Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nghien Cứu Sản Xuất Thử Nghiệm Mayonnaise It Chất Beo Từ Dầu Hạt Cải Va Gel Kappa Carrageenan
Nghien Cứu Sản Xuất Thử Nghiệm Mayonnaise It Chất Beo Từ Dầu Hạt Cải Va Gel Kappa Carrageenan
LI CM N
Sut thi gian hc tp v rn luyn ti trng, c s ch o ging dy ca
thy c trong trng cng nh trong Khoa Cng Ngh Thc Phm trang b cho
em nhng kin thc l thuyt v thc t b ch cho cuc sng v cng vic ng
thi to iu kin thun li cho qu trnh thc hin ti. Xin chn thnh cm n
qu thy c.
Cho em c gi li cm n chn thnh n c TS. Phan Th Khnh Vinh
hng dn v ch bo chu o cho em trong sut qu trnh thc hin ti.
Gia nh l ngun ng lc tinh thn v ng h vt cht cho con trong nhng
nm qua v nhng thng thc hin ti tt nghip. Cho con c cm n Ba v
M v cc anh ch to iu kin thun li cho con.
Qua y cng xin cm n cc bn cng lp, cc bn v cc anh ch cng thc
tp nhit tnh ng gp kin, trao i kin thc v gip cng vic thun
li v c hiu qu.
Sinh vin thc hin
Ninh c Chi
ii
MC LC
LI CM N ..............................................................................................................i
MC LC ...................................................................................................................ii
DANH MC BNG................................................Error! Bookmark not defined.
DANH MC HNH .................................................................................................... v
LI M U ............................................................................................................. 1
CHNG I: TNG QUAN ....................................................................................... 3
1.1. Tng quan v mayonnaise........................................................................................... 3
1.1.1. Ngun gc xut x ............................................................................................3
1.1.2. Phn loi mayonnaise ........................................................................................3
1.1.3. a tr v cch s dng.........................................................................................5
1.1.4. Th trng tiu th.............................................................................................5
1.2. H nh tng ................................................................................................................ 6
1.2.1 C s l thuyt v h nh tng ........................................................................6
1.2.2. Cc yu t nh hng ti s to thnh nh tng trong st mayonnaise ..........8
1.2.3. S ph hy nh tng .......................................................................................8
1.2.4. Cc yu t nh hng n s bn vng ca h nh tng ................................9
1.3. Thnh phn ca sn phm mayonnaise ..................................................................... 9
1.3.1. Du n ...............................................................................................................9
1.3.1.1. n gc, c im, phn loi ............................................................................9
1.3.1.2. Thnh phn ha hc ca du ........................................................................12
1.3.1.3. Tnh cht ca du .........................................................................................15
1.3.1.4. So snh du ht ci v mt s du khc. ......... 17
1.3.2. Cht to nh ................................................................................................... 18
1.3.2.1. Trng ............................................................................................................18
1.3.2.2. Sa bt..........................................................................................................19
1.3.2.3. Protein u nnh ...........................................................................................21
1.3.3. Cht n nh carrageenan ................................................................................22
1.3.3.1. n gc, nh ngha ca carrageenan .............................................................22
