Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(ClH.55l) sosHur s xoHqe XI B, Ha BocToqHocrtag.flHcxo TeppnTop 1,1. CoxpaHunuarcr pyKonncb cnucaHa co cTapocraBlrHcKofo opl4rHana. OHa xpaHnrcr n focyAapcrseHHou I,Icropulecxou lry:ee
2, 183-s Mocxee. Pyronncl cocTollT H3 l 84 neprarraeuuslx ngcrog. lltzctst
184 uvercr,rurur 3anucH 1,1 pficyHKl.r 6olee no:.{ Hero BpeMeH . Tercr Hanucau
ycTaBoM B oAug cro:r6eu. IIncrg 2| v-22v HanllcaHbl rocslrra ycraaov. flaulTCHHaficKH narepur
(XVKOBCKAJI -'| 1,1XOMI4IIIEILAMAHOBA 1984: 68 69). llaurrHnr 6r,trt NsAaH B.C. fonu-
POB
urerrxo n B.@. ly6poaNHo s 196'7 r, s Mocrcse, B aauuo cTaTse aHaJIH3 npoBoI,trcr no 3ToMy H3AaHltrc, Kpoue .4arupolrn ronqov XI B. tsBecTHa n arnposra XI-XII BeKaMu (fOJlbIl EHKO - AYEPOBIZHA 1967,. 5; CEII,VIIJ_| EB 195l: 87; OPOJ1OBA 1972: 4). Kpove ocuosHoro noqepKa B naMrTHHKe pa3IuqaeTc eule KaK MHHHMyM 7 4pyrnx noqeproB (fOnblilEF{ KO
,..I
397
nepenpaBneHa us 6yxrrt
(rT .cra;..,rrT ,) cT
,nart:
nqlcrlIca,rt.,,rt,rralacTlt9lxtrr'rt,M'Hnxlyx(yl)K9lcrntT.cn:96v.17.
Cynnu, rar BI4Ho H3 BbIu]eyKa3aHHLIx npHMepoB, ynorpe6l-n,rcr nocJIe DIaloJloB ABHxeHu, AJLI BbIp u{ eHH,l uenH Aect.s} .lg unu AJl, coKpauleH} .l
[pHaToqHoro npeAnolt< eHnlI qelu. Tyr BoI(Ho oTMeTHTb, qTo B ApeBHepyccKHx naM THHKax ynorpe6.neune cynnHa BcTpeqaeTc, I{ nocle flIafoJloB, He
o6o:Haqarour-rx BHJK
Hne. IIo ua6mo4eur.rro A.A. llore6Hrl, nocne IJIaroIoB
ntaTfi
3TIrMoIorHqecKu poAcTBeHHlIx
poa-
rru repuuH eIrle He pa:pa6oran A DKe no MHeHun caMoro yueHoro (EOPKOBCKHI,i 1949: 335, npr.rrrle.r. 9).
9to xacaet:c. cTapocJIaBrHcK} Tx Ko.4eKcoB, To L B Hx oqeHb peAKo
uoNHo Ha6,rIoAarh TaKI.Ie KoHcTpyKlulr, B KoTopllx nepe cynI4HoM cToI. T He
Cynpacnscxo pyxonHcu
(Xl
n.): rcr4a ax
398
nAnAO 1983:27,35)1
B usyuaeuona
naM_sTHIdKe cynuH noo6r.qe ynorpe6lrercx nocne JIHqrrux { opu DIafoJIoB, Ho B Tpex cnyqa. x BcTpeqaeTc, n nocJle npuvacru, a
oAIrH pzl3 u nocle uuQurrr.trasa. B srux nplrMep x np qacTux Lurn uHQIlHrrrnr
Kor,qa cynux
6rn
cr:
n9HA ... c,LncT,L nF,tlEaueE (Mp PqEB 2000: l l6), B KIoIloBoM c6opHnKe
(cnncor XI r. c KoeKca KoHua D( - HaqanaXR.)i Eogb syna pou,la ... sleje
pod,a zakonoma lstapllo (MEYER 1944:288).
