Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Global Arbitration Review

    Uploaded by

    Ale
    341 views49 pages
    Vol_3_Issue_2

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    Vol_3_Issue_2

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    341 views49 pages

    Global Arbitration Review

    Uploaded by

    Ale
    Vol_3_Issue_2

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 49
    JBAL ARBITRATION REVIEW Cove [SRI OU eo ny Tain ree Editorial regulars 08 of fe month s Conterence dory 6 Cover sory: Rusia ond rotation Size of the mek. ° Pexpectves on MKAS 1s lh: Puble pale. arbtrabiy and enforcement 9 aM Optona!eriaton eaveee 3 Feoneos freezing orders 7 COMMUNITY NEWS. White & Case hos expressed futher Confcsence ins arbiration practice, ‘Snnouneing Iwo signiccrt lateral res, in Landon and Wosnington, (0G. the announcement follows & Series of intemal promotions thal ‘ream, al Tot, Wile & Case's International arbitation has grown by fve pariners this year ‘cao dba Aes Mente who Innis NAFTA benson dion forthe Mesa an memento pais: Capper ‘il wor om London Meer ned sno doce eae hae parce recht oor eh pes con pce par co a $3 Pad Pl Coma, Lan, some he utero ay An it ee ‘eto ced Jaton Hatem sud Kae Aerynaing gt cone Debi Tero flowed by fro cry ‘Sole asmoe QU 1 parmer ine Londo "How ong es wth Herr So econ ther prin rls Bac Dasger ——o_ be Se ‘eat, joined MeDernot Will & Einery LLP Tv London the nm ht Lovell a nog Xtc abl cr oh Las Wai Smee heey one Lo Teng omar son pec He ae el epction in he els” He aed ht he Daven tie pow head ern Incanto res White & Case growth hits five partners. Stent Begin who} wkd exensey ‘contacted tons om A (Con ined te Senin Hehe appeals te comtntion airy ..-As others also do well in 2008 partnership season The Furanenn ing at parine season ie fll wing, with several arian ‘Groups doing well anc seeing ther Sondidates succeed, Grows td se candle nade eter Sah Dobos & Po, ees ape Ste Meyer For LL Fab Jove Fees racine Deng ‘he meron! bon pop hve one Cog Teel London tele Mico ‘en Gino (Tyo) Heer Sah ao ‘led an bitoni y= fan COMMUNITY NEWS PCA picks new soeretary gener oie ps2 ‘The manent Con en be DrAgorinoandin December rough in peer at yr toe Geant Prac Bnet Nets anbaader the US firmer senir ener of be ICC ewe, "andcomerd to hr sid ged mht Kio wt ew sce en Kiser wil te oer the in Speer emit iby a pores Pa is come ator een mens th oe ‘A Deberoie Pinon LE Catesne 202 Filmed now ubion SR THO en en Hou whe eeng Amir in New or and Karls Sera nes fapelackn 100 whmenmev ae SPE ic. {non he coe pe They ee Fimo sera Re af ron cer thd sg inte Maing omgthe ns new panera Deberaie & Ge far Fisk sen, Nee Wend th apse of Kr, Plimpoa incrasonal dsp group can now At Fulbright & Jaworski LLP Richand Hi tae Mi mao Veshagen said the pr bys goes to ein oo yas growth suceeded with been eae prin Hi pine coy DU te in epson of be ere of Seo andes yer ag faba Lord Per in 208 oo Baker © Mekent LP Heine Mm nh ef ao" Caden Qe jae Londo fe ‘econ pane Falher Bu nee, EMBED poston Net i cine ante mora ‘Ae Skat She Meat & LL fo ym nny 207 jt een AC eke em tra ‘rae Macs sos Tidy © Nelon he bath Shwe lated The bart bath pons patayccemn ind Ronciton, Sawcnicsalkepacicne eipe -ECTA hunches Dubs lat yeure ver eh een yarter id ied coed” wat sctuckt ing theo sn us _TH London Cor of eran Abiron iain Nati nition ch" ioaind aig OCA Ce ECM at wo i be ong on titan uy he Eergy Chater Mich! Swan fare ced Sent PS roa Fn Cente Tuner hii Atriun notes Nemec famine He mason Fb, On San mis gee ofthe DIFC ad Adin Wine, ‘seem epson ‘erway rlcon pu th o> ‘A Fs roku Deringer Alex Yin contenu wf the fr egy and SRS BE oft LUA eect ‘a New ene pe thea Vnoe Somos group. Po 4, pct inersananlwrion bd ined Joba Whine bed of Cy & Cade on cen Waly ihe ew ‘gon wha cl fru oniesnest aoe and dapat elton pecs eden ie LIAS opin “ef he ‘ray ek He pi of he in FaorledSwanpd pomoton sexe wel erent MPG ad beeen connie of Dab ‘Sm ow aving ConocoPilfsn acai "Mihl hr exelent egrcss bash nah Wie Me a” iste ine he ‘gut Vnear se Interior Cenex ating cmny emg ertiina) ECLA tern fips jt woe fn Seiler of resent Dsptes Fredy pecan and bles, IO 10-7 ion ah oni ‘Brac Dering ced aitaon cre rome he po cies (China-New Zealind FTA paves wa (Chine New paves way Restless London duo move once more 38) sina! s fected: wremen, Not fong after winning @ moor inla- inl in he samen ation of os thoy biomes feloled arbitration, Stephen York Cau snain 3008 7 ghetto ns Daya fond Shai Wade have let Kipatick —“"Nehew Geary sn tron atizeion BARE dpe ean pono Chg Slockton LLP for Reed Smith LLP. paraerat Alon & Grey LLiane“Sephenand_ 1240 remiehogh noosin “et 4ay"We rel he oppor to Shares ema om, ivan eclan gome RB nnee e oy or th “A Cra eames pa od otk with he Reed Sth em at ave the fr Ren Sahin she a ee | ‘ecu nf ineniondl ach ht the Gem can wellognie han cp he no Reef oe eee pepe ge ‘ort preter Ey he ny Ara cea ‘ier prac ‘ha yd oe ‘Charles Hewesoe, deputy head of Reed ‘Meanwhile Wade, 39, is co-chair ofthe ‘beer imestncat unten China uaconddonaly Sei ieon om Boop Sen Yoel ce Cepek of res Somat mew pce arg no ne thn ‘ee mnt Adan pte ene SID me ert somcitntgecyses | Errata Syren eto ‘thie thea Inde anon Pep sug | Clown oy eet werden”) | Se gi in Aad UNCETRAL agaoueye | te andwetldone) | ead Une Th ee gore pus ae Spored tra faces to deere | means sone many Te hero hong Mba: Lary Shore oo | Ghul erat ae a free | EAE ete hy Gt fe irl ietetng Sern erin one CGison Dunn & Crt wor coun! ore | pace head Rab luna We aed he | Ease apy and cota coe rponen Clete we | ‘nme he pe of pry nd Tenperirtompetns Acorn rei, "York We ony joined Kapeick (ie 3, Zl Andis ge ws Stockton 26, mV Es LLP | gine Th shh he mel under ‘ot belie at wih Homme el 2000. He | 2 34 We apd fry tte lv mye some im er bon pte nih ne ut gen ca Wars ene oer of ie ough pent ‘ti eben rs wee The ‘Sev opis comarca Mig COMMUNITY NEWS Colombia's constitutional court appoint Mantilla-Serrano Flrtndy Mana Serna Colanbi-bore [ncn baton rer a Shew Sting LL Pr har bee poi! oe juceof Claman cou ‘Th sort in ce me ey Colon nt Ado tos il ‘whens ote sine nee ‘Alvarez appointed Canadian QC Hens Aloe Caan Sem Fak Maen Don LP ho bec adel SSL He wa sponte Ques Coun ty the ene goreor in coum o ‘Beh Cain fo enepoenl eitand entation he el fin” Aare, [Sle purer and cnc of he bration Lng kon Maps Dao sod See aia eee relocates to DC ing Gonand ors US em, ‘Shere Sag hs mee Jo Sige fen Spor to the US pa He abo ar ejb let of Moy Sg, bene uty bet of eG wore atom prrsce He lab bee whe US tit See Snge leo as i os ein ‘Whitesell joins Dechert in the US Intensonl Couto Aieton Ase Mae ‘While Dechert LLP tack Ber ote US Wien ed thes Pais fic A= te wl nove Wiig, Diath ner Sh le he ICC ly af igen sce gene Arbitration specialists lead ABA and ASIL {i ofthe US me nel ern ote selon eed by leer wwe yo | Tenn stron Th Ameen Bar ‘Reocton a chen Cay ani of Whe {San LL? a 209 pretense, ogy Res of Pratl Brule Devnet ‘ety bun poser of he Amer ‘Sty often Lae She creed J Aes pe flere iw Alonaey a Canta Use Her oe pecs la ewe. Bronnas joins CPR “Th lr tit fx Cone rownion wd Rens hr eae Lorine Bremen wei vic pent eee 2 ICC spat a “personality clash” et of he Cae pre i sey one con oe ppl on Reed amp 9 we The king Soret ctOpi | ana cpa led ene Re at ‘Abwrion Cue Urn Conenenn [Chae Pi Maen aps in bi expres, tgp oar the US th Rn UGSaCinsn Tine 77 nomenon | TEC ton iced by Renin hoyen "Rina te et a to rari Steet SSorcrrpined "mann er nencoon Aner bin 3 wh” ane rach Suits with Rosi de bck | aparing who cee gros encore oUS cea et twSont tan aprSignn aricef ean | oie eh coe Pree Rear Concer ot he cy of oper SXJous Dor LLR"a wade bemen the US| Eng sd ac nog be LIA" | Sache th Rann eee ‘Sn Stockett nino dots lesen low aa i hi poe hell, Inds dpe Se consconeo e ie anode et ‘Mops 208 thd 17 ce wre Oe fide | sn hme adem Res Poe In Moscow, they ‘Shiota fe Braj ee oak “The chaeges | think that the inc ee Fol Sah uth don Cour real London Court ConocePilie Se be oer the 30. cain sgn Senate Fineeaitich we anne ems eg ‘natural place 10 @ke a Russian arbitration. Several of International without deciding to explore their legs options. Inwyets interviewed fo: this piece aid the LIA | © Arbitration is starting, eg tuna mney oy of Ee mane ore | to rival Sweden as the | Stem boon: sea bya pecs STSSTe Serta ene lace to take a | samsie inc tiepey sete Nite pe | Ratural place to take a | Sperry usa ein ers aco ‘Serge Volon, hea! ofthe Rusis“CIS dior | Russian arbitration 10 make inatant-cofee in Krasnodkr, South Rus, vel cs Bo aa enon op peseal Tema be CE bom tnenniSon oni team ttc ey ‘Sere Rane connec UR efitwsin enacton who merce Bt Bac enn nd Aenea Exes ‘the nto ey Ege ie pt get yee "ls Ke ala cr Resmi conten Othe nw beatine Deg