St o6 %P V Chee!a)apati (anes.ara ao 8 %nr Su:ra!ania (oundan V 5he State o6 Madras

Page2!

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 5'4

CAUSE TITLE Suresh Chandra -ahri V St o6 -ihar .ith (ur:a0han Singh EXTRADICTION

CITATION %3 1444 SC 2420

540 541 542

-havesh Ja1anti La+hani V St o6 Maharashtra and "rs 2a1a Singh Lahoria Vs /nion o6 3ndia Sara:jit i0+ Singh Vs /"3

2004 4 SCC 551 %3 2001 SC 1#1$ 2008 2 SCC 41#

INDIAN PENAL CODE Common 8ntention 54' (urpreet Singh Vs St o6 Punja: Common #1.ect 544 545 -hag.an Singh and "rs V State o6 MP Pandurang Chandra+ant Mhatre and "rs V State o6 Maharashtra Deat( Sentence 54$ 54# Pan0hhi and "rs v St o6 /P Shivu and %nr Vs ( High Court o6 ,arnata+a and %nr %3 1448 SC 2#2$ 200# ' SC%L& 15# 2002 4 SCC 85 2004 10 SCC ##' %3 200$ SC 141

Do2r$ Demand - Crue t$<Deat( 548 544 550 551 552 55' 554 555 55$ 55# 558 554 5$0 5$1 5$2
Page3"

%ppasahe: 8 %nr v St o6 Maharashtra %run V1as 8 %nr v %nita V1as (ovindaraju V State o6 ,arnata+a He! Chand v St o6 Har1ana ,ans aj v St o6 Punja: 8 "rs

%3 200# SC #$' %3 1444 SC 20#1 J5 2004 # SC 521 1444 $ SCC #2# 2000 5 SCC 20# 144' CrLJ 1$'5 SC %3 200# SC '14$ 200# CrLJ '2$2 SC %3 200$ SC 2855 2001 4 SCC $18 2004 ' SCC 144 2004 # SC%L& 444 %3 2001 SC 2828 1441 1 SCC '#1 1441 4 SCC 248

,undu)a -a)a Su:rah!an1a! 8 %nr v St o6 %P M Srinivasu)u V St o6 %P aja La) Singh V St o6 Jhar+hand a! -adan Shar!a v St o6 -ihar a!esh ,u!ar v St o6 Chhattisgarh ee!a %ggar.a) v %nupa! 8 "rs Sasi+u!ar V 5he State o6 57 Satvir Singh 8 "rs v St o6 Punja: 8 %nr Shanti 8 %nr v St o6 Har1ana Soni 2evraj:hai -a:u:hai v St o6 (ujarat 8 "rs

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 5$' 5$4 5$5 5$$

CAUSE TITLE St o6 ,arnata+a v MV Manjunathego.da 8 %nr State o6 West -enga) v "ri)a) Jais.a) 8 %nr Suresh ,u!ar Singh V State o6 /<P 5ri!u+h Maroti ,ir+an V St o6 Maharashtra *urder<Cu &a1 e 3omicide =ot Amountin' to *urder

CITATION %3 200' SC 804 1444 1 SCC #' 2004 # SC%L& $24 200# CriLJ 20 SC

5$# 5$8 5$4 5#0 5#1 5#2 5#' 5#4 5#5 5#$ 5## 5#8 5#4

%!rit Singh V St o6 Punja: -a)+ar Singh v St o6 /ttara+hand 2 Sai)u Vs State o6 %P (ur!ai) Singh Vs State o6 Punja: Mani)a) Mohan)a) Shah and "rs V Sardar Sa1ed %h!ed Sa1ed Maha!ad and %nr Manu:hai %ta:hai V St o6 (ujarat 7aresh (iri Vs State o6 MP athnasha)van V State o6 ,arnata+a Shai+ Mastan Va)i V State o6 %P St o6 ajasthan V Chittar!a) State o6 Har1ana V Jagat Pau) 8 "rs State o6 /P Vs 3ndrajeet A Su+hatha Vad)a Chandraiah V St o6 %P Section 120+

%3

200# SC 1'2

2004 CrLJ 2480 SC %3 2008 SC 505 %3 1482 SC 14$$ %3 %3 1454 SC '44 200# SC 24'#

200# 1' SC%L& # 200# ' SCC 4#4 200# 4 SCC '42 200# 8 SC%L& $54 200# 8 SC%L& $25 %3 2000 SC '158 200$ 14 SC%L& 108

580 581 582 58'

%ja1 %gar.a) V /"3 Cha!an La) and "rs V St o6 Punja: Harihar Prasad et0 v St o6 -ihar Su!an Sood A ,a!a) Jeet ,aur V State o6 ajasthan Section 193 and 344 8PC

%3 %3

1442 SC 1$'# 2004 SC 24#2

14#2' SCC 84 %3 200# SC 2##4

584

M S Sheri66 v 5he State o6 Madras and "rs Section 30! 8PC

%3 1454 SC '4#

585

Man+a!!a V State o6 ,era)a Section 37!

2004 1' SC%L& '$#

58$

State o6 /P V Manoj ,u!ar Pande1

2004 1 SCC #2

Page31

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. -n%ound *ind 58# Jagdish V St o6 MP JUVENILE JUSTICE +or%ta Sc(oo Act - Section 10A 588

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

2004 12 SC%L& 580

-a)u A -a+thvat0ha)u Vs St o6 5a!i) 7adu Determination of A'e of :u6eni it$

%3 2008 SC 14'4

584 540 541 542 54' 544 545 54$

Jitendra a! A Jitu Vs St o6 Jhar+hand J1oti Pra+ash ai A J1oti Pra+ash Vs St o6 -ihar

%3 200$ SC 14'' %3 2008 SC 1$4$ %3 2005 SC 2#'1 %3 2001 SC 22'1 %3 200$ SC 215# %3 200' SC '811 2004 $ SC%L& #2$ 2008 8 SC%L& $08

Pratap Singh Vs St o6 Jhar+hand a! 2eo Chauhan A aj 7ath Vs St o6 %ssa!

avinder Singh (or+hi Vs State o6 /P Surinder Singh and %nr Vs State o6 /P Vi+ra! Singh Vs St o6 Har1ana Vi!a) Chadha Vs Vi+as Choudhar1 and "rs :u6eni e :u%tice Act 198!

54# 548 544

%rnit 2as Vs St o6 -hiar Ja!ee) Vs St o6 Maharashtra ajinder Chandra Vs St o6 Chhattisgarh 8 %nr :u6eni e :u%tice Act 2000

%3 2000 SC 22$4 %3 200# SC 4#1 %3 2002 SC #48

$00 $01

-a:)oo Pasi Vs St o6 Jhar+hand Hari a! Vs St o6 ajasthan 8 %nr

2008 1' SC%L& 1'# 2004 $ SC%L& $45

Section 20
$02 $0' $04 $05 -ijender Singh Vs St o6 Har1ana 8 anr &erati La*!an Vs St o6 %P anjit Singh Vs St o6 Har1ana Sidharth et0 Vs State o6 -ihar P ea of :u6eni it$ $0$ $0# $08
Page32

%3 2005 SC 22$2 2004 1 SC%L& 41 2004 1 SC%L& 58$ %3 2005 SC 4'52

Munne1 A

ahat Jan ,han Vs St o6 /P

%3 200$ SC 2402 2004 ' SC%L& 145 %3 2005 SC '54$

Pa.an Vs St o6 /ttaran0ha) Sat:ir Singh and "rs Vs State o6 Har1ana

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. $04

CAUSE TITLE Satish A 2hanna Vs St o6 MP and ors Section ! - Pro1ation of #ffender% Act 19"8

CITATION %3 2004 SC 2$4'

$10

Sudesh ,u!ar Vs State o6 /ttara+hand NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT De a$ in For2ardin' Sam& e%

%3 2008 SC 1120

$11

Hardip Singh V St o6 Punja: =DPS Act - Section 42

2008 11 SC%L& 51'

$12

,arnai) Singh V State o6 Har1ana Searc( of a Per%on<of an /nc o%ed P ace<in a Pu1 ic P ace

2004 8 SCC 5'4

$1' $14 $15 $1$ $1# $18 $14 $20 $21 $22 $2' $24 $25 $2$ $2# $28 $24 $'0 $'1 $'2

%:du) ashid 3:rahi! Mansuri v St o6 (ujarat %h!ed v St o6 (ujarat -harat:hai -hag.anji:hai v St o6 (ujarat 2adu A 5u)sidas Vs State o6 Maharashtra & Mi0he)raj v 7C- 5iruvandru! (anga -ahadur 5hapa v St o6 (oa Ja.ahar Singh A -hagat Ji Vs St o6 (7C5 o6 2e)hi Joseph 9ernande; v State o6 (oa ,a)e!a 5u!:a v St o6 Maharashtra 8 %nr ,anhai1a La) v State o6 MP ,rishna ,an.ar A 5ha+uraeen v St o6 Madan La) 8 %nr v St o6 HP Manohar La) v St o6 ajasthan 7ara1anas.a!1 avishan+ar Vs %sst 2ire0torE 2ire0torate o6 3nte))igen0e Pon %dithan v 21 2ir 7ar0oti0s Contro) -ureau Madras agh:ir Singh v St o6 Har1ana Sat1a:a)an Vs State o6 ,era)a 8 "rs St o6 Punja: v -a)dev Singh St o6 Punja: v Surinder ani a)ias Chhindi evenue ajasthan

2000 2 SCC 51' 2000 # SCC 4## 2002 8 SCC '2# %3 2000 SC '20' %3 2008 SC 1#20 2000 10 SCC '12 %3 2004 SC 2'41 2000 1 SCC #0# 1444 8 SCC 25# 2000 10 SCC '80 2004 2 SCC $08 200' # SCC 4$5 144$ 11 SCC '41 %3 2002SC'$58 1444 $ SCC 1 144$ CrLJ 1$44 C2J 2004 SC #42 1444 $ SCC 1#2 2000 10 SCC 424 %3 1444 SC 18#2

State o6 Punja: v -a):ir Singh

Page33

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. $'' $'4 5 5 Hanee6a v St o6 ,era)a /"3 8 "rs v L2 -a)a! Singh Section "0 of =DPS Act $'5 $'$ (ur:a* Singh v State o6 Har1ana Sajan %:raha! v St o6 ,era)a Section "4 $'# 7oor %ga V St o6 Punja: and %nr PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION Di%c(ar'e $'8 S 7a1a+ Vs % %ntu)a1 and %nr

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION 2004 %3 SCW ''00 2002 4 SCC #'

%3 2001 SC 1002 %3 2001 SC '140

2008 4 SC%L& $81

%3 148$ SC 2045

Di%&ro&ortionate A%%et% $'4 Jana+ira!an vs State rep :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e 8 e'a ,ratification $40 $41 $42 Chaturdas -hag.andas Pate) Vs 5he State o6 (ujarat C3 &!den Vs State o6 /ttar Pradesh Madhu+ar -has+arrao Joshi V State o6 Maharashtra Sanction $4' $44 $45 State o6 57 v 2a!odaran State through 3P %P v , 7arasi!ha0har1 State o6 HP v MP (upta PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE $4$ $4# Ja0o: Mathe. V St o6 Punja: and %nr Ma)a1 ,u!ar (angu)1 V 2r Su+u!ar Mu+herjee and "rs RIGHT OF PRISIONERS $48 $44 $50 $51 $52 $5'
Page34

%3 200$ SC 110$

%3 14#$SC144# %3 14$0SC548 2001 CriLJ 1#5

%3 1442 SC 5$' %3 200$ SC $28 2004 2 SCC '44

%3

2005 SC '180

2004 4 SCC 221

%!ir Shad ,han and anr V L H!ing)iana and ors Citi;ens 6or 2e!o0ra01 thro its President V St o6 %ssa! and "rs 2avid Patri0+ Ward and %nr V /3 and "rs 2 , -asu Vs St o6 West -enga) Hussainara ,hatoon Vs Ho!e Se01 St o6 -ihar Patna ,a!)esh+u!ar 3sh.ardas Pate) V /3 and "rs

1441 4 SCC '4 1445 ' SCC #4' 1442 4 SCC 154 %3 144# SC $10 %3 14#4 SC 1'$0 1445 4 SCC 51

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. $54 $55 $5$ $5# $58 $54 $$0 $$1 $$2 $$' $$4 $$5 $$$ $$# $$8 $$4 $#0 $#1 $#2

CAUSE TITLE ,e.a) Pati S!t V State o6 /P and "rs Murti 2evi V State o6 2e)hi and "rs a!a Murth1 V State o6 ,arnata+a 2 /padh1a1 Vs St o6 %P 8 "rs Sanja1 Suri and %nr V 2e)hi %d!inistration and %nr S!t 7i)a:ati -ehera a)ieas La)ita -ehera V State o6 "rissa and "rs State o6 %P Cha))a a!+rishna edd1 8 "rs

CITATION 1445 ' SCC $00 1448 4 SCC $04 144# 2 SCC $42 %3 200$ SC 144$ %3 1488 SC 414

144' 2 SCC #4$ 2000 5 SCC #12 1448 # SCC '42 1440 CriLJ 1'2# 144# ' SCC #$$ 1445 4SCC 2$2 1445 $ SCC '21 1441 2 SCC '#' 1440 2 SCC $$1 1444 CriLJ 22#' 148' 2 SCC 4$ %3 14#8 SC 1$#5 1440 ' SCC 114 144' Supp?1@SCC#22

State o6 (ujarat and %nr V HonC:)e High Court o6 (ujarat State o6 Har1ana and another V a! 2i1a

State o6 Har1ana V (haseeta a! State o6 M<P< v< Sh1a!sunder 5rivedi and "rs State o6 Madh1a Pradesh V Mohan Singh State o6 Maharashtra and "rs V avi+ant S Pati)

State o6 Punja: and ors V Joginder Singh and ors State 5hrough Supdtt Centra) Jai) 7 2e)hi V Charu)ata Joshi 8 %nr Shee)a -arse v St o6 Maharashtra Suni) -atra Vs 2e)hi %d!inistration Suni) (upta and "rsV St o6 MP 5<7< Mathur v< State o6 /ttar Pradesh SC AND ST PREVENTION OF ATROCITIES! ACT

$#' $#4

(angu)a %sho+ 8 %nr v State o6 %P Lunara! V -hupat Singh and "rs DELA* IN PRONOUNCING JUDGMENT

%3 2000 SC #40 2004 ' SCC #44

$#5

%ni) ai vs St o6 -ihar DOMESTIC (IOLENCE ACT

%3 2001 SC '1#'

$#$

S -atra 8 %nr V S!t 5aruna -atra EN(IRONMENTAL PROTECTION

200# ' SCC 1$4 2008 11 SC%L& 482 %3 148# SC 108$

$## $#8

% Cho.gu)e and Co Ltd V (oa 9oundation and "rs MC Mehta and anr V /"3 and ors

Page35

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. $#4 $80 $81 $82 $8' MC Mehta V ,a!a) 7ath and "rs MC Mehta V ,a!a) 7ath and "rs Susetha V State o6 57 and "rs

CAUSE TITLE %3 %3 %3

CITATION 2000 SC 144# 2002 SC 1515 200$ SC 284'

57 (odavar!an 5hiru!u)pad V /"3 and "rs 57 (odavar!an 5hiru!u)pad V /"3 and "rs E(IDENCE ACT ADMISSION

2008 # SCC 12$ %3 2005 SC 425$

$84

Seth a!da1a) Jat Vs La*!i Prasad ALIBI

%3 2004 SC 24$'

$85

Munshi Prasad and "rs Vs State o6 -ihar APPROVER EVIDENCE

%3 2001 SC '0'1

$8$

State 2e)hi %d!n vs Jagjit Singh CHILD WITNESS

%3 1484 SC 548

$8# $88

2attu

a!rao Sa+hare and "rs v St o6 Maharashtra

144# 5 SCC '41 %3 2004 SC 2242

Hi!!at Su+hadeo Wahur.agh and "rs Vs St "6 Maharashtha COMPEL TO UNDERGO MEDICAL EXAMINATION

$84

Sharda Vs 2hara!pa) CRIME SCENE MAP

200' 2 C5C #$0

$40 $41

Santa Singh v 5he State o6 Punja: 5ori Singh v 5he State o6 /P DYING DECLARATION

%3 145$ SC 52$ %3 14$2 SC '44

$42 $4' $44 $45 $4$ $4# $48 $44 #00


Page36

%ni) Pra+ash Shu+)a V %rvind Shu+)a Cher)opa))i Che)i!ina:i Sahe: 8 %nr Vs St o6 %P La*!an Vs State o6 Maharastra Sa1ara:ano A Su)tana:egu! V St o6 Maharashtra Sharad -irdhi0hand Sarda v St o6 Maharashtra Sharda Vs State o6 ajasthan

200# $ SC%L& '$# %3 200' SC 1014 %3 2002 SC 24#' 200# CriLJ 1458 %3 1484 SC 1$22 %3 2010 SC 408

Sher Singh Vs State o6 Punja: State o6 5a!i) 7adu Versus ,aruppasa!1 Su+anti Moharana vs State o6 "rissa

%3 2008 SC 142$ %3 2004 SC 448 2004 10 SC%L& 24$

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE FALSUS IN UNO FALSUS IN OMNIBUS

CITATION

#01 #02 #0' #04 #05 #0$ #0#

%ni!iredd1 Ven+ata a!ana and "rs V Pu:)i0 Prose0utor HC o6 %P -hag.an 5ana Pati) v St o6 Maharashtra 2a):ir Singh and "rs v St o6 Punja: Ja++i at Se)varaj and %nr v St rep :1 3P Coi!:atore State o6 /P v %ni) Singh State o6 /P v Shan+er /gar %hir and "rs v St o6 -ihar GRANT OF PARDON BY PRESIDENT

2008 5 SCC '$8 %3 14#4 SC 21 %3 148# SC 1'28 200# CrLJ 1$#1 SC %3 1488 SC 1448 %3 1481 SC 84# %3 14$5 SC 2##

#08

,ehar Singh Vs /"3 HOSTILE WITNESS

%3 1484 SC $5'

#04 #10 #11 #12 #1' #14 #15 #1$ #1# #18 #14

2ah1a:hai Chhagan:hai 5ha++er v St o6 (ujarat (urpreet Singh v St o6 Har1ana Ja!atraj ,e.a)ji (ovani v St o6 Maharashtra ,aruppanna 5hevar and "rs v St o6 57 ,hujji a)ias Surendra 5i.ari v St o6 MP aghunandan v St o6 /P a! Chander v St o6 Har1ana Sat Pau) v 2e)hi %d!inistration Shri a:indra ,u!ar 2e1 v St o6 "rissa

%3 14$4 SC 15$' %3 2002 SC '21# %3 14$8 SC 1#8 %3 14#$ SC 480 %3 1441 SC 185' %3 14#4 SC 4$' %3 1481 SC 10'$ %3 14#$ SC 244 %3 14## SC 1#0 2000 4 SC%L& 15' %3 144' SC 1842

S.aran Singh v State o6 Punja: Var+e1 Joseph v St o6 ,era)a rep :1 Cir0)e 3ns o6 Po)i0e IDENTIFICATION

#20 #21 #22 #2'

-udhsen 8 %nr V State o6 /P 2 (opa)a+rishnan Vs Sadanand 7ai+ Heera and %nr Vs St o6 ajasthan

%3 14#0 SC 1'21 %3 2004 SC 44$5 %3 200# SC 2425 2004 4 SCC '85

State o6 /P V Su+hpa) Singh and "rs INJURIES ON THE ACCUSED

#24 #25
Page37

-ha:a 7anda Sar!a and "rs v State o6 %ssa! Hare ,rishna Singh and "rs v State o6 -ihar

%3 14## SC 2252 %3 1488 SC 8$'

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. #2$ #2# #28 Jagdish v State o6 ajasthan

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION %3 14#4 SC 1010 %3 14#$ SC 22$' %3 1448 SC '11#

La+sh!i Singh and "rs v State o6 -ihar a! Sunder Badav and "rs v 5he State o6 -ihar INSANITY

#24

2ah1a:hai Chhagan:hai 5ha++er V State o6 (ujarat INTERESTED WITNESS"CHANCE WITNESS

%3 14$4SC15$'

#'0 #'1 #'2 #'' #'4 #'5 #'$ #'# #'8 #'4

-aha) Singh v St o6 Har1ana 2a)ip Singh and "rs v St o6 Punja: (u)i Chand and "rs v St o6 ajasthan Hari ":u)a edd1 and "rs v St o6 %P

%3 14#$ SC 20'2 %3 145' SC '$4 14#4 ' SCC $48 %3 1481 SC 82 2004 8 SCC 14$ %3 14#$ SC 2'04 2005 11 SCC 142 %3 1481 SC 1'40 1444 ' SCC 50# %3 145# SC $14

Hari a! v St o6 /P Sar.an Singh and "rs v St o6 Punja: See!an at Veerana! v St :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e St o6 ajasthan v ,a)+i and %nr St o6 ajasthan v 5eja a! and "rs Vadive)u 5hevar v St o6 Madras JUDICIAL AND EXTRA - JUDICIAL CONFESSION

#40 #41 #42 #4' #44 #45 #4$

%ja1 Singh v St o6 Maharashtra -a:u:hai /desinh Par!ar V State o6 (ujarat -ishnu Prasad Sinha 8 %nr vs St o6 %ssa! 9ran0is Stan)1 A Sta)in v 7C- 5hiruvananthapura! aj ,u!ar ,ar.a) Versus /nion o6 3ndia Shiva ,ara! Pa1as.a!i 5e.ari V St o6 Maharashtra Siva+u!ar vs St o6 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e LEADING #UESTIONS

%3 %3 %3 %3

200# SC 2188 200# SC 420 200# SC 848 200# SC #44

%3 1441 SC 45 2004 1 SC%L& #1# %3 200$SC$5'

#4#

Var+e1 Joseph Vs State o6 ,era)a rep :1 Cir0)e 3P OCCULAR EVIDENCE DISCRIPANCIES

%3 144'SC1842

#48 #44 #50


Page3

-har.ada -hogin:hai Hirji:hai Vs State o6 (ujarat a!esh.ar Vs State o6 ajasthan

%3 148' SC #5' %3 1452 SC 54 2000 1 SCC 24#

St o6 Hi!a0ha) Pradesh v Le+h aj 8 %nr

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. #51 State o6 (ujarat v

CAUSE TITLE aghunath Va!anrao -a*i

CITATION %3 1485 SC 1042

PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENT #52 ,hatri vs State o6 -ihar PROMISSORY ESTOPPEL #5' #54 #55 #5$ #5# #58 #54 &*press 7e.spapers Pvt Ltd 8 "rs vs /"3 and "rs Mu+und S.arup Mishra vs /"3 and ors Pine Che!i0a)s Ltd 8 "rs vs %ssessing %uthorit1 and "rs Pro!oters 8 -ui)ders %sso0iation o6 Pune vs Pune Muni0ipa) Corporation 8 "rs St o6 ,arnata+a and %nr vs , , Mohandas and "rs /"3 vs (anesh i0e Mi))s and %nr /P Po.er Corporation Ltd and %nr vs Sant Stee)s and %))o1s P Ltd and "rs PROOF BEYOND REASONABLE DOUBT #$0 #$1 #$2 #$' #$4 #$5 #$$ #$# #$8 Harijana 5hirupa)a 8 "rs v PP HC %P 3nder Singh 8 %nr v St 2e)hi %d!n ,rishna Mo0hi 8 "rs v St o6 -ihar MaDsoodan 8 "rs v St o6 /P Masa)ti v State o6 /P Sardu) Singh 8 Jagtar Singh v St o6 Har1ana Shivaji Saha:rao -o:ade 8 %nr v St o6 Maharashtra St o6 West -enga) v "ri)a) Jais.a) 8 %nr Su0ha Singh and %nr v St o6 Punja: RAPE VICTIM #$4 ##0 ##1 2e)hi 2o!esti0 Wor+ing Wo!ens 9oru! vs /"3 and "rs Sa+shi vs /"3 and "rs St o6 Punja: vs (ur!it Singh and "rs RIGOR MORTIS ##2 -aso Prasad 8 "rs v St o6 -ihar SCIENTIFIC"EXPERT EVIDENCE ##' -hag.andas v St o6 ajasthan %3 145# SC 584 %3 200# SC 1014 1445 1 SCC 14 2004 5 SCC 518 144$ 2 SCC '84 2002 $ s00 4#0 14#8 4 SCC 1$1 2002 $ SCC 81 %3 148' SC 12$ %3 14$5 SC 202 2002 8 SCC '#2 %3 14#' SC 2$22 1444 1 SCC #' %3 200' SC '$1# 148$ 1 SCC 1'' 200# 2 SCC 5'$ 1442 2 SCC $8' 200# $ SCC 14' 200# $ SCC 484 1448 4 SCC $'0 M%7/ SC 4$02 200# %3 1481 SC 10$8

Page3!

