Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Affadavit Yeates
Affadavit Yeates
.,y:..(.. .:
......
':.'.
.~.
".,
,..... :
..". ':."
.~ '.' .'.
: '; ... ;
........
"
--..
,'
Plaintiff
'~
::~".:
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
v.
.....
)
)
)
----------------)
AFFIDAVIT OF EUGENE F. YEATES
State Of Maryland
)
)
SSe
accordance therewith.
2.
.-
; <t":
11
..
.,
.i~_.;'
d
'i,
.: ~}~~~ :i;~
3.
.~
" ;fo
.:.3
.~.
i'~
-f"
:f~".
.1
II
.;:.
I 9,
1~7B
r.
:."
located by CIA.
I .' .. ~~ ..
I documents.
. :~t~='~j'~~
. ,. -c , ~
Subsequently by
,I
rJ
'jl
'.
filed a request with NSA for the eighteen do~~ents- in his own
"
~i
dated 'January
9, '1979;
name on December 22, -1978 . In a letter
.
.
.
- -.
Roy R. 'Banner, thief, ~olict Staff, advised Mr. Gers~en that~
l'"
,II the NSA records that had been referred to this Agency by CIA
II were exempt from release under 5 U.S.C.S 552(b)(1) because they..
.' -.......
11.) are classified in their entirety, and exempt from release under
I
,
~s
'~A
copy of this
Iof
~etter
(A copy
i true, and
II attached
1\ the
! affirmed
IIII
'I
'.-
.~(~
..",
<:....
...,
li<:' ,
E=-~.
~~"
~~,-.
"\
,:':::~.:J './~::
,
552(b)(3)
~-5i'
~;
unde~
~'.'.
::.
'
f:"~'f")
,;;- '.:",
5 U.S.C.
..:
f?'~~,:.
"
'le"', ,
F,;i."
"":"'.
~" . . . .
Sft:., ,
t.'
by counsel, filed an
rcrx
.1
~,..
~r~,
1J?
\.
docum~nts, ':'~\
,'"
'
"
"
it.i.:' ,,;',
<,
':.
in possession or under the control of NSA relating to UFOs :';"~':':',/::':.'~ .';.~.~ I~{
.",-. r. -;
,,:~ . ~"' t4 ~/
and the UFO phenomena. (A copy of this letter is attached ,to '::";","'"
:..: ~!;:
,"
, ...:.:.:..:~. ,:';':':,I,L
:::u~i;~:;;.t '[~ ~
: .. :-:0: .. ,;.!.~
1\
iI
I
Ii
I
I
I,
I
II
\:
I;
I'
I',I
II
I'
I;
i:
"
I.
I'
1I
Ii
I:
II
,:'
U"S'C~
5798, 50 U.S.C. 5
~;'.'
,~~.
',:':
- .'.
I:
I:
Ii
. .:
>};j' ~.
NSA,:./\~~;.):;~:,I~l
l'
~~.
I\% '
'.
:.:.. ~~1 .
403(d)(.3~;>~'~':J.:.i ~l1
..
.''. '~~j.:':",~.
552 (b) (5) because they are intra agency memoranda, or letters ~ ..>
, ,'~'" ,t
ff;;.
-.h , ....,
::;~
~'~:~':"::i~;J .~ m.
~: "
~~~-:::. ff~'
',0:
e ,.:-.
;:':f;~: ::t~:i~
~".
Q~~~ .
-.
.The
:"~~'>:;j. r~"~;;
Jan~a~Y;{:.f..:if~ ,~\:i
::.".'': ,....
3:;f~N;~
.
1.:?
&'.'
g..
pot::
I
~
~.'
,
..
..
'
",
A total of seventy-nine
response to plaintiff.
.:
6.
'\
(A
7.
"
i,
!.
CI~
~ppealed
-'
and the subsequent
.,'
:1
'By
reply letter dated March 24, 1980, the NSA Freedom o~ Informa-
,
~::
IiII
'... I
I
to
I
I
8.
rece~tly
Ii
I!.,
~xhibit
.:I~~'.:-
8.)
II
9~
,
I
,I
Ii
II
I,
,
j;
11
ii
Ii
.. ' ..
".i.;:~~~ ~l~
..
"
A primary signals
intell~g~~~~A~.
. '~~"I.;7v:~.~ -l'~~
, ':':":'J~-:,--:~:~
'::::~"::!;~f~~
:;:H
-~'.~.~-:.:.;:.:.
Th~.:!:'fl!f~~:~
'.;:~~~~.4:l~~"~
:J>01
-t~~
.(COMINT):~~\!
~~~
.... : .. .-.. .. '.,;..',
~
Of the NSA records at issue in this case, only four are not
.
COMIN~
separ~tely.
..
~~~~~~ .~~
.~~~:..::::. '~':'.~:'.
.........
..~"!
,...;. :~~jk;)
j.
.,:'r
10.
I'
:~:';: ...-..'~
", f;.
",
'.
"
"
II
..
'':{';:
public use.
~1~
.::,;.:<:'~.
".' .,:.r.
.~
I:
~:
"I '
: roo.
