23/04/2004

http://www.yorku.ca/hjackman/papers/ext-and-skept.html



  
  ! "$#%
$&
 '()+* ,-(.

1/ 03254,6789:25/;60
2<=;>?A@+?CBEDF=;>GIHEJCGIBEDKJCBLNMO= PQ<R7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>W@+DYXEZ[BEJ:P\PQ<A@CP\S]BED_^`XBEJCBEDa@Ebc?DYHE?CBED_Pd=;B>HCe
PQ<CBfPQ<CBHED_^`HCe=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJj[k@+lmBfPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%G,bp@E=g[qPQ<A@CPr[H>sPtHCeEHEZD\uCBvb1=;BCe>GIHEZb;L
PQZDKJwHEZ:P\PhHuCBwex@Eb;>IBy=gJC>nZ??CHED_Pi@+ub;Bzn9HEJCGIBv= S]BLR@{>W@|;>sPQDa@E=;XE<:Pd|m@+JC>cMFBED+PhHfPQ<CBjXvb;HEuA@Eb
>nlmBE?:Pd=;G}_PQ<A@CP=;>:~3@{>W@?DYHHCePQ<A@CPMFBjLH+~5=gJex@{GsP~<A@CS]BfPQDKZCBuCBvb1=;BAS]B>W@+uCHEZ:P\PQ<CBNMFHEDb;L
@+DYHEZJCLZC>:7@CST=;L>IHEJ|;>W@+DYXEZ[BEJ:P=;>JCHAPtB>n?CBG,=p@Eb1b ^`GIHEJ:ST=gJCG,=gJCXz-h3\/gJj?A@+D_Pd=;GnZbp@+D~
7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>W@+JC>cMFBED+PhHfPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>W@eDa@+[B{MFHEDKl`PQ<A@CP@Eb1b;H{MF>eHED@JCB{M
@+JCLj>IBBE[W=gJCXvb ^k[HEDYBDa@{Lv=;Go@Eb%>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[@{GIGIHEDYLv=gJCXfPhHNM<=;Gn<MFB[W=;XE<:PrJCHAPtBAS]BEJj<A@CS]B
uCBvb1=;BCe>W@CP@Eb1bz-+\0vBAS]BED_PQ<CBvb;B>I>:~nPQ<CBEDYBy=;>W@N>IBEJC>IBy=gJM<=;Gn<R7@CST=;L>IHEJ|;>W@{GIGIHEZJ:PtHCe
GIHEJ:PhBEJ:PrDYBE[k@+?C>kPQ<CBjGIHEJCGIBE?:PQZA@EbPhBEDKDa@E=gJR=gJf@ex@{>n<=;HEJPQ<A@CP@+uC>IHvb S]B>ZC>HCePQ<CBJCBBL
PhHDKZb;BjHEZ:P\PQ<CBj>IGIBEJA@+D=;H>kPQ<CBjXvb;HEuA@Eb%>nlmBE?:Pd=;GLB>IGnD=guCB>Czs2<CBweHvb1b;H{MO=gJCXNMO=1b1bcuCHAPQ<
?DYB>IBEJ:P\PQ<CB?DYHEub;BE[>7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>?CH>,= Pd=;HEJj<A@{>W@{>W@N>sPQDa@E=;XE<:PUT>IHvbgZ:Pd=;HEJPhH
>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[~3@+JCLjLv=;>IGnZC>I>kPQ<CBNM@C^=gJM<=;Gn<j<=;>v=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJA@EbUTBAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[LHB>
MFB@+lmBEJPQ<CBj>sPQDYBEJCXAPQ<wHCePQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%Gn<A@Eb1b;BEJCXBz
2<CBjLBAPi@E=1b;>HCe7@CST=;L>IHEJ|;>?CH>,= Pd=;HEJj}K?A@+D_Pd=;GnZbp@+Db ^k<=;>G,bp@E=g[>kPQ<A@CP=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJ
?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>[k@{>I>,= S]BR@{XEDYBBE[BEJ:P~nPQ<A@CP\Pi@EbglHCev@+JwHE[J=;>IG,=;BEJ:P=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBEDF=;>
ZJ?DYHEub;BE[k@CPd=;G:~3@+JCLfPQ<A@CP@|p3M@+[?[k@+J|MFHEZb;L<A@CS]BJCHfPQ<CHEZCXE<:Ph>:@+DYBJCHAP
ZJCGIHEJ:PQDYHAS]BEDY>,=p@EbV~uZ:P/MO=1b1bm@{GIGIBE?:P\PQ<CBE[eHED+PQ<CBj>o@+lmBjHCev@+DYXEZ[BEJ:Pr<CBEDYBzs2<CB?ZDK?CH>IB
HCePQ<=;>?A@+?CBEDF=;>kPhHy=gJ:S]B>sPd=;X@CPhBfPQ<CBj>sPi@CPQZC>HCeE>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[ MO= PQ<=gJf@7@CST=;L>IHEJ=p@+J
eDa@+[B{MFHEDKlc~JCHAP\PhHjBAS@EbgZA@CPhBfPQ<CB[BED= Ph>HCePQ<CBweDa@+[B{MFHEDKlW= Ph>IBvb eKz
{7 F/17{60NF0\725\6
0\/p{9v/1032/1032544T254
7@CST=;L>IHEJwG,bp@E=g[>kPQ<A@CP@?DYHE?CBED\ZJCLBEDY>sPi@+JCLv=gJCXjHCePQ<CBNMFHEDKlo=gJCX>HCePQ<CBy=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJ
?DYHGIB>I>DKZb;B>HEZ:P\PQ<CB?CH>I>,=gu=1b1= PK^`HCeDa@{Lv=;Go@Eb%>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[uCBGo@+ZC>IBy=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJ
?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>[k@{>I>,= S]BR@{XEDYBBE[BEJ:PruCBAPMFBBEJPQ<CBy=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBED@+JCLfPQ<CBy=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBBz
BjGo@+Jj[k@+lmBj>IBEJC>IBjHCeELv= eeBEDYBEJCGIB>W@Eb1bcD=;XE<:P~uZ:PtHEJb ^@{X@E=gJC>sP@uA@{GnlmXEDYHEZJCLjHCe
>n<A@+DYBLuCBvb1=;BCeKzof<A@CP=;>>n<A@+DYBLjLHB>JCHAP=gJwXBEJCBEDa@Eb%Go@Eb1beHEDGIHE[[BEJ:P5= P=;>kPhHHjLEZb1bV~
PQD= PhB+~AHED5ex@+[W=1b1=p@+D+PhHj>sPi@+JCLJCHAPd=;GIBz{{Z:PMO= PQ<CHEZ:P@wS@{>sPtGIHE[[HEJwXEDYHEZJCL+~nPQ<CBEDYBy=;>JCH
?bp@{GIBweHEDLv=;>n?Z:Pi@+J:Ph>kPhH<A@CS]BfPQ<CBv=gDEZA@+DKDYBvbozzzzs2<CBuA@{>,=;GG,bp@E=g[ =;>kPQ<A@CPr[ZCGn<
GIHE[[ZJ= PK^`HCeuCBvb1=;BCe=;>JCBBLBLfPhH?DYHAST=;LBR@uA@{>,=;>eHEDGIHE[[ZJ=;Go@CPd=;HEJf@+JCL
ZJCLBEDY>sPi@+JCLv=gJCXz-5
6 JCB[W=;XE<:P\PQ<=gJl`PQ<A@CP\PQ<CB[BEDYBwex@{GsP\PQ<A@CPtHEZDF=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBEDY>[ZC>sPt>n<A@+DYB[H>sPtHCeEHEZD
uCBvb1=;BCe>?DYHAST=;LB>JCHR@{>I>nZDa@+JCGIBfPQ<A@CP\PQ<CB>IBuCBvb1=;BCe>MO=1b1bcuCBfPQDKZCB+~A>,=gJCGIBy= Pt>IBBE[>kPQ<A@CP
PQ<CBR@{XEDYBBE[BEJ:PtGIHEZb;LuCB?DYHLEZCGIBLu:^@bp@+DYXBjGIHE[[HEJwXEDYHEZJCLjHCe maIom@+uCHEZ:P

