:

,

,

,

.

:

,
, .

:

, .
:

.
,

)(1

 "

".

-1 , -
,- , ,2001 .33

"
".
"
").(1
"

"

)(2

"
,

,
" .
"

".
:


2


, .
- 1 :

,

).(3

-1 , ,- ,
, , , .92,91,90
-2 , ,

, ,, .670
-3 , , ,,
.9

,
,



........ .

 ,
:
,
.
- 2 ) :( Excution


,
,
" " .

,

.

,

, .
,
.1976

*
,
.
* ,

:

.


.
*
.
*
.
*
).(1

).(2
- 3 :
,

.

-1 , , . 41,38

-2 , , ,
, ,1992 ,.308,307,

) (
,
,


.

9 98
01 ,

,
,

,
.
- 4 :
-02
250 24 2002
,
,

.

,
6


.
,

.

,

,

,
.


,
.

,

,
.


,

7

 ,
.

:

,
.
: :

,

)(1

-1 , ,
, , .120

,
2
27-91
, .

,

,

.
8

 ) (


,

,
,


, .

:
*
.
*

125 "

" .
*
.
*
,
124 "
93 " .
9

 :



,

).(1
:

.


,
,
.


,

)(2

,
.


,

10

-1 , , .129,123
-2 .

) .(1

.


.

,

)(2

).(3

).(4

:
,

,
.
:
11

)(5

-1 , , , , 59,5
-2
...
-3
.
-4
.

.
-5 , , ,
, , , .301

.


,
,
.

).(1

,
,
12


,
,
).(2
,


),(3

)(4

)(5

,
.

-1 , , , . 316
-2 , , .90
-3
25
.
-4 , , .317
-5 : .

:


,
, 71
13



).(1


.

,
,


).(2

.
:

,

) .(3

,

.

-1 , , .40
14

-2 , , .157,156
-3 , , .72

.

)(1
.
.

,

(2

.

,
.
:

,

).(3

.

4 " 88/131
15



".

-1 , .74
-2 , , .124
-3 , , .152

: ) (

),(1

,

22
" ".

,
.


.

16



) .(2 ,

,


,

.

-1 , , .83
-2 , ,
, ,2005 , .91

)(1

.

,

)(2

17

 ,

" "

" ,
.


.
,
,


.
.

).(3

,
.

-1 , .518,
-2 , , .172
-3 , , 93,92

18

 "
"MATTEL
13/07/1948

, "
"MATTEL ).(1

15/11/2005 019341

),(2
". "

,87/19

,

". ",

.

:

.
: :

).(3
19

-1 , , .218
-2 , ,2005 ,07 .133
-3 , , .131

26
" 131-88
" ,


).(1

,
),(2



.


.

,

20


).(3

35 131-88 "

"). (4

,

-1 ,
, , .258
-2 , , .132
-3 , , .136
-4 , , .186

.


,
.
,


.

,

21

.(1

,
.
23

.


.

,

.

-1 , , .188

08/04/1989 " ."
, 54362 " ."
,

22


,


,

)(1

19/04/1999
160507 " ".......

.

015869 , 12/07/2005
" ."
11/01/1996 96/2220

" "
88/131

. 169

-1 , , ,03 ,1991 .165

23

 .

169 ,
829



.


.


,
.

548 , 06/12/1999

.
:
,


.
24

.(1

,

-1 , , .181,180

),(1


.

).(2

,
).(3




, ,
.
25



.
,

8 131/ 88 04 1988
, "

" .
9 "

".

-1 49 "
15
52 51 50
".
-2 , , ,.......... ,
-3 , , .102

,
.

,

26



.


151-81
18 1981
).(1
6 293-95


51 59-85

)(2

829
.

,

,

-1 03 ,
07
.
27

-2 , , .184

).(1


,
.
96 "


".


, ,

.

,

.

,


:
.
28

-1 , , .109

.

,

,

).(1

.

,



29

 .
.

,

.
,


. 26/07/1950




.

-1 , , .107

,


.

,
30

 " "
.

,

.



, ,

.
"
"

,


.




,
,
31


.


,

,
.



.

,

, .

,

, " "
".......

" .


).(1
32


"

-1 , , . 110

".
17/11/1948 "

".
14/01/1948
"
35
,
.



,

".


.

33



.



,

,
.


.

12/01/1934 "
" " vendon 30/11/1929
22/11/1929 ", "gironde

. 22/11/1929
"" La coste .
:
,

,
34

 ,
.

,

.
,

.

.

.

,



).(1
35

 ,

.

,

).(2




829
.

,
.

,

,
,

-1 , , . 619
36

-2 , , .193

.