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. ##4 ##5 ##$ ### ##8 ##4 #80 #81 La)it Pop)i v Canara -an+ 8 "rs

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION 200' ' SCC 58' %3 14#8 SC 118' %3 14#4 SC 14 %3 14$# SC 1550 1444 # SCC 280 1442 ' SCC #00 J5 1448 ' SC 44' %3 144$ SC 1441

Mohan La) 8 %nr v %jit Singh 8 %nr St ?2e)hi %d!in@ v Pa)i a! St o6 %P v Madiga -oosena 8 "rs St o6 HP v Jai La) 8 "rs St o6 Maharashtra v Su+hdeo Singh 8 anr St o6 /P v Har:an Sahai 8 "rs State thro C-3 7e. 2e)hi Vs SJ Choudhar1 SECONDARY EVIDENCE

#82

,a)1an Singh Vs S!t Chhoti 8 "rs SECTION 6

%3 200# SC 1014

#8'

7ar:ada 2evi (upta V -irendra ,u!ar Jais.a) and %nr SECTION 10

200' 8 SCC #45

#84

State 7C5 o6 2e)hi vs< 7avjot Sandhu A %6san (uru SECTION $%

%3 2005SC'820

#85 #8$ #8# #88 #84 #40 #41 #42 #4' #44

%!itsingh -hi+a!sing 5ha+ur v St o6 Maharashtra (eejaganda So!aiah v St o6 ,arnata+a Hi!a0ha) Pradesh %d!inistration Vs "! Pra+ash ,hujji a)ias Surendra 5i.ari v St o6 MP Pu)u+uri ,ota11a 8 "rs Vs ,ing &!peror Sanja1 A ,a+a et0 v St 7C5 o6 2e)hi St o6 HP v Jeet Singh St o6 /P v 2eo!an /padh1a1a State o6 Maharashtra v 2a!u Suresh Chandra -ahri v St o6 -ihar SECTION 16&

%3 200# SC $#$ %3 200# SC 1'55 %3 14#2 SC 4#5 %3 1441 SC 185' 144# L #4 3% $5 %3 2001 SC 4#4 %3 1444 SC 124' %3 14$0 SC 1125 2000?4@SC%L&8 %3 1444 SC 2420

#45 #4$

aghunandan v State o6 /P a! Chander v State o6 Har1ana SOLITARY WITNESS

%3 14#4 SC 4$' %3 1481 SC 10'$

#4#
Page4"

Harijan Megha! Jesha vs State o6 (ujarat

%3 14#4SC15$$

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. #48 #44 800 801

CAUSE TITLE ,ara!jit Singh v State 2e)hi %d!inistration La))u Manjhi 8 %nr v St o6 Jhar+hand 7athusingh v State o6 MP 5hangai1a v St o6 57 SUDDEN PROVOCATION

CITATION 200' 5 SCC 241 200' 2 SCC 401 %3 14#' SC 2#8' 2005 4 SCC $50

802

Jagat Singh Vs State o6 Punja: TAPE RECORDED CONVERSATION

1444 2 SC%L& 4$'

80' 804 805 80$ 80# 808 804

7 Sri a!a

edd1 et0 v V V (iri a! Singh

%3 14#1 SC 11$2 %3 148$ SC ' %3 14#' SC 15# %3 14$4 SC #2 2010 2 SC%L& 104 %3 14$8 SC 14# %3 14#5 SC 1#88

a! Singh 8 "rs v

M Ma)+ani v State o6 Maharashtra S Pratap Singh v 5he State o6 Punja: 5u+ara! S 2igho)e V Mani+rao Shivaji ,o+ate Busu6a))i &s!ai) 7agree v State o6 Maharashtra >i1auddin -urhanuddin -u+hari v -rij!ohan a!dass Mehra 8 "rs TESTIMONY OF POLICE

810

5ahir Vs State 2e)hi JUDGEMENT )RITING

%3 144$ SC '0#4

811 812 81' 814 815 81$ 81# 818

%)o+ ,u!ar

o1 v 2r S7 Sar!a 8 %nr

%3 14$8 SC 45' %3 2001 SC $5$ %3 1444 SC ''81 %3 200' SC 4$84 2008 8 SCC '45 %3 14#$ SC 20'# %3 1454 SC 144 %3 14$4 SC 11$#

%!ina %h!ed 2ossa 8 "rs v St o6 Maharashtra -a)raj 5aneja 8 %nr v Suni) Madan 8 %nr -hupinder Shar!a v St o6 Hi!a0ha) Pradesh Lattu Mahto Vs State o6 -ihar C Shar!a v /"3 8 "rs Surendra Singh 8 "rs v St o6 /P S.aran Lata (hosh v H, -anerjee 8 "rs ALTERATION OF JUDGMENT

814 820

Sooraj 2evi v P1are La) 8 %nr Vinod ,u!ar Singh v -H/

%3 1481 SC #'$ %3 1488 SC '#15

Page41

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE LA'OUR AND SER(ICE LA) ACCIDENT IN THE COURSE OF EMPLOYMENT

CITATION

821

&S3 Corporation Vs 9ran0is 2e Costa AD-HOC"CASUAL EMPLOYMENT

%3 144# SC 4'2

822 82'

(angadhar Pi))ai V Sie!ens Ltd La) Mohd 8 "rs V 3ndian ai).a1 Constru0tion Co Ltd 8 "rs

200# 1 SCC 5'' 1444 1 SCC 54$

824

CONTRACT LABOUR ashtri1a Che!i0a) and 9erti)i;ers Ltd 8 %nr V (enera) &!p)o1ees %sso0iation and "rs DISCIPLINARY ACTION

200# 5 SCC 2#'

825 82$ 82# 828 824 8'0 8'1 8'2

2epot Manager %PS 5C V

aghuda Siva San+ar Prasad

200# 1 SCC 222 200# 1 SCC 5$$ 200# 2 SCC 4'' 200# 4 SCC $$4 2005 8 SCC 4$ 14$4 2 SCC 100 1484 2 SCC 1## 200# 4 SCC $2#

Jas:ir Singh V Punja: and Sind -an+ and "rs J, S1ntheti0s Ltd V ,P %gra.a) and %nr Mangt o6 Coi!:atore 2ist Cent Coop -an+ V Se01 Coi!:atore 2t Cent Coop -an+ &!p %sso 8 %nr ":ettee Pvt Ltd V Mohd Sha6iD ,han 5u)sipur Sugar Co Ltd V St o6 /P 8 "rs /"3 V Par!a 7anda /PS 5C V a! ,ishan %rora DISENGAGEMENT RETRENCHMENT

8'' 8'4 8'5 8'$ 8'# 8'8 8'4 840 841 842 84'

2istri0t ed Cross So0iet1 V -a:ita %rora and "rs (anga ,isan Sah+ari Chini Mi))s Ltd V Jaivir Singh (uru Ja!:hesh.ar /ni thro egistrar V 2hara! Pa)

%3 200#SC28#4 200# 11 SC%L&404 200# 2 SCC 2$5 200# 5 SCC #42 2004 8 SCC 145 200# 2 SCC 428 200$ 1 SCC 10$ 2001 # SCC 1 200# 4 SCC 44 2002 ' SCC 25 200$ 8 SCC 544

Har1ana /r:an 2eve)op!ent %uthorit1 V "! Pa) Muni0ipa) Corp 9arida:ad V Siri 7i.as Punja: State &)e0tri0it1 -oard and %nr V Sudesh ,u!ar Puri M Be))atti V 5he %sst &*e &ngg S%3 Ltd and ors V 7ationa) /nion Water 9ront Wor+ers and ors Srira! 3ndustria) &nterprises Ltd V Maha+ Singh and "rs 5he ange 9orest "66i0er V S 5 Hadi!ani

/"3 and "rs V Ju!!asha 2i.an

Page42

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 844 /P 2rugs and Phar! Co Ltd V

CAUSE TITLE a!anuj Badav and "rs

CITATION 200' 8 SCC ''4 2004 11 SC%L& $08 %3 200$ SC 4#5 %3 2005 SC 144' 2005 # SCC ''8

DOCTRINE OF PROPORTIONALITY 845 84$ 84# 848 Chair!an 0u! M2 Coa) 3ndia Ltd and %nr V Mu+u) ,u!ar Choudhuri and "rs L, Ver!a Vs HM5 Ltd 8 %nr Mahindra 8 Mahindra Ltd vs 7- 7aravade et0 V a!ana vs %PS 5C 8 "rs ESI ACT Section 2 844 Shri 7ava+esari Pra+ashan Ltd and "rs V &!p)o1ees State 3ns Corp and "rs Section 4" 850 9erti)i;ers 8 Che!i0a)s 5ravan0ore Ltd Vs INDUSTRIES 851 -anga)ore Water Supp)1 8 Se.erage -oard Vs % MISCONDUCT 852 85' 5he /P St eg Manager ajasthan St oad 5ransport Corp Vs Sohan La) et0 2004 8 SCC 218 2004 11 SC%L& '5 ajappa 8 "rs %3 14#8 SC 548 egiona) 2ir &S3C 8 "rs 2004 11 SC%L& #$$ %3 1484 SC 141$

oad 5ransport Corp Vs 7anhe La) ,ush.aha

PROOF OF EMPLOYMENT 854 ajasthan St (anganagar S Mi))s Ltd Vs St o6 REGULARI'ATION OF SERVICE 855 Se01 St o6 ,arnata+a 8 "rs Vs /!adevi 8 "rs REINSTATEMENT " BACK WAGES 85$ 85# 858 854 -harat Heav1 &)e0tri0a)s Ltd V %ni) and ors (enera) Manager Har1ana oad.a1s V udhan Singh Metropo)itan 5ransport Corporation Vs V Ven+atesan /P St -rass.are Corpn Ltd and %nr V /dai 7arain Pande1 SECTION 10 - INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT 8$0 8$1 -i+ash -hushan (hosh and "rs V 7ovartis 3ndia Ltd and %nr S1ndi0ate -an+ Vs (enera) Se01 S1ndi0ate -an+ Sta66 %sso0iation 8 %nr 200# 5 SCC 541 2000 5 SCC $5 200$ 11 SC%L& 5$# 2005 5 SCC 541 2004 11 SC%L& 50 200$ 1 SCC 4#4 200$ 4 SCC 1 ajasthan 8 %nr 2004 8 SCC 1$1

Page43

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE SECTION $&F OF INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT

CITATION

8$2

Muni0ipa) Corp 9arida:ad vs Siri 7i.as TERMINATION OF SERVICE

2004 8 SCC 145

8$' 8$4

2ire0tor 9ood and Supp Punja: and %nr V (ur!it Singh St -an+ o6 3ndia Vs 7 Sundara Mone1 WORKMAN

200# 5 SCC #2# %3 14#$ SC 1111

8$5 8$$ 8$#

C (upta V ()a*o S!ith ,)in Phar!a0euti0a) Ltd Canteen Ma;door Sa:ha V Meta))urgi0a) &ngg Cons 3 Ltd 8 "rs Muir Mi))s /nit o6 75C ?/P@ Ltd V S.a1a! Pra+ash Srivastava and %nr LAND AC+UITION DETERMINATION OF MARKET VALUE

200# # SCC 1#1 200# 10 SC%L& 202 200# 1 SCC 441

8$8 8$4 8#0 8#1 8#2 8#'

%ttar Singh 8 %nr Vs /nion o6 3ndia -hagat Singh 8 "rs Vs /nion o6 3ndia /"3 and %nr Chi!an)a) Hargovinddas Vs Spe0ia) Land %0Duisition "66i0er Poona and %nr La) Chand Vs /nion o6 3ndia /"3 and %nr Saguntha)a 2ead thro Lrs V Spe0ia) 5ehsi)dar L% and "rs /"3 vs Pra!od (upta 8 "rs DEVELOPMENT CHARGES

2004 11 S0a)e 5# 2004 11 S0a)e 251 %3 1488 SC 1$52 2004 11 SC%L& $2# M%7/ SC 01'4 2010 %3 2005 SC '#08

8#4 8#5

,asturi and "rs Vs State o6 Har1ana Sai:anna=2ead :1 L s Vs %sst Co!! 8 Land %0D "66r INTEREST ON SOLATIUM

200' 1 SCC '54 2004 4 SCC 404

8#$

Vi)u:en Jha)ejar Contra0tor 2 :1 L s Vs State o6 (ujarat SECTION 6

2005 4 SCC #84

8##

Vija1 7ara1an 5hatte 8 "rs Vs St o6 Maharashtra 8 "rs SECTION 1%

2004 11 SC%L& 525

8#8

Mohan Singh Vs 3%%3 SECTION 1( ) &0

144$ 8 SC%L& 251

8#4 880

Spe0ia) Land %0Duisition "66i0er /, Proje0t Vs Maha:oo: 8 %nr /P %.as &va! Vi+as Parishad Versus (1an 2evi ?dead@ :1 L s

2004 ' SC%L& 2$' 1445 2 SCC '2$

Page44

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE LEGITIMATE E&PECTATION

CITATION

881 882 88' 884

Chie6 Co!! o6 35 8 "rs vs Sushee)a Prasad 8 "rs Poona! Ver!a 8 "rs Vs 2e)hi 2eve)op!ent %uthorit1 Saroja V Chinnusa!1 ?2@ :1 L< s 8 %nr Se01 St o6 ,arnata+a 8 "rs v /!adevi 8 "rs LIMITATION ACT

200# ' SC%L&40$ %3 2008 SC 8#0 %3 200# SC '0$# %3 200$ SC 180$

885 88$ 88# 888

J ,u!aradasan 7air 8 %nr Vs 3 5C Sohan 8 "rs San+ar 2astidar v Shri!ati -anju)a 2astidar 8 %nr Seth a!da1a) Jat v La*!i Prasad 5he State o6 West -enga) Vs 5he %d!inistrator Ho.rah Muni0ipa)it1 and "rs MA&IMS DOCTRINE OF EXDEBITO JUSITIAE

2004 ' MLJ 522 SC %3 200# SC 514

2004 5 MLJ 442 SC %3 14#2SC#44

884

Jet P)1 Wood Private Ltd 8 %nr Vs Madhu+ar 7o.)a+ha 8 "rs DOCTRINE OF READING DOWN

%3 200$ SC 12$0

840

%run ,u!ar 8 "rs Vs /"3 8 "rs INVESTIGATION AND IN#UIRY DISTINCTION

200$ 4 SC%L& '20

841 842

2har!esh:hai Vasudev:hai 8 "rs Vs St o6 (ujarat 8 "rs Surjit Singh Vs Mahanagar 5e)ephone 7iga! Ltd LEGISLATIVE INTENT

2004 $ SCC 5#$ 2008 $ SC%L& 20#

84'

Ve!aredd1 ,u!aras.a!1

edd1 8 %nr Vs St o6 %P

%3 200$ SC '51#

MIMANSA PRINCIPLE OF INTERPRETATION 844 845 &!p St 3nsuran0e Corp Vs HM5 Ltd 8 %nr (ujarat /rja Vi+ash 7iga! Ltd Vs &ssar Po.er Ltd PURPOSIVE INTERPRETATION 84$ -o!:a1 21eing 8 M6g Co Ltd Vs -o!:a1 &nviron!enta) %0tion (roup 8 "rs SCOPE OF PRECEDENT 84# Pra+ash %!i0hand Shah vs State o6 (ujrat MOTOR (E,ICLE ACT %-.. ACT LIABILITY 848
Page45

%3 2008 SC 1'22 %3 2008 SC 1421

%3 200$SC1484

%3 148$SC4$8

7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs Pre!:ai Pate) "rs

%3 2005 SC 2''#

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. APPROPRIATE MULTIPLIER 844 400 401

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Ltd vs Char)ie 8 ors S!t Sar)a Ver!a 8 "rs Vs 2e)hi 5ransport Corp 8 %nr /P St oad 5ransport Corp 8 "rs Vs 5ri)o Chandra 8 "rs

%3 2005 SC 215# 2004 $ SCC 121 144$ 4 SC%L& 522

CHILD VICTIM - APPROPRIATE COMPENSATION 402 , Ma)i+ and %nr V ,iran Pa) and "rs CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE 40' 404 -ijo1 ,u!ar 2ugar Vs -id1adhar 2utta 5he M2 57S5C Ltd Vs ,3 -indu 8 "rs FAKE LICENCE 405 40$ 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Vs ,anti 2evi 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Vs ,a!)a GENUINENESS OF THE LICENCE 40# /nited 3ndia 3nsuran0e Co Vs %n:ari 8 "rs HIRER LIABILITY 408 ajasthan State oad 5ransport Co Vs ,ai)ash 7ath , %3 144# SC '444 2000 10 SCC 52' %3 2005 SC 2850 %3 2001 SC 1414 %3 200$ SC 1255 2005 8 SCC 4#' %3 2004 SC 250$

JUST COMPENSATION 404 410 "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs Mohd 7asir 8 %nr 5he 2iv Contro))er ,S 5C Vs Mahadeva Shett1 8 %nr NO FAULT LIABLITY 411 ,aushnu!a -egu! and "rs V 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Ltd and "rs NON PAYMENT OF PREMIUM 412 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Ltd Vs PAY AND RECOVER 41' 414 415 41$ 41# 418
Page46

2004 $ SCC 280 %3 200' SC 41#2

%3 2001 SC 485

u)a 8 "rs

%3 2000 SC 1082

-ritish 3ndia (enera) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd v Captain 3t:ar Singh 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd v Cha))a -haratha!!a 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd v S.aran Singh 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co v -a)jit ,aur 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Vs ,usu! 8 ors 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co v ,a!)a

%3 1454 SC 1''1 2004 8 SCC 51# %3 2004 SC 15'1 %3 2004 SC 1'40 %3 200$ SC '440 %3 2001 SC 1414

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 414 420 421

CAUSE TITLE "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd v Shri 7anjappan 8 "rs "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs 7anjappan Pra!od ,u!ar %gra.a) Vs Mushtari -egu! 8 "rs PLYING WITHOUT PERMIT

CITATION %3 2004 SC 1$'0 %3 2004 SC 1$'0 %3 2004 SC 4'$0

422

7ationa) 3nsuran0e Vs Cha))a /pendra ao 8 "rs PREMIUM UNPAID

2004 8 SC%L& 40

42'

7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs See!a Ma)hotra RASH AND NEGLIGENCE - IPC 4$%

%3 2001 SC 114#

424

Sha+i)a ,hader 8 "rs Vs 7ausheer Ca!a 8 "rs SCHEME OF MOTOR VEHICLE ACT

%3 14#5 SC 1'24

425

2eepa) (irish:hai Soni 8 "rs Vs /nited 3ndia 3nsuran0e Co SECTION 11 OF MOTOR VEHICLE ACT

%3 2004 SC 210#

42$

Ma))a Pra+asarao Vs Ma))a Jan+i SECTIONS 9$A AND 9$B OF MOTOR VEHICLES ACT 19*9

2004 ' SCC '4'

42#

7ationa) 3nsuran0e VS Jethu SECTION 149 $!

a! 8 "rs

1444 4 SCC $2

428

Sadhana Lodh V 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd and %nr SECTION 16* A AND 166 OF MOTOR VEHICLES ACT

200' ' SCC 524

424 4'0

2eepa) (irish:hai Soni 8 "rs v /nited 3ndia 3nsuran0e 5he "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd et0 v Hansraj:hai V ,oda)a 8 "rs SECTION 16*A OF MOTOR VEHICLE ACT 19((

2004 5 SCC '85 2001 5 SCC 1#5

4'1 4'2

7inga!!a 8 %nr v /nited 3ndia 3nsu Co Ltd "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs Hansraj:ai V ,oda)a SECTION 1%0 OF MOTOR VEHICLE ACT

%3

2004 SC '05$

%3 2001 SC 18'2

4''

73C Vs Meghji 7aran Sorati1a 8 "rs THIRD PARTY LIABILITY

2004 4 SC%L& 50

4'4

/nited 3ndia 3nsuran0e Co!pan1 Vs Lehru 8 "rs THIRD PARTY"PERSON"VEHICLE

%3 200' SC 1242

4'5 4'$
Page47

, 7anda+u!ar v M2 5hantha) Peri1ar 5ransport Corpn Ma))a..a v 5he "rienta) 3nsu Co Ltd 8 "rs

144$ %CJ 555 SC 1444 1 SCC 40'

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 4'# 4'8 4'4

CAUSE TITLE 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Ltd v %sha ani 8 "rs

CITATION 200' ' SCC 22' 2000 %CJ 1 SC %3 14## SC 1#'5

7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co v Shri Satpa) Singh 8 "rs Pushpa:ai Purshotta! /deshi 8 "rs v anjit (inning 8 Pressing Co P Ltd 8 %nr

NEGOTIA'LE INSTRUMENTS ACT ACCOUNT CLOSED 440 441 Jugesh Sehga) Versus Sha!sher Singh (ogi 7ara1ana Menon A Mani=vs= St o6 ,era)a CAUSE OF ACTION 442 Sadanandan -hadran v Madhavan Suni) ,u!ar CIVIL SUIT AND CRIMINAL COMPLAINT NO RESJUDICATA 44' Sh Vishnu 2utt Shar!a Vs S!t 2a1a Sapra COMPLAINT BY POWER OF ATTORNEY 444 445 C( Praveen =Vs= Mohd 5ajuddin Shan+ar 9inan0e and 3nvest!ents vs St o6 %P COMPOUNDING THE OFFENCE 44$ ajendran Vs 7 Mohanan DEFAULT SENTENCE WHILE ORDERING COMPENSATION 44# Vija1an Vs Sadanandan HANDWRITING EXPERT 448 ( So!esh.ar ao Vs Sa!ineni 7agesh.ar ao L+,-../ E01234+-5.+ D+56-B738+0 21 P3221 444 450 451 -a)aji Sea6oods &*ports ?3@ Ltd Vs M%C 3ndustries Hiten P 2a)a) v -ratindranath -anerjee ,7 -eena v Muni1appan 8 anr LIMITATION 452 45' Munoth 3nvest!ents Ltd Vs Puttu+o)a Properties Ltd 8 anr Sa+eth 3ndia Ltd 8 ors v 3ndia Se0urities Ltd NOTICE 454 CC %)avi Haji v Pa)apett1 Muha!!ed 8 %nr 200# $ SCC 555 %3 2001 SC 2#52 %3 1444 SC 1040 1444 1 C5C $ 2001 $ SCC 1$ %3 2001 SC 2845 2004 10 SC%L& 2$8 2004 $ SCC $52 2004 4 -o!C 20$ C2J 2004 SC 1188 2008 10 SC%L& $54 2004 8 SC%L& $48 1448 $ SCC 514 2004 4 SC%L& 455 %3 200$SC''$$

Page4

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 455 45$ 45# 458 Jagdish Singh v 7atthu Singh , 3ndira v 2r ( %dinara1ana State o6 MP v Hira)a) 8 "rs

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION %3 1442 SC 1$04 200' 8 SCC '00 144$ # SCC 52' 2004 8 SCC ##4

V aja ,u!ari v P Su::ara!a 7aidu 8 %nr PERSON IN CHARGE OF THE COMPANY

454 4$0 4$1 4$2

,, %huja Vs V, Vora ,P( 7air Vs Jinda) Mentho) 3ndia Ltd 7ationa) S!a)) 3ndustries Corp Ltd V Har!eet Singh Painta) and %nr 7, Wahi Vs She+har Singh POST DATED CHE#UE

2004 4 SC%L& 8# 2001 10 SCC 218 M%7/ SC 0112 2010 %3 200# SC 1454

4$'

Shri 3shar %))o1 Stee)s Ltd v Ja1as.a)s 7&C" Ltd PROSECUTION OF A COMPANY

4$4

%ni) Hada Vs 3ndian %0r1)i0 Ltd PROSECUTION OF A SICK INDUSTRY

%3 2000 SC 145

4$5

,usu! 3ngots %))o1s Ltd Vs Pennar Peterson Ltd SCOPE OF SECTION 1*(

%3 2000 SC 454

4$$ 4$# 4$8 4$4 4#0

2 Vinod Shivappa v 7anda -e))iappa (oa P)ast P Ltd v Chi0o /rsu)a 2 Sou;a Modi Ce!ents Ltd v Shri ,u0hi) ,u!ar 7andi 7&PC Mi0on Ltd 8 "rs v Mag!a Leasing Ltd Pre! Chand Vija1 ,u!ar v Bashpa) Singh 8 %nr SECTION 11( A OF NI ACT

200$ %3 SCW 2#5# 2004 2 SCC 2'5 %3 1448 SC 105# %3 1444 SC 1452 2005 4 SCC 41#

4#1

-harat -arre) 8 2ru! Manu Co Vs %!ir0hand P1are)a) SENTENCING-POWER OF A MAGISTRATE

%3 1444 SC 1008

4#2

Pan+aj:hai 7agji -hai Pate) Vs St o6 (ujarat STANDARD OF PROOF-PRESUMPTION

%3 2001 SC 5$#

4#'

,rishna Janardhan -hat Vs 2attathara1a Hegde STOP PAYMENT

%3 2008 SC 1'25

4#4

MM5C Ltd 8 %nr Vs Med0h) Che!i0a)s 8 Phar!a Pvt Ltd

2001 8 SC%L& 141

Page4!

