Aion Pint 26.200) Shia Rone 9 ‘The Method of Division and the Division of the Phocdrus Kenneth Dost ‘The paradoxical character of the Pharr swell kno Ki ot nly he ros deeply bfrcte of al Plato's diloges, with it af ved to Speeches shut es a th second t tr a the loge in Hh Pst ma sly othe portance iyi ing (264), Ne oo Psy, atmps to Mea he uiying prc of dialog have een proposed since apie nes. Heri, wh takes fe ses of dale to ‘eat reports compting tee ln the nj veo het He Soul; or he good (Heat 1089, 16), while early 100 years le Hach 1952, vente hat modem wie ages wih and ie fm cach ote nan fe Yar of combi Dhe proposed asves edo ‘evariaons on two geet approaches One I th ita thre sale Sj of investigation ha unifies th voles, the os como recente ies bring pilosopny and tbr. Those who lai Is plsopy ad o ‘erasiz he st al ofthe itgue in which ilsepy sens asthe ih ‘Stipes of ero, and regard th send be coeerd ith he theta [eneiples wih which phos mast css coer el whe ose "ho aim tis etc ed to cps the second hal by tang th specs {th begining tobe example for he subsequen: examination of tole? np scoreation sony be repoderance~ Hacks nino vary {sonia remains he ale The be eae appcech i tha the oes fora single withing tee i fonda uidedbacse the Kindo ty (hu te Pinedrarntocts an ean i naative oy ater ha here iy? Wa atrcve about he ew tht he ait of the dislage nly far sive hed is tha is proponents Go not avo exphin away Wha appease "a as 1,1 he ie pe i age i revit pl yy toes ins tater a i ome bey oH a wean "ei be Vist ms 1 owe 4, 711; Rae th ‘ene Wate aA ss rons a {retest ot rt es pata Selatan tery om pam fe 6a he Por ee ay of id ld ‘yet tr re Wn Nee 820 ‘funda iterece inthe seria eso in te two ae ofthe dogs ‘or dhe veo sorte one thee oh ter when pinion ss vey Givided aboot when mre ingot Nevers, Tie tha he lege ‘cs xh wy ms well a nanive wy, 9 that he here oy Isto be ond ne by miniizing the ifereeeRerwees het hes bat by Insag om i I fitspesh nticiating the method of von hte Integer Betwern tet bles ofthe Slope, Sere dve he gna "ules and eas ot species teat ee aguied 37) alata the tw ale fhe Sialic eplre these vo spies espe {ively and tha be thematic nity ofthe Phaedra oreo othe a Te ‘eof dso nes sess whi genus Po smetine its» proce flr snecuncing i and e dae 50 tee nh te ati of vont beloeSacrats inoue the meal He irae dvson by dsingusting adn int the vo specie of an Le ‘etc vn nspitn, sod eater i our suspects He thew ales {othe sto elacon when be pus ut th his earler Wo species tok the “asius Linde of mental derangement ito a comos species’ In ation fo lnm surveying he yes die dese ef fying them win = ‘Simon ges id tes fal ig the peta mo species, he oats ‘began by providing us with amber of ehnoromis of he same pe a he ple—nothr worth he strc ogo uel an serena he Festa sein ered Ta adilogoe wach anoooes that lxpty can bs be communicated nt ty sgt writing bu by plating tals rom which ther Words prow ithe coascta fother people" (276e-27a, wanlatons we my OE “lee eerie insted), ad tha ie tr alot ese exten even inthe cate of wing (276d), at stpeng that Plato does no offer + e195, ae tol ds hey Se bie ois ens wen ey a esi pes Le ke ‘eps gua am ett ened Be) er Sy, (al watt occ ee “in en ee ey ha Sst i ca een gat mma ied "hep tse A, opti as tbe wy ot de oars oe Mae ch ts es pre Ee eA ‘nimi mn poet ann 70 hat mere pps er ep) hy yt) um nso cn pene ete et 8 et {Exons te nae fs ince ea al ow ee Sin puts mn og mee Pn salghtoewudexpinationo tow te Pha insece on organi ity nse itis patie Bet kes ws pec or tease: ors The Petiniony Neraive ‘The dog opens wih dichotomy between cy and mate In ely fo 2 {seston from Sores, Phadnis he wei om tity and gino ve o walk ousie the ey wal When Ps mentons ht he pee toring wit the spech wer Lysas, Socrates