You are on page 1of 17

.

. .
.

.
0.1,
(490-430 ..).
, .
0.2.
,
, . ,

.
0.3. , .
, .

, .

1.
1.1. ( 5 ..),

( )
.
:

;
1.2. ,
.

.
(460-370 . ) .
, ().
1.3. ;
; ; ,
.

(meaningless)
.
, ,
, . ,
(540-475 ..)

.
, .
,

. , .., ,
, .

.
, , ,
.
- .
. , , ,
.
, ,
, . , :
, (: Nehamas, (1981)).
1.4.
( ) . (
) ( ),
. ,
( ), .
, , ( ),
, .
,
. , , . Russell
, ,
, .
, ,
(500; - 428 . ) . ,
:
, , . ,
. (. Weyl, (1963)).
,
2.1. . :
, ...
.

. , ,
: ... , , ...
.

( Eves (1953)),
, .
(408 355 ..).

:
, , ...,
.
,

. ,
.

.

.

.

2.
2.1. ,
,
,
. ,
,
,
,
.
: ():
: (:
():
(): ,
,
.
, ,
, . ,
(.
(
),
.
,
.
2.2.. ,
,

, ,
,
, ..., . . [Eves.
(1953)].

,
., .
,
, . , )
1/2 1/2 min, )
1/4, 1/4
min, ...,
( ):

, :
. ,
( - -

. 1)
.
, .
2.2.b. ,
(. . 1), ,
, , ..,
. : , ,
-
, :


[. 1 (. 1)].
.
., .: .

.


:

.
[.: 1 .()]
.
, , ,
.

.
2.3. , [. : Whitrow (1961)]
,
[ 1, . (1)],
, ,
,
.
, Whitrow, .

Whitrow
,
( ) -- (.: )
, .
Whitrow, ,
1-1

(. minima perceptibilia)
[. Grnbaum (1968)]. ,
(
) Whitrow
-- ,
. , ,
, .
, G.J. Whitrow
.
2.4. Grnbaum (1968), Whitrow .
Grnbaum,
. Whitrow Whitrow,

( ) --
. , Whitrow,
( minima perceptibilia
)
.
Grnbaum, minima perceptibilia,

.


. ,
,
: ..:

, standard


. . (1)

Sn ,
:

[;o: S = , , a2,..., n-1,... Sn =


// < 1 . (. : ( 1956)].

O 1 (): ,
(): .
O Grnbaum o 1 ,
y,
, y
. Grnbaum

,
[Grnbaum (1968)]. , ,

[ 1, . (1)]
() ,
.
, , Grnbaum

. , ,

.
2.5. . ,

.

[ 1, (1)]
, 1. ,
1 ,
,
(). , ,
, ,
[Te Hennepe (1963)]. ' ,
, ,

, , (
).
.
lim l/n = 0, l/n
n .
S = {l/n, neN} (..: S = { l/l, 1/2,
1/3,...}). , l/n , !
l/n.

,
( Grnbaum),
,
.
,
: (): .
.
, (): , :
;
, (): :
,
: ;
; ; "
, ,
. [Poper, (1972)].

3.
3.1 :
,
. :
' . , ,
, .
, . ,
, '
, . ,
.
3.2. , . Russell , [.: .
Russell: (1965), (1938)]. Russell

. ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
: , ).

, '

. ,
. Russell,
:
' ,
( )

. . ,
, Cantor ,
, . .
, .
3.3 .
: (1) (2): ,
(3) , S [. (1)].

(4): '- (5):


U Ux U

, S, '
, S, ( .: , ,).
,, , ( 2, = S,), ... , ,

',
: { S, S,, S,..., Sn..} n = 1,2,3,...,
S, S,, S,,... ava. S, S (ux/ua), S (UX/UA)2, ...
ux/ua < 1 ( Grnbaum (1968)).
2.4 2.5.
( -). ", .
. Weyl
, - (.:
). . Weyl,


' ...
, , ,
,
,
(, ,
).