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION 4#5

CAUSE TITLE

CITATION

, -has+aran Vs San+aran Vaidh1an -a)an 8 %nr VICARIOUS LIABILITY

%3 1444 SC '#$2

4#$ 4##

a!rajsingh Vs State o6 MP SMS Phar!a0heuti0a)s Ltd Vs 7eeta -ha))a RECONSTRUCTION OF RECORDS

2004 5 SC%L& $#0 200# ' SC%L& 245

4#8

State o6 /P V %:hai

aj Singh 8 %nr RENT CONTROL CASES

2004 4 SCC $

ABUSE OF PROCESS OF COURT 4#4 Sardar &states Vs %t!a a! Pro P Ltd BONAFIDE RE#UIREMENT 480 481 482 48' ,annia!!a) Vs Che))ara! Phu) ani and "rs Vs Sh 7au:at Sar)a %huja Vs /33C Ltd Sesha!:a) dead thro L s V Che)ur Corp Che)ur -ui)ding and "rs DEFAULT IN PAYMENT OF RENT 484 485 48$ 48# -ai Chan0ha) and "rs V S1ed Ja)a)uddin and "rs ,% a!esh and "rs V S!t Sushee)a -ai and "rs Patta:ira!an and "rs 14#0 ' SCC 124 %3 1448 SC 1'45 %3 1485 SC 582 2004 4 SC%L& '42 ai %h)u.a)ia %3 %3 2002 SC 1#'4 14#' SC 2110 2004 8 SC%L& #4$

%3 1444 SC 100 M%7/ SC 0115 2010

S Sundara! Pi))ai and "rs V V

Sar)a (oe) 8 "rs Vs ,ishan Chand FIXATION OF FAIR RENT

488 484 440

(irdhari La) 2ead :1 Lrs V Hu+a! Singh and "rs Miran 2evi V -ir:a) 2ass Mistr1 Pre!ji:hai Vitha)das V (anesh:hai ,eshavji STATUS OF LANDLORD

14## ' SCC '4# 14## ' SCC 44$ 14## ' SCC 11

441

&)ias Versus Cheri1an SUB-TENANACY

442 44'

%t!a a! Properties P Ltd Vs 9edera) Motors -ajaj %uto Li!ited V -ehari La) ,oh)i

2005 1 SCC #05 %3 1484 SC 180$

Page5"

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

SL.NO. 444 445

CAUSE TITLE Ce)ina Coe)ho Pereira and "rs V /)has Maha:a)esh.ar ,ho)+ar and "rs oop ,u!ar vs Mohan 5hedani TENANT MEANING

CITATION %3 2010SC$0' %3 200' SC 2418 2004 11 SC%L& #44

44$

St o6 Maharashtra 8 %nr Vs Super Ma* 3nternationa) Pvt Ltd 8 "rs SPEED* TRIAL

44# 448 444 1000 1001

-ipin Shanti)a) Pan0ha) v St o6 (ujarat Hussainara ,hatoon 8 "rs v Ho!e Se0retar1 Moti La) Sara6 Vs State o6 J 8 , 8 %nr Pan+aj ,u!ar V St o6 Maharashtra 8 "rs State o6 /P v Sha!:hu 7ath Singh 8 "rs )A/F ACT

%3 2001 SC 1158 %3 14#4 SC 1'$4 %3 200#SC5$ %3 2008 SC '0## %3 2001 SC 140'

1002 100'

Sardar ,han 8 "rs V S1ed 7aj!u) Hasan ?Seth@ 8 "rs 5a!i) 7adu Wa+6 -oard V Lara:sha 2arga Panruti

%3

200# SC 144#

J5 2008 ?1@SC 12'

Page51

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE

NOMINAL INDE&

Sl. No 1 2 3

Cause Title % Cho.gu)e and Co Ltd V (oa 9oundation and "rs % Ven+atasu::iah 7aidu v S Che))appan 8 "rs % Ven+atasu::iah 7aidu Vs S Cha))appan and "rs

Citatio# 2008 11 SC%L& 482 %3 2000 SC '0'2 %3 2000 SC '0'2

Title &nviron!enta) Prote0tion Civi) La. Civi) La.

Su$ Title &nviron!enta) Prote0tion CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 CPCF"rder '4 u)e 'a Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 11 Se0 20' %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 4 CPCF"rder 8 u)e 1 Preventive 2etention %nti0ipator1 -ai) Se0tion 154 %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 8 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Se0 120 Civi) Servi0e Judi0ia) %nd &*tra = Judi0ia) Con6ession CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# Preventive 2etention Civi) Servi0e Se0tion 154 ?1@ Judi0iar1

4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

%:du) ashid 3:rahi! Mansuri v St o6 (ujarat %0e Pipe)ine Contra0ts Pvt Ltd v -PCL %da)at Prasad Vs oop)a) Jinda) 8 "rs %dhuni+ Stee)s Ltd v "rissa Manganese and Minera)s Pvt Ltd %dit1a Hote)s P Ltd vs -o!:a1 S.adeshi Stores Ltd 8 "rs %2M Ja:a)pur Vs Siv+anth Shu+)a %dri 2haran 2as vs St o6 West -enga) %ghnoo 7agesia v St o6 -ihar %gri (o)d &*i!s Ltd vs Sri La+sh!i ,nits and Wovens and "rs

2000 2 SCC 51' 200# 5 SCC '04 2004 # SCC '88 200# # SCC 125 %3 200# SC 15#4

72PS %r:itration %0t Cr<P<C %r:itration %0t Civi) La. Constitution Cr<P<C Cr<P<C %r:itration %0t

%3 14#$ SC 120# 2005 4 SCC '0' 14$$ 1 SC 1'4 200# ' SCC $8$

13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

%h!ed v St o6 (ujarat %ja1 %gar.a) V /"3 %ja1 Hasis and "rs< Vs< ,ha)id Muji: Sehravardi and "rs< %ja1 Singh v St o6 Maharashtra %jendraprasadji 7 Pande 8 %nr Vs S.a!i ,eshavpra+eshdasji 7 8 "rs %, (opa)an Vs 5he State o6 Madras %, ,raipa+ and "rs Vs /"3 %)agarsa!1 and "rs V State o6 2SP %)) 3ndian Judges %sso0iation Vs /"3

2000 # SCC 4## %3 1442 SC 1$'#

72PS 3PC Constitution &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Constitution Constitution Cr<P<C Constitution

%3 1481 SC 48# %3 200# SC 2188

%3 200# SC 80$ %3 1450 SC 2#

%3 14#0 SC 150 2004 1' SC%L& '#$ 2002 4 SCC 24#

Page52

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 %)o+ ,u!ar

Cause Title o1 v 2r S7 Sar!a 8 %nr

Citatio# %3 14$8 SC 45' %3 14$' SC 424

Title Judge!ent Writing Civi) La. Cr<P<C Judge!ent Writing Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La.

Su$ Title Judge!ent Writing CPCFSe0 80 Se0tion 154 Judge!ent Writing ight "6 Prisioners CPCF"rder 22 u)e 10 Se0tion 2# La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# Spe0i6i0 Per6or!an0e Prose0ution "6 % Co!pan1 21ing 2e0)aration epresentation "6 Peop)es %0t 2e)a1 3n Pronoun0ing Judg!ent 9a)sus 3n /no 9a)sus 3n "!ni:us Constitutiona) Va)idit1 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Se0tion 154 Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution CPCFSe0 151 Juveni)e Justi0e %0t 148$ 2o0trine "6 eading 2o.n

%!ar 7ath 2ogra Vs /nion o6 3ndia /"3 %!ar Singh v -a).inder Singh 8 "rs %!ina %h!ed 2ossa 8 "rs v St o6 Maharashtra %!ir Shad ,han and anr V L H!ing)iana and ors %!it ,u!ar Sha. and %nr Vs 9arida ,hatoon and %nr %!itsingh -hi+a!sing 5ha+ur v St o6 Maharashtra %!rit La) (overdhan La)an v St -an+ o6 5ravan0ore 8 "rs

200' 2 SCC 518 %3 2001 SC $5$ 1441 4 SCC '4 2005 11 SCC 40' %3 200# SC $#$ %3 14$8 SC 14'2

30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40

%!rit Singh V St o6 Punja: %ndhra -an+ vs %-7 %!ro -an+ 7V 8 "rs %nig)ase Bohannan Vs a!)atha 8 "rs

%3

200# SC 1'2

3PC Civi) La. Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t &viden0e %0t Civi) La. 2e)a1 3n Pronoun0ing Judg!ent &viden0e %0t Constitution 3PC Cr<P<C

%3 200# SC 2511 %3 2005 SC '50' %3 2000 SC 145 200# $ SC%L& '$# 2004 4 SCC '10 %3 2001 SC '1#' 2008 5 SCC '$8 %3 2008 SC $$'

%ni) Hada Vs 3ndian %0r1)i0 Ltd %ni) Pra+ash Shu+)a V %rvind Shu+)a %ni) Vasudev Sa)gaon+ar V 7aresh ,usha)i Shigaon+ar %ni) ai vs St o6 -ihar %ni!iredd1 Ven+ata a!ana and "rs V Pu:)i0 Prose0utor HC o6 %P %nuj (arg 8 "rs V Hote) %sso0iation o6 3ndia 8 "rs %ppasahe: 8 %nr v St o6 Maharashtra %pren Joseph a)ias Current ,unju+unju 8 "rs v St o6 ,era)a

%3 200# SC #$' %3 14#' SC 1

41 42 43 44

% %ntu)a1 vs

S 7a1a+ 8 "rs

1488 2 SCC $02 %3 14$4 SC 44' %3 2000 SC 22$4 200$ 4 SC%L& '20

Cr<P<C Civi) La. Juveni)e Justi0e Ma*i!s

%rjun Singh Vs Mohindra ,u!ar and "rs %rnit 2as Vs St o6 -hiar %run ,u!ar 8 "rs Vs /"3 8 "rs

Page53

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 45 46 47 48 49 50 51

Cause Title %run V1as 8 %nr v %nita V1as %run V1as 8 %nr v %nita V1as %shan 2evi and %nr Vs Phu).asi 2evi and "rs %sho+ ,u!ar Badav and "rs< Vs< State o 6 Har1ana %s)a! -a:a)a) 2esai vs St o6 Maharashtra %t!a a! Properties P Ltd Vs 9edera) Motors %ttar Singh 8 %nr Vs /nion o6 3ndia

Citatio# %3 1444 SC 20#1 %3 1444 SC 20#1 200' 12 SCC 214 1485 ?4@ SCC 41# 1442 CrLJ '#12 2005 1 SCC #05 2004 11 S0a)e 5#

Title Cr<P<C 3PC Civi) La. Constitution Cr<P<C ent Contro) Cases Land %0Duition

Su$ Title 2is0harge 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath CPCF"rder 21 u)e 4# Civi) Servi0e Can0e))ation "6 -ai) Su:=5enana01 2eter!ination "6 Mar+et Va)ue Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) Juveni)e Justi0e %0t 2000 Judi0ia) %nd &*tra = Judi0ia) Con6ession CPCF"rder 21 u)e 4# 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness 2e6au)t 3n Pa1!ent "6 ent Su:=5enana01 Lega))1 &n6or0ea:)e 2e:t=-urden "6 Proo6 Se0tion 154 CPCF"rder 4 u)e 1' MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder Judge!ent Writing CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 8$ -orsta) S0hoo) %0t = Se0tion 10a CPCF"rder 41 u)e 22 %nd ''

52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62

- Saha 8 "rs v MS ,o0har - Vish.anath V State o6 ,arnata+a -a:)oo Pasi Vs St o6 Jhar+hand -a:u:hai /desinh Par!ar V State o6 (ujarat -a:u)a) Vs aj ,u!ar and "rs

14#4 4 SCC 1## J5 2008 2 SC '05 2008 1' SC%L& 1'# %3 %3 200# SC 420 144$ SC 2050

Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Juveni)e Justi0e &viden0e %0t Civi) La. &viden0e %0t ent Contro) Cases ent Contro) Cases 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La.

-aha) Singh v St o6 Har1ana -ai Chan0ha) and "rs V S1ed Ja)a)uddin and "rs -ajaj %uto Li!ited V -ehari La) ,oh)i -a)aji Sea6oods &*ports ?3@ Ltd Vs M%C 3ndustries -a)dev Singh 8 anr v State o6 Punja: -a)dev Singh V Surinder Mohan Shar!a and "rs

%3 14#$ SC 20'2 14#0 ' SCC 124 %3 1484 SC 180$

1444 1 C5C $ %3 144$ SC '#2 200' 1 SCC '4 2004 CrLJ 2480 SC %3 1444 SC ''81 %3 144$ SC 2#81 %3 2008 SC 14'4 200' 4 SCC $0$

63 64 65 66 67

-a)+ar Singh v St o6 /ttara+hand -a)raj 5aneja 8 %nr v Suni) Madan 8 %nr -a)ra! son o6 -hasa a! V 3)a! Singh and ors -a)u A -a+thvat0ha)u Vs St o6 5a!i) 7adu -anarsi and "rs V a! Pha)

3PC Judge!ent Writing Civi) La. Juveni)e Justi0e Civi) La.

Page54

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79

Cause Title -and)a!uddi %t0huta a!aiah 8 ors v St o6 %P -anga)ore Water Supp)1 8 Se.erage -oard Vs % ajappa 8 "rs -an+ o6 -ihar Ltd v 2r 2a!odar Prasad 8 %nr -an+ o6 -ihar Ltd V Maha:ir La) and "rs -anti A (uddu v St o6 MP -arnes 3nvest!ents Ltd and "rs V aj , (upta and "rs -asavaraj Pati) 8 "rs v St o6 ,arnata+a 8 "rs -aso Prasad 8 "rs v St o6 -ihar -e)i a! 8 anr Vs Sa)ig a!

Citatio# 144$ CrLJ 44$' %3 14#8 SC 548 %3 14$4 SC 24# %3 14$4 SC '## 2004 1 SCC 414 %3 2001 SC 2818 %3 2000 SC '214 %3 200# SC 1014 %3 144$ SC #5# %3 14#' SC 10$ %3 14## SC 2252 2004 11 S0a)e 251

Title Cr<P<C La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C Civi) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Constitution &viden0e %0t Land %0Duition

Su$ Title Se0tion 154 3ndustries La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee La. "6 Contra0tFVi0arious Lia:i)it1 Se0tion 1$1 CPCF"rder 21 54 Se0 '1' igor Mortis 5rans6er "6 Propert1FMortgage 9reedo! "6 &*pression 3njuries "n 5he %00used 2eter!ination "6 Mar+et Va)ue Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution Co!!on ":je0t 9a)sus 3n /no 9a)sus 3n "!ni:us S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e CPCF"rder 21 u)e 4# Se0tion 118 % "6 7i %0t einstate!ent F -a0+ Wages %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 8 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e "00u)ar &viden0e 2is0ripan0ies CPCF"rder 21 u)e 11

u)e

-ennett Co)e!an 8 Co Vs /"3 -ha:a 7anda Sar!a and "rs v State o6 %ssa! -hagat Singh 8 "rs Vs /nion o6 3ndia /"3 and %nr

80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87

-hag.an Prasad Srivastava v 7P Mishra -hag.an Singh and "rs V State o6 MP -hag.an 5ana Pati) v St o6 Maharashtra -hag.andas v St o6 ajasthan

%3 14#0 SC 1$$1 2002 4 SCC 85 %3 14#4 SC 21 %3 145# SC 584 %3 1445 SC '58

Cr<P<C 3PC &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t La:our %nd Servi0e La. %r:itration %0t

-han.ar La) Vs Sat1anarain and anr -harat -arre) 8 2ru! Manu Co Vs %!ir0hand P1are)a) -harat Heav1 &)e0tri0a)s Ltd V %ni) and ors -harat Se.a Sansthan vs /P &)e0troni0s Corporation Ltd

%3 1444 SC 1008 200$ 11 SC%L& 5$# 200# # SCC #'#

88 89 90

-harat:hai -hag.anji:hai v St o6 (ujarat -har.ada -hogin:hai Hirji:hai Vs State o6 (ujarat -has+aran V Sreedharan

2002 8 SCC '2# %3 148' SC #5' 2002 $ Supre!e '84

72PS &viden0e %0t Civi) La.

Page55

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115

Cause Title -havesh Ja1anti La+hani V St o6 Maharashtra and "rs -hopat Singh ,ishan Singh v St o6 Maharashtra -hupinder Shar!a v St o6 Hi!a0ha) Pradesh -hupinder Singh 8 "rs vs Jarnai) Singh and %nr -ijender Singh Vs St o6 Har1ana 8 anr -ijo1 ,u!ar 2ugar Vs -id1adhar 2utta -i+ash -hushan (hosh and "rs V 7ovartis 3ndia Ltd and %nr -ipin -ehari Sar+ar 8 %nr V St o6 West -enga) -ipin Shanti)a) Pan0ha) v St o6 (ujarat -ishnu Prasad Sinha 8 %nr vs St o6 %ssa! -, 7ara1ana Pi))ai vs Para!es.aran Pi))ai 8 %nr -o!:a1 21eing 8 M6g Co Ltd Vs -o!:a1 &nviron!enta) %0tion (roup 8 "rs -ondar Singh and "rs Vs 7iha) singh -onder and %nr vs He! Singh dead :1 L s and "rs -PCL vs 5he (reat &astern Shipping Co Ltd -rig Sa.ai -ha.ani Singh V 3ndian Hote)s Co Ltd and ors -ritish 3ndia (enera) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd v Captain 3t:ar Singh 8 "rs -S7L Vs /"3 -udhsen 8 %nr V State o6 /P -ur!ah She)) "i) 2istri:uting no. +no.n as -PCL V ,haja Midhat 7oor 8 "rs C % Su)ai!an and "rs Vs State -an+ o6 5ravan0ore %).a1ee and "rs C (upta V ()a*o S!ith ,)in Phar!a0euti0a) Ltd Canteen Ma;door Sa:ha V Meta))urgi0a) &ngg Cons 3 Ltd 8 "rs C-3 S35 7e. 2e)hi v %nupa! J ,u)+arni C-3 V State o6 ajasthan

Citatio# 2004 4 SCC 551 %3 14#' SC 44$ %3 200' SC 4$84 200$ CrLJ '$21 %3 2005 SC 22$2 %3 200$ SC 1255 200# 5 SCC 541 %3 1454 SC 1' %3 2001 SC 1158 %3 200# SC 848

Title Cri!ina) La. Cr<P<C Judge!ent Writing Cr<P<C Juveni)e Justi0e Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C Speed1 5ria) &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Ma*i!s Civi) La. Civi) La. %r:itration %0t Civi) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Constitution &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C

Su$ Title &*tradi0tion Se0tion 154 Judge!ent Writing Can0e))ation "6 -ai) Se0 20 Contri:utor1 7eg)igen0e Se0tion 10 = 3ndustria) 2isputes %0t 5ender "6 Pardon Speed1 5ria) Judi0ia) %nd &*tra = Judi0ia) Con6ession CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# Purposive 3nterpretation %dverse Possession %dverse Possession 2o0trine "6 Su:stitute CPCF"rder 40 u)e 1 Pa1 %nd e0over 9reedo! "6 5rade 3denti6i0ation 5rans6er "6 Propert1FLease CPCFSe0 100 Wor+!an Wor+!an Po)i0e Custod1 Se0tion 154

%3 2000 SC $14 %3 200$SC1484 2004 1 LW #0$ 2004 ' LW 1#4 200# 12 SC%L& 24# %3 144# SC 218'

%3 1454 SC 1''1 %3 200$ SC 1'8' %3 14#0 SC 1'21 %3 %3 1488 SC 14#0 200$ SC 2848

200# # SCC 1#1 200# 10 SC%L& 202 %3 1442 SC 1#$8 2001 ' SCC '''

Page56

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140

Cause Title C-3 Vs State o6 (ujarat CC %)avi Haji v Pa)apett1 Muha!!ed 8 %nr Ce)ina Coe)ho Pereira and "rs V /)has Maha:a)esh.ar ,ho)+ar and "rs C( Praveen =Vs= Mohd 5ajuddin Cha0+o and %nr Vs Mahadevan Chaganti Sat1anara1ana and "rs vs St o6 %P Chair!an 0u! M2 Coa) 3ndia Ltd and %nr V Mu+u) ,u!ar Choudhuri and "rs Chair!an 5a!i) 7adu Housing -oard Madras Vs 5 7 (anapath1 Cha))a!ane Hu0hha (o.da V M 5iru!a)a and %nr Cha!an La) and "rs V St o6 Punja: Chandra!ohan a!0handra Pati) and "rs V -apu ,o1appa Pati) 2ead thro Lrs and "rs Charan La) Sahu v /nion o6 3ndia 8 "rs Chaturdas -hag.andas Pate) Vs 5he State o6 (ujarat Chenna -o1anna ,rishna Badav vs St o6 Maharashtra and %nr Cher)opa))i Che)i!ina:i Sahe: 8 %nr Vs St o6 %P Chie6 Co!! o6 35 8 "rs vs Sushee)a Prasad 8 "rs Chi!an)a) Hargovinddas Vs Spe0ia) Land %0Duisition "66i0er Poona and %nr Chinna!a) and ors V P %ru!ugha! and anr Chintha!ani %!!a) Vs 7andagopa) (ounder and %nr Chitiva)asa Jute Mi))s Vs< Ja1pee e.a Ce!ent Chure1 La) V State o6 /P C3 &!den Vs State o6 /ttar Pradesh Citi;ens 6or 2e!o0ra01 thro its President V St o6 %ssa! and "rs Co!! o6 Wea)th 5a* ,anpur 8 "rs V Chander Sen 8 "rs Co!!er0ia) %viation and 5rave) Co and "rs v Vi!)a Panna)a) %3

Citatio# 200# SC 2522

Title Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t ent Contro) Cases 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Civi) La. Cr<P<C La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Civi) La. 3PC Civi) La. Constitution PC %0t Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Legiti!ate &*pe0tation Land %0Duition Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C PC %0t Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. Civi) La.

