Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1/,234
!"#$%&'())$*+,-.+,/'0#+1,#1
!"#$%&'()'%*+,-.&'/*0#'*,0$%,!#1(2&'*
.'(#!*/0(1'%+*1-#/2## #
34*5'&
?'
!"##$"%&'())($'*+ ',**-.'(%!',/01%"23/.4'
IURP FRPSXWHU VLPXODWLRQV WR HOG5
ZRUNLQUDLQIRUHVWVWRWKHODWHVWLQXLG
RZYLVXDOL]DWLRQDQGZLQGWXQQHOVWR
H[DPLQHLJKW
7KHELJJHVWGLIFXOW\IRXQGLQLJKW
ELRPHFKDQLFVLVGXHWRWKHGLYHUVLW\RI
PHFKDQLVPVDQLPDOVKDYHGHYHORSHG
0(3."%&' 6(%$' )/./()01/).' ,*' 0*%."!/)'
7)*8-/6.',1(,'%*)6(--$'!*'%*,'()"./'(,'
,1/' /%/)&$' .0(-/.' ,$7"0(--$' (..*0"(,/!'
ZLWKPDQPDGH\LQJPDFKLQHV)RU
/9(67-/4' ,1/' 0-(.."0' :3,,(5;*3<*=.<"'
,1/*)/6'"%'(/)*!$%(6"0.'0(%'8/'3./!'
WRFRPSXWHWKHDPRXQWRI OLIWDJLYHQ
(/)*+*"-' 7)*!30/.4' 83,' ",' *%-$' =*)<.'
=1/%' ,1/' ="%&' 1(.' (' .6(--' (%&-/' *+ '
DWWDFN UHODWLYH WR WKH DLU IORZ 7KH
,1/*)/6'7)/!"0,.',1(,'"+ '="%&.'()/',**'
ODUJH WKH RZ ZLOO VHSDUDWH IURP WKH
ERXQGDU\FDXVLQJYRUWLFHVWKDWOHDGWR
WXUEXOHQFH DQG VWDOOLQJ $QLPDOV
1)(6*&7#'&&87991/00/+-:;*,*0(6*%:/)59;*,*93*4(7!<0=4(=((>?@@AB@CBDE:F85
!"#$%&'()*+(#!%+,-
!"#$%&'()**'!!"#$"#%&'()*+(*&,*$)*-&"#!!
$%&'()#*+,#-&.,/&,#%0#1/,234
!"#$%&'())$*+,-.+,/'0#+1,#1
SRZHUFXUYHRI DSLJHRQDWLQWHU7
.#$&*0#% "3##$"G41#+#% *&+3)*'#%
01#,+-%4,!)$%3+#$&(0%*%H7"1*3#$%
FXUYHKH FRQFOXGHG WKH FXUYH
!"#$%&'(%)*$%+*,-".-%/0%12"3*)
4*"% (,'"&"0#'0% 4&01% *% 3+,3#))#+7
)O\LQJ DQLPDOV IDFH WKH VDPH EDVLF
5*"#$% "-"0#.% 01*0% "#3*+*0#"% )&20%
SUREOHP DV DHURQDXWLFDO HQJLQHHUV
DQGWKUXVWJHQHUDWLRQ
KRZWRJHQHUDWHOLIWDQGWKUXVW$QLPDO
%\HPSOR\LQJFRPSDUDWLYHDQG
#'#+/#0&("%)&.&0%01#%*.,!'0%,2 %3,4#+%
(,.3!0*0&,'*)%
*33+,*(1#"8% +#7
*'%*'&.*)%(*'%/#'#+*0#%4&01%&0"%.!"()#"%
VHDUFKHUV WRGD\ KDYH EHHQ DEOH
0,%",.#01&'/%)#""%01*'%41*0%4,!)$%5#%
WR GHWHUPLQH KRZ YLVFRXV WKH
+#6!&+#$%0,%5*)*'(#%&0"%4#&/10%41&)#%&'%
DWPRVSKHUHDELUGLV\LQJWKURXJK
WKHDLU7KHUHLVWKXVDQHYROXWLRQDU\
.!"0%5#%5#2,+#%*%+,4&'/%.,0&,'%
SUHVVXUHIRU\LQJDQLPDOVWRGHYHORS