~ ~.l
. . :-:
, r '
.
";.~~./.~!:ff~.i:!il :;72.
,-:::' . ;:.
... :
.01'
:~
.~:.~~
(~,~.~
,.-::..:..;.:~
...
i,
Ii
iil:
,;
i'
This
':"<:';:1,',:
i~~~~~~~:;1:2:
"
-. i
,.
I!
I!,
by the public.
'\
fo~'~;~~'~;':~{?HI~
. ;::.':':i:;
! which more than half the encrypted. and plain text radio
ca tions of foreign governments, foreign organiza tions,
their representatives are carried.
'."
.",'"'
~~~mt;!:l .~.
and:" :~~t~~~l ~l
.. ~~;.:...:. ,.' :i;tc
.. ....:t~~~1~~ :}
'.-" ...~'.:",~~:'~.~.'.
....;,~fo
.....
".
11.
..
'"
;'~'7:.
..': :; ~~~;.~~!
./~
.: "': ..
...
.-.
~
:.
':.~~~.~
'. : :r".. ~ -.,;ftr
'
'.:' :~~:;;~f;~i~~
/~:~.'
.: :~\.:?~t~~~
.. \ .
~
..
...
".
~.:
... -. ....
. .:~~~.
"
'
;...
:~ ". '
.~'
. -:
.'!"
tti ...
f~' ~:"~.'.
~ ..
P::::
,:.;
.'
"
.1
~.: ~.:
."
.
.~.';-'"
so, too, a s ~t
nown to
:~*
.....
.'J.: .;-.
is a
".
'.
prima~y
expected to know, ~lso, that NSA cannot possibly intercept eV~~:~f';,:; &'~
~.
;.'.J.'.:
.:.".::'-;
."
".
":".1
~~ ~:f:
..
:.~
".
'.
:\~
,j~
.'.:::;)).
States terminal.
......
.-....
.:
II
II
,.
t,
......
presumably know well' -- NSA must focus its interception activi-.;,~~ .,:,-::~
pO:.
-'
'.
;~;~
-.
",
'::'.~~ .j:.i.
.'
...4,:;
,-'I
intelligence information.
.-.'
'-.
~' :.~:~,
'.;..
-...,~~
..
......
.' .
~
.. .1
-..
.~. ..-.
"
.,,:
"
'.
......
. .' ~
','
I!
.. ~,.':". : ~.:
of those that are intercepted, which yield. to NSA procesSing.:-, <~.::.
.1
I:
;,[r
li!
13.
,.~:
.:';':
,:,:.);;~t~::i1
activities requires that the lines, channels, links and systems -; ~'i':';
II
\1
~~identified.jf a
foreign
gO~:~'~i;~i~ij
<~'.t~~i: :~~
of ways.
1.
=.'-.'
...
"
~:
.~.
..... :
.,
I'
r:
.~
.!.
.,.~.i~~Y~~~.: ;7~
Ii;~
...
'~)"',7: ',''';~
. :~'.::: :.".".:-
.:
.~i;,~~ .~
'I
. <S;,~~~~
I
I
.',
.!.'.~
':.
.:- ."
~:.
~
'.
!;
Tori
.;:
-".
!i
,"
Finally, a
.,
!.
.',
!:
,;
~
:i
;.
'.
'.
!"~
t;
i:
p
"
~!
14.
tha~
source is lost unless and until NSA can establish a new and
i~
;,
j:
equivalent intercept.
I'.
The infor.
.... ::
:\
r:
I.
i!,.
"I,
t
I:I'
Obviously, if a
~OMINT
,.
I:
r:
!:
i:
."
I"'
i,r :
,".
"
r:
Sometimes it is impossible
,.
I
I
i
I
I,
I'
I!
"
15.
':
i,
:t
II
Ii
"I
NSA
I'
interest.
II
~ I
n
P
l:
;,
Ii
I
i,
"/-.
I!
o
I:
t,
ttJSi
52iU.ibU
&I.e
~,
~~
!;
;j
.I:'
techniques.
~.
~~'
.~~
16.
~i~
li~
",~
B:
purposes.
If
;; .'
s:
Without~entifYing the
11 tions.
f#
~,
};::..
~~'
-I
11
inferences and
I collection
and
I
intelligen~e
officials to draw
"
I~~
t:~,
~...r.i
~
lor,
J,
..
'(I~
..
"
,~ ~:
1!r
..
'
~,::
I<lit
/I capa~ilities
l!
intelli-
~:
....:
p'
The
- II
"
~'
II
,-
\0
I gence
..
~~1~
r~
~~
.....
~:
..
I~~~.
C,r,of.
. ;:;.:~
:0'
i~
~~
f":'
~}1'
r'
;r~
r~
,~,
I capabilities
17.
klY.' -
~ u;~
r:.{
,-'
~:
~~I!> '
~.,t
~;;:
~1.
~~~.
I?:
~~'
.~~
~
~"-'!.~~
"
~~~: .
tiiiJ
~.,
.",..
~~,
f' ,
~1; "
ffi'~~
pI.
