EVALUATION NORMS

TITLE OF PAPER

MAM, NO QUIERO MAS: LOOKING AHEAD IN THE REMEDIATION OF

FEEDING DISORDERS IN HISPANIC INFANTS
Ailema Fernandez Frigerio, PsyD, LMHC
Carlos Albizu University, United States of America
Referee: Roberto Kertsz, MD, Ph.D. rkertesz@uflo.edu.ar . November 23, 2014
The topic of the paper is significative for the posible public?

Yes
X

No

Does it contain new and innovative data, as a positive contribution?

(Not necessarily indicated for informative papers)

Yes
X

No

The interpretations of data and results, and the conclusions are adequately
fundamented?

Yes
X

No

The title corresponds appropriately to the contents? Comple Very Well Little
tely
well
X
The abstract or summary provides suffcient
Comple Very Well Little
information, specially when it is readed isolately?
tely
well
?
X

Nothing

The key words are appropriate?

Comple Very Well Little

tely
well
X

Nothing

The paper is written to be read by different publics? Comple Very Well Little
tely
well
X

Nothing

The references are adequate, sufficient and

according to the scientific norms?

Nothing

Only for empirical papers

The general organization of the article
is adequate?

Comple Very Well Little

tely
well
X

Nothing

Comple Very
tely
well

Well
X

Little

Nothing

The description and information

Regarding materials and methods is
adequate?

Comple Very
tely
well

Well
X

Little

Nothing

Results are presented clearly?

Comple Very
tely
well

Well

Little

Nothing

Little

Nothing

X
The discussion and the conclusions are
consistent with the results?

Comple Very
tely
well
X

Well

Final reccomendations
To accept the paper as it is presented

Yes
X
Yes

No

Yes

No

The paper can be accepted alter a thorough revision

The paper can not be accepted