Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Decsion Making Powerpoint
Decsion Making Powerpoint
Decision Making
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 01
Preference matrix
Table that allows managers to rate alternatives based on several
performance criteria.
Decision theory
Approach when outcomes associated with alternatives are
in doubt.
Decision Tree
Model to compare alternatives and their possible
consequences.
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 02
Quantity (Q)
The number of customers served or units produced per
year.
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 03
Break-Even Analysis
Total cost = F + cQ
Total revenue = pQ
A - 04
Example A.1
A hospital is considering a new procedure to be offered at
$200 per patient. The fixed cost per year would be $100,000
with total variable costs of $100 per patient. What is the
break-even quantity for this service? Use both algebraic and
graphic approaches to get the answer.
The formula for the break-even quantity yields
100,000
F
=
Q=
= 1,000 patients
p-c
200 100
A - 05
Example A.1
The following table shows the results for Q = 0 and Q = 2,000
Quantity
(patients)
(Q)
100,000
2,000
300,000
400,000
A - 06
Example A.1
400
300
(2000, 400)
Profits
(2000, 300)
Total annual costs
Break-even quantity
200
100
Loss
Fixed costs
|
500
1000
1500
Patients (Q)
2000
A - 07
Application A.1
The Denver Zoo must decide whether to move twin polar bears to Sea
World or build a special exhibit for them and the zoo. The expected
increase in attendance is 200,000 patrons. The data are:
Revenues per Patron for Exhibit
Gate receipts
$4
Concessions
$5
Licensed apparel
$15
Estimated Fixed Costs
Exhibit construction
Salaries
Food
$2,400,000
$220,000
$30,000
Is the predicted
increase in
attendance
sufficient to
break even?
A -08
Application A.1
TR = pQ
$0
$6,000,000
TC = F + cQ
$2,650,000
$5,400,000
Where
p = 4 + 5 + 15 = $24
F = 2,400,000 + 220,000 + 30,000
= $2,650,000
c = 2 + 9 = $11
Q
0
250,000
5
4
3
2
1
0 |
50
100
150
200
250
Q (thousands of patrons)
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 09
Application A.1
Q
TR = pQ
TC = F + cQ
0
250,000
$0
$6,000,000
$2,650,000
$5,400,000
Where
p = 4 + 5 + 15 = $24
F = 2,400,000 + 220,000 + 30,000
= $2,650,000
c = 2 + 9 = $11
A - 10
Example A.2
If the most pessimistic sales forecast for the proposed
service from Example 1 was 1,500 patients, what would be
the procedures total contribution to profit and overhead per
year?
pQ (F + cQ) =
= $50,000
A - 11
Fm
The fixed cost of the make option
cb
The variable cost (per unit) of the buy option
cm
The variable cost of the make option
A - 12
Make-or-buy decision
Total cost to buy
Fb + cbQ
A - 13
Example A.3
A fast-food restaurant featuring hamburgers is adding
salads to the menu
The price to the customer will be the same
Fixed costs are estimated at $12,000 and variable costs
totaling $1.50 per salad
Preassembled salads could be purchased from a local
supplier at $2.00 per salad
Preassembled salads would require additional
refrigeration with an annual fixed cost of $2,400
Expected demand is 25,000 salads per year
What is the break-even quantity?
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 14
Example A.3
The formula for the break-even quantity yields the
following:
Fm Fb
Q= c c
b
m
=
12,000 2,400
= 19,200 salads
2.0 1.5
A - 15
Application A.2
At what volume should the Denver Zoo be
indifferent between buying special sweatshirts from
a supplier or have zoo employees make them?
Fixed costs
Buy
$0
Make
$300,000
Variable costs
$9
$7
Fm Fb
Q= c c
b
m
300,000 0
Q= 97
Q = 150,000
A - 16
Preference Matrix
A Preference Matrix is a table that allows you to
rate an alternative according to several
performance criteria.
The criteria can be scored on any scale as long as the same
scale is applied to all the alternatives being compared.
A - 17
Example A.4
The following table shows the performance criteria, weights,
and scores (1 = worst, 10 = best) for a new thermal storage air
conditioner. If management wants to introduce just one new
product and the highest total score of any of the other product
ideas is 800, should the firm pursue making the air conditioner?
