Odd reading by the Osoleen and its impact upon scholars differences

Abstract: This study tackles the odd reading by the Osoleen and explains
to what extent they establish their argument upon it. I have defined the
readings, and their relation to the Holy Quran. I defined the odd reading
both linguistically and lexically (religiously), its religious authority and
whether it is related to the Quran or not. Then, I reviewed the methods of
argument by the Osoleen in their odd reading. I discussed their evidence
then I pointed out their conditions of the odd reading. I substantiated this
study with practical examples from Feqh.

- - -
-
2006 124-93 :

- -

- - .

- -

.
:

:
:

.1 .
.2 .

.3 .
.4 .

.5
.

.6
.
2006 )(1

94

: .
: .

: .
: .

: .
: .

: .

: .
: .
: .
: .

: .
: .

.
- -

: :

- :

)(1

: .
- :

95

)(2

2006 )(1

" :

" ).(3

: :

" : ").(4

: ):(5

- 1 .

- 2 .

- 3 .

" :

:

").(6

: :

.
:

: .
) (7 ).(8

: ) (9

2006 )(1

96

-1

- -

-2

)(10

" : "

:
-1

-2

.
.

...

.
:

" :

").(11
97

2006 )(1

" :

").(12

: :

: :

: .
:

).(13

: :

.1 " : ").(14

.2 " : ").(15

.
:

" : - -

" ).(16

" : :

").(17

).(18

" : :

... " :
").(19

" :

").(20

2006 )(1

98

" :

").(21

).(22
-

" :

").(23

)(24

).(25

" :

99

2006 )(1

 ").(26

" : ").(27

" : ").(28
: :

)(29

" : ) (

").(30

" : )

( : ").(31

" : : )

( ... :

.(32)

" : ").(33

: : :

- -

-1

:
-1

).(34

).(35

" :


2006 )(1

100

").(36
-2

- -

) (37 .

" :

").(38
-3

- -
).(39

: :

-1

:
- -

)(40

).(41

-2
-3

)(42

- - -

)(43

" :

").(44

"
").(45

101

2006 )(1

: :

:
-1

- -

).(46

-2

: -

- :

).(47

-3

).(48

- -

).(49

- -

-4

2006 )(1

102

).(50

" :

").(51

: :

- 1
:

- -

" :

.(52)"

-2

).(53

: .

-3

- -

103

2006 )(1

 ).(54
-4

).(55

1
.

3
.

: :
:

" "

).(56

2006 )(1

104

" :

").(57
:

").(58

"

" :

) ( ").(59

- -

) (
.

).(60

: :
:

1 .

2 .

- ) - (

) (61 :
- -
) : ( ).(62

).(63

) ( )(

" ").(64

105

2006 )(1

).(65

" :

:

)

( ) (

").(66

" :

").(67

: :

).(68

" : ") (69 " :

" .

) (1

).(70

" : "

)(71

- .

" :
2006 )(1

106

").(72

" :

").(73

" ").(74

)(2

)(75

).(76

" :

").(77

" :
)(78

"

" :

").(79

"

: ").(80
:

" :
107

2006 )(1

").(81

).(82

)(83

)(
) : ( ) (.

( " : ").(84
: .

- :

:
) ( ) (85

-
2006 )(1

108

.(86)-

: :

).(87

) : (

: :
-1

) :
( ) :

( ) (88

) (89

).(90

-2

)(91

: :

-1

) : (

)(92

:
) (93

.
-2

- -" :

").(94

109

2006 )(1

.
:

- -

- :

) (

) ( :

).(95

" : )

( ").(96

-1

.

- 2 )(
- -

- - ) (

).(97

" : : : )

( ").(98

-3 ) : (

2006 )(1

110

- 4
.

- 5
)

() (99
- ) - ( ).(100

).(101
- :

)(102

) :

( ) (103

- -

).(104

).(105

) ( - -
.

:
111

2006 )(1

- 1 ) ( )(

).(106

- 2 )(

.(107)

- 3

).(108

" : ").(109

" : ").(110

" :

").(111
: :

) : ( ) (112

" : :

").(113

" :

").(114

" :

").(115

2006 )(1

112

- 1 )(
.

- 2
.
- 3 :

.
- :
:

).(116

" :

.(117)"

" :

").(118

" : ").(119
" :

").(120

: :

).(121

" : : )

( : ").(122

" :

: :
").(123
113

2006 )(1

: :

.
:

. .

).(124
" :

... : :
").(125

).(126

).(127

:
.

" :

") .(128

.
" :

").(129
2006 )(1

114

:
)(1

)(2

)(3

.

