2

( `

,2

A MMI

`,

ua ch

7[,

,
` 3 2`

A M M
I

ls[

A

1 998

AMMI

AM M

4 7 1 6 )

( A M M )I l[
,

( 1988
)

No

M M I

MM

MM

au hc an d Z ob el (

1995
)

AMM I

M M I ?

AM M I

l[

kj

iy

+ +

.ys

( IP
,

j 1

( )
:

ia

k 1

ljk

(1)

( )

C A ) is
(

gn

lu v
a lue )

( 1)

;
H G G au hc M A T M O D E L
.
P
L
c
l
i

or le u
s

:
:
1 9 9 6 2 0 0 9 1 9 9 7 0 5 2 1
.

MM

IPC A

MM

iP

I Pc A

IPC A

o n

co m p os it
;

,j
E

i(z )

,
,

y y

22

( IP

IPC A

is( gn lu ar va lu

Z
,

c A )

( 196
8 ) F

ol ob

CA I

IP C A

F t E

A M M I

l1[

K e m tP

d ,

i IP

df

c A

IP

CA

1 IPC A Z

I (P

u a e

(;

a n

d Z

IP

c A I

IP

23

CA

c A Z

a
b e l ( 1 9 9 5 ) S h fii

IPC A

2992 )

` 2

E IG A ( ) V

(C

o r n e

l iu

1996

19 9 5
)

IPC A

IPC A
2

IP C A

(3 )

A M MI

AM MI

J A M M I
,

au hc an d Z ob el (

A M M x

I PC A

( )

( 3)

( )

I PC A ( )

f`

IP

(3
)

CA

IP

( t 992
)

l[

E i2 l

( l)r

IP

) I (P

( 2)

e s
e
e
s

( co r p on d cn an al y is )

( 1)
Sh a
f i

( 1984
)

on

2, 1)

MA

A T

T MO DEL

( )D E I

(A G )

(l 8)

M A T M O D E L A M M I
,

l( P C A )

l0[

`3

n
a

ma
g os

97 %

1993
)

dn oF x(

0 % l[
1

T h

r es u

lt

r e a

En

Ge
v

n o t

y p

ir

o n

r A

bl

e s

id u

t y Pe

Th

o v e r

th

ts

M S

5 5

75 15

35

7368

38

4 93 7

ig

e
ifi

a n e e

e v e

gn

i f ic
a

t IP C A

a x

IPC A Z

0 484 1

5 53 8

6971
.

0 5 0 14
2959

1203
.

0295

0 17 7 0

4292

17 8 4

l ]

2857

7294

18

28 0 7

0651

4826

0 7043 0

9583

3977

17 0 5

0 0729

4337

3120

8301

6387

4115

0 00 2
.

2 1 16
0299

2083
.

0
0

1476

0 0658
.

0 0199 0 0915

0 26 6 8

4043

10

1497

7484

2585

0646

6662

0399

r o

1 2 3 8 10

3680

b b il it y

22 30
.

1 32 8

7 5 19

4940

(
IPCA I

1)

IPC A Z
,

IP C A I IP C A

0969

4322

(I P C A I 5 ) 2

1280

0205

3873

1429

pe s

IP C A S
0

0 2797

ty

3724

2094

e n o

c A

0 2 9 13

0 0424
.

o r

IPC A 4

0766

IPC A 3

s e s

4503

IP C

A S

22

1417

Th

204

e r r o r

1453

c A 4

c n

IP

3 76 4

o n

t m a t r x

57 0169

0550

ir

e n

1 5359

c A 3

e n v

r o n

1 4259

IP

e n v

10

8 9 8 3 35

e s eo r es o

IP C A I
.

t y P e b y

Df

::

C A I

IP

n o

er r o r

oc

t h e ge

e n o

o n

r ro r

bl

r a

M I (

l y s si

t o n

IP C A

te r a

70 20 %

in t

AM

a n a

In

47 %

e n

56%
.

IP

MM

ea n

n t

me

o u r e e

80 % 90 %

10

15 t h e m

z2[

IP C A

T a b le

65

CA

IP

M M I

)
.

8
6

0 %
4

IP

31

( )

CA

3 5

IP

CA I 5

( l)

CA I 5

> B>

E> G

> A>

F.

I C A I

A MM I
.