peetensee gop |‘ ame wee | Uh Wm makeResponse em atlne tera ot” | scien Can | Eafe Tremere | SSutaclatetiinert pane nce _ | Oftn indy ging ab whe Secon fiimesctie” | Recaresoy Rae as MAS | pn sonny hang became veisivtrant roy tte | pee Abr em ppan he" | Seg ton reo et wet atikinaratwaety —|Cchietasent detent” | Spar ketfar we a Rit Ticino kes Kenia rps” |fuseimsrocts tegen cle | cue aed tut won cee SOREL cece, am on ten nips Senden sve aed SoS yw Ltn cl Pees geen re Sree at onl anon | Sa of ee San ema exe Ne Siitcig aiiecierccamimacd” | whowsergonikedey peste mie | sent ape icone pena eesti Eocene | arte eet aber | wake bm op Somes fay ine UR. Panes br of Jat Minor empl he eanany RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION ti aud ~ MEAS a other" cour ae apposting enforcement more ea Serle, df he Rais dpe Th Reco ed | ‘Abi oa ar eon pb py, Unde the Neer Comenson cere cn be ‘uli rove ob conay wpe Doha an fa ly ay ade aga he an Fee a= ‘ved erie nal be dw gat the py Te ne beconng eee ‘Sia Jv, ser who vers cont Je Da LLRs pation ‘hoe Ron don cus cere of rinse a Ee hgh et Sipe onl spine mbit woh Sten eed ah suri Rosa be rer 0 nee re end va eR cou a ey ects mae Rete eee and spe nn ec ok ‘Sam epson of te pre eos Deco cht oe refered widely se plac at ft rm aed dbo pep aw tng igre a tesame sper cid dean when » Maco foes Scholes ck fs pen ‘Test mmo hy La ooo Usd The mr eh Mancow OF Redeye fo tnd USE aon. Since he pes Son ow, ‘rena hn ving eer ihe rearing te oe cour nd ending | fake nied see by he eae Ina he ee condo ope ctemiiagsashicereyheyes | ‘scat paul "Ouy esd & pil Bitdecon bsp de ering an ‘evero/Rn lc aon "The fda cto sober pe dep with Roi copa, Many oe cf pesur can be upto ex at forth Srp abou be ngerpole red Jor bods Mow eee ~ nace tem fo-tad ‘top magenta wt per Tu Moscoso hk pt om hl eins af eet poe go set ‘han bali Dan Coleg post] Bein LLP and oan ch gi Ran Ee ‘Asoc u ha atone e metapsan ‘eres ch at Moa ad Se Reed ae ‘rosrbimaonepon unre do “Te rte a Ros hin plement nd spron ich sox conan Te eof ‘Reni ante uy of pactones et A Moscow court refused enforcement of an arbitral award from Stockholm — because of a lack of a hyphen ‘Sos the pote of cocng om bee ec pang ch a ‘cmp oben enc sep ane code ihe tng ghee radeon ht er owed he New York ‘ebensne Sho bore of cont ame erwcen the ea ein Ra ‘ur woul beled on ply tmameet GAS hugh tee kd pain ‘third Gond ut eth the B80 percent sare it Mas nee sy th MKAS cold wok conte om ee toe Thy ya the | peter tog vile 08 encase ‘pe wr turson unk MAS rar ay Spay fate” Sh pos ort is inet founded -Bease pars ean he ‘lino ice sons he cyan Fre rs a fl uncool Shake ole fhe MEAS eer Ce ‘owas a KAS wel gre nl net {nto ed a conan tow ececy On trvcand he roese oid cry omg or he te Ine oped Cheanong hee war ‘moderna fan 30 Now om ‘he cnet bea yl ‘heres ence ge acc fe al orl ad concn so send ‘Sue powt or ben fe es he present teeth prions pocay bie ‘Shang wn me ges AS ‘ated heel fe pad oss KAS ie thr pune One ay sees thea aso of tring bey” Men EAs hing wah age KAS it alone ping tthe sort The Arti Ie i tk, Gar of Comme a rey Atami Koso pie oF MKAS 9 ‘uso bn role ed ie eaing tao in Rasen fom he Src thn these cour i to ern dm 5 ite oro rome at rain ora ‘aque eine ala tt. Ba he ge on ee re een ah kg Mosc the view naa clas ve scare nd pty th seo oho ge dps fo Ret le ted RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION INTERVIEW WITH ALEXANDER KOMAROV Alexander Komuarov is president of Russia’ intetnational arbitral institution, the International Commercial Arbitration Court — better known as MKAS. By Sarah Dookhun Me ae peanut miAs, | crnpnton yt tio nb ho ug osc hyn ti mot 0 [esei cys te ecys aor vets veer eet stan n is ion Sootine cae wishin tt Soren nana ste ree | nt anne = sinh i ‘Some Sie enm Richart wingers | SiR tsa ty sunisuasdastnewanare. | MKAS's new rules ~ the points of difference “ihe me SAS mere le men the cain Detwey o dS sis | 12006 MAS evil re Thee ache +The dry of conden ex bod sob fins led aoa fl oa 62 0 |i ange hc he jars oul ear © Tato tsb 207th phe preidiom, rier ten poet ne, exer sed employe of MS ‘Aconde Kororbt benpeen of | MAS aso nel he eas ‘omar dog de pose Tey Spon Rasa station paces. se tho vile for them fp vet + Unlove ped pate wlbe +The tan mar sb ued dt GAR: Whats your background Tear ty aslestne ite pers on al edhe MBAS set "cae onthe nator Law Fy (ermine th ci done ced (re ding te rd te pre, tte Moca Sele fo Foe Usosi, ea ee iStsonie 7 pena nettle | +s a piel el, ein he a er USI inoy of ogy Tae na USSR ‘telolingcdvcdon sd experince win fermenting inl soe “Tole Rywomnsnoss 1am 2 prlcsor send | 15 dn farang motteon of er KAS ree Force ‘pow bon dined 180 fm th fein oe hi IAS ace 158, + MEAS ater manga rm tel opps 2 tee feng it thy wil som ni MAS. ofthe ang se RUSSIA AND ARRITRATON omen a» pred erica aoa! oft abitton ees Bt he emo iit | York bt wo i pe now an eve MAS hr misaned isdomnepson _hage bese saws Bey ‘och seer iy be Chel of ‘ovation conser! dpe not onl for Wh! percentage of MKAS awards ore [si pret abot mene” | uses Do Russon pes tend o ue domestic independ sas fred re dsolion ‘Re MKAS we do ot push chef of foreign eur orinemationel Gi Sor Union cso Sy of esha an cf ao of MEASE XGepour rks ple Te mains mor af | conn and we do tw fm | leh be eed tht beans sn adamant eset reat in ie with fri wh we ur ee sy ay Ag. | MKAS do or ne the pe Rn The ‘ern ben pr ‘Serva ish bok commingled” | part the stbisen amet ea pie ‘seer ofimereiag MKASubisuionsonh| fe the ng te etson peeing. Whos the rationale behind the Inthe thes wo rence she ier | Mow therm ipa o Ros and nk obladcrk/veccetory having weh © thearbentr a ncn no eens to | we natn Spr one, promnert oe? The sajer ter of the pe dnc vanetatet |For atts RAS wh 08 The tolbbk sng ondng inthe purrs sete tha nforaon | lal eal cng he Rasa pe, rine dei gs Newt ne | eed {hough ee ao tino ty ‘eh epg hs mon bee ‘pretation Tae ay ie wh ‘gece baton RAS TH ‘con ool repent cig het easement of att WKAS |. Langan not bai to ant MAS, seo! ping myer Gene) tr tyre | MEKAS has its seat ‘ary fog cone sea Ran wry el ini sae or pope cael inter lof acti ake wert ual in Moscow and this) Pyptique minal hve ws feyienowccsucdnae PeGueinnuies Unde Buneeee| seater aaeae en voaae oo _procenings So the douche ct 2 kindof new rules. Under the seboraions at IKAS, Eitdimesimemcpnma | oldrules,che place teins woe nme aes nthe be of arbitration also. jm the hearings be in English o he whale Seakocsene ag had to be within the | Reoy iether, Senecio ciwrecea, | Russian Federation. | Siyvmerennbutinn at MeSturssrlstines woncnins | Now it is possible Soe fine obo so hd eo wih th for parties to hold | Kimani norsepameares | hearings anywhere in| Rumnasemn cen aun atece Saymuteieddndegenoe | the world ‘pce gi de Reson gai arhinaing ouside Moxcon: | spray more key e appoint» peactng Eodah myer rp EE en oo pats Aaa tend {Some pane fea Se Sibmitwinos evidence ch ar winest | casa t MKAS fore yh |e eH RRA a of a Fotemente tis, orewinesos hen | ence aul mene polecr | ae fom!) cme oeRans ape Comerammes alneangr nas kan toying nde te son ont D one sono es Sticker Deseo ray ese” ST bios hed rekeyucin crn aber mon! | Anan he rasp ‘Sonu cemeTie Rin eakint | fhe br mang done 0 ao Ass corer concoma Stic tt of eine ope tee fursonponye ‘rin sen reno tpi and mat | What would you esfmate isthe quanfly Theat joy of MKAS ain concern Shiot Raso egos ate ntso epeincedin | oF experienced intematondl SbiWaHon a loer ane Ran ur Wed seta Bare roctionessin Rusio? reo ee her Bhp 9 Bor stour tien cour such vidence | Toul wy the alt our ponent 207, eee ee pets whee Isnt nl wed ery itn Ofenune dr _—_| are econing ae epee He Maem ai ui prep Mw a the Sipe the arc and KAS wy “hee areal neon we fonts eng oboe on Alem tara stce hea oe alee _| which aves print ste ae od fer Sones bon ee pres ot OFevdenee We do hte rendu od te Rama gern tw wo ene ster jon i 2g es [grenl mide eather ndence pcs Thy ae paring expres fe peeing ee preted tony Unis Sesredy the pac be ors amee__Soungr gn ire ey ck St Gcomny se Ore Dein ihe Cab apeie he KAS itu ay sso” inte emmy expences Sic ams rae es USK ‘toe cnc od equ ithe weasos tata ton armas we ne era ie Lt fie Eni oeeeding Theyre hte lar eo ater ema ado, Pr New | thle br nated at spur fom hore RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION icin, which te pati gu, Howe you een an incre nthe use oF tat cone ene he pcraon of ‘ote oe Ren Bence ‘Commsrct ersiraton aromeons of ie MAS scart ot li ca Terohing dputern Russad And whyé sx she nay of taal rats your opinion of the Rion Tehuben slongtntng mon Rams, tom Side court attiyde talmemations! emg en the Sot Un ft dts [lation and the enforcement cf sua fourtrgn wale or ogy scamsme Some proctioners have roe that nore? ‘Mn benched