Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Borderlands - Nielson
Borderlands - Nielson
Labels Suck
1
Borderlands K
Borderlands KritikIndex
Borderlands KritikIndex.......................1
1NC Shell.................................................2
Link: Nation-States...................................5
Link: Citizenship......................................6
Link: Immigration Law............................7
Link: US/Mexico Border........................12
Link: Marriage Visas..............................13
Link: Temporary Workers.......................14
Link: Gender Advantages.......................15
Link: Ecology/Environments Advantages17
Link: Economy Advantages...................18
Link: Heteronormativity Advantages.....21
Link: Terrorism Advantages...................22
Link: Drug Trafficking...........................23
Link: Critical Affs (Non- Transnational Feminism)
24
Link: Western Academics.......................25
Impacts: Feminism Turns.......................26
Impacts: Imperialism..............................28
Impacts: Biopower.................................32
Impacts: Dehumanization.......................33
Impacts: Gender Violence......................34
Impacts: Poverty.....................................35
Impacts: Colonization.............................36
Alternative: Mestiza Consciousness.......38
Alternative Solvency..............................41
Alternative Solvency: Gender/Intersectionality 52
Answer To: Perm....................................53
Answer To: Framework..........................57
Answer To: Borderlands only applies to the Latino/a Popn
Answer To: Utopian Alternative.............59
***Aff: A2 Borderlands***...................60
Borderlands Ignores Mexican Perspective61
Borderlands are Homogenizing..............63
Orientalism Turn.....................................64
Globalization Turn..................................65
Cultural Identity Turn.............................66
Immigration Reform Turn......................67
Alt Cant Solve.......................................68
Perm........................................................69
58
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
2
Borderlands K
1NC Shell
(A) LINK- Citizenship law is a boundary dividing control that creates identity around
American power.
Dudziak & Volpp 5 (Mary L. Dudziak is the Judge Edward J. and Ruey L. Guirado Professor of
Law, History, and Political Science at the USC, and a visiting professor of law at Harvard Law
School. Leti Volpp professor of law -UC Berkeley) American Quarterly (57.3 593-594) ALM
On the coast,
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
3
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
4
Borderlands K
(C)ALTERNATIVE Reject the duality of aff immigration and embrace the mestiza
consciousness to break down duality between races, sexes, etc. within a new value system
embedded in a culture of harmony.
Prez 5 (Emma, Assoc. Prof. of history at the University of Texas, El Paso, NWSA Journal 17.2
(2005) 1-10) ALM
Decades ago Gloria Anzalda
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
5
Borderlands K
Link: Nation-States
Nation-states and democracy are rooted in the Europes attempt to make itself the center of
the world
Orozco-Mendoza 8 (Elva Fabiola, thesis: Borderlands Theory: Producing
Border Epistomologies with Gloria Anzaldua, Virgina Polytechnic Institute
and State University, April 24, p. 8. DAP)
One of the goals of modernity was to change the obscurantism of the world into reason. During this period,
the European civilization expanded all over the world due to the fact that they managed to carry on the
social production of frontiers; a concept that according to Walter D. Mignolo and Madina V. Tlostanova was
On the one
side of the frontiers was civilization; on the other; nothing, just
barbarism or emptiness (Mignolo and Tlostanova, 2006: 205).9 According to this
classification, civilization was meant to be a synonym of Western
Europe while barbarism was to be understood as the remainder,
i.e. Africa, Asia, and America. From this context, then, frontiers became
the spaces of influence that Europeans accommodated to
exercise control over its periphery on the basis of racist values
that led to the establishment of opposing categories such as us
and them, or, we and others. With this classification, Europe attempted to
appoint itself the center of the world and tried to divide up the
earth to organize the worlds exploitation and to export the border form to the
periphery (Balibar, 2004: 7). Thus, exporting the border form to the periphery
not only implied organizing the world in units called nationstates, but it also meant developing a cultural or spiritual
nationalism that required citizens to associate the democratic
universality of human rights with particular national
belonging... leading inevitably to systems of exclusion: the
divide between ...populations considered native and those
considered foreign, heterogeneous, who are racially or
culturally stigmatized (Balibar, 2004: 8).
described as [a] line indicating the last point in the relentless march of civilization.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
6
Borderlands K
Link: Citizenship
The borderlands and citizen are oppositions. The citizen needs negation in order to know
itself.
Dudziak & Volpp 5 (Mary L. Dudziak is the Judge Edward J. and Ruey L. Guirado Professor of
Law, History, and Political Science at the USC, and a visiting professor of law at Harvard Law
School. Leti Volpp professor of law -UC Berkeley) American Quarterly (57.3 593-610 ) ALM
Nayan Shah, in "Between 'Oriental Depravity' and 'Natural Degenerates': Spatial Borderlands and the Making of Ordinary Americans,"
focuses upon the lived experiences and regulation of the bodies of migrants once within the terrain of the United States. He newly
examines little-known sodomy, statutory rape, and vagrancy cases in California in the early twentieth century wherein Asian men,
perceived as the importers of unnatural sexual practices, were prosecuted for intergenerational, working class, and same-sex relations
with adolescent boys. While the "foreigner" and the "degenerate" were not doctrinal categories, they functioned discursively to
identify and explain moral peril. American identity consolidated around the normal masculine through the casting out of perverse
behavior, ascribed to Asian men. The cases show
the state
"needs its negation in order to know itself." As she documents, when Americans invented a political structure
in which to practice the fundamental rights of mankind, they were simultaneously devising structures that fundamentally deprived a
large segment of the population of their human rights. Thus, her essay troubles the assumption of "we the people": at its founding core,
some Americans could be considered stateless. Kerber also contradicts the
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
7
Borderlands K
Law's role in border regions makes apparent that the relationship between law and society is more dynamic. Mae Ngai demonstrates this
in her book Impossible Subjects, showing the ways law
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
8
Borderlands K
Law is limited in the sense that the American identity must interrogate laws limits; in a
case of declaring clemency to a person, the laws are unclear as to when to apply the rule of
law or not, when sovereignty does or doesnt apply. It is this legal borderland that law
constructs what is the American identity is.
Dudziak & Volpp 5 (Mary L. Dudziak is the Judge Edward J. and Ruey L. Guirado Professor of
Law, History, and Political Science at the USC, and a visiting professor of law at Harvard Law
School. Leti Volpp professor of law -UC Berkeley) American Quarterly, 57.3, p. 597-598 ALM)
An exploration of law and borders must begin with a discussion of the borders of law itself. Law
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
9
Borderlands K
"Coolies," Jung argues, were not "a people but a conglomeration of racial
imaginings" that emerged in the era of emancipation. Linked with slavery, the
banning of the importation of "coolies" allowed immigration restriction to proceed in
the name of freedom. The power of this association of immigration and freedom helps
explain the perennial contradiction of how U.S. immigration law is imagined to have
been historically unfettered, but with certain exceptions. Jung's focus on "coolies"
also provides an important piece of the story of American exceptionalism: the moral
imperative to prohibit slavery and coolieism around the world rationalized U.S. expansionism abroad, from China and Cuba in the 1850s
to the Philippines in the 1890s. Thus, as Jung asserts, the
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
10
Borderlands K
Legal borderlands are spaces of exception where the rule of law is often suspended or
revoked through dehumanization of those who do not receive rights or through the
obliteration from the imagination of those spaces. The narrative of American
exceptionalism has permitted the notion that the US is only limited to what happens within
its territorial limits, and thus what happens outside those limits does not guarantee
democracy and full rights for certain bodies.
