You are on page 1of 84

MECH103 Mechanisms and Dynamics of Machinery

Chapter 10 Introduction to Mechanism Synthesis

Mechanism synthesis
Qualitative synthesis: to create the potential solutions Some linkage design in the absence of a well-defined algorithm that predicts the solution Iteration between analysis and synthesis: With the help of CAD such as Working Model or popular programs Norton textbook: Chap 3
2

Mechanism synthesis classification


Function generation: correlation of I/P motion with O/P motion in an
mechanism (black box: mechanical analog computer, artillery rangefinder, shipboard gun aiming system); Linkage performs a mathematical function w/ input the independent variable and output the dependent variable

- rocker output Path generation: control of a Point in the plane such that it follows some
prescribed path; The linkage guides some pt. (coupler pt.) along a desired path

Motion generation: control of a Line in the plane such that it follows some
prescribed set of sequential positions: bucket control on a bulldozer (rigid body guidance); The linkage guides a body through a specified path with specified orientation

- simple case: coupler output

Mechanism synthesis: two approaches


Traditional Computer-aided design synthesis

- Graphical (chap 3) - Analytical (chap 5)


4

Synthesis CAD program: Symech http://www.symech.com


More CAD programs: http://www.tenlinks.com/CAE/products/kinematics.htm

- Working model

Two-Position Synthesis
Rocker output: - Grashof crank-rocker is desired - a trivial case of function generator Coupler output (complex motion) - more general - simple case of motion generation - two positions of a line are defined as O/P

Two-Position Synthesis 4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Design a 4-bar Grashof crank-rocker to give 45 of rocker rotation with equal time forward and back, from a constant speed motor input

Nortons textbook, Example 3-1, p. 93 See Animation\WM\Ch3\fig3_4\ in Nortons CD-Rom

Limiting conditions: Toggle positions 4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 1

B2 B1 O4

The linkage in its two toggle positions


8

Nortons textbook Example 3-1, p. 93

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 2, 3

B2 O2 B1 O4

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 4a

B2 O2 B1 O4

10

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 4b
a O2 A2 B1 O4 a B2

O2 A2 =

1 (O2 B2 O2 B1 ) 2

11

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 5 Link 2
a a B2 A1 O2 A2 B1 O4 Link 2

12

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 6
Link 3 Link 2

B2 A1 O2 A2 B1 O4

13

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 7
Link 3 Link 2

A2 A1 O2 Link 1 B1 O4

B2 Link 4

14

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 8
Link 3 Link 2

A2 A1 O2 Link 1 B1 O4

B2 Link 4

Find the Grashof condition:


15

< L+S = P+Q >

If non-Grashof (>), then redo Step 3~8 by moving O2 further from O4

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis


Step 9

Link 2 O2

Link 3

B2 Link 4

Link 1 O4

- Simulate this mechanism to check its function and transmission angles (Nortons CD: working model file)
16

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis

17

4-bar Grashof crank-rocker synthesis

In inch
18

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

19

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

Step 1
Draw link CD in two desired positions

D1 Link 4 C1 C2

D2

20

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

Step 2
Draw construction line from C1 to C2 and from D1 to D2

D1 Link 4 C1 C2

D2

21

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

Step 3
Bisect C1C2 and D1D2 and extend to intersect at O4

D1 Link 4 C1 C2

O4

D2

22

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

Step 4:
draw an arc about O4 to intersect O4C1 and O4C2 at B1 and B2 respectively

D1 Link 4 C1 B1 O4 B2 D2 C2

O4CiDi = output link, i=1,2


23

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

Step 5:
Follow Steps 2~8 of previous example to complete the C1 linkage

D1 Link 4 C2 B1 O4 B2 D2

24

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

Link 4

D1

a O2 A2

C1 B1

a B2

C2

O4

D2

25

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

D1 Link 4 Link 2 Link 3 A1 O2 A2 Link 1 B1 O4 D2 C1 B2 C2

26

Rocker output- two positions with complex displacement (motion generation)


Problem: design a 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2

27

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots


Problem: design a inverted 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2 and then C3D3. Use specified fixed pivots O2 and O4

Step 1
Draw link CD in three desired positions

Norton, Section 5.8 Synthesis CAD program: Symech http://www.symech.com


28

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots


Problem: design a inverted 4-bar linkage to move link CD from position C1D1 to C2D2 and then C3D3. Use specified fixed pivots O2 and O4

Step 2
Draw the ground link O2O4

29

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots Step 3


Draw the arcs from C2 to O2 and from D2 to O2

(a) Original coupler three-position problem with specified pivots (b) Position of the ground plane relative to the second coupler position (arbitrary).