F ig

B ip lo
a n a

CA I 5

1 2

> H >

ly

i s fo

r e s u

e n o

IP C A

IP

CA

bl

A MMI

Th

t er ,

f g

IP

CA

e n o

y eP

t a b l l t y

fo

e
r
R

e s s o n

a n a

ly

e r e n

t a

n a

l y s m

s s

e ()v a

th

od

lu

St

bi l i t y

e a n

d i ff

Ce

I) (2 )
.

55 65

4022

()

4988

70 13

54 34

2 98 9

0
.

r a n

e r e n e e

0
0
0

9588

0 4 3 53

s :

5 98 0

7 7 58

1 4347

8081

1 0866

7 3 30

1 5170

9 2 62

3161

9682

7 25 1

IP

CA I 2

08 5 9
.

7791

8 92 0

9153

7772

5 38

4 24

549

54 5

1241

296

276

05 7 4

14 4 1

820

64 8

0 4 16

1 280

1 65

1 5 38

693

23 9

05 2 3

(2 ) IP C A

240
640

0519

4 056
1 668

te

036
.

286

536

464

14 3
356

321

35 7

1%

o n

D ( 1 ) 1
b

D ( l)

M RD
.

8 22 2

te

IP

No

ly is

I) ( l )

f A MM I

A MM I

V n r a n

ty P

z[ 20[

a r a

a n a

AM M I

t y pe

lt

e n o

IP

CA I 2
,

D ( 2
)

iD

CA I 2

IP

IP C A I 2

> B > H > C > E> A > D > G

C A I 2

IP

IP

I{

3 5

( 1.

IP C A

( 3)

0 %
6

IP C A

IP C A Z (

CA I

IP

a s e

a ra

t e

IPC A I 5

f g

o
,

t y pe

e n o
:

ig

ta

s
bi l i t y b a e d

e a n e e

if i

e v e

a r

o n

l% p

r o

:
5
IP C A 1 2 I ) ( 2 ) 1

b b ili

ty

a r a

e n o

ty p

s ta

bi l i t y

;
b

A MM I

IP

CA I 2

IP

> H > D > B > C > A > E > G

> H >
>

> A >

> c >

>

>

>

>

H >

>

D (

A >

>

>

> G > F > c > E

;
;

i
) A M M I D ( 2
1
)

CA

IPC A

A M

A M M I 14[

A M

IP
(n

A M M

io se )

` 3

MM I

CA

A M M I

AM M I

IP C A IP C A

IP

CA

9[,

IP

A MM I

CA

M I

A MM I

M I

AM

M I

> G

>

> B > H > C > E > A >

A M M I

D ( 2)

(2 )

M M I

M M I D (1 )

A M M I

IP

CA I 2

gJ,

Co m
.

H
J

.tl

11

19 9 2

2992

a r

in

u e

H
H

Ga

ue

( a

u e

a u e

( a

u e

1se- 1S

llo b

J h

e n
p

a n

a n

373

,,q

Jq

Sh
a

Y
Y

a rl

J
.

I n `

e ,
o

Z b l
862

1 P

e e

(;

a n

d D
e r

n a

ro

C
.

( ,e

W ll

( r

l y s is

A bs tr

e v e

e v e r

lo p e d
,

A MM I

ba
e s

s e

e r e

a n a

o n

t im a t e s

p l ie

a e

t io n s

n o

s s
ly i

ta t

u a n t

T he

f D w
d

o r

re

ds

e r e

le

v a n

re a

13

io

e a

e n e

l G

cS

e s

a n

n t

d P la

e s

Br

ding

e e

o u n e

(ed

n s o n

Ha

I)

R o bi n

s o n

il

1 19 3
e n e e

sc

u t ra

li

3640

o u r n a

a n

r e u

f Ag

lt

u ra

s e a re

l Re

14

7 4 2 ~ 7 54

e n e

g o

468
2

r a s
l Y i ld T i l

e
M i r co

u
mP

)u r n a

my

83

o l

r
En v i

ty

El

s e v

ie

te r

e a

Am

da m

f he N

e r

a n

~ 4 78

e n o

15 3 ~ 1 6 0

o no

80

ie s

n a

t er

e n

Po w

9 16

It h a

e r

t e r a e t io n

In

Yo

920
e

( d

a n

d G

a n

a u e

( )
.