5#(,.#"% .,+#% #22&(&#'0% 01*'% *%
)*+/#% .!"()#"% *'$% ,01#+% *$*30*0&,'"%
DSSLQJPRWLRQ6LQFHFRP7
01*0% 4,!)$% 1#)3% 01#.% 3+,$!(#% .,+#%
3!0#+"%*)),4%+#"#*+(1#+"%0,%.,$#)%
OLIWRUFRXQWHUDFWGUDJ7KLVLVLPSRVVL7
1"365$%:8(/,(#7*382#(9:(&6#(#78#!&#$(;<.6*8#(
PDQ\ YDULDWLRQV RQ 9:(*(895#"(!1"=#>
5)#% 2,+% .*'-%
D GHVLJQ WKH\ KDYH WRJHQHUDWHWKUXVWEXWLQZLQJJHRPHWU\
*'&.*)"8% *'$%
*)",%5##'%*5)#%0,%3,"&0%
0 1 , " # % 0 1 * 0%
)RU WKDW UHDVRQ UHVHDUFK RQ LQVHFW
EHKDYLRUDO VWUDWHJLHV LJKW LV IRFXVHG RQ RSWLPL]DWLRQ DQG
4#&/1% .,+#%
5&+$"%!"#%0,%.&'&.&=#% FRQWURO SUREOHPV KRZ WR SURGXFH
01*'% 9:% ;&),7
$+*/% 7% "!(1% *"% 01#% 01#% .,"0% 2,+(#% 4&01% 01#% )#*"0% 3,4#+%
/+*."% +*+#)-%
(1*+*(0#+&"0&(% 5#'0% 7% (,'"&$#+&'/% 3,4#+% 3+,$!(0&,'% &"% ",%
GHYHORS WKH
4&'/"%,2 %$#"(#'$&'/% FRVWO\IRUVPDOOLQVHFWV,QKHUODE
*5&)&0-% 0,% 2)-%
"#*/!))"8%41&(1%*)),4% *0%E,+'#))8%J*'#%I*'/%"0!$&#"%"&.!)*7
2,+% +#$!(#$% 4&'/7
<1,"#% *'&7
WLRQVRI IDOOLQJSDSHUDQGLQVHFWLJKW
"3*'%
*'$%
4&'/%
*+#*%
.*)"%01*0%(*'%
+HUWHDPKDVIRXQGPDQ\VLPLODULWLHV
1"365$%78(/(0122(3%,%3%4%,0($"*0(5%&6(
H[SRVHG WR WKH DLU EHWZHHQ WKH WZR PRWLRQV %RWK
\FRPHLQD
%&.(5%,0(.*&9$8
2I FRXUVH EHKDYLRU "-"0#."% *+#% *'*)-=#$% 4&01% *% .#01,$%
ZLGH YDULHW\
(*'% ,')-% (,.3#'"*0#% 2,+% ",% .!(1% 01*0% #.31*"&=#"% 01#% +*3&$)-% (1*'/&'/%
,2 %"1*3#"%*'$%"&=#"8%5!0%01#+#%*+#%",.#%
7% 0+!)-% !'/*&')-% *'&.*)"%
&'0+&'"&(% )&.&0*0&,'"% ,'% 1,4% 01#-% *+#%
"1*3#%,2 %01#%5,!'$*+-%
4,!)$% ',0% 5#% *5)#% 0,% 2)-8%
FRQVWLWXWHG7KHPHWKRGVRI ELRPH7
!"#$%&'()*+(,%' )*-#+%7%*%+*+#%2#*0!+#%&'%
*'$% "&.!)*0&,'"% ,2 % 5&+$%
(1*'&(*)% #'/&'##+&'/% (*'% 5#% !"#$% 0,%
WKDWFDQ\FRPH PDQXIDFWXUHGV\VWHPV
"1*3#% (*'% 0#))% +#"#*+(1#+"%
JHQHUDWHSRZHUFXUYHVSORWVRI IRU7
I*'/>"% )*5% &"% *)",%
41*0% )&.&0"% ,'% "1*3#% #?&"0% LQDZLGHYDULHW\ 4,+;&'/% ,'% *% 2!'$*7
ZDUGYHORFLW\YHUVXVPXVFOHIRUFHXVHG
$-'%#(.&%'()/'
IRU\LQJDQLPDOV
IRUDJLYHQDQLPDO7KHVKDSHRI WKRVH
