F

W
EF

W
KK

ELF

KKKK
KKKK
KKKK

KK
KK

KK

KK

K
L

K

K
L

KK
LK



W
K JK
K JK
K JK
K JK
K JK


K

W
W

EF
W

LW
W

EFKKK
EFKK
EFKK

LLLLW

W

WW
WK

K

K
WK
K

W
K
K
K

K
W

EFW
KEF

W
K
J JWK
K J
K K
JW
K J J
K
K JW
K
W
J J
K J

K
K
K
K
K

K
K
K
K
K

College of Graduate studies

Department: Administrative sciences
Specialization: Administrative sciences

MA. THESIS SUMMARY

Thesis Title: An Assessment of safety & security departments readiness in the
situation of crisis and disasters. (A Field study to examine Royal Commission safety
& security employees attitudes towards crisis and disasters)

Prepared by: Bader Abdulmuhsen Alsheikh.

Supervisor: Prof. Amir Khodair Alkabaisi
Thesis Defense Committee:
1. Prof. Amir Khodair Alkabaisi.
2. General Dr. Abbass Abu shama
3. Dr. Abdullah Hamed Alsalamah

(Supervisor)
(member).
(member).

Defence Date: 17/3/1249H - 25/3/2008

Research Problem: This research attempts to examine the role of the Royal
Commission safety & security departments through .Readiness in situation of crisis
and disasters . This issue was addressed through the following principle question: Are
safety & security departments at Royal Commission for Jubail & Yanbu ready for
situation of crisis and disasters.

Research Importance:
A scientific importance : This come through the scientific prove of the importance of
the pro-active role of safety & security departments and their readiness in preventing
or mitigating and minimizing the intensity of its effects.
B practical importance : This represented in this research final suggestions and
recommendations to improve and upgrade crisis management and disaster recovery
plans in Royal Commission for Jubail & Yanbu.

Research Objectives
1. identify previous crisis and disaster situation in Jubail & Yanbu and how they were
managed.
2. identify potential crisis and disaster situation in both industrial cities of Jubail & Yanbu.
3. identify major causes that may lead to future crisis and disaster in Jubail & Yanbu.
4. asses safety & security department's readiness for crisis & disasters in Royal Commission
for Jubail & Yanbu.
5. Identify appropriate methods to enhance the role of safety and security departments and
their readiness of crisis and disasters.

Research Questions
1.
2.
3.
4.

did the Royal Commission for Jubail & Yanbu previously managed crisis & disaster situation?
what are the potential crisis & disasters situations for Royal Commission for Jubail & Yanbu?
what are the major future causes of crisis and disaster in Royal Commission for Jubail & Yanbu?
what is the level of readiness at safety & security department in Royal Commission to manage
crisis and disasters situations?
5. what are the main methods to enhance the role of safety & security departments and their
capabilities to resolve crisis & disasters situations?

Research Methodology:
This research shall apply the descriptive methodology through (documentation) which is
primarily an examination & analysis of related literature and secondly through (social
survey) via a sample been out of research society.

Main Results
1. It becomes obvious from the research society individuals views and opinion that the possibility of
Royal Commission of Jubail & Yanbu, to be subject to crisis and disasters is in average rate. The
prominent those crisis and disasters were: huge fires- leakage of toxin gases- leakage of chemical
gases- blasts due to chemical reactions.
2. research society individuals have agreed also on the importance of reasons that leads to crisis and
disasters, and the prominence reasons in there viewpoints were: negligence of employees towards
safety instructions- non benefiting from past experience and events- neglecting of alert signals.
3. research society individuals have agreed that among various elements of Readiness' the following
are available at safety & security department: a- co- ordination be scenarios.
4. Agreement by research society individuals in accepting strongly available methods and ways
raised for enhancing the role of security and safety department to face crisis and disasters and the
most prominent ways and methods in their viewpoints were: providing the administration with
modern equipments and systems- supporting the administration with specialized cadres in safety
and security level- granting additional authorities for safety and security administration.

-
-
-
-
-
-

--

--
--
--
--
--

--

--
--
--
--

--
--

-
--
--
--

One Way ANOVA??

One Way ANOVA??

Scheffe??

One Way ANOVA??

One Way ANOVA??

One Way ANOVA??

One Way ANOVA??

-
-
-
-
-

 W-

?
?
W

KKK

K




KEWF

K

K

KEWF

KEWF

KK
W

EW

EW F

W-

EF
E{F
KEWF

?K
?
K

EW FEF

KK

EF
EF
KE JWKF

W-

 W-

WW

K
K
K
K

K
K
K
K
K
K
K

K
K
E F
K
W

W-

K
K

W-

WE

??
EWF
W

K
W E

EWF

K
EWFWE
EWKF
?W

KEWF?

