Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hagbi Yaniv Agnon Heidegger and Nietzsche
Hagbi Yaniv Agnon Heidegger and Nietzsche
'
.1
" " 2 ,
, .
, " " ,,
. .
3.
1
, , : - " .
: .2007 , ,
. - , .
2
" " , , , ,
.
3" " , , "
) . ( . : '" . ' ".
,(2002) 36-35 . .132 ,
.
, -
www.biu.ac.il/js/li/aj
'
, 4,
) (1976-1889 ) ,(1970-1887 ,
- ,
.
.2
, ,
, " "
) 5.(1924-1912 , ,
. " .
, , " 6.
, 7. ,
, . " " "
" , , "
][ ][ " 8,
. " ?
, ".
" "
" :
. ," " " ,
" ) . (.
4 . Charles :
Bambach. Heidegger's Roots: Nietzsche, National Socialism, and the Greeks. Ithaka: Cornell
.University Press, 2005 , ,
, .Martin Heidegger. Nietzsche I und II. Pfullingen: Neske, 1961 :
5 .
6 . .- : " , .
7 . .
8 . .
9.
73
'
, ' : ,
-"'.
10
- .
" ,
",
11
12
, , .
,1870 , 1872
, .
13
" ,
" , ,
. .
" " .
" " , ,
, , , . .
.
, ".
14
, .
, ,
. , " , , .
15
74
'
, ,
. , " ,
",
16
, " :
"
".
17
. ) (
" ,
" 18. , ,
" " , " :
] [ , , ,
; , , ! ) (
!"
19
" " , ,
1870 . " :
, .
,
, " 20.
, .
, 1870 ,
" " . , ,
.
, , ,
16 . .
17.
18 .- : " , .136 : ,2002 .127
19
) .(419
20 . .
75
'
, , ,
.
21
- . ,
, " ][ ".
22
" " , ,
" " , ,
,1870 , ,"
".
23
" " .
, , ,
" :
".
24
. "
",
25
, , ,
" " .
, , "
".
26
" ?" ,
,
, .
,Incipit tragoedia
" . " , " , ,,
21-
,
.Philippe Lacoue-Labarthe. Heidegger, Art, and Politics: The Fiction of the Political. :
.Translation: Chris Turner. Oxford, UK; Cambridge, Mass., USA: B. Blackwell 1990, p. 34
22
. .
23 . .
24 . .
25 . .
26 . .
76
'
".
27
" " .
.
, .
" " , , :
" , ,
" 28. -
.
? ,
, " ,
" , , "
".
29
" " ,
,- " " ,
, , " . "
" " , " " ,
,
.
. , -
" . " " " , " ,
" ) ( .
. , . ,
, , :
- ,-
, . ,
. ; - ,
" : , - ,
?
Heidegger. Nietzsche I. p. 279. 27
28 . .
Heidegger. Nietzsche I. p. 354. 29
77
'
. , , .
30
,.
,
, ,
. " " ,
, .
, " : , ,
?"
31
, , ,
" : -
' : , , !'"
32
" " ,
. ,
. ,
. , ,
, ,
" " , .
.3
, , .
,
. " , ,
- " :
, , , ,
30 . . : .- : ,1985 30
) .(3
31 . ) 354 .(341
32.
78
'
' ".
33
. "
35
36
. ,
, , -
. ",
" "" , " " " ,
.
:
. ,
. , ?
- , ?
, .
37
.
, , ,
. , , .
38
39
33
- . . : . , : " ,
-.
34 . .11
35
. : ." ,
79
'
.
, , , :
- ,
- ,
, ; .
, , , ,
40
.
41
42
, ,
. " "" :
][
".
43
" , ?
. ,
, " :
",
44
. " ,
39
. .
" ' ' ) (" :
Quentin Meillassoux. After Finitude: An Essay on the Necessity of Contingency. Translation: Ray
.Brassier. London: Continuum 2008, p.90
40 . . .93
41 . . ' , ) 41 .(549
42 . ) 44-43 .(551
43" . . - : " , .96
44
. .
80
'
" , , .
, , , , , , " :
] [...
" 45. " :
."...
46
" , ,
:
, , ;
; ; ;
; ; ,
, , , ,
: , , -
47
?
, " " . ,
, , ,
48
. , ,
, , " :
- ".
49
,
, ; " "" :
,
".
50
, ." "
,
45 . .
46.
47 . .- : " , .252-251
48 . .- : ,1968 .112 : .
" ' ' " " , ." , .164-162
49 . .
50 . .269
81
'
" : ".
51
, ,
, , . , .
, , ,
52
, .
" : . ,
".
53
, " : ,
".
54
.
causa efficiens ,
,
.
. " ] [...
, , "
" ,"causa efficiens- .
55
, , ,
56, ) ,(causa materialis ) causa
(formalis , ) 57.(causa finalis
, ,
. ,
51 . .
52 . .
53 . .
54 . .