by ers noon, MEAS oars xe at pal very wel or win se cours a ing mor Tks ink every mince aaaey Sine thesfuion Keeps @signiteant Tin nth cee of mrisinel|people dat mntonabiaton x beter ian Shae of the Coss ond pays Tho ‘son sven: Rear iw pening fr | hess cr when desing wih crass” YBMOIOG @ smal amount compared “fecompsone othe ast come nang, mimi Spurs The ice te parr ve Yo oer Mojo orb instons 6 Ms (Cimcrsioml stator fy tewaed | emake Haber ste car gion or ely fo changet “oelpig iverson "adieaon wena the choice | Amore te” ae euted apd de ile sano ov foe atradon | wih by the Ran Fenn Chamber of pore bul choo | Conan 0 whe MAS “It cannot be denied seacbed MKAS proposed some dine 360 10 Which ales or cartes othr than that some courts ‘Moscow are populr wih Rion portos 7 mart of _|leretbiratlon ond are you seeng any in a remote part of ome ‘cra lh rn We hope tour Fron willbe screed oa i ton rein ie wh he dey acetate Russia may review | ‘Generally I would sey that Resian partes the merits ofa case | [Meeeotemmcmen | or deny enforcement | Miiaarineae ate satin Ginter | MEAS proposed of an arbitral award | Arms Ommment™| SOE NE AO by interpreting the /atmuinatameiteanm | Cue £06 pre public policy clause econ! Economie Chamber ere proportion in the of the New York yepmaicedete se | distribution of costs Comennoritos: Siteamwmaranerwnn | of the arbieration broadly” Tht otinne'onanmg¢S mers | We hope that our “Te sconmamoyaeme ppc | proposal will be ten we cone sce sme lene _| mesial pss Brien accepted to make Sige mmatejrsdeowenidt |" RKAS teed Hvaevesscocemnag | ts situation more in Dwmaaras semen eis beouwn | Rua penee set stgeranere | Jine with the widely Cicrcnuciatrcanpie nGemayeraier |(kurseemidesn heir aératenon | accepted patter "fh tt nec tose teoxt MAS ene her ston be | What do you £88 a heh of cttcatirnen tockvtah eau cumt | Sieter Renae tener aee nk | hematanalaetraton in usiot Whot ‘Stvnenen ar snientOfeane om Reson paisa hrS helper | pls does MKAS have or promating Slinuiow wow emu cies ain | SieKouoysndee ore onde | Ht Sectors irwsh trtonlacic, [Gre dem hve soenpen weit | Toms engd np re ‘cian n ane peu coue rant |e mpsy of Ea pts wel pres» | Romande ey pray pose desea Coreims ome pve |i pase LA Each | er sin Ta ee od Conia micr te mer near dey | priate pre 1G ‘ine! reson tein don tate er il ed yee se ese ton tee Sepals yolcy ur efe Neva" | Soverl MAS obtatos bosed abroad | Saw hne cpus tee nese Comet eth ve manoned that robe wih | Syed ch ares pp Taw ne epost 00 Tixas'etnt to secetocl einen! | way uci owe cya UNCITRAL MeL wih bing ax |Tomats oortsporse to he? ‘Ehng Ru nc he leg tow sey etic tljprensty |e on trey en roms rch | ya are secre or ca chpocadeal sere wintepesty [opiniones atc nt tof | finan ec me gay afer prove hares caaloreinw be [ees ce tat aga septate | You sn opiate wy bot Mfc ec ondvo mee cng | ronson in Sout of. une. | pomat RAS nd owl conn Res teddies onions" [Ta qa re mcg oy | decane ieeecomenc and” | Thankyou PERSPECTIVES ON MKAS Non-Russians who have sat as MKAS arbitrators say it is a reliable and objective institution, if occasionally inefficient PER RUNELAND Berwin LLP Consultant, London My ne esting a bat tok pe rng In 207d ev ppt se Sire bit whch ae ft Seems sendy 0 en om he pti ke sen fol naan tees ghoy ree ea shone exper irerasoa abn ‘ume 0 Rss tt oor ee There me Ss of MKAS tat make ‘be intesion!ubiaton pre eno ‘fief London o Sekai, Fr example {duc orem mee ‘goby sol wok eae tr Th tke erry tee, ‘iron + high esl dang tran se MKAS igh qui o Ste La a Toate an opin ins Cnn op on ‘bean, cing wo al nd brome sho be pce by Caan gion ‘ep y pond he gue wa ed pons Be ih uy al es, aly KAJ HOBER Monnheimer Swarting Advokatbyé Partner Stockholm and Moscow "haya arbre MKAS sot 28 to Sh cas oe the p18 yea nd yee work has een pry ae ad cose Thea see cued some 20 a ‘Aayone wo dsb a MEAS ston isan obj pos it wrong Parse an ‘omit sone ant alah ‘Ge MRAS lt ote meso god ‘rperenced iron niin cote ‘Eom fn my experience wen sing on pel ‘th Rio sole hy spac i ee ‘ae stro ys ge inthe ae wo Poe ble a ay ie whe RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION, Ica ft ine cat Be pnt heath cme dt he eeu ee ad KAS aponnent te nhs a othe [SAS aan o Beane pa of ist ther ri tons ap anal nt of ‘ir ved This arangenes ence te So the sy of he elope of MAS atbraton process cheaper tha other abil imoninana ch IEC Sota od cman Par vag be fr mney hae ie prnaexpeicefthe colonel ern Ro nd hee ‘ater tht held of efccment {Geos yon re a MEAS ao on sje a he peice fy bea undead hr na red Sd the ks fy neato aoa Staion a probly beng Je specu mer nang rele pens ced igen ein when gt MEAS, Ron eta ie of tice td ie ‘Seth Ratio es or ae iret de oon, ‘hich my ie pola emai when ‘mat the ences owt ta Bethe evi on ce MASI sre st ofc Ar ‘we chowig ay a ttn deeds hotly on te pred he cee ‘wher MEAS sin sol be proved ferina comet Aloogh carn ct shuld Se an int acount oe tampering ‘Se MAAS rey he ail pce 3 oe tet be cone ia Ramin areca ope aoe lange or eo intrte at somal ening in Ree RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION. 4 (CHRISTER SODERLUND Vinge Priner Stocknom hao oil eed cet MAS erie ran rerosingegerene Psi Fare og the evo conducted In Weren pace te pein nde dolls wewery whe par te ad phy sed nd dca dle Davi GOLDBERG SJ Berwin UP Partner London hae ao ee MAS pal a an air fsbo ge sd nal dpe Some Wester ‘bers donot leap pps MEAS ‘oot snl moon “Runen ht MEAS ck priya coupe caimadel sac part anche ‘ay sbi oo poe Tere de ‘tpi Goon tee wing thr ot ors jae the amisraon of he ‘cra omen ckingAebion do not ‘ics bre sock cone he pcs of ‘he abn sb by te ett, whch = ntient at poy de tc ‘indigo ens any prs campin RICHARD KRENDLER Sheorman & Steing LP Partner Fronkiurt ‘yt ot ng oe eth ae he dna ae igor ihn Meco cube nee ing ‘hat pcm dus hieqaiy or ‘hse pent ening Moon aero fh pce depen ‘the bean ‘meng inne sper de ‘ropet of wing recon yb {eld ae ht MKAS isons ‘Serve sate stowgh don nk iit ‘tyne nay pene or ‘When constingt MKASsbiton. the dca Roi ad pep dat the pene mee cones othe "Th aie wih MAS soy {he tod ofthe fs pl te prego {ot nn, eign pea oe Ming MAS a8 wie tion “The rot coy oe ang ta ect ‘it compos on shee on ‘he delphi eae no ay eo "Rasa cing utr tang fiat prctone an ue when (ones cabernet or lenge ein ‘el nd isace om th cort Wh Moro aS ena, wl eof the age es, oe erin tol jory, ‘he dr uy wen eae ion. ‘isis scoped UNCITRAL Mod! Le ds pry wt New rk Coon of ‘rial vt. the proton legeaton ‘imino tt of oer aren, wich ‘lene sod pio flo, ‘hee te gust of ctones aie aces be ecw 280d 0 eto aeons ‘amoral melon we eel Prong for sterason under UNCITRAL re dea seep fed concen res ‘When veg the Resin eae anbieiton ts woth dining bene he ‘hier ine organ decent Specie hat mee yan ring the {Saheecogton al noc of RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION, WHO’S WHO OF ARBITRATION IN i RUSSIA As the Russian economy expands, so local arbitration skills are developing SCT [crete tons | pease ima tirarheon” | Chipman Ses toy doe nce soe Riso fesse ats asain e4o | fice thn be Rein rec a fPusctondon the US ays Aeraner | ooo hen ching int ero Gem | late pnts “Theye become sce onan peso of MAS Russ froth woot They dt hae intron | cies ae ae we of ngs ‘cabo wbston ee ovo wo allon Nor do ty hve mach fiterand estos Hes then sy ‘mo avery ond erator! | “png inthe mdf cation saan | te Swen Raman cons noe te ad aie mm i i kn he si | chan ht aed incon pring bition mary | sae tos Moe Kn cmc | exact nego “Taey ont ee inert! nw fw nh peomaene se | a wien inne Rein aw precady | Sou now" oe inthe county fe Rusa yes we se | Engh carmen iwc cen goad or | When Sk Bean, Chl ti ‘ident are.ioourcoleciveperie's | crating he ind four incement stectos | Reine wre Mono towne on ‘ote inthe Ra 8 a shar or mr ‘was need hse expec we stioaon nc mgi ec caige__| tee nalned wc sec fon win | str ci med od iiinaey otter dopeihse sbi, | Ros sowed wpe tien eo hint onan Rumors paler | Tha Rian ingen woe mped | nian Dreher see Shs wt suteraconstioser bre sen gt he_| nscale tech neo Inte ao he Soe Lon bison wor | Sings Aem'nme OAStrs we | pte'peulc eat eceange eto trn eng em nite, DDmen eye hyf eggs “a en er Ti Rminprcmbe onmeraee' |sonrbciinor Reman euncac | nettr tee posers se oe Sieimrnatnd pt Rena apenas | Wench Okstwe wre on | Suomen Bree ase s Solera tcmestemnseges | Rou pecerdncersntnsrsey” | weer ae Sader bne e e connor, Seong own ony mc ch | Sooke nimeguecttonngsierncies |siteptms Chie Che var” | Poreber le” acta ae ring pions Ttcctrece’” | Kinigeinorn caverta” | nar Seno tc ans eo is{GShee Pail tn ity shauna anal Race Spee woh hr oe Gaim Doh beds Co |Tv fens won communi | ""Tactecet pl to an wk SSccbebecayecumgn te Ronin’ [avin pag om iis Ines | Res indve eet sty “ccelnue'netwmee qouiy) |mensiha ie