K
WE
EWKF
W
Natural K
EEKKKFFDisasters
Technical Disasters
EFEF

KEWF
W

WE

WE

K
--

KEWF
W

EWF
EWKF
WHeritage
KK
K
K
KEWFKK

 Webster
KEWF

K
W

W

FK
KEW
W

KEWF
W

KEWFK

WEF

KEWF
WEF

KEWKF
WE
F
KEWF
W

KEF
W EF
K
W
EF

W
W

KEWF

 W
K
K
K K
K
K
K
K
F K
KE
K
KEWF
W

--

K
W
EWK F
Disaster
KEWFK

 W
WE
F
EWF
W

KEF
W

KEWF
W EF

KEWF
W

KEWF

W
K

?KKK J?
?? ??

KEF

LLL
FFW

KEE
W
K
K
K

K
K
K
K K
K

KEWFK
EF
KKKK

KEWF

 W
K K
K K
K K
K K
KEWF
K K
EWF K
K K
--

K


KEF
EF

KEWF
W
EF K
F

EKK
K
K
K

K
K

K

K

KE JWF

KEWFKK

KEWF

KEF

 --

K
W
W

KEWFK
W
K K
W K
K
K
KEF
WEF
K K

K K

K K

K K

KK

K K

KEWFKK
WEF
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K
K K
KE JWFKK

 W
JW J
K
KW J
W J
KEWF
WEF

K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
KE JWFK
K K
WEFEF
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
KE JWFE JWF
EF
EF??
WE JWF
W

W
K

K
K
K
K
W J

W
K
K
K
K
K
K
W J
W
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
W J

WK
K
K
K
K
K
K
W J

W
K
K

K
K
K
K
K
K
W J

WK
K
K
K
K
W J

K
W
K
K
K
K
K
K
W J

K

W
K
K
K
K
K
K

 W J
W
K
K
K
K
K
K
W J

K

K
W
K
K
K

W
K
EKK
F
K
KK

K EF

 EF

G

X
X
X
X




X X




X
X
X X
X

X X X X
X
X X X
X X X X
X X
X X
X X X
X
X X X
X X
X X X X
X X X
X
X X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X
X

{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
EFK
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
G

EF
K
E{FE{F
W

{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{

K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
EF K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K

 --

EFKK
WE JWF
EFW
W
KW K
KW K
KW K
KW K
KW K
KW K
FW
WE
W K
K
WW K
K
W K
K
KW K

EF

F
WE JWFE
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K
K
K K
K K
K K
KK