Dudziak & Volpp 5 (Mary L. Dudziak is the Judge Edward J. and Ruey L. Guirado Professor of
Law, History, and Political Science at the USC, and a visiting professor of law at Harvard Law
School. Leti Volpp professor of law -UC Berkeley) American Quarterly (57.3 593-610 ) ALM
Legal borderlands can be understood as physical zones where, as Andrew Hebard writes, the "territorial
and legal limits of the United States are being negotiated." These physical zones can exist within the fifty states and
Washington, D.C.for example within the space of U.S. prisonsor outside, in the form of an
unincorporated territory such as the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. In either case they
inevitably implicate the relationship between American identity and democracy and
the rule of law. Because American identity and democracy are fused, sites where the
rule of law is suspended, revoked, or never implemented constitute what we could
consider spaces of exception. These spaces of exception, so long as they carry the
appellation "American," require some kind of legitimation for the suspension of
normal democratic processes, either through the dehumanization of those who do not
receive those rights or through the obliteration from the imagination of those spaces,
disappeared in a Bermuda Triangle of collective memory.
All three essays in this section raise the question of empire and challenge the idea of American exceptionalism, particularly the
presumption that America stands as an exception to the history of imperialism. The
idea of American
exceptionalism has permitted the notion that the United States is limited to the
territorial boundaries of the nation-state; what happens "outside" those boundaries
does not implicate the same level of concern for the rule of law, [End Page 602] democracy,
and full rights. Thus, if Guantnamo is a prison camp, or if the United States fails to guarantee equal
citizenship to residents of U.S. territories, the narrative of exceptionalism holds that
this does not implicate America itself and its commitment to the rule of law and
individual rights.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
11
Borderlands K
At the border to the US, border officers must take into account who, when, and on what
legal grounds to act and also when to not-act which risks unequal social sorting by the state
Heyman 9 (Josiah McC.- Canadian Journal of Law and Society - Volume 24, Number 3, 2009)
ALM
On what principles, and in what ways, does the United States sort out mobile
populations in its south-western border region? Analysing discretion on the part of frontline border officers is fundamental to exploring these questions. This discretion involves not only decisions
about when, on whom, and on what legal grounds to act but also decisions about
when and on whom not to act. Examination of non-actions completes the range of
information needed to delineate unequal social sorting by the state. Unequal sorting is specified
in the analysis of field materials through a novel prism, paying attention to why and how certain borderlanders are trusted in
enforcement settings while others are considered potential risks. The
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
12
Borderlands K
physical journeying through the southwestern United States, his own crip-queer-mestizo
consciousness, and his life in the borderlands. These borderlands are, as the section title announces,
literally "in the shadow of the American Dream," outside of a normative national
fantasy of community and identity.
Wojnarowicz echoes Anzaldua, who at the end of Borderlands/La Frontera exhorts a dominant
Anglo culture to "[a]dmit that Mexico is your double, that she exists in the shadow of
this country" (86). For both Anzalduia and Wojnarowicz, Mexico functions less as a physical entity and
more as an abstract principle of sexual, physical, and cultural otherness abjected
from a normate America. Once again, we can see the desire to keep these entities separate, to
maintain distinction and stave off contagion in the military fencing stretching across
the US-Mexico border today.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
13
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
14
Borderlands K
Temporary worker visa just do violence to the people on the borderlands and hurt their
identities
Camacho 08 Alicia Schmidt Camacho, Professor of American Studies at Yale, Migrant
Imaginaries: Latino Cultural Political in he US and Mexico Borderland 2008 pg 64
Galarza viewed braceros as a threat to the livelihood of U.S.-born farmworkers. Claims
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
15
Borderlands K
Today, more than ever before, few would conate gender and women in the same breath in the
way that sexuality was once a code word used for lesbian, gay, bisexual, or
transgendered. In fact, Chicana history argued strenuously in the work surveyed earlier in this essay that
collapsing categories was insufficient. Gender could thus only mean a plurality: male,
female, and many in between and beyond. Sex could mean heterosexual, bisexual,
gay/lesbian, and transgendered. Sexuality could mean feminine, masculine, twospirited, and many other expressions of being between and beyond. Just as social scientists amplied the concept of class to include
social location as well as caste and other categories, and just as race now includes color, ethnicity, and mixed-cultural ancestry, few of
the original, organizing concepts in Chicano/a studies have remained singular. Pluralism in interpretation reigns.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
16
Borderlands K
Genderitselfisaborderland;societyhaspolarizedgender,sexuality,sex,alongwith
forcinganindividualtogiveuponeidentitytoknowanotherwherepluralismshouldbe
preferred.
Gonzalez,3(DeenaJ.,GenderontheBorderlandsRetextualizingtheClassics,Frontiers:a
JournalofWomenStudies,Volume:24(2&3),p.25.DAP)
Chicana feminism dissuades one from capturing any feminism at all under the rubric
of Gender on the Borderlands, because gender can and does mean male as well as
female, men as well as women. The original proposal for the St. Marys University conference by the same title
contained as well an implicit understanding that one other purpose was at playin addition to
surveying Chicana history, art, literature, and culture, an opportunity existed to
present new directions in the eld. The notion that the entire concept of gender was a borderland itself
guided the conference planners and Antonia Castaeda, the conference organizer. The double-sided, three-fold conference announcement
depicts a butch womans back (Claudia Rodrguez, photo by Alma Lpez), which includes the cityscape of downtown Los Angeles and
is also reproduced on the cover of this special volume. A public demonstration of women marching with banners was embedded in the
art piece.
Today, more than ever before, few would conate gender and women in the same breath in the
way that sexuality was once a code word used for lesbian, gay, bisexual, or
transgendered. In fact, Chicana history argued strenuously in the work surveyed earlier in this essay that collapsing categories
was insufcient. Gender could thus only mean a plurality: male, female, and many in
between and beyond. Sex could mean heterosexual, bisexual, gay/lesbian, and
transgendered. Sexuality could mean feminine, masculine, two-spirited, and many
other expressions of being between and beyond. Just as social scientists amplied the
concept of class to include social location as well as caste and other categories, and
just as race now includes color, ethnicity, and mixed-cultural ancestry, few of the original,
organizing concepts in Chicano/a studies have remained singular. Pluralism in interpretation reigns.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
17
Borderlands K
the most pressing problem of the twenty-first century may be that racism,
homophobia, and sexism continue alongsideand are exacerbated bythe shrinking
sustainability of the natural environment. My examination of how Mexican Americans and the Rio Grande
Valley experienced racial oppression and exploitation following the US-Mexico War and into the twentieth century supports this claim.
While Anzaldas work comments on a more contemporary reading of these dynamics, South Texas writer Jovita Gonzlez offers
historical insight on current injustices and ecological imbalances along the border.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
18
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
19
Borderlands K
U.S. capitalist practices devalue the bodies in the Borderlands by making them
unintelligible and disposable and the white American the valuable profiteer.
Hames-Garcia, 00 (Michael, Department Head and Associate Professor of Ethnic Studies
Education, How to Tell a Mestizo from an Enchirito: Colonialism and National Culture in the
Borderlands, Diacritics, Volume: 30(4), p. 119. DAP)
In closing, I want to offer an answer to the question my title asks, How does one tell a mestizo from an Enchirito? My answer is
informed by the thinking of Anzalda, as well as Fanon and Cabral. One
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
20
Borderlands K
Tostabilizethenewglobalworldorderthroughglobalizationandcapitalismonlydefines
andredefinesculturalbordersandcolonizesthosewhoarestucktryingtofitwithinit.