nvr oct ie” | Shanta ce cae eee eomrofon cthcconpanTic ”” |chnkalUsso nate inca | Tp cbr ste et Raa trp nae ped ounion | Nino tty nl | weer oer ora "non pea cn fre Ter opto ae cmd fy fie) | Mateo Aout nniagsts Rac the Impron hegmens beens obenaes | Teen e"Whos hoa bon ‘hanes br you wi be ei couse! | Forse ae rte poe in Kini wo nge ehonie o amo ies mater Whe ew ea_| pening cent in Rats sp | pol ori pn marca on ‘ga Rustin members of Cd Chance in| vance pepe hte soci post wa oe_| ue rose mc st neo pars joe Mos we chien by nin pede Tee rig fps nd thr hin ol daw | tor elds ad come 2 ivadvcas intl season | dhe we bl “Ths decane became the bi or oc fs Skim taro he Sere tht “The ke vew 6 Ue stbinaon seein | iter wth ome! od has ins esi Rem The ee die ne | pene iy tor ie ‘et wh eo edentah aion An aneron pred fe ons {patna wun nse, RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION, SUPERARBITRATORS ALEXANDER KOMAROV, ‘8 Fray afm Ruston Rs cron tis en Resend ce 1988 Sle enough ing CV Gna Stocktcin Vien, Bop Warton ‘ppc bao noe to So ‘Bicone he famed pe a he og ein ‘Site toa omer fy sake m Rs {hd ine ble pane ope, Magan ‘Se aa ncling besoin unter ‘te Cove te Posen oe Res Jake Reforms hy pref eR Inna one fr Conners ‘itn fr IEC Ri on bd Fig meen the Aron ne laf te Choraed ttn Arbor | se Came ttn ‘ton ae nated in he mo conor Rentn bine pole ode raion Sve cathe epee ig of ci rad or frcignceoomac more ed ALEXEY KOSTIN. 55 fray of the Reson ei neal Relators woe he Whito Bunce Sol af te Univers of ‘enon Hara Des Seba AE Sipe re ‘tbo lacing the IC ltr ‘Cou of toon ch Aion Ie file Sora Chante of Commer the Alsons Peden of MAS egslabedev Choiman cf the Maire wanaien Andrey Gorcety "ns Vkowo independent Serod Vion Doves &eboout WP | erin ein & rity Dyekn Magis Researt— Drew kucctin Herbert smh Cs UP enter egos Fuansey Nanay Donnie Fetew Lovee LP evaory feschenty ‘kokoro Pros Proctonar oe sod fhaboteaty win | Bana SERGE! LEBEDEY, 73 Commerce ancnciy Nacht Servi md Sap and seed Ue ati econo Be ‘sss moc lion er» Re US ta se Fs ‘Atay fe Sohn Tees wax pen youl fo the Mono and Pri ae of (hrs Chance LEP ad oes Dy Ln Pi Tie + merterf the MKAS pres Common Hea re ste Mo ‘ered Resa roti to he Une | Nacors Commision oo Intenuonal ade Ln Seng cbse i ting oni ae bat ial ery cea ery end oe nih dete hing til itr uke nt Kamo ext i aad ‘sf Come inti 208, eae i am Honore ie peer af he ie wed te Geld fers sbinnon aes Ronan abieaton pc “incon peng han ines snen presen af te pel 2 ‘al dined the ci, og ye ‘ost insesmen ea fe ak force. ie so ar 3 pucrappted ater 2 {nme 307 bomen» US compu be IAN 2¥RIN. 56 an Zin very wel kon rl ny ic de ap atin pont HIGHLY REGARDED MIKHAIL IVANOV, 45 meragrg cama | Perasbuah sire Sh Fiona fai! I paced ery pao nd ‘Secale ion ue he | P'S fm nwo rs coe owt sopping ene hi cent mon) He the coun s Swi om sompay th fant ain pt of i'S Perrys hi eens the ea poe RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION. 2 ice pede HKAS he cl poe ‘irrational stieton nk Aniey founded in 192 lo enero pepe, ter the Rese att ign roms fit He ery hy wep lepine sone pcr Ar soe 2 nce wk ds te teins Rian ‘lang th f the SCC a te Kd ‘Ss! by Ream ol compu SC Stren cli ton eon Bagh oan Aton Aton The pate | Sign oars ef area al comme wane op Ser see wh {utc hy soo co ofthe Mas and SPs Sos deed oper in 2 anh ade ‘moaging er the St Peng of Toa ht aceedel he ai le fe sesso in Rass Ho So March He 1 pro ecerenes ia he cco ‘atl ston wee Manche ‘rand every knowles one RUSSIA. AND AR@ITRAION ORS KARABELNKOV. 39 7 ter Rain nd Slo gractensr and ds rnin rts gp Ad he ah | cst pet an alse Ty srotecar otc, SMe one merewee fr ceil fn” | ent he nt lp em oxen ows Schod of Socal |tobe“Runte eps pin ntermonal | web ada ha wo an ry Fee ‘Rew ihe Rai gr ol | Uae the Cert fie and company LUKOIL reat iin spate | Pr Une He on he rr of a rh Rehan see ares ins pola SOU ESeTecac. | tenminoen Cce sensor vsaaeerascnwnee — [SacwS EMT cain iia | asouteesiore ae nt eee eect eee eee ee ee rece See ee ee eee eer ee eee mee ee ne marta ay | anne en, | Sin ne eet ee eae aoe erree ee ae ee rT Sei eee eaee era neces ae iretataeae Zany ohn ma | anttne Geparmeien Ce | "a clos Me pester Ceerearmee | einen seit | otf ete Ditadonesrestorn [foamvucenancsttepes | Sura icing SUSE tear [Igmemtemrtecemeses | Genoa aticleorn esti Seems ere =e Create oe te sir pte cme | aa Ameristar | sentria hee enn : ‘book Renwgwition ad ewfrcenent offre athimal | Exmpe, which covers 13 jrisdictions i the A Sareea er eee te ee rn oh iiiad Celanese een tan iceman | Soa oe mewn Tee et ‘putes, He son the MAS panel of abiratom__| [VAN MARISIN. 46 ee sepa: cod mm ome “Moscow aod in Stockholi under UNCITRAL | edo of irenional i Nina ikovs See eee } | Snweremg cur in arbitration cases with 2 Russian aw spect. | Fedeeainnt ert of he ICE Irrat Cost bit, ber fhe Chur Teas Anand edonthepe sf atson 4 MKAS Pons dese bet YUADIMIR KHVALEL 40 cn ined Crd Chace Masco otfice_| Sent Rnb ben-knorn fsnon epee Former Bote {20a pmo sare Si os a, | “Sh ale elem ho 8 pomnet o9 ekende cS i thn ade ging fora 200 and | te cafe eu ys oe fryer 205 ‘itor wh Bn Ran, Engh nd Marsan soa prions un Fl, phe een on eration cll Chance wo sppatn te op 2 Moin Ove ene plan nde (Tian Ath appari), a ef ton Coral into Tee 7 ey ert Comer pte at Caer Cone LP in amon ye | ini Cara te Chater Coma oo Soy hp ye an, | ‘yo an etn: Te ie ‘Micasonpacasonrs They ave sted ‘hey Shepp rnin bition “Vilkova reaches in the department of private | shheeisenierrg tem | NOTABLE [ar amuoy 2 | SERGE VOLESON, 34 \ forme tos shape Ratan eo Te Aine emoartings wipe ven ‘Alor deer een and per | arc cou naps nS, \ecladocmeson te sam dat decd sce | toed urns por min ton dell SCC atron bougs 4US compa “Aso ged Cld Che 204, ses aoa tat vena fr Reina ‘con Sic ong un the | writen ing Engh le which he says els | es Rana he rhe i [Us tee hone bre om apove ane ker Meee ony ae fers me tnermanl son pt kd [sR om | Mase LP (now Dewey & Lea a ions by cae es hin ao tie nse Brine Pam La tn ein Afr ht eed Wee Bel ‘ving tack Resi a jing Chabon & "ion ced in arson onder the aly ofthe 1 Itraon Cae far whe comes ieraton bene, ‘nny of Raion ann eb orn Uo Eng nw Thesame tne cmp eve be le thy Ruin coro eterna ron Ieinpoing ix tem ough dee Conan He ashe op Lad ee ‘aun a tou wore dcr op Ld wea che Rian ste court refed enforcement (OLGA ANSIMOVA, 52 terrae nf Hanhaton ip Anions coms to he mame [pet tad hh cy RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION 1 ore tk op foe rs ne Part or he Enon ices wen nding an ero atest pt om “Rasa ve ves” Weners Eup lye, Suing ee oer by Rasa wo ‘out usin py il be ey Mow “She hr td guy ntntons Forbert NASA ht MAS ‘Kroc ond reponse ate wld the teats eo igh quay ale fen Sue LLP 208 er 1 yee ot oder cts LP a Maso: She os ny n> ote coun the Resin somaya Spare os fae he Deatey DYAKN, 31 INosconl mages Drsy Dain hed he Moo dpe ‘tho Lg Lgl Seton 3 Het omer inoue oun Rise ‘hero compen Eero" Mgies it Sevres Dyin ponte ah ainoson od en oe door aed pe ‘owe! uke othe tins LISSA AND ARBITRATION. chert copy a rn, ‘Senbipofsbn s Ueinn oe SUlgeeand aa and exp th xn Mono Moura under eerie Imac on wo nw ign abn nd ‘oo MAS ee YAROSLAV KUMON, 34 tevethaur Beings Fe pacts bah on ml iran Mian tds ere "oan nih Te bce eposig Ra ag oper ‘lng company nope wer LTA Fae sowt onl othe pp ploy "imor exc henner of esto ens fw fu “Doe jel re Rs th lo cote ot ed eed ‘cpr dhs ppm le change fer ny em nase een ore ‘Nie ing a ena ain Fos med Kin ei | eshing bt wirason rb oe ‘prin oan ape of Sete ‘Tiooon ad bi noes cet tl ae Bi Ty wld member af ur tena ee mel a poe Bg ry boy Maco ace Reet ‘lov neo ee Rain ced scnaonal onsen the Yee ‘Neon of he Pee Bacar Deg Inert wit group. aout the corer owt Te pre ‘an ae n Urn, DMIRY KUROCHKN, 37 sur Ieee ct on dpe son He Sto laude Meow Se nae of Inna Rte the Unter of and’ owing shy enn {Be Ceroan inion fron inurl wetan proce et Mas LUA, SCC and ICC radar ‘plone wean nd erent ‘Flign tel aOesapl f Sort haces obining seeing onder rn oy Ni Ces in nn sn atrcon perigee | sloofthe IA acne ane pei eho IEYA NIKIFOROY, 37 = Mesaging panne / Potasoug) 00" Pgenty Alanson & {ya Nikon i fo point abi the Reson fn Egon Papa fae Preps He tbe deed nein ie indo anon mee ‘er psig fo te Schoo of ae oft Recfong Soe Unies he ae ‘Rese Univer He then completes te ICC Inert Ca bei ‘etn ese oa Fig & roams LL Wogan, De Niki lenat expr ince seccniyeoetng Ros pra ‘nol oianon eos ad etree regi acon: Nees Lod. Tian wre mera sie terra ‘nbn nding “ence i neon ane Aon’A Ron Viw and ‘New bean fe Lol Pome DOMINIC PELLEW, 37 Downe Plea Eng nd French sid praconee ho rely ree Now (199 0201 a hn Ps He 9 ta 7 he oe Eel LLP a ened Farell Croup, wd by Resin econo Peli Ren pe cig ints nero ean en se ‘Net em merit eden {dor whee te aon ete, en edie Bo