|

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|



 


       !
"   # ##$  #  
 %" " #& 
$  
"#'# #  !%#


( &# ! #& 
 (#!!#



 









   





 






 

 
 


m !

) %"



 


  "
#







 



$
#
m

%&%
'
'(
'%)
'%
''*
'*)

'*+


'( !



* +%"



 


 $



   
#

, $ 
,






$ 


 






 



(
,

 -./




  (#'# !%#  0
%" 1  '# '   #
%"   #$ 1  ## #
"#!% 1  %#'# #& "  
# %# 1" ! '  
%#


(#'# !%#
-


 
 

$
$

 



. 



$ 





$

 














  









 










 



 

 
 
 




$
#






Subject matter of conventional redemption










#

#/ 




pacto de retro





 
 


 









 
m

*)+
*
*
*
*%
*+
*&
 




#


$
#



Nature of conventional redemption

-





#





 




#







#
#

$ 








-






 
 





 



 




  




 
#


 



 
 


-





 

 
#



# 
 


%
-


 $
#






 


$

|||||||||||||m
 m
|

'
-




  
#



 

 

 

. 
#


$

  

*
-




# 
 
#




 $ 




$


$

 

+
-

$






  








 

 














 


 
 
 

 


 



$
#
m

%+(

&


 

 

 


 
 
 













 




 


#
 


#







 



$
#



(
-
 $
 

 

# 
 




 

 














$

m** !





 $ 




  














$



Option to buy and right of repurchase
x

 

 





 




$
#

$



#.


#


 
$
#


$














 
 





x
0 




#




 

$


$


 

 





 






$
#

$










#


 


 

#


 
 


 

#


m  





#







 

#




#
 


$  






 





1 
 



$  


 

 



 


 



 

 
 






2


m
*)


1  







 

# 


 











#



#









 
 






 


. 

 



#













 


 











#

 




#







#/ 



ight to redeem and right of repurchase

 


# 
 
 







 



 



 







 
#


 


    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|

3    

#


#

 

#

 


!

 



#

  

#




 
4 

$


 



 
 



 
# 
 
m
 

 








5


#



 


 



m



#
#

# 
 !



 
  
 
   




 
 










#

 







 )
 "#"   %! #  
2 !#$   #&  &##1 "3
 4  %" #&   1  #
%"   25
) 4  '# !  %##
  # #15
* 4 %# # &  %# #& 
 # %" # !
  %# #& !%# #
  1 %#  "5
6 4  %"  &# !& 
% #&  %" %"5
7 4  '#  !& # % 
 #   #5
   # " 1  !  &
&    # #& 
%    "# 
"  % ! #&   # 
%&#!" #&  # ##
  #&  &## "$  !# $
& # # & #  "'  
'   # #1   "#
  1"   8" #  
1


2 #
-


 





  






.  
  #
#








#


 



 






#/ 






  




#




 
 #










Mhe pacto de retro problem

 






  










#
$

 $ 



 #  








  



Pacto de retro and mortgage
6




7


0 



0 





#

 




#



#/ 


  



#/ 





 






 



 $

 
  





  




 


 



  


 

# 
 







-










 




 






$



























# 
 

 





 


 !

 


$


$


 










 


#

|||||||||||||m
 m
|


#




 

-









 






 


 


 
 









 


#

 
#





#
 








 




Subsequent sale of property by vendor a retro



 


$













 
8










 









#.


#

$




 
 


$






$9
 


 

 



9

 



 







Y
 
 
     

  






 







 










 



 

 


 

#



#

!






 
 



 


  

#
#








-
.


 


 



 










.



  



  


 



 
$





 






#



 
  


  
#
 







ntention to execute mortgage may be fairly inferred
m



#






























# 



 
 









 



2


'

m

*)


#

 $





 




 











 






m








#



. 
#













 





  




$




 
 











 
$













$




 



 
  

 

 



















 


$

. 
 