Sandoval00(Chela,AssistantProfessorofCriticalandCulturalTheoryfortheDepartmentofChicanoStudies
atUniversityofCalifornia,SantaBarbara, ...p.18.DAP)
Other efforts have been made to define and name this new global world order. So-called
multinational late capitalism is identified and defined in works ranging from Daniel Bells The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism, to
Lyotards The Postmodern Condition.3But such works are flawed, their authors little more than apologists(71), Jameson asserts, for
what is a devastating and neocolonial global transformation. Rather
the perversity of
postmodern socio/political/economic culture must be courageously confronted and
opposed in all its neocolonial dimensions and originality.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
21
Borderlands K
eight dollars per person and the ability to read restricted the crossings. I would ask, How did the emergent and rigid policing of the
border between the United States and Mexico in the early twentieth century reinforce a white colonial heteronormative way of seeing
and knowing that fused race with sex? Further investigation will illustrate that
14
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
22
Borderlands K
The idea of a rule of law, the idea that law can contain power, has perhaps been most
threatened within the walls of Abu Ghraib. Here, the power of one nation is exercised
in another through the control of prisoners by their captors. The story that emerges from Abu Ghraib
would seem the opposite of the story of liberation Yoneyama finds in constructions of postwar Japan, as the prison is exposed as a site of
torture. Yet in "'Setting the Conditions' for Abu Ghraib: The Prison Nation Abroad," Brown
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
23
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
24
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
25
Borderlands K
The presence of multilingualism opens up the question of the ethics and politics of
translation, which scholars such as Gayatri Spivak (1993), Emily Apter (2001), and E. Anthony Hurley (2005) have
developed at length. Spivak argues that postcolonial studies is more accurately positioned in an interdisciplinary and/or crossdisciplinary framework rather than solely in English, and that the
graduate curriculum should include the indepth study of at least one language indigenous to the postcolonial world in order to
contravene the very imperium of English (1993, 277). This is equally true of the status
of French for francophone studies. In this context, it is important for scholars versed in
indigenous languages to publish studies of literature written in these non-dominant
languages, as well as studies analyzing the use of indigenous languages within works
written in English, Spanish, or French. While some writers present texts whose linguistic otherness is sutured
over through the use of translation of words and the presence of glossaries, others use multilingualism in order to destabilize the
dominant linguistic power position. Interesting comparisons can be drawn between writers making use of multilingualism in different
languages, such as the Berber and Arabic- inflected French of Algerian writer Assia Djebar, the Shona-inflected English of Zimbabwean
Tsitsi Dangarembga, and the Spanish and Nahuatl-inflected English of Chicana thinker Anzalda. The
presence of
indigenous, national, or ethnic languages defamiliarizes dominant languages for a
native reader of English or French and makes those languages more hospitable to
native speakers
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
26
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
27
Borderlands K
The women of the borderlands are in constant danger caught in a double-bind of violence
and patriarchal protection
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL
The world is not a safe place to live in. We shiver in separate cells in enclosed cities, shoulders hunched, barely keeping the
panic below the surface of the skin, daily drinking shock along with our morning coffee, fearing the torches being set to our buildings, the attacks
in the streets. Shutting down. Woman
does not feel safe when her own culture, and white culture, are
critical of her; when the males of all races hunt her as prey. Alienated from her mother culture, alien in the
dominant culture, the woman of color does not feel safe within the inner life of her Self.
Petrified, she cant respond, her face caught between los in tersticios, the spaces between the different
worlds she inhabits. The ability to respond is what is meant by responsibility, yet our cultures
take away our ability to act-shackle us in the name of protection. Blocked, immobilized, we cant
move forward, cant move backwards. That writhing serpent movement, the very movement of life, swifter than lightning,
frozen.
Not me sold out my people but they me. So yes, though home permeates every sinew and cartilage in my body, I too am afraid of going home.
Though Ill defend my race and culture when they are attacked by non-mexicanos, conozco el malestarples its women, como burras, our strengths
used against us, lowly burras bearing humility with dignity The ability to serve, claim the males, is our highest virtue. I wonder how my culture
makes macho caricatures of its men.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
28
Borderlands K
Impacts: Imperialism
US imperialism enacts violence necessary to maintaining colonial rule shrouded within a
romantic narrative of progress.
Dudziak & Volpp 5 (Mary L. Dudziak is the Judge Edward J. and Ruey L. Guirado Professor of
Law, History, and Political Science at the USC, and a visiting professor of law at Harvard Law
School. Leti Volpp professor of law -UC Berkeley) American Quarterly (57.3 593-610 ) ALM
The belief in American exceptionalism has been fueled by the failure of the United States
to claim sovereignty over other nations to the extent that Western European powers did.
But imperial powers have also disclaimed sovereignty in the service of imperialism, as
contradictory as this might seem. Christina Duffy Burnett, in her essay "The Edges of Empire and the Limits of
Sovereignty: American Guano Islands," persuasively shows how American imperialism has, in part, consisted of
efforts to impose limits upon expansion. While, as she writes, we tend to associate
imperialism with "the expansion of territory, the projection of power, and the
imposition of sovereignty," American imperialism has also involved the
circumscribing of power to reduce the responsibilities that come with sovereignty .
Burnett mines the history of the American Guano Islands, as "seemingly insignificant" places in the history of American expansion, to
show the wide range of formal, legal practices of boundary management that attended territorial expansion. The Guano Islands
uninhabited but rich with fertilizer that led to a nineteenth-century craze for guanowere legally categorized as appertaining to the
United States, belonging to yet not a part of the United States. The uncertainty of the status of appurtenance created a flexibility to
implement control without responsibility. As with Guantnamo, the limiting of federal power, by reducing the responsibility of the
federal government to protect those on annexed territory, is no less an imperialist move than the extension of sovereignty to that territory.
If Burnett shows us that imperialism can be not just about expansion but about limits , Andrew
Hebard, in his essay "Romantic Sovereignty: Popular Romances and the American Imperial State in the Philippines," reminds us that
imperialism was also about mundane legal and bureaucratic work. As he notes, other scholars have
linked imperialism to the literary aesthetic of the romance, aligning the imaginary of an imperial nation to the imaginary of the romance.
But Hebard argues that conventions
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
29
Borderlands K
The use of informal imperialism allows concealment of true motives, fueling dozens of
regional conflicts around the world which can grow into major world wars
Mooers 6, (Collin, THE NEW IMPERIALISTS: IDEOLOGIES OF EMPIRE, Chapter 6, Chair of the Department
of Politics and School of Public Adminstration at Ryerson University, Toronto)
The demise of the formal territorial empires in the second half of the twentieth century and the consequent decoupling of political power
from the extensive reach of capital accumulation has posed special advantages and problems of its own. For the American empire, from
The
lack of a formal empire has allowed the American state to present itself to the world
as a non- or even anti-imperialist power. It has been able to conceal its imperial
ambition in an abstract universalism . . . to deny the significance of territory and
geography altogether in the articulation of imperial power.6 But policing U.S. interests has had its
own costs and perils. The dogma of economic openness7 was dependent on either the
cooperation of compliant local regimes or, failing that, an increasing number of
small wars which, as one recent champion of such conflicts admits, might as well
be called imperial wars.8 In the twentieth century alone, it is estimated that the
United States sent troops or sponsored local forces to fight in sixty such small wars.
The hazard of small wars of empire is that they can turn into major ones, resulting
in the perennial danger of imperial overreach as happened most spectacularly for
the U.S. in Vietnam. American defeat at the hands of the Vietnamese famously established the conditions for the Vietnam
syndrome the belief that the U.S.A. could not and should not fight wars it could not
guarantee it would win. And winning in military terms meant the deployment of
overwhelming force, preferably against much weaker enemies as in the Grenada or
Panama invasions. The same guiding principle was in force in the 1991 Gulf War. It may have been premature for George
Woodrow Wilson onward, it was taken for granted that economic prosperity could be secured without territorial aggrandizement.5
Bush Sr. to declare an end to the Vietnam syndrome after that conflict since the very small number of allied deaths had not yet
sufficiently tested the American publics willingness to accept a larger number of casualties. The Vietnam syndrome proved alive and
well in the aftermath of the Somalian debacle of 1993 where 1,200 U.S. troops were routed by local warlords and forced to withdraw.
The Clinton Doctrine, which dominated military policy for the rest of the 1990s, sought to avoid U.S. casualties at all costs. Economic
openness, now enshrined under the equally euphemistic ideology of globalization, would be secured by means of a modern
equivalent of old-fashioned gunboats in cruise missiles and aircraft armed with precision-guided munitions.9
The Aff Policies are rooted in Anglo terrorism this creates conflict, war and death.