 --

K
EFFF

K EF

EWFEE

KEWKF

KK
KEWF
WEF

K
K
K
K
K
K

K K
K K
K
K
KEWF K
W
KW K
KW K
KW K
KW K
W
K
KEWF
WEF
K K
K K
K K
KEWFK K
W
K K
K K
K K
KEWKFK K

EF
WE JWF
WK
K

K
K
WK

KK

K
WK

K
K
WK

K
W

K

K

--
EF

KK

EFEF

KEWF

F
E
FE
FE

K E
F

KEF
EF

WEFEF

KEWF
WEF


KE
WF
K
WE
F

KEWF

KE JWF
WEF
K
K
KK
K
K
K
K
KEWFK

WE
F

KE JWF
--

EF

KE
F

K

K

KEWF
WEF

KEWF
WEF

KEWF
WEF

W
K K
K K
K
KEWFK
W

W
W
K
K

 W K
K
W K
K
W K
KEWF
--

K
K
W

KEWKF

KEWFK


W
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
KE JWFK
W K

K
K
E F
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K

K

KE WFK



K
EF

W
W

W

K
W

EWF

 --

KKK

EWF
W

KEWF
W

KEF


KEWKF
FF

KEWFEE
EF

W
W K

W

K
W K

K
W K
K
W K
K

W K
K
W K


E JWF

K
K
K

K
WF K
KE
K
K
K K
K K
K

E JWFK

EF

WE
K

K
K
K

K
K
K
K
K
K
KEF K
K K
KEWKF K

 --

WEF
W J

K
W J

K
W J

K
W J

K
W J
K

W J
KE JWF
EF

K
WEF
W J

K
W J
K
W J

K
W
J
K

W J
KE JWF
WEF
W J

K
W J

K
W J
K

W J

W J

KE JWF

WEF

W J
K

W J
K

W J
K

W J
KE JWF
EF
W

WE
KE
KE
WE
KE
KE

WE
KE

KEWFKE

EF
W
E FW
J

KKK
KEF
E FW J

KEF
EFW J

KE JWF
E F

W
K K
K K
K K


EF
K

EF
*

K K
K

KK

EF*

K
K
K
K
K
K
K

K
K
K
K
J
K K
K
K

J



K
K J
J

K
K J K

E F

KEWF

KEWF

EF

W
W

K
W
K

K
W

K
W

KEWF
--
FFW

KEWFEE
EF

KEWF
W

KEWF

EW F


KEWF
W

KKKK

KEWF
W
J
K
K J

 J

K
J
K
J

KE JWFK

W
K

K
E
F
K
K

K
K K

K K
K
KE JWF

W
W

K
KW

KE JWF

F
E

K
--

K
WKEWF

K
W

K
KW

KKKK
W

K
KW

K
W

K
W

K
W

KE JWF
W
W
K

K

W J

EF
K
W J

K
W
J

K
W J
K
W J

K
W J

KE JWF
WEF
W J

K
W J
K

 W
J

K
W J
E F
K
J
K

W J
K
W J

K
KW J
W J

K
W J

K
W
J
W
FW
KE

KEWF
EF
W

F K
KE
FEF K
E F
EF
KE

EF
*

J
K
K J
K J
K J
J
K
K J
K J
K J
K J
K J
K J

K J
J
K J
J
K J
K J
J K J
K K J
K J K J
K J K J
J KK J

K J
K J

EF*

W
-

F

EKK


KEWF

KKKEFEF
EF

EF
KEWF


EW F

E F

KKK

KE JWF

W
W

KKF
E
W
K

KE JWFK

KEWF

KE JWFEF

F
WE
K

K
K

KE

KE JWF

WF
KEKK

K
K

K
EF

KEWF
EF
W
K K
K K
K K
K K
KEWFsimulation Training K
W

F
E
KEWF
W
E FW

K
KKKW

KEWF
W
K

K
FW

E
KEWF
WE F

KKK
W
E F

KE JWF

KK
W


K
K

KEWF

EFEF
W
K
F
KE
K
K
K

K
K
K
K
K
K
KEF

K
K

K
K
F
KEWFEWFEKKK
-

K

KEWF


KEWF

F
E

KEWF
W

FF
KEWFEE

EF

KEWF
EF

KE JWF

KEWF
K

KE JWF
K

KEWWF

K
K

KEWF

KEWF


W
W

K
W

K
W

KE JWF
W

K
W

KE JWF


KEWF
EF

W
WEF J

K
WEF J

W
KKK

KKKK

K
W
J
W

KEUNDROFK
K

KEWF

W
KW
KW
KW

KKK

W
K

KEWF

K
-

K


K

EF

E{F

KEWF

KEW F
W
WW
K

KEWF

EWF

KEWF

KEWF

W
W K

K
W K

W K


W

K

F
E

K

KE JWF

W
K
W

KE
WF

K

EFW

FEF
KEW
K
WK
EFW J

KEWF
W
J

KEWF

K
K

KEWF
WW

EWF
EF

KEF


KE JWF

K
KEWF

KEWF
E F

KEWF

KK

KEWF

KKKK

KEWF
WEF
K

KEWF

K
W
W J

KK
W J
K
K
W J


K
W J

E JWF
K

W
KEWF K
K
K
K K
KE JWFK K

K
K

 EF
*

EF*

EF
K


KEWF
WEF

KEWF

KEWF

KE JWF
W
KK

KK

KK

KK K
KK

KK

KEWFK

 W
K
K
K
K
K K
K K
K K
K K
K
KEWF

W

K

K

KE F
K

KEWF

K

KEWF
K

KEWF

KEWFK

KEWF

FF

KE JWFEE

KE JWF

EBlast!F
EEssential

TechnologiesF

KE JWF

KEWF

W
K

K
K

K

K
K

KEWF

K
FF

KEWFEE

KEWF
FFEF

KEWFEE

FFW

KEWFEE

KE JWF

KEWF
W