30

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots Step 4


Draw the arcs from C2 to O4 and from D2 to O4

(a) Original coupler three-position problem with specified pivots (b) Position of the ground plane relative to the second coupler position (arbitrary).

31

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots Step 4


Transferring O2O4 to O2O4

(c) Transferring second ground plane position to reference location at first position
32

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots Step 5


Repeat the process for the 3rd coupler position. Transferring O2O4 to O2O4

O2 O4 (d) Position of the ground plane relative to the third coupler position (e) transfer 3rd ground plane position to ref location at 1st position
33

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots

O2 G

O2 O2 O4 H

O4

O4
O2O4

(f) Check the 3 inverted positions of the ground plane


O2O4 and O2O4

E1F1, E2F2 and E3F3

(g) Find the ground pivot points: G and H


34

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots

(h) The correct inversion of desired linkage


35

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots

(i) Re-invert to obtain the result (E1F1 pivots)


36

(j) Re-place the Link CD

Three-position Synthesis with specified Fixed Pivots

37

Quick-return Mechanism
- Used in single point metal cutting machine. - Forward = cutting

38

Analytical Mechanism Synthesis


Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis Design a four-bar linkage, which will move a line on its coupler link such that a point P on that line will be first at P1 and later at P2 and will also rotate the line through an angle 2 between those two precision positions. Find the lengths and angles of the four links and the coupler link dimensions A1P1 and B1P1 as shown in Fig 5-1.

P2

P1

A1 A2

B2

B1

o2 o4

Fig. 5-1 Nortons textbook

39

Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis

The problem statement is: Design a four-bar linkage, which will move a line on its coupler link such that a point P on that line will be first at P1 and later at P2 and will also rotate the line through an angle 2 between those two precision positions. Find the lengths and angles of the four links and the coupler link dimensions A1P1 and B1P1 as shown in Figure 5-1.

40

Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis

The displacement of the output motion of point P P21 = R2 R1 (5. 1)


s1

Link 3
V1 = Z1 S1
(5. 2a)

Z1

Ground link 1
G1 = W1 + V1 U1
(5. 2b)
W1

V1 u1

Thus if we can define the two dyads W1, Z1, and U1, S1, we will have defined a linkage that meets the problem specifications. Dyads = open kinematic chain of 2 binary links and one joint
41

G1

Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis

First solve for the left side of the linkage (vectors W1 and Z1). A vector loop equation around the loop which includes both positions P1 and P2 for the left-side dyad.

P21 z2 z1

W2 + Z2 P21 Z1 W1 = 0

(5.3)

x - component

(5.6a)
W2 W1

[ w cos ] ( cos 2 1) [ w sin ] sin 2 + z cos ( cos 2 1) z sin sin 2 =


y - component

p 21 cos 2

[ w sin ] ( cos 2 1) [ w cos ] sin 2 + z sin ( cos 2 1) + z cos sin 2 =


42

p 21 sin 2

(5.6b)

Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis

[ w cos ] ( cos 2 1) [ w sin ] sin 2 + z cos ( cos 2 1) z sin sin 2 =

p 21 cos 2

[ w sin ] ( cos 2 1) [ w cos ] sin 2 + z sin ( cos 2 1) + z cos sin 2 =

p 21 sin 2

There are eight variables in these two equations: w, , 2, z, , 2, p21 and 2. Three of the eight are defined in the problem statement, namely 2, p21 and 2. Of the remaining five w, , 2, z, , we are forced to choose three as free choices (assumed values) in order to solve for the other two. One strategy is to assume : Values for the three angles, , 2,
43

Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis

B = cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2


C = p 21 cos 2

A = cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2

(5.7a)

E = sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2 F = p 21 sin 2

D = sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2

(5.7b)

Aw + Bz = C Dw + Ez = F

(5.7c)

Solving simultaneously,
CE BF ; w= AE BD
44

z=

AF CD AE BD

(5.7d)

Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis

Repeat the process for the righthand dyad, U1S1


U2 + S2 P21 S1 U1 = 0
(5.9a)

S1 S2

The x and y component equations become:


cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2
+ s cos (cos 2 1) s sin sin 2 = p 21 cos 2
(5.10a)

U2

U1

sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2


+ s sin (cos 2 1) + s cos sin 2 = p 21 sin 2
45

(5.10b)

2, p21 and 2 Right-hand dyad: three angles , , 2

Left-hand dyad: three angles , 2,

Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis

B = cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2


C = p 21 cos 2

A = cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2

(5.11a)

E = sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2 F = p 21 sin 2

D = sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2

(5.11b)

Au + Bs = C Du + Es = F

(5.11c)

Solving simultaneously,
CE BF u= ; AE BD
46

AF CD s= AE BD

(5.11d)

Nortons FOURBAR program for 2 position synthesis

47

Ex: 5-1, p.219

Nortons FOURBAR program for 2 position synthesis

48

Three-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis There are 12 variables in these FOUR equations (Eq. 5.22): w, , 2 , 3, z, , 2, 3 , p21 , p31 , 2 and 3. Six of the 12 are defined in the problem statement, namely 2, 3, p21 , p31 2 and 3. Of the remaining six w, , 2, 3, z, , we are forced to choose three as free choices (assumed values) in order to solve for the other FOUR.

left-hand dyad

W2 + Z2 P21 Z1 W1 = 0 W3 + Z3 P31 Z1 W1 = 0

(5.19) (5.20)

right-hand dyad
U2 + S2 P21 S1 U1 = 0 U3 + S3 P31 S1 U1 = 0
(5.28)

49

Nortons FOURBAR program for 3 position synthesis

50

Nortons FOURBAR program for 3 position synthesis

51

Nortons FOURBAR program for 3 position synthesis with fixed pivot points

52

Nortons FOURBAR program for 3 position synthesis with fixed pivot points

53

Bulldozer Mechanism

Bulldozer: a tractor-driven machine usually having a broad blunt horizontal blade for moving earth (as in road building) http://www.kenkenkikki.jp/special/no02/e_index.htm http://maeweb.ucsd.edu/~mae3/spring2002/mae3_19/web/load.html

54

Backhoe Bucket Mechanism

Backhoe: an excavator whose shovel bucket is attached to a hinged boom and is drawn backward to move earth
55

Mechanism Categories
Function Generation Mechanisms

A function generator is a linkage in which the relative motion between links connected to the ground is of interest.

- Correlation of an input motion with an output motion in a mechanism


56

- Typically, correlation of 2 grounded links

Mechanism Categories
Function Generation Mechanisms A function generator is a linkage in which the relative motion between links connected to the ground is of interest.

A four-bar hand actuated wheelchair brake mechanism


57

Mechanism Categories
Function Generation Mechanisms

A four-bar drive linkage for a lawn sprinkler


58

Mechanism Categories
Path Generation Mechanisms In path generation, we are concerned only with the path of a tracer point and not with the motion (rotation) of the coupler link.

59

Example: film advance mechanism, See Animation/WM/Ch3/camera in Nortons CD-Rom Control of a point so that it follows a prescribed path Doe not specify orientation

Mechanism Categories
Path Generation Mechanisms In path generation, we are concerned only with the path of a tracer point and not with the motion (rotation) of the coupler link.

Crane straight line motion

60

Mechanism Categories
Motion Generation Mechanisms In motion generation, the entire motion of the coupler link is of interest (rigid body guidance).

- Control of a line in a plane so that it assumes a prescribed set of positions and orientations - Hard to do with more than 3 positions if ground pivots specified
61

Mechanism Categories
Motion Generation Mechanisms In motion generation, the entire motion of the coupler link is of interest (rigid body guidance).