 






  




#/ 



$9
 

 



m


 

 

 
$


 




. 
#


1 

    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|

 






$
#


$



# 






 *  " #& #$  "#" %%#
#    1  # %"  
"#   2 !#

 6
 %#'# #& " )  #
%% #  "#" %%# #   #



Presumption in case of doubt






#









#


#


. 
#


$






 
 
 

m 
*)



 


#







 


 



 











$



-




 







#



 


 
 

 





#








 
 
 

 

m 
*)






 
#


Effect where contract held as an equitable mortgage






 

#


 



 

 







. 
#








#
 $
 







 
 




. 






. 
#


 
$
 



#




 




$
$

$


#.

 





 





 



#






$










#




$


5



#


5

# 
  








# 








#


 



 



m)&& 

%




 




 

 


#









 


 
 

 
#


 










#

  



Pacto de retro sales not favored
1

 


 

 





$






 
#


















 

 









  
#





 
$









. 
#




#
$ 
#







|||||||||||||m
 m
|

 7   " & #  " )

 6$  %% '# ! 0 &# 
&#!# #&  !


-&#!#




#


#



 



 


















 



 


 
 









x
-


 







#












#

 

 

 







#













#










#












x




#

 



 








 
  & #  " $ 
 " #&  % !$  
&#  &#!   #&  "#"

#    !$  %#
"# "  

#1'$  '# !  "
  # %" 1 *   &#! 
! & 8! 1    "' "#
#     "#" 1    1
 # %"

  & # "#'# !%# 
# # %% 1  "#"  # # #&
 1  #& %"


:
$ 

 






$


$


 



 


 


 


x


 



#


 

















$


  



-














 


$

 





 


 
  




#
 



#





-


 





 









$
#







# 



 
 




 
  
 


 


#




 


 


#
%


















 
 
)




$





)




  






 
 
 

 



-


 





$



$


 









 
 
$



  


 
 

)



    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|


)5

 


#


 









$

 
9
 


 

#



 
-





   $
 
#




.  

  

 


 


 




 



Phen article 1606, par.3, not applicable
-




#







#



#







 




$
#
 

 



2 



$  


#






 

 







Date from which period reckoned
;









m 
*)*





 

 

#





















#



 



 

 



;






m 
*)*



#





 



 


 


/
# 
 
!




/

# 
 




 









 


$ 
#
 



Effect of stipulation extending period of repurchase

m
 
 

 

 

-



 #




 

#



 

  



#



#


 



$




 




# 

#




 
 


 


 


  




#

$ 




 
  

  







#
)

!

 

 

$ 





 



eason for limiting period of redemption
m



 






 






 



Validity of penal clause providing automatic
termination of redemption period
-







 






 



  

 


 






 

)




 





#

$

 
 


 


 


#







 . 


$



 9  " #&  %#% $ 
"### #& #1%   ' 
' #&  & #&  '# # "#!% 1
 %#'# #& "   # 
"#   - #& /#% 1# 
8" #$ &  '#   


|||||||||||||m
 m
|

udicial order for recording of consolidation of
ownership
-




$$



$





  

 




$9

 
# 
$
#
#

 
 


 


$



#
 



4 

6
 


/




 



$


#













 



#


 





#



. 
#












$


#
$









 
 

 



 
#



$

  


#




 
 
 
 

# 






-




m 
*)+




.   


 
#


$






 

 







  

 

 

 




# 
$


 

#

 





$
m



 

#
$ 
 $



  





#


 



/


 


#
m 
*)+





 
 

#






  

 
 



 

 



Effect of failure to comply with the requirement


 






$






 
m 
*)+





#

 


$





#
 



4 

6
-




 
 


 



  #

m 

*)+









  


 

 



Action to consolidate ownership

 
 


#
 




 

$ 

 
 "
#
#

4,
 


$














  

 

 

m 
*)+













 



# 



 




 

  



 :
 '# !   "# 
' %## 1#   ' &#! 
'$ ' &   "# "#" # !#
# '  ! #&   #
%"$ 1# %8" #  %#'# #&
 # 1    -# 1
1 %" #  %#



 






<


 




# 
 !

 
 
m'*



. 

$

 






 









  

#





 
 


 


 

$ 

 











#



 
 

    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|


 

 















#
 



Exception:

$  


7









4 
 


 
 

 


 





$






 
 
 

 





#.