Su$ Title Se0tion 154 7oti0e Su:=5enana01 Co!p)aint -1 Po.er "6 %ttorne1 CPCFSe0 100 Can0e))ation "6 -ai) 2o0trine "6 Proportiona)it1 Spe0i6i0 e)ie6 %0tFPer!anent 3njun0tion CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 Se0 120 CPCF"rder 41 22 %nd '' Constitutiona) Va)idit1

200# $ SCC 555 %3 2010SC$0' C2J 2004 SC 1188 %3 200# SC 24$#

%3 148$ SC 21'0 2004 11 SC%L& $08 1440 1 SCC $08 2004 1 SCC 45' %3 2004 SC 24#2

u)e

200' ' SCC 552 1440 1 SCC $1' %3 14#$SC144# 200# CrLJ #82 SC %3 200' SC 1014 200# ' SC%L&40$ %3 1488 SC 1$52 %3 1440 SC 1828

3))ega) (rati6i0ation -ai) 21ing 2e0)aration Legiti!ate &*pe0tation 2eter!ination "6 Mar+et Va)ue CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession CPCFSe0 10 %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) 3))ega) (rati6i0ation ight "6 Prisioners Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession Court 9ees %0t

200# 4 SCC 1$' %3 2004 SC 1$8# 2008 10 SCC 450 %3 14$0SC548 1445 ' SCC #4' %3 148$ SC 1#5' %3 1488 SC 1$'$

Page57

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 141 142

Cause Title 2 (opa)a+rishnan Vs Sadanand 7ai+ 2 , -asu Vs St o6 West -enga)

Citatio# %3 2004 SC 44$5 %3 144# SC $10

Title &viden0e %0t Cri!ina) La.

Su$ Title 3denti6i0ation ight "6 Prisioners MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder S0ope "6 Se0tion 1'8 CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Hosti)e Witness 3nsanit1 9a)sus 3n /no 9a)sus 3n "!ni:us 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 Persona) La.FMus)i! Wo!en ?Prote0tion "6 ights "n 2ivor0e@ %0t 148$ %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 11 CPCF"rder 20 u)e 14 Chi)d Witness Cri!e S0ene Map ight "6 Prisioners &*tradi0tion Se0tion 1$' % %nd 1$$ "6 Motor Vehi0)es %0t S0he!e "6 Motor Vehi0)e %0t CPCFSu!!ar1 Suits Co!p)ete Justi0e

143 144 145

2 Sai)u Vs State o6 %P 2 Vinod Shivappa v 7anda -e))iappa 2adi Jagannadha! Vs Ja!!u)u a!u)u and "rs

%3 2008 SC 505 200$ %3 SCW 2#5# %3 2001 SC 2$44

3PC 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Civi) La.

146 147 148 149 150 151

2adu A 5u)sidas Vs State o6 Maharashtra 2ah1a:hai Chhagan:hai 5ha++er v St o6 (ujarat 2ah1a:hai Chhagan:hai 5ha++er V State o6 (ujarat 2a):ir Singh and "rs v St o6 Punja: 2a)ip Singh and "rs v St o6 Punja: 2a)pat ,u!ar 8 anr v Prah)ad Singh 8 ors

%3 2000 SC '20' %3 14$4 SC 15$' %3 14$4SC15$' %3 148# SC 1'28 %3 145' SC '$4 %3 144' SC 2#$

72PS &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Civi) La.

152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162

2ania) Lati6i 8 %nr V /"3 2atar S.it0hgears Ltd v 5ata 9inan0e Ltd 8 %nr 2attara1a V Shai+h Mah:oo: Shai+h %)i and %nr 2attu a!rao Sa+hare and "rs v St o6 Maharashtra Santa Singh v 5he State o6 Punja: 2avid Patri0+ Ward and %nr V /3 and "rs 2a1a Singh Lahoria Vs /nion o6 3ndia 2eepa) (irish:hai Soni 8 "rs v /nited 3ndia 3nsuran0e 2eepa) (irish:hai Soni 8 "rs Vs /nited 3ndia 3nsuran0e Co 2e6ian0e ,nitting 3ndustries Pvt Ltd Vs Ja1 %rts 2e)hi 2ev %uthorit1 V S+iper Cons Co P Ltd and anr
Page5

%3 2001 SC '458 2000 8 SCC 151 %3 14#0 SC #50 144# 5 SCC '41 %3 145$ SC 52$ 1442 4 SCC 154 %3 2001 SC 1#1$ 2004 5 SCC '85 %ir 2004 s0 210# 200$ 4 MLJ 4'4 SC %3 144$ SC 2005

Civi) La. %r:itration %0t Civi) La. &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Cri!ina) La. Cri!ina) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Civi) La. Constitution

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 163 164 165 166 167 168

Cause Title 2e)hi 2o!esti0 Wor+ing Wo!ens 9oru! vs /"3 and "rs 2e)hi Jud Serv %sso 5is Ha;ari Court 2e)hi V State o6 (ujarat and ors 2epot Manager %PS 5C V aghuda Siva San+ar Prasad 2esh -andhu (upta V 7 L %nand 8 ajinder Singh 2eva+i 7andan Prasad V St o6 -ihar 8 "rs 2hani a! (upta and "rs V La)a Sri a! and %nr

Citatio# 1445 1 SCC 14 1441 4 SCC 4'1 200# 1 SCC 222 1444 1 SCC 1'1 %3 148' SC 11'4 %3 1480 SC 15#

Title &viden0e %0t Constitution La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Constitution Civi) La.

Su$ Title ape Vi0ti! Co!pu)sor1 5esti!on1 2is0ip)inar1 %0tion CPCF"rder 21 u)e $$ Civi) Servi0e CPCF"rder 21 u)e 15 %nd 1$ Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution 3nte))e0tua) Propert1F5rade Mar+ Persona) La.FHindu La.F%doption %nd Maintenan0e 3nvestigation %nd 3nDuir1 2istin0tion CPCFSe0tion 4 Se0 '14 5er!ination "6 Servi0e %rrest %nd Custod1 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 Persona) La.FHindu La.FMarriage %nd 2ivor0e CPCF"rder 2' u)e 1 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e 3nte))e0tua) Propert1FCop1 ight Se0 20 Status "6 Land)ord Mi!ansa Prin0ip)e "6 3nterpretation

169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180

2hannja1 a! Shar!a v MS /ppada1a 8 "rs 2hari.a) 3ndustries Ltd 8 %nr Vs MSS 9ood Produ0ts 2har!a Sha!rao %ga)a.e V Pandurang Miragu %ga)a.e 8 "rs 2har!esh:hai Vasudev:hai 8 "rs Vs St o6 (ujarat 8 "rs 2hu)a:ai vs state o6 MP 2i)a.ar Singh Vs Parvinder Singh 2ire0tor 9ood and Supp Punja: and %nr V (ur!it Singh 2ire0torate o6 &n6or0e!ent vs 2eepa+ Mahajan and another 2istri0t ed Cross So0iet1 V -a:ita %rora and "rs 2ora: Ca.asji Warden v Coo!i Sora: Warden 8 ors 2urga Prasanna 5ripath1 Vs %rundhati 5ripath1 2.ari+a Prasad V 7ir!a)a and "rs

%3 14$0 SC #45 %3 2005 SC 1444 %3 1488 SC 845

Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Ma*i!s Civi) La. Cr<P<C La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La.

2004 $ SCC 5#$ 2005 ' SCC 42# C2J 2004 SC 1'48 200# 5 SCC #2# %3 1444 SC 1##5 %3 200#SC28#4 %3 1440 SC 8$# %3 2005SC'24# 2004 14 SC%L& $82

181 182 183 184 185

& Mi0he)raj v 7C- 5iruvandru! &astern -oo+ Co 8 "rs Vs 2- Moda+ 8 %nr &erati La*!an Vs St o6 %P &)ias Versus Cheri1an &!p St 3nsuran0e Corp Vs HM5 Ltd 8 %nr

%3 2008 SC 1#20 %3 2008 SC 804 2004 1 SC%L& 41

72PS Civi) La. Juveni)e Justi0e ent Contro) Cases Ma*i!s

%3 2008 SC 1'22

Page5!

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202

Cause Title &ngineer S1ndi0ate vs State o6 -ihar 8 "rs &ntertain!ent 7et.or+ ?3@ Ltd Vs Super Cassette 3ndust &S3 Corporation Vs 9ran0is 2e Costa &verest Coa) Co!pan1 P Ltd V St o6 -ihar &*press 7e.spapers Pvt Ltd 8 "rs vs /"3 and "rs 9addi v St o6 MP 9C3 Vs S 7 7agar+ar 9erti)i;ers 8 Che!i0a)s 5ravan0ore Ltd Vs egiona) 2ir &S3C 8 "rs 9(P Ltd V Sa)eh Hooseini 2o0tor 8 %nr 9ran0is Stan)1 A Sta)in v 7C5hiruvananthapura! 9ree Lega) %id Co!!ittee Ja!shedpur vs St o6 -ihar 9u;)un:i V , ,hader Va)i 8 %nr ( a!a0handra edd1 8 Co Vs /o3

Citatio# 200# ' SCC 44 2008 4 SC%L& $4 %3 144# SC 4'2 %3 14## SC 2'04

Title %r:itration %0t Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C %r:itration %0t Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C

Su$ Title 7on Spea+ing %.ard 3nte))e0tua) Propert1FCop1 ight %00ident 3n 5he Course "6 &!p)o1!ent CPCF"rder 40 u)e 1 Pro!issor1 &stoppe) Se0tion 154 CPCF"rder 21 10

148$ 1 SCC 1'' 14$4 $ SC '12 %3 2002 SC 808 2004 11 SC%L& #$$ %3 200# SC 1058 %3 200# SC #44

u)e

&si %0tFSe0 45 5rans6er "6 Propert1FPart Per6or!an0e Judi0ia) %nd &*tra = Judi0ia) Con6ession -ai) Se0tion 125 %r:itration %0t= 1440FSe0 '0 Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession Hand.riting &*pert Se0 '1' Se0 '14 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent CPCF"rder 21 u)e 15 %nd 1$ %d=Ho0FCasua) &!p)o1!ent CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 S0 %nd St %0t CPCF"rder 21 84 5o 42

%3 1482 SC 14$' %3 1480 SC 1#'0

%3 2004 SC 2$24 2004 ' LW 80# 2004 10 SC%L& 2$8 C2J 2004 SC 1'48 2002 SCC Cr) 24#

( Se+ar v (eetha 8 "rs ( So!esh.ar ao Vs Sa!ineni 7agesh.ar ao (anesh (ogoi Versus State o6 %ssa! (anesh La) Vs State o6 ajasthan

203 204 205 206 207 208 209

(anga -ahadur 5hapa v St o6 (oa (anga ,isan Sah+ari Chini Mi))s Ltd V Jaivir Singh (anga:ai (opa)das Mohata v< 9u)0hand and others (angadhar Pi))ai V Sie!ens Ltd (angu:ai -a:)1a Chaudhar1 8 "rs v Sitara! -ha)0handra Su+htan+ar 8 "rs (angu)a %sho+ 8 %nr v State o6 %P (anpat Singh 2ead :1 Lrs V ,ai)ash Shan+ar and "rs

2000 10 SCC '12 200# 11 SC%L&404 %3 144# SC 1812

72PS La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Cri!ina) La. Civi) La.

200# 1 SCC 5'' %3 148' SC #42 %3 2000 SC #40 %3 148# SC 144'

u)e

Page6"

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231

Cause Title (auhati /niversit1 Versus 7ihar)a) -hatta0harjee (eejaganda So!aiah v St o6 ,arnata+a (enera) Manager Har1ana oad.a1s V udhan Singh (eorge 8 "rs v St o6 ,era)a 8 %nr (hansh1a! 2ass and "rs Vs 2o!inion o6 3ndia (hansh1a!das and anr V "! Par+ash and anr (hasi a! and "rs Vs Chait a! Saini and "rs (hu)a! asoo) and %nr Vs State o6 Ja!!u and ,ash!ir and %nr (irdhari La) 2ead :1 Lrs V Hu+a! Singh and "rs (oa P)ast P Ltd v Chi0o /rsu)a 2 Sou;a (opa) Singh 8 "rs V /jagar Singh 8 "rs (opa)a+rishna Pi))ai and "rs V Meena+shi %1a) and "rs (ovindaraju V State o6 ,arnata+a (ra!ophone Co!pan1 o6 3ndia Ltd V -irendra -ahadur Pande1 and "rs (ujarat -ott)ing Co Ltd 8 ors v Co0a Co)a Co 8 ors (ujarat -ott)ing Co Ltd and "rs V Co0a Co)a Co and "rs (ujarat /rja Vi+ash 7iga! Ltd Vs &ssar Po.er Ltd (u)i Chand and "rs v St o6 ajasthan (upte Cardia0 Care 0enter and Hospita) Vs ")1!pi0 Phar!a Care Pvt Ltd (ur:a* Singh v State o6 Har1ana (ur0haran Singh and "rs vs 2e)hi %d!inistration (urdev ,aur and "rs Vs ,a+i and ors

Citatio# 1445 $ SCC #'1 %3 200# SC 1'55 2005 5 SCC 541 %3 1448 SC 1'#$ %3 1484 SC 1004 %3 1444 SC 1242 %3 1448 SC 24#$

Title Civi) La. &viden0e %0t La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. ent Contro) Cases 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. 3PC Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Ma*i!s &viden0e %0t Civi) La. 72PS Cr<P<C Civi) La.

Su$ Title CPCF"rder 4 u)e $ Se0tion 2# einstate!ent F -a0+ Wages Se0tion 154 CPCFSe0 80 CPCF"rder 21 58 CPCF"rder 21 4# CPCFSe0 80 9i*ation "6 9air ent S0ope "6 Se0tion 1'8 Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession CPCF"rder 20 u)e 12 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath 3nte))e0tua) Propert1FCop1 ight CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 Mi!ansa Prin0ip)e "6 3nterpretation 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness CPCFSe0 10 Se0tion 50 "6 72PS %0t Can0e))ation "6 -ai) Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder Se0tion 1$1

u)e u)e

%3 148' SC 1188 14## ' SCC '4# 2004 2 SCC 2'5 %3 1454 SC 5#4

%3 14$# SC 155 J5 2004 # SC 521 %3 1484 SC $$#

%3 1445 SC 2'#2 %3 1445 SC 2'#2

%3 2008 SC 1421 14#4 ' SCC $48 %3 2004 SC 2''4 %3 2001 SC 1002 %3 14#8 SC 1#4a

200# 1 SCC 54$

232 233

(ur!ai) Singh Vs State o6 Punja: (urna! ,aur v -a+shish Singh 8 "rs

%3 1482 SC 14$$ %3 1481 SC $'1

3PC Cr<P<C

Page61

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257

Cause Title (urpreet Singh v St o6 Har1ana (urpreet Singh Vs St o6 Punja: (uru Ja!:hesh.ar /ni thro egistrar V 2hara! Pa) H S -ains vs State Ha))u 8 "rs v St o6 MP Hardev Singh V (ur!ai) Singh ?2@ :1 L s Hardip Singh V St o6 Punja: Hare ,rishna Singh and "rs v State o6 -ihar Hari ":u)a edd1 and "rs v St o6 %P

Citatio# %3 2002 SC '21# %3 200$ SC 141 200# 2 SCC 2$5 %3 1480 SC 188' %3 14#4 SC 14'$ %3 200# SC 1058 2008 11 SC%L& 51' %3 1488 SC 8$' %3 1481 SC 82 2004 8 SCC 14$

Title &viden0e %0t 3PC La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Civi) La. 72PS &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Juveni)e Justi0e Cr<P<C 3PC &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. 3PC Constitution Cr<P<C

Su$ Title Hosti)e Witness Co!!on 3ntention 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent Se0tion 15$?'@ Se0tion 154 5rans6er "6 Propert1F"stensi:)e ".ner 2e)a1 3n 9or.arding Sa!p)es 3njuries "n 5he %00used 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness Juveni)e Justi0e %0t 2000 Co!pensation /nder Se0tion '5# Se0 120 So)itar1 Witness Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t Se0tion 154 Senten0ing 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent CPCF"rder 20 u)e 18 3denti6i0ation CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Judi0iar1 Se0tion 154

Hari a! v St o6 /P Hari a! Vs St o6 ajasthan 8 %nr

2004 $ SC%L& $45 %3 1488 SC 212# 14#2' SCC 84 %3 14#4SC15$$ 2002 $ s00 4#0 %3 1481 SC '$1 J5 2004 ?11@SC 240 200# 5 SCC #42 200# 2 SCC '55 %3 200# SC 2425 %3 1448 SC $18

Hari Singh v Su+h:ir Singh and "rs Harihar Prasad et0 v St o6 -ihar Harijan Megha! Jesha vs State o6 (ujarat Harijana 5hirupa)a 8 "rs v PP HC %P Harpa) Singh 8 %nr v St o6 Hi!a0ha) Pradesh Haru (hosh Vs State o6 West -enga) Har1ana /r:an 2eve)op!ent %uthorit1 V "! Pa) Hasha! %::as Sa11ad vs /s!an %::as Sa11ad 8 "rs Heera and %nr Vs St o6 ajasthan

Heera)a) vs ,a)1an Ma) 8 "rs He! Chand v St o6 Har1ana He!ani Ma)hotra Vs< High Court o6 2e)hi He!ant 2has!ane V C-3 8 "rs

1444 $ SCC #2# 2008?#@ SCC 11 2001 # SCC 5'$

Page62

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 258

Cause Title Hero Vinoth !inor Vs Sesha!!a)

Citatio# %3 200$ SC 22'4

Title Civi) La.

Su$ Title &ase!ent %0t Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution Se0tion 2# La. "6 Contra0tF-an+ (uarantee %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 4 Chi)d Witness Cri!e S0ene Map CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 La. "6 Contra0tF-an+ (uarantee %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 8 Se0tion 140 CPCF"rder 40 1 -asi0 Stru0ture Jurisdi0tion Lega))1 &n6or0ea:)e 2e:t=-urden "6 Proo6 -ai) 3n 5%2% "66en0e CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 Speed1 5ria) ight "6 Prisioners CPCF"rder 40 u)e 1 CPCFSe0 148a Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t CPCFSe0 10 -asi0 Stru0ture

259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281

HH- (i)) 8 %nr v 5he ,ing Hi!a0ha) Pradesh %d!inistration Vs "! Pra+ash Hi!adri Che!i0a)s 3ndustries Ltd V Coa) 5ar e6ining Co Hi!adri Che!i0a)s 3ndustries Ltd vs Coa) 5ar e6ining Co Hi!!at Su+hadeo Wahur.agh and "rs Vs St "6 Maharashtha 5ori Singh v 5he State o6 /P Hi!!at:hai V i+hi)a) and "rs

%3 1448 PC 128 %3 14#2 SC 4#5 %3 200# SC 2#48

Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Civi) La. %r:itration %0t &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. %r:itration %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. Constitution Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. Speed1 5ria) Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Constitution

200# 8 SCC 110 %3 2004 SC 2242 %3 14$2 SC '44 %3 %3 14#8 SC 418 1444 SC '#10

Hindustan Constru0tion Co Ltd V St o6 -ihar 8 "rs Hindustan Petro)eu! Corpn Ltd V Pin+0it1 Mid.a1 Petro)eu!s Hira La) and "rs V State o6 /P and "rs Hira)a) Patni V Loon+ara! Sethi1a and "rs His Ho)iness ,esavananda -harati Sripadaga)varu 8 "rs Vs St o6 ,era)a 8 %nr Hiten P 2a)a) Vs -ratindranath -anerjee Hiten P 2a)a) v -ratindranath -anerjee Hitendra Vishnu 5ha+ur and "rs et0 vs St o6 Maharashtra and "rs HPCL Vs Sri Sri!an 7ara1an and %nr Hussainara ,hatoon 8 "rs v Ho!e Se0retar1 Hussainara ,hatoon Vs Ho!e Se01 St o6 -ihar Patna 3C3C3 V ,arnata+a -a)) -earings Corp Ltd and "rs 3)a Vipin Pand1a Vs S!ita %!:a)a) Pate) 3nder Singh 8 %nr v St 2e)hi %d!n 3ndian -an+ Vs Maharashtra State Co= operative Mar+eting 9ederation Ltd 3ndira 7ehru (andhi v
Page63

200' $ SCC 50' %3 2004 SC 2'80 %3 14$2 SC 21

u)e

%3 14#' SC 14$1 %3 2001 SC '84# 2001 $ SCC 1$ %3 1444 SC 2$2' %3 2002 SC 2548

%3 14#4 SC 1'$4 %3 14#4 SC 1'$0 %3 1444 SC '4'8

%3 200#SC2404 14#8 4 SCC 1$1 %3 1448 SC 1452 %3 14#5 SC 2244

aj 7arain

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 282 283

Cause Title 3ndira Sa.hne1 vs /"3 3nds) 9in Corp o6 3ndia Ltd v Cannanore Spinning 8 Weaving Mi))s Ltd 8 "rs

Citatio# %3 2000 SC 448 2002 5 SCC 54

Title Constitution Civi) La.

Su$ Title eservation La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee Persona) La.FMus)i! Wo!en ?Prote0tion "6 ights "n 2ivor0e@ %0t 148$ %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 11 Li!itation %0t CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 3nte))e0tua) Propert1FPatents Pro6essiona) 7eg)igen0e CPCF"rder 8 u)e $ Sudden Provo0ation %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 # 5rans6er "6 Propert1FLease 7oti0e /nsound Mind 3njuries "n 5he %00used CPCF"rder '2 % u)e ' %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) 9a)sus 3n /no 9a)sus 3n "!ni:us Hosti)e Witness Juveni)e Justi0e %0t 148$ Cogni;an0e CPCF"rder 21 84 5o 42 CPCFSe0 4# Se0 4$8

284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305

3D:a) -ano V State o6 /P 8 %nr 3ron 8 Stee) Co Ltd v 5i.ari oad Lines J ,u!aradasan 7air 8 %nr Vs 3 5C Sohan 8 "rs J M -is.as Vs 7 , -hatta0harjee and "rs J Mitra and Co Pvt Ltd V %sst Contro))er o6 Patents and 2esig and "rs Ja0o: Mathe. V St o6 Punja: and %nr Jag Mohan Cha.)a 8 anr vs 2era adha S.a!i Satsang 8 ors Jagat Singh Vs State o6 Punja: Jagdish Chander Vs a!esh Chander and "rs

%3

200# SC 2215

Civi) La. %r:itration %0t Li!itation %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t %r:itration %0t Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t 3PC &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Juveni)e Justi0e Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C

200# 5 SCC #0' 2004 ' MLJ 522 SC %3 2002 SC 1$44

2008 10 SCC '$8 %3 %3 2005 SC '180 144$ 2222

1444 2 SC%L& 4$' 200# $ SC%L& '25 %3 1444 SC 1$44

Jagdish 2utt 8 %nr V 2hara! Pa) 8 "rs Jagdish Singh v 7atthu Singh Jagdish V St o6 MP Jagdish v State o6 ajasthan Jagraj Singh V -irpa) ,aur Jai Singh and "rs V 5he State o6 ,arnata+a Ja++i at Se)varaj and %nr v St rep :1 3P Coi!:atore Ja!atraj ,e.a)ji (ovani v St o6 Maharashtra Ja!ee) Vs St o6 Maharashtra Ja!una Singh vs -hadai Shah Jana+ aj V (urdia) Singh and %nr Janaparedd1 Lat0han 7aidu V Janaparedd1 San1asa!!a Japani Sahoo Vs Chandra Se+har Mohant1
Page64

%3 1442 SC 1$04 2004 12 SC%L& 580 %3 14#4 SC 1010 %3 200# SC 208' 200# 10 SCC #88 200# CrLJ 1$#1 SC %3 14$8 SC 1#8 %3 200# SC 4#1 %3 14$4SC1541 %3 14$# SC $08

u)e

%3 14$' SC 155$ %3 200# SC 2#$2

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 306 307 308

Cause Title Jas:ir Singh V Punja: and Sind -an+ and "rs Jasvinder Singh and "rs< et0 Vs< State o6 J and , Jas.ant)a) 7atvar)a) 5ha++ar Vs Sushi)a:en Mani)a) 2angar.a)a and ors Ja.ahar Singh A -hagat Ji Vs St o6 (7C5 o6 2e)hi Ja1endra Vishnu 5ha+ur Vs St o6 Maharahstra and %nr Jet P)1 Wood Private Ltd 8 %nr Vs Madhu+ar 7o.)a+ha 8 "rs Jitendra a! A Jitu Vs St o6 Jhar+hand J, S1ntheti0s Ltd V ,P %gra.a) and %nr Jodha1an V -a:u a! and "rs

Citatio# 200# 1 SCC 5$$ 200' 2 SCC 1'2 %3 1441 SC ##0

Title La:our %nd Servi0e La. Constitution Civi) La.