New Rollerblade brake system


62

Mechanism Categories
Motion Generation Mechanisms

Hood

Four-bar automobile hood linkage design

63

Two position synthesis


Design a four-bar crank and rocker mechanism to give 45o of rocker rotation with equal time forward and back, from a constant speed motor input. 1 Draw the rocker O4B in both extreme positions, B1and B2 in any convenient location with angle 4 = 45o. 2 select a convenient point O2 on line B1B2 extended. 3 Bisect line B1B2 , and draw a circle with that radius about O2. 4 Label the two intersection of the circle with B1B2 extended, A1 and A2. 5 Measure O2A (crank, link2) and AB (coupler, link3).

64

Two position synthesis


Design a four-bar crank and rocker mechanism to give 45o of rocker rotation with equal time forward and back, from a constant speed motor input.

65

Motion Generation Mechanisms: Graphical Solution


Two position synthesis C1D1 and C2D2
1. Draw the link CD in its two desired positions, C1D1 and C2D2 2. Connect C1 to C2 and D1 to D2. 3. Draw two lines perpendicular to C1 C2 and D1D2 at the midpoint (midnormals) 4. Select two fixed pivot points, O2 and O4, anywhere on the two midnormals.

66

Motion Generation Mechanisms: Graphical Solution


Two position synthesis (coupler output) C1D1 and C2D2

The rigid body to be moved from position 1 to 2 is secured to link 3.

67

Three positions with specified fixed pivot points, coupler as the output
1. Draw the link CD in its three desired positions, C1D1, C2D2 and C3D3 and locate the fixed pivot points O2 and O4. Draw an arc from C1 with radius O2C2 and another arc from D1 with radius O2D2. Locate the intersection, O2. Draw an arc from C1 with radius O4C2 and another arc from D1 with radius O4D2. Locate the intersection, O4.

O4

O2 C2 D1 C1 O2 O2 O4 O4 C3 D2 D3

2.

3.

68

Three positions with specified fixed pivot points, coupler as the output

4.

Draw an arc from C1 with radius O2C3 and another arc from D1 with radius O2D3. Locate the intersection, O2. Draw an arc from C1 with radius O4C3 and another arc from D1 with radius O4D3. Locate the intersection, O4.

O4 O2 C1 O 2

C2 D1 C3 O2 O 4 O2

D2 D3

5.

O4

O4

69

Three positions with specified fixed pivot points, coupler as the output
6. Connect O2 to O2 and O2 to O2 . Draw two midnormals and locate the intersection, G. Connect O4 to O4 and O4 to O4 . Draw two midnormals and locate the intersection, H. O2G is link 2 and O4H is link 4. Construct a link (3) containing GH and CD.

O 4 O 2 O4 C2 D1 G O2 C3 O4

7.

D2 H D3

O2

8. 9.

C1

10. Verify the solution by constructing the mechanism in three position

70

Two position Motion synthesis

71

Mechanism used in Mechanical Analog Computer


Type LC-1: WWII Navy PV-1 "Balance Computor

Librascope Incorporation, Burbank, California Made for the WWII U.S. Navy Lockheed PV-1 Vega "Ventura" antisubmarine patrol bomber. The computer has 19 dials to input fuel load and tanks, bomb load, guns, ammo, torpedos etc. and uses this information to calculates Total Weight and Center of Gravity. http://dcoward.best.vwh.net/analog/libra.htm
72

Two-Position Motion Generation by Analytical Synthesis

we j ( + 2 ) + ze j ( + 2 ) p 21e j 2 ze j we j = 0

we e
j

j 2

+ ze e

j 2

p 21e
j

j 2

ze

we

=0
Euler formula

we (e

j 2

1) + ze (e

j 2

1) = p 21e
(5.6a)

j 2

x - component

e j = cos + j sin , j = 1

[ w cos ] ( cos 2 1) [ w sin ] sin 2 + z cos ( cos 2 1) z sin sin 2 =


y - component

p 21 cos 2

[ w sin ] ( cos 2 1) [ w cos ] sin 2 + z sin ( cos 2 1) + z cos sin 2 =


73

p 21 sin 2

(5.6b) Textbook p.213

Slide 42,

Final Solution to Example: Design a four-bar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion y O4