$








 
 




 







 ;
 '  # # 
'#<   "#


1#
 





#



 
 



 



 





#$

 



#












 


$



#/ 


  

 

m



$









 

 
 




 





/


 

 $





$











 

#/ 



 

 


$

0


$




 












ight to eject vendor
6 
 
#

$











  
 








 




$







$ 







 


$






#
 



$







 
 "# #&  '# "#
!0  #&   #& !%#  
'$  &  '  
%#% #&  '#


 

 




 

 


 



 




$

 






  


$



 
 










m



 

$





 
 
 
 

 



$



     1   # %"$ 
' #&  % #&  ' !!#' 1#
"2  1# #&   " #& "
6;:$ ! "#!%  '# # !  1#
%#% $ &   1 # !0  #& 
 #& !%#





 

 


  

5
 
 

  "


 
#
  




 


$




5

|||||||||||||m
 m
|

 ) & ' %#$ 8#   

! "#"$ #   '
!!#' 1   #& %"$ # #&
! ! "   &# !#  
%"' 


 !   %% &  %#
1# #  !!#' #  & '
$  1" " " #&   ! #
!  % 1"  ! ' "2

 *   " #&  %" "$ 
' ! ! #&   '# # "#+
  "#! #  ! %# 
%" #&  1#  #5  #
 & # # #$  ' "#  "#!%
# "# #  % !%#


edemption in joint sale by co-owners/co-heirs of
undivided immovable


5



 $ 
$
#

#


/ 

  $









 

 

 



 
 
 






 
  $





1  


5 


$



 $ 

$
#


 

 

 




  $
 


$
 




$









 !




. 



$




 




 







 
#








Effect of redemption by co-owner of entire property

 
#


5






 
 








 







-










  



5 



 6 " # #&  "#+#1 #& 
' !!#' 1# ! ' # 
 % $ ! % " 
 #& %"    #1 $ 
 ' "# "#!% ! # ! 
1# %#% 


 


$
/ 



 7 &  ' # ' ' $
 "# &# !%# "#  #
 " #& ! "% &#  #1 $
1    '$ #   
%# !# !$

= &  "   '$
   #   1 # # #& 
$  "# &# !%# !  
 ! &#  1#


edemption against heirs o vendee

$





 

 






 


$



 
 

    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|



 
  $





 
#

 $ 




#

  






8$

#

  

 



#

/





 

$



 

 







 







 
 '# "# ' !& #& 
 #& %" 1#  # 
'  %" #&  $   #3

 % #&  "#"$  
# ! % ! ! 
# #&  5
)
 "  & % !
#   #


Obligation of vendor a retro in case of redemption
8




$


<


6 







= 



>





$



 
-



$




 






 

#


 
#






  





#

$


?






  




-




  



 
 







#


$





#
 #
#


$





#





$
 



 


 
  










#











 









Necessary expenses





 



$
 


 


 



$



 
 





 




 


 

#





$




 



 



 



$
 
#






 


/


 




#
#
#

$



Useful expenses




 
 


$




 



$




;






$


#



 












$




 $

 

. 


$




$


$





#/ 







 





|||||||||||||m
 m
|









m 
'%*


'%+



,,




$










$
 
#

$


!

 







 





 
 #






Offer to redeem and tender of payment generally
required


 

 


$

 
 


 

 

 



 


$

 

 



. 






#


#

 





 
#







 







 
 










 




2 


 








 

 


$










 $



-








 

 




 



 








 








$
#



 

 


$ 
 






 




$
#
$



Consignation of price generally not required
-






.  