#1

PQ<CBNMFHEDb;Lz{7@CST=;L>IHEJ{~<CH{MFBAS]BED~AG,bp@E=g[>kPQ<A@CP@{XEDYBBE[BEJ:P=gJC>nZDYB>XBEJCBEDa@Eb%GIHEDKDYBGsPQJCB>I>

uCBGo@+ZC>IBjBAS]BEJf@+J cIcc:=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBEDvMFHEZb;Ly=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPrZC>W@{><A@CST=gJCXuCBvb1=;BCe>M<=;Gn<
MFBEDYB[H>sPdb ^
PQDKZCBu:^k<=;>H{MJRb1=;XE<:Ph>Cz-x\,Bvb1=;BCe>M<=;Gn<f@+DYBjGIHEDKDYBGsPru:^
PQ<CBjHE[J=;>IG,=;BEJ:P
=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBEDUV>b1=;XE<:Ph>[ZC>sPruCBjGIHEDKDYBGsPru:^`HEusBGsPd= S]Bj>sPi@+JCL@+DYL>:~A>IH[H>sPtHCeEHEZD\uCBvb1=;BCe>
[ZC>sPruCBfPQDKZCBz-5
vH{MFBAS]BED~ABAS]BEJR= e7@CST=;L>IHEJj<A@{>[k@+JA@{XBLfPhHj>n<CH{MPQ<A@CP[k@{>I>,= S]BjBEDKDYHED@+uCHEZ:P\PQ<CB
MFHEDb;Ly=;>>,=g[?b ^kZJ=gJ:PhBvb1b1=;Xv=gub;B+~+\= P=;>JCHAP@CP@Eb1b%G,b;B@+D+PQ<A@CPr<CB<A@{>DYB@Eb1b ^@{LLEDYB>I>IBL
PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G.UV>MFHEDKD=;B>Czs2<CBjGIHEJCG,bgZC>,=;HEJwHCe7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>W@+DYXEZ[BEJ:P=;>JCHAP\PQ<A@CPMFB[ZC>sP
<A@CS]B[H>sPdb ^
PQDKZCBuCBvb1=;BCe>:~uZ:PrDa@CPQ<CBED+PQ<A@CPMFBjGo@+JJCHAPr<A@CS]B[H>sPdb ^$ex@Eb;>IBjHEJCB>:~3@+JCL
PQ<CB>IBJCBBLJCHAP@+[HEZJ:P\PhHfPQ<CBj>o@+[BfPQ<=gJCXzof<=1b;BR@NG,b;B@+DvM@C^kJCHAP\PhH<A@CS]B[H>sPdb ^
ex@Eb;>IBuCBvb1=;BCe>=;>kPhH<A@CS]B[k@E=gJb ^
PQDKZCBuCBvb1=;BCe>:~3@+JCHAPQ<CBEDvM@C^=;>kPhHwex@E=1bPhH<A@CS]BuCBvb1=;BCe>}KuCB
=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@+ub;B+@CP@Eb1bz3}'DYHGnlc~:eHEDF=gJC>sPi@+JCGIB+~AGo@+JJCHAPruCBy[k@{>I>,= S]Bvb ^k[W=;>sPi@+lmBEJ5z
7@CST=;L>IHEJj?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>kPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBjHE[J=;>IG,=;BEJ:P=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBEDvMO=1b1bcuCBR@+ub;BfPhHjGIHE[BZ?MO= PQ<
@+JR=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJwHCeZC>:~3@+JCLfPQ<CBEJf@+DYXEZCB>kPQ<A@CPr[H>sPtHCePQ<CBuCBvb1=;BCe>W@{>I>,=;XEJCBLfPhHZC>HEJ
>nZCGn<f@+JR=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJj[ZC>sPruCBfPQDKZCB+~uZ:P= P=;>?DYBG,=;>IBvb ^7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>?DYB>nZ??CH>,= Pd=;HEJ
PQ<A@CP\PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G[k@C^`LBEJ:^cz{vH{MGo@+JMFBuCBj>nZDYB+~nPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;GMO=1b1bm@{>nlc~nPQ<A@CP\PQ<CB
HE[J=;>IG,=;BEJ:P=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBEDvMO=1b1bcuCBR@+ub;BfPhHR@{>I>,=;XEJf@+J:^kuCBvb1=;BCe>kPhHZC>W@CP@Eb1bF2AHuCB
=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@+ub;B+~AHEZD\Z:PKPhBEDa@+JCGIB>[ZC>sPruCBDYBvb1=p@+ub ^`GIHEDKDYBvbp@CPhBLNMO= PQ<S@+D=;HEZC>HEusBGsPh>=gJ
PQ<CBNMFHEDb;LR@+DYHEZJCLZC>:~uZ:P\PQ<CB?DYB>IBEJCGIBjHCeE>nZCGn<f@DYBvb1=p@+ub;BjGIHEDKDYBvbp@CPd=;HEJR=;>?DYBG,=;>IBvb ^