1.3.3.2. Tnh cht ca carrageenan ............................................................................23
1.3.3.3. ng dng ca carrageenan ...........................................................................25
1.3.4. Cc ph gia khc .............................................................................................25
1.3.4.1. t nng ..........................................................................................................25
1.3.4.2. ng ...........................................................................................................26
1.3.4.3. i ...................................................................................................................26
1.3.4.4. m .................................................................................................................26
1.3.4.5.tt ...................................................................................................................27
1.3.4.6. id sorbic (C6H8O2) ........................................................................................27
1.4. Cng ngh sn xut mayonnaise .............................................................................. 28
1.4.1. Mt s im cn lu khi phi ch ................................................................ 28
ii
DANH MC BNG
Bng
Ni dung
Trang
1.1
1.2
1.3
11
1.4
11
1.5
30
2.1
31
2.2
33
2.3
33
3.1
48
3.2
53
3.3
55
3.4
57
t cht bo
3.5
57
bo
3.6
57
3.7
58
-carrageenan
3.8
59
DANH MC HNH
Ni dung
Hnh
Trang
1.1
1.2
Mt s mn n dng c km mayonnaise
1.3
S h nh tng n gin
1.4
S h nh tng phc tp
1.5
C ch n nh nh tng
1.6
Du ht ci SIMPLY
1.7
Sa bt OLD LAC
19
1.8
24
1.9
M tt WASABI
27
27
2.1
31
2.2
35
bo t du ht vi
2.3
S b tr th nghim xc nh bn v nht h nh
38
tng
2.4
40
42
S b tr th nghim xc nh t l ng, m tt
44
3.1
47
acetic
3.2
47
acid acetic
3.3
49
Ni dung
Hnh
3.4
Trang
50
axid
3.5
51
3.6
52
sung bt nng
3.7
52
3.8
54
Sn phm sa lt tri cy
58
LI M U
Theo xu hng thi i, nhu cu pht trin cc sn phm chc nng c tc
dng phng chng mt s bnh do tui tc v tc ng xu n mi trng ang
ngy cng a chung. Bn cnh ngi tiu dng cng c xu hng la chn
nhng loi thc phm sn c tin dng.
Mt trong nhng sn phm p ng c cc tiu ch trn l nhm st
mayonnaise bi khng nhng giu dinh dng m tnh cht h nh tng ca n
cho php d dng b sung cc nhm cht x thc vt, vitamin, khong cht,
Omega3, Omega6 v cc cht chng oxy ha tan trong du.
Du ht ci l ngun nguyn liu ph bin, c bit rt giu Omega3,
Omega6 vi t l 1/3 rt ph hp thay th cc loi du nnh, du hng dng
trong sn xut mayonnaise.
Mt trong nhng vn ng quan tm nghin cu pht trin sn phm
mayonnaise l gim thiu lng cholesterol c trong trng g nh mt nguyn liu
truyn thng sn xut mayonnaise.
Mt trong nhng gii php l s dng sa bt gy thay trng g v s
dng gel carrageenan vi vai tr cht n nh v lm bn h nh tng. Trn
c s v c s phn cng ca ban ch nhim Khoa Cng Ngh Thc Phm,
em tin hnh ti Nghin cu sn xut th nghim mayonnaise t cht
bo t du ht ci v gel Kappacarrageenan.
Ni dung ca ti bao gm
Tm hiu v st mayonnaise, thnh phn ha hc, tnh cht ca nguyn liu,
cc quy trnh sn xut mayonnaise.
Nghin cu xc nh bn, nht ca h nh tng mayonnaise trc v
sau khi b sung acid acetic.
Nghin cu xc nh t l cc thnh phn phi ch.
xut quy trnh sn xut.
Th nghim sn xut mayonnaise t cht bo t du ci, nh gi cht lng
sn phm, tnh ton s b chi ph nguyn liu sn xut mayonnaise t cht bo.
Mc tiu ti
Th nghim sn xut sn phm c tnh mi vn m bo gi tr dinh dng
v gi tr sinh hc, c xem nh l mt loi sn phm chc nng cn thit cho mi
ngi.
ngha khoa hc
Gp phn cung cp thm thng tin khoa hc v vai tr n nh h nh tng
mayonnaise ca gel Kappacarrageenan, a ra quy trnh sn xut th nghim mt
loi st mayonnaise gp phn phong ph th trng st.
ngha thc tin
M rng ng dng ca gel Kappacarrageenan thay cho bt carrageenan.
To ra hng pht trin mi cho cng nghip sn xut nc st, gia v.
Do kin thc bn thn cn hn ch, thi gian thc hin c hn v mt s iu
kin khch quan khc nn ti khng th trnh khi sai st. Rt mong nhn c
s ng gp ca thy c v cc bn ti c hon thin hn.