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL
The Gringo, locked into the fiction of white superiority seized complete political power,
stripping Indians and Mexicans of their land while their feet were still rooted in it. Con el destierro y el
exillo fuimos desuiiados, destmncados, destripados-we were jerked out by the roots, truncated, disemboweled,
dispossessed, and separated from our identity and our history. Many, under the threat of Anglo
terrorism, abandoned homes and ranches and went to Mexico. Some stayed and protested. But as the courts, law
enforcement officials, and government officials not only ignored their pleas but penalized them for their efforts, tejanos had no other recourse but
armed retaliation. After Mexican-American resisters robbed a train in Brownsville, Texas on October 18, 1915, Anglo vigilante groups began
lynching Chicanos. Texas Rangers would take them into the brush and shoot them. One hundred Chicanos were killed in a matter of months,
whole families lynched. Seven thousand fled to Mexico, leaving their small ranches and farms. The Anglos, afraid that the maclcanosw would
seek independence from the U.S., brought in 20,000 army troops to put ( an end to the social protest movement in South Texas.
Race hatred
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
30
Borderlands K
The boarder creates a third country, filled with ten million human lives that are faceless,
nameless, invisible, and taunted, this is the borderland, were its thought of nothing more
than a war zone.
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL
We have a tradition of migration, a tradition of long walks. Today we are witnessing la migration de los pueblos mexicanos, the return odyssey to
the historical/mythological Aztln. This time, the traffic is from south to north.El retomo to the promised land first began with the Indians from
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
31
Borderlands K
State power proceeds from but is not limited by the geographic space mapped as
America wherein law does not provide a boundary around the powers of sovereignty, but
instead provides a language through which state power is invoked. The way American law
is imagined and understood outside of its borders allows western colonialism to a
borderless imperialism.
Dudziak & Volpp 5 (Mary L. Dudziak is the Judge Edward J. and Ruey L. Guirado Professor of
Law, History, and Political Science at the USC, and a visiting professor of law at Harvard Law
School. Leti Volpp professor of law -UC Berkeley) American Quarterly (57.3 593-610 ) ALM
If state power proceeds from, but is not limited by, the geographic space mapped as
"America," how are boundaries of American power drawn? Are there boundaries, or has
the globe itself become an American space? Does law play a role in negotiating the terms
of American power in the world? Long before the idea of "preemptive war" entered American political discourse and
before the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq came to define a new level of depravity in global perceptions [End Page 604] of Americans, there
Law does
not provide a boundary around the powers of sovereignty, but instead provides a
language within which state power is invoked. The essays in this section engage the question of where in the
was little faith in the idea that law and legal institutions served as an enforceable brake in the arena of global politics.
world American legal ideas and institutions operate, and examine how legal categories play a role in constructing an American sphere in
the world and in defining the terms of entry to that sphere.
Empire is usually thought of as the ultimate expression of a nation's power in other regions of the world. The essence of empire is the
conquest of foreign territory, and imperial power is exercised through control of that territory. The essays on borders of territory show
that American exercise of imperial power has also involved a disclaiming of sovereign power over territory that it in fact controls. In this
section, Teemu Ruskola, in "Canton Is Not Boston: The Invention of American Imperial Sovereignty," introduces a third way of
conceptualizing empire, and along the way reframes the way we might think of nations themselves.
The role of American law outside of U.S. territory depends on how other regions of
the world are imagined and understood. In the nineteenth century, suggests Ruskola, the world was not divided
only into the categories of sovereign and "savage." Although this binary categorization constituted the
primary justification for Western colonialismthe physical occupation and control of
"savage" territoriesthere was a third category of "semicivilized" peoples. Such
peoples might possess a degree of sovereignty, yet they could not impose their laws on
the "civilized," even when the "civilized" came within the borders of their territory.
This practice of Western extraterritorial jurisdiction constituted a form of borderless,
nonterritorial imperialism.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
32
Borderlands K
Impacts: Biopower
We need to decolonize all relations of power that are constructed by a white colonial
heteronormative gaze that biopolitically controls and regulates populations.
Prez 3 (Emma, Assoc. Prof. of history at the University of Texas, El Paso, Frontiers: A Journal
of Women Studies 24.2&3 - 122-131) ALM
The
borderlands have been [End Page 122] imprinted by bodies that traverse the region, just as
bodies have been transformed by the laws and customs in the regions we call
borderlands. In the History of Sexuality, Michel Foucault challenges us to look closely at bodies
and how they are engraved and transformed through laws, customs, and moralities
imposed upon them through centuries. 2 He is not as direct about coloniality, but we can still borrow from a
I began with this passage in order to inscribe a gaze on the borderlands that is geographic and spatial, mobile and impermanent.
critique that exemplifies how land is imprinted and policed by those traversing and claiming it as they would claim a bodyboth
becoming property for the colonizers. Native Americans became as much the property of the Spanish as did the land that came to be
known as the Spanish borderlands.
must
move into the decolonial imaginary to decolonize [End Page 123] all relations of power,
whether gendered or sexual or racial or classed.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
33
Borderlands K
Impacts: Dehumanization
The acts of policing borders structures a border binary that stabilizes parochialism,
patriarchy, and patriotism which dehumanizes each mestiza.
Ramlow 6 ((Todd R., Bodies in the Borderlands: Gloria Anzaluda's and
David Wojnarowicz's Mobility Machines, MELUS, Volume: 31(3), Fall, p. 175176. DAP)
the mestiza consciousness is born out of exclusion, out of the inaccessibility of both
sides of the border to queers of all sorts. "We are a synergy of two cultures with various degrees of Mexicanness or
Angloness. I have so internalized the borderland conflict that sometimes I feel like one
cancels out the other and we are zero, nothing, no one" (Borderlands 63). The borderlands
are, of course, policed on "this side" by la migra, the INS, and an ever increasing
deployment of military resources and surveillance. Del otro lado is policed by a dominant
cultural logic intolerant of physical and sexual differences. As Anzaldua asserts: "I abhor my
culture's ways, how it cripples its women, como burras, our strengths used against us, lowly
burras bearing humility with dignity. ... I abhor how my culture makes macho caricatures of its men"
(Borderlands 21-22). These normalizing discourses are not, of course, unique to either side of this binary; they are
ordering principles that structure both. Parochialism, patriotism, and patriarchy
make up a trinity of exclusion and exploitation . In between these exclusions are the
borderlands, a physical and abstract space conditioned by the policing of bodily and
sexual difference.
In the borderlands
The Aff has condemned women and homosexuals to order, anything outside of the norm
leads to a lesser, non-human life, or death.
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL pg 40
My culture, selfishness is condemned, especially in women; humility and selflessness, the
absence of selfishness, is considered a virtue. In the past, acting humble with members outside the family ensured that you
would make no one envidioso (envious); therefore he or she would not use witch- craft against you. If you get above yourself, youre an
envidiosa. If
you dont behave like everyone else, la gente will say that you think youre better than
others, que te owes grande. With ambition (condemned in the Mexican culture and valued in the Anglo) comes envy nesprro carries
with it a set of rules so that social categories and hierarchies will be kept in order: respect is
reserved for la abuelq papd, elpatrn, those with power in the community. Women are at the bottom of the ladder one
rung above the deviants. The Chicano, mextcano, and some Indian cultures have no tolerance for deviance. Deviance is
whatever is condemned by the community. Most societies try to get rid of their deviants. Most
cultures have burned and beaten their homosexuals and others who deviate from the sexual
common. The queer are the mirror reflecting the heterosexual tribes fear: being different, being
other and therefore lesser, therefore sub-human, in-human, non-human.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
34
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
35
Borderlands K
Impacts: Poverty
The otherness created by the physical separation of the borders causes poverty and
institutionalized violence
Ramlow 6 ((Todd R., Bodies in the Borderlands: Gloria Anzaluda's and
David Wojnarowicz's Mobility Machines, MELUS, Volume: 31(3), Fall, p. 178.
DAP)
Throughout Wojnarowicz's travels, the same outcasts and queers who occupy Anzaldfia's la frontera populate his shadowy borderlands.