M<A@CP\PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;GEZCB>sPd=;HEJC>Cz-5\/ PtGIBED_Pi@E=gJb ^k[k@C^`>IBBE[U%PhHZC>kPQ<A@CPMFB<A@CS]BuCBvb1=;BCe>:~
uZ:P\PQ<=;>W@Eb;HEJCBy=;>JCHAPtBEJCHEZCXE<{~3@CPb;B@{>sPMO= PQ<=gJR7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>eDa@+[B{MFHEDKlc~nPhHR@{>I>nZDYBZC>
PQ<A@CPMFBjLHz
/gJCLBBL+~57@CST=;L>IHEJj<=g[>IBvb e[k@+lmB>kPQ<=;>BAPQDYBE[Bvb ^`G,b;B@+DF=gJj<=;>JCHAPhHED=;HEZC>Lv=;>IGnZC>I>,=;HEJwHCe
Y3M@+[?[k@+Jh
+Z??CH>IByb1=;XE<:PQJ=gJCXj>sPQD=glmB>W@NLB@{LfPQDYBBy=gJf@N>cM@+[?{5/m@+[>sPi@+JCLv=gJCXJCB@+DKu:^cz{^kuCHLA^=;>
DYBLEZCGIBLfPhHy= Ph>Bvb;BE[BEJ:Ph>:~CM<=1b;BjBEJ:Pd=gDYBvb ^ku:^`GIHv=gJCG,=;LBEJCGIB}a@+JCLjHEZ:PtHCeELv= eeBEDYBEJ:P
[Hvb;BGnZb;B>:EPQ<CBfPQDYBBy=;>kPQZDKJCBLy=gJ:PhH[`^k?<:^]>,=;Go@EbcDYBE?b1=;Go@vz{^kDYBE?b1=;Go@5~nPQ<CBR3M@+[?[k@+J{~
[HAS]B>BA@{GsPdb ^@{>/%Lv=;L+3@{GIGIHEDYLv=gJCXfPhHy= Ph>JA@CPQZDYBy= PtLBE?A@+D_Ph>kPQ<CBj>cM@+[?{~ABEJCGIHEZJ:PhBEDY>
@+JCLj>IBBE[>kPhHDYBGIHXEJ=B[`^$eD=;BEJCL>:~3@+JCLR@+??CB@+DY>kPhHDYBAPQZDKJPQ<CBv=gDXEDYBBAPd=gJCX>=gJ
{JCXvb1=;>n<5z{/ Pr[HAS]B>kPhH[`^k<CHEZC>IBR@+JCLj>IBBE[>kPhHNMD= PhBR@+D_Pd=;G,b;B>HEJjDa@{Lv=;Go@EbI=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJ5z
0vHjHEJCBjGo@+JPhBvb1bPQ<CBjLv= eeBEDYBEJCGIBz
{Z:P\PQ<CBEDYBy=;>W@NLv= eeBEDYBEJCGIBz{^kDYBE?b1=;Go@NGo@+J3U;PrDYBGIHXEJ=B[`^$eD=;BEJCL>:5= PtGo@+J3U;PrDYBGIHXEJ=B
@+J:^PQ<=gJCX+~A>,=gJCGIBy= PrJCBAS]BEDGIHXEJ=BLR@+J:^PQ<=gJCXy=gJPQ<CBwe=gDY>sPr?bp@{GIBz{/ PtGo@+J3U;PrlIJCH{M[`^
eD=;BEJCL>.U.JA@+[B>}_PQ<CHEZCXE<wHCeEGIHEZDY>IBy= Pt>IBBE[>kPhH+K~5= PtGo@+J3U;PrDYBE[BE[uCBED\[`^k<CHEZC>IBz{/ PtGo@+J3U;P
[B@+JM<A@CP/%LHu:^
PQ<CBNMFHEDYLjE<CHEZC>IB5U~:eHEDBA@+[?b;B+~A>,=gJCGIBfPQ<CBj>IHEZJCLjE<CHEZC>IB5U:= P
[k@+lmB>M@{>JCHAPb;B@+DKJCBLy=gJf@NGIHEJ:PhBAP\PQ<A@CPMFHEZb;LjXv= S]By= P\PQ<CBD=;XE<:Pr[B@+J=gJCXNHED@+J:^
[B@+J=gJCXR@CP@Eb1bz{/gJCLBBL+~5/%LHEJ3U;Pt>IBB<CH{M[`^kDYBE?b1=;Go@NGo@+JjuCBj>o@E=;LfPhH[B@+Jf@+J:^PQ<=gJCXu:^
PQ<CBj>IHEZJCL>= Pr[k@+lmB>:~JCHED+PhH<A@CS]BR@+J:^
PQ<CHEZCXE<:Ph>Cz-+
vH{M~nPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G[k@C^@{>nlc~AGo@+JMFBuCBj>nZDYBfPQ<A@CPMFBR@+DYBJCHAPb1=glmBfPQ<CBR3M@+[?[k@+Jk_ZC>sP
LB>IGnD=guCBL+~A>sPQZCGnlMO= PQ<f@+??A@+DYBEJ:P\PQ<CHEZCXE<:Ph>W@+JCL[BE[HED=;B>M<=;Gn<Rbp@{Gnlk@+J:^kDYB@Eb
GIHEJ:PhBEJ:P`7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>W@+DYXEZ[BEJ:Pr[k@C^`>n<CH{MPQ<A@CP~nPhHfPQ<CBjBAPhBEJ:P\PQ<A@CPMFB<A@CS]B
GIHEJ:PhBEJ:PeZbcuCBvb1=;BCe>:~[H>sPtHCePQ<CH>IBuCBvb1=;BCe>MO=1b1bcuCBfPQDKZCB+~uZ:P\PQ<CBweDa@+[B{MFHEDKlJCBBLBLfPhH
B>sPi@+ub1=;>n<PQ<=;>GIHEJCG,bgZC>,=;HEJjZJCLBEDYGnZ:Ph>HED@{>I>nZDa@+JCGIBfPQ<A@CPr<A@CS]BR@+J:^kuCBvb1=;BCe>W@CP@Eb1bzs2<CB
XBEJCBEDa@Ebc?DYHEub;BE[HCePQ<CBjGIHEJJCBGsPd=;HEJjuCBAPMFBBEJwHEZD\[W=gJCLR@+JCLfPQ<CBNMFHEDb;LDYBE[k@E=gJC>Cz{/gJ

