Professional Documents
Culture Documents
KE
&/EE/>DE'DEd
/EdZEd/KE>&/EE
/t/&/E>
'ZKhW///
WWZ
Published :
Directorate of Studies
The Institute of Cost and Works Accountants of India
12, Sudder Street, Kolkata-700 016
Printed at :
Repro India Limited
50/2, T.T.C. MIDC Industrial Area, Mahape, Navi Mumbai - 400 710.
KDWE/hD
KE
&/EE/>DE'DEd/EdZEd/KE>&/EE
&/E>
'ZKhW///
WWZ
/Ey
^
,WdZED
WE
E
WW/
^&
&^
tD
d & W
W
^
>
>
/&
&D/&
WZK:dW>EE/E'/Es^dDEdE>z^/^
Y
> d
`/d
d
> d
d
&
>
t
&
z
>
Loan amount
2,53,930
= `
= ` 65,785
Annuity factor of 15%
3.86
E
^
z
K
W
/
d
Z
/
`
E
&D/&
^K
/
d
d
E
Ws
`
W
`
Cost of assets
2,53,930
= `
= ` 60,894
Annuity factors of 10%
4.17
^>
>
dWs
`
d
Ws
W
d `
` d
>y
d
W
``
d`
&D/&
Y
E'>DZ`d
d
``
&`
E ' > D ^
`d
`
dDZ`
`
DZD^E'>
dWs
z
Ws&
tDZ
^
ZDZ
/
D^
>^D Z
>
`
E
/D^
D ^
D Z
E
`
&D/&
W `
`
EWsD^```
` D Z
^ED^
/
E
/DZD^
DZ
D^
h
^`
^
>K
>&
W
EWs
EWsD^DZ
D^
ED
Y
>`d
` & ` >
/
d W D
d&D
`d`
` d sW
&D/&
EWs`
z
&
d
d d
d
Z
z
&
K
^//
z
/
/
<
`
`
`
`
`
/
/&
/Wd
d
/Wd
Wd
d
^/
>
/
y
y
&D/&
^d
/d
y
^d
dyy
^
EWs^^
yy
yy
yy
y
Ky
Ky`
/Wd
d
/Wd
Wd
d
EWs
/
/Wd
D
&D/&
^
^
>s
>&
W
d
WWd
^dWs
&
`
&Z
ds'd&``
d
>y
d`
Ey
X-5
lakhs
5
t
X-5
3.35
5
d
E
X-5
3.35 0.4 = ` 0.268 X - ` 1.34
5
d
E/E
sW&EWs`
,yy
yy
y
X=
14.64
= ` 20.00 lakhs d`
0.732
&D/&
Wd
>
W
>d
W
W
&
W&
EWs/
'
,
Z
d,/``
EWsdD
Y
^
>`d
`/
`/
`
/
`
^
d
'`
``
D^
d
`
W
``
` 95,000
3.791
Z`
d
&D/&
d
`
W
W
>^W
` 4,40,000
6.145
d`
Z`
d
^`
`d
^^
d
W
`
`
Z`
d
4,74,100
3.791
,`
d
W
W
>^
d`
Z`
E`
d
7,19,598
6.145
,`
`
^`
`d
&D/&
Y
/
d
`d
/
``
d
^
s
^
Z
^
K
&`
`
&
`
/^>
Z
`
,Z`
^`
Z`
s
`
`
,Z`
^`
21,17,500
36,57,500
19,50,000
17,07,500
Z`
>&
&D/&
/^D
Z
`
,Z`
^`
Z`
s
`
`
,Z`
^`
Z`
>&
W
d``17,07,500 ,
`120 per day to
Y
&y>
WD
`
h
/ZZ
W/W/
EWs
W
^
&
&D/&
^ > ` d
W
W/
`
t
WD
/ZZ/
'
`
h
/ZZ
E
ddWD`
`
,
WWD
` 11,42,000
4,00,000
`
/W//W/
d
Or 1.064 =
``,`
&D/&
^`,
= `
12,15,088
4,00,000
,
E
EWsd
``
`
^W/
W
W/
Z
W/^>
,
d EWs
^EWs
W
W/
`
EWs
W`
`
&D/&
dW/
EWs``
, EWs ` EWs
&
d^>
Y
y z W y `
W z ` z
Wy
EWs
W
Wz
EWs
W
`
`
Wyz
^
t
E`
W
`
d
Z
W
D
&D/&
Wy
EWs W
EWs
W
EWs
`
^
^
W
`
`
`
`
EWs
Wz
EWs W
EWs
W
EWs`
^
^
W
`
`
`
`
EWs
dWyz`
14,40,000,0 00
`
/Wz^
` 19,80,000,000
`
&D/&
Standard deviation
Expected net present value
/Wy
37,947
= 0.42
90,000
/Wz
44,497
= 0.4944 or 0.50
90,000
Wz
W
/WyW/
90,000 + 3,00,000
= 1.30
3,00,000
/WzW/
^
Z
W E
Ws
E
`
`
`
`
`
Question 8
C developed original specification of a product and founded C Manufacturing Ltd. In 2009 the firm
manufactured 980 Nos. at an average price of ` 900 each. In 2010 due to continuous price rise of the
inputs, he raised his prices at an average of 12%, since he knew he could sell his plants full capacity of
980 Nos. per year. In spite of price rise for the product, which sold for over ` 1,000 for the first time,
C was surprised to learn in late 2010 (as may be seen from the financial statements) that C
Manufacturing Ltd. show a decline in earnings and still worse, decline in cash flow.
&D/&
,
t&/&K
t`
`
/>/&Kd`
^
K
Z
>
D>
/^`
'
/d
/
/
W
E
/
Z
t>/&K
/
&D/&
Z
K
W
>>/&K
>
`
,
955
746
/
//d
,
`
9,00,000
1.28 = 1,175.50
980
``
d`E`
dE`
,E`
//d
`
974.50
= ` 1146.50
0.85
d`E`E&
&D/&
Y
A large profit making company is considering the installation of a machine to process the waste
produced by one of its existing manufacturing process to be converted into a marketable product. At
present, the waste is removed by a contractor for disposal on payment by the company of ` 50 lakhs
per annum for the next four years. The contract can be terminated upon installation of the aforesaid
machine on payment of a compensation of ` 30 lakhs before the processing operation starts. This
compensation is not allowed as deduction for tax purposes.
d`
d
`
`
^
z
`
^
D
t
K
&
/ `
d
` d
`>
`
` &
`
d
W
z
W
&D/&
^/W
`
z
^
D
t
K
&/
>
/
d
/
d
^/&
`
z
D
d
/
d
>
W
d
W
E
Es```
^ `
E
D
&D/&
/
^ E d
^
Y
>
Ey
zd
y
z
`
Z`
s
`
W
W`
`
z
^`
`
t
^`y`z `
d /
`
d `
z
W
Z h EWs
d'D>
Wyz``
d
d
&D/&
d
z
Wy
`
Wz
`
WZ
Z
t
/
D
>
^
^`
^
y
z
>
s
D
^
d
W
>d
W
D
^
y
z
&D/&
EWs
z
D
>W
E
Ws
`
`
y
Ws
`
`
z
Ws
`
Z
d D z d
z
,
P.I. =
Machine Z =
1,27,490
= 1.159
1,10,000
Machine X =
1,98,057
= 1.10
1,80,000
Machine Y =
2,40,093
= 1.20
2,00,000
^z
z
z
^EWsWy
`
>/
E
`
W
d
`
3,21,680
&D/&
^EWsWz
z
`
>/
E
d
`
W
`
^zz
^ y z
yzd
y
Y
`d
/
`
` d //
d/
d//
`
`
`
`
W
`
`
`
`
W
d
Z
(i) Construct a decision tree for the proposed investment project.
