Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Prophet Is Not Like Us
Prophet Is Not Like Us
Ohie<x!leqkvi!@!
!
fhqOb! %XuQvig"! fie<! dr<gjt! Ohie<x! lekqe<! kie<! we<etuqz<?!
dr<gt<!gmUt<!yOv!gmUt<!kie<!we<X!nxquqg<gh<hm<Mt<tK!!
nz<GINe<!27.221/!
!
lg<gt<! njeuVl<! nkqZl<! Gxqh<hig! gihqIgTl<! fhq! Lal<lK!
L^<khi! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! leqkI! kie<!
we<X!fl<Hgqe<xeI/!nh<hcbqVf<Kl<! Olx<%xh<hm<m!Nbk<K!usel<! fie<!
dr<gjth<! Ohie<X! leqkI! kie< we<X! nVth<hm<mkqe<! kk<Kuole<e@!
we<hjk!-r<G!sx<X!Nvib<Ouil</!!
!
fhq! =^i! njzaq^<^zil<! nuIgt<! kf<jk! -z<zilz<! \eelieK?!
lv{qk<kuIgjt! dbqIh<hqk<K! uip! juk<kK?! hqxuqg<GVmIgjt! g{<!
dt<tuIgtig! lix<xqbK?! ohVl<! ohVl<! uqbikqgjt! wz<zil<!
lVf<Kgt<!-z<zilz<!jg!ogi{<M!kmUuK!&zl<!Sglig<Gkz<!Ohie<x!
L0\q^ik<! .! nx<Hkr<gjt! nuIgt<! sLkibk<kqeI! hiIk<kKl<! -uI!
nz<zia<uqe<! Glivvigk<! kie<! -Vg<g! Ou{<Mole! fqjek<K! -uI!
nz<zia<uqe<!GlivI!we<X!%xqeI/!!
!
dj^X! njzaq^<^zil<! nuIgt<! lv{qk<K! F~X! uVmr<gTg<Gh<!
hqe<! dbqI! ohx<oxPf<kjk! hiIk<kKl<! b,kIgt<! -uI! nz<zia<uqe<!
GlivI!we<X!osie<eiIgt</!!
kqk<kqg<Gl<! kqVljxbil<! GINe<! ]vQhqz<! lzg<G! ! nlvIgjt!
oh{<hizig! !)lzibqgk<! we<hkig*!dhObigqg<gh<hMukiz<! lzg<Ggt<!
nz<zia<uqe<!oh{<!lg<gt<!we<X!L]<vqg<Ggt<!osiz<z!Nvl<hqk<keI/!!
!
-ju! Ohie<x! -jugjt! uqmUl<! dbIuie! w{<{x<x! L0\q^ik<!
)nx<Hkr<*! gt<! fhqgt<! Ogilie<! Lal<lK! L^<khi! ^z<zz<zia|!
njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgtqml<!gi{h<hm<me/!!
!
uiEzgqz<! fQf<kq! uVl<! sf<kqvje! kr<gt<! kqVg<gvk<kiz<! slqg<jR!
osb<K!-v{<M!K{<mig!hqtf<K!gim<ceiIgt</!!
!
lvr<gt<! -uIgt<! njph<hqx<gq{r<gq! -uIgt<! s&gl<! uf<ke"/! $vqb!
ouh<hl<! kig<glzqVg<g?! Olgl<! -uIgt<! OhiGlqmr<gTg<ogz<zil<!
%mOu!ose<X!Gjm!hqck<kK/"!
!
-uIgt<!kqVg<gvr<gtqz<!gx<gt<!k^<hQa<!)Kkq*!osb<ke"/!!
!
=k<k!lvk<kiz<!osb<bh<hm<m!lql<hI!)!hqvsr<g!Oljm*!-uIgtqe<!hqvquiz<!
nPkK"!
!
uqvz<gtqzqVf<K!Dx<Xg<g{<!yzqk<OkicbK/!!
!
kr<gt<! kib<! kf<jkbIgtie! Nlqei! fibgq?! nh<Kz<zia<! fibgl<!
vzqbz<zia|! ne<a|li! -uIgjtBl<! OkipI! apvk<! \ihqI!
vzqbz<zia|! ne<a|l<! nuIgtqe<! -V! hqt<jtgjtBl<! dbqIh<hqk<kz<?!
gib<f<klvl<! ktqIk<kz<?! Ofibitqgt<! -uIgtqe<! kqVg<gvk<kiz<!
kmuh<hm<mKl<! SgliGkz<! -ju! Ohie<x! w{<{x<x! nx<Hkr<gjtg<!
gim<ceiIgt</!!