"
"
L'
'I
1'\,
"
w,'
}~
~-
;..J.
1}~':
~,
~:
f.'~
r.- ~
6',
I
..
IIi:J
"
.. ..
'.'t
tI
'I
ji
Ii,- rest,
The
,II'
I,'I
il
I,
I'
'I
Ii
"
resuI~
..
.. : .
", '.;;:
....'e,
in exceptionally
I'fl
I:II
IJ
I"!
\
.. '~'.' :".;
"
.. :-
I!
\I
il'J
h
" classification
II
I!
.; .
......
~~~~~.
...
! sucfi
I
~s
Ii
~""~~l ".I~
::
dproperly
I'(I
_~i
so classified.
thereof remains
-' .. :,
~',
"
II, they are properly classified 'dthin the categories provided-'II in Section 1-1 of the Order. I have reviewed all of the COM IN; . I
I
I,
-, ~
!I 3-1
I
r-
..
,~
,";
:.:~I~~~"~':.:!
..
~'--'.:";~
this time and determined that the records should continue to be,,':..;.;
. ..~.-:;:~ ~~~ ~\
.~ \. ~.': !:=.'
.:
".:'
in~elli~,~
,~
~\.::.,t..-::,::.
.~.~
-~. e ,
Because
..
....
..; .
,
~
!Ii
l!
;~?~~
..','
-.',
:~~~~~rt%.;t! .~
:. ;~."
"
~~r
{',"
r..~ J
.:.~:
..
18.
I'
.",
.~.:,,=--
.-:-
.i :
:;r..
....<"
-.
I'
I'
W:,
d~
Public disclo-
I of
Ii'I
l!
-infor~
.\1
II
"I;';
Moreover,
II
.......
";;!:
~.<>,
II
'
t~ :~.:'.: ~,':\
I!
I!
II
II
.": ...
~ele~se
~,
~.
I
i
Ii info rrna tion concerning. the communications intelligence act'ivi ties' ! ~;~
nr of the United States. The disclosure. of these records or any por- ~....
:.:.
il
: ..
!l
.~,
,:;,
O{.
..
;;L::
t.~~
f:'.:
403(d) (3.
~~'
that the COMINT records are exempt from release under 5 U.S.C.
~f
..
t=~:
l';;
.'
~%
'11
the
~~
.....
'
.'
I COMINT
I
I
..
..
';
..
-.
..';':
.i
'I
!~
I~
'.
~"
exemptions (b) (1) and (b)(3) are not based only on the subs tan-
of
.--_ ...
~!. .' ..
';
'~ .~ ..::'.
II
I!! disclosure
.: ..
~~
".:
': , .'
~L~:.: '~
~.,:::)::
i I~{>-
I
!
i
I
10
ij
~ j.:.:..
~r-: .'.: .
\'
".
..
'"
".
.,
'j
seeks.
i-
:1
originally transmitted.
'I
-.~
:J
./
'i
II
I
-\
The
conte~t.
On~
of
Questions which
--_.-
~as
The
entire report has been released except for the name and organization of the preparer of the document.
This is not a
purposes.
which provides that the FOIA does not apply to matters that
are specifically exempted from disclosure by statute.
..
"
..
,
I'
i:
;:
i.
~tatute
applicable
.'
I;
r~late
I
I
"
i~
I!:
~
curr~n!-ly
informa~
and prop_erly
,"
"
I:
I,
I:
I:
Ii
I:
Moreover
disclos~re
of
u.s.c.
which
I,
I
i:
!i
I'
I'
.,
;
'.
I,
I,
i
Ii
II
I
i
-,
'.
"
':
o!:
,.
~'.
specif~cally
86-36 which
The
-:
..
-'.
';
",
. : .~. .
:.r
.!{
.'
.,' .
.~.-
: ..~ ..
an~lysis,
It includes the
I:
Finally,
..
:'.~
.-
:~.
request.
c.
"
request.
I.
II.1
Ii
~ctivities
Ii
ph~nomena
il
.i /
d.
lj
The final
non~COMINT
I;
.:: .
Ii
.'"
I,
I
I;i:
request.
I:
'I
I,
.;
I'
"
, .
.~
..... :.
,
!:
-.~
'
f ...
13
.....
~'..... :"
.'.'
.:' '.
..:...
:~
....'
:: '...
21.
.,.t:'
;!
"
_---:~~~e.11J
e.u t "-I
EU NE F. Y~ES
.
I
~.::~/
.:
-.
".
--...
':~.'-'
.......
'.'
.'? .
-. "",
:::'.
'.'
!
:
J;
...,.,:
.....
'.
,.
I'
:,
I'
. "'~.. ~'.-:--
",
....
"~\
I:
!~
\!
r
;1
Ii
1\
i
I
il
. '.~
'.'
)
11
..,: .
',.
,
"
IiP.
~
14
11
I!I;
.....
- ....
....
...
......
.'
.- .
!,
:;
'."
'
.. ':.'
:.'.:. .. ~
." -:
".:,
!:
..... : ...
!:
.. . :~:.~..
. ,~
.~
..
'
Ii
:'.
.. "
-.'
:.'