K

KK

K
K

KEWFK

W
K
K
K
K
K

K
K

K
K

KEWF

W
K J
W J
KK
KK
KK
KK
KK
KE JWFK J

W
W
J

W J
K
K W
J

KE JWFK
W J

KEWF

 KK
KK
KK
K
K
K

K
EWF

W
K

K
K
K

K
K
K
K

KEWF

K

K
E
F
K

KE JWF
K
K

KEWF

K
FF

KEWFEE

KEWF

KEWF

F
E
F
KK
E


KE JWF

W
EKKF K
K
K
EFK K
EKKF K
EKKF K
F K
FEKK
KE JW

EF

KEWF

 KK

F
KE

KEWF

KEWF

EWF

--

EWFW

KE JF

KEWF

WE F

KEWF
W
W

KE JWF
EF F

W ELL

KE JWF
WE F

KEWF
W

KEWF

EFW
W

KEWF
W

KEWF

--

KEWF

EF

KEWF

J F
KE

KEWF

W
W J
K

W J

K
W J

KEWF
W
W J
K

W J
K
W J
K
W J
K
W J

K
W
J

KEKKKF
W J
KEWF

 --

W
K K
K K
K K
W
K

K
K

K
K

K
K

F
E

KE JWF
EF
LL

KEWF
K

K
K
KE JWFEF
W
WK

EF


K
W K

K
W K

K
WK

K
W K

EKKK F

KE JWF
W
K
K
K

K
K
K

K
K
KE JWFKKK

LLELLLLF
W

W
K K
K K
K
K

K
K
W K
KK


K
K
W
FW K
KE
W K

K
WK
KKKKK
WK

K
K

K
K K

K
WW K
E

K
E

K
WK

K
K

K
K

K
K
KKKK

KKK

K

KK


K

FF

KEWFEE

-


EF

EF
K


EF

W

K
EF

F
KEW

KEKK
LLELF

W
K

K
K

K
K
K
EF K
KEF
K K
EFLL

E F
K
W

EF
K
EF

EFW

W
K
K
K K
K

K
K K

 K
K
K
K
K

K
K K
K K
K K
KK
K K
KK
K K
KK

K
F
KE JW

EF
EFEFEF

K EF

FE{F
E
KE{FE{F
EF
KEF EF

EFE{F
KE JWF
KK
EF
E{FEF


.
K
EF
E{F EF

K
FK
Ewww.rcjy.gov.saE)
E{F

EFEF
EF
KEF

E{F
EFEF
KEF
W

EFKK
KE{F
FEF
KE JW

LLELLLLF

KKKLLELLLLF
W
W
J
K

K
J

K
J
K
J

K
W
J

K
J
K
K J

 K J
?? J
??

E F

K
J

K
J
K
J
K
J
K
K J

E
F
W
K K
K
K
K
K
K
K K
KK K
K K
K
K

K

EF
L

EFW
EFW

WK
K
KWK
WK
K
EF

EFW

EF
F EF

KKEKK

KLL JWKLLLW
W
F
F E
E
K

KK
K

K

K


W
W
K

 WW
W K
K
WK
K
WW
K
W
W
K
KW

E{{F

KE JWF

{WLLWLLW
W

EF

EFEF

E F

W
K K
K K
K K
K K
K K

K
K
K K
K K
K
K
K K
KK

KK
JF K
KE
K K
K K
W
K K
K K
K K
K K
K
K
K K
K K
K K
K K
KK
KK
KK
K
K
KK


K{WLLWLLW
W

C
EF
W
K

W
K


{WLLWLLW
W

E F

EF

ECF

E
F

{{
WK
K

K
K

W
K

K
K

KK

KK

E JF

K
K
FWEF:
KE
W

KK




KK

 W
K

K
{

K
FWEF:
KE
W
K

K
K
K

K
W
K
K

 K
K
K
K
K
K
FWE F:
KE
W

K
K

K

K

K
W
K
K??
K
K??

 K
K??
K
?

K?
K

K??
KEFWEF:
W
K
K

K
K
W
K

K
K
K
K

W K

WK

K
FW EF:
KE
W
K
K
K
K

K
K
W
K
W
K K
K K

W
K K
K K

 K
W
K K
K K

K K

K
W
K K
K K

K K

K K

K K
K K
FW EF:

KE
W
F

W
E

K

W
K
K
K

K
K

W
K
K
K
K

K
K

FEF:
E
W

K
K

K
W
K
W

K
K

K
K
K

 K
K
K
W

K
FWEF:
KE
W
EF

K
EF
K

W

K

K

K

 W
K

K
K

K
K
K
K
K
K

K
K

K
EFWEF:
W

K

K

K
W
K

K

K
K
K
KEFEFEF
K
W
K J
K J

K J
K J
J
K
K
W
K J
K J

K J

K J
J
K
FE
F:
KE

K

K

K

K

K

K

K

EF
K

 W
K
K
K
K
K
W
K

K K

K K

K
K
K K
FEF:
KE
W

K

K

K

K


K
K

K
W

K
K
K
K

W
KK
K

FWEF:
KE
W

K


K

K

K

K

K

K

K
W

K
E F K
K
FWEF:
KE
W
F
E
K

K
K
W
K

K
K



K
K

K
K

K
K

K
K

FWEF:
KE
W
K
K
K
W
K

K
K

K
K

K
K

K
FWEF:
KE
W
K

K
W

K

K
W
K

K
K

K
K

K
K

K
K

K
FWEF:
E
W
K

K
K
K
K
W

 K
K
W
K
K
W K

K
W
K

K
W

J
K
K J

K J
J
K
J
K

EF



K
K
W

K
W

K
K

K
K
K

 W-

EF
K

W-

KE JWF
FEF
E

W-

KEF
F
KE

W-

KEWF

EF

EFEF
KEFEF

W-

?W

F?
KEW
W

n Z

2 N

K( 1-K )

[ ( N-1) +
2

K( 1-K ) ]

 KZn E
KZN E
?Population

Proportion?ZK

KEK=0.5F{
Z E
KE=0.05F{
Z2 E

E2=3.841F {
{
EWFKE2=6.635F
E2=3.841F{
EF
KEFZE{F
EFEF
EF

K
E{F EF
EFKEFEF
EF
KEFEF

W-

W--

? ?

