4

CONSILIUL SUPERIOR al
MAGISTRATURII
din REPUBLICA MOLDOVA
JUDECATORIA COMRAT

COBET
MATHCTPATYPEI
PECHYBJIHKI4 MOJIJOBA
CY,TA KOMPAT

MD-3 800, UTA Gagauzia or. Comrat,

str. Lenin 242, tel: 2-37-07

Ns

din "

1)

MD-3800, ATO Faray3Hst r. KoMpaT,

yn.JleHHHa 242, Ten: 2-37-07

2014

ExceHegenbHoe aHani4THTTecxoe H3gaHHe

B (poicyce nege.rin
r. Kompa-r, nep. gpyac6m 2a
Ha Bain 3anpoc OT 23.12.2014.
Bonpocbz 4-5. 17upon 3C51611,11, Limo eye) Hamepermo 3amReueaem paccmompeHue ucKoeoeo
3(2316.1701M Paoea u KopoRHK OMHOCUMellb110 ymeepoicaenuR aupeKmopa o6ulecmeennoeo
mane/cm-tam GRT. Talc 1111 3M0 u ecru Hem, mo noqemy awl He 6boo do cux nop
3a6eptuetio? I7oqemy nepenocRmcH 3aceaanwi?
Bonpoc 5. KaK mooicem cya npoKammeHmupoeamb unOopmaywo o mom, Limo
npeaceaame.ab Hapoanoeo coopanusi ,amumpuii Koncmanmunoe o6pamwicsi 6 Bbicundi
coeem maeucmpamypbi c npocb6ou paccmompemb aelicmeusi cyabu Tpueopuit Komea,
3amHeuealoufeeo paccmompewue ucKa KopoxiK u Paaosa.
OTBeT: OTHOCHTeJ113110 riosiBHBmeticsi B CMI4 3a51B.ileHl4r1 II14p0H CT. H
KOHCTaHTHHOBa g.F. 3aSIB.TleHHA OTHOCHTeJlEHO TOFO, tITO cyg HamepeHHO
3aTsiruBaeT paccmoTpeHHe HCKOBOFO 3aARTIeHHS1 PagOBa 14 KOp0J151K, o6)Kanyionmx
KoHxypc HO 1436paH1410 H ripmca3 o6 yTBep)KgeHHH glipexTopa o6mecTBeHHoro
TenexaHana GRT, cny)K6a CHCTeMaTH3aHHH, 06061HeH1451 cyne6HoH FlpaKTHKH H
cB5Beci C 06WeCTBeHHOCTIA-0 Cyga KoMpaT mmiceT coo6mHTB, =no gaHHBie
yTBepicgeHllsi He COOTBeTCTByIOT geriCTBHTeMBHOCTH. gen HaX0,2111TC51 Ha
paccmoTpeHm4 B cyge KoMpaT c 20.09.2014 Toga, HpH 3TOM germ paccmaTpHBaeTcm
B pa3ymHme cpoKH C rieTOM 3arpy)KeHHocTH cygm4, CJI0)KHOCTH gena H
noBegeHHem yilaCTHHKOB. 3THM >Ice 06yCJTOBJleHbl Hp1411HHIII OTI10)KeHH51 cyge6Hipix
3acegaHml:
- 07.10.2014 foga no geny 6mna HamaTa nogroToma, cyge6Hoe 3aceAaHlie 6bIJI0
OTJ10)KeHO B CBSI3H C ygoBneTBopeHHem xogaTaRcTBa HcTlia 0 npegocTaBneHm4
BpemeHH gJI51 3aKI1101.1eHH51 cornamem45i C agBOKaTOM, a Taioice B CB5I314 C
06513aHHOCT1310 OTBeTLIHKa npegcTaBHTB goxa3aTenBcTBa 060CHOBaHHOCTI4
o6)KanoBaHHoro agMHHHCTpaTHBH0F0 aKTa;
- 28 oicTn6pn 2014 roga cyge6Hoe 3ace,gaHHe He COCT051,TIOCb, B B14gy Toro, 'fro
cygm paccmaTpuBaionnA Reno Haxognncm Ha 3acegaHHH Bmcmero CoBeTa
MarpicTpaTypm;
- 04 noa6pa 2014 rona npoBegeHHe HOgFOTOBKH Rena x cyge6Homy
pa36HpaTenbcTBy 61DIJI0 OT.TIO)KeHO Ha 14 HO516p51 2014 roga no xogaTaticTBy