replies, guraphraing Pr, "at bearing what Phoodus an Lysis id ogo ou be more moet 6 hi hon he mos urget business. The allison othe opening of Pr st shina ee, where he odes wave city Thebes saying he wil ther stove his preset barnes Pasa tls Sots ta the spesch of Ly ie, eh Paeras ha pete cing sug wth he aor as clever Tecate ages tat ne sol med sexs faves sme who ot a love with ater han sameone who Sorts replies tht ite pech ha signed that racaton shi al be sad tte who te 9a ned "eh and old ite of young, ite Sorter and mat the, hen two ely ‘be sophisticated @227ba). The word for "sophisticated ic tun ter wha te pecs tha fart odovere cle ‘com ‘eyo inte ais" (2). These epsing les, wih he ‘references fo the cist up a conepin of he ty a the home oF wha {ria ocosed i al (ty wall re ened aga at 274 8280), 3 ice where Iles rotrcl tft compete wit ving date (274 273), and where rents te roc that ge ogo ast he pomp Ings of mre “As Phoea esves he cy walls be ees eras whos "ck with pasion fochenring species, ad sein his, sexing i. he was ile wit plese because e moo have bis ellow-Kaxybant” (286)? They proceed o walk Sows a plane te, which the Kerybans, was asses wi Dans (Ge are! 1886-1809, 1T8cF OCD 1949,"nees), ano discus the poe Jeet, sees in pes vc ne mth in which Bre g06 ‘he Nox winced Orta. Now that hy ar ote he ata the coated cavsoamet of walls and wring, we enor utente Dhetomena ike sickness, Koran eray and being overpowered By the Fore of me. ‘When Pas ss Sorts whether alive the myth o be ae, Scr replies tha athovgh such ms canbe es slog of ata event fo "Padre net tn pth At a a a | ‘te Senor aps craps am pts a en jee Cw engi He pes See bea hen ‘spt ate geen aon er nme ee ‘Sia. pnt iss etna opr) te ‘eon one, ae neg Ds2 xa tat ridin was Bow af hocks by he Nath ing og tough ‘Steck se of natenr wnld be oerweting wees on aa gra de oer Sere, power, kept bsy by he juin of he Delhi oracle Yokoo ane and be wonders wheter be sa wl best more compen an svazly spine (nena) ta Typha, ead spe ese ‘wha partes y nataeina iin a uit (230s), Wo cn recog his ‘ admbraon ofthe we owe ofthe plieade's rh tape of thew: the bac horse ia age of he lave pr ofthe arte sou ced “copii” (vo tOygerin whih i susequey desced Intenso com pleniy 38a Rap 580), whe he whe hase gene and simple, and Draken he vine nso of the hue "Tey sont ret by the plan ee sacred to Dionysus, and a chaste-tee (agra) sce Hers (Fare 1896-1009, 1 38 note), Soca iss ten with an oa by hat gs. Her lle be aso wt igsip (2530) an hus wich ces. o once again we havea contrat Bewesm ony ‘es and wld ete, pesonfed ee by Hera apd Dionyss respectively ‘Socrates grceee texan the pice tk hs bay tensa be lst grin ofthe lt. sos sated aus, fe the colon fhe ae, ad ns the sills of he lean (230). He does mo pu nyt in is ‘ou bet he eras fa itu for apc a im ere 206, oa ‘omit meaphor tahoe he Snlogue)- Tae ain be at eld they by someone ee is tha Tam lover of ewig, and cooay as {and ues coe't ant oe eating, pele in cies do (230). When Sova ap tht hey donot man (Bent each ater than Bat hey ‘Sat as evident choes Bs wor neal He achaowleges ae hat Sethe igh caning they cen inden nck a, wea he a tha ccc {othe pi of Zeus a soa te fat robes were poke y an ake, St hey oe rovaing ten ano eve a sade ha © {ysl tlt wut (2752). Bathe pestesss at Dodane ad Dep ‘vere seceafa nl when they wert a state of madness ané no when ey ‘wee i cota of ems (24), that ease oo suing at ‘re te goeme by an oth o Heea who I sented ere with chat {the agus), and aobely observing the sebe wih is oly senses, Scrat Tels place andthe ess have oi ac i. But when Paes rece Lysas" speech, the radiance on his face makes Socrates ecstatic (Gea) tring hs a Phe" Baehie pe (Cove ge). ‘then Paes ser an cathy the pln te, stl of Damp to compel