$






 
 

/

 


 








8




#
8




 




# 
 

 

-







  


 













 
 


$

$ 

  

  


$







$


 
 

 

 


 






 


$




 




#
/

 


 

 



/


  
 


 


$







$








#



 
  $






  


 
 


/
1

$

  










 
 


$
#


 






n case of absence of the vendee a retro

 

 


 
#
 





$

 






 














#




$



 


 

 



 9 &   ! #&  "# #&  
 #  #  $ ' # #1
&$    ! # !! &#
# %# #& #    ! #&
!%#$ & # ! 1 %  
%" 1   1 "

    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|

#  '  # &  
! #&  $  #!    ! #&
!%#$    %# 1 
!%#   '$ '   
% "#%# #  !  %# 
    $ "# &#!  '
#&   #&  


ight of parties as to fruits of land
 

 

 




 

$


$ 




 



 
 



 
  



 

 
-











 
, $ 
 











#


$




 


-


 



 








$






#

 #



 

 











 

 


-

 




#

$



 



#

 #



  



 

 


-





 



 








 



 


 



#

 

 

#

 



$
 $ 










 


 





 










 $














$

 








# $





#



 



 








$







 :
 '# 1# "#'   #
 "'  & &#!  " # !#
"#   '$    %"
  1"   ! ' " 
## &$   ""#" 1  "#! #&
 %" 1    


ight of vendor a retro to recover thing sold free from
charges

$






 

 #







 
$

 



 
 
# 
$
#

 





#
 




$
#






#








#


$






$




# 







$



 

  $







  

 






 










$

# 


  
 

 



 

$



$








 
















  

 


#
#
$  





 



 -./



|||||||||||||m
 m
|

 ;  !%#    # 

#$ %#  ! !  "##
%   "#"$   %" #& # 1#
"2   %" # #  % !$
#   # "# 1 #1% 
!  ## 



 

 

#
$
#


$
#





Mransfer of ownership by onerous title
1#
 





#



 

 








 









 




 



#








 
#

 
8$









#






  


#

 

 

 





$

#















3
 










-



  


 



 
#


#


 





. $





 



# 
 
8

#




 


 







. $








 
#



Nature of dation in payment


 














m
 
















#/ 








 
 

#























#/  $
$
 


# 
 


 








. $




 




# 
 

 



#/ 








 

#

 




 

 



Basis and nature of right of legal redemption




$ 





 


 



 


$







 


 
 








 



 


#
$




$ 

 

Example:




$







 
  

 



 
 





.



$

#
 
#






 
 




 










 




 

$
#


 




$ 

 
 






#  




$

#

$
-
 



 


 






#



 

    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|


 



 






 
 
#



#



 $ 

#

 

#














 









 $ 









#
 







# 


$  


 



 








 
#


 

#


 $ 


 

 



#


-



   "
5 
-








$


 
2


$ 


 

 






 



#


#

#
 


#



nstances of legal redemption
m 
*)
*
*
*%


)&&



;





 



 




 <


4 
#








 .



 

  













4 

#









6#


m 

 


'




4 
#
/
#


 







  

 




%
4 
#










#
/

 





 

()


#
#

 
 



#


-







5/

 











  









 
 





'
4 
#



 





 

#





 

&)



 

  

 


#
$
#

$






 



3m4



 
 




 
 


  

$



 

 
 


 

 



5


m 
*)



 )  "#+#1 #&   ! " 
 #& !%#  "   #&  
# "#+#1 # #&  #& !$  # # 
 %# &  %" #&  # 
# "'$  !%#  %
#  # #

# 1# # !# "#+#1  #
"   #& !%#$  ! # #
#  %#%## #    !
%"' '    #1  "#!!#


  
      




#
5 


 !




#

 
 















5!

|||||||||||||m
 m
|






#



 




!



%




#
#

  


 



 


5





  



5
 




 




#
$





#






  






5
 


 
4 
#


5

  

 
  #
#






# 





5



,5

$

 



 

















 $ 

#






 




nstance:
1




 

 
 


 





#

  








5 


#
#




 


 

#
 # 
 



 

 
$ 

#


  

 




#




 


  

  





#

$
m)&& 
 


 
 



 

 


5 


5


 

 



 

#
$

#
m
*)


*




 



 








  $


  

5
#

 




#.

. 
 
  $



 

 
# 



Phen right cannot be invoked

 


#
$











 






#


  
/



5/

-







  


#






$



 







$

#





#















 




#/ 



 




$  
$










5

 @ 









#








5


$

 





Price of redemption



. 