W
K E
K E
W
EFW

J J JF
J J J
KE
EFW

WEF
E
KEF

EFW
W
EFEFEF
E
KEF


E FW

EFEFW
EF EFEF
E
KEF

EFW
W
EFEFEF
E
KEF

E FW

EFEFW
KEFEFEF

KEClosed QuestionnaireF
W--

?EW
F


KEW F
W
WKK

KEFEF

KEF
WKK

EF

EF
EF

EF

EF
K

 EF
EZF

** {
** {
** {
** {

* {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {

{
{
** {
** {
** {
** {
{
{
** {
{
** {
{
{**{*

EF
EZF

** {
** {
** {
** {
** {

** {
** {
* {
** {
** {

* {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
* {
** {
** {
{
{**{*

EF
EZF

* {
* {
** {
** {
{
{

** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {

** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
{**{*

 EF
EZF

** {
** {
** {

** {
** {
** {
** {

** {
** {
** {
* {
** {
{
** {
** {
{**{*

E JF
E{F
E{F

E{FE{F

K

EF
WEF
EF

EZF

** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {
** {

EZF

{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{
{

{**{*

EF
E{F
K
W--

EF
EWF
FEF
ECronbach's AlphaEFFE

EF
KEF
EF
EZF

EF
{{{
K

 W-

Statistical Package for Social Sciences

ESPSSF
E F
EZ JF

FE{ZLF
E
WEWF
EL F{
K

E LF{{
K

ELF{{
K

ELF{{
K

ELF{
K
E F

EZ JF

FE{ZLF

 E
W

E LF{
K

ELF{{
K

ELF{
K
W
EPearson Correlation CoefficientF??

KEF

KECronbach's AlphaEFF
W
K

K
EMeanF K

F
KEW
EWeighted MeanFEF K
F

E
KEWFEF
EStandard DeviationF K

KEWF

Goodness of FitEF K
E F

EF

KEWF
EIndependent Samples T-testFEF K

JF
KE
EOne Way ANOVAF
EF K

JF
J J J
KE J

EScheffeF K
F
J J
J J J
E
K

W-
W--

KK
K
W--

W
KK
KK

W--

W
KE JF

K
K

K

K

K
K

W
K

KK
K

FW
E J
FW
J J
KE
W

EF

EFEF
E{F

E{FEF
K

EF







%



%




EF
*

{
{
{
{

E{FEFEFEF*

EFEF
E{F EF
EF

E{FEFEF
EF
E{F

E{FEF
E{FEF

E{FEF
K
EF

65

70

65

60
50

42

40
29

25

30
20
10

EF
*

{
{
{
{

E{FE{FEFEF*

EF

E{FE{FEF

EFEFEF
E{F
EF

E{F
EF

E{F
EF

KE{F

EF
*

{
{
{
{
{

E{FE{FEFEF*

EF
E{F E{FEF

EFEF
EF
E{F

E{FEF
EF

E{F

E{FEF

EF

KE{F

EF

EFEF
EFE{F
EF E{F
E{F
E{FEF
EFEKKF
E{F

E{FEF
E{FEF
EF
KE{F

EF

{
{

EFEF
EFE{F
E{F
E{FEF

E{FEF
K

EF

120
95

99

100
80
60
40

15

17

20
0

EF

{
{

EFEF
E{F
EFEF
E{FEF

E{FEF
K

W
W

WEFEF

 EF

{**

{**

{**

{**

{** { {

{** { {

{**

{**

{**

{** { {

{**

{

{

{

F
E

{**{*

 EF J

{*

{**

{*

{**

{**

{** { {

{**

{**

{**

{**

{ {

F
E

F
E

EF

{**{*

EF

KK

E{FE{F
E{{ F
EF

E
F

{F

E{
ELF

K

EF
{{

? ?EF K

{ZEFP

K{EF

E J J J J J JF
W
? ?EF K


E{F

KE{F
E
F
K
? ?EF K

KE{FE{F
? ?EF K

KE{FE{F
?EF K
?

