You are on page 1of 72

Welcome!

Safeguarding the Health of


America’s Children:
The Important Role of Nutrient-Rich Foods

Ann Marie Krautheim, MA, RD, LD


Senior Vice President, Nutrition Affairs, National Dairy Council
The Current Child Nutrition
Environment

IOM 2010 Dietary


Committees Guidelines

School
Lunch
Program

School
Breakfast WIC
Program
Program
Child Nutrition
Reauthorization
3
Kids: Overweight and
Undernourished

Fiber

Potassium Vitamin E
Nutrients of
Concern

Magnesium Calcium

Source: 2005 Dietary


Guidelines – Nutrients of
Concern for Children

4
The Need to Shift the
Dialogue

Nutrient-Rich Foods

5
Commitment to Child
Nutrition

• Decades of Research and Exciting In-


School Programs that:

– Encourage physical activity

– Reinforce dairy’s important role in child


health and wellness

– www.fueluptoplay60.com

6
The Role of Nutrient-Rich Foods
in the Diets of Children

Lynn L. Moore, DSc, MPH


Preventive Medicine & Epidemiology
Boston University School of Medicine
Primary Goals of Today’s Talk
• Explore healthy eating patterns in children and
adolescents
• Examine selected micronutrient needs among US
children and the potential contributions of nutrient-
rich foods to nutritional adequacy
• Examine effects of eating patterns on body fat in
children and adolescents

8
Adequacy of Food Group Intake as
Measured by 2005 Healthy Eating Index
9-13 yrs 5
14-18 yrs
4
Grains
Median HEI Score

3 Vegetables
Fruit

0
l

n
t

.
ta

ta

ta
ui

i
ra
le
To

To

To
Fr

G
n/
le

le
gr
ho

ho
e/
W

W
ng
ra
O

(NGHS)
9
Adequacy of Intake as Measured by 2005
Healthy Eating Index (part 2)
Meat Group
10

8 Dairy For last 2 factors, lower


scores reflect intakes
Median HEI Scores

that are too high


6

4 9-13 yrs
14-18 yrs
2

0
tal tal ils at
s
um
.O f i
To To t. d
ret S a S o
c
is
D

(NGHS)
10
Healthy Eating Pattern
(using lean beef consumption as a marker for a
healthier diet during adolescence)

11
Consumption of Lean and Non-Lean Beef
among Young Children
Girls
12
<80% lean
Girls - Mean Beef Consumption:
10
80-85% lean Preteens: 13 ounces/week
Teens: 11 ounces / week
8
>85% lean
OZ/wk

2
Boys - Mean Beef Consumption:
0 Preteens: 16 ounces/week
3-5 6-9 10-12
Age (yrs)
13-17
Teens: 22 ounces / week

12
Boys •After age 10, girls show a
10 decrease in their intake of fatty
8
beef
OZ/wk

4
•Boys show increases in beef of
2

0
all types, but especially in the
3-5 6-9
Age
10-12 13-17 intake of fatty beef
FCS

12
Eating Patterns Associated with Beef
Intake among Teens

• Most beef consumed is of a high-fat variety


• Beef consumption is not associated with intake of fruits,
vegetables, whole grains or dairy
• The apparent adverse effects of beef intake in many
epidemiologic studies may be a consequence of the overall
eating pattern rather than the beef itself
•Dietary messaging needs to focus on the incorporating
healthier eating patterns, not avoidance of selected foods
that are higher in energy or fat

13
Nutrient-Rich Foods
Dairy: milk, yogurt, cheese
(Ca, K, Mg, vit. D, phos, protein)

Fruit: melons, bananas, papaya, prunes,


oranges (Mg, K), fortified juices (Ca)
(fiber)
Vegetables: broccoli (vit. A), soy (Ca,
K), beets, mushrooms, potatoes (B6), green
leafy/spinach (vit. A, Mg, Ca), tomatoes(K,
Mg) (fiber)

14
Selected Minerals of Concern

Percent Meeting RDA


100
90
9-13 yrs
80
70
Percent

14-18 yrs
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Ca Mg K Phos Zn

* Data from 2300 girls in the National Growth and Health Study
15
Selected Vitamins of Concern

Percent Meeting RDA


100
90 9-13 yrs
80
70 14-18 yrs
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Vit A B6 B12 Vit C Vit D Vit E
* Data from 2300 girls in the National Growth and Health Study
16
Adolescent Protein Intake
Beef 16.9 % Meeting Protein RDA according to Weekly Beef
Intake
Poultry 13.5 100
Milk 7.5 80 Beef

Percent
Yeast bread 7.3 60 <6
6-<12
Cheese 6.5 40 12-<18
18-42
Fish etc 3.5 20
Pork 3.0
% Contribution to 0
Eggs 3.0 Total Protein Intake 9-13 yrs 14-18 yrs 19-20 yrs
Ham 2.4

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 % Meeting Protein RDA by Dairy Intake

100

• Beef & poultry are primary sources of 80

protein among adult Americans 60

Percent
<1.25
40
•Milk is #3 source, cheese is #5 1.25-<2.5
2.5-<6
20

• Adolescents consuming more beef or 0


9-11 12-13 14-15 16-18 19-20
dairy are more likely to meet protein DRI Age (yrs)

Food Data Source from: Cotton, PA. J Am Diet Assoc. 2004; 104:921-930 (Data from 1994-1996 CSFII) NGHS
17
Conceptualizing Obesity
Simple Obesity Complicated Obesity
• Excess weight for height • Excess central body fat

• High body mass index • Rates of central obesity


(BMI) rising faster than simple
obesity
• Not associated with other
abnormalities (e.g., BP, • Clusters with other risk
lipids, glucose) factors (lipids, BP,
glucose/insulin,
inflammatory markers)
• Rising rates for past few
decades
• Now recognize emerging
epidemic of complicated
obesity
18
Eating Patterns & Obesity
Can we identify eating patterns that are
associated with the acquisition of different
amounts of body fat during childhood?

19
New Data from NHANES III

Large, representative sample, cross-sectional


- Includes all ages but we looked at children & adolescents
- Dietary data based on single 24-hour recall

20
Adjusted Mean Intake of Dairy, Fruit & Vegetables
by Quartile of Central Body Fat
Adolescent Females Quartile 1
Quartile 2
Girls with most central body fat
Servings / day

4
Quartile 3

3
Quartile 4 consumed the least dairy

1 Quartile 1
Adolescent Males Quartile 2
0 4 Quartile 3
Quartile 4

Servings / day
Dairy Fruit Vegetables
3

2
Boys with most central body fat
consume less dairy and fewer 1

fruits & vegetables 0

Dairy Fruit Vegetables

Bradlee ML et al. IJPO 2009


21
Adjusted Mean Intake of Grains & Meats by
Quartile of Central Body Fat
Adolescent Females
10
Quartile 1
Girls with higher levels of body fat
Servings / day

8 Quartile 2 consumed less grains


Quartile 3
6
Quartile 4
4

2
Adolescent Males
0
Grains Meat/Protein 10 Quartile 1
Food Group Quartile 2
8 Quartile 3

Servings / day
Quartile 4
6

Boys consumed substantially more


4
grains & meats than girls
2

Boys with more central body fat 0


consumed few grains Grains Meat/Protein
Food Group

Bradlee ML et al. IJPO 2009


22
Food Intake among Adolescents
with/without Central Obesity
Intake in Major USDA Food Groups Milk & Fruit Subgroup Servings
8 1.4
<85th %ile
7 <85th %ile 1.2
Servings / day

≥ 85th %ile
6 ≥ 85th %ile 1.0
5 0.8
4 0.6
3 0.4
2 0.2
1 0.0
0 Milk Cheese Citrus, melon, Other fruit
berries
Dairy F&V Fruit Veg. Grains Meats

Vegetable Subgroups & Whole Grains Meats/Other Protein Subgroup Servings


2.5
2.0
<85th %ile
<85th %ile 2.0
1.6 ≥ 85th %ile
≥ 85th %ile
1.5
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.5
0.4
0.0
0.0 Red meat Processed Poultry, fish Eggs, nuts,
Dark grn, orange Potatoes, etc Other nonstarchy Whole Grains seeds, soy

Bradlee ML et al. IJPO 2009


23
Food Intake and Risk of Abdominal Obesity
in Adolescents
Food Ref
Group Group O.R. (95% CI) O.R. (95% CI)

Dairy <2/day 2-<3/day 3+/day

1.0 0.89 (0.60, 1.3) 0.48 (0.30, 0.76)

Fruit 0/day >0 - <2/day 2+/day

1.0 0.93 (0.66, 1.3) 0.74 (0.46, 1.2)

Veg. <3/day 3-<5/day 5+/day

1.0 0.67 (0.45, 1.0) 0.76 (0.50, 1.2)


(NHANES III)
24 Adjusted for age, gender, race, SES, height and TV hours/day
DASH Eating Pattern and BMI in
Adolescent Girls

28

26
BMI (kg/m )
2

24

22 DA<2.5 & FV<3 svgs/day


DA<2.5 & FV>=3 svgs/day
20 DA>=2.5 & FV<3 svgs/day
DA>=2.5 & FV>=3 svgs/day
18
9-10 11-12 13-14 15-16 17-18 19-20
Age (years)
NGHS

25 Adjusted for age, height, SES, race, activity, & TV watching


DASH & Waist Size in Adolescent Girls

80
Adolescent Girls
78
Waist Circumference (cm)

76

74

72

DA<2.5 & FV<3 svgs/day


70
DA<2.5 & FV>=3 svgs/day
68 DA>=2.5 & FV<3 svgs/day
DA>=2.5 & FV>=3 svgs/day
66
9-10 11-12 13-14 15-16 17-18 19-20

26 Adjusted for age, height, SES, race, activity, & TV watching


Summary – Nutrient Rich Foods for Children

• In general, most children and adolescents consume too


few whole grains (and too little fiber)
• They also consume too few fruits & vegetables,
particularly nutrient-rich vegetables
• Most children and adolescents consume too little dairy
• The intake of lean meat is generally low in children and
adolescents (predominant meat source is higher fat
ground beef)

27
Summary – Nutrient Rich Food Patterns

• Need to focus on entire eating patterns in children and


adolescents
• Fatty meat is often consumed as a part of less healthy
eating patterns: higher intakes of fatty meats are
consumed with more starchy vegetables and refined
grains and less dairy
• Dairy, when consumed with higher intakes of fruits &
vegetables is similar to a DASH eating pattern

28
Foods that are Part of a Healthy Dietary
Patterns among Children

• Higher intakes of dairy


• Consumption of fruits & vegetables, particularly dark
green, yellow-orange vegetables, tomatoes
• Higher intakes of lean meats plus other protein sources
such as eggs, nuts, seeds, soy
• Focus on consumption of whole grains

29
Consequences of such a Healthy Dietary
Pattern among Children and Adolescents

• Will be more likely to meet the DRI for nutrients such


as calcium, magnesium, potassium, phosphorus, vit. A
• Will have higher intakes of protein (particularly
complete proteins) and fiber
• Will gain less body fat, particularly central body fat
during childhood

30
Thank You!
Nutrition in Schools

Karen Rafferty, RD, LMNT


Senior Research Dietitian
Osteoporosis Research Center – Creighton University
Omaha, NE

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


New opportunity to improve
children’s milk consumption

Milk enhancements improve milk consumption and


increase meal participation in the
National School Lunch Program:
The School Milk Pilot Test

Journal of Child Nutrition and Management 2009; 34(fall)


Karen Rafferty, Diane Zipay, Camellia Patey, Jennifer Meyer

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


33
New opportunity to improve
children’s milk consumption

 The School Milk Pilot Test (SMPT) 2001-2002


School Nutrition Association (ASFSA)
National Dairy Council

 The Westside School Milk Pilot Study (W-SMPS) 2006


Westside Community Schools
Children’s Hospital
MeadowGold Dairy
American Dairy Association/Dairy Council of Nebraska
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
(Omaha, NE)

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


34
The School Milk Pilot Test

 Background

 Objectives and design

 Outcomes

 Projected impact

 Opportunities

 Conclusion
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
35
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

DGA Food Groups to Encourage

Low-fat and fat-free


Whole milk and milk products
Grains

Fruits
Vegetables

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


36
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

 Children age 2-8: 2 cups

 Individuals age 9+: 3 cups

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


37
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

Mean daily
intake of
selected
beverage
categories by
age groups

Rampersaud et al JADA 2003;103:97

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


38
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

Mean daily
intake of
selected
beverage
categories by
age groups

Rampersaud et al JADA 2003;103:97

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


39
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

20 oz.
sweetened
carbonated beverages

5 oz.
milk

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


40
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

Achieving nutrient adequacy


Studies show that diets
3 cups 1% milk
low in calcium and dairy
% of DRI (age 9-18)
foods tend to be low in
multiple nutrients. . . 69% Ca
. . . and that individuals 56% P
who obtain their calcium
from non-dairy sources fail 54% Pro
to meet the nutrient 25% K
profile of those who
consume dairy foods. 23% Mg
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
41
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

Percentage of school age children reporting usual


calcium intakes below the AI

100
90 Males
80 Females
70
Percentage

60
50
40
30
20
10
0
4–8 (800 mg) 9–13 (1300 mg) 14–18 (1300 mg)

What We Eat in American Age Group (AI)


NHANES 2005-2006

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


42
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

Percentage of school age children reporting usual


phosphorus intakes below the EAR

100 Males
90
Females
80
70
Percentage

60
50
40
30
20
10
0
4–8 (405 mg) 9–13 (1055 mg) 14–18 (1055 mg)

What We Eat in American Age Group (EAR)


NHANES 2005-2006

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


43
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

Percentage of school age children reporting usual


magnesium intakes below the EAR

100 Males
90
Females
80
70
Percentage

60
50
40
30
20
10
0
4–8 (110 mg) 9–13 (200 mg) 14–18 (340/300
mg)
What We Eat in American
NHANES 2005-2006
Age Group (EAR)

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


44
Need for new innovations for
children’s milk consumption

National survey of student beverage preferences –


reported reasons for not drinking milk at school
 Availability of competitive beverages

 Poor temperature control (milk served warm)

 Limited milk varieties/flavors available

 Inferior product quality

 Unattractive/juvenile packaging (paper-board cartons)

 Milk containers hard to open/drink from

Nicklas TA. JACN 2003; 22:340-356

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


45
The School Milk Pilot Test

A school based strategy designed to measure the effect of a


variety of milk enhancements on:
 Overall participation in the reimbursable school meal
programs
 Milk sales
 Milk consumption

To project the impact of national implementation on:


 Diet quality
 Student health and wellness

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


46
The School Milk Pilot Test

Test Markets:

SMPT
 Nine test markets in the Northeast, Southeast,
Mountain and West Coast regions
 Over 100,000 students from 146 schools
(99 secondary, 47 elementary)

W-SMPT
 Midwestern, urban school district
 4 elementary schools

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


47
The School Milk Pilot Test

Milk Enhancements tested:

Promotional milk marketing activities


Milk packaged in plastic resealable bottles (PRB)
Coolers to maintain chilled milk at 35-37º
3 milk flavors offered (plain, chocolate, + one)
Chocolate milk upgraded to retail quality
8 oz milk (PRB) offered on meal line
10 oz milk (PBR) offered on meal line
10 and 16 oz milk (PBR) available a la carte
16 oz milk (PBR) available in vending machines

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


48
The School Milk Pilot Test

Change in School Lunch ADP


Test vs. Control

8%

6% + 4.8%

4%

+ 1.5% + 480,000
2%

0%
Elementary School Seconday School
(NS) (p < 0.05)

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


49
The School Milk Pilot Test

Impact of increased participation in the NSLP on


NUTRIENT DENSITY:
 Protein
NSLP participants  Vitamin A
consume more  Vitamin B12
nutrients at lunch  Riboflavin
 Calcium
than nonparticipants.  Phosphorus
 Potassium

Gordon A and Fox MK, 2007


School Nutrition Dietary Assessment Study–III:
USDA Food and Nutrition Service

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


50
The School Milk Pilot Test

Impact of increased participation in the NSLP on


DIET QUALITY:

NSLP participants were more likely to have


adequate usual daily intakes of key nutrients. . .

. . . and were less likely than non-participants


to consume competitive foods in school.

Gordon A and Fox MK, 2007


School Nutrition Dietary Assessment Study–III:
USDA Food and Nutrition Service

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


51
The School Milk Pilot Test

Change in Milk Sales


Test vs. Control

30%
+ 22%
25%
+ 15%
20%
15%
10%
+ 9%
5% W-SMPS

0%
Elementary Schools Seconday Schools
(p < 0.05) (p < 0.05)

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


52
The School Milk Pilot Test

Change in Milk Consumption per serving unit sold


Test vs. Control

30% + 26%

25%
+ 18%
20%

15%

10% + 13%
W-SMPS

5%

0%
Elementary Schools Seconday Schools
(p < 0.05) (p < 0.05)

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


53
The School Milk Pilot Test

Change in Milk Consumption per 100 in attendance


Test vs. Control

45% + 39%
40%
+ 35%
35%
30%
25%
20%
+ 21%
15% W-SMPS
10%
5%
0%
Elementary Schools Seconday Schools
(p < 0.05) (p < 0.05)

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


54
Flavored milk opportunities

Over 90% is
low-fat and
fat-free

Annual School Milk Survey, 2009


Milk Pep, SNA, NDC

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


55
Flavored milk opportunities

Impact of FLAVORED milk consumption on nutrient


density:
1% 1%
Per 8 oz serving: Plain Chocolate Soda Fruit
Milk Milk Drink
Calcium (mg) 290 290 0 0
Vitamin D (IU) 130 130 0 0
Vitamin A (IU) 480 490 0 0
Potassium (mg) 366 425 0 25
Protein (g) 8 8 0 0
Fat (g) 2.5 2.5 0 0
Sugar (g) includes lactose 12 24 27
68 29
73
Added Sugar (g) 0 12 68
27 73
29
USDA Nutrient Database for Standard Reference
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
56
Flavored milk opportunities

RCT, secondary analysis Nutrient Densities


Calcium intervention Calcium (mg)
n = 149 adolescent girls Phosphorus (mg)
Age 14-16 yr
Potassium (mg)
36 months
Vitamin D (IU) Low-Fat Chocolate Milk
High Calcium intake
Magnesium (mg) Calcium-Fortified Composite
 1494 mg Ca
Dairy foods Sodium (mg)

 1014 mg Ca Energy

Calcium-fortified foods 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450
 304 mg Ca
Protein (g)
 Orange juice
Carbohydrate (g)
 RTE breakfast cereal
 Snack bars Sugars added (g)

 Breads Total Fat (g)

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Rafferty, unpublished data 2009
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
57
Flavored milk opportunities

Impact of FLAVORED milk consumption on diet quality


and health outcomes:

 drink more milk and get more calcium

 do not have higher intakes of added sugars or


total fat

 not associated with adverse effects on BMI

Murphy et al, JADA 2008; 108:631


1999-2002 National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys
7,557 children and adolescents aged 2 to 18 years

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


58
Flavored milk opportunities

Impact of FLAVORED milk consumption on diet quality


and health outcomes:
 participate in school lunch more often
Annual School Milk Assessment, 2005-06.
Milk Processor Education Program and SNA

 drink less soda and fruit drinks


The Bogalusa Heart Study
Ranganathan et al, JADA 2005;105:1391

 sweetened beverage intake at age 5, but


not flavored milk intake … was positively
associated with adiposity from age 5-15.
Fiorito et al, AJCN 2009;90:935

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


59
Flavored milk opportunities

“…small amounts of sugars added to


nutrient dense foods, such as reduced-fat
milk products, may increase a person’s
intake of such foods by enhancing the Dietary Guidelines for Americans
appeal of these products, thus improving
nutrient intake without contributing
excessive calories.” “When sugars are added to
otherwise nutrient-rich foods,
such as dairy products, the
American Heart Association quality of children’s and
adolescents’ diets improves.”

“… replacing sweetened drinks in


school vending machines with 100% The American Academy of Pediatrics
fruit juices, water, and lowfat plain or
flavored milk.”
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
60
Implementing milk enhancements

Impact of milk consumption on HEALTH & WELLNESS:


 Development and maintenance of a strong skeleton
 Improved bone strength at all stages of life
 Reduced incidence of fractures
 Maintenance of bone and muscle as a recovery
beverage
 Not associated with increased weight, BMI, or obesity
Moore et al, J Pediatr 2008;153:667
Goulding et al, JADA 2004;104:250
Thorpe et al, J Nutr 2008;138:1096
Fiorito et al, AJCN 2009;90:935
Murphy et al, JADA 2008;108:631

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


61
Implementing milk enhancements

Over 10,700 schools have implemented the


piloted milk enhancements now known collectively
as the New Look of School Milk.

Annual School Milk Survey, 2009


Milk Pep, SNA, NDC
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
62
Implementing milk enhancements

Schools using PRB for 8 oz. milk

Annual School Milk Survey, 2009


Milk Pep, SNA, NDC
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
63
Conclusions

1. School children drink more milk when it is offered


well chilled
in plastic re-sealable bottles
in a variety of sizes and flavors
at diverse points of sale within school
2. Increases were measured in
average daily participation in the NSLP
volume of milk sold
quantity of milk consumed
3. Implementing similar milk enhancements in schools
nation-wide could be projected to
improve the nutritional intake
diet quality
health & wellness
Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center
64
Solutions for schools
and beyond

1. Improve opportunities for school children to enjoy


cold milk in plastic re-sealable bottles, in low-fat
flavors that appeal

2. Use Nutrient Density as the basis for dietary


recommendations and the foundation for School
Wellness nutrition policies

3. Educate the public, parents, and children with the


positive approach that emphasizes total nutrient
content of Food Groups to Encourage

Creighton University Osteoporosis Research Center


65
NDC’s Commitment to Child
Nutrition
Commitment to Child Nutrition

• NDC’s Long History of Commitment to Child Health

• Child Nutrition Health Education Kit


– Child Nutrition white paper
– Fact sheets on lactose-free milk, cheese and
flavored milk
– More

• Fuel Up to Play 60 Program


– ENGAGE youth to invest in their own health by
arming them with nutrition and physical activity
know-how
– INVITE collaboration between youth and adult
mentors to build a customized plan
– Help them ACTIVATE their program with
supporting materials and grants
67
Commitment to Child Nutrition

Get Up & Play Fuel Up


60 Minutes/Day Nutrient Rich Foods
68
Commitment to Child Nutrition

• Continuing to emphasize the consumption of nutrient-rich


foods in child nutrition programs helps to ensure overall diet
quality consistent with the Dietary Guidelines.

• NDC Resources:
o www.nationaldairycouncil.org
o www.thedairyreport.com
o www.fueluptoplay60.com

69
Questions?
A Few Quick Reminders…
• CPEU

• Survey

• Slides posted on The Dairy Report


Thank you!

You might also like