).(1
,

:

.

,

.
"


,

" ).(2


.

.

37


,

.

-1 , , . 141,140
-2 , , . 194,193

).(1

,

,

.

, 1991

.

,
.


38


.




.

,

.(2

11/04/1993
" . "

-1 , , . 145
-2 , , .144

"

,

.



39


" ).(1




.
1999-06-28
"....

,
,
,
).(2

)(3

23/10/2000 620

, 16/03/1965
15/07/1998

-1 , , , 1999 . 219
-2 , 1 , .
-3 , , . 196
40

 ,

,1997
"" .
18/11/1997
,

. 2000

41

 :


,

, .


,

,
,

.

:




,

.

42

:



.

.


.







, .

1940 ,

.


43

 ,



.
557 1956


.

1940


.
1959



,

,
" 22
55 1959

,

44


".


68 ... " 10434

.(1) "....

)(2

275
.

"


"
279 .

-1 , , .542
-2
,
, 1990
.

45


280


, )(1
.

830 "
,
829

)(2

.


".




.



,


46



,
,

-1 , , .67
-2 829
,
.

,
.



,
23 , 1952
15 ,1953

,

47

,
:
,
11
-15 1943 -"
" ,

,
,


.

,

. " "Rog



", "Dastillon

,

,
48

 .

"
"

.


.
11 88/131


.

,
,


.


49

 ,




.

:



.
* :


.

, , ,
,
.
""
"
,
.
"" "

50

 ,
".
,
1952
1923
,


, ,

).(1



,


,


.
"" "

,
"

)(2

.
51

 " " "

" .
"
)
(
" .

-1 , , . 524
rvro ,droit administratif ,3eme edition , page 92-2

* :

,

,
,
,
,

.(1

,
" " ,
"

52

 ,
".
" "


" " ,

.


,

,


).(2

-1 , , , ,
. 225
duperoux ,la rgle de la non retreoactivit des actes administrative ,page 95-2

,

53

 ,

.


,

,

.

" " MATTEL ,1952
13/07/1948
" " MATTEL

05/01/1999 ,
31/01/1999 ,
" " MATTEL
,
,
.


.

, 73
54

 131-88

.

,




.

:
,


.
,
)(1

,
.



55

 .
,

)(2

-1 , , . 579
-2 ,

.

,
.

).(1

:


,
, .

,
,

.

,

56

 ,
.
* :


,

.

)(1

-1 , , . 532

.

,
,
.
" "

, .
" "


57


.
" " Helbronner
,
,

.
. 1913
1910

,

,1875
,


,


,

.

.
1953
1950
58

.
1935

1947
40
,

,
.

"

,
.


,

.


,
" .
59


04/02/1964


,
.

, 1960
" ...
,

,
" .


,

.

1947 /05/ 03

.


" "
60


.



).(1
" " ODENT

,

-1 , , . 538

.
.

.
" " ODENT

,
,


.

,

61


.
" " ODENT
,

.

.

,10/08/1945

,
12/05/1941
.
31/12/1941
30/09/1942 ,03/04/1942
20/02/1942
03/04/1942
.

10/11/1942 " NANTES
"
.

.
62



, 1953
.

,

).(1

,
:

.


.

,
.

.

.
-1 , , 542

63

* :
" "
.


,
" .



.



,
.

"

" .


.
" "


64

 ,


,

,
.

15
).(1

,





.


, .

65






,


,
.

-1 , , . 543

,

,

.
,
,
169 "
66


,
" .


,

,

.


.

)(1 ,

.

829 "

-1 , ,-
, ,2005, .329

" .
67

 830 "

. " 829


,
,

.
.

,


,
.

.
"


" .
.


08/05/1922 ""FORTIER
68

 " "FORTIER " BARRE

" fORTIER 49000 .
""FORTIER
01/04/1821
, 19/07/1821
"
"FORTIER
,
""FORTIER
01/04/1821
,

.

,

,
.


,
.


69


).(1


,
.


88/131 04 1988

-1
, , .

6 30
:
.

35 "

"
.

,

73

70


.


,
.


, 35
37 88/131 169 278

)(1

829
,

.
:


,

1 " 278 275

".

.
169

, 282
71


.
169
282

).(1



.

, ,

50840 16
. 1988
282


),(2
169

.


18 1990 169

72

-1 , , . 287
-2 ,
.

,


.


.... .



,
.


282 ,

.


, 282
.
73

 282

,
169
.

,


.

,
170

.

819 ,
,
.

.


74


,

.

,


, 170
24/07/1994 " 111973

" .
50840 /16 1988/
"
. ".........


,
.

75