Su$ Title 2is0ip)inar1 %0tion Civi) Servi0e CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Crp0F%:s0onding %00used 2o0trine "6 &*de:ito Jusitiae 2eter!ination "6 %ge "6 Juveni)it1 2is0ip)inar1 %0tion CPCF"rder 20 u)e 14 Se0tion 1$4?1@ %rrest %nd Custod1 CPCF"rder 20 u)e 14 Prote0tion "6 Wea+er Se0tion Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e %00ount C)osed 2eter!ination "6 %ge "6 Juveni)it1 2e6au)t 3n Pa1!ent "6 ent Se0 40$ 5erritoria) Jurisdi0tion 5hird Part1FPersonFVehi0) e Civi) Servi0e Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Se0ondar1 &viden0e

309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318

%3 2004 SC 2'41 2004 # SCC 104 1 %3 200$ SC 12$0 %3 200$ SC 14'' 200# 2 SCC 4'' %3 148' SC 5#

72PS Cr<P<C Ma*i!s Juveni)e Justi0e La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Civi) La. Constitution

Jogendra 7aha+ 8 ors vs State o6 "rissa Joginder ,u!ar vs State o6 /P Johri Singh V Su+h Pa) Singh and "rs Jo))1 (eorge Varghese and %nr V 5he -an+ o6 Co0hin

%3 1444SC25$5 1444 4 SCC 2$0 %3 %3 1484 SC 20#' 1480 SC 4#0

319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326

Joseph 9ernande; v State o6 (oa Jugesh Sehga) Versus Sha!sher Singh (ogi J1oti Pra+ash ai A J1oti Pra+ash Vs St o6 -ihar , % a!esh and "rs V S!t Sushee)a -ai and "rs , %n:a;hagan Vs 5he Superintendent o6 Po)i0e , -has+aran Vs San+aran Vaidh1an -a)an 8 %nr , 7anda+u!ar v M2 5hantha) Peri1ar 5ransport Corpn ,< Manjusree Vs< State o6 %P

2000 1 SCC #0# 2004 4 SC%L& 455 %3 2008 SC 1$4$ %3 1448 SC 1'45 %3 2004 SC 524 %3 1444 SC '#$2 144$ %CJ 555 SC 2008?'@ SCC 512

72PS 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Juveni)e Justi0e ent Contro) Cases Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Constitution

327 328

,a)e!a 5u!:a v St o6 Maharashtra 8 %nr ,a)1an Singh Vs S!t Chhoti 8 "rs


Page65

1444 8 SCC 25# %3 200# SC 1014

72PS &viden0e %0t

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 329 330

Cause Title ,a!a)anantha 8 "rs V State o6 5a!i) 7adu ,a!)esh+u!ar 3sh.ardas Pate) V /3 and "rs %3

Citatio# 2005 SC 21'2

Title Cr<P<C Cri!ina) La.

Su$ Title Senten0ing ight "6 Prisioners Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e -ona6ide eDuire!ent 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath So)itar1 Witness 72PS %0t = Se0tion 42 Hosti)e Witness -ai) 2eve)op!ent Charges 7o 9au)t Lia:)it1 CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 (rant "6 Pardon -1 President La. "6 Contra0tF/njust &nri0h!ent ight "6 Prisioners Persona) La.FMus)i! Wo!en ?Prote0tion "6 ights "n 2ivor0e@ %0t 148$ Produ0tion "6 2o0u!ent Hosti)e Witness Se0tion 2# ight "6 Co!p)ainant Person 3n Charge "6 5he Co!pan1 Lega))1 &n6or0ea:)e 2e:t=-urden "6 Proo6 Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0

1445 4 SCC 51

331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343

,anhai1a La) v State o6 MP ,annia!!a) Vs Che))ara! ,ans aj v St o6 Punja: 8 "rs

2000 10 SCC '80 %3 2002 SC 1#'4

72PS ent Contro) Cases 3PC &viden0e %0t 72PS &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Land %0Duition Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Cri!ina) La.

2000 5 SCC 20# 200' 5 SCC 241 2004 8 SCC 5'4 %3 14#$ SC 480 %3 144$ SC '240 200' 1 SCC '54 %3 2001 SC 485 %3 14#4 SC 1''1

,ara!jit Singh v State 2e)hi %d!inistration ,arnai) Singh V State o6 Har1ana ,aruppanna 5hevar and "rs v St o6 57 ,ashi 7ath o1 vs State o6 -ihar

,asturi and "rs Vs State o6 Har1ana ,aushnu!a -egu! and "rs V 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Ltd and "rs ,a1ja1 3ndustries P Ltd Vs %sne. 2ru!s P Ltd and "rs ,ehar Singh Vs /"3 ,era)a State &)e0 -oard V Hindustan Constru0tion Co Ltd 8 "rs ,e.a) Pati S!t V State o6 /P and "rs

%3 1484 SC $5' %3 200# SC 425 1445 ' SCC $00

344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351

,hatoon 7isa V State o6 /P 8 "rs ,hatri vs State o6 -ihar ,hujji a)ias Surendra 5i.ari v St o6 MP ,hujji a)ias Surendra 5i.ari v St o6 MP ,ishan La) V 2har!endra -a6na and %nr ,, %huja Vs V, Vora ,7 -eena v Muni1appan 8 anr ,7 Shu+)a v 7avnit La) Mani)a) -hat 8 %nr

2002 $ SC%L& 1$5 %3 1481 SC 10$8 %3 1441 SC 185' %3 1441 SC 185' 2004 # SCC $85 2004 4 SC%L& 8# %3 2001 SC 2845 14$# CriLJ 1200 SC

Civi) La. &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C

Page66

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No

Cause Title

Citatio#

Title

Su$ Title Servants %gainst Prose0ution

352 353 354 355

,onajeti aja:a:u V St o6 %P 8 %nr ,P( 7air Vs Jinda) Mentho) 3ndia Ltd , 3ndira v 2r ( %dinara1ana ,rishna Janardhan -hat Vs 2attathara1a Hegde ,rishna ,an.ar A 5ha+uraeen v St o6 ajasthan ,rishna Mo0hi 8 "rs v St o6 -ihar ,u)dip Singh v Su:hash Chander Jain 8 "rs ,u!ar Sudhendu 7arain 2e: Vs enu+a -is.as and ors ,undu)a -a)a Su:rah!an1a! 8 %nr v St o6 %P ,usu! 3ngots %))o1s Ltd Vs Pennar Peterson Ltd L Chandra+u!ar Vs /nion o6 3ndia La0hh!an 2ass V a! La) and %nr La+sh!i and %nr V Chinna!!a) A a11a!!a) and "rs La+sh!i ,ant Pande1 v /"3 La+sh!i a! -hu1an V Hari Prasad -hu1an and "rs La+sh!i Singh and "rs v State o6 -ihar La) Chand Vs V333th %dd) 2ist Judge and ors La) Chand Vs /nion o6 3ndia /"3 and %nr La) 2evi and %ns Vs Vaneeta Jain and "rs La) Mohd 8 "rs V 3ndian ai).a1 Constru0tion Co Ltd 8 "rs La)ai A 2indoo 8 %nr v St o6 /P La)it Pop)i v Canara -an+ 8 "rs La))an Chaudhar1 and "rs v St o6 -ihar La))u Manjhi 8 %nr v St o6 Jhar+hand
Page67

2002 CriLJ 2440 2001 10 SCC 218 200' 8 SCC '00 %3 2008 SC 1'25

Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t

5ender "6 Pardon Person 3n Charge "6 5he Co!pan1 7oti0e Standard "6 Proo6= Presu!ption Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Prose0ution "6 % Si0+ 3ndustr1 -asi0 Stru0ture egistration %0tFSe0 1# %nd 44 CPCF"rder 1' u)e 10 3nter Countr1 %doption CPCF"rder 20 u)e 4 5o 14 3njuries "n 5he %00used CPCF"rder 21 u)e $4 2eter!ination "6 Mar+et Va)ue CPCF"rder 4 u)e $ %d=Ho0FCasua) &!p)o1!ent Se0tion 154 S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e Se0 204 Se0 '1'

356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375

2004 2 SCC $08 2002 $ SCC 81 %3 2000 SC 1410 %3 1442 SC '85 144' CrLJ 1$'5 SC %3 2000 SC 454 %3 144# SC 1125 %3 1484 SC 142'

72PS &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. 3PC 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Constitution Civi) La. Civi) La. Constitution Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Land %0Duition Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C

%3 2004 SC 2'52 1484 2 SCC 244 200' 1 SCC 14# %3 14#$ SC 22$' %3 144# SC 210$ 2004 11 SC%L& $2# %3 200# SC 25##

1444 1 SCC 54$ %3 14#4 SC 2118 200' ' SCC 58' %3 200$SC''#$ 200' 2 SCC 401

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 376 377

Cause Title La))u Manjhi 8 %nr v St o6 Jhar+hand La)sai ,hunte V 7ir!a) Sinha and "rs

Citatio# 200' 2 SCC 401 200# 4 SCC ''0

Title &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C

Su$ Title So)itar1 Witness Se0 '84 Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution Judge!ent Writing 21ing 2e0)aration Civi) Servi0e 2o0trine "6 Proportiona)it1 Se0tion '04 5ender "6 Pardon S0 %nd St %0t Se0 14' %nd '44 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Se0tion 1$4?2@ Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e 3))ega) (rati6i0ation Se0tion 1$4 CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 11 %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 4 2o0trine "6 Proportiona)it1 %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) epresentation "6 Peop)es %0t

378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388

La)u Prasad Badav V State o6 -ihar Lattu Mahto Vs State o6 -ihar La*!an Vs State o6 Maharastra Li)a 2har Vs< State o6 ajasthan and "rs L, Ver!a Vs HM5 Ltd 8 %nr Lt Co) SJ Chaudhar1 v St 2e)hi %d!in Lt Co!!ander Pas0a) 9ernandes V St o6 Maharashtra 8 "rs Lunara! V -hupat Singh and "rs M S Sheri66 v 5he State o6 Madras and "rs M Srinivasu)u V St o6 %P M% %nton1 A %ntappan Vs St o6 ,era)a

200# 1 SCC 44 2008 8 SCC '45 %3 2002 SC 24#' 2008?'@ SCC 512 %3 200$ SC 4#5 %3 1484 SC $18 %3 14$8 SC 544 2004 ' SCC #44 %3 1454 SC '4# %3 200# SC '14$ 2004 $ SC%L& '$

Cr<P<C Judge!ent Writing &viden0e %0t Constitution La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cri!ina) La. 3PC 3PC Cr<P<C

389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399

Madan La) 8 %nr v St o6 HP Madhu+ar -has+arrao Joshi V State o6 Maharashtra Maha:ir Singh Vs State o6 Har1ana Mahadeo Sav)ara! She)+e 8 "rs v Pune Muni0ipa) Corp 8 %nr Mahant Sa)ig a! V Musa!!at Ma1a 2evi Maharashtra State &- v "L High Court &rna+u)a! Maharshi 2a1anand /niversit1 8 %nr v %nand Coop LC So0 Ltd 8 %nr Mahat!a (andhi Saha+ra Sa++are ,ar+hane vs 7ationa) Heav1 &ngg Coop Ltd 8 %nr Mahindra 8 Mahindra Ltd vs 7- 7aravade et0 Main Pa) and %nr V State o6 Har1ana and "rs Ma+han La) -anga) v Manas -hunia 8 "rs
Page6

200' # SCC 4$5 2001 CriLJ 1#5 2001 # SCC 148 1445 ' SCC '' %3 1455 SC 2$$ %3 1482 SC 144# 200# 5 SCC 245 200# $ SCC 4#0 %3 2005 SC 144' 2004 10 SCC $42 %3 2001 SC 440

72PS PC %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. %r:itration %0t %r:itration %0t La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C Civi) La.

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 400 401 402 403 404 405

Cause Title Ma+han Singh 2 :1 Lrs V ,u).ant Singh Ma)a1 ,u!ar (angu)1 V 2r Su+u!ar Mu+herjee and "rs Ma))a Pra+asarao Vs Ma))a Jan+i Ma))a..a v 5he "rienta) 3nsu Co Ltd 8 "rs Mane+a (andhi Vs /"3 8 %nr Mangt o6 Coi!:atore 2ist Cent Coop -an+ V Se01 Coi!:atore 2t Cent Coop -an+ &!p %sso 8 %nr Mani)a) Mohan)a) Shah and "rs V Sardar Sa1ed %h!ed Sa1ed Maha!ad and %nr Manjunath %nandappa /r6 Shivappa Hanasi V 5a!!anasa 8 "rs Man+a!!a V State o6 ,era)a Manna)a) ,hetan and "rs V ,edar 7ath ,hetan and "rs Manohar La) Chopra v ai -ahadur ao Seth Hira)a)

Citatio# %3 200# SC 1808 2004 4 SCC 221 2004 ' SCC '4' 1444 1 SCC 40' 14#8 1 SCC 248 200# 4 SCC $$4

Title Civi) La. Cri!ina) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Constitution La:our %nd Servi0e La.

Su$ Title Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession Pro6essiona) 7eg)igen0e Se0tion 11 "6 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 5hird Part1FPersonFVehi0) e Constitutiona) Va)idit1 2is0ip)inar1 %0tion MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder Spe0i6i0 e)ie6 %0tFSpe0i6i0 Per6or!an0e Se0 '0$ CPCF"rder 21 u)e 4$ CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e -ai) MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee 7on Spea+ing %.ard Medi0ia) 7eg)igen0e Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t -ai) Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution

406 407 408 409 410

%3

1454 SC '44

3PC Civi) La. 3PC Civi) La. Civi) La.

%3 200' SC 1'41 2004 1' SC%L& '$# 14## 2 SCC 424 14$2 Supp 1 SC 450

aja

411 412

Manohar La) v St o6

ajasthan

144$ 11 SCC '41 200' 1 SCC $'2

72PS Cr<P<C

Mansa: %)i vs 3rsan and %nr

413 414 415 416 417 418 419

Manu:hai %ta:hai V St o6 (ujarat MaDsoodan 8 "rs v St o6 /P Margaret La)ita Sa!ue) v 3ndo Co!!er0ia) -an+ Ltd Mar+6ed Vanaspati and %))ied 3ndustries vs /"3 Martin 9 2Sou;a Vs Mohd 3sh6aD Masa)ti v State o6 /P Masroor v St o6 /P and %nr

%3

200# SC 24'#

3PC &viden0e %0t Civi) La. %r:itration %0t Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C

%3 148' SC 12$ %3 14#4 SC 102 200# 11 SC%L& 1'8 %3 2004 SC 2044 %3 14$5 SC 202 J52004 8 SC '48

420

Matajog 2o:e1 v H C -hari


Page6!

%3 145$ SC 44

Cr<P<C

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439

Cause Title Mattapa))i Che)a!a11a and %nr V Mattapa))i Ven+ataratna! and %nr Ma1adevi V Jagdish Prasad Ma1ar H, Ltd 8 "rs vs ".ners 8 Parties vesse) MV 9ortune &*press 8 "rs MC Mehta and anr V /"3 and ors MC Mehta V ,a!a) 7ath and "rs MC Mehta V ,a!a) 7ath and "rs MC Mehta Vs /"3 Metropo)itan 5ransport Corporation Vs V Ven+atesan M(M5 o6 2evi 5heatre V Vish.anath aju Miran 2evi V -ir:a) 2ass Mistr1 Pre!ji:hai Vitha)das V (anesh:hai ,eshavji Mitha:hai Pasha:hai Pate) 8 "rs Vs St o6 (ujarat Mithu Vs State o6 Punja: MM5C Ltd 8 %nr Vs Med0h) Che!i0a)s 8 Phar!a Pvt Ltd Modi Ce!ents Ltd v Shri ,u0hi) ,u!ar 7andi Moha!ed Masthan V So0iet1 Congregation -ros S Heart and %nr Mohan La) 8 %nr V %jit Singh 8 %nr Mohan La) 8 %nr v %jit Singh 8 %nr Mohan Singh Vs 3%%3 %3

Citatio# 14#2 SC 1121

Title Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. &nviron!enta) Prote0tion &nviron!enta) Prote0tion &nviron!enta) Prote0tion Cr<P<C La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. ent Contro) Cases ent Contro) Cases Cr<P<C Constitution 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Civi) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Land %0Duition

Su$ Title egistration %0tFSe0 1# %nd 44 Persona) La.FHindu La.FMarriage %nd 2ivor0e CPCF"rder # u)e 11 &nviron!enta) Prote0tion &nviron!enta) Prote0tion &nviron!enta) Prote0tion Se0tion 154 einstate!ent F -a0+ Wages CPCF"rder 41 u)e 11 9i*ation "6 9air 9i*ation "6 9air Po)i0e Custod1 Constitutiona) Va)idit1 Stop Pa1!ent S0ope "6 Se0tion 1'8 CPCF"rder 21 u)e '5 Se0 482 S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e Se0tion 1# Persona) La.FMus)i! Wo!en ?Prote0tion "6 ights "n 2ivor0e@ %0t 148$ CPCF"rder 21 u)e 48 %nd 50 CPCF"rder '4 u)e 1 CPCFSe0 4# Speed1 5ria) ent ent

%3 200# SC 142$ 200$ ' SCC 100 %3 %3 %3 148# SC 108$ 2000 SC 144# 2002 SC 1515

2008 1 SCC 40# 2004 11 SC%L& 50 2004 # SCC ''# 14## ' SCC 44$ 14## ' SCC 11 C2J 2004 SC 1014 %3 148' SC 4#' 2001 8 SC%L& 141 %3 1448 SC 105# %3 200$ SC 1#0$

14#8 ' SCC 2#4 %3 14#8 SC 118' 144$ 8 SC%L& 251

440 441 442 443 444

Mohd %h!ed ,han V Shah -ano -egu! and "rs Mohit -hargava vs -harat -hushan -hargava 8 "rs Morgan Stan)e1 Mutua) 9und v ,arti0+ 2as Moti La) -an+er V Mahraj ,u!ar Mah!ood Hasan ,han Moti La) Sara6 Vs State o6 J 8 , 8 %nr
Page7"

%3 1485SC445 %3 200# SC 1#1#

Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Speed1 5ria)

1444 SCW 2801 %3 14$8 SC 108# %3 200#SC5$

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468 Moti

Cause Title a! 8 "rs v State o6 MP

Citatio# %3 14#8 SC 1544 %3 2005SC#40 %3 1454 SC '00 %3 14$' SC #4$ %3 1458SC144 200# 1 SCC 441 1448 1 SC 8$8 200# 2 SCC 5'$ M%7/ SC 0041 2010 %3 1481 SC 1220 2004 8 SCC 145 2004 8 SCC 145 %3 1480 SC 1$22 %3 200$ SC 2402 %3 2001 SC 2#52 %3 2001 SC '0'1 1448 4 SCC $04 %3 14## SC 242

Title Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C La:our %nd Servi0e La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Constitution Juveni)e Justi0e 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t &viden0e %0t Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t %r:itration %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La.

Su$ Title Se0tion 1$#?2@ %nti0ipator1 -ai) Sear0h %nd Sei;ure La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee egistration %0tFSe0 1# %nd 44 Wor+!an Pu:)i0 Prose0utor Pro!issor1 &stoppe) Se0tion 154 Senten0ing 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent Se0tion 256 "6 3ndustria) 2isputes %0t &nviron!ent %nd Po))ution P)ea o6 Juveni)it1 Li!itation %)i:i ight "6 Prisioners CPCF"rder 20 u)e 18 Se0 '40 5ape e0orded Conversation %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 4 5rans6er "6 Propert1FLis Pendent CPCFSe0 24 CPCF"rder 21 5#

MP Lohia et0 V St o6 West -enga) and %nr MP Shar!a 8 "rs v Satish Chandra 2M 2e)hi 8 "rs MS %nirudhan v 5he 5ho!0oCs -an+ Ltd Mst ,irpa) ,aur Vs -a0han Singh and "rs Muir Mi))s /nit o6 75C ?/P@ Ltd V S.a1a! Pra+ash Srivastava and %nr Mu+u) 2a)a) 8 "rs v /"3 Mu+und S.arup Mishra vs /"3 and ors Mu))a and %nr V St o6 /P Muniappan v St o6 57 Muni0ipa) Corp 9arida:ad V Siri 7i.as Muni0ipa) Corp 9arida:ad vs Siri 7i.as Muni0ipa) Coun0i) at)a! Vs Vardivha! 8 "rs Munne1 A ahat Jan ,han Vs St o6 /P Munoth 3nvest!ents Ltd Vs Puttu+o)a Properties Ltd 8 anr Munshi Prasad and "rs Vs State o6 -ihar Murti 2evi V State o6 2e)hi and "rs Muthangi %11anna V Muthangi Jaggarao and "rs 7 7atarajan vs - , Su::arao 7 Sri a!a edd1 et0 v V V (iri

%3 200' SC 541 %3 14#1 SC 11$2 %3 2004 SC 221# %3 145$ SC 54' 2004 4 C5C #4 %3 148# SC 20$1

7 Srinivasa v ,uttu+aran Ma0hine 5oo)s Ltd 7agu:ai %!!a) 8 "rs Vs - Sa!a ao 7ahar 3ndustria) &nterprises Ltd 8 "rs Vs Hong ,ong 8 Shanghai -an+ 7an01 John L1ndon V Pra:hati La) Cho.dhur1 and "rs

u)e

Page71

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 469 470 471 472 473

Cause Title 7andini Satpath1 Vs P L 2ani 8 %nr 7anh+u Singh 8 %nr v St o6 -ihar 7arain Prasad %ggar.a) ?2@ :1 L s V St o6 MP 7ara1an -hag.antrao (osavi -a)aji.a)e Vs (opa) Vina1a+ (osavi and "rs 7ara1ana Menon A Mani=vs= St o6 ,era)a 7ara1anas.a!1 avishan+ar Vs %sst 2ire0torE 2ire0torate o6 evenue 3nte))igen0e 7ar:ada 2evi (upta V -irendra ,u!ar Jais.a) and %nr 7aresh Chandra %gar.a) Versus -an+ o6 -aroda

Citatio# %3 14#8 SC 1025 %3 14#' SC 441 %3 200# SC 2'44 %3 14$0SC100 %3 200$SC''$$

Title Constitution Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t

Su$ Title Co!pu)sor1 5esti!on1 Se0tion 1$1 5rans6er "6 Propert1FLease CPCF"rder 1 u)e 8 %00ount C)osed Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Se0tion $ CPCF"rder 4 u)e 1' MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder So)itar1 Witness CPCFSe0 10 Pa1 %nd e0over Pa1 %nd e0over P)1ing Without Per!it Se0tions 42a %nd 42: "6 Motor Vehi0)es %0t 14'4 %0t Lia:i)it1 Pre!iu! /npaid Pa1 %nd e0over 9a+e Li0en0e Pa1 %nd e0over Person 3n Charge "6 5he Co!pan1 Se0 '1' Se0 '84 Se0 482

474 475 476

%3 2002SC'$58 200' 8 SCC #45 2001 ' SCC 1$'

72PS &viden0e %0t Civi) La.