Performance Criterion
Market potential
30
240
20
10
200
Operations compatibility
20
120
Competitive advantage
15
10
150
Investment requirements
10
20
20
Project risk
Weighted score =
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
750
A - 18
Example A.4
Because the sum of the weighted scores is 750, it falls short
of the score of 800 for another product. This result is
confirmed by the output from OM Explorers Preference
Matrix Solver below
Total
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
750
A - 19
Application A.3
The following table shows the performance criteria, weights, and
scores (1 = worst, 10 = best) for a new thermal storage air
conditioner. If management wants to introduce just one new
product and the highest total score of any of the other product
ideas is 800, should the firm pursue making the air conditioner?
Performance Criterion
Market potential
10
50
30
240
Operations compatibility
20
10
Competitive advantage
25
Investment
requirements
10
30
20
Project risk
No.
Because
715 >800
Weighted score =
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
200
175
715
A - 20
A - 21
Example A.5
A manager is deciding whether to build a small or a large
facility
Much depends on the future demand
Demand may be small or large
Payoffs for each alternative are known with certainty
A - 22
Example A.5
The best choice is the one with the highest payoff
Alternative
Small facility
Large facility
Do nothing
A - 23
Laplace
Minimax Regret
A - 24
Example A.6
Reconsider the payoff matrix in Example 5. What is the best
alternative for each decision rule?
a. Maximin. An alternatives worst payoff is the lowest
Worst Payoff
200
160
A - 25
Example A.6
b. Maximax. An alternatives best payoff ($000) is the
Best Payoff
Small facility
270
Large facility
800
A - 26
Example A.6
c. Laplace. With two events, we assign each a probability
Weighted Payoff
0.5(200) + 0.5(270) = 235
0.5(160) + 0.5(800) = 480
A - 27
Example A.6
d. Minimax Regret. If demand turns out to be low, the best
Alternative
Low Demand
High Demand
Small facility
200 200 = 0
Large facility
200 160 = 40
800 800 = 0
Maximum
Regret
530
40
The column on the right shows the worst regret for each
alternative. To minimize the maximum regret, pick a
large facility. The biggest regret is associated with having
only a small facility and high demand.
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 28
Application A.4
Fletcher (a realist), Cooper (a pessimist), and Wainwright (an
optimist) are joint owners in a company. They must decide
whether to make Arrows, Barrels, or Wagons. The government
is about to issue a policy and recommendation on pioneer
travel that depends on whether certain treaties are obtained.
The policy is expected to affect demand for the products;
however it is impossible at this time to assess the probability
of these policy events. The following data are available:
Payoffs (Profits)
Alternative
Land Routes
No treaty
Land Routes
Treaty
Sea Routes
Only
Arrows
$840,000
$440,000
$190,000
Barrels
$370,000
$220,000
$670,000
Wagons
$25,000
$1,150,000
($25,000)
A - 29
Application A.4
Which product would be favored by Fletcher (realist)?
Fletcher (realist Laplace) would choose arrows
Which product would be favored by Cooper (pessimist)?
Cooper (pessimist Maximin) would choose barrels
Which product would be favored by Wainwright (optimist)?
Wainwright (optimist Maximax) would choose wagons
What is the minimax regret solution?
The Minimax Regret solution is arrows
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 30
A - 31
Example A.7
Reconsider the payoff matrix in Example 5. For the expected
value decision rule, which is the best alternative if the
probability of small demand is estimated to be 0.4 and the
probability of large demand is estimated to be 0.6?
The expected value for each
alternative is as follows:
Alternative
Possible Future
Demand
Alternative
Small
Large
Small facility
200
270
Large facility
160
800
Expected Value
Small facility
Large facility
The large
facility is
the best
alternative.
A - 32
Application A.5
For Fletcher, Cooper, and Wainwright, find the best decision
using the expected value rule. The probabilities for the events
are given below.
What alternative has the best expected results?