ape Meso and Ms ‘Ste anf ners oa ‘Prec atone in Mone “eoagh Rest em oe rng insoonn Lado Sen oe {rel drt or ver ca ot here “ncn pd we hy MKAS oe conc {don rove ecu tars He ‘Sheer go MAS ll big psc ONES TO WATCH FRANCESCA ALBERT, 35 secon, She nary promising ema! Engh oie kegs bo pct don td Toye sion 0 her est ‘adhe bro ad ater use ‘ST Arbirtion Sh ah worked on resent ‘Sern not me ys he Iie f the LCI reer asin Inde eps to he Reson sen ‘ein te deg e+ ace [in spsang wbabosimyer oe pound Maco She beady corte pent ha her cla an ge TE footw ato pte’ Albers gt LLM programmes oe sect of eg dct vesneneo Que ‘Ucinan Minar of es he Roppongi ALEXE| DUDKO, 31 RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION Aron soot thre pc ement 2 Raman copay stows re puch saat bin sate te edn opts econ ed fr more comes es, Sh "Ra eo ean te see om Io "The SCC ase pp fs te LIA {9 1CC we teconng are meped Rnsan pres eapropl ater wo oen fom cig Sr and no lng el wc ‘sg lhe two he ako worked a MKAS bore jning Lint in 20, Dado we tre sive fee nthe Nenad he {he GO es vey to ctor ‘coming ore auc on he ieee ‘coun occas un the rls a the SCsthe LSTA a the MAS, n son {GUNCITRAL and of bons Hi jon dlr x depute He wea oe of | head oon une UNCITRAL | evceny RASCHEVSKY, 30 | th Kaige Ob, Rtn encine Ran ompy wor eng ce de ee ‘As air who cy bad Eon cue sey al ‘sistowe cote el come, lt ee joel Ylor Koy are 208 an ese he leit a ‘Sache pd aun i ohne a nernionsl ton, Th wok ety ‘Gok hime London fron aan conde senna ie po e+ nds Rosen uke which ne ep ‘nme in he poplin sa ‘nnn "Tor sie he SOC whch 8» lot pus fom he omer Soviet a {nan compass aps Rasen. TATIANA MINAEVA, 34 Cave le pal coming ncn of ae the worked a the Moscow ofc of Clon {Che Ec Hematae Naes ae Duele and at kaon Pres Mono sine the dee incor tan, She tr reprocend pare unr he aor sn Commerce he SCs nnn fo MEAS bers Te etme her epee ie ropeng he May of Engr of owen me srs ropden i USS talon wae sbowt suey agement RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION, PARTICULARITIES OF RUSSIA-RELATED INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION ‘Many of the assumptions about how Russian corporations react during arbitration are no longer true. By Richard Chlup of Mannheimer Swartling’s Moscow office he won Rast ke see Rosin lesan ame antennal | Ther at xpos of oun Tings in ‘pec suoisom: The sronioms | tenon animal cou sper dt Se one dew or expe wth er [sometimes app oatcnton | Bon a ayo doen se | compas Sane ownen oes happen le Reaute ompice orice quan = | commer coure Thi urempon may cleat beth fourden he ree company. Scher its pone peror “noma, | pote che eet ofthe hein | mayne enn 0 2 he yey ed Emopciesnk)sbirason non itn counet— | ic hey mya tl el eben he cmpny he 19 ‘he saver = te owed ston wat” compan the ocd 9 Jes te | wih he saeco ether the ints mmc eben wrk | Some one ips ferns ty sigs en Fesoied e Landa Partha ataon ‘Sm dato sat eco borne ‘ork pesirmed in Rms oer ade gn |The wie” intratioa aeain in| acres ut woul epee una in youssmmentar mel surat ticaion | When eating othe" Cire | becurfammai ot apycih ta SonkxnceWhielener om Poli the | anton ob aa mind aly sacety | Rae hai rg a he xy 10 tthe very (Ch Repub crater Cone! Euvpee |g compan esporvorin 04 work on | dilate tht re cancer aes Scone brome mpi up| he gl mur The compury ideas, | wh Ren are Secale ae fctoocer foo Raa inbred th somewhat ol dpe aon ed wien ‘rove sor tha ne Cova Bogen lee | int amber ef co ited? The nrc sly", Risa ac —_| atten, Of coune auch wer exit in Rusia, | deforms of evsence~ ae documen ewes een nd boning econ: Hone hy fo en equ | wine apr —then the eo open bnens nota outs Ronin” Wan Sophy more Hy | eqn eyes Rann pare ‘han snd uy bey se nt append. | bled net ong igs gl wi fane | Commerc cous Raa pry wil expe ‘Wah hema vpn nd Wepre frm agencea aflame | ht winner ae not ct en mach Ireesing planes ofc men he | harks ee epee afconet Ronan | rey ere Th npn sree Aino bean ning ey Ronin gen howrcy hi geceon au | kan supe Ran ere A Eaope Fone eno ger ee ning nora enemiveenpone to tenons | company fr exe wll apc Sa the ‘pond in coer They aren loner the | an smn wagon nse cour Hoa cnn of epee wih a employee ol gn win ony tet csespe fom | the ther han th compay ea emer tate —| my be ajc to wes esinooy Bur Becase fer colgonosbinattwie ecw on | ane empany ad wor ones og nc | Roman ple has ney eo at Segre weed gi thom ond apt acer the lade experienced igh | ein oly wht in ing + Rain pry clement ine courte neuro oa Accra ay atone Ferd sobecone tect td ake | aioe Know ay ne ve me of the ants of wera ‘A Rist compan gow het bbe ovwionding hs gros eens | ompuniee Daring th ly 1990 Europese there roma oe pce of Read he sand peepon ws ‘evenna wbinaon tat arte 2 ony were ob men wth encore dere steno techy wea ey ht mot enw tc cits ware na ince in minty ‘gma niet Thich ds oui ery el be hen by opi to fn te sniong Renton lps ep nly documents spe by peso toned there be sorpan tot ener Thetremesaronpe moms |esaperince ina |S th ol se Shem ec mbsene patciin’” |peetgioncfcr twins pases ore” | toe mond sie Rem Stir ocnistom’wes’tom te [fuse cinder omieoes Toy sneond_ | Spee ley Sp np Scccomper own whch wr skosaned —|Sarekowr worng psain | Smt jh emo ne ne with che prospect of international arbitration | ‘not ahways aware chat any e-mail ca be used i RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION stron anil aye cet y | abt Bing ae mac polematc Fulles | aks Momeer soning seba 1222 ‘sand eibnd i doeanentry eee! | tothe commerce snot pete and MAS Rul thet fr ey oe 2 counengen nay br ecese en dclawia | arent of clam ep 30 das Ths pte ‘Unmet Kesey essed Reon | Spey | feces dear Ts ne a become res wemetiesind oe pie hat be | "One sou at be amare wt ots | rena or gn par fe pgs af Semen ani iin opis ujncan | eben amon en ‘he aston that wt e-mail was peer reece | hus ae of aver 25 per cet ofthe cmmanys | tat Mowcom th eto the bacon ‘olla ul yeild nor ncessry so | ae eget come ofthe hale? | Ge on 221 MAS alo ks ppene Inswertoaoieon Wor ping te ecpon th ome ean. om the ls dh he psy hl orgy cd™ wc ip Rusa one "rl ay eon with Russ | Iria ns aire aon enon caer coors may awning cnn latin |_| pan wher the uding comet we | te heme of eps mee a Irma abieion we 3Tom of ey | aly ccc fey se sng Fis, | prope by he sheen te see ihe spare MEAS ce One sald be Formas in Reson leg ate 1 Trgmey sacri ot el TDlueoemtsin coe ogo Pcimglintjareaenacac” | Russian law has arco nasi ELSuSioiSiemtraenge | a very narrow ee ny a a fet ‘Sree erate ty concept of implied | Shrine fata wks Runs toh Hees i apecaficcurtote | authority. One should | fr ema ccsRacip ai, Sgnymeeromtetere’ | therefore be aware | Simmer mavwlintons ret that authorisation penny fnaphat methane ad Representation asd authority iy Resian law and evidence of ‘w inhereatiy unfit This syminecry nevertheless Seip one sitiwtotae cing | authorisation has Wi Nrescw eater aes CoubFetankcsteesivamedae much more practical | aAmte ee cee rms tie font had no athoriy And cone eae | importance in Russia Syren | than one would ten De mea ied aon. gh ace 2 sn okey Alough ch son expect in a Western | ter eommon hind gy Binge ‘Sich effete Cel Coumiay | jurisdiction The mer ya kan a ‘Sogn di ry ye fa | men Onn ene ol of Kong cep Tp ofp me Sonpiatsopee cane gh | ‘Fhe Cth Ra tee ae feretepvton taped met _| Abana html Commer | Sette eaten ey ESceinguionacotwnd yan ch ue | Aine Gena ose ris end ec eamnner corny aloned brie omer eae | Whenepng ersten oc | teeta nan age ey “Shoton otha meied per sfscrng) | smctins were Rus of | tea cama Rete cate ‘Tome mon Omens ene” | cir Conmerl teen Car, | place brecbes rsp Winn tembonsse ndcrsacret” | miecor BAST coche cecal | Sete Santon s cy eae to station ix mah me paige | again eracdariwrtas case” | shefoae ad senha eo he ‘sRonamonrenascowaicen | Mise aiiusoncacbrcnilaels | wists pueeto ee este joc ten owed hi rs Noon) Fey lps Taw me In abdon co sing tate pson | the apace he MKAS Rr | Compr fp Rus go er eg he eon pl sien ac os tor, | oe sill be awe fee ening | hese alse he fhe hs tobe an fein mis of | on ac in ph, | me orgy cry miogement ch can | Atte out ne all ver anit | Aiton wot in Ru ei hree test our orth chare otc lw Ace» 21th MKAS Ral whi the fue | haere by incesing tn Reon ‘ode cher and other compeydoamoens | pues we te capes 9 MAS Th | hon ncn! wean sel ee Held commer gir Walcot gantcd_| grvson is ed om te rapecone rvion | ligne oe a ol a pre eon {SEU coun bute Be wana n| Rar ino ieraoral bron Hong, ss Inain, the FUas2 sone | sed ha one sel not be cred by the | Rin! Cp a f he hii od igo ted or on at the corner mgser | exten asf este se MAAS tht | pa of Meier Svong Roe thes consign to pen is does nx pce he aes ro chosing | tru Hs a eB Cary Snpanfem- ws Kusan comps nc_—_| arr of hing Gxtnn 3 fe MKAS | the Conk Re RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION. THE EFFECT OF PARALLEL LITIGATION UNDER RUSSIAN LAW International arbitration remains somewhat vulnerable to tactical litigation in Russia, reports ‘Vladimir Khvalei (partner and head of dispute) of Baker & McKenzie Moscow office T: sR repuaion egy rt te san of pate, “with pte overtones Beaute of Ohi eign fier wh yap ig "Ther ance cpr ep Sevlanecon the comment see Rito hing fe 158 Nee tere to Roman coe and ‘wiki be ed yan nena onl of er dese yt Fro owe tht ep dos ot ay wok ‘Epa wine come by wel eps Se th eps and how itd ge Rs ‘hig uc th New Yar Comentn, ‘eve qutone "Why won {Tear ny coca pb ne ‘Sore rn wea om ether She mje of hi ade Ashore seer (erumdracod he bt cour of Rau) do ‘ice sgn ed od poste newer uo era Lea ‘eat vor unbinsit s mai of he abration agreement Inprnpl he Rei cour ae Sound by "ipa fo eh NewYork Comon {hc Eaopen Coenon om temas Ti Coa Se coe inser rf ep ema ner i men pea tr ka Fesrecfowt ‘a id ti pa ‘eke A well-dratted arbitration agreement together with the reliance on the commitment assumed by Russia on the signing of the 1958 New York Convention appear to guarantee a dispute won't be referred to a Russian court CCmeganding prov cn be od in he Cade i tr Proce of te Ran eben For eampe th inch cout Sha iore semen faim nb sh don pep nen 4 dit beer ae pare ihe ame ge mace an yon ene ‘birth Pevelr ‘easier Gt spat aon {cites the ee eng ted bye ‘nck cour ding ofr bel th tthe ee oh il ou nee promenade ipthe ‘incapable of big permed ocle sy + hina ne pe ine pte ‘reat Gs beng i ce on Fr San te set tc ae rakslr bcs pee o ap of ing peste rece 0): oF 1+ arated aad hs Ben sted in 3 dpa ‘hint core dota wre ‘ern etre he tls! ice ioich, So dope cea ik of cootntion in gr eamp ie coe ws 0 {erm ad ce cacy a wor ‘Se eal oi fr exalts spp rein eens ether pry hk ‘Beeqesed ee nous se dpi fi code in grea = thee no dul at these rl yep he tes come incperse ocpe f be ened eae op, ough ch 2 RISSIA AND ARBITRATION ry in ny afer ceed ia being | Sic nhc ce the marty scholer she roscto ht iti a bon by e ocicnding the eng nce ch tar ee ead Sy termes ‘eve ofa inermon! enone Sos Ar shee cout fot tape 4am aon yo treed pari" ing ow ote NewYork Conenson nd aged rain fn heangech ape The Cl Cle a te een Fees the Etpen Coneson on Inerasnal | eee oh ep hat indo tl n pier ston oa the Commer! Aion, ecordace wh he gener rey the ash Sonera anya al ead ye Fornnglen one ca he pene | Cou nar thet fhe esta company. enmson my be tought ay tere ‘elanh Cou ofa stoi ss eather es wel eae hat yay" Grail 1662) He "ieee ‘menfreaeanarinano ape beeen | feign lsc ede inept ofa‘ te nt bes pry th coe 2 asm company nds Sin campy fat | sumacon tt weer aa he an hema ed ye ion seu any anda ener nee bite | ian cour wile wanes runing recent 8 Gr eats ey el sieht’ The arcana alco pepe Zoe ea rb el pate pen pc perme drs om ged ‘teh Raa ey i | rap asl pr foo tore wh prance nna Indeene of wee of fro sare abe ee Thie agpach ped te | elu ween an atoning chang i Sorin soamued ty hepeoe” Sie A Coan en | ener ate ‘May 20s Ne 20770) oocyte Sopeme Aries Cure The viene of ete Rai ot een nner few ke | Bea vl pole wn one dso, (Gpe sen hr pac poly has een Imumtfaif ech ye | ang 2 er ke irene a ‘cepa jeeson ecenere | ead aad isomer mes | Shoal tbe kn ial ef rem the “lé Sees” | ccemeeeaenee | oe (ctr af Renn see core mode tj re pe RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION PROBLEMS WITH OPTIONAL ARBITRATION CLAUSES In certain types of agreement, Russian courts may refuse to uphold optional arbitration agreements, writes Alexey Barnashov (counsel and head of dispute resolution) from White & Case's Moscow office ‘en Rin cour onthe pte oe ‘not le! ker ween a ey -impernnce king tr t Sky he neti epee ecm een at it ey ening Sr mun li ny ed In 974 by Fieri Eran cer got ike ICC enrol Car of ont cate tema feel | Vt abnor he a tere ‘Smt fe yy ‘se rn bin pe) in Sec ancy amore tymaiee | shown p12) thea aesen cement ny peg Oi em ape as Seton at Se Rr 8, "eke met a on ot tt Townes stein etree | ‘fected rr roa ‘est pono nd = FScpur to ion wh he patie se rt pane pel Many jurisdictions now uphold ‘optional arbitration” agreements. Although there is yet to be case Jaw from Russian courts on the point, at least one legal thinker has written that they are impermissible, making their use risky pon how: bron ws nd ‘econ wade pte rad in ‘chi ny ered byte pce ‘fete nero wich pgs he tefcce sould be ie om ie bps ingot wes ae the shen meng oe Foca, ad Goll, op pa 78) ‘Ad iat tht oral our foe count Panc te United Kango die Une Serer among he do sec op the wy of ch nas As one Fah aut or ad at eo pe Beha he hing thoi ine ihe “ance iin omni i ace ‘Spe depress nachna fd yeah pina ro cles syd growing in popu tere of th taney ascent math ce cl el be bet ose ek Fr eco oe pe ere roe uy oye ine {Gul be nderned fr -nk a egey Inde 1951 «Geman om cn {loners cone) lied nati Saige th ted at sition” Foch aint el, op scp a8) Ferthemor: hen te apn ten ‘ote pry deca won Feng sce ne ey ny ope "bt th oer fr the oe ‘eae ene onda” oh, oad Golan. op ct ore 48 no 13) te tases toh opto bieon| reer depeaigon i ep of cera ns competi Wits ober parce ‘he eng coun ugh te Scrbed ‘The sin leg content ‘Therese es fw ip Rus ta ‘betel iw and dome ge That Sidi oy sin ie petion Steg rks, Rams ceo’ abo eee over legiicn The min erat oy pring RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION eee ene a Serta eer eaters Sete ec ere coemre mia sien aate eee tee cee eee ae eee pee eee ese ere ee arcs nore oe ees Seer ess ‘Sau ope pone soreoeh paren rte sega Star ee emcee etme enone er Scherclpralecana torent Sevincg eae erecta es ee [ee eet a fee ee Counc, eee ence emeenee ee pe eo otee nasal ee eeoeennees tt] cee | fo tire he etna he jin Jute meine ugh, KAS dco a KASS eel yb eld yen ‘Sy etree to met RAS, ace avg the et ep ry ‘aero oe Ie Karabelnikov specifically refers to financial deals between a Rusian borrower and UK- based banks or financial institutions, where the lender reserves the option to sue in the courts in England or elsewhere ‘A eg ory terse commer askieton su 9 yr ey dele a ‘Rs psig op ~ pecan bg econ gtlon djs ‘se ome prey the mee ade ‘Solin wth nthe i seve ‘cele ude penne! (vies ‘Reacher oars roc depen earth ps eral bs depron: eke Sop rbinah Cour te Raion Feder er or need jes dems Once plsedin ow ora ad oe ‘ere preeaoncol become ernie ene bn, “The vil he oon arbieion “Tre flown ote diet ‘bron se hc clade doe of ‘ng a i abe of ‘npr se hep adc earn pons ye ‘pet et Tes pipe on tps oli pe te ‘ly ep open re pn aged eo nt th eta sf ec Few Sat a cn eer 305) ‘ise ea member athe rach nd aos dt he Supreme ich Cure fhe Ronn Feo, Toe Che of eS peng choice Bewesn ‘arabe core) eed wily ‘Tectia to pid een a Scents For ean non ase 9 asin ‘hued th ie pes ad led eo pe were tht th bri che thi ace ip a nd aA ‘ed itn Cee Chace ne al ny of Rian et (Ce fs Fade ‘ei Sia por a ‘ean feed ry ah ae few ng ea tb (feted ana Cote he In destin ht he cae wt rere be ‘ena juaon vibe cing exc in mether cartes coer wid cof the MAS: sa ins ee where he i ele ned he abi ‘Sech Gaerg enn r epi eC ome hi a at fe py fats Coase “The con came othe coho ha he pao {na owas pen ere ‘my 20). i sd pete ‘Taemcend yp gig an pin been {Mb nd tse cour) ouch mae roe eo il cle what ise ied upon in Poteorito txbook sihcgh een me Karbon} “mmeriry on the NewYork Ceo he fe anasto ean wh RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION itn oma tthe opal | lar Kh nae estress | ARIEFO'S WHOLEGAL. Moweamendct Svbion nd te cour yb el ly coring Arie" Comesng_| tape Rs hw tse Set al pie magnon nang | ny Sa 0 92) on rye | ae pay San oe nara men ‘en wees op Sos enon Comiy Sn snty | pas nein ei ee eteenasmpefic tas | en oben pn ks —_| Engh ashe ging i ath aration | fun efe | semen sc she Newer Convene wil rhb Ast |p vo Ran | rot | lw muming a pl ton een | Senate | Fess ht al word Professor Yarkov’s Ty ttc dartenersteoteerer | DOOK indicates that | | | “anne, on the one hand, and UK-based banks oF Russian case law does {international inca ans onthe other not recognise the \ ‘thre eh bao lene nares Be oon Saeinerdecptoringeesaeiaie” | CYpe of clause that \ ‘The International Who's Scometoaaeerartom etn | allows for selection | we af Busine Lawyer Set gs art! see ho eer the commenceeat of bien eign of arbitration or ‘Using 11 years of Sade eee state court, as independent research inert bcm or | Pyle aatascrt ala of seg cope (Coorong pat thr ten a arbitrate reement to \ review of the world’s seep Se Kb “Ea | leading private ‘Tita Sel a practice Inwyers Comeertnac SSN Ce | sence fea Carvirncae iearsos” | pecmments mm re 2 nine prac cece c! teers ras ord sie ects en that R || Oe 850 of he wre Simtgucatamtemementy™” | heethtacts melee tengo pathogen 