Scot make sal speech abot eo, Sores ola hgh be bs been rape by thle Nymps (io), begins to peak he dtyra bic ter of Dionyes (238), and he end ht speech eas“ oie os ths very spo (aie 242), Take ogee is imagery once asin cpposes «9 to nate, hs tne in er ofthe ovine of Hera and Dios, td fest cach eal spake to os met cleny ender opposite condone Feit-convoled datoge with othe people within he walls (230) and the 2 ssi opemes to nate sd he walls 2), Socrates bins hie omn speech by Wentiying oe a kindof spate (237i, ant proceeds to tie peily what kid of mpi se os bya informal empleymest ofthe tho festa he il oral to fice a 2588 Within especies of what eles an les "be dings ‘ro pipes which we flow wherever hey laa pote ppt oles ‘Brean an quod opinion hts a wt re. When opnon ences {oni bj soning te wal eat tsa eal select, ‘hile when appetite isin contl and rags vs witht exsoning ova pice ‘tisealed bes Mos we ate tok as many eames case it has ny feces: bi boc! ood itn be ato in a ier pc ‘Same and mas othe pam of est a othe ated leases of emf bses sealed er (23742388, “All be previous dchotonies futon an ffm colton fr th above vision at "what eles an leads unto the priary dichotomy of enate ‘gett and acquit opinion. Analgacaing al he examples we hve ond {3s si aalogns pis which antipate a seven On ove se te ata wd fall of meacng monsters. on he eter he humanly ono cy wih wal o Rep oa danger (2, 29h) “NOnone side ssavage bese on theses me one 2308). 5.0m one side Dionysian vine maine, onthe ier sce under the ‘suspic of Her, ton of es oer es 2306-82 2428) 4On one side th ma tendency respond to ove wth en pasion, ‘on the her hee” behavior tet eleistingly bade sex a com rity ade 240, 5 On one sic ou oaturlspeites, om he ke Gare, On one ies nar edzy to bi onthe cera eo age seliconal (2302385, 1. Tae second Hal wil rset a pre contest bese ntl ving convertion aed artical pred of the acguliton of wt ta re evo hfe 27475. All es dehetonies ae betwee pina natu an acquit order, an he source fom which te lest aed inte preset passage ring ciple divided ino is dal species of aural ppc and neauied pen. ‘This ul species ab he rail ta vere oh wo feof te i logo The fist bal ites how os ata appetite cn lead 0 raion teh by means of fs, hile he econ al deere ow tr aed ep Jone canlead to hare goal by memo constucte cine of dco guises opaons IT Patinnde ‘The chatomy between mt appetite and soqued els in Socrates sgecch x ecapiltd ithe plier ofthe fo ores. The white Tere is over bran wi col and shes companion of auhenBs Bn white the bac Pre i's companion f har (253): In he deserpion af the white rete term tasted ere a "opinion", ova, is sully translated inthis pasage 36g" even ‘hough eewbee ce Plato dear snot ala tensed a “opinion or {ynoni.The eo othe waa raison pay in he roe comet {tate woos topetier wash chaste corp hepa the Repu. wit white hare presenting spite Tove of hone. ‘the oust of daa as gio" emphsis fs connection with hone Oh {his vaw de words, smpason of doa” te esealy a esate fhe frevious words, lover of once er Ba the edison ofa aol ‘arctic Tere te reasons why Tae nt lowed tis pace. (1) The arpciton of dane hee a epition iat oly compa wth he ‘epable's pate sult actulysreagtbens the corespondence the ‘Repub le Republi ho the wipe ol ss asaced, Weber ht ‘ho proper vin cou) of the peta’ iste presarve te dicts of ‘only abt what so Be ere ad what i ws (422), in ther words. 