A1 P21 A2 B2

B1

A1x=0.0, B1x=1.721, A2x=2.656, B2x=5.065 A1y=0.0, B1y=-1.75, A2y=-0.751, B2y=-0.281


O2
74

Example: Design a four-bar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion A1x = 0.0, B1x = 1.721, A2x = 2.656, B2x = 5.065 A1y = 0.0, B1y = -1.75, A2y = -0.751, B2y = -0.281 R1 = (A1x, A1y), R2 = (A2x, A2y), P21 = R2 - R1 = (2.656, -0.751), p21 = 2.76
A B1 y A2 y B2 y 1 1 y o 2 = tan tan = 56 . 519 A B 1x A2 x B2 x 1x
1

2 = tan 1

P21 y P21x

o = 15 . 789

From graphical method, determine the I/P for Eq. (5.7) = 94.394, 2 = -40.366, = -45.479

Solve for (w z) dyad using Eq. (5.7)


ArcTan( y / x), if x > 0 y tan 1 ( ) = x ArcTan( y / x) + , otherwise
75

Example: Design a fourbar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion

B = cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2


C = p 21 cos 2

A = cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2

(5.7a)

E = sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2 F = p 21 sin 2

D = sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2

(5.7b)

Aw + Bz = C Dw + Ez = F
w= CE BF = 4 .000 AE BD

(5.7c)

z=

AF CD = 0 .000 AE BD

76

Example: Design a fourbar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion From graphical method, determine the I/P for Eq. (5.11) = -93.449, 2 =54.330, = 134.521

B = cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2


C = p 21 cos 2

A = cos (cos 2 1) sin sin 2

(5.11a)

E = sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2 F = p 21 sin 2

D = sin (cos 2 1) + cos sin 2

(5.11b)

Au + Bs = C Du + Es = F

(5.11c)

Solving simultaneously,
CE BF u= = 4 .000 AE BD
77

s=

AF CD = 2 .455 AE BD

Example: Design a four-bar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion (5. 2a) Link 3 V1x = z cos s cos = 1.721 V =2.455

V1 = Z1 S1

V1 y = z sin s sin = 1.750


(5. 2b)

3 = tan 1

V1 y V1x

o = 45 . 479

Ground link 1

G1 = W1 + V1 U1 G1x = w cos + v cos 3 u cos = 1.655 G =6.447 G1 y = w sin + v sin 3 u sin = 6.231
1 = tan 1

G1 y = 75.123o G1x

Determine the initial & final value of the input crank wrt vector G 2i = - 1=19.271, 2f = 2i + 2 = -21.095 Determine the coupler point wrt point A and the vector V rp = z = 0.0, p = - 3 = 0

78

Example: Design a fourbar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion Locate the fixed pivots in the global frame using all the vector definitions
1 = tan 1
A1 y = 90.0o A1x

R1 = (A1x, A1y)

R1 = 0

O2 x = R1 cos 1 z cos w cos = 0.306 O2 y = R1 sin 1 z sin w sin = 3.988 O4 x = R1 cos 1 s cos u cos = 1.962 O4 y = R1 sin 1 s sin u sin = 2.243
O O = tan 1
2 4

O4 y O2 y o = 75 . 123 O O 2x 4x

79

Example: Design a fourbar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion Link 1 : Link 2 : Link 3 : Link 4 : Coupler : g = 6.447, 1 = 75.123 w = 4.000, = 94.394 v = 2.455, 3 = -45.479 u = 4.000, = -93.449 rp = 0, p = 0

Crank angle: 2i = 19.271

2f = -21.095

80

Final Solution to Example: Design a fourbar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion y O4

A1 P21 v

u x A2 B2

B1

G1 = W1 + V1 U1
O2
81

Final Solution to Example: Design a fourbar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion y O4

A1 P21 v

u x A2 B2

B1

O2
82

Final Solution to Example: Design a fourbar mechanism to give 2 positions shown in Fig. P3-1 of coupler motion y O4

u A1 P21 A2 v B2

B1 w

O2
83

Lockheed PV-1 Vega "Ventura" antisubmarine patrol bomber

84

You might also like