Land routes,
No Treaty
(0.50)
Land Routes,
Treaty Only
(0.30)
Sea routes,
Only (0.20)
Arrows
840,000
440,000
190,000
Barrels
370,000
220,000
670,000
Wagons
25,000
1,150,000
-25,000
Alternative
A - 33
Application A.5
Land routes, No
Treaty
(0.50)
Land Routes,
Treaty Only
(0.30)
Arrows
(.50) * 840,000` +
Barrels
(.50) * 370,000` +
Wagons
(.50) * 25,000` +
Alternative
(.30)* 1,150,000 +
Sea routes
Only (0.20)
Expected Value
Arrows is the
best alternative.
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 34
Decision Trees
E1 & Probability
E2 & Probability
E3 & Probability
Payoff 1
Payoff 2
Payoff 3
Alternative 3
1st
decision
Alternative 5
Possible
2nd decision
E2 & Probability
= Event node
Alternative 4
E3 & Probability
Payoff 1
Payoff 2
Payoff 3
Payoff 1
Payoff 2
= Decision node
Ei = Event i
P(Ei) = Probability of event i
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 35
Example A.8
A retailer will build a small or a large facility at a new location
Demand can be either small or large, with probabilities
estimated to be 0.4 and 0.6, respectively
For a small facility and high demand, not expanding will have a
payoff of $223,000 and a payoff of $270,000 with expansion
For a small facility and low demand the payoff is $200,000
For a large facility and low demand, doing nothing has a payoff
of $40,000
The response to advertising may be either modest or sizable,
with their probabilities estimated to be 0.3 and 0.7, respectively
For a modest response the payoff is $20,000 and $220,000 if the
response is sizable
For a large facility and high demand the payoff is $800,000
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 36
Example A.8
Low demand [0.4]
Dont expand
2
1
Expand
$200
$223
$270
Do nothing
$40
Advertise
Sizable response [0.7]
$20
$220
A - 37
Example A.8
Low demand [0.4]
Dont expand
2
1
Expand
$200
$223
$270
0.3 x $20 = $6
Do nothing
$40
$20
Advertise
$6 + $154 = $160
$220
A - 38
Example A.8
Low demand [0.4]
Dont expand
Expand
$200
$223
$270
Do nothing
$40
Advertise
$160
$160
$20
$220
A - 39
Example A.8
Low demand [0.4]
Dont expand
Expand
$270
1
$200
$223
$270
Do nothing
$40
Advertise
$160
$160
$20
$220
A - 40
Example A.8
Low demand [0.4]
$200
x 0.4 = $80
Dont expand
Expand
$270
1
$223
$270
x 0.6 = $162
Do nothing
$40
Advertise
$160
$160
$20
$220
A - 41
Example A.8
Low demand [0.4]
$200
$242
Dont expand
Expand
$270
1
$223
$270
Do nothing
$40
Advertise
$160
0.4 x $160 = $64
$544
$160
$20
$220
x 0.6 = $480
A - 42
Example A.8
Low demand [0.4]
$200
$242
Dont expand
Expand
$270
$223
$270
Do nothing
$40
$544
Advertise
$160
$160
$544
$20
$220
A - 43
Application A.6
a. Draw the decision tree for the Fletcher, Cooper, and
Wainwright Application 5
b. What is the expected payoff for the best alternative
in the decision tree below?
Land routes,
No Treaty
(0.50)
Land Routes,
Treaty Only
(0.30)
Arrows
840,000
440,000
190,000
Barrels
370,000
220,000
670,000
Wagons
25,000
1,150,000
-25,000
Alternative
A - 44
Application A.6
A - 45
Solved Problem 1
A small manufacturing business has patented a new
device for washing dishes and cleaning dirty kitchen sinks
The owner wants reasonable assurance of success
Variable costs are estimated at $7 per unit produced and
sold
Fixed costs are about $56,000 per year
a. If the selling price is set at $25, how many units must be
b. Forecasted sales for the first year are 10,000 units if the
price is reduced to $15. With this pricing strategy, what
would be the products total contribution to profits in the
first year?
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 46
Solved Problem 1
a. Beginning with the algebraic approach, we get
Q=
56,000
F
=
pc
25 7
= 3,111 units
Using the graphic approach, shown in Figure A.6, we first draw
two lines:
Total revenue = 25Q
Total cost = 56,000 + 7Q
The two lines intersect at Q = 3,111 units, the break-even
quantity
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 47
Solved Problem 1
250
200
Total revenues
150
Break-even
quantity
100
$77.7
Total costs
50
3.1
0
A - 48
Solved Problem 1
b. Total profit contribution
A - 49
Solved Problem 2
Herron Company is screening three new product idea: A, B, and C.