(ii) What net present value will the project yield if worst outcome is realized?
probability of occurrence of this NPV?
(iii) What will be the best and the probability of that occurrence?
(iv) Will the project be accepted?
What is the
EWs
/
&D/&
(i)
d
d12%
W
E
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
47,717
40,000
6,717
`
`
&D/&
^EWs
W
E
Z
:
Z
E
2,045.40
(ii) If the worst outcome is realized the Net present value which the project will yield is
` 8,111 (negative). The probability of occurrence of this Net present value is 8%.
(iii) The best outcome will be path 6 when Net present value is higher i.e. ` 10,703 (positive).
The probability of occurrence of this Net present value is 6%.
(iv) Yes, the project will be accepted since the Expected Net present value probability sum
total is positive.
(b) In most of the situations the Net present value method (NPV) and Profitability Index (PI) yield
same accept or reject decision. In general terms, under PI method a project is acceptable if
profitability index value is greater than 1 and rejected if it is less than 1. Under NPV method a
project is acceptable if Net present value of a project is positive and rejected if it is negative.
Clearly a project offering a profitability index greater than 1 must also offer a net present value
which is positive. But a conflict may arise between two methods if a choice between mutually
exclusive projects has to be made. Consider the following example:
W
W
Ws
/
E
2,00,000
=2
1,00,000
1,00,000
= 2.5
40,000
W/
EWs
dE
t
W/EWsEWs
&D/&
Y
yd
D`
/ ` D
``d
d /
Kty
z
` ``
`d
`
`
z
/ d
^
D
W`
>
Z`
W`
`
y
^
W`
`
&D/&
>
W
>^
EWs
`
` 1,22,152
2.4019
/
^
W`
>
W
>^
EWs
`
` 1,12,152
2.4019
/
`
1,12,152
^
` z
z
Y
^`d
d
`d
d
d`
d
&D/&
`
d
Z
/`
/
`
W
^`
d
`
100
>
s
,
` 276 lakhs
12,000 students
= ` 2,300
K``
^
d`
`
'
707.00
>s`
&``
&D/&
^dh
s`
&`` 50 lakhs
d
>
,
` 513.60 lakhs
12,000 students
Y
Ktd
t
&
dD
W WsK/
&K
D
K ,
d
&D/&
d
h
^W
W
WsK
D
WsK
D
&K
Z
^Ws K
than the cost of not drilling 5 millions of dollars. Therefore, Big Oil should drill upto 6,000 feet.
^W
W
WsK
D
WsK
D
&K
Z
^ Ws K
dK
^W
W
WsK
D
WsK
D
&K
Z
E/>
^ Ws K
K
&D/&
tE
>
t
WWW
t W W
W
W
W
W
,W
P (x y) 0.4
=
= 0.8
0.5
P (x)
d
tW W
tW
W W W
W
W
P (x y z)
0.3
0.3
=
=
= 0.75
P (x) P (y/x) 0.5 0.8 0.4
d
Y
d&/
&
d d
d
d
d ` d
&D/&
`
`
/
`
d
^
K
`
`
,
K
z
^^
t
^d&
^&^
^
/
/
`
`
`
Z
5,50,000
6,58,950
Costs
Materials (i)
(Refer to working note 3)
Cutting (ii)
62,500
1,01,700
1,25,000
1,73,730
7,37,500
9,34,380
2,62,500
3,76,800
Others (iii)
Since, the company can earn an additional profit of ` 1,14,300 (` 3,76,800 ` 2,62,500) if matching
d
&D/&
tE
^
`
`
`
`
D
`
`
&``
5,50,500
`
``
6,58,950
``
`
1,01,700
K
`
`
`
`
`
E
Z
W
d
d&
&D/&
Y
>
`
^`
`dW
d
, / `
d
&/
ts d
W/ZZ/ZZ/W/ZZ
/ZZ
W/ZZ
CFi
W/ZZ CO0 =
(1+ r)n
t
K
&E
E>
ZZ/ZZ
E
K`
&`
Z
d
`
400 crore =
80 crores
(1 + r)15
d/ZZ
/ZZ
d
` 400 crores
&Ws&
` 80 crores
d /ZZ
&D/&
d/ZZ
`Ws&
`
`
`Ws&
`
`
d/ZZ
/ZZ
d/ZZ
7.36 crores
1%
` 17.28 crores
tE
E
`
d
d
`
`
E
E^d
&D/&
/ZZ
/ZZ
t
/ZZ
>
,`
`
Z
d
`
28.69 crores
(1 + r)15
d/ZZ
/ZZ
d
` 100 crores
3.484
&Ws&
` 28.69 crores
d/ZZ
`
Z
E
,``
E
`
Z
`
Z
`
&D/&
W/ZZ/ZZ
d/ZZ/ZZdyz>
d
/ZZ d
`
`
3 .4 %
` 300 crores
` 100 crores
= 10.2% is added to the project IRR which gives equity IRR of 28% .
Y
W`s`
`>``
Rising costs have cut sharply into net income for DD for the last 2 years This year management again
d
`
Z
,
/
^
/
ZW
40
&D/&
`
>sZ
30
E
d
>Z
W
W
E
>s
&
E
`
` 4,16,00,00 0
40
= 10,40,000 rides
Fixed costs
Contribuit on per ride
At old price =
3,52,00,00 0
40 - ` 10
At new price =
3,52,00,000
` 50 - ` 10
&D/&
`
>s
E
d
>&
:
^``
`
WW
w orking Note
s
`
`
`
`
&
`
Y
d `
`d
d
Z
t
company assets = equity
V
VE
+ B debt D
V0
V0
/
VE
V0
E^
s`
s`
s`
&D/&
80 lakhs
` 140 lakhs
`
Z
tZ
d
/
,
d
Y
y>
/``
`
t`d
z
` &
K ` /
z
`
d
`
t
&D/&
/
z
`
`
`
`
`
&
W
d
E
W
/
^
Ws/&
z
/&
Ws&
`
`
t
^s
WsK&
/`
Ws
EWs
ZEWs
&D/&
Y
^
` d
`
z
z
z
&d
W
&d
W
&d
W
d
d
dEWs
d
^
EWs
z/
z//
&d
W
&W
&d
W
&W
x or CF
`
z///
&d
W
&W
x or CF
EWs
x or CF
Ws
Ws
>
EWs
dWs
&D/&
W
z/
y X
y X
y X
W
y X W
1 = 85.4
z//
W
y X
y X
y X
y X W
2 = 98.61 = 9.930
z///
y X
y X
y X
W
y X W
3 = 74.29 = 8.619
^
85.4
(1.08)
98.61
(1.08)
74.29
(1.08)6
= 13.8749
&D/&
^
/
/
Y
:>^
d
d`
d
`
`d
`
Ws
`
z
>Z
Ws/&
dWs
/d
/d
K
`Ws/&
&D/&
d^
z
>
/
K
/
K
E
K
Ws/&
dWs
dWs
>Ws^d
```
^tE
d
Ws
tE
/W
z
>
/
>
/
W
E
&D/&
z
s
W>
>&
>Z
>
d
>d
d
&d
Ws
Ws
dWs
d^
dWs
D
EWs
>,
&D/&
Y
/
` h
^
&
W
`
W
W
'
E
t
d
Wyz
W
EWs
^
`
y
z
t
t
W
EE&
24,00,00,00,000
EWs
EWs
W
E&
&D/&
6,00,00,00,000
EWs
EWs
Z
EWs
KyW
z
s
75,000
SD
ENPV
1,06,000
s
1,35,000
2,40,000
K s s W y z
,EWsEWs
Y
> d
``
t
d
^
`
Z`
&D/&
8,00,000
2,00,000
W
Ws
d/ZZ
Et
Ws
/
/ZZ 18% +
4.0776 - 4.000
= 18.63%
4.0776 - 3.9544
/ZZ
>Z
,,
3.837
, %
Z
WsydWs^s/
y
d
>
d
>
&d
Wd
Co - PV of SV
CFAT
8,00,000 - 23,300
2,02,424
&D/&
Y
d d D >
W D E ` ` d
d
d
WD
WE
z
&`
&`
WZ
0.8163 respectively. Which of the project should be accepted?
