Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cisplatin: Synthesis, Antitumour Activity and Mechanism of Action
Cisplatin: Synthesis, Antitumour Activity and Mechanism of Action
7 - I985
I73
review articles
Introduction
The c o m p o u n d PtCI2(NH3)~, has been known for
more than a century and occurs in two isomers, i.e.
trans-PtCl2(NH3)2 and cis-PtCl2(NH3)2. The full
name of the latter isomer is cis-diamminedichloroplatinum(n), abbreviated in the literature as e.g.
cis-DDP, cisplatin, cis-platinum, C D D P , D D P , CP
and P D D . The cis-Pt(NH3)2 moiety is usually abbreviated as cis-Pt in formulae, l The two compounds
have the Pt(n) in a square-planar co-ordination and
do not isomerize under ambient conditions. In
Figure ~ schematic structures are given of these two
platinum co-ordination compounds.
Experiments in the early sixties in which the
growth of Escherichia coli was studied as a function
of the electric field - generated between platinum
electrodes with aqueous NH4CI as the electrolyte showed an unexpected filamentous growth, which
was initially not understood. 2 Subsequent experiments by the same investigators showed that the
origin of the filamentous growth had nothing to do
with the electric field, but was in fact caused by the
presence of small amounts of platinum co-ordination
compounds formed upon dissolution of the Pt
electrodes in the NH4Ci containing solutions)
A m o n g those cis-PtCl2(NH3)2 turned out to be the
most effective in further bacterial tests, and ~ase of
this compound in the treatment of Sarcoma 180
tumours induced in mice, showed that complete
remission was possible in many casesJ
The first clinical trials were reported in I972 with
very promising results. 5 Large scale applications of
the drug had to wait some time, since toxic side
effects, such as vomiting, bone marrow and kidney
toxicity were very seriousJ 6 After improvements in
the administration procedure - based on combination therapy and advanced protocols - the drug
has developed as the leading anti cancer drug in the
USA (30 ooo patients each year) and is also registered widely in E u r o p e and in Japan (there only since
I984).
Interest in the study of the mechanism of action
began about a decade ago. It is generally accepted
that a better knowledge of the mechanism may lead
to better administration procedures and to derivatives or analogues with superior properties. A better
understanding of the mechanism may also lead to a
better understanding of m e t a l - D N A interactions, a
process of great importance in many biological
events. 7
Abstract
A review is presented on the successful antitumour drug
i74
H3N\ / C I
/
H3N
Pt
CI
/C{
H3N,\
Pt
/ \
CI
NH3
0
N~PI \ O
H3 1
- -
FIGURE I
H2
/t'~l
H2C
H2
H2
/N~pt,/
- ~ C ~ C/ CH2 H2C~N/ ~0
C~ H2
3 H2
0
H
0
.CH2
C/
%0
H
H~
__c__ H
C--N\ /O--C~c~
~C ~
~o
!/',o
Apart f r o m t h e above mentioned classical compound cisplatin, nowadays many other compounds
of related structure are known to possess similar
biological activities, and some of these are undergoing intense clinical trials in several countries.
Based on research in this field during the last decade,
it has become evident that - in order to have
antitumour activity - the Pt compounds should at
least fulfil the following structural requirements:
- the geometry of the amine ligands should be cis;
thus: (amine)2PtX2 or (amine)2Pt'"Y2X2;
- the X ligands should be easily leaving groups, such
as Cl-, SO42-, oxalate(2-), malonate(2-), citrate(2-), ascorbate(2-). [N.B. In the case of Pt(iv)
compounds the Y ligands are trans to each other,
and so far only Y=OH- has resulted in active
compounds];
- the amine ligands, or at least one of them, should
have a hydrogen bond donor function, i.e. should
be a primary or a secondary amine.
The compounds depicted in Figure 2 all fulfil these
requirements. This, of course, does not automatically indicate that all these compounds can be used to
cure turnouts. The molecular basis of the side
reactions in blood, organs and tumour tissue are far
from understood and elucidation will need many
years of research by pharmacologists, toxicologists,
biologists and (bio)chemists. Now, only the reactions with DNA are understood to some extent.gThe
remainder of this review will focus upon the route of
' 2"-c/I--",
H2
C3
H--C/
CH3
H2
N\Im/OHCl
lai r
cm N/I\
H--C
OH Cl
C4
3''
H2
/.
%.