Resource constraints allow only one of them to be commercialized. The
performance criteria and ratings, on a scale of 1 (worst) to 10 (best),
are shown in the following table. The Herron managers give equal
weights to the performance criteria. Which is the best alternative, as
indicated by the preference matrix method?
Performance Criteria
1. Demand uncertainty and project risk
2. Similarity to present products
3. Expected return on investment (ROI)
4. Compatibility with current
manufacturing process
5. Competitive Strategy
Product A
3
7
10
4
Rating
Product B
9
8
4
7
Product C
2
6
8
6
A - 50
Solved Problem 2
Each of the five criteria receives a weight of
1/5 or 0.20
Product
Calculation
Total Score
= 5.6
= 6.8
= 5.4
A - 51
Solved Problem 3
Adele Weiss manages the campus flower shop. Flowers must
be ordered three days in advance from her supplier in Mexico.
Although Valentines Day is fast approaching, sales are almost
entirely last-minute, impulse purchases. Advance sales are so
small that Weiss has no way to estimate the probability of low
(25 dozen), medium (60 dozen), or high (130 dozen) demand for
red roses on the big day. She buys roses for $15 per dozen and
sells them for $40 per dozen. Construct a payoff table. Which
decision is indicated by each of the following decision criteria?
a. Maximin
b. Maximax
c. Laplace
d. Minimax regret
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
A - 52
Solved Problem 3
The payoff table for this problem is
Demand for Red Roses
Low
(25 dozen)
Alternative
Medium
(60 dozen)
High
(130 dozen)
Order 25 dozen
$625
$625
$625
Order 60 dozen
$100
$1,500
$1,500
($950)
$450
$3,250
$0
$0
$0
Do nothing
A - 53
Solved Problem 3
a. Under the Maximin criteria, Weiss should order 25 dozen, because
if demand is low, Weisss profits are $625, the best of the worst
payoffs.
b. Under the Maximax criteria, Weiss should order 130 dozen. The
greatest possible payoff, $3,250, is associated with the largest
order.
c. Under the Laplace criteria, Weiss should order 60 dozen. Equally
weighted payoffs for ordering 25, 60, and 130 dozen are about
$625, $1,033, and $917, respectively.
d. Under the Minimax regret criteria, Weiss should order 130 dozen.
The maximum regret of ordering 25 dozen occurs if demand is
high: $3,250 $625 = $2,625. The maximum regret of ordering 60
dozen occurs if demand is high: $3,250 $1,500 = $1,750. The
maximum regret of ordering 130 dozen occurs if demand is low:
$625 ($950) = $1,575.
A - 54
Copyright 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall
Solved Problem 4
White Valley Ski Resort is planning the ski lift operation for its
new ski resort and wants to determine if one or two lifts will
be necessary. Each lift can accommodate 250 people per day
and skiing occurs 7 days per week in the 14-week season and
lift tickets cost $20 per customer per day. The table below
shows all the costs and probabilities for each alternative and
condition. Should the resort purchase one lift or two?
Alternatives
Conditions
One lift
Two lifts
Utilization
Installation
Operation
0.9
$50,000
$200,000
1.0
$50,000
$200,000
1.0
$50,000
$200,000
0.9
$90,000
$200,000
1.5
$90,000
$400,000
1.9
$90,000
$400,000
A - 55
Solved Problem 4
The decision tree is shown on the following slide. The payoff
($000) for each alternative-event branch is shown in the
following table. The total revenues from one lift operating at
100 percent capacity are $490,000 (or 250 customers 98 days
$20/customer-day).
Alternatives
Economic Conditions
One lift
Bad times
Normal times
Good times
Bad times
Normal times
Good times
Two lifts
A - 56
Solved Problem 4
Bad times [0.3]
0.3(191) + 0.5(240) +
0.2(240) = 225.3
Normal times [0.5]
$191
$240
One lift
$225.3
$256.0
Two lifts
$256.0
0.3(151) + 0.5(245) +
0.2(441) = 256.0
$240
$151
$245
$441
A - 57
A - 58