0 presen on pisioe cured fromthe el of reson. This is expt ne Alsen of spied wrt hare he chs f anaes in teratoma cy ‘shoe dstipushing wwe of courage ein a che sity to reser he ‘pe (be reed from te ato rales (29) Through! he Repd> Tethe spre clement, wither conve init pyelopealYerson a3 com one fe sul ein pital eget telat fui, is [sfuncton oly when enfress against appetite picions tht takes ve fom ‘aon What suggesting i tro formals, vero anor {companion af dn’ deci lle carci ae gag 0 svi of single characterise We ae being tid that he white Rose lover omar and eer (ike tov of hor the publ) cones ‘of ua pain opinion held good ath. from etn. 12) Th antes ere Btvoea bbs doe recy aces the nei beeen our inate edency tad hubs and ou acgued daca in Sosa fit pecs C274-238n), and ee dn says ante ‘piin” one of cognes, ater an as Ln’ The canelation in te alin of doxa ‘dove honoris ese a efrmuation of he carelatn in the eer ern pina spc ta sss wpe a mg. a my ‘Sica fo pane sha eo ne om ‘ht tere aon arp Pr ha Sirti ste sphere Thea ee Parl sve er lent pay bn og A otc eet) “oer nee nana be ey Meee ec heat ee etsy, tebe in ptt ed pe ha = Shoot ti geno 2S rl pasado with puri f what es. en hee inte ptinade aca ‘Ren emus tat ee sul hich ner cof mere al Fel [yar ocd a take hl nourismes om option, doze (248 woud te ‘Shing fe lt expt tote dora tom ploy 000 ers. 12) Desai bere const nth elcome, which wa clasiied aa es of acqied doe" Sere’ speech, whee dace is pensally gre © ‘wean pion 378) “Te harlot metaphor goes beyond Soc Sst pec atrdung think ‘cnc within se few (000 the person of tector wh Rovers fd edits betwee the ote vo principles (247-8. The discon Socrates spech of ot Salling eicile—ine spe and sexsi. opinion de et pec razon tn stalin bough alae Iteeweral ner. For exampe, the eisin of or ling pip in so Specie is done becuse Knowing (eee) the sates i the est pcp (Gor for aking decision (2572). Ths piel st edule eer © ‘pi ape. Ptr io te aps Socrates tye thal whe he ve ‘ots dee mbes it peed y eee or) beds conal 2488, ‘icet, Sorter’ matvaton fo expel dsingssing ony Wo lating i ‘les in bie fist spec, even hoagh the atonal icp of reson I ‘eer, srs obit ene ro conesved eagle in te sane some eset and oiion. Ts ised a he plod by he fact tha onthe ores (ope hoor-ovag omnia) ave te poe © pal fe chro whe etn, he sear ean ony tt noece the ee ton tha the hore tke, and hsm dependent plieg poser of 980. Te thsi ofthe omeson bth of Sees" specs of rf eason aso he eg price carol, compare oth oe sn he Rep tha te prc othe Phocta sto deste how exon cn ake te fhe ‘er to pricier is on purposes. Thais where te ity ofthe igus Hes: Reson sts ath bckpourd, ike the chest etn is ass, el the focus io epi eat of "he dialogue to this pat vo be simple into four stages, excite of iodo 1 Congrats ste frst mo speeches betwee the solver a he Tove whic he monlover is prefered pel the grounds al ves Canst he red Decne ey reo of oa ee "abe sony Iitrappliedt ths eosin, 206 2214) 2E Soci itn of or ling lang pci eo the two series ‘url pete for amu, dau pinta purses he good e378, - 3. The pte’ aecount ofa or apt for rowing te imal frm ‘ependson he abit of reason 0 col mpetie abl sprites aly oveaping agi ph en clon mp al a Sse smh oon266 hao 85856), ‘Tis alinae'sbetgue! account of how the eo ape of the Wack nase enable us 1 recolet neligBle ei (2542-2840) Ath finale gs clmstesin ae asnit of hoe hal fa Jeadng principe oor app for plese can bag ws tas epeeeasion of | tet th exe hal wl fish am account of ow thi ca slo be whe "eer all opinion ht pares the good! The plone kw ha thane ‘whee niloral aly never sieves clear oom of aly bees fhe aisha he res either sree appetite oe teens isles by arse epiions mast nour emcee instead with opinion C24) tn et use such peopl fr pole oe Knowledge we ru i Stayner onset th opinions thy owed y ere ones bae oi ayo tintin gn ops cw fhe phasis the sto specs onthe upd bkvor ‘oF over is not had understand why eos wot be deibod as ad of Imada ht why ol Plato wae lay pulorby at apis of at Imac (295-2506) Thre sm eco ofthe allegary a the cave In Soe “Setiton of he pilospte vo lok upon Set hese ae semi of ‘beat Wel