SECTION STRENGTH WEAKNESS

abstract UE== User equpment

this should have been mentioned in the
abstract
INTRODUCTION In this work, we propose a technique to
determine the optimal placement of
Femtos for ensuring certain minimum SNR
to all indoor UEs and thereby provide data
rates equivalent to that enjoyed by outdoor
UEs
Clear cut problem statement.
But the presence of a large number of
Femtos can lead to problems like high
inter-cell interference and frequent
handovers.
No remedy proposed
RELATED WORK Building upon the above work, we
constrained optimal Femto placement
problem by considering path loss across
walls and floors inside the building,
thereby making it a realistic enterprise
building scenario.
Why the paper occurs at the first place is
very clear.
reference no 7 is too old <2006>
PROPOSED WORK
B. Assumptions
Assumptions are very clearly point wise
written

PROPOSED WORK
C. Formulation of Mathematical Model
Equations which are copied are given with
proper reference no

the SNR at the farthest point of the sub-
region must be
higher than threshold SNR
This is basically if min is greater than
some threshold then all must be
greater than that threshold kind of
strategy.

Steps are very precise and clear But
Eqns (1) and (8) are non-convex
equations which cannot be solved by any
available tools. Hence these equations
are first converted to convex equations
and then to linear equations.

PROPOSED WORK
D. Femto placement constraints

We assume that a sub-region is serviced
only by a single Femto which
results in


This is probably an assumption saying no
overlap in service area.

Eqns (24), (25) and (26) are convex
constraints which are
converted into linear constraints by
applying PLAP (Piecewise
Linear Approximation) and leading to the
deduction of the following equations
Why not use convex optimization
LPP MODEL AND SOLUTION
B. Solution Procedure

That the algorithm enhances performance
..is only stated no proof or reference is
given