Sn phm nh tng
Mayonnaise
(>80% cht bo)
Mayonnaise sa lt
(50 60% cht bo)
Dressing (20%
cht bo)
Lu
c mt vi khun
Mayonnaise
Coliform
0,1
25
b. Nh tng nc trong du
10
bit Trung Quc l quc gia bit s dng du sm nht, cho n ngy nay du u
nnh vn c a chung nc ny.
b. c im
Cc loi du c dng dng lng c thnh phn khc nhau v mu sc cng khc
nhau nu du no c mu cng sng th du c im si cng cao.
c. Phn loi du n
Du n c th c phn thnh nhiu loi da vo thnh phn v cc tnh
cht ca cc acid bo. C th chia du thnh cc nhm ch yu sau.
Nhm acid lauric (du da, du ht c)
Nhm cht bo ny c tnh cht rt khc bit so vi cc loi du khc do s
hin din mc cao ca acid lauric (40-50%, C12:0), k n l acid myristic v
cc acid bo bo ha c 8, 10 v 14 C. im c trng ca nhm ny l s hin
din t l rt thp cc acid bo khng bo ha, tng ng im nng chy rt
thp. Mc d vy, nhm du da v nhm du c vn c s dng trong cng
nghip thc phm v trong ch bin margarine.
Nhm b thc vt (b ca cao)
Nhm cht bo ny c thnh phn tryglicerid v acid bo rt c bit ch yu
t cc acid bo khng no c 1 ni i nh C18:1, C20:1, C24:3. B thc vt c gi
tr kinh t cao, s dng ch yu trong ch bin chocolate v ko.
Nhm acid oleic v acid linoleic (du olive, du c, du bp, du hng
dng, du ht ci)
y l nhm du hin din ph bin nht. Acid bo to nn du nhm ny
ch yu C18:1 v C18:2. Lng acid bo bo ha trong nhm du ny ch chim ti
a 20%.
Du ht ci
Nhiu ngui tin rng du ht ci l khng tt v n c ly t nh my ht
ci du, c cho l y cc acid eruxic l nguyn nhn gy tn thng tim.
Nhng cc nh my du ht ci to ra ging ci mi nh phng php bin i
gen nn lm gim rt nhiu lng acid eruxic, trnh xa mc nguy him v lm mch
ngn li cn C18 8.
11
Thnh phn
Ga tr
Triacylglycerols (%)
94,4 99,1
Phospholipids (%)
Du th
2,5
Nc kh cht nha
0,6
0,1
Axt bo t do (%)
0,4 1,2
Cht bo bo ha (%)
0,5 1,2
Tocopherols (ppm)
700 1200
Chlorophylls (ppm)
5 50
Sulfur (ppm)
3 25
Thnh phn
Gi tr
Acid bo ha (w/w %)
6,3
62,4
31,3
12
13
14
15
16
Triglycerid
glycerin + 3 acid bo t do
17
18
19
20
Thnh phn
Nc trong sa bt l nc lin kt do nc loi qua qu trnh sy nn
sn phm c tnh ht m rt cao.
Lipit ca sa bao gm cht bo, phosphatit, glicilipit, steroit.
Cht bo sa (milk fat) c coi l thnh phn quan trng. V mt dinh
dng, cht bo c sinh nng lng cao, c cha cc vitamin ha tan trong cht
bo (A, D, E ). C ti 98-99% cht bo ca sa l cc triglixerit, 1 2% cn li l
phospholipit, cholesterol, caroten v vitamin A, D, E, K.
Protein : Trong dung dch c cha hai kiu protein khc nhau :
+ Protein ha tan: gm albumin, imunoglobulin, lisozim, lactoferin,
lactoperoxydaza,
+ Protein trng thi keo khng bn: gm mt phc h mixen hu c ca
cc caseinat v canxi phosphat.
b. Tnh cht ca sa bt
T trng ph thuc vo thnh phn ca sa, t trng dao ng trong khong
1,026 1,032 m3 (trung bnh 1,029). Thnh phn protein, gluxit, cht khong (t
trng >1). Cn hm lng cht bo li lm gim t trng ca sa. Nn khi dng sa
bt gy th t trng s thp.
nht ca sa ph thuc vo thnh phn ha hc ca sa, trc ht l
protein cn cc mui lactoza khng nh hng ti nht. Hm lng cht bo
cng tng th th nht cng cao. Cng nh sa bt c nht cao do c hm
lng cht kh cao.