Driving through the American southwest, Wojnarowicz draws our attention to the many Navajo
men, Native American families, and Chicano teenagers who live in these borderlands,
and whose lives are seemingly invisible to the normate culture that surrounds them . For these
mestizaje, poverty and human misery are the spoils of their Otherness, and they are as
close to and far from the normate as the "real world" is from the inside of one's car. Imagining the normate
subject's response to scenes of abjection, Wojnarowicz asserts the norm's refusal to see the
misery it causes, or to recognize its own role in that abjection.
Owning a vehicle, you could drive by and with the pressure of your foot on the accelerator and with your eyes on the road you could
pass it quickly .... The
images of poverty would lift and float and recede quickly like the gray
shades of memory so that these images were in the past before you came upon them .
(Close 31) Wojnarowicz, of course, cannot make such a refusal, because he has himself experienced the violence and scorn of the
normate. Elsewhere Wojnarowicz identifies with a Native Americanteenager who had disrupted the morning rush hour in an unnamed
southwest city by turning into oncoming traffic and running down a white college student. While he doesn't necessarily condone such
institutionally validated
murderous violence routinely perpetrated against cripples, queers, and mestiza/os : "I
murderous violence, Wojnarowicz empathizes with the Native American boy's reaction to the
wondered why any of these things, like the kid in his camaro, are
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
36
Borderlands K
Impacts: Colonization
Granting citizenship today still practices colonial mindsets where
immigrants, whether colonized or entering a border, give up their
political autonomy, which ultimately justifies oppression and
disposable labor.
Orozco-Mendoza 8 (Elva Fabiola, thesis: Borderlands Theory: Producing
Border Epistomologies with Gloria Anzaldua, Virgina Polytechnic Institute
and State University, April 24, p. 8-9. DAP)
This mechanism was crucial to sustain colonization since colonized
Citizenship was not only restricted to men who were married, literate, heterosexual,
and proprietors, but also, and especially, to men who were white. In turn, the individuals that
fell outside the space of citizenship were not only the homosexuals, prisoners, mental
patients and political dissidents Foucault had in mind, but also blacks Indians, mestizos,
gypsies, Jews, and now, in terms of globalization, ethnic minorities, immigrants, and Auslandern
(foreigners) (Castro-Gomez and Johnson, 2000: 513).
To be sure, Europeans not only denied colonized people a citizen status but they also
classified native people as inhuman, devilish, or even animals, as inscribed in the philosophies
predicated by Kant (1764), Hegel (1822), and others who considered that underdevelopment was a characteristic proper of nonEuropeans (Natter, 2008). Thus, since
epistemologies of the colonized were erased from world history, since they held no
value in the eyes of Europeans. Thus, the following step in colonization consisted of imposing
assimilation into European settler cultures; that is how the Nahuatl and Maya
languages were changed into Spanish, the Congolese, Kituba, or Lingala into French,
or the Dahomeyan into English. This was also the reason why millions of people were forced to
abandon their religion in order to be converted into Christianity. In sum, the culture,
traditions, and religion of colonized people were used against them to justify
oppression. For instance, the art and writing of the Maya civilization was destroyed under
the justification that Maya texts were considered pagan. Similarly, the religious rites and
human sacrifices of the Aztec culture were used as a justification for the destruction
and subjugation of the Aztec people.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
37
Borderlands K
the collapse of the U.S.S.R., the surviving hegemon, the United States, no
longer had the patience to use the United Nations to put forward its own values, but
rather pursued what might be referred to as peace under imperial domination (diguo
tongzhi xia de heping). America's invasion of Iraq has damaged the authority of the United
Nations and the principle of the inviolability of national sovereignty. Before the war broke out, Bush repeatedly sent out warnings in
which he stated that if the Security Council refused to pass a resolution authorizing the use of force, the United Nations would become
irrelevant. Some hawks in the administration and conservative newspapers even threatened that the United States could withdraw from
affairs, Dominique de Villepin, Nelson Mandela commented on this shift: "Since the establishment of the U.N., there have been no world
wars; therefore, anybody, and particularly the leaders of the superpowers, who takes unilateral action outside the frame of the U.N. must
receive the condemnation of all who love peace." On a visit to Ireland on June 20, 2003, he went on to say, "Any organization, any
country, any movement that now decides to sideline the United Nations, that country and its leader are a danger to the world. We cannot
allow the world to again degenerate into a place where the will of the powerful dominates over all other considerations ."4 [End Page
The strategy of preemption is not simply a military strategy, but is, in fact, a kind
of barbaric politics, a serious attack against civilized humanity. It is ultimately tied to the question
160]
of whether the world is seeking civilization and order, or whether it is entering into a period of violence and chaos. The United States'
adoption of this strategy provoked the intense opposition of Europe and, indeed, the entire world because many believe that a strategy of
preemption would take the world in the latter direction. As a result of the Iraq War, a deep rift was opened up between America and its
force for rationality and civilization. The dispute that arose between Europe and America during the Iraq War was both a conflict of
potential profit and a sign of civilizational disparity.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
38
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
39
Borderlands K
struggles. A century ago, the period [End Page 102] of nation-state consolidation in Europe seemed to come to an end with the
unification of Germany and Italy. European leftists of the era tended to address "the national question" primarily with regard to those
European nations that were shut out or suppressed by nation-state formation. Debates about national culture resurfaced in a
revolutionary context when independence movements swept Africa and Asia during and after World War II, and a substantial body of
literature attempting to integrate anticolonial struggle, national liberation, and socialism arose from the capitalist "periphery." Much of
this literature, and the wars for independence out of which it grew, adapted the language of nationalism to its own purposes. These
movements gave new hope that national liberation struggles would prove compatible with greater human freedom and equality. Despite
that hope, the destructive effects of nationalism are today visible everywhere: for example, the
devastating wars in the Balkans, the repression of indigenous peoples by national bourgeoisie throughout the Americas, religiousnational strife between Sinhalese and Tamils in Sri Lanka, the vertiginous intensification of national chauvinism in the United States,
Western Europe, and Australia. Simultaneously,
capitalism, colonialism, and national culture. Instead, her major work, Borderlands/La Frontera, is usually discussed (or, more often
than not, simply cited) as a contribution to feminist and antiracist discussions about the construction of the self within multiple contexts
3
of domination and about that self's resistance to oppression and struggle for recognition. While acknowledging the importance of
Anzalda's contributions to these discussions, this essay examines Borderlands as offering a forward-looking alternative to nationalism,
4
specifically, to Chicano cultural nationalist positions articulated during the 1960s and 1970s, at the height of the Chicano Movement. I
argue that central
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
40
Borderlands K
We need to examine this apartheid in more detail before we investigate its remedy, la
conciencia de la mestiza is the first commitment to solvency.
Sandoval 00 (Chela, Assistant Professor of Critical and Cultural Theory for the
Department of Chicano Studies at University of California, Santa Barbara, ... p. 18. DL
More obvious for contemporary cultural theorists in the human and social sciences, though, is
the commitment to this mode of differential and op- positional consciousness that has emerged in the writings of a diverse array of
schol- ars, including Stuart Hall, Audre Lorde, Donna Haraway, Cornel West, Judith Butler, Homi Bhabha, Jacques Derrida, Michel
Foucault, Gloria Anzalda, Gayatri Spivak, Ernesto Laclau, Chantal Mouffe, Hayden White, Patricia Hill Collins, Jos Este- ban Muoz,
Emma Prez, and Trinh T. Minh-ha. They
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
41
Borderlands K
Alternative Solvency
Binary struggles cause struggles in the consciousness. Each act from each witness compiles
a stronger resistance to the binary illusion which is key to dismantling institutional
oppressions.
