Domestic Violence in Same-Sex Couples
Emily Johnson
Erin Seldat-Kline
April 19, 2012Johnson
Domestic Violence in Same-Sex Couples
typically when one is asked to think of domestic and
intimate partner violence, one is inclined to picture a drunk
overweight man in a wife-beater smacking his wife around while
their children hide in their rooms. However, there is another
dark side of domestic abuse that does not get near the attention
it deserves: violence and abuse in same-sex relationships. Very
Little is known about domestic and intimate partner violence
within same-sex couples when compared with what is known about
violence within heterosexual couples
Research has continued to provide solid evidence supporting
the notion that the prevalence of domestic abuse within same-sex
relationships mirrora that of heterosexual relationships
however, the differences lay in the help-seeking behaviors of
the individuals involved and the resources available to them
(Hester et al., 2010), as well as the methodologies implemented
in studying same-sex domestic violence
Several factors present obstacles that prevent researchers
from collecting valid and reliable data concerning same-sex
domestic vielence-obstacles that interfere with research results
and thus cannot adequately represent the group studied
Historically, research methods have developed and molded to fit
and reflect the socio-economic and political context of the
particular era. Also, with the introduction of new interest
groups (and therefore new needs of these groups) these methodsJohnson
Domestic Violence in Same-Sex Couples
change. As such, different research methods with different
levels of credibility and impact can be found across the globe
(Hester et al., 2010).
These differing methodologies can pose problems in
accurately researching and documenting differences between
genders. There exists a “gendered paradigm war” when it comes to
researching domestic violence within same-sex relationships
greater emphasis on qualitative research within lesbian couples
on quantitative research within gay male couples. such
qualitative research includes interviews and surveys, while
quantitative research leans more towards questionnaires (Hester
et al., 2010).
This variety of methodologies often results in invalid and
unreliable data. Recorded prevalence rates for physical violence
have been shown to vary 88-69% in lesbian relationships and 118—
47% in gay male relationships (Hester et al., 2010). One of the
earliest studies regarding same-sex domestic violence suggested
a 47% perpetration rate amongst same-sex couples, but more
recent results show that 47.5% of lesbian but only 29.78 of gay
males experience intimate partner violence (Brown and Groscup
2008). Results from another study showed that within the sample
represented, 22% of lesbian and 298 of gay male relationships
have experienced regular abuse-physical, psychological
emotional, sexual-from a partner (Hester et al., 2010)