23/04/2004

http://www.yorku.ca/hjackman/papers/ext-and-skept.html

#2

v7 B>IGo@+D_PhB>.UTGo@{>IB+~5= PtBAs?DYB>I>IBLy= Ph>IBvb e=gJPQ<CBNMFHEDKD_^

PQ<A@CP@Eb1b%HCeEHEZD\uCBvb1=;BCe>[W=;XE<:PruCB
ex@Eb;>IBzs2<CBj>o@+[B?DYHEub;BE[BAs?DYB>I>IB>= Ph>IBvb e=gJR7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>Go@{>IBy=gJPQ<CBweHEDK[HCePQ<CB
MFHEDKD_^
PQ<A@CPMFB[W=;XE<:Pex@E=1bPhH<A@CS]BuCBvb1=;BCe>W@CP@Eb1bz{4C@CPQ<CBED+PQ<A@+Jf@+JC>cMFBED=gJCXfPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G:~
PQ<CBEJ{~57@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>BAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[>IBBE[>kPhHyb;B@{LfPhHR@wPK^s?CBjHCeE>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[@CPb;B@{>sP@{>:~5= e
JCHAPr[HEDYB+~ALv=;>sPQZDKu=gJCXz-aE

23/04/2004

http://www.yorku.ca/hjackman/papers/ext-and-skept.html

#3

. 2540{F/pEF0\7'4c{25/;9j9603254cF7\/;9:25/;60

vH{MFBAS]BED~ABAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[>sPQDYBEJCXAPQ<CBEJC>>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[HEJb ^=gJPQ<CBj>IBEJC>IBfPQ<A@CP~5= euCHAPQ<
BAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[@+JCLy= Ph>>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Ebc<:^s?CHAPQ<CB>,=;>MFBEDYBfPQDKZCB+~CMFBNMFHEZb;LuCBNMFHEDY>IBjHCeePQ<A@+JMFB
MFHEZb;LuCBy= e=gJ:PhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[@+JCLy= Ph>>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Ebc<:^s?CHAPQ<CB>,=;>MFBEDYBfPQDKZCB}a@{>I>nZ[W=gJCXfPQ<A@CP
<A@CST=gJCXwex@Eb;>IBuCBvb1=;BCe>=;>uCBAPKPhBED+PQ<A@+Jj<A@CST=gJCXJCHuCBvb1=;BCe>W@CP@Eb1bVhz,+lmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[ =;>JCHAP~
<CH{MFBAS]BED~A>sPQDYBEJCXAPQ<CBEJCBLy=gJPQ<CBj>IBEJC>IBfPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G.UV>Gn<A@Eb1b;BEJCXBJCBBL>kPhHuCB
Pi@+lmBEJj[HEDYBj>IBED=;HEZC>,b ^cz{/gJCLBBL+~5= PMO=1b1bcuCBR@+DYXEZCBLuCBvb;H{MPQ<A@CPtEZ= PhBfPQ<CBjHE??CH>,= PhBy=;>kPQ<CB
Go@{>IBz
/ Pr[k@C^=gJ= Pd=p@Eb1b ^`>IBBE[@{>= eEBAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[[BEDYBvb ^k[HAS]B>kPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@EbcuZ[?R=gJPQ<CBDKZCXfPhH
@+JwBAS]BEJRb;B>I>W@+??CB@Eb1=gJCXyb;HGo@CPd=;HEJ{~uZ:P\PQ<CBJCB{Mb;HGo@CPd=;HEJf@{GsPQZA@Eb1b ^k<A@{>[k@+J:^
@{LAS@+J:Pi@{XB>HAS]BED+PQ<CB?DYBAST=;HEZC>HEJCBz{.S]BEJR= ePQ<CBjBAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sPtGo@+J3U;Pr?DYHAS]BfPQ<A@CPMFB
@+DYBEJ3U;P\PQ<CHEZCXE<:Pdb;B>I>>cM@+[?[BEJwBAPhGCz~nPQ<=;>LHB>JCHAPr[B@+JPQ<A@CPrJCHAPQ<=gJCX<A@{>uCBBEJ
X@E=gJCBLzn6JCBy=;>>sPd=1b1bIb;BCePMO= PQ<f@?=;GsPQZDYBy=gJM<=;Gn<wHEZD c1:@+DYBjXBEJCBEDa@Eb1b ^
S]BED=;Lv=;Go@Ebzs2<CB
?CHv=gJ:P=;>JCHAP\PhH?DYHAST=;LBR@+Jf@+DYXEZ[BEJ:P\PQ<A@CPt>n<CH{MF>kPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G.UV>>IGIBEJA@+D=;HjGIHEZb;LEJ3U;P
<A@+??CBEJj}YHED+PQ<A@CP= P=;>ZJ=gJ:PhBvb1b1=;Xv=gub;BjBAPhGCzK~uZ:PrDa@CPQ<CBED+PhHZJCLBEDY>sPi@+JCLjHEZD>IBE[k@+J:Pd=;GW@+JCL
BE?=;>sPhBE[W=;GGIHEJCGIBE?:Ph>=gJf@M@C^
PQ<A@CP\PQ<CB?CH>I>,=gu=1b1= PK^`HCe= Ph><A@+??CBEJ=gJCXjLHB>JCHAP
ZJCLBEDK[W=gJCBjHEZDG,bp@E=g[>kPhHlIJCH{MOb;BLXBy=gJwHAPQ<CBEDGo@{>IB>Czs2<CBDYBvb;BAS@+JCGIBjHCeEGIHEJ:PhBEJ:P
BAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[ =;>JCHAP K,m\@[k@CPKPhBEDHCeE>n<= ePd=gJCXfPQ<CBuZ[?R=gJPQ<CBDKZCXz{4C@CPQ<CBED~5= P@+[HEZJ:Ph>
PhHR@N>n<= eP\PhHR@wPK^s?CBjHCeEGIHEJCGIBE?:PQZA@EbcuCHHElIlmBBE?=gJCXy=gJM<=;Gn<PQ<=gJCX>b1=glmBlIJCH{MOb;BLXBjGo@+J
e=gJCLR@[HEDYBj>IBGnZDYB?bp@{GIBz
7vHv=gJCXj>IHy=gJ:S]Hvb S]B>GnZ:PKPd=gJCXfPQ<CB?<=1b;H>IHE?<=;Go@Eb1b ^kDYBvb;BAS@+J:PEHv=gJ:Ph>=gJf@M@C^
PQ<A@CPt>IBE?A@+Da@CPhB>
Go@{>IB>b1=glmBfPQ<CBR3M@+[?[k@+Jj}xM<CH?ZDK?CHED_PhBLvb ^klIJCH{MF>JCHAPQ<=gJCXR@+uCHEZ:P\PQ<CBNMFHEDb;LR@+DYHEZJCL
<=g[+eDYHE[qPQ<CH>IBy=gJM<=;Gn<MFBjLHlIJCH{M@+uCHEZ:P\PQ<CBNMFHEDb;LR@+DYHEZJCLZC>Cz{7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>
@{GIGIHEZJ:PtGnZ:Ph>kPQ<CBWHv=gJ:Ph>=gJw>nZCGn<f@M@C^
PQ<A@CP\PQ<CBjGo@{>IB>HCeEXBEJZ=gJCBlIJCH{MOb;BLXBR@+DYB
GIHEJCGIBE?:PQZA@Eb1b ^=;>IHvbp@CPhBLweDYHE[qPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%>IGIBEJA@+D=;H>:~}_PQ<CBlIJCH{MFBED\<A@{>uCBvb1=;BCe>MO= PQ<f@
GIBED_Pi@E=gJwGIHEJ:PhBEJ:P~nPQ<CBR3M@+[?[k@+JRbp@{Gnlm>uCBvb1=;BCe>BEJ:Pd=gDYBvb ^mM<=1b;By=gJ:PhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sP\PQ<CBHED=;B>LH
JCHAPr}_PQ<CBlIJCH{MFBED@+JCLfPQ<CB?CBEDY>IHEJwLBGIBv= S]BLu:^@+JwBAST=1b%LBE[HEJj<A@CS]BuCBvb1=;BCe>MO= PQ<PQ<CB
>o@+[BjGIHEJ:PhBEJ:Phz
2<CBEDYBy=;>:~3@,ePhBED@Eb1bV~JCH vKo.acIA=g[?CBEDa@CPd= S]BfPhHR@+JC>cMFBED+PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;GCzoBNMO=1b1b%GIHEJ:Pd=gJZCBfPhH
@{GsP\PQ<CBNM@C^MFBjLHNM<CBAPQ<CBEDvMFB<A@CS]BR@+Jf@+JC>cMFBED+PhHfPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;GHED\JCHAPzs2<CBweBvb P
?DYB>I>nZDYBfPhHR@+JC>cMFBED+PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G=;>HCev@NLv= eeBEDYBEJ:Pt>IHED_PzoBweBBvbc[HEDYBjHCev@ K:acII
=g[?CBEDa@CPd= S]BfPhHR@+JC>cMFBED+PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G.UV>Gn<A@Eb1b;BEJCXBfPhHjHEZD\uCBvb1=;BCe>Czs2<CBDYB@EbI=gJ:PhBEDYB>sPtHCe
>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[ =;>kPQ<CB?CH>I>,=gu=1b1= PK^
PQ<A@CP\PQ<CBDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb%XEDYHEZJCL>eHED I1.HEZD\}YBE[?=gD=;Go@EbVFuCBvb1=;BCe>
GIHEZb;LuCBy=gJ:S]B>sPd=;X@CPhBLR@+JCLfPQZDKJwHEZ:P\PhHuCBZJs_ZC>sPd= e=;BLzs2DYB@CPd=gJCXj>IHE[BAPQ<=gJCXR@{>W@uCBvb1=;BCe
@CP@Eb1bc?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>kPQ<A@CP= P=;>>nZusBGsP\PhHDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb%BAS@EbgZA@CPd=;HEJ{~AGnD= Pd=;G,=;>n[@+JCL
_ZC>sPd= e=;Go@CPd=;HEJ5z-hnE\O@+J:^`HCePQ<CBuCBvb1=;BCe>MFB<A@CS]B}YBAS]BEJPQDKZCBuCBvb1=;BCe>:Go@+JPQZDKJwHEZ:P\PhHuCB
eHEZJCLNM@+J:Pd=gJCXNM<CBEJw>nZusBGsP\PhHj>nZCGn<wBAS@EbgZA@CPd=;HEJ5z,+ZCGn<juCBvb1=;BCe>:~ABAS]BEJR= ePQDKZCB+~AGo@+JJCHAP