4.
4.1 Gr. Vlastos [. Gr. Vlastos: (1966)],
: 1]. :
, . 2]. ,
,
3]. , 3.1]. .
4]. , , ( ),
. 5] : 4
, .
4.2. " [.: Grnbaum (1968), Russell (1932) (1965)],
.
, ,
' . ,
, . ;
" . Russell : ... ,
, ,
. ", . Russell,

. (. ).
. ", Russell,
. , (2.1.)
(),
. Russell [ (1922)] ...
".

, ,
, , -. , .. ti,
, t2
, (
) ( ti 2),
, . ,
, .
4.3. ' ,
Gr. Vlastos (1966). ,
, :
, ( ),
. Vlastos
. "
U
S. " t (
), U = S/t = 0/0, (
Vlastos , ).
, .
, , ,
,
( ). ,
. , ,
:
' . [Russell: ( 1965)].
, ,
, . ,
(. Russell), ,
(. Vlastos). ,

, ,
. , .
.
[' Russell Braithwaite, . Gale (1968)],
, ,
, '
.
' , , ,

, .

5.
5.1
( ) (). " -


. , .
: "
, , . ( 1).

(.:
). ,
.
, .
, , ,
, [. 1)]. , , ,
2 . [ (3)]. , ,

,
, -, [. (2)]. " , ,
, ' . , :
, . "
.
5.2 A'rpd Szab (1966) .
Szab,
, ,
. , , 3.2.,
, ,
. , Szab,
.
. ,
, .
' , (. 3.2.).
5.3. , G.I
Whitrow (1961), . Russell (1938) M.Evellin [. Rssel: (1938)].
' , ' goto ,
, , ( .:,
), , , ,
. ", .
Evellin, , , . ,
, , , , ,
,: .
, (2), ( , ,
), M. Evellin . ', '
, Evellin , ,
. ,
, '
. , '
,
- '
. '' ,
!
5.4. ,
. (. 4 5).

(4) (5),
. , ,
.
t [. (1)], .
, , ,
(5), : (1): , (2):
, (3): .
: (1):
, (2) , (3):
, ,
. , , t,
(5) ' . ", ,

, , , , t
[. (6)], --
, , ,
(7),
.

, ( ) .

. ,
, 1
' .
5.5 , . Grnbaum
. . Grnbaum (1968),

, .
(event - status) . Grnbaum,
,, ,, [. .: (1), (2), (3)],
,
. ", (.
), . ,
, .
, , , (
., , ): ,
, , (, ,,
, ) [. (3)].
, M. Evellin 2 ,
, . Grnbaum
2 , . , Grnbaum,
,
5.3 5.4. .
6.
'
.
,
.
,
, .
, ,
.

.
.
, ' .
, ,
. ,
.
,
. ,
' .

. Eves, (1953): "An introduction to the history of mathematics", (3rd edition, Holt,
Rinehart and Winston).
R. M. Gale, (1968): "The language of Time", London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
A. Grunbaum (1968): "Modern Science und Zeno's paradoxes", (George Allen and
Unwin, London).

H.A. Fraenkel: "Abstract set theory", (3rd revised edition, North - Holland publishing
Co., Amsterdam).
A. Nehamas (1981): "On Parmenides three ways of inquiry", : , .
35/34, .
K.R. Popper (1972): "Conjectures and Re futations", (Routledge and Kegan Paul).
B. Russell (1965) "Mysticism and Logic", (Unwin Books, London).
B. Russell (1938): "The principles of Mathematics", (2rd edition, N.Y.: W.W. Norton and
Company).
B. Russell (1922): "Our Knowledge of the external World", (Allen and Unwin, Ltd,
London).
. (1956): , .
A. Szab (1966): "The Origins of Euclidean Axiomatics", (Lectures given at the
University of London).
E. Te Hennepe (1963): "Language Reform and Philosophical Imperialism: Another
Round with Zeno", Analysis, T. 23.
O. Testudo (1981): "Space for Zeno", , . 33/34.
. (1974): , ,
. .
Gr. Vlastos (1966) "A note on Zeno's Arrou/', Phronesis, t. 11).
H. Weyl (1963): "Philosophy of Mathematics and natural Science", (N.Y.: Atheneum).
G.J. Whitrow (1961): "The natural Philosophy of time". (London: Thomas Nelson and
Sons, Ltd).

You might also like