Sc cng b mt ca sa khng n nh. N ph thuc vo rt nhiu yu t
trc ht l thnh phn ha hc, nhit v thi gian bo qun. Sc cng b mt
i vi sa gy l 47,2 51,9 dyn/cm.
axid hot ng biu th tnh hot ng ca cc ion H+. Ga tr pH t 6,5 6,8.
Tnh cht to keo c ba pha tn ti ng thi :
Dung dch huyn ph : Thnh phn gm nc v cc cht ha tan nh
lactoza, mui khong v vitamin ha tan trong nc.
21
T l
T l
Tryptophan
1,1%
Threonine
4,8%
Leucine
8,4%
Lysine
6,0%
Isoleucine
5,8%
Methionine
1,4%
Valine
5,8%
Phenylalanine
3,8 %
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Nng lng
900 Kcal
Cht m
Cht bo khng bo ha
Omega-3
8g
Omega-6
20 g
Omega -9
58 g
Cht bo bo ha
7.7 g
Vitamin E
28 mg
Cacbonhydrat
ng
Cholesterol
Natri
31
Rong sn kh
Lc ly tm
Vn tc quay: 4000
vng/pht
Bao gi
R ng tan gi
Kt ta KCl
Lm lnh 2 gi
Cp ng
Thi gian 24gi,
Nhit - 200C
32
1 gam KCl
33
Yu cu
Nhit ng c, 0C
36
53
Sc ng, g/cm2
550
Hm lng khong, %
0,83
2.1.1.3. Sa bt
Sa bt c dng ti ny l sa bt c hm lng cht bo thp trong
c sa bt tch bo (35%), sa bt ton phn (18%), ng saccaroza, m,
hng tng hp, hn h cc khong cht (D, E, C, B1, B2, B6, B12, Niacin, acid
Folic, acid Pantothenic),...
Bng 2.3. Thnh phn dinh dng ca sa bt
Trng lng
Nng lng
Cht bo
Cacbonhydrat
Cht m (protein)
Cht x
Taurine
m
n v
Kcal
Kj
g
g
g
g
mg
%
Trong 100g bt sa
364,7 445,1
1.526 1.862
7,5 9,1
55,8 68,2
18,5 22,6
4,0 4,9
99 121
2,16
34
35
2.1.2.6. id Sorbic
S dng dng bt. c mua ti phng th nghim Cng Ngh Thc Phm.
2.1.2.7. b
Trong qu trnh nghin cu, s dng l thy tinh, khi lng tnh 220g. Vt
liu thy tinh tr vi tc nhn acid ca thc phm, c trong sut cao, khng b
chy xc hay h.
2.2. Phng php nghin cu
2.2.1. B tr th nghim
2.2.1.1. kin quy trnh sn xut st mayonnaise t cht bo
Qua nghin cu ti liu tham kho d kin quy trnh sn xut st mayonnaise
nh sau.
Sa bt
gy
Nc m
( 40-500C)
Du ht
ci
gel -carrageenan
( 500C- 600C)
Ha tan
Phi trn 2
Phi trn 1
nh
khuy 1
Bt nng, du ht ci,
nc
nh
khuy 2
ng ,
mui, m tt
dm,
Acid sorbic
Bo
qun
ng chai
Du
ht ci
Phi trn 3
nh khuy 3
36
37
38
Sa gy (5%)
Nc (5%)
Du ht ci
(10%)
Sa gy (10%)
Nc ( 10%)
Du ht ci
(10%)
Phi trn 1
Phi trn 1
Hn hp 1 hoc 1 phi
trn vi hn hp 2 gm
(10%) d v gel
carrgeenan vi t l (%)
10
40
25
50
Hn hp 3
Nc
nh khuy 1
Xc nh bn nht
ca h nh tng
Chn t l gel
-carrageenan, sa thch
hp
39
40
Sa (10%)
Nc ( 10%)
Du ht ci
(10%)
Sa (5%)
Nc ( 5%)
Du ht ci
(10%)
Phi trn 1
Phi trn 1
Hn hp 1 hoc 1 phi
trn vi hn hp 2 gm d
(10%) v gel
carrgeenan vi t l (%)
10
25
40
50
Hn hp 3
Dm (14,86%)
Nc
Khuy trn 1
Xc nh
bn nht
ca h nh
So snh
bn, nht
trc v sau
b sung dm
41
42
nh
khuy 1
Hn
hp 1
Hn
hp 2
Hn hp 3
Phi trn vi hn hp gm (2%) du ht
ci, nc v bt nng vi tng t l %
Hn hp 4
Dm
(14,86%)
nh khuy 2
Xc nh nht,
bn h nh tng
Chn t l bt
nng thch hp
nc.
