You are on page 1of 3

Stewart1

RodStewart
EnglishIIP7
Mr.Sabot
28October2014
TheChangingofDetectiveSpooner
TheHerosJourneybyJosephCampbellisanamazingrepresentationandmodel
depictingthestorylineofnearlyeverystory,tale,mythorlegend.Althougheachpartofthis
modelisnotalwayspresentineverystory,eachstorydoesfollowthebasiclayout.
I,Robot
isan
excellentstorydepictingeverypointofCampbell'smodel,althoughinavaryingorder.As
DetectiveSpoonerinvestigatesthecaseofDr.Lanningssupposedsuicidein
I,Robot
,hishatred
ofrobotsgrowsanddevelopsthroughandbeforetheSupremeOrdeal,untilheisforcedtotrust
oneintheResurrection,allowinghimtoobtaintheRewardthathehadoriginallynotseeked.
TheseeventsallowDelSpoonersperspectivetochangeandgrowasnewchallengeswere
forceduponhim,givinghimknowledgeandpatiencetotrustthoseheoriginallydeemed
untrustworthy.
TheSupremeOrdealwithineachstoryputstheherothroughahardshipagainsthis/her
greatestfearorenemy.Thisisusuallytheturningpointinthestory,wheretheheroissetupon
thefinallegofhisjourney.In
I,Robot
,DetectiveSpoonersSupremeOrdealoccurswhenthe
NS5sprovehisoutrageousandstupidtheoryofrobotscommittingcrimescorrectbyenactinga
curfewuponeveryoneandmaintainingorderthroughviolenceofwhich,accordingtothethree
laws,isimpossible.Thiseventsendsthedetectiveoffinsearchofawaytofixthiswrong,and


Stewart2

shuttheNS5sdown.TherobotsrisingupalsorevealsthefinalcluesheneededtosolveDr.
Lanningsuntimelydeath,whichthrewtheseeventsintomotion.
FollowingtheSupremeOrdealistheResurrection.Thisisthepointinthestoryinwhich
theheroischanged,abletoreturnnewwhetherliterallywithanewlife,oranewperspective
thathasbeenshownortaughttohim.DetectiveSpoonerisinUSRwithSonnyandDr.Calvin,
beingarrestedbyrobots.SonnyagreeswithV.I.K.I.,foolingSpoonerintothinkinghesgoingto
killDr.Calvin.Hewinks,duplicatingitasSpoonerhaddoneearlierinthefilm,andhelpsthe
duotoescapetodestroyV.I.K.I.ThisinstantistheResurrectionofSpooner,bestowingonto
himanewopinionofSonny.ThisnewopinionallowshimtobetterworkwithandtrustSonny,
asheacceptedtheconceptofmoralityandbrokethetraditionofcalculatingdecisions.
ThenextpartoftheHerosJourneyistheReward.TheRewardiswhattheherowas
strivingtoretrieve,whetheranitemlikeasword,pen,cape,etc.,orknowledgeandexperience
thatcanleadtogreaterunderstanding.SpoonersRewardin
I,Robot
learningtotrusttherobots
whileovercominghislongtimefearandhatredforthem.Initially,hewasouttoprovethatthe
robotswerejustasbadaswehumansare.Althoughhesucceeded,hisendgoalwastobring
abouttherestorationofpeaceandorder.SonnysRewardwasthatofacceptanceandfriendship
byDelSpooner.AstheNS5sweredecommissioned,Sonnysdreambecamerealityandhe
becamethefigureuponthehill,ashewalkedintoanewlifeofunknownandoftheunexpected.
Campbellsingeniousmodelhelpsustoexplainandfollowavarietyofstorieswiththe
samemethodtohelpusbetterunderstandthetaleasitunfolds.In
I,Robot,
thehero,Detective
Spooner,learnsthatrobotscanbesimilartousandcanbetrusted.Heoriginallybelievedthat
theywereallthesame,calculatingdecisionsandopportunities,andpossessednosoul,making


Stewart3

computedjudgements,notmoralones.HelearnedthroughSonnythatnotallrobotsarethe
same,justlikehumans.Asthestoryprogressed,theSupremeOrdealjustifiedSpoonershatred
andreluctancewithrobots,whiletheResurrectiongavehimanotherperspectiveandanew
respectforSonny.

You might also like