aABoxaTa HcTua H3BeKOBa H.R. 0 npeaocTaBsteHHH Bpemem4 gJISL 03HaKOMJIeHH51

C maTepHartamH gena, a Taxxce A.1151 ripegoeTaBfleHHA gon0J1H14TeJlbHbIX
TIOKa3aTeJIbCTB cTopoHoil oTBerrimxa;
14 Hom6psi 2014 roaa 14 03.12.2014 ro,aa cyAe6Hoe 3acegamae 6mno omoNceHo B
CB513H C 3a5IRTIeHHSIMH OTB04(0B TpeTbHm IIHLIOM Ha cTopoHe OTBeTLIHKa
C.F. npegcegaTemBeTBytoutemy cyAbe Kai-reBy Fit, a Taxxce 3asnutem451 o
camooTHoge cy,21E,H OT 14.11.2014 roga, B CB51314 c paccmoTpeHHem cygbeti
rpmicAaHcxoro Ae.ria no Hcxy Xexoria H. K
000 Ogurtelecom o
KomneHcaukm moparmHoro Bpeaa, B KOTOpOM HHTepecht 000 Ogurtelecom
ripeAcTaansui SMITH FIHpoH C.F., COF.TIaCHO ripmca3a N2007 OT 14.12.2011 Foga
Ha3Hattemm [IHp0H C.F. VICTIOJIH51101IIHM 06513aHHOCTH ,Empewropa 000
Ogurtelecom H goBepeHHocTH BmaaHHoil AmpexTopom 000 Ogurtelecom
MaT/011.10HOK A. OT 01.09.2010 Foga, TITO npoTHBopelmT yTBemic,item4simHpoH
C.F. 06 OTCyTCTBHH opHrHHarta npuKa3a, ero HeAecICTBI4TeJ113HOCTH H
Bee
yxa3aHHme 3a5lBJ1eH1451 6bIJIH OTKJI0HeHbI KaK He060cHoBaHmile;
- 28 Hom6psi 2014 roTka cyge6Hoe 3acegaHme He COCTOSIJI0C13. B CBSI3H C
HaxoKtkeHHem cygbli B MegHI1HHCKOM oTnycKe;
- 20 geica6psi 2014 roga npoBeAeHHe noAroToBicH ,Etema K cyAe6Homy
pa36HpaTembeTBy OTJ10)KeHO Ha 30.12.2014 roga, H3-3a HeABKH HCTIOB, TpeTbero
JIMA, a Taxxce 1.10 xogaTailcTBy npegcTaBwresur HcTua, B CB5I3H C ero yitacTHem B
npoBegeHm4 npoueccyanbHmx ,LketicTBHA no yFOHOBHOMy gemy B FeHepambHa
npoxypaType PM.
OAHoBpemeHHo citegyeT OTMeTHTb, LITO CJIWKHOCTE gema cB513aHa C
ocnapHBaHHem He TOJIbK0 npHxa3a o6 yTBepxc,aeHHH gHpeKTopa 06utecTBeHHoti
KOMIMHHH GRT, HO H 3aKOHHOCTb1-0 npoBegeHHA Bcero KoHxypca Ha 3ameuteHHe
BaKaHTHOil ,110JI)KHOCTH, TITO Tpe6yeT npoBepxy co6snogeHHA Bceil npouegypm
opramnaTopam11, COOTBeTCTBHe KaHAHAaToB npegb5IBJ131emmm KpwrepHsfm,
X1OCTOBepHOCTb npeAcTaBsieHmAx KaHAHAaTamm AOKyMeHTOB H cHeAeHmI H T.,1..
Bonpoc 3. Cmenan IlupoH pacKpumuKoeag aeitC1126101 cyabu Tpu2opuil KoReea, Komopbtu
He npeaocmaeRAem emy 603M00/CHOCHIU 110.11)211UMb opu2unaR aoKymeHma, npuRawcombiu
K UCKy Paa06a u KOp0.115110) (ebtnucKy u3 npuica3a N9007 om 14.12.2011 2., co2RacHo
Komopomy Cmenan Hupon Ha3HazieH UOIORHSHOUIUM 065i3aHHOCHIU aupocmopa
Ogurtelecom). 17ottemy opu2uHaR aoKymewma He 6b1R npeacmaeRen Cmenany Ilupou?
Bonpoc 2. Cmenan Ilupon panee HeoauoKpamHo 3a518.1151.11, tIMO cyabsi KoMpamcKo2o
palm-wow cy&a Tpueopuii KoRee HapywuR 3aKOH, U373416 8b111UCKy U3 npuKa3a Ar9.007 om
14.12.2011 2. (coenacHo Komopamy Cmenan Ilupon Ha3Hatien ucnantonoulum
o6R3aHnocmu aupeKmopa Ogurtelecom) u3 apyeozo umeioUleZOCR Fla paccmompenuu
epaoicaanoc000 aeRa (N22-16/2012 no ucKy )KeKoea HUK011aR K jo6poey Oeaopy u 000
Ogurtelecom), u npuKpenue ebinucKy u3 npuKa3a K 2pa3IcaancKamy &any N23-126/14 no
ucKy BaReHmunbi KOpORRK u Teop2uii Pa&oea K Ha6RtoaameRbHamy coeemy OK GRT o
npu3Hanuu HeaeficmeumeRbHbut4 KonKypca Ha 3ameuyenue aoRdicHocmu aupeKmopa TB
OK GRT, ommene n.1. PeuteHuR AN 1 Ha ocnoeanuu npomoKoRa N223 3aceaaHuR
Ha6Rioaame.abH000 coeema. Tax RU 3mo Ha camam Beene?