}a@{GIGIHEDYLv=gJCXfPhHR@ex@+[W=1b1=p@+DFb1=gJCBjHCePQ<CHEZCXE<:PGIHEZJ:P@{>lIJCH{MOb;BLXB+~A>,=gJCGIBlIJCH{MOb;BLXBy=;>:~3@CP

b;B@{>sP~T_ZC>sPd= e=;BLfPQDKZCBuCBvb1=;BCeKz-h332<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;GkPi@+lmB>kPQ<=;>?DYHGIB>I>:~CM<=;Gn<R=;>
?DYB>nZ??CH>IBLu:^
PQ<CBJCHAPd=;HEJC>HCeuCBvb1=;BCev@+JCLlIJCH{MOb;BLXBfPQ<CBE[>IBvb S]B>:~3@+JCLR@+DYXEZCB>kPQ<A@CP~
=gJex@{GsP~AHEZD\uCBvb1=;BCe>}a@+uCHEZ:P@NGIBED_Pi@E=gJwLHE[k@E=gJBzXzoPQ<CBjBAPhBEDKJA@EbMFHEDb;L+ o:QcO?A@{>I>
[ZC>sPhBED\}a@+JCLfPQ<ZC>kPQ<A@CPMFB<A@CS]BJCHlIJCH{MOb;BLXBy=gJPQ<A@CPtLHE[k@E=gJ{hzs2<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb
>IGIBEJA@+D=;Hj>IBED_S]B>W@{>W@NXBEJCBEDa@EbcDYBG,=g?CBweHED>n<CH{MO=gJCXfPQ<A@CPrJCHj>nZCGn<juCBvb1=;BCe>Go@+JjuCB
_ZC>sPd= e=;BLz
ePQ<CBy=gJ:PhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sP=;>D=;XE<:P=gJPQ<=gJlo=gJCXfPQ<A@CPtHEZD+PQ<CHEZCXE<:Ph>W@+DYBjGIHEJC>sPd= PQZ:Pd= S]Bvb ^=gJCLBE?CBEJCLBEJ:P
eDYHE[HEZDBEJ:ST=gDYHEJ[BEJ:P~nPQ<CBEJPQ<CBDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb1= PK^kDYBEZ=gDYBE[BEJ:Ph>MFHEZb;LuCBu=gJCLv=gJCXZ?CHEJjZC>
BAS]BEJR= e+MFBNMFBEDYBj>cM@+[?[BEJ{~ABAPhGCz~A>IHfPQ<CB>IBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%>IGIBEJA@+D=;H>MFHEZb;L<A@CS]BfPhHuCB
ZJCLBEDY>sPhHHLR@{>HEJCB>=gJM<=;Gn<PQ<CBDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb1= PK^`GIHEJC>sPQDa@E=gJ:Ph>MFBEDYBJCHAPt>o@CPd=;>me=;BLz-h,+v6J
PQ<CBjHAPQ<CBED\<A@+JCL+~5= ePQ<CHEZCXE<:Ph>W@+DYBJCHAP@+Z:PhHEJCHE[HEZC>}a@{>kPQ<CBjBAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sPt>nZCXXB>sPh>:K~
PQ<CBEJPQ<CBDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb1= PK^kDYBEZ=gDYBE[BEJ:Ph>MFHEZb;LJCHAPruCBu=gJCLv=gJCXjHEJw>cM@+[?[BEJ{~A>,=gJCGIBfPQ<CB
DYBEZ=gDYBE[BEJ:Ph>W@+DYBjHEJb ^ku=gJCLv=gJCXZ?CHEJPQ<=gJCX>kPQ<A@CP@{GsPQZA@Eb1b ^k<A@CS]BuCBvb1=;BCe>Czs2<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G=;>
BEJCX@{XBLy=gJPQ<CB?DYHGIB>I>HCeDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb1b ^`BAS@EbgZA@CPd=gJCXjHEZD+PQ<CHEZCXE<:Ph>:~3@+JCLfPQ<=;>?DYHGIB>I>
?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>kPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBEDYBR@+DYBfPQ<CHEZCXE<:Ph>kPhHuCBjBAS@EbgZA@CPhBLz{/ ePQ<CBjBAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sP=;>D=;XE<:P~
@+JCLfPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G.UV>>IGIBEJA@+D=;Hy=;>HEJCBNM<CBEDYBfPQ<CBEDYBR@+DYBJCHfPQ<CHEZCXE<:Ph>kPhHuCBjBAS@EbgZA@CPhBL+~
PQ<CBEJw>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%LHEZu:P=gJ:S]Hvb S]B>= Ph>IBvb e=gJf@wPK^s?CBjHCeEE?Da@{XE[k@CPd=;GGIHEJ:PQDa@{Lv=;GsPd=;HEJ5zU2<CB
>nlmBE?:Pd=;G.UV>?Da@{GsPd=;GIB?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>kPQ<CBfS]BED_^k?<CBEJCHE[BEJA@<CBR@CPKPhBE[?:Ph>Go@{>sP=gJ:PhH
LHEZu:Pz-hC5
.PhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[?ZC>n<CB>kPQ<CBjGIHE[?A@+Da@CPd= S]Bvb ^k[HLBEDa@CPhBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%G,bp@E=g[qPQ<A@CPr[H>sPtHCeEHEZD
uCBvb1=;BCe>GIHEZb;LuCBwex@Eb;>IBfPhHfPQ<CB[HEDYBDa@{Lv=;Go@Eb%G,bp@E=g[qPQ<A@CPMFBjLHJCHAPr<A@CS]BR@+J:^kuCBvb1=;BCe>W@CP
@Eb1bz{vH{MFBAS]BED~u:^`>sPQDYBEJCXAPQ<CBEJ=gJCX5UT>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[ =gJPQ<=;>ex@{>n<=;HEJ{~ABAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[B@{>,=;BED+PhH
=;XEJCHEDYBz
6eEGIHEZDY>IB+~5=gJwHEZD\?Da@{GsPd=;Go@EbIb1= eB+~A>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[ =;>W@EbM@C^]>B@{>s^
PhHy=;XEJCHEDYBz,{H?CBEDK<A@+?C>HEJCB
>n<CHEZb;Lj>o@C^
PQ<A@CPtBAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[[k@+lmB>= PtB@{>,=;BED+PhHyb;BXv= Pd=g[k@CPhBfPQ<=;>BAS]BED_^]L@C^k?Da@{GsPd=;GIBzn6e
GIHEZDY>IB+~5= eEHEJCBNMFBEDYBJCHAPr?Da@{GsPd=;Go@Eb1b ^`Lv=;>n?CH>IBLfPhHy=;XEJCHEDYBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[@+JCLNMFBEDYB?bp@{XEZCBL
u:^
PQ<CBjAS]BED_Pd=;XH5UT>nZCGn<w>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%>IGIBEJA@+D=;H>Go@+JR=gJCLEZCGIBy=gJw>IHE[B+~3@+JwBAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sPr[HAS]B
MO=1b1bcJCHAPr<CBvbg?wHEJCBz,+ZCGn<S]BED_Pd=;XHjGo@Eb1b;>eHED+PQ<CBfPK^s?CBjHCeE>sPQDa@E=;XE<:PUT>IHvbgZ:Pd=;HEJM<=;Gn<j[k@C^
JCBAS]BED\uCBweHED_PQ<CGIHE[W=gJCXz
2<CB?Da@{XE[k@CPd=;GGIHEJ:PQDa@{Lv=;GsPd=;HEJR=gJ:S]Hvb S]BLjLHB>JCHAP~AHCeEGIHEZDY>IB+~?DYB>nZ??CH>IBfPQ<A@CP\PQ<CB
>nlmBE?:Pd=;GW@+JCL<=;>=gJ:PhBEDb;HGnZ:PhHED@+DYBj>IBE?A@+Da@CPhB?CBHE?b;BzT\Jf@{GsPQZA@Eb%>nlmBE?:Pd=;GGIHEZb;LuCB
@{GIGnZC>IBLu:^k<=;>=gJ:PhBEDb;HGnZ:PhHEDHCev@{>I>nZ[W=gJCXfPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBEDYBy=;>W@+JwBAPhBEDKJA@EbMFHEDb;L+~AHAPQ<CBED
[W=gJCL>:~ABAPhGCz~A>,=g[?b ^=gJST=gD_PQZCBjHCePQ<CBwex@{GsP\PQ<A@CPr<CBfPi@+lmB><=g[>IBvb ePhHuCBjBEJCX@{XBLy=gJf@
LBEuA@CPhBNMO= PQ<f@+JCHAPQ<CBED\?CBEDY>IHEJ5zs2<CBjLv=p@Eb;HXy= Ph>IBvb e?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>kPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBEDYBjBAT=;>sPh>
>IHE[BHEJCBjHAPQ<CBED+PQ<A@+JPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;G<=g[>IBvb eKzs2<=;>ex@+[W=1b1=p@+D\lo=gJCLjHCe?Da@{XE[k@CPd=;G
GIHEJ:PQDa@{Lv=;GsPd=;HEJwLHB>JCHAP@+D=;>IBNM<CBEJwHEJCB+~3@{>7vB>IGo@+D_PhB>Lv=;L+~Av=gJ:PhBEDKJA@Eb1=B>.U%PQ<CB
>nlmBE?:Pd=;GI>?CH>,= Pd=;HEJM<CBEJwHEJCBy=;>BAS@EbgZA@CPd=gJCXjHEJCB5UV>H{MJjuCBvb1=;BCe>Czs2<CB?CH>,= Pd=;HEJwLBCeBEJCLBL
@+uCHAS]B+~A>nZCXXB>sPh>:~<CH{MFBAS]BED~nPQ<A@CPtBAS]BEJR=gJw>nZCGn<e=gDY>sPx?CBEDY>IHEJA@Ebc[BLv= Pi@CPd=;HEJC>:~AHEJCBy=;>
GIHE[[W= PhBLfPhHfPQ<CBjXBEJCBEDa@EbS]BED=;Lv=;Go@Eb1= PK^`HCeEHEJCB5UV>uCBvb1=;BCe>Cz
7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>?CH>,= Pd=;HEJwGo@+JjuCBZJCLBEDY>sPhHHL+~nPQ<CBEJ{~3@{>BEJ:Pi@E=1b1=gJCXfPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBjXBEJCBEDa@Eb
S]BED=;Lv=;Go@Eb1= PK^`HCeEHEZD\uCBvb1=;BCe>W@+uCHEZ:P\PQ<CBNMFHEDb;L[ZC>sPruCB?DYB>nZ??CH>IBLu:^`HEZD\?Da@{GsPd=;GIBjHCe
Xv= ST=gJCXR@+JCLR@{>nlo=gJCXweHED\DYB@{>IHEJC>:~3@+JCLj>IHjGo@+JJCHAPruCBfPi@+lmBEJPhHuCBR@CPt>sPi@+lmBy=gJw>nZCGn<f@
?Da@{GsPd=;GIBz-h.+lmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%LHEZu:Ph>W@+DYBjv=;Lvb;B5U.JCHAPE_ZC>sP=gJPQ<CBj>IBEJC>IBfPQ<A@CPMFBjGo@+JjJCBAS]BED
23/04/2004

