A statement prepared for delivery by Spokane County Commissioner Shelly O'Quinn before moving to hire colleague Todd Mielke as the county's chief executive.
Original Title
Shelly O'Quinn's statement on Spokane County CEO
A statement prepared for delivery by Spokane County Commissioner Shelly O'Quinn before moving to hire colleague Todd Mielke as the county's chief executive.
A statement prepared for delivery by Spokane County Commissioner Shelly O'Quinn before moving to hire colleague Todd Mielke as the county's chief executive.
Next on our agenda is the matter of concluding the process of
identifying and appointing the County's next CEO. This decision culminates
a process that has spanned more than 6 months. The process has
received critical media attention, so | would like to take a moment to
address concerns that have been raised. The process of selecting Spokane
County's next CEO was transparent, thorough and well defined. A few key
points, which have been previously stated, but are worth repeating...
+ The job was posted in January and involved nationwide advertising for
the position. Ads were placed in comparable west coast cities such as
Boise, Portland, Seattle and Salt Lake and advertised nationally through
the National Association of Counties and the International City/County
Management Association. aa
All applications received an initial screening from the County Senior
Executive team and Senior Human Resources staff to identify those
applicants who met the position qualifications. Marshall Farnell, our
current CEO and the person who is perhaps best positioned to determine
the qualifications of applicants, was a part of that team.
The applications were then forwarded to seven prominent individuals,
people who are themselves highly qualified to judge the qualifications of
our candidates because they have proven themselves as successful
executives of significant organizations in our community. These seven
were engaged to scrutinize the qualified candidates and to identify the
most qualified ones to be considered by Commissioner French and
myself.+ Then, for the first time since we created the process, the Board of County
Commissioners became involved; we interviewed the ranked finalists who
had been chosen by the selection committee
+ Today, we are at the final stage of our process....the selection of anew
Spokane County CEO. Commissioner French and myself interviewed two
candidates. One of them has since pulled their name from consideration;
that leaves us to decide whether or not to appoint the number one ranked
and sole remaining finalist for the position: Todd Mielke.
‘And while there are those who might claim that the process might have
somehow been rigged to produce this result, I'd like to assure the citizens
of Spokane County that the process was fair and unbiased. It was also
extraordinary, given that no process of any kind is required of the Board of
County Commissioners in making personnel decisions of this kind.
Commissioner French and | designed this process to ensure that it was
transparent and accountable to the public.
That being said, | move that the Board of County Commissioners
appoint Todd Mielke as the Chief Executive Officer of Spokane County
and that staff move forward with negotiating and signing a contract
that will include a start date mutually agreeable to the parties and
following his resignation from the Board of County Commissioners
once an employment contract has been executed.| would like to speak to my motion..
As | previously noted, we employed a hiring process that was
thorough and thoughtful. It was formally established by Commissioner
French and myself this past December and January. Commissioner French
and I approved each stage of the process. Early on we dismissed the idea
of expending public money to retain a headhunter as being an
unnecessary, if not wasteful, use of public funds. We were confident in the
expertise of our Human Resources Department to promote the position
sufficiently to attract qualified candidates. That process worked. We
received 84 applicants from 24 states. While it might be a practice of some
organizations to employ a headhunter, it is not universally treated as a
prerequisite - even for hiring a CEO. Avista didn't find Scott Morris
through a headhunter. Mayor Condon didn't find Theresa Sanders, the
clty Administrator, through a headhunter. In fact, he didn’t undergo any
formal or public process at all in hiring her.
In other words, Commissioner French and | had enough confidence in our
own staff and their knowledge to nationally advertise the position and to
initially screen applicants for qualifications. And in that process, we were
saving precious public money. Commissioner French and | appropriately
exercised our discretion and appropriately balanced the interest of the
public in deciding to forego a headhunter.Commissioner French and | also mutually decided on employing a
selection committee to identify from among the qualified applicants
the most qualified candidates for the position. He and | appointed
individuals to that committee by consensus. We chose people who are
prominent executives in our community. People whose reputations are
above reproach. People who, while active in the affairs of our community
and respected advocates for the welfare of our community, have not been
politically active enough to disqualify themselves from serving on the
screening committee, knowing that Commissioner Mielke was one of the
applicants. Commissioner French and | took great pains to ensure that the
screening process and those involved in it had high integrity.
Permit me to mention those individuals and once again thank them for the
significant amount of time they put into this process to ensure Spokane
County had a qualified CEO candidate: Jeff Phillips, CEO of Rosauers;
Christine Johnson, Chancellor of the Community Colleges of Spokane;
Elaine Couture, Regional Chief Executive of Providence Health Care;
Kevin Pearson, CEO of Wagstaff, Inc.; Doug Cochran, Chief of Staff for
the State Auditor Office and a former Yakima County Administrator; Kris,
Mikkelson, Former CEO of Inland Power, and Rob Higgins, CEO of the
Spokane Realtors Association. These are highly respected and qualified
people in our community and we can not thank them enough for their
involvement and commitment to our CEO process.
This group of well respected leaders recommended to Commissioner
French and myself two candidates in ranked order for our consideration:
Number 1) Todd Mielke and Number 2)Richard Davis. CommissionerFrench and | interviewed both candidates. As | mentioned earlier, Richard
Davis has withdrawn his name from consideration. So, that leaves Todd
Mielke, the number one ranked candidate and the only remaining qualified
candidate for consideration.
| honor and respect the process that Commissioner French and | created.
And | honor and respect the members of the selection committees. | am
confident in their judgment. To disregard and dismiss their
recommendation would be to second guess their judgment and to dishonor
their esteemed professional credentials and reputations. | am confident that
Todd Mielke is qualified to serve as CEO of Spokane County. And as long
as he is qualified - and, again, the selection committee determined that he
is - Commissioner French and | should feel,confident and justified in
appointing him.
| understand that there are those who believe that because we are arriving
at the conclusion of a process that culminated with one of our own County
Commissioners as a - as THE - finalist, that we should start the process
over again. It's as though something is wrong with the outcome. To those
who question the prospect that Todd Mielke should be appointed, | would
like to remind that the hiring of prominent executives from within is not
uncommon in this community - or others. | mentioned earlier that Scott
Morris was appointed as Chairman, President and CEO of Avista from
within. Thayne McCulloh, President of Gonzaga University, was promoted
from within. Those are just two,examples that come to mind, but I'm certain
there are others.Therefore, it is out of respect for the process that Commissioner French
and | established and for the staff and community leaders who played
pivotal roles in it that | once, again, seek a second to my motion.
IF no second to the motion...
At this point, it appears that my motion is defeated for lack of being
seconded, That concludes our process for appointing a new CEO. Soon,
Commissioners Mielke, Commissioner French and | will confer about how
to proceed from here