I chose this scene in Life of Pi as my pivotal scene because this was the scene that makes the reader start to question how realistic the novel really is.
Pi arrives on the island after a big storm hits and his boat drifts ashore. Pi and Richard Parker immediately fill up on fresh water and find lots of food to satisfy them, as they had no food left over on their boat.
The scene takes place on Algae Island it is an island full of meerkats and freshwater ponds. The island becomes strange by nightfall because Pi noticed dead fish rise to the surface of the ponds at night and disappear by morning. There were a few more scenes on the island that made me question the book. There were teeth in the center of leaves that were glued together taking in the appearance of fruit. The final decision was made Pi decides he cannot stay on the island so he packs lots of food for Richard Parker and himself, leave the carnivorous island and set out to sea once again.