OTBeT: H3 14MeIOINHXCSI B maTepnanax geJra onpegemeHml CyAeH o6 OTKJIONeFIPII4

xogaTaticTB o6 OTBO,Tke H HpOTOKOROB cyne6Horo 3acegannst ycmaTpnBaeTcsi, wro
Bbnueyxa3annme yrBep)Kgenna ne COOTBeTCTB)TIOT geRCTBI4TeJlbHOCT14.
B COOTBeTCTBIII4 CO CT.24 141) 3aKOlia PM 06 agMHHPICTpaTHBHOM cyge
X9.793 OT 10.02.2000 roga <<AgMPIPICTpaT14BlibIcl cyg paccmaTpnBaeT PICKOBOe
3a5tanenne npn yitacTnn ncTua N OTBeT1114Ka PI/PIJII4 I4X npegcTaBnTendi B
COOTBeTCTBPIPI C nponegyport, yeTaHOBIleHH011 Fpa)K,LkaliCKI4M nponeccyariblimm
KOgeKCOM, 3a HeicoTophimll
HCICTI10110HHHMH,
npegycmoTpeHHEamll
HaCTOSIIIIHM 3BICOHOM>>.

Cor.nacHo -11.(3) CT. 24 3aKona 06 agMMEnCTpaTHBHOM cyge npn

paccmoTpeHnn B a,21MHHHCTpaTHBHOM cyne VICKOBOF0 3a51B.TIeHI431 o6
annymnpoBaHnn 06xcanyemoro a,nmmincTpaTnBnoro aKTa npeacTaBaeHne
gOlCa3aTeabeTB BmeHneTcsi B 0603BHHOCTb oTBeTiunca, a npn paccmoTpemn4
Tpe6oBaHnst 0 BO3MeINelIPII4 npnin4HeHnoro yinep6a B 06513aHHOCTb o6enx
cTop0H.
KpoMe TOFO, B C00TBeTCTBI4I4 c Mb)
cT.22 yxa3aHnoro 3aKOHa B cmyciae
HpPIN5ITI451 HCKOBOFO 3a51B.TIeH1131 K paccmoTpeHmo cygEst pacnopsnicaeTcsi - o
npegcTaBaeHHH cygy OTBeTIIHICOM o6xca.3yemoro agmHHHcTpaTm3Horo aKTa,
goicymeHTaHHH, Ha OCHOBBHHH KOTOpOrI OH 6bIJI H3ABH, BbIIIHCOIC HJIH
gpyrux ciaegeHHii, KoTopme CyL C'IHTaeT Heo6xogHmbumi gm] paccmoTpeHmt
germ.
B yKa3aHHo'n CBSI3I4, npurio)Kamme K ncxy KOHHH mormn 6bITb ygocToBepeHm B
yeTaHOBJleHHOM Imps:mice, a I4Mel4H0 HoTapHaAbHo, aABOICBTOM JII460 Tem
topngniTecxlim JINLjOM, KoTopoe SIEJIReTC51 aBTOpOM NJIN anagembnem FIOXII4HHI4Ka
goxymeHTa. HCX0A51 I43 Toro, IITO BbIIINCKPI H3 npnxa3a X2007 OT 14.12.2011 roga
O Ha3Hamem4H C 15.12.2011 roga FInpon C. PICTIOJIHS110HIPIM 06513aHHOCTI4
glipexTopa 000 Ogurtelcom mgaHa 000 Ogurtelcom y HCTII0B HCT H He
AOJDICI-10 6bITb ero opHrHHaJla, H 3aBep1iTb OHH ero He snpase. Ho3Tomy
xogaTaficTso IIHpOH C. 06 06H3aH1414 HCTHOB npegcTasHTb eMy 3aBepeimyto
KOHHIO 3T0f0 HpHica3a OTICJI0110110 3a He060CHOBBHHOCTb10. Yxa3annoe
xogaTatIcTBo camo HO ce6e cTpanno, yITI4TIDIBaff, LITO oppirnHanm yica3affliort