^^EWsWD
z
&
`
`
W
dW
`
>//
EWs
^^EWsWE
z &
W
dW
`
`
`
>//
EWs
^ W E E
&D/&
Y
d `
`
` d
z
D
^
`
`
W
dt
EWZ
Z
`
Ws ` `
>Ws
`
`
/z
//z
///z
/sz
W
Ws
`
`
`
`
sW
Ws
D
d
>Ws
Ws
E
d
`
&D/&
Y
`d
/
`
` d
d
`
`
d
W
W
`
`
`
`
`
`
d
Z
EWs
tt
EWs
t
t
E
d
EWs
Path No.
50,000
Joint probability
Year 1 x year 2
24,000
.08
32,000
0.12
44,000
0.20
40,000
0.24
0.30
0.06
1.00
CASH
OUTLAY
80,000
60,000
50,000
60,000
dEWsEWs
W
z&`
z&
d/ Cash Outflows NPV
`
Ws`
`
`
^EWs
:W
EWs`
EWs
/EWs`d
EWs`
d EWs ` d
EWs`
dEWs`
Y
z
/
d`
d`
d
`>
&D/&
d`
&Z
z
`
`
`d
z
Z
z
W`
/`
d ^>D
dt
EdWs
z
tE
(a)
K
EWs
EWs
/W
W
/W
W
/
d
d
/
d
z
`
z
`
z
`
&D/&
E
Ws
Ws
dWs
>Ws`
EWs
//>
W
>
z
z
z
`
`
`
>
dW
>d
E
Ws
dWs
Z
^ W s Ws /
Y
&
`d
&&d
&&
Z
>
`
>W
&D/&
d^
100 .35
1
(1.12)
100 .35
1
(1.12) 2
100 .35
1
(1.12)3
/
z
W
Ws
3 66.6460 lakhs
= 199.938
2 66.6460 lakhs
= 133.292
1 66.6460 lakhs
= 66.6460
Question 29
ABC Ltd. is considering a proposal to acquire a machine costing ` 1,10,000 payable ` 10,000 down and
balance payable in 10 annual equal instalments at the end of each year inclusive of interest chargeable at
15%. Another option before it is to acquire the asset on a lease rental of ` 15,000 per annum payable at
the end of each year for 10 years. The following information is also available.
d^`
d
/
z
K/d
/``
d
` Ws&
``
&D/&
d
z
/
/
Z
`
`
`
`
` ` `
d^
E&
Ws&
Ws
`
`
`
`
`
z
/
/
`
W
^
E
E/`d
&D/&
`d
`
` d
K//>K
/`
d `
dWs& ^
`
W``
/`
` ,
/ ` ``
dE>
Y
z
`
dd
d^
/d
/
d
z
E
/
Z
Ws&
Ws
d
>
EWs
&D/&
EWs
Z
z
E
Ws&
Ws
>
E
0.8929
0.7972
0.7117
= 0.8504,
= 0.7231,
= 0.6148
1.05
1.1025
1.1576
EWs
&D/&
^KhZ^K&&/EE/E'
Y
d^> >
d``
d
K
K
s
`
h^`
/
h^
W
Z
/ &
K
h^`
&
h^`
`
d/tz
ts
d ^ ^ &
Z
h
d
z
&
K/
`
z
Z
W
/
K
d
EK
dK
&D/&
K//
z Z / K
Z
d Z
K
/
d
d
E
W ^ K
W
h^
`
^
d / /
dW
`
K
s
W
d
E
z
d
ts
dW
`
d
d
dd
z
&D/&
&K/
`
z
E
512.25
K//
`
'
d
E
z
490.389
Y
y >
`
^
>&/
Z/
d
d
t
&D/&
`
Z`
>/
/
d
/
W
Z
&
Y
d
`
E
>/
>/
W
E`
D
`
d`d
`d
z
z
&D/&
tE
W
`
W
>d
W
E
E.P.S. =
` 10,96,875
1,00,000
W^`
D`
Hence, P/E =
` 109.70
` 10.97
= 10
W
W
`
>
Z
`
W`
`
` `
` 20 lakhs 100
` 42 lakhs
` 18 lakhs 100
` 32 lakhs
= 56.25%
= 47.6% W
/`
`
`
>/`
/`
Z`
&D/&
W
>d
W
E
E.P.S. =
` 13,21,125
` 1,00,000
= ` 13.21
W`
Z
`
W
/ ` d
``,
``
/`
`
W
>/
W
>d
W
E
` 14,38,125
E.P.S. =
= ` 13.07
1,10,000
W`
Z
`
d
&D/&
Y
d^D^>
`
`
`
`
Z
^
h
d
K
Z
&
^
d
`d
``
ZDD
DDD
E
d ` ` `
`
E
/
d ^
&D/&
z
,
>
`
`
z
D^>
`
d
EW`
>/
W
>W`
W
E
`
E`
ZtE
`
EW`
>/
W
>W`
W
E
ZtE
`
&D/&
WD^>
`
`
Z
W
:K
d
W^W``
d
`Zd
W^/d
,
``
d `
`
d ^ > Z
/
E
ZtE
`
>/`
EW
>/
E
>W
W
&D/&
E
` 70.32
:
d
W^W``
dW^`
d^>Z
d
^ K
d
tE
`
W
E
&
&
`
E
`
`
`
Z
E
&D/&
`
&
>W
^
h
d
K
E
W
=
=
` 20 lakhs
` 37.50 lakhs
=
Secured loans
Share Capital + Reserves and surplus
Y
d D ` d
` t
/
```
d`
` ` d
` ` `
` d t
&D/&
/
//
///
d`
d`
d`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
(15% on ` 7,50,000)
`
W
>/
`
>d
1,90,000
1,45,000
1,05,000
E
Z
d//
` ` d
tE
D
E
/
//
///
`
`
`
`
`
`
&D/&
Y
d^>
`
`
W^`
d``
d
/
`
d``
,``
^
W
Z
W
t
t
t
Z
^
W
Z
W
>
Z
&D/&
tE
<
Ke =
10
+ 0.06
110
Z<
Revised K e =
12
+ 0.06
105
Y
,
> ` `
&
Kd`
Zd`
E``d
,
/`
` /d d
firm estimates even higher sales and profits in future years.
d
`
d`
,
`d
,`
`
,
d `
/`
,
/
Z
Z
&D/&
^`E`
E`d
d`
>
,``
``
Z`
625
lakhs 100 = 28.41%
2,200
W
^`K`/`
Z
Operating income
180
100 = `
lakhs 100 = 20%
investment
900
>D
W
Or K e =
` 900 lakhs
i.e. 18 lakhs
` 50
15
= 3%, pre - tax cost = 7.5%
5
Div.
