From:BillRoss Sent:Tuesday,February25,201411:35AM To:Bonanducci,Chris Cc:Mastrull,DianeGensler,Howard Subject:Citydeskperformancereviews.

Chris, Adisturbingpatternhascometomyattentionregardingperformance reviewsbeingdonebyCityEditorNancyPhillips.Firstoffanumber ofGuildmembershavetoldmedirectlythatPhillipshassaidBilland Stanhavesaidtopscoresareonlytobegiventoreporterswhoare nationallyrecognized.Second,Phillipshasbeenextremelyharshand criticalinsomeofhercomments,toapointwhereshemadeemployees cry,orothersthatmayborderondiscrimination.I'veurgedmy memberswhosufferedthisunfairtreatmenttocallyoudirectly,and scheduleanappointmentforyoutoreviewwiththemtheirperformance review.I'vehadnoothercomplaintsfromanyothernewsroom department.Ourmembersdidtheirpartinthereviewswithoutapeep, andIwillnotletoneconflictedEditor,getherkicksbyabusingour members,ortakingretributionagainstafewshemaynotlike,orfeel threatenedby.PleasekeepmeinformedifIcanhelpinanyway. Thanks,

BillRoss ExecutiveDirector TNGCWALocal38010