Ramlow 6 ((Todd R., Bodies in the Borderlands: Gloria Anzaluda's and
David Wojnarowicz's Mobility Machines, MELUS, Volume: 31(3), Fall, p. 172173. DAP)
Both Anzaldua and Wojnarowicz see observation
public disclosure of
a private reality becomes something of a magnet that can attract others with a similar
frame of reference; thus each public disclosure of a fragment of private reality serves
as a dismantling tool against the illusion of ONE-TRIBE NATION; it lifts the curtains
for a brief peek and reveals the probable existence of literally millions of tribes" (Close
121). Wojnarowicz's eye/I witnessing describes the limits and violence of binarism, the structure upon which the
authority and consciousness of the dominant is imagined and maintained. What he
uncovers is multiplicity, both individual and collective, and the possibility of
connection and alliance.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
42
Borderlands K
We must confront white heteronormative ways of seeing and knowing through a strategy of
disidentification and reinterpret them with a decolonial queer gaze
Prez 3 (Emma, Assoc. Prof. of history at the University of Texas, El Paso, Frontiers: A Journal
of Women Studies 24.2&3 - 122-131) ALM
In my study of Chicanas, I've put forth the notion of the decolonial imaginary as a means not only of finding women who have been so
hidden from history, but also as a way of honoring their agency, which is often lost. The premise that Mexican women are passive wives
who follow their men had to be contested. Now, I'm asking, how is the decolonial imaginary useful for lesbian history and queer
studies?
and literary texts, newspapers, police records, widows' wills, court dockets, medical
of these and more must be reinterpreted
with a decolonial queer gaze so we may interrogate representations of sexual deviants
and track ideologies about sex and sexuality.
records, texts by sexologists, religious tracts, as well as corridos all
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
43
Borderlands K
Seeing through a decolonial queer gaze allows for different interpretations of what is
beyond a heteronormative imaginary that doesnt dismiss what is unfamiliar but instead
honors the differences between and among us.
Prez 3 (Emma, Assoc. Prof. of history at the University of Texas, El Paso, Frontiers: A Journal
of Women Studies 24.2&3 - 122-131) ALM
Historical research on and of borderland queers is not as abundant. Part of the problem is that the queer gaze has only recently become
sanctioned. Queer history, after all, is a new, growing field. Despite
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
44
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
45
Borderlands K
coatlicue
state is the alternate consciousness that we delve into, feeling sorry for ourselves until
coatlicue kicks our butt and says, "Ya. Parale." Time to move on, to get through this,
to learn from all you have experienced in your material and psychic worlds. It's that
crucial time when we're haunted by the shadow beast, our inner selves, that part that won't let us rest,
that part that says, you're never going to meet the ideal expected of you. I call my own
shadow beast that ego-driven, maniacal, Eurocentric-minded part of me immersed in
inner battle. When I'm so exhausted by my own inner demons, I call upon la facultad to
assist me so that I may delve into the coatlicue state to recover a sense of humility, to
recover a sense of cultural, psychic identity. There is a kind of self-therapy that is so much
a part of Gloria's concepts, but her theories are more than self-therapy. Gloria's theories,
when applied, call upon us to transform not only ourselves but also our many
communities.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
46
Borderlands K
Past philosophers prove that the idea of the mestiza consciousness is the only way to solve
the inner struggle while addressing the communal struggle simultaneously.
Tamdgidi 8 (Mohammad, Assistant Professor Department of Sociology at University of
Massachusetts Boston, I Change Myself, I Changethe World: Anzalduas Sociological
Imagination in Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza, Paper presented at the annual
meeting of the American Annual Meeting, Sheraton Boston, July 31, p. 15-16. DAP)
Anzalduas notion of simultaneity of self and global transformation also has close affinities with the ideas of the Caucasian
philosopher, George Ivanovitch Gurdjieff (1872?1949). A man of GreekArmenain ancestry born in Kars
(at the borders of Tsarist Russia and Ottoman Turkey) and raised in the borderlands
of diverse ethnic, cultural and religious traditions, Gurdjieff expressed quite similar
considerations for bridging diverse modes of knowing and being in the world. Although
he was raised in patriarchal culture that to a considerable conceptual influenced
spiritual worldview and practice, his teaching nevertheless provides useful conceptual
insights that can further enrich Anzalduas liberatory strategy of global transformation
via selfknowledge and change. Reminiscing about his life as a boy living in Gurdjieffs Institute for Harmonious
Deelopment of Man in Priere, France, a young Fritz Peters notes (as quoted above) how central to Gurdjieff was the conviction that the
only for humanity as a whole lies in the distinct and unique (self)development of each individual. Gurdjieffs thought found reception
among a generation of contemporary artists, including those gathered in he The Rope, a group of Lesbian artists who drew inspiration
from his teaching (Patterson 1998).
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
47
Borderlands K
The oppressed develop a sixth sense, its a survival tactic, its in all of us, it is needed to be
able to break away from dualities of the borderland.
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL pg 60-61
La facultad is the capacity to see in surface phenomena the meaning of deeper realities, to see the
deep structure below the surface. It is an instant sensing, a quick perception arrived at without
conscious reasoning. It is an acute awareness mediated by the part of the psyche that does not
speak, that communicates in images and symbols which are the faces of feelings, that is, behind
which feelings reside/hide. The one possessing this sensitivity is excruciatingly alive to the
world. Those who are pushed out of the tribe for being different are likely to become more
sensitized (when not brutalized into insensitivity). those who do not feel psychologically or physically safe in
the world are more apt to develop this sense. Those who are pounced on the most have it the
strongest-the females me homosexuals of all races the dark skinned, the outcast the persecuted,
the marginalized, the foreign. When were up against the wall, when we have all sorts of
oppressions coming at us, we are forced to develop this faculty so that well know when the next person is going
to slap us or lock us away. Well sense the rapist when hes five blocks down the street. Pain makes us acutely anxious to avoid more of it, so we
have that radar.
Its a kind of survival tactic that people, caught between the worlds, unknowingly
cultivate. It is latent in all of us
La facultad, allows us to break away from an everyday mode of consciousness and that
thrusts us into a less literal and more psychic sense of reality increases awareness
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL
I walk into a house and I know whether it is empty or occupied. I feel the lingering charge in the air of a recent fight or love-making or
depression. I sense the emotions someone near is emitting-whether friendly or threatening. Hate and fear-the more intense the emotion, the
greater my reception of it. I feel a tingling on my skin when someone is staring at me or thinking about me. I can tell how others feel by the way
they smell, where others are by the air pressure on my skin. I can spot the love or greed or generosity lodged in the tissues of another. Often I
sense the direction of and my distance from people or objects-in the dark, or with my eyes closed, without looking. It must be a vestige of a
proximity sense, a sixth sense thats lain dormant from long ago times.
Fear develops the proximity sense aspect of la facultad. But there is a deeper sensing that is
another aspect of this faculty. It is anything that breaks into ones everyday mode of perception,
that causes a break in ones defenses and resistance, anything that takes one from ones habitual
grounding, causes the depths to open up, causes a shift in perception. This shift in perception
deepens the way we see concrete objects and people; the senses become so acute and piercing
that we can see through things, view events in depth, a piercing that reaches the underworld (the realm of
the soul). As we plunge vertically, the break, with its accompanying new seeing, makes us pay
attention to the soul, we are thus into awareness-an experiencing of soul self.
We lose something in this mode of initiation, something is taken from us: our innocence, our unknowing ways, our safe and easy ignorance.
There is a prejudice and a fear of the dark, chthonic (underworld), material such as depression, illness, death and the violations that can bring on
this break. Confronting
anything that tears the fabric of our everyday mode of consciousness and
that thrusts us into a less literal and more psychic sense of reality increases awareness and la
facultad.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
48
Borderlands K
We solve for duality, that is the rooted in white rationality, this is the cause of all violence.
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL Pg 58
Four years ago a red snake crossed my path as I walked through the woods. The direction of its
movement, its pace, its colors, the mood of the trees and the wind and the snake--they all spoke to me, told me things. I look for omens
everywhere, everywhere catch glimpses of the patterns and cycles of my life. Stones speak to Luisah Teish, a Santera; trees whisper their
secrets to Chrystos, a Native American. I remember listening to the voices of the wind as a child and understanding its messages, Los espiritus
that ride the back of the south wind. I remember their exhalation blowing in through the slits in the door during those hot Texas afternoons. A gust
of wind raising the linoleum under my feet, buffeting the house. Everything trembling. Were not supposed to remember such otherworldly
events. were supposed to ignore, forget, kill those fleeting images of the souls presence and of the spirits presence. weve been taught then that
the spirit is outside our bodies or above our heads somewhere up in the sky with god. We're supposed to forget every cell in our bodies, every
bone and bird and worm has spirit in it.
