You are on page 1of 38

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Steering systems
Subtitle: this is the subtitle of the presentation

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Your speaker
Mark Pecqueur
Onsiphore Pecqueur (1792 1852)
Professor at KdG University college
Independent expert on Engines and vehicles
More than 18 years active in the world of alternative
fuels and drive systems
Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Overview
Introduction
Understeer & oversteer
The perfect steering system
Different steering principles

The Ackermann steering system


Forces & Moment on the wheel
Properties of the steering system
Cornering performance
Conclusion
Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Understeer & oversteer

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Understeer & oversteer

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

The perfect steering system

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

The perfect steering system


Equation of the straight AM:

y =x

l
b
r+
2

Equation of the straight BM:

(x b )
f

l
b
r
2

From geometry we know that the mirroring is around Y axle equal to reversing the
direction coefficient of straight. The equation for straight BS is then equal to:
l
l l b
y = (x b )
=x
y
b
b
b
r

r
r
2
2
2
f

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

The perfect steering system


If we define:

l
b
r +
2

l b
b
r
2

b
2

Than we can say that AM is equal to:


y = x P and BS: y = x Q W

We will now calculate the X and Y coordinates of the intersection of this two
straights with r as parameter:
W
AM = BS x p = x Q W X is than:x Q p = W x =
Q p
l
l

Qp =
b
b
r
r+
2
2
f

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

The perfect steering system


If we work this out we get:

b + b
l r l
2
2

b + b
r 2 r 2

l r +l
Qp

Finaly:

Qp

2 l r
b
r
4
2

If we combine this with (d) we can calculate x:


l b
b
r
2
x = l
2
r
b
r
4
f

+ bf
r

bf
2

=
=
2 r

b
r b +
2
2 r
f

2 r b +b
=
x
4 r
f

2
f

This is the equation of the x


coordinate of the intersection
of straight AM and BS we can
now also calculate the y
coordinate in the
intersection.

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

The perfect steering system


y =x p

Fill in x and P and we get:

+ bf
r 2 bf

2 r

b
2
In the end we get:
y

bf l

2 r

2 r b +b
x=
4 r
f

2
f

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

10

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

The perfect steering system


In a first evaluation we calculate the
coordinates x and y during straight
ahead driving. This means that the
curvature is than equal to: Applying
this to the equation we get:

2 r b +b
x = lim
4 r

b
2

y = lim

bf l

=0
2 r
b

During this situation the intersection is: , 0


2

We find this point in the middle of the


front axle of the vehicle.
The second interesting point is the point with the smallest turning circle. This is when the vehicle is
turning around his rear wheel the curvature is than equal to:

b
2

Aplying this value into the equation for x and y we


b l
get:
2 r b +b =
=
y
=
lim
x lim
b
b 2 r
4 r
b
2

= l

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

11

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Different steering principles

Turntable steering system

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

12

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Different steering principles


Pivot steering system

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

13

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Different steering principles


Pivot steering system

tg ( WU ) =

r
and

b
2

tg ( Wi ) =

b
2

The realtion between the two angels is than:


tg ( Wi ) tg ( WU ) =

b
b
r
r+
2
2
1 1 =b
tg ( ) tg ( ) l
f

ore:

=
f

l b
b
r
4
f

WU

Wi

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

14

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Different steering principles


Pivot steering system

30,00

25,00

wheel angle ()

20,00

15,00

10,00

5,00

55

53

51

49

47

45

43

41

39

37

35

33

31

29

27

25

23

21

19

17

15

13

11

0,00

radius (m)

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

15

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Different steering principles

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

16

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Different steering principles

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

17

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

The Ackermann steering system

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

18

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Forces & Moment on the steering


angle center line.
Moments du to vertical forces

Influence of or caster

Fncos()
Fnsin()

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

19

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Forces & Moment on the steering


angle center line.
Moments du to vertical forces

M=Fnsin()sin()ra

offset tot increase stability

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

20

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Forces & Moment on the steering


angle center line.
Influence of the lateral forces

M=lsFs
n=lscos()
The caster is relative small so cos() is
almost equal to 1 so we get:
MFsn