Hn hp du n, nc v bt nng cn c chun b trc.
43
44
Theo tiu chun Vit Nam v cht bo qun th gii hn ti a acid sorbic c
trong 1 kg sn phm t sa l 1000mg/kg nn lng acid sorbic b sung c nh
vo st mayonnaise t cht bo l 700mg/kg.
Hn hp 1
Khuy trn 1
Hn hp 2
Hn hp 3
Bt nng,
nc, du
ht ci
Phi
trn 3
Khuy trn 2
Hn hp 4
ng 1%
M tt
0,2%
ng 1%
M tt
0,5%
ng 1%
M tt
0,8%
ng 1,5%
M tt 0,2%
ng 1,5%
M tt 0,5%
ng 1,5%
M tt 0,8%
Phi trn 4
nh khuy 3
nh gi
cm quan
Chn t l
phi trn
thch hp
45
46
47
120
bn (%)
100
80
60
40
20
0
1
S th nghim
nht (cP)
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
1
S th nghim
48
Th nghim Sa (%)
1
2
5
5
3
4
5
6
5
5
10
10
7
8
Thnh phn
Gel
Du ht ci
(%)
carrageenan (%)
10
20
25
20
40
50
10
25
20
20
20
20
Nc
(%)
65
50
35
25
60
45
10
40
20
30
10
50
20
20
Theo kt qu nghin cu v da vo th hnh 3.1 v hnh 3.2 cho thy,
49
120
bn (%)
100
80
60
40
20
0
1
S th nghim
50
nht (cP)
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
1
S th nghim
Hnh 3.4. th biu din nht h nh tng trc v sau khi cho dm
51
52
Hnh 3.7. th biu din im cm quan sau khi phi trn ph gia
53
Thnh
phn
1
ng (%)
1,5
1,5
1,5
M tt (%)
0,2
0,5
0,8
0,2
0,5
0,8
54
Nc, 5%
(40-500C)
Du ht
ci, 9%
Sa bt gy,
5%
gel -carrageenan,
50%,
0
(50 C- 600C)
Ha tan
Phi trn 2
Phi trn 1
Bt nng, 7%
nc, 5,14%
du ht ci, 2%
nh khuy 1
(5 pht)
nh khuy 2
(5 pht)
Phi trn 3
ng, 1,5%
Mui, 1%
M tt, 0,2%
Dm 14,86%
A. sorbic, 0,07%
Bo
qun
ng chai
Du
ht ci,
9%
Phi trn 4
nh khuy 3 (2 pht)
55
Gel carrageenan
50,0
Sa bt gy
5,0
Du ht ci
20,0
Dm
14,86
Nc
10,14
Bt nng
7,0
ng
1,5
Mui
1,0
M tt
0,2
Acid sorbic
0,07
Nguyn liu
Phi trn 1
t t 9% du ht ci vo sa ha tan, trong khi va va khuy bng
tay trong 1 pht th thu c h nh tng. Thu c hn hp 1.
Phi trn 2
56
57
H s im c
quan trng lng
trng
Trng thi
23
4,6
1,3
5,98
Mi
22
4,4
4,4
24
4,8
0,9
4,42
Mu sc
22
4,4
0,8
3,52
Tng
18,32
Nhn xt
Da vo bng cp cht lng theo tiu chun TCVN 3215-79 th sn phm
c tng im cm quan 18,32 t loi kh.
