.

)2011- (8

@ @

@ @
@ @
@ @
@ba@a@@@ba@na@j@bma@
@ @a@buna@a@bu@@a@pab

* .
**. .
***.
****.

*
**
***
****

96

)2011- (8

:



.



:
) (.


30
2010/2009.


.(Rubric) .
) (6
.
: .

97

)2011- (8

-1:


) (Vollrath Hopp, 2003 ) .(Xila Liu, 2003


"" " " ) .(2001


) .(2005


) (2005



) (2005

) .(2005


) .(2007

) .(2005

.

98

)2011- (8

.
1-1 :

:


.

:
)1994(

2001 10
178

.
2-1 :

:
)2006( :

. :
. . )2006( :

. :

99

)2011- (8

.
.
)2005( :


.
) 2005( :
.
.
)2005( :
. :
-1
.
-2 .
)2007( :

.
.



.

100

)2011- (8

3-1 :


:

:
-1
-2

4-1 :

:
.
.
5-1 :


.


.
6-1 :

.2010/2009

101

)2011- (8

7-1 :
: .
:

.
-2 :
1-2 :


.
2-2 :
30
2010/2009 .
%30
.
3-2 :

) (Rubric
3 .

.

%85
.

102

)2011- (8

:
%100 -%90. %89.9 -%80 . %79.9 -%65. %64.9 -%50. %50. 4-2 :
:


.
.
.
:
: . : . : .
) (photo shop) (3D Max) (Auto cad
.

103

)2011- (8

-3 :

:
1-3 :


.
1-1-3

)(1
:

60.71% 1.1507 3.6429

50.00% 1.5191 3.0000

62.22% 1.3870 3.7333

.9492 3.8571

64.28%

.9904 3.8667

64.44%

60.33% 1.1993 3.6200

) (1
) (1 ) 3.00 ( 3.867
) %50.00 .( %64.44

104

)2011- (8

) (3.62 4
.%60.33
%95 ) (2.9388 , 4.301 ) (1
)) (( :

) (1
2-1-3

) (2
:

4.2143

.9749

70.24%

105

4.1429

)2011- (8

.8644

69.05%

1.0271 3.8571

64.28%

1.2314 3.1429

52.38%

1.3789 2.9167

48.61%

60.91% 1.0953 3.6547

) (2
) (2 ) 2.916 ( 4.1429
) %48.61 .( %70.24
) (3.65
4 . %60.91
%95 ) (3.0063 , 4.302 ) (2
)) (( :

) (2

106

3-1-3

)2011- (8

) (3
:

52.07% 1.5776 3.2143

60.71% 1.1507 3.6429

64.28%

64.28% 1.1673 3.8571

47.61% 1.2924 2.8571

57.79% 1.2104 3.4857

3.8571

.8644

) (3
) (3 ) 2.85 ( 3.85
) %47.61 ( %64.28
) ( 3.4857 4
. %57.79
%95 ) (2.7867 , 4.184 ) (3
)) (( :

107

)2011- (8

) (3
4-1-3

AutoCad

AutoCad

) (4
AutoCad :

.8516 4.5714

76.19%

.7595 4.5000

75.00%

.6504 4.5000

75.00%

.7595 4.5000

75.00%

63.10% 1.0509 3.7857

72.86% 0.8143 4.3714

108

)2011- (8

) (4 AutoCad
) (4 ) 3.78 ( 4.57
) %63.10 .(%76.19
) (4.3714
4 .%72.86
%95 ) (3.90 , 4.84 ) (4
)) ((AutoCad :

) (4 AutoCad
5-1-3

3DMAX

3DMAX


) (5
3DMAX :

109

)2011- (8

AutoCAD

4.2857

1.1387

71.42%

3.2857

1.4898

54.76%

2.6429

1.4468

44.05%

3.2857

1.5406

54.76%

3.2143

1.5776

53.57%

3.3428

1.4387

55.71%

) (5 3DMAX
) (5 ) 2.6429 ( 4.2857
) %44.05 .(%71.42
) (3.3428
4 %55.71
%95 ) (2.5121 , 4.173 )(5
)) ((3DMAX :

) (5 3D MAX
6-1-3

PHOTOSHOP

PHOTOSHOP

110

)2011- (8

)(6
PHOTOSHOP :

2.0648 1.4286

23.81%

2.0232 1.3571

22.61%

2.1380 1.4286

23.81%

2.0978 1.3571

22.61%

1.9386 1.2857

21.43%

2.0524 1.3714

22.85%

) (6 PHOTOSHOP
) (6 ) 1.2857 ( 1.4286
) %21.43 .( %23.81
) (1.3714 4
. %22.85
%95 ) .(0.1863 , 2.556 ) (6
)) ((PHOTOSHOP :

111

)2011- (8

) (6 PHOTOSHOP
7-1-3

) (7
:

-1

60.33%

-2

60.91%

-3

57.79%

-4

AutoCAD

72.86%

-5

D MAX3

55.71%

-6

PHOTOSHOP

22.85%

55.1

) (7

112

)2011- (8

) (7
:

) (7
) (7 ) (7
%55.1
)(photo shop)(3D Max
.
.
2-3 :
:
) (6
.
:

113

)2011- (8

%60.33 . %60.91 . %57.79 . %72.86 . Auto cad %54.71 . D3 max %22.85 .Photoshop ) (%55.1 .
.

4-3 :
:
.
.
. . . . . . - .

114

)2011- (8

:
-1
.
-2 .
:
. . . .
.

.1 . :
.. .. 2002.[HR]13
.2 ) "(2005 "
17 -15 2005
.
.3 ) "(2005 "

.
.4 ) "(2005
"
.
.5 ) "(2005 :
"
.
.6 ) "(2005 "
.

115

)2011- (8

.7 ) "(2007
) (" 35 ) (1 2007
.
.8 .
31.2001
.9 )2006(
) (Icee 2006
.
)2006(
.10
) (Icee 2006
.
11.
Vollrath Hopp, Topic for the Standardization of
International Engineering Education, Journal of World
Federation of Engineering Organization (WFEO), Committee on
Education and Training, No. 10, Dec. 2003.
12.
Xila Liu, The Engineering Educationof the 21st century,
Journal of World Federation of Engineering Organization
(WFEO), Committee on Education and Training, No. 10, Dec.
2003.

116