!
-jugjtobz<zil<! hiIk<K! uqm<M! Le<! ose<x! sLkibk<kqeI!
osie<eK! Ohie<X! fhq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtqe<!
sLkibk<kqeVl<! -uIgjt! nz<zia<uqe<! GlivI! we<X! osiz<zq!
uqmg<! %miOk!we<hkx<gig! fhqOb!%XuQvig"/!fie<! dr<gjth<! Ohie<X!
leqke<! kie<! )nz<zia<uqe<! Glive<! nz<z*! we<X! nz<zia<! fhqgt<!
fibgk<kqx<G!lg<gtqml<!osiz<Zl<hc!gm<mjtbqm<mie</!!
-Ok!gVk<Kh<hm!-lil<!nz<zili!h,^vq!vzqbz<zia|!ne<a|!nuIgt<!
HVki!]vQhqz<!fuqe<Xt<tiIgt</!!
k0lk<k!nk<a|e<esivi!///////////////////////////////////////////////////!
f^ivi)gqVk<KuI*! gt<! kr<gt<! fhq! =^i! njzaq^<^zil<! nuIgt<!
sl<hf<klig!)GlivI!we<X!*!uikqk<kjk!uqm<M!uqm<M!fhq!^z<zz<zia|!
njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! uqsbk<kqz<! fQ! ficb! Hgjp! osiz<zq!
fqjxOux<xqg<! ogit<"! nuIgTg<G! sqxh<hqz<! fqe<Xl<! wjugjt! wz<zil<!
OsIg<g! fiMgqe<xiObi! njugjt! wz<zil<! OsIk<Kg<! ogit<"!
v^|Zz<zia<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<! nuIgtqe<! sqxh<hqx<Gl<!
nf<k^<kqx<Gl<! fqs<sbl<! uvl<hqz<jz! uibiz<! Hgp<f<K! kQIk<K! uqm!
LcbiK!
!
b,kIgTl<?! gqVk<KuIgTl<! kr<gt<! kr<gt<! fhqliIgjt! uvl<H! lQxqk<!
kgik!uiIk<jkgjt!osiz<zq!upqogm<Mh<! OhieiIgt</!fil<! uvl<hqx<Gt<!
-Vf<K! ogi{<M! fl<! dk<kl! fhq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!
nuIgjt! wu<utU! Hgp! -bZOli! nu<utU! Hgpzil<?! HgpUl<!
Ou{<Ml</!!
!
fil<! nuIgjth<! Hgp! Hgp! flK! gQIk<kqBl<! sqxh<Hl<! nkqgvqk<Kg<!
ogi{<Om!Ohigqe<xe/!-K!fil<!g{<!%mib<!gi[l<!gim<sqBliGl</!!
!
Olx<%xqb!usek<kqz<! fhq!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<! nuIgjt!
nz<zia<uqe<! GlivI! we<X! osiz<zilz<! nh<Ka|! uv^|Za|!
nxquiIgt<?!wkiIk<k!kk<Kuk<jk!nxqOu!okvqf<K!ogit<t!lim<miIgt</!
okvqf<K! ogit<t! Lbx<sqg<gUl<<! lim<miIgt</! lixig! nuI! fl<jlh<!
Ohie<x!sikiv{!leqkI!kie<?!FHuk<kqeiz<!lm<MOl!nuVg<G!uqOs]l<!
gqm<cbK!we<X!hqkx<xqk<!kqvquiIgt<!we<hK!out<tqm!ljz"/!!
!
fhqgt<! Ogilie<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTg<Gl<!
flg<Gl<! nef<kl<! nef<kl<! SVkq! )fgzqb<bk<*! nch<hjmbqZl<?! Bg<kq!
)ngzqbk<*! nch<hjmbqZl<! hiGhiM! d{<M! we<hjk! nMk<K!
gi[Ouil</!!
!
SVkq!)fgzqb<bk<*!nch<hjmbqz<!!
!
2*!fhq!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTl<!fiLl<!osiz<zq!
gzqli! ]aikk<kqz<! uqk<kqbisl<! ;! fil<! osiz<uK! n]<aK!
ne<e! Lal<lke<! nh<Ka|! uv^|Za|! .! Lal<lK!
^z<zz<zia|!
njzaq!
u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! fqs<sbl<!
nz<zia<uqe<! ncbiVl<! K~kVliuiIgt<! we<X! fie<! sim<sq!
osiz<gqOxe<!we<hkiGl</!!
fhq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! osiz<uK! Ohie<X!
fil<! osiz<z! LcbiK/! nh<hc! biVl<! osie<eiz<! ke<je! fhq! K~kI!
we<X!osie<eueigq!gihqvigquqMuie</!!