Bng 3.5: Ch tiu cm quan cht lng sn phm st mayonnaise t cht bo
Tn ch tiu
c im sn phm
Trng thi
Mu sc
Mu trng
Mi
c trng, hi ha
c trng, hi ha
STT
01
02
03
04
05
Ch Tiu
nV
Tnh
Tng vi sinh vt Cfu/ g
hiu kh
Coliforms
Cfu/ g
E. coli
Cfu/ g
Salmonella
Cfu/ g
Tng BT nm men- Cfu/ g
nm mc
Kt
Qa
10
SanPin 2.3.2.1078-01
103
7
Khng c mt trong 0,1g
KPH Khng c php c mt
KPH Khng c php c mt
2
Nm men khng qu 500
Nm mc khng qu 50
58
Rong
kh
KCl
Nc
Tng cng
sn kg
S
lng
n gi( VN/n v)
0,1
35.000
3.500
kg
0,0303
240.000
7.212
lt
500
4.500
15.272
59
ci cho 10 l.
n v
Gel -carrageenan
kg
9.220
9.220
Sa bt gy
kg
0,1
250.000
25.000
Du ht ci
lt
0,4
56.000
22.400
ng
kg
0,0321
19.000
609,9
Mui
kg
0,0214
6.000
128,4
Dm
lt
0,2972
14000
4.160,8
Bt nng
kg
0,14
30.000
4.200
Nc
lt
0,2035
500
101,75
M tt
kg
0,0043
500.000
2.150
10
Acid sorbic
kg
0,0015
300.000
450
11
L thy tinh
ci
10
5.000
50.000
STT
S lng
n gi (VN Thnh
/n v)
(VN)
Thnh phn
Tng
tin
118.420,25
60
61
gel-network
based
on
agar-carrageenan
blend
cross-linked
with
62
Kappaphycus Eucheuma. . . . . .
. . , 211 .
21. . - : , 2000.- 80 .
Website
22. www.baigiang.violet.vn/present/showprint/entry_id/4985754
23. www.canolaoilguide.com/canola-oil-vs-vegetable-oil
24. www.nutrition.about.com/od/askyournutritionist/f/canola.htm
25. www.tailieu.vn/xem- 24
26. www.vcn.vnn.vn/PrintPreview tai-lieu/luan-van-khao-sat-anh-huong-cua-viecbo-sung-tinh-bot-trung-va-sua-bot-den-chat-luong-san-pham-ta.669359.htm
27. www.tailieu.vn/xem-tai-lieu/protein-dau-anh.739366.html.aspx?ID=4325.
28. www.vinachem.com.vn/Desktop.aspx/Xuat-ban-pham/113/1484/ 26
29. www.vi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trng_(thc_n).
PH LC
PH LC 1: Xc nh nht qua my Brookfield dng Viscometer DV-I
S dng my o nht Brookfield o nht, th cc u d ln
lt t 61 n 64, cc u d s cng ln th phm vi o rng hn.
Yu cu dch o phi c rt trong ng o ring ca my, u d khi o
khng c trm y cc v khi mun so snh v nht h nh tng cn o
ng cng nhit .
n v o
Vn tc kim u d: vng / pht
nht: cP
Trong ti ny s dng:
S du d: 64
Vn tc ca kim u d: 60 vng /pht
Nhit o 280C
Bng kt qu o nht h nh tng
Bng a1: Kt qu o nht h nh tng trc v sau khi cho acid acetic
Ga tr (cP)
S th
nghim
239,67
197,67
1430,17
1120,17
2211,67
1770
3005,35
2939
385,67
253,3
4452,33
2206,67
4735,67
4699
4940,6
4800,5
Ga tr (cP)
3010
3939
6279
7404,67
Ga tr (cP)
6350
PH LC 2: Xc nh bn
Cho 10ml mayonnaise vo ng chia vch (10 vch u nhau ). Cho vo
my ly tm v ly tm khong 5 pht vi vn tc 1.500 vng / pht. Sau t ng
vo cc nc si 3 pht v li tip tc ly tm 5 pht.