.#'0*)% 3+,5)#.% &'% &'7
FXUYHVFDQWHOOXVDORWDERXWKRZWKH
%*0&%1'234'4#&5&' VHFW IOLJKW JLYHQ WKDW
12,"'3%"'%4".5/
*'&.*)>"%4&'/"%*+#%"1*3#$8%1,4%2*"0%01#-%
(5&'%$+&'*)45*)%*6' &'"#(0"%.!"0%5#*0%01#&+%
I1#'%&0%(,.#"%0,%&'"#(0"8%
5#*08%*'$%1,4%4&'/%/#,.#0+-%(1*'/#"%
4&'/"% 1!'$+#$"% ,2 %
,*+*4(4*$)%'$)'
.!(1%,2 %01#%01#,+-%*33)&#$%
GXULQJLJKW7KH\KDYHEHHQXVHG
0&.#"%*%"#(,'$%0,%/#'7
KRZWKH\DUH
0,%)*+/#+%*'&.*)"%',%),'/#+%
WRVWXG\HYHU\WKLQJIURPFRPSDUDWLYH
#+*0#% #',!/1% )&208% 1,4%
6$)%4*434&/78
DSSOLHV )RU H[DPSOH DQ
.,+31,),/-% 5#04##'% 5&+$% "3#(&#"8% 0,%
(*'% 01#-% 3,""&5)-% *)0#+%
*'*)-"&"% ,2 % 2,!+% "3#(&#"%
41-%)*+/#%5&+$"%.!"0%/#'#+*))-%0*?&%*'$%
01#% 4&'/% .,0&,'"% 0,%
,2 % 2+!&0% 2)&#"% 4&01% "&.&)*+%
WKHQ\RYHUDOLPLWHGUDQJHRI VSHHGV
#?#(!0#%0!+'"%*'$%,01#+%
"1*3#"8%5!0%$&22#+#'0%.*""#"8%2,!'$%01*0% *$K!"0.#'0"L%%<,%*'"4#+%01&"%6!#"0&,'8%
41&)#%".*))%5&+$"%#?1&5&0%*%.!(1%4&$#+%
WKHVPDOOHULHVH[SHQGHGOHVVHQHUJ\ KHUODEKDVGHYHORSHGQRYHOPHWKRGV
UDQJHRI \LQJVSHHGVDQGPRGHV
*"%.#*"!+#$%5-%(*+5,'%$&,?&$#%,!03!08% 2,+%*'*)-=&'/%01#%;&'#.*0&(%$*0*%2+,.%
@'%ABCD8%E,)&'%F#''-(!&(;8%*%3&,'##+%
WKDQWKHODUJHURQHVZKLOHKRYHULQJ KLJKVSHHGYLGHRVRI LHV7KH\HPSOR\
&'% 01#% "0!$-% ,2 % *'&.*)% 2)&/108% 3#+7
01#%,33,"&0#%,2 %41*0%1*33#'"%&'%5&+$"% 3+&'(&3*)% (,.3,'#'0% *'*)-"&"8% "1*3#%
2,+.#$%*%"#.&'*)%"0!$-%#?3)*&'&'/%1,4%
,QVHFWV IRU WKH PRVW SDUW DUH *'*)-"&"8%*'$%(,.3!0*0&,'*)%/#,.#0+-%
KXPPLQJELUGV KRYHU +H VXJJHVWHG
VODYHV WR WKH YLVFRXV IRUFHV EDWWHULQJ 0,%#?0+*(0%*((!+*0#%3,"&0&,'%$*0*%2+,.%
1#)&(,30#+"8% ',0% 2&?#$74&'/% 3)*'#"8%
WKHLU WKLQ PHPEUDQRXV ZLQJV 7KH WKH \V IDVW EXW VXEWOH PRWLRQV
*"% 01#% 3+,3#+% .,$#)% 2,+% 5&+$% 2)&/10%
3+,5)#.%&"%',%),'/#+%01#%!"#%,2 %.!"()#"% 7KH\KDYHFRQFOXGHGWKDW\ZLQJVFDQ
/RRNLQJDWWKHDWVKDSHRI WKH
!"#$%&'(6&&8'??!9339,.>5%-%3#$%*>9"0?5%-%?@%2#'A#..#"B+2*!-<C*!-#$BD122BE>F80
!"#!"#$"#%&'()*+(*&,*$)*-#!"#$%&'!()**
!"#$%&'()*&%#(+*,-.