BbMPICKI4 npegocTaBnsumcb camnm FIHpon C.F. B xamecTBe ero nonHomoting Arm
npegcTaaneHnsi mrrepecoB 000 Ogurtelcom HO gpyrnm rpa)Kgancxnm
genam, paccmaTpnBaemmm B cyge KompaT.
Hcntamn ripanoweHa K ge.ny KOHNSI BbITIPICKI4 H3 npnica3a X9.007 OT 14.12.2011
Foga 0 na3Haitennn FImpoH C.F. 14CHOJIHSHOLIMM 06513aHHOCTI4 gnpeKTopa 000
Ogurtelecom, nognmcaHHaA nogrmcbto FInpoHa C.F. A B xoje npoBegeHnst
IlOgFOTOBKI4 II0 eJIy, cygom o6o3peBancsi opnrnitast Tort >ice BbIIINCKI4 I43
nplixa3a X2007 OT 14.12.2011 roga, no Aemy X22-16/2012 Ho 3a nogrincbto
glipexTopa MaTromoHoic A. TaKnm o6pa3oM B maTepnanax Atria I4MelOTC51 gBa
pa3HIDIX goKymenTa, TO eCTb ,nBe BbITIPICKI4 H3 ogHoro npuxa3a X9.007 OT
14.12.2011 Foga nognncamme pa3Hmmn stnnamn.

KpoMe TOFO, B cyge KoMpaT HCKOBOg maTepHail (HCKOBbIe 3aSIBJWITHA H

gOKyMeHTM, nparimiceHHme K HHM), cicaHuppoTcsi H B OTCKaHlip0BaHHOM BHge
ripHo6matoTcsi B geno, 3aperHcTpHpoHaHHoe B HHTerpHpoHaHHoil nporpamme
permTpanHH gen (PIGD), ITT HcKrnoTiaeT BO3M0)KHOCTb BlIeCeHHA H3meHeHHA H
gOIIOJIHeHH11, HOCKOJIbKy nporpamma PIGD aBTOMaTHLIeCKH (131HKeHpyeT gaTy H
spemA CO3gaHH51 Rena H maTepHallos gema. no3Tomy HeicmogaeTcsi BO3M0)ICHOCTb
npH061neHHA HHbIX gOKyMeHTOB H3 gpyroro gema H T.H..
Bonpoc 1. 17oziemy npu npuHRmuu UCK06020 3asuvenuR om Tpueopusi Paoea u
BaReHmuHbl KOp0.7151K (oMHOCUMegb110 ymeepoic6eHUR 6upeKmopa o6ltieCM8e1111020
megeKanana GRT), cyd He yica3aii ucmyam na mo, Limo ne 6bula co6nioaena Oocyoe6HaR
npoyeoypa? (Hanybz o6pammucb 6 cyo, ne ac3lc6astuucb omeema na noaannoe 6
Ha6mooamenbilbdi coeem npeosapume.gbnoe 3asumenue).
OTBeT: CITHTal0, T-ITO Bonpoc ABJISIeTC5I He KOppeKTHbIM, TaK KaK B (1)yHKIIH14 CJIy)K6bI
CHCTeMaT143aIIHH, o6o6meHmsr cyge6Ha HpaKTHKH H CBSI361 C 06ILleCTBeHHOCTI310
Cyga KOMpaT He BX0g5IT HOJIHOMOIIHA HO KOMMeHTHpOBaHHIO npoueccyanamx
pemeHHA npHHHmaemmx Cygb5IMH rip pacemoTpeHHH gem.

CTapundi cnetumalleT c.gyacom cllcremaTtnalum,

o6o61I(e111411 cyge6Hoil ripaKTHicll H cBa3eil C 0611leCTBeHHOCTb10
Cyta KoMpaT Kw Ha 11YKAJI