477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492

7aresh (iri Vs State o6 MP 7athusingh v State o6 MP 7ationa) 3nstitute o6 Menta) Hea)th and 7euro S0ien0es Vs C<Para!esh.ara 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co v -a)jit ,aur 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd v Cha))a -haratha!!a 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs Cha))a /pendra ao 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e VS Jethu a! 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs Pre!:ai Pate) "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs See!a Ma)hotra 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd v S.aran Singh 8 "rs 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Vs ,anti 2evi 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Vs ,usu! 8 ors 7ationa) S!a)) 3ndustries Corp Ltd V Har!eet Singh Painta) and %nr 7ava) ,ishore Singh v St o6 -ihar 7avjot Singh Sidhu V State o6 Punja: and %nr 7ee)u Chopra 8 %nr V -harti
Page72

200# 1' SC%L& # %3 14#' SC 2#8' %3 2005 SC 242 %3 2004 SC 1'40 2004 8 SCC 51# 2004 8 SC%L& 40 1444 4 SCC $2 %3 2005 SC 2''# %3 2001 SC 114# %3 2004 SC 15'1 %3 2005 SC 2850 %3 200$ SC '440 M%7/ SC 0112 2010 2004 # SCC 502 %3 200# SC 100' 2004 1' SC%L& '1'

3PC &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516

Cause Title 7&PC Mi0on Ltd 8 "rs v Mag!a Leasing Ltd 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Ltd v %sha "rs ani 8

Citatio# %3 1444 SC 1452 200' ' SCC 22' %3 2005 SC 215# %3 2001 SC 1414 %3 2001 SC 1414 %3 2000 SC 1082 2000 %CJ 1 SC 2004 4 SC%L& 50 %3 2004 SC '05$

Title 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t 72PS Cr<P<C Constitution La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488

Su$ Title S0ope "6 Se0tion 1'8 5hird Part1FPersonFVehi0) e %ppropriate Mu)tip)ier Pa1 %nd e0over 9a+e Li0en0e 7on Pa1!ent "6 Pre!iu! 5hird Part1FPersonFVehi0) e Se0tion 1#0 "6 Motor Vehi0)e %0t Se0tion 1$'a "6 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Can0e))ation "6 -ai) -ai) Se0tion 1$1 Se0tion 154 Person 3n Charge "6 5he Co!pan1 Se0tion 54 Se0 20# Constitutiona) Va)idit1 2is0ip)inar1 %0tion CPCF"rder 8 u)e 4 CPCFSe0 20 Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession CPCFSu!!ar1 Suits Se0tion 1$'a "6 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Just Co!pensation

7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Ltd vs Char)ie 8 ors 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co v ,a!)a 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Vs ,a!)a 7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co Ltd Vs u)a 8 "rs

7e. 3ndia %ssuran0e Co v Shri Satpa) Singh 8 "rs 73C Vs Meghji 7aran Sorati1a 8 "rs 7inga!!a 8 %nr v /nited 3ndia 3nsu Co Ltd 7iranjan Singh and %nr vs Pra:ha+ar ajara! ,harote and "rs 7ir!a) Jeet ,aur vs State o6 MP 7irpa) Singh 8 "rs v St o6 Har1ana 7isar %)i v St o6 /P 7, Wahi Vs She+har Singh 7oor %ga V St o6 Punja: and %nr 7oor ,han v St o6 ajasthan

%3 1480 SC #85 2004 # SCC 558 %3 14## SC 10$$ %3 145# SC '$$ %3 200# SC 1454 2008 4 SC%L& $81 %3 14$4 SC 28$ %3 2001 SC 2''# 2005 8 SCC 4$ 2004 4 SC%L& ''8 200$ $ SCC 20# 2004 5 MLJ #$1 SC %3 2000 SC 2548

7 7air 8 "rs Vs /nion o6 3ndia ":ettee Pvt Ltd V Mohd Sha6iD ,han ")1!pi0 3ndustries Vs Mu))a Hussain1 -hai Mu))a %+:era)) "! Pra+ash Srivastava Vs< /"3 8 %nr "!pra+ash 8 "rs v adha0haran 8 "rs

"7(C Vs S-3 "verseas -ran0h -o!:a1 "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs Hansraj:ai V ,oda)a "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs Mohd 7asir 8 %nr

%3 2001 SC 18'2 2004 $ SCC 280

Page73

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 527 528 529 530

Cause Title "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd Vs 7anjappan "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd v Shri 7anjappan 8 "rs "rissa H1dro Po.er Corporation Ltd Vs Sant.ant Singh (i)) P Janardhana ao Vs ,annan and "rs P Manohar edd1 and -ros V Maharashtra ,rishna Va))e1 2ev Corp and "rs P S ana+rishna 8 %nr edd1 V M , -hag1a)a+sh!i

Citatio# %3 2004 SC 1$'0 %3 2004 SC 1$'0 200$ 4 SCC $$' 2004 11 SCC 511 %3 %3 2004 SC 1##$ 200# SC 125$

Title Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Civi) La. Civi) La. %r:itration %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. 3PC Civi) La. 3PC Speed1 5ria) 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C

Su$ Title Pa1 %nd e0over Pa1 %nd e0over CPCFSe0 4$ CPCF"rder 21 4# %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 8 Spe0i6i0 e)ie6 %0tFSpe0i6i0 Per6or!an0e CPCFSe0 11 CPCF"rder 2$ 1 2eath Senten0e CPCFSe0 11 Co!!on ":je0t Speed1 5ria) Senten0ing=Po.er "6 % Magistrate Se0tion 154 Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee P)ea "6 Juveni)it1 CPCFSe0 48 Constitutiona) Va)idit1 -ona6ide eDuire!ent Senten0ing CPCF"rder 22 ' %nd 4

u)e

P V Jose V ,ani0+a!!a) 2ead :1 L s Pada! Sen and %nr V 5he State o6 /P Pan0hhi and "rs v St o6 /P Pandit 3sh.ardas V St o6 MP 8 "rs Pandurang Chandra+ant Mhatre and "rs V State o6 Maharashtra Pan+aj ,u!ar V St o6 Maharashtra 8 "rs Pan+aj:hai 7agji -hai Pate) Vs St o6 (ujarat Par+ash Singh -ada) 8 %nr V St o6 Punja: 8 "rs Par+ash Singh -ada) 8 %nr v St o6 Punja: 8 "rs Pa.an ,u!ar Jain V 5he Pradeshi1a 3nd and 3nv Corp o6 /P Ltd and "rs Pa.an Vs St o6 /ttaran0ha) Pentapati Chinna Ven+anna and "rs V Pentapati -engararaju and "rs Peop)es /nion 6or Civi) Li:erties 8 %nr v /"3 Phu) ani and "rs Vs Sh 7au:at Phu) Singh V State "6 Har1ana Piara Singh and "rs Vs 7atha Singh and "rs Pine Che!i0a)s Ltd 8 "rs vs %ssessing %uthorit1 and "rs P, Pa)anisa!1 Vs 7 %ru!ugha! 8 %nr ai %h)u.a)ia

2000 4 SCC '50 %3 14$1 SC 218 %3 1448 SC 2#2$ 14#4 4 SCC 1$' 2004 10 SCC ##' %3 2008 SC '0## %3 2001 SC 5$# %3 200# SC 12#4

u)e

531 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540

200# 1 SCC 1 2004 $ SCC #58 2004 ' SC%L& 145 %3 14$4 SC 1454 %3 2004 SC 45$ %3 14#' SC 2110

Cr<P<C Civi) La. Juveni)e Justi0e Civi) La. Constitution ent Contro) Cases Cr<P<C Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La.

14#4 4 SCC 41' %3 1441 SC 1524

u)e

1442 2 SCC $8' 2004 4 LW #5

Pro!issor1 &stoppe) CPCF"rder # u)e 11

Page74

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 541

Cause Title Po))ution Contro) -oard v Mohan Mea+ins Pon %dithan v 21 2ir 7ar0oti0s Contro) -ureau Madras Poona! Ver!a 8 "rs Vs 2e)hi 2eve)op!ent %uthorit1 Pooran Ma) V 5he 2ire0tor o6 3nspe0tion ?3nv@ 7e. 2e)hi 8 "rs Popu)ar Muthiah Vs State rep :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e Post (raduate 3nst o6 Medi0a) &du and es Chandigarh V Jaspa) Singh and "rs

Citatio# %3 2000 SC 145$

Title Cr<P<C

Su$ Title 9ra!ing "6 Charge Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Legiti!ate &*pe0tation Constitutiona) Va)idit1 einvestigation -1 %ppe))ate Court Medi0ia) 7eg)igen0e Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution -ai) S0ope "6 Pre0edent CPCFSe0 151 Pa1 %nd e0over 2eter!ination "6 %ge "6 Juveni)it1 CPCFSe0 4# S0ope "6 Se0tion 1'8 CPCF"rder # u)e 11 CPCF"rder 21 u)e '5 Pro!issor1 &stoppe) CPCFSe0 10 Se0tion 2# La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent 5hird Part1FPersonFVehi0) e

542 543 544 545 546

1444 $ SCC 1 %3 2008 SC 8#0 14#4 1 SCC '45 200$ $ SC%L& 41# 2004 # SCC ''0

72PS Legiti!ate &*pe0tation Constitution Cr<P<C Civi) La.

547 548 549 550 551 552 553 554 555 556 557 558 559 560 561 562 563

Pra:ha+ar V Sinari v Shan+er %nant Ver)e+ar Prah)ad Singh -hati vs 7C5 2e)hi and %nr Pra+ash %!i0hand Shah vs State o6 (ujrat Pra+ash H<Jain Vs Ms< Marie 9ernandes Pra!od ,u!ar %gra.a) Vs Mushtari -egu! 8 "rs Pratap Singh Vs St o6 Jhar+hand Prati:ha Singh and %nr V Shanti 2evi Prasad and %nr Pre! Chand Vija1 ,u!ar v Bashpa) Singh 8 %nr Pre! La)a 7ahata 8 %nr vs Chandi Prasad Si+aria Prithvi0hand a!0hand Sa:)o+ V S B Shinde Pro!oters 8 -ui)ders %sso0iation o6 Pune vs Pune Muni0ipa) Corporation 8 "rs Pu+hraj 2< Jain and "rs< Vs (opa)a+rishna Pu)u+uri ,ota11a 8 "rs Vs ,ing &!pero Punja: 7ationa) -an+ 8 ors v Surendra Prasad Sinha Punja: 7ationa) -an+ Ltd v Shri Vi+ra! Cotton Mi))s 8 %nr Punja: State &)e0tri0it1 -oard and %nr V Sudesh ,u!ar Puri Pushpa:ai Purshotta! /deshi 8 "rs v (inning 8 Pressing Co P Ltd 8 %nr
Page75

%3 14$4 SC $8$ J5 2001 4 SC 11$ %3 148$SC4$8 %3 200' SC 4541 %3 2004 SC 4'$0 %3 2005 SC 2#'1 %3 200' SC $4' 2005 4 SCC 41# %3 200# SC 124# %3 144' SC 1424

Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Ma*i!s Civi) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Juveni)e Justi0e Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488

200# $ SCC 14' %3 2004 SC '504 144# L #4 3% $5 %3 1442 SC 1815 %3 14#0 SC 14#' 200# 2 SCC 428 %3 14## SC 1#'5

anjit

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 564 565 566 567 568 569

Cause Title C Chandio+ and %nr V Chuni La) Sa:har.a) and "rs Jana+ira!an vs State rep :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e , %nand Vs egistrar 2e)hi High Court

Citatio#

Title

Su$ Title Spe0i6i0 e)ie6 %0tFSpe0i6i0 Per6or!an0e 2isproportionate %ssets Conte!pt "6 Court Chi)d Vi0ti! = %ppropriate Co!pensation 9reedo! "6 5rade Sear0h %nd Sei;ure Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Hosti)e Witness Se0tion 1$5 CPCFSe0 80 9reedo! "6 5rade 7on Spea+ing %.ard CPCFSe0tion 4 CPCFSu!!ar1 Suits Judi0ia) %nd &*tra = Judi0ia) Con6ession La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Proo6 "6 &!p)o1!ent Hirer Lia:i)it1 Se0tion 1$#?2@ Co!pounding 5he "66en0e -ai) Juveni)e Justi0e %0t 148$ CPCFSu!!ar1 Suits

%3

14#1 SC 12'8

Civi) La. PC %0t Conte!pt "6 Court Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Constitution Cr<P<C

%3 200$ SC 110$ 2004 8 SCC 10$ %3 2004 SC 250$ 1444 $ SCC $'2 %3 14$' SC 822

, Ma)i+ and %nr V ,iran Pa) and "rs ajagopa) A (opa) 8 %nr V St o6 57 8 "rs adha+ishan v St o6 /P

570 571 572 573 574 575 576 577 578 579 580 581 582 583 584 585 586 587

agh:ir Singh v St o6 Har1ana aghunandan v St o6 /P aghunandan v State o6 /P aghunath 2as Vs /"3 ai Sahi: a! Ja.a1a ,apur and "rs V 5he State o6 Punja: aipur 2eve)op!ent %uthorit1 vs Cho+ha!a) Contra0tors ai;ada 5opandas 8 %nr v (ora+hra! (o+a)0hand aj 2ugga) Vs a!esh ,u!ar -ansa)

144$ CrLJ 1$44 %3 14#4 SC 4$' %3 14#4 SC 4$' %3 14$4 SC $#4 1455 2 SC 225 1484 ' SC 144 %3 14$4 SC 1'48 %3 1440 SC 2218

72PS &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Constitution %r:itration %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. 3PC La:our %nd Servi0e La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C Juveni)e Justi0e Civi) La.

aj ,u!ar ,ar.a) Versus /nion o6 3ndia aja -ahadur 2hanraj (irji v aja P Parthasarath1 a1ani!varu 8 "rs aja La) Singh V St o6 Jhar+hand ajasthan St (anganagar S Mi))s Ltd Vs St o6 ajasthan 8 %nr ajasthan State oad 5ransport Co Vs ,ai)ash 7ath , ajeev Chaudhar1 vs St 7C5 o6 2e)hi ajendran Vs 7 Mohanan ajesh anjan Badav at Pappu Badav vs C-3

%3 1441 SC 45 14$' ' SC 421 200# CrLJ '2$2 SC 2004 8 SCC 1$1 %3 144# SC '444 %3 2001 SC 2'$4 2004 4 -o!C 20$ %3 200# SC 451 %3 2002 SC #48 %3 200' SC 1'22

ajinder Chandra Vs St o6 Chhattisgarh 8 %nr ajni ,u!ar Vs Suresh ,u!ar Ma)hotra and %nr
Page76

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 588 589 590 591 592 593 594 595 596 597 598 599 600 601 602 603 604 605 606 607 608 609 610 611 612

Cause Title ajni:ai a)ias Mannu:ai v ,a!)a 2evi 8 "rs a+esh Vs State o6 Har1ana a! -adan Shar!a v St o6 -ihar a! Chander v St o6 Har1ana a! Chander v State o6 Har1ana a! Chander Vs /"3 a! Chandra Singh V Savitri 2evi and "rs a! 2eo Chauhan 8 aj 7ath Chauhan v St o6 %ssa! a! 2eo Chauhan A aj 7ath V St o6 %ssa! a! 2eo Chauhan A aj 7ath Vs St o6 %ssa! a! (ovind /padh1a1 vs Sudarshan Singh and "rs a! Pat and "rs V State o6 Har1ana a! Prasad 2agdura! Vs Vija1 ,u!ar Moti)a) Mira+han.a)a and "rs a! Pratap Badav vs Mitra Sen Badav and %nr a! Singh 8 "rs v a! Singh

Citatio# %3 144$ SC 144$ %3 2001 SC 2521

Title Civi) La. Cr<P<C 3PC &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Constitution Civi) La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Juveni)e Justi0e Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Civi) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. 3PC Cr<P<C

Su$ Title CPCF"rder '4 1 u)e

%3 200$ SC 2855 %3 1481 SC 10'$ %3 1481 SC 10'$ %3 148$ SC 11#' 200' 8 SCC '14 %3 2000 SC 2$#4

Se0 '14 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Hosti)e Witness Se0tion 1$5 Civi) Servi0e CPCF9raud Senten0ing Senten0ing 2eter!ination "6 %ge "6 Juveni)it1 Can0e))ation "6 -ai) %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) CPCF"rder 1 u)e 10 -ai) 5ape e0orded Conversation Se0 482 3njuries "n 5he %00used 9urther 3nvestigation %nd e= 3nvestigation ight "6 Prisioners CPCFSe0 100 CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# Spe0i6i0 e)ie6 %0tF2e0)aration CPCF"rder 1 u)e 10 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath 5ender "6 Pardon

2001 5 SCC #14 %3 2001 SC 22'1 %3 2002 SC 14#5 2004 # SCC $14 %3 14$#SC2#8 200' 1 SCC 15 %3 148$ SC ' %3 200# SC 1218

a! Singh V Sonia 8 "rs a! Sunder Badav and "rs v 5he State o6 -ihar a!a Chaudhar1 Vs< State o6 -ihar a!a Murth1 V State o6 ,arnata+a a!avi)aso! (randhasa)a Versus 7SS ,ara1oga! a!0handra Vs 2a!odar 5ri!:a+ 5an+sa)e 2 and "rs a!esh Chand %rda.ati1a v %ni) Panj.ani a!esh Hiranand ,undan!a) Versus Muni0ipa) Corporation (reater -o!:a1 a!esh ,u!ar v St o6 Chhattisgarh a!esh.ar V 5he State o6 ajasthan

%3 1448 SC '11# 2004 ?$@ SCC '4$ 144# 2 SCC $42 2000 5 SCC $4 200# $ SCC #'# 200' # SCC '50 1442 2 SCC 524 2001 4 SCC $18 %3 1452 SC 54

Page77

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 613 614 615 616 617 618 619 620 621 622 623 624 625

Cause Title a!esh.ar Vs State o6 ajasthan a!raj A 7anhoo A -ihnu v State o6 Chhattisgarh a!raj A 7anhoo A -ihnu Vs State o6 Chhattisgarh a!rajsingh Vs State o6 MP an:ir 8 "rs v St o6 Punja: ang -ahadur Singh 8 "rs vs St o6 /P anjit Singh v St o6 Punja: anjit Singh Vs St o6 Har1ana apta+os -rett 8 Co Ltd v (anesh Propert1 ashtri1a Che!i0a) and 9erti)i;ers Ltd 8 %nr V (enera) &!p)o1ees %sso and "rs asi+)a) 2a)patra! 5ha++ar V St o6 (ujarat and "rs atan La) Jain and "rs V /!a Shan+ar V1as and "rs athnaiah V State o6 ,arnata+a

Citatio# %3 1452 SC 54 2004 14 SC%L& 5'' %3 2010 SC 420 2004 5 SC%L& $#0 %3 14#' SC 1404 %3 2000 SC 1204 %3 1448 SC '148 2004 1 SC%L& 58$ %3 1448 SC '085 200# 5 SCC 2#' 2004 1' SC%L& $28 %3 2002 SC 804

Title &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Juveni)e Justi0e Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C Civi) La. Cr<P<C

Su$ Title "00u)ar &viden0e 2is0ripan0ies Senten0ing Se0 4'' % Vi0arious Lia:i)it1 Se0tion 1$1 Senten0ing Se0 '14 Se0 20 5rans6er "6 Propert1F5enan01 -1 Ho)ding "ver Contra0t La:our Se0tion 15$?'@ CPCF"rder 21 u)e '5 %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder Se0tion 154 Senten0ing CPCF"rder 21 u)e '5 2eter!ination "6 %ge "6 Juveni)it1 CPCF"rder 1 u)e 10 Judge!ent Writing ight "6 Prisioners 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath CPCF"rder 4# u)e 1 5rans6er "6 Propert1F9eeding 5he (rant -1 &stoppe)

J5 2008 ' SC 5$4

626 627 628 629 630 631 632 633 634 635

athnasha)van V State o6 ,arnata+a attan Singh v State o6 Hi!a0ha) Pradesh attan Singh Vs St o6 Punja: avinder ,aur V %sho+ ,u!ar and %nr avinder Singh (or+hi Vs State o6 /P a;ia -egu! Vs Sahe:;adi %n.ar -egu! and "thers C Shar!a v /"3 8 "rs 2 /padh1a1 Vs St o6 %P 8 "rs ee!a %ggar.a) v %nupa! 8 "rs e+ha Mu+herjee Vs %shis ,u!ar 2as and "rs

200# ' SCC 4#4 %3 144# SC #$8 14#4 4 SCC #14 200' 8 SCC 284 %3 200$ SC 215# %3 1458 SC 88$ %3 14#$ SC 20'# %3 200$ SC 144$ 2004 ' SCC 144 2005 ' SCC 42#

3PC Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Civi) La. Juveni)e Justi0e Civi) La. Judge!ent Writing Cri!ina) La. 3PC Civi) La.

636

enu 2evi V Mahendra Singh and "rs


Page7

%3 200' SC 1$08

Civi) La.

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 637 638 639 640 641 642 643 644 645 646 647 648 649 650 651 652 653 654 655 656 657 658 659 660

Cause Title evajeetu -ui)ders and 2eve)opers V 7ara1anas.a!1 and Sons and "rs , ,rishna ,u!ar and %nr vs St o6 %ssa! M Ma)+ani v State o6 Maharashtra M Be))atti V 5he %sst &*e &ngg 7 Jadi and -rothers 8 "rs vs Su:hash0handra ohit Singh 8 "rs v St o6 -ihar 7o. St o6 Jhar+hand 8 "rs oop ,u!ar vs Mohan 5hedani os1 Ja0o: Vs Ja0o: % Cha+ra!a++a) o;an Mian V 5ahera -egu! 8 "rs S Madanappa and "thers Vs Chandra!!a and %nr S 7a1a+ v % S 7a1a+ Vs % %ntu)a1 8 %nr %ntu)a1 and %nr

Citatio# 2004 10 SCC 84 %3 1448 SC 5'0 %3 14#' SC 15# 200$ 1 SCC 10$ %3 200# SC 25#1 %3 200# SC 10

Title Civi) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Civi) La. ent Contro) Cases Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C PC %0t Constitution Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. ent Contro) Cases 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Civi) La. Land %0Duition

Su$ Title CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# %nti0ipator1 -ai) 5ape e0orded Conversation 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent CPCF"rder 8 u)e 1 CPCF"rder 8 u)e $ Su:=5enana01 Persona) La.F(uardian %nd Wards %0t La. "6 Contra0tF9rustration "6 Contra0t CPCF"rder 20 u)e 2 9ra!ing "6 Charge 2is0harge Hu!an ights Vio)ation %nd Co!pensation Se0tion '20 CPCF"rder 22 u)e ' %nd 4 5rans6er "6 Propert1F ede!ptio n "6 Mortgage 5ape e0orded Conversation CPCF"rder 21 u)e $4 CPCF"rder 40 u)e 1 2e6au)t 3n Pa1!ent "6 ent Cause "6 %0tion Se0tion 144?2@ CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 2eter!ination "6 Mar+et Va)ue

%3 200' SC 2418 %3 14#' SC 2040 %3 200# SC 288' %3 14$5 SC 1812 %3 148$ SC 2045 %3 148$ SC 2045 148' 4 SCC 141 C2J 2004 SC 1'48 %3 200' SC 2588

udu) Sah V State o6 -ihar and %nr u!i 2har vs State o6 West -enga) 8 %nr S %!arjit Singh ,a)ra dead :1 Lrs and "rs Vs Pra!od (upta dead :1 Lrs and "rs S 7a;eer %h!ed v St -an+ o6 M1sore 8 "rs S Pratap Singh v 5he State o6 Punja: S S 2a1ananda V , S 7agesh ao and "rs

%3 200# SC 484 %3 14$4 SC #2 144# 4 SCC 451 2000 4 SCC 5$0 %3 1485 SC 582 1448 $ SCC 514 200' ' SCC 524 %3 1441 SC 1825 M%7/ SC 01'4 2010

S Sa)ee!a -i V S P1ari -egu! and %nr S Sundara! Pi))ai and "rs V V Patta:ira!an and "rs Sadanandan -hadran v Madhavan Suni) ,u!ar Sadhana Lodh V 7ationa) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd and %nr = Sagar Mahi)a Vid1a)a1a Sagar Vs Pandit Sadashiv ao Harshe and "rs Saguntha)a 2ead thro Lrs V Spe0ia) 5ehsi)dar L% and "rs

Page7!