FUHGLWKWWSZZZHSDJRYUHJLRQHOGVKWPPHWKRGVJSVLQGH[KWPO
#$%&'(!)*+!,%-+.%+!$/!0.+123
!"#$%&'())$*+,-.+,/'0#+1,#1
!"# $%&"'"&# ()# *%+),%-('# ).+,-/)# *0(*# .7*"+# ),$7'(*,%-# 9+%$# (# 9%)),'# %9 #
SDVVLYHO\ UHVLVW WKH WHQGHQF\ IRU WKH $UJHQWDYLVWKHODUJHVW\LQJELUGHYHU
ZLQJWRLS7KDWUHVLVWDQFHFDXVHVDQ WRKDYHH[LVWHG7KHWHDPXVHGERQH
()1$$"*+1#,-#2,-/#%+,"-*(*,%-#*0(*#'"*)# &"-),*1#(-&#%*0"+#)*+74*7+('#$"()7+"3
WKH\WXUQXVLQJQRIXUWKHUDFWLYHZLQJ PHQWVWRFRQUPWKDWWKHKHDY\ELUG
PRYHPHQW7KH\KDYHDOVRXVHG ZDVLQGHHGDLHU7KH\VXJJHVWHG
WKLV PRGHO WR GHPRQVWUDWH WKDW DS3
VHYHUDO SRVVLEOH ZD\V WKH ELUG FRXOG
SLQJZLQJLJKWFDQUHTXLUHOHVVHQHUJ\ KDYHREWDLQHGWKHH[WUDHQHUJ\LWZRXOG
WKDQ[HGZLQJLJKWVXJJHVWLQJWKDW QHHG WR VXSSRUW LWV ZHLJKW ZKLOH \3
PDQHXYHUDELOLW\DQGHQHUJ\HIFLHQF\ ,-/:*0"# %.*,%-)# +(-/"# 9+%$# '"(.,-/#
-""&#-%*#!"#4%$."*,-/#
JRDOV
#
!"#$%&$#'($)*+,$
-.#%$#'($/0(12
:KLOH XLG PHFKDQ3
,4)# ',5"# 6(-/# (+"# $"(3
)7+,-/#2,-/#$%*,%-)#,-#
*0"# '(!8# !,%'%/,)*)# (+"#
7),-/#-"2#*1.")#%9 #&(*(#
DYDLODEOHWRWKHPWRH[3
SDQGWKHUDQJHRI LJKW
/04"5($ 78! "#$%&'! ()*! "+$$&,-*./0! 1213! ,&4)*05,%45-)*!
!,%$"40(-,4)# )*7&,")#
)6!75&,)8#459'%0!#*5-:%%0;!#!75&,)0#%,!6,)$!5<&!=%,#00-4!