13, Sook cel eras the arene eg acgetnped nas |Seeecaeman tarts | Jeon Eteestrmyonenn ase” | mraccaecsn sara | cone aoe SEE crate | pate eeepc profesional boris mich” _| th apts wie Gem cme |e beng ened Rory icy of | is win te exe rien of Ran | Ali tie nen art No.28, 2012 | couse stow vr ef iw augheimbe || To ardee a copy please | ” ‘hosen=arlogwauch sche permed | git the bookstore at i swww.whoseholegal.com RUSSIA AND ARBITRATION RUSSIA AND THE ECT: THE UNPLUMBED DEPTHS OF PROVISIONAL APPLICATION ‘The provisional application of the Energy Charter Treaty raises tricky substantive issues, says Sophie Nappert. an arbitrator at 3 Verulam Buildings, London cdo ‘Source aan pine poe wth Ue ed. nn cen ds inv on fg ent np nai, A whch vines orn oo ‘a onopto ie epi re ed ‘Etc hn ey cy pedi i a al = nf pant and 8 ied y he ‘Rissa potion wer th egy Chae Tey Tse ay dat a nena fing Te en ree, ‘inna Pn, mete penton foes, Sate ae nor pnt coding de pet ‘our wavs wake Earp Uni ne ‘Shey soe Bt we denen Cher ems Song in Ron nce tad te ee There ep howe te Bore heresy sllow lr pstorl sppewon Inia 1 ctx) Aah icon the ciued non weeaon ‘eee ty Rams pes tin sume | ston which wll 90 Sui toned i ee ‘eon poccding aed got Rei by ‘hes naj shells Gro Mewes ‘ley Ente Yar User nd etn es xe ed pin sm ae oak at qveion ried by ‘Rawat pvr ppston of ere | an Kaper Cin ih some ft iment 1 other signatories [nse deco on jain Tr cathe eb ow hat The aay orto spin by Ceunga sec time | The Eno Chcer Tay the it bn Si ap ere wh ets feet fetus ping th Fle 15 noc dos prove an tin of Fw ti cs igh eel th The 2 asethe Rodan “pono ay Aah enon be ‘how estan oe mscpa sod (ater the te inte pct on The concept | of provisional | application is absent from article 15(4) of the Constitution Article 23, however, of the 1995 Federal Law on International Treaties of the Russian Federation specifically recognises the provisional application by Russia | of international creates ifs0 provided | by the treaty or by agreement with the rramet ned at promod an pein item cry a py tan eset. cn of sd coca lyr minding Uae a he Eu nh ied 2 ‘Sgutoy ate which ve no rae the ery tn, rn ln ro Nowy topical fre Ra orion te ay Hing ped ino nc st er eneey Trt Vena Creation) agi be orape ot posal pation Gee 8 SLA way povatny sped where ‘rl thon oor sceion ose {say minder rape ‘Seine polo oer oben oe ‘Conon, avon sus at apron Jeplyng1 coe were min for Ie a wok df he objet nd pape they expen the co bbe Arle 35 ofthe Veuns Coneton pos rcinay png oy fre) ‘heey men pir he nepaaing ronda yb rae semaine (ne re 252) om Canon his Cmeon ‘ovional apfeaboe of atc, which ek Sake sect othe oe pri Tse "nme tron apnon bene RUSSIA AND AR@ITRATION, Article 45 of the Energy Charter Treaty (0) ah anys ly iy realy png sry fo ach 3) Any ay mein iia "omy neh te $4 he tpi of oe Tyan nn pg 3) er a 10 he ‘ha th sil api seins” ro at han «Cig sp a ef he ey ee ‘ri retin Ir as Port dee Tm of ot ween ‘pi jr ons hal ee pen 2) (9 Nesta pga (1a try texan of yom he att (9) The aos of te Seria hal ri ot ‘sig oe he psy cht ten fan df he ot hin a poo Sri ea ‘elo rtm te pin! apo ‘evar it fr fray pt Are ‘opto The iui ena spe 8) ih wea haa ey mer nd ent of Seta. (Gat tpi ser match spina tai np he ‘vin An ch ty may ty hi of ay mer ong (Tet sh nn wt ‘tt dei ton tion he pty re nd th rap ny enki te pense) Derate ‘Mi dn ig ited pnb) goa pga er (2) Ne sign ich eo eteten ms of er ice al mesma” ee pial See rf ec ‘soon np) tienen et rete hefty we Comeng Pas ar fe 4S ay ‘csr ayn he bus ofr! yar lig a fe ae often eras mee den Bye oe sl ‘penn ae ge (2. ‘ote pi aga tet nif ey (0 Nomi pg ay 1 su) sal cp amy sina mang «eon sity Hed Aes 14.4 ital eA Regi Bot ‘sumer hal apy PrP roily df ese Dt eer ip hy at tig ey ate te ew orc he ps of me see cd eT a i Sy eae 4h te “al pig Fg ey fs he ‘el pis! open ie wc (4) Ping ae ny in fe f Thy tt fee ig fey ar iran oat Sutras hl et pea te pine — se ‘coining eat cuomayintrnuind bot Arile 52) ofthe may poids h | ina aoingo ht sdpted ‘The tbl weston, hog ooh heresy ste with oppor eda, | Kean sole te a fice pace to pnenea goer apes inate rte fearon boat the compet of eqied nseauing of wha sionnry he Wace pevond appro, Pane fo | beens of es essa an a fae een preps 2m. ipl pct Sc opel pe Provo pion ane aici 4 [Ruths reper decent | da ye arate ale 10) the Ens Cher | on apples son sponte wo gen Trseckapuony ste ogse yp Se | noes con ene rin” | The“ excepn hain we cat povonah pening nyo freer | Spin Cn th Eengy Carer | ul ape of se 1 fe omer cheng tet gues, de een tht | Tray pple Rs wh he ‘epn e,which soe tpona prorat nonin ith she Gamer ik #8 ‘epee mut ot be cont! wth the scm en om The_| "wth tng ph ing | pny a ese po Soe nich ecu belo Themen nt epg) | aol a ne eying pid of Carer Tey poston bercea Deceater | pre nye he The g o ate 4 on be inept io ans oyna cen Ape Saperstein | incon oe ag a ie ‘sate hal expen decd ta wa umble | ytti tsea Soxhteae | econo poe appeon min at foaply he ety pronsoly Aer Apel 198, | fir ms i pee Uetcomaeee wih ese el proto pean wa itd the Stewindr dni Spree | the neg Charter ea asters tr eat a ig or od he ‘hee mutes ewe mh emery | mt note ncn ih ene for | ears c | pv ra ie Th Rata he scaon poetite ‘he ead lon tte "The dele reve of Rais inert mene wh he nedtan of ake mn 2 eu 2 law rcpt hen he pe a Sojcreo the Sn Doms 1956 Penerary | ict In ision wo coe Roa ‘ating pn 998 ber the Duns posed The wun aka and at poder ite | lw ahead pee eto | Sikeaton seal se new of mepestins | thing wel the dems esepsa Bxs_| the pon speaan a wens The ‘a digemenscomneced wih he wens | he bade of proving piston nd ter» | Conca af be Rasen eee sg ‘nic preeal etn eons a Ee charge | th endo ei pte ccs ‘Be burden rook ‘stuarl naes psn ose PUSSIA AND ARBITRATION. bs ee tn icon co he Feder ‘Aven (he Stic Dun and Coun othe Felton acer 1,105, 1 abet fom aie 150) ath Comeon bony rly sept repr rl of ‘esanal a ernaonal seo he Rin Feo eae tng prof {Be Ruta lp pecs Arie 2, ower of he Rusa eden pecs eco he Feral spon by Rea of etn trees to whch es pga ried bythe ay or by peneoc a ober spate ‘Piemonte opto {sly fed yon se ke SB Raia tb aed eh ane 4 mater ofa option fe deca, pe th no Despised ney neo iv" fee dct pra 10, Then ie wey ‘onicon by» pany pa fon ‘Rvme pon ol pete and un on dope emer) fhe ay Fens apeson and hee persion Eline prt eat wm btn oe ‘son prea 212 319. ‘The ngs ae (it be he en on ter Coe Moly nesses, pa 23) ‘inti bereen porto sph tele 1) an 2h the ay. ‘A es de gh beeen the ‘ion bund oem he amas ‘acne odgoet Me ice Wakes tise Marea arn tame ser nes Compe | pene eee ce ‘ig he ening rr choo pani never Nav Sy bane! Baar 419952 | "Hon the en comet ecg fore been de on the be imporance af Leg Rep 39) tc evn se oes within | a in commci h soie Wer Sjalpyenworcrdsth prtetr— ee cey ae ell cel The apne | stn, do the aramid dipwte in uncon sce he curt har fr the | of feang ro prem denn om | ty sh Acs netelae topes dgment fete seed bent hy gues of | Sapa of ane sane hat wel) shen ican ree seer jac | tae dmc vid made gsi copper orig sean and how tabol| fein al cue seco wil ony ma anodes gute eth comet of fap wan, cae doses ieetjoe and convenes” dove jecioa 0 of | The prance | nope wae onal 2 Sapreme Cou Ac 18 hn pai hardls he Mob eed Th USSI2 ition ening nde ‘The wide Marsan ote cag | seman cpr of him anders gace geroed by | iene nal in conection wth dameic| Het‘ and coment neuen tha PDVSA ol gn mig cou proces whe ce company | Pte ppc wm elie hii" ExonMllit parison abe aploain | suena etn fw, On aceon | andconien™ia th scams mk the Crm Nero ese Orinoco Ble ough he gh cour wl uc tlc | the ony cnn 3 aft See Cove ct Un2007 wer ene raced meses | waning” wore ction i a of__| 6 Whee th oto the ate bc EssonMbl os ona he ew ol camps the Co jrcceon an Jama Ac 1982 (8 lj nl comeence men he sce nor nga aerave argc h | appenene by Onc fn Camel. Seon 25, | wild show tat thew a el th Veo nce nme tea poeran aon a= th cor my ise | Eng nd Wa Th spss mh uy ci apa neaca andcnmmened ICC | toga thf tat kw jrcisan | montane fr nang tha he pendent FREELING ORCERS Assith any Gesng onde peat | sont! othe Mca hi requemene | youl ron with igen se, whet mace Seomrne ot trea eak | dura ae ‘Screspoe lalvshors presence nore Fino of ee wht re Ie tngnd Athos eer ar rae ee Sowne coda wlan eo smcarby he | Mak PDVSA mtbr for eases peri that, ‘Etninc acolo econo chou | The are eis wo can which ke | he au comida he ul oo on ‘ernie theo cone tte | Engi eae ae comet the een’ | nim joe reo epee Signe. oneafesng ne jut md meen A_| oft ctinn vos 49) 0 ‘cae wo the Nien cure ponies wekemg ancl sean wll | guns wee Eig orden of ‘Alnogh Mal cere shoving Torun the making ceingeier‘nea, | uegn anton Ind te prerbed | oes et had ead {Mowe beak tte mpd wil | helen on cae where notdwige | cate af con api PSA shore thes obese ner urnl