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 661 662 663 664 665 666 667 668 669 670 671 672 673 674 675 676 677 678 679 680

Cause Title Sahara 3ndia 8 "rs vs M C %ggar.a) Hu6 Sahe: ,han Vs Mohd Busu6uddin and "rs S%3 Ltd and ors V 7ationa) /nion Water 9ront Wor+ers and ors Sai:anna=2ead :1 L s Vs %sst Co!! 8 Land %0D "66r Sajan %:raha! v St o6 ,era)a Sa+eth 3ndia Ltd 8 ors v 3ndia Se0urities Ltd Sa+iri Vasu V State o6 /P 8 "rs Sa+shi vs /"3 and "rs Sa)auddin %:du)sa!ad Shai+h vs St o6 Maharashtra Sa)ee! -hai 8 "rs v St o6 Maharashtra 8 "rs Sa)e! %dvo0ate -ar %ssn Vs /"3 Sa)e! %dvo0ate -ar %ssn VS /"3 Sa!:haji Hindurao 2esh!u+h and "rs V State o6 Maharashtra Sa!ee ,han Vs -indu ,han Sanjana M Wig vs Hindustan Petro Corporation Ltd Sanja1 A ,a+a et0 v St 7C5 o6 2e)hi Sanja1 2utt V St o6 Maharashtra 5r C-3 -o!:a1 Sanja1 2utt vs C-3 -o!:a1 Sanja1 Suri and %nr V 2e)hi %d!inistration and %nr San+ar 2astidar v Shri!ati -anju)a 2astidar 8 %nr %3 %3

Citatio# 200# SC 12$1 200$ SC 18#1

Title Civi) La. Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Land %0Duition 72PS 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C Civi) La. %r:itration %0t &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cri!ina) La. Li!itation %0t

Su$ Title CPCF"rder 4 u)e 1' CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent 2eve)op!ent Charges Se0tion 50 "6 72PS %0t Li!itation Se0tion 154 ape Vi0ti! %nti0ipator1 -ai) CPCF"rder # u)e 11 CPCF%!ended CPC CPCF%!ended CPC %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) CPCF"rder '4 u)e 2a %)ternative Se0tion 2# Se0 '84 -ai) 3n 5%2% "66en0e ight "6 Prisioners Li!itation %0t Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution (rant "6 Pardon -1 Sessions Judge CPCF9raud &*tradi0tion 5rans6er "6 Propert1FMortgage e!ed1

2001 # SCC 1 2004 4 SCC 404 %3 2001 SC '140 %3 1444 SC 1040 2008 2 SCC 404 2004 5 SCC 518 %3 144$ SC 1042 200' 1 SCC 55# %3 %3 200' SC 184 2005 SC ''5'

2008 11 SCC 18$ %3 1448 SC 2#$5

2005 8 SCC 242 %3 2001 SC 4#4 2004 5 SCC #8# 1444 5 SCC 410 %3 %3 1488 SC 414 200# SC 514

681 682 683 684 685

San+aran Moitra v Sadhna 2as 8 %nr Santosh ,u!ar Satish:hushan -ari1ar Vs< State o6 Maharastra Santosh V Jagat a! and %nr

200$ 4 SCC 584 2004 ?$@ SCC '4$ M%7/ SC 004# 2010 2008 2 SCC 41# %3 1450 PC 88

Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Civi) La. Cri!ina) La. Civi) La.

Sara:jit i0+ Singh Vs /"3 Sardar %utar Singh Vs aja Sir Moha!!ad &ja; asoo) ,han sin0e de0eased 8 "rs
Page
"

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 686 687 688 689 690 691 692 693 694 695 696 697 698 699 700 701 702 703

Cause Title Sardar &states Vs %t!a a! Pro P Ltd Sardar (ovindrao Mahadi+ and %nr Vs 2evi Sahai and "rs Sardar 3D:a) Singh Vs State 2e)hi %d!n 8 "rs Sardar ,han 8 "rs V S1ed 7aj!u) Hasan ?Seth@ 8 "rs Sardu) Singh 8 Jagtar Singh v St o6 Har1ana Sar)a %huja Vs /33C Ltd Sar)a (oe) 8 "rs Vs ,ishan Chand Saroj ani V Sudarshan ,u!ar Chadha Saroja V Chinnusa!1 ?2@ :1 L< s 8 %nr Saroja v Chinnusa!1 2ead :1 L s 8 %nr Sar.an Singh and "rs v St o6 Punja: Sasi+u!ar V 5he State o6 57 Sat Pau) v 2e)hi %d!inistration Sat:ir Singh and "rs Vs State o6 Har1ana Sathappa Chettiar v a!anathan Chettiar

Citatio# 2004 8 SC%L& #4$ %3 1482 SC 484

Title ent Contro) Cases Civi) La. Cr<P<C Wa+6 %0t &viden0e %0t ent Contro) Cases ent Contro) Cases Civi) La. Legiti!ate &*pe0tation Civi) La. &viden0e %0t 3PC &viden0e %0t Juveni)e Justi0e Civi) La. Juveni)e Justi0e Civi) La. 3PC

Su$ Title %:use "6 Pro0ess "6 Court CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 5ender "6 Pardon Wa+6 %0t Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t -ona6ide eDuire!ent 2e6au)t 3n Pa1!ent "6 ent Persona) La.FHindu La.FMarriage %nd 2ivor0e Legiti!ate &*pe0tation CPCFSe0 11 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Hosti)e Witness P)ea o6 Juveni)it1 Court 9ees %0t P)ea o6 Juveni)it1 egistration %0tFSe0 1# %nd 44 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e CPCF"rder 21 u)e 22 CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 CPCF"rder 1 u)e 10 CPCFSe0 80 21ing 2e0)aration

14## 4 SCC 5'$ %3 200# SC 144#

2002 8 SCC '#2 %3 1444 SC 100 2004 4 SC%L& '42 %3 1484 SC 15$2 %3 200# SC '0$# %3 200# SC '0$# %3 14#$ SC 2'04 2004 # SC%L& 444 %3 14#$ SC 244 %3 2005 SC '54$ %3 1458 SC 245 %3 2004 SC 2$4' 144# ' SCC $#4 %3 2001 SC 2828

Satish A 2hanna Vs St o6 MP and ors Satish ,u!ar V >ari6 %h!ed and "rs Satvir Singh 8 "rs v St o6 Punja: 8 %nr

704 705 706 707 708 709

Sat1a:a)an Vs State o6 ,era)a 8 "rs Sat1anarain -ajoria and anr V a!narain 5i:re.a) and anr Sat1anarain -ajoria and anr Vs a!narain 5i:re.a) and anr Savitri 2evi Versus 2istri0t Judge (ora+hpur Sa.ai Singhai 7ir!a) Chand Vs /"3 Sa1ara:ano A Su)tana:egu! V St o6 Maharashtra

C2J 2004 SC #42 144' 4 SCC 414 %3 1444 SC 158'

72PS Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t

1444 2 SCC 5## %3 14$$ SC 10$8 200# CriLJ 1458

Page

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 710 711 712 713 714 715 716 717 718 719

Cause Title

Citatio#

Title

Su$ Title La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee %r:itration %0t 144$FSe0 11 Legiti!ate &*pe0tation egu)ari;ation "6 Servi0e 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness -ona6ide eDuire!ent CPCFSe0 4# Li!itation %0t %d!ission Civi) Suit %nd Cri!ina) Co!p)aint 7o esjudi0ata Persona) La.FMus)i! Wo!en ?Prote0tion "6 ights "n 2ivor0e@ %0t 148$ MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder Se0 '11 Senten0ing ash %nd 7eg)igen0e = 3PC 42# Persona) La.FMus)i! Wo!en ?Prote0tion "6 ights "n 2ivor0e@ %0t 148$ Court 9ees %0t Co!p)aint -1 Po.er "6 %ttorne1 Se0tion 154 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath Constitutiona) Va)idit1

S-3 V Mrs 3nde*port

egistered and ors

S-P 8 Co vs Pate) &ngineering Ltd 8 %nr Se01 St o6 ,arnata+a 8 "rs v /!adevi 8 "rs Se01 St o6 ,arnata+a 8 "rs Vs /!adevi 8 "rs See!an at Veerana! v St :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e Sesha!:a) dead thro L s V Che)ur Corp Che)ur -ui)ding and "rs Seth Hira)a) Patni v Sri ,a)i 7ath Seth a!da1a) Jat v La*!i Prasad Seth a!da1a) Jat Vs La*!i Prasad Sh Vishnu 2utt Shar!a Vs S!t 2a1a Sapra

%3 1442 SC 1#40 M%7/ SC 1#'$ 2004 %3 200$ SC 180$ 200$ 4 SCC 1 2005 11 SCC 142 M%7/ SC 0115 2010 %3 14$2 SC 144 2004 5 MLJ 442 SC %3 2004 SC 24$' 2004 8 SC%L& $48

Civi) La. %r:itration %0t Legiti!ate &*pe0tation La:our %nd Servi0e La. &viden0e %0t ent Contro) Cases Civi) La. Li!itation %0t &viden0e %0t 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t

720

Sha:ana -ano Vs 3!ran ,han

%3

2010 SC '05

Civi) La.

721 722 723 724

Shai+ Mastan Va)i V State o6 %P Shai)endra ,u!ar v State o6 -ihar 8 "rs Shai)esh Jasvanth:hai 8 %nr vs St o6 (ujarat 8 "rs Sha+i)a ,hader 8 "rs Vs 7ausheer Ca!a 8 "rs

200# 4 SCC '42 %3 2002 SC 2#0 200$ 2 SCC '54 %3 14#5 SC 1'24

3PC Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488

725 726 727 728 729 730

Sha!i! %ra V State o6 /P 8 %nr Sha!sher Singh v ajinder Prashad and "rs

2002 # SCC 518 %3 14#' SC 2'84 2008 10 SC%L& $54 %3 14#5 SC #5# 1441 1 SCC '#1 %3 14$2 SC 1#$4

Civi) La. Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C 3PC Constitution

Shan+ar 9inan0e and 3nvest!ents vs St o6 %P Shan+er v State o6 /P Shanti 8 %nr v St o6 Har1ana Shanti Prasad Jain V 5he 2ire0tor o6 &n6or0e!ent
Page
2

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 731 732 733 734 735 736 737 738 739 740 741 742 743 744 745 746 747 748 749 750 751 752 753 754 755

Cause Title Sharad -irdhi0hand Sarda v St o6 Maharashtra Sharda Vs 2hara!pa) Sharda Vs State o6 ajasthan

Citatio# %3 1484 SC 1$22 200' 2 C5C #$0 %3 %3 2010 SC 408 2002 SC 20'1

Title &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C 3PC Civi) La. Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t La:our %nd Servi0e La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Civi) La.

Su$ Title 21ing 2e0)aration Co!pe) 5o /ndergo Medi0a) &*a!ination 21ing 2e0)aration Se0 '14 CPCFSe0 42F"rder 21 u)e 24 ight "6 Prisioners Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession Se0tion 154 Se0tion 154 21ing 2e0)aration %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) 7o!ination CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# Spe0i6i0 e)ie6 %0tFSpe0i6i0 Per6or!an0e Judi0ia) %nd &*tra = Judi0ia) Con6ession Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) 2eath Senten0e CPCF"rder 21 u)e 4# %nti0ipator1 -ai) Post 2ated CheDue &si %0tFSe0 2 Hosti)e Witness CPCF"rder 21 u)e 84 5o 42 CPCFSe0 24

Shashi+ant Singh Vs 5ar+esh.ar Singh Shau+at Hussain a)ias %)i %+ra! and "rs V -hunesh.ari 2evi 2ead :1 Lrs and "rs Shee)a -arse v St o6 Maharashtra Shee)a 2evi 8 "rs V La) Chand 8 %nr Shei+h Hasi: a)ias 5a:ara+ v St o6 -ihar Sheonandan Pas.an V St o6 -ihar 8 "rs Sher Singh Vs State o6 Punja: Shingara Singh V State o6 Har1ana and %nr Shipra Sengupta V Mridu) Sengupta and "rs Shiv (opa) Sah vs Sita a! Saraugi 8 "rs Shiv ,u!ar Shar!a Vs Santosh ,u!ari Shiva ,ara! Pa1as.a!i 5e.ari V St o6 Maharashtra Shivaji Saha:rao -o:ade 8 %nr v St o6 Maharashtra Shivappa and "rs V State o6 ,arnata+a Shivu and %nr Vs ( High Court o6 ,arnata+a and %nr Shreenath and %nr Vs ajesh and "rs Shri (ur:a+sh Singh Si::ia and "rs vs St o6 Punja: Shri 3shar %))o1 Stee)s Ltd v Ja1as.a)s 7&C" Ltd Shri 7ava+esari Pra+ashan Ltd and "rs V &!p)o1ees State 3ns Corp and "rs Shri Shri Shri a:indra ,u!ar 2e1 v St o6 "rissa adhe1 Sh1a! Vs Sh1a! -ehari Singh adhe1 Sh1a! Vs Sh1a! -ehari Singh

%3 14#' SC 528 148' 2 SCC 4$ 200$ 10 SC%L& #5 %3 14#2 SC 28' 148# 1 SCC 288 %3 2008 SC 142$ 200' 12 SCC #58 %3 14$4 SC '## %3 200# SC 14#8 200# 8 SCC $00 2004 1 SC%L& #1# %3 14#' SC 2$22 2008 11 SCC ''# 200# ' SC%L& 15# %3 1448 SC 182#

%3 1480 SC 1$'2 2001?2@SC%L&1# ' %3 1484 SC 141$ %3 14## SC 1#0 %3 14#1 SC 2''#

%3 14#1 SC 2''#

Page

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 756 757 758 759 760 761 762 763 764 765 766 767 768 769 770 771 772 773 774 775 776 777 778 779

Cause Title Siddara!a 8 "rs Vs State o6 ,arnata+a Sidharth et0 Vs State o6 -ihar Si!ranjit Singh Mann and "rs vs St o6 -ihar Singhai La) Chand Jain 2ead Vs ashtri1a S.a1a! Se.a+ Sangh Patna Sita a! V adha:ai and "rs

Citatio# %3 200$ SC '2$5 %3 2005 SC 4'52 %3 148# SC 144 144$ ' SCC 144 %3 14$8 SC 5'4 %3 2008 SC '41 %3 200$SC$5' %3 2004 SC 2840 200# ' SC%L& 245 %3 200# SC 2'$4 148' ' SCC '#$ %3 144' SC 14$0

Title Cr<P<C Juveni)e Justi0e Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. Constitution Cri!ina) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Cr<P<C Civi) La. 3PC Judge!ent Writing Civi) La. Cr<P<C Civi) La. Constitution Land %0Duition 2o!esti0 Vio)en0e %0t

Su$ Title Senten0ing Se0 20 Can0e))ation "6 -ai) CPCFSe0 11 Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0essionF%v1a vahari+a 2e:t 5ender "6 Pardon Judi0ia) %nd &*tra = Judi0ia) Con6ession Persona) La.FHindu La.FMarriage %nd 2ivor0e Vi0arious Lia:i)it1 Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession Hu!an ights Vio)ation %nd Co!pensation ight "6 Prisioners %ppropriate Mu)tip)ier Se0tion 154 CPCFSe0 151 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath %)teration "6 Judg!ent CPCF"rder # u)e 11 Se0tion 154 CPCF9raud Pu:)i0 3nterest Se0tion 18 8 50 2o!esti0 Vio)en0e %0t

Sitara! Sao A Mungeri Vs St o6 Jhar+hand Siva+u!ar vs St o6 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e S!ruti Pahari1a V Sanja1 Pahari1a SMS Phar!a0heuti0a)s Ltd Vs 7eeta -ha))a S!t %ss ,aur ?2@ :1 L s Vs ,artar Singh ?2@ :1 L s 8 "rs S!t 2ipo Vs Wassan Singh and "rs S!t 7i)a:ati -ehera a)ieas La)ita -ehera V State o6 "rissa and "rs S!t 7i)a:ati -ehera a)ieas La)ita -ehera V State o6 "rissa and "rs S!t Sar)a Ver!a 8 "rs Vs 2e)hi 5ransport Corp 8 %nr S7 Shar!a V -ipen ,u!ar 5i.ari 8 "rs Sneh (upta Vs 2evi Sarup and "rs Soni 2evraj:hai -a:u:hai v St o6 (ujarat 8 "rs Sooraj 2evi v P1are La) 8 %nr Sopan Su+hdeo Sa:)e and "rs Vs %sst Charit1 Co! and "rs SP C-3 8 "rs v 5apan ,r Singh SP Chenga)vara1a naidu vs Jagannath SP (upta Vs President o6 3ndia 8 "rs Spe0ia) Land %0Duisition "66i0er /, Proje0t Vs Maha:oo: 8 %nr S -atra 8 %nr V S!t 5aruna -atra

144' 2 SCC #4$ 2004 $ SCC 121 14#0 1 SCC $5' 2004 $ SCC 144 1441 4 SCC 248 %3 1481 SC #'$ %3 2004 SC 1801

200' $ SCC 1#5 %3 1444 SC 85' %3 1482 SC 144 2004 ' SC%L& 2$' 200# ' SCC 1$4

Page

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 780 781 782 783 784 785 786 787 788 789 790 791 792 793 794 795 796 797 798 799 800 801 802 803

Cause Title Sri Je1ara! &du0ationa) 5rust and "rs Vs % ( S1ed Mohideen and "rs Sri ,rishna Singh V Mathura %hir and "rs Sri Vedagiri La+sh!i 7arasi!ha S.a!i 5e!p)e v 3nduru Patta:hira!i edd1 Srira! 3ndustria) &nterprises Ltd V Maha+ Singh and "rs SS Munna La) V SS aj+u!ar 8 "rs St ?2e)hi %d!in@ v Pa)i a! St -an+ o6 3ndia 8 %nr V Mu)a Saha+ari Sa+har ,ar+hana Ltd St -an+ o6 3ndia v 3nde*port egistered 8 ors

Citatio# %3 2010 SC $#1 %3 1482 SC $8$

Title Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t 3PC ent Contro) Cases &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C

Su$ Title CPCFSe0 42 CPCFSe0 42F"rder 21 u)e 24 CPCFSe0 42 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent Persona) La.FHindu La.F%doption %nd Maintenan0e S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e La. "6 Contra0tF-an+ (uarantee La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee 5er!ination "6 Servi0e 9ra!ing "6 Charge 5ender "6 Pardon 9ra!ing "6 Charge S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e Se0 '40 Medi0ia) 7eg)igen0e "00u)ar &viden0e 2is0ripan0ies S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e Se0tion 2# Pro!issor1 &stoppe) 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath 5enant Meaning S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e Se0 482 Senten0ing

%3 14$# SC #81 200# 4 SCC 44 %3 14$2 SC 144'

%3 14#4 SC 14 %3 200# SC 2'$1

%3 1442 SC 1#40 %3 14#$ SC 1111 %3 14$' SC 1850 %3 14$' SC 1850 2004 $ SCC 522 %3 14$# SC 1550 %3 200# SC 1'# %3 2005 SC '2#4

St -an+ o6 3ndia Vs 7 Sundara Mone1 St o6 %P v Chee!a)apati (anes.ara ao 8 %nr St o6 %P V Chee!a)apati (anes.ara ao 8 %nr St o6 %P v (o)0onda Linga S.a!1 8 %nr St o6 %P v Madiga -oosena 8 "rs St o6 %P vs V Sar!a St o6 Har1ana 8 "rs V ao 8 "rs &t0 aj ani

St o6 Hi!a0ha) Pradesh v Le+h aj 8 %nr St o6 HP v Jai La) 8 "rs St o6 HP v Jeet Singh St o6 ,arnata+a and %nr vs , , Mohandas and "rs St o6 ,arnata+a v MV Manjunathego.da 8 %nr St o6 Maharashtra 8 %nr Vs Super Ma* 3nternationa) Pvt Ltd 8 "rs St o6 Maharashtra v Su+hdeo Singh 8 anr St o6 Maharashtra Vs Sa)!an Sa)i! ,han 8 %nr St o6 MP vs Munna Chou:e1 8 %nr

2000 1 SCC 24# 1444 # SCC 280 %3 1444 SC 124' 200# $ SCC 484 %3 200' SC 804 2004 11 SC%L& #44 1442 ' SCC #00 200' 10 SC%L& 1041 %3 2005 SC $82

Page

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No

Cause Title

Citatio#

Title

Su$ Title Se0tion 14# "6 Crp0 Prote0tion 5o Pu:)i0 Servants %gainst Prose0ution 9ra!ing "6 Charge Sear0h %nd Sei;ure Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Sear0h %nd Sei;ure Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e ape Vi0ti! MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness Se0 482 Se0tion 2# S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e Se0tion 1$1 Senten0ing Se0tion '04 Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t Person %nti0ipator1 -ai) Se0 '0$ %pprover &viden0e Se0tion 10

804 805 806

St o6 "rissa 8 "rs v (anesh Chandra Je. St o6 "rissa v 2e:endra 7ath Padhi St o6 Punja: v -a):ir Singh

2004 8 SCC 40 2005 1 SCC 5$8 %3 1444 SC 18#2

Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C

807 808

St o6 Punja: v -a)dev Singh St o6 Punja: v Jas:ir Singh and "rs

1444 $ SCC 1#2 1445 4 C 3M&S #$5 SC

72PS Cr<P<C

809 810

St o6 Punja: v Surinder

ani a)ias Chhindi

2000 10 SCC 424 144$ 2 SCC '84

72PS &viden0e %0t

St o6 Punja: vs (ur!it Singh and "rs

811 812 813 814 815 816 817 818 819 820 821 822 823 824 825

St o6 ajasthan V Chittar!a) St o6 ajasthan v ,a)+i and %nr St o6 ajasthan v 5eja a! and "rs St o6 ajasthan Vs ,ashi a! St o6 /P v 2eo!an /padh1a1a St o6 /P v Har:an Sahai 8 "rs St o6 /P v M, %nthon1 St o6 /P vs a! Veer Singh 8 "rs

200# 8 SC%L& $54 %3 1481 SC 1'40 1444 ' SCC 50# %3 200# SC 144

3PC &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t

%3 14$0 SC 1125 J5 1448 ' SC 44' %3 1485 SC 48 %3 200#SC'0#5 %3 2001SC140' 1444 1 SCC #' %3 2005SC2$22 J5 144# # SC $51 %3 1484 SC 548 %3 1484 SC 548 %3 2005SC'820

St o6 /P Vs Sha!:hu 7ath Singh and "rs St o6 West -enga) v "ri)a) Jais.a) 8 %nr Standard Chartered -an+ vs 2ire0tor o6 &n6or0e!ent State :1 the C-3 v %ni) Shar!a State 2e)hi %d!n Vs Jagit Singh State 2e)hi %d!n vs Jagjit Singh State 7C5 o6 2e)hi vs< 7avjot Sandhu A %6san (uru
Page
6

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 826 827 828 829 830

Cause Title State o6 %P Cha))a a!+rishna edd1 8 "rs State o6 (ujarat and %nr V HonC:)e High Court o6 (ujarat State o6 (ujarat v aghunath Va!anrao -a*i a! 2i1a

Citatio# 2000 5 SCC #12 1448 # SCC '42 %3 1485 SC 1042 1440 CriLJ 1'2# 144# ' SCC #$$

Title Cri!ina) La. Cri!ina) La. &viden0e %0t Cri!ina) La. Cri!ina) La.

Su$ Title ight "6 Prisioners ight "6 Prisioners "00u)ar &viden0e 2is0ripan0ies ight "6 Prisioners ight "6 Prisioners MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder Cogni;an0e San0tion Senten0ing ight "6 Prisioners Senten0ing ight "6 Prisioners Senten0ing Senten0ing ight "6 Prisioners -ai) 3n 5%2% "66en0e Se0tion 2# Sear0h %nd Sei;ure %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) 7oti0e La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee Senten0ing 2is0harge CPCFSe0 84

State o6 Har1ana and another V

State o6 Har1ana V (haseeta a!