7&,-)8>!"4-&*5-050!<#(&!$#*#.&8!$),&!#44%,#5&!)*&0!0-*4&>
GRQHLQWKHHOG:LQG
*7--"')# 7)"&# *%# !"# *0"#
.+,$(+1#2(1#%9 #4%''"4*,-/#.01),%'%/,3
%99 # (# ."+40# *%# *(5,-/# (# +7--,-/# )*(+*#
FDO DQG NLQHPDWLF GDWD IURP D \LQJ %99 #(-#,-4',-"#(-),-/#"-"+/1#9+%$#
DQLPDO4XDQWLWLHVOLNHPHWDEROLFUDWH WKHUPDOFROXPQV$QRWKHUJURXSRI
ZHUH UVW GHWHUPLQHG YHU\ LQGLUHFWO\ !,%'%/,)*)# 0()# &"*"+$,-"&# *0"# /',&,-/#
!1#$"()7+,-/#*0"#$())#(#!,+&#'%)*#&7+3
PHFKDQLVPRI DQHZO\GLVFRYHUHG\LQJ
LQJ D ORQJ LJKW
',;(+&#!1#-%*,-/#*0(*#
7KHVHGD\VWKHUH
(-&# ())7$,-/#
(# *0,45"-"&# +,!# ,$3
!"#$%#&%'"%($%!)#**+)#$
$%)*#%9 #*0(*#2()#
SOLHVKHDYLO\PXVFOHG
IDW ORVV 7KHVH
ZLQJV6WLOORWK3
)"!&%,+))#"%$!&-$-!)!$
&(1)8# *0"+"# (+"#
*'..#"%///0)1!)2$3"'4+-#$ "+)#4%-*,-7"#*%#)*7&1#
)"-)%+)8# )(*"'',*"#
*0"# .*"+%)(7+)8# *0"#
5&3"#6#-#&)#-$!66#%%$)'$
*+(-)$,**"+)# (-&#
HDUOLHVW YHUWHEUDWHV
&(*(#'%//"+)8#*0(*# DWPRVSKHULFSK\VLRORJLFDO WR GHYHORS DSSLQJ
!&-$7#1!4+'"!*$-!)!$'8$
(+"#)$(''#"-%7/0#
IOLJKW IRU HYLGHQFH
*%#(**(40#*%#(#!,+&# \LQJDQLPDOVLQWKHZLOG %9 # *0"# $"40(-,)$#
2,*0%7*# ),/-,9,3
!"0,-&# ,*)# "99,4,"-*#
4(-*'1# 40(-/,-/#
DQGFRQWUROOHGLJKW
LWVPRYHPHQWDQGDUHTXLFNHQRXJKWR DELOLWLHV
4%-)*(-*'1#)"-&#.01),%'%/,4('#(-&#$%3
WLRQGDWDWRWKHODE7KLVSURYLGHV 3%0.4$/%56*52
7-.+"4"&"-*"&#(44"))#*%#(*$%).0"+,48#
(QJLQHHUV DQG GRFWRUV DUH DOUHDG\
SK\VLRORJLFDO DQG EHKDYLRUDO GDWD RI (..'1,-/# *0"# 97-&($"-*('# !,%'%/1#
\LQJDQLPDOVLQWKHZLOG
DQG SK\VLFV RI DQLPDO LJKW WR PDQ
%LRORJLVWVFDQDOVRXVHSDOHRQWRORJL3
PDGH DSSOLDQFHV +HUH DW +DUYDUG
FDOHOGGDWDWRJXUHRXWZKHWKHUDQ 3URIHVVRU 5REHUW :RRG UXQV D 0L3
H[WLQFW VSHFLHV PLJKW KDYH RZQ $ 4+%!%*,4)# <(!%+(*%+1# *0(*# ,)# !7,'&,-/#
WHDP OHG E\ 6DQNDU &KDWHUMHH IURP PLFURVL]HGURERWLFLHVZLWKPLOLWDU\
7H[DV 7HFK 8QLYHUVLW\ PDGH D FRP3
DSSOLFDWLRQV +LV ZRUN LOOXPLQDWHV
$%+"#%9 #*0"#97-&($"-*('#)4,"-4"#3#!1#
WU\LQJWRUHFRQVWUXFW\LJKWKHKDV
OHDUQHGPRUHDERXWWKHSDVVLYHFRQWURO
RI PDQHXYHUV WKDW -DQH :DQJ QRWHG
$WWKHVDPHWLPHLQFRQVWUXFWLQJ
WKHVHURERWV:RRGDQGKLVWHDPKDYH
GHYHORSHG QHZ WHFKQLTXHV WR FUHDWH
DUWLFLDO LQVHFWOLNH ZLQJV :LWK
*0"# +"4"-*# "=.'%),%-# %9 # ,-*"+")*# (-&#
4%$.7*,-/#.%2"+8#*0"+"#,)#)7+"'1#$740#
PRUHWRFRPH
!"#$%&'()&* +#),-* ./0* (-* #)* 1223(&4*
5#$%&6#$(7-*78)7&)$'#$8'*()*9#:8$*;8<-&=
9(&(5(.:(;
!"#$%&'()**'!!"#$"#%&'()*+(*&,*$)*-&""!!