7 3 1 1 5

u ra
e

n l

e e

s s

A
a

oc

a r

10 3

8 6 2 8 6 8

67

m b r id g

ta n

f S

1 2 3 13 5

h e rn

t ie a

cS

e e s

ie n

3 0 9 3 2 8

7 3

1 1 8
i

e s

4 5 5 3

43

In

Pl

a n

e rl e

r e e

t e s

d in

4 3 8 4 4 3

90

P r in

ip l

a n

d P

ro s

ts

s :

(d
e

a r

Ha y w

l )

pp

o n

32

922

927

37

498 509

19 3 8

ta t

u re a u

e
d A p p li d G

ie n

cS

1 12 1 1 7

10

lt

tr

a l

(, u r n a

19 9 4

a r

~ ,

tu r a

f A r i e

In

a n

lt

u r a

d bo k

e n e e

SC

f P la

n t

a n

28
ro

5 5 6 58 0

p Phy

o n

Zh

d C

t ly

Ze

S ou t

e
e

pa

o
od f

e r

it e r io

e r

m
t

u e s t io n s

st

da

n t

e r e

de l ; G

ts

Ag

ha
.

ls

e n o

ty p

1 Un

the
a

e u s se

Pr

im

ir o

lt

d fo

n v

t a

r e s u
e s t

e n o

vet

o n

i o lo g y

sr

ty p e

,h
,

lt i p li e a t iv

t in g

be e

e ;

lt

d M

th e

s
di

a n

lu

X ia

ar l U n er s ;

T he

w it h

u l t

e v a

his p a p e

ly z in

a n a

fo

e n

Ch

(,u t h

th

r a

e o n e o r

AM MI m

M a in E f fe

s e

ie ty S ta b ility B a

M z

s
l y is in

a n a

Ar

19 7 2

n e e

f V

it a t iv

n e

A ddit iv

81

e r s

In

e a

( d

e s sa r a

k li

) pp

8 4 9

Ag

)f

f R

715

33

n ie

a e e

is t ie a l m

A MM I
:

a n

Key w

T h

n e

,tJ

A g lr l

the
o

P rt

e)I

ic

e n e

r a n

` )n

cS

r o

d B i o lo g y

19 9 3

Z ha
(

e
f Ag r i

H u
t e

H
N

bi l l
o

c o r e

Fo

e , e a re

f R

d H ll

is

a n

o n , e r r e s

ra

u r n a

1 99 1

ik a

din

T h

l l k k

ho

19 8 7

n le t r

hn

Jp n

705

ie n t i

2 9 95

Jo

a n

1963

ly

hn

19 92

1 96 2

a r e e

n a n

a n

a z

19 9 5

m d

n a

d A P P li e d ( ;

a n

cS

F lo

o u r n a

1M H

390 ( h
,

d F

e a rl

Zo bel,

Ps y

s a

19 7 1

19 8 4

1 96 9

R
H

fii

a n

ta t

S
a

11 8 6 ~
C

44

l A

u r n a

El)P in M

r e t e a

a t o n

19 6 5

,
1966

M A I M ( ) I ) El
E

d R

K {a
1

n e t r e s

e r

ll

In

C
33

e e

in s o n

s se

t a t s t le a

An

ie n

cS

W i lk

B io

d R

1993b

go

1979

de l

a n

T heo

d l

P i l ho

19 9 2

1990

A Ru

I)

to

Ro m

ro

1 16 12 5

19 6 3
,

18 ( 2 )

g to n

l i

19 8 8

M o ll

l n

( 1 9 9 3

H
a s

d G

a s s a r

r ls ` ) n

d R

a n

e s s

Hu hn

19 9 3

a n

C R ( P r

ll

a u e

a n

a ue

5
.

1 64 19 6

,01, .
9

adh

91Q

)pp

E be r h

( a

,
O
gJ19
C

liu

oc k

o r n e

MMI M
hu

k :

C h

by

In

o s e

a n

to
a

o n

e a s u r e

he

lu

p p l ie

t io n

( E in

te

he

e n

t ;

e x a

e e o v a

e n t

a n

o r

( A M M I ) m o d e l ha s

r e n e e s

te s o

630716)

t e r a e t io n

p p li e d

al `

ir

del

e n v

b i l it y d i f f e

in

o n

t a

v a r

r a e

bi l it y

te

v a r

A MM I

t io n ;

ta

Ho w

i e t ie s i n

b i li t y

m p le in d ie a

t io n

r a e

te

th a t

d
ia

v a r

n e e

a n a

b i li t y

s s
ly i

he

ie t y
t

he

Im
.