bn nh tng xc nh theo cng thc:
X=
V *100
10
Ga tr (%)
Trc khi cho acid acetic
57,4
56,1
78,7
70,0
91,2
84,0
95,0
89,0
70,28
50,5
100
95,0
100
97,0
100
100
Ga tr (%)
100
100
100
100
Ga tr (%)
100
H s quan trng
1.3
0.8
0.9
1,0
4,0
im chung
Loi tt
18,6 20
Loi kh
15.2
18.5
Yu cu v im trung
bnh cha c trng lng
i vi cc ch tiu
Cc ch tiu quan trng
nht 4.7
Cc ch tiu quan trng
nht 3.8
11.2
15.1
Mi ch tiu 1.8
7.2 11.1
Mi ch tiu 1.8
4.0 7.1
Mi ch tiu 1.0
0 3.9
Ch s quan
trng
C s nh gi cht lng
Hi mn, hi long, c vn cc nh
1.3
Ch s quan trng
C s nh gi cht lng
Mu trng
Mu hi trng
Mu vng nht
Mu vng
0.8
Mu hi ng vng
Bc nh
gi
Thang
im
c trng, hi ha
V hi nng cay
0.9
C s nh gi cht lng
Thang
Ch s
im quan trng
C s nh gi cht lng
Mi c trng, hi ha
Mi ca dm v m tt r rng
Mi ca m tt v dm rt r rt
Mi ca dm v m tt
im ca cc kim
nghim vin
1 2
3
4
5
Trng
thi
Mu sc
Mi
V
4
5
4
4
3
4
4
3
5
5
4
4
Tng s
im
im
trung
bnh
H s
quan
trng
im c
trng
lng
21
4,2
1,3
5,46
4
5
5
Tng
21
20
22
4,2
4
4,4
1
0,9
0,8
4,2
3,6
3,52
16,78
im ca cc kim
nghim vin
1 2
3
4
5
Trng
thi
Mu sc
Mi
V
4
2
3
5
2
3
4
2
3
4
1
3
Tng s
im
im
trung
bnh
H s
quan
trng
im c
trng
lng
21
4,2
1,3
5,46
5
3
3
Tng
22
10
15
4,4
2
3
1
0,9
0,8
4,4
1,8
2,4
14,06
im ca cc kim
nghim vin
1 2
3
4
5
Trng
thi
Mu sc
Mi
V
4
1
2
4
2
3
4
1
3
5
1
2
Tng s
im
im
trung
bnh
H s
quan
trng
im c
trng
lng
20
1,3
5,2
4
2
3
Tng
21
7
13
1
0,9
0,8
4,2
1,26
2,08
12,74
4,2
1,4
2,6
im ca cc kim
nghim vin
1 2
3
4
5
Trng
thi
Mu sc
Mi
V
4
5
5
5
4
4
5
5
5
4
4
5
Tng s
im
im
trung
bnh
H s
quan
trng
im c
trng
lng
21
4,2
1,3
5,46
4
5
5
Tng
22
23
24
4,4
4,6
4,8
1
0,9
0,8
4,4
4,14
3,84
17,84
im ca cc kim
nghim vin
1 2
3
4
5
Trng
thi
Mu sc
Mi
V
4
2
3
4
3
3
5
3
3
4
2
4
Tng s
im
im
trung
bnh
H s
quan
trng
im c
trng
lng
21
4,2
1,3
5,46
5
1
4
Tng
22
11
17
4,4
2,2
3,4
1
0,9
0,8
4,4
1,98
2,72
14,56
im ca cc kim
nghim vin
1 2
3
4
5
Trng
thi
Mu sc
Mi
V
4
1
3
4
1
3
5
2
2
5
1
3
Tng s
im
im
trung
bnh
H s
quan
trng
im c
trng
lng
21
4,2
1,3
5,46
4
2
3
Tng
22
7
14
4,4
1,4
2,8
1
0,9
0,8
4,4
1,26
2,24
13,36