Like many Indians and Mexicans, I did not deem my psychic experiences real. I denied their occurrences and let my inner senses atrophy. I
White rationality to tell me that the existence of the other world was mere pagan
superstition I accepted their reality, the official" reality of the rational, reasoning mode which is
connected with external reality the upper World, and is considered the most developed
consciousness-the consciousness of duality.
The other mode of consciousness facilitates images from the soul and the unconscious through
dreams and the imagination. Its work is labeled fiction, make-believe, wish-fulfillment. White
anthropologists claim that Indians have primitive and therefore deficient minds that we cannot
think in the higher mode of consciousness-rationality. They are fascinated by what they call the magical mind, the
allowed
savage mind, the participation mystique of the mind that says the World of the imagination-the world of the soul-and of the spirit is just as real
as physical reality.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
49
Borderlands K
The alt is the only way to step out of the constricting boundaries of society.
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL
Why does she have to go and try to make 'sense' or it all? Every time she makes sense of
something, she has to cross over, kicking a hole out of the old boundaries of the self and slipping under or over, dragging the old skin along, stumbling over lt. it hampers her movement in
the new territory, dragging the ghost of the past with her. It is a dry birth, a breech birth, a
screaming birth, one that Fights her every inch of the way. It is only when she is on the other side
and the shell Cracks Open and the lid from her eyes lifts that she sees things in a different
perspective. It is only then that she makes the connections, formulates the insights. it is only then
that her consciousness expands at tiny notch, another rattle appears on the rattlesnake tail and the
added growth slightly alters the sounds she makes. Suddenly the repressed energy rises, makes
decisions, connects with conscious energy and a new life begins. it is her chance to crossover, to
make a hole in the fence and walk across, to cross the river, to take that flying leap into the dark,
that drives her to escape, that forces her into the fecuna cave of her imagination when she is
cradled in the arms of Coatlicue who will never let her go. If she doesnt change her ways, she
will remain a stone forever.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
50
Borderlands K
The Alt creates a fifth race, this racial, ideological, cultural and biological crosspolinization, an alien consciousness is presently in the making-a new Mestiza
consciousness
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL
Jos Vasconcelos, Mexican philosopher, envisaged una raza mestlza, una mezcla de razas afines,
una raza de color-la primera mza sfntesis del globo. He called it a cosmic race, la raza csmica, a
fifth race embracing the four major races of the World? Opposite to the theory of the pure
Aryan, and to the policy of racial purity that white America practices, his theory is one of
inclusivity At the confluence of two or more genetic streams, with chromosomes constantly
crossing over, this mixture of races, rather than resulting in an inferior being, provides hybrid
progeny a mutable, more malleable species with a rich gene pool. From this racial, ideological,
cultural and biological cross- pollinization, an alien consciousness is presently in the making-a
new Mestiza consciousness, una conctencia de mujer: It is a consciousness of the Borderlands.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
51
Borderlands K
we perceive the version of reality that our culture communicates, Subconsciously we see an
attack on ourselves and our behalfs as a threat and we attempt to block with a counter
stance, we need a mestiza of consciousness to get out of this cycle.
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL
The ambivalence from the clash of voices results in mental and emotional states of perplexity.
Internal strife results in insecurity and indecisiveness. The mestizas dual or multiple personality
is plagued by psychic restlessness. In a constant state of mental neantilism, an Aztec World
meaning torn between ways, la mestiza is a product of the transfer of the cultural and
spiritual values of one group to another Being tricultural, monolingual, bilingual, or
multilingual, speaking a patois, and in a state of perpetual transition, the mestiza faces the
dilemma of the mixed breed: which collectivity does the daughter of a dark skinned mother
listen to? El cboque de un alma atrapado entre el mundo del, espiritu y el mundo de la tcnica a
veces la deja entullada Cradled in one culture, sandwiched between two cultures, stradling all
three cultures and their value systems la mestiza undergoes a struggle of flesh, a struggle of
borders, an inner war. Like all people we perceive the version of reality that our culture
communicates Like others having or living in more than one culture we get multiple often
opposing messages The coming together of two self consistent but habitually incompatible
frames of reference causes un choque a cultural collision Within us and within la Cultura
chicana commonly held Mexican culture and both attack commonly held beliefs of the
indigenous culture Subconsciously we see an attack on ourselves and our behalves as a threat
and we attempt to block with a counter stance
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
52
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
53
Borderlands K
of consciousness and
knowing is then also a process of individual and collective becoming, and through Anzaldua,
Wojnarowicz, Deleuze and Guattari, and the critical lens of disability studies, we can understand how subjectivity
becomes multiple.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
54
Borderlands K
we need to be
arrested. Some past experience or condition has created this need. This stopping is a survival mechanism, but one
which must vanish when its no longer needed if growth is to occur. We need Coatlicue to slow
us up so that the psyche can assimilate previous experiences and process the changes. If we
dont take the time, shell lay us low with an illness, forcing us to rest. Come, little green snake. Let the
wound caused by the serpent be cured by the serpent. The soul uses everything" to further its own making. Those activities or
Coatlicue state which disrupt the smooth flow (complacency) of life are exactly what propel the
soul to do its work: make soul, increase consciousness of itself. Our greatest disappointments and
painful experiences--if we can make meaning out of them--can lead toward becoming more of
who we are. Or they can remake meaningless. The Coatlicue state can be a way station or it can
be a way of life.
touchstone. lf it sticks around after having outlived its usefulness, we become stuck in it and it takes possession of us. But
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
55
Borderlands K
Legalized borderlands can be both a physical space of transition between territories as well
as contact zone between ideas, as spaces of ideological ambiguity than can open new
possibilities of both repression and liberation.
Dudziak & Volpp 5 (Mary L. Dudziak is the Judge Edward J. and Ruey L. Guirado Professor of
Law, History, and Political Science at the USC, and a visiting professor of law at Harvard Law
School. Leti Volpp professor of law -UC Berkeley) American Quarterly (57.3 593-610 ) ALM
What, then, is a legal borderland? We might start with the role of law in borderlands that are geographic places. Borderlands can
U.S. territories where the Constitution does not follow the flag, or Guantnamo. Their ambiguity seems to render them sites of abnormal
placing them on the edge of the law. But we can also draw upon the idea of
legal borderlands to demarcate ideological spaces or gaps, holes in the imagining of America, where
America is felt to be "out of place," contexts in which, in spite of American ideals of
democracy and rights, violations of the law are routinized, such as in the space of the prison. The
supposition that these spaces are exceptional, rather than the norm, enables the
continued belief that "the story of America is the story of the rule of law," for stories
of the violation of the rule of law are explained through their location in those
physical spaces or their placement in those ideological gaps.9
Law also helps define the boundaries of American national identity. That American identity and
law are conflated is indisputable. But American ideology incorporates a particular vision of law,
which is law as the rule of law, and law as the guarantor of democracy, equality, and
freedom. Americans believe that their law is the rule of law. U.S. history most often
renders America as the guarantor of freedoms and rights. Thus, Americanization
projects are understood as projects of democratization. And yet sovereign power
includes the power to suspend the rule of law. To harmonize suspension with the idea
of law, suspension is characterized as a state of exception, and is rationalized in the
name of national security.10 This volume develops the concept of legal borderlands in part to consider spaces of
legal regulation,
exception that illustrate disjunctures between American identity and the rule of law. The essays in this volume demonstrate that there is a
necessary outside to this notion of the United States as the embodiment of the rule of law. American
history is marked
by episodes that can be simultaneously conceptualized as violations of the law and as
actions sanctioned by law; violations of law are as fully a part of America as what we consider to be its democratic
inside. Ruptures in the guarantees of rights have been as central to actual practice as the guarantees have been to American ideology.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
56
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
57
Borderlands K
it is the violence of colonial invasion and subjugation by race that opens this border
between skin and mask, where faces shatter into the wretchedness of insanity,
capitulation, or death. But this location, which is neither inside nor outside, neither good
nor evil, is an interstitial site out of which new, undecidable forms of being and original
theories and practices for emancipation, are produced. For example, the concept of split
consciousness articulated by third world thinkers including W. E. B. Du Bois, James Weldon Johnson, Fanon, Audre Lorde,
Gloria Anzalda, Paula Gunn Allen, and Trinh T. Minh-ha arises out of this location. These theorists see
what they do as they do it from the dominant viewpoint as well as from their own,
shuttling between realities, their identities reformatting out of another, third site. In this
True,
formulation, both the limits of insanity and the possibilities of emancipation are born out of the same horrors of subjugation. In both cases,
movementdifferential
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
58
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
59
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
60
Borderlands K
***Aff: A2 Borderlands***
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
61
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
62
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
63
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
64
Borderlands K
Orientalism Turn
The borderlands criticism creates a discursive practice similair to Orientalism in the way
it displaces the geographic differences of the area into one vast imagined territory.