55 . . ' , ) 41 .(550
56
. : . : . ,1999
.181-180
57 , , ,
. , . . : .
.181
82
'
, .
" ",
58
, ,
.
. ,
, , .
. ,
, ,
" : -
" , " " " ".
59
; ,
.
60
, ,
, .
. , ,
, , ,
.
" " ,
. , " " , ,
.
61
"
, ?"
" ",
63
62
64
59 . .177 .
60 . .195
61
. .
62 . .
63 . .
64 , -.
83
'
" 65.
. "
".
66
"" .
67
) , ,
( , ,
, ,
. ,
, , , ,
, ,
, .
.
" " , " , ] [...
, - '' , , , .,
, ,
-".
68
" " ,
, " "
. " "
, , , ,
, . .
" , ".
69
""
. "
",
70
- .
" ".
71
, .
65 . .
66 . .
67 . ,.
68 . . ' , ) 14 .(7
69 . . : ." .186-185
70 . .
71.
84
'
- , ,- , ;
. .
,
. " :
, ".
72
" "
,
" " , ,
.
.
? ,
, , ?
.4 - : Doppelgnger-
.
, .
,Doppelgnger , ' 73.(1796) Siebenks
, , , .
74
, ' , "
" 75. 1815- ' ' ' ,(1815/16) Die Elixiere des Teufels
72.
73
oder Ehestand, Tod und Hochzeit des Armenadvokaten F. St. Siebenks im Reichsmarktflecken
) Kuhschnappel , , , - , ..
( .' ) Die unsichbare Loge
( ) (1793) Hesperus - ( ) .(1795 Siebenks- .
74
, )""( )""(
85
'
, . 1828- -
" "Doppelgnger ,
.
76
77
) Der Student von Prag ( )(1913
78
, ,
) Der Golem( ).(1915
79
, ,
.
. ,
, ,
"" . , ,
, ,
.
" " . .
, ,
. , ,
") William Wilson "( ) (1839 .
") La nuit de dcembre "( ) ,(de Musset
Le Horla . ) (1846
-.
76
, .
77
,Gerald Br. Das Motiv des Doppelgngers als Spaltungsphantasie in der Literatur und :
im Deutschen StimmFilm. Amsterdam: Rodopi 2005, pp. 672-675.
78 1926-.1935-
79
86
'
"" . ?
:
,
. , ,
, ][
80
.
,1915 , ,
81.
.
82
, , ,
.
.
83
, ",
, , .
,) Der Zauberlehrling- (,
84
, ,Homunculus , -
.
, , ,
. ,
, , " " .
80 . .
81 , :' . , ,.
.272-256 ,110-82
Andreas Burnier. Mystiek en Magie in de Litteratuur. Leiden: Nijhoff 1988, p.12 82
83
1934- - ,
) (
" " , : . .:
- . - : , .183 " " )' . , ,.
.(272-268
87
'
,
Das Unheimliche
)" "(? - ,
" " , .
85
86
,"
" , , ,
, .
; ,
, , . ,
, . ,
- , .
.
" " ,
. , "" ,Dasein-
," : Dasein ' ' ] ,Das Man' ' ,
, ,[ '' ]
[ '' Dasein- ][ -
-- ] ---
[".
87
- ; ,
,
. "- - ,."..
, , "
- ] [ Dasein" 88.
, . ,
- , .
85
- . - .- : ,1997
.67
86 . . : .- : ,1988 .27
Martin Heidegger. Sein und Zeit. Tbingen: Niemeyer Verlag. 1927 (1967), p. 184 87
Ibid. p. 185. 88
88
'
89
--- ,
, .
, , .
90
, ,
, , ,
" " . ,
, -
.
, " " , ,
" " , " , "" . "
.
" " , .
" ":
, - , ,
, , .
; , , ,
, .
91
, .
. , ,
" : ,
" 92. ,
Ibid. p. 186. 89
90
"" ,
89
'
" : ".
93
, ,
94
"
" " : .
'
. ".
95
"
97
Unheimliche- , - ,
. Unheimlich
, , , . Heim
, "" .
, , " , ."unheimlich
98
, " : Unheimlichkeit
--".
99
- , - , .
93.
94
Johann Wolfgang Goethe. Aus Meinem Leben: Dichtung und Warhiet. in Goethes Werke Bd. 9:
90
'
" " , ,
.
100
" :
" 101. ,
, " . " ,
. , ,
.
" .- " , " -
".
102
, . , ,
"" , ," ] [Heimkehr
".
103
, ,
-.
, " " .
, ,
, .
.5 :
, .
,
100
) (Geheimnis Dasein- ,
91
'
, .
, , , , .unheimliche-
.
" " , , " ",
. , ,
. ,
104
. "
",
105
-.
106
, ,
, , , ,
. .
.
, ,
. ,
" " , " , ,
" ][
".
107
" : ,
, . .
. . .
. ,
".
108
- ,
. , " " , , ,
92
'
. " " .
" : ? /
" . , , ; ,
.
93