KE{FE{F

KEWF
?EF
K

KE{FE{F

K
?EF K
?E F


E{F

KE{F

KEW F
EF
F
KEW
? ?EF K

KE{FE{F

KK

EF

KEwww.spa.gov.saEFF

K

W

WEFEF

 EF

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

K
{ { {

{ { { {

{ { {

{ {

{ { {

{ { {

K

K

{ {

{ {

{ { {

{

{ {

{ {

{**{*

 EF J

{**

{** {

{**

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{ { {

{ { {

K { { {
E

F
{ { { {
EKK

{ { {

{ { {

{ {

{ {

{**{*

{ { {


EF

KK

E{F E{F
{F



E FE{


E {{F

ELF

K
EF
{

K


E J J J J J JF

W
?EF K
?


E{F
EWF KE{F
KE JWF
?EF K
?

KE{FE{F

WF
EWFE
KEWF
K
?EF
?

KE{FE{F

KE JWF

KEE FFW

?EF K
F
E{F?E
KE{F


F
KEW
? ?EF K

KE{FE{F

K
?EF K
?

KE{FE{F

K
KEWF
?EF K

KE{FE{F

W F
KEWFEWFEWFE

WEF
KEF

KEF

KEF

KEF

KEF

KEF
WEF

 EF

{** {

{ {

{** {

{ {

{** {

{ {

{** {

{ {

{** {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{** {

{ {

{** {

{ {

{** {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{**{*

 EF J

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{**{*

 EF J

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{* {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{**{*

EF

E
F
E{FE{F

E{{FEF
EF

F
E{{
ELF

K
EF
{{

EFK
?

ZEFP?

?EF{
P?

{ZEF
KEF

W
??

KE{FE{F

??
??
K
W
?EF K

?
KE{FE{F
K

K
? EF K

?
KE{FE{F
K
?EF K
?

E{F
KE{F
FK
EW
?EF K
?
E{F
KKE{F
?
?

E{F
KE{F
W
? EF K
?
E{F
KE{F
K
?EF K
?
KE{FE{F
K

?EF K
?
E{F
KE{F
K
K
? EF K
?
E{F
EFKE{F
K

K
? ?

E{F
E
F KE{F
W
?EF K
?

E{F
KKE{F
?EF K
?

KE{FE{F
K

? EF K
?
KE{FE{F
KEF
?EF K
?
KE{FE{F
KEF
? ?

E{F
E
FKE{F
W
?EF K
?
KE{FE{F
K

K????
?EF K
?
KE{FE{F
K

?EF K
?
E{F
KKE{F
? EF K
?
E{F
EFKE{F
K
? EF K

?
KE{FE{F
KEF

K
?EF K

?
FKE{F E{F
K E
K


?
?

E{F
EFKE{F

W
?EF K
?

KE{FE{F
K

K
? EF K
?
E{F
EFKE{F
K
?EF K
?
E{F
EFKE{F
K
? EF K
?
KE{FE{F

EF
K

? EF K

?
FKE{FE{F
KE

??

E{F
EFKE{F

W
? EF K
?
E{F
KKE{F
?EF K
?
KE{FE{F
KEF
?EF K
?

KE{FE{F
KEF

?EF K
?
KE{FE{F
KEF
W

WEFEF

 EF

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

K

K

{
KKK

{ {

{ {

{

{

{ {

{

{

{

K

K

K

{**{*

 EF J

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{** {

{ {

K

K

{ {

{ {

{

{

{**{*

EF

KK

E{FE{F
E{{F
E F

{F

{

E LF

K
EF
{

K



E J J J J JF
W
?EF K
F
?EKKK

KE{F E{F

K
?EF K
?

 E{F
KE{F

K
? EF K
?


E{F
KKKE{F
?EF K

KE{FE{F

K
?EF K
?

E{FE{F
? EF K
?

KE{FE{F

K
? EF K
?