P0
t
W
W
<
Ke =
1.50
50
&D/&
W
^
`
`
`
>/`
`
`
W
>d
W
W
E
D
``
` 700 + ` 900
``
` 700
^
` 2,200 + ` 900
` 2,200 + ` 900
/
``
`
>
`
D
`
` `
`
&D/&
`
`
`
>/`
W
>d
W
W
E
`
`
700 + 500
1,200
lakhs = `
lakhs = 38.7% (less than 40%)
2,200 + 900
3,100
D``
Z ^ W^
`
`d
Y
`d
d
`
` `
`
``
`
d K
d
d
h
market price ranges for the next three years. The historical data and the projections of the treasurer
&D/&
,
D
z
`
`
z
&
W
D W
d ^ / ^
>W^
`
^`
^W
Z
W
>
D
/
Z
W
K>
K
W/^`
^
/d
/
d
E/d
W^
Z
&D/&
d>
` D
&W
t
D
/
d
`
^
`
E
`
` 10 crores
` 400
``
`
E
` 10 crores
` 980
``
`
E
` 10 crores
` 980
^/d
/d
/d'
`
`
/d
/d ' /
ZK/
``
``
`
&D/&
^/d
/d
/d'
`
`
/d
/d'/
ZK/
``
``
`
^d
z
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
^`
^/d
/
/d`
Z
&D/&
^ ^
E
`
t
>/
Z
E
Z
d
>d
d
E
`
^ ^
E
t
/d
Z
d
>d
d
>/
E
E
W^`
Z
Z
&D/&
^
1st year earnings after tax + 3 years Earnings after tax (1 - Dividend payout) No. of years
2
No new venteure =
60% 3 years
60% 3 years
`
`
60% 3 years
`
^
`
E
t
K
E
K
E
K
E
K
E
/
&D/&
tE
^
^
s`
Z
d
`
=
=
=
=
EBIT
Debt +Market vlaue of equity shares
` 7.15 crores
` 7.15 crores
12
crores
+ ` 45 crores
`
` 7.15 crores
` 57 crores
ZK/
^ ZK/
,
/
`
`
D`
&D/&
/
``
/
&W
/
&W
/
&W
/
d
t
/
/
/
Y
d ,>> ` d
E
d,>>```
^&
t
> Z
E
&D/&
Or
K```
K```
K`
K
`
K
`
`
E
i.e.
` 30 crores + 0.5x
=2
` 8 crores + x
``
``
or x =
` 14 crores
1.5
E`
i.e.
` 8 crores + x
` 40 crores
<5
``
`
^`
E^
&D/&
,
&
`
Y
^>
/d
`
Wd
`
&
`
W^
tE
Degree of operating leverage (DOC) =
=
Contribution
EBIT
EBIT
PBT
` 1,120
` 320
&D/&
Y
yz > d
yz>
/
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
K
D
(Beta D ) + E (Beta E )
D+E
D+E
Beta A =
d
/ZW
x=
10
= 16.67 per cent
0.6
rA =
D
E
rEd +
rE
D+E
D+E
KZ rE =
.20 - .05
= .30 or 30%.
.5
&D/&
d
/ Z W
Risk Premium =
20
= 16.67%
1.2
d
d W^
E
/d
/
E
d
E
E
E
WZ
Z
dW^
d
Y
`/
/ K
d
W^``
`
&D/&
d
Dividend
Ke - g
P0 =
9.00
0.18 - 0.09
W`
^
,t
d
'
`
Z
W
W^
`
`
`
`
t
D+
Vc =
Ra
(E - D)
Rc
Rc
t
s DW
Z Z
Z
&D/&
,
Vc =
9.00 +
.15
(22.50 - 9.00 )
.18
.18
20.25
.18
`
Y
W
E
D
p = equity
+ debt
D + E
D + E
ZZZZZZ
Question 14
A Ltd. is an all equity Financed Company. The current market price of share is ` 180. It has just paid
a dividend of ` 15 per share and expected future growth in dividend is 15%. Currently, it is evaluating
a proposal requiring funds of ` 20 lakhs, with annual inflows of ` 12 lakhs for 3 years. Find out the
Net Present Value of the proposal, if (i) It is financed from retained earnings; and (ii) It is financed by
issuing fresh equity at market price with a floatation cost of 5% of issue price.
EWs
&&Z
Z
` 15 + 2.25
100 + 15% = 24.58%
` 180
&D/&
EWsWE&
z
`
&&
D1
Cost of Equity =
100 + Growth Rate
P0 (1 - floatation cost)
+ 15 % = 25.09%
` 180 (1 - .05)
` 15 + 2.25
EWsW
z
EWs
E
`
,
Y
d ^ > `
d``
W^`/
Z
W^
K>
E^`
/d`
ROI =
EBIT
3.6
100 =
100 = 20%
Capital Employed
10 + 2 + 6
&D/&
`
/d
/
d
>d
d
>W
^
Z
^W
^ZKW
^ZK
d
^
W
t
W^
d
EBIT
EBIT - Interest - Preference dividend
3.6
= 1.4754
3.6 - .9 - .26
>&>K>
3
1.4754
&D/&
Y
dd``&
DzdD
YTM =
`
`
YTM =
6.3 + (13.5/5 )
9.00
or
= 9.30%
(103.5 + 90)/2 96.75
Question 17
M/s Transindia Ltd. is contemplating calling ` 3 crores of 30 years, ` 1,000 bond issued 5 years ago
with a coupon interest rate of 14 per cent. The bonds have a call price of ` 1,140 and had initially
collected proceeds of ` 2.91 crores due to a discount of ` 30 per bond. The initial floating cost was `
3,60,000. The Company intends to sell ` 3 crores of 12 per cent coupon rate, 25 years bonds to raise
funds for retiring the old bonds. It proposes to sell the new bonds at their par value of ` 1,000. The
estimated floatation cost is ` 4,00,000. The company is paying 35% tax and its after tax cost of debt
is 8 per cent. As the new bonds must first be sold and their proceeds, then used to retire old bonds,
the company expects a two months period of overlapping interest during which interest must be paid
on both the old and new bonds. What is the feasibility of refunding bonds?
EWs
WstE
`
Ws&
>/tE
EWs
ZZEWs
&D/&
tE
/
>
&
K
>
d
d
K
/
>
d
d
E
/
>
d
&D/&
Y
& `
maturity with YTM at 16% payable annually and duration 4.3202 years . Given 1.16 = 2.4364.