831 832 833 834 835 836 837 838 839 840 841 842 843 844 845 846 847 848 849

State o6 Har1ana V Jagat Pau) 8 "rs State o6 Har1ana vs -ahajan)a) State o6 HP v MP (upta State o6 ,arnata+a V aju

200# 8 SC%L& $25 %3 1442SC$04 2004 2 SCC '44 200# 11 SC%L& 114 1445 4SCC 2$2 %3 2005SC'5$# 1445 $ SCC '21 %3 2005SC222 %3 200'SC'141 1441 2 SCC '#' J5 1440 1 SC 28 2000?4@SC%L&8 2005 ' SCC 1$4 200# 4 SCC 1'5 144$ # SCC 52' %3 14$# SC 1105 J5 2004 8 SC 2## %3 2005 SC '54 %3 2008 SC 1204

3PC Cr<P<C PC %0t Cr<P<C Cri!ina) La. Cr<P<C Cri!ina) La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Cri!ina) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Civi) La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Civi) La.

State o6 M<P< v< Sh1a!sunder 5rivedi and "rs State o6 M<P< Vs -a)a A -a)ara! State o6 Madh1a Pradesh V Mohan Singh State o6 Madh1a Pradesh Vs -a)u State o6 Madh1a Pradesh Vs (hansh1a! Singh State o6 Maharashtra and "rs V avi+ant S Pati) State o6 Maharashtra v %nand Chinta!an 2ighe State o6 Maharashtra v 2a!u State o6 MP thro C-3 et0 v Pa)tan Ma))ah 8 "rs State o6 MP V -a00hudas a)ias -a)ra! and "rs State o6 MP v Hira)a) 8 "rs State o6 MP v ,a)ura! State o6 MP V Shei+h Shahid State o6 "rissa vs 2e:endranath Padhi State o6 Punja: and %nr V Ja)our Singh and "rs

Page

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 850 851 852

Cause Title State o6 Punja: and ors V Joginder Singh and ors State o6 Punja: and "rs V Phu)an ani and %nr State o6 Punja: and "rs V Shri (anpat aj

Citatio# 1440 2 SCC $$1 %3 %3 2004 SC 4105 200$ SC '084

Title Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. Civi) La.

Su$ Title ight "6 Prisioners CPCFSe0 84 CPCFSe0 84 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e Se0tion 154 ?1@ Medi0ia) 7eg)igen0e CPCFSe0 151 CPCFSe0 80 Senten0ing Se0tion '2# CPCFSe0 80 21ing 2e0)aration San0tion CPCFSe0 151 e0onstru0tion "6 e0ords 9a)sus 3n /no 9a)sus 3n "!ni:us %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) Se0 '#$ %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) Speed1 5ria) 9a)sus 3n /no 9a)sus 3n "!ni:us Se0tion 1$4 3denti6i0ation MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot

853 854 855 856 857 858 859 860 861 862 863 864 865 866 867 868 869 870 871 872 873 874

State o6 Punja: v -a):ir Singh State o6 Punja: V (urdip ,aur State o6 Punja: V Shiv a! and "rs

%3 1444 SC 18#2 2008 14 SC%L& '$4 %3 2005 SC '280

72PS Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Civi) La. &viden0e %0t PC %0t Civi) La. e0onstru0tion "6 e0ords &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Cr<P<C 3PC Cr<P<C Speed1 5ria) &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t 3PC

State o6 Punja: vs 2arshan Singh State o6 Punja: Vs (eeta 3ron 8 -rass Wor+s Ltd State o6 Punja: Vs Pre! Sagar and "rs State o6 Punja: Vs< (ur!it Singh 8 "rs State o6 Serai+e))a Vs< /"3 State o6 5a!i) 7adu Versus ,aruppasa!1 State o6 57 v 2a!odaran State o6 /P and "rs Vs oshan Singh ?2ead@ :1 L s< and "rs< State o6 /P V %:hai aj Singh 8 %nr

%3 200' SC 41#4 %3 14#8 SC 1$08 2008CriLJ'5'' %3 144$ SC 1'4' %3 1451 SC 25' %3 2004 SC 448 %3 1442 SC 5$' %3 2008 SC 1140 2004 4 SCC $ %3 1488 SC 1448 2004 4 SCC 2#1 200# 10 SCC #45 2004 1 SCC #2 2008 11 SCC 15' %3 2001 SC 140' %3 1481 SC 84# %3 14$4 SC '58

State o6 /P v %ni) Singh State o6 /P V -anne a)ias -aijnath and "rs State o6 /P V (ovind 2as a)ias (udda and %nr State o6 /P V Manoj ,u!ar Pande1 State o6 /P V Punni and "rs State o6 /P v Sha!:hu 7ath Singh 8 "rs State o6 /P v Shan+er State o6 /P V Singhara Singh and "rs State o6 /P V Su+hpa) Singh and "rs State o6 /P Vs 3ndrajeet A Su+hatha

2004 4 SCC '85 %3 2000 SC '158

Page

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No

Cause Title

Citatio#

Title

Su$ Title %!ounting 5o Murder

875 876 877 878 879 880 881 882 883 884 885 886 887 888 889 890 891 892 893 894 895 896 897 898

State o6 /P Vs Sho:hanath 8 "rs State o6 /ttaran0ha) V -a).ant Singh Chau6a) and "rs State o6 West -enga) and "rs Vs ,aran Singh -ina1a+ and "rs State o6 West -enga) v "ri)a) Jais.a) 8 %nr State ep :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e and "rs V 7M5 Jo1 3!!a0u)ate State SP through C-3 vs 7a)ini 8 anr State thro C-3 7e. 2e)hi Vs SJ Choudhar1 State through 3P %P v , 7arasi!ha0har1 State 5hrough Supdtt Centra) Jai) 7 2e)hi V Charu)ata Joshi 8 %nr S5C o6 3ndia Ltd Vs Jainsons C)othing Corp and %nr Su:e Singh vs St o6 Har1ana 8 "rs Su:hash Mahadevasa Ha:i: vs 7e!asa %!:asa 2har!adas 8 "rs Su:ra!ania (oundan V 5he State o6 Madras Su0ha Singh and %nr v St o6 Punja: Sudesh ,u!ar Vs State o6 /ttara+hand Sudhir 8 ors et0 V State o6 MP et0 Sudhir ( %ngur 8 "rs v M Sanjeev 8 "rs Su+ 2as v /5 o6 %runa0ha) Pradesh Su+anti Moharana vs State o6 "rissa Su!an Sood A ,a!a) Jeet ,aur V State o6 ajasthan Su!itra 2evi Vs -hi+ar Choudar1 Su!ti:ai 8 "rs vs Paras 9inan0e Co 8 "rs Sunder Singh v St o6 /P Sunder:hai %!:a)a) 2esai Vs State o6 (ujarat

%3 2004 SC 2'45 2010 1 SC%L& 442 %3 2002 SC 154' 1444 1 SCC #' 2004 5 SC%L& ''0 1444 5 SCC 25' %3 144$ SC 1441 %3 200$ SC $28 1444 CriLJ 22#' %3 1444 SC 2##8

Cr<P<C Constitution Civi) La. 3PC Cr<P<C Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t PC %0t Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C Civi) La. Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Juveni)e Justi0e Cr<P<C Civi) La. Constitution &viden0e %0t 3PC Cr<P<C Civi) La. Cr<P<C Cr<P<C

3nDuest

eport

Pu:)i0 3nterest CPCFSe0 151 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath "rder "6 e!and

Senten0ing S0ienti6i0F&*pert &viden0e San0tion ight "6 Prisioners La. "6 Contra0tF-an+ (uarantee %rrest %nd Custod1 CPCFSe0 11 5ender "6 Pardon Proo6 -e1ond easona:)e 2ou:t Se0 $ Se0 204 CPCF"rder # u)e 11 Lega) %id 21ing 2e0)aration Se0 120 Se0tion 125 CPCF"rder 1 u)e 10 Sear0h %nd Sei;ure Se0 452

200$ ' SCC 1#8 %3 200# SC 1828 %3 1458 SC $$ %3 200' SC '$1# %3 2008 SC 1120 2001 2 SCC $88 %3 200$ SC '51 148$ 2 SCC 401 2004 10 SC%L& 24$ %3 200# SC 2##4 %3 1485 SC #$5 %3 200# SC '1$$

%3 145$ SC 411 %3 200' SC $'8

Page

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 899 900 901 902 903 904 905 906 907 908 909 910 911 912 913 914 915 916 917 918

Cause Title Suni) -atra Vs 2e)hi %d!inistration Suni) &nterprises and %nr Vs S-3 Co!!er0ia) and 3nternationa) -an+ Ltd Suni) (upta and "rsV St o6 MP Surendra Singh 8 "rs v St o6 /P Suresh Chandra -ahri v St o6 -ihar Suresh Chandra -ahri V St o6 -ihar .ith (ur:a0han Singh Suresh ,u!ar Singh V State o6 /<P Surinder Singh and %nr Vs State o6 /P Surja a! Vs State o6 ajasthan

Citatio# %3 14#8 SC 1$#5 %3 1448 SC 2'1#

Title Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. Cri!ina) La. Judge!ent Writing &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C 3PC Juveni)e Justi0e Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Ma*i!s &nviron!enta) Prote0tion Cr<P<C Cr<P<C Judge!ent Writing &viden0e %0t La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La.

Su$ Title ight "6 Prisioners CPCFSu!!ar1 Suits ight "6 Prisioners Judge!ent Writing Se0tion 2# 5ender "6 Pardon 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath 2eter!ination "6 %ge "6 Juveni)it1 Senten0ing Senten0ing 3nvestigation %nd 3nDuir1 2istin0tion &nviron!enta) Prote0tion %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) Senten0ing Judge!ent Writing Hosti)e Witness Se0tion 10 = 3ndustria) 2isputes %0t CPCF"rder 21 u)e 4$ CPCF"rder # u)e 11 CPCF"rder 22 u)e ' %nd 4 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e ight "6 Prisioners 3nterest %0t 5esti!on1 "6 Po)i0e

1440 ' SCC 114 %3 1454 SC 144 %3 1444 SC 2420 %3 1444 SC 2420 2004 # SC%L& $24 %3 200' SC '811 %3 144#SC18 2004 $ SCC 51' 2008 $ SC%L& 20# %3 200$ SC 284'

Surjit Singh v 7ahara a! 8 %nr Surjit Singh Vs Mahanagar 5e)ephone 7iga! Ltd Susetha V State o6 57 and "rs S.a!i Prasad V State o6 MP S.a!1 Shraddananda A Mura)i Manohar Mishra V State o6 ,arnata+a S.aran Lata (hosh v H, -anerjee 8 "rs S.aran Singh v State o6 Punja: S1ndi0ate -an+ Vs (enera) Se01 S1ndi0ate -an+ Sta66 %sso0iation 8 %nr S1ndi0ate -an+ Vs Vija1 ,u!ar and "rs 5 %rivandanda! vs 5V Sat1apa) 8 %nr 5 (nanave) V 5 S ,anagaraj and %nr

J5 200# 4 SC ''# %3 2008 SC '040

%3 14$4 SC 11$# 2000 4 SC%L& 15' 2000 5 SCC $5 %3 1442 SC 10$$

%3 14## SC 2421 %3 2004 SC 2'$#

919 920 921 922

5 5 Hanee6a v St o6 ,era)a 5<7< Mathur v< State o6 /ttar Pradesh 5aha;hathe Pura1i) Sara:i and "rs V /"3 and %nr 5ahir Vs State 2e)hi

2004 %3 SCW ''00 144' Supp?1@SCC#22 2004 # SCC '#2 %3 144$ SC '0#4

72PS Cri!ina) La. Civi) La. &viden0e %0t

Page!"

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 923 924 925 926 927 928 929 930 931 932 933 934 935 936 937 938 939 940 941 942 943 944 945 946 947

Cause Title 5a!i) 7adu Wa+6 -oard V Lara:sha 2arga Panruti 5apinder Singh v St o6 Punja: 8 %nr 5ara Chand V Sagar:ai A Chai1a)i:ai 5ara Chand V Sagar:ai A Chai1a)i:ai 5ara 2evi v Sri 5ha+ur adha ,rishna Maharaj 5ara Singh 8 others v St o6 Punja: 5a1a::hai M -agasar.a))a and anr V Hind u::er 3nd Pvt Ltd 5hangai1a v St o6 57 5he %ndhra -an+ Ltd V Srinivasan and "rs 5he 2iv Contro))er ,S 5C Vs Mahadeva Shett1 8 %nr 5he M2 57S5C Ltd Vs ,3 -indu 8 "rs 5he "rienta) 3nsuran0e Co Ltd et0 v Hansraj:hai V ,oda)a 8 "rs 5he ange 9orest "66i0er V S 5 Hadi!ani 5he eg Manager ajasthan St oad 5ransport Corp Vs Sohan La) et0 5he State o6 -o!:a1 Vs ,athi ,a)u "ghad and "rs 5he State o6 ,arnata+a Vs ,rishnappa 5he State o6 Punja: V %jai: Singh and %nr 5he State o6 Punja: Vs 7athu a! 5he State o6 West -enga) Vs 5he %d!inistrator Ho.rah Muni0ipa)it1 and "rs 57 (odavar!an 5hiru!u)pad V /"3 and "rs 57 (odavar!an 5hiru!u)pad V /"3 and "rs 5ri!u+h Maroti ,ir+an V St o6 Maharashtra 5u+ara! S 2igho)e V Mani+rao Shivaji ,o+ate 5u)a a! vs ,ishore Singh 5u)sipur Sugar Co Ltd V St o6 /P 8 "rs
Page!1

Citatio# J5 2008 ?1@SC 12' %3 14#0 SC 15$$ %3 %3 200# SC 2054 200# SC 2054

Title Wa+6 %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. Civi) La. Civi) La. Cr<P<C Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 La:our %nd Servi0e La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. Constitution Cr<P<C Constitution Civi) La. Li!itation %0t &nviron!enta) Prote0tion &nviron!enta) Prote0tion 3PC &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C La:our %nd Servi0e La.

Su$ Title Wa+6 %0t Se0tion 154 5rans6er "6 Propert1FLease 5rans6er "6 Propert1F ede!ptio n "6 Mortgage Court 9ees %0t Se0tion 154 CPCF"rder '4 2a

%3 148# SC 2085 1441 Supp 1 SCC 5'$ %3 144# SC 1240

u)e

2005 4 SCC $50 %3 14$2 SC 2'2

So)itar1 Witness CPCF"rder 22 u)e ' %nd 4 Just Co!pensation Contri:utor1 7eg)igen0e Se0tion 1$' % %nd 1$$ "6 Motor Vehi0)es %0t 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent Mis0ondu0t Co!pu)sor1 5esti!on1 Senten0ing Ha:eas Corpus CPCF"rder 22 u)e ' %nd 4 Li!itation %0t &nviron!enta) Prote0tion &nviron!enta) Prote0tion 2o.r1 2e!and = Crue)t1F2eath 5ape e0orded Conversation Cogni;an0e 2is0ip)inar1 %0tion

%3 200' SC 41#2 2005 8 SCC 4#' 2001 5 SCC 1#5 2002 ' SCC 25 2004 8 SCC 218 %3 14$1SC1808 2000 2 SC%L& $10 %3 145' SC 10 %3 14$2 SC 84

%3 14#2SC#44 2008 # SCC 12$ %3 2005 SC 425$

200# CriLJ 20 SC 2010 2 SC%L& 104 %3 14## SC 2401 14$4 2 SCC 100

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 948 949 950 951 952 953 954

Cause Title / Suvetha vs State :1 3nspe0tor o6 Po)i0e /da1 Mohan)a) %0har1a v State o6 Maharashtra /gar %hir and "rs v St o6 -ihar /jagar Singh V Jeo /nion -an+ o6 3ndia v Man+u 7ara1ana /nited 3ndia 3nsuran0e Co Vs %n:ari 8 "rs /nited 3ndia 3nsuran0e Co!pan1 Vs Lehru 8 "rs

Citatio# 2004 # SC%L& 144 2001 5 SCC 45' %3 14$5 SC 2## %3 1454 SC 1041

Title Cr<P<C Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Civi) La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488

Su$ Title e)ative "6 Hus:and -ai) 9a)sus 3n /no 9a)sus 3n "!ni:us Persona) La.FHindu La.FSu0ession La. "6 Contra0tFContra0t "6 (uarantee (enuineness "6 5he Li0en0e 5hird Part1 Lia:i)it1 Sear0h "6 % PersonF"6 %n &n0)osed P)a0eF3n % Pu:)i0 P)a0e 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent CPCFSe0 84 CPCF"rder 21 84 5o 42

%3 148# SC 10#8 2000 10 SCC 52' %3 200' SC 1242

955 956 957 958 959 960 961 962 963 964 965 966 967 968 969 970 971

/"3 8 "rs v L2 -a)a! Singh /"3 and "rs V Ju!!asha 2i.an /"3 V %nanto 2ead and %nr /"3 V ,ishori)a) (upta and -ros /"3 V Par!a 7anda /"3 vs (anesh i0e Mi))s and %nr /"3 vs Pra!od (upta 8 "rs /"3 vs Pra!od (upta 8 "rs /"3 vs 5ha!isharasi and "rs /"3 Vs Bu!na! %nand M /P %.as &va! Vi+as Parishad Versus (1an 2evi ?dead@ :1 L s /P 2rugs and Phar! Co Ltd V a!anuj Badav and "rs /P Po.er Corporation Ltd and %nr vs Sant Stee)s and %))o1s P Ltd and "rs /P St -rass.are Corpn Ltd and %nr V /dai 7arain Pande1 /P St oad 5ransport Corp 8 "rs Vs 5ri)o Chandra 8 "rs /P St oad 5ransport Corp Vs 7anhe La) ,ush.aha /P State Sugar Co V Ms< Su!a0 3nternationa) Ltd

2002 4 SCC #' 200$ 8 SCC 544 %3 %3 200# SC 15$1 1454 SC 1'$2

72PS La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. Civi) La. La:our %nd Servi0e La. &viden0e %0t Civi) La. Land %0Duition Cr<P<C Constitution Land %0Duition La:our %nd Servi0e La. &viden0e %0t La:our %nd Servi0e La. Motor Vehi0)e %0t 1488 La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La.

u)e

1484 2 SCC 1## 1448 4 SCC $'0 %3 2005 SC '#08 %3 2005 SC '#08 1445 4 SCC 140 200# 5 SC%L& $0$ 1445 2 SCC '2$ 200' 8 SCC ''4 M%7/ SC 4$02 200# 200$ 1 SCC 4#4 144$ 4 SC%L& 522 2004 11 SC%L& '5 144# 1SCC 5$8

2is0ip)inar1 %0tion Pro!issor1 &stoppe) CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# 2eter!ination "6 Mar+et Va)ue -ai) Preventive 2etention Se0tion 18 8 50 2isengage!ent etren0h!ent Pro!issor1 &stoppe) einstate!ent F -a0+ Wages %ppropriate Mu)tip)ier Mis0ondu0t La. "6 Contra0tF-an+ (uarantee

Page!2

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 972 973 974 975 976

Cause Title /PS 5C V a! ,ishan %rora /sha -a)ashahe: S.a!i 8 "rs vs ,iran %ppaso S.a!i 8 "rs V aja ,u!ari v P Su::ara!a 7aidu 8 %nr V a!ana vs %PS 5C 8 "rs Vadive)u 5hevar v St o6 Madras

Citatio# 200# 4 SCC $2# %3 200# SC 1$$' 2004 8 SCC ##4 2005 # SCC ''8 %3 145# SC $14 200$ 14 SC%L& 108 %3 14$5 SC 101# 2008 10 SC%L& #15 %3 144' SC 1842 %3 144'SC1842 %3 144$ SC 2#15 %3 200$ SC '51# %3 14$' SC 442 2004 11 SC%L& 525 %3 14$2 SC 441 %3 200' SC 402' 2004 $ SCC $52 C2J 2004 SC 418 2004 $ SC%L& #2$ 2005 4 SCC #84 2008 8 SC%L& $08 1448 1 SCC 110 %3 1488 SC '#1

Title La:our %nd Servi0e La. Civi) La. 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t La:our %nd Servi0e La. &viden0e %0t

Su$ Title 2is0ip)inar1 %0tion CPCF"rder $ u)e 1# 7oti0e 2o0trine "6 Proportiona)it1 3nterested WitnessFChan0e Witness MurderFCu)pa:)e Ho!i0ide 7ot %!ounting 5o Murder Constitutiona) Va)idit1 %ppre0iation "6 &viden0e 3n %ppea) Hosti)e Witness Leading Guestions &nviron!ent %nd Po))ution Legis)ative 3ntent 3nso)ven01 %0t Se0tion $ CPCF"rder '' 1

977 978 979 980 981 982 983 984 985 986 987 988 989 990 991 992 993 994 995

Vad)a Chandraiah V St o6 %P Vajrave)u Muda)iar Vs Sp) 21 Co))e0tor Madras Va)son and %nr V State o6 ,era)a Var+e1 Joseph v St o6 ,era)a rep :1 Cir0)e 3ns o6 Po)i0e Var+e1 Joseph Vs State o6 ,era)a rep :1 Cir0)e 3P Ve))ore Citi;en We)6are 9oru! Vs /nion o6 3ndia Ve!aredd1 ,u!aras.a!1 edd1 8 %nr Vs St o6 %P Ven+ata eddi and "rs V Pothi eddi Vija1 7ara1an 5hatte 8 "rs Vs St o6 Maharashtra 8 "rs Vija1 Pratap Singh vs 2u+h Haran 7ath Singh 8 %nr= Vija1 S1a) and %nr< Vs State o6 Punja: Vija1an Vs Sadanandan Vija1an Vs Sadanandan , 8 %nr Vi+ra! Singh Vs St o6 Har1ana Vi)u:en Jha)ejar Contra0tor 2 :1 L s Vs State o6 (ujarat Vi!a) Chadha Vs Vi+as Choudhar1 and "rs Vineet 7arain and "rs V /nion o6 3ndia and %nr Vinod ,u!ar Singh V -anaras Hindu /niversit1 and "rs Vinod ,u!ar Singh v -H/

3PC Constitution Cr<P<C &viden0e %0t &viden0e %0t Constitution Ma*i!s Civi) La. Land %0Duition Civi) La. Constitution 7egotia:)e 3nstru!ents %0t Cr<P<C Juveni)e Justi0e Land %0Duition Juveni)e Justi0e Constitution Civi) La. Judge!ent Writing

u)e

Civi) Servi0e 2e6au)t Senten0e Whi)e "rdering Co!pensation Co!pensation /nder Se0tion '5# 2eter!ination "6 %ge "6 Juveni)it1 3nterest "n So)atiu! 2eter!ination "6 %ge "6 Juveni)it1 Pu:)i0 3nterest CPCF"rder 20 ' %)teration "6 Judg!ent

u)e

%3 1488 SC '#15

Page!3

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENTS OF LEGAL IMPORTANCE


Sl. No 996 997 998 999 100 0 100 1 100 2 100 3

Cause Title Virendra Vs St o6 Punja: Visha+a and "thers V ajasthan and "thers

Citatio# %3 145# SC 84$ %3 144# SC '011

Title Constitution Constitution Cr<P<C Civi) La. &viden0e %0t Cr<P<C Civi) La. &viden0e %0t

Su$ Title 9reedo! "6 &*pression Prote0tion "6 Wea+er Se0tion Se0tion 154 CPCF"rder 21 u)e '2 5ape e0orded Conversation Se0 40$ CPCFSe0 14$ 5ape e0orded Conversation

Wi)a1at ,han 8 "rs v State o6 /P Bashpa) Singh Vs V333 %dd) 2ist Judge and "rs Busu6a))i &s!ai) 7agree v State o6 Maharashtra >ahira Ha:i:u))ah Shei+h 8 %nr v St o6 (ujarat >i)a Singh and "rs V Ha;ari and "rs >i1auddin -urhanuddin -u+hari v -rij!ohan a!dass Mehra 8 "rs

%3 145' SC 122 1442 2 SCC 504 %3 14$8 SC 14# %3 2004 SC '4$# %3 14#4 SC 10$$ %3 14#5 SC 1#88

Page!4

Compiled by Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy C!e""ai

You might also like