http://www.yorku.ca/hjackman/papers/ext-and-skept.html

#4

{@ GsPrZ?CHEJPQ<CBE[~uZ:P@Eb;>IHy=gJPQ<CBj>IBEJC>IBfPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBv=gD\DYBoBGsPd=;HEJR=;>?DYB>nZ??CH>IBLu:^

PQ<CB
S]BED_^kJCHEDK[k@CPd= S]B?Da@{GsPd=;GIB>kPQ<A@CP\PQ<CBA^`XEDYH{MHEZ:PtHCeKz-hC5

23/04/2004

http://www.yorku.ca/hjackman/papers/ext-and-skept.html

#5

F
{ zof<=;Gn<R=;>?CBEDK<A@+?C>W@NXHHLfPQ<=gJCX+~A>,=gJCGIB[k@+J:^MFHEZb;LjGIHEJC>,=;LBEDF= Ph>W@+u=1b1= PK^
PhH?DYHAST=;LB
>nZCGn<f@NEZ=;GnlDYBCeZ:Pi@CPd=;HEJwHCeE>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[qPhHuCBR@DYBLEZCGsPd=;HjHCev@+J:^
PQ<CBHED_^`HCe[B@+J=gJCXz
}a{BBym@Eb S]BA^@+JCLj6MFBEJC>:~5K.PhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>n[~3{Bvb e_YcJCH{MOb;BLXB+~3@+JCLR+lmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[~\{<=1bI4,BAS
n3E~3@+JCLyGI=gJJ{~5K4C@{Lv=;Go@EbI/gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJf@+JCLy{?=;>sPhBE[Hvb;HXA^T\=gJRBv,HEDYB}YBLz ca
Io:cxv.a:ac,~:eHEDG,bp@E=g[>HCePQ<=;>>IHED_P
E z{%HED@NGnD= Pd=;G,=;>n[HCe7@CST=;L>IHEJwHCePQ<=;>>IHED_P~A>IBByz{Ib;Bv=gJ3UV>K4C@{Lv=;Go@EbI/gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPi@CPd=;HEJf@+JCL
+lmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[W\=gJRBv,HEDYB}YBLz caIo:cxv.a:ac,~3@+JCLRCPd=;Gn<RK
=;XE<:PO@+JjuCBR@+J
/gDKDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb\J=g[k@Eb1\=gJR%HEDKJub1= PQ<j}YBLz F:3KI1;%1cjCvmcWcTn5~}Y9@+[uD=;LXBA
/ 2n3E
?5zA{Ez
+ z{-2<CByBAPQ<CHLjHCeA2DKZ:PQ<R=gJRBAPi@+?<:^]>,=;GI>,~?{vz,{BBR@Eb;>IHyaZC>sP@{>kPhHH[ZCGn<
@CPKPQD=guZ:PhBLjBEDKDYHED\D=;>nlm>LBE?D= ST=gJCXfPQ<CBj>nZusBGsPtHCe<=;>>nZusBGsPr[k@CPKPhBED~A>IHfPhHH[ZCGn<
@{GsPQZA@Eb%BEDKDYHED\DYHEuC>W@?CBEDY>IHEJwHCePQ<=gJCX>kPhHjXHNMDYHEJCXR@+uCHEZ:Pz} 1_
zof<=1b;By7@CST=;L>IHEJf@+??CB@Eb;>kPhHfPQ<CB?CH>I>,=gu=1b1= PK^`HCev@+JwHE[J=;>IG,=;BEJ:P=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBED~
HE[J=;>IG,=;BEJCGIBy=;>?DYHEuA@+ub ^k[HEDYBfPQ<A@+JM<A@CP=;>JCBBLBLjHEJPQ<CBy=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBEDUV>?A@+D_Pr}a@+JCLy= P
[k@C^b;B@{LfPhHjHAPQ<CBEDF=;>I>nZCB>HCe+M<CBAPQ<CBED@+JwHE[J=;>IG,=;BEJ:PruCBv=gJCXNMFHEZb;LweBBvbm@+J:^kJCBBLfPhH
=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPtHAPQ<CBEDY>kPQ<CBNM@C^MFBjLH+hzs2<CB}K[BEDYB+FDYBEZ=gDYBE[BEJ:P\PQ<A@CP\PQ<CBy=gJ:PhBEDK?DYBAPhBED\<A@CS]B+~
@{>W@[k@CPKPhBEDHCeex@{GsP~AHEJb ^
PQDKZCBuCBvb1=;BCe>>n<CHEZb;LuCBjBEJCHEZCXE<eHEDF7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>W@+DYXEZ[BEJ:Pz
+z,{BBy9HE<CBEDYBEJCGIB2<CBHED_^`HCeA2DKZ:PQ<f@+JCLycJCH{MOb;BLXBv?5zAEC5-2<CByBAPQ<CHLjHCeA2DKZ:PQ<
=gJRBAPi@+?<:^]>,=;GI>,~?5z{{z
Ez{-2<CByBAPQ<CHLjHCeA2DKZ:PQ<R=gJRBAPi@+?<:^]>,=;GI>,~?5z{{z
+zs2<=;>?CHv=gJ:P=;>>sPQDYB>I>IBLu:^Ib;Bv=gJ5z
Ez{KcJCH{MO=gJCXjHEJCB5UV>H{MJR
=gJCLv~??5zECz