1.16
0.16
c (c 1.16 ) 1 + 0.16
6
1.16 + 6c 0.96
= 2.9298
1.4364 c + 0.16
d``
Y
D
Z
Z
d
He is considering to invest in AA rated, `1,000 face value bond currently selling at `1,025.86. The bond
has five years to maturity and the coupon rate on the bond is 15% p.a. payable annually. The next interest
payment is due one year from today and the bond is redeemable at par. (Assume the 364 day T-bill rate
to be 9%). You are required to calculate the intrinsic value of the bond for Mr. Z. Should he invest in the
bond? Also calculate the current yield and the Yield to Maturity (YTM) of the bond.
dDZ
PVIF 14%
TIME
CF
PV (CF)
1
150
0.877
131.55
2
150
0.769
115.35
3
150
0.675
101.25
4
150
0.592
88.80
5
1150
0.519
596.85
PV (CF)
i.e.
W
&D/&
^D
/W
dzdD
WWs/&Ws/&
&
`
Z
zD
Z
`
z
t
D
Discount or premium
Coupon interest +
Years left
YTM =
Face Value + Market value
2
zdD&s
>
(1,000 - x)
160 +
0.17 =
1,000 + x
2
`
&D/&
Ws/&Ws/&
z
Ws
160
W
W
.624
99.84
0.104
0.312
s
4.236
Duration
=
(1 + yields) 1.17
d
`
`
,```
,
d
`
`
``
&D/&
&/EE/>^Zs/^
Y
y>
:
E
/
t
E / ` ,
11.50 90
365
,
2.836
` 5 crores `
100 + 2.836
E
``
`
Y
W``/
:
td
D:``
&``
:
`
20,00,000
(Refer to working note) `
1.0199452
`
&D/&
tE
/ `
91
d `
Y
>`d
^d
`
d
&
Z
&
&
`
&
` 70,40,000 18 90
Interest =
100 360
`
`
```
&&
&`
/`
d
&^&^
`
d
E&``
` 9,27,200 100
67,23,200
`
`
Ed
&D/&
Y
d
default. The factor has agreed to pay money due after 60 days and will take the responsibility of
d
`
` s d
^
d
`
^
`
E
Z
/ W
`
`
d
`
>
`
E
d
&D/&
Y
D^E>`d
d
` &
d
z
D^E>
Z
&
&Z
&
/
`
&`
&ini interest
` 792000
&
d
E` `
Ed
&D/&
tKZ</E'W/d>DE'DEd
Y
,>
`
D
>s
&D
W
^
d
^
tE
`
^
z
&D/&
D>
W^W>
z/
`
z//
`
W
^
`
& `
`
^Z`
W
D`
dW
K
* 25,20,000
2,000
30,000
>
#32,88,000
6,000
42,000
^
s`
^`
^
W
&D/&
tE
z/
D
>K^
z//
`
`
W
d>
>D^
W^tZ
z/
z//
^
&'
`
`
d
>
^tE
t
t
&D/&
Y
d
Z
`
`
K
`
d
`
^
`
Z
&
>
1
`
&
dE
Zt
`
`
Z
Zt
t
Zt
&
Zt
Zt
&D/&
>
Zt
Zt
Et
ddE
&D
`
Z
`
^D
Z
``
`
tE
Z`
`
K`
`
t
Z`
`
K`
`
Z
/^
&D/&
,
&&
&t
Z
`
` 86,40,000
52 weeks
4 weeks `
&
``
^
`
` 1 63,20,000
8 weeks
52 weeks
`
`
`
W
`
```
Zt
` 9304615
52 weeks
4 weeks
`
>
``
Zt
1
2
`
` 31,80,000
1
1 weeks
52 weeks
2
`
&D/&
Y
d
W^
`
Z
K
d
W
^
Z
dd
&
d
d
d`
d
dz
t
^tZ
^
`
t
`
`
&
`
`
Zt
>
`
&D/&
` 90,00,000
1.5 weeks
52 weeks
Et>
tE
`
`
`
`
`
`
d`
d^
`
d
`
Y
yz > /
tt
W
K
Z
K
&
d
K
d
`
`
K
`
^
`
Z
d
/
&D/&
d
`
Zh
tWW
Z
t
`
K
1
`
12
1
`
12
&
d D
>
K
Z
2
12
2
12
d
Z
1
12
1
12
E
&D/&
DW&dE
D
`
>
t
>
DW&
D
`
t
>
DW&
D
d``
`
Z
>
>>
DW&
Y
dDEW>
^
D
t
D
`
`
`
`
d
`
^ W
`
d
/
/`
/
&D/&
^d
`
^
>'^
dD
>D
>t
D
>
`
dD
^
d
d`
W
Z
D`
&
d`
d
>
^
D`
D
t`
d>
`
t> ` `
&D/&
Y
Z
K
d
W
^W
`
d
d
d
d
`
Z
Wt
t
^tE
//
Z
1,30,000 ` 100
52
t/W/ 1,30,000
0.80 212.50
52
&
1,30,000 212.50
52
/
3 4
1,30,000 212.50
4 52
/
&D/&
>
1,30,000 100
52
1,30,000 37.50
52
1,30,000 75
52
EtE
&
Y
`
Z
>
&
`
d
W
^
&
D
>K
&
d
d
d
`
Z
W
z
&D/&
/.
tE
//
`
Z/ = 87,000
tW/
D = 87,000
4
` 117
52
2
0.80 117
52
>K
2
0.60 129
= 87,000
52
&'/
/
= 87,000
3
246
= 87,000
52
//.
6
0.8 246
52
///.