!
3*!-^<zil<! Jf<K! givqbk<kqe<! lQK! njlg<gh<hm<mK! 2*! ]aikk<K!
)sim<sq! hgVkz<*! 3*! okiPjg! ! 4*! \gik<! ! ! 5*! Ofie<H! ! 6*!
a\<\|! flg<G! -u<juf<Kl<! gmjl! Neiz<! Lal<lK!
^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTg<G! -^<zik<kqe<!
gmjl!fie<G!kie</!ohiVt<!-Vf<kiZl<!\gik<!gmjlbqz<jz/!!
! !
!
!
!
!
)Nkivl<!;!vk<Kz<!La<kiI*!
4*!K~g<gl<! flK!dTju!Lxqk<K!uqMl</!fibgk<! kqVOleq!v^|Oz!
gvQl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTg<G! K~g<gl<!
dTju! Lxqg<giK/! nuIgt<! g{<gt<! K~r<gqeiZl<! dtl<!
K~r<giK/!weOu!dT!LxqbiK/!!
5*!flg<G! JOujtk<! okiPjg! gmjlbiGl</! fhq! ^z<zz<zia|!
njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTg<G! NX! Oujt! okiPjg!
gmjlbiGl</!Olx<%xqb!Jf<Kl<!ka\<\|K okiPjgBliGl</!!
!
hka\<\k<! hqaq!!fihqzk<ke<! .!zg<! .!)fhqOb"*!ka\<\|k<! okiPjg!
okiPgUl</! -K! dlg<G! nkqgliGl</! lx<x! dlK! dl<lk<kiIgTg<G!
gmjl!-z<jz/!)nz<!GINe<!28.8:*!
!
6*!fil<! fie<G!ljeuqliIgjt!uqm!nkqglieuIgjt!yOv!slbk<kqz<!
kqVl{l<! osb<K!ogit<t!nElkq!-z<jz/!Neiz<! fhq!^z<zz<zia|!
we<X!wr<gt<!GVfikI!^|hq!ap<vk<!sqk<kQgq!giaqvq!)^z<zla|z<zia|!
ulk<k! zqz<zia|z<! Nzq*! nuIgt<! npGhm! nvhqbqZl<! nke<!
olipqohbIh<jh!klqpqZl<!hicBt<tiIgt</!!
!
-h<hcobz<zil<! -Vg<g! -ghv! fz<uip<ju! upr<Gl<! ut<tz<! fhq!
^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTl<!fiLl<!slliGOuili@!
!
6*!oubqz<! ouh<hl<! nuIgtqe<! Heqk!Oleqbqz<! kig<gilz<! kMh<hkx<gig!
Olgl<! fqpzqm<mK/! fl<lqz<! wuIg<OgEl<! -h<hcB{<mi@-z<jzOb"! hqe<!
wh<hc!slliuiIgt</!@!
!
7*! kibqe<! ubqx<xqz<! -Vg<Gl<OhiOk! zu<a|z<! la<h,pqz<! wPkh<hMl<!
Oheiuqe<! Yjsjb! n{<{z<! na<lK! fhq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!
u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! Ogm<cVg<gqxiIgt</!fil<! dzgqz<! hqxf<k!hqe<Hl<! %m!
Ogm<hkqz<jzOb"/!fiLl<!nuIgTl<!ye<xi!@!
!
8*!fhqgt<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! hqxg<Gl<!
OhiOk! nz<zia<ju! nxqf<kuIgtig! )NvqHz<zia<uig*! hqxf<kiIgt</!
fiOli! hqxf<K! hVuolb<kqb! hqe<H! nz<zia<ju! nxqgqe<Oxil</!
we<xiZl<! nuIgt<! nxqf<k!ntuqx<G!fil<! nxqukqz<jz/!hqe<! wr<r{l<!
fl<jlh<Ohie<x!leqkviuiIgt<@!
!
9*! F~V! Lal<lK! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!
ytqbi)zi*euIgt</! kqjvbqe<xqh<! hiIg<g! LcbiK/! dkiv{lig"!
$vqbje! wu<uiX! kqjvbqe<xq! hiIg<g! LcbiOki! nK! Ohie<Ox!
Lal<lK! L^<khi! v^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!
nuIgjtBl<!h]vqbk<!we<x!kqjvbqe<xq!hiIg<g!LcbiK/!!