sod oper eine ne Sen dein por! | or snmouning yah ce ard. ‘Shami pupae enpaing te cious fos gion unr con 28 te Cl Aura nginsom the eter in {ai eters we Jinn snd advent Ac 1982 oeong, | PONY cal iy eg vo seg "Ast with ay en or he ‘pec o the conan in whch he, "anareraon” poly of he Veneaesa srpinet wn ts mnt ononenae 2 | oa mateo gr mle rena sol | goreaten poe eno eto i {Geos neon te mT eof been J. ‘Sapean of anc, or een, ae Bare wiles rine cunts menmnt Nowy ier Jeon a whee exe on ure ao fied Fre Ml ws tice and coments mar Sad Altes pope oer wl dr coast) uh wk a Eagan an et Stn Ey Us HTT EWCA opments | kee ot oe ee a for ieed wa he en epee | emesent nor apap to mite th ne. at 2— ep" {ved ont be saree weer The second hdr ie apie so umount | epee wr 25 hol ae phy we iNovem he oat that econ gohe mene uae apd omvenence™ | The obvious concen tt ths fone cay feces fm he sour fton 3 th Sapene Cort At 94) and | ar rer junc ee i eon ‘to wating er perma oe the “grpiene(eeton 23) the Akieason | proving aking le ebewher.prcay ‘itmal-w noel ry be eed Gcion | AE 90) en sppheasonn wpe of | whee the oponset eden nd "Nayefiteaicadon Ae 96) thei sgn aaron Th ppc comune | jon tt he ak of orig neem cou em gor not cal acnkt | auth ean th armen dviory | econ te atin at an ord [rine protetanofcrne or ase fach | Comme on Arist Law pened in| pace od ony PVA sr end 1 Tasg adeno i oy tere | spre euary 1986 de sapemenary | folie no proces or eprtions ip Ean tec npn ene oraeeesch at | pref ry 197 {nd Wis wa fod tor ose Usoing hls afnormaton oie In detuning now be old eae it | cn sy bak oi Shevtete pened ota sere coral | diction We} examined he san the | Se ay nd he ‘is tCidon St Roa Fly La fama] Cone Appia she me ef Rple | pao ws tho gt fhe eon SLR Syn he comet oa fetung oa, | of Hat Dar 1D 20 whee rbd | won Mahl eek enna he The sppcmcnc ato unpncy walmeotiy the wie fering rset ral | Susy whee POVSA ad ee ball fac 1 ptimct on tee bigs soe ok ht the | ae" a Ct Sede Te» Ct | wee bated ‘aon wil aj esac erie | [008] QB 1H whe indeed tc cing | "The ering rer red pint PONSA ame er pile begat hve” | wa erin npcdee the Engh cor ‘Sure athe ste vee the oe ed; ae ee fun th aes company at Hl 3 li ating eitoin nin Mla Cad Capt» Usa and On| ht PDVSA bef ave eer nde ew (Me. Boe] WLR Hobos kamen. | ttn one och phe The de “Fre thd nd al nde egies she pant | sors of condeton 19 Behe india | er ma pub and der {Soul cathe boson nag epience ich coed pimpin | cea atts cate eee ho “Secjnserits pps the ofcamty aay hee of wheter” | Hower old be ewe ren se ‘eet 3) ofthe haton Aer) eng orca be eficed war one_| Can oll be ee or he ong ‘ins wth tet horde he pleat ome bee ‘ier wen en ne, coupe “pnt snk we he jr "Tne cs demons tn ngs heh eto m Boe ch red ager pene femal su Acs pel |courtsboul ni een fe doaeton © ane eps» welee min dt he Eg hhc inti ance ofsecepl sama, wonide being cre aS reg) aur eae he net cae rent iow tata docs che onan he ponder the Spates | comeing he longa jetta, They Souc lost inde usicion she ft sutedy song nk th the radon or | wend oder ner nine wh onal walnut icnppepeae ere | chow ne ee tron sng | the cours fhe be wt nd he mpeg ‘our gant et | ets peceeng inthe sence fs Hots | pitino ects Tech no ory heh iJ eterna dete appeach | These cee deco bl acege spleen woud need clara veh bee, [heidi emcee whee the batie”| prem serpin 0 epeiguncion- evelyn showing th the etuaal—| rocedngs we aie oben. Shopping sn ng plan oe ng [ito poucor smile fre ime tenets | PDVSA might he bowser» | Court een whee te tne al comet seca econ #40) ofthe Arbon | aetna ka Nos Lal—_| wih Engng bce yeaa [Asbo Whew thespian in sonerson | EWH 17S (Coma wich he aur | amot ewer alt we ‘than aitncon hr bare semced "|e ade nnn re nde eon | wing object oro pa vege Sri whch he an uno yet eer Adan ce 8m caoneton wd | apt ee aera MORAL DAMAGES: A CRITIQUE OF DESERT LINE An ICSID panel appears to have added a new element to the formula for moral damages. By Meriam Alrashid of George Washington University mre uf nese Dates (CSD) Yrs Abie Award bce ere in nh de -Ovtr nc ape” se L Febru the lero Cen fre | ie ket emComercl Cait The | hint elo Tc rig iter mucosa or mon danugs theca = nea ut ns ier Weed | nk lo feeble 3 Ona ety Dee tine Pec LLG ‘énenss pre euttndngtlines owed cer and equ event Coney ining tar Yren hal aed a viion | be conga fre comple ad poe grovent ed colt al Oe eet ‘forecle ofthe Biter mesentery Boh pr apt oe vay che alain al a nn Dee Teeveen he Sulla of Oman neon avr Dene ine oc ning conti Ue Poe cane angst apn os The USE ron wo! ws uns won| nse alin cure | fan bel tr os ‘mana cond conte of flebaxe | smlimere Manu eon tren hehe nye # yer pn on ly hepa oF Yer! reese ges company peonondl Yer sme pasate pty Orin sr dies he an ‘ni rss, See SID Cae No ARB/US/17) | Yeas my prise cen ng the | Rese penn md ag ci Montage ein mit pte | arf Dt Lie re ene, ng tense yn CSID bral an eny | Atmnin ree prope ode | The ebunals ting ne evans acason Int © Binoy depute wth cnn toashstencne | The nal eed Yes eerion ht he nga ICID Teel ged mol mage:_ genenr the Oca lene agmcment” | “Ouatereleen agree charged Reel 1 ARBV77/2, 18 Albough eer | ther eur icing righ the sie econ that the meen ed a esa nou ac nt tindag peloton ecg | tak Deine Pca preted apt | fom fred cee nego ICSID cam Der Lanett oy athe thea ropes yng ty wee uc | men ed w ano eral abi ‘col can osm anrdaf mon! rage tat” pops spent poe ethan hfe sve De Lie jes bn ‘Sotease i und wed ngage vos | Going saved uh eee. ocng te of peek Onan pay Suk ions he sor. ang quo mpg | nse th pocon were adrd ie fm icone aon me aoe ep age sy ont ara nana be company to accept etlenem Dc Line Pes eel hens rn a, frock coer ane, Str ins"box meno Ukiaty Dest aig iy mph ae mee [ine rjc sacle pes ourt ah eon en al hel Backgrood ‘lise shore Done Lie Pee | thresh agin crane Om contrcton company Dot Line | owner coimr opt gary t_| rated cpu hl ohne at Prec bp aig nd Yo ‘nc on pyc fhe een nant | on he Coe eas ne cose 197 ander see ee contac with | ar he bl ‘ending be ba ‘errno ad Dos ie Priel Yn ie |e rao uc tn! ‘cred work oder bur ewe oe would seks wetted bron nd leds | The wal on brace he ripe conti wher pu ase atthe oer wi 1CSID a Aap 2 Jing at | “Ose ean pee ceed Sone wed fr eau we ‘or ached the bea ene eat | nd dc te ee eet “oem pid tngon be dsp amount, nl memo inca eng componente a ead rg and Dose Line Pree heed aed | Gorm coped wr ct cone | genet 204 bee Sok Mannie ty aorknc gees "aetna ec et | "ie Pj son ie oe ‘rowdy Bid pry wiconmcrs | he enw concen ada | dened wun ude ese id ‘meerpd wah The sienna acd iy a refed imeest__| xT uml hen coe Doe Lies ‘Srnec sen | oye re” | Pperm ong e Chale menpeeeaiatne |Snpececrcacncgeeae | temneumminiseterrmtats tmliratorcannyticeseteconeny | Bastin gescagrcmmncin ge | teem occ nic sees ‘Siva Crome Cone” | ams oases Seems | pata td olden eb ed Scetiectharmenet oma” /uocargesagwantiorcemay” | Sets te coun thw ime Tne gescpen eatin |epgetwonndsovcrietiaies | Spuninonee ste ta tpes deiesrformd altos |store Rasjapemdapea” | Sobiehreapotse pony cn Somme iiclpemceray | Comddmaes mates rehonet | Stench reece mre a mniegane Ditin Poke gn Aeciemra? ker Gearca, | “Megane Roe feat ay SeutTaknaerencancg rece gran esa acts | seeps esa SFirtpinscqearaltipone |Sutele eageanlbevagere | tcoaee cage ae eae eect ace SimminatnisSpenipigsar | "Tacebonsante alee acer ‘clpenie pai mond hed feomectereadattatoes | sunt wecrmecelaie tei ge papel { Tepe Ove Ray oc Cacho | Senne rose tan ck Dour ine rjc and del seo he oman a leo nl Aes E-Kashese tt i pe of cy one MORAL DAMAGES. (he Latins UNIRIAAwlVil et No "85evar3) p29. ohh king tie oe "Tee LC Dak A te Rael Sts onal Weng oT. ‘Samo hr foe ero “So uc a ake nan uri adhe tor seni Grete (ILC Report the Do ral 2/360 Wa fe mu a {rel 30.7 ner ecm oe Gels a Uated Nese Sede smn fete enol go the {ae ph he rer UNRIAA lV {Saks Ne S11) pt ed 192), When onder hot comput ore Doser “inner cops the ‘dina fo soem oe pererance fe [ce day-care rth cst crn pr rte | eat anak fy” exe sermons tence ‘Synth He sin bi From th de of eh masa ing an roche wh the any fence [Gove Te biel unl oped ee the merit he epee, whi Marat Chalet cd at re oe Frnt hep org” Mater oleh adn te de er ‘ge re doth th al spd Sy ti ok ‘putiond on uh condo’ Deco ef) Ji fh ancora Med Cine Coneiin, UNVRIAAX Gs Na AE ‘yess enetean commision rer enpeatan foray Ainersn mocha rac ee by enema fees bt deed ‘took san uatnoune price ne see Skene af ay dre or comin he pat ‘is Cane (C8 Brel IX UNRIAA (ker No. 1859 a 19 ae 12211903), Attouph hv ces ie scr on thee of Br Parse eve. ‘Sis round oer eta ve bana for expel "sre sna of yg om ees | Dacre Line Proce porto for dru ‘cntacor md ted poop ee or 9), She rm es nay ng ec rnc reno et ee he | prin sn seed in DoLn Ps ‘Seg he mesa yn ar cars

    You might also like