KE{FE{F

KK
K

W


T-testEF

WE JF

WEF

 EF

{*

{**

{*

{*

{*

{
{**

{
J
{

{
{

{

{

{

{

{ {


{
{


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {

{ {


{ {





{
{


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{



{

{

{







{

{

{

{

{

{

{

F
E

{**{*

 EF J

P
{**

{*

{*

{ J

{ J

{ J

{ J

{ J

{

{





{



{

{



{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{



{

{

{

{

{



{





{

{

{

{

{



{

{

{

{



{

{

{ {

{ {

{

{



{



{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{



{

{



{

{

F

F

EF

{**{*

T-testEF
EF

{ {

W
E{F EF K
??E{F
E{F
KE{F

K
E{F
EF K
? ?E{F
E{F
KE{F

K
E{F EF K
?E{F
?EF
KE{FE{F

K
E{FEF K
??E{F

KE{FE{F

KE{ JF
E{F
EF K
??E{F
E{F
KE{F

KE{ JF
E{FEF K
??E{F
E{F
KE{F

K
E{FEF K
?E{F

?
KE{FE{F



KE{ J{F

E{FEF K
??E{F

KE{FE{F

KE{ JF
E{FEF K
?
?E{F

KE{FE{F

K
E

WEF

 EF

{ { J

K{

{ {

{ {

{ { J

{ { J

{ { J

{ {

{ {

{* {

{ {

{

{

{

{

{

{

K

{

K

{

K

{

{

{

K

{

{

{

K

{

{

{

K
{ {


{ { {

{ { {

{ { {


K
{ {

{ { {

K
{ {


{ { {


{ { {

K
{ {

K
{ {

K
{ {

K { {

{ { {


{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{**{*

 EF J

*P

{ {

{ {

{ { J

{ { J

{ { J

{ {

{* {

{ {

{ { J

{ {

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

K { {

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

K { {

{ { {

{ { {

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{ {
{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{ {

{

{

{

{

{

{

F
E
KK

{**{*

T-testEFEF

W
E{FEF K
?E{F
?
KE{FE{F

E{ J{F
K
E{FEF K
?E{F
?
KE{F
E{F

KE{ J{F
E

WEF

 EF



P
{

{**

{*

{*

{**

{ J

{**

{ J

{ {
{

{
{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{**{*

 EF J



P

{**

{ J

{**

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{**{*

 EF J



P
{

{**

{**

{**

{**

*{

{**

{ J

{**

{**

{**

{*

{*

{ {

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{ {

{**{*
{ {

T-testEFEF
{{

W
W K

W
KEF
E{ J{F

E{FE{F
KE{FE{F

W
E{F
E{F
KE{FE{F

W
EF
E{FE{F
KE{FE{F
W K

W
E{FE{F
E{F

 KE{F
KEF

W
E{FE{F
E{F
KE{F
KEF

W
E{FE{F
E{F
KE{F
KEF

WEF
W

??EF K

E{FE{F
KE{FE{F
K
?EF K

?
E{F

E{FE{FE{F
K
?
?EF K

E{FE{F
KE{FE{F
KEF
??EF K

E{FE{F

KE{FE{F

KEF
W

?EF K
?
E{FE{F

KE{FE{F
KEF

KE{ J{F
?EF K

?


E{FE{FE{F
FE{F
KE
?EF K
?
E{FE{F
E{F
KE{F
KEF
?EF K
?
E{FE{F
E{FE{F
KEF
?
?EF K

E{FE{F
E{FE{F
K
W

?EF K
?
E{F
E{FE{F

E{F
K
?EF K
?
E{FE{F
E{FE{F
K
?EF K
?
E{F
E{FE{F
E{F
K
?EF K
?
E{F
E{FE{F
KE{F
W

? ?EF K

E{FE{F

E{F
KE{F
KEF

??EF K

E{FE{F
KE{FE{F
KEF
??EF K

E{FE{F
E{FE{F
EF K
K
?EF K
?
E{FE{F
KE{FE{F

KEF
E{ J{F
K
W

?EF K
?
E{FE{F
E{F
FKE{F


E
J{F
KE{
?EF K

?
E{F
E{F
KE{FE{F
KEF
?EF K
?
E{F
E{F
KE{FE{F
KEF
??EF K

E{FE{F
E{F
KE{F
KEF
W

?EF K
?

E{FE{F
KE{FE{F
EF


E{ J{F
?EF K
?
E{F
E{F
KE{FE{F

KEF

?EF K

?

E{FE{FE{F
KE{F
KEF
?EF K

?
E{FE{F

KE{FE{F
KEF
?EF K
?

E{FE{F
E{F
KE{F
KEF

E{ J{F
K
??EF K

E{FE{F
E{FE{F
K
KEF

KE{ J{F
E

WEF

 EF

{* { J

{ { J

{ { J

{* { J

{ { J

{ { J

{ { J

{ { J

{ { J

{** { J

{

K

{

K

{

K

K

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

K
{


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {

{ {


{ {

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{ {

{

K

{

{

K

{

K

K

{

{

K

K

K

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

K

{ { {

{ { {

{ { {

{

{

{ {

EKKK

{**{*

 EF J

{**

{ J

{**

{ J

{ { J

{** { J

{ { J

{* { J

{

K

{

K

K

{

{

K

K

{

{ {

{ {

{ {


K
{


{ {


K
{

{ {

{ {

{ {


{ {


{ {


{ {

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{

{**{*

T-testEFEF

{{

W
E{FEF K
?E{F
?
KE{FE{F

KE J{F
E{FEF K
?E{F
?
E{F
KE{F

KE J{F
E{FEF K
?E{F
?
KE{FE{F

E J{F
K
E{FEF K
?E{F
?