H2 H2 H2 H2
/C--C\ / C
N /OH2
P1
H2C
C
H2 H2
FIGURE 2
I75
H20
H20
cis-PtCl2(NH3) 2 ~
cis-[PtCl(H20) (NH3)2]+ ~
[Pt(NH3)2(H20)2] 2+
t~-H+
cIs-[PtCI(OH)(NH3) 2]
H20
~I-H+ PKa.5"6
~
[Pt(OH) (H20)(NH3)2]~
I~-H+PKa=7.3
[Pt(OH)2(NH3)2]
specific interaction of cisplatin with DNA is an
important event, which may eventually lead to cell
killing. The evidence can be summarized as follows:
- induction of filamentous growth indicates that cell
division is hampered and cell growth is not; ~~
- induction of lysis in lysogenic bacteria also indicates interaction with DNA. Even a correlation
between antitumour activity and prophage induction in lysogenic bacteria was found; ~6
- i n h i b i t i o n of DNA synthesis is selectively inhibited, whereas RNA and protein synthesis are
not. ~7
It should be stressed here, however, that although
binding to the DNA is evident, these observations do
not necessarily prove that this binding is the only
important reaction that leads to the cell killing, and
in particular to the killing of the tumour cell.
Nevertheless, detailed binding studies of cisplatin
(and analogues) to DNA and to fragments of DNA,
are receiving considerable attention. The next section will deal with the molecular basis of these
Pt-DNA interactions.
B i n d i n g o f cis-Pt to D N A , D N A f r a g m e n t s and
nucleotides
FIGURE 3
I76
NH3
.H20~. / NH3
O'"
Pt~.
H2N~
~N~
Sugar
CYTIDINE
NH2
GUANINE
"2~
H2O~
P,I~
ADENINE
Sugar
TRINUCLEOTIDES
.,N%,/,, ?,,,
H
Sugar
ADENINE
Sugar
FIGURE 4
AND
TETRANUCLEOTIDES
OLIGONUCLEOTIDES
j?\
IG\ / N H 3 ~
X~ / Pf " , ,//
monofuncflonolly bound
mtersfrond crosslink
NH3 - Pt - G
NH.3
'.
DNA-orotem crosshnk
FIGURE 5
Schematic representations of several possibilities of monofunctional and bifunctional binding of the cis-Pt unit to
DNA
I77
,~
FIGURE
come quite strong and one could think about possibilities of cis-Pt binding without (complete) disruption of base pairs. Very recently we have shown that
the decanucleotide d(TCTCGGTCTC) and the
complementary strand d ( G A G A C C G A G A ) can
form a double helix after Pt chelation to the central
GpG part of the first strand. 3' [N.B. For clarity the
bridging phosphates have been omitted from the
formulae.] Chottard et al. (Chottard JC, personal
communication) have made similar observations for
deca- and octa-oligonucleotides (see also Fig. 7).
The fact that the double helix remains intact after
cis-Pt binding is rather unexpected and this raises the
question whether or not such a lesion occurs in DNA
in vivo. Very recent work by Marzilli and Den
Hartog, however, has shown that one of the 31p
NMR signals of DNA containing cis-Pt is essentially
similar to that of our decanucleotide dimer (discussed above) after Pt binding. 3334Detailed analyses
of the several possible distortions of DNA after Pt
binding, primarily based on the observed spectral
features, have shown that a kink in the DNA with an
angle of about 40-7 ~ can explain all the observations
available up to now. z6 Future work will deal with
larger DNA fragments and a comparison will be
made of the binding processes and structures of the
formed adducts with those present in DNA of
normal cells and tumour cells (Den Hartog JHJ, et
al., unpublished observations). The first results of
this work are already mentioned below.
D(.OTt: .
C -
T -
C -
G - G - T - C - T - C"')'z
~l
LESIONS
10
f..L~- PT
PT
/\
D( I c,
_ C-
I - g-
\G'/Gp,f
D(S'G-
A-
G-
A - C-
I - C - I - C3'~
C - G - A-
G - A3 ' )
_..._~
~ ( )~' T - C 1
2
D(x,A
J
I - C3
tl
- G - A - G -
G5
G6
T - C7
8
T - C~')"
9
10
C -
C - A - G - A - Go,)
J
FIGURE 7
Double-stranded decanucleotides
after binding of cisplatin to the
central GG part of one strand. It
appears that the double-helical
structure can remain intact after
the Pt binding
I78
REPAIR
Preliminary observations by Poirier on the frequency of DNA lesions in peripheral blood lymphocytes, have shown that patients who did not respond
to the cisplatin treatment, indeed had a much smaller
number of Pt-DNA lesions (Poirier M, personal
communication to Lohman PHM, I984). This observation might be of great importance for the understanding why certain Pt compounds show such a vast
difference in activity towards various types of cancer.