23/04/2004

http://www.yorku.ca/hjackman/papers/ext-and-skept.html

#6

2<CBweZD_PQ<CBED\?CH>I>,=gu=1b1= PK^

PQ<A@CP7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>?CH>,= Pd=;HEJRb;B@CS]B>ZC>MO= PQ<PQ<CB?CH>I>,=gu=1b1= PK^`HCe
PQ<CBv=gD\uCBv=gJCXR@N>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[@+uCHEZ:P\PQ<CB Ic:c:HCeEHEZD\uCBvb1=;BCe>MO=1b1bcJCHAPruCBjLB@Eb PMO= PQ<j<CBEDYB+~
PQ<CHEZCXE<R7@CST=;L>IHEJj<=g[>IBvb ev@+DYXEZCB>kPQ<A@CPt>nZCGn<MFHED=;B>W@+uCHEZ:PtHEZD>IBvb e_xlIJCH{MOb;BLXBR@+DYB
ZJ.eHEZJCLBLy=gJj<=;>KcJCH{MO=gJCXjHEJCB5UV>H{MJR
=gJCLv@+JCLyKI=gDY>sP,BEDY>IHEJ\Z:PQ<CHED= PK^Tz
n j{BBR{Bvb1bp@+DY> v1Kc]IoaooI1mv]:,1oE~5{Da@+JCLHE[ II1cRn.v1c~
G,7vH{MFBvb1b 1oNIocKz
 {zT+Pb;B@{>sPM<CBEJwHEJCB?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>W@+Jwv=gJ:PhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sPUTGIHEJCGIBE?:Pd=;HEJwHCeEBE?=;>sPhBE[W=;G
_ZC>sPd= e=;Go@CPd=;HEJ5z{/ eEHEJCB?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>W@+JwBAPhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sPtHEJCB+~CM<CBEDYBW_ZC>sPd= e=;Go@CPd=;HEJR=;>
ZJCLBEDY>sPhHHLy=gJPhBEDK[>HCePQ<CBDYBvb1=p@+u=1b1= PK^`HCePQ<CBDYBvb;BAS@+J:PruCBvb1=;BCe_eHEDK[W=gJCX?DYHGIB>I>IB>:~A>nZCGn<
>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Eb%>IGIBEJA@+D=;H>LHJCHAP\PQ<DYB@CPhBEJk_ZC>sPd= e=;Go@CPd=;HEJ5z
, Ezn6JCGIBR@{X@E=gJ{~3@{>I>nZ[W=gJCXfPQ<A@CPtHEJCBy=;>MFHEDKlo=gJCXNMO= PQ<f@+JR=gJ:PhBEDKJA@Eb1=;>sPt>IBEJC>IBjHCe
_ZC>sPd= e=;Go@CPd=;HEJ5z
C +zn6JCBjGo@+Je=gJCLjHEJCB>IBvb e=gJf@N>,=g[W=1bp@+D\?CH>,= Pd=;HEJST=;>W@wST=;>kPQ<CB?DYHEub;BE[HCeeDYBBNMO=1b1bzoB
LH<A@CS]BR@?Da@{GsPd=;GIBjHCe=gJCEZ=gD=gJCXNM<CBAPQ<CBEDGIBED_Pi@E=gJf@{XBEJ:Ph>W@+DYB}Y>n<CHEZb;LuCB<CBvb;L+
DYB>n?CHEJC>,=gub;BweHED+PQ<CBv=gD@{GsPd=;HEJC>CzTXBEJ:Ph>M<CHR@+DYBDYB>n?CHEJC>,=gub;BweHED+PQ<CBv=gD@{GsPd=;HEJC>>n<CHEZb;L
uCB?ZJ=;>n<CBLjHED\DYB{M@+DYLBL+~nPQ<CH>IBNM<CHR@+DYBJCHAP~A>n<CHEZb;LJCHAPzaZC>sP@{>kPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;GkPQD=;B>
PhHjBAPhBEJCLjHEZD\?Da@{GsPd=;GIBjHCeDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb%GnD= Pd=;G,=;>n[ =gJw>nZCGn<f@M@C^
PQ<A@CPrJCHEJCBjHCeEHEZD\uCBvb1=;BCe>
PQZDKJwHEZ:P\PhHuCBDa@CPd=;HEJA@Eb1b ^_ZC>sPd= e=;BL+~nPQ<CBy=gJCGIHE[?A@CPd=gu=1b1=;>sPtBAPhBEJCL>HEZD\?Da@{GsPd=;GIBjHCe
BAS@EbgZA@CPd=gJCXfPQ<CBR@{GsPd=;HEJC>HCeEHAPQ<CBEDY>=gJf@M@C^M<=;Gn<jDYBEZ=gDYB>kPQ<A@CPrJCHjHEJCBy=;>DYB>n?CHEJC>,=gub;B
eHED@+J:^PQ<=gJCXzs2<=;>=;>HCePhBEJPi@+lmBEJPhHj>nZCXXB>sP\PQ<A@CPMFBR@+DYBJCBAS]BEDA_ZC>sPd= e=;BLy=gJj?ZJ=;>n<=gJCX
HAPQ<CBEDY>>,=gJCGIBJCHjHEJCBy=;>DYB>n?CHEJC>,=gub;BweHED+PQ<CBv=gD@{GsPd=;HEJC>Cz38\J.eHED_PQZJA@CPhBvb ^m~nPQ<CBjBEJ:Pd=gDYB