flo4lexaulee flaroJla ABIDKeHfi ToxecTBeHHo JIorfiqecKoMy noJlexaqeMy ,4ecrnn-n, BblparKeHHofo uHQnHr.nusou: (tt4\l ...| ...) c,f,,B9LllJHTH
a)
' nprvepu
399
cr) rllttrn:
34v.5, (ngrj,e
nrru) rrxnT
n9rrc9a.l
q.
yKa3aTeJlbHolo MecTotlMeHNr
94,T!rit cEH.) n9\rcEtTHTx (rama I oy,lr.): 78v.5,
4.
xe
| Iroru n
ra). (noycrlrr
ra,r,ra
Br,tBoABr
B cgrgfi c HaJIfiqHeN ltlt lafureHo KaTefopll1,1 cynHHa B qsHrce C HacKolo naTepnKa MoxHo KoHcTaTupoBaT[,, qTo B To BpeM, cynun eule He 6slrt
BblTecHeH nNSnHurHsotul, TaK KaK B I,ByqaeMoM naM. THltKe o ero ynorpe6JreHH} l csnAeTerlcmytor l9 nplrMepoB. Kpoue stux AaHHr,Ix, Ha fi BbIBoAbl
noTBepxaroTc, t{ TeM, qTo B ApeBHepyccKllx pyKonnc x, B ToM qHcJIe H B
rpaMoTax, ynorpe6leHne cynnHa Ha6,rrc4aeTc BnJroTB ao XlV s. (COKOIOBA 1962: 235), n ro.rrrxo HaqHHa, c XV s. oH 6lIn slItecHen oKoHqaTeI} ,Ho
raH$uHuruxov (IOMTEB 1956: 1 l). Cornacgo MHeHLlrc HeKoTop tx yqeHblx,
Aa} K rpaMoTLI XV s. eue He noTBepx(qa} oT oKoHqaTeJlbHoro ucq$HoBeHnr
KaTeropHH cynHHa
(EoPKoBCK} l
].9qs:
Ta-zzl).
Xorr cynnH, no rce neporrnocT| 4, ,RllJ c eI:1e x so rpaMMaTHL]ecxofi rareropne ,3LIKa trucqa, MoxHo co Bce onpeefleHHocTb o yTBepx,{ aTb, qTo npoqecc ero ucqe3HoBeHH, yxe Haq ucr, 06 grolr cBHAeTeIbcrzyer 23 np Mepa, B KoTopbtx cynuH 3aMeHeH uu$uxurnaou. A sro rHavnr,
qTo noclte rafonoB BIDKeHH, (,&nr artpaxennr qenn ecrsnr VnV rla
coKpaueHu, npllAaToqHoro npeAnoxeHn, qenrl) yxe qaue ynorpe6lcercrt
400
eule cTorJr cynIaH: (rr4e xl, e9rr;o.) ca.K\rHL{ ^ TH (nrrlftrrfi cr,,rrcn): 9.10.
(rlxr6e) n.rllr| ll.rt (rl rrrxr,rerl ryErl^ TI,): 170.15_16. K nepaovy
npHMepy MoxHo o6aBHTb el]le oAuH, B KoTopoM npH fnafoJ]e c\KHhqTH MbI
Ha6Jrrc Ura ynorpe6neHae BuH. naAexa, a 3To MoxeT cBI]AeTerbcTBoBaTL o
ToM, qTo AaHHbIi fnafo, ynpaBJrreT He poAl{ TeJrbHblM, a BLiHHTeIbH!,IM
flapexoM: (1orn) no;..rr, M\r] c\KHNlqTH: l1.19 - 1lv.l. Ec;rr.r npl{ Mepbt
3aMeHbI cynltHa HHHHHT11BoM Mol-yT rHtx6 onocpeAcTBoBaHHo oK r36IBaTb,
qTo B 3blKe nllcqa yxe Haqanocb Hcqe3HoBeHBe cynuHa (y.tursteafl, qTo H B
cTapocJlaBrHcKHx pyKonncrx 3aperncTpHpoBaHbl 3aMeHr,I cynHHa uHIiHtrTHBoM, cM. HI{ xe), Tora ABa Br,IueyKa3aHHblx npHMepa c nprMr,IM AonoJIHeH eM
cTBeHHo yKa3btBa} oT Ha HaqaBuIH c, B q3blKe
B poA. naIexe yxe Henocp
n -rcqa npouecc oTMHpaHl,i.fi KaTef opHI{ cynfi Ha,
C.rregyer oTMeTnTb, qTo cynnH Mof 3aMeHrTbc, He ToJIbKo ttH{ uHurnBoM, Ho } l npHAaToqHL,IM npeAJloxeHlleM uenH. Ho .[aHHo npo6jreN4rJl M6I He
MoxeM KacaTbc, B cHJry Toao, qTo An, 3Toro rryr(Ho 6blno 6rt MIr.rerr Aaa eapHaHTa oAHol-o I,1 Tolo xe TeKcTa. Bo3HHKllIt4x B pa3Hoe sperutx. .{ pynalr nyrev
ycTpaHeH
'l
cynl4Ha
tPuurrnrou. Kap.n X. Meep BrIIBI,IJI cJleAyrouee cooTHoueHne cyn Ha u vHQtIHtltnsa B qeTblpex KoAeKcax: s Accel\raHoson eBaHreJILrH (xoHeu X a. Ha,r&lo XI r.) cynux ynolpe6neH 16 par,, a 3aMeHa cynl{ Ha r.ruQNHrlrrloou
BcTpeqaeTc- 8 pas; s MapnnHcKoM eBaHreJIHLl (roHeu X o,) cynlrH 3aperHc' pupomrr 16 par, a nHQnHzrnB BMecTo Hero rra6IroaeTc l 12 paz; a 3orpaQcKoM eBaHfefln .l (rorreq X e.) rrapr.qy c 7 cynuaauu crorr l8 nHQuHLrrnson; l
CassrrHo xlrr.rre (XI r.) cynlH $nryplrpyer l l pas, a nHQnrrnrrrr Ha ero MecTe no- BJrleTc, 9 pas (MEYER 1944: 276). Haennue nauu 23 npHMepa
BbtTecHeHla, cynuua raxQuuuuaBoM MoryT yKa36IBaTb He ToJlLKo Ha ,3bIK nncua, Bo3MoxHo, Hx cIeAoBaJIo 6H aogsec,ra r.r r npororparly, )^ IIrTBIBlt ToT
< Parr, ,rro B H3yqaeMoM naMrTHuKe oTHouleHue cynu* a 14 nH$uHnrusa, croxlqefo BMecTo cynuna 19 t< 23.
Ognaxo, npuulrlvla Bo BHHMaHne Te Ba cnyqa, 3aMeH ,I cynaHa nH{ uuutnsov, nocne KoTopblx np Moe onoJIHeHI{ e cTorr s po5. nagexe (cu.
artue), uoxuo npenonoxrrL, qTo KpoMe 3TIlx AByx npHMepoB no rpaHe
Mepe ellle HecKoJlbKo cJryqaeB npoucxo,4rT He H3 npororpaQa, Ho oTpuDftaloT
xuro.r:r,tx nepenficqura.
IIprrue.rarrne
* Hanncarrue
Hacroque pa6orrt craao Bo3MoxHbIM 6:rarogapr no.q4epNrce focyapcTBeHHoro HayqHofo ccJleoBaTeIlcKoro QoHga (OTKA;
perncTpaquoHH I HoMep:
D 13 457
4).
"Iureparypa
14,
3A1,1MoB opaax,
t} nr, l983.
co-
40z
403