Reading architecture requires us to allow buildings to
speak to us.
But how can inanimate objects speak to us?
Especially if those objects are not representational? Pentre Ifan Burial Chamber, 2000 BCE John Portman, Bonaventure Hotel, Los Angeles. 1976. Richard Neutra, Edgar J. Kaufmann House, Palm Springs, 1946. According to Vitruvius (Marcus Vitruvius Pollio, 1 st cent. BCE), in De Architectura a building must be considered in terms of three elements: Utilitas Firmitas Venustas Utilitas need function plan Firmitas means structure section Venustas art beauty elevation
Utilitas need function plan
Firmitas means structure section
Venustas art beauty elevation
Utilitas as Message: TWA Terminal, JFK Transamerica Bldg. SF, CA Utilitas by Addition: Louis Kahns Richards Medical Laboratory, University of Pennsylvania Utilitas by Division: Urge towards symmetry: Firmitas/Stucture will always be a function of: Advances in engineering Availability and strength of materials Cost available for materials Other historical and geographical factors
Architecture is the adaptation of form to resist force. John Ruskin (19 th c.) All structures seek a balance between tension and compression.
Traditionally there were two ways to handle this: through trabeated structures
or through arcuated structures. Trabeated Structures CANTILEVER Milstein Hall, Cornell University (Rem Kolhaas) Gale House, Oak Partk, IL (Frank Lloyd Wright) Villa Savoye, Poissy, France. LeCorbusier. ARCUATED STRUCTURES Colosseum, Rome. Hagia Sophia, Instanbul Venustas art beauty elevation
Hertziana, Rome Gugenheim Museum, Bilbao What makes architecture good? Does it express its function in a meaningful, interesting, and appealing way? Does it seem to fit its surroundings (by complementing or contrasting with it in an interesting and meaningful way)? Is its design and execution structurally sound? Does it create a meaningful (interesting, surprising, enjoyable, delightful, disturbing etc.) space? Will it endure? Has it endured?
Analyzing a Building: Space: Solids and Voids Scale and Proportion Weight & Mass Basic Design Elements
Analyzing a Building: Space: Solids and Voids Symmetry Asymmetry
Symmetry Asymmetry Analyzing a Building:
Weight & Mass: Materials Massing for Weight Relationship to Ground (high or low?) Texture Color Ornamentation Light Acoustics Context Basic Elements Roof Walls Windows Doorways Orientation Roof Types Butterfly Roof Butterfly w/Solar Panels Barrel Vault Roof Wall Types Rusticated Half-timbered Clapboard Board and Batten Siding
Wainscoting Stucco Wall Glass Wall Window Types Lancet Palladian Oeil-de-boeuf (ox-eye) Double-hung window Bay window Ribbon Window Casement window Dormer Doorways Arched Pedimented Venetian Door French Door Sliding Door Orientation Aesthetic Cultural Ecological The Getty Center Richard Meier