?DYHGIB>I>HCeEBAS@EbgZA@CPd=gJCXNM<CBAPQ<CBEDHAPQ<CBEDY>>n<CHEZb;LuCB<CBvb;LDYB>n?CHEJC>,=gub;BweHED+PQ<CBv=gD@{GsPd=;HEJC>
?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>W@CPb;B@{>sPt>IHE[BjGIHXEJ= Pd= S]BjHEDBAPQ<=;Go@EbcDYB>n?CHEJC>,=gu=1b1= PK^`HEJwHEZD\?A@+D_Pr}_PQ<CB
GIHEJCGIBEDKJR=;>MO= PQ<M<A@CPMFBj>n<CHEZb;LjLH+hz{/ eJCHjHEJCBNMFBEDYBDYB>n?CHEJC>,=gub;BweHED+PQ<CBv=gD@{GsPd=;HEJC>:~
PQ<CBEJjJCBv= PQ<CBEDvMFHEZb;LNMFB+~5=gJM<=;Gn<wGo@{>IBfPQ<CBjBAS@EbgZA@CPd=;HEJC>MFHEZb;L<A@CS]BJCH?CHv=gJ:Pz
ZCB>sPd=;HEJ=gJCXNM<CBAPQ<CBEDHEZD\DYB@{GsPd= S]BR@CPKPd= PQZCLB>W@+DYBW_ZC>sPd= e=;BL?DYB>nZ??CH>IB>kPQ<A@CPMFBjGo@+J
uCB<CBvb;LDYB>n?CHEJC>,=gub;BweHED+PQ<CBE[~A>IHR@+J:^@+DYXEZ[BEJ:P@CPKPhBE[?:Pd=gJCXfPhHj>n<CH{MPQ<A@CPrJCHjHEJCBy=;>
DYB>n?CHEJC>,=gub;BweHED@+J:^PQ<=gJCXNMO=1b1bI=gJ:S]Hvb S]BR@wPK^s?CBjHCe?Da@{XE[k@CPd=;GGIHEJ:PQDa@{Lv=;GsPd=;HEJj}= e= P=;>[B@+J:P
PhHj>n<CH{MPQ<A@CPtHEZD\DYB@{GsPd= S]BR@CPKPd= PQZCLB>W@+DYBJCHAPr}YBv= PQ<CBEDBAPQ<=;Go@Eb1b ^`HEDGIHXEJ= Pd= S]Bvb ^m3_ZC>sPd= e=;BL+hz
. z,+ZCGn<jDa@{Lv=;Go@Eb%>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[ =;>JCHAP~nPQ<CBEJ{~3@|gDYBvb;BAS@+J:P@Eb PhBEDKJA@CPd= S]Bv|PQ<A@CP\PQ<CBfPQ<=gJlmBED
[ZC>sPrDKZb;BjHEZ:P\PhHyb;BXv= Pd=g[k@CPhB<=;>G,bp@E=g[qPhHlIJCH{MOb;BLXBz{/ e+MFBR@{>I>nZ[BfPQ<A@CP\PhHuCBjBEJ:Pd= Pdb;BL
PhH[k@+lmBR@NG,bp@E=g[qPhHlIJCH{MOb;BLXB+~nPQ<CBjG,bp@E=g[BED\[ZC>sPrDKZb;BjHEZ:P@Eb1bcDYBvb;BAS@+J:P@Eb PhBEDKJA@CPd= S]B>:~
PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;GGo@+JjuCBZJCLBEDY>sPhHHLR@{>kPQD_^T=gJCXfPhHjGIHE[BZ?f@wPK^s?CBjHCeEEZJ= S]BEDY>o@EbU
@Eb PhBEDKJA@CPd= S]BfPQ<A@CPrDKZb;B>HEZ:P@Eb1b%G,bp@E=g[>kPhHlIJCH{MOb;BLXBz{7@CST=;L>IHEJ3UV>?CH>,= Pd=;HEJC>>nZCXXB>sPh>:~

C< H{MFBAS]BED~nPQ<A@CPt>nZCGn<jZJ= S]BEDY>o@Ebm@Eb PhBEDKJA@CPd= S]B>Go@+JJCHAPruCBfPQDYB@CPhBLR@{>DYBvb;BAS@+J:P~A>,=gJCGIBfPQ<CBA^

@+DYBR@EbgDYB@{LA^kDKZb;BLjHEZ:Pru:^
PQ<CB?DYHGIBLEZDYBjHCev@{>nlo=gJCXweHEDA_ZC>sPd= e=;Go@CPd=;HEJR= Ph>IBvb eKz,3M@+[?[k@+J
=;>JCHAP@DYBvb;BAS@+J:P@Eb PhBEDKJA@CPd= S]Bj>,=gJCGIBy= P=;>DKZb;BLjHEZ:Pru:^
PQ<CB?DYB>nZ??CH>,= Pd=;HEJC>HCePQ<CB
Lv=;>IGIHEZDY>IBz

23/04/2004

http://www.yorku.ca/hjackman/papers/ext-and-skept.html

C -2<CB?CHv=gJ:P=;>JCHAP\PQ<A@CPMFB[ZC>sP@{GIGIBE?:P\PQ<=;>GIHEJCG,bgZC>,=;HEJR=gJwHEDYLBED+PhHR@CS]Hv=;L
>nlmBE?:Pd=;G,=;>n[~uZ:P\PQ<A@CPMFB[ZC>sP@{GIGIBE?:P= P=gJwHEDYLBED+PhHjBAs?bp@E=gJPQ<CBjBAT=;>sPhBEJCGIBjHCePQ<CB
GIHEJCGIBE?:PQZA@Eb%>IGn<CBE[By=gJPhBEDK[>HCe+M<=;Gn<PQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Ebc?DYHEub;BE[ =;>>sPi@CPhBLz{{Z:PtHEJCGIBfPQ<CB
GIHEJCG,bgZC>,=;HEJR=;>>sPi@CPhBL+~nPQ<CBj>nlmBE?:Pd=;Go@Ebc?DYHEub;BE[LHB>JCHAP@+D=;>IBz}aCPQDa@3MF>IHEJ{~ o{3IT~
nEz

$,  #){
$

 W_   "
$&


#7