)(4

)(5

.
)(6

115

2006 )(1

)(1
)(2

.25/1

: 21/2
.332/1

)(3

.405/1

)(5

.299/1

)(7

.318/1

)(9

209.210

)(4
)(6
)(8
)(10

208/1 .71/1
.203/1

.69 68/1

20/9

.560/1 818
)(11

.318 /1

)(12

.196/1

)(14

.203/1

)(16

.5/2

)(18

.71/1

)(13

)(15
)(17

495 /3 .140 /1
.47/1

.228/1

)(19

.30

)(20

.229/1

)(22

220/2 203/1 .347/3

)(24

220/2 194/1 257/1

)(21

)(23

.222/2
.347/3

2006 )(1

116

229/1 155/1 .144/1

)(25

.79/1

)(27

.281

)(29

281/1 216/2

)(30

.25/2

)(32

.281/1

)(34

257/1 .414/1

)(26
)(28

)(31
)(33

.257 /1

.79/1

25/2 34 .222/1
.34

.216/2

)(35

.229/1

)(36

.25/1

)(37

194/1 .230/1

)(38

.130/5

)(39

.222/2

)(41

.25/2

)(43

.281/1

)(45

.34

)(47

34 .216 /2

)(48

34 .204 /1

)(50

.34

)(40
)(42
)(44
)(46

)(49

117

52/2 25/2 .204 /1

.299/1
.281/1

.230/1

231/1 .26 /3

2006 )(1

)(51

.231 /1

)(52

.194/1

)(54

.26/2

)(53

233/1 .220/2

)(55

.233/1

)(56

81/2 47/1

)(57

.47/1

)(59

.81 /2

)(61

.206/1

)(63

.224/1

)(64

.233 232/2

)(58
)(60
)(62

287/2 .222/1
.287 /2

.81 /2
.185

)(65

.224/1

)(66

.226/1

)(67

.226/1

)(68

.204/1

)(70

: 82/1 257/1 142/1

)(71

.257/1

)(69

.204/1

.25/1

)(72

.142/1

)(73

.142/1

)(74

.222/1

)(75

127 249 229/1

.204/1

2006 )(1

118

)(76

.249

)(77

.257/1

)(79

.155/1

)(81

.222/1

)(83

.226/1

)(85

.184

)(87

75/3 354/2 128/2 194/1

)(88

.184

)(89

164 .285

)(91

.354 /2

)(93

284 .523

)(95

281 /1 354 /2 /3

)(96

.220 /1

)(98

.91 / 3

)(99

.78

)(78
)(80
)(82
)(84
)(86

)(90
)(92
)(94

)(97

.229/1

.204/1

.143/1
.226

91/3 .233/4
.91/3

.354 /2
.184

9113 2.292
7 232 /4 .189 /4

.189/4

) (100 .158
) (101 307/ 2 .249
119

2006 )(1

) (102 111/ 5 81/5 274/11

243/6 142/2 .340

) (103 .89

) (104 111/5 97/1 74/2

298/2 /10 .283/19

) (105 24/3 343 416/4

.283/19

) (106 111/5 75/3 228/2

345/2 .259/4

) (107 .111/5
) (108 .283/19
) (109 .75/3

) (110 .111/5
) (111 .274/11
) (112 .89

) (113 .340
) (114 .416/4

) (115 .275/4
) (116 485/1 437/1 347/3
.292/1

) (117 .485 /1
) (118 .347/3

) (119 .45

) (120 .399/1
) (121 142/1 .292/1
) (122 .142/1

) (123 .364/13
) (124 485/1 347/3 292/1
2006 )(1

120

.252/1
) (125 .291/1

) (126 .347/3
) (127 .485/1
) (128 .252/1

) (129 .263/4

.1

" " - 1986.

.2

" " - 1386 .

.4

" " - -

.5

" " - -

.6

" -

.3

.7
.8

" " .

1400 - .
.

" 1974.

" " .
"

" - -
.9

" " .

.10 " "

-

- - 1999.

121

2006 )(1

.11 " "

- - .

.12 " " -

- 1402 - .

.13 " " - 1990.

.14 " " .

.15 " ".

.16 " "

- -

1997 .

.17 " " -

1956 - .

.18 " "

.

.19 " " -

1997 .

.20 " " -

1401 - .

.21 " " .

.22 " " .

.23 " " .

.24 " " -

.

.25 " " - - 1406.

.26 " " -

- - - 1993.

.27 " " -

1405.
2006 )(1

122

.28 " "

- 1997 - .

.29 " " - -

.

.30 " " -

1398 1978 / .

.31 " " -.

.32 " " - -

1985.

.33 " " .

.34 " "

-.

.35 " "

.

.36 " " - 1402

.

.37 " "

- - 1990.

.38 " "

-.

.39 " " .

.40 " "

- 1997 - .

.41 " " - -

1400 - .

.42 " " .

.43 " "

1959.

.44 " " -.

123

2006 )(1

.45 " " -

- 1999.

.46 " " -

- 1982.

.47 " " .

.48 " " - -

1405.

.49 " "

- - 1399 -

.50 " " .

.51 " ".

.52 " " - -

1996 - .

.53 " "

- - .

.54 " " -

- - .

.55 " "

.

.56 " "

-
1998.

.57 " " - -

1996.

.58 " " - 1996.

.59 " " .

2006 )(1

124