d/
>W
8
117
= 87,000
52
t = 87,000
`
1
49
52
K = 87,000
2
80
52
dW
EtE
``
&D/&
dKZ^DE'DEd
Y
>`d`
` d
d
W
/
W
d `
d
z
,>
W
^h
^
s`
&
ED
/
t
Z
&
'
,
EW
&
/
W
W
WW
&D/&
tE
&
/
1 month :
23,00,000
1 = 1,91,666
12
26,00,000
2 = 4,33,333
12
3 months =
29,50,000
3 = 7,37,500
12
Y
d W / `
/
d
W^
`
t d
/Z
`
/`
Z
W
= ` 3,12,083
W
Z```
`
/
/
W`
`
&D/&
W`
`
E
`
E
```
^ `
` d
Y
Z'>
/`d
W
`d
dZ^
WW
W
^
`>
/
//
///
/s
Z t W
^WW
`/>
W
^
>s
>&
W
/
/
s &
W
W
/
//
///
/s
&D/&
/
Z
/
d ///
Y
:
dd
:,
`
K
W
W
:
d:
d
&
: E E
E,
E d
E
&D/&
^
E
`
`
`
d
Y
d yz > d
yz
dtW
t
^
>`d
`
d
E
`
`
'
`
`
/
Z
t
`
E
^
Z
/d'W
&D/&
d
d ' W d
&
d
/
d
d
tE
/
Average rate of interest Cost of goods sold Average collection period in days for non-defaulting accounts
365 days
&
18% ` 85 45 days
`
365 days
&
18% ` 85 42 days
`
365 days
&
18% ` 85 40 days
`
365 days
&
18% ` 85 80 days
`
365 days
Y
^
^W
`
s
`
d
`
K
d
/d
z
W
&D/&
/
`
d
`
``
d`
`
``
d`
&`
`
>W`
`
`
Return =
(due to change in credit policy )
d
,
Y
d
d
,
/
30
365
, `
1
d
1.024568
,
&D/&
Y
:<>>
/
d
W
/K
//K ///K
W
^`
`
z
KW:<>>
`
K/
K//
K///
^
1 200
= 16.67
12
1.5 210
= 26.25
12
2 220
= 36.67
12
3 250
= 62.50
12
/
/
/
/
E
/:<>>K//
&D/&
Y
`
` d d
W
W/
W//
`
`
W
Wz
W
WW
W
W
`
`
`
^
Z`
25
20
15
50,00,000
50,00,000
50,00,000
365
365
365
Z
`
^
`
`
`
Z
/
`
/
/
`
`
`
& W / `
W// ` t W //
W/dW//
`
&D/&
^,DE'DEd
Y
d > ` > d
`````
`d
z
D
d
dd`
>^`
E>d
`d
t
/`/
d`
`
t : D t :
/ d
d
&
2 Tb
+
t d W
`
`
/ /
2 10,00,000 1000
0.05
`
&D/&
/EsEdKZzDE'DEd
Y
d
^E
E
&
^`
`
d^
/E
E
`
`
`
`
`
W
^
^
^
`
`
d
&D/&
^
`
d
`
K
/E
h
h
h
`
/E///
E
`
d
&D/&
Y
>
`
`
^
^
/W
/d
^`
K
'^
W
s`
&`
d`
/>sW
`
/W
W
`
`
`
`
^
'
>
W
/W
/W
//
/ZZ
^
&D/&
Y
`
K`E
E/>
z
KYKY
Z/>
/
2 SC 0
ic 1
EOQ =
t
^
K
^
Z
2 72,000 500
= 1,60,00,00 0
5% of ` 90
Z>E>dEh
Z
E
Normal Usage =
=
Annual usage
Normal working days in a year
72,000
Z
300
&D/&
YK
KY
^
K
Z
E
Order size
2
Z
Z
Z
`
`
K`
/
KY`
`
W
KY`
`
d
d,
&D/&
dKK>^&KZ&/EE/>E>z^/^W>EE/E'
^,h'd&hE&>Kt^ddDEd^,&>Kt^ddDEd
Y
d>
D
E
d
D
D
`
^
`
t
`
:
&
D
D
:
:
`
W::
:
&D/&
K
W
t
W
:
`
D
:
:
W>:
^:
^:W
>KD
W:
t:
W
`
^
^K
D
ZK
:^
&^
D^
K
&W
DW
::W
Z:D:^
:::W
^
W
/
`
&D/&
>/
>/
K
,
Y
d^'>DD
^D
`
`
>
^
'Z
ZW^
W>
W
Wd
&
>
E&
>/
^
` `
W
D
/
d
`
` `
&D/&
/ ` / `
W
d`
`
d
Z
W&&^^&W
D
&K
WD
`
>^
D
dZ
WZ
W
Wd
>W>D
&
d&
d
W>
W W
&
&
d
d W
&
W>>
&D/&
Wd
d
d
^
Z
W
>
t
/t
W>W
^t
D
D
t
&&^D
`
^
tK
^&
^/
^/
d&W
W&
W/
W
W
Wd
/t
d&
`
&D/&
Y
&>
^
D
`
D
`
>
^`
^
Z^
>
K
/
D
`
D
`
>
D
/>
^
W
d/
/^D
E^
>
``
E
'
`
&D/&
'
W
/
W
D`
d>
Z
W&&^^t
D
^t
D
D
/t
/
^
W
d/
>
/
Et
&D/&
D
`
^
W
`
d/
`
`
&K
`
W
D
>'
&K
' d
^&WtD
^
`
&
^
`
/>
/
Et
d&
&
W
W
W
&Z
&D/&
Y
yz > ^ / ^
yz>
`
^
^
>
>
^
&
W
>
/
&D/&
yz>
/^
`
^
>
'
>K
E
E
>
/
>/
E
`
d`
` ` `
Z
h
^
K
E/
`
/
/
/
>
E
&D/&
&/
W
E
&&
/
E
E
Y
& / ^ ^ >
&^
/^D
E^
`
>
^
^t
K
Wd
EKW
E/W
Z
W>D
&D/&
^
D
D
`
`
^
D
D
`
`
^
^W>
^
K
/
&
>
>
d`
&^>D
K
`
EWd/
KWt
/
^
/
&D/&
^
/K
'K
/W
EK
/
`
W>
W
^
E/
&
`
/^
W
E&
E
`
`
^
^
`
W>W
`
&D/&
^^
`
K
>
E
W^
^W^
Y
y>
`
&
>
^
^`
d
d
d``
``
^
```
d``
Wy>
t
&
`
W
>W
&D/&
```
```
>/``
W
``
d
`
d
`
W`
E/dW/
75
W&^D
`
/
^D
&
`
`
`
`
`
>K
W&
W
dW
D
&D/&
Zd/KE>z^/^
Y
&^D
t
&W
Z^
>
`
`
`
t
Current assets
Current liabilities
K
Kt
K`
K
`
`
``
Liquid assets
Current liabilities
Current assets - Stock
` 1,60,000
>
K
K
`
` ^
K
^
`
W&^
Fixed assets
= 0.75
Proprietary fund
&
W
W
E
W
K `
W
&D/&
K W
`
&
`
`
WZ^
``
`
^
``
`
Z^
^
^
`
&
^
Y 8
h^
'W
^&
'W
d
d
/
>
`
`
^
>
^
/
&
&D/&
'W
`
'WD
^
`
Gross Profits
`
Gross Profit Margin
^d^
^
`
`
dd
d
`
Sales
Total Assets Turnover
` 2,70,000
0. 3
^'WK'^
K'^`
`
/
/
COGS
2,16,000
=
Inventory turnover
4
`
W
360
Average Collection Period
`
Credit Sales
Debtors turnover
` 2,16,000
18
&D/&
``
`
>
^&`
>`
`
`
`
^`
&
>
/
^
&
Y
d WYZ>
'W^EW^ZD
^Z
&^&>
Z^
/ `
W >
^
tE
^
&D/&
Fixed Assets 1
=
Sales
3
26,00,000 1
= Sales = Rs.78,00,000
Sales
3
26,00,000
13
= Current Assets = Rs. 22,00,000
Current Assets 11
Fixed Assets 13
=
Current Assets 11
ZDt
`
^
>'W
t
ZDt `
tt
`
^ZD
3
= ` 3,31,500
12
^&'t
6
= ` 3,97,800
100
>
Current Assets
= 2
Current Liabilities
22,00,000
= 2 Current Liabilitie s = ` 11,00,000
Current Liabilitie s
Debtors
365
Credit Sales
Debtors
365 = 60 Debtors = ` 12,82,191.78 or ` 12,82,192
78,00,000
>>
&D/&
Long term Loan 2
=
Current Liabilities 1
Long term loan 2
= Long term loan = ` 22,00,000.
