values applies to all people and cultures Plato • Cultural Relativism: Moral values are relative to one’s culture; there are Sextus Empiricus no universally held values Montaigne
◆ MoralSkepticism: there are no known absolute
moral values: we endorse moral values simply because they are ours J L Mackie Objections to Ethical Relativism (the belief that no values ought to be applied to all) James Rachels (Naturalistic Fallacy) • The existence of moral differences does not justify them (“is does not imply ought”) • We would have to tolerate cruel cultures [but] • Relativism allows for no moral progress • In fact, there are universal moral values that are simply interpreted differently in cultures