ooking upward Le id ebecoeseneeacerted aout he thing slow, which cans hit be consid ad (490), In te cave tye ad ake ifs cave Evel loked pa he ight and as Minded, "Wha oon hk be wou af amene i him sha what be sa beer vas inion at x hecan o's some howto wht i oP oe turd toward whit se sees move corey (Rep, S1Sed). The expected frst tad Socrates wate fo oe, woul have bee alone ies oH ‘oui! the pets ws The at of mass into Paar care ‘Sods she mtapor of Bdnss inthe Rep, th of which re at sss te oer fhe gine rome vibe, We caaot ‘ak he tvoton by a smth exten of our empl owl beens {Gr afaeace betwee he empl ad he neligie quale ater than (qt. The supon that segue css th vie sehen ‘be Rapes conversion (5c, 87) and ithe Padus 5 eal. ‘de ap fom sense percepion wo ineligible counterpart. Wher tht Teapapyated as kind of este appcttive come o testa oe lnlep, ine econ alt appears the metaphors ee opin) at ‘ake rot nour sland Recomen no ongersmetesogtin ba something Tae cen nena penne ely se ne rts pa atc ayer yt ‘eae tera oe ee hepa ht ns ode ae n/t hey ee pm itis ey ot inert and inns to Bot the Phoerus an Repub (S15 singh or abi wo nk his sears “by ature rom oo bly be ued wo by tas. The qusion ‘hen tees hw thre who have acc by nae in pereing tein [ies the wor can rng lng oes who rcp of dag 0 With ‘nena anita In the Ropu to be ccnp by an eda ‘tem hat eophasiner mathemati, since msthomats, ab ache (933), abe praca ppicatons othe ibe eal wth paces tt belong ‘henge ru, and ta cen se be former 9 make ws ava he ate ($214:520), For he same reson ecto, toot be a fecin (S18). The Repub’ else sytem, however, polis stain foal pe Sevbed an mauve y the loa, whereas be Phd sted oxi te ‘walls estas pola nsittons an Focus insta 0 he int ‘pecoal dnenson. The abe Cth inte Est ba sot 2 bere fom Shadows projected within acon of pti encima bt snp alg Inve wth someone taal Suet, he eine fr hein er tha i. ‘laren the second Pl ot he commana ch fate acto at he interpersonal ce of etre. "Te amon een fo Best ne bythe lege fhe as, Socrates aes tht ind were erignly human beings who wees over come ith pleasure when the Meet were Dor i some appste. tht hey ‘cme uceecered doe) with oan eink, aed wiht nce Ing From thom th cca cars nto being, wn il fe the Moses noed 10 food Fat spend theives i song abd when hy ie he tall each fe Muses which af us have honored thm (2596-0) The begining of Be sty seca Sorts” cscipion af he philosopher whose expericaceof ety ‘eau cases hore eaealy bay lakng upward he scones ‘aconcersed (20k about the things bolow 284). Here, as ther, the Sri fe plesoe i st wrk. The cide eobrqvent rin a reataes ho <0 noting bt slag, mats te toques etamorposs fo x concre wih ‘ppt oa conse wth voce Socrates rm tha the ied reper 0 Cale lope and Uni those hola a pilropie! Le ed oor he ma of | there Mazes sho, more tha th ter Maes, te concerned wih eves std ‘ith oth vine and human seshes, and wh sng wih Be sweet vice (259), Homa speech, rpecsly mh eae pissy can ae acoaee- fom wih he ie, taro can. ‘ace the pallande end te slope wn is eto, efecto he ‘ac hor fies appte tthe wie bse of Nentving piion hat sins athe beat Inmedatly afer the plide Phar reso love hoor {nd opaioo: peeps Lysis lve of honor toting) wil ep hie fom ‘hig pec, for people efi oc the pinion GS) th ay {Me spins 2576-8), Ax Scr nd Phas posed with her examination ‘tne epstelly ses hth primary aim of tre eo nee people's opinions aout whats pood since te peed god isthe gl ofa268 co ation Tha oer nb cel with he ener pb, rato does Soto oom wht lly st at nl the opto (Bare) ae Ul ‘tae a ow the ot, or ht ely god o abba waa wil be the ‘opmion (Be) fort pve the mali he pio ha couse of ation ee ned ony ara tht lke the igs yaad opie ob goo. I the ray wl be abe eo mate he pie (eee) oe meth ese things god and meter time se oposite 260-264, Cones eo andj are expecially vuln w tas tease uae coneps Iie io fn ter, theres much dsagresnent and uceraiaty a a they ee © (23a) "Tha te uma gon of he audenors neque opis hat am he go aml. goo aed the jus ees, te hares ome “We can pect ourselves gas stove maniplation, Socrates yi stati can becuz not merely pret, saw bet acne (200 ef. Gorgias 4626) But htre sto bea echne, the speaker ho nies the ‘paige of is allence mst bein by towing he ul ae tha sing "piniae C2), The wy to aie hi abd prevent people fos bing i= [sty sims a stingy ech End of hing actly from each bet by the meh of sion Theft pnt of the men,‘ costs in “ewig peor tng ta re sctere everywhere digg he ino 2 sinle Ko’, and the second "he St) to ide secording forms, he ‘ara joints and pot otro hack off «prin the manner OF «bad braces (2484). “he oletion can be eared out only if we have a peor conception ofthe ind of oes with ch he vated tage aa be ned Seca could ‘ot ve bap wo cal prophesy, mati, poetry, an owe, ll wih & ‘inl oem of vine aes ibe hal no cancel of vie mass begin ‘wh Simla e can procet i vie the encoding he os ns tered Rave to sity to engin thos forms Tha 8 wh he etd i ‘receded bythe pliode’saeoont of latent Fnoledge of he tele forms of hag, thse within ike» vague memory. We must hve some rowleige ofthe whole fore we xa cogs hat nd Bow each nl [at of The tc fron ppd 1 ie mee practic of to [resappser power af peer oops nih. When Socrates says thf be blevessomeore be capable of sexing ow ngs by ox can be omine in one nd divided in tony, e wou follow i as he woof Iona god 256), allsng toe pind’ the eccu of aw We ol Temes thea in rer eb he oes. ‘Soca appl His mod ot ol fhe sore of tos, he forms fs ssbjct mater, bt oof are, he sel. The way cua te ate of fying is determine wheter snp or complex, and hen eerie how ‘ctr andr cedupe mach ete, what We swt he so By se wish to pede tof someting. We mt rt Strib the fem of he su ‘vid arp seers 0 see wheter 5 by mate one and on gee0 ot ‘form, cand we mos eerie How as ede acted up, ad tide ‘must ditingis he varions Kl of speeches an show how een typ of fpecch ar soa to persue cranes of wl 2708-2718, Te mth of ‘son spin atl ie evs the veo sgl fo, ta we ae ‘curt knowledge ofthe abet to which weare wing ase or acne by fur speech: the level ofthe aulence ite (he spctes of sou, a the Intermediate eel ofthe kinds of speeches tt ca inten the ain’ pina. TV. Appi Rete ‘Teche, ue psteme is mare tan her, i avo egies aplication (ee Rooeh 1996, 202126, 3141, 44, 50,32, 70) and so reap requis de ily to comaine teary wth sens perception i aan bart fege and yologieal lsifctons te speaker “mst e able t dcr hse ‘hinas in paca far apd fol tam cll nits senses Tie). We ‘tno nly nw wha pe of pron spo to hat pe of speech, Bu ‘en we eet scone we a sabe able cope espa the pe ‘Batts porson acl cxcmles (27-2723). Thre ahd face os well ‘We most ac only ow he conarae palgy of species and sous, fe shle to subsume the poson in eto ws une the eect eof sou We ‘bo mt be snstve tothe ccrtnces ofthe omen Since we ant my fxacly these worst the se peson under a crearstaes and at all tes wit sual eetvenes, meso mast he abl fo recopine "whe is fy nr) 4 peak an he oop, hen pe iy, pecs, | hyperbolic, anda he ote kids fees he as seed When they ae ‘iy Clan rd when fey me ome ak” 272). Ts conc tf aio cena o's contin freee fnthe Repude, or example ‘Socrates pons at tat someone wha working te ec Tet th ah ‘momen (iron go, the wer rane” (S708). Tot aurring ten ht Somes depres wien Sponches, which we by ‘tue unespomsive to canginaceonstanes fav of lagu. te ‘myth of Tie and Thro, when Theat stows Taras be ene of Weis Tt he ives, Thos ces cata tw improve metry and indo. stead esos, it wl produce forgtules sive people