No difference in either the Pt uptake or the loss of
DNA-bound adducts, however, could be established
after treatment by cisplatin of sensitive and resistant
rat carcinoma cells (Roberts J J, personal communication to Lohman PHM, I984). Possibly, in contrast
to the resistant cells, the sensitive cells are incapable
of repairing the important, but minor, Pt-DNA
lesion (the 'key DNA lesion').
FURTHER
RESEARCH
Closing
remarks
Vol. 7 - I985
Acknowledgements
The authors are indebted to their students, coworkers, and colleagues for their invaluable contributions to the research described in this review
paper. Their n a m e s are m e n t i o n e d as co-authors in
the references. Support to the research came from
the State University of Leiden, Medical Biological
L a b o r a t o r y T N O Rijswijk, The Netherlands Organisation for the A d v a n c e m e n t of Pure Research
( Z W O ) , the Netherlands Foundation for Chemical Research (SON; grant I I-28-17), the Dutch
National Cancer Foundation ( K W F ; granted projects M B L 79-I, M B L 83-I, I K W - 8 3 - I 6 ) , Johnson
and Matthey Ltd. (Pt loan), Ciba-Geigy (gift of
K2PtC14). The progress in this research was stimulated through m a n y discussions with Prof. J.C.
Chottard (Paris) and his group, made possible by the
support of the Dutch-French Cultural A g r e e m e n t .
References
Reedijk J. Nomenclature for platinum antitumour compounds. In: Hacker MP, Douple EB, Krakoff M, eds.
Platinum coordination complexes in cancer chemotherapy. Boston: M. Nijhoff, I984:3-8.
2 Rosenberg B, Van Camp L, Krigas T. Inhibition of cell
division in Escherichia coli by electrolysis products from
a platinum electrode. Nature 1965;2o5:698-9.
3 Rosenberg B, Van Camp L, Grimley EB, Thomson AJ.
The inhibition of growth or cell division in Escherichia
coli by different ionic species of platinum(w) complexes.
J Biol Chem I967;242:I347-52.
4 Rosenberg B, Van Camp L, Trosko JE, Mansour VH.
Platinum compounds: a new class of potent antitumour
agents. Nature I969;222:385-6.
~ Roberts J J, Thomson AJ. The mechanism of action of
antitumour platinum compounds. Progr Nucleic Acid
Res Mol Biol I979;22:71-133.
6 Wiltshaw E. Cisplatin in the treatment of cancer. Plat
Met Rev I979;23:9o-8.
7 Marzilli LG, Eichorn GL. Metal-ions in genetic information transfer. New York: Elsevier/North Holland,
I984.
8 Van Kralingen CG. Antitumor Platinum Compounds:
Synthesis, structure and biological activity. Delft: Delft
University of Technology, I979. Dissertation.
Marcelis ATM. Interaction of antitumor platinum compounds with nucleic acid fragments. Leiden: State
University of Leiden, I982. Dissertation.
~c,Marcelis ATM, Reedijk J. Binding of platinum compounds to nucleic acids, in relation to the antitumor
activity of cL~-diamminedichloroplatinum (n) and derivatives. Recl Trav Chim Pays Bas I983;Io2:I2I-9.
N Martin RB. Hydrolytic equilibria and N7 versus NI
binding in purine nucleosides of c/s-diamminedichloroplatinum(H). In: Lippard SJ, ed. Platinum, gold and
other metal chemotherapeutic agents: chemistry and
biochemistry. Washington American Chemical Society,
t983:231-44. (ACS Symposium Series. Vol. 209).
22 Lippard SJ. New chemistry of an old molecule: c/sPt(NH3)2C12. Science I982;218:to75-82.
J3 Pinto A, Kippard SJ. Binding of the antitumor drug
c/s-diamminedichloroplatinum(n) (cisplatin) to DNA.
Biochim Biophys Acta t985;78o:t67-8o.
179
14 Prestayko AW, Crooke ST, Carter SK,eds. Cisplatin,
current status and new developments. New York:
Academic Press, I98O.
~5 Rosenberg B. Some biological effects of platinum
compounds. Plat Met Rev 197I;I5:42-4.
~6 Reslova S. The induction of lysogenic strains of Escherichia coli by cis-dichlorodiammineplatinum(iQ. Chem
Biol Interact I972;4:66-7o.