11,00,000
1
>
Z
&
E
&
d
>>>
>
E
E^Z
`
Capital
1
1
= Share Capital = 15,00,000 = ` 3,00,000
Reserves and Surplus 4
5
4
= ` 12,00,000
5
W>WYZ>
W
` W
`
d D
d t
d tK
^
d 'W
^
d ^
d EW^
'W
&D/&
^WYZ>
>
^
`
&
`
Z^
>
^ Z
D
^ &
'
Y
t
,
W
W
E
Z/ZK/EW
/
dZEWZ
dZ
ZK/
/
EWZ
ZdZ
ZK/
/
dZEWZ
ZdZ
ZK/
&D/&
/s/EWK>//^
Y
dd>d
d`Z'
Zdd>
`
td>
t
WDZZZZ
t
ZKZ
Z
Z
^
Z
Z
D1
+ g, t
P0
WD
Z
.175 =
4 (1.08)
+ 0.08
P0
.095 =
4 (1.08)
P0
P0 =
4 (1.08)
.095
`
&D/&
Y
>d
/ `
>z
z
&
W
`
`
`
W
`
`
`
D
P4 =
D5
K s - gn
t<
E
`
`
P4
2.55
0.16 - 0.08
`
`
WW`
,>
``
&D/&
Y
W>Z
`/
&
h
Ke =
t
D1
+g
P0
W
E``W`
Therefore, K e =
<`
` 1.12
` 15
+ 12%
Y
y>d
`d`
d
DD
,
`
`
&D/&
DDDD/D
P0 =
P1 + D1
1+ K e
tW`
WD
`
<
P0 =
P1 + D1
1+ K e
140 =
P1 + 6.4
1 + 0.096
W
W
P0 =
P1 + D1
1+ K e
140 =
P1 + 0
1 + 0.096
W
W 156.04
E
W
E/
>
Z
/
D
E ..
K
/
`
/
&D/&
Y
y>
`
W
Z
y>`
E
W
z
y>
WWd
`
WW/d
>`
WWd
>d
WWd
>W
`
`
Zh
/&
15,80,800 + 7,68,000
23,48,800
7,68,000 + 3,20,000
10,88,000
'Z
'Z
1,04,00,000
40,00,000 + 64,00,000
80,00,000 + 32,00,000
1,12,00,000
&D/&
z^
z
`
`
z
`
z
Yield on shares
Equity share capital
3,51,040
80,00,000
z
E d
y>/
/ & ' Z d
/&
'Z
/y>
dy>^
ZW
' y >
dy>
ZW
E
Z
Z
s^
Actual yield
W
Expected yield
4.39
10.70
`
&D/&
Y
D,
d`
D
Z
D
d
P0 =
D 0 (1 + g)
(k - g)
t
WW
'
,
W
P0 =
3 (1 + 0.05)
= ` 63.00
(0.10 - 0.05)
W
P0 =
2.60 (1.05)
= ` 136.50
(.07 - .05)
Y
`d
d,
&D&
/ <
WD
<Z<Z
&D/&
t
<
Z Z
W
<
<
P0 =
D1
(k e - g)
t
W W
<
'
P0 =
2.00
(k e - g)
P0 =
2.00
0.154 - 0.07
`
,
<
<Z<Z
d
P0 =
D1
(k e - g)
P0 =
2.00
0.16 - 0.07
`
&D/&
Y
dyz>
`
EW
K
E
Z/
t`
t
`
EW
>W
d
`
>y
r(E - D)
Ke
D
P =
+
Ke
Ke
,`<W`
6x
0.2 (6 - 6x)
+
0.16 0.16 0.16
Hence ` 48 =
`y
^
Y
dDyz>
`
W
&D/&
E
Z
tt
tt
Dyz>
t
P=
D + (E D)(r / k e )
Ke
t
W
D
`
`
Z
<
3.50 + (5 3)
W
`
0.12
0.15
.15
3 .50 + 2.0
0.12 =
.12
0.12
t
,
^
0 + (5 0)
0.12
0.15
0.12 = ` 52.08
Y
D > /
`/`
`D > `
^DDD>
&D/&
t
W
`W
W
`
``
E
sD>
EW
``
1
(Rs.5 + P 1)
1.10
3,75,000 75,000
=
105
21
t
W
100 =
p1
1.10
W
E
`
2,50,000 25,000
=
110
11
sD>
`
`
t
&D/&
K^dK&W/d>
Y
>
z<
>E^,dD
>
W
^
Z
` ^
`
`
`
`
ZW^^ `
d d
`
D
^^
&D/&
E^Z
^
^
t
^
<K
`
W
Z
Y
,W>sDs
^
` ` Ds
Z
`
W^
` ` Ds
` ` Ds
` `
`
`
` `
W / W `
`
d
d/
&D/&
^
t
/
`
<Kt
^
Z
W
`
t
<K
D
^
Z
W
`
t
<K
&D/&
Y
&yz>
`
W
d
`
` ` dW^W^ `
Z
W
/
D `
yz>
^
&^
t
&E
t
E^
E^
&D/&
</
<
< /
<
tD
^
E
W
>
`
t
<K
Y
W `
`
W `
d
` d `
d
t
ZsZ
E^
E
&D/&
D `
W^ `
W^ `
Z
&D/&
Y
`
Z
WZ
Z
Z
`
W `
`
`
`
`
`
` `
`
^
&D/&
t
<K
t
<K
^
W
`
^
W
`
D
Y
d
& `
Z
W^& `
d>
z
^
`
`
`
` `
d /
/t
^
<WDZZZ
ZZ
ZZ
<E^
&D/&
<
<<
t
^
Z
W
d
D
^
W
d
`
t
<K
`
t
<K
&D/&
W/d>^dZhdhZ
Y
d,>>Zd
1) W
2) E
3)
d,>>ZZZ
^&
t
/
d
d
/
//d/
>
d
/
/d
/
d
&D/&
E
>
d
>
d
d
Y
d^^>D
&
>
^
&
Z
/
>d>
Z
^d>
W
W
^&D
d
z
Y
Z
>
d
&D/&
^DZd>
^
/
&Z^>^^D^
t
>^>W
^^
DE
^
&Z
D
>^d
^d
^d
D&>
>
>
^
>
>d
,&
400
1.02 1.05
200 24.25 140 120%
&D/&
>
&
Z
>
^
^
Y
&>
^ `
W^ ` `
K ` `
&s`
` Z
`
K
K
EW
`
W^
W^
t
W^
`
`
!" # $ $% !
&D/&
W^
K
W
E
W^
E
W^
W^
&"'"
10,00,000
` 5.71
1,50,000 25,000
Y
d^>
^ ^ ` >^
^ `
t ^
^
>^
^
d
^ ^ >
^>^^^
t
^
^
>
^>WW
^
D
^
^^>^
&D/&
Y
/D
d
zz/
Z
`
`
/d
`
`
t
W `
`
D
`
/,'W
>
'/d
t
Z
D
/^'W
/d
t
Z
D
tt
t
t
/DKZWKZd/KE
,
<
<
ZZZ
t<K
>
<
<
t
&D/&
^
/d
&d'
W&&&,
W
W&&&
`
d
/d
E
t
&&&
W
W
d&&&`
W/'
,-. /.