 









#
 


 



 
 



  $
 


$
 

#

#



 
5








 












Purpose of the grant of right to co-owners

 

#


 

 


 





 


# 


 
 


    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|


$


#

  
 







 )
 #1 #& 8#  
# '   #& !%# 1  %" #&
 $   #& 1" # # " #
"$  $    # #
#1   


   # %%" # 8"
 1"  %  ##0$ $
'$ #  # %% ' &#
 & #& # 

& 1# # !# 8# #1  #
"   #& !%#   ! !$
 #1 #&  8#  #& ! 
  %&5  # #  '
 ! $  # 1# & 2 
!%#


ight of legal redemption of adjacent owners of rural
lands
4.  


 


 <









  

 


 







#



#

!






#

/
!




#



 
 !

%

  






 




 

 
!

'




$











!



*








#



#

#



$ 








$ 



/  







 

 



/






 $

 



 

#

 







 

# 









 


#
 





$









/






 










. 







#
 


 




#




 

$












 
#





4



A

 


  












 







-


 



 


  






#
 
 



 




#



 



  





  






# 




$


 




#

/





 


 



$

 






Preference as between two or more adjacent owners
of rural lands
-






/


 


 

 

 



 $

 






/  




|||||||||||||m
 m
|






#

#



$











 
.

 



,5
 
 
 

 







Purpose of the grant of right to owners of adjoining
rural lands


# 

/




#









$ 
   

 $
 



 

 



 )) 4'  %" #&   1"
 # !  #    !8# %##
#& "#   &#  %"" %%#
1  # !$ '  #
! &# %"#$  # #  +#$ 
#1 #&  8#     #& %+
!%#   # %"

&  +   %&"$ 
#1 #&  8#   '   #&
!%#$ #   # %"

4 1# # !# #1 #& 8#
 1 # "   #& %+!%# #
!%#$  #1 1#   #& 
  2# %%  8&  
%&


/+!%#
-





 

 
 
#

-


 
#










5
#
$



-!%#
-

 







#
 




$

   


 


 
 



  







-23



  

 

#



/

!



  





#







 






/
 




#









  




#
 !




1 
#





#
#





 
 



#$
.  

#


#


/  



 




$
#
 



 
-


 
 













#







 



$
#








 

$  

 



?$











 


 

#



 

m
*






  




 








 







 )*
  #&  %+!%# #
!%#  #  " 1 *  

    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m

  


||||||||||||||||||||||
|

&#!  #"  1   %#%"'

'#$ #   '#$   " ! 

 #&   #  "#   -
#& /#% $  ""#!%   &&' #&
 '#    ' 1 #"
#& #  %# !%#


  #& !%# #& "#+#1
"  #& 8# #1


 

 




 

  




  



 

m
*)

*


*




 
$ 



#$

 


#
-





5 #




 





 













#












$


 
?$



 






 

 


 








)5

 




   $
 
#





.  

  
 



 


 



 
-



 


#



 

 




  


 



 
-





   
-





  

  #

 


 
 
#



 

 


 











  


 





 








 


#

)5

 


 
 
 
#$ 


/


 



/


#





Notice by vendor or prospective vendor

 

)






 


  
 $
#

  $
$

#


$







#



#

$







.  

$

 $


 


$


#












  



$
  

 
# 




 
 




Notice must be in writing
m

 

 
 


$#


#

 
 









. 






#




 



 




 

 


#$ 


#




$



 












$
  




. 


#




 
 


   $



Form of written notice
m 
*


  #



 




 










 
 





 

  
1






 



  







|||||||||||||m
 m
|



 



)



 



 



1  





#$

 


$ 




 



 $ 
 




 


#

  $


  





#




$ 


 


 
 






$

 
/ 



How right is exercised

 
















 








 




 
 




$9

#




 
$

 

 

$
 









  #









#

 
8 



 

#






 
 
 

#

  







 
 
 



 
 
  

  #
 



;


 
 



.  



$
 
 


 


$ 

 








#
 





 




#
 
0





 

#

 


 


 


#




 


$ 

  
 







 








#

  





#

$


9









  
 

    | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | m
|

m