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

21

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Forces & Moment on the steering


angle center line.
Tire trail

Influence of the lateral forces

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

22

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Forces & Moment on the steering


angle center line.
Tire properties

Gough-diagram of a 195/70 VR 14 at a tire pressure of 2,2 bar


Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

23

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Forces & Moment on the steering


angle center line.
Influence of the camber offset

FRl
FRr

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

24

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Forces & Moment on the steering


angle center line.
Influence of the tire deformation on the moment around the king pin

displacement from the camber offset while driving in a curve

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

25

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Properties of the steering system

wa=(wl+wr)
is=ishiss

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

26

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Properties of the steering system


Dynamic steering ratio

i =

sw

sdyn

wgem

Left

Average steering angle

Right

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

27

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Properties of the steering system


stiffness of the steering system

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

28

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Properties of the steering system


stiffness of the steering system

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

29

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Cornering performance
Stationary cornering just not drifting out of the curve

F cos( ) G sin( ) = F
c

sl

+ F sr

F cos( ) G sin( ) = (F
c

F cos( ) G sin( ) =
c

nl

+ F nr )

F c sin( ) + G cos( )

The centriugal force is equal to:


m v = G v
F =
g r
r
2

G v
cos( ) G sin( ) =
g r
2

v
g

G tg ( ) =

G v

sin( ) + G cos( )
g r

tg ( ) + 1
g r

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

30

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Cornering performance
Stationary cornering just not drifting put of the curve

Now we calculate the speed v:


v

g r

1 tg ( ) = + tg ( )

+ tg ( )
g r 1 tg ( )
v

g max

+ tg ( )
g r
1 tg ( )

Let us suppose that we drive on a flat road we have than:

v = gr

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Cornering performance
Stationary cornering just not roll over

F cos( ) h G sin( ) F sin( )


c

Replacing Fc by

g r

G v
g r

k max

b
h tg ( )

and deviding by cos() we get:

= tg ( ) + b
h

b
2
g r
b
h tg ( )
2

tg ( ) h
v

b
b
G cos( ) = 0
2
2

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

32

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Cornering performance

k max

Cornering stability

> v g max

b
2
g r
b
h tg ( )
2

tg ( ) h

>

+ tg ( )
g r
1 tg ( )

Square both terms and deviding by gr:

tg ( ) + b
h

<

tg ( ) > + tg ( )
1

tg ( ) b
h
2

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

33

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Cornering performance
Friction coefficient
0,5
0,55
0,6
0,65
0,7
0,75
0,8
0,85
0,95
0,95

Track Width Track Width Track Width Track Width


0,70
0,75
0,80
0,85
Height C G Height C G Height C G Height C G
0,70
0,75
0,80
0,85
0,64
0,68
0,73
0,77
0,58
0,63
0,67
0,71
0,54
0,58
0,62
0,65
0,50
0,54
0,57
0,61
0,47
0,50
0,53
0,57
0,44
0,47
0,50
0,53
0,41
0,44
0,47
0,50
0,37
0,39
0,42
0,45
0,37
0,39
0,42
0,45
0,70

0,75

0,80

0,85

http://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=o2ApDSgcnuQ&feature=relat
ed

Height center of gravity

0,90
0,80
0,70
0,60
0,50
0,40
0,30
0,5

0,6

0,7

0,8

0,9

friction coefficient

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

34

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Cornering performance
Instationary cornering behavior

Mg=Jgg

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

35

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Cornering performance
Instationary cornering behavior
Slalom test

During this test the drive turns the steering


wheel from left to right with a give
frequency at a given speed. During the test
the yaw rate and the lateral acceleration
are measured. If we take a close look we
see that the knik in the yaw rate and the
drop in the lateral acceleration always
accur between 1 and 2 Hz. This is the
natural frequency of the suspension
system in this situation. If the speed go up
the lag also gos up. At 100 km/hour the lag
is equal to 90. This means that the drive
has already turned the steering wheel for
90 before he get any information back
aboud the behavior of the vehicle.
Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

36

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Conclusion
Cornering stability of the HPV is a serious issue
The basics are the same bud the implementations must
be different

Light weight is a must


Make a good project!

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

37

Erasmus LLP Intensive Programme

Thanks

Questions?

Mark Pecqueur
+32 476 40 87 44

Powering the Future With Zero Emission and Human Powered Vehicles Terrassa 2011

38

You might also like