17 2011

20

. , Phil
2001 (
2001),

(.),
,

. ,
- ,
.
,
.
, 8 2010,
. ,
, ...
,
think tanks, .. ,

, .
, ,
,
.
/(),
[INSTITUTE FOR SECURITY AND DEFENCE ANALYSIS /ISDA],


, ,
,
,

.

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

 -
.2292/95
2984/02, ,
,
,
, ..
(EA), 2007,

()
().
,
3883/2010,
.

(), , ,
()
() :
,
- ,
.. ( - )
,
()
.
- ,

.

.
:
.

()

(1)



.
(2)

.

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

(3)
()

(/) ()

(/)
()
(),
().
.

()

(1)
,


.
(2)
,
.
(3)
/, (5) ,
-
(), .
, .
15 2010,

,
.
, ,
( ).
,
.
, .

(/ /),
,



.

2005,



, (, ,
, ),

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org


.
,
,
, ,

,
-

.
,

,
, ,
(

)
(
).

,
,


.

-
,
, ,
,
,
. ,
(),
(),
,

.
,

,

().
,

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org


.
. ,

.
.
, -
,
.
,

. ,

-
IFOR, SFOR, ALBA KFOR.
, ,
, . ,
,
,

.

,
,
,

. ,

, (..
). -
,
,
casus belli
.


- ,



.


,
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

 ,
- ,
.
, .E
,
,
(),
.

.
() 2001
2005,
,
,
,
.

. ,

.
, ,
.
.


.
,
.
, ,
, ,
. , ,
- ,
.


. , ,
.
()


. ,
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org


, ,
. ,
,
.
Sir Jullian Corbet
.
, ,
.
/ ,
, ,
,
.
, [.. ]
,
.
.
, .

, Sir Michael Howard.
,
- ,

. , ,

.

- .
,

. ,
.
,
, ,
.
,
,
,
, .
,
.
,
,

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

 -
, .
,
, : - .
-
,
.
, -,
. ,

.

.

. ,

,

. ,

, , ,
.
,

,
.
, , ,



.
.

.

.

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

,
, ,
: ,
:
.

.
:
.
.
,
,
, ,
.
, ,
.
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

 .

.
.
,
,
().
.

:
.
;

.
.
.
,
.
.
- .

.
. lessons learned
- .
.
. ,
Sun Tzu, , Clausewitz, Corbet, Jomini, Liddell Hart,
Tukhachevsky, Sokolovsky ..,
- .
.

.
.
.
,
.
:
, , .
,
.
,
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

10

 . , ,
.
, ,
.


. ,
,
,
.

: , .
, .

.

. ,
.
()
,
. ,


(The cult of offensive),

,
.
.

,
,
1930
litzkrieg. 1956
Blitzkrieg
1956 1967 1973.

.

.

,

.

,

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

11

 .
, .

, status quo,
.
[
,
,
],
- ,
.

/preemptive strike.
,


. , .
,

.
,

.

-

,

. ,
,

( .. 2020: New Strategic Concept, .U.:
Europe 2020 Strategy/European Security and Defence Policy (ESDP),
- , - ).
,
,
,

,
.
, ,
. ,
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

12

 . , ,
,
.
( - )
, -,
, ,
.

1
.

R. Lloyd, Strategy and Force Planning Framework, in Strategy and Force Planning Faculty, ed.,
Strategy and Force Planning, (Newport: Naval War College Press, 2000), pp. 1-4, see also
D.Ochmanek, S.Hosmer, The Context for Defence Planning: The Environment, Strategy and Mission, in
st
Z.Khalizad, D.Ochmanek, eds., Strategy and Defence Planning for 21 Century, (Santa Monica: RAND,
1997), pp.35-40.

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

13

, ,
/
,
:

;
,

;

,

;

;

;

/ ;


;
,
,

;


;


( )


,
;
,
,

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

14


.
,
, ,
(/)
,
.
,
(), 72,
3, . 3433/2006 ( 20)
,
,

, .
, ,
,
,
.
: ()
().
()
, ,
, ,
() ,

, ,
..
.
,
,
.
,
, '
.
,
, , ,
. ,
, ,
(),
.
,
.
, 2001
2005

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

15

 ,
.
,
.
:

;

,
;
;
(, ,
, ),
,

,
.

.
, ,
/
[failed states / rogue states].
,
,
.

.

.
,
,
- .
-,
,

,

.
,

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

16


.

,
.
, 1990,
,
.

, . ,

(), 12 2010,


, , .


.
. ,
Helmuth von Moltke
: ,
,
.
, : ,
,
,
. , ,
, ;

.
.
, ;
.
,
! (...).
, .
,

. ,
- -
,

!
,

,

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

17


-,

!.

, 1974!
, .

,
[, , ] , ,

[Low Intensity Conflict / LIC] [High Intensity
Conflict/HIC]. ,
/ !
,
,
,
,
,

,

.
,
..,
,
. ,

, (
)
.

,
-
, ,

.