~7Harder HC, Smith RG, Leroy AF. Template primer
inactivation by c/s- and trans-dichlorodiammine platinum for human DNA polymerase ct, [3, and Rauscher
Murine Leukemia Virus reverse transcriptase, as a
mechanism of cytotoxicity. Cancer Res I976;36:
382I-9.
~" Gellert RW, Bau R. X-ray structural studies of metalnucleoside and metal-nucleotide complexes. In: Sigel H,
ed. Metal ions in biological systems. Vol. 8. New York:
Marcel Dekker, 1979:I.
~ Brouwer J, VandePutte P, Fichtinger-Schepman AMJ,
Reedijk J. Base-pair substitution hotspots in GAG and
GCC nucleotide sequences in Escherichia coli K-I2
induced by cis-diamminedichloroplatinumOl). Proc Natl
Acad Sci USA I98I;78:7oio- 4.
-~) Fichtinger-Schepman AM J, Lohman PHM, Reedijk J.
Detection and quantification of adducts formed upon
interaction of diamminedichloroplatinum(n) with
DNA, by anion-exchange chromatography after enzymatic degradation. Nucl Acid Res I982;IO:5345-56.
2t Fichtinger-Schepman AM J, Van der Veer JL, Den
Hartog JHJ, Lohman PHM, Reedijk J. Adducts of the
antitumor drug cis-diammit~edichloroplatinum(I 0 with
DNA: formation, identification and quantitation. Biochemistry I985;24:707-I3.
Rahn RO. Chromatographic analysis of the adducts
formed in DNA complexed with c/s-diamminedichloroplatinum 0I). J Inorg Biochem I984;21:3I I-2I.
Plooij ACM. Effects of cisplatin and related cis- and
transplatinum compounds on cultured mammalian cells:
-genotoxic properties and their molecular background.
Leiden: State University of Leiden, I984. Dissertation.
24 Chottard JC, Girault JP, Chottard G, Lallemand JY,
Mansuy D. Interaction of ctk-[Pt(NH3)2(H20)2](NO3)2
with ribose dinucleoside monophosphates. J Am Chem
Soc 198o; 1o2:5565-72.
Den Hartog JHJ, Altona C, Chottard JC, et al. Conformational analysis of the adduct cis-Pt(NH3)2d(GpG)
in aqueous solution. A high field (500-300 MHz) nuclear
magnetic resonance investigation. Nucl Acid Res
I982;Io:4715-3o.
26 Den Hartog JHJ. Cisplatin induced distortions in DNA.
Leiden: State University of Leiden, 1985. Dissertation.
27 Marcelis ATM, Den Hartog JHJ, Reedijk J. Intrastrand
cross-linking of the guanines of the deoxytrinucleotide
d(G-C-G) via cis-Pt(NH3)2Cl2. J Am Chem Soc 1982;
IO4:2664-5.
Marcelis ATM, Canters GW, Reedijk J. Chelation of
ct~-Pt(NH3)2CI2 by the deoxynucleotide d(C-C-G-G).
Recl Trav Chim Pays-Bas I98I ;Ioo:39I-2.
29 Tran-Dinh S, Neumann JM, Girault JP, Chottard JC,
Igolen J, Huynh-Dinh T. Conformation of d(ATGG)cisPt(NH3)2 in aqueous solution by proton magnetic
resonance spectroscopy. Inorg Chim Acta 1983;79:2534.
~o Girault JP, Chottard JC, Guittet ER, Lallemand JY,
I80
Huynh-Dinh T, Igolen J. Specific platinum chelation by
the guanines of the deoxyhexanucleotide d(T-G-GC-C-A) upon reaction with cis-[Pt(NH3)2(H20)2](N03)2.
Biochem Biophys Res Commun I983;IO9: I x57-63.
3t Caradonna JP, Lippard SJ, Gait MJ, Singh M.
The antitumor drug cis-[Pt(NHa)2CI2] forms an
intrastrand d(GpG) cross-link upon reaction with
[d(ApGpGpCpCpT)]2. J Am Chem Soc I982; 1o4:
5793-5.
32 Den Hartog JHJ, Altona C, Van Boom JH, Van der
Marel GA, Haastloot CAG, Reedijk J. cis-Diamminedichloroplatinum(u) induced distortion in a doublehelical DNA fragment. J Am Chem Soc i984;IO6:15283~ .
Vol. 7 - I985
Received N o v e m b e r I984.
Accepted for publication April I985.