!
weOu! kie<! nuIgt<! oubqzqz<! fqe<xiZl<! fqpz<! uqpiK/! -Vtqz<!
-Vf<kiZl<! ytqlblig! -Vh<hiIgt</! nuIgt<! liS! lVux<x!
K~b<jlbie!F~vie!)ytqbie*!uIgt</!!
!
nz<zia<uqmlqVf<K! dr<gTg<G! F~I! ! ytqBl<?! Kzil<hvlie! Ouk!
F~Zl<!uf<kqVg<gqe<xe!
)nz<!GINe<!6.26*!
!
-u<usek<kqz<! %xh<hm<m! F~I! )ytq*! we<hK! fhqgt<! fibgl<!
^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgOt!kie</!!
-Vt<!gh<hqbuIgTl<!ytq!lqg<guIgTl<!sllieuIgti@!
:/! wuIgt<! Lal<lK! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTg<G!
upqhm<miIgOti!nuIgt<!fqs<sbl<!nz<zia<Ug<G!upqhm<muIgOt!kie</!!
ule<!BkqBx<!x^|z!hgk<!nki!nz<zia<!)nz<GINe<!.!5;91*!
!
okiPjgbqz<! o]b<G! nuIgt<! Ohie<x! ohvqbiIgt</! v^|z<!
^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<<! ! nuIgtieiZl<! svq! -uIgTjmb!
Rihgl<! uVkieK!liM?!gPjkBjmb!Rihgk<kqz<! &p<Gujk!uqmUl<!
lqgg<! ogm<mkiGl<! we<X! )lNkz<zia<*! we<Oe! nuvqe<! upqOgM"!
nuIkl<!ogit<jgjb!sl<lkqh<huIgtqe<!lkqbQel<"!
!
NgOu?! fl<Ljmb! Bg<kq! Nvib<s<sq! nch<hjmbqZl<?! )]iQnk<! SVkq!
nch<hjmbqZl<*! fiLl<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!
nuIgTl<! sllz<z! we<hKl<! fl<jlh<Ohiz<! leqkVlz<z! we<hKl<!
okt<tk<!oktquigquqm<mK"!
!
lqKZg<Gl<////////////////!
!
lqKZg<Gl<////////! )dr<gjth<! Ohie<X*! we<hkqe<! gVk<kiuK?! \er<gOt"!
fQr<gt<! wu<uiX! nz<zia<uig! -z<ziK! nueqe<! ncbiIgtig!
-Vg<gqe<xQIgOti!nK!Ohie<Ox!fiEl<! nz<zia<! nz<z"!nz<zia<uqe<!
GlivEl<!nz<z"!fie<!nz<zia<uqe<!ncjlkie<!we<hkiGl</!
!
nk<OkiM?! we<etuqz<! uaq! nxquqg<gh<hMgqe<xK/! fie<! nz<zia<uqe<!
K~ke<?!fQr<gt<!weg<G!upqh<hm<M!fmg<g!Ou{<Ml<!we<hKliGl</!
!
NgOu! flK! dbqVg<Gl<! dbqvie! sIkiOv! OkiNzl<?! Lal<lK!
L^<khi?! na<lK! L\<khi! ]hQUz<! Lk<eqhQe<?! va<lKe<zqz<! NzlQe<!
^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgjth<! hx<xq! fl<! sqf<kjebqz<?!
osbzqz<?! osiz<zqz<?! gqvqjbgtqz<! nuIgt<! sikiv{! fl<jlh<Ohie<x!
leqkI! we<x! w{<{l<! .! fqjeh<H! uvilz<! fl<! =lijeh<! hiKgik<Kg<!
ogit<t!Ou{<Ml</!
!
fl<! dt<tk<kqz<! dbqvqz<?! dkqvk<kqz<! kjsbqz<! fic! fvl<Hgtqz<!
nuIgtqe<! g{<{qbl<?!H{<{qbl<?!lvqbijk!nuIgt<! duh<H!djxf<K!
-v{<mxg<gzf<K! uqm! Ou{<Ml<"! wz<zil<! uz<z! nz<zia<! nkx<G!
fz<zVt<!Hvquieig"!
!
-jxui"! d{<jljb! d{<jlbig! wr<gTg<G! gim<c?! njk! hqe<hx<xq!
fmh<hkx<Gl<! nsk<kqbk<jk! nsk<kqblig! gim<c?! njk! kuqIf<K!
fmh<hkx<Gl<!nVt<!Hvquibig"!nvalIviaQlQOe"!bivh<hz<!NzlQOe"!
!
!