wil no Tenge hve tel on tht mai: ad only the appearance of wi since they wl ed wat Bing stated 7140295), Sores ws hat ‘ten Wars scm Speak a if thy were ineliget, bt Som ask them anything aot wha ys, om 2 ese to ear ty anys sy ost tbe same one hing. And once is ig,” ai bi a i a 3‘rita down, every peed ls aloes everywhere equal © hore wh endrtand tad, st th sme, the for WOM ‘sno etable And des ot knw to whit Sed peak sata whom t shel at 7562) ‘na imal npn of he et of von, Sorat aka wheter we ces leprae beter of ths ileitite] one, which is wten Wi Storied nthe sul of te leant ao ale odie tel nd oo 0 ‘wom soul peak or keep sent” (276a). Socom who is kaowldgeeble ‘ho the athe gd, ade eat when he is seas tou sowing ie {edt of hei kroed, would ot sow than ting: Butt gues fates, sce he wl pln forthe sae of navies and wil wit, er he write, 1oteashe up Feminist tnt for when arent te Frets ‘ld ae ad forall ser follow alg the same tack. ‘Ande wil enjoy seing tem row delicate shots. T's Imochoble. and show seosnes, wher one mes Us the of dct an king tbl soul plant ad sows ‘Cth wea cht cna knowedpe: whic ar able help ‘hemssves nd the one ha pnt her; Wiehe not aie tes bt contin sed from whch eter Words ow ine char crf oer people (27602772) “The wade ht the set ean sch aes att po mote han epinions ‘sed from fhe teacher, whic re asepe povioaly Th Tessas {Syeto te Hate visor, Pens necawe Tom young Tofen hang ay pi ints, bar now looking a you snd recogiang tat you blew. t ace So wel (Sop 265d Only mn th tent as bre al owndestand the teachings through are they Tansfomed from opinion aneoced seeds) 12 Frome (nls tha havea 8). "Toca tat Sores iaration of Mens sv in aproblem of cone. Atte cals Sots tye ta te coc pions have Been Sed up inte sve a finde, bu he mere repel ake the Ft {ue in leet ways be wold evenly have Anoledge as exact 5 =n) tes en Sed). What male this tration psi, on te Men's econ Tt thoy of clon: me eae of scovering Uw a ama ‘dase ty the sees slne, soe a he mare of ware abd of rather, ecun thy ar thn lly af previously seen and ben forte) Staten on bse by The ight Led of ringer, The same ‘eter of llsctongovere the expan ite st af ofthe Pac ‘ow auront ppetie an avakon so wat (2486-25) inthe secon al ireland hy = Boel meta, butte pin strated i te sme: Wis "cht Sha Agu wih mat cae ate ae aaa ae semi nr es ne as ons tu itn us nd cn be sine bythe ght Kind of sensory sis Inthe ire a he neoyof wim compare egos Ui ‘ees oly the ecetion of atin Kn of bes tog er ee: Inte ‘nd halt compare tabi bet allow oi a neds nl the ah seed {oe placed tap ours. Aitiowsh Soca’ empbins mas bees on he spent af doe: weston aching, and wrong ced sub oly for bene of the seoun dseminson of owed (274) iu canot be the whol sry from he pot of iw of Pat wo conse to wae pilosa Boks With ‘nmin ener. Ts athe ery olt wae Soctascismises wing 3s [Sted only io bead for cr fgal o 9, e ade, or lo {soo fellow slong he sate tack. And he wil ny ssing them grow dl [Shc sot" (2), The lt sentnce mene tht sriten words can have the ‘Sine effects oral ones the vce plang of weds nh lf ora ‘ce. Our ween Worl can hve oly ited ae fr oss i aus. ‘ce ey re ly sre apposition of wh area live iin swe ens carsles withthe oe thm 8 reindrs when te Deco ot fet of wot we wo peeled. Bat hi beste can tve te sre {teeton tess ol words ato Fs realy since th heunstanes in ‘ie hyn ed nthe cater of hoe whe sed ey, peice In theirone wy they ean aesorpih he wo gal that Sete emphasize ‘hate teaching resin mere opinions bt Sone sve wi the sea the tecpent 2766277), and tha they know who seat and when to Keep ‘le 26." "The way tit Soca achieve ie Frm objvive with aa peach mas by sling tion od feng hs tenes nt tely tase eines Bt ‘hina ogh mise be hope tha he efor woul gee ‘ute inspht or ecaectn. The