KE{FE{F

KE J{F
E{FEF K
?E{F
?
E{F
KE{F

KE J{F
E{FEF K
?E{F
?
E{F
KE{F

KE J{F
F
W
E
J

One Way ANOVA?

WEF
EF
One Way ANOVA??

{ {

{

{ {

{ {

{
{ {

{ {

{*

EF
F {

E
K

One Way ANOVA??

WEF
EF
One Way ANOVA??

{*

{ {

{

{ {

{ {

{
{ {

{ {

{*

EF
F {

E

K

F{

E
K
??
WEFScheffe
EF
Scheffe??

{
{
{

{*

EF

F {
EFE
F
E

E F
KK
J

One Way ANOVA??

WEF
EF
One Way ANOVA??

{ {

{

{ {

{ {

{
{ {

{ {

{*

EF
F {

E
K
J

?
One Way ANOVA?
WEF
EF

One Way ANOVA??

{ {

{

{ {

{ {

{
{ {

{*

EF
F {

E
K
J

?
One Way ANOVA?
WEF
EF
One Way ANOVA??

{ {

{ {

{
{ {
{ {

{

{*

EF
F {

E
K
J

One Way ANOVA??

WEF
EF
One Way ANOVA??

{ {

{
{ {
{ {

{
{ {
{ {

{
{ {
{ {

{

{*

EF
{
F

W--

EF
EFE{F
KE{F
EF
EF E{F

E{F E{F
K

EF

E{F
EF
E{F
E{F
K
EF
KE{F

K
KK

EF

??EF
EF E{F
E{F??
KEF

EF
EF E{F
EF
K E{F

EF
KE{F
K
W--

K
W
E{F

E{F
K

E{F

EF


EF

EF

EF

KK

K
W
E{F
K

E{F
K

E{F
K

EF

F
E

K
W

E{F
KEF
KEF

E{F
K

E{F
E
F
K

EF

EF J

EF J

K
W
E{F
K

E{F
K


E{F
K

EF

F
EKKK

--
W

{
F

E
K
{
F

K E
{
F

E
E F
EF
KEF
{
F

E
K
{
F

E
K
{
F

E
K
{
F



E
K

W
EF K
W
K

K

K
K
K

K

K

K

K
K

KK
F
E

K
K


K
K
K
K
KK

K
K
EF
K

K
K
K
K

F
E

F
KE
K

K
K

EF

W

K
K
K
K

WE

W KEF

K
W
KEF

K
W
KEF

K
KEF

KW
W
KEF

K
W
KEF

K
KEF

KW
KWKEF

KEF

KW
KEF

KWSPSS
KEF

KW
W KEF

K
W KEF
K

W KEF

K
KEF

KW
KEF

KW
KEF

KW
KWKEF

WKEF

KW
KWKEF

KEF

KW
KWKEKF

KEF

KW
KWKEF

KEF

KW
KEF

KW
KEF

KW
W
KEKF

W KEF

K
WKEF

KW
JWKEF

KW
W KEF

K
W KEF

WKEF

W
KEF

W
WKEF

WWKEF

K
W KEF

K
WKEF

KEF

KEF

KEF
WEspssF

WKEF

K
KEF

KW
KWKEF

KWKEF

KW
W
KEF

K
WKEF

WKEF

KEF

KWSPSS
WKEF

WKEF

K
KEF

KW

KEF

W
KWKEF

KWKEF

KEF

KW

KWKEF

KWKEF

KEF

KW
WKEF

K
KWWKEF

KEF

KW

WE

KEF

KW
KEFEF

KW
KEF

KW
KKEF

KW
KKKEF

W

K

KE JF

W

K
KEF

W
K
KEF

KW
KEF

W

K
KEF

KW
KEF

KW

KEF

KW
KEF

KW

KEF

KW


WE

??KEF

KEFW
??KEF

KEFW
? ??KEF

W EF
K
KEF

?
W

KEFEF
? ?KEF

K
?KEF

KEF
?
KEFW
KEF?KEF

?
K
?KEF

KEFW?
?
?
?KEF

 ?KEF

W?
LL JL
K
? W
?KEF

WE

KEKF

KEF

K
Kwww.rcjy.gov.saEF

Kwww.spa.gov.saEF

W KEF

KEF

L
KEKF

KEF
W

E

E

K
KK

KK

KK

KK

KK

KK

KK

KK

KK

K
K

 EFE

KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKL

FW
J
E
K

K
K

 W
E3F

WK

KKKKKKKKKKKKKKWK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKWK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKWEFK

EKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKF

WK

L

WK

WEFK

EKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKF

W
EF

WE3F

EF









EF
EF


EF

W
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

KKK W

WE3F

E
F

EKK








W
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK


KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

 W
K

WE3F

KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

WE3F

F



EKKK

W
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK



KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK