TO: Nesta R. Marley, Executive Vice President Greasyburger Corp.
FROM: David Phelps and Kianna Weaver, Labor Research Analysts DATE: February 5, 2014 SUBJECT: Negative Effects of Minimum Wage Increase
Labor research and analysis has shown that raising the minimum wage would have a negative effect at every level.
The Worker
Studies have shown that raising the minimum wage would have little to no effect on reducing poverty (Burkhauser). A reduction in the amount of low-skilled, low-wage, jobs would leave many current minimum wage earners unemployed (A Confusion of Economists). Prospective workers that cannot find a job at minimum wage are not allowed to work for less money (Samuelson). May reduce the perks, benefits, vacation, and overall job training of current employees (Neumark, Wascher). 20.9 percent of minimum wage workers who lived in poor families only received 16.8 percent of the benefits (Burkhauser). Workers willing to receive a cut in pay in order to learn a valuable trade or skill will not be allowed the opportunity (Williams). Sustained lack of unemployment for low-skilled workers has often resulted in an increased propensity for criminal behavior. Roughly 60% of those considered living in poverty dont work and are not looking for work (Why Raising the Minimum Wage Kills Jobs).
The Employer
The increase in labor costs would be partially displaced to consumers, affecting bottom line sales. (Burkhauser) Businesses would have to scale back on their personnel, be more selective of their hiring, and renew focus on efficiency and cutbacks (Neumark, Wascher). As employers seek to be more efficient another wave of job extinction such as that which eliminated movie ushers, gas station attendants, fast food help, and variety of other minimum wage jobs will occur (Williams). Workforce discontentment due to scaling back of benefits would lead to low productivity (Burkhauser). Small businesses could no longer afford to continue operating (Burkhauser). All efforts at expansion would be severely hindered due to a lack of previously available funding.
The Government
The loss of low-wage jobs will force potential productive members of society to rely on government aide. This influx of new claimants will cause scale-backs on other much needed programs (Neumark, Adams). Government job training programs that teach basic skills become useless because employers will hire less low-skilled workers (Neumark, Adams). Forceful redistribution of wealth has never worked. A dramatic increase in the unemployed resulting from an increased minimum wage could lead the country into a recession (Neumark, Adams).
Discussion
But, arent we being greedy as a corporation by not sharing our increasing wealth directly with our workers?
FALSE. By using our increased wealth to expand the breadth of our business, we are creating new jobs, which is much more beneficial to the working class as a whole.
Doesnt increasing the amount that consumers can spend on our products help improve the economy as a whole thus improving our bottom line earnings?
FALSE. Minimum wage hikes have immediately preceded large spikes in unemployment and recession as shown in the graph in attachment 2. It is also a leading indicator of corporate bankruptcies.
Conclusion
Our recommendation is that you take immediate action to help safeguard against items directly pertaining to Greasyburger Corp. i.e. the items listed under The Employer. Of secondary concern is a plan of action against the remaining intermediate concerns that will have an indirect or unforseen effect on your bottom line earnings.
Sincerely,
David Phelps Labor Research Analyst
Kianna Weaver Labor Research Analyst
Attachments (3): Works Cited; 4-Week Moving Average of Initial Claims; Federal Minimum Wage Rates.
Black dots representing minimum wage increases from attachment 3. Increases occur primarily before a spike in unemployment and are indicative of a possible forthcoming recession.
Attachment 1 Works Cited
Adams, Scott and Neumark David, Do Living Wage Ordinances Reduce Urban Poverty? NBER Working Paper no. 7606, National Beureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Mass., (2000)
Burkhauser, Richard V., Written testimony before the Committee on Education and the Workforce, U.S. House of Representatives, 106 th Congress, April 27, 1999.
Burkhauser, Richard V., Couch, Kenneth A., and Glenn, Andrew J. Public Policies for the Working Poor: The Earned Income Tax Credit Versus Minimum Wage Legislation, Research in Labor Economics 15 (1996): 65-109
Burkhauser, Richard V., Couch, Kenneth A., and Wittenburg, David C. Who Gets What from Minimum Wage Hikes A Re-estimation of Card and Kruegers Distributional Analysis in Myth and Measurement: The New Economics of the Minimum Wage, Industrial and Labor Relations Review 49(1996)
Neumark , David, How Living Wages Affect Low-Wage Workers and Low Income Families(San Francisco: Public Policy Institute of California, 2002)
Samuelson, Paul. Economics, 9 th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1973.pp.393-394
Williams, Walter. Government Sanctioned Restraints that Reduce Economic Opportunities for Minorities. Policy Review, No. 2 (I 977). p. 11, (Quoted in Poverty and Wealth: The Christian Debate Over Capitalism, by Ronald H. Nash. [Westchester. Illinois: Crossway Books, 1986], p, 122.)