Vaquera-Vsquez 98 (Santiago, Texas A&M - Latin American Issues 14(6).
http://webpub.allegheny.edu/group/LAS/LatinAmIssues/Articles/Vol14/LAI_vol_14_section_VI.
html - ALM
Cultural criticism on the Borderlands has created a discursive practice which arises
from the meeting of the so-called "First World" with a geographic "Other," the "Third
World." This type of project, in which a critical field is marked out through a
geographic region, is similar to the practice of "Orientalism" critically reviewed by
Edward Said. However, where Orientalism becomes a colonialist project by the West to
control the East-through a discourse which displaces the geographic differences between the
East and West into one single vast imagined territory- Borderlands criticism, and its
controlling forces, arises from within the area in question.2 Just as Said reads Orientalist
works through the "imagined geographies" that the works construct, so too can the
borderlands be subjected to a topographical reading. The region that is now the
southwestern United States, and formerly Spanish and then Mexican territory, comprises the
largest body of work in what we can term a "Borderlands project," a project which is a
discursive field made up of historical chronicles, linguistic documents, artistic and literary
works, and distinct political and social realities. This is an ongoing work that has been under
construction since the 16th century Spanish chronicles describing the region. However, rather
than map the history of this area-such a historical review extends well beyond the purview
of this study3 --the present work presses forward to the twentieth century to note recent
formulations of the border as the Borderlands.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
65
Borderlands K
Globalization Turn
TURN-Blurring the lines of identity can give a false sense of tolerance to violence caused by
globalization and therefore create a corporate multiculturalism.
Hames-Garcia, 00 (Michael, Department Head and Associate Professor of Ethnic Studies
Education, How to Tell a Mestizo from an Enchirito: Colonialism and National Culture in the
Borderlands, Diacritics, Volume: 30(4), p. 110-111. DAP)
At times, Anzalda is clearly in line with theorists like the Cuban linguist and philosopher
Roberto Fernndez Retamar, who argues that Latin Americans should choose cultural
identification with the most oppressed sectors of their societies [Fernndez Retamar 27]. At
other times, however, Anzaldas argument loses the specificity it needs, and there is
little to distinguish the new mestiza from the Enchirito of late capitalism. This
happens, for example, when she describes the importance of gay men and lesbians as
border crossers: homosexuals have strong bonds with the queer white, Black, Asian,
Native American, Latino, and with the queer in Italy, Australia and the rest of the
planet. ... Our role is to link people with each otherthe Blacks with Jews with
Indians with Asians with whites with extraterrestrials [Borderlands 8485]. The
juggling of cultures, blurring of cultural boundaries, and appropriation of modes of
living characteristic of profit-motivated corporate multiculturalism seem at times to
resemble the practice of the new mestiza:
The new mestiza copes by developing a tolerance for contradictions, a tolerance for
ambiguity. She learns to be an Indian in Mexican culture, to be Mexican from an Anglo
point of view. She learns to juggle cultures. She has a plural personality, she operates in
a pluralistic modenothing is thrust out, the good the bad and the ugly, nothing rejected,
nothing abandoned. Not only does she sustain contradictions, she turns the ambivalence
into something else. [79]
Anzalda is developing a new epistemology here, but one needs to be careful to ask,
what makes this new, what makes it different from capitalist contradiction and flux?
Surely a late capitalist epistemology also needs to sustain contradictions, to be plural,
to juggle cultures, and to tolerate ambiguity, and, although it does not ground itself in
the resistance of the oppressed, it has proved remarkably successful in adapting that
resistance to its own purposes. Anzalda has acknowledged this aspect of capitalist
culture in the Keating interview, characterizing it, similarly to Amin, as a homogenizing
unity [Keating 110]. I will return to her response to this capitalist homogenization in the
next section. First, I want to engage seriously with objections that some have raised to the
ways Borderlands figures the new mestiza epistemology
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
66
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
67
Borderlands K
Excellence,UniversityofVictoria,Borderlands:ComparingBorderSecurityinNorthAmericaandEurope,p.
4344.DAP)
The failure of the federal government to establish a guest-worker program to regulate the
border crossing of migrant labourers has rendered current federal border-control policies
both crime inducing and self-defeating. As long as the federal government fails to establish
such a program, it will continue to undermine its ability to define border security in terms
of a single national interest: stopping violent and organized criminals and terrorists.
Without a federal immigration policy that distinguishes migrant workers from criminal
and terrorists, informal organizations involved in mediating life and movement through the
borderlands will raise political polarizing questions about whose security is being protected
by US government border policy.
For example, although Mom and Pop small-scale human smugglers and migrant
assistance networks claim to provide individual security and human rights protection for
undocumented migrants who supply inexpensive labour to American companies and
households, these networks are unable to ensure a steady flow of migrant labourers to
Arizona business. In a climate of Arizona-Sonora border crackdowns, small scale smugglers
are often intercepted by the federal border patrol, which makes organized criminal
networks and gangs. Thus human traffickers in organized criminal networks essentially
secure flow of inexpensive labour, which is in high demand by the agricultural,
construction, and restaurant industries. In direct opposition to human traffickers and migrantassistance networks, US civilian militia volunteers claim to secure the southern border of the
United States from any and all undocumented corssers, ranging from terrorists to illegal aliens,
of whom the latter are said to run up US health-care costs and steal jobs from Americans.
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
68
Borderlands K
ADI 2010
Labels Suck
69
Borderlands K
Perm
Every step toward consciousness is a step forward
Anzaldua , former professor at SFSU, 87
Gloria Anzaldua, former Professor at San Francisco State University and leading scholar in
Chicano cultural theory and Queer theory. (1987) Borderlands/La Frontera: The New
Mestiza DJL
Every increment of consciousness, every step forward is a travesia, a crossing. I am again an
alien in new territory. And again, and again. But if I escape conscious awareness, escape
knowing, I wont be moving. Knowledge makes me more aware, it makes me more
conscious. Knowing is painful because after it Happens I can't stay in the same
place and be comfortable. I am no longer the same person I was before. I am a member of a conquered people who are
taught to believe they are Inferior because they have indigenous blood, believe in the supernatural and speak al deficient language. Now
she beats her- self over the head for her inactivity, a stage that is as necessary as breathing. But that means being Mexican. All her life
shes been told that Mexicans are lazy. She has had to work twice as hard as others to meet the standards of the dominant culture which
have, in part, become her standards. Why does she have to go and try to make sense of it all? livery time she makes sense of
something, she has to "Cross over, kicking a hole out of the old boundaries of the self and slip- ping under or over, dragging the old
skin along, stumbling over.
The attempt to exclude the aff creates new borderland zones of knowledge.
Donadey, 7 (Anne, Department of European Studies and Womens Studies at San Diego State University,
Overlapping and Interlocking Frames for Humanities Literature Studies: Assia Djebar, Tsitsi Dangarembga, Gloria
Anzaldua, College Literature, Fall, Volume: 34(4), p. 23. DAP)