Paes shown ws how Pao woop {hive someteg omparahleby mean of writen mods Nowhere have We ‘een preset with rma doce that we ae expe to tent den {ve formulation ofthe uth, Ines! we were offered = mh sone eens of ih re ore estan nett thn eters: we wero gen maps lke recllecton and sed planting that presen esalleages fr our trpetve ‘hiking and we were aed with loge ts emphases moze tae ay oe Pisosic work tb importance of oncaeid sous, wiles ee ing text the pate ds of Pts dialogues, 0 hat We ae fered tothinethegh he pletion fal selma ingot of ung i Pl. By sch mea we ae conta Fredo coe ve ata ne Work of the dnoge sod ct merely priv espns to sive fr owed Tyenequaitnce oft subject aber us velning ssid with iin y sition “ty gansta ong ngam ‘Ween sole he tertve poles elt tbe extent ti we ae ale Sooke ally ef © Which te words eft. Tote eet hat we succeed, ‘he azo take oo nour souls and om ino srething mre buf me ack the ability to ind ee te worst thir srace meaning the inlogve kc ot peak to us at hus achive he second bjtve a wel eng ‘en tee hoe for whom ino stable (276), Tose whose more “epeode on elious ion, and ho lack he mosvaton a wi pase ‘slpon-bset ny wth exaust molt f hei Seles come der ‘ak (3 229), wold nthe Phair eal crtimations of what ey Siren belve-th sol and gos ftadsona eign, Plato wes m2 Wy "hat nits he dng pels of te Repo: Weald fm childhood ean belt abst je and bent ‘hngs wee rah pn hese elif ay pres, we key lnc honorthem. And then x guesione comes lon ed aks ‘nan in hoe cartons whats beaut, and when be ‘reer ha he as Hear fom the awe, the tguent rele ho and des this ten and to many paces. This Foote fi othe belt thi hing m0 are bens Then ly th se ith wht ot nd goed ane the tings he beweved mos. Tae when be no longer Beives thes prices tobe his wn ar eo Be obeyed, ashe Sid efor an does uc scorer te ones. Fo a abiding Me comes ives. Thats hy. mist be enreely.caefl ow yu ide [people] oleic. (38539) “The send hl ofthe lg sow then, ow ache an ring mine the hghes eligi tra the a, he pod and he eas 276) bruh the pc of hate ed by segied opimins tte fst al showed this nc four iat peti, The nae begen by infaaly Callen, or aes tsvesieg a mer of aie he stoi oppeston ‘ste abt oy followed by oppositions twcn pasinae and cal Ine se, Typhi pte a time dence, Dinan mines and Hera Sobriy.appetcandel-somta te common oni of wc became slew {pile of what rar an eae ust peti fr please ad “nga ope ht sims the good Te fl ad senha of be iaoeve {xplred ech of thee respectively and the cuit mcuapber. in which they npr sth lack and whe read he ning concept of renal, tego the hr i ta whic ero apettve nae ow he po an ot merely th pls, nd which eds oo opto omar x rns Fooning expres ut so longer bere opinion The slog em mt bee, ra snge theless Atte eases hs Ves ees figs, snarl coumie a vale ity, bat row ‘ele del 0 quel, a or oe ine and outsides, ur mate and bur quent “Dear Pan an al ther gods of ti ies, Socrates peas, ‘estat ay bone beau wii, on hn my exter posession be ie om ‘eal armony wit wat is within me Deparment of Philosophy Unvesiy of Gin (Guelph ON, Came NIG 2 BIBLIOGRAPHY Moi oi. 20, pea he ie: eo, atc Ploy Pas Pa Dine ners Crohn a une es Pcs Pe li Ch ni 19172 ‘SS Rony reo Pe Mie sua 2 Ta Pov of Es ia A aif a Paiste i abe orn OC ee eam 8) Fan Pa Psi Wig ey Un Sree Asa re ei 031 Cee Po Pay Ae Hae Brom toy yo i Sx of he ay ‘Sepa mth he rerio a’ Rapi an MD Lang ta nl ent, 9 9 Fare Sa es Coen Fert tinny Ca ang Cntr eae Po orn ot iy) Pn heel Poe Ri ipa re erences marine ar tina an ccahammittorseamnertomaeearea, Mate: Go 135, The Ut fe Pn” Cha! ul 3-505 ea 65 ett tant serlaceines om mmmvins writ eee ce na ravens ST, crm tiene eee ee eran mine SESS Ee eS LEAT eens be eh ta CdSe Ase Pry ‘ei. i Pe ye aa en 9.9 ita ite as on ren ship fs at.