W
W
Y
zs>
`
` ,
z
d
t
s/,Z/D/>>^>d
&&& `
'
&D/&
0 #. $% %-
<K
<K
t
>tt
<<<
tt
t
d
D
D
'<<
<K
ZD `
Y
d^D^>
^
Z
Z
Z
^
h
d
K
Z
&
d
`d `
`
Z D D
DDD
E
&D/&
d ` ` `
`
E
/
d^
z
,
>
z
^>^
Wdy
dy
Wd
WZ&ZE/sE
Yhd/zZE/E'^
EKK&Yhdz^,Z^
W^
s'DW^Z^
WZd/Kd/D^
E
& `
` /E>h/E' WZD/hD ` ^
d `
, `
D
^>^
W/d
Wd
&D/&
dy
Wd
WZ&ZE/s/E
Yh/dzZE/E'^
EKK&Yh/dz^,Z^
W^
WZd/Kd/D^
DZ<dWZ/K&^,Z
DW^ `
`
^
Y
,
> ` `
&
Kd `
Zd ` E
` ` d
,
/ `
` /d d
d
`
d `
,
` d
, `
`
,
d `
/ `
,
/
Z
Z
&D/&
<
<W^DW^y
ZK/<ZK/
<
<<
^
`/E><^
dKd>^^d^WZ^Ed
/d/KE>/Es^dDEd
dKd>^^d^&dZWZKWK^>
ddKd>^z^/E>Kty
^z
y/^d/E'd
Dy/DhDWZDD/^>/d/KE>d
d `
`
E
DW^W
`
/d&ZKDEtWZK:d
/EdZ^d
Wd
dy
Wd&ZKDEtWZK:d
WddWZ^Ed
dKd>
EKK&^,Z^
W^Z
WZd/Kd/D^
DW^Z
d^^d^Zd/KdKd>ddKd>^^d^y
^ZYh/Z
KDDEd
W^DW^
, `
` `
&D/&
>sZ'
Y
///
///yz
/
`
^
`
s
&^
`
^
`
`
^
^
&W
>^&W
^
/d
K>K>
/d
^
/d
d
&>/dd
^
/d
d
&>/dd
^
/d
/
d
&>
^
&D/&
Y
d
>E^,d
>
`
`
Z
E&
Z
d `
d
/dW^ ` ` `
^
/d
/
d
d
d
K>K> /d
&>
/dd
>
d
E
W^
Wd
Wd
/
/d
Y
d
s
/
/
W
`
`
&D/&
&
/dd/d/d/
/d
K/d
^
/EKD^ddDEd
^
&
/d
d
d
Y
` ` `
/ ` `
tZK/
/
t
/ ` /d
^
s
&
/d
d
/d
ZK/
ZK/<
D
K>/d
&>/dd
&D/&
>
h
^
K>
E/d
[/d]
Y
d `
d
W/
W/
W/
>E^,dK&d,KDWEz^KEDZ,
>
`
`
Z
Z
d
/D
^
K
/d
/
d
d
W^
E
//dW^
&D/&
y/d
/d///d/
W
W
/d
/d
d
d
Wd
E
W^
t
W
W
W
W
W^
D
W
W W
W
/d
d
d
E
W^
&D/&
>^/E'
Y
>
`
/d,Z
> `
KZ
``
d
dts
d
d
zZ
dZ
Ws
>
WsK&`
z
W
K
d
d
E
Ws
W
E`
>Ws>
>y`
z
>
d
E
W
W
&^>
,/^
> `
` ^
&D/&
Y
`
`
`Z
`
z
Z
E
d
z&
DZ
Z
Z
W
Z
>yEWsZ/
W
>Z
24,60,000
15
Wd
Wd
/dWd
Ws&
Ws
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
dy
Wsd/
E
>dW
Ws`
&D/&
ZZWs/Ws
y
y`
>Z&`
Y
d^>`d
d<>>,
>,>dd,>
d
,>
/,>
`
>
`
Z
yWs&Z
y
>y
E>>
y
d
yWs&
y
Y
/
`dhZs
`
>&d>Y`W
d/Y
KdZ
>
`
^/
Ws
&D/&
Ws
Ws
Ws/
Wsy
E,
t
> y
WyWs&
W
z
>
d
Ws
W
dKd>
W
z
d
Ws
W
z
/
/
W
Ws W
d
Wy
W
/E
/Ws&
Y
, & > D
``
z
/ZZ
t
&D/&
`
&`
>
>
Ws&/ZZ
Ws&/ZZ
/ZZ
>
Ws&
Z
>
>
Wd
Wd
/d
W
z `
W
W
>
Wd
Wd
/d
W
W
Z
/ `
/K
Z `
&D/&
Y
> ` d
d`
d
d
d
/
d
d
d`zd
z>
EW
z
W
/ / d
d
E
Ws
W
Wsd
> W
^
d
/W
E
^
d
>
W
>
d
>
W
`
&D/&
Y
>d
` d
z
d
d
/
>
ds^>
W
`
y
W
z >
d
E
W
W
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
y
Wy
z
d
W
W
/K
y
y ` d `
&D/&
/EdZEd/KE>&/EE
Y
D^h<,D^///
d
d
Z
^Z
'W
,d/
>
/
^ `
d/
`
^Z
^
`
`
Y
d
Zh^
^Z
`
`
,Z
,h^
h^,h^
^ ` d `
E `
`
`
&&^
W
W
Y
Kh^'
dDtD:
/h^
'
^ZD
&D/&
&^
Y
> D ^ Z & Z /
>t
Z t
D
K
K
^
&
K
hZK
>h^
d
Y
/,dh^
h<:
h^
h<
h^
:
h<
h^
:
h<
h^
:
h^
/K
h^Zh< `
^EWE
tE&
h<
h<
:
h^
h^
h^
:
h^
h<
:
&
`
&D/&
tE
^E
W
h<
:
h^
Zd
>dW
EZ
EW
h<
Z
:
h^
dW
EZ: `EZh^
` EWh< `
Y
h</
>
^
D
>
/
D
>
D
&
^/
^>W
W
^
Z
^/h<
^^d>//
,
E
&
D
d,
&D/&
Y
>>/h^
DE
d h^
h^
d/
d'D&>
s
&
d
d
d/h^
d ` h^
d &d
d d
h^ >
h^/
>h^
E
&Z
d
z
Ws
E>K>d
t
`
&d
^
s
&
d
d
K&d
&D/&
W
z
z
z
z
z
K&d
Z
Z
t
Z
tE
Z
Z
Z
Ws&
WZ
EWs
d
K
EWs
`
t
Z
&
Y
h< &
^
^
^
^W
DDZ
h^
h<W
&
&yK
W
W
W
d K ' Z
,
&
&D/&
/&
d
d
K
^W
/KW
E
dE
W
s
W
W
>
Z
E
W
Z
E
&
D
K
KK>W
&D/&
/EdZ^dZd^tW^
Y
Zd
>
dt
^
,
>/
d
1 + 0.098 X
5
i
3
8
X = 1 + 0.0105 X
1 +
12 100 12
12
K
/
dd
yy
3
`
12
Y
&Z
d&Zt
Z
&
Z
^
^ d
^
3
12
3
12
^
&D/&
Y
d
y
z
D
d
d
>/KZ
>/KZ
dyz,
d
y>/KZzdd
t
yz
&Z
sZ
y
d
>/KZ
z
d
>/KZ
E
yd>/KZ>/KZ
z>/KZd>/KZ
y>/KZ
zd
W
>/KZdd>/KZ
LIBOR + 0.10
T + 0.55
Bank
Co. X
Co. Y
T + 0.70
LIBOR + 0.25
Market
LIBOR + 0.75
Y
,&>
&Z&Z
yz > yz >
&Zz
>yz>
&D/&
, & > yz
^>
^yz>
&Z/d
yz
Z
&Z
W
&Z
E'
12%
12%
Bank
FR + 1.85
FR + 1.4
ABC
XYZ
12%
FR + 1
FR + 2.25%
Market
12%