.
,
,
,
, - . ,
,

, circles of threat.
,

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

18

 , ,
,
( - ) .
1974
,

/ . ,
, ,
, .., ,
(), . ,
,
,
21 ,
/
.
, ,

,
1996
.. ,
.
-. ,


.
,


,
-

,


( , ,
, , ,
...).

-


, .

(grand strategy). ,
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

19

 ,
,
,

, .
,
,
.


.

,
.
,
, ,
.
, - ,
,
- .

. 2001 ,

:



()


, -
,
.
, :
.
status quo.
.
, .

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA

17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

20

.
.
;
,
.
. ,

,
.
.
,

.
,
, .
,

,
.

,
,
.
,

, ,
, - , -

.


!


,
.


.
,

1987, ,
(, 1993), (1996),
(1997),

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

21

 (MoU).
,
:
(, , , )
(
, , ). ,
:
, ,
,
, .
-
, /
.
, ,
,
,
.

1987, ,
.
1987,
1996

S-300 , 1998-99.
,

() - . ,
,
,

:
, (deterrence by denial),


(deterrence by punishment).


, .

-
. , ,
- - ,

. ,


() .
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

22

 ,
. ,
,

, -
, ,
(counter-offensive capabilities) ,

2001, .

, ,
.
,
;
:
. ,
status quo , , ,

,

.

. ,
,
,
,
.
- - - -
.
.
/
.
,
.


.


.
.
, .
,
.
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

23

 ,
,

.

: (maneuver-mobility),
.


-
- RMA (Revolution in Military
Affairs) RBA (Revolution in Business
Affairs). , ,

.
, -
(Revolution in Military Affairs Revolution in Business Affairs / RMA-RBA)
.
, .


,

,

.
,
,

( ).
,


ad hoc
, .
,



:
.
.
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

24

 / (
/21 ) V, .
.. .
.
.

,
, .
:
.

. , ,

. ,
,
.
.
,
,
.
,
.
.

.
, ,


/ ;
.
.
, (mandate)

.


.
, ;
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

25

 .
-
.
, , ,
. ,
,
.
, ,
,
.
,

,
.
,
.
. statusquo , ,
. ,
,
,
.

,

- ,
: ,
-
, ,
.

-
,
,
,

.
,
, ,

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

26

, ,
:
.
.
.
.
.
- .

.

.
,

, , ,
,
, , ,


,
,
.



. ,

(),
, ().

, (, , ,
) ,
/
,
/ ,
/ .
,
,
,
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

27

 ,

.

- ,


. , ,
,

.
,
, ,
,
.
10 15 .
,
.
,
!

. .
(
)

,


.

,
, ,
:
,
,

/

Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

28

 .
,
,
.
,
,

.



.
,

(extended deterrence) ,

.
,
,
, .

:


.
,
,
,
.


. ,
, ,
, , (..) ,
.
,
,

.
...
,
,


,
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

29


...

2001, /
1998 1999,
, 20-1, (, , 2003)
, 21 , (, 2007)
UKs MoD/Directorate of Air Staff, AP3000: British Air Power Doctrine, (Crown
Copyright, 1999),
UKs MoD/Joint Warfare Publication, JWP 0-01: British Defence Doctrine, (Caldwell
Prince Ltd, London)
UKs Naval Staff Directorate BR 1806: British Maritime Doctrine, (The Stationery
Office, London)
Z. Khalilzad D. Ochmanek: Strategy and Defense Planning for the 21st Century,
(RAND 1997)
Barry R. Posen: The Sources of Military Doctrine, (Cornell University Press, New York,
1984),
Lawrence Freedman: War, (Oxford University Press, London, 1994)
Azar Gat: The Development of Military Thought the Nineteen Century, (Clarendon
Press Oxford, New York, 1992)
Tom Donnelly and Sean Naylor: Clash of Chariots, the Great Tank Battles, (The
Berkley Publishing Group, New York, 1996)
Hans-Christian Hagman: European Crisis Management and Defence: The Search for
Capabilities, (Adelphi Paper 353/IISS, Oxford University Press, New York, 2002)
Uri Bar-Joseph: Israels National Security towards the 21st Century, (Frank Cass
Publishers, London, 2001)
E. Sloan, The Revolution in Military Affairs, (McGill-Queens University Press, 2002)
Naval War College: Strategy and Force Planning, (The Strategy and Force Planning .
Faculty, Newport, 2000)
William Odom, 'Soviet Military Doctrine,' Foreign Affairs (magazine), Winter 1988/89
A. Beleyev, "The Military-Theoretical Heritage of M. V. Frunze," Krasnaya Zvezda (Red
Star), November 4, 1984, quoted in William Odom's article in Foreign Affairs
(magazine), Winter 1988/89
The Dictionary of Military Terms, Department of Defence/ Joint Chief of Staff,
formulates the same definition, (London: Greenhil Books, 1999)

: www.mod.mil.gr/el/enimerosi/omilies.html
Institute for Security and Defence Analysis ISDA
17 Ag. Sikelianou Street, Neo Psychico, Athens 15 451, Greece.
Tel.: +30 211 015 